← ❄️ Winter lessons · Home
⭐ 0
Winter Science · GCSE Chemistry · water, ice and snow crystals
❄️ Winter ScienceMini-Lesson

Why Every Snowflake Has Six Sides

3 missions and a finale. Six sides, floating ice and the hunt for two matching snowflakes. Guess, learn, then check.

  1. Mission 1Why does every snowflake have six sides?
  2. Mission 2Why does ice float?
  3. Mission 3Are two snowflakes ever the same?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why does every snowflake have six sides?

Make a guess: Why does every snowflake have six sides?

Mission 1

One molecule of water

One water moleculeOHHabout 104.5°covalent bond(shared electrons)oxygenhydrogenbent, not a hexagon
  • A water molecule is H₂O: one oxygen atom joined to two hydrogen atoms.
  • Each join is a covalent bond: a shared pair of electrons. Covalent bonds are strong.
  • The molecule is bent. The two bonds meet at about 104.5°.
  • It is not a hexagon. So where does six come from?
Mission 1

Two kinds of attraction

  • Inside a molecule: strong covalent bonds hold H to O.
  • Between molecules: much weaker attractions, called intermolecular forces.
  • Water's are strong for intermolecular forces, but still far weaker than a covalent bond. A-level students will call them hydrogen bonds.
  • When ice melts, it is these forces between molecules that are overcome. The covalent bonds stay put.
Quick check
?An ice cube melts. What is overcome?
Mission 1

Rings of six

Rings of sixcovalent bond, strongforce between molecules, weakeroxygenhydrogenhexagonal lattice (ice Ih)
  • In ice, each water molecule is held by four neighbours.
  • The molecules join into rings of six: hexagons.
  • The rings stack into a hexagonal lattice: a repeating, ordered pattern. Scientists call this form of ice ice Ih.
  • William Barnes confirmed this lattice with X-rays in 1929.
Mission 1

From ring to crystal

From ring to crystalfrozendroplethexagonalplatearmssproutbranchedcrystalwater vapour → ice (no liquid step)blue arrows: corners stick out, grow fastest
  • A snow crystal is not a frozen raindrop.
  • Water vapour in a cloud turns straight to ice on a tiny frozen droplet.
  • It first grows as a tiny six-sided prism: a flat plate or a short column, copying the lattice.
  • On a plate, the six corners stick out into the moist air, so they grow fastest and sprout branches.
Mission 1

Kepler asked first

Who asked, who answeredKepler askswhy six?16111885Bentley photographsa snow crystalBarnes: X-rays confirmthe hexagonal lattice19291936Nakaya grows snowcrystals in a labnot to scale
  • In 1611 the astronomer Johannes Kepler wrote a short book, The Six-Cornered Snowflake, as a New Year gift for his emperor.
  • He guessed that the six sides came from the way tiny units stack, like cannonballs.
  • He admitted the science of his day could not answer it.
  • Barnes's X-ray work of 1929 confirmed Kepler was on the right track: stacking water molecules gives the six-fold pattern.
Quick check
?How does a snow crystal form?
Mission check

?Why does every snowflake have six sides?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why does ice float?

Make a guess: Why does ice float?

Mission 2

Density

  • Density = mass ÷ volume. How much stuff is packed into a space.
  • Liquid water: about 1.00 g/cm³. Ice: about 0.92 g/cm³.
  • Freeze 100 g of water and you still have 100 g. But it now takes up about 9% more space.
  • Less dense than the liquid, so it floats.
Mission 2

Lattice versus liquid

Lattice versus liquidliquid waterice16 molecules, jostling16 molecules, in ringssame molecules, more space → lower density
  • In the liquid, molecules jostle and slide past each other, packed fairly close.
  • In ice, the forces between molecules lock them into the open hexagonal lattice, with more space between them.
  • Same molecules, more space between them: lower density.
  • The basic particle model misses this: it ignores the forces and the spaces between particles.
Quick check
?100 g of water freezes solid. Which is correct?
Mission 2

The 4 °C twist

Density of water against temperature1.0000.9990.998densest at about 4 °Caxis broken0.92ice: about 0.920102030temperature (°C)density (g/cm³)
  • Cool water and it gets denser, as you would expect, down to about 4 °C.
  • Below 4 °C it gets less dense again as the molecules begin to arrange themselves more openly.
  • At 0 °C it freezes to ice, less dense still.
  • Water is densest at about 4 °C, not at freezing. In most substances the solid is the densest form.
Mission 2

Why lakes freeze from the top

Lake in wintercold airice floats, 0 °Ccolder, less denseabout 4 °C,densest, sinksicebergabout nine-tenthsbelow the surface
  • In autumn, surface water cools to about 4 °C and sinks. The lake fills with 4 °C water from the bottom up.
  • Colder water is less dense, so it stays on top, and that is where ice forms.
  • Ice floats, so it builds a lid on the surface. Below the lid, the lake stays liquid.
  • If the coldest water and ice sank, lakes could freeze from the bottom up, and some might never fully thaw in summer.
Quick check
?A lake cools in autumn. Which water ends up at the bottom?
Mission check

?Why does ice float?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Are two snowflakes ever the same?

Make a guess: Are two snowflakes ever the same?

Mission 3

Shape depends on the weather

Which shape, which weather0−10−20−30 °Cplates and columnslarge branched starscolumns and needlesthin platesmore humidity: more branchinglow humidity: simple prismssimplified · after Nakaya (1930s)
  • In the 1930s physicist Ukichiro Nakaya grew the first artificial snow crystals, in a cold lab at Hokkaido University.
  • He found that the shape depends on temperature and humidity in the cloud.
  • Near −2 °C: thin plates. Near −5 °C: columns and needles. Near −15 °C: large branched stars. Around −30 °C: plates and columns again.
  • More humidity: more branching. Low humidity: simple prisms.
Mission 3

Reading a snowflake

  • A slender needle says: I grew near −5 °C in high humidity.
  • A big branched star says: I grew near −15 °C.
  • A capped column (a column with a plate on each end) says: I started near −5 °C, then moved into air near −15 °C.
  • Nakaya compared snowflakes to messages sent down from the clouds.
Quick check
?You find a capped column: a short column with a flat plate on each end. What does it tell you?
Mission 3

A crystal's life story

  • As a crystal falls, it meets ever-changing temperature and humidity.
  • Each change makes the arms grow a little differently. The final shape records the exact path it took.
  • All six arms took the same path at the same times, so they grow alike: symmetry.
  • No two crystals follow the same path, so no two complex crystals look alike.
Mission 3

Bentley's claim, and how to test it

Supported, not proved5,000+ photos,no two alike→ supports the claimone matching pair→ disproves itBentley chose the prettiest:not a fair sample
  • Wilson Bentley, a Vermont farmer, photographed his first snow crystal in 1885, then more than 5,000 others. He never found two the same.
  • "No two alike" is a claim about every snowflake ever. 5,000 photos can support it but never prove it.
  • One matching pair would disprove it. Tiny, simple plates can look identical under a microscope.
  • Bentley also chose the most photogenic crystals, so his album is not a fair sample of falling snow.
Quick check
?Bentley photographed more than 5,000 snow crystals and found no two alike. What does that show?
Mission 3

Twins in the lab

  • Libbrecht (Caltech) grew two crystals side by side in the same changing conditions.
  • They came out nearly identical: same conditions, same shape.
  • So the shape is set by growth conditions, not by chance or magic.
  • Nature almost never gives two crystals exactly the same journey. That is the real reason.
Mission check

?Are two snowflakes ever the same?
Finale

Snow crystal or snowflake?

Crystal or flakesnow crystal:one crystalsnowflake:a clump of crystalsmost snow crystals are small and simple
  • A snow crystal is a single crystal of ice, with the six-fold pattern.
  • A snowflake can be one crystal, or a clump of hundreds that collided in the air.
  • Those big fluffy flakes in a mild snowfall are clumps.
  • Perfect stars are rare. Most snow crystals are small and simple.
Quick check
?Ice melts at 0 °C. Diamond, a giant covalent structure, needs a far higher temperature. Why?
Recap

The big ideas

  • A water molecule is bent, held together by strong covalent bonds.
  • Between molecules are much weaker forces. Melting ice overcomes those, not the covalent bonds.
  • In ice the molecules form rings of six: a hexagonal lattice. The crystal copies that pattern.
  • The open lattice leaves more space between molecules, so ice is less dense than water and floats. Most solids sink.
  • Water is densest at about 4 °C, so lakes freeze from the top.
  • Shape depends on temperature and humidity along the crystal's path. Complex crystals are never alike; simple ones can be.
❄️

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've finished Why Every Snowflake Has Six Sides. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why does every snowflake have six sides?
  2. Mission 2Why does ice float?
  3. Mission 3Are two snowflakes ever the same?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a mate to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

❄️ More winter lessons

📚 Sources for this lesson (16)
  1. Kenneth G. Libbrecht, Snow Crystals, open-access monograph, arXiv:1910.06389 (v2, 9 December 2021), https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.06389 (PDF https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.06389v2). Page numbers are the printed page numbers in the PDF. Used for: snow crystal vs snowflake, "not a frozen raindrop; that type of precipitation is called sleet", growth from water vapour "directly from the gaseous to the solid state" (p. 17–18); Fig. 1.5 growth sequence droplet → prism → branches from six corners (p. 18); Kepler 1611, The Six-Cornered Snowflake, gift to Rudolf II, cannonball stacking, science not advanced enough (p. 25–26); Bentley: Jericho, Vermont, first snow crystal photograph 1885 aged 19, more than 5,000 images over 46 years, chose the most photogenic (about a hundred a winter), "well-formed stellar crystals are exceedingly rare", 1931 book with W. J. Humphreys (p. 26–28); Barnes 1929 X-ray structure of ice, hexagonal lattice of ice Ih, "three hundred years after Kepler" (p. 28–29); Nakaya at Hokkaido University, 1930s, first synthetic snow crystal 12 March 1936, morphology (Nakaya) diagram, needle near −5 °C, stellar near −15 °C, capped columns from a change of conditions (p. 30–32); "No Two Alike?" section: complex crystals virtually never identical, simple hexagonal prisms can look alike, isotopes and dislocations, path through the clouds (p. 42–44); ice Ih structure, covalent bonds within molecules and weaker hydrogen bonds between, exactly one hydrogen between neighbouring oxygens, bond angle 104.5° vs tetrahedral 109.5°, four bonds per oxygen (p. 48–50); densities ice ≈ 917 kg/m³, water ≈ 1000 kg/m³ (p. 57).
  2. Kenneth G. Libbrecht, SnowCrystals.com (Caltech), "Snowflake Science" page, https://snowcrystals.com/science/science.html. Quoted: "The six-fold symmetry you see in a snow crystal arises from the arrangement of water molecules in the ice crystal lattice"; stellar crystal begins as a small hexagonal plate, branches sprout from the six corners; ever-changing temperatures and humidities, same path for all six arms, no two follow the same path; Nakaya diagram: largest stellar crystals around −15 °C, needles and columns around −6 °C, capped columns when temperature changes, more branching at high humidity, simple prisms at low humidity (or when tiny).
  3. Kenneth G. Libbrecht, SnowCrystals.com, "Snowflake Primer" (older Caltech-hosted copy), https://www.its.caltech.edu/~atomic/snowcrystals/primer/primer-old.htm. Quoted: "The water molecules in an ice crystal form a hexagonal lattice"; thin plates and stars around −2 °C, columns and slender needles near −5 °C, plates and stars around −15 °C, a combination of plates and columns around −30 °C; simpler shapes at low supersaturation.
  4. Kenneth G. Libbrecht, SnowCrystals.com, "Snowflake Branching", http://www.snowcrystals.com/branching/branching.html. Quoted: "The six corners of a snow crystal grow a bit faster because they stick out farther into the humid air".
  5. Kenneth G. Libbrecht, SnowCrystals.com, "Identical-Twin Snowflakes", http://www.snowcrystals.com/identicaltwins/identicaltwins.html. Two separate crystals grown side by side in the lab, "very similar to one another, although they are not precisely identical"; symmetry requires symmetrical growth conditions.
  6. U.S. Geological Survey, Water Science School, "Water Density", https://www.usgs.gov/special-topics/water-science-school/science/water-density. Quoted: "Upon freezing, the density of ice decreases by about 9 percent"; molecules "align themselves in a regular lattice"; "The lattice arrangement allows water molecules to be more spread out than in a liquid"; "In most substances solids are more dense"; water at about 4 °C denser than at 0 °C, denser water sinks; if water were densest at freezing "the lake could freeze from the bottom up" and "some frozen lakes might not totally thaw in summer"; "almost all of the volume of an iceberg is below the water line". Density table (g/cm³): 0 °C 0.99987; 4.0 °C 1.00000; 10 °C 0.99975; 21 °C 0.99802.
  7. Jericho Historical Society, "Wilson A. Bentley" biography, https://snowflakebentley.com/biography/. Born 9 February 1865, Jericho, Vermont; first snow crystal photograph 15 January 1885; "well over 5,000" crystals, "never finding two the same"; Snow Crystals published November 1931; died 23 December 1931.
  8. AQA GCSE Chemistry (8462) specification, §4.2 Bonding, structure, and the properties of matter, https://www.aqa.org.uk/subjects/chemistry/gcse/chemistry-8462/specification/subject-content/bonding-structure-and-the-properties-of-matter. Quoted in Coverage and Points: §4.2.1.4, §4.2.2.1 (including HT limitations of the particle model), §4.2.2.4, §4.2.2.6.
  9. AQA A-level Chemistry (7405) specification, §3.1.3.7 Forces between molecules, https://www.aqa.org.uk/subjects/chemistry/a-level/chemistry-7405/specification/subject-content/physical-chemistry. Quoted: "The importance of hydrogen bonding in the low density of ice and the anomalous boiling points of compounds."
  10. Pearson Edexcel GCSE (9–1) Chemistry (1CH0) specification, Issue 4, March 2024, https://qualifications.pearson.com/content/dam/pdf/GCSE/Science/2016/Specification/gcse-chemistry-spec.pdf. Statements 1.31 (dot-and-cross including water), 1.32, 1.34a ("low melting points and boiling points, in terms of forces between molecules (intermolecular forces)"), 2.1–2.3 (pp. 13–14, 17).
  11. Cambridge OCR GCSE (9–1) Gateway Science Chemistry A (J248) specification, Version 4.0, August 2026, https://www.ocr.org.uk/Images/234598-specification-accredited-gcse-gateway-science-suite-chemistry-a-j248.pdf. Statements C1.1a, C1.1c (model "does not take into account the forces of attraction between particles, the size of particles and the space between them"), C2.3d, C2.3f.
  12. Department for Education, National curriculum in England: science programmes of study, Key Stage 3, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-curriculum-in-england-science-programmes-of-study/national-curriculum-in-england-science-programmes-of-study. Chemistry "The particulate nature of matter": "changes of state in terms of the particle model"; Physics "Matter": "the differences in arrangements, in motion and in closeness of particles explaining changes of state, shape and density"; "the anomaly of ice-water transition"; "similarities and differences, including density differences, between solids, liquids and gases"; Working scientifically: "present reasoned explanations, including explaining data in relation to predictions and hypotheses".
  13. AQA, Report on the Examination, GCSE Chemistry 8462/1H, June 2023, Q04.5, https://filestore.aqa.org.uk/sample-papers-and-mark-schemes/2023/june/AQA-84621H-WRE-JUN23.PDF. Quoted: "There was much confusion between bonds and intermolecular forces"; "Students often thought intermolecular forces had to be broken in methane but bonds had to be broken in poly(ethene)."
  14. AQA, Report on the Examination, GCSE Chemistry 8462/1H, June 2022, Q3.1–3.2, https://filestore.aqa.org.uk/sample-papers-and-mark-schemes/2022/june/AQA-84621H-WRE-JUN22.PDF. Quoted: "There are no intermolecular forces in diamond, let alone strong ones."
  15. H.-J. Schmidt, B. Kaufmann and D. F. Treagust, "Students' understanding of boiling points and intermolecular forces", Chemistry Education Research and Practice (Royal Society of Chemistry), 2009, DOI 10.1039/B920829C, https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlehtml/2009/rp/b920829c. Abstract: "The most prominent alternative conception was that boiling involves breaking covalent bonds."
  16. Met Office, "Sleet", https://weather.metoffice.gov.uk/learn-about/weather/types-of-weather/snow/sleet. Sleet "has no internationally agreed definition" and "is reported in meteorological observations as a combination or mix of rain and snow"; "frozen precipitation that partially melts as it falls". Used only to justify removing the word "sleet" (see Points, Independent review).

→ GCSE Chemistry revision