← ❄️ Winter lessons · Home
⭐ 0
Winter Maths · GCSE · perimeter, area, sequences and symmetry
❄️ Winter MathsMini-Lesson

The Snowflake with an Infinite Edge

3 missions and a finale. Build a snowflake whose edge never stops growing. Guess, learn, then check.

  1. Mission 1How can a shape have an infinite perimeter?
  2. Mission 2Can a shape with an infinite edge still fit on a page?
  3. Mission 3You start with a triangle. So why six arms?
Mission 1

Mission 1: How can a shape have an infinite perimeter?

Make a guess: How can a shape have an infinite perimeter?

Mission 1

Start with a triangle

  • Draw an equilateral triangle: three equal sides, three equal angles.
  • Each side is 9 cm.
  • Perimeter is the distance all the way round: 3 × 9 = 27 cm.
Mission 1

The rule

The edge rule9 cm3 cm3 cm3 cm3 cmremoved1 edge → 4 edges, each ⅓ as long
  • Take an edge. Cut it into three equal parts.
  • Remove the middle third. In its place, build the other two sides of a smaller equilateral triangle, pointing outwards.
  • One edge becomes 4 edges, each one third as long.
Quick check
?An edge is 9 cm long. You apply the rule once. How long is the new path along it?
Mission 1

Do it to every edge, again and again

Stages 0 to 3Stage 0 · 3 edgesside 9 cmStage 1 · 12 edgesStage 2 · 48 edgesStage 3 · 192 edges
  • Stage 0: a triangle, 3 edges. Apply the rule to every edge.
  • Stage 1: a six-pointed star, 12 edges. Stage 2: 48 edges. Stage 3: 192 edges.
  • Edges: × 4 each stage. Edge length: 9 → 3 → 1 → 1/3 cm, × 1/3 each stage.
Mission 1

Perimeter = number of edges × edge length

Edges times length equals perimeterStageEdgesEdge lengthPerimeter039 cm27 cm1123 cm36 cm2481 cm48 cm3192⅓ cm64 cm× 4× ⅓× 4/3× 4× ⅓× 4/3× 4× ⅓× 4/3
  • Stage 0: 3 × 9 = 27 cm. Stage 1: 12 × 3 = 36 cm.
  • Stage 2: 48 × 1 = 48 cm. Stage 3: 192 × 1/3 = 64 cm.
  • Each stage: × 4 edges, × 1/3 length. Together: perimeter × 4/3.
Quick check
?The stage-3 perimeter is 64 cm. What is the stage-4 perimeter?
Mission 1

It never stops

  • Perimeters: 27, 36, 48, 64, 85⅓, … The term-to-term rule is × 4/3.
  • 4/3 is more than 1, so every stage is longer than the last. No stage is the last one.
  • Keep applying the rule for ever and the perimeter grows without bound. That is what "infinite perimeter" means here.
Mission check

?How can a shape have an infinite perimeter?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can a shape with an infinite edge still fit on a page?

Make a guess: Can a shape with an infinite edge still fit on a page?

Mission 2

What step 1 adds

What step 1 adds1/91/91/9area 1added: 3 × 1/9 = 1/3
  • Call the area of the first triangle 1 unit.
  • Step 1 adds 3 new triangles, one on each edge. Each has sides 1/3 as long as the original.
  • Lengths × 1/3 means area × 1/9 (a third as wide and a third as tall).
  • Area added at step 1: 3 × 1/9 = 1/3 of a unit.
Quick check
?A triangle's sides are all made 1/3 as long. What happens to its area?
Mission 2

Step 2 adds less

What step 2 adds1/811/34/27area addedstep 1, step 2added: 12 × 1/81 = 4/27
  • Step 2 adds 12 triangles, one on each of the 12 edges. Each is 1/9 of a step-1 triangle: 1/81 of a unit.
  • Area added at step 2: 12 × 1/81 = 12/81 = 4/27 of a unit.
  • Compare: step 1 added 1/3 = 9/27. Step 2 added 4/27. The amount added is × 4/9 each step.
  • Four times as many triangles, each a ninth of the size: 4 × 1/9 = 4/9.
Quick check
?Step 2 adds 4/27 of a unit of area. How much does step 3 add?
Mission 2

Fenced in

Fenced inthe circle through the first three corners
  • Draw the circle through the three corners of the first triangle.
  • Every new triangle, at every step, stays inside that circle.
  • So the snowflake's area can never be more than the circle's area. It is bounded.
Mission 2

The paradox, stated carefully

  • After any number of steps, the shape has a finite number of edges, a finite perimeter and a finite area.
  • Perimeters go × 4/3 each step: they grow without bound. Added areas go × 4/9 each step: they shrink towards nothing.
  • Keep going for ever: the edge becomes longer than any ruler, but the shape still fits inside the circle.
  • Adding up every step exactly is A-level maths. The answer is 8/5 of the first triangle: not infinite.
Quick check
?You apply the rule 100 times. Which statement about the stage-100 perimeter is true?
Mission check

?Can a shape with an infinite edge still fit on a page?
Mission 3

Mission 3: You start with a triangle. So why six arms?

Make a guess: You start with a triangle. So why six arms?

Mission 3

Two kinds of symmetry

Two kinds of symmetryequilateral triangle3 mirror linesorder 3parallelogram0 mirror linesorder 2
  • Line symmetry: fold along the line and the two halves match. The line is a mirror line.
  • Rotational symmetry: turn the shape about its centre and it looks the same before a full turn.
  • The order of rotational symmetry is how many times it matches in one full turn.
  • An equilateral triangle: 3 lines of symmetry, rotational symmetry of order 3.
Quick check
?A parallelogram (not a rectangle or a rhombus) has no lines of symmetry. What is its order of rotational symmetry?
Mission 3

Step 1 makes a star

Six mirror lines60°6 mirror lines · order 6
  • Step 1 adds a point to each of the three edges: the triangle becomes a six-pointed star.
  • The star has 6 lines of symmetry and rotational symmetry of order 6.
  • Every later step treats every edge the same way, so nothing breaks that symmetry. The snowflake keeps 6 and order 6 at every stage.
Quick check
?You turn a stage-2 snowflake about its centre. What is the smallest turn that makes it look exactly as it did?
Mission 3

Zoom in and see it again

Zoom instage 4× 3the same shape, smaller
  • Zoom in on one edge of the snowflake and you see the same jagged shape again. Zoom again: the same again.
  • This is called self-similarity. Shapes like this are called fractals.
  • The word was coined by Benoit Mandelbrot in 1975, from the Latin fractus, "broken".
Mission 3

Where it came from

  • The Swedish mathematician Helge von Koch published the curve in 1904.
  • He wasn't modelling snow. His paper's title says why he built it: a continuous curve with no tangent anywhere, made by an elementary construction.
  • A real snow crystal also has six-fold symmetry, from the way its water molecules are arranged in ice. The winter science lesson has that story.
Mission check

?You start with a triangle. So why six arms?
Finale

Two sequences, two fates

Two sequencesPerimeter (cm)27364864× 4/3× 4/3× 4/3grows without boundArea added (units)1/34/2716/24364/2187× 4/9× 4/9× 4/9shrinks towards 0
  • Perimeters: 27, 36, 48, 64, … Rule × 4/3. The multiplier is more than 1, so the terms grow without bound.
  • Areas added: 1/3, 4/27, 16/243, … Rule × 4/9. The multiplier is less than 1, so the terms shrink towards zero.
  • Both are geometric sequences: each term is the one before multiplied by the same number.
Quick check
?The perimeters 27, 36, 48, 64, … cm form a sequence. What is its term-to-term rule?
Recap

The big ideas

  • The rule: cut each edge in thirds, replace the middle third with two sides of a smaller equilateral triangle.
  • Edges × 4, length × 1/3, so the perimeter × 4/3 each step: 27, 36, 48, 64 cm. It grows without bound.
  • New triangles × 4, each area × 1/9, so the area added × 4/9 each step: 1/3, 4/27, 16/243. The shape never leaves one circle.
  • At every stage the shape is finite. "Infinite" describes the never-ending process, not any one stage.
  • Six lines of symmetry and order 6, from the stage-1 star onwards. Zoom in: the same shape again, a fractal.
❄️

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've finished The Snowflake with an Infinite Edge. 🎉

  1. Mission 1How can a shape have an infinite perimeter?
  2. Mission 2Can a shape with an infinite edge still fit on a page?
  3. Mission 3You start with a triangle. So why six arms?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a mate to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

❄️ More winter lessons

📚 Sources for this lesson (10)
  1. Department for Education, Mathematics: GCSE subject content and assessment objectives, November 2013, reference DFE-00233-2013. PDF: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/254441/GCSE_mathematics_subject_content_and_assessment_objectives.pdf. Content references used: N2, N12 (Number, p. 4–5); A23, A24 (Sequences, p. 8); R12 (Ratio, proportion and rates of change, p. 8); G1, G16, G17, G19 (Geometry and measures, p. 9–10). The document's typographic convention (standard / underlined / bold for tiers) is on p. 4. The PDF's font and underline data was checked at review: N2, N12, A23, G1, G16, G17 are standard type; in A24 "simple geometric progressions (rⁿ where n is an integer, and r is a rational number > 0" is underlined and "or a surd) and other sequences" is bold; in R12 "make links to similarity (including trigonometric ratios)" is underlined; in G19 "areas and volumes" is bold (Higher only) and the rest of the statement underlined.
  2. Department for Education, National curriculum in England: mathematics programmes of study, Key Stage 3 section: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-curriculum-in-england-mathematics-programmes-of-study/national-curriculum-in-england-mathematics-programmes-of-study. Bullets used: "generate terms of a sequence from either a term-to-term or a position-to-term rule"; "use the 4 operations … applied to … proper and improper fractions"; "interpret fractions and percentages as operators"; "derive and apply formulae to calculate and solve problems involving: perimeter and area of triangles, parallelograms …"; "regular polygons, and other polygons that are reflectively and rotationally symmetric"; "identify properties of, and describe the results of, translations, rotations and reflections applied to given figures".
  3. O'Connor, J. J. and Robertson, E. F., "Niels Fabian Helge von Koch", MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive, University of St Andrews: https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Koch/. Used for: Koch's full name, dates (born 25 January 1870, Stockholm; died 11 March 1924, Danderyd), the 1904 paper's title and its translation, the construction of the curve from a segment and of the snowflake from an equilateral triangle, and the description of the result as a continuous curve of infinite length with no tangent at any point.
  4. zbMATH Open, record for H. von Koch, "Sur une courbe continue sans tangente, obtenue par une construction géométrique élémentaire", Arkiv för Matematik, Astronomi och Fysik 1, 681–702 (1904), JFM 35.0387.02: https://zbmath.org/2653553 (retrieved through the zbMATH Open API). Used for the journal, volume and page numbers.
  5. Weisstein, E. W., "Koch Snowflake", MathWorld (Wolfram Research): https://mathworld.wolfram.com/KochSnowflake.html. Used to confirm the construction ("replacing the middle third of each side by the two other sides of an outward-pointing equilateral triangle"), N_n = 3·4ⁿ, L_n = (1/3)ⁿ, perimeter 3(4/3)ⁿ, the area recurrence A_n = A_(n−1) + (1/3)(4/9)^(n−1)Δ and the limiting area 8/5 Δ, and "first described by Koch (1904)".
  6. O'Connor, J. J. and Robertson, E. F., "Benoit Mandelbrot", MacTutor History of Mathematics Archive: https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Mandelbrot/. Used for Mandelbrot's dates (20 November 1924 – 14 October 2010) and the 1975 book Les objets fractals: forme, hasard et dimension.
  7. IBM, "Fractal geometry" (IBM history pages): https://www.ibm.com/history/fractal-geometry. Used for: "He coined the term 'fractal' to refer to a new class of mathematical shapes", derived "from the Latin word fractus, meaning broken or uneven".
  8. Scientific American, Observations blog, "Famed mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot, father of fractal geometry, dead at 85" (October 2010): https://www.scientificamerican.com/blog/observations/famed-mathematician-benoit-mandelbrot-father-of-fractal-geometry-dead-at-85/. Used for: "Mandelbrot coined the term 'fractal' in 1975".
  9. Libbrecht, K. G. (Professor of Physics, California Institute of Technology), SnowCrystals.com, "Snowflake science": https://www.snowcrystals.com/science/science.html. Used for the single bridging line in 3.6: "The six-fold symmetry you see in a snow crystal arises from the arrangement of water molecules in the ice crystal lattice."
  10. All arithmetic (edge counts, edge lengths, perimeters 27, 36, 48, 64, 85⅓ cm; areas added 1/3, 4/27, 16/243, 64/2187; ratios 4/3 and 4/9; 27 × (4/3)¹⁰⁰ ≈ 8.4 × 10¹³ cm ≈ 8.4 × 10⁸ km; the bounding-circle check to stage 6) computed exactly with Python's `fractions` module in this session.

→ GCSE Maths revision