← A-Level Economics · CCEA A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Economics (AS and A2) · Market structures; Perfect competition; Monopoly; Monopolistic competition
Mini-Lesson

Market structures; Perfect competition; Monopoly; Monopolistic competition

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Can a market with only one firm still behave as if it were full of competitors?
  2. Mission 2Can a new idea that wipes out whole industries still leave an economy better off?
  3. Mission 3Why can't one wheat farmer charge even slightly more than the market price?
  4. Mission 4When a product is very profitable and anyone can start selling it, where do the profits go?
  5. Mission 5Why can two people sitting side by side on the same train have paid very different fares?
  6. Mission 6Why might it make sense for only one company to lay the water pipes in a city?
  7. Mission 7Why can a popular new kind of café make big profits at first, then only just cover its costs later?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Market failure (part 1); 1 mission in Costs and revenues; 2 missions in Business objectives; Business growth; Measuring markets.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Can a market with only one firm still behave as if it were full of competitors?

Make a guess: Can a market with only one firm still behave as if it were full of competitors?

Mission 1

The threat of entry

Threat of entrythe marketone firmopen doorpotentialentrantsA perfectly contestable market has:free entry and free exit (no sunk costs)the same technology for entrantsperfect information about prices and profits
  • A contestable market: one where new firms can enter and leave easily, so the threat of entry disciplines the firms already there.
  • What counts is how easy it is to get in and out, not how many firms there are now.
  • Perfectly contestable market:
    • free entry and free exit: no sunk costs
    • entrants can use the same technology and reach the same costs as incumbents
    • perfect information about prices and profits
  • In theory, even a market with one firm can be perfectly contestable.
  • William Baumol and colleagues set out the theory in 1982.
Mission 1

Sunk costs

Sunk vs recoverablesunk costcannot be recoveredon exitlaunch advertisingspecialist researcha non-refundablelicencemachinery with noother userecoverable on exitcan be sold, leased orendeda delivery vanan aircraftrent on a short lease
  • Sunk cost: a cost that cannot be recovered when a firm leaves the market.
  • Examples: launch advertising, specialist research, a non-refundable licence, machinery with no other use.
  • Not sunk: a delivery van or an aircraft, which can be sold or leased to someone else.
  • Sunk costs are a barrier to exit, and so a barrier to entry: an entrant risks losing them if it has to leave.
  • Say: "a sunk cost cannot be recovered on exit" — not: "a sunk cost is any fixed cost". Rent on a short lease is fixed but can be ended.
Quick check
?A firm is thinking of starting a new bus service on a local route. Which of these costs is most likely to be a sunk cost?
Mission 1

Worked example: hit-and-run entry

Hit-and-runPrice0100Quantityincumbent price 15entrant14price falls to ACprice = AC:normal profit onlyAC = 10entrant leavesentrant's profit: (14 - 10) × 100 = 400Incumbent: price 15, above AC = 10.No sunk costs: the entrant leaves with nothinglost.
  • Illustrative data. One incumbent charges 15. Its AC = 10: supernormal profit of 5 a unit.
  • An entrant with the same AC of 10 undercuts at 14.
  • It sells 100 units before the incumbent can react.
  • Profit while there: (14 − 10) × 100 = 400.
  • The incumbent cuts its price. The entrant leaves. No sunk costs, so it loses nothing on exit.
  • This is hit-and-run competition: enter, take the profit, leave.
  • So the incumbent's best defence is to price at AC from the start: normal profit only.
Mission 1Graph lab

How high can the price go?

Illustrative data. Incumbent AC = MC = 10. Its profit-maximising price is 16. A hit-and-run entrant would sell 100 units before the incumbent reacts. It enters if its profit while there is greater than its sunk cost of entry.

How high can the price go?PriceQuantity01003000162020010DAC = MCprofit-maximising price 16
  • Takeaway: the higher the sunk costs, the higher the price the incumbent can safely charge. The market is less contestable.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. An incumbent has an average cost of 8. A hit-and-run entrant with the same costs would sell 50 units before the incumbent could react, and would have sunk costs of 150. It enters only if its profit while there is greater than its sunk costs. What is the highest price the incumbent can charge without attracting entry?
Mission 1

Contestability and efficiency

Contestable natural monopolyPrice0PmP = ACQmQcQuantityACMCD = ARMRMonopoly: MR = MC gives Pm and Qm.Contestable: price is pushed down to P = AC, atQc.
  • In a perfectly contestable market, in the long run:
    • Normal profit only (P = AC). Any supernormal profit invites hit-and-run entry.
    • Productive efficiency: a firm that does not produce at the lowest possible cost is undercut.
    • X-inefficiency is squeezed out: slack is punished.
    • With two or more firms, P = MC: allocative efficiency.
  • A single firm with falling AC (a natural monopoly) prices at P = AC, not P = MC: P = MC would mean a loss.
  • So behaviour depends on how easy entry is, not just on how many firms there are now.
Mission 1

Barriers to entry and exit

  • Every barrier makes a market less contestable.
  • Barriers to entry:
    • Sunk costs: start-up advertising, specialist equipment.
    • Economies of scale: an entrant starts small with higher AC.
    • Product differentiation and branding: loyal customers.
    • Intellectual property (patents, copyright) and R&D spending.
    • Legal barriers: licences, regulation.
    • Incumbents' strategy: limit pricing, predatory pricing.
  • Barriers to exit: sunk costs written off, long contracts, redundancy payments.
Quick check
?A market is served by one firm whose average cost falls over the whole range of market demand. The market is perfectly contestable. In the long run, where will the firm set its price?
Mission 1

Real markets: how contestable?

  • Airline routes were the classic example: aircraft can move from route to route, so entry to one route looks cheap.
  • The EU opened its internal air market fully in 1997: any EU airline could fly any route inside the EU. Low-cost airlines entered many routes.
  • But later studies of US routes found fares were lower where more airlines actually flew. The threat of entry alone did not hold fares down fully.
  • Reasons: airport slots, branding, loyalty schemes and incumbents' fast price cuts.
  • Usefulness of the model:
    • It explains why some firms with large market shares still keep prices low.
    • It shows that market structure is not everything: conduct depends on entry conditions.
    • Few real markets are perfectly contestable.
Mission 1Evaluate

Does contestability protect consumers?

  • Advantages: lower prices, normal profit, productive efficiency, pressure to innovate, without the need for many firms.
  • Disadvantages: supernormal profit is low, so there may be less to spend on R&D; firms may focus on short-run survival.
  • It depends on the size of sunk costs: high sunk costs, little threat.
  • It depends on how fast incumbents react: a quick price cut makes hit-and-run unprofitable.
  • It depends on information: entrants must know profits are there.
  • It depends on policy: removing barriers (deregulation, opening markets) may do more than breaking up firms.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: one coach company runs the only service between two towns. It earns large supernormal profits. Which change is most likely to make it lower its fares, even though no rival has yet entered?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can a new idea that wipes out whole industries still leave an economy better off?

Make a guess: A new technology wipes out an old industry. What happens to the economy as a whole?

Mission 2

Invention and innovation

  • Invention: creating a new idea, product or process, often protected by a patent.
  • Innovation: turning an invention into something used commercially: a product people buy, or a method firms adopt.
  • Many inventions are never innovated; the gain to the economy comes from innovation.
  • Research and development (R&D): spending on finding and developing new products and processes.
  • Example: a Kodak engineer built the first digital camera in 1975, but the firm's main business stayed camera film for decades.
  • Say: "invention creates the idea; innovation brings it to market" — not: using the two words as if they mean the same.
Quick check
?A university lab develops a new battery that stores twice as much energy. Five years later a car maker starts selling cars that use it. Which statement is correct?
Mission 2

Creative destruction

Creative destructionSalesTimeOld product (film): firms fade outNew product (digital): firms appear
  • Creative destruction (Joseph Schumpeter, 1942): innovation creates new products, firms and markets and destroys old ones.
  • Example: digital photography and then smartphone cameras replaced film. Kodak, long the giant of camera film, filed for bankruptcy protection in January 2012.
  • Effects on market structure:
  • It can break monopoly power: a newcomer with a better product can overtake a dominant firm that seemed safe behind its barriers to entry.
  • It rewards the innovator with temporary supernormal profit, until others copy or leapfrog it.
  • It can also create new dominant firms, especially in digital markets.
Quick check
?Streaming services spread quickly. Many shops renting out films on disc closed, while new firms making shows for streaming grew fast. How is this best described?
Mission 2

Does market power help innovation?

  • For (Schumpeter): firms with market power earn supernormal (abnormal) profit, which can finance R&D. Large firms can also bear the risk of failed projects.
  • Patents give an innovator a temporary monopoly (usually up to 20 years), so it can earn the profit that rewards its R&D.
  • Against: a monopolist that already earns high profit may feel little pressure to innovate. In competitive markets, firms must innovate or lose customers.
  • Oligopolies often compete through innovation and other non-price competition. Perfectly competitive firms earn only normal profit in the long run and new ideas are copied at once, so they have little means or reason to do R&D.
Quick check
?Which statement best supports the view that large firms with market power can benefit consumers through innovation?
Mission 2Evaluate

Is creative destruction worth it?

  • Consumers gain new and cheaper products; displaced workers and owners lose jobs and capital.
  • It depends on time: job losses come first; higher productivity and new jobs may take years.
  • It depends on mobility: workers whose skills fit the old industry may stay unemployed (structural unemployment) unless they retrain or move.
  • It depends on what follows: if new dominant firms build high barriers, competition may weaken until the next wave.
  • It depends on policy: patent length, competition policy and support for retraining shape both the gains and the losses.
Mission check

?Banking apps spread through a country. Banks close most of their branches and many branch staff lose their jobs, while new firms that build payment software grow fast. Which judgement of the effect on the economy is best supported?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why can't one wheat farmer charge even slightly more than the market price?

Make a guess: Why can't one wheat farmer charge even slightly more than the market price?

Mission 3

The assumptions

Assumptions of perfect competitionmany sellersidentical productsperfect informationfree entry and exit
  • Perfect competition assumes:
    • many buyers and sellers, each too small to affect the price
    • identical (homogeneous) products: one seller's output is a perfect substitute for another's
    • perfect information: everyone knows every price
    • free entry and exit: no barriers
  • Also assumed: firms aim to maximise profit; factors of production are mobile.
  • Real markets come close, but never fully: wheat and other crops, some currency markets.
  • It is a model: few real markets meet every assumption. It is used as a benchmark for comparing other structures.
Mission 3

A price taker

Industry and firmIndustryPrice (£)0PeQeQuantityDSFirm: the price is set by the industryPrice, revenue (£)0PeOutput (q)P = AR = MR = DThe firm's output axis is on a much smallerscale than the industry's.
  • Two diagrams:
    • Industry: market D and S set the price, Pe.
    • Firm: sells any amount it wants at Pe. Its demand curve is horizontal at Pe.
  • Charge above Pe? Buyers switch to identical products: the firm sells nothing.
  • Charge below Pe? Pointless: it can already sell all it wants at Pe.
  • So the firm is a price taker: every extra unit sells for Pe.
  • P = AR = MR = D, a horizontal line.
  • Say: "the firm's demand curve is perfectly elastic" — not: "market demand is perfectly elastic". Market demand slopes down as normal.
Quick check
?In a perfectly competitive market, why is each firm's demand curve horizontal at the market price?
Mission 3

Case: the world wheat price

  • Wheat (US hard red winter), world price, annual averages:
    • 2021: about 315 dollars per tonne
    • 2022: about 430 dollars per tonne
    • 2023: about 340 dollars per tonne
  • 2022 was the year Russia invaded Ukraine; both are major wheat exporters.
  • No single farmer caused these swings, and none could resist them.
  • Each farmer's only choice: how much to grow and sell at the world price.
Mission 3

How much to produce?

MC = MRPrice, revenue (£)0Output (q)P = AR = MR = DMCLeft of the crossing: MC < MR, so produce more.Right of it: MC > MR, so produce less.Profit is greatest where MC = MR, on the risingpart of MC.
  • Profit is maximised where MC = MR.
  • For a price taker, MR = P. So produce where MC = P, on the rising part of MC.
  • Why:
    • MC below P: the next unit adds more to revenue than to cost → produce it.
    • MC above P: the unit adds more to cost than to revenue → don't produce it.
Mission 3

Profit, normal profit or loss

Three outcomes for a price takerCosts, revenue (£)0Output (q)MCACtangentto ACP = AR = MR = Dsupernormal profit = (P − AC) × qP = AR = MR = Dnormal profit: P = AC at the output where MC =MRP = AR = MR = Dloss = (AC − P) × q
  • Find output where MC = MR. Then compare AR (= P) with AC at that output.
  • P > AC: supernormal profit = (P − AC) × Q, a rectangle.
  • P = AC: normal profit (break-even): just enough to keep the firm in this industry.
  • P < AC: loss = (AC − P) × Q.
  • Say: "supernormal (or abnormal) profit" — not: "a big profit". Normal profit is already counted in AC as a cost.
Mission 3

Worked example: two prices

Three outcomes for a price takerCosts, revenue (£)02926152030Output (q)MCACtangentto ACP = AR = MR = Dnormal profit: P = AC at the output where MC =MRP = AR = MR = Dloss = (AC − P) × q
  • Illustrative data. One firm's costs (fixed cost 360):
OutputMCAVCAC
20151129
30261426
40431928
  • Price 26: MC = 26 at 30 units. AC = 26 → normal profit.
  • Price 15: MC = 15 at 20 units. Loss = (29 − 15) × 20 = 280.
Quick check
?A diagram shows a perfectly competitive firm with MC, AC and a horizontal line at price P. MC = MR at output Q1. At Q1, AC is below P.
AreaPosition
ARectangle from AC to P in height, 0 to Q1 in width
BRectangle from 0 to P in height, 0 to Q1 in width
CArea between the MC curve and the price line, from 0 to Q1
DRectangle from 0 to AC in height, 0 to Q1 in width

Which area shows the firm's supernormal (abnormal, economic) profit?

Mission 3Graph lab

Price changes

The firm from an earlier screen. Price is now 26; the firm makes normal profit at 30 units.

Price changesPrice and costOutput0102040500204060q = 3026MCACP = MR
  • Takeaway: output follows the MC curve. At 43, MC = 43 at 40 units, so output is 40 and supernormal profit is (43 − 28) × 40 = 600 (TR 43 × 40 = 1,720; TC 28 × 40 = 1,120).
Mission 3

Shut down or carry on?

Shutdown and supplyCosts, revenue (£)010Output (q)ACAVCMCshutdown price = minimum AVC
  • In the short run, fixed costs must be paid even at zero output.
  • Shut down → loss = fixed cost.
  • Carry on → loss = TC − TR.
  • Rule: carry on if TR ≥ TVC, i.e. P ≥ AVC. Revenue covers variable costs and pays part of the fixed cost.
  • Shut down if P < AVC at every output.
  • Shutdown price = minimum AVC.
  • The firm from an earlier screen: shutdown price = minimum AVC = 10.
Mission 3Graph lab

Close or keep going?

Same firm. Fixed cost 360. Shutdown loss = 360.

Close or keep going?Price and costOutput01020405001020304050q = 3026MCACAVCP = MRshutdown price 10
  • Takeaway: produce as long as P ≥ AVC. At 15: TR 300 > TVC 11 × 20 = 220, so the extra 80 pays part of the fixed cost and the loss is 280 < 360: carry on. Below 10, shutting down loses less.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A perfectly competitive firm faces a price of 8. Where MC = 8, it would produce 100 units, with AVC of 9 and AC of 12. What should it do in the short run?
Mission 3

The firm's supply curve

Shutdown and supplyCosts, revenue (£)010Output (q)ACAVCMCshutdown price = minimum AVCfirm's short-runsupply curve
  • At each price, the firm produces where P = MC.
  • So its MC curve shows how much it supplies at each price.
  • Below minimum AVC it supplies nothing.
  • Firm's short-run supply curve = its MC curve above minimum AVC.
  • Industry supply = the firms' supply curves added sideways (horizontally).
Mission check

?A firm sells standard cardboard boxes in a perfectly competitive market. The market price is 15 per box. At its current output, the marginal cost of its last box is 12. What should it do to maximise profit?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When a product is very profitable and anyone can start selling it, where do the profits go?

Make a guess: When a product is very profitable and anyone can start selling it, where do the profits go?

Mission 4

The long run

  • Long run: all factors can change. Firms can enter or leave the industry.
  • In perfect competition there are no barriers, so entry and exit are free.
  • Normal profit: the minimum return needed to keep the firm's resources in this industry. It is their opportunity cost.
  • Normal profit is counted inside AC. So at P = AC, the owners earn just enough to stay.
  • Say: "normal profit" — not: "no profit". The owners are still paid their opportunity cost.
Mission 4

Supernormal profit attracts entry

Supernormal profit attracts entryIndustryPrice (£)0P1P2Q1Q2QuantityDS1S2entryFirmCosts, revenue (£)0P1P2q2q1q1Output (q)ACMCAR = MRAR = MRnormal profitsupernormal profitPrice P1 is above minimum AC: supernormalprofit.Supernormal profit attracts entry: industrysupply shifts right, S1 to S2.Price falls to P2 = minimum AC. Each firm cutsoutput back to q2.Normal profit. Entry stops.
  • Build it in steps (two panels: industry and firm):
  • 1. Industry: D and S1 set price P1, above minimum AC. Firm: supernormal profit rectangle.
  • 2. Profit is a signal: new firms enter. Industry supply shifts right: S1 → S2.
  • 3. Price falls to P2 = minimum AC. Each firm cuts output back to the lowest point of AC.
  • 4. Supernormal profit is gone: normal profit only. Entry stops.
Quick check
?A perfectly competitive industry is earning supernormal profit. New firms enter until the long run is reached. What happens to output?
Mission 4

Losses drive exit

Losses drive exitIndustryPrice (£)0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityDS1S2exitFirmCosts, revenue (£)0P2P1q1q2Output (q)ACMCAR = MRlossPrice P1 is below minimum AC: loss. Firmsleave, S1 shifts left, and price rises to P2 =minimum AC.
  • The mirror image:
  • 1. Price below minimum AC: firms make losses.
  • 2. In the long run, loss-making firms leave. Industry supply shifts left: S1 → S2.
  • 3. Price rises back to minimum AC.
  • 4. The firms that remain make normal profit. Exit stops.
Mission 4

Long-run equilibrium

Long-run equilibriumIndustryPrice (£)0PeQeQuantityDSFirmCosts, revenue (£)0PeqeOutput (q)ACMCAR = MRminimum ACP = AR = MR = MC = ACEach firm is at minimum AC, making normalprofit.
  • Entry and exit stop only when price = minimum AC.
  • Firm in long-run equilibrium: P = AR = MR = MC = AC (at its minimum).
  • Each firm makes normal profit: no reason to enter or leave.
  • Industry: D and S set this price; the number of firms adjusts to match demand.
Mission 4Graph lab

A demand boom

Illustrative data. 240 identical firms, each making normal profit at a price of 26. Assume each firm's costs do not change as the industry grows.

A demand boomMarketPriceMarket quantity02040607,20026DS (240 firms)One firmPriceFirm output (q)02040600204060q = 30MCACP = MR (26.0)
  • Takeaway: entry continues until price is back at minimum AC (26). More firms; same output each.
Mission 4

Worked example: the boom, step by step

  • Illustrative data. Each firm: minimum AC = 26 at 30 units.
  • Start: market demand at 26 is 7,200 units → 7,200 ÷ 30 = 240 firms.
  • Short run: demand rises. Still 240 firms. Price jumps to 43; each firm makes 40 units.
    • Industry output: 240 × 40 = 9,600.
    • Profit per firm: (43 − 28) × 40 = 600 (supernormal profit). AC at 40 units = 28.
  • Long run: firms enter until price = 26 again.
    • Market demand at 26 is now 14,700 units → 14,700 ÷ 30 = 490 firms.
  • Industry output doubles and more; each firm is back to 30 units and normal profit.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. In a perfectly competitive industry, each firm's minimum AC is 4 at an output of 500 units. Today 100 firms each produce 550 units and sell at 6. At a price of 4, market demand would be 60,000 units. Costs do not change as firms enter. How many firms will there be in the long run?
Mission 4

Why the long run is efficient

Long-run equilibriumIndustryPrice (£)0PeQeQuantityDSFirmCosts, revenue (£)0PeqeOutput (q)ACMCAR = MRminimum ACP = AR = MR = MC = ACEach firm is at minimum AC, making normalprofit.
  • Allocative efficiency: P = MC. The value of the last unit to buyers equals its cost.
  • Productive efficiency: output at minimum AC, the lowest cost per unit.
  • Consumers pay the lowest price that firms can sustain: minimum AC.
  • Effect on agents: consumers gain the lowest sustainable price; producers earn only normal profit; inefficient firms are driven out.
Mission 4Evaluate

A benchmark, not a description

  • Few real markets meet every assumption: products differ, information is costly, entry takes time and money.
  • It depends on economies of scale: where minimum efficient scale is large, many small firms would each have high costs. A few big firms can produce more cheaply.
  • It depends on innovation: with only normal profit in the long run, and rivals able to copy any idea, firms have little to fund or reward R&D. Dynamic efficiency may be weak.
  • It depends on time: entry and exit can take years, so supernormal profits and losses can last.
  • Still useful: it is the benchmark against which monopoly and other structures are judged.
Mission check

?A city's market for bicycle repairs is perfectly competitive and in long-run equilibrium. The city then charges every repair firm a fixed yearly fee, whatever its output. Demand is unchanged. What happens in the long run?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why can two people sitting side by side on the same train have paid very different fares?

Make a guess: Why can two people sitting side by side on the same train have paid very different fares?

Mission 5

Same product, different prices

  • Price discrimination: charging different buyers different prices for the same good or service, for reasons not linked to cost.
  • Examples: peak and off-peak train fares; child and adult cinema tickets; student discounts.
  • Not price discrimination: a higher price because supplying costs more (e.g. delivery to a remote island).
  • Say: "price discrimination" only when cost is the same — not: for any price difference.
Mission 5

Three conditions

Three conditions for price discrimination1 Market powera price maker, not a price taker2 Groups with different elasticityLess elastichigher pricePED −1.4More elasticlower pricePED −33 No resalelow pricehigh priceIllustrative data.

1. Market power: the firm must be a price maker. A price taker cannot set prices.

2. Separate groups with different price elasticities of demand, and a way to tell them apart (age, time, place, ID). The group with the more elastic demand gets the lower price.

3. No resale: buyers at the low price must not be able to sell on to those charged more.

  • If resale is easy, the low-price group buys for everyone (market seepage or arbitrage).
Quick check
?A firm with market power plans to charge students a lower price than other adults for an identical product. Its costs are the same for both groups. Which situation would stop this plan from raising its profit?
Mission 5

Three degrees

Three degrees of price discriminationFirst degree: each buyer pays their ownmaximumPrice0QuantityDSecond degree: price per unit falls after a blockof unitsPrice per unit0Units boughtThird degree: different prices for differentgroupsAdultshigher priceStudentslower price
  • First degree (perfect): each buyer pays their own maximum willingness to pay.
  • Second degree: price depends on how much you buy: bulk discounts, lower price per unit after a set amount.
  • Third degree: different prices for different groups: age, time of day, location.
  • Real firms rarely know every buyer's maximum price. Personalised online pricing is an attempt to get closer.
Mission 5

Third degree: the diagram

Third-degree price discriminationMarket 1: less price elastic demandPrice0P1Q1QuantityAR1 = D1MR1MC = ACMarket 2: more price elastic demandPrice0P2Q2QuantityAR2 = D2MR2MC = AC
  • Two markets, the same MC (constant).
  • In each market, the firm produces where MR = MC.
  • Price in each market is read off its own AR (demand) curve.
  • The less price elastic market pays the higher price.
  • The more elastic market pays less: a high price there would lose too many sales.
  • Say: "the higher price is charged in the market where demand is less price elastic" — not: "the richer group always pays more".
Mission 5

Worked example: business travellers and students

Worked example: business travellers and studentsBusiness travellersAR = 120 − Q, MR = 120 − 2QPrice0702050QuantityARMRMC = ACStudentsAR = 40 − 0.5Q, MR = 40 − QPrice0302020QuantityARMRMC = ACIllustrative data. The two graphs use differentscales.
  • Illustrative data. MC = AC = 20.
  • Business travellers: AR = 120 − Q, so MR = 120 − 2Q.
    • MR = MC: Q = 50, P = 70.
  • Students: AR = 40 − 0.5Q, so MR = 40 − Q.
    • MR = MC: Q = 20, P = 30.
  • PED at those prices: business −1.4; students −3. Students pay less.
  • One price for all: the best single price is 70. Students (who pay at most 40) buy nothing.
    • Output 50; profit (70 − 20) × 50 = 2,500.
  • Price discrimination: output 70; profit 2,500 + (30 − 20) × 20 = 2,700.
Mission 5Graph lab

Who pays more?

Same two markets as the previous screen. Now the students' demand grows: at every price, students want to buy more.

Who pays more?StudentsPriceQuantity01002000801202030AR (students)MRMCBusiness travellersPriceQuantity01002000401205070AR (business)MRMC
  • Takeaway: each market has its own MR = MC price. The less elastic group pays more; when both groups have the same PED, they pay the same price.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm sells in two separate markets with the same constant MC = 10. In market A, AR = 70 − 2Q, so MR = 70 − 4Q. In market B, AR = 30 − 0.5Q, so MR = 30 − Q. Which prices maximise its profit?
Mission 5

Perfect price discrimination

Perfect price discriminationPrice030102040QuantityP = MCAR = DAR = D = MRMCMRconsumer surplusprofitdeadweight lossproducer surplusSingle price: output 20, price 30.Each unit sells at its own price up to output 40.CS = 0, DWL = 0.
  • Each unit sells at the buyer's maximum price, so the demand curve becomes the MR curve.
  • The firm produces where D = MC, the P = MC output: the same output as perfect competition.
  • All consumer surplus becomes producer surplus. Consumer surplus = 0.
  • No deadweight loss: allocatively efficient output.
  • Illustrative data (as): AR = 50 − Q, MC = 10.
    • Single price: Q = 20, profit 400, consumer surplus 200, deadweight loss 200.
    • Perfect price discrimination: Q = 40, producer surplus 800, consumer surplus 0, deadweight loss 0.
  • Say: "efficient but not equitable" — not: "consumers gain because output rises".
Quick check
?A single-price monopolist becomes able to practise perfect (first-degree) price discrimination. Its costs do not change. Compared with before, which statement is correct?
Mission 5

Who gains and who loses?

  • Producers: more profit. It may fund investment, or keep a service running (e.g. a rail route).
  • Consumers in the high-price group: pay more; lose consumer surplus.
  • Consumers in the low-price group: may be served for the first time.
  • In an earlier screen, students were served only under price discrimination.
  • Total output: may rise. Then some deadweight loss is removed.
  • Real example: the 16–25 Railcard gives one third off most rail fares in Great Britain.
Mission 5Evaluate

Good or bad?

  • It depends on output: if total output rises, welfare can rise; if it does not, welfare usually falls.
  • It depends on who pays more: lower prices for students, children or pensioners can help equity; higher prices for those who must travel at peak times may not.
  • It depends on use of profit: research and investment, or higher payouts to owners?
  • It depends on costs of separating groups: checking ID, building booking systems.
  • It depends on fairness: buyers may see personalised prices as exploitation.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: a theme park charges local residents less than tourists for an identical day ticket. Its costs are the same for both groups. Which pair of conditions is needed for this to earn more profit than one price for all?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Why might it make sense for only one company to lay the water pipes in a city?

Make a guess: Why might it make sense for only one company to lay the water pipes in a city?

Mission 6

What makes a monopoly natural

Average cost keeps fallingPrice / cost0economies of scaleQuantityLRACDAverage cost falls across the whole market.
  • Some industries have huge fixed costs and low marginal costs: water pipes, rail track, power grids.
  • So average cost keeps falling as output rises, across the whole market.
  • Natural monopoly: one firm can supply the whole market at a lower average cost than two or more firms could.
  • A second network would duplicate the fixed cost: wasteful.
  • Say: "natural monopoly" for a cost reason — not: "a monopoly protected by law or a patent".
Mission 6

Worked example: one network or two?

  • Illustrative data. A town needs 300 connections. The network costs 1,200 (fixed). Each connection adds 2 (marginal cost).
  • One firm: AC = 1,200 ÷ 300 + 2 = 4 + 2 = 6.
  • Two firms, 150 connections each: AC = 1,200 ÷ 150 + 2 = 8 + 2 = 10.
  • Splitting the market raises average cost from 6 to 10.
  • Same marginal cost; the difference is the fixed cost spread over fewer users.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A rail line has a fixed cost of 900 and a marginal cost of 3 per journey. The market is 150 journeys. If two firms each build their own line and each carries 75 journeys, what is each firm's average cost?
Mission 6

The natural monopoly diagram

The natural monopoly diagramPrice / cost0P1P2P3Q1Q2Q3QuantityP = ACP = MCAR = DMRLRACMCMR = MCloss at P = MCMC lies below AC while AC is falling.Three possible prices: MR = MC (unregulated), P= AC and P = MC.At P = MC, price is below AC: a loss.
  • AC (LRAC) falls across the whole demand curve. MC lies below AC.
  • Three possible prices:
    • Unregulated: MR = MC. High price, low output, profit above normal.
    • P = AC: normal profit. Output higher, price lower.
    • P = MC: the allocatively efficient output. But P < AC: a loss.
  • So a natural monopoly cannot be allocatively efficient and cover its costs without help.
  • Say: "MC is below AC whenever AC is falling" — not: "MC is above AC".
Mission 6

Worked example: three prices

Worked example: three pricesPrice / cost022104180300360QuantityAR = DMRACMCAC 14AC 9Illustrative data: AR = 40 − 0.1Q, MC = 4, AC =1,800/Q + 4.
  • Illustrative data. AR = 40 − 0.1Q. MC = 4. Fixed cost = 1,800.
  • Unregulated (MR = MC): 40 − 0.2Q = 4 → Q = 180, P = 22. AC = 1,800 ÷ 180 + 4 = 14.
    • Profit = (22 − 14) × 180 = 1,440.
  • P = AC: Q = 300, P = 10. AC = 1,800 ÷ 300 + 4 = 10. Normal profit.
  • P = MC: Q = 360, P = 4. AC = 1,800 ÷ 360 + 4 = 9.
    • Loss = (9 − 4) × 360 = 1,800: the whole fixed cost.
Mission 6Graph lab

Set the price cap

Same natural monopoly. A regulator sets a maximum price (price cap).

Set the price capPrice, costsQuantity18022AR = DMRMCAC
  • Takeaway: lowering the cap raises output; profit is normal at P = AC (10); below that the firm makes a loss.
Mission 6

Lump-sum or per-unit?

Lump-sum subsidy versus per-unit taxLump-sum subsidy: AC shifts down, MC andoutput do not changePrice / cost0PQQuantityDMRMCAC1AC2Per-unit tax: MC shifts up, output fallsPrice / cost0P2P1Q2Q1QuantityDMRMCMC + taxIllustrative data.
  • Lump-sum tax or subsidy: a fixed amount, whatever the output. It changes fixed cost only.
    • ATC shifts; MC does not. Price and quantity do not change. Only profit changes.
  • Per-unit tax or subsidy: changes MC. Price and quantity change.
  • At P = MC, the natural monopoly makes a loss. A lump-sum subsidy equal to the loss lets it stay open at the allocatively efficient output, without changing its MC.
  • Taxpayers fund the subsidy: weigh its cost against the welfare gain.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A regulator makes a natural monopoly charge P = MC = 6. It then sells 500 units, and its average total cost at that output is 8.5. What lump-sum subsidy lets it just cover its costs?
Mission 6

Price caps: RPI − X

  • UK regulators of privatised utilities (e.g. Ofwat for water, Ofgem for energy) cap prices.
  • The classic formula, first used in 1984, is RPI − X: prices may rise each year by inflation (RPI) minus X%.
  • Worked example: RPI = 4%, X = 2. Maximum price rise = 4 − 2 = 2%. A price of 50 can rise to 51.
  • If the firm cuts costs by more than X, it keeps the extra profit: an incentive to be efficient.
  • Water added K for investment: RPI − X + K. Newer UK caps use other inflation measures (CPI or CPIH); the idea is the same.
  • Know the regulator's role; the details of how each one works are not needed.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A regulated firm's price cap is RPI − X. RPI inflation is 3% and X is set at 5. What can the firm do to its price this year?
Mission 6

Other ways to regulate

  • Profit (rate-of-return) regulation: profit capped at a % of capital.
    • Risk: little reason to cut costs; firms may over-invest to raise the allowed profit.
  • Quality standards: a price cap can tempt a firm to cut quality. Regulators set standards (e.g. leaks, delays).
  • Performance targets: fines or rewards linked to service, e.g. punctuality or customer complaints.
  • Impact: lower prices and higher output, but possibly less profit for investment.
Mission 6

Who should own it?

  • Nationalisation (public ownership): the state owns the firm.
    • For: can price nearer MC; long-term investment; no supernormal profit to shareholders.
    • Against: weak profit incentive, so costs may drift up (X-inefficiency); political interference; funding competes with other public spending.
  • Privatisation: sale of state firms to private owners.
    • For: profit motive cuts costs; access to private capital.
    • Against: a private natural monopoly still needs regulation; profit may come before investment.
  • Example: water in England and Wales was privatised in 1989. Scottish Water is publicly owned.
  • Either way, each area is still served by a single network of water pipes.
  • The evidence on which model performs better is mixed; it depends on regulation and management.
Mission 6Evaluate

Does regulation work?

  • It depends on information: the firm knows its costs better than the regulator. X may be set too low or too high.
  • It depends on regulatory capture: a regulator may come to serve the industry it regulates.
  • It depends on quality: price caps can lead to cost cuts that harm service, unless standards are enforced.
  • It depends on investment: tight caps may squeeze money for new pipes, track and cables.
  • Effects to weigh: prices, output, employment, profit, efficiency, quality, choice, economic welfare.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: a small town is served by one broadband network that costs a lot to build but very little to connect each extra home. A second firm plans to build its own full network and win half the town's homes. Assuming total demand does not change, what happens to the average cost of supplying a home?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Why can a popular new kind of café make big profits at first, then only just cover its costs later?

Make a guess: Why can a popular new kind of café make big profits at first, then only just cover its costs later?

Mission 7

Many firms, different products

  • Monopolistic competition: many firms, each selling a differentiated product.
  • Low barriers to entry and exit.
  • Each firm has a little price-setting power: its product is not identical to rivals'.
  • Examples: cafés, hairdressers, restaurants, takeaways, a new style of café such as bubble tea.
  • Firms are small, so each one acts independently: it does not plan around one rival's reaction.
Mission 7

Standing out: non-price competition

  • Product differentiation: real or perceived differences (quality, design, location, service, brand).
  • Non-price competition: competing on anything but price: branding, advertising, loyalty cards, opening hours, new menu items.
  • Aim 1: shift the firm's demand curve right (more customers at each price).
  • Aim 2: make demand less price elastic (customers less willing to switch).
  • Say: "the firm's demand curve slopes downward because its product is differentiated" — not: "because it has few rivals".
Quick check
?A hairdresser in a busy town centre raises its price slightly. It loses some customers but not all of them. Which best explains why?
Mission 7

The short run

Monopolistic competition in the short runPrice0P1Q1QuantityAR = DMRACMCsupernormal profitDemand slopes down. MR lies below it.MR = MC gives output Q1. Price is read up toAR.AR > AC at Q1: supernormal profit.Illustrative data.
  • Profit is maximised where MR = MC. Price is read up to the AR curve.
  • AR > AC: supernormal profit. AR < AC: a loss. AR = AC: normal profit.
  • In the short run, this looks just like the monopoly diagram. The difference is what happens next.
Mission 7

Worked example: short-run profit

Monopolistic competition in the short runPrice0P1Q1QuantityAR = DMRACMCsupernormal profitDemand slopes down. MR lies below it.MR = MC gives output Q1. Price is read up toAR.AR > AC at Q1: supernormal profit.Illustrative data.
  • Illustrative data. A new bubble tea shop.
  • Demand: AR = 30 − 0.2Q, so MR = 30 − 0.4Q.
  • Costs: MC = 0.2Q. AC = 360/Q + 0.1Q.
  • MR = MC: 30 − 0.4Q = 0.2Q, so Q = 50.
  • Price from AR: 30 − 0.2 × 50 = 20.
  • AC at Q = 50: 360/50 + 0.1 × 50 = 7.2 + 5 = 12.2.
  • Supernormal profit = (AR − AC) × Q = (20 − 12.2) × 50 = 390.
Mission 7

From short run to long run

From short run to long runPrice0P1P2P3Q3Q2Q1QuantityACMCAR1 = D1MR1AR2 = D2MR2AR3 = D3MR3P2 = ACsupernormal profitlossSupernormal profit: new firms enter.Entry: each firm's demand shifts left andbecomes more price elastic.Normal profit: AR2 touches AC. Entry stops.Loss: firms leave and each remaining firm'sdemand shifts right.
  • Profit above normal is a signal. Barriers are low, so new firms enter.
  • Each firm loses some customers to the newcomers: its demand curve shifts left.
  • More close substitutes: demand becomes more price elastic.
  • Entry stops when AR just touches (is tangent to) AC: normal profit.
  • Losses work the other way: firms leave, and each remaining firm's demand shifts right until AR touches AC again.
  • Say: "each firm's demand curve shifts left as firms enter" — not: "the market demand curve falls".
Mission 7Graph lab

Let new firms in

Illustrative data. Start: 4 shops; each earns a profit of 390.

Let new firms inPrice and costOutput of one shop020406080100010305020AR = DMRMCAClowest AC
  • Takeaway: entry continues until profit is normal, at the point where AR touches AC to the left of the lowest point of AC.
Mission 7

Worked example: the long run

From short run to long runPrice0P1P2P3Q3Q2Q1QuantityACMCAR1 = D1MR1AR2 = D2MR2AR3 = D3MR3P2 = ACsupernormal profitlossSupernormal profit: new firms enter.Entry: each firm's demand shifts left andbecomes more price elastic.Normal profit: AR2 touches AC. Entry stops.Loss: firms leave and each remaining firm'sdemand shifts right.
  • Illustrative data. After entry, each shop's demand: AR = 18 − 0.125Q, so MR = 18 − 0.25Q.
  • Costs are unchanged: MC = 0.2Q; AC = 360/Q + 0.1Q.
  • MR = MC: 18 − 0.25Q = 0.2Q, so Q = 40.
  • Price: 18 − 0.125 × 40 = 13.
  • AC at Q = 40: 360/40 + 0.1 × 40 = 9 + 4 = 13.
  • P = AC: profit per unit 0. Normal profit.
  • PED at the chosen price: SR −2; LR −2.6. Demand is more elastic after entry.
Mission 7

Excess capacity

Excess capacityPrice01384060excess capacityQuantitylowest ACP > MCAR2 = D2MR2ACMCOutput 40 is below 60, the output at lowest AC.P = 13 is above MC = 8.Illustrative data.
  • The long-run tangency is on the falling part of AC.
  • So output is below the output at the lowest AC: excess capacity.
  • In the previous screen: output 40; lowest AC (12) at 60. Excess capacity = 60 − 40 = 20 units.
  • Not productively efficient: P = AC = 13 > lowest AC = 12.
  • Not allocatively efficient: P = 13 > MC = 8. Buyers value one more unit more than it costs to make.
  • Say: "excess capacity: output is below the level that minimises AC" — not: "the firm has too many workers".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. In long-run equilibrium, a monopolistically competitive firm produces 18 units at a price of 34. At that output, AC = 34 and MC = 18. Its AC is lowest at 30 units, where AC = 30. Which describes this firm?
Mission 7

Compared with the other models

Long run: three market structuresPerfect competitionPrice0QuantityACMCAR = DMonopolistic competitionPrice0QuantityACMCAR = DMRMonopolyPrice0QuantityACMCAR = DMRsupernormal profit can lastIllustrative diagrams. Same cost curves in each.
Long runPerfect competitionMonopolistic competitionMonopoly
ProductsIdenticalDifferentiatedUnique
BarriersNoneLowHigh
Demand facing firmHorizontalDownward, quite elasticDownward, less elastic
ProfitNormalNormalAbove normal can last
P and MCP = MCP > MCP > MC
Output at lowest AC?YesNo: excess capacityNot usually
  • The key gain over perfect competition: variety. Buyers can choose the café, style or location they like best.
Mission 7

Advertising

AdvertisingPrice0QuantityACAC1AR1AR2AC2Advertising shifts demand right and makes itless price elastic.It also raises costs: AC shifts up.
  • Advertising aims to shift the firm's demand right and make it less price elastic (brand loyalty).
  • It also raises costs: AC shifts up.
  • Short run: if extra sales outweigh the extra cost, profit rises.
  • Long run: rivals copy the idea, and new firms enter. Profit returns to normal.
  • Informative advertising (prices, opening hours, what is new) helps buyers choose.
  • Persuasive advertising (image, brand) may add to costs and prices without making the product better.
Quick check
?A nail salon launches a successful advertising campaign that makes its customers more loyal. In the short run, what happens to the salon's demand curve?
Mission 7Evaluate

Is excess capacity a waste?

  • It depends on how much buyers value variety: a slightly higher price than perfect competition may be the cost of choice.
  • It depends on how elastic demand is: with many close substitutes, demand is very elastic, the tangency is near the lowest AC, and the excess capacity is small.
  • It depends on the type of advertising: informative or persuasive.
  • It depends on dynamic efficiency: normal profit leaves little to fund research, but rivalry pushes firms to try new products.
  • It depends on how realistic the model is: some firms build brands, or win locations, that rivals cannot easily copy.
Mission check

?Illustrative case: a town has a few gyms making large profits. Opening a gym is easy, and each gym differs a little in equipment and classes. New gyms open until the market settles. Which describes a typical gym in the new long-run equilibrium?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • A contestable market has low barriers to entry and exit; the threat of entry disciplines incumbents.
  • With no sunk costs, hit-and-run entry removes supernormal profit: price is pushed towards average cost.
  • Real markets are rarely perfectly contestable: sunk costs, branding and quick responses protect incumbents.

Mission 2

  • Invention creates an idea; innovation brings it into use. Creative destruction: new products and firms replace old ones.
  • Supernormal profit from market power can finance R&D; competition can also force innovation.

Mission 3

  • A perfectly competitive firm is a price taker: P = AR = MR = D, a horizontal line.
  • It produces where MC = MR = P. Compare P with AC: supernormal profit, normal profit or loss.
  • In the short run it keeps producing while P ≥ AVC; its supply curve is MC above minimum AVC.

Mission 4

  • Supernormal profit attracts entry; losses cause exit. Both stop at price = minimum AC.
  • Long-run equilibrium: P = MR = MC = minimum AC; normal profit (zero economic profit).
  • It is allocatively and productively efficient.

Mission 5

  • Price discrimination: different prices for the same product, not explained by cost.
  • Conditions: market power; groups with different PED that can be told apart; no resale.
  • Third degree: MR = MC in each market; the less elastic market pays more.

Mission 6

  • A natural monopoly has falling average cost across the whole market, so one firm supplies most cheaply.
  • Unregulated, it sets MR = MC; P = AC gives normal profit; P = MC is efficient but loss-making.
  • Regulators use price caps (RPI − X), profit limits, quality and performance targets; owners may be public or private.

Mission 7

  • Many firms, differentiated products, low barriers: each firm has a downward-sloping, fairly elastic demand curve.
  • Short run: MR = MC; profit above normal or a loss is possible. Long run: entry or exit leaves normal profit (AR tangent to AC).
  • Long run: excess capacity and P > MC, but buyers get variety.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Business Economics for CCEA A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Can a market with only one firm still behave as if it were full of competitors?
  2. Mission 2Can a new idea that wipes out whole industries still leave an economy better off?
  3. Mission 3Why can't one wheat farmer charge even slightly more than the market price?
  4. Mission 4When a product is very profitable and anyone can start selling it, where do the profits go?
  5. Mission 5Why can two people sitting side by side on the same train have paid very different fares?
  6. Mission 6Why might it make sense for only one company to lay the water pipes in a city?
  7. Mission 7Why can a popular new kind of café make big profits at first, then only just cover its costs later?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · CCEA