← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 1 1A Catholic Christianity – Section 2: Marriage and the Family (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Marriage and the Family (part 2)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?
  2. Mission 2Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?
  3. Mission 3Can a promise made "till death us do part" ever be undone, and who gets to decide?
  4. Mission 4Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?
  5. Mission 5If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?

Make a guess: Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?

Mission 1

Methods and reasons

Methods of contraceptionArtificialBarrier: condomHormonal: pill, implant; someemergency pills*IUD: the coil*Natural (NFP): avoid sex on fertiledays, tracked by body signsPermanent: sterilisation: vasectomy(men), tubal ligation (women)* May act after conception: some emergencypills, the IUD in some cases. Many believerswho accept contraception reject these, seeingthem as close to abortion.
  • Contraception: deliberately preventing pregnancy. Family planning: deciding whether, when and how many children to have.
  • Artificial methods: barrier (condom), hormonal (pill, implant), IUD (coil).
  • Natural methods (natural family planning, NFP): avoiding sex on the woman's fertile days, tracked by body signs.
  • Permanent: sterilisation (vasectomy for men, tubal ligation for women).
  • Some methods may work after conception (some emergency pills, the IUD in some cases). Many believers who accept contraception reject these, seeing them as close to abortion.
  • Reasons: spacing children, health, money, the couple's relationship; condoms also protect against STIs.
Mission 1

Catholic teaching: Humanae Vitae

Humanae Vitae: two meanings never separatedHumanae VitaePope Paul VI, 1968 (Catholic teaching)UnitiveProcreativejoins the coupleopen to new lifeneverseparated(HV 12)Natural family planning (NFP): forserious reasons (HV 16)Artificial contraception and sterilisation(HV 14)
  • Humanae Vitae (Pope Paul VI, 1968), paraphrase: sex in marriage has two meanings, unitive (joining the couple) and procreative (open to new life). They must never be separated (HV 12).
  • So each act of intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11): artificial contraception and sterilisation are wrong (HV 14).
  • Responsible parenthood (HV 10): couples may space births for serious reasons using NFP, which works with the body's natural rhythm (HV 16).
  • Roots in natural law: Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274) saw reproduction as a basic human purpose.
Mission 1Read the source

"Be fruitful"

"God blessed them. God said to them, 'Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it.'" (Genesis 1:28, WEBBE)

  • Catholic reading: children are a gift and a purpose of marriage; the couple cooperates with God the Creator, so sex should stay open to life.
  • Many Protestants: a blessing on humanity as a whole; it does not require every couple to have as many children as possible.

Q1 What does God tell the first humans to do?

Show answer

Be fruitful and multiply: have children.

Q2 Why might a Protestant say this verse still allows contraception?

Show answer

It blesses humanity's growth in general; responsible choices about family size can honour it.

Quick check
?A Catholic married couple have serious health reasons to avoid a pregnancy for two years. What does Catholic teaching allow?
Mission 1Diversity

Other Christians

The range of Christian views on contraceptionNatural methods onlyCouple's conscience123451Catholic: natural methods only2Some conservative evangelicals: leavefamily size to God; avoid contraception3Orthodox: many allow non-abortivemethods within marriage, after pastoralguidance4Church of England: accepted for goodreasons (Lambeth 1930); the couple'sconscience (1958)5Methodists and most Protestants:responsible use is good stewardshipAll these Christians reject methods that actafter conception if they see them as ending alife.
  • Church of England: the Lambeth Conference of 1930 first accepted contraception within marriage for good reasons; by 1958 it called family planning a matter of the couple's conscience.
  • Methodists and most Protestants: responsible use of contraception within marriage is good stewardship; it can strengthen the couple's love.
  • Orthodox: many allow non-abortive methods within marriage after pastoral guidance.
  • Some conservative evangelicals: leave family size to God and avoid contraception.
  • All these Christians reject methods that act after conception if they see them as ending a life.
  • Many Catholics use contraception in practice, though the teaching has not changed.
Mission 1

Situation ethics and non-religious views

Situation ethics: agape decidesSituation ethicsJoseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)agapeselfless lovehealththe couple'srelationshipresourcesthe child'swelfareExampleA couple where another pregnancy couldendanger the mother's life: the loving act maybe reliable contraception.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1905–1991, Situation Ethics, 1966): the only absolute is agape (selfless love). Do the most loving thing in each situation.
  • E.g. a couple where another pregnancy could endanger the mother's life: the loving act may be reliable contraception.
  • Humanists: decide by reason and consequences: health, the child's welfare, the couple's choice, the planet's resources.
  • Atheists: no divine command against it; most support easy access.
  • Catholic response: love is not measured only by results; Humanae Vitae warned that contraception could lead to less respect for women and more infidelity (HV 17).
  • Other Christians reply: agape and Jesus' command to love fit well with responsible parenthood.
Mission 1Diversity

Islam

Contraception: IslamIslamAllowed? Most scholars: reversible methodsConditions: within marriage, with bothspouses' consent (e.g. health, spacing);sterilisation only for serious health reasons;methods acting after conception widelyrejectedKey source: Hadith: Companions practised 'azl(withdrawal) and the Prophet did not forbid it(Sahih al-Bukhari 34:432, 62:136)Some Muslims oppose contraception from fearof poverty (Qur'an 17:31).
  • Muslims believe children are a gift from Allah; having a family is a strong Sunnah.
  • Hadith report that Companions practised 'azl (withdrawal) and the Prophet did not forbid it.
  • Your spec names Sahih al-Bukhari 34:432 and 62:136 (paraphrase): this happened while the Qur'an was being revealed, and the Prophet added that any soul Allah wills to create will come into being.
  • So most scholars allow reversible methods within marriage, with both spouses' consent, for reasons such as health or spacing.
  • Permanent sterilisation: generally only for serious health reasons. Methods acting after conception: widely rejected.
  • Some Muslims oppose contraception from fear of poverty, citing: "Slay not your children, fearing a fall to poverty, We shall provide for them and for you." (Qur'an 17:31, Pickthall)
Mission 1Diversity

Judaism

Contraception: JudaismOrthodox JudaismAllowed? Yes, with a rabbi's guidanceConditions: especially for the wife's health;the pill (used by the woman) preferred to thecondom (compare Onan, Genesis 38:9)Key source: "Be fruitful and multiply" (Genesis1:28): the first mitzvah; Yevamot 61b: at least ason and a daughter (Beit Hillel)Reform and Liberal JudaismAllowed? Yes: a responsible choice for thecoupleConditions: health and family welfare comefirstKey source: "Be fruitful and multiply" (Genesis1:28): the first mitzvah; Yevamot 61b: at least ason and a daughter (Beit Hillel)Both put the mother's life and health first.
  • "Be fruitful and multiply" (Genesis 1:28) is counted the first mitzvah (commandment).
  • Talmud, Yevamot 61b (paraphrase): Beit Hillel teaches the duty is fulfilled with at least a son and a daughter.
  • Orthodox Jews: contraception allowed with a rabbi's guidance, especially for the wife's health. Methods used by the woman (the pill) are preferred to the condom, which wastes seed (compare Onan, Genesis 38:9).
  • Reform and Liberal Jews: a responsible choice for the couple; health and family welfare come first.
  • Both put the mother's life and health first.
Mission 1Diversity

Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh views

Contraception: Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh viewsHinduismAllowed? Many accept, once the duty to havechildren is metConditions: ahimsa (non-harm) rules outmethods that destroy an embryoKey source: householder stage (grihastha);ahimsaBuddhismAllowed? No ban: most accept (preventingconception harms no being)Conditions: methods acting after conceptionmay break the First Precept; intention (cetana)mattersKey source: First Precept (not harming life)SikhismAllowed? No Guru forbids it: a matter for thecoupleConditions: sex disciplined within marriage;methods acting after conception opposedKey source: kaam (lust), one of the five thieves
  • Hindus: the householder stage (grihastha) includes the duty to have children. Many Hindus accept contraception once that duty is met; ahimsa (non-harm) rules out methods that destroy an embryo.
  • Bhagavad Gita 3.37–43: desire (kama) is the enemy of wisdom; control the senses. Some read this as self-control within marriage rather than a ban on contraception.
  • Buddhists: no ban. Preventing conception harms no being, so most accept it. Methods that act after conception may break the First Precept (not harming life). Intention (cetana) matters.
  • The XIV Dalai Lama, in The Natural World (paraphrase): with a growing world population, birth control is needed; non-violent methods are best.
  • Sikhs: no Guru forbids it; a matter for the couple. Kaam (lust) is one of the five thieves, so sex should be disciplined within marriage. Methods that act after conception are opposed.
  • Sikh Missionary Society, Introduction to Sikhism, Q124 (paraphrase): contraception is the couple's own decision.
Quick check
?Which statement about religious attitudes to contraception is accurate?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Family planning should be left to the couple, not religious teaching."

Argument map: family planning and the couple"Family planning should be left to thecouple, not religious teaching."ForThe couple knows their health, money andrelationshipSituation ethics: love decides case by caseHumanists: personal freedomMost Protestants and many Jews, Hindus,Buddhists and Sikhs leave it to conscienceAgainstCatholics: the meaning of sex comes fromGod, not from choice (Humanae Vitae)A conscience needs forming by teachingChildren are a gift, not a lifestyle decisionSome methods may end a lifeAnother viewThe couple decides, but within religious limits(e.g. no methods that act after conception).Judge it byWho has authority over moral choices? · Isevery act or the whole marriage what must beopen to life? · How much do consequencesmatter?
  • Reasons for: the couple knows their health, money and relationship; situation ethics: love decides case by case; Humanists: personal freedom; most Protestants and many Jews, Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs leave it to conscience.
  • Reasons against: Catholics: the meaning of sex comes from God, not from choice (Humanae Vitae); a conscience needs forming by teaching; children are a gift, not a lifestyle decision; some methods may end a life.
  • Another view: the couple decides, but within religious limits (e.g. no methods that act after conception).
  • Judge it by: Who has authority over moral choices? Is every act or the whole marriage what must be open to life? How much do consequences matter?
Mission 1Worked answer

Contrasting beliefs with a source

Contrasting beliefs with a sourceBelief 1Catholics believe artificial contraception iswrong.SourceHumanae Vitae (1968) teaches that each actof intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11).DevelopmentA condom or pill closes the act to life, so onlynatural family planning is allowed, and onlyfor serious reasons.contrastBelief 2Many Protestants, e.g. the Church of England,accept contraception within marriage.SourceThey read "Be fruitful, multiply" (Genesis1:28) as a blessing on humanity as a whole,not a rule for every act.DevelopmentSo responsible parenthood can be loving(agape), helping the couple care for thechildren they have.

Question: Explain two contrasting religious beliefs about contraception. Refer to sacred writings or another source of religious belief.

  • Belief 1: Catholics believe artificial contraception is wrong. Source: Humanae Vitae (1968) teaches that each act of intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11). Development: a condom or pill closes the act to life, so only natural family planning is allowed, and only for serious reasons.
  • Belief 2: many Protestants, e.g. the Church of England, accept contraception within marriage. Source: they read "Be fruitful, multiply" (Genesis 1:28) as a blessing on humanity as a whole, not a rule for every act. Development: so responsible parenthood can be loving (agape), helping the couple care for the children they have.
Mission check

?A doctor in a busy clinic is asked by two married patients from different faiths whether their religion allows them to use an implant to space their children. Which reply would be most accurate for both a Church of England patient and a Sunni Muslim patient?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?

Make a guess: Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?

Mission 2

Three ways to decide

Three ways to decideRules anddutiesNatural LawoftenabsolutistConsequencesutilitarianism,situationethicsoften relativistCharactervirtue ethicsgood actsfollow
  • An ethical theory is a method for deciding what is right.
  • Rules and duties: some acts are right or wrong in themselves (e.g. Natural Law: preserve life, never kill the innocent). Often absolutist.
  • Consequences: the right act produces the best results (e.g. utilitarianism, situation ethics). Often relativist.
  • Character: become a good person, and good acts follow (virtue ethics).
  • Religious believers use all three, alongside scripture and religious authority.
Mission 2

Situation ethics

Situation ethics: agape decidesthe most lovingthingrule(a guideline)only one absolute: agape (unselfish love)Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)
  • Joseph Fletcher (1905–1991), American Episcopal priest; Situation Ethics: The New Morality (1966).
  • Only one absolute rule: agape, unselfish love for others.
  • In each situation, do the most loving thing. Other rules are useful guidelines, not absolutes.
  • Fletcher points to Jesus putting people before Sabbath rules: "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath." (Mark 2:27)
  • Criticisms: hard to predict results; people may call selfish choices "loving"; it may allow acts many see as always wrong (e.g. torture "for the greater good").
Mission 2Read the source

Love fulfils the law

Situation ethics: agape decidesthe most lovingthingrule(a guideline)only one absolute: agape (unselfish love)Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)

"Love doesn't harm a neighbour. Love therefore is the fulfilment of the law." (Romans 13:10)

  • Jesus: "You shall love your neighbour as yourself." (Matthew 22:39)

Q1 How could a situationist use Romans 13:10?

Show answer

Love is the aim of every rule, so love can decide when rules clash.

Q2 How might a Catholic reply?

Show answer

Love works through God's commands, not against them: "fulfilment", not replacement.

Mission 2

Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism: add up the happinessan action++−++−each person affected: happiness + orunhappiness −add it up: right if it gives the greatesthappiness to the greatest numberBentham (1789): principle of utility · Mill(1863)
  • Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832), An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789): the principle of utility: the right act gives the greatest happiness to the greatest number.
  • John Stuart Mill (1806–1873), Utilitarianism (1863): "actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness."
  • WMD: some argue that nuclear weapons deter war, so they bring the greatest good; critics answer with the vast suffering if they are ever used.
  • Criticisms: a majority's happiness could justify harming a minority; results are hard to predict; justice and rights can be ignored.
Quick check
?A government argues: "Executing a few murderers will deter thousands of future killings, so it is right." Which approach is this?
Mission 2

Natural Law

Natural Law treePrimary precepts(as usually taught)secondary preceptspreserve lifedo not murderreproduceCatholic teaching:sex should stayopen to new life(Humanae Vitae,1968)educate the younglive in societyworship GodRoot: the first precept"good is to be done and pursued, and evil is tobe avoided" (Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II,q. 94, a. 2)reason discovers God's moral order in humannature
  • Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae: God built a moral order into human nature that reason can discover.
  • The first precept: "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided" (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 94, a. 2).
  • Primary precepts (as usually taught): preserve life; reproduce; educate the young; live in society; worship God.
  • Secondary precepts apply them: e.g. do not murder (from preserving life).
  • Catholic teaching on contraception (Humanae Vitae, 1968) applies the precept of reproduction: sex should stay open to new life.
Mission 2Read the source

Aquinas on natural inclinations

Natural Law treePrimary precepts(as usually taught)secondary preceptspreserve lifedo not murderreproduceCatholic teaching:sex should stayopen to new life(Humanae Vitae,1968)educate the younglive in societyworship GodRoot: the first precept"good is to be done and pursued, and evil is tobe avoided" (Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II,q. 94, a. 2)reason discovers God's moral order in humannature

"whatever is a means of preserving human life, and of warding off its obstacles, belongs to the natural law" (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 94, a. 2)

  • Aquinas adds: humans also share with animals the inclination to "sexual intercourse, education of offspring", and, by reason, "to know the truth about God, and to live in society".

Q1 Which primary precept does the first sentence describe?

Show answer

Preserve life.

Q2 How does Aquinas find these precepts?

Show answer

By reason, from the natural inclinations of human nature.

Quick check
?A Catholic doctor refuses to perform an abortion, saying "Innocent life must always be preserved, whatever the circumstances." Which approach does this most reflect?
Mission 2Diversity

One issue, several theories

One issue, several theoriesRule-basedConsequences / loveDivorcesanctity of vows: apromise before Godmust be keptcompassion: love maymean letting anunhappy couple part(situation ethics)Death penaltysanctity of life: onlyGod gives and takeslifeprinciple of utility:deterrence, protectionRacial discriminationall people are equal(image of God;Humanist humanrights)positive discriminationmay give a faireroutcome (utilitarian);critics: still treatingpeople by raceFamily planningCatholic Natural Law:sex open to new life,so artificialcontraception is wrongsituation ethics:contraception may bethe most loving choice(e.g. a mother's health)Abortion and euthanasiasanctity of life(absolutist)situation ethics mayallow them as themost loving act insome casesTreatment of criminalsmost religioustraditions andhuman-rights lawreject tortureabsolutelysituation ethics mightaccept torture "for thegreater good"
  • Divorce: sanctity of vows: a promise before God must be kept (absolutist) · compassion: love may mean letting an unhappy couple part (situation ethics).
  • Death penalty: principle of utility (deterrence, protection) · sanctity of life: only God gives and takes life.
  • Racial discrimination: all people are equal (image of God; Humanist human rights) · positive discrimination: favouring under-represented groups may produce a fairer outcome (utilitarian), but critics say it is still treating people by race.
  • Family planning: Catholic teaching applies Natural Law: sex should stay open to new life, so artificial contraception is wrong · situation ethics: contraception may be the most loving choice, for example to protect a mother's health or care for the children a couple already has.
  • Abortion and euthanasia: sanctity of life (absolutist) · situation ethics may allow them as the most loving act in some cases.
  • Treatment of criminals: situation ethics might accept torture "for the greater good"; most religious traditions and human-rights law reject torture absolutely.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Love is the only rule a Christian needs."

Argument map: love the only rule?"Love is the only rule a Christian needs."ForRomans 13:10 and Matthew 22:39: lovefulfils the lawJesus put people before Sabbath rules(Mark 2:27)Rules cannot cover every situationAgainstCatholic teaching: some acts are alwayswrong, whatever the motiveHumans easily mistake selfish wishes forloveClear rules protect the weakJesus also kept and taught thecommandmentsAnother viewUse both: rules as the normal guide, lovefor the hard casesJudge it byCan humans predict which act is most loving?· Do absolute rules ever cause harm? · Whatdo scripture and tradition say about rules?
  • Reasons for: Romans 13:10 and Matthew 22:39: love fulfils the law; Jesus put people before Sabbath rules (Mark 2:27); rules cannot cover every situation.
  • Reasons against: Catholic teaching holds some acts are always wrong, whatever the motive; humans easily mistake selfish wishes for love; clear rules protect the weak; Jesus also kept and taught the commandments.
  • Another view: use both: rules as the normal guide, love for the hard cases.
  • Judge it by: Can humans predict which act is most loving? Do absolute rules ever cause harm? What do scripture and tradition say about rules?
Mission check

?A hospital has one donor heart. Patient X is a young parent; patient Y is older and has waited longer. Which reasoning best fits virtue ethics?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Can a promise made "till death us do part" ever be undone, and who gets to decide?

Make a guess: Can a promise made "till death us do part" ever be undone, and who gets to decide?

Mission 3

Ending a marriage

Separation, divorce, annulmentSeparationliving apart, still marriedDivorcethe marriage is ended in lawAnnulmentthe marriage was never validLaw in England and WalesNo-fault divorce since April 2022: the onlyground is that the marriage has broken downirretrievably.
  • Divorce: the legal ending of a marriage. Separation: living apart while still married.
  • Annulment: a declaration that a marriage was never valid in the first place.
  • Remarriage: marrying again while a former spouse is still alive.
  • Law in England and Wales: since April 2022, no-fault divorce (Divorce, Dissolution and Separation Act 2020). The only ground: the marriage has broken down irretrievably; no one has to be blamed.
  • Common reasons: adultery, abuse, addiction, money worries, growing apart.
Mission 3

What Jesus taught

What Jesus taught: Mark and MatthewMark 10:8; Genesis 2:24"the two will become one flesh"Mark 10:11–12No exceptionMatthew 19:9; 5:32One exception:sexual immorality
  • Marriage is God's work: "the two will become one flesh" (Mark 10:8; Genesis 2:24).
  • Matthew 19:1–12: Pharisees ask whether divorce is allowed. Jesus says Moses allowed it "because of the hardness of your hearts" (Matthew 19:8), but it was not God's plan.
  • In Matthew, one exception: sexual immorality (Matthew 19:9; 5:32). Mark has no exception (Mark 10:11–12).
Mission 3Read the source

Matthew 19

"What therefore God has joined together, don't let man tear apart." (Matthew 19:6)

"I tell you that whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery." (Matthew 19:9)

Q1 Who joins a couple in marriage, according to Matthew 19:6?

Show answer

God; so humans should not separate them.

Q2 What does Matthew 19:9 say remarriage after divorce usually is?

Show answer

Adultery, except where the divorce followed sexual immorality.

Mission 3

Catholic teaching: annulment, not divorce

Catholic teaching: annulment, not divorceWas the marriage valid?YesThe bond remainsCCC 2382Civil divorce may betolerated (rights,children); separationallowedCCC 2383No remarriage while aformer spouse livesNoChurch tribunal (e.g.no free consent,force or fear)Annulment: nevervalidBoth free to marry inchurchCCC 2386A spouse unjustly abandoned is not to blame.Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia (2016)Accompany divorced and remarried Catholicswith care and discernment.
  • A valid, consummated sacramental marriage cannot be dissolved by any human power (CCC 2382, paraphrase).
  • Divorce is a grave offence against the natural law (CCC 2384, paraphrase), but civil divorce may be tolerated to protect legal rights or children (CCC 2383); separation is allowed.
  • A spouse unjustly abandoned is not to blame (CCC 2386).
  • Remarriage while a former spouse lives is not accepted; the person cannot usually receive Holy Communion.
  • Annulment (declaration of nullity): a Church tribunal finds the marriage was never valid, e.g. no free consent, force or fear, no intention of a lifelong faithful union open to children. Both may then marry in church.
  • Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia (2016): accompany divorced and remarried Catholics with care and discernment; some bishops allow Communion case by case.
Quick check
?Maria married at 18 because her family forced her. Years later a Catholic tribunal grants her an annulment. What does this mean?
Mission 3Diversity

Other Christians

Christians on divorce and remarriageCatholicDivorce? civil divorce may be tolerated; thebond remainsRemarriage in church? no, while a formerspouse lives, unless the first marriage isannulledOrthodoxDivorce? allowed out of mercy (economy)Remarriage in church? up to three marriages;a second wedding has a penitential toneChurch of EnglandRemarriage in church? since 2002 (GeneralSynod), at the priest's discretionMethodists and many ProtestantsDivorce? a sad last resort; God forgivesRemarriage in church? can be a fresh startSome evangelicalsDivorce? only for adultery (Matthew 19:9) ordesertion by an unbelieving spouse (1Corinthians 7:15)
  • Orthodox: marriage is meant for life, but out of mercy (economy) the Church allows divorce and up to three marriages; a second wedding has a penitential tone.
  • Church of England: since 2002 (General Synod), divorced people may remarry in church at the priest's discretion.
  • Methodists and many Protestants: divorce is a sad last resort; God forgives; remarriage can be a fresh start.
  • Some evangelicals: divorce only for adultery (Matthew 19:9) or desertion by an unbelieving spouse (1 Corinthians 7:15).
Mission 3

Situation ethics and non-religious views

Situation ethics: weighing with agapeSituation ethicsJoseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)agapekeep thepromisepreventharmDo the most loving thing. If staying togethercauses lasting harm, divorce may be the lovingact.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics, 1966): do the most loving (agape) thing. If staying together causes lasting harm, divorce may be the loving act.
  • Humanists and atheists: marriage is a human commitment; if it has failed, divorce can be best for adults and children; remarriage is fine.
  • They support no-fault divorce: less conflict, less blame.
  • Catholic response: compassion is right, but love also means keeping promises; separation can protect people without denying the marriage.
  • Other Christian response: many agree that love and forgiveness can make divorce and remarriage right in some cases.
Mission 3Evaluate

Sanctity of vows or compassion?

Argument map: sanctity of vows or compassion?Sanctity of vows or compassion?Sanctity of vowsThe promise was made before God for lifeJesus taught against divorce (Matthew19:6)Stability for childrenEasy divorce weakens commitmentCompassionNo one should stay in abuse or miseryGod forgives and offers new startsChildren can suffer more from conflictMoses allowed divorce because of humanweakness (Matthew 19:8)Another viewBoth matter: work hard to save the marriage,but allow separation or divorce when it trulyfails.Judge it byIs a vow unbreakable or a commitment to try?· Whose welfare counts most? · Doesallowing divorce show mercy or weakenmarriage?
  • Sanctity of vows: the promise was made before God for life; Jesus taught against divorce (Matthew 19:6); stability for children; easy divorce weakens commitment.
  • Compassion: no one should stay in abuse or misery; God forgives and offers new starts; children can suffer more from conflict; Moses allowed divorce because of human weakness (Matthew 19:8).
  • Another view: both matter: work hard to save the marriage, but allow separation or divorce when it truly fails.
  • Judge it by: Is a vow unbreakable or a commitment to try? Whose welfare counts most? Does allowing divorce show mercy or weaken marriage?
Mission 3Diversity

Islam

Divorce in Islam: the processAllowed as a last resortTry to reconcile: an arbiter from each family(Qur'an 4:35)Talaq: divorce by the husbandIddah: a waiting time of three monthly cycles(Qur'an 2:228)Retain in honour or release in kindness (Qur'an2:229)Khul'A wife can seek divorce by returning her dowry,or through a judge or Shari'ah council.
  • Divorce is allowed as a last resort; a hadith calls it the most disliked of permitted things (Abu Dawud, paraphrase).
  • First, try to reconcile: "appoint an arbiter from his folk and an arbiter from her folk." (Qur'an 4:35, Pickthall)
  • Talaq (divorce by the husband), then iddah: a waiting time of three monthly cycles, to allow reconciliation and check for pregnancy (Qur'an 2:228).
  • "Divorce must be pronounced twice and then (a woman) must be retained in honour or released in kindness." (Qur'an 2:229, Pickthall)
  • A wife can seek divorce by khul' (returning her dowry) or through a judge or Shari'ah council.
  • Surah 2:226–241 also covers a waiting period of four months after a husband's vow to stay apart (2:226), fair treatment and provision for divorced women.
  • Sunni and Shi'a rules: Shi'a law requires a set formula before two just witnesses, and three pronouncements at one sitting count as one at most. Sunni schools do not require witnesses; the classical Sunni schools mostly counted three at once as final, a view many modern Sunni scholars reject.
Mission 3Diversity

Judaism

Divorce in Judaism: the getAllowed, though sad (Deuteronomy 24:1)Beth Din (rabbinic court)Get (bill of divorce): given by the husband; thewife must accept it freelyRemarriageOrthodox: agunah warningA civil divorce is not enough: without a getneither may remarry. A woman whose husbandrefuses is an agunah ("chained" woman).ReformDivorce and remarriage accepted; a get isencouraged, and the movement's ownprocedures help where a husband refuses.
  • Divorce is allowed, though sad. Deuteronomy 24:1: the husband "writeth her a bill of divorcement, and giveth it in her hand" (Deuteronomy 24:1, JPS 1917).
  • The get (bill of divorce) is given by the husband before a Beth Din (rabbinic court). The wife must accept it freely.
  • Orthodox: a civil divorce is not enough; without a get neither may remarry in Orthodox Judaism. A woman whose husband refuses is an agunah ("chained" woman).
  • Reform: divorce and remarriage accepted; a get is encouraged but the movement's own procedures help where a husband refuses.
  • Maimonides (1138–1204), Mishneh Torah, Laws of Marriage (Ishut) ch. 24 (paraphrase): sets out conduct that gives grounds for divorce. Arguments for and against divorce: the sanctity of marriage vs ending a home without peace (shalom bayit).
Mission 3Diversity

Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh views

Divorce: Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh viewsHindusMarriage is a sacred samskara, ideally bindingbeyond this life. Divorce was not part oftraditional Hindu law.BuddhistsMarriage is a social contract, not a sacrament:no religious ban on divorce. Reduce suffering;act with compassion (karuna).SikhsThe Anand Karaj joins two souls. Divorce isstrongly discouraged; families and the sangattry to reconcile the couple. Civil divorce isreluctantly accepted.
  • Hindus: marriage is a sacred samskara, ideally binding beyond this life; divorce was not part of traditional Hindu law.
  • Hindu Marriage Act 1955 (India) allowed divorce on grounds such as cruelty, desertion and adultery; divorce by mutual consent was added in 1976. Some Hindus argue duty (dharma) means keeping the marriage; others that suffering serves no dharma.
  • Buddhists: marriage is a social contract, not a sacrament; no religious ban on divorce. Reduce suffering; act with compassion (karuna).
  • Ven. K. Sri Dhammananda (1919–2006), A Happy Married Life (paraphrase): if a couple truly cannot live in harmony, they may part rather than live in misery.
  • Sikhs: the Anand Karaj joins two souls; divorce is strongly discouraged and families and the sangat try to reconcile the couple. Civil divorce is reluctantly accepted.
  • Rahit Maryada ch. 11 (Article 18 on Anand marriage): sets out the Sikh marriage and allows a widow or widower to remarry; it does not provide a ceremony of divorce.
Quick check
?An Orthodox Jewish woman has a civil divorce, but her husband refuses to give a get. Which statement is accurate?
Mission 3Worked answer

Vows and compassion

Answer plan: should religious people never divorce?"Religious people should never divorce."ForCatholics: a valid marriage cannot be dissolved(CCC 2382). "What therefore God has joinedtogether, don't let man tear apart" (Matthew19:6). Vows before God are sacred.AgainstMuslims, Jews and most Protestants allowdivorce as a last resort; staying in abuse is notloving (situation ethics); God forgives.WeighingThe Catholic view rests on the sacrament beingpermanent; the other on compassion for realsuffering. Which is stronger depends onwhether a vow can be broken by the otherpartner's behaviour.ConclusionYour justified judgement

Question: "Religious people should never divorce." Evaluate this statement.

  • For: Catholics believe a valid marriage cannot be dissolved (CCC 2382); Jesus said "What therefore God has joined together, don't let man tear apart" (Matthew 19:6). Vows before God are sacred.
  • Against: Muslims, Jews and most Protestants allow divorce as a last resort; staying in abuse is not loving (situation ethics); God forgives.
  • Weighing: the Catholic view rests on the sacrament being permanent; the other view rests on compassion for real suffering. Which is stronger depends on whether a vow can be broken by the other partner's behaviour.
Mission check

?Two Christians each divorce after their spouses leave them. One is Catholic, one is an Anglican in England. Both want to marry again in church. What is most likely?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?

Make a guess: Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?

Mission 4

Roles then and now

Two religious approaches to rolesComplementarianequal in worth;different andcomplementary rolesEgalitarianequal in worth; rolesshared orinterchangeable,decided by gifts andcircumstancesEqual worth
  • Traditional roles: man as breadwinner and head; woman as homemaker and main carer.
  • Today: most couples both work; more fathers share childcare or stay at home; roles are negotiated.
  • Gender equality: men and women have equal worth, rights and opportunities.
  • Two religious approaches:
  • Complementarian: equal in worth, different and complementary roles.
  • Egalitarian: equal in worth, roles shared or interchangeable, decided by gifts and circumstances.
Mission 4

Genesis: equal in God's image

Genesis: equal in God's imageGenesis 1:27male and female:both in God's imageGenesis 2:18=ezer: helper (also used ofGod), so not inferiorGenesis 3:16"he will rule over you"after the Falla common reading: theresult of sin, not God'soriginal plan
  • "God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27)
  • Both share God's image and the same blessing and task (Genesis 1:26–31).
  • Genesis 2:18: the woman is "a helper comparable to him". The Hebrew word (ezer) is also used of God helping Israel, so it does not mean inferior.
  • Genesis 3:16: after the Fall, "he will rule over you". Many Christians and Jews read this as the result of sin, not God's original plan.
Mission 4Read the source

Ephesians 5

"subjecting yourselves to one another in the fear of Christ." (Ephesians 5:21)

"Wives, be subject to your own husbands, as to the Lord." (Ephesians 5:22)

"Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the assembly and gave himself up for her" (Ephesians 5:25)

Q1 What does 5:21 ask of both spouses?

Show answer

To submit to one another.

Q2 What kind of love does 5:25 ask of husbands?

Show answer

Self-giving love like Christ's, who gave his life.

Mission 4Diversity

Christian views on roles

Ephesians 5: to one anotherEphesians 5:21 · to one another"subjecting yourselves to one another in thefear of Christ."5:22"Wives, be subject toyour own husbands,as to the Lord."5:25"Husbands, love yourwives, even as Christalso loved theassembly and gavehimself up for her"
  • Complementarian (many evangelicals, some traditional Christians): the husband is a loving, serving head; the wife supports and respects him (Ephesians 5:22–25).
  • Egalitarian (many Anglicans, Methodists, liberal Christians): 5:21 means mutual submission; "neither male nor female" (Galatians 3:28); roles by gifts.
  • Catholic: man and woman are equal in dignity and complementary. John Paul II (Mulieris Dignitatem, 1988) read Ephesians 5 as mutual submission.
  • CCC 2207 (paraphrase): the family is the original cell of social life, where people first learn respect, care and responsibility.
  • Dignity of work in the home: John Paul II (Laborem Exercens, 1981, 19; Familiaris Consortio, 1981, 23) taught that caring for home and children is real work that society should value; women must not be penalised for it, nor shut out of paid work.
Quick check
?An egalitarian Christian is asked how she reads Ephesians 5:21–25. What would she most likely say?
Mission 4Diversity

Islam

Roles in IslamIslamEqual before Allah: "Whosoever doeth right,whether male or female, and is a believer..."(Qur'an 16:97); created "from a single soul"(Qur'an 4:1)Different responsibilities: the husband mustprovide (Qur'an 4:34); a wife's own earningsand property remain hers; mahr is paid to her"they (women) have rights similar to those (ofmen) over them in kindness, and men are adegree above them." (Qur'an 2:228) Scholarsdiffer on what the "degree" means.Diversity: traditional Muslims stress distinctroles; many British Muslims share work andchildcare
  • Equal before Allah: "Whosoever doeth right, whether male or female, and is a believer..." (Qur'an 16:97, Pickthall); both created "from a single soul" (Qur'an 4:1).
  • Different responsibilities: the husband must provide for the family (Qur'an 4:34); a wife's own earnings and property remain hers; mahr (dowry) is paid to her.
  • "they (women) have rights similar to those (of men) over them in kindness, and men are a degree above them." (Qur'an 2:228, Pickthall) Scholars differ on what the "degree" means (e.g. extra responsibility).
  • Surah 4 (An-Nisa) sets out rights of wives, inheritance and the husband's duty (4:34, a verse read in very different ways).
  • The time of Muhammad: Khadijah ran a trading business and employed him; Aisha was a leading teacher; hadith say the Prophet mended his clothes and helped with housework.
  • Diversity: traditional Muslims stress distinct roles; many British Muslims share work and childcare.
Mission 4Diversity

Judaism

Roles in JudaismJudaism"A woman of valour who can find? for her priceis far above rubies." (Proverbs 31:10)Sung in many Jewish homes on Friday night:she runs a home, trades and buys a field(31:16).Orthodox: equal worth, different roles; thehome is a woman's special sphere of holiness(e.g. Shabbat candles)Reform and Liberal: egalitarian: roles in homeand synagogue are shared
  • Genesis 1:26–31: men and women created together in God's image and given the same blessing.
  • "A woman of valour who can find? for her price is far above rubies." (Proverbs 31:10, JPS 1917) This poem (31:10–31) is sung in many Jewish homes on Friday night, often by the husband; the woman runs a home, trades and buys a field (31:16).
  • Orthodox Jews: equal worth, different roles. Women are exempt from many time-bound commandments, partly to allow for family duties; the home is a woman's special sphere of holiness (e.g. Shabbat candles).
  • Reform and Liberal Jews: egalitarian: roles in home and synagogue are shared.
Mission 4Diversity

Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh views

Roles: Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh teachingHinduismManusmriti 3.55–60: where women arehonoured the gods rejoiceArdhangini: "half of the body" of her husband.Many Hindus today share roles; others keeptraditional ones.Buddhism: Sigalovada SuttaFive duties each wayThe husband1honours her2does not look downon her3is faithful4gives her authorityin the home5gives her gifts(ornaments)The wife1manages the homewell2is hospitable torelatives3is faithful4protects thefamily's wealth5is skilfulSikhismGuru Granth Sahib 788: husband and wife arethose who have one light in two bodies. Equalpartners in grihasth.
  • Hindus: Manusmriti 3.55–60 (paraphrase): women must be honoured by fathers, brothers and husbands; where women are honoured the gods rejoice, and where they are not, rites bring no reward.
  • The wife is ardhangini ("half of the body") of her husband; stridharma (women's duty) traditionally centred on home and family. Many Hindus today share roles; others keep traditional ones.
  • Buddhists: Sigalovada Sutta: the husband honours her, does not look down on her, is faithful, gives her authority in the home and gives her gifts (ornaments); the wife manages the home well, is hospitable to relatives, faithful, protects the family's wealth and is skilful.
  • The life of the Buddha: Siddhattha left his wife Yasodhara and son Rahula; later his stepmother Mahapajapati became the first nun, and Yasodhara and Rahula also joined the Sangha.
  • Sikhs: Guru Granth Sahib 788 (paraphrase): those who merely sit together are not husband and wife; husband and wife are those who have one light in two bodies. Equal partners in grihasth.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly matches a teaching about roles in the family?
Mission 4

Non-religious views

Unpaid care: shared or not sharedUnpaid housework and care: an idea, not dataNot sharedone partnerFeminist critique: "different roles" can hideinequality (e.g. women doing most unpaidhousework)Sharedone partnerthe otherRoles decided by the couple, not by sex orscripture (Humanists); many believers alreadyshare rolesReligious responsesComplementarity values women's distinct gifts;Catholic teaching says work in the homedeserves recognition.
  • Humanists: equal rights and opportunities; roles decided by the couple, not by sex or scripture.
  • Feminist critiques: "different roles" can hide inequality (e.g. women doing most unpaid housework).
  • Many atheists and Humanists support shared parental leave and equal pay.
  • Religious responses: complementarity values women's distinct gifts; Catholic teaching says work in the home deserves recognition; many believers already share roles.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Men and women should have different roles in the family."

Argument map: different roles in the family?"Men and women should have differentroles in the family."ForComplementarian reading of Ephesians5:22–25 and Qur'an 4:34Orthodox Jewish and traditional HinduteachingBiological differences (pregnancy,breastfeeding)AgainstGenesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28Ephesians 5:21: mutual submissionGGS 788: "one light in two bodies"Humanist equalityModern families need flexibilityAnother viewEqual worth is essential; whether roles differshould be the couple's free choice.Judge it byDoes "different" mean "unequal"? · Arescripture's roles timeless or cultural? · Whodecides: tradition or the couple?
  • Reasons for: complementarian reading of Ephesians 5:22–25 and Qur'an 4:34; Orthodox Jewish and traditional Hindu teaching; biological differences (pregnancy, breastfeeding).
  • Reasons against: Genesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28; Ephesians 5:21 mutual submission; GGS 788 "one light in two bodies"; Humanist equality; modern families need flexibility.
  • Another view: equal worth is essential; whether roles differ should be the couple's free choice.
  • Judge it by: Does "different" mean "unequal"? Are scripture's roles timeless or cultural? Who decides: tradition or the couple?
Mission check

?In a family, the mother is a surgeon and the father works part-time so he can do the school run and cook. Which statement best describes how the main religious traditions would see this?
Mission 5

Mission 5: If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Make a guess: If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Mission 5

Prejudice, discrimination, equality

Prejudice and discriminationPrejudice(thought)judging unfairlybefore knowing(an attitude)Discrimination(action)treating someoneunfairly becauseof a prejudiceUK law1970Equal Pay Act1975Sex Discrimination Act2010Equality Act (now)
  • Prejudice: judging someone unfairly before knowing them (an attitude). Sexism: prejudice based on sex.
  • Discrimination: treating someone unfairly because of a prejudice (an action).
  • Gender equality: equal rights, status and opportunities for women and men.
  • UK law: Equal Pay Act 1970; Sex Discrimination Act 1975; now the Equality Act 2010.
  • Examples: unequal pay for the same work; women passed over for promotion; girls denied schooling (Malala Yousafzai, shot in 2012 for campaigning for girls' education).
Mission 5

Christian teaching on equality

Christian teaching on equalityGenesis 1:27Both sexes are made in God's image.Galatians 3:28"There is neither Jew nor Greek, there isneither slave nor free man, there is neithermale nor female; for you are all one in ChristJesus."John 20:18Mary Magdalene first told the others thatJesus had risen: women as disciples andwitnesses.CCC 1938 (Catholic, paraphrase)Sinful inequalities between people contradictthe Gospel.
  • Both sexes are made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).
  • "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." (Galatians 3:28)
  • Jesus treated women as disciples and witnesses: Mary Magdalene first told the others he had risen (John 20:18).
  • Catholic: CCC 1938 (paraphrase): sinful inequalities between people contradict the Gospel. Men and women have equal dignity (CCC 369).
  • John Paul II's theology of the body (1979–84): man and woman are equal and complementary; each is a gift to the other.
  • Catholic opposition to discrimination: the Church calls for equal pay, opposes violence against women, and supports girls' education worldwide (e.g. through CAFOD and religious orders' schools).
Mission 5Read the source

Equality and leadership

"But I don't permit a woman to teach, nor to exercise authority over a man, but to be in quietness." (1 Timothy 2:12)

  • Compare Galatians 3:28: "neither male nor female".
  • Galatians 3:23–29: before faith came, people were under the law; now, baptised into Christ, all are God's children and heirs.

Q1 What does 1 Timothy 2:12 forbid?

Show answer

Women teaching or having authority over men.

Q2 How might an Anglican who supports women priests read it?

Show answer

As advice for one church in Paul's time, while Galatians 3:28 states the lasting principle.

Mission 5Diversity

Women's ministry in the churches

Women's ministry in the churches1994Church of England: womenpriests2014Church of England: law allowswomen bishops2015First woman bishop: Libby Lane2025Sarah Mullally chosen as thefirst woman Archbishop ofCanterburyMethodists, Salvation Army, URC, manyBaptists: women ministers; the Salvation Armyfrom its start (Catherine Booth)Catholic and Orthodox: male priesthoodOnly men can be ordained priests. OrdinatioSacerdotalis (John Paul II, 1994): the Churchhas no authority to ordain women. Catholicsstress roles, not worth.
  • Catholic: only men can be ordained priests. John Paul II (Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, 1994): the Church has no authority to ordain women. Reasons: Jesus chose twelve men as apostles; the priest acts in the person of Christ.
  • Catholics stress this is about roles, not worth; women lead as religious sisters, teachers, theologians; since 2021 they can be formally installed as readers and acolytes.
  • Orthodox: male priesthood, for similar reasons of tradition.
  • Church of England: women priests since 1994, bishops since 2014 (first, Libby Lane, 2015); in 2025 Sarah Mullally was chosen as the first woman Archbishop of Canterbury.
  • Methodists, Salvation Army, URC, many Baptists: women ministers; the Salvation Army from its start (Catherine Booth).
  • Some evangelical churches: women lead in many ways but not as senior pastors (1 Timothy 2:12).
Quick check
?A firm refuses to promote a woman because the manager believes "mothers aren't committed to their jobs". Which statement is accurate?
Mission 5Diversity

Islam

Women and worship: IslamIslamTeaching on worth: equal reward for faith andgood deeds: "men who surrender unto Allah,and women who surrender" (Qur'an 33:35)Who leads worship: separate rows or rooms;women may lead other women; most scholars:only men lead mixed congregational prayerExample: Khadijah, businesswoman; Aisha, aleading scholar; Fatima al-Fihri foundedal-Qarawiyyin, Fez (859)
  • Equal reward for faith and good deeds: Qur'an 33:35 lists "men who surrender unto Allah, and women who surrender" through ten pairs (Qur'an 33:35, Pickthall).
  • Worship: men and women pray in separate rows or rooms; women may lead other women; most scholars teach only men lead mixed congregational prayer. Attending the mosque is a duty for men at Jumu'ah, optional for women.
  • Equality in action: Khadijah, successful businesswoman; Aisha, a leading scholar; Fatima al-Fihri founded al-Qarawiyyin in Fez (859), often called the oldest university still working.
  • Many Muslims say discrimination against women comes from culture, not Islam; groups such as Muslim Women's Network UK campaign for women's rights.
Mission 5Diversity

Judaism

Women and worship: JudaismOrthodox JudaismTeaching on worth: both made in God's image(Genesis 1:27)Who leads worship: separate seating(mechitzah); only men count for a minyan andlead public prayer; rabbis are menExample: women's learning and leadershiproles are growingReform and Liberal JudaismTeaching on worth: both made in God's image(Genesis 1:27)Who leads worship: mixed seating; womenrabbis and cantorsExample: Regina Jonas, first woman rabbi(Germany, 1935); in Britain, Jackie Tabick(1975)
  • Both made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).
  • Orthodox: separate seating (mechitzah); only men count for a minyan (prayer quorum of ten) and lead public prayer; rabbis are men. Women's learning and leadership roles are growing.
  • Reform and Liberal: mixed seating; women rabbis and cantors. First woman rabbi: Regina Jonas (Germany, 1935); in Britain, Jackie Tabick (1975).
  • Israel's Basic Law: Human Dignity and Liberty (Knesset, 1992), paraphrase: every person's life, body and dignity are protected; it is used to oppose discrimination, including against women.
Mission 5Diversity

Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh views

Women and worship: Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh viewsHinduismTeaching on worth: the same atman in all: thetrue yogi "sees the Life-Soul resident / In allthings living" (Bhagavad Gita 6.29)Who leads worship: women increasingly trainas priests; some temples still limit women'srolesExample: God worshipped as female too(Durga, Lakshmi, Saraswati)BuddhismTeaching on worth: women and men can bothreach enlightenmentWho leads worship: the Buddha founded anorder of nunsSikhismTeaching on worth: Guru Granth Sahib 473(paraphrase): why call her inferior, from whomkings are born?Who leads worship: women may lead anyservice, read the Guru Granth Sahib and serveas granthiExample: Bibi Jagir Kaur, first womanpresident of the SGPC (1999); still few womenin senior Sikh bodies
  • Hindus: the same atman (self) is in all, so all deserve equal regard. The Gita's true yogi "sees the Life-Soul resident / In all things living" (Bhagavad Gita 6.29, Arnold).
  • God is worshipped as female too (Durga, Lakshmi, Saraswati). Women increasingly train as priests; some temples still limit women's roles.
  • Buddhists: women and men can both reach enlightenment; the Buddha founded an order of nuns.
  • Soma Sutta (Samyutta Nikaya 5.2, paraphrase): Mara taunts the nun Soma that a woman cannot reach the goal; she replies that womanhood does not matter when the mind is concentrated and sees the Dhamma.
  • Sikhs: Guru Granth Sahib 473 (paraphrase): we are born of woman, and through woman the family goes on; so why call her inferior, from whom kings are born? Women may lead any service, read the Guru Granth Sahib and serve as granthi.
  • Divergent Sikh practice: few women in senior Sikh bodies; women are not permitted to perform kirtan inside the Harmandir Sahib. Bibi Jagir Kaur became the first woman president of the SGPC (1999).
Quick check
?Which statement about women in religious leadership is accurate?
Mission 5

Does equal mean the same?

Does equal mean the same?Equal worthSamenesssame rights, rolesand opportunitieseverywhere,including religiousleadership. ManyHumanists andegalitarian believers.Complementarityequal worth andrights, but some roleslinked to sex.Catholic andOrthodox teaching,Orthodox Judaism,many Muslims.
  • Equality as sameness: the same rights, roles and opportunities everywhere, including religious leadership. Held by many Humanists and egalitarian believers.
  • Equality with difference (complementarity): equal worth and rights, but some roles linked to sex. Held by Catholic and Orthodox teaching, Orthodox Judaism and many Muslims.
  • Humanists: no reason, apart from tradition, to bar women from any role; tradition should change when it causes unfairness.
  • Catholic response: the male priesthood follows Christ's choice and does not judge women's worth; Mary is honoured above all saints.
Mission 5Evaluate

"Religions treat women as equals."

Argument map: do religions treat women as equals?"Religions treat women as equals."ForEqual image of God (Genesis 1:27),Galatians 3:28, Qur'an 33:35, GGS 473,Soma SuttaWomen priests, rabbis and leaders inmany traditionsFaiths campaign against sex discriminationAgainstMale-only priesthood (Catholic, Orthodox)and rabbinate (Orthodox Judaism)Separate roles in mosquesSome texts (1 Timothy 2:12; someManusmriti verses)Practice often lags behind teachingAnother viewEqual worth is taught everywhere; the debateis whether different roles are fair.Judge it byEqual worth or equal roles? · Teaching orpractice? · Which tradition or group?
  • Reasons for: equal image of God (Genesis 1:27), Galatians 3:28, Qur'an 33:35, GGS 473, Soma Sutta; women priests, rabbis and leaders in many traditions; faiths campaign against sex discrimination.
  • Reasons against: male-only priesthood (Catholic, Orthodox) and rabbinate (Orthodox Judaism); separate roles in mosques; some texts (1 Timothy 2:12; some Manusmriti verses); practice often lags behind teaching.
  • Another view: equal worth is taught everywhere; the debate is whether different roles are fair.
  • Judge it by: Equal worth or equal roles? Teaching or practice? Which tradition or group?
Mission check

?On one street, the Anglican church's vicar is a woman, while the Catholic parish next door has only ever had male priests. Both churches teach that women and men are made equally in God's image. What best explains the difference?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Catholics (Humanae Vitae): only natural family planning, for serious reasons; most other Christians accept contraception within marriage.
  • Islam ('azl hadith) and Judaism (first mitzvah, pill preferred) allow it with conditions; Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs mostly accept it but reject methods that act after conception.
  • Situation ethics and Humanists judge by love and consequences.

Mission 2

  • Situation ethics: do the most loving thing (agape). Utilitarianism: the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
  • Natural Law: reason discovers God's moral order; primary precepts: life, reproduction, education, society, worship.

Mission 3

  • Divorce ends a marriage in law; annulment declares it was never valid. Catholics accept annulment, not remarriage after divorce; most other Christians allow remarriage.
  • The key debate: sanctity of vows (Matthew 19:6) vs compassion (Matthew 19:8).
  • Situation ethics and Humanists put compassion and the welfare of those involved first.
  • Islam (talaq, iddah, khul'), Judaism (get, agunah) and, reluctantly, Dharmic traditions allow divorce as a last resort.

Mission 4

  • Equal in God's image (Genesis 1:27); Ephesians 5 read as headship (complementarian) or mutual submission (egalitarian).
  • Catholic: equal dignity, complementarity; CCC 2207; work in the home has dignity.
  • Other faiths: Qur'an 2:228 and 4:34; Proverbs 31; Manusmriti 3.55–60; Sigalovada Sutta.
  • Sikhs: GGS 788, one light in two bodies.

Mission 5

  • Prejudice is an attitude; discrimination an action; sex discrimination is illegal under the Equality Act 2010.
  • Christians: Genesis 1:27, Galatians 3:28; Catholic and Orthodox churches ordain only men; Anglicans and most Protestants ordain women.
  • Other faiths: Qur'an 33:35; Orthodox vs Reform Judaism; Gita 6.29; Buddhist nuns; practice does not always match teaching.
  • Sikhs: GGS 473; women may lead any service.
  • Soma Sutta: womanhood is no barrier to insight.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Marriage and the Family (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?
  2. Mission 2Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?
  3. Mission 3Can a promise made "till death us do part" ever be undone, and who gets to decide?
  4. Mission 4Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?
  5. Mission 5If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel