← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 2 2A Catholic Christianity – Section 4: Peace and Conflict (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Peace and Conflict (part 1)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1When a war is fought in God's name, is religion really the cause?
  2. Mission 2Can a war ever be fought justly, and who decides the rules?
  3. Mission 3Is refusing to fight brave or naive? Why do some believers never use violence?
  4. Mission 4War can start in a day. How do believers try to build a peace that lasts?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Catholic Christianity: Marriage and the Family (part 2); 1 mission in Catholic Christianity: Crime and Punishment (part 1).

Mission 1

Mission 1: When a war is fought in God's name, is religion really the cause?

Make a guess: When a war is fought in God's name, is religion really the cause?

Mission 1

Conflict and war

Conflict and wardisagreementConflicta serious disagreement or strugglebetween people or groups; it may or maynot become violentWararmed conflictbetween countriesCivil wararmed conflictbetween groupswithin a country
  • Conflict: a serious disagreement or struggle between people or groups. It may or may not become violent.
  • War: armed conflict between countries, or between groups within a country (civil war).
  • Wars almost never have one cause. Historians look for several causes working together.
  • Religions teach that war is a great evil, even when they accept it may sometimes be necessary (see Mission 2).
Mission 1

Greed, self-defence, retaliation

Causes of warwargreedself-defenceretaliationpoliticsresourceshistoryculture andidentityreligionUsually these overlap.
  • Greed: wanting more land, wealth, power or resources. "Where do wars and fightings amongst you come from? Don't they come from your pleasures that war in your members?" (James 4:1, WEBBE)
  • "The love of money is a root of all kinds of evil." (1 Timothy 6:10, WEBBE)
  • Self-defence: protecting a country or its allies from attack. Most religions and international law (UN Charter, Article 51) accept it.
  • Retaliation: striking back after an attack, often for revenge. It can start a cycle of violence that is hard to break.
  • Religions generally reject greed and revenge as reasons for war; many accept self-defence.
Mission 1

Politics, resources, history, culture

Causes of warwargreedself-defenceretaliationpoliticsresourceshistoryculture andidentityreligionUsually these overlap.
  • Politics: struggles for power; clashing ideologies; leaders seeking support at home.
  • Resources: oil, water, farmland, minerals.
  • History: old grievances, past wars, borders drawn by empires.
  • Culture and identity: ethnic, national or language groups who feel threatened or excluded.
  • Religion: beliefs, holy places, or religious identity can be part of a conflict.
  • Usually these overlap: religion often marks who belongs to a side, even when the dispute is about land or power.
Quick check
?After a border guard is killed, Country X shells a village in Country Y "to teach them a lesson". Country Y then bombs a city in Country X. Which reason for war is shown most clearly?
Mission 1

Holy war

Holy warEuropeHoly LandJerusalemThe Crusades10951291Popes called Christians to recapture Jerusalemand the Holy Land; Muslim, Jewish and Christiancivilians suffered.Lesser jihad (Muslim teaching)struggle in defence of the faith under strictconditions, not a war to force conversion:"There is no compulsion in religion" (Surah2:256)
  • Holy war: a war fought for religious reasons, believed to be commanded or approved by God.
  • The Crusades (1095–1291): popes called Christians to recapture Jerusalem and the Holy Land; Muslim, Jewish and Christian civilians suffered.
  • Some modern extremist groups claim religious reasons for violence; most believers of those faiths reject their claims.
  • In Muslim teaching, lesser jihad is struggle in defence of the faith under strict conditions, not a war to force conversion: "There is no compulsion in religion" (Surah 2:256, Pickthall).
Mission 1

Is religion to blame?

Is religion to blame?Case against religionmany atheists andHumanistsdivides people into"us" and "them"can make violencefeel sacredleaders use it to winsupportRichard Dawkins,The God Delusion(2006): religionmakes suchdivisions worseReligious repliesmost wars havemainly political,economic or ethniccausesextremists misusereligion against itsown teachingreligion also worksfor peace: mediatingand helping victims
  • The case against religion (many atheists and Humanists): religion divides people into "us" and "them"; it can make violence feel sacred; leaders use it to win support. Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion (2006), argues religion makes such divisions worse (paraphrase).
  • Religious replies: most wars have mainly political, economic or ethnic causes; the most destructive wars of the 20th century were not fought for religion; extremists misuse religion against its own teaching.
  • Religion also works for peace: religious leaders and groups mediate and help victims.
  • Humanists also note that non-religious ideologies (nationalism, fascism, communism) have caused terrible wars.
Mission 1Read the source

Put away the sword; do not begin hostilities

At Jesus' arrest a disciple strikes the high priest's servant with a sword (Matthew 26:47–51, paraphrase). Jesus says:

"Put your sword back into its place, for all those who take the sword will die by the sword." (Matthew 26:52, WEBBE)

"Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors." (Surah 2:190, Pickthall)

  • Surah 2:190–195 goes on (paraphrase): fight only until persecution ends; if the enemy stops, stop; "Allah loveth not aggressors".

Q1 Why does Jesus refuse to be defended by force?

Show answer

Violence leads to more violence; in Matthew 26:53–54 he says he could call on angels, but must fulfil scripture.

Q2 Which two limits does Surah 2:190 put on fighting?

Show answer

Fight only those who fight you; do not start the fighting.

Mission 1Diversity

Causes of conflict and the response of faith

Teachings on conflictSourceTeachingJewishIsaiah 2:1–5"they shall beat their swordsinto plowshares"; nationscome to learn God's waysBuddhistItivuttaka 50conflict begins in the mind:greed, hatred, delusion (theThree Poisons)HinduRig Veda 10.191come together, speaktogether, let your mindsagreeSikhZafarnama 22(Guru GobindSingh, 1705)when all other means havefailed, it is right to take upthe swordSituation ethicsJoseph Fletcher,Situation Ethics(1966)do the most loving thing ineach situation
  • Jewish: the prophet's vision of peace: "they shall beat their swords into plowshares ... neither shall they learn war any more" (Isaiah 2:4, JPS 1917); Isaiah 2:1–5 sees nations coming to learn God's ways instead.
  • Buddhist: conflict begins in the mind. The three roots of unskilful action are greed, hatred and delusion (Itivuttaka 50, paraphrase): the Three Poisons.
  • Hindu: Rig Veda 10.191 (paraphrase): come together, speak together, let your minds agree; a prayer for unity in place of conflict.
  • Sikh: in the Zafarnama (letter to Emperor Aurangzeb, 1705), Guru Gobind Singh writes that when all other means have failed, it is right to take up the sword (verse 22, paraphrase).
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1905–1991, Situation Ethics, 1966): do the most loving thing in each situation. Applied to conflict: Jesus chose non-violence at his arrest; the Zafarnama allows force as a last resort to protect others.
Quick check
?A Sikh soldier explains why she joined the army: "I would rather talk than fight, but if every other way has failed to protect innocent people, I will use force." Which source matches her view most closely?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Religion is the main cause of war."

Argument map"Religion is the main cause of war."Forholy wars such as the Crusadesextremist violence in religion's namereligious identity can harden divisionssacred places are fought overAgainstmost wars have political, economic orethnic causesnon-religious ideologies caused thedeadliest warsreligion is often used as a label for sidesformed for other reasonsreligious teachings limit war: Jesus: "Putyour sword back into its place" (Matthew26:52); the Qur'an: "begin not hostilities"(Surah 2:190); Isaiah's vision of swordsbeaten into ploughshares (Isaiah 2:4)Another viewreligion can be both a cause of conflict anda powerful force for peaceJudge it byWould the war happen without religion? · Isreligion the cause, or the badge of a side? · Dothe teachings support the war, or are theymisused?
  • Reasons for: holy wars such as the Crusades; extremist violence in religion's name; religious identity can harden divisions; sacred places are fought over.
  • Reasons against: most wars have political, economic or ethnic causes; non-religious ideologies caused the deadliest wars; religion is often used as a label for sides formed for other reasons; religious teachings limit war.
  • For example, Jesus: "Put your sword back into its place" (Matthew 26:52).
  • And the Qur'an: "begin not hostilities" (Surah 2:190).
  • Also: Isaiah's vision of swords beaten into ploughshares (Isaiah 2:4).
  • Another view: religion can be both a cause of conflict and a powerful force for peace.
  • Judge it by: Would the war happen without religion? Is religion the cause, or the badge of a side? Do the teachings support the war, or are they misused?
Mission check

?Two neighbouring countries dispute a dam that controls water for millions of farmers. Talks fail. One president calls the coming war "a sacred duty". Most people in both countries follow the same religion. Which analysis is most accurate?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can a war ever be fought justly, and who decides the rules?

Make a guess: Can a war ever be fought justly, and who decides the rules?

Mission 2

Where the idea came from

Where just war theory came from354–430St Augustine of Hippo: war only torestore peace. City of God (XIX, 12):"peace is the end sought for by war"c. 1225–1274St Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae(II-II, q. 40, a. 1): three conditions:authority · just cause · right intentionc. 1483–1546 · 1583–1645Francisco de Vitoria and Hugo Grotiusadd more conditions, including rules forconduct in warTodayCatholic and Anglican teaching, and manyother Protestants, accept just war as a lastresort.
  • Just war theory: a set of conditions that, Christians in this tradition hold, must all be met for a war to be morally right, and limits on how it is fought.
  • St Augustine of Hippo (354–430) asked how Christians, taught to love enemies, could serve as soldiers.
  • His answer: war may be a sad necessity to restore peace and stop wrongdoing, never for revenge or gain.
  • In City of God (XIX, 12) he writes that "peace is the end sought for by war".
  • St Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274) set out three conditions in the Summa Theologiae (II-II, q. 40, a. 1).
  • Later thinkers (e.g. Francisco de Vitoria, c. 1483–1546; Hugo Grotius, 1583–1645) added more, including rules for conduct in war.
Mission 2Read the source

Aquinas' three conditions

Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40, a. 1 (English Dominican translation):

> "In order for a war to be just, three things are necessary. First, the authority of the sovereign by whose command the war is to be waged."

  • Second: "a just cause": those attacked deserve it because of some wrong they have done.
  • Third: "a rightful intention": to advance good or avoid evil, not for cruelty or power.
  • Aquinas quotes Augustine: "we go to war that we may have peace."

Q1 Why can a private person not start a just war?

Show answer

Only the ruler responsible for the common good has authority.

Q2 Could a war with authority and a just cause still be unjust?

Show answer

Yes: a wicked intention, such as revenge or greed, makes it unlawful.

Mission 2

The criteria today

The just war criteriaGoing to warjus ad bellumJust causee.g. self-defence, protecting theinnocentLegitimate authoritya lawful governmentRight intentionpeace and justice, not gain or revengeLast resortevery peaceful means triedReasonable chance of successno pointless loss of lifeProportionalitygood achieved outweighs harm causedFighting the warjus in belloDiscriminationcivilians never deliberately targetedProportional forceno more force than needed; prisonersand wounded treated humanely

Going to war (jus ad bellum):

  • Just cause: e.g. self-defence against attack, or protecting the innocent.
  • Legitimate authority: declared by a lawful government, not a private group.
  • Right intention: to restore peace and justice, not to gain land, wealth or revenge.
  • Last resort: every peaceful means (talks, sanctions) has been tried.
  • Reasonable chance of success: no pointless loss of life.
  • Proportionality: the good achieved must outweigh the harm caused.

Fighting the war (jus in bello):

  • Discrimination: civilians must never be deliberately targeted.
  • Proportional force: no more force than needed; prisoners and the wounded treated humanely.
Quick check
?Before going to war, a government spends a year on talks, mediation and sanctions, and only then sends troops. Which just war condition is it trying to meet?
Mission 2Read the source

Catechism 2309

Catechism 2309: legitimate defence by military forceCCC 2309 (paraphrase)Damagelasting, grave andcertainOther meansimpractical orineffectiveSuccessserious prospectsNo graver evilsthan the evil to beremovedall atthe sametimeJudged by those responsible for the commongood

The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 2309) lists "strict conditions for legitimate defense by military force". All must be met at the same time (paraphrase):

  • The damage done by the aggressor is lasting, grave and certain.
  • All other means of stopping it have proved impractical or ineffective.
  • There are serious prospects of success.
  • Using arms must not produce evils graver than the evil to be removed; modern weapons weigh heavily in this.
  • The Catechism calls these the traditional elements of the "just war" doctrine.
  • Judging them belongs to those responsible for the common good (lawful leaders), not to individuals.

Q1 Which condition do modern weapons make hardest to meet?

Show answer

The last: not causing greater evils.

Q2 Why does the Catechism speak of "defense"?

Show answer

Only defending against aggression can be a just cause.

Mission 2

Christian sources and views

Christian views on just warSituation ethics (Joseph Fletcher)Do the most loving (agape) thing ineach case: might support a war toprotect the innocent, or rule out onethat causes great suffering.Just war as a lastresortCatholic andAnglican teaching;many otherProtestantsAbsolute pacifismQuakers; someMennonites. Jesustaught non-violence.
  • "Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities, for there is no authority except from God" (Romans 13:1). The ruler "doesn't bear the sword in vain" (Romans 13:4).
  • Romans 13:1–7: supporters read it as giving lawful governments authority to use force; critics say it is about obeying laws, not waging war.
  • Catholic and Anglican teaching, and many other Protestants, accept just war as a last resort.
  • Quakers and some Mennonites reject it: Jesus taught non-violence (pacifism in Mission 3).
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1905–1991, Situation Ethics, 1966): do the most loving (agape) thing in each case. War might sometimes be the most loving choice, to protect the innocent; it could also rule out a war that meets the criteria but causes great suffering.
Quick check
?Which Bible passage do Christians who support just war most often use to show that lawful rulers may use force?
Mission 2Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Just war ideas across six religionsChristianity: just warMeaning: conditions that must all be metKey condition: last resort; civilians nevertargetedSource: Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40;Romans 13:4; CCC 2309Islam: lesser jihad (jihad: "striving")Meaning: defensive war with strict conditionsKey condition: legitimate leader; self-defenceor protecting the oppressed; never to forceconversion; stop when the enemy seeks peaceSource: Qur'an 2:190; 8:61; 4:75; 4:90Judaism: milchemet mitzvah / milchemetreshutMeaning: obligatory war (commanded by God,or defence) / optional war (needed a king andthe Sanhedrin)Key condition: proclaim peace first; do not cutdown fruit treesSource: Deuteronomy 20:10; 20:19Hinduism: Dharma YuddhaMeaning: "righteous war": the Kshatriya duty toprotect societyKey condition: fight only warriors; never theunarmed, the fleeing or those who surrenderSource: Bhagavad Gita 2.31Sikhism: Dharam YudhMeaning: "war in defence of righteousness"Key condition: last resort; not for revenge, landor plunder; minimum force; civilians unharmedSource: Zafarnama 22; Dasam Granth 1133Buddhism: no "just" war (most Buddhists)Meaning: the First Precept forbids killing;hatred breeds hatredKey condition: some accept defence as thelesser harm, but killing is still unskilful, withkarmic resultsSource: the First Precept
  • Islam: lesser jihad (jihad means "striving"; the greater jihad is the inner struggle to live as God wills).
  • "Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors." (Qur'an 2:190, Pickthall)
  • Conditions most scholars teach: declared by a legitimate leader; in self-defence or to protect the oppressed; a last resort; never to force conversion; civilians, crops, trees and places of worship spared; stop when the enemy seeks peace (Qur'an 8:61).
  • Surah 4:69–110: Muslims should fight for "the feeble among men and of the women and the children" (4:75, Pickthall); if enemies offer peace, "Allah alloweth you no way against them" (4:90, Pickthall).
  • Sunni and Shi'a: many Twelver Shi'a scholars teach that only defensive jihad is allowed until the Hidden Imam returns; Sunni scholars require a legitimate ruler.
  • Judaism: milchemet mitzvah (obligatory war: commanded by God, or defence when attacked) and milchemet reshut (optional war: needed a king and the Sanhedrin, so most say it cannot happen today).
  • "When thou drawest nigh unto a city to fight against it, then proclaim peace unto it." (Deuteronomy 20:10, JPS 1917). Fruit trees must not be cut down (20:19).
Mission 2Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Just war ideas across six religionsChristianity: just warMeaning: conditions that must all be metKey condition: last resort; civilians nevertargetedSource: Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 40;Romans 13:4; CCC 2309Islam: lesser jihad (jihad: "striving")Meaning: defensive war with strict conditionsKey condition: legitimate leader; self-defenceor protecting the oppressed; never to forceconversion; stop when the enemy seeks peaceSource: Qur'an 2:190; 8:61; 4:75; 4:90Judaism: milchemet mitzvah / milchemetreshutMeaning: obligatory war (commanded by God,or defence) / optional war (needed a king andthe Sanhedrin)Key condition: proclaim peace first; do not cutdown fruit treesSource: Deuteronomy 20:10; 20:19Hinduism: Dharma YuddhaMeaning: "righteous war": the Kshatriya duty toprotect societyKey condition: fight only warriors; never theunarmed, the fleeing or those who surrenderSource: Bhagavad Gita 2.31Sikhism: Dharam YudhMeaning: "war in defence of righteousness"Key condition: last resort; not for revenge, landor plunder; minimum force; civilians unharmedSource: Zafarnama 22; Dasam Granth 1133Buddhism: no "just" war (most Buddhists)Meaning: the First Precept forbids killing;hatred breeds hatredKey condition: some accept defence as thelesser harm, but killing is still unskilful, withkarmic resultsSource: the First Precept
  • Hinduism: Dharma Yuddha ("righteous war"). The Kshatriya (warrior varna) has a duty (dharma) to protect society.
  • Krishna tells Arjuna: "Nought better can betide a martial soul / Than lawful war" (Bhagavad Gita 2.31, Arnold).
  • Rules (Mahabharata; Manusmriti VII): fight only warriors; never the unarmed, the fleeing or those who surrender; no poisoned weapons.
  • Gandhi read the Gita's battle as the inner struggle between good and evil.
  • Sikhism: Dharam Yudh ("war in defence of righteousness"): a last resort; not for revenge, land or plunder; minimum force; civilians unharmed; end when its aim is met.
  • Guru Gobind Singh (Zafarnama 22): when all other means have failed, it is right to take up the sword (paraphrase).
  • Dasam Granth 1133 is your spec's named source on Dharam Yudh.
  • Buddhism: most Buddhists say no war is "just": the First Precept forbids killing, and hatred breeds hatred.
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944), War and Peace: A Buddhist Perspective, argues that the early Buddhist texts never justify war, yet in practice a nation may have to use force to stop an aggressor; the killing still breaks the First Precept (paraphrase).
  • Some Buddhists accept that defence may be the lesser harm, but still see killing as unskilful, with karmic results.
Quick check
?Which is a condition of lesser jihad as most Muslim scholars teach it?
Mission 2Evaluate

"A just war is impossible today."

Argument map: is a just war impossible today?A just war is impossible today.ForModern weapons cannot spare civilians:discrimination and proportionality failPope Francis (Fratelli Tutti, 2020, §258):the old criteria are now very hard to applyPacifists: war is never the most loving wayAgainstAn invaded country still has a just cause todefend itself (UN Charter, 1945, Article51)Intervention may stop genocidePrecision weapons can reduce civiliandeathsAnother viewThe theory still matters: it is used to judgeand limit wars, even when no war fullymeets itJudge it byCan any modern war meet every condition? ·Is doing nothing ever worse? · Who decideswhether the conditions are met?
  • Reasons for: modern weapons (bombs on cities, nuclear weapons) cannot spare civilians, so discrimination and proportionality fail. Pope Francis (Fratelli Tutti, 2020, §258) argues it is now very hard to apply the old just war criteria (paraphrase). Pacifists say war is never the most loving way.
  • Reasons against: a country that is invaded still has a just cause to defend itself; the UN Charter (1945, Article 51) recognises this. Intervention may stop genocide. Precision weapons can reduce civilian deaths.
  • Another view: the theory still matters because it is used to judge and limit wars, even when no war fully meets it.
  • Judge it by: Can any modern war meet every condition? Is doing nothing ever worse? Who decides whether the conditions are met?
Mission 2Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Reason, source, developmentReason 1Lawful governments have God-givenauthority to protect people.Sourcethe ruler "doesn't bear the sword in vain"(Romans 13:4)Developmentso a government may use force to defend itscitizens, as long as the war is a last resort.Reason 2War may be needed to restore peace andprotect the innocent.DevelopmentAugustine taught that peace is the aim of ajust war; the strict conditions stop warbecoming revenge or greed.

Question: Explain two reasons why many Christians accept the Just War theory.

  • Reason 1: Lawful governments have God-given authority to protect people. Source: the ruler "doesn't bear the sword in vain" (Romans 13:4). Development: so a government may use force to defend its citizens, as long as the war is a last resort.
  • Reason 2: War may be needed to restore peace and protect the innocent. Development: Augustine taught that peace is the aim of a just war; the strict conditions stop war becoming revenge or greed.
  • (c) 5 marks: two reasons, each developed, plus one source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check

?A country's border towns are shelled by its neighbour. After months of failed talks, its parliament votes to defend them. Its generals then propose bombing the neighbour's capital, home to millions, to end the war quickly. Which just war condition does the generals' plan most clearly break?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Is refusing to fight brave or naive? Why do some believers never use violence?

Make a guess: Is refusing to fight brave or naive? Why do some believers never use violence?

Mission 3

What pacifism is

From pacifism to holy warAbsolutepacifismnever rightConditionalpacifismsometimesthe lesserevilJust warlast resortHoly warreligiousreasonsNon-violent actionmarches, boycotts, sit-ins
  • Pacifism: the belief that war and violence are wrong; disputes should be settled peacefully.
  • Absolute pacifism: violence is never right, not even in self-defence or to protect others.
  • Conditional (relative) pacifism: violence is almost always wrong, but may be the lesser evil in extreme cases; or opposition to some kinds of war (e.g. nuclear war).
  • Conscientious objector: someone who refuses to fight on grounds of conscience. Many have served in non-combat roles such as ambulance work.
  • Passive resistance / non-violent direct action: opposing injustice without violence: marches, boycotts, sit-ins, refusing to obey unjust laws.
  • Pacifism is not doing nothing: pacifists actively work for peace (see Mission 4).
Mission 3Read the source

The Sermon on the Mount

"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." (Matthew 5:9)

"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also." (Matthew 5:38–39)

  • "love your enemies … pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you" (Matthew 5:44)
  • At his arrest Jesus tells Peter: "all those who take the sword will die by the sword." (Matthew 26:52)
  • "Peace I leave with you. My peace I give to you; not as the world gives, I give to you." (John 14:27)

Q1 What does Jesus replace "an eye for an eye" with?

Show answer

Not returning violence: turning the other cheek.

Q2 How might a conditional pacifist read Matthew 5:39?

Show answer

As a rule for personal revenge, not as forbidding a government to protect the innocent.

Mission 3

Quakers and the peace churches

Quakers and the Peace Testimony17th centuryQuakers (the ReligiousSociety of Friends) founded inEngland1660declaration to King Charles II"We utterly deny all outward wars and strifeand fightings with outward weapons, for anyend or under any pretence whatsoever."Why: "that of God" is in every personWorld Warsmany were conscientiousobjectors; some served in theFriends Ambulance UnitTodaythe Peace Testimony; otherpeace churches: Mennonites,Church of the Brethren
  • The Religious Society of Friends (Quakers), founded in 17th-century England, holds a Peace Testimony.
  • Their declaration to King Charles II (1660): "We utterly deny all outward wars and strife and fightings with outward weapons, for any end or under any pretence whatsoever."
  • Reason: "that of God" is in every person, so no one may be killed.
  • Many Quakers were conscientious objectors in the World Wars; some served in the Friends Ambulance Unit.
  • Other historic peace churches: Mennonites, Church of the Brethren.
  • Most Catholics and many other Christians respect Quakers' witness but hold that a just war may sometimes be a last resort (see Mission 2).
Quick check
?Gemma says: "War is nearly always wrong, but I would support it to stop a genocide." Which kind of pacifism, if any, does she hold?
Mission 3

Catholic teaching and the popes

A developing theme in papal teachingCatholic teachingNot absolutely pacifist: legitimate defenceunder strict conditions (CCC 2308–2309);supports conscientious objectors (CCC 2311).1963John XXIII, Pacem in Terris: in theatomic age, war can hardly be a wayto restore justice (paraphrase)1965Paul VI at the United Nations: "Nomore war, war never again!"2017Francis, World Day of Peacemessage: "Nonviolence: A Style ofPolitics for Peace"2020Francis, Fratelli Tutti: "Never againwar!"
  • The Catholic Church is not absolutely pacifist: states may use force in legitimate defence under strict conditions (CCC 2308–2309).
  • But it honours those who renounce violence, as long as others' rights are not harmed (CCC 2306, paraphrase), and supports conscientious objectors (CCC 2311).
  • A developing theme in papal teaching:
  • John XXIII, Pacem in Terris (1963): in the atomic age, war can hardly be a way to restore justice (paraphrase).
  • Paul VI at the United Nations (1965): "No more war, war never again!"
  • Francis, World Day of Peace message (2017): "Nonviolence: A Style of Politics for Peace". Fratelli Tutti (2020) repeats "Never again war!"
  • Some Catholics (e.g. members of Pax Christi) now ask the Church to move further towards non-violence; others defend the just war tradition.
Mission 3

Non-violent resistance in action

Non-violent resistance in action123IndiaGandhi (1869–1948): satyagraha; the SaltMarch (1930)1Montgomery, USAMartin Luther King Jr (1929–1968): thebus boycott (1955–56)2WarsawEmanuel Ringelblum (1900–1944): secretarchive (Oyneg Shabes) in the WarsawGhetto3Thomas Merton (1915–1968)Catholic Trappist monk: wrote against nuclearwar and the Vietnam War; non-violence is theChristian way to resist evil (Faith and Violence,1968)
  • Mohandas (Mahatma) Gandhi (1869–1948): satyagraha ("truth-force"): resisting injustice by non-violence and willingness to suffer. The Salt March (1930) helped win Indian independence (1947).
  • Martin Luther King Jr (1929–1968), Baptist minister: led the Montgomery bus boycott (1955–56) and the civil rights movement. Inspired by the Sermon on the Mount and by Gandhi.
  • Thomas Merton (1915–1968), Catholic Trappist monk: wrote against nuclear war and the Vietnam War; argued non-violence is the Christian way to resist evil (Faith and Violence, 1968).
  • Emanuel Ringelblum (1900–1944): in the Warsaw Ghetto he organised a secret archive (Oyneg Shabes) recording Nazi crimes: resistance without weapons.
Quick check
?Which of these is an example of passive resistance?
Mission 3Diversity

Other religions

Pacifism in five religionsIslamNot pacifist overalldefensive jihad is allowed, but peace is thegoal: "if they incline to peace, incline thou alsoto it" (Qur'an 8:61)Abel: "I shall not stretch out my hand againstthee to kill thee" (5:28); many Arab Springprotesters (2010–11) used non-violentmethodse.g.: Khudai Khidmatgar ("Servants of God"),led by Abdul Ghaffar Khan (1890–1988)JudaismMost are not pacifistsself-defence is allowed; peace is the hope ofthe prophets (Micah 4:1–6; Isaiah 2:4)e.g.: Emanuel Ringelblum's secret archive inthe Warsaw GhettoBuddhismMany are pacifiststhe First Precept: refrain from harming livingbeingsCunda Kammaraputta Sutta: the Buddhapraises one who has laid down the rod andweaponHinduismAhimsaahimsa (non-harming)Rig Veda 10.191.4: all united in mind andpurpose; but Kshatriyas may have a duty tofighte.g.: Gandhi's satyagrahaSikhismNot absolutely pacifistDharam Yudh is allowed, but peace is the goalGuru Granth Sahib 831e.g.: the Akali movement (1920–25):non-violent protest, e.g. at Guru ka Bagh(1922)
  • Islam: not pacifist overall (defensive jihad is allowed), but peace is the goal: "if they incline to peace, incline thou also to it" (Qur'an 8:61, Pickthall).
  • Surah 5:27–30: Abel tells his brother, "Even if thou stretch out thy hand against me to kill me, I shall not stretch out my hand against thee to kill thee" (5:28, Pickthall). In the Arab Spring (2010–11) many protesters used non-violent methods.
  • Abdul Ghaffar Khan (1890–1988) led the Muslim non-violent movement Khudai Khidmatgar ("Servants of God") against British rule.
  • Judaism: self-defence is allowed, so most Jews are not pacifists; peace is the hope of the prophets (Micah 4:1–6; Isaiah 2:4).
  • Buddhism: many Buddhists are pacifists: the First Precept is to refrain from harming living beings.
  • In the Cunda Kammaraputta Sutta the Buddha praises one who has laid down the rod and weapon (paraphrase).
  • Hinduism: ahimsa (non-harming); Gandhi's satyagraha.
  • Rig Veda 10.191.4 prays that all may be united in mind and purpose (paraphrase). But Kshatriyas may have a duty to fight.
  • Sikhism: not absolutely pacifist (Dharam Yudh), but peace is the goal.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 831 is your spec's named source on peace.
  • The Akali movement (1920–25) won control of gurdwaras through non-violent protest, e.g. at Guru ka Bagh (1922).
Quick check
?Why are many Buddhists pacifists?
Mission 3

Criticisms and non-religious views

Criticisms of pacifism and repliesCriticismReplyPacifism may letaggressors win: couldHitler have beenstopped without war?Non-violence hasworked: India 1947;US civil rights; thelargely peacefulrevolutions of 1989There is a duty toprotect the weak;doing nothing can alsocause deathViolence breeds moreviolenceDietrich Bonhoeffer (1906–1945)German Lutheran pastor drawn to pacifism;joined resistance circles plotting against Hitler,believing it was his duty; executed in 1945.
  • Criticism: pacifism may let aggressors win. Could Hitler have been stopped without war?
  • Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906–1945), a German Lutheran pastor drawn to pacifism, joined resistance circles plotting against Hitler, believing it was his duty; he was executed in 1945.
  • Criticism: there is a duty to protect the weak, and doing nothing can also cause death.
  • Responses: non-violence has worked (India 1947; US civil rights; the largely peaceful revolutions of 1989); violence breeds more violence.
  • Non-religious views: Humanists differ. Many are conditional pacifists who judge each war by its consequences and human rights. Bertrand Russell (1872–1970) was imprisoned in 1918 for anti-war writing and became first president of CND (1958).
Mission 3Evaluate

"Religious believers should always be pacifists."

Argument map: should religious believers always be pacifists?Religious believers should always bepacifists.ForJesus taught "turn … the other also" and"love your enemies"Quakers, many Buddhists and Gandhishow non-violence can workModern war kills mainly civiliansAgainstMost Christians accept just war as a lastresort (CCC 2309)Islam, Judaism, Sikhism and Hinduismallow defensive warFailing to protect the innocent may be thegreater evil (Bonhoeffer)Another viewConditional pacifism: work for peacealways, but accept force as a last resortJudge it byIs non-violence a rule or a goal? · Is a refusalto protect others itself a choice to let harmhappen? · Has non-violence succeededagainst brutal regimes?
  • Reasons for: Jesus taught "turn … the other also" and "love your enemies"; Quakers, many Buddhists and Gandhi show non-violence can work; modern war kills mainly civilians.
  • Reasons against: most Christians accept just war as a last resort (CCC 2309); Islam, Judaism, Sikhism and Hinduism allow defensive war; failing to protect the innocent may be the greater evil (Bonhoeffer).
  • Another view: conditional pacifism: work for peace always, but accept force as a last resort.
  • Judge it by: Is non-violence a rule or a goal? Is a refusal to protect others itself a choice to let harm happen? Has non-violence succeeded against brutal regimes?
Mission check

?During a war, a young nurse says she would never use violence, even to defend herself. She volunteers to drive ambulances on the front line, helping the wounded of both sides. Which best describes her position?
Mission 4

Mission 4: War can start in a day. How do believers try to build a peace that lasts?

Make a guess: War can start in a day. How do believers try to build a peace that lasts?

Mission 4

More than "no war"

From negative peace to positive peace"The work of righteousness will be peace"(Isaiah 32:17)Forgiveness and reconciliationpositive peaceJusticefor grievancesDialogue and mediationa neutral helperCeasefireno fighting: negative peaceNegative peace: no fighting. Positive peace:justice, fairness and trust, so that fighting doesnot return.
  • Peacemaking: actively working to end conflict and build a peace that lasts.
  • Negative peace: no fighting. Positive peace: justice, fairness and trust, so that fighting does not return.
  • Peace and justice go together: "The work of righteousness will be peace" (Isaiah 32:17).
  • Peacemaking includes: dialogue, mediation (a neutral helper), justice for grievances, forgiveness and reconciliation (restoring relationships; see an earlier lesson).
  • Pope Paul VI (World Day of Peace, 1972): "If you want peace, work for justice."
Mission 4Read the source

Blessed are the peacemakers

"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." (Matthew 5:9)

"You are the light of the world. A city located on a hill can't be hidden." (Matthew 5:14)

  • Matthew 5:1–16, the Beatitudes: God blesses the merciful, the peacemakers and those persecuted for doing right; disciples are salt and light in the world.
  • "As you would like people to do to you, do exactly so to them." (Luke 6:31; Luke 6:27–31 also commands love of enemies)

Q1 What does Jesus call peacemakers?

Show answer

Children of God.

Q2 How might "light of the world" inspire peacemaking?

Show answer

Christians should act visibly for good, not just believe privately.

Mission 4

Christian peacemakers

Christian peacemakersSt Oscar Romero (1917–1980)El SalvadorArchbishop of San Salvador; spoke outagainst violence and injustice towardsthe poor; shot while celebrating Mass(1980); canonised 2018Dorothy Day (1897–1980)co-founded the Catholic Workermovement (1933): houses of hospitalityfor the poor; a committed pacifistDesmond Tutu (1931–2021)South AfricaAnglican archbishop; non-violentopposition to apartheid; chaired theTruth and Reconciliation Commission(1996–98)Martin Luther King Jr (1929–1968)USAnon-violent civil rights campaignerEach was motivated by the Gospel's linkbetween peace and justice.
  • St Oscar Romero (1917–1980), Archbishop of San Salvador: spoke out against violence and injustice towards the poor as El Salvador slid into civil war; he was shot while celebrating Mass (1980) and canonised in 2018.
  • Dorothy Day (1897–1980): co-founded the Catholic Worker movement (1933): houses of hospitality for the poor; a committed pacifist who opposed war, even the Second World War.
  • Desmond Tutu (1931–2021), Anglican archbishop: led non-violent opposition to apartheid; chaired South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (1996–98).
  • Martin Luther King Jr (1929–1968): non-violent civil rights campaigner (see Mission 3).
  • Each was motivated by the Gospel's link between peace and justice.
Quick check
?Which Christian peacemaker co-founded a movement that runs houses of hospitality for the poor and refused to support any war?
Mission 4

Christian organisations for peace

Christian organisations for peacePax Christifounded 1945, Franceinternational Catholic peace movement:reconciliation, disarmament, peace education;promotes non-violenceCommunity of Sant'EgidioRome, 1968Catholic lay community; mediated the talksthat ended Mozambique's civil war (Romepeace accord, 1992); dialogue betweenenemies; help for refugeesCorrymeela CommunityNorthern Ireland, 1965Christian community bringing Catholics andProtestants together for reconciliation
  • Pax Christi (founded 1945 in France): international Catholic peace movement. Works for reconciliation, disarmament and peace education; promotes non-violence.
  • Community of Sant'Egidio (Rome, 1968): Catholic lay community. Mediated the talks that ended Mozambique's civil war (Rome peace accord, 1992); runs dialogue between enemies and help for refugees.
  • Corrymeela Community (Northern Ireland, 1965): Christian community bringing Catholics and Protestants together for reconciliation.
Mission 4

The United Nations

The United Nations and peaceUnited Nations (1945)"to save succeeding generations from thescourge of war" (UN Charter, Preamble)General Assemblypopes haveaddressed it since1965Security Councilsanctions orapproving force;permanent memberscan vetoPeacekeeping (since1948)"blue helmets"monitor ceasefiresand protect civilians;Nobel Peace Prize1988Human rightsUniversal Declarationof Human Rights(1948); development;humanitarian aidCriticismspermanent members can veto action;peacekeepers have sometimes failed to protectcivilians
  • Founded in 1945, after the Second World War, "to save succeeding generations from the scourge of war" (UN Charter, Preamble).
  • Security Council: can order sanctions or approve the use of force to restore peace.
  • Peacekeeping (since 1948): "blue helmet" troops monitor ceasefires and protect civilians; awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1988.
  • Promotes human rights (Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948), development and humanitarian aid.
  • Many religious leaders support its work; popes have addressed the General Assembly since 1965.
  • Criticisms: permanent members can veto action; peacekeepers have sometimes failed to protect civilians.
Mission 4Diversity

Peacemaking in other religions

Peacemaking in five religionsIslamWord: salam (peace): a name of God and theMuslim greetingSource: "Repel the evil deed with one which isbetter" (Qur'an 41:34)Malik's Muwatta 21.3.10: Abu Bakr forbidskilling women, children and the elderly, andcutting down fruit treese.g.: the Muslim Peace Fellowship (1994)JudaismSource: "seek peace, and pursue it" (Psalm34:14; 34:15 in Hebrew numbering)Perkei Avot 1:18: the world stands on justice,truth and peaceBuddhismSource: "hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada5)Karaniya Metta Sutta: loving-kindness to allbeingse.g.: the Buddhist Peace Fellowship (1978);Engaged Buddhism (Thich Nhat Hanh,1926–2022)HinduismWord: prayers end "Om shanti, shanti, shanti"(peace)Bhagavad Gita 11: all beings within the onedivine forme.g.: Gandhi's satyagrahaSikhismservice (sewa) for allGuru Granth Sahib 599 and 1330e.g.: Khalsa Aid (1999): relief in war zones,whatever people's faith
  • Islam: salam (peace) is a name of God and the Muslim greeting. "Repel the evil deed with one which is better, then lo! he, between whom and thee there was enmity (will become) as though he was a bosom friend." (Qur'an 41:34, Pickthall)
  • Malik's Muwatta 21.3.10: Abu Bakr's instructions forbid killing women, children and the elderly, and cutting down fruit trees (paraphrase).
  • Muslim peace groups (e.g. the Muslim Peace Fellowship, 1994) work for reconciliation.
  • Judaism: "seek peace, and pursue it" (Psalm 34:14, JPS 1917; 34:15 in Hebrew numbering).
  • Perkei Avot 1:18 (also spelled Pirkei Avot): the world stands on justice, truth and peace (paraphrase).
  • Buddhism: "hatred does not cease by hatred at any time: hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada 5, Müller). The Buddhist Peace Fellowship (1978) and Engaged Buddhism (Thich Nhat Hanh, 1926–2022) apply mindfulness and compassion to conflict.
  • The Karaniya Metta Sutta: loving-kindness to all beings, as a mother protects her only child (paraphrase).
  • Hinduism: Gandhi's satyagraha; prayers end "Om shanti, shanti, shanti" (peace).
  • Bhagavad Gita 11: the vision of all beings within the one divine form (paraphrase).
  • Sikhism: service (sewa) for all; Khalsa Aid (1999) brings relief to people in war zones whatever their faith.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 599 and 1330 are your spec's named sources.
Quick check
?Which source would a Buddhist most likely use to explain why revenge cannot bring peace?
Mission 4

How conflicts are resolved

How conflicts are resolved1. Ceasefirethe fighting stops2. Talks, often with a mediatore.g. Sant'Egidio for Mozambique; in NorthernIreland, Fr Alec Reid helped open talks3. Agreement on justice and power-sharingRome peace accord, Mozambique (1992); GoodFriday Agreement, Northern Ireland (1998)4. Reconciliation over yearsSouth Africa's Truth and ReconciliationCommission (1996–98): victims told theirstories; amnesty for full confession
  • Steps: ceasefire → talks (often with a mediator) → agreement on justice and power-sharing → reconciliation over years.
  • Northern Ireland: churches and individuals (e.g. Fr Alec Reid, a Redemptorist priest) helped open talks that led to the Good Friday Agreement (1998).
  • South Africa: the Truth and Reconciliation Commission let victims tell their stories and offered amnesty for full confession.
  • Non-religious views: Humanists work for peace through human rights, democracy, education and international law. Peacemaking does not need religion, but many religious people are motivated by it.
Quick check
?After a civil war, a Catholic community invites leaders from both sides to Rome and helps them talk until they sign a peace accord. What is this an example of?
Mission 4Evaluate

"Working for peace is the most important thing a religious believer can do."

Argument map: is working for peace the most important thing?Working for peace is the most importantthing a religious believer can do.For"Blessed are the peacemakers" (Matthew5:9)Every faith values peace (salam, shalom,shanti)Without peace, nothing else (worship,education, care for the poor) is secureAgainstMany believers say worship of God, orfollowing God's will, comes firstJustice may come before peace: a falsepeace can hide oppressionCaring for the poor and sick is equallycommanded (Matthew 25)Another viewPeace, justice and worship are inseparable:Romero and King saw peacemaking aspart of following GodJudge it byCan there be peace without justice? · Whatdoes each religion say is the most importantduty? · Is peacemaking only for leaders, or foreveryone?
  • Reasons for: "Blessed are the peacemakers" (Matthew 5:9); every faith values peace (salam, shalom, shanti); without peace, nothing else (worship, education, care for the poor) is secure.
  • Reasons against: many believers say worship of God, or following God's will, comes first; justice may come before peace (a false peace can hide oppression); caring for the poor and sick is equally commanded (Matthew 25).
  • Another view: peace, justice and worship are inseparable: Romero and King saw peacemaking as part of following God.
  • Judge it by: Can there be peace without justice? What does each religion say is the most important duty? Is peacemaking only for leaders, or for everyone?
Mission check

?Two neighbouring villages have fought over water for years. A ceasefire holds, but each side still blames the other and the water is still unfairly shared. According to most religious peacemakers, what is still missing?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Wars usually have several causes: greed, self-defence, retaliation, politics, resources, history, culture and sometimes religion.
  • Holy war is war believed commanded by God (e.g. the Crusades); most religious believers today reject it, and their teachings limit war.
  • Teachings that limit war: Matthew 26:52; Surah 2:190.
  • Critics say religion divides and sanctifies violence; believers reply that most wars are political or economic and that religion is often misused.

Mission 2

  • Just war theory (Augustine, Aquinas) sets conditions for going to war (just cause, authority, intention, last resort, success, proportionality) and rules for fighting (discrimination, proportional force).
  • CCC 2309: legitimate defence only, with grave and certain damage, no other means, serious prospects of success and no graver evils.
  • Other traditions have their own conditions: lesser jihad, milchemet mitzvah and reshut, Dharma Yuddha, Dharam Yudh; most Buddhists reject the idea of a just war.

Mission 3

  • Absolute pacifists reject all violence; conditional pacifists accept it as a last resort; passive resistance opposes injustice without violence.
  • Quakers, many Buddhists and Gandhi are pacifists; most Christians, Muslims, Jews, Sikhs and Hindus accept defensive war, while valuing peace.
  • The Catholic Church is not pacifist, but recent popes have moved strongly towards non-violence ("War never again!").

Mission 4

  • Peacemaking aims at positive peace: justice, reconciliation and trust, not only an end to fighting.
  • Christian peacemakers (Romero, Day, Tutu, King) and organisations (Pax Christi, Sant'Egidio, Corrymeela) act on Matthew 5:9; the UN keeps and builds peace internationally.
  • Other faiths have their own peacemakers and sources: Qur'an 41:34, Psalm 34:14, Dhammapada 5, Gandhi, Khalsa Aid.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Peace and Conflict (part 1) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1When a war is fought in God's name, is religion really the cause?
  2. Mission 2Can a war ever be fought justly, and who decides the rules?
  3. Mission 3Is refusing to fight brave or naive? Why do some believers never use violence?
  4. Mission 4War can start in a day. How do believers try to build a peace that lasts?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel