← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 1 1A Catholic Christianity – Section 4: Matters of Life and Death (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Matters of Life and Death (part 1)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If the universe began with a Big Bang, is there still room for a Creator?
  2. Mission 2If God gave humans "dominion" over the earth, can we use it however we like?
  3. Mission 3If humans evolved from earlier life, can they still be made in the image of God?
  4. Mission 4If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?
  5. Mission 5People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Catholic Christianity: Marriage and the Family (part 2).

Mission 1

Mission 1: If the universe began with a Big Bang, is there still room for a Creator?

Make a guess: If the universe began with a Big Bang, is there still room for a Creator?

Mission 1

Two kinds of question

Two kinds of questionScience asks: how?What happened,and in what orderBy what processesEvidence that canbe testedReligion often asks:why?Is there a purpose?Who, if anyone, isbehind it?Meaning: creationaccountsInterpretationhow a sacred text is readClashone side has to giveway (some people)Fitthe two questions fittogether (manyreligious people)
  • Science asks how: what happened, in what order, by what processes. It answers from evidence that can be tested.
  • Religion often asks why: is there a purpose? Who, if anyone, is behind it?
  • A creation account (creation story) is a sacred text about the beginning of the world and its meaning.
  • Many religious people say the two kinds of question fit together. Others think one side has to give way.
  • The key word is interpretation: how a sacred text is read decides whether it clashes with science.
Mission 1Read the source

Genesis 1

The order of creation in Genesis 1 and Genesis 2Genesis 1 (1:1–2:3)1Day 1light2Day 2sky and waters3Day 3land and plants4Day 4sun, moon, stars5Day 5sea creatures and birds6Day 6land animals, then humans7Day 7restGenesis 2 (from 2:4)manfromdustgardenanimalswoman

"In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth." (Genesis 1:1)

"God saw everything that he had made, and, behold, it was very good." (Genesis 1:31)

  • Genesis 1: God creates by speaking, over six days, then rests on the seventh (Genesis 2:1–3). Humans come last.
  • Genesis 2 (from 2:4): a second account. God forms the man from dust before plants and animals, then the woman.
  • Your spec names Genesis 1–2 (Christianity) and Genesis 1–3 (Judaism).

Q1 In Genesis 1, how does God create?

Show answer

By speaking: "God said… and there was…"

Q2 Which two things in Genesis 1:1 and 1:31 matter most for belief?

Show answer

God is the source of everything; what God made is good.

Mission 1

The Big Bang

The Big Bang: the universe over timeFirst proposed by Georges Lemaître, 1927and 1931about 13.8 billionyears agoHot, dense beginning;expanding and coolingever sinceearly universeFaint radiation leftover: the cosmicmicrowave backgroundover billions ofyearsFirst stars, thengalaxies and planetsabout 4.5 billionyears agoEarth forms
  • Scientists' best account: about 13.8 billion years ago the universe was extremely hot and dense, and it has been expanding and cooling ever since.
  • Evidence: distant galaxies are moving away from us (red shift); the cosmic microwave background, faint radiation left over from the early universe.
  • Stars, then galaxies and planets, formed over billions of years. Earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago.
  • The theory was first proposed by Georges Lemaître (1894–1966), a Belgian Catholic priest and physicist, in 1927 and 1931.
  • Lemaître kept science and faith distinct: the theory describes the physical beginning; it neither proves nor disproves God.
Quick check
?Which statement about Georges Lemaître is correct?
Mission 1Diversity

Christians read Genesis differently

Christians read Genesis differentlyLiteralNon-literal123Young-earth creationismSome Christians (e.g. some evangelicals):Genesis is accurate history; six days;many say the earth is only thousands ofyears old.1Days as stagesThe "days" can be stages or a poeticframework.2Genesis as theologyMost Catholics, Anglicans, Orthodox,many Protestants: true about who andwhy, not a science report.3AllGod is Creator; the universe depends on Godand is good.
  • Literal reading (creationists, e.g. some evangelical Christians): Genesis is accurate history; God made everything in six days; many say the earth is only thousands of years old (young earth). The Big Bang is rejected or reinterpreted.
  • Non-literal reading (most Catholics, Anglicans, Orthodox, many Protestants): Genesis is true about who and why, not a science report. The "days" can be stages or a poetic framework.
  • These Christians see the Big Bang as how God created: science and faith are compatible.
  • Shared belief: God is Creator; the universe depends on God and is good; humans have a special place in it.
  • Catholic and most other Christian teaching: God creates ex nihilo (out of nothing). Science studies how the universe develops; it cannot explain why there is something rather than nothing.
  • Pope Francis (Pontifical Academy of Sciences, 27 October 2014): the Big Bang does not contradict a divine Creator but needs one; God is "not a magician, with a magic wand" (paraphrase and short phrase).
Quick check
?Most young-earth creationists would respond to the Big Bang theory in which way?
Mission 1Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Origins of the universe in six religionsChristianityCreator?GodAccountGenesis 1–2: six days, then restKey sourceGenesis 1:1Big BangMany: how God created. Literalistsreject it.IslamCreator?AllahAccountSix days (many: six periods)Key sourceQur'an 21:30; Surah 67:1–5Big BangMany: Qur'an and sciencecompatible; some reject partsJudaismCreator?GodAccountGenesis 1–2 (Torah)Key sourceGenesis 1–3Big BangReform: accepted. Orthodox: someliteral, many read days as stagesHinduismCreator?Brahman (many Hindus)AccountEndless cycles: creation,preservation, dissolutionKey sourceRig Veda 10.129 (Hymn ofCreation)Big BangMany: a vast, cyclical universe fitsSikhismCreator?Waheguru, Karta PurakhAccountFrom the primal void (sunn), Godcreates by hukamKey sourceGuru Granth Sahib 1037Big BangMany: science shows how hukamworksBuddhismCreator?No creator GodAccountNo single story: world-systemsarise and decay in cyclesKey sourceMajjhima Nikaya 63; Dalai Lama(2005)Big BangDalai Lama: sets it beside abeginningless universe
  • Islam: Allah is the one Creator of everything. The Qur'an speaks of creation in six days (Qur'an 7:54), read by many Muslims as six periods.
  • "Have not those who disbelieve known that the heavens and the earth were of one piece, then We parted them" (Qur'an 21:30, Pickthall). Many Muslims see this as fitting the Big Bang.
  • Surah 67:1–5: Allah created seven heavens "in harmony"; look again, "Canst thou see any rifts?" The order of the universe points to its Creator. Many Muslims hold that the Qur'an and science are compatible; some reject parts of modern science that seem to contradict the Qur'an.
  • Judaism: God created the universe (Genesis 1–2; the Torah is the first part of the Tenakh).
  • Orthodox Jews: Genesis is God's word; some read it literally, many read the days as stages; the Jewish calendar counts years from creation.
  • Reform Jews: Genesis teaches meaning and values; the Big Bang and an ancient universe are accepted.
Mission 1Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Origins of the universe in six religionsChristianityCreator?GodAccountGenesis 1–2: six days, then restKey sourceGenesis 1:1Big BangMany: how God created. Literalistsreject it.IslamCreator?AllahAccountSix days (many: six periods)Key sourceQur'an 21:30; Surah 67:1–5Big BangMany: Qur'an and sciencecompatible; some reject partsJudaismCreator?GodAccountGenesis 1–2 (Torah)Key sourceGenesis 1–3Big BangReform: accepted. Orthodox: someliteral, many read days as stagesHinduismCreator?Brahman (many Hindus)AccountEndless cycles: creation,preservation, dissolutionKey sourceRig Veda 10.129 (Hymn ofCreation)Big BangMany: a vast, cyclical universe fitsSikhismCreator?Waheguru, Karta PurakhAccountFrom the primal void (sunn), Godcreates by hukamKey sourceGuru Granth Sahib 1037Big BangMany: science shows how hukamworksBuddhismCreator?No creator GodAccountNo single story: world-systemsarise and decay in cyclesKey sourceMajjhima Nikaya 63; Dalai Lama(2005)Big BangDalai Lama: sets it beside abeginningless universe
  • Hinduism: the universe goes through endless cycles of creation, preservation and dissolution (for many Hindus, Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva are three aspects of Brahman; Vaishnavas and Shaivas see Vishnu or Shiva as supreme). Many Hindus say a cyclical, vast universe fits modern cosmology.
  • The Hymn of Creation (Rig Veda 10.129): before creation there was neither being nor non-being; the hymn ends by asking who really knows how creation arose, and wonders if even the highest knows (paraphrase).
  • Sikhism: no step-by-step creation story like Genesis; Waheguru (God) created everything by the divine will (hukam). The Mool Mantar (Guru Granth Sahib 1) calls God Karta Purakh, the Creator.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 1037 (Guru Nanak, Raag Maru): before creation there was only the primal void (sunn); from it God formed air, water, earth and sky, and by God's command all things come and go (paraphrase). Many Sikhs say science shows how hukam works.
  • Buddhism: no creator God and no single creation story. World-systems arise, decay and are reborn in cycles, without a known first beginning.
  • The Buddha refused to answer whether the universe is eternal: such questions do not lead to the end of suffering (Cula-Malunkyovada Sutta, Majjhima Nikaya 63: the parable of the poisoned arrow).
  • The Dalai Lama, The Universe in a Single Atom (2005): chapter 4 sets the Big Bang beside the Buddhist idea of a beginningless universe; elsewhere in the book he says that if science disproves a Buddhist claim about the physical world, Buddhists should give that claim up (paraphrase).
Mission 1

Does science count against God?

Does science count against God?Atheists and HumanistsThe universe can be explained without God: aCreator is an unnecessary extra.Religious repliesFirst causeThe Big Bang needs a cause: why is therea universe at all?Fine-tuningThe laws of physics are finely balanced forlife; some see design in this.How, not whyScience explains how, not why: it cannotrule out a Creator.
  • Atheists and Humanists (non-religious people who live by reason and human values) point out that the universe can be explained by science without God.
  • Argument: if physics can describe the universe from its earliest moments, a Creator is an unnecessary extra. Creation stories were early attempts to explain what science now explains.
  • Many add that a literal six-day creation conflicts with the evidence.
  • Religious replies:
    • The Big Bang needs a cause: why is there a universe at all? (the First Cause argument)
    • The laws of physics are finely balanced for life; some see design in this.
    • Science explains how, not why: it cannot rule out a Creator.
Quick check
?Many Buddhists say that the question "How did the universe begin?" is not important to answer. Why?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Science has shown that God did not create the universe."

Evaluate: has science shown that God did not create the universe?"Science has shown that God did not createthe universe."ForThe Big Bang explains the universe'sdevelopment by physical laws.A literal six-day creation conflicts with theevidence.Explanations needing fewer causes areoften preferred: no need for God.AgainstScience explains how, not why there isanything at all.A beginning fits belief in creation(Lemaître; creation ex nihilo).Many scientists are believers.Other viewsBuddhists: the question is unimportant.Many Hindus and Sikhs: the universe'svastness fits their scriptures.Judge it byDo science and religion answer the samequestion? · Does a beginning need a cause? ·Does it depend on how scripture is read?
  • Reasons for: the Big Bang explains the universe's development by physical laws. A literal six-day creation conflicts with the evidence. Explanations that need fewer causes are often preferred (no need for God).
  • Reasons against: science explains how the universe developed, not why there is anything at all. The Big Bang suggests a beginning, which fits belief in creation (Lemaître; creation ex nihilo). Many scientists are believers.
  • Other views: Buddhists see the question as unimportant; many Hindus and Sikhs see the universe's vastness as fitting their scriptures.
  • Judge it by: Do science and religion answer the same question? Does a beginning need a cause? Does it depend on how scripture is read?
Mission 1Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Worked answer: belief, source, developmentBelief 1BeliefChristians believe God created the universeout of nothing (ex nihilo).Source"In the beginning, God created the heavensand the earth" (Genesis 1:1).DevelopmentSo many Christians see the universe asdepending on God, and the Big Bang as theway God's creation began.Belief 2BeliefSome Christians read Genesis literally.DevelopmentThey believe the world was made in six days,so they reject the Big Bang where it conflictswith Genesis.

Question: Explain two religious beliefs about the origins of the universe. Refer to sacred writings or another source of religious belief and teaching.

  • Belief 1: Christians believe God created the universe out of nothing (ex nihilo). Source: "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth" (Genesis 1:1). Development: so many Christians see the universe as depending on God, and the Big Bang as the way God's creation began.
  • Belief 2: Some Christians read Genesis literally. Development: they believe the world was made in six days, so they reject the Big Bang where it conflicts with Genesis.
Mission check

?A science teacher who is a practising Catholic explains the Big Bang in class, then goes to Mass and says the Creed: "maker of heaven and earth". Which belief best explains why she sees no clash?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If God gave humans "dominion" over the earth, can we use it however we like?

Make a guess: If God gave humans "dominion" over the earth, can we use it however we like?

Mission 2

Why the world has value

Why the world has valuethe worldCreated good"Very good" (Genesis 1:31)Awe and wonder"The heavens declare the glory ofGod." (Psalm 19:1)Future generationsValued for its own sake and for thoseto come (non-religious people too)The opposite ideaCommoditySomething to be bought, sold and usedup for profit
  • For many religious people the world has value because God made it and called it "very good" (Genesis 1:31).
  • Awe and wonder: the deep amazement people feel at nature's size, beauty and order. Many believers see God in it.
  • "The heavens declare the glory of God." (Psalm 19:1)
  • The opposite idea: the world as a commodity, something to be bought, sold and used up for profit.
  • Non-religious people may also feel awe and value the world for its own sake and for future generations.
Mission 2Read the source

Dominion and stewardship

Dominion and stewardship: three sourcesGenesis 1:28"God said to them, 'Be fruitful, multiply, fillthe earth, and subdue it. Have dominion overthe fish of the sea, over the birds of the sky,and over every living thing that moves on theearth.'"Genesis 2:15"The LORD God took the man, and put himinto the garden of Eden to cultivate and keepit."Psalm 24:1"The earth is the LORD's, with its fullness;the world, and those who dwell in it."

"God said to them, 'Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it. Have dominion over the fish of the sea, over the birds of the sky, and over every living thing that moves on the earth.'" (Genesis 1:28)

"The LORD God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to cultivate and keep it." (Genesis 2:15)

"The earth is the LORD's, with its fullness; the world, and those who dwell in it." (Psalm 24:1)

Q1 Which verse gives humans the job of looking after the earth?

Show answer

Genesis 2:15: "cultivate and keep it".

Q2 If "the earth is the LORD's", who owns the world?

Show answer

God; humans only look after it.

Mission 2

Dominion or stewardship?

Two readings of dominionDominion asunlimited useSome have readGenesis 1:28 aspermission to usenature without limitLynn White (1967)blamed this readingfor part of theecological crisisDominion asstewardshipMost Christians andJews todayResponsible rule,like a good kingLook after the worldon God's behalf;answer to God for it
  • Dominion: rule or authority over creation (Genesis 1:28).
  • Some have read dominion as permission to use nature without limit. The historian Lynn White (1967) blamed this reading for part of the ecological crisis.
  • Stewardship: humans look after the world on God's behalf and must answer to God for it.
  • Most Christians and Jews today read dominion as stewardship: responsible rule, like a good king who cares for his people.
  • Responsibility: a duty to care for the world for others now and for future generations.
Quick check
?A farmer says: "This land belongs to God. I farm it, but one day I will have to answer for how I treated it." Which idea is she expressing?
Mission 2

Use and abuse of the environment

Use and abuse of the environmentPollutionHarmful substances in air, wateror landGlobal warmingBurning fossil fuels releasesgreenhouse gases, which trapheatNatural resourcesNon-renewableCoal, oil, gas, metals: can run outRenewableSun, wind, water: replacednaturally
  • Pollution: harmful substances in air, water or land (exhaust fumes, plastic waste, chemical run-off, oil spills).
  • Global warming: burning fossil fuels releases greenhouse gases, which trap heat and change the climate.
  • Natural resources: materials from the earth. Non-renewable (coal, oil, gas, metals) can run out; renewable (sun, wind, water) are replaced naturally.
  • Sustainability (sustainable development): meeting today's needs without stopping future generations meeting theirs.
  • Responses: recycling, renewable energy, conservation, campaigning, changing what people buy and eat.
Mission 2

Christian responses

Christian responses: teaching and actionCatechism2415Dominion is not absolute; itmust respect the good ofothers, including futuregenerations.Assisi, 1986Christian Declaration onNature: humans areresponsible to God forcreation; dominion doesnot mean domination.Laudato Si',2015Pope Francis: care for "ourcommon home"; the poorsuffer most fromenvironmental damage.Stewardship in actionrenewableenergyrecyclingconservationcampaigns
  • Stewardship means acting: Christians support recycling, renewable energy, conservation and campaigns for climate justice.
  • Catholic teaching: humans' dominion over creation is not absolute; it must respect the good of others, including future generations (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2415, paraphrase).
  • Pope Francis, Laudato Si' (2015): care for "our common home"; the poor suffer most from environmental damage (paraphrase and short phrase).
  • The Christian Declaration on Nature (Assisi, 1986): humans are responsible to God for creation; dominion does not mean domination (paraphrase).
  • Some Christians still use the world as a resource first: they argue human needs and development come before nature.
Mission 2Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Caring for the environment in five religionsIslamKey ideakhalifah (trustees), mizan(balance), fitraSourceQur'an 2:30; 55:8; 30:30; Sahihal-Bukhari 45:656In practiceMuslims believe they will answerfor how they used the earth(akhirah)JudaismKey ideabal tashchit, tikkun olam, gemiluthasadimSourcePsalm 24:1–3; Deuteronomy20:19; Jewish Declaration onNature (Assisi, 1986)In practiceDo not cut down fruit trees, evenin war; no needless wasteHinduismKey ideaahimsa; Brahman present in allthingsSourceBhagavad Gita 13.27–34; HinduDeclaration on Nature (Assisi,1986)In practiceBishnoi protection of trees; Chipkomovement (1970s)SikhismKey ideaGod present in creation; sewaincludes caring for the earthSourceGuru Granth Sahib 8; 1037In practiceEcoSikh and gurdwaraenvironmental projectsBuddhismKey ideapratitya samutpada(interdependence); First andSecond PreceptsSourceDhammapada 270; BuddhistDeclaration on Nature (Assisi,1986)In practiceAvoid harm and waste (thePrecepts)
  • Islam: humans are khalifah (vicegerents, trustees) on earth: "I will create a vicegerent on earth" (Qur'an 2:30, Yusuf Ali).
  • Allah set the mizan (balance) in creation: "That ye exceed not the measure" (Qur'an 55:8, Pickthall).
  • Fitra: the natural state of creation and of human nature, in harmony with Allah's will (Qur'an 30:30).
  • On the Day of Judgement (akhirah) Muslims believe they will answer for how they used the earth.
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 45:656 is your spec's named hadith on care for living things.
  • Judaism: "The earth is the LORD'S, and the fulness thereof" (Psalm 24:1, JPS 1917).
  • Psalm 24:1–3 and the Jewish Declaration on Nature (Assisi, 1986): the earth belongs to God, and humans are its guardians (paraphrase).
  • Bal tashchit (do not destroy): even in war, do not cut down fruit trees (Deuteronomy 20:19); extended by the rabbis to all needless waste.
  • Tikkun olam (repairing the world) and gemilut hasadim (acts of loving kindness) include care for the environment.
Mission 2Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Caring for the environment in five religionsIslamKey ideakhalifah (trustees), mizan(balance), fitraSourceQur'an 2:30; 55:8; 30:30; Sahihal-Bukhari 45:656In practiceMuslims believe they will answerfor how they used the earth(akhirah)JudaismKey ideabal tashchit, tikkun olam, gemiluthasadimSourcePsalm 24:1–3; Deuteronomy20:19; Jewish Declaration onNature (Assisi, 1986)In practiceDo not cut down fruit trees, evenin war; no needless wasteHinduismKey ideaahimsa; Brahman present in allthingsSourceBhagavad Gita 13.27–34; HinduDeclaration on Nature (Assisi,1986)In practiceBishnoi protection of trees; Chipkomovement (1970s)SikhismKey ideaGod present in creation; sewaincludes caring for the earthSourceGuru Granth Sahib 8; 1037In practiceEcoSikh and gurdwaraenvironmental projectsBuddhismKey ideapratitya samutpada(interdependence); First andSecond PreceptsSourceDhammapada 270; BuddhistDeclaration on Nature (Assisi,1986)In practiceAvoid harm and waste (thePrecepts)
  • Hinduism: Brahman is present in all things; harming nature harms the sacred. Ahimsa (non-violence) extends to the environment.
  • Bhagavad Gita 13.27–34: one who sees the Supreme Lord present equally in all beings truly sees (paraphrase). The Hindu Declaration on Nature (Assisi, 1986) points to this reverence for all life.
  • Examples: the Bishnoi community's protection of trees; the Chipko movement (1970s), villagers hugging trees to stop logging.
  • Sikhism: God is present in creation; air is the Guru, water the father, and earth the great mother (Japji, closing verse, Guru Granth Sahib 8, paraphrase).
  • Guru Granth Sahib 1037 (Guru Nanak): before creation there was only the primal void; from it God formed air, water, earth and sky (paraphrase).
  • Many gurdwaras and Sikh groups (e.g. EcoSikh) run environmental projects; sewa (selfless service) includes caring for the earth.
  • Buddhism: everything is interdependent (pratitya samutpada, dependent arising): harming nature harms all beings.
  • "Because he has pity on all living creatures, therefore is a man called Ariya." (Dhammapada 270, Müller)
  • In Buddhist teaching, the First Precept (do not harm living beings) and the Second Precept (do not take what is not given) apply to nature and its resources.
  • The Buddhist Declaration on Nature (Assisi, 1986): compassion and interdependence call for care of the natural world (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which term is correctly matched with its meaning?
Mission 2

Non-religious views

Why Humanists protect the planetHumanists and many atheistsOne lifeThe only world we have; noafterlifeFuture generationsWell-being of people and animals,now and in futureScientific evidenceAbout climate change and pollutionProtect the planet
  • Humanists and many atheists see no Creator, but argue humans have strong reasons to protect the planet.
  • This is the only world we have, and there is no afterlife; the well-being of people and animals now and in future depends on it.
  • They rely on scientific evidence about climate change and pollution.
  • Some non-religious thinkers give nature value in itself; others value it for its use to humans and other sentient beings.
Quick check
?Why would most Humanists say people have a duty to protect the environment?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Humans have the right to use the earth's resources as they wish."

Evaluate: may humans use the earth's resources as they wish?"Humans have the right to use the earth'sresources as they wish."ForGenesis 1:28 gives dominion.Human needs matter: food, homes, jobs,escaping poverty.Some argue technology will solveshortages.Against"The earth is the LORD's" (Psalm 24:1):humans are stewards, not owners.Humanists: future generations haveinterests too.Pollution and climate change harm thepoorest most (Laudato Si').Other traditions agree: Muslims arekhalifah, not owners; bal tashchit, ahimsaand the Precepts forbid needless harm.Judge it byWhat does "dominion" mean? · Do futuregenerations have rights? · Do animals andnature have value in themselves?
  • Reasons for: Genesis 1:28 gives dominion; human needs (food, homes, jobs, escaping poverty) matter. Some argue technology will solve shortages.
  • Reasons against: "The earth is the LORD's" (Psalm 24:1): humans are stewards, not owners. Humanists: future generations have interests too. Pollution and climate change harm the poorest most (Laudato Si').
  • Other traditions agree: Muslims are khalifah, not owners; bal tashchit, ahimsa and the Precepts forbid needless harm.
  • Judge it by: What does "dominion" mean? Do future generations have rights? Do animals and nature have value in themselves?
Mission 2Worked answer

Different beliefs

Worked answer: two different beliefsBelief 1BeliefMost Christians believe humans are stewards.DevelopmentGod put the man in Eden "to cultivate andkeep it" (Genesis 2:15), so they recycle, saveenergy and support climate campaigns.Belief 2: a different beliefBeliefBuddhists believe all things areinterdependent.DevelopmentHarming nature harms all beings, so theykeep the First and Second Precepts byavoiding harm and waste.

Question: Explain two different religious beliefs about humans' relationship with the natural world.

  • Belief 1: Most Christians believe humans are stewards. Development: God put the man in Eden "to cultivate and keep it" (Genesis 2:15), so they recycle, save energy and support climate campaigns.
  • Belief 2: Buddhists believe all things are interdependent. Development: harming nature harms all beings, so they keep the First and Second Precepts by avoiding harm and waste.
Mission check

?A city council plans to fill in a wetland, home to rare birds, to build a car park that will bring jobs. Which response best reflects stewardship as most Christians understand it?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If humans evolved from earlier life, can they still be made in the image of God?

Make a guess: If humans evolved from earlier life, can they still be made in the image of God?

Mission 3

Evolution in brief

Natural selection1VariationIndividuals in a populationdiffer, e.g. in colour.2EnvironmentSome features suit theenvironment better (here:dark bark).3Survive and reproduceThe best suited survive andreproduce more.4Over generationsThose features spread:"fittest" means best suited,not strongest.over 3.5 billionyears agoLife on Earth beginsabout 300,000years agoModern humans (Homosapiens) appear
  • Evolution: living things change over many generations; new species develop from earlier ones.
  • Natural selection: individuals with features that suit their environment survive and reproduce more, so those features spread.
  • "Survival of the fittest" (Herbert Spencer's phrase, later used by Darwin): "fittest" means best suited, not strongest.
  • Evidence: fossils, shared anatomy, and DNA showing all life is related.
  • Life on Earth began over 3.5 billion years ago. Modern humans (Homo sapiens) appeared about 300,000 years ago, sharing ancestors with other apes.
Mission 3Read the source

Darwin

Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 1859On the Origin of SpeciesCharles Darwin, 1859Closing sentence (first edition)"There is grandeur in this view of life, with itsseveral powers, having been originallybreathed into a few forms or into one; … fromso simple a beginning endless forms mostbeautiful and most wonderful have been, andare being, evolved."Later editions read"breathed by the Creator into a few forms"

Charles Darwin (1809–1882), On the Origin of Species (1859), closing sentence:

> "There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; … from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved."

  • Darwin also wrote The Descent of Man (1871), applying evolution to humans.
  • Later editions read "breathed by the Creator into a few forms". Darwin moved towards agnosticism in later life.

Q1 What does Darwin say all life began from?

Show answer

A few forms, or one.

Q2 Does this sentence attack religion?

Show answer

Not directly: it expresses wonder; but it explains the variety of life without special creation of each species.

Mission 3

Dawkins

The Blind WatchmakerRichard Dawkins, The Blind Watchmaker(1986)Natural selection explains living things thatlook designed, without any designer.
  • Richard Dawkins (born 1941), biologist and atheist: The Selfish Gene (1976), The Blind Watchmaker (1986), The God Delusion (2006).
  • Natural selection explains living things that look designed without any designer: a "blind watchmaker".
  • So, he argues, there is no need for God to explain human origins, and belief in God is very probably mistaken.
  • Humans are not specially created; they are one product of the same process as all life.
Quick check
?Which statement matches Richard Dawkins' view rather than Charles Darwin's?
Mission 3Read the source

Made in God's image

Made in the image of God; dust and breathImage of God (Genesis 1:27)Humans can reason, love, chooseand relate to God.?Genesis 2:7Read the verse above: what doesGod form the first human from?

"God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27)

"The LORD God formed man from the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul." (Genesis 2:7)

  • Imago Dei (image of God): humans can reason, love, choose and relate to God.
  • Humans are made last in Genesis 1 and given responsibility for creation (Genesis 1:26–31).
  • Genesis 1:26–31 is your spec's named source for Jewish responses: God makes humans and declares all creation "very good".

Q1 What two things does Genesis 2:7 say humans are made from?

Show answer

Dust of the ground and God's breath of life.

Q2 Which belief about humans could evolution not explain, for many believers?

Show answer

The God-given soul and the image of God.

Mission 3Diversity

Christian responses

Christian responses to evolutionRejects humanevolutionAcceptsevolution123CreationismSome evangelical and other Christians:God created each kind directly, and Adamand Eve as the first humans.1Theistic evolutionMost Catholics, Anglicans, Orthodox,many Protestants: evolution is how Godcreated life.2Catholic teachingThe body may have evolved; the spiritualsoul is created directly by God.3Christian sourcesPius XII, 1950Humani Generis: the body may have evolved;the soul is created directly by God.Pope Francis, 27 October 2014Evolution is not inconsistent with creation: itneeds beings to be created that can evolve.Diocese of ManchesterSynod motion: science and Christian belief arecompatible.
  • Creationists (some evangelical and other Christians): God created each kind directly and Adam and Eve as the first humans. Human evolution from earlier species is rejected.
  • Theistic evolution (most Catholics, Anglicans, Orthodox and many Protestants): evolution is how God created life; God gives each human a soul.
  • Catholic teaching (Pope Pius XII, Humani Generis, 1950): the body may have evolved; the spiritual soul is created directly by God.
  • Pope Francis (27 October 2014): evolution is not inconsistent with creation, because evolution needs beings to be created that can evolve (paraphrase).
  • Church of England, Diocese of Manchester: a diocesan synod motion (Special Agenda IV) affirmed that science and Christian belief are compatible (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement best sums up Catholic teaching on human evolution?
Mission 3Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Human origins and evolution in five religionsIslamOriginsAllah created Adam from clay andbreathed His Spirit into himSourceQur'an 32:7–9; Surah 21:30–33ResponseMost accept change within species;many reject human descent fromother speciesDiversitySome Muslim scientists accept fullevolution as Allah's methodJudaismOriginsGod made humans in the divineimageSourceGenesis 1:26–31; Jonathan Sacks(2011)ResponseMany Orthodox and most ReformJews accept it as how God createdDiversitySome Orthodox Jews read Genesisliterally and reject itHinduismOriginsThe atman (eternal self) is not aproduct of evolution; the universe isancient and cyclicalSourceRig Veda 10.129ResponseFew Hindus see a conflictDiversitySome link Vishnu's avatars withevolution; some Vaishnava groups(e.g. ISKCON) reject itSikhismOriginsGod is the Creator of all life byhukamSourceGuru Granth Sahib 19ResponseMany accept evolution as part ofhow hukam worksDiversity—BuddhismOriginsNo creator; all beings areinterconnected and changeconstantly (anicca)SourcePoisoned arrow (Majjhima Nikaya63)ResponseMost Buddhists accept evolutionDiversity—
  • Islam: Allah created the first human, Adam, from clay and breathed His Spirit into him (Qur'an 32:7–9).
  • "Who made all things good which He created, and He began the creation of man from clay" (Qur'an 32:7, Pickthall).
  • Surah 21:30–33: Allah made "every living thing of water" and set the sun and moon in orbits (Pickthall). Many Muslims see such verses as fitting science.
  • Most Muslims accept change within species; many reject the idea that humans descended from other species, because Adam was created specially. Some Muslim scientists accept full evolution as Allah's method.
  • Judaism: God made humans in the divine image (Genesis 1:26–31).
  • Some Orthodox Jews read Genesis literally and reject evolution; many Orthodox and most Reform Jews accept it as the way God created.
  • Rabbi Jonathan Sacks (1948–2020), The Great Partnership (2011): science takes things apart to see how they work; religion puts them together to see what they mean (paraphrase).
Mission 3Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Human origins and evolution in five religionsIslamOriginsAllah created Adam from clay andbreathed His Spirit into himSourceQur'an 32:7–9; Surah 21:30–33ResponseMost accept change within species;many reject human descent fromother speciesDiversitySome Muslim scientists accept fullevolution as Allah's methodJudaismOriginsGod made humans in the divineimageSourceGenesis 1:26–31; Jonathan Sacks(2011)ResponseMany Orthodox and most ReformJews accept it as how God createdDiversitySome Orthodox Jews read Genesisliterally and reject itHinduismOriginsThe atman (eternal self) is not aproduct of evolution; the universe isancient and cyclicalSourceRig Veda 10.129ResponseFew Hindus see a conflictDiversitySome link Vishnu's avatars withevolution; some Vaishnava groups(e.g. ISKCON) reject itSikhismOriginsGod is the Creator of all life byhukamSourceGuru Granth Sahib 19ResponseMany accept evolution as part ofhow hukam worksDiversity—BuddhismOriginsNo creator; all beings areinterconnected and changeconstantly (anicca)SourcePoisoned arrow (Majjhima Nikaya63)ResponseMost Buddhists accept evolutionDiversity—
  • Hinduism: few Hindus see a conflict. The universe is ancient and cyclical; the atman (eternal self) is not a product of evolution.
  • Rig Veda 10.129 leaves the origin of the universe, and so of life, open: who really knows? (paraphrase). Some Hindus link the order of Vishnu's avatars (fish, tortoise, boar…) with evolution; some Vaishnava groups, such as ISKCON, reject Darwinian evolution.
  • Sikhism: God is the Creator of all life by hukam (divine will); many Sikhs accept evolution as part of how hukam works.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 19 (Guru Nanak): from the True One came air, from air water, and from water all the worlds; God's light is in every heart (paraphrase).
  • Buddhism: no creator; most Buddhists accept evolution. All beings are interconnected and change constantly (anicca).
  • The poisoned arrow (Cula-Malunkyovada Sutta, Majjhima Nikaya 63): speculating about origins does not lead to the end of suffering.
Quick check
?A student says: "Evolution shows that only the strongest deserve to survive, so the weak have less value." How would most religious believers reply?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Evolution and belief that God created humans cannot both be true."

Evaluate: can evolution and belief that God created humans both be true?"Evolution and belief that God createdhumans cannot both be true."ForA literal Genesis (six days, Adam first)conflicts with evolution.Natural selection explains apparent designwithout God (Dawkins).Suffering and extinction are hard for someto fit with a loving Creator.AgainstTheistic evolution: God creates throughnatural processes.Catholic teaching: the body may evolve;the soul is God's direct creation (Pius XII,John Paul II).Genesis teaches meaning, not biology(many Christians, Reform Jews).Other viewsBuddhists: no conflict, as they hold nocreator.Many Hindus and Sikhs: evolution is partof the divine order.Judge it byMust sacred texts be read literally? · Can aprocess be both natural and God-given? ·Does evolution explain the soul and moralvalue?
  • Reasons for: a literal Genesis (six days, Adam first) conflicts with evolution. Natural selection explains apparent design without God (Dawkins). Evolution involves suffering and extinction, which some find hard to fit with a loving Creator.
  • Reasons against: many believers accept theistic evolution: God creates through natural processes. Catholic teaching: the body may evolve; the soul is God's direct creation (Pius XII, John Paul II). Genesis teaches meaning, not biology (many Christians, Reform Jews).
  • Other views: Buddhists see no conflict because they hold no creator; many Hindus and Sikhs see evolution as part of the divine order.
  • Judge it by: Must sacred texts be read literally? Can a process be both natural and God-given? Does evolution explain the soul and moral value?
Mission 3Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Worked answer: response, source, developmentResponse 1ResponseMany Christians, including Catholics, acceptevolution as God's way of creating.SourcePope Pius XII, Humani Generis (1950): thebody may have evolved, but the spiritual soulis created directly by God.DevelopmentSo Catholics can accept the science whilebelieving each person has a God-given soul.Response 2ResponseSome Christians reject human evolution.Source"God created man in his own image" (Genesis1:27).DevelopmentThey believe humans were created directly, sohumans did not descend from other species.

Question: Explain two religious responses to the theory of evolution.

  • Your paper adds: "In your answer you must refer to a source of wisdom and authority."
  • Response 1: Many Christians, including Catholics, accept evolution as God's way of creating. Source: Pope Pius XII, Humani Generis (1950): the body may have evolved, but the spiritual soul is created directly by God. Development: so Catholics can accept the science while believing each person has a God-given soul.
  • Response 2: Some Christians reject human evolution. Source: "God created man in his own image" (Genesis 1:27). Development: they believe humans were created directly, so humans did not descend from other species.
  • 5-mark (c) tip: two developed points, plus a source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check

?A Catholic doctor studies the human genome and says: "Our DNA tells me how we came to be. My faith tells me who we are." Which belief is she expressing?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?

Make a guess: If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?

Mission 4

Sanctity of life

Sanctity of life and quality of lifeSanctity of lifeGod-givenIntrinsic: not fromhealth, ability, ageor usefulnessFrom beginning tonatural endQuality of lifeFreedom from painIndependenceRelationshipsEnjoying life
  • Sanctity of life: the belief that human life is holy (sacred) and has special value, because it is given by God.
  • So life must be protected and respected from its beginning to its natural end.
  • Many believers add: only God may decide when a life begins and ends. "The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away." (Job 1:21)
  • The value is intrinsic: it does not depend on health, ability, age or usefulness.
  • Non-religious people may also say every human life has great value, but not because it is God-given.
Mission 4Read the source

Made by God

Made by God: three sourcesGenesis 1:27"God created man in his own image."Jeremiah 1:5"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you.Before you were born, I sanctified you."1 Corinthians 6:19"Don't you know that your body is atemple of the Holy Spirit who is in you,whom you have from God? You are notyour own"

"God created man in his own image." (Genesis 1:27)

"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you. Before you were born, I sanctified you." (Jeremiah 1:5)

"Don't you know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you, whom you have from God? You are not your own" (1 Corinthians 6:19)

  • Genesis 1–3: humans made in God's image; God breathes life into the man (Genesis 2:7).

Q1 Which verse says God knows a person before birth?

Show answer

Jeremiah 1:5.

Q2 Why would "you are not your own" matter for decisions about life and death?

Show answer

Life belongs to God, so it is not simply ours to end.

Mission 4

Quality of life

Quality of life: open questions?pain · independence · relationships · enjoymentWho decides?Can it be measured?Can a life with great suffering still be worthliving?Many believers use both ideasLife is sacred, and suffering should berelieved.
  • Quality of life: how good a person's life is: their health, freedom from pain, independence, relationships, ability to enjoy life.
  • Doctors use it when choosing treatments; patients use it when deciding what they want.
  • Arguments based on quality of life say that a life's value can depend on what it is like for the person living it.
  • Questions: who decides? Can a life with great suffering still be worth living? Can quality of life be measured?
  • Many believers use both ideas: life is sacred, and suffering should be relieved (e.g. by good medical care).
Quick check
?Which statement is an argument from quality of life rather than sanctity of life?
Mission 4

Imago Dei and Catherine of Siena

Catherine of Siena: dignity from loveThe Dialogue, c. 1378St Catherine of Siena (1347–1380)Dignity from loveHuman dignity comes from being loved andcreated by God, not from what a person cando.
  • Imago Dei: humans are made in the image of God, with reason, free will, and the capacity to love and know God.
  • St Catherine of Siena (1347–1380), The Dialogue (c. 1378), in the section on discretion: she asks God why he gave humans such dignity, and answers that it was out of his immeasurable love; God saw his creature in himself and fell in love with her (paraphrase).
  • So human dignity comes from being loved and created by God, not from what a person can do.
  • Catholic teaching: every human life is sacred from conception to natural death (Pope John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae, 1995, paraphrase).
Mission 4Diversity

Christian views

Christian views on sanctity of lifeStrong sanctityWeakersanctity12Catholic teaching; many evangelical andfundamentalist ChristiansInnocent human life must never bedeliberately ended, whatever its quality.1Many liberal Protestants, someAnglicansLife is God's gift, but love (agape) andcompassion can mean quality of lifematters in hard cases.2AllThe sick, disabled and dying are equallyvaluable; relieve suffering (hospices, medicalcare).
  • Strong sanctity of life (Catholic teaching; many evangelical and fundamentalist Christians, who read the Bible as literally true in all it teaches): innocent human life must never be deliberately ended, whatever its quality.
  • Weaker sanctity of life (many liberal Protestants, some Anglicans): life is God's gift, but love (agape) and compassion can mean that quality of life matters in hard cases.
  • All agree that the sick, disabled and dying are equally valuable, and that suffering should be relieved (hospices, medical care).
Mission 4Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Why life is special in five religionsIslamWhy specialA gift and trust from Allah, whoalone decides when each life endsKey termsaving one life is like saving allmankindSourceQur'an 3:145; 5:32; Surah 4:29JudaismWhy specialCreated by God in the divineimage; of supreme valueKey termpikuach nefeshSourceGenesis 1:27; Deuteronomy30:19; Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5HinduismWhy specialEvery being has an atman, part ofBrahman; a human birth is a rarechance for mokshaKey termatman; ahimsaSourceBhagavad Gita 2:17; KathaUpanishad 1.3.3SikhismWhy specialGod's light is in every being; life isa chance to become gurmukhKey termjot; gurmukhSourceGuru Granth Sahib 1239BuddhismWhy specialNo creator, but a human rebirth isa rare chance to reachenlightenmentKey termFirst PreceptSourceKhuddakapatha 2; Dhammapada129
  • Islam: life is a gift and a trust from Allah, who alone decides when each life ends (Qur'an 3:145).
  • "whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as if he had killed all mankind, and whoso saveth the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind" (Qur'an 5:32, Pickthall)
  • Surah 4:29: "kill not one another" (Pickthall); many Muslims apply it to suicide too.
  • Judaism: life is created by God in the divine image (Genesis 1:27) and is of supreme value. "Therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19, JPS 1917).
  • Pikuach nefesh: saving a life overrides almost every other commandment, including Shabbat.
  • Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5: whoever destroys one life is as if they destroyed a whole world; whoever saves one life saves a whole world (paraphrase).
  • Orthodox Jews tend to apply sanctity of life strictly; Reform Jews give more weight to quality of life and personal conscience.
Mission 4Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Why life is special in five religionsIslamWhy specialA gift and trust from Allah, whoalone decides when each life endsKey termsaving one life is like saving allmankindSourceQur'an 3:145; 5:32; Surah 4:29JudaismWhy specialCreated by God in the divineimage; of supreme valueKey termpikuach nefeshSourceGenesis 1:27; Deuteronomy30:19; Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5HinduismWhy specialEvery being has an atman, part ofBrahman; a human birth is a rarechance for mokshaKey termatman; ahimsaSourceBhagavad Gita 2:17; KathaUpanishad 1.3.3SikhismWhy specialGod's light is in every being; life isa chance to become gurmukhKey termjot; gurmukhSourceGuru Granth Sahib 1239BuddhismWhy specialNo creator, but a human rebirth isa rare chance to reachenlightenmentKey termFirst PreceptSourceKhuddakapatha 2; Dhammapada129
  • Hinduism: every being has an atman (eternal self), part of Brahman. "Indestructible, Learn thou! the Life is, spreading life through all" (Bhagavad Gita 2:17, Arnold).
  • Katha Upanishad 1.3.3: "Know the Atman (Self) as the lord of the chariot, and the body as the chariot" (Paramananda). The body carries the self, so life is precious.
  • Ahimsa (non-violence) protects all life. A human birth is a rare chance to reach moksha.
  • Sikhism: God's light (jot) is in every being; life is a gift of God's grace and a chance to become gurmukh (God-centred).
  • Guru Granth Sahib 1239 is your spec's named source on the sanctity of life.
  • Buddhism: there is no creator, but life is precious: a human rebirth is a rare chance to reach enlightenment.
  • The First Precept (Khuddakapatha 2): I undertake the training to refrain from taking life (paraphrase).
  • "All men tremble at punishment, all men fear death; remember that you are like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter." (Dhammapada 129, Müller)
Quick check
?Why do most Buddhists value human life highly, even though they do not believe in a creator God?
Mission 4

Non-religious views and Singer

Peter Singer and a replyPeter SingerCapacity to suffermattersSelf-awareness andplanning a futurematterValuing human lifejust because it ishuman = speciesismSanctity-of-lifereplyMade in God'simage (Genesis1:27)Value is intrinsic:not from health orabilityJudging by qualityrisks treating sick,disabled or oldpeople as lessvaluable
  • Humanists: human life is valuable because it is the only life we have; there is no God and no afterlife. Value comes from human experience, relationships and choices.
  • So quality of life and personal autonomy (the right to make decisions about your own life) matter greatly.
  • Peter Singer (born 1946), Practical Ethics (1979), Rethinking Life and Death (1994): the traditional sanctity of life gives value to human life just because it is human. He calls this speciesism.
  • Singer argues that the capacity to suffer, and to be self-aware and plan a future, are what matter morally; so some animals have more of these than some humans (paraphrase).
Quick check
?What is Peter Singer's main criticism of the traditional sanctity of life?
Mission 4Evaluate

"The sanctity of life matters more than the quality of life."

Evaluate: does sanctity of life matter more than quality of life?"The sanctity of life matters more than thequality of life."ForLife is God's gift (Job 1:21; 1 Corinthians6:19).Judging lives by quality risks treatingdisabled, sick or old people as lessvaluable.Quality is hard to measure and canchange.AgainstCompassion (agape; karuna) meanssuffering matters.Humanists stress autonomy: peopleshould judge their own lives.Singer: the sanctity doctrine is speciesistand ignores suffering.Middle positionsMany believers hold both: life is sacred, soit is never ended deliberately, but qualityof life guides care (e.g. refusingburdensome treatment).Judge it byIs value given by God or by experience? · Whodecides? · Can the two ideas be heldtogether?
  • Reasons for: life is God's gift (Job 1:21; 1 Corinthians 6:19). Judging lives by quality risks treating disabled, sick or old people as less valuable. Quality is hard to measure and can change.
  • Reasons against: compassion (agape; karuna, Buddhist compassion) means suffering matters.
  • Humanists stress autonomy: people should judge their own lives. Singer: the sanctity doctrine is speciesist and ignores suffering.
  • Middle positions: many believers hold both: life is sacred, so it is never ended deliberately, but quality of life guides care (e.g. refusing burdensome treatment).
  • Judge it by: Is value given by God or by experience? Who decides? Can the two ideas be held together?
Mission 4Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Worked answer: teaching, source, developmentTeaching 1TeachingLife is created by God.Source"God created man in his own image" (Genesis1:27).DevelopmentSo Christians believe every human has equalworth, whatever their health.Teaching 2TeachingSaving one life is like saving the whole ofhumanity.SourceQur'an 5:32.DevelopmentSo Muslims believe they must protect life, andending it wrongly is a grave sin.

Question: Explain two religious teachings about the sanctity of life.

  • Your paper adds: "In your answer you must refer to a source of wisdom and authority."
  • Teaching 1: Life is created by God. Source: "God created man in his own image" (Genesis 1:27). Development: so Christians believe every human has equal worth, whatever their health.
  • Teaching 2: Saving one life is like saving the whole of humanity. Source: Qur'an 5:32. Development: so Muslims believe they must protect life, and ending it wrongly is a grave sin.
  • 5-mark (c) tip: two developed points, plus a source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check

?A hospital chaplain visits a young man badly injured in a rugby accident. He says: "My life is worth nothing now." Which reply best reflects a sanctity-of-life view?
Mission 5

Mission 5: People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Make a guess: People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Mission 5

Abortion and the law

Abortion and the law in the UK1967Abortion Act (England, Wales,Scotland): legal if two doctorsagree it is needed on setgrounds199024-week limit for mostgrounds; no limit if thewoman's life is at risk, toprevent grave permanentinjury, or for serious fetalabnormality2026England and Wales: a womancannot be prosecuted forending her own pregnancyThe 1967 Act's rules (two doctors, 24 weeks)still govern how abortions are provided.
  • Abortion: the deliberate ending of a pregnancy so that it does not result in the birth of a child. (A miscarriage is the natural loss of a pregnancy.)
  • Abortion Act 1967 (England, Wales, Scotland): legal if two doctors agree it is needed on set grounds, such as risk to the woman's physical or mental health.
  • Since 1990 the limit for most grounds is 24 weeks. No limit if the woman's life is at risk, to prevent grave permanent injury, or for serious fetal abnormality.
  • Since the Crime and Policing Act 2026, a woman in England and Wales cannot be prosecuted for ending her own pregnancy; the 1967 Act's rules (two doctors, 24 weeks) still govern how abortions are provided.
  • Laws differ worldwide: from a total ban (e.g. Malta allows it only to save the woman's life) to abortion on request.
Mission 5

When does a life begin?

When does a life begin? Four points in pregnancy010203040weeks1234Conception (0)Egg and sperm join. Many pro-lifebelievers: a human life with full statusstarts here; the Catholic Church: a personfrom conception.1Ensoulment: 120 days (some Muslimteaching)When the soul enters the body.2Viability (around 24 weeks)The fetus could survive outside thewomb, with medical help.3BirthIn Jewish law, the fetus becomes a fullperson once it is born.4
  • Conception (fertilisation): egg and sperm join to form a genetically unique embryo. Many pro-life believers say a human life with full status starts here.
  • Ensoulment: when the soul enters the body. Some Muslim teaching places this at 120 days; the Catholic Church treats the embryo as a person from conception.
  • Viability: when the fetus could survive outside the womb (around 24 weeks with medical help).
  • Birth: in Jewish law, the fetus becomes a full person once it is born.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes viability?
Mission 5

Pro-life and pro-choice

Pro-life and pro-choicePro-lifeThe unborn childhas a right to lifeGroups: SPUC, LIFESanctity of lifeA human beingfrom conceptionDisabled people'slives are equallyvaluablePro-choiceA woman has theright to decide whathappens to herbodyGroups: BPAS,Abortion Rights,Humanists UKAutonomyQuality of life of thewoman and thechildSafe legal abortionprevents dangerousillegal ones
  • Pro-life: the unborn child has a right to life; abortion is wrong (some allow exceptions, e.g. to save the mother's life). Groups: SPUC (Society for the Protection of Unborn Children), LIFE.
  • Arguments: sanctity of life; the fetus is a human being from conception; disabled people's lives are equally valuable; alternatives exist.
  • Pro-choice: a woman has the right to decide what happens to her body. Groups: BPAS (British Pregnancy Advisory Service), Abortion Rights, Humanists UK.
  • Arguments: autonomy (personal choice); quality of life of the woman and the child; safe legal abortion prevents dangerous illegal ones.
Mission 5Read the source

Before birth

Before birth: Christian sourcesPsalm 139:13"For you formed my inmost being. You knit metogether in my mother's womb."Jeremiah 1:5"Before I formed you in the womb, I knewyou."Luke 1:41"When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, thebaby leapt in her womb"Side note: Exodus 21:22–23, read two waysHurt to a pregnant woman: if "no harmfollows", a fine; serious harm is "life for life".Older translations read a miscarriage (fetusvalued, not equal to the mother); the WEBBEreads "gives birth prematurely" (both livesprotected equally).

"For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother's womb." (Psalm 139:13)

"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you." (Jeremiah 1:5)

"When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, the baby leapt in her womb" (Luke 1:41)

  • Some Christians point to Exodus 21:22–23: if a pregnant woman is hurt and "no harm follows", there is a fine; serious harm is "life for life". Older translations read the verse as a miscarriage, so some argue the fetus is valued but not equal to the mother; the WEBBE reads "gives birth prematurely", which others take to protect both lives equally.

Q1 What do these three passages suggest about the unborn?

Show answer

God knows and forms them before birth; the unborn child responds to Mary's greeting.

Q2 Do they directly mention abortion?

Show answer

No: they are applied to it by interpretation, which is why Christians disagree.

Mission 5Diversity

Christian views

Christian views on abortionNeverLimited casesConscience123Catholic teachingDirect abortion is always gravely wrong.Mother's life at risk: life-saving treatmentallowed even if the child dies (doubleeffect).1Church of EnglandOpposed in principle; accepts strictlylimited cases as the lesser evil (e.g. risk tothe mother's life, serious abnormality).2Some liberal ProtestantsE.g. many Methodists and Quakers:accept abortion more widely, out ofcompassion and respect for conscience.3Situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966)Do the most loving thing (agape) ineach situation; abortion maysometimes be right, e.g. after rape.Catholic response: love neverrequires killing the innocent.
  • Catholic teaching: life begins at conception; direct abortion is always gravely wrong (CCC 2270–2272).
  • Humanae Vitae (Paul VI, 1968) rules out directly intended abortion, even for therapeutic reasons (paraphrase).
  • Mother's life at risk: Catholic teaching allows life-saving treatment (e.g. removing a cancerous womb, or the damaged tube in an ectopic pregnancy) even if the unborn child dies as a foreseen but unintended result: the principle of double effect.
  • Church of England: strongly opposed in principle, but accepts strictly limited cases where abortion may be the lesser evil (e.g. risk to the mother's life, serious abnormality).
  • Some liberal Protestants (e.g. many Methodists and Quakers) accept abortion more widely, out of compassion and respect for conscience.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape) in each situation; abortion may sometimes be right, e.g. after rape. Catholic responses: love never requires killing the innocent.
Quick check
?A pregnant woman is found to have an ectopic pregnancy, which will kill her if untreated. Which statement best describes Catholic teaching?
Mission 5Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Abortion in five religionsIslamPersonbeginsEnsoulment at about 120 daysGenerallyMany scholars: before 120 daysfor serious reasons (some onlybefore 40 days)Life at riskAllowed (all schools)SourceQur'an 17:31; Sahih al-Bukhari55:549JudaismPersonbeginsAt birth (the fetus is valuedbefore)GenerallyOrthodox: mainly to protect themother's life or health; Reform:more left to conscienceLife at riskAllowed: her life comes firstSourceMishnah Sanhedrin 4:5HinduismPersonbeginsTraditionally, the atman is presentfrom conceptionGenerallyTraditionally breaks ahimsa andbrings bad karmaLife at riskMany accept itSourceAtharva Veda 6.113SikhismPersonbeginsAt conception, when God givesthe soulGenerallyMany allow it only in limited casesLife at riskMany allow it (limited cases)SourceGuru Granth Sahib 74BuddhismPersonbeginsRebirth traditionally begins atconceptionGenerallyFirst Precept: do not harm livingbeings; intention (cetana) shapeskarmaLife at riskDalai Lama: exceptions, judgedcase by caseSourceFirst Precept; Dalai Lama (1993)
  • Islam: life is sacred from Allah. "Slay not your children, fearing a fall to poverty" (Qur'an 17:31, Pickthall).
  • A hadith (Sahih al-Bukhari 55:549) teaches that the unborn child develops in stages, and after about 120 days an angel breathes in the soul (ensoulment) (paraphrase).
  • Many scholars allow abortion before 120 days for serious reasons (some only before 40 days); after ensoulment, only to save the mother's life. All schools allow it when the mother's life is at risk.
  • Judaism: the fetus is valued, but it becomes a full person only at birth.
  • Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5: each life is a whole world (paraphrase).
  • Orthodox Jews allow abortion mainly to protect the mother's life or health (some include mental health); Reform Jews leave more to the woman's conscience.
Mission 5Diversity

Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Abortion in five religionsIslamPersonbeginsEnsoulment at about 120 daysGenerallyMany scholars: before 120 daysfor serious reasons (some onlybefore 40 days)Life at riskAllowed (all schools)SourceQur'an 17:31; Sahih al-Bukhari55:549JudaismPersonbeginsAt birth (the fetus is valuedbefore)GenerallyOrthodox: mainly to protect themother's life or health; Reform:more left to conscienceLife at riskAllowed: her life comes firstSourceMishnah Sanhedrin 4:5HinduismPersonbeginsTraditionally, the atman is presentfrom conceptionGenerallyTraditionally breaks ahimsa andbrings bad karmaLife at riskMany accept itSourceAtharva Veda 6.113SikhismPersonbeginsAt conception, when God givesthe soulGenerallyMany allow it only in limited casesLife at riskMany allow it (limited cases)SourceGuru Granth Sahib 74BuddhismPersonbeginsRebirth traditionally begins atconceptionGenerallyFirst Precept: do not harm livingbeings; intention (cetana) shapeskarmaLife at riskDalai Lama: exceptions, judgedcase by caseSourceFirst Precept; Dalai Lama (1993)
  • Hinduism: traditionally the atman is present from conception, so abortion breaks ahimsa and brings bad karma.
  • Atharva Veda 6.113 counts killing an embryo among grave sins (interpretations vary).
  • Many Hindus accept abortion to save the mother's life.
  • Sikhism: life begins at conception, when God gives the soul.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 74 (Guru Nanak, Sri Raag Pehre): the first "watch" of life is in the womb, where the soul is placed by God's command and remembers God (paraphrase).
  • Buddhism: the First Precept: do not harm living beings. Rebirth is traditionally thought to begin at conception; intention (cetana) shapes karma.
  • The Dalai Lama (New York Times interview, 1993): abortion is negative, but there can be exceptions, judged case by case, for example if the child would be severely disabled or the birth would cause serious problems for the parent (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Why do many Muslim scholars treat abortion before 120 days differently from abortion after it?
Mission 5

Non-religious arguments

Non-religious arguments on abortionNon-religious viewsHumanists: autonomyMost support the right to choose; thewoman's autonomy and wellbeing mattermost; an early fetus cannot yet feel or haveinterests. Many accept limits later inpregnancy.Utilitarianism: consequencesWeigh the happiness and suffering ofeveryone affected (woman, child, family);abortion may be right if it leads to lesssuffering.Non-religious pro-lifeThe fetus is a human being, and killing it iswrong whatever one's religion.
  • Humanists: most support the right to choose; the woman's autonomy and wellbeing matter most; an early fetus is not yet a person who can feel or have interests.
  • Many Humanists accept limits later in pregnancy, as the fetus develops.
  • Utilitarianism: weigh the happiness and suffering of everyone affected (woman, child, family); abortion may be right if it leads to less suffering.
  • Some non-religious people are pro-life: they argue the fetus is a human being, and killing it is wrong whatever one's religion.
  • Religious replies: the unborn's value does not depend on what it can do (sanctity of life); utilitarian sums can overlook the weakest.
Mission 5Evaluate

"A woman should always have the right to choose abortion."

Evaluate: should a woman always have the right to choose abortion?"A woman should always have the right tochoose abortion."ForAutonomy over one's own body.Quality of life for the woman and child.Safe legal abortion saves women's lives.Utilitarianism may support it in hard cases.Situation ethics (agape) may also supportit in hard cases.AgainstSanctity of life (Psalm 139:13; Jeremiah1:5).The unborn child cannot speak for itself.Alternatives such as adoption.Disability rights concerns.Other traditions add Qur'an 17:31, ahimsaand the First Precept.Middle positionsMany accept abortion only in some cases(mother's life at risk, rape, early inpregnancy) or before ensoulment.Judge it byWhen does a person begin? · Whose rightscome first? · Does the reason for the abortionmatter?
  • Reasons for: autonomy over one's own body; quality of life for the woman and child; safe legal abortion saves women's lives; utilitarianism may support it in hard cases.
  • Situation ethics (agape) may also support it in hard cases.
  • Reasons against: sanctity of life (Psalm 139:13; Jeremiah 1:5); the unborn child cannot speak for itself; alternatives such as adoption; disability rights concerns.
  • Other traditions add Qur'an 17:31, ahimsa and the First Precept.
  • Middle positions: many accept abortion only in some cases (mother's life at risk, rape, early in pregnancy) or before ensoulment.
  • Judge it by: When does a person begin? Whose rights come first? Does the reason for the abortion matter?
Mission 5Worked answer

Different beliefs

Worked answer: two different beliefsBelief 1BeliefCatholics believe abortion is always wrong.DevelopmentLife begins at conception and is sacred, soending it is killing an innocent human;treatment to save the mother is allowedunder double effect.Belief 2: a different beliefBeliefMost Humanists believe a woman should beable to choose.DevelopmentHer autonomy and quality of life matter most,and an early fetus cannot yet feel or haveinterests.

Question: Explain two different beliefs in contemporary British society about abortion.

  • Belief 1: Catholics believe abortion is always wrong. Development: life begins at conception and is sacred, so ending it is killing an innocent human; treatment to save the mother is allowed under double effect.
  • Belief 2: Most Humanists believe a woman should be able to choose. Development: her autonomy and quality of life matter most, and an early fetus cannot yet feel or have interests.
Mission check

?A Catholic and a member of the Church of England are asked about a 30-year-old woman who will die unless her pregnancy is ended. Both say treatment to save her life is acceptable. Which shared belief best explains this?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Creation accounts (Genesis 1–2, the Qur'an, Hindu scriptures) say the universe has a source and meaning; Buddhists have no creation story, and Sikh scripture describes creation without a step-by-step account.
  • The Big Bang (first proposed by Lemaître, a Catholic priest) is accepted by many believers as how creation happened; literalists reject it where it conflicts with scripture.
  • Atheists and Humanists say science explains the universe without God; believers reply that science answers how, not why.

Mission 2

  • Many believers value the world because God made it; awe and wonder point to its Creator. The commodity view treats it as a resource to use up.
  • Most Christians and Jews read dominion as stewardship; Muslims speak of khalifah; Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists stress ahimsa, God in creation and interdependence.
  • Humanists protect the environment for present and future well-being, using scientific evidence (e.g. Humanist Climate Action).

Mission 3

  • Evolution by natural selection (Darwin, 1859) explains how species, including humans, developed; Dawkins argues it removes the need for God.
  • Creationists reject human evolution; most Christians accept theistic evolution, and Catholic teaching says the soul is created directly by God (Pius XII, 1950; John Paul II, 1996).
  • Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists respond in different ways; for many there is no conflict.

Mission 4

  • Sanctity of life: life is holy and God-given (imago Dei; Job 1:21); quality of life: how good a life is for the person.
  • Every religion values life: Qur'an 5:32 and pikuach nefesh; atman and ahimsa; God's light in all (Sikhism); the First Precept and precious human rebirth (Buddhism).
  • Christians differ: strong sanctity (Catholic and many fundamentalist Christians) or weaker sanctity, where agape lets quality of life count in hard cases.
  • Humanists and Singer stress quality of life, autonomy and suffering; Catholics reply that value never depends on abilities.

Mission 5

  • UK law: Abortion Act 1967, 24 weeks for most grounds, no limit when the woman's life is at risk; since 2026 women in England and Wales cannot be prosecuted for ending their own pregnancy.
  • Catholic teaching: life from conception; direct abortion always wrong; double effect when the mother's life is at risk. The Church of England accepts strictly limited cases.
  • Many Muslims (before 120 days), Jews, Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists also allow it in limited cases.
  • Pro-life (sanctity) vs pro-choice (autonomy, quality of life); Humanists mostly pro-choice; situation ethics and utilitarianism weigh consequences.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Matters of Life and Death (part 1) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If the universe began with a Big Bang, is there still room for a Creator?
  2. Mission 2If God gave humans "dominion" over the earth, can we use it however we like?
  3. Mission 3If humans evolved from earlier life, can they still be made in the image of God?
  4. Mission 4If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?
  5. Mission 5People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel