← A-Level Economics · CCEA A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Economics (AS and A2) · Costs and revenues in the short run and long run
Mini-Lesson

Costs and revenues in the short run and long run

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why can the next batch of bread cost a bakery more to make than the batches before it?
  2. Mission 2Why do some industries have thousands of small firms while others have only two or three?
  3. Mission 3If a seller must cut its price to sell one more, why does that extra sale bring in less than the price?
  4. Mission 4Why can a giant firm make things more cheaply than a small one, and when does size start to hurt?
  5. Mission 5Why might a business that brings in money every year still be making no real profit?
  6. Mission 6Why would a business stop making more when each extra sale still brings in money?
  7. Mission 7Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Fiscal policy; Supply-side policies.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why can the next batch of bread cost a bakery more to make than the batches before it?

Make a guess: Why can the next batch of bread cost a bakery more to make than the batches before it?

Mission 1

Fixed and variable costs

Fixed and variable costsCosts0100Output (batches per day)TFCTVCTCTFCIllustrative data. TC = TFC + TVC
  • Fixed costs (FC, or total fixed cost TFC): do not change with output in the short run. Rent, insurance, loan interest, salaried staff.
  • Fixed costs must be paid even at zero output.
  • Variable costs (VC, or total variable cost TVC): change with output. Ingredients, energy, packaging, hourly wages.
  • Total cost (TC) = fixed cost + variable cost.
  • In the long run all costs are variable: the bakery can move to a bigger site (see Mission 2).
Mission 1

Average and marginal cost

  • Average fixed cost: AFC = TFC ÷ Q.
  • Average variable cost: AVC = TVC ÷ Q.
  • Average total cost (often just average cost, AC): ATC = TC ÷ Q = AFC + AVC.
  • Marginal cost: the extra cost of producing one more unit. MC = change in TC ÷ change in Q.
  • Fixed costs do not change, so MC is also the change in variable cost.
  • Say: "marginal cost is the cost of the next unit" — not: "the average cost of all units".
Mission 1

Worked example: a bakery

  • Illustrative data. Fixed cost (oven lease and rent) = 100 a day. Output in batches of bread per day.
QTFCTVCTCMCAFCAVCATC
01000100––––
1100601606010060160
2100100200405050100
31001302303033.3343.3376.67
410018028050254570
510026036080205272
610038048012016.6763.3380
  • MC of the 5th batch = 360 − 280 = 80.
  • ATC at 5 batches = 360 ÷ 5 = 72, or AFC + AVC = 20 + 52.
  • At zero output, TC = TFC = 100.
  • MC rises from the 4th batch: the ovens are fixed, so each extra batch needs more work hours than the one before.
  • MC below ATC pulls ATC down (batches 2–4). The 5th batch's MC of 80 is above the ATC of 70, so ATC rises to 72.
Quick check
?A firm's fixed costs are 200 a week. When it produces 40 units, its total variable cost is 600. Illustrative data. What is its average total cost at 40 units?
Mission 1

Why the curves have their shapes

The cost curve familyCosts034Output (batches per day)MCAVCATCAFCdiminishingreturnsred brackets: ATC − AVC = AFC, narrowingIllustrative data
  • MC falls at first, then rises. Why: with the ovens fixed, diminishing marginal returns set in. Each extra worker adds less output, so each extra batch needs more labour (MC = wage ÷ MP).
  • AFC falls all the time: the same fixed cost spread over more units.
  • AVC and ATC are U-shaped:
    • below its minimum, MC pulls the average down
    • above it, MC pulls the average up
  • So MC cuts AVC and ATC at their lowest points (bakery: AVC lowest at 3 batches, ATC at 4).
  • The gap between ATC and AVC is AFC, so it narrows as output rises.
Quick check
?Which statement about a firm's short-run cost curves is correct?
Mission 1Graph lab

Which curves move?

Same illustrative bakery as the worked example.

Which curves move?CostsOutput (batches)1234560100200MCAFCAVCATC
  • Takeaway: fixed costs move AFC and ATC only. Wages and other variable costs move AVC, ATC and MC.
Mission 1

What shifts the cost curves

What shifts what(1) Wage rise: all upCosts0OutputMC1AVC1ATC1MC2AVC2ATC2(2) Rent rise: ATC onlyCosts0OutputMCAVCATC1ATC2(3) Productivity rise: all downCosts0OutputMC1AVC1ATC1MC2AVC2ATC2
  • Higher input prices (wages, energy, raw materials): AVC, ATC and MC shift up. AFC unchanged.
  • Higher fixed costs (rent, insurance, a licence fee): AFC and ATC shift up. AVC and MC unchanged.
  • Higher productivity (better technology, training, organisation): each worker makes more, so MC, AVC and ATC shift down.
  • Say: "a rise in fixed cost shifts ATC" — not: "it shifts MC".
Mission 1

Worked example: revenue, cost and profit

  • Same illustrative bakery as the earlier worked example. Each batch sells for 90.
  • Revenue = price × sales volume. At 5 batches: 90 × 5 = 450.
  • Profit = revenue − total cost = 450 − 360 = 90.
  • Per batch: 90 − ATC of 72 = 18; 18 × 5 = 90.
  • Percentage change = (new − old) ÷ old × 100. From 4 to 5 batches:
    • sales volume: (5 − 4) ÷ 4 × 100 = 25%
    • revenue: 360 → 450, +25%
    • total cost: 280 → 360, +28.57%
    • profit: 80 → 90, +12.5%
  • At the margin: the 5th batch adds 90 of revenue and 80 of cost, so profit rises by 10. The 6th adds 90 but costs 120, so profit falls to 60.
Quick check
?A free software update lets each worker in a print shop produce more pages per hour. Wages and rent do not change. What happens to the print shop's cost curves?
Mission check

?A phone-case factory makes 1,000 cases a day at an average total cost of 12 per case. Making the 1,001st case would add 15 to its total cost. Illustrative data. If it makes that case, what happens to its average total cost?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do some industries have thousands of small firms while others have only two or three?

Make a guess: Why do some industries have thousands of small firms while others have only two or three?

Mission 2

Short run and long run

  • Short run: at least one factor of production is fixed, usually capital (the size of the plant).
  • Long run: all factors can be changed. The firm can build a bigger plant or a smaller one.
  • So in the long run there are no fixed costs: all costs are variable.
  • The length of each period differs by industry: a café can add a coffee machine in a week; a steelworks takes years to build.
  • Diminishing returns are a short-run idea: they need a fixed factor.
  • Say: "the short run is the period when at least one factor is fixed" — not: "the short run is less than a year".
Mission 2

Many short runs make one long run

SRAC envelopeAverage cost0Output (Q)SRAC1SRAC2SRAC3LRACgreen: the lowest cost at each outputpurple dot: SRAC1 touches the LRAC. Black dot:the lowest point of SRAC1, further right.
  • Each plant size has its own U-shaped short-run average cost (SRAC) curve.
  • In the long run the firm picks the plant with the lowest average cost for the output it plans.
  • The long-run average cost (LRAC) curve traces the lowest average cost at each output. It is the envelope of the SRAC curves.
  • Each SRAC touches the long-run curve at one output and lies above it everywhere else.
  • So short-run average cost can never be below long-run average cost at the same output.
  • Where LRAC is falling, each SRAC touches it to the left of the SRAC's own minimum. Only at the LRAC minimum do the two minimums meet.
  • Say: "the LRAC is the envelope of the SRAC curves" — not: "the LRAC joins the minimum points of the SRAC curves".
Mission 2Graph lab

Stuck with the wrong plant

Stuck with the wrong plantAverage costOutput (units a week)0801201600246810405LRACSRAC (plant 40)
  • Takeaway: in the short run the firm moves along its SRAC; in the long run it changes plant and moves along the LRAC.
Quick check
?The table shows average cost per unit (illustrative data) for three plant sizes. A firm has the medium plant. It expects to sell 300 units a week for many years.
Output per weekSmall plantMedium plantLarge plant
1006811
200856
3001164
4001585

What is the long-run average cost of 300 units, and what should the firm do in the long run?

Mission 2

The shape of the long-run curve

LRAC shapes and MESCosts (£)0MESOutput (Q)LRACeconomies of scale: LRAC fallsconstant returns to scale: flatdiseconomies of scale: LRAC rises
  • LRAC falls: economies of scale. LRAC flat: constant returns to scale (output and total cost grow in step). LRAC rises: diseconomies of scale.
  • Textbook shape: U-shaped. The reasons for each part are in Mission 4.
  • Say: "economies of scale lower average cost" — not: "economies of scale lower total cost". Total cost still rises with output.
Mission 2

Minimum efficient scale

LRAC shapes and MESCosts (£)0MESOutput (Q)LRACeconomies of scale: LRAC fallsconstant returns to scale: flatdiseconomies of scale: LRAC rises
  • Minimum efficient scale (MES): the lowest output at which long-run average cost reaches its minimum.
  • On a U-shaped curve: the bottom of the U (the start of the flat part, if there is one).
  • A firm producing below MES has higher average cost than a rival at or above MES.
  • The steeper the curve below MES, the bigger that cost penalty, and the harder it is for small firms to survive.
  • Say: "MES is the smallest output at the lowest average cost" — not: "MES is the biggest a firm can grow".
Mission 2

How many firms can a market hold?

MES and market demandAverage costOutput per yearmarket demandLRACMES1. MES 10,000: room for up to 100 firmsAverage costOutput per yearmarket demandLRACMES2. MES 400,000: room for 2 firmsAverage costOutput per yearmarket demandLRAC3. LRAC still falling at demand: naturalmonopolyIllustrative data
  • Compare MES with market demand at a price equal to the minimum average cost.
  • Room for firms at MES ≈ market quantity ÷ MES.
  • Illustrative data. Market demand: 1,000,000 units a year.
  • MES of 10,000 → room for up to 100 firms: many small firms can compete (low concentration).
  • MES of 400,000 → room for only 2 firms at lowest cost: a few big firms (high concentration, oligopoly).
  • MES at or above total market demand → room for one firm at lowest cost: a natural monopoly.
Mission 2

Real world: large passenger jets

  • Designing a new airliner costs billions before the first plane is sold. Spreading that cost needs huge output.
  • Two firms make most of the world's large passenger jets.
  • Real data (company figures): in 2023 Airbus delivered 735 commercial aircraft and Boeing 528.
  • Compare hairdressers: low MES, small local markets, thousands of firms.
  • High MES relative to market demand is one reason a market ends up with few firms.
Quick check
?At a price equal to the lowest possible average cost, buyers want 600,000 units a year. The minimum efficient scale is 150,000 units a year (illustrative data). How many firms can the market hold, each producing at the lowest average cost?
Mission 2Evaluate

Does MES decide how many firms there are?

It depends on …

  • How big the market really is: trade can turn a national market into a world market, leaving room for more firms at MES.
  • How steep the cost curve is below MES: if the cost penalty is small, small firms survive by offering variety, local service or a niche.
  • Technology: new methods can lower MES (small-scale brewing, online retail) or raise it (huge research costs).
  • Firms' behaviour and barriers: mergers, branding and patents can concentrate a market even when MES is low.
  • Judge: MES sets a limit on how many firms can produce at lowest cost. It does not, on its own, fix the number.
Mission check

?A country buys 1.2 million washing machines a year. The minimum efficient scale is 0.8 million machines a year (illustrative data). The country then joins a free-trade area, and its producers can now sell in a market of 6 million machines a year. Which statement is correct?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If a seller must cut its price to sell one more, why does that extra sale bring in less than the price?

Make a guess: If a seller must cut its price to sell one more, why does that extra sale bring in less than the price?

Mission 3

Three measures of revenue

Revenue table plotted as curvesRevenue108642−2−612345Quantity (Q)AR = DMRMR is plotted at the midpoint of each step.Illustrative data.
  • Total revenue (TR) = price × quantity sold.
  • Average revenue (AR) = TR ÷ quantity. With one price for all units, AR = price.
  • Marginal revenue (MR) = the change in TR from selling one more unit: MR = ΔTR ÷ ΔQ.
  • Say: "marginal revenue is the extra revenue from one more unit" — not: "the price of one more unit".
Mission 3

Worked example: a revenue table

Revenue table plotted as curvesRevenue108642−2−612345Quantity (Q)AR = DMRMR is plotted at the midpoint of each step.Illustrative data.
  • Illustrative data. A street stall faces the demand below and charges one price to everyone.
Quantity per hourPrice = ARTR = P × QMR = ΔTR
1101010
28166
36182
4416−2
5210−6
  • AR is the price column: the AR curve is the demand curve.
  • MR falls faster than AR, and turns negative after 3 units.
  • TR is highest (18) where MR changes from positive to negative.
Mission 3

Why MR is below price

Gain and loss of a price cutRevenue08623Quantity (Q)AR = Dgain: the 3rd unit sells for +6loss: the first 2 units earn 2 less each, −4MR = 6 − 4 = 2
  • To sell a 3rd unit, the stall cuts its price from 8 to 6, for every buyer.
  • Gain: the 3rd unit sells for +6.
  • Loss: the first 2 units now earn 2 less each: 2 × 2 = −4.
  • MR = 6 − 4 = 2, below the price of 6.
  • So when a firm must lower its price to sell more, MR < AR for every unit after the first.
  • Say: "AR is the demand curve; MR lies below it" — not: "MR equals the price".
Quick check
?A firm charges one price to all buyers. At a price of 15 it sells 20 units a week. At a price of 14 it sells 22 units (illustrative data). What is the marginal revenue per extra unit?
Mission 3

A price taker

A price takerPrice / revenue05QuantityP = AR = MRTotal revenue0204QuantityTRIllustrative data: price 5, so TR rises by 5 withevery unit.
  • In a perfectly competitive market, a firm is a price taker: it can sell as much as it likes at the market price.
  • It never has to cut its price to sell more, so each extra unit adds exactly the price to TR.
  • So P = AR = MR, all one horizontal line.
  • TR is a straight line from the origin, rising by the price with each unit.
  • Illustrative data: price 5 → TR 5, 10, 15, 20 …; MR = 5 every time.
Mission 3

Drawing the curves

AR, MR and TRPrice / revenue189−9−18AR = DMRMR is twiceas steep as ARTotal revenue0546Quantity (Q)TR
  • AR = D: the downward-sloping demand curve.
  • With a straight-line demand curve, MR starts at the same point on the price axis and is twice as steep.
  • MR meets the quantity axis halfway to where AR does.
  • TR is an arch: it rises while MR > 0, peaks where MR = 0, and falls once MR < 0.
  • Say: "TR is maximised where MR = 0" — not: "where AR = 0", where TR is zero.
Mission 3Graph lab

Where does revenue peak?

Where does revenue peak?PriceQuantity05101520−10010218AR = DMRTotal revenueQuantity05101520050100236TR
  • Takeaway: TR peaks where MR = 0, at the midpoint of the demand curve, where demand is unit elastic (PED = −1).
Mission 3

MR and PED

AR, MR and TRPrice / revenue189−9−18AR = DMRMR is twiceas steep as ARunit elastic,PED = −1elasticinelasticTotal revenue0546Quantity (Q)TR
Part of the demand curvePED (absolute value)MRPrice cut → TR
Upper halfgreater than 1 (elastic)positiverises
Midpoint1 (unit elastic)zeroat its peak
Lower halfless than 1 (inelastic)negativefalls
  • A firm aiming to maximise profit never chooses an output where MR < 0: making more would lower TR and raise costs (see Mission 6).
  • Say: "demand is price elastic where MR is positive" — not: "where the demand curve is flat".
Quick check
?At a firm's current price, its price elasticity of demand is −0.6 (0.6 as an absolute value). It cuts its price a little to sell more units. Which statement is correct?
Mission 3

Worked example: from a data table to profit

  • Illustrative data: the stall from an earlier screen, now with its total cost (TC).
QP = ARTRMRTCAC = TC ÷ QMC = ΔTCProfit = TR − TC
11010106644
2816694.537
3618212436
4416−216440
  • TC at zero output is 2 (fixed cost), so MC of the 1st unit = 6 − 2 = 4.
  • Profit is highest (7) at 2 units: the 2nd unit adds MR 6 > MC 3; the 3rd adds MR 2 < MC 3.
  • Profit per unit = AR − AC: at 2 units, 8 − 4.5 = 3.5; × 2 units = 7.
Quick check
?A firm charges one price to all buyers (illustrative data).
QuantityPriceTotal cost
12010
21822
31636
41452

At 3 units, what are average revenue and total profit?

Mission check

?A theatre charges one price for every seat. At a price of 30 it sells 400 tickets a night. At a price of 28 it sells 450 tickets a night (illustrative data). What is the marginal revenue per extra ticket?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Why can a giant firm make things more cheaply than a small one, and when does size start to hurt?

Make a guess: Why can a giant firm make things more cheaply than a small one, and when does size start to hurt?

Mission 4

Cost per unit as a firm grows

Economies and diseconomies of scaleCosts (£)0Output (Q)firm growseconomiesof scalediseconomiesof scaleLRAC
  • Economies of scale: long-run average cost falls as the scale of output rises.
  • Diseconomies of scale: long-run average cost rises as the scale of output rises.
  • They are long run: the firm grows by changing all its inputs, including plant size.
  • A firm's own growth moves it along its LRAC curve.
  • Say: "economies of scale lower average cost" — not: "lower costs". Total cost still rises with output.
Mission 4

Internal economies of scale

  • Internal economies come from the firm's own growth.
TypeWhy average cost falls
TechnicalBigger, specialised machines; mass production; larger containers cost less per unit of capacity
ManagerialSpecialist managers (finance, marketing, engineering) each run a bigger output
FinancialLenders see big firms as less risky: lower interest rates, more ways to raise money
PurchasingBulk buying earns discounts on inputs
MarketingOne advert or brand spread over many more sales
Risk-bearingMany products and markets: a fall in one is offset by others
  • Many are about indivisibilities: some inputs (a machine, an advert, a specialist) cannot be bought in small slices.
Mission 4

Worked example: why bigger ships carry more cheaply

Increased dimensions: bigger cargo holdSimplified modelside 1side 2container shipSurface area (steel)6 → 24 (×4)Volume (cargo)1 → 8 (×8)Steel per unit of cargo6 → 3 (halves)
  • Think of a cargo hold as a cube (simplified model).
  • Side 1 → 2: surface area (steel to build) 6 → 24, ×4. Volume (cargo it holds) 1 → 8, ×8.
  • Steel per unit of cargo: 6 ÷ 1 = 6 → 24 ÷ 8 = 3. It halves.
  • This is the law of increased dimensions, a technical economy of scale.
  • A bigger ship also needs only a slightly larger crew and engine per container carried.
  • Real data: MSC Irina, delivered in 2023, carries 24,346 twenty-foot containers.
Quick check
?Which is an example of a financial economy of scale?
Mission 4

External economies and diseconomies

Internal and external economies of scaleCosts (£)0Q1Q2Output (Q)XYZLRAC1LRAC2LRAC3internal economies: movement along LRAC1external economies: shift down, X to Zexternal diseconomies: shift up to LRAC3
  • External economies come from the growth of the industry (often in one area), not of the firm.
  • Examples: a pool of skilled workers, specialist suppliers nearby, shared transport links, local colleges and research.
  • Real clusters: technology firms around Silicon Valley, financial firms in the City of London.
  • Effect: every firm's LRAC curve shifts down, whatever its own output.
  • External diseconomies: the industry grows so much that congestion, higher rents and competition for skilled workers push every firm's LRAC curve up.
  • Say: "internal economies: a movement along the LRAC; external economies: a shift of the LRAC" — not the other way round.
Mission 4Graph lab

Move along or shift?

Move along or shift?Average costOutput of one firm0801201600246810405LRAC1
  • Takeaway: the firm's own growth moves it along the curve; the industry's growth shifts the curve.
Quick check
Internal and external economies of scaleCosts (£)0Q1Q2Output (Q)XYZLRAC1LRAC2
?A diagram shows two LRAC curves for a firm, LRAC2 below LRAC1. Point X is on LRAC1 at output Q1. Point Y is further along LRAC1 at a larger output Q2, with a lower average cost. Point Z is on LRAC2 at output Q1. A new rail link cuts transport costs for every firm in the firm's industry. The firm's output stays at Q1. Which movement shows this?
Mission 4

Diseconomies of scale

Economies and diseconomies of scaleCosts (£)0Output (Q)firm growseconomiesof scalediseconomiesof scaleLRAC
  • As a firm grows very large, average cost can rise. Main causes:
  • Communication: more layers of managers; messages are slow and distorted.
  • Coordination and control: hard to keep many sites and departments working together; harder to check that staff do their jobs well.
  • Motivation: workers feel like a small part of a huge machine; absence and staff turnover rise.
  • These are internal diseconomies: they come from the firm's own size.
Quick check
?A firm has grown to 40,000 employees in 30 countries. Decisions take months to pass through layers of managers, and staff surveys show falling motivation. Its cost per unit is now rising as output grows. What is the best explanation?
Mission 4Evaluate

Is bigger better for consumers?

It depends on …

  • Whether cost savings are passed on: with strong competition, lower average cost means lower prices; a dominant firm may keep the savings as profit.
  • Diseconomies: past a point, more size raises average cost.
  • Barriers to entry: economies of scale protect established firms, which can weaken the pressure to keep costs and prices down.
  • Judge: size can lower costs, but whether consumers gain depends on competition and how the firm is run.
Mission check

?A food firm grows over several years (illustrative data). At 10,000 meals a week its total cost is 200,000. At 50,000 meals it is 600,000. At 120,000 meals it is 1,800,000. What do these figures show?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why might a business that brings in money every year still be making no real profit?

Make a guess: Why might a business that brings in money every year still be making no real profit?

Mission 5

What profit is

Accounting profit and economic profitTotal revenue: 120,000Total costsexplicit costs 85,000accounting profit 35,000implicit costs 35,000:salary 30,000 + interest 5,000economic profit = 0 (normal profit)Illustrative data
  • Profit = total revenue − total costs.
  • Profit = TR − TC.
  • Total costs means the opportunity cost of every resource the firm uses.
  • Some costs are paid out in money. Some are not. Both count.
Mission 5

Explicit and implicit costs

Accounting profit and economic profitTotal revenue: 120,000Total costsexplicit costs 85,000accounting profit 35,000implicit costs 35,000:salary 30,000 + interest 5,000economic profit = 0 (normal profit)Illustrative data
  • Explicit costs: money actually paid out. Wages, rent, materials, energy, interest on loans.
  • Implicit costs: the value of the owner's own resources used in the business. No payment is made.
  • Examples: the salary the owner gives up by not working elsewhere; the interest her own savings could have earned; the rent her own building could have earned.
  • Accounting profit = TR − explicit costs.
  • Economic profit = TR − explicit costs − implicit costs.
  • Economists treat normal profit as a cost: the reward the owner must get to keep her resources in this business.
  • Say: "accounting profit ignores implicit costs" — not: "accounting profit is wrong". It answers a different question.
Mission 5

Worked example: the café

Accounting profit and economic profitTotal revenue: 120,000Total costsexplicit costs 85,000accounting profit 35,000implicit costs 35,000:salary 30,000 + interest 5,000economic profit = 0 (normal profit)Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data. A café, one year. Figures per year.
  • Total revenue: 120,000.
  • Explicit costs (food, staff, rent, energy): 85,000.
  • Accounting profit = 120,000 − 85,000 = 35,000.
  • Implicit costs: the owner gives up a salary of 30,000 as a manager elsewhere. She put 100,000 of her savings in; at 5% interest they would earn 100,000 × 0.05 = 5,000.
  • Implicit costs = 30,000 + 5,000 = 35,000.
  • Economic profit = 35,000 − 35,000 = 0.
  • The accounts show a profit. Yet she would do just as well elsewhere. That is normal profit.
Mission 5

Normal, supernormal and subnormal profit

Profit as a rectangleCosts and revenue01298100OutputACAR = ACACARARsupernormal profit = 300normal profit (AR = AC)subnormal profit (a loss) = 100
  • Normal profit: the minimum profit needed to keep the firm in its current use. TR = TC, so AR = AC.
  • Supernormal profit: profit above normal profit. TR > TC, so AR > AC.
  • Subnormal profit (a loss): profit below normal profit. TR < TC, so AR < AC.
  • Here costs include normal profit. So TR = TC is not "no money": it is exactly enough.
  • Say: "the firm earns normal profit" — not: "the firm makes no profit".
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A designer runs her own studio. Last year her revenue was £200,000 and her explicit costs were £150,000. She gave up a salary of £45,000 to run it, and she put £80,000 of her savings into the business, which could have earned 5% interest. What kind of profit did the studio earn?
Mission 5

Profit on a cost diagram

Profit as a rectangleCosts and revenue01298100OutputACAR = ACACARARsupernormal profit = 300normal profit (AR = AC)subnormal profit (a loss) = 100
  • Profit per unit = AR − AC.
  • Total profit = (AR − AC) × Q: a rectangle.
  • Illustrative data, Q = 100, AC = 9:
  • AR = 12: profit = (12 − 9) × 100 = 300. Supernormal.
  • AR = 9: profit = 0. Normal profit.
  • AR = 8: profit = (8 − 9) × 100 = −100. A loss.
  • (Which output a firm picks comes in Mission 6.)
Mission 5Graph lab

Slide the price

Slide the pricePrice and costOutput0591215Q = 100ACAR
  • Takeaway: AR above AC: supernormal profit. AR = AC: normal profit. AR below AC: a loss.
Quick check
A profit rectangle at 50 unitsCosts and revenue0201650OutputARACprofit rectangleIllustrative data
?Illustrative data. A diagram shows a firm producing 50 units. At this output its average revenue is 20 and its average cost is 16. What is the area of the profit rectangle?
Mission 5

Why profit matters in a market economy

  • Signal: supernormal profit shows buyers want more. Resources move in. Losses show they want less. Resources move out.
  • Firms enter in search of supernormal profit and leave when they make subnormal profit.
  • Incentive: profit rewards risk-taking, effort and new ideas.
  • Source of finance: retained profit pays for investment and research.
  • So firms may want to maximise profit: to reward owners, fund growth and survive bad years.
  • Normal profit is the minimum that keeps resources in their current use.
Mission 5Evaluate

Is supernormal profit good or bad?

It depends on …

  • Barriers to entry: with free entry, new firms compete it away. Behind high barriers it can last, with higher prices for buyers.
  • Where it comes from: a better product or lower costs, or market power?
  • How it is used: reinvested in research and new products (dynamic efficiency), or paid out while prices stay high.
  • Time: a short-run reward for risk is different from a profit that lasts for decades.
  • Judge: supernormal profit is a useful signal and reward, but it also needs watching when it persists.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A software engineer leaves a job paying 60,000 a year to build her own app business. In its first year the app earns revenue of 90,000. She pays 50,000 for servers, design and marketing. She has no other costs. Which statement is correct?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Why would a business stop making more when each extra sale still brings in money?

Make a guess: Why would a business stop making more when each extra sale still brings in money?

Mission 6

Thinking at the margin

  • Profit = TR − TC.
  • Marginal revenue (MR): the extra revenue from selling one more unit.
  • Marginal cost (MC): the extra cost of making one more unit.
  • MR > MC: one more unit adds to profit. Make more.
  • MR < MC: one more unit cuts profit. Make less.
  • Profit is maximised where MC = MR.
  • Say: "profit is maximised where MC = MR" — not: "where revenue is highest" or "where cost per unit is lowest".
Mission 6

Worked example: the profit table

The profit hillRevenue and costs0123456Output (Q)TRTCProfit−1021216146−8profit max0123456TR max (Q = 5)MR and MC of each extra unit18614410668210−212123456Output (Q)MRMCIllustrative data

Illustrative data. Fixed costs are 10. The firm must cut its price to sell more.

Output (Q)Price = ARTRMRTCMCProfit (TR − TC)
0200–10–−10
11818181662
216321420412
314421026616
41248634814
51050244106
6848−25612−8
  • Units 1 to 3: MR > MC. Each adds to profit.
  • Unit 4: MR = 6 but MC = 8. It still brings in money, yet profit falls by 2.
  • Best output: 3 units, profit = 42 − 26 = 16.
  • Not at Q = 5, where TR peaks at 50. Not at Q = 4, where AC is lowest (34 ÷ 4 = 8.5).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A bakery sells batches of bread at a fixed price of 5 per batch, however many it sells. Its fixed costs are 4. The marginal cost of the 1st to 5th batches is 2, 3, 4, 6 and 8. How many batches maximise its profit?
Mission 6

MC = MR on the diagram

MC = MR on the diagramCosts and revenue0P*AC*Q*OutputAR = DMRMCACsupernormal profit = (P* − AC*) × Q*
  • Find Q where MC cuts MR from below. That is the profit-maximising output.
  • Go up from that Q to the AR (demand) curve to read the price.
  • Go up to AC at the same Q to read cost per unit.
  • Profit = (AR − AC) × Q: the rectangle between price and AC.
  • If AR < AC at that output, MC = MR gives the smallest loss the firm can make while producing.
  • Say: "read the price off the demand (AR) curve" — not: "off the point where MC = MR".
Mission 6Graph lab

Find the best output

Find the best outputRevenue, cost, profitOutput0123456−100204060TRTCprofit—MR of thelast unit—MC of thelast unit−10Profit
  • Takeaway: profit climbs while MR > MC and falls once MC > MR, even though revenue is still rising. The peak is the MC = MR output.
Quick check
MC cuts MR at an output of 40Costs and revenue01240OutputAR = DMRMCACIllustrative data
?Illustrative data. On a diagram, MC cuts MR from below at an output of 40, where MC = MR = 12. At an output of 40, average revenue is 25 and average cost is 18. What price does the profit-maximising firm charge, and what is its profit?
Mission 6

Making a loss: carry on or shut down?

Shutdown and break-evenCosts and revenue0OutputMCACAVCbreak-even pointshutdown pointP1 = AR= MRP2P3P1 above min AC (break-even and long-runshutdown point): profitP2 between min AVC and min AC: a loss, butkeep producing (loss is less than fixed costs)P3 below min AVC: shut down, no output (loss= fixed costs)
  • Short run: fixed costs must be paid even at zero output (rent, loan repayments).
  • Shut down: loss = fixed costs.
  • Carry on: loss = TC − TR.
  • So carry on if TR covers variable costs. Every unit sold then pays something towards fixed costs.
  • Rule: produce if TR ≥ TVC, i.e. P ≥ AVC. Shut down if P < AVC.
  • Shutdown point: the minimum of AVC.
  • Say: "shut down if price is below average variable cost" — not: "shut down as soon as the firm makes a loss".
Mission 6

Worked example: shut down or not?

Shutdown and break-evenCosts and revenue0OutputMCACAVCbreak-even pointshutdown pointP1 = AR= MRP2P3P1 above min AC (break-even and long-runshutdown point): profitP2 between min AVC and min AC: a loss, butkeep producing (loss is less than fixed costs)P3 below min AVC: shut down, no output (loss= fixed costs)
  • Illustrative data, one week. Fixed costs 600. Best output 100 units. AVC = 8.
  • Price 10: TR = 1,000. TVC = 800. TC = 1,400.
  • Carry on: loss = 1,400 − 1,000 = 400. Shut down: loss = 600.
  • Carry on. Contribution = (10 − 8) × 100 = 200 towards fixed costs.
  • Price falls to 7: TR = 700, less than TVC of 800.
  • Carry on: loss = 1,400 − 700 = 700. Shut down: loss = 600.
  • Shut down: P (7) < AVC (8).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm's fixed costs are 2,000 a month. At its best output of 500 units, its AVC is 6 and its ATC is 10. The price is 7. What should it do in the short run?
Mission 6

Break-even and the long run

Shutdown and break-evenCosts and revenue0OutputMCACAVCbreak-even pointshutdown pointP1 = AR= MRP2P3P1 above min AC (break-even and long-runshutdown point): profitP2 between min AVC and min AC: a loss, butkeep producing (loss is less than fixed costs)P3 below min AVC: shut down, no output (loss= fixed costs)
  • Break-even point: price = minimum AC. TR = TC: normal profit.
  • Price between min AVC and min AC: a loss, but keep producing in the short run.
  • Long run: every cost is variable. A firm exits if it expects P < AC to last.
  • Long-run shutdown point: the minimum of AC.
  • Supernormal profit attracts entry where barriers are low.
Quick check
Shutdown and break-evenCosts and revenue0OutputMCACAVCbreak-even pointshutdown pointP1 = AR= MRP2P3P1 above min AC (break-even and long-runshutdown point): profitP2 between min AVC and min AC: a loss, butkeep producing (loss is less than fixed costs)P3 below min AVC: shut down, no output (loss= fixed costs)
?Illustrative data. A firm's minimum AVC is 4 and its minimum average total cost (AC) is 6. The market price falls from 8 to 5 and is expected to stay there. What should the firm do?
Mission 6Evaluate

Do real firms set MC = MR?

It depends on …

  • Information: firms rarely know their exact MC and MR. Many use rules of thumb, such as adding a mark-up to cost.
  • Objectives: owners and managers may aim for growth, sales or a satisfactory profit instead.
  • Time: a firm may hold prices below the short-run profit-maximising level to keep rivals out or win loyal buyers, aiming at long-run profit.
  • Competition: in fierce competition, firms that stray far from maximum profit may not survive.
  • Judge: MC = MR is a model of how profit-seeking firms behave, more accurate in competitive markets than as a description of how managers decide.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A water park makes a large profit each year. It is thinking of opening for one extra hour every evening. The extra hour would bring in 900 of ticket and food sales. It would add 1,100 to costs (staff, lighting, heating the pools). What should a profit-maximising water park do?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Make a guess: Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Mission 7

Two questions about waste

  • Efficiency: getting the most out of scarce resources.
  • Ask two separate questions:
    • How is it made? At the lowest possible cost per unit? → productive efficiency
    • What is made, and how much? The goods society values most? → allocative efficiency
  • One can hold without the other.
  • Both are static efficiency: efficiency at a point in time, with today's technology.
  • Dynamic efficiency asks a third question: are costs and products improving over time?
Mission 7

Productive efficiency

Minimum average costCosts (£)0OutputACMCminimum ACLeft of the minimum: MC < AC, so AC falls.Right of it: MC > AC, so AC rises.Productive efficiency: the output at minimum AC.
  • Productive efficiency: output where average cost (AC) is at its minimum.
  • At that output, MC = AC: the MC curve cuts the AC curve at its lowest point.
  • Why? If the next unit costs less than the average (MC < AC), it pulls AC down. If it costs more (MC > AC), it pushes AC up.
  • Say: "productively efficient at minimum AC" — not: "at the lowest total cost" (that is zero output).
Mission 7

Worked example: finding minimum AC

  • Illustrative data. Fixed cost = 60.
OutputTotal costAC = TC ÷ QMC of that unit
110010040
21306530
31505020
41684218
52004032
62464146
  • AC is lowest, 40, at 5 units: the productively efficient output.
  • 5th unit: MC 32 < AC 42 before it → AC falls.
  • 6th unit: MC 46 > AC 40 before it → AC rises.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A firm's total costs are: 10 units, 300; 20 units, 440; 30 units, 570; 40 units, 720; 50 units, 950. At which output is the firm productively efficient?
Mission 7

Allocative efficiency

Allocative efficiencyPrice (£)0PeQ1QeQ2QuantityP > MCDS = MCP < MCP = MCQ1: P > MC, too little is made.Q2: P < MC, too much is made.
  • Allocative efficiency: resources make the goods and services society values most, in the right amounts.
  • Condition: P = MC.
    • Price shows what buyers will pay for the last unit: its marginal benefit (MB) to them.
    • MC shows the cost of the resources used for it: the value of what else they could have made.
  • P > MC: buyers value one more unit above its cost → too little is made.
  • P < MC: the last unit costs more than it is worth to buyers → too much is made.
  • Say: "allocatively efficient where P = MC" — not: "where P = AC" (that is normal profit).
Mission 7Graph lab

Can both happen at once?

A price-taking firm always produces where P = MC. You set the market price.

Can both happen at once?Price and costOutput01020305002060q = 4043MCACP = MR
  • Takeaway: P = MC holds at every price; minimum AC only when the price equals minimum AC (here 26).
Quick check
?A firm sells its product for 30. At its current output, the marginal cost of the last unit is 18. What does this show?
Mission 7

Dynamic efficiency

Dynamic efficiency: process innovationCosts (£)0OutputAC1AC1AC2Process innovation: lower cost at every output
  • Dynamic efficiency: efficiency over time, through innovation.
    • Process innovation: new methods lower costs → the whole AC curve shifts down.
    • Product innovation: new and better products.
  • It needs investment, R&D and new technology.
  • Funding: retained supernormal profit is a major source.
  • Incentive: firms innovate to win or protect profit.
  • Static efficiency today can conflict with dynamic efficiency tomorrow.
Mission 7

X-inefficiency

X-inefficiencyCosts (£)0Q1Outputwasted costACX-inefficient
  • X-inefficiency: a firm produces at a cost above the lowest possible cost for its output.
  • On the diagram: a point above the AC curve, not on it.
  • Causes: organisational slack, overstaffing, overpaying suppliers, managers not pushed to cut costs.
  • Most likely where competition is weak, e.g. a protected monopoly.
  • Competition (or the threat of entry) removes it: high-cost firms lose sales.
  • Say: "X-inefficient" only for costs above the AC curve — not: for every firm away from minimum AC. A point on the curve, away from its minimum, is productively inefficient but not X-inefficient.
Quick check
Points on and above an AC curveCosts (£)0OutputACWXYZ
?A diagram shows a firm's AC curve and four points.
PointPosition
WOn the AC curve, at its minimum
XOn the AC curve, at a smaller output than W
YDirectly above W, well above the AC curve
ZOn the AC curve, at a larger output than W

Which point shows X-inefficiency?

Mission 7

Comparing market structures

Structures comparedPerfect competition (long run)Costs, revenue0OutputACMCP = AR = MR = DFirm with market powerCosts, revenue0P1Q1OutputP > MCACAR = DMRMC
  • Long-run outcomes, as usually taught:
ProductiveAllocativeDynamic
Perfect competitionYes (min AC)Yes (P = MC)Limited: only normal profit; no secrets to protect
Monopolistic competitionNo (excess capacity)No (P > MC)Some: product variety
OligopolyUnlikelyNo (P > MC)Possible: profits and rivalry fund R&D
MonopolyUnlikely; may be X-inefficientNo (P > MC)Possible: profits fund R&D; or none, with no rivals
  • Firms with market power face a downward-sloping demand curve, so they can set P above MC.
Mission 7

Case: patents

  • A patent gives an inventor the sole right to sell an invention for a set time.
  • WTO members must offer patent protection for at least 20 years from the filing date.
  • Static cost: a monopoly → P > MC → allocatively inefficient.
  • Dynamic gain: the expected profit pays for costly R&D (e.g. new medicines).
  • A deliberate trade: less static efficiency now for more dynamic efficiency later.
Mission 7Evaluate

Static or dynamic: which matters more?

  • It depends on whether profit is reinvested: supernormal profit may fund R&D, or be paid out to owners.
  • It depends on competitive pressure: a protected monopoly may stop innovating and let costs drift up.
  • It depends on economies of scale: one large firm's minimum AC may be far below that of many small firms.
  • It depends on time: static losses happen now; dynamic gains, if any, come later and are uncertain.
  • Oligopoly: rivalry can drive innovation and non-price competition, but collusion raises prices and restricts output.
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A firm produces exactly at the lowest point of its AC curve. Its price is 12. At this output, its marginal cost is 7. Which statement is correct?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • TC = FC + VC; fixed costs are paid even at zero output.
  • AFC, AVC, ATC are costs per unit; MC is the cost of the next unit.
  • Diminishing returns make MC rise; MC cuts AVC and ATC at their lowest points.
  • Input prices move AVC, ATC and MC; fixed costs move AFC and ATC; productivity gains shift costs down.

Mission 2

  • In the long run all factors and costs are variable; the LRAC is the envelope of the SRAC curves, and SRAC is never below it.
  • Minimum efficient scale compared with market demand limits how many firms can produce at the lowest average cost.

Mission 3

  • TR = P × Q; AR = TR ÷ Q = price, so the AR curve is the demand curve; MR = ΔTR ÷ ΔQ.
  • When a firm must cut its price to sell more, MR is below AR; a price taker has P = AR = MR.
  • TR is highest where MR = 0, at unit elasticity; MR is positive where demand is elastic and negative where it is inelastic.

Mission 4

  • Economies of scale: long-run average cost falls as output grows; diseconomies: it rises.
  • Internal economies (technical, managerial, financial, purchasing, marketing, risk-bearing) come from the firm's own growth.
  • External economies and diseconomies come from the industry's growth and shift every firm's LRAC.

Mission 5

  • Accounting profit = TR − explicit costs; economic profit also subtracts implicit costs (opportunity costs of the owner's own resources).
  • Normal profit: AR = AC. Supernormal (abnormal) profit: AR > AC. Subnormal profit (loss): AR < AC.

Mission 6

  • Profit is maximised where MC = MR (MC cutting MR from below); the price is read off the AR (demand) curve.
  • In the short run, keep producing if P ≥ AVC (TR ≥ TVC); shut down if P < AVC.
  • Break-even is at minimum AC; in the long run firms exit if they expect P < AC to last.

Mission 7

  • Productive efficiency: minimum AC (MC = AC).
  • Allocative efficiency: P = MC.
  • Dynamic efficiency: costs and products improve over time through R&D and investment.
  • X-inefficiency: costs above the AC curve, often where competition is weak.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Costs and revenues for CCEA A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why can the next batch of bread cost a bakery more to make than the batches before it?
  2. Mission 2Why do some industries have thousands of small firms while others have only two or three?
  3. Mission 3If a seller must cut its price to sell one more, why does that extra sale bring in less than the price?
  4. Mission 4Why can a giant firm make things more cheaply than a small one, and when does size start to hurt?
  5. Mission 5Why might a business that brings in money every year still be making no real profit?
  6. Mission 6Why would a business stop making more when each extra sale still brings in money?
  7. Mission 7Can a firm make goods at the lowest possible cost and still waste resources?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · CCEA