← A-Level Religious Studies · AQA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2C Hinduism – Good conduct and key moral principles
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: Good conduct and key moral principles

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1A thinker, a worker and a lover of God: can they all reach the same goal by different roads?
  2. Mission 2Millions do yoga in gyms. Is that the same yoga Hindu teachers practised to win liberation?
  3. Mission 3What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?
  4. Mission 4Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
  5. Mission 5Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Hinduism: Sources of authority (part 1); 1 mission in Hinduism: Self, death and afterlife.

Mission 1

Mission 1: A thinker, a worker and a lover of God: can they all reach the same goal by different roads?

Make a guess: A thinker, a worker and a lover of God: can they all reach the same goal by different roads?

Mission 1

What "yoga" means

  • Yoga from Sanskrit yuj: "to yoke", "to join". A discipline that unites the self with the ultimate.
  • Also called a marga (path): a way to moksha, liberation from samsara (the cycle of rebirth).
  • The Bhagavad Gita teaches several yogas side by side; each chapter is titled a yoga.
  • Not mainly postures: the postures belong to hatha yoga (see Mission 2).
  • Key belief shared by all paths: karma and ignorance bind the atman; the right discipline frees it.
Mission 1

Different paths for different people

Paths to mokshamokshaJnanaknowledgereflective mindKarmaactionactive personBhaktidevotionemotional heartRajameditationcontemplativeRaja: Vivekananda's fourth path
  • Hindus believe people differ in temperament, so different paths suit different characters:
  • Jnana yoga: path of knowledge, for the reflective mind.
  • Karma yoga: path of action, for the active person.
  • Bhakti yoga: path of devotion, for the emotional heart.
  • Raja yoga: path of meditation, for the contemplative (see Mission 2).
  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902) popularised this fourfold scheme in his lectures Karma Yoga, Bhakti Yoga, Jnana Yoga and Raja Yoga (1896). The Gita itself mainly names three.
  • AQA asks for suitability and links: most Hindus combine paths.
Mission 1

Karma yoga: selfless action

  • Karma yoga: doing one's dharma (duty) without attachment to results (nishkama karma).
  • Action itself does not bind; desire for its fruits does.
  • Offer every action to God; this purifies the mind (chitta-shuddhi) of selfish desire.
  • Aim: identification with the transcendent, the self no longer acting for itself.
  • AQA calls it selfless effort: good conduct done for its own sake, not to earn good karma.

> "Therefore, thy task prescribed / With spirit unattached gladly perform, / Since in performance of plain duty man / Mounts to his highest bliss." (Bhagavad Gita 3:19, Arnold)

Mission 1Read the source

No one can stop acting

> "No man shall 'scape from act / By shunning action; nay, and none shall come / By mere renouncements unto perfectness. / Nay, and no jot of time, at any time, / Rests any actionless; his nature's law / Compels him, even unwilling, into act" (Bhagavad Gita 3:4–5, Arnold)

  • Krishna answers Arjuna's wish to escape karma by not acting.

Q1 Why is "shunning action" impossible, according to Krishna?

Show answer

Our nature drives us to act all the time; even thinking is a kind of action.

Q2 What, then, is the way to escape karma?

Show answer

Act without attachment: karma yoga, the earlier screen.

Mission 1

Jnana yoga: the path of wisdom

  • Jnana: knowledge, not facts but direct realisation that atman is Brahman.
  • Method: viveka (discrimination between real and unreal), vairagya (renunciation), study of the Upanishads with a guru: hearing, reflecting, meditating.
  • Aim: identification with Brahman; ignorance (avidya) ends, and with it rebirth.
  • Classically linked to Advaita Vedanta and Shankara.
Quick check
?Which person is following karma yoga in the Gita's sense?
Mission 1

Bhakti yoga: the path of devotion

  • Bhakti: loving devotion to a personal God, often Krishna, Rama, Shiva or the Goddess.
  • Open to everyone, whatever caste or learning (Gita 9:32;).
  • Practices: puja, chanting the divine name, singing (kirtan, bhajan), pilgrimage.
  • Liberation is often by God's grace, and may be eternal loving union rather than merging (Ramanuja).

> "Only by fullest service, perfect faith, / And uttermost surrender am I known / And seen, and entered into, Indian Prince!" (Bhagavad Gita 11:54, Arnold)

Mission 1Diversity

How do the paths relate?

ThinkerHighest pathOthers
Shankara (c. 8th century)Jnana alone directly liberatesKarma and bhakti purify the mind and prepare for knowledge
Ramanuja (trad. 1017–1137)Bhakti, with surrender to God's graceKarma and jnana lead into bhakti
Vivekananda (1863–1902)All four are equally validBest combined; choose by temperament
  • The Gita itself praises each in turn: chapter 3 action, chapter 4 knowledge, chapters 9, 11–12 devotion. Each school claims the Gita supports it.
Quick check
?Which statement matches Shankara's view of the paths of yoga?
Mission check

?Ravi, a software engineer, works without chasing bonuses and offers his work to Krishna. In the evenings he sings bhajans at the mandir, and on Sundays he reads the Upanishads with a teacher. A friend says he is "confused, because he mixes three paths". Which reply fits Hindu teaching best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Millions do yoga in gyms. Is that the same yoga Hindu teachers practised to win liberation?

Make a guess: Millions do yoga in gyms. Is that the same yoga Hindu teachers practised to win liberation?

Mission 2

Raja yoga: the path of meditation

  • Raja yoga, the "royal" path: control of the mind through meditation.
  • Main text: the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali (about 195 short sutras; dating debated, many scholars place them around 400 CE).
  • Definition in Yoga Sutra 1.2 (paraphrase): yoga is the stilling of the movements of the mind (chitta vritti nirodha).
  • When the mind is still, the self rests in its own true nature (1.3).
  • The name "raja yoga" for Patanjali's system was popularised by Vivekananda, Raja Yoga (1896).
  • Links: jnana yoga needs meditation to turn knowledge into realisation (see Mission 1).
Mission 2

The eight limbs (ashtanga)

Eight limbs1Yamarestraints2Niyamaobservances3Asanaa steady, comfortable seat4Pranayamabreath control5Pratyaharawithdrawing the senses6Dharanaconcentration7Dhyanameditation8SamadhiabsorptionYoga Sutra 2.29: from outer to innerouterinnerGoal: kaivalyathe self freed from matter

Yoga Sutra 2.29 lists eight limbs, from outer to inner:

  • 1 Yama: restraints (ahimsa, truthfulness, non-stealing, brahmacharya, non-possessiveness).
  • 2 Niyama: observances (purity, contentment, austerity, self-study, surrender to Ishvara).
  • 3 Asana: a steady, comfortable seat (2.46). 4 Pranayama: breath control.
  • 5 Pratyahara: withdrawing the senses. 6 Dharana: concentration. 7 Dhyana: meditation.
  • 8 Samadhi: absorption.
  • Goal: kaivalya, the self freed from entanglement with matter.
  • Ethics first: postures and breath come only after yama and niyama.
Quick check
?In Patanjali's Yoga Sutras, what does asana mean?
Mission 2

Hatha yoga

  • Developed c. 11th–15th centuries, especially among the Nath yogis (traditionally founded by Gorakshanath).
  • Key text: Hatha Yoga Pradipika (Svatmarama, 15th century).
  • Practices: asanas, pranayama, cleansing techniques (shatkarma), locks (bandha) and seals (mudra).
  • Aim: purify the body and its subtle channels, awaken kundalini energy, and realise the body's divine nature; also strength and health.
  • Hatha means "force": a forceful, physical method.
  • The Hatha Yoga Pradipika presents hatha as a stairway to raja yoga (1.1–2, paraphrase).
Mission 2Read the source

Hatha serves raja

Hatha Yoga Pradipika 1.1–2 (paraphrase):

  • The author bows to Shiva, who taught hatha yoga as a stairway for those who wish to climb to raja yoga.
  • He teaches hatha only for the sake of raja yoga.

Q1 How does the text see the relationship between hatha and raja yoga?

Show answer

Hatha is a means; raja yoga, the stilled mind, is the goal.

Q2 What would this text say about postures practised only for fitness?

Show answer

They miss the point: the body is trained to serve meditation and liberation.

Mission 2

How yoga came West

Yoga's journeyIndiac. 400 CE(debated)Yoga Sutras of Patanjali,India15thcenturyHatha Yoga Pradipika(Svatmarama)Chicago1893Vivekananda at the World'sParliament of Religions,Chicago1920Paramahansa Yoganandaarrives in the USAMysoreRishikesh1930s–60sT. Krishnamacharya inMysore develops dynamicposture sequences1936Swami Sivananda founds theDivine Life Society, Rishikesh1959Sivananda centres open inthe West (SwamiVishnudevananda)1966B. K. S. Iyengar, Light onYoga1968the Beatles in Rishikesh2015first International Day ofYoga, 21 June, set by the UNin 2014
  • 1893: Vivekananda speaks at the World's Parliament of Religions, Chicago; Raja Yoga (1896) presents yoga as meditation.
  • 1920: Paramahansa Yogananda arrives in the USA; Autobiography of a Yogi (1946).
  • 1930s–60s: T. Krishnamacharya (1888–1989) in Mysore develops dynamic posture sequences; students B. K. S. Iyengar (Light on Yoga, 1966), K. Pattabhi Jois, Indra Devi.
  • 1936: Swami Sivananda founds the Divine Life Society, Rishikesh; Swami Vishnudevananda opens Sivananda centres in the West from 1959.
  • 1960s–70s: Maharishi Mahesh Yogi; the Beatles in Rishikesh (1968).
  • 2015: first International Day of Yoga (21 June), set by the UN in 2014.
  • Ashrams such as the Sivananda ashram in Kerala.
Mission 2

New purposes

  • Much Western yoga focuses on fitness, flexibility and stress relief, often with no religious aim.
  • Scholar Mark Singleton, Yoga Body (2010), paraphrase: modern posture yoga blends hatha with Indian and Western physical culture (gymnastics, body-building) of the early 20th century.
  • Some Western teachers keep mantra, meditation and ethics; others teach postures alone.
  • Back in India, posture yoga is now also promoted for health and as national heritage.
  • Purpose changes significance: for liberation (moksha), health, or both.
Mission 2Diversity

Who does yoga belong to?

ViewKey claim
"Take back yoga"Yoga's Hindu roots are hidden when it is sold as exercise; the Hindu American Foundation campaign (2010)
Universal giftMany Hindu teachers (e.g. the Sivananda and Vivekananda traditions) welcome all: yoga is a science anyone can practise
Shared heritageJains and Buddhists also have yoga traditions; Patanjali is not "Hindu" in a narrow sense
Some ChristiansSome avoid yoga as a Hindu religious practice; others adopt it as exercise or as Christian meditation
Quick check
?What was the traditional aim of hatha yoga, according to texts such as the Hatha Yoga Pradipika?
Mission check

?A gym in Leicester advertises "Hot Power Yoga: burn calories, no spiritual stuff". A Hindu student says this is "still connected to yoga, but only to one part of it". Which explanation fits the history best?
Mission 3

Mission 3: What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?

Make a guess: What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?

Mission 3

Dharma: what holds things up

Three levels of dharmacosmicsun, seasonssocialfamily, societypersonalmy dutydhr: to hold, uphold, support
  • Dharma comes from the root dhr: to hold, uphold, support.
  • English needs many words for it: duty, righteousness, law, virtue, religion, the right way.
  • It also means a thing's nature: the dharma of fire is to burn; of water, to flow.
  • So dharma is at once cosmic (how the world is ordered), social (how society works) and personal (how I should live).
  • A much-quoted saying: dharma protects those who protect it (Manusmriti 8.15, paraphrase).
Mission 3

Sanatana dharma: the eternal way

Universal and personalsvadharmavarna + ashramasanatana (sadharana) dharmafor everyonenon-violence · truthfulnessnot stealing · puritycontrol of the sensesManusmriti 10.63tension(Arjuna)
  • Sanatana means eternal: without beginning or end.
  • Sanatana dharma has two common uses:
  • 1. A name for the religion. Many Hindus prefer it to "Hinduism" (a name from outside): their way is not founded at a point in time but is eternal truth.
  • 2. Universal dharma. Duties for everyone, whatever their class or stage of life (also called sadharana dharma, common dharma).
  • Manusmriti 10.63 (paraphrase) sums them up: non-violence, truthfulness, not stealing, purity, control of the senses.
  • Your spec: "Sanatana dharma (universal dharma)".
Mission 3

Universal and personal dharma

Universal and personalsvadharmavarna + ashramasanatana (sadharana) dharmafor everyonenon-violence · truthfulnessnot stealing · puritycontrol of the sensesManusmriti 10.63tension(Arjuna)
  • Alongside universal dharma, each person has svadharma: their own dharma.
  • Traditionally this is fixed by varna (class) and ashrama (stage of life): varnashrama dharma.
  • Krishna to Arjuna:

> "this is better, that one do / His own task as he may, even though he fail, / Than take tasks not his own, though they seem good." (Gita 3:35, Arnold)

  • Tension: Arjuna's universal dharma says "do not harm"; his svadharma as a warrior says "fight a just war". The Gita is built on that conflict.
  • Your spec asks for "the relationship between them".
Quick check
?Which is an example of sanatana (universal) dharma rather than varnashrama dharma?
Mission 3Read the source

When dharma declines

  • Adharma: the opposite of dharma: disorder, injustice, unrighteousness. It harms the world, society and the self, and brings bad karma.

> "When Righteousness / Declines, O Bharata! when Wickedness / Is strong, I rise, from age to age, and take / Visible shape, and move a man with men, / Succouring the good, thrusting the evil back, / And setting Virtue on her seat again." (Gita 4:7–8, Arnold)

  • Arnold translates dharma as "Righteousness" and adharma as "Wickedness".
  • Tradition pictures dharma as a bull that loses a leg in each of four ages (yugas); many Hindus believe we live in the last, the Kali Yuga.

Q1 According to the passage, why does Krishna take visible form?

Show answer

To protect the good, destroy evil and re-establish dharma.

Q2 What does "from age to age" suggest about time?

Show answer

Dharma declines and is restored again and again: time is cyclical.

Quick check
?A teacher says: "The dharma of fire is to burn, and of water to flow." What does dharma mean here?
Mission 3Evaluate

Universal or personal dharma first?

Argument mapUniversal (sanatana) dharma matters morethan the dharma of one's own class andstage of life.ForIt binds everyone; non-violence and truthare the "summary" of dharma (Manusmriti10.63).Reformers such as Gandhi appealed touniversal values to attack untouchability.AgainstThe Gita (3:35, 18:47): doing your owndharma, even imperfectly, is better thananother's.Society works only if each role is filled;svadharma gives the universal a concreteshape.Judge it byWhich fits the texts? · Which guides realchoices? · Which fits a modern, plural society?
  • Claim: Universal (sanatana) dharma matters more than the dharma of one's own class and stage of life.
  • For: It binds everyone; non-violence and truth are the "summary" of dharma (Manusmriti 10.63).
  • For: Reformers appealed to universal values such as non-violence and equal dignity to attack untouchability (e.g. Gandhi).
  • Against: The Gita (3:35, 18:47) says doing your own dharma, even imperfectly, is better than another's.
  • Against: Society works only if each role is filled; svadharma gives the universal a concrete shape.
  • Judgement criteria: Which fits the texts? Which guides real choices? Which fits Hinduism in a modern, plural society?
Mission check

?Dr Mehta, a Hindu surgeon, says: "Not harming and telling the truth are duties for everyone. But as a doctor I also have duties others don't: I must cut people open to heal them." Which pair of ideas is she using?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?

Make a guess: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?

Mission 4

What ahimsa asks

  • Ahimsa: non-violence, non-harming (a- "not" + himsa "harm").
  • It covers thought, word and deed: hatred and cruel speech are himsa too.
  • It also covers harm you cause or approve through others.
  • Why: the same atman is in every living being.

> "… sees the Life-Soul resident / In all things living, and all living things / In that Life-Soul contained." (Bhagavad Gita 6:29, Arnold)

  • Karma: harm returns as suffering, in this life or the next.
  • Positive side: compassion and respect for all life.
  • AQA calls ahimsa a virtue: a quality of character, not just a rule.
Mission 4

Ahimsa in Hindu tradition

  • Chandogya Upanishad 3.17.4: non-violence is listed with austerity, generosity, uprightness and truthfulness as the "gifts" of a life lived as sacrifice (paraphrase).
  • Mahabharata (Anushasana Parva): ahimsa is called the highest dharma (ahimsa paramo dharmah).
  • Yoga Sutras 2.30–2.35: ahimsa is the first yama (restraint); where it is firmly established, hostility ceases (paraphrase).
  • Manusmrti 10.63: ahimsa is among the duties common to all four varnas (paraphrase).
  • But Hindu ahimsa is usually weighed against other duties: sacrifice in the Vedic period, the warrior's duty, self-defence. It means minimising harm rather than an absolute vow.
  • By contrast, Jains (an Indian tradition with ahimsa at its heart) take it further: monks and nuns vow ahimsa absolutely, some sweeping their path to protect tiny beings; Jains hold that harm binds karma to the soul.
  • AQA spellings: smrti, Manusmrti.
Quick check
?Which statement best shows how Hindu ahimsa differs from Jain ahimsa?
Mission 4

Animals

Circles of carehumanscows and animalsinsectsplantsthoughtworddeedatman in all living beings
  • Animals have atman and are part of samsara: a human may be reborn as an animal, and an animal as a human.
  • The cow is honoured as a mother (gau mata): she gives milk, and Krishna was a cowherd. Most Hindus do not eat beef; many states in India restrict cow slaughter.
  • Vegetarianism is widespread and seen as sattvic, but varies: many Bengali and coastal Hindus eat fish; some communities eat meat; some Shakta temples still offer animal sacrifice.
  • Many Hindus support gaushalas (cow shelters) and avoid leather, silk or products tested on animals; others accept animal testing for human medicine as a lesser harm.
  • Treatment of animals is named in your spec: give different Hindu views.
Mission 4Read the source

Manusmrti on killing animals

Manusmrti, chapter 5 (paraphrase):

  • 5.38: whoever kills an animal without lawful reason will suffer a violent death in later births, as many times as the animal has hairs.
  • 5.45: one who harms harmless creatures for his own pleasure finds no happiness, living or dead.
  • 5.48–51: meat cannot be got without harming living beings, so avoid it. The one who permits, cuts, kills, buys, sells, cooks, serves or eats the meat all share in the killing.
  • But 5.39–44: killing an animal in Vedic sacrifice is said not to be killing.

Q1 According to 5.51, does a person who only buys meat escape responsibility?

Show answer

No: buyer, cook and eater all count as slayers.

Q2 What tension does 5.39–44 show inside the text?

Show answer

Ahimsa is the ideal, but older ritual violence is allowed as an exception.

Mission 4

Harm you cannot avoid

  • Manusmrti 3.68–69 (paraphrase): every householder has five "slaughter-houses": the hearth, the grinding stone, the broom, the pestle and mortar, the water pot. Small creatures die through them every day.
  • So the householder performs five daily sacrifices (to the gods, the sages, the ancestors, all beings and guests) to make amends.
  • Point: Hindu ahimsa accepts that some harm is unavoidable; the duty is to keep it as small as possible and to act with care and intention not to harm.
  • Contrast: Jain monks organise their whole life to avoid even this harm.
Mission 4

The embryo and the unborn child

  • Many Hindus believe the atman is present from conception, so the embryo is a living being in samsara.
  • Dharma texts class killing an embryo (bhruna-hatya) among the gravest sins.
  • Many Hindus believe abortion creates bad karma for those who take part, and interrupts the karmic journey of the soul being born.
  • Sex-selective abortion of girls is widely condemned by Hindu leaders as himsa; it is illegal in India (PCPNDT Act, 1994).
  • Indian law allows abortion in set circumstances (Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971, amended 2021). Many Hindus accept it where the mother's life is at risk.
Mission 4Diversity

Different Hindu views on the embryo

ViewReasoning
Abortion is always wrongThe atman is present from conception; any abortion is himsa and brings bad karma
Allowed to save the motherAhimsa means the least harm: losing both lives is worse; the mother has duties to her family
Allowed in hard cases (rape, severe disability)Compassion (daya) for the woman; the soul will be reborn; intention matters
Embryo researchSome accept research on spare IVF embryos to heal others (compassion); others reject destroying any embryo
  • Most Hindus agree on the value of life from conception; they differ on whether ahimsa can ever require choosing the lesser harm.
Mission 4Evaluate

Can a person live by ahimsa today?

Can a person live by ahimsa today?Ahimsa, meaning never harming any livingbeing, is a realistic standard in the modernworld.ForMillions of Jains and Hindus live as strictvegetarians; ahimsa shapes diet, work andmedicine.Ahimsa is about intention and minimisingharm, which anyone can practise.AgainstHarm is built into life: farming, transport,medicine. Even the Manusmrti, a Hindulaw text, admits that daily housework killssmall creatures (3.68).Modern supply chains hide harm; theManusmrti says the buyer of meat sharesin the killing (5.51).Judge it byIs ahimsa an absolute rule or an ideal toapproach? · Does intention or outcome mattermore? · Is Jain or Hindu ahimsa the standardbeing tested?
  • Claim: Ahimsa, meaning never harming any living being, is a realistic standard in the modern world.
  • For: Millions of Jains and Hindus live as strict vegetarians; ahimsa shapes diet, work and medicine.
  • For: Ahimsa is about intention and minimising harm, which anyone can practise.
  • Against: Harm is built into life: farming, transport, medicine. Even the Manusmrti, a Hindu law text, admits that daily housework kills small creatures (3.68).
  • Against: Modern supply chains hide harm; the Manusmrti says the buyer of meat shares in the killing (5.51).
  • Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa an absolute rule or an ideal to approach? Does intention or outcome matter more? Is Jain or Hindu ahimsa the standard being tested?
Quick check
?Which reasoning would most Hindus who allow abortion when the mother's life is at risk use?
Mission check

?Meera, a Hindu, is choosing a silk sari for a wedding. Ordinary silk is made by boiling silkworms in their cocoons; "ahimsa silk" lets the moths emerge first. She says: "I'm not the one boiling them, so it isn't my concern." Which reply applies Hindu teaching on ahimsa most accurately?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Make a guess: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Mission 5

Ahimsa meets the warrior's duty

  • In the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna, a kshatriya (warrior), refuses to fight his relatives at Kurukshetra.
  • Krishna answers: a warrior's svadharma (own duty) is to fight a righteous war (dharma yuddha); refusing would be sin.

> "Nought better can betide a martial soul / Than lawful war" (Bhagavad Gita 2:31, Arnold)

  • The atman cannot be killed (2:19–20), so the soldier destroys only bodies.
  • So in traditional Hindu ethics, ahimsa is the general rule, but force to protect dharma can be a duty for those whose role it is.
Mission 5

Dharma yuddha: rules of righteous war

  • Just cause: to defend dharma, protect the weak, resist aggression; not greed.
  • Last resort: in the Mahabharata, Krishna goes as envoy to seek peace before the war.
  • Rules of conduct (Mahabharata; Manusmrti 7.90–93, paraphrase): fight only equals and armed opponents; do not strike those who surrender, flee, sleep or have lost their weapons; no hidden, poisoned or barbed weapons; spare non-combatants.
  • Even in war, the warrior should fight without hatred and without desire for gain.
  • AQA spelling: Manusmrti.
Mission 5Read the source

Two ways to read the battle

> "… if thou shunn'st / This honourable field--a Kshattriya-- / If, knowing thy duty and thy task, thou bidd'st / Duty and task go by--that shall be sin!" (Bhagavad Gita 2:33, Arnold)

  • Literal reading (e.g. Sri Aurobindo, 1872–1950, Essays on the Gita): the Gita really does teach that righteous war can be a duty.
  • Allegorical reading (Gandhi, Anasaktiyoga, 1929): Kurukshetra is the human heart; the battle is between good and evil impulses; the Gita teaches selfless action and so, in the end, non-violence.

Q1 What does Krishna say Arjuna's refusal would be?

Show answer

Sin: a failure in his duty as a kshatriya.

Q2 How can Gandhi accept this verse yet reject war?

Show answer

He reads the "field" and the "battle" as the inner struggle of the soul, not a call to physical fighting.

Quick check
?Why can Krishna urge Arjuna to fight without abandoning ahimsa, on the traditional reading of the Gita?
Mission 5

Weapons of mass destruction

  • The epics describe the brahmastra, a weapon able to destroy the world. In the Mahabharata, sages step between two such weapons and order them withdrawn: some weapons must never be used.
  • WMD break dharma yuddha rules: they cannot spare non-combatants, they poison land and future generations, and they kill without distinction.
  • J. Robert Oppenheimer recalled Gita 11:32 at the first atomic test (1945): "Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds" (his own rendering, recalled in 1965).
  • Gandhi (paraphrase of his 1946 writing): the atom bomb was a devilish use of science and showed the futility of all violence; it will not be destroyed by counter-bombs, only by non-violence.
  • Other views: India tested nuclear weapons (1974, 1998) and holds a no-first-use policy; some Hindus defend this as deterrence to protect dharma and the nation; many others hold that WMD can never fit ahimsa.
Mission 5

Gandhi's ahimsa

Gandhi's influencesInfluencesGujarati VaishnavahomeJain friends andteachers (e.g.Raychandbhai)the Gita, read asallegoryTolstoythe Sermon on theMountGandhi's ahimsaactive love, notpassivitytruth the end,non-violence themeansthe courage of thestrongdiscipline: simpleliving, vegetarianism,fasting
  • Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869–1948).
  • Influences: his Gujarati Vaishnava home, Jain friends and teachers (e.g. Raychandbhai), the Gita, Tolstoy and the Sermon on the Mount.
  • Ahimsa for Gandhi is active love, not passivity: refusing to hate, while resisting injustice.
  • It is the courage of the strong: he wrote (1920, paraphrase) that if the only choice were cowardice or violence, he would choose violence.
  • Linked with truth: he came to say that "Truth is God". Non-violence is the means; truth is the end.
  • Discipline: brahmacharya, simple living, vegetarianism, fasting.
Mission 5

Satyagraha: truth force

Salt March mapArabian SeaGujaratSabarmati Ashram,AhmedabadDandiabout385 kmon footThe Salt March12 March – 6 April 1930At Dandi: made salt in defiance of the Britishsalt tax: civil disobedience
  • Satyagraha: satya (truth) + agraha (holding firmly): "truth force" or "soul force". Name chosen in South Africa, 1906–08.
  • Method: non-violent resistance to unjust laws: non-cooperation, boycott, strikes, marches, civil disobedience, fasting.
  • The satyagrahi accepts suffering (arrest, beatings) rather than inflicts it, aiming to convert the opponent, not to defeat them.
  • Rules: no hatred, no secrecy, no damage to persons, accept the legal penalty.
  • Salt March (12 March – 6 April 1930): about 385 km to Dandi to make salt in defiance of the British salt tax.
Mission 5Diversity

Hindu views on war today

ViewKey ideaExample
PacifismAhimsa rules out all war; resist only non-violentlyGandhi; many modern Hindu peace groups
Dharma yuddhaWar can be a duty if just in cause and conductTraditional reading of the Gita and Manusmrti; Aurobindo
Strength to protectAbsolute non-violence is weakness; a nation must defend itselfV. D. Savarkar (1883–1966) and some Hindu nationalists
  • All three claim the Gita: the debate is about how to read it.
  • For WMD: deterrence vs "never".
Mission 5Evaluate

Is ahimsa a workable standard in the modern world?

Is ahimsa a workable standard?Ahimsa is a relevant and viable standard tolive by today.ForGandhi's non-violent resistance(satyagraha, "truth force") helped winIndian independence (1947) and shapedthe US civil rights movement.Modern weapons make war's harmuncontrollable; non-violence may be theonly rational path.AgainstNon-violence relies on the opponent'sconscience. Gandhi's 1938 advice thatJews in Germany resist non-violently wasstrongly criticised (e.g. by Martin Buber,1939).Independence came with the violence ofPartition; India itself keeps an army andnuclear weapons.Judge it byIs ahimsa a personal virtue or a state policy? ·Does it require results to be valid? · Doesdharma yuddha already make ahimsarealistic?
  • Claim: Ahimsa is a relevant and viable standard to live by today.
  • For: Gandhi's non-violent resistance (satyagraha, "truth force") helped win Indian independence (1947) and shaped the US civil rights movement.
  • For: Modern weapons make war's harm uncontrollable; non-violence may be the only rational path.
  • Against: Non-violence relies on the opponent's conscience. Gandhi's 1938 advice that Jews in Germany resist non-violently was strongly criticised (e.g. by Martin Buber, 1939).
  • Against: Independence came with the violence of Partition; India itself keeps an army and nuclear weapons.
  • Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa a personal virtue or a state policy? Does it require results to be valid? Does dharma yuddha already make ahimsa realistic?
Quick check
?Which action best fits Gandhi's idea of satyagraha?
Quick check
?A Hindu argues that nuclear weapons can never be used in a dharma yuddha. Which reason best supports this?
Mission check

?A modern Hindu soldier serves in a United Nations peacekeeping force and says: "I keep ahimsa: I use force only to protect civilians, never in anger, and I'd prefer talks to fighting." Which tradition of interpretation is he closest to?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Yoga ("joining") is a disciplined path (marga) to moksha; different paths suit different temperaments.
  • Karma yoga: duty without attachment; jnana yoga: knowledge that atman is Brahman; bhakti yoga: loving devotion to a personal God.

Mission 2

  • Raja yoga (Patanjali) stills the mind through eight limbs, built on Samkhya dualism, aiming at kaivalya.
  • Hatha yoga purifies the body as a stairway to raja yoga; modern posture yoga grew from it and from physical culture.

Mission 3

  • Dharma (from dhr, "uphold"): the order that sustains the cosmos, society and the person; the successor to Vedic rta.
  • Sanatana dharma: the eternal way (a name for the religion) and the universal duties of all; svadharma: duties of one's own class and stage of life.

Mission 4

  • Ahimsa is non-harming in thought, word and deed, based on atman in all beings and on karma.
  • Applied to animals (vegetarianism, cow protection) and the embryo (life from conception; views differ on the lesser harm).

Mission 5

  • Traditional Hindu ethics weighs ahimsa against a warrior's duty: dharma yuddha allows just war under strict rules.
  • Gandhi read the Gita as an inner battle and made ahimsa a political force through satyagraha.
  • WMD break the rules of righteous war; some Hindus accept nuclear deterrence, many reject it.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: Good conduct and key moral principles for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1A thinker, a worker and a lover of God: can they all reach the same goal by different roads?
  2. Mission 2Millions do yoga in gyms. Is that the same yoga Hindu teachers practised to win liberation?
  3. Mission 3What holds the world together, and why do Hindus say it is slowly wearing away?
  4. Mission 4Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
  5. Mission 5Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · AQA