← IB Economics · SL IB Economics revision
⭐ 0
IB Diploma Economics SL · 2.8 Market failure: externalities and common pool or common access resources
Mini-Lesson

Market failure: externalities and common pool or common access resources

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  2. Mission 2When a product harms people nearby who never bought it, why does the market sell too much?
  3. Mission 3Why do fishers who all want fish next year still empty the sea this year?
  4. Mission 4How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Competitive market equilibrium; 3 missions in Role of government (part 2).

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Make a guess: Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?

Mission 1

The cost nobody pays for

  • A firm pays for labour, materials, energy: its private costs.
  • Its production may also harm third parties, who are outside the trade: polluted air and rivers, noise, carbon emissions.
  • That harm is an external cost. Nobody pays the firm's victims through the market.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost.
  • At the margin: MSC = MPC + MEC (marginal external cost).
  • A negative production externality = an external cost created by producing a good.
  • Examples: a chemical plant's waste in a river harms fishing downstream; an airport's noise lowers the value of nearby homes; a coal power station's emissions harm health.
Mission 1

Worked example: adding up social cost

  • Illustrative data: a paper mill dumps waste in a river. Per tonne of paper:
  • Marginal private cost (wood, labour, energy) = 300.
  • Marginal external cost (lost fishing, water cleaning downstream) = 80.
  • MSC = MPC + MEC = 300 + 80 = 380.
  • Buyers value the last tonne at 360 (MPB). No external benefit, so MSB = 360.
  • The mill makes the tonne: to it, 360 > 300. To society: 360 − 380 = −20. Society loses 20 on that tonne.
  • If all 1,000 tonnes cost the same: private cost 300,000; external cost 80,000; social cost 380,000.
Quick check
?Illustrative data: a cement works has a marginal private cost of 45 per tonne. Its dust causes a marginal external cost of 15 per tonne to nearby residents. What is the marginal social cost of a tonne of cement?
Mission 1

The diagram

Negative production externalityCosts and benefits0P*PmQ*QmQuantityoverproductionMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCMEC
  • Step 1: the market. Supply = MPC; demand = MPB = MSB (no external benefit). Market equilibrium at Qm, Pm.
  • Step 2: add the external cost. MSC lies above MPC; the vertical gap = MEC.
  • Step 3: the social optimum is where MSB = MSC: Q* (less), P* (higher).
  • Firms respond to private costs only, so the market produces Qm > Q*: overproduction.
  • The price Pm is too low: it does not include the external cost.
  • Say: "the market overproduces compared with the social optimum" — not: "the market is in disequilibrium".
Mission 1

The welfare loss

Welfare lossCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYwelfare loss (W, X, Y)external cost (not all a welfare loss)W = social optimum
  • For each unit from Q* to Qm: MSC > MSB. It costs society more than it is worth.
  • Adding up these losses gives a triangle:
  • corners: the social optimum (MSB = MSC); MSC at Qm; MSB at Qm.
  • The triangle points towards the social optimum.
  • Called the welfare loss.
  • Say: "welfare loss = the triangle between MSC and MSB, from Q* to Qm" — not: "the whole area between MSC and MPC". That bigger area is the external cost of all output, most of which is still worth bearing.
Mission 1Graph lab

Turn up the pollution

Illustrative data: MPB = MSB = 100 − Q; MPC = 20 + Q. The marginal external cost (MEC) is the same for every unit.

Turn up the pollutionPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: a bigger MEC does not change what the market produces; it lowers the social optimum and widens the welfare loss.
Quick check
Points on the externality diagramCosts and benefits0Q*QmQuantityMPB = MSB = DMPC = SMSCWXYZ
?A negative production externality diagram has MPB = MSB, MPC and MSC. The points are:
PointWhere it is
Wwhere MSC meets MSB (above Q*)
Xon MSC directly above Qm
Ywhere MPC meets MPB (at Qm)
Zon MPC directly below W (at Q*)

Which area shows the welfare loss?

Mission 1

Putting a number on the external cost

  • Carbon dioxide is a global external cost: emissions anywhere add to climate damage everywhere.
  • The social cost of carbon estimates the damage from one more tonne of CO₂, in today's money.
  • Two US government estimates for emissions in 2020: $51 per tonne (2021) and $190 per tonne (2023).
  • The gap comes mostly from assumptions, above all how much weight to give damage to people in the future.
  • So the MEC used for policy depends on value judgements, not only on science.
Mission 1Evaluate

How big is the problem?

  • It depends on measuring MEC. Health, nature and future harm have no market price, so estimates vary widely.
  • It depends on elasticity. For a given MEC, the more price elastic demand and supply are, the bigger the overproduction (Qm − Q*) and the welfare loss.
  • It depends on who and where. Many small polluters, or harm across borders, make the external cost hard to trace and charge.
  • It depends on time. Some damage builds up over years (carbon, soil), so today's MEC may understate the harm.
  • Ways to correct it (taxes, regulation, permits, property rights) are in an earlier lesson.
Mission check

?Illustrative data: a fertiliser plant's runoff harms a lake. The table shows marginal values at each output (thousand tonnes).
OutputMPB = MSBMPCMEC
10903010
20804015
30705020
40606025
50507030

What is the socially optimal output?

Mission 2

Mission 2: When a product harms people nearby who never bought it, why does the market sell too much?

Make a guess: When a product harms people nearby who never bought it, why does the market sell too much?

Mission 2

Benefit to you, cost to others

Third-party costMPBexternalcostbuyerbystandersMPBMSB = MPB − MECMECNot to scale
  • Marginal private benefit (MPB): the benefit to the buyer of one more unit. It is the buyer's demand curve.
  • Some consumption harms third parties: people outside the deal.
  • Marginal external cost (MEC) of consumption: the harm to third parties from one more unit consumed.
  • Marginal social benefit (MSB) = MPB − MEC. The external cost cuts the benefit to society.
  • Buyers respond to private, not external, costs and benefits.
  • Example: second-hand smoke. Tobacco kills over 7 million people a year, including over 1.6 million non-smokers exposed to second-hand smoke (WHO).
  • Other cases: loud music at night, litter, driving after drinking alcohol.
Mission 2

Overconsumption on the diagram

Externality in consumptionPrice, costs and benefits0P1Q*Q1overconsumptionQuantityMPBMPC = MSCMSBwelfare loss
  • Step 1: no production externality, so MPC = MSC. The market settles where MPB = MPC: quantity Q1, price P1.
  • Step 2: MSB lies below MPB by the external cost. The social optimum is where MSB = MSC: quantity Q*.
  • Q1 > Q*: the market overconsumes.
  • Step 3: each unit from Q* to Q1 has MSC above MSB. Society loses on every one.
  • The shaded triangle between Q* and Q1 is the welfare loss. It points to the social optimum.
  • Say: "the welfare loss is the triangle between Q* and Q1" — not: "the whole area under MSB".
Mission 2Graph lab

Turn up the harm

Turn up the harmPrice, costs and benefitsQuantityQ1MPBMPC = MSC
  • Takeaway: the market ignores external costs, so a bigger external cost means a bigger gap between Q1 and Q*.
Quick check
?A product causes no external cost in production, so MPC = MSC = 10 for the 50th unit. For that unit, the buyer's MPB is 12 and the external cost of consuming it is 4 (illustrative data). From society's point of view, should the 50th unit be consumed?
Mission 2

Demerit goods

  • A demerit good is more harmful to the consumer than they realise.
  • It is overconsumed if left to the market.
  • Examples often given: tobacco, alcohol, gambling, recreational drugs.
  • Why overconsumed:
  • Imperfect information: buyers underestimate the harm to themselves.
  • Short-termism and addiction: today's pleasure outweighs tomorrow's cost.
  • External costs: most demerit goods also harm third parties.
  • Calling a good "demerit" is a value judgement: someone decides it is bad for people.
Mission 2

The demerit-good diagram

Demerit or merit goodPrice, costs and benefits0Q*Q2Q1QuantityMPB(perceived)MPB (fullinformation)MSBMPC = MSCinformation failureexternal costwelfare loss
  • Step 1: buyers act on MPB (perceived). Market at Q1, where it meets MPC = MSC.
  • Step 2: with full information, buyers would value it less: MPB (full information) lies lower. Quantity falls to Q2.
  • Step 3: adding the external cost gives MSB, lower still. Social optimum Q* where MSB = MSC.
  • Overconsumption: Q1 > Q2 > Q*. Welfare loss: the triangle between Q* and Q1.
  • Say: "overconsumed" for a demerit good — not: "overproduced because firms make too much".
Mission 2

Who decides what is "bad"?

  • Positive statement: can be tested against evidence. "Smokers underestimate the risk of lung cancer."
  • Normative statement (value judgement): an opinion about what ought to be. "People should not smoke."
  • Case for treating a good as demerit:
  • Evidence of information failure, addiction, harm to others.
  • Case against:
  • Consumer sovereignty: adults are the best judges of their own welfare.
  • Fears of paternalism: the state imposing its tastes.
  • Which goods count changes over time and between societies.
  • Policy responses (taxes, bans, information) are in an earlier lesson.
Quick check
?Which of these statements about a product is a value judgement, not a positive statement?
Mission 2Evaluate

How serious is the overconsumption?

  • It depends on the size of the external cost: hard to measure, so Q* is an estimate.
  • It depends on information: if buyers learn the true harm, perceived MPB falls on its own.
  • It depends on who is harmed: harm to the buyer alone is a weaker case than harm to others.
  • It depends on the value judgement: views differ on how far the state should overrule personal choices.
Mission check

?In a city's main streets, late-night fast food leaves litter behind. Cleaning it up costs the city, and residents dislike it. The food sellers and buyers pay nothing towards this. What happens in the market for late-night fast food?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why do fishers who all want fish next year still empty the sea this year?

Make a guess: Why do fishers who all want fish next year still empty the sea this year?

Mission 3

Rival, but no one can be kept out

Goods gridExcludableNon-excludableRivalNon-rivalPrivate goodCommon poolresourcePublic good
  • Recall the two tests: rival? excludable?
  • Some resources are rival but non-excludable:
    • fish in the open sea: a fish one boat catches, another cannot
    • groundwater that any landowner may pump
    • common grazing land; a forest anyone may log
    • the atmosphere's capacity to absorb pollution
  • IB name: common pool resources (rivalrous but non-excludable).
  • Say: "rival but non-excludable" — not: "a public good". A public good is non-rival.
Quick check
?Which of these is a common pool (open-access) resource?
Mission 3

The tragedy of the commons

Shrinking fish stockmy gain: all of itthe cost: shared by allThree years on: a smaller shoal and smallercatches for every boat.
  • Tragedy of the commons: users of a common resource, each acting in their own interest, over-use it until it is depleted.
  • Each user gets all the benefit of using more.
  • The cost (a smaller stock, lower catches for everyone, now and later) is shared among all users.
  • So each user's private gain from using more is larger than the gain to society.
  • Everyone reasons the same way. Total use exceeds the sustainable level: the stock shrinks year after year.
  • Nobody owns the stock, so nobody gains from conserving it.
Mission 3

Worked example: one more tonne

  • Illustrative data. 10 boats share a fishing ground.
  • One extra tonne caught today shrinks the breeding stock, so future catches fall by 2 tonnes in total.
  • That loss is shared equally among the 10 boats.
  • The boat that catches the extra tonne:
    • gains 1 tonne
    • loses its share of the future loss: 2 ÷ 10 = 0.2 tonnes
    • net: 1 − 0.2 = +0.8 tonnes → it fishes more
  • Society: 1 − 2 = −1 tonne → the extra catch makes everyone worse off overall.
  • With 100 boats, each boat's share is only 0.02 tonnes. The more users, the weaker each one's reason to hold back.
Quick check
?20 farmers graze cows on common land. One farmer adds an extra cow, which gives her milk worth 300. The extra grazing means every cow on the common gives less milk: a total loss of 600 spread equally across the 20 farmers. (Illustrative data.) What is the effect on society, and will she add the cow?
Mission 3

Unsustainable use is a negative externality

Over-use as an externalityPrice0Q*Q1Quantity of fish caughtMPB = MSBMPCMSCMECwelfare loss
  • Each boat's private cost (MPC): fuel, crew, nets.
  • It ignores the external cost it imposes on others: lower catches for other boats and for future fishers.
  • Unsustainable production creates a negative externality.
  • Market catch Q1 > socially optimal Q*: over-use.
Mission 3Graph lab

How much should the fleet catch?

Illustrative data. Fish demand and boats' private costs are fixed. The market catch is 80 tonnes.

How much should the fleet catch?Price per tonneCatch (tonnes)Q1D = MPB = MSBMPC
  • Takeaway: the market catch stays at 80 however large the external cost; a fee equal to the external cost brings the catch to Q*.
Mission 3

Real world: the northern cod

  • Off Newfoundland, Canada, the northern cod stock supported fishing for centuries.
  • After the Second World War, factory freezer trawlers and sonar made catches far bigger.
  • Quotas existed, but stock estimates were too high, and a 1989 advice to cut quotas by half was not followed.
  • On 2 July 1992 Canada stopped the fishery: a moratorium.
  • About 40,000 fishers and related workers were affected: the largest layoff in Canadian history.
  • The stock did not quickly recover. A limited commercial fishery reopened only in 2024.
  • Lesson: over-use can destroy a resource. Government limits can also fail when information is poor.
Mission 3

Managing the commons

Policy toolkitRegulation and quotasRules on how much, when and howto fishTradable permits (cap and trade)A cap on the total catch, split intoshares that can be tradedCollective self-governanceUsers set and monitor their own rules
  • Legislation and regulation: catch quotas, closed seasons, minimum net mesh sizes, protected areas.
  • Tradable permits (tradable quotas): a cap on the total catch, split into shares that can be bought and sold.
  • Collective self-governance: users manage the resource themselves, with their own rules, monitoring and penalties.
  • Elinor Ostrom (Nobel Prize, 2009) showed many communities do this successfully, for pastures, forests and fisheries.
  • International agreements: when the resource crosses borders (next screen).
Mission 3

Why cooperation must be international

  • Global nature: the high seas, the atmosphere and migratory fish stocks cross borders. No single country can protect them.
  • Challenges:
    • each country gains by over-using while others hold back: free riding between countries
    • countries differ in income, priorities and responsibility for past damage
    • no world government can force a country to sign or comply
  • Monitoring: are countries doing what they promised? Satellite and catch data help but are costly and incomplete.
  • Enforcement: often relies on peer pressure, trade measures or the gains from continued cooperation.
  • Montreal Protocol (1987) on ozone-depleting substances: ratified by every UN member state.
  • Paris Agreement (2015) on climate: each country sets its own targets; there is no penalty for missing them.
Quick check
?Every country would gain if all fishing nations limited their catch of a migratory tuna stock. Why might an international agreement still fail?
Mission 3Evaluate

Can over-use be stopped?

It depends on:

  • Information. How big is the stock and how fast does it regrow? The cod quotas were set on estimates that were too high.
  • Monitoring and enforcement costs. Oceans are vast; illegal catches are hard to spot.
  • Political pressure. Quotas mean lost jobs now for gains later.
  • The users. Small groups who know each other can often govern a common well; thousands of anonymous users rarely can.
Mission check

?In a dry valley, farmers pump water from one shared underground aquifer. Any landowner may drill a well, and the water table is falling each year. Which explanation is best?
Mission 4

Mission 4: How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Make a guess: How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Mission 4

Private and social costs and benefits

Private and social costs and benefitsThe firm's scale: privatecost against private benefitSociety's scale: adds the effectson third partiesPCprivate costPBprivate benefitECexternal costEBexternal benefitSC = PC + ECSB = PB + EB
  • A firm counts its private costs and benefits: what it pays and what it earns.
  • Society also counts external costs and benefits: effects on third parties.
  • Social cost = private cost + external cost (SC = PC + EC).
  • Social benefit = private benefit + external benefit (SB = PB + EB).
  • A new road: building costs (private); noise for nearby homes (external cost); faster journeys and fewer crashes (benefits).
  • A project can lose money for its builder yet still be worth it to society, or the other way round.
Mission 4

Valuing things that have no price

Valuing things that have no priceMarketpricesRevealedpreferenceStatedpreferenceRevealed preference: similar houses sell for lessunder a flight path. Stated preference: a surveyasks willingness to pay.Value of a statistical lifeone dot = 1,000 people100,000 people × 100 each= 10 millionIllustrative data
  • Clean air, quiet and travel time are not sold in shops. Economists estimate their value in money:
  • Market prices: use a related price, e.g. the cost of cleaning up a river, or of treating an illness.
  • Revealed preference: watch what people actually pay.
    • Similar houses sell for less under a flight path: the gap values the noise.
    • Workers in riskier jobs are paid more: the extra pay values the risk.
  • Stated preference: ask people in a survey what they would be willing to pay.
  • Value of a statistical life (illustrative data): 100,000 people each pay 100 to cut their risk of dying this year by 1 in 100,000.
    • Expected deaths fall by 1.
    • Total paid = 100,000 × 100 = 10 million: the value of one statistical life.
  • It is not the value of any one named person's life.
Quick check
?To value the loss of quiet near a new airport runway, researchers compare the prices of similar houses inside and outside the flight path. Which method are they using?
Mission 4

Why externalities are hard to measure

  • Who is affected? Harm can spread far, across borders and to future generations.
  • How much harm? Scientists may not know the effect of a pollutant for years.
  • What money value? Different methods give different numbers for the same harm.
  • Survey problems: people may overstate what they would pay, or refuse to put a price on nature.
  • So a tax or subsidy set equal to the "external cost" rests on an estimate.
  • This is a key limitation of policies to correct externalities, such as Pigouvian taxes and tradable permits.
Mission 4Graph lab

Getting the tax wrong

Illustrative data: the true external cost is 20 per unit. The government sets a tax per unit equal to its estimate.

Getting the tax wrongPrice / costs and benefitsQuantityQ*QmMPB = MSBMPCMSC
  • Takeaway: the tax corrects the market only if it matches the true external cost, so measurement matters.
Mission 4

CBA in use

  • Cost-benefit analysis (CBA): adding up all the social costs and social benefits of a project, valued in money, to decide whether to go ahead.
  • Transport: governments value time saved, accidents avoided, noise and emissions before building roads and railways.
  • Health: some health services compare a treatment's cost with the quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) it adds.
  • Flood defence: a 1936 US law allowed federal flood projects if benefits "to whomsoever they may accrue" exceed the estimated costs.
  • Regulation: the US Environmental Protection Agency recommends a value of a statistical life of US$7.4 million (in 2006 dollars), updated to the year of each analysis, when it weighs rules that cut deaths from pollution.
  • Stakeholders: CBA shows who bears costs (residents, firms, taxpayers) and who gains (travellers, patients).
Mission 4Evaluate

How far can we trust a CBA?

It depends on:

  • The estimates: the money values put on life, time and nature can differ widely. Small changes can flip the decision.
  • Who wins and who loses: CBA adds up gains and losses. A project can pass while one group (e.g. nearby residents) loses heavily and is not compensated.
  • Time and uncertainty: long-lived projects and climate harms reach far into the future, and forecasts can be optimistic.
  • Who does the analysis: interest groups and politicians may push for favourable numbers.
  • Still, a CBA makes assumptions visible, so they can be challenged.
Mission check

?A government taxes each tonne of a chemical a factory releases into a river. The tax equals its estimate of the external cost per tonne. Scientists later find that the estimate left out harm to fishing communities downstream, across the border. What is most likely?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • A negative production externality makes MSC = MPC + MEC lie above MPC.
  • The market produces where MPB = MPC: more than the social optimum where MSB = MSC.
  • The welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MSB from Q* to Qm, pointing to the social optimum.

Mission 2

  • A negative consumption externality puts MSB below MPB, so the market consumes Q1 > Q* and creates a welfare loss.
  • Demerit goods are overconsumed because of imperfect information and external costs; calling a good "demerit" is a value judgement.

Mission 3

  • Common pool (open-access) resources are rival but non-excludable.
  • Each user gains all the benefit but shares the cost, so the resource is over-used: the tragedy of the commons.
  • Responses: regulation, tradable permits, property rights, collective self-governance.
  • Global resources need international cooperation, with monitoring and enforcement.

Mission 4

  • Social cost = private cost + external cost; social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
  • Values for things with no price come from related markets, revealed preference and surveys, so they are estimates.
  • Measuring externalities is hard, which limits taxes and other policies that depend on it.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Externalities and common pool resources for IB Economics SL. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why does a factory that pays all its own bills still produce too much?
  2. Mission 2When a product harms people nearby who never bought it, why does the market sell too much?
  3. Mission 3Why do fishers who all want fish next year still empty the sea this year?
  4. Mission 4How can a government put a price on cleaner air before deciding whether to build a road?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to IB Economics · SL