← A-Level Religious Studies · AQA · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA A-level Religious Studies (7062) · 2C Hinduism – Self, death and afterlife
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: Self, death and afterlife

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
  2. Mission 2Is your deepest self a tiny part of God, a separate soul, or God itself in disguise?
  3. Mission 3If your thoughts are not your true self, what is left of you?
  4. Mission 4If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?
  5. Mission 5If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?
  6. Mission 6When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?

Make a guess: Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?

Mission 1

Four aims of life

Four aimspurusharthas: "aims of a person"dharmaright living, duty,virtuearthawealth, security,success, powerkamapleasure, love, beautymokshaliberation fromsamsara
  • The purusharthas: "aims of a person", four goals a full human life may pursue.
  • Dharma: right living, duty, virtue.
  • Artha: wealth, security, success, power.
  • Kama: pleasure, love, beauty, enjoyment of the senses.
  • Moksha: liberation from samsara (see Mission 6).
  • All four are legitimate. The question is how they fit together.
  • Your spec: "the four aims of life; and their relative importance".
Mission 1

Artha: wealth and power

  • Earning a living, owning property, supporting a family, building a business, and for rulers, governing well.
  • Without artha, a household cannot give to the poor, support temples or pay for ritual.
  • The Arthashastra (attributed to Kautilya, compiled c. 2nd century BCE–3rd century CE): a manual of statecraft and economics; wealth as the basis of a stable kingdom.
  • Artha is good when gained and used within dharma: honestly, generously, without harm.
Mission 1

Kama: pleasure and love

  • Delight in the senses, music, art, food, friendship, romantic and sexual love within marriage.
  • The Kama Sutra (Vatsyayana, c. 3rd century CE) is a guide to the art of pleasant living, not only to sex.
  • Kama shows that Hindu tradition does not reject pleasure: it is one of life's aims.

> "These am I, free from passion and desire; / Yet am I right desire in all who yearn" (Gita 7:11, Arnold)

  • Krishna is present in desire that is not contrary to dharma (the Sanskrit of 7:11): kama, too, needs dharma's limits.
Mission 1

How the four fit together

River and banksmokshabeyondthe threeartha and kamadharma: the banksdharma: the bankstrivarga = dharma, artha, kama
  • Trivarga: the first three, the "group of three" for life in the world.
  • Dharma frames artha and kama, like the banks of a river: they give the water its course.
  • Moksha goes beyond the three: it is freedom from the whole cycle in which they are pursued.
  • Two directions of life: pravritti (engagement with the world: dharma, artha, kama) and nivritti (withdrawal: moksha).
  • Most Hindus live engaged lives and turn more towards moksha with age.
Mission 1Read the source

Which aim is best?

Manusmriti 2.224 (paraphrase):

  • Some say the chief good is dharma and artha; others, kama and artha; others, dharma alone; others, artha alone.
  • The text's answer: the chief good is the three together (trivarga).

Q1 Which aim is missing from the debate in this verse?

Show answer

Moksha: the passage concerns life in the world.

Q2 What is Manu's own answer?

Show answer

All three in balance, not one alone.

  • Your spec spells the text Manusmrti.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the place of artha in Hindu teaching?
Mission 1

The aims across the stages of life

Aims across ashramaspravritti: engagementBrahmacharyastudentdharmaGrihasthahouseholderartha and kamawithin dharmaVanaprastharetirementvairagya(detachment)Sannyasarenunciationmokshanivritti: withdrawal
  • Brahmacharya (student): learn dharma; self-discipline.
  • Grihastha (householder): pursue artha and kama within dharma; raise a family; support society.
  • Vanaprastha (retirement): loosen ties; growing vairagya (detachment, freedom from craving).
  • Sannyasa (renunciation): give up everything for moksha.
  • Vairagya is the bridge: detachment turns a person from the three worldly aims towards liberation.
Mission 1Evaluate

Is moksha the most important aim?

Argument mapMoksha is the most important of the fouraims.ForIt alone ends samsara; the others aretemporary and bind (even punya).The Upanishads and Vedanta makeliberation the highest goal (paramapurushartha).AgainstDharma is the foundation: without it noaim is pursued rightly, and moksha is notreached.For most Hindus the householder's threeaims fill most of life; Manusmriti 2.224praises the three together.For some bhakti traditions, loving Godmatters more than liberation itself.Judge it byMost important for whom, and at which stageof life? · For the individual, or for society?
  • Claim: Moksha is the most important of the four aims.
  • For: It alone ends samsara; the others are temporary and bind (even punya).
  • For: Upanishads and Vedanta make liberation the highest goal (parama purushartha).
  • Against: Dharma is the foundation: without it, no aim is pursued rightly, and moksha is not reached.
  • Against: For most Hindus the householder's three aims fill most of life; Manusmriti 2.224 praises the three together.
  • Against: For some bhakti traditions, loving God matters more than liberation itself (see Mission 6).
  • Judgement criteria: Most important for whom, and at which stage of life? For the individual, or for society?
  • Your spec asks for "their relative importance".
Mission check

?Anjali, 45, runs a successful firm, gives a share of her profit to a hospital, and loves classical music. She plans to hand the firm to her children at 60 and spend her time on pilgrimage and meditation. How does her life fit the four aims?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Is your deepest self a tiny part of God, a separate soul, or God itself in disguise?

Make a guess: Is your deepest self a tiny part of God, a separate soul, or God itself in disguise?

Mission 2

Atman: the self that is not the body

Robesbodylaid asidenew set: new bodythe self (atman) does not changeGita 2:22
  • Atman: in Hindu belief, the real, eternal self in every living being.
  • Hindus hold that it is not the body, the mind or the personality: these change; the atman does not.
  • The body is like clothing:

> "Nay, but as when one layeth / His worn-out robes away, / And taking new ones, sayeth, / 'These will I wear to-day!' / So putteth by the spirit / Lightly its garb of flesh" (Gita 2:22, Arnold)

> "Never the spirit was born; the spirit shall cease to be never" (Gita 2:20, Arnold)

  • The atman wearing a body and caught in rebirth is called the jiva or jivatman (embodied self).
Mission 2Read the source

The chariot (Katha Upanishad 3)

The chariotchariot= the bodylord of the chariot= atman (Self)driver= intellectreins= mindfive horses= sensesroads= objects of the sensesKatha Upanishad 3:3–4

Yama, the god of death, teaches the boy Nachiketas (Paramananda translation, 1919):

> "Know the Atman (Self) as the lord of the chariot, and the body as the chariot. Know also the intellect to be the driver and mind the reins." (Katha 3:3)

  • Katha 3:4 (paraphrase): the senses are the horses; the objects of the senses are the roads.

> "He who does not possess discrimination, whose mind is uncontrolled and always impure, he does not reach that goal, but falls again into Samsara" (Katha 3:7)

Q1 Who drives the chariot, and for whom?

Show answer

The intellect drives, holding the reins of the mind; the atman is the lord of the chariot, who rides.

Q2 What happens if the horses run wild?

Show answer

The journey fails: the person is reborn in samsara, 3:7.

  • Your spec's set passage: the parable of the chariot, Katha Upanishad 3.
Mission 2

Brahman: the reality behind everything

  • Brahman: ultimate reality, the ground of all that exists.
  • Sat-chit-ananda: being, consciousness, bliss. Not three parts: three ways of naming one reality.
  • Neti neti, "not this, not this" (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad): nothing we can point to is Brahman; every description falls short.
Mission 2

Two selves in one heart?

Two birds, one treejivatmaneats the fruitparamatmanwatches, does noteatMundaka Upanishad 3.1.1
  • Jivatman: the individual self, embodied, acting, reaping the results of its deeds.
  • Paramatman: the supreme self, God, dwelling in every heart as inner controller.

> "There are two who enjoy the fruits of their good deeds in the world, having entered into the cave of the heart ... The knowers of Brahman call them shadow and light." (Katha 3:1, Paramananda)

  • Mundaka Upanishad 3.1.1 (paraphrase): two birds on one tree; one eats the fruit, the other watches without eating.
  • The big question: are the two really one, or really two?
Mission 2Diversity

Three Vedanta answers

Three readings of tat tvam asiSchoolSelf andBrahman"You arethat" meansAdvaita:Shankara, c.788–820 (bytradition)identical"you are that":strict identityVishishtadvaita:Ramanuja,1017–1137 (bytradition)souls arethe body ofBrahmanBrahman isthe inner selfof "you"Dvaita: Madhva,1238–1317eternallydifferentatat tvam asi:"you are notthat"
  • Advaita (non-dual), Shankara (c. 788–820 by tradition): atman is Brahman. The sense of being a separate jiva is due to avidya (ignorance) and maya. Tat tvam asi means strict identity.
  • Vishishtadvaita (qualified non-dual), Ramanuja (trad. 1017–1137): souls are real and distinct, but are the body of Brahman, as a part to its whole. Tat tvam asi: Brahman is the inner self of "you", as a soul is of its body.
  • Dvaita (dual), Madhva (1238–1317): God (Vishnu) and souls are eternally different. Souls depend wholly on God. Madhva reads the text as atat tvam asi, "you are not that".
  • All three are Vedanta: they read the same Upanishads, Gita and Brahma Sutras.
  • "You are that" (tat tvam asi) comes from the Chandogya Upanishad (VI), where a father shows his son salt dissolved in water: unseen, yet in every sip (paraphrase).
Mission 2

Samkhya: spirit and matter

Samkhya dualismPurushapure consciousness ·many separateselvesPrakritimatter: body, senses,mind and intellecttwo different realitiesliberation = kaivalya ("aloneness")the self realises it was never prakriti
The chariot: Samkhya readingThe chariot: Samkhya readingpurusha:the lord of the chariot (pure consciousness)prakriti:chariot, horses, reins and driver (matter)
  • Samkhya, one of the six classical schools (darshanas); classic text: Ishvarakrishna's Samkhya Karika (c. 350–450 CE).
  • Dualism: two kinds of reality. Purusha: pure consciousness, many separate selves. Prakriti: matter, including body, senses, mind and intellect.
  • Classical Samkhya has no Brahman: liberation (kaivalya, "aloneness") is the self's realising it was never prakriti.
  • The chariot read two ways:
  • Samkhya: the passenger is a purusha; chariot, horses, reins and driver are all prakriti.
  • Advaita: the passenger is atman, which is Brahman; the chariot belongs to the world of maya.
  • Your spec pairs Advaita Vedanta (non-dualism) with Samkhya (dualism).
Quick check
?On the Samkhya reading of the Katha chariot, which part stands for purusha?
Quick check
?Which statement would Madhva (Dvaita Vedanta) accept?
Mission 2Evaluate

Is the atman identical with Brahman?

Argument mapAtman is Brahman: the self is God, not aseparate soul.For"You are that" and the Shandilya Vidyaread most naturally as identity.If Brahman is infinite and non-dual,nothing can stand outside it.AgainstExperience: I suffer and do not knoweverything; Brahman does not suffer(Ramanuja).Bhakti needs two: a lover and a beloved(Madhva; much popular practice).Samkhya: many separate conscious selves,no one cosmic self.Judge it byWhich reading fits the most texts? · Whichexplains ignorance and suffering? · Which fitshow Hindus live and worship?
  • Claim: Atman is Brahman: the self is God, not a separate soul.
  • For: "You are that" and "this self ... is Brahman" (Shandilya Vidya) read most naturally as identity.
  • For: If Brahman is infinite and non-dual, nothing can stand outside it, so no second self.
  • Against: Experience: I suffer and do not know everything; Brahman does not suffer. Ramanuja: identity cannot explain this.
  • Against: Bhakti needs two: love and worship require a lover and a beloved (Madhva; much popular practice).
  • Against (Samkhya): many separate conscious selves, no one cosmic self.
  • Judgement criteria: Which reading fits the most texts? Which explains experience of ignorance and suffering? Which supports the way Hindus actually live and worship?
Mission check

?A teacher says: "The space inside a clay pot seems separate from the sky. When the pot breaks, nothing travels anywhere: it was always the same space." Which view of atman and Brahman does this picture express?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If your thoughts are not your true self, what is left of you?

Make a guess: If your thoughts are not your true self, what is left of you?

Mission 3

Samkhya: counting what is real

  • Hindu thought has six classical darshanas ("views": schools of philosophy) that accept the authority of the Vedas.
  • Samkhya ("enumeration", counting) is one of the oldest. It lists the basic principles (tattvas) of reality: 25 in all.
  • Its legendary founder is the sage Kapila. Its classic text is the Samkhya Karika of Ishvarakrishna (c. 4th–5th century CE).
  • Samkhya ideas appear earlier in the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita, often in a form that includes God.
  • Yoga (Patanjali) is its sister school: Samkhya gives the theory, yoga the practice.
Mission 3

Two realities: purusha and prakriti

Two realitiespurusha (many)prakriti (one)consciousness,witness, inactivenature, unconscious,activemistaking: purusha takes the activity ofprakriti for itself ("I am angry", "I am thisbody")
  • Samkhya is dualist: reality has two eternal, separate kinds.
  • Purusha: pure consciousness. It only witnesses; it does not act or change. There are many purushas, one for each living being.
  • Prakriti: nature or matter. It is one, unconscious, always active and changing.
  • Key point: the mind, ego and intellect belong to prakriti, not to purusha. Thinking is a material process; awareness of it is purusha.
  • Suffering begins when purusha mistakes the activity of prakriti for itself: "I am angry", "I am this body".
  • So in Samkhya, the atman is a purusha: one of many, distinct from body and mind and from every other self.
Mission 3

The three gunas

Three strandsprakriti: three strands (gunas) in one ropesattva:light, calmrajas:energy, passiontamas:inertia, darkness
  • Prakriti is made of three gunas ("strands", qualities), mixed in different proportions in everything:
  • Sattva: light, purity, calm, goodness.
  • Rajas: energy, passion, restlessness, desire.
  • Tamas: heaviness, darkness, inertia, dullness.
  • Before creation the gunas are in balance; when the balance is disturbed, the world unfolds.

> "Sattwan, Rajas, and Tamas, so are named / The qualities of Nature, "Soothfastness," / "Passion," and "Ignorance." These three bind down / The changeless Spirit in the changeful flesh." (Bhagavad Gita 14:5, Arnold)

  • Hindus apply the gunas to food, character and actions: e.g. sattvic food is fresh and vegetarian; many aim to increase sattva.
Quick check
?In Samkhya, which of these belongs to purusha rather than to prakriti?
Mission 3Read the source

The chariot, read by Samkhya

Chariot, two readingslord: Atmandriver: intellectreins: mindhorses: senseschariot: bodyroads: sense objectsSamkhya reading: lord = purusha (rides,does not drive); all else = prakritiAdvaita readinglord of the chariot = atman, one with Brahman

Katha Upanishad, Part 3, Paramananda translation (1919):

> "Know the Atman (Self) as the lord of the chariot, and the body as the chariot. Know also the intellect to be the driver and mind the reins." (Katha 3:3)

> "The senses are called the horses; the sense objects are the roads" (Katha 3:4)

  • A Samkhya reading: the lord of the chariot is purusha, who rides but does not drive. Body, intellect, mind and senses are all prakriti.
  • An Advaita reading (see Mission 4): the lord of the chariot is the atman, which is one with Brahman.

Q1 Which parts of the chariot would Samkhya place in prakriti?

Show answer

The chariot, driver, reins, horses and roads: body, intellect, mind, senses and objects.

Q2 Why might Samkhya like the image of a passenger?

Show answer

Purusha is present and aware but does not itself act.

Mission 3

Liberation: kaivalya

  • The goal is kaivalya: "aloneness" or isolation of purusha from prakriti.
  • It comes through viveka: discriminating knowledge that "I am not this body, mind or ego".
  • When purusha is no longer confused with prakriti, the dance of prakriti stops for it. No more rebirth.
  • Liberation is not union with God: each liberated purusha remains itself, separate and pure.
  • Classical Samkhya is non-theistic: it does not need Ishvara (a Lord) to explain the world. Many Hindus who use its ideas do believe in God.
Mission 3Diversity

Atman: Samkhya and Advaita

Samkhya and Advaita comparedSamkhya(dualism)AdvaitaVedanta(non-dualism)What isreal?Two: purushaand prakritiOne: BrahmanHow manyselves?Many purushasOne atman,identical withBrahmanThe worldReal, made ofgunasAppearance(maya) on thelevel of ultimatetruthGodNot needed(classical)SagunaBrahman,Ishvara, on theeveryday levelLiberationKaivalya: selfisolated fromnatureMoksha:realising atmanis BrahmanBoth agreethe self is not body or mind; ignorance binds;knowledge frees
Samkhya (dualism)Advaita Vedanta (non-dualism)
What is real?Two: purusha and prakritiOne: Brahman
How many selves?Many purushasOne atman, identical with Brahman
The worldReal, made of gunasAppearance (maya) on the level of ultimate truth
GodNot needed (classical)Saguna Brahman, Ishvara, on the everyday level
LiberationKaivalya: self isolated from natureMoksha: realising atman is Brahman
  • Both agree: the self is not body or mind; ignorance binds; knowledge frees.
Mission check

?A yoga teacher tells a class: "Yoga unites your mind with your true self." Which response would a classical Samkhya thinker give?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?

Make a guess: If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?

Mission 4

One without a second

BrahmanNirguna Brahmanwithout qualities"neti, neti"not this, not thissat-chit-anandaseen through mayaSagunaBrahman /Ishvaraeveryday levelworld ofmany thingsatman=atman =Brahman
  • Advaita ("non-dual") Vedanta is the school of the philosopher Shankara (c. 8th century CE); it reads the Upanishads as teaching that atman and Brahman are one.
  • For Shankara's Advaita, Brahman alone is ultimately real: "one only, without a second" (Chandogya 6:2:1, paraphrase).
  • Nirguna Brahman: without qualities; beyond thought and words. It can only be described by negation: neti, neti ("not this, not this", Brihadaranyaka 2:3:6).
  • Positively, it is described as sat-chit-ananda: being, consciousness, bliss.
  • Saguna Brahman (with qualities) or Ishvara (the Lord): Brahman as seen from within the world: creator, worshipped as Vishnu, Shiva or the Goddess. Real at the everyday level, not the final truth.
  • Shankara teaches that atman is Brahman: the true self is not a part of Brahman but Brahman, fully.
Mission 4Read the source

"You are that"

  • Chandogya Upanishad 6 (paraphrase): Uddalaka teaches his son Shvetaketu. Salt dissolved in water cannot be seen, yet every sip tastes of it (6:13). The subtle essence pervades everything; "that is the Self, and you are that" (tat tvam asi).
  • Shankara reads "you are that" as identity: the self and Brahman are one, not two.
  • The Gita on the self (Arnold):

> "Never the spirit was born; the spirit shall cease to be never; / Never was time it was not; End and Beginning are dreams!" (Bhagavad Gita 2:20, Arnold)

  • In Katha 3 the atman is the "lord of the chariot"; for Advaita, that lord is Brahman itself, not one self among many.

Q1 What does the salt show about Brahman?

Show answer

It is present everywhere, though not seen.

Q2 How does Shankara read "you are that"?

Show answer

As strict identity of atman and Brahman.

Mission 4

Adhyasa: superimposition

Rope and snakedusklampsuperimposed: snakelight comes: the snake fadesknowledge removes the error;the rope never changed
  • Adhyasa: seeing one thing as another. Shankara opens his Brahma Sutra commentary with it.
  • Rope and snake: at dusk a rope looks like a snake. The snake is superimposed on the rope. You feel real fear; but there was only ever a rope.
  • Shell and silver: mother-of-pearl glints like silver.
  • In the same way we superimpose body, mind and individuality onto the self ("I am tall", "I am sad"), and the qualities of the self onto body and mind.
  • Advaitins call the power by which the one Brahman appears as many maya.
  • Ignorance (avidya) does not make the rope vanish; knowledge removes the snake. So, for Shankara, liberation is by jnana (knowledge).
Quick check
?In Shankara's image of the rope mistaken for a snake, what stands for Brahman?
Mission 4

Three levels of reality

Three levels of realityUltimate (paramarthika)Brahman alonecancelled by the level aboveMundane, empirical (vyavaharika)people, gods, karma, dharma, science,worship: fully real for uscancelled by the level aboveIllusory (pratibhasika)dreams, the snake in the rope: real only whilethe mistake lastsShankara himself mostly contrasts twostandpoints (everyday and ultimate); later
  • Advaitins distinguish three levels:
  • Illusory (pratibhasika): dreams, the snake in the rope. Real only while the mistake lasts.
  • Mundane, empirical (vyavaharika): the everyday world of people, gods, karma, dharma, science and worship. Fully real for us: you must still keep your promises and avoid the bus.
  • Ultimate (paramarthika): Brahman alone.
  • Each level is cancelled only by the one above: waking cancels the dream; knowing Brahman cancels the separateness of the world.
  • Shankara himself mostly contrasts two standpoints (everyday and ultimate); later Advaitins set out three.
Quick check
?A follower of Shankara cares for her elderly parents out of duty. On which level of reality does that duty belong?
Mission check

?A student reads that, for Shankara, the world is maya. She concludes: "So Advaitins think nothing we do here matters." How would a follower of Shankara reply?
Mission 5

Mission 5: If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?

Make a guess: If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?

Mission 5

Karma: action and its results

Seed to fruitactiondeed, word,thoughtimpressionresultthis life or alater onenot fate: new seeds are planted every day
  • Karma means action, and the results that action brings.
  • Every intentional act (in deed, word or thought) leaves an impression that will bear fruit, now or in a later life.
  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad IV.4.5 (paraphrase): as a person acts, so they become; doing good, one becomes good; doing evil, one becomes evil. What a person desires shapes what they do.
  • Karma is not fate: today's choices make tomorrow's karma.
  • Karma is not a judge's sentence: most Hindus see it as a moral law of cause and effect, like a seed growing into a plant.
Mission 5Read the source

Samsara: the cycle of lives

Samsara cyclebirthlifedeathrebirthkarmathe subtle body carries karmagod (deva)humananimalplantheaven (svarga)hell (naraka)both temporarymoksha
  • Samsara: the cycle of birth, death and rebirth, driven by karma and by desire and ignorance.

> "To man's frame / As there come infancy and youth and age, / So come there raisings-up and layings-down / Of other and of other life-abodes, / Which the wise know, and fear not." (Gita 2:13, Arnold)

> "Some Jivas (individual Souls) enter wombs to be embodied; others go into immovable forms, according to their deeds and knowledge." (Katha 5:7, Paramananda)

  • What travels? The atman, with a subtle body (sukshma sharira) that carries the karmic impressions.

Q1 What comparison does Gita 2:13 make?

Show answer

Moving to a new body is like moving from childhood to youth to old age in one body.

Q2 What decides the next birth in Katha 5:7?

Show answer

Deeds and knowledge.

Quick check
?Priya's grandfather says: "Your karma is not your fate." What does he most likely mean?
Mission 5

Three kinds of karma

Three arrowssanchita: accumulatedstored from past livesprarabdha: fruit-bearingalready shot: working out inthis lifekriyamana or agami: karma inthe makingon the bow: still in your hands
  • Sanchita (accumulated): the whole store of karma from past lives, not yet bearing fruit. Arrows in the quiver.
  • Prarabdha (fruit-bearing): the part of that store that has begun to work out in this life: body, family, lifespan. An arrow already shot: it cannot be called back.
  • Kriyamana or agami (karma in the making): karma made now by present acts. The arrow being fitted to the bow: still in your hands.
  • Liberation, on the common Vedanta account: knowledge burns sanchita, stops new kriyamana sticking; prarabdha runs its course until this body dies.
Quick check
?Which kind of karma explains the family and body a person is born with?
Mission 5

Realms and types of rebirth

Samsara cyclebirthlifedeathrebirthkarmathe subtle body carries karmagod (deva)humananimalplantheaven (svarga)hell (naraka)both temporarymoksha
  • Rebirth can be as a god (deva), a human, an animal, or an immovable form such as a plant (Katha 5:7). Tradition speaks of 8,400,000 forms of life.
  • Realms (lokas): heavenly worlds (svarga), the earth, and hell-worlds (naraka). Time in heaven or hell is temporary: when the karma is used up, the soul is born again.
  • Chandogya Upanishad V.10.7 (paraphrase): those of good conduct soon enter a good birth; those of bad conduct a low birth, even as an animal.
  • So neither heaven nor hell is the final goal. The goal is moksha: release from the whole cycle (see Mission 6).
Mission 5

Why a human birth matters

  • Animals and other beings mostly live out their karma; they do not choose with full moral awareness.
  • Humans can reflect, choose and act deliberately: they make new karma and can seek moksha.
  • So a human birth is precious and rare: an opportunity, not a reward to waste.
  • Gods also live out good karma in heaven, and must be reborn when it is spent.
Mission 5

All life is connected

One self, many bodiesscholarcowelephantdogpersonthe wise see the same self in allGita 5:18
  • An atman lives in every being, human or not; only the bodies and karma differ. (For Advaita it is one and the same self in all; for Ramanuja and Madhva each being has its own.)

> "To him who wisely sees, / The Brahman with his scrolls and sanctities, / The cow, the elephant, the unclean dog, / The Outcast gorging dog's meat, are all one." (Gita 5:18, Arnold)

  • Arnold's Victorian wording reflects the prejudice of the verse's setting against those outside the varnas; the verse's point is that the wise see the same self in all, whatever society's ranking.
  • Any being may have been, or become, a human, and the reverse: life is one family.
  • This supports ahimsa (non-violence), vegetarianism for many Hindus, and care for animals and the earth.
  • Your spec: "the interconnectedness of all life".
Mission 5

Good karma still binds

Two chainsbad karma (iron)bindsgood karma (gold)binds toonishkam karmaaction without desire for itsfruit: it does not bind
  • Good deeds bring good results, but a good result is still a result: it ties the soul to more births, even in heaven. A golden chain still binds.
  • Sakam karma: action done with desire for its fruit (reward, praise, heaven). It binds.
  • Nishkam karma: action done without desire for its fruit, as duty or as offering to God. It does not bind.
  • Karma yoga: the path of selfless action; purifies the mind and leads towards liberation.
  • Your spec: good conduct with reference to karma and karma yoga (selfless effort).
Mission 5Read the source

Krishna on action

Krishna teaches Arjuna (Arnold translation, 1885):

> "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them." (Gita 2:47, Arnold)

> "As the kindled flame / Feeds on the fuel till it sinks to ash, / So unto ash, Arjuna! unto nought / The flame of Knowledge wastes works' dross away!" (Gita 4:37, Arnold)

Q1 Does Krishna tell Arjuna to stop acting?

Show answer

No: act, but without craving the result.

Q2 What does knowledge do to karma in 4:37?

Show answer

Burns it up, as fire burns fuel to ash.

Quick check
?A nurse works long shifts in a hospice. She says: "I don't do it for thanks or for a better rebirth; I offer the work to Krishna." What does her attitude show?
Mission 5Evaluate

Is karma fair?

Argument mapKarma is a just way of explaining why livesturn out differently.ForEveryone receives what their own actsproduce: no favourites, no randomness.It gives a reason to act well, and hope: thefuture is not fixed.AgainstNo one remembers past lives: is it just tosuffer for what you cannot recall?It can be misused to blame the poor, thesick or the disabled; many Hindus rejectthat use.If the past shapes my present, how freeam I? Response: prarabdha sets thesituation, not the choice.Judge it byDoes it fit experience? · Does it leave room forfree will? · Does it lead to compassion or toblame?
  • Claim: Karma is a just way of explaining why lives turn out differently.
  • For: Everyone receives what their own acts produce: no favourites, no randomness.
  • For: It gives a reason to act well, and hope: the future is not fixed.
  • Against: No one remembers past lives; can it be just to suffer for what you cannot recall?
  • Against: It can be misused to blame the poor, the sick or the disabled for their condition; many Hindus reject that use.
  • Against: If my present is shaped by the past, how free am I? Response: prarabdha sets the situation, not the choice.
  • Judgement criteria: Does it fit experience? Does it leave room for free will? Does it lead to compassion or to blame?
Mission check

?A Hindu teacher is revered as jivanmukta: liberated while still alive. Yet he falls ill and dies like anyone else. Followers ask why. Which answer fits the teaching on karma?
Mission 6

Mission 6: When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?

Make a guess: When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?

Mission 6

Moksha: release from the cycle

Exit from the wheelsamsarabirth, death, rebirthheaven: still insidekarmadesireignorancemoksha
  • Moksha means release or liberation: freedom from samsara, the cycle of birth, death and rebirth.
  • In Hindu teaching, what binds the self is karma, desire and avidya (ignorance of the true self).
  • Moksha is believed to end all three: no more rebirth, even in heaven.
  • It is the highest of the four aims of life (see Mission 1), and for many Hindus the purpose of life itself.
Mission 6

Free while still alive?

  • Jivanmukti: liberation while still in a body. Many traditions, especially Advaita, hold that the liberated live on until their fruit-bearing karma (prarabdha) runs out (see Mission 5).
  • The jivanmukta acts without selfish desire, is calm in pleasure and pain, and makes no new binding karma.
  • Videhamukti: liberation at death, when the body falls away.
  • Many theistic traditions see full liberation as coming after death, in God's presence.
Mission 6Diversity

What is moksha like?

What is moksha like?TraditionThe self in mokshaAdvaita(Shankara)atman is Brahman: likerivers entering the sea, noseparate selfVishishtadvaita(Ramanuja)the soul keeps its identity,serving God in VaikunthaDvaita (Madhva)eternally distinct anddependent; bliss in God'spresenceGaudiya(Chaitanya)loving service of Krishna(prema), valued even abovemokshaSamkhya andYogakaivalya: the self's"aloneness", freed frommatter
  • Advaita (Shankara): realising that atman is Brahman. Nothing new is gained: ignorance ends. Like rivers entering the sea, losing name and form (Mundaka Upanishad 3.2.8, paraphrase).
  • Vishishtadvaita (Ramanuja): the soul keeps its identity and enjoys God's bliss for ever, serving him in his realm (Vaikuntha).
  • Dvaita (Madhva): the soul is eternally distinct and dependent; liberated souls enjoy bliss in God's presence.
  • Gaudiya Vaishnavism (Chaitanya; ISKCON today): loving service of Krishna (prema) is the highest goal, valued even above moksha.
  • Classical Samkhya and Yoga: kaivalya, the self's "aloneness", freed from matter (see Mission 3).
  • Your spec: "different understandings of the nature of moksha".
Quick check
?Which description of moksha would a follower of Ramanuja's Vishishtadvaita give?
Mission 6

Many paths to one goal

Paths up one mountainmokshajnanaknowledgekarmaactionbhaktidevotionrajameditation
  • Jnana yoga (knowledge): study, reflection and meditation that remove ignorance. Suits the reflective. Central for Advaita.
  • Karma yoga (action): duty done without desire for its fruit (Gita 2:47). Suits the active.
  • Bhakti yoga (devotion): loving worship of a personal God. Suits the emotional; open to all, whatever their birth.
  • Raja yoga (meditation, after Patanjali) is often counted as a fourth path.
  • The Gita weaves the paths together; most Hindus follow more than one (detail in a later lesson).
Quick check
?Ravi spends an hour a day in meditation on the question "Who am I?", seeking to see that he is not the body or the mind. Which path is he following?
Mission check

?A Bengali devotional song says: "I want to taste sugar, not to become sugar." What view of the final goal does it express?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Four purusharthas: dharma, artha, kama, moksha; dharma frames artha and kama; moksha goes beyond all three.
  • Relative importance is debated: Manusmriti 2.224 praises the three together; Vedanta makes moksha the highest aim.

Mission 2

  • In Hindu belief, atman is the eternal self; the jivatman is that self embodied and reborn (Gita 2:22; the Katha chariot shows the self as lord, the intellect as driver).
  • Tat tvam asi (Chandogya VI) is read as identity (Shankara), part and whole (Ramanuja) or difference (Madhva).
  • Advaita: atman is Brahman. Samkhya: many purushas, separate from prakriti, with no Brahman.

Mission 3

  • Samkhya is dualist: many purushas (pure consciousness) and one prakriti (nature, made of sattva, rajas and tamas); mind and intellect belong to prakriti.
  • Liberation (kaivalya) comes through knowing the self is not prakriti; classical Samkhya needs no God, but Patanjali adds Ishvara and the eight limbs of yoga.
  • Samkhya and Advaita agree that the self is not body or mind; they disagree on whether there are many selves or one Brahman.

Mission 4

  • Vedanta interprets the Upanishads, Brahma Sutras and Gita; Shankara's Advaita holds that Brahman alone is real and atman is Brahman.
  • The world appears through maya and avidya, by adhyasa (superimposition, like a rope seen as a snake); there are illusory, mundane and ultimate levels of reality.

Mission 5

  • Karma: action and its fitting results, a law within the universal order; samsara: rebirth driven by karma, desire and ignorance (Gita 2:13; Katha 5:7).
  • Three kinds: accumulated (sanchita), fruit-bearing (prarabdha), karma in the making (kriyamana/agami).
  • Human birth is the chance to act freely and seek moksha; selfless action (nishkam karma, karma yoga) does not bind (Gita 2:47).

Mission 6

  • Moksha: release from samsara by ending karma, desire and ignorance; jivanmukti is liberation while alive.
  • Advaita: realising identity with Brahman; theistic traditions: eternal loving relationship with God.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: Self, death and afterlife for AQA A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Is it wrong for a Hindu to want money and pleasure, or are they part of a good life?
  2. Mission 2Is your deepest self a tiny part of God, a separate soul, or God itself in disguise?
  3. Mission 3If your thoughts are not your true self, what is left of you?
  4. Mission 4If only one reality exists, why do we see a world full of separate things?
  5. Mission 5If you can't remember your past lives, how can you be paying for what you did in them?
  6. Mission 6When the cycle of rebirth finally ends, do you merge into the divine or stay yourself for ever?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · AQA