AQA A-level English Literature (7712/7717) · Wuthering Heights
Mini-Lesson
Wuthering Heights
7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Why do a stranger and a servant tell this great love story?
Mission 2Heathcliff opens Catherine's coffin. Why do readers still pity him?
Mission 3Catherine says “I am Heathcliff.” So why marry Edgar?
Mission 4The story ends with a reading lesson. Is that a happy ending?
Mission 5A ghost at the window, an opened grave: is this a Gothic novel?
Mission 6Heathcliff never kills anyone. So how does he take two houses?
Mission 7Same novel, three critics, three different books. Who's right?
The specification points and sources are listed under the lesson: see Sources.
Mission 1
Why do a stranger and a servant tell this great love story?
Make a guess: Why do a stranger and a servant tell this great love story?
Wuthering Heights · structure, narrators and timeScreen 1
Stories inside stories
Published in 1847 as by Ellis Bell: Charlotte later explained the sisters feared "authoresses are liable to be looked on with prejudice" (1850).
Frame narrative: Lockwood, the new tenant of Thrushcross Grange, keeps a diary dated 1801 and 1802.
Inside it, the housekeeper Nelly Dean tells him the history, from Chapter IV.
Inside Nelly's story sit more voices: Catherine's diary (Ch. III), Isabella's letter (Ch. XIII), Zillah's report (Ch. XXX).
Catherine and Heathcliff never narrate: we only hear them through others, an embedded narrative.
Wuthering Heights · structure, narrators and timeScreen 2
How your exam asks this
AQA Lit A Paper 1, Section C (open book, clean copy): one essay linking Wuthering Heights with your poetry text on an aspect of love, 25 marks. All five AOs count; AO4 (connections) and AO5 (interpretations) are each 12%. At AS, Paper 2 Section B compares it with a second prose text (25 marks).
Essay practice is for class. These seven missions build the knowledge every answer needs.
ExtractWuthering Heights · structure, narrators and timeScreen 3
Lockwood's first entry
1801—I have just returned from a visit to my landlord—the solitary neighbour that I shall be troubled with. This is certainly a beautiful country! In all England, I do not believe that I could have fixed on a situation so completely removed from the stir of society. A perfect misanthropist’s Heaven—and Mr. Heathcliff and I are such a suitable pair to divide the desolation between us. A capital fellow! He little imagined how my heart warmed towards him when I beheld his black eyes withdraw so suspiciously under their brows, as I rode up, and when his fingers sheltered themselves, with a jealous resolution, still further in his waistcoat, as I announced my name.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter I, opening paragraph
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the phrase where Lockwood's verdict on Heathcliff is most clearly contradicted by his own description. (Use the extract on screen 3.)
Tap a word in the extract.
— — . ! , . — . . ! , , , , , .
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter I, opening paragraph
Wuthering Heights · structure, narrators and timeScreen 5
Starting near the end
The novel opens in 1801, near the end of the story: Heathcliff is already Lockwood's landlord and master of the Heights.
Nelly then goes back about thirty years, to the night Mr Earnshaw brings a child home from Liverpool (Ch. IV). C. P. Sanger (1926) dated this to 1771.
"Thus ended Mrs. Dean’s story" (Ch. XXX): her tale has caught up with the present. Chapter XXXII jumps to 1802.
Effect: we see the damage first, so suspense is about how and why, not what.
Wuthering Heights · structure, narrators and timeScreen 6
Two narrators, two kinds of bias
Lockwood is an outsider who misreads: he mistakes a heap of dead rabbits for cats and guesses wrongly whose wife the young Mrs Heathcliff is (Ch. II).
Nelly is an insider and an actor. She admits she and Hindley "plagued and went on with" the child Heathcliff "shamefully" (Ch. IV), hides things and takes sides.
Some critics, notably James Hafley (1958), have even cast Nelly as the novel's villain; others find her mostly trustworthy, if limited.
Method → effectScreen 7
?Catherine has just said it would degrade her to marry Heathcliff, and Nelly has seen him slip out. What is Brontë doing here? (Chapter IX)
“Joseph is here,” I answered, catching opportunely the roll of his cartwheels up the road; “and Heathcliff will come in with him.”
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Rank themScreen 8
?Rank these answers to: how does Brontë's narrative structure shape our response to Heathcliff? (1 = strongest)
Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.
Mission checkScreen 9
?Why do a stranger and a servant tell this great love story?
Brontë filters the lovers through an outsider who misreads and an insider who takes part. Because the story starts near its end and comes to us second- or third-hand, we have to weigh each witness, so judging Catherine and Heathcliff becomes the reader's job.
Mission 2
Heathcliff opens Catherine's coffin. Why do readers still pity him?
Make a guess: Heathcliff opens Catherine's coffin. Why do readers still pity him?
Wuthering Heights · HeathcliffScreen 1
A child named by others
Mr Earnshaw finds him in "the streets of Liverpool": "a dirty, ragged, black-haired child" (Ch. IV).
One name, a dead son's, "both for Christian and surname": no family, no inheritance.
Others name him: "gipsy brat" (Mrs Earnshaw); "a little Lascar, or an American or Spanish castaway" (Mr Linton, Ch. VI). A Lascar: an Indian or South-East Asian sailor.
His birth and parents (Ch. IV), and later the fortune he returns with (Ch. X), are never explained.
Wuthering Heights · HeathcliffScreen 2
Race, Liverpool and empire
In 1771, when Sanger dates his arrival, Liverpool was Britain's leading slave-trading port; Britain abolished the trade in 1807.
The slurs mark him as racially other. Name them as the characters' prejudice, not the narrator's facts.
Maja-Lisa von Sneidern (1995) reads him through Liverpool's slave trade. Terry Eagleton (Heathcliff and the Great Hunger, 1995) reads him as Irish, linking him to the Famine of Brontë's 1840s, while admitting the dates don't fit.
Wuthering Heights · HeathcliffScreen 3
Made by cruelty, then making it
Hindley "deprived him of the instructions of the curate" and set him to farm labour (Ch. VI): degradation.
He overhears "It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now" (Ch. IX), leaves, and returns rich (Ch. X).
His revenge uses the system's tools: debts, marriage, a forced marriage for his son.
On Hareton: "we’ll see if one tree won’t grow as crooked as another" (Ch. XVII).
ExtractWuthering Heights · HeathcliffScreen 4
The night Catherine dies
“May she wake in torment!” he cried, with frightful vehemence, stamping his foot, and groaning in a sudden paroxysm of ungovernable passion. “Why, she’s a liar to the end! Where is she? Not there—not in heaven—not perished—where? Oh! you said you cared nothing for my sufferings! And I pray one prayer—I repeat it till my tongue stiffens—Catherine Earnshaw, may you not rest as long as I am living; you said I killed you—haunt me, then! The murdered do haunt their murderers, I believe. I know that ghosts have wandered on earth. Be with me always—take any form—drive me mad! only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! Oh, God! it is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!”
He dashed his head against the knotted trunk; and, lifting up his eyes, howled, not like a man, but like a savage beast being goaded to death with knives and spears.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XVI. Nelly has just told Heathcliff, waiting in the Grange garden, that Catherine is dead.
Tap the evidenceScreen 5
?Tap the words where Heathcliff turns his grief into a demand. (Use the extract on screen 4.)
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XVI. Nelly has just told Heathcliff, waiting in the Grange garden, that Catherine is dead.
Method → effectScreen 6
?How does Nelly's narration shape our view of Heathcliff here? (Use the extract on screen 4.)
Show the extract (screen 4)
“May she wake in torment!” he cried, with frightful vehemence, stamping his foot, and groaning in a sudden paroxysm of ungovernable passion. “Why, she’s a liar to the end! Where is she? Not there—not in heaven—not perished—where? Oh! you said you cared nothing for my sufferings! And I pray one prayer—I repeat it till my tongue stiffens—Catherine Earnshaw, may you not rest as long as I am living; you said I killed you—haunt me, then! The murdered do haunt their murderers, I believe. I know that ghosts have wandered on earth. Be with me always—take any form—drive me mad! only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you! Oh, God! it is unutterable! I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!”
He dashed his head against the knotted trunk; and, lifting up his eyes, howled, not like a man, but like a savage beast being goaded to death with knives and spears.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XVI. Nelly has just told Heathcliff, waiting in the Grange garden, that Catherine is dead.
howled, not like a man, but like a savage beast being goaded to death with knives and spears.
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Wuthering Heights · HeathcliffScreen 7
Readings across time
1850: Charlotte Brontë's preface: "Whether it is right or advisable to create beings like Heathcliff, I do not know: I scarcely think it is." He "stands unredeemed".
Arnold Kettle (1951): a rebel with cause, who turns his oppressors' weapons (money, arranged marriage) on them.
Terry Eagleton (Myths of Power, 1975): he ends as a pitiless capitalist landlord.
He finally loses "the faculty of enjoying their destruction" (Ch. XXXIII).
AO5: weigh these views; don't just list them.
Pick the strongestScreen 8
?Which sentence answers best: ‘Heathcliff is more sinned against than sinning.’ Discuss.
Mission checkScreen 9
?Heathcliff opens Catherine's coffin. Why do readers still pity him?
We pity Heathcliff because Brontë shows us the nameless child, the slurs and the degradation before we see the revenge, and gives his grief a terrible intensity. But she never excuses his cruelty, which repeats what was done to him. Strong answers argue both and explain how the narrative builds the tension between them.
Mission 3
Catherine says “I am Heathcliff.” So why marry Edgar?
Make a guess: Catherine says “I am Heathcliff.” So why marry Edgar?
Wuthering Heights · CatherineScreen 1
Two houses, two selves
On the ledge Lockwood finds "Catherine Earnshaw", varied to "Catherine Heathcliff" and "Catherine Linton" (Ch. III): three possible selves.
Bitten by the Lintons' dog, she stays five weeks at the Grange (Ch. VI–VII).
She returns "a very dignified person" in a riding habit, afraid the dogs will spoil her "splendid garments" (Ch. VII).
Gilbert and Gubar (1979) read this, in Miltonic terms, as a fall: her education into ladyhood.
ExtractWuthering Heights · CatherineScreen 2
The confession
I’ve no more business to marry Edgar Linton than I have to be in heaven; and if the wicked man in there had not brought Heathcliff so low, I shouldn’t have thought of it. It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now; so he shall never know how I love him: and that, not because he’s handsome, Nelly, but because he’s more myself than I am. Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same; and Linton’s is as different as a moonbeam from lightning, or frost from fire.
…
My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods: time will change it, I’m well aware, as winter changes the trees. My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath: a source of little visible delight, but necessary. Nelly, I am Heathcliff!
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter IX. Catherine has accepted Edgar's proposal and talks to Nelly in the kitchen; Heathcliff, unseen, hears the first part.
Tap the evidenceScreen 3
?Tap the word that shows Catherine's choice is about social rank. (Use the extract on screen 2.)
Tap a word in the extract.
; , . ; : , , , . , ; , .
…
: , , . : , . , !
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter IX. Catherine has accepted Edgar's proposal and talks to Nelly in the kitchen; Heathcliff, unseen, hears the first part.
Method → effectScreen 4
?How does Brontë present Catherine's two loves? (Use the extract on screen 2.)
Show the extract (screen 2)
I’ve no more business to marry Edgar Linton than I have to be in heaven; and if the wicked man in there had not brought Heathcliff so low, I shouldn’t have thought of it. It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now; so he shall never know how I love him: and that, not because he’s handsome, Nelly, but because he’s more myself than I am. Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same; and Linton’s is as different as a moonbeam from lightning, or frost from fire.
…
My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods: time will change it, I’m well aware, as winter changes the trees. My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath: a source of little visible delight, but necessary. Nelly, I am Heathcliff!
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter IX. Catherine has accepted Edgar's proposal and talks to Nelly in the kitchen; Heathcliff, unseen, hears the first part.
My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods: time will change it, I’m well aware, as winter changes the trees. My love for Heathcliff resembles the eternal rocks beneath: a source of little visible delight, but necessary.
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Wuthering Heights · CatherineScreen 5
Marriage and a woman's property
Under coverture, a married woman's property passed to her husband; the Married Women's Property Acts came only in 1870 and 1882.
Catherine plans to "aid Heathcliff to rise" with Edgar's wealth. Nelly's reply: "With your husband’s money, Miss Catherine?" (Ch. IX). The money would never be hers.
So her plan to have both lives rests on a legal illusion.
Wuthering Heights · CatherineScreen 6
Enclosed
After Heathcliff's return and Edgar's ultimatum she fasts and falls into delirium (Ch. XII): "I wish I were a girl again, half savage and hardy, and free".
She begs Nelly to "Open the window": the window links back to the ghost in Chapter III.
Dying, she calls her body "this shattered prison" (Ch. XV).
Readings differ: a revolt against the lady's role (Gilbert and Gubar), or self-will, as Nelly suspects.
Rank themScreen 7
?Rank these answers to: ‘Catherine is destroyed by her own choices rather than by her society.’ (1 = strongest)
Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.
Write itScreen 8
?Write 3–4 sentences: how does Brontë present Catherine's divided self in Chapter IX? Use one quotation and one point of context.
How does Brontë present Catherine's divided self in Chapter IX?
Model answer
Brontë gives Catherine two incompatible truths in one speech: Heathcliff is "more myself than I am", yet it "would degrade" her to marry him. The contrasting similes set Edgar's changeable "foliage" against the "eternal rocks" of Heathcliff, so the self she marries is the surface one. Because a wife's property passed to her husband, her hope of helping Heathcliff with Edgar's money is an illusion: the division can't be resolved within marriage.
Check your own answer
Mission checkScreen 9
?Catherine says “I am Heathcliff.” So why marry Edgar?
Catherine marries Edgar because marrying Heathcliff "would degrade" her, and she believes she can keep Heathcliff as part of herself while living as Mrs Linton. Class, and a law that made a wife's money her husband's, make that double life impossible, and Brontë shows the split destroying her.
Mission 4
The story ends with a reading lesson. Is that a happy ending?
Make a guess: The story ends with a reading lesson. Is that a happy ending?
Wuthering Heights · the second generationScreen 1
Names that come round again
Cathy (Catherine Linton): daughter of Catherine and Edgar. Linton Heathcliff: son of Heathcliff and Isabella. Hareton Earnshaw: son of Hindley and Frances.
The ledge read "Catherine Earnshaw … Heathcliff … Linton" (Ch. III). Cathy's life runs backwards: born a Linton, married a Heathcliff, to marry an Earnshaw.
Hareton bears the name carved over the door with "1500" (Ch. I): the old family line.
Wuthering Heights · the second generationScreen 2
Heathcliff's experiment
He degrades Hareton as Hindley degraded him: "we’ll see if one tree won’t grow as crooked as another" (Ch. XVII).
He knows what he is spoiling: "one is gold put to the use of paving-stones" (Hareton), the other, his sickly son Linton, "tin polished to ape a service of silver" (Ch. XXI).
He traps Cathy at the Heights and forces her marriage to the dying Linton (planned in Ch. XXVII; reported as done in Ch. XXVIII), to take the Grange.
ExtractWuthering Heights · the second generationScreen 3
Lockwood at the window
“Con-trary!” said a voice as sweet as a silver bell. “That for the third time, you dunce! I’m not going to tell you again. Recollect, or I’ll pull your hair!”
“Contrary, then,” answered another, in deep but softened tones. “And now, kiss me, for minding so well.”
“No, read it over first correctly, without a single mistake.”
The male speaker began to read: he was a young man, respectably dressed and seated at a table, having a book before him. His handsome features glowed with pleasure, and his eyes kept impatiently wandering from the page to a small white hand over his shoulder, which recalled him by a smart slap on the cheek, whenever its owner detected such signs of inattention.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XXXII. Lockwood, back in September 1802, approaches the Heights and watches Cathy and Hareton through the open lattice.
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the phrase that shows who holds authority in this lesson. (Use the extract on screen 3.)
Tap a word in the extract.
“-!” . “ , ! . , !”
“, ,” , . “ , , .”
“, , .”
: , , . , , , .
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XXXII. Lockwood, back in September 1802, approaches the Heights and watches Cathy and Hareton through the open lattice.
Wuthering Heights · the second generationScreen 5
What the ending changes
Echo: again an outsider watches a young pair through a window, as Catherine and Heathcliff once watched the Linton children (Ch. VI). This time the window is open and the scene is tender.
Difference: books once burned or flung (Ch. XXXI) now mend the bond. The couple will marry "on New Year’s Day" and move to the Grange (Ch. XXXIV).
Lyn Pykett (1989) sees Cathy and Hareton forming a modern nuclear family, with feminine values replacing the old patriarchal Heights.
Method → effectScreen 6
?How does Brontë present the new relationship here? (Chapter XXXIII, at breakfast, under Heathcliff's eye.)
she had sidled to him, and was sticking primroses in his plate of porridge.
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Pick the strongestScreen 7
?Which sentence best answers: does the second generation offer a happy ending?
Mission checkScreen 8
?The story ends with a reading lesson. Is that a happy ending?
Partly. The second generation replays the first with differences: Cathy teaches Hareton to read, the window is open, and love is playful rather than destructive. But the price is a move to the calm of the Grange and a Heights shut up: some readers find the ending healing, others find the first lovers' wildness left out of it.
Mission 5
A ghost at the window, an opened grave: is this a Gothic novel?
Make a guess: A ghost at the window, an opened grave: is this a Gothic novel?
Wuthering Heights · the moors and the GothicScreen 1
The Gothic toolkit
Gothic fiction, from Walpole's The Castle of Otranto (1764), uses isolated old buildings, barriers, dreams, ghosts, transgression and terror.
Brontë uses it: the panelled bed, the ghost-child, the opened coffin (Ch. XXIX), Nelly's "Is he a ghoul or a vampire?" (Ch. XXXIV).
But she relocates it: no castle, but a Yorkshire farm with "the house" as its living room and "1500" carved over the door (Ch. I).
ExtractWuthering Heights · the moors and the GothicScreen 2
The dream at the window
“I must stop it, nevertheless!” I muttered, knocking my knuckles through the glass, and stretching an arm out to seize the importunate branch; instead of which, my fingers closed on the fingers of a little, ice-cold hand!
The intense horror of nightmare came over me: I tried to draw back my arm, but the hand clung to it, and a most melancholy voice sobbed,
“Let me in—let me in!”
…
Terror made me cruel; and, finding it useless to attempt shaking the creature off, I pulled its wrist on to the broken pane, and rubbed it to and fro till the blood ran down and soaked the bedclothes
…
“It is twenty years,” mourned the voice: “twenty years. I’ve been a waif for twenty years!”
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter III. Lockwood, snowed in at the Heights, sleeps in Catherine's old panelled bed and dreams.
Tap the evidenceScreen 3
?Tap the words that show the "civilised" narrator turning violent. (Use the extract on screen 2.)
Tap a word in the extract.
“ , !” , , ; , , !
: , , ,
“ — !”
…
; , , ,
…
“ ,” : “ . !”
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter III. Lockwood, snowed in at the Heights, sleeps in Catherine's old panelled bed and dreams.
Wuthering Heights · the moors and the GothicScreen 4
Haworth and the moors
Patrick Brontë's family moved to Haworth parsonage, on the edge of the West Riding moors, in 1820.
Charlotte (1850): "It is rustic all through. It is moorish, and wild, and knotty as a root of heath."
She insists Emily's "native hills were far more to her than a spectacle".
The moors are freedom (Ch. VI, XII) and danger: Lockwood is lost in snow, Cathy strays (Ch. II, XVIII).
Wuthering Heights · the moors and the GothicScreen 5
Storm and calm
Lord David Cecil (Early Victorian Novelists, 1934): the Heights stands for storm, the Grange for calm.
For Cecil these are not good against evil but two forces of one natural order; their children's union restores harmony.
Test it: the Grange has its own violence (Skulker's bite, Ch. VI); the moor ends in peace (Ch. XXXIV).
Link: Keats's ‘La Belle Dame sans Merci’ also sets love in a haunted landscape.
ExtractWuthering Heights · the moors and the GothicScreen 6
The last paragraphs
“There’s Heathcliff and a woman yonder, under t’ nab,” he blubbered, “un’ I darnut pass ’em.”
…
I lingered round them, under that benign sky: watched the moths fluttering among the heath and harebells, listened to the soft wind breathing through the grass, and wondered how any one could ever imagine unquiet slumbers for the sleepers in that quiet earth.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XXXIV. Nelly reports a shepherd boy's words; the last paragraph is Lockwood's, at the three graves.
Method → effectScreen 7
?How does Brontë end the novel? (Use the extract on screen 6.)
Show the extract (screen 6)
“There’s Heathcliff and a woman yonder, under t’ nab,” he blubbered, “un’ I darnut pass ’em.”
…
I lingered round them, under that benign sky: watched the moths fluttering among the heath and harebells, listened to the soft wind breathing through the grass, and wondered how any one could ever imagine unquiet slumbers for the sleepers in that quiet earth.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XXXIV. Nelly reports a shepherd boy's words; the last paragraph is Lockwood's, at the three graves.
wondered how any one could ever imagine unquiet slumbers for the sleepers in that quiet earth.
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Rank themScreen 8
?Rank these answers to: ‘Wuthering Heights is a Gothic novel.’ (1 = strongest)
Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.
Mission checkScreen 9
?A ghost at the window, an opened grave: is this a Gothic novel?
Yes, with a difference. Brontë uses Gothic conventions (the ghost at the window, the opened grave, Nelly's "ghoul or a vampire"), but sets them in a dated farmhouse on real moors, and makes cruelty and fear as frightening as any ghost. The ending keeps both readings alive.
Mission 6
Heathcliff never kills anyone. So how does he take two houses?
Make a guess: Heathcliff never kills anyone. So how does he take two houses?
Wuthering Heights · class, property and inheritanceScreen 1
Two houses, two classes
Wuthering Heights: an old farming family, "Hareton Earnshaw" and "1500" over the door (Ch. I). The family eats and works in one room, "the house".
Thrushcross Grange: gentry. Mr Linton is a magistrate with a "rent-day" (Ch. VI); the drawing-room is "carpeted with crimson".
Heathcliff, with no surname or land, starts below both.
Wuthering Heights · class, property and inheritanceScreen 2
Land, heirs and wives
An entail or family settlement ties land to a line of heirs, often male. Edgar fears his property, "in default of heirs male", may pass to Heathcliff's power through Isabella (Ch. X).
Old Mr Linton's will secured the Grange to his daughter's line, not his son's daughter (Ch. XVI): Cathy is passed over.
Under coverture, a wife's property passed to her husband.
C. P. Sanger (1926) found the novel's property law consistent, and judged Nelly right to doubt Heathcliff's title to the Grange lands.
ExtractWuthering Heights · class, property and inheritanceScreen 3
Two transfers
The guest was now the master of Wuthering Heights: he held firm possession, and proved to the attorney—who, in his turn, proved it to Mr. Linton—that Earnshaw had mortgaged every yard of land he owned for cash to supply his mania for gaming; and he, Heathcliff, was the mortgagee.
…
He had bequeathed the whole of his, and what had been her, moveable property, to his father: the poor creature was threatened, or coaxed, into that act during her week’s absence, when his uncle died. The lands, being a minor, he could not meddle with. However, Mr. Heathcliff has claimed and kept them in his wife’s right and his also: I suppose legally; at any rate, Catherine, destitute of cash and friends, cannot disturb his possession.
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XVII (after Hindley's death) and Chapter XXX (Linton's will, reported by Zillah through Nelly).
Tap the evidenceScreen 4
?Tap the word that names Heathcliff's legal hold over the Heights. (Use the extract on screen 3.)
Tap a word in the extract.
: , —, , . — ; , , .
…
, , , : , , , . , , . , . : ; , , , .
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XVII (after Hindley's death) and Chapter XXX (Linton's will, reported by Zillah through Nelly).
Wuthering Heights · class, property and inheritanceScreen 5
Four steps to two houses
1. Debt: Hindley mortgages "every yard of land" to him (Ch. XVII).
2. Marriage: through Isabella, his son Linton becomes heir to the Grange.
3. Forced marriage: Cathy is held at the Heights and married to the dying Linton (Ch. XXVII). Edgar's plan to protect her through trustees fails: his lawyer "had sold himself to Mr. Heathcliff" (Ch. XXVIII).
4. A will: Linton leaves "what had been her" property to Heathcliff (Ch. XXX).
Wuthering Heights · class, property and inheritanceScreen 6
Readings of the property plot
Arnold Kettle (1951): Heathcliff defeats the property-owners with their own tools, money and arranged marriage.
Terry Eagleton (Myths of Power, 1975): capitalist property-dealing overruns the old yeoman economy.
Q. D. Leavis: the novel records an older rural culture overturned by social change around 1801.
At the end Joseph gives thanks that "the lawful master and the ancient stock were restored to their rights" (Ch. XXXIV).
Method → effectScreen 7
?Heathcliff compares Hareton with his own son Linton. (Chapter XXI)
one is gold put to the use of paving-stones, and the other is tin polished to ape a service of silver.
Step 1 Which method matters most?
Step 2 What is the effect?
Pick the strongestScreen 8
?Which sentence uses context best to explain Cathy's position in Chapter XXX?
Mission checkScreen 9
?Heathcliff never kills anyone. So how does he take two houses?
Heathcliff takes the Heights as mortgagee of Hindley's gambling debts, and the Grange through marriage: Isabella's son inherits it, Cathy is forced to marry him, his will hands over "what had been her" property, and Heathcliff claims the lands "in his wife's right and his also". Brontë makes the law of land, heirs and wives the instrument of revenge.
Mission 7
Same novel, three critics, three different books. Who's right?
Make a guess: Same novel, three critics, three different books. Who's right?
Wuthering Heights · critical readingsScreen 1
The first readers, 1847–1850
Reviewers granted the novel power but found it coarse, savage or "a purposeless power" (Douglas Jerrold's Weekly Newspaper, 1848).
Many assumed the Bells were one writer. In 1850 Charlotte revealed her sisters and explained the pseudonyms.
Her Editor's Preface defended "a native and nursling of the moors" who, "Having formed these beings, she did not know what she had done."
Sanger's 1926 study of its exact chronology challenged that idea of an unconscious genius.
Wuthering Heights · critical readingsScreen 2
The Marxist lens: who owns, who works?
Asks how class, property and labour shape the story.
Arnold Kettle (1951): Heathcliff's rebellion uses his enemies' own tools, money and arranged marriage.
Terry Eagleton (Myths of Power, 1975): Catherine's choice of Edgar for status betrays her deepest self for social gain; Heathcliff's capitalist property-dealing overruns the old yeoman economy.
Limit: it can shrink the lovers' passion and the ghosts into economics.
Wuthering Heights · critical readingsScreen 3
The feminist lens: what can a woman do?
Asks how the novel presents women's power, bodies, property and voices.
Gilbert and Gubar (The Madwoman in the Attic, 1979) read it as a rewriting of Milton's Paradise Lost, with Catherine's fall into ladyhood at the Grange.
Lyn Pykett (1989): the ending makes the Heights a home of feminine values.
Evidence: Isabella's letter (Ch. XIII); coverture in Linton's will (Ch. XXX).
Wuthering Heights · critical readingsScreen 4
The psychoanalytic lens: what is hidden?
Asks about desire, repression, doubles and the unconscious (after Freud).
Catherine's "he’s more myself than I am" invites reading Heathcliff as her other self.
Thomas Moser (1962) read windows, doors, keys and pokers as sexual symbols.
Some critics note the lovers' strangely sexless bond and link it to an unconscious fear of incest: they were raised as brother and sister.
Limit: it can treat characters as patients, not constructs.
Sort itScreen 5
?Which lens is each claim using?
Tap a statement, then tap the group it belongs in. Then press Check.
The second question I have great interest in; it is this—Is Mr. Heathcliff a man? If so, is he mad? And if not, is he a devil? I sha’n’t tell my reasons for making this inquiry; but I beseech you to explain, if you can, what I have married: that is, when you call to see me; and you must call, Ellen, very soon.
…
tell him, also, to set his fraternal and magisterial heart at ease: that I keep strictly within the limits of the law. I have avoided, up to this period, giving her the slightest right to claim a separation
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XIII (Isabella's letter) and Chapter XIV (Heathcliff to Nelly, about Isabella). Before 1857 a full divorce needed a private Act of Parliament, granted only for adultery; a wife could seek one only if adultery came with life-threatening cruelty. The "separation" Heathcliff mentions was a legal separation from the church courts, which did not allow remarriage.
Rank themScreen 7
?Rank these uses of criticism in answer to: how does Brontë present marriage as a form of power? (1 = strongest)
Tap the strongest answer first, then the next one. Tap a numbered answer again to undo.
Write itScreen 8
?Apply one lens to the extract on screen 6 in 3–4 sentences, and give one limit of that lens.
Show the extract (screen 6)
The second question I have great interest in; it is this—Is Mr. Heathcliff a man? If so, is he mad? And if not, is he a devil? I sha’n’t tell my reasons for making this inquiry; but I beseech you to explain, if you can, what I have married: that is, when you call to see me; and you must call, Ellen, very soon.
…
tell him, also, to set his fraternal and magisterial heart at ease: that I keep strictly within the limits of the law. I have avoided, up to this period, giving her the slightest right to claim a separation
Source: Wuthering Heights, Chapter XIII (Isabella's letter) and Chapter XIV (Heathcliff to Nelly, about Isabella). Before 1857 a full divorce needed a private Act of Parliament, granted only for adultery; a wife could seek one only if adultery came with life-threatening cruelty. The "separation" Heathcliff mentions was a legal separation from the church courts, which did not allow remarriage.
Choose a Marxist, feminist or psychoanalytic lens. How does it help you read the extract on screen 6, and what does it leave out?
Model answer
A feminist reading sees Isabella's question "what I have married" as a wife discovering that marriage has handed her body and fortune to a stranger, while Heathcliff boasts that he keeps "strictly within the limits of the law". The law, not just the man, is on trial. But this lens says less about Isabella's own earlier infatuation, or about the Gothic "devil" language that makes Heathcliff seem more than human.
Check your own answer
Mission checkScreen 9
?Same novel, three critics, three different books. Who's right?
No single lens owns the novel. Marxist, feminist and psychoanalytic readings each light up real evidence: mortgages and wills, Isabella's letter and coverture, doubles and dreams. Strong answers use a reading, test it on precise words and say where it stops working.
Recap
Big ideas
A frame narrative: Lockwood's 1801–02 diary contains Nelly's story, which contains letters, a diary and other reports.
The novel opens near the end (1801), goes back about thirty years, catches up by Chapter XXX and closes in 1802.
Neither narrator is neutral: Lockwood misreads; Nelly acts, withholds and judges. Read their testimony critically.
In Section C, structure gives you connections with your poems' viewpoints (AO4).
Heathcliff is defined by others' names and slurs; his origins and fortune are never explained.
He is degraded by class (Ch. VI, IX), then uses property, money and marriage to degrade others (Ch. XVII, XXVII).
Readings: Charlotte's 1850 unease; Kettle's justified rebel who adopts his enemies' methods; Eagleton's capitalist landlord; post-colonial readings of his race and origins.
Pair his grief with a poem of love and loss from your anthology, comparing how each presents love that outlasts death.
The scratched names (Ch. III) and her Grange "education" (Ch. VI–VII) set up Catherine's divided self.
Chapter IX: "degrade", the souls speech and the foliage and rocks similes; Heathcliff hears only the first part.
Coverture and marriage law make her plan to help Heathcliff with Edgar's money an illusion.
Link with anthology poems about love and social convention, comparing how each speaker weighs desire against rank.
The second generation echoes the first in names and patterns: Cathy's names run backwards; Hareton repeats Heathcliff's degradation.
Heathcliff's plan uses Hareton and Linton, and a forced marriage, to take both houses.
The ending repairs through literacy and tenderness, but at the cost of the old wildness.
Compare with an anthology poem on maturing or renewed love.
Gothic conventions relocated to a Yorkshire farm: the panelled bed, the ghost-child, the opened coffin.
The moors are freedom and danger; Charlotte (1850) calls the novel "moorish, and wild, and knotty as a root of heath".
Cecil's storm and calm: a reading to test, not a fact.
Compare haunted or deathless love in your anthology poems.
The Heights is an old farming family's house; the Grange is gentry. Heathcliff starts below both.
Entail and settlements favour male heirs; coverture gives a wife's property to her husband.
Heathcliff's four steps: mortgage, marriage, forced marriage, will. Kettle, Eagleton and Leavis read this as class history.
Link: marriage as transaction in anthology poems such as Hardy's ‘The Ruined Maid’.
Reception: 1847–48 reviewers granted the power but disliked the savagery; Charlotte's 1850 Notice and Preface explained the Bells and framed Emily as an untaught genius.
Marxist (Kettle, Eagleton), feminist (Gilbert and Gubar, Pykett) and psychoanalytic (Moser; doubles and the unconscious) readings each answer different questions.
AO5 is assessed: weigh readings against the text and against each other.
Key quotations to learn
1801—I have just returned from a visit to my landlord(Ch. I (Lockwood)) The frame opens near the end of the story.
A capital fellow!(Ch. I (Lockwood)) The outsider's misreading of Heathcliff.
we plagued and went on with him shamefully(Ch. IV (Nelly)) The narrator admits her own part in the cruelty.
I have undergone sharp discipline, which has taught me wisdom(Ch. VII (Nelly)) Nelly's claim to be a reasonable judge.
Thus ended Mrs. Dean’s story.(Ch. XXX (Lockwood)) The past narrative catches up with the present.
gipsy brat(Ch. IV (Mrs Earnshaw)) The outsider named by prejudice.
a little Lascar, or an American or Spanish castaway(Ch. VI (Mr Linton)) Origins guessed, never fixed.
deprived him of the instructions of the curate(Ch. VI (Nelly)) Degradation by class and education.
we’ll see if one tree won’t grow as crooked as another, with the same wind to twist it(Ch. XVII (Heathcliff)) He repeats his own degradation on Hareton.
I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!(Ch. XVI (Heathcliff)) Catherine as his self: grief as self-loss.
I have lost the faculty of enjoying their destruction(Ch. XXXIII (Heathcliff)) Revenge empties out before his death.
Whether it is right or advisable to create beings like Heathcliff, I do not know: I scarcely think it is.(Charlotte Brontë, Editor's Preface (1850)) The first sister-critic's unease: reception context.
It would degrade me to marry Heathcliff now(Ch. IX (Catherine)) Class shapes her choice; Heathcliff hears this.
he’s more myself than I am(Ch. IX (Catherine)) Love as shared identity.
My love for Linton is like the foliage in the woods(Ch. IX (Catherine)) Surface, changeable love.
Nelly, I am Heathcliff!(Ch. IX (Catherine)) The self she cannot marry.
I wish I were a girl again, half savage and hardy, and free(Ch. XII (Catherine)) Nostalgia for the unenclosed self.
I’m tired of being enclosed here(Ch. XV (Catherine)) The body and marriage as prison.
one is gold put to the use of paving-stones, and the other is tin polished to ape a service of silver(Ch. XXI (Heathcliff)) Hareton's worth wasted; Linton's value fake.
we’ll see if one tree won’t grow as crooked as another(Ch. XVII (Heathcliff)) The experiment of repeated degradation.
No, read it over first correctly, without a single mistake.(Ch. XXXII (Cathy)) Power through learning.
sticking primroses in his plate of porridge(Ch. XXXIII (Nelly)) Playful, domestic renewal.
Together, they would brave Satan and all his legions.(Ch. XXXIV (Lockwood)) The new couple's strength, seen by an envious outsider.
Let me in—let me in!(Ch. III (the ghost)) The outsider at the window.
Terror made me cruel(Ch. III (Lockwood)) Violence beneath civility.
“Wuthering” being a significant provincial adjective, descriptive of the atmospheric tumult to which its station is exposed in stormy weather(Ch. I (Lockwood)) The house named for storm.
Is he a ghoul or a vampire?(Ch. XXXIV (Nelly)) Gothic language, then doubted.
unquiet slumbers for the sleepers in that quiet earth(Ch. XXXIV (Lockwood)) The poised final line.
It is moorish, and wild, and knotty as a root of heath.(Charlotte Brontë, Editor's Preface (1850)) Early reception: the novel as rustic.
his property, in default of heirs male, might pass into such a one’s power(Ch. X (Nelly on Edgar)) Inheritance favours male heirs.
The guest was now the master of Wuthering Heights(Ch. XVII (Nelly)) The outsider becomes owner.
he, Heathcliff, was the mortgagee(Ch. XVII (Nelly)) Debt, not force, transfers the land.
He had sold himself to Mr. Heathcliff(Ch. XXVIII (Nelly on Mr Green)) The law itself is bought.
what had been her, moveable property(Ch. XXX (Nelly, after Zillah)) Coverture in five words.
Catherine, destitute of cash and friends, cannot disturb his possession(Ch. XXX (Nelly)) A woman dispossessed.
Is Mr. Heathcliff a man? If so, is he mad? And if not, is he a devil?(Ch. XIII (Isabella)) A wife's testimony; Gothic and feminist readings.
I keep strictly within the limits of the law(Ch. XIV (Heathcliff)) Cruelty within the law.
he’s more myself than I am(Ch. IX (Catherine)) The double: psychoanalytic readings.
he, Heathcliff, was the mortgagee(Ch. XVII (Nelly)) Property: Marxist readings.
Having formed these beings, she did not know what she had done.(Charlotte Brontë, Editor's Preface (1850)) The 'unconscious genius' view of Emily.
we had a vague impression that authoresses are liable to be looked on with prejudice(Charlotte Brontë, Biographical Notice (1850)) Why the sisters wrote as the Bells.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Wuthering Heights for AQA A-level English Literature. 🎉
Mission 1Why do a stranger and a servant tell this great love story?
Mission 2Heathcliff opens Catherine's coffin. Why do readers still pity him?
Mission 3Catherine says “I am Heathcliff.” So why marry Edgar?
Mission 4The story ends with a reading lesson. Is that a happy ending?
Mission 5A ghost at the window, an opened grave: is this a Gothic novel?
Mission 6Heathcliff never kills anyone. So how does he take two houses?
Mission 7Same novel, three critics, three different books. Who's right?
13 Crossref-it, "Wuthering Heights: critical approaches", https://crossref-it.info/textguide/wuthering-heights/35/2535; Dispatches from the Former New World, "The Marxist Brontës?", https://dispatchesfromtheformernewworld.com/2019/01/23/on-my-bookshelf-the-marxist-brontes/
14Wuthering Heights : Ch. III , VII (1812–1826), IX (2919–2992), XII (4588–4612), XV (5850–5860)
15 Wikipedia, "Wuthering Heights", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuthering_Heights; Sandra M. Gilbert and Susan Gubar, The Madwoman in the Attic: The Woman Writer and the Nineteenth-Century Literary Imagination (New Haven: Yale UP, 1979), "Looking Oppositely: Emily Brontë's Bible of Hell"
23Wuthering Heights : Ch. I (102), IV (1234), VI (1676, 1732), X (3674), XVI (6012–6014), XVII (6846–6856), XXI (8009), XXVII (9944), XXVIII (10305–10373), XXX (10722–10729)
24 Wikipedia, "Wuthering Heights", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wuthering_Heights; Sanger's legal analysis summarised at https://wuthering-heights.co.uk/legal (Grange settled by old Linton's will on Edgar for life, then his sons in tail, then Isabella's line; Nelly "quite right in her suspicions")