← A-Level English Language · Edexcel · A-Level English Language revision
⭐ 0
Pearson Edexcel A-level English Language (9EN0) · Investigating Language: Journalism
Mini-Lesson

Investigating Language: Journalism

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1'Flood in' or 'arrive': same people, same event. What did the verb do?
  2. Mission 2How does a headteacher's 'Shall we sit down?' differ from a friend's?
  3. Mission 3You've recorded your family at dinner. What question could it answer?
Mission 1

'Flood in' or 'arrive': same people, same event. What did the verb do?

Make a guess: 'Flood in' or 'arrive': same people, same event. What did the verb do?

Language in the media · representation and agencyScreen 1

Representation and framing

Same event, different representationThe Daily BeaconMigrants flood in atPort EllisGreyport Ledger120 people arrive atPort Ellis by boatSame event, different representation. Invented outlets(dailybeacon.example, greyportledger.example) andheadlines.
  • News doesn't just report events: it represents them, choosing what to include, what to call it and what comes first.
  • Lexical choice: protesters or rioters; arrive or flood in. Water metaphors (flood, wave) present people as an uncontrolled mass and a danger.
  • Framing: Robert Entman (1993) defines it as selecting some aspects of a reality and making them more salient, to promote a particular definition of the problem, cause, moral judgement or remedy.
Language in the media · representation and agencyScreen 2

Transitivity: who does what to whom

Who does what to whomActivePoliceinjured12 protestersPassive with agent12 protesterswere injuredby policeAgentless passive12 protesterswere injuredactor?Nominalisationthe injuriesjob lossesactor?Red box = the actor (the doer). Dashed grey = actorhidden.

Transitivity analysis (from Halliday) asks who is the Actor (the doer), what is the Process (the verb) and who is the Goal (the one the process is done to).

FormExampleWho caused it?
ActivePolice injured 12 protestersshown, first
Passive with agent12 protesters were injured by policeshown, last
Agentless passive12 protesters were injuredhidden
Nominalisationthe injuries, job losseshidden
  • Norman Fairclough (Language and Power, 1989) argues such choices are ideological: critical discourse analysis asks whose interests they serve.
Extract Language in the media · representation and agencyScreen 3

Two reports of one protest (invented examples)

TEXT A, The Daily Beacon (dailybeacon.example)

TWELVE HURT AS JOBS PROTEST TURNS UGLY

Twelve protesters were injured yesterday when a demonstration outside the Vantor Motors plant in Greyport got out of hand. Hundreds of workers had gathered after 500 job losses were announced on Monday. Shoppers told of chaos as the crowd surged towards the gates.

TEXT B, Greyport Ledger (greyportledger.example)

POLICE CHARGE INJURES 12 AT JOBS PROTEST

Riot officers charged a peaceful crowd of workers outside Vantor Motors yesterday, injuring twelve. The workers were protesting after the company axed 500 jobs on Monday. "We were just standing there," said one machinist.

Source: Written for this lesson (invented example: both outlets, the company, the town and the people are invented).
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the passive in Text A that hides who caused the injuries. (Use the extract on screen 3.)

Tap a word in the extract.

, (.)

. . .

, (.)

, . . " ," .

Source: Written for this lesson (invented example: both outlets, the company, the town and the people are invented).
Sort itScreen 5
?Does each clause or phrase from the extract show or hide the actor? (Use the extract on screen 3.)
Show the extract (screen 3)

TEXT A, The Daily Beacon (dailybeacon.example)

TWELVE HURT AS JOBS PROTEST TURNS UGLY

Twelve protesters were injured yesterday when a demonstration outside the Vantor Motors plant in Greyport got out of hand. Hundreds of workers had gathered after 500 job losses were announced on Monday. Shoppers told of chaos as the crowd surged towards the gates.

TEXT B, Greyport Ledger (greyportledger.example)

POLICE CHARGE INJURES 12 AT JOBS PROTEST

Riot officers charged a peaceful crowd of workers outside Vantor Motors yesterday, injuring twelve. The workers were protesting after the company axed 500 jobs on Monday. "We were just standing there," said one machinist.

Source: Written for this lesson (invented example: both outlets, the company, the town and the people are invented).

Tap a statement, then tap the group it belongs in. Then press Check.

Language in the media · representation and agencyScreen 6

Bias, stance and the multimodal page

The multimodal news pagedailybeacon.exampleThe Daily BeaconTWELVE HURT ASJOBS PROTESTTURNS UGLYHundreds of workers hadgathered after 500 job losseswere announced on Monday.imageOutside the plant gatesShoppers told of chaos as thecrowd surged towards thegates.“Commentsheadlinestandfirstimagecaptionreporting verbpull quotecomment threadInvented outlet; generic image placeholder.
  • Voices: who is quoted (officials or witnesses) and the reporting verbs (said, claimed, admitted).
  • Evaluative lexis and modifiers (peaceful, ugly) and modality signal stance in a text that claims objectivity.
  • Synthetic personalisation (Fairclough, 1989): a mass audience is addressed as individuals, often with you.
  • Graphology: headline size, image, caption, layout; online, hyperlinks and comment threads.
  • Edexcel's terms: weigh bias, subjectivity and objectivity across print and online journalism.
Pick the strongestScreen 7
?Which comment best analyses the Ledger's headline, 'Police charge injures 12 at jobs protest'?
Language in the media · representation and agencyScreen 8

How your exam asks this

  • Component 3, Language and Journalism (1 h 45, 45 marks): a subtopic is pre-released on 1 December. Section A (15 marks) analyses unseen data from it; Section B (30 marks) is an evaluative essay that must connect with data from your own investigation.
  • Expect print and online journalism, and questions about context, audience, purpose and bias.
Mission checkScreen 9

?'Flood in' or 'arrive': same people, same event. What did the verb do?
Mission 2

How does a headteacher's 'Shall we sit down?' differ from a friend's?

Make a guess: How does a headteacher's 'Shall we sit down?' differ from a friend's?

Language diversity · language and powerScreen 1

What kind of power?

What kind of power?Instrumental (Wareing1999)A head: 'Phones away,please.'Influential (Wareing1999)An advert: 'Join 10,000happy members.'Power in discourse(Fairclough 1989)A teacher deciding whospeaks nextPower behind discourse(Fairclough 1989)institution: the schoolsystem behind theteacherInvented examples.
ConceptWhoMeaningInvented example
Instrumental powerWareing (1999)Power held through a role or authority, backed by rulesA head: 'Phones away, please.'
Influential powerWareing (1999)Power to persuade, without the authority to commandAn advert: 'Join 10,000 happy members.'
Power in discourseFairclough (1989)Power exercised inside an interaction: topics, turns, terms of addressA teacher deciding who speaks next
Power behind discourseFairclough (1989)The social structures that make that control seem normalThe school system behind the teacher
  • Fairclough's critical discourse analysis shows how language makes unequal power look natural.
Language diversity · language and powerScreen 2

Face, politeness and indirectness

Four politeness strategiesmost directBald on record'Sit down.'Positive politeness'Shall we all grab a seat, guys?'Negative politeness'Could you possibly sit down?'Off record'Plenty of chairs free.'don't do the FTAleast directmorepower,distance orimposition:movedownInvented examples. Brown and Levinson (1978; 1987).
  • Face (Goffman, 1967): the public self-image we want to protect. Brown and Levinson (1978; 1987): positive face = the wish to be liked; negative face = the wish not to be imposed on.
  • Orders, requests and criticism are face-threatening acts (FTAs). Choice of strategy depends on power, social distance and size of imposition.
StrategyInvented example
Bald on record'Sit down.'
Positive politeness (stress closeness)'Shall we all grab a seat, guys?'
Negative politeness (avoid imposing)'Could you possibly sit down?'
Off record (hint)'Plenty of chairs free.'
  • Grice (1975): hearers assume we cooperate, so a hint creates an implicature they must work out.
Language diversity · language and powerScreen 3

Powerful and powerless speech

  • In unequal encounters the powerful speaker opens and closes the talk, sets topics, asks the questions, can phrase orders as questions (indirect directives), may interrupt, and chooses terms of address (first name downwards, title upwards).
  • O'Barr and Atkins (1980): low-status witnesses in US trials, of both sexes, used more hedges and intensifiers: powerless language.
  • Synthetic personalisation (Fairclough, 1989): mass texts address everyone as one friendly 'you'.
  • Edexcel also lists political discourse, persuasion and prestige: ask who gains from each choice.
Extract Language diversity · language and powerScreen 4

A meeting in the head's office

A meeting in the head's office1HEAD:ah (.) Kai (.) come in (.) shall we sit down2KAI:yeah sure sir3HEAD:now (.) I'm sure you know why you'rehere4KAI:is it about the coursework5HEAD:it is (.) I wonder if you could possibly getthe draft to me by Friday6KAI:I'll try and //7HEAD:// Friday (.) thanks Kai(.)micro pause//overlapping speechInvented example.
HEAD: ah (.) Kai (.) come in (.) shall we sit down
KAI: yeah sure sir
HEAD: now (.) I'm sure you know why you're here
KAI: is it about the coursework
HEAD: it is (.) I wonder if you could possibly get the draft to me by Friday
KAI: I'll try and //
HEAD: // Friday (.) thanks Kai
Source: Written for this lesson (invented example). Key: (.) micro pause · // overlapping speech.
Tap the evidenceScreen 5
?Tap the phrase where the head uses negative politeness to soften a request. (Use the extract on screen 4.)

Tap a word in the extract.

: (.) (.) (.)
:
: (.)
:
: (.)
: //
: // (.)
Source: Written for this lesson (invented example). Key: (.) micro pause · // overlapping speech.
Sort itScreen 6
?Which politeness strategy does each invented request use?

Tap a statement, then tap the group it belongs in. Then press Check.

Language diversity · language and powerScreen 7

How your exam asks this

  • Component 3 (1 h 45, 45 marks), Language and Power: Section A on unseen data from the pre-released subtopic (15 marks); Section B an evaluative essay linked to your own investigation (30 marks).
  • On the Language and Journalism topic, use these ideas to ask whose voices a story quotes, names and frames.
Rank themScreen 8
?Rank these analyses of the head's 'shall we sit down' (screen 4), strongest first.
Show the extract (screen 4)
HEAD: ah (.) Kai (.) come in (.) shall we sit down
KAI: yeah sure sir
HEAD: now (.) I'm sure you know why you're here
KAI: is it about the coursework
HEAD: it is (.) I wonder if you could possibly get the draft to me by Friday
KAI: I'll try and //
HEAD: // Friday (.) thanks Kai
Source: Written for this lesson (invented example). Key: (.) micro pause · // overlapping speech.

Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.

Mission checkScreen 9

?How does a headteacher's 'Shall we sit down?' differ from a friend's?
Mission 3

You've recorded your family at dinner. What question could it answer?

Make a guess: You've recorded your family at dinner. What question could it answer?

Language investigation · question, data, methodScreen 1

From topic to question

From topic to questionArea of interest: family talkTopic: questions at dinnerResearch question:how do two speakers'questions differ in form andfunction?A good question is specific · answerable · comparative.
  • Start with an area of interest, then narrow it to a research question your own data can answer.
  • A good question is specific, answerable from the data and often comparative (two groups, two settings).
  • You may add a hypothesis, a prediction to test, but your conclusion can reject it.
Rank themScreen 2
?Rank these research questions for a family-dinner recording, from strongest to weakest.

Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.

Language investigation · question, data, methodScreen 3

Collecting data

A transcript with a key1P1:can you pass the potatoes (.) please2C1:[here you go]3P2:[thanks] (.) so how was school today4C1:(2) fine (.) we did fractionsKey(.)= micropause[ ]= overlapping speech(2)= pause in secondsInvented example. Speakers anonymised as labels.
  • Choose the type: spoken, written, multimodal, word lists, or attitudes (surveys, interviews).
  • Collect enough to see patterns, and keep the conditions comparable.
  • Observer's paradox (Labov, 1972): we want to study how people speak when not being observed, but we can only find out by observing them. Reduce it by recording for longer and using later sections.
  • Transcribe spoken data with a key (pauses, overlaps); give speakers labels.
Language investigation · question, data, methodScreen 4

Choosing methods

  • Quantitative: count features and compare (e.g. number of questions per speaker per hour), shown in tables or charts.
  • Qualitative: close analysis of examples in context, using the language levels and frameworks (e.g. politeness, turn-taking).
  • Strong investigations combine both: counts show the pattern, examples explain it.
  • Evaluate your method: sample size, what you couldn't control, what you'd do next.
Language investigation · question, data, methodScreen 5

Ethics

  • Informed consent: tell people what you're studying and get their permission, spoken or written.
  • Under 16: you also need a parent's or carer's permission.
  • Right to withdraw: anyone can pull out, even after agreeing.
  • Anonymity: no real names or identifying details; use labels (Speaker A, Parent 1). Keep recordings secure.
  • No secret recording: BAAL guidance calls deception unacceptable. If knowing the aim would change how people speak, give the general purpose, or explain straight after and delete the data if anyone refuses.
Sort itScreen 6
?Is each plan ethical as it stands, or does it need fixing? (Invented scenarios.)

Tap a statement, then tap the group it belongs in. Then press Check.

Language investigation · question, data, methodScreen 7

How your exam asks this

  • Edexcel Component 3 (exam, 1 hour 45 minutes, 45 marks): research one pre-released subtopic (out each 1 December) and collect your own data. Section A: unseen data, 15 marks. Section B: 30 marks, linking to data from your investigation. You can't take your research into the exam.
Quick checkScreen 8
?Gil wants to know whether his two younger sisters, aged 9 and 14, use more slang with friends than with their parents. Which plan best answers his question?
Mission checkScreen 9

?You've recorded your family at dinner. What question could it answer?
Recap

Big ideas

  • News represents events through choices of lexis, metaphor and order; framing (Entman, 1993) makes some aspects salient.
  • Transitivity: active voice shows the actor; agentless passives and nominalisation hide it (Fairclough, 1989: such choices are ideological).
  • Stance shows in voices, reporting verbs, evaluative lexis, modality and graphology.
  • Component 3: research the pre-released journalism subtopic; weigh bias, subjectivity and objectivity.
  • Power can be instrumental (from a role) or influential (from persuasion) (Wareing); Fairclough separates power in discourse from power behind it.
  • Brown and Levinson's face and politeness strategies, and Grice's implicature, explain how indirect forms can carry commands.
  • In unequal encounters the powerful control topics, turns and address; O'Barr and Atkins linked 'powerless' features to status.
  • Narrow a topic into a specific, answerable, often comparative research question; a hypothesis is optional and can be rejected.
  • Match data and method to the question: combine quantitative counts with qualitative analysis, and evaluate your method's limits. Reduce the observer's paradox.
  • Ethics: informed consent (parents too for under-16s), right to withdraw, anonymity, no secret recording.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Investigating Language: Journalism for Pearson Edexcel A-level English Language. 🎉

  1. Mission 1'Flood in' or 'arrive': same people, same event. What did the verb do?
  2. Mission 2How does a headteacher's 'Shall we sit down?' differ from a friend's?
  3. Mission 3You've recorded your family at dinner. What question could it answer?

Your stars: 0 / 0

Next: more lessons and games on the A-Level English Language · Edexcel page.

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a mate to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level English Language · Edexcel

Specification points and sources for this lesson are listed at the bottom of the page.

Sources (18)

The specification points and sources behind this lesson.

  1. 1 Pearson Edexcel 9EN0 spec Issue 6, Component 3
  2. 2 Pearson Edexcel 9EN0 spec Issue 6, Component 3 overview and Language and Power; Language and Journalism ; Appendix 6 transcription key
  3. 3 Edexcel 9EN0 Issue 6 : Component 3
  4. 4 Willamette University framing notes, "Selection and Salience (Entman)", https://people.willamette.edu/~ccollins/framing/allenm/selectionandsalience.htm (Entman, R. M. 1993, "Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm", Journal of Communication 43(4))
  5. 5 Halliday, M. A. K., An Introduction to Functional Grammar (1985) (general attribution; not checked online)
  6. 6 Fairclough, N. (1989) Language and Power, Longman (paraphrase; not checked online beyond S6)
  7. 7 Wikipedia, "Synthetic personalisation" (citing Fairclough 1989), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synthetic_personalisation
  8. 8 Vaia, "Language and Power", https://www.hellovaia.com/explanations/english/key-concepts-in-language-and-linguistics/language-and-power/
  9. 9 WSU Scalar, "Fairclough: Language and Power", https://scalar.libraries.wsu.edu/fournier/fairclough-language--power
  10. 10 Vaia, "Norman Fairclough", https://www.hellovaia.com/explanations/english/key-concepts-in-language-and-linguistics/norman-fairclough/
  11. 11 "Politeness theory" (archived encyclopedia article), https://wikipedia2007.classicistranieri.com/en/p/o/l/Politeness_theory.html
  12. 12 Vaia
  13. 13 Grice, H. P. (1975) "Logic and Conversation", in Cole and Morgan (eds) Syntax and Semantics 3
  14. 14 Githens course notes, "A Theory of 'Powerless Language'" (Georgetown), https://faculty.georgetown.edu/bassr/githens/powrless.htm
  15. 15 Loughborough University library record, Language, Society and Power: an introduction, ed. Thomas and Wareing, https://vufind.lboro.ac.uk/Record/360895/Details
  16. 16 BAAL, Recommendations for good practice in Applied Linguistics student projects (2000), https://www.baal.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/goodpractice_stud.pdf
  17. 17 "Observer's paradox", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Observer%27s_paradox (citing Labov, Sociolinguistic Patterns, 1972, p. 209)
  18. 18 All scenarios, people and research questions: invented for this lesson