← IB Economics · HL IB Economics revision
⭐ 0
IB Diploma Economics HL · 2.7 Role of government in microeconomics (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Role of government in microeconomics (part 1)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?
  2. Mission 2Why would a government ever make something cost more?
  3. Mission 3When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?
  4. Mission 4When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Competitive market equilibrium; 1 mission in Critique of maximizing behaviour.

Mission 1

Mission 1: What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?

Make a guess: A law holds the price of bread below the market price. What is most likely?

Mission 1

A legal top price

Ceiling above and below equilibriumCeiling above Pe: not bindingPrice0PcPeQeQuantityDSCeiling below Pe: bindingPrice0PePcQeQuantityDSPc: price ceiling (maximum price)
  • A maximum price (price ceiling): the highest price that can legally be charged.
  • To have any effect it must be set below the equilibrium price. Then it is binding.
  • Set above equilibrium, it changes nothing: the market price is already lower.
  • Why do governments use them? To make essentials affordable (rents, basic food, fuel) and to protect consumers from sharp price rises.
Mission 1

Why a shortage appears

Shortage under a ceilingPrice0PePcQsQeQdshortage (excess demand)QuantityDSPc: price ceiling (maximum price)
  • Step 1: market clears at Pe, Qe.
  • Step 2: a ceiling is drawn below Pe.
  • At the lower price, quantity demanded extends to Qd.
  • Quantity supplied contracts to Qs.
  • Step 3: the gap Qd − Qs is excess demand: a shortage.
  • Only Qs is bought and sold. Trade falls from Qe to Qs.
  • Say: "an extension of demand and a contraction of supply" — not: "demand rises and supply falls" (neither curve shifts).
Quick check
?In a market, the equilibrium price is $20. The government sets a maximum price of $25. What happens?
Mission 1

Worked example: how big is the shortage?

  • Illustrative data. Demand: Qd = 100 − 2P. Supply: Qs = 4P − 20 (P in $, Q in thousands).
  • Equilibrium: 100 − 2P = 4P − 20, so 6P = 120, Pe = $20, Qe = 60.
  • Ceiling at $15:
  • Qd = 100 − 2 × 15 = 70.
  • Qs = 4 × 15 − 20 = 40.
  • Shortage = 70 − 40 = 30 thousand.
  • Quantity traded falls from 60 to 40.
Mission 1Graph lab

Lower the ceiling

Lower the ceilingPrice ($)Quantity6020DSprice ceilingshortage 30
  • Takeaway: the lower the ceiling, and the more elastic demand and supply are, the bigger the shortage.
Quick check
?Use the illustrative market in an earlier screen (Qd = 100 − 2P, Qs = 4P − 20). The ceiling is set at $18. What is the shortage?
Mission 1

Who gets the goods?

  • Price no longer rations, so something else does:
  • Queues (first come, first served), waiting lists, ballots.
  • Ration coupons from the government.
  • Sellers' preference: friends, regular customers, or discrimination.
  • Black (shadow) markets: illegal resale above the ceiling.
  • In an earlier screen, only 40 thousand units are supplied. Buyers would pay up to $30 for the 40-thousandth unit (100 − 2P = 40 gives P = 30), so black-market prices can rise above the old equilibrium of $20.
  • Berlin froze most rents at 2019 levels in 2020. Reports followed of landlords demanding large payments for furniture as a condition of renting. Germany's Constitutional Court struck the law down in 2021.
Mission 1

Winners and losers

Welfare under a ceilingPrice0PePcQsQeQuantityBCEdemand priceDSB: moves from producers to consumersdeadweight (welfare) loss = C + E
  • Assume the scarce goods go to the buyers who value them most.
  • Area B (between Pe and the ceiling, up to Qs): moves from producers to consumers who still buy.
  • Areas C + E (between Qs and Qe): trades that no longer happen. This is the deadweight (welfare) loss.
  • Consumers: gain B, lose C. Those who buy gain; those shut out lose.
  • Producers: lose B and E. Always worse off.
  • If goods go to the wrong buyers (waiting in line, luck), consumers gain less, and the time spent waiting is a further loss.
  • Say: "welfare loss" or "deadweight loss" — not: "the shortage is the loss" (the shortage is a quantity, the loss is an area).
Mission 1

Worked example: welfare in numbers

  • Same illustrative market as an earlier screen. Demand meets the price axis at $50; supply at $5.
  • Before: consumer surplus = ½ × 60 × (50 − 20) = 900. Producer surplus = ½ × 60 × (20 − 5) = 450.
  • Ceiling $15, Q = 40. Demand price at Q = 40 is $30.
  • Producer surplus = ½ × 40 × (15 − 5) = 200 (down 250).
  • Consumer surplus = 1000 (up 100): gains B = (20 − 15) × 40 = 200, loses C = ½ × 20 × (30 − 20) = 100.
  • Deadweight loss = ½ × 20 × (30 − 15) = 150. Check: 1350 − 1200 = 150.
  • Spending by consumers (and producers' revenue): 20 × 60 = 1200 → 15 × 40 = 600.
Quick check
Welfare under a ceilingPrice0PePcQsQeQuantityBCEDS
?The diagram shows a ceiling below Pe. Area B is the rectangle between Pe and the ceiling, from 0 to Qs. C is the triangle between Qs and Qe, below demand and above Pe. E is the triangle between Qs and Qe, above supply and below Pe. Which area is the deadweight loss?
Mission 1

Case: rent control

  • In 1994, San Francisco extended rent control to small, older rental buildings.
  • Covered tenants became nearly 20% more likely to stay at their address.
  • But landlords of covered buildings cut their supply of rental housing by 15% (selling to owner-occupiers, converting to condominiums).
  • Rents across the city rose by an estimated 5.1%: new renters paid more.
  • Over time supply becomes more elastic, so the shortage grows.
  • Landlords may cut maintenance, so quality falls.
  • Tenants stay in homes that no longer suit them: housing is misallocated and workers move less.
  • Supporters point to security: tenants avoid sudden rent rises and can stay in their communities.
Mission 1

Evaluate: does a maximum price help?

It depends on…

  • Elasticity and time: inelastic demand and supply keep the shortage small in the short run. Supply becomes more elastic over the years, so the shortage grows.
  • How far below equilibrium: a small gap may protect buyers at little cost. A large gap creates queues and black markets.
  • Enforcement and rationing: who actually gets the goods, and at what price?
  • Alternatives: subsidies, income support or building more homes raise supply instead of cutting it.
  • Stakeholders: consumers who buy, consumers shut out, producers, workers in the industry, the government.
Mission check

?A city caps rents below the equilibrium rent. Demand for rental homes does not change over the next ten years, yet the shortage of rental homes gets bigger. Which best explains this?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why would a government ever make something cost more?

Make a guess: A law sets the lowest price for milk above the market price. What happens to the amount of milk people buy?

Mission 2

A legal bottom price

Price floor below and above equilibriumFloor below Pe: not bindingPrice0PeQeQuantityDSPf (price floor)Floor above Pe: bindingPrice0PeQeQuantityDSPf (price floor)
  • A minimum price (price floor): the lowest price that can legally be charged.
  • To have an effect it must be set above the equilibrium price (binding).
  • Why do governments use them?
  • Raise producers' incomes, especially farmers, whose prices swing with the weather.
  • Cut consumption of harmful (demerit) goods, such as cheap strong alcohol.
  • The minimum wage is a floor in the labour market.
Mission 2

Why a surplus appears

Why a surplus appearsPrice0PeQdQeQssurplus (excess supply)QuantityDSPf (price floor)
  • Step 1: market clears at Pe, Qe.
  • Step 2: a floor is drawn above Pe.
  • At the higher price, quantity demanded contracts to Qd.
  • Quantity supplied extends to Qs.
  • Step 3: the gap Qs − Qd is excess supply: a surplus.
  • Without other action, only Qd is sold. Trade falls from Qe to Qd.
  • Say: "a contraction of demand" — not: "demand falls" (the demand curve has not moved).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Demand: Qd = 100 − 2P. Supply: Qs = 4P − 20 (P in $, Q in thousands). Equilibrium is $20 and 60 thousand. A minimum price of $25 is set. What is the surplus?
Mission 2

What happens to the surplus?

Government buys the surplusPrice0PeQdQeQsQuantityDSPf (price floor)government spending = Pf × (Qs − Qd)
  • Left unsold: producers carry the cost of goods they cannot sell. Some sell illegally below the floor.
  • Bought by the government (a guaranteed price): taxpayers pay. The stock must be stored, destroyed, given away or sold abroad cheaply.
  • Production limits: output is capped so less surplus is made.
  • Real case: the US dairy price support programme bought dairy products that did not sell. By December 1981, more than 560 million pounds of cheese were in government warehouses. The President ordered 30 million pounds given free to people in need.
  • Pounds here are a weight (lb): 560 million lb is about 254,000 tonnes.
  • Say: "excess supply" or "surplus" — not: "oversupply means supply has shifted".
Mission 2

Worked example: a guaranteed price

  • Illustrative data: same market as an earlier screen. Floor $25, and the government buys the surplus.
  • Qd = 50, Qs = 80, surplus = 30 thousand.
  • Government spending = $25 × 30 = $750 thousand.
  • Consumers' spending: 20 × 60 = $1200 → 25 × 50 = $1250 thousand (they pay more for less).
  • Producers' revenue: $1200 → 25 × 80 = $2000 thousand.
  • Of that $2000, consumers pay 1250 and taxpayers 750.
Mission 2Graph lab

Raise the floor

Raise the floorPrice ($)Quantity (thousands)6020government buysDSprice floor
  • Takeaway: a higher floor and more elastic demand and supply mean a bigger surplus and a bigger bill.
Quick check
?Use the market in an earlier screen. The government guarantees a minimum price of $22 and buys any surplus. How much does it spend?
Mission 2

Case: minimum unit pricing for alcohol

  • Scotland set a minimum price per unit of alcohol: 50p from 2018, raised to 65p on 30 September 2024.
  • A unit is 10 ml of pure alcohol. Units = volume (litres) × % alcohol.
  • 70 cl bottle of 40% spirit: 0.7 × 40 = 28 units. Minimum price = 28 × 65p = £18.20 (it was £14.00 at 50p).
  • It mainly raises the price of cheap, strong drinks.
  • Estimates for the first years (Public Health Scotland, 2023), compared with no policy: alcohol sales down about 3%, deaths wholly caused by alcohol down 13.4%, hospital admissions down 4.1%.
  • Unlike a tax, the extra money goes to retailers and producers, not the government.
  • Debate: supporters say it targets harmful drinking; critics say it hits low-income drinkers hardest and rewards retailers.
Quick check
?Under a 65p minimum unit price, what is the lowest legal price for a 75 cl bottle of wine that is 13% alcohol?
Mission 2

Winners and losers

Welfare under a price floorPrice0PeQdQeQuantityDSPf (price floor)transfer from consumers to producersdeadweight lossFirms produce Qd.
  • Consumers lose: they pay more and buy less.
  • Producers who sell gain: the higher price on Qd (a transfer from consumers).
  • If the state buys the surplus: producers gain much more, taxpayers pay, and resources are used to make goods nobody buys at that price. Large deadweight loss.
  • If nobody buys it: producers lose on the unsold output, and a deadweight loss appears between Qd and Qe.
  • Allocative inefficiency: at Qs, the cost of the last unit is above what buyers value it at.
  • But for a demerit good with external costs, the market quantity may be too high. A floor that cuts consumption towards the social optimum can raise welfare.
Quick check
?A minimum price is set above Pe. The government does not buy any surplus, and firms produce only what they can sell (Qd). On the minimum-price diagram on the previous screen, which area moves from consumers to producers?
Mission 2

Evaluate: does a minimum price help?

It depends on…

  • Elasticity: inelastic demand means a small surplus and higher spending by consumers. Elastic demand and supply mean a big surplus.
  • What happens to the surplus: storage and dumping abroad cost money and can hurt farmers in other countries.
  • The aim: to support farm incomes, or cut harmful consumption? A tax raises the price too, and the money goes to the government.
  • Time: guaranteed prices encourage more output each year, so surpluses can grow.
  • Who gains: large producers sell most, so they gain most.
  • Stakeholders: consumers, producers, the government (taxpayers), foreign producers.
Mission check

?To cut smoking, a government wants to raise the retail price of cigarettes by the same amount using either a new tax per pack or a minimum price per pack. Assume both give the same retail price. What is the main difference between them?
Mission 3

Mission 3: When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?

Make a guess: When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?

Mission 3

A tax on spending

Who hands the tax to the governmentBuyerSellerpays the priceGovernmenttaxBuyers pay the tax onlythrough the price.
  • An indirect tax is a tax on spending on goods and services.
  • The seller hands the tax to the government. Buyers pay it only through the price.
  • Examples: VAT and sales taxes; duties on fuel, alcohol and tobacco.
  • To the seller, the tax is like an extra cost of each unit sold.
Mission 3

The tax diagram

Tax incidencePrice0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityDSS + taxtconsumers' burden: (P1 − Pe) × Q1producers' burden: (Pe − P2) × Q1Tax revenue = both rectangles = t × Q1welfare loss: units between Q1 and Qe nolonger traded
  • Build it in steps (a tax of t per unit):
  • 1. Start at equilibrium: Pe, Qe.
  • 2. Supply shifts up by the tax: S → S + tax. Vertical gap = t.
  • 3. New equilibrium: price buyers pay rises to P1; quantity falls to Q1.
  • Sellers keep P1 − t per unit.
  • The price rises by less than the tax (unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic).
  • Say: "supply decreases; there is a contraction of demand" — not: "demand falls".
Mission 3

Who bears the tax?

Tax incidencePrice0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityDSS + taxtconsumers' burden: (P1 − Pe) × Q1producers' burden: (Pe − P2) × Q1Tax revenue = both rectangles = t × Q1welfare loss: units between Q1 and Qe nolonger traded
  • The incidence of a tax: how its burden is shared between consumers and producers.
  • Consumers' share per unit = P1 − Pe (the rise in the price they pay).
  • Producers' share per unit = Pe − (P1 − t) (the fall in the price they keep).
  • The two shares add up to the tax, t.
  • Government revenue = t × Q1: the rectangle between P1 and P1 − t, from 0 to Q1.
  • Who hands the money over (the formal incidence or impact) does not decide who bears it.
Mission 3

The lost triangle

Tax incidencePrice0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityDSS + taxtconsumers' burden: (P1 − Pe) × Q1producers' burden: (Pe − P2) × Q1Tax revenue = both rectangles = t × Q1welfare loss: units between Q1 and Qe nolonger traded
  • Units between Q1 and Qe are no longer traded.
  • Buyers valued them above their cost of production, so the gain on those units is lost.
  • This loss is the deadweight loss (it is not tax revenue): the triangle between D and S, from Q1 to Qe.
  • Also called the welfare loss: a loss to society.
Quick check
Areas A, B and C after a taxPrice0P1PeP2Q1QeQuantityABCDSS + taxtABC
?The diagram shows a market before and after a tax of a fixed amount per unit: D, S and S + tax; equilibrium Pe and Qe before; P1 and Q1 after; and P2 = P1 − tax. Which area shows the burden on producers?
AreaPosition
ARectangle between P1 and Pe, from 0 to Q1
BRectangle between Pe and P2, from 0 to Q1
CTriangle between D and S, from Q1 to Qe
DRectangles A and B together
Mission 3

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. Before the tax: P = $6, Q = 60 units.
  • Per-unit tax: $1.50. After the tax: consumers pay $7, Q = 50.
  • Producers receive $7 − $1.50 = $5.50.
  • Consumers' burden: ($7 − $6) × 50 = $50. Producers' burden: ($6 − $5.50) × 50 = $25.
  • Government revenue: $1.50 × 50 = $75.
  • Consumer spending: $6 × 60 = $360 → $7 × 50 = $350.
  • Producer revenue (after tax): $6 × 60 = $360 → $5.50 × 50 = $275.
  • Welfare (deadweight) loss: ½ × $1.50 × (60 − 50) = $7.50.
  • CS falls by ½ × ($7 − $6) × (60 + 50) = $55; PS falls by ½ × ($6 − $5.50) × (60 + 50) = $27.50.
  • Check: $55 + $27.50 = $75 revenue + $7.50 DWL.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Before a tax, a good sells at 5.00 per unit and 100 units are traded. After a tax of 2.00 per unit, consumers pay 6.20 and 76 units are traded. What is the total burden of the tax on producers?
Mission 3

Elasticity decides the split

Elasticity and tax incidence(a) Inelastic demand: consumers bear mostPrice0P1PeP2QuantityDSS + tax(b) Elastic demand: producers bear mostPrice0P1PeP2QuantityDSS + taxPerfectly inelasticdemand: consumersbear it allPriceQuantityDSS + taxPerfectly elasticdemand: producersbear it allPriceQuantityDSS + taxconsumers' burdenproducers' burden
  • The side of the market that is less price elastic bears more of the tax.
  • Inelastic demand (e.g. cigarettes, fuel): sellers raise the price and buyers keep buying, so consumers bear most.
  • Elastic demand: buyers switch away, so sellers must absorb the tax: producers bear most.
  • Extreme cases:
    • perfectly inelastic demand: consumers bear it all
    • perfectly elastic demand: producers bear it all
  • Approximate consumers' share = PES ÷ (PES + |PED|).
  • Say: "demand is price inelastic" — not: "demand is low".
Mission 3Graph lab

Shift the burden

Start: a tax of 1.50 per unit; PED −1, PES 2. Consumers bear 2/3 of each unit's tax.

Shift the burdenPriceQuantityQ1QeP1PeP2DSS + tax
  • Takeaway: less elastic demand → consumers bear a bigger share (here 8/9), and Q falls less.
Quick check
?A government wants to raise as much revenue as possible from a tax of the same amount per unit, with the smallest fall in quantity sold. Supply conditions are similar. Which good should it tax?
Mission 3

Stakeholders

  • Consumers: pay a higher price, buy less; consumer surplus falls.
  • Producers: keep less per unit, sell less; producer surplus falls. Revenue falls.
  • Workers: fewer units made can mean fewer jobs in the industry.
  • Government: gains revenue (t × Q1) to spend; can target goods it wants used less.
  • Society:
    • in an efficient market, a deadweight loss
    • where the good has a negative externality, the tax can move output toward the social optimum
  • Indirect taxes are often regressive: lower-income households spend a larger share of income on them.
Mission 3

Case: the UK sugar levy

  • Soft Drinks Industry Levy, from April 2018, charged on producers and importers. Rates at the start:
    • 18p per litre: drinks with 5 g to 8 g of sugar per 100 ml
    • 24p per litre: 8 g or more
  • (Both rates have risen each year since April 2025.)
  • Below 5 g: no levy. So firms could avoid it by cutting sugar.
  • 2015 to 2018, average sugar in UK soft drinks fell from 4.4 g to 2.9 g per 100 ml.
  • Most of the fall came from reformulation, not from buyers switching.
  • Caution: the study shows a trend; it cannot prove the levy alone caused it.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does the tax work?

  • It depends on PED:
    • inelastic demand → high revenue, small fall in Q
    • elastic demand → bigger cut in consumption, less revenue
    • one tax rarely maximises both
  • It depends on information: to correct an externality, the tax should match the external cost. That is hard to measure.
  • It depends on time and side effects: PED grows in the long run; very high taxes can encourage smuggling and illegal markets.
Mission check

?A city has a fixed number of parking spaces and no space to add more. The city now charges the owners a fixed tax for each space used per day. Demand for parking is unchanged. Who bears the tax?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Make a guess: When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Mission 4

A payment per unit

A payment per unitGovernmentProducersubsidy per unitlower priceBuyer
  • A subsidy is a payment from the government to producers that lowers their costs.
  • A specific subsidy pays a fixed amount per unit.
  • Why governments use them:
    • lower prices of goods they want used more, e.g. public transport
    • support producers' incomes, e.g. farmers
    • raise output where there are external benefits
  • An export subsidy pays domestic firms for each unit they export.
Mission 4

The subsidy diagram

Subsidy incidencePrice0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityDSS − subsidysconsumers' gain: (Pe − P1) × Q1producers' gain: (P2 − Pe) × Q1Dashed box: cost to government = s × Q1welfare loss: extra units cost more thanbuyers value them
  • Build it in steps (a subsidy of s per unit):
  • 1. Start at equilibrium: Pe, Qe.
  • 2. Supply shifts down by the subsidy: S → S − subsidy. Vertical gap = s.
  • 3. New equilibrium: the price buyers pay falls to P1; quantity rises to Q1.
  • Producers receive P1 + s per unit.
  • The price falls by less than the subsidy (unless demand is perfectly inelastic or supply perfectly elastic).
  • Say: "supply increases; there is an extension of demand" — not: "demand increases".
Mission 4

Who gains, and what it costs

Subsidy incidencePrice0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityDSS − subsidysconsumers' gain: (Pe − P1) × Q1producers' gain: (P2 − Pe) × Q1Dashed box: cost to government = s × Q1welfare loss: extra units cost more thanbuyers value them
  • Cost to the government = s × Q1: the rectangle between P1 + s and P1, from 0 to Q1.
  • That rectangle splits in two:
    • consumers' gain per unit = Pe − P1
    • producers' gain per unit = (P1 + s) − Pe
  • The two gains per unit add up to the subsidy, s.
  • This split is the incidence of the subsidy.
Quick check
Market with a subsidy: areas W, X, Y, ZPrice0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityWXYS − subsidyDSZ
?The diagram shows a market before and after a subsidy of a fixed amount per unit: D, S and S − subsidy; equilibrium Pe and Qe before; P1 and Q1 after; and P2 = P1 + subsidy. Which area shows the total cost of the subsidy to the government?
AreaPosition
WRectangle between Pe and P1, from 0 to Q1
XRectangle between P2 and Pe, from 0 to Q1
YTriangle between S and D, from Qe to Q1
ZRectangle between P2 and P1, from 0 to Q1
Mission 4

Paying more than anyone gains

Subsidy incidencePrice0P2PeP1QeQ1QuantityDSS − subsidysconsumers' gain: (Pe − P1) × Q1producers' gain: (P2 − Pe) × Q1Dashed box: cost to government = s × Q1welfare loss: extra units cost more thanbuyers value them
  • The government pays for the whole rectangle.
  • Consumer and producer surplus rise by less than that.
  • The gap is a deadweight loss: the triangle between S and D, from Qe to Q1.
  • Why? The extra units cost more to make than buyers value them.
  • Also called a welfare loss: there is overallocation of resources to this good.
  • Where there are external benefits, a subsidy can instead move output toward the social optimum.
Mission 4

Worked example

  • Illustrative data. Before: P = $8, Q = 60 units.
  • Per-unit subsidy: $3. After: consumers pay $6, Q = 70; producers receive $9.
  • Government spending: $3 × 70 = $210.
  • Consumer spending: $8 × 60 = $480 → $6 × 70 = $420.
  • Producer revenue (incl. subsidy): $480 → $9 × 70 = $630.
  • CS rises by ½ × ($8 − $6) × (60 + 70) = $130.
  • PS rises by ½ × ($9 − $8) × (60 + 70) = $65.
  • Deadweight (welfare) loss: $210 − $130 − $65 = $15 = ½ × $3 × (70 − 60).
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Before a subsidy, a good sells at 10.00 per unit and 200 units are traded. After a subsidy of 4.00 per unit, consumers pay 7.00 and 260 units are traded. What is the total cost of the subsidy to the government?
Mission 4

Elasticity decides the split

Elasticity decides the split(a) Inelastic demand: consumers gain mostPrice0P2PeP1QuantityDSS − subsidy(b) Elastic demand: producers keep mostPrice0P2PeP1QuantityDSS − subsidyPerfectly inelasticdemand: consumersget it allPriceQuantityDSS − sPerfectly elasticdemand: producersget it allPriceQuantityDSS − sconsumers' gainproducers' gain
  • The side of the market that is less price elastic gets more of the subsidy.
  • Inelastic demand: the price falls a lot → consumers gain most.
  • Elastic demand: the price barely falls → producers keep most.
  • Extreme cases:
    • perfectly inelastic demand: consumers get it all; Q does not change
    • perfectly elastic demand: price unchanged; producers get it all
  • More elastic demand and supply → a bigger rise in Q (and a bigger bill).
  • Approximate consumers' share = PES ÷ (PES + |PED|).
Mission 4Graph lab

Who keeps the subsidy?

Start: a subsidy of 2 per unit; PED −0.5, PES 1. Consumers get 2/3 of each unit's subsidy.

Who keeps the subsidy?PriceQuantityQeQ1P2PeP1DSS − subsidy
  • Takeaway: more elastic demand → the price falls less, so producers keep more (consumers' share 1/3) and Q rises more.
Quick check
?A government subsidises a good to cut the price that buyers pay. In which market will buyers get the largest share of each unit's subsidy?
Mission 4

Stakeholders

  • Consumers: pay less, buy more; consumer surplus rises.
  • Producers: receive more per unit, sell more; producer surplus rises.
  • Workers: more output can mean more jobs in the industry.
  • Government: pays s × Q1. Opportunity cost: that money cannot fund schools or hospitals, or must come from taxes or borrowing.
  • Foreign producers: export subsidies help domestic firms undercut them in world markets.
  • Producers may come to depend on the subsidy, with less pressure to cut costs.
Mission 4

Case: paying the buyer instead

  • From 2023 to 30 September 2025, US buyers of qualifying new electric cars could claim a federal tax credit of up to $7,500.
  • This subsidy went to buyers, so it shifted demand up, not supply.
  • The split is the same: it depends on elasticities, not on who receives the payment.
  • If car supply is inelastic, sellers can raise prices and keep much of the credit.
Mission 4Evaluate

Is the subsidy worth it?

  • It depends on elasticities: with elastic demand, the price barely falls and most of the money goes to producers.
  • It depends on information: to correct an external benefit, the subsidy should match its size. That is hard to measure.
  • It depends on the opportunity cost: the same money could fund other spending or lower taxes.
  • It depends on time and side effects: subsidies are hard to remove once firms and voters rely on them; firms may stay inefficient.
Mission check

?A small country's wheat farmers sell all their wheat at the world price, which they are too small to change. The government pays farmers a subsidy for every tonne they grow. Who gains the subsidy?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • A binding maximum price sits below equilibrium. Quantity demanded extends, quantity supplied contracts: a shortage.
  • Non-price rationing and black markets follow. Producers lose, some consumers gain, and a deadweight loss appears.

Mission 2

  • A binding minimum price sits above equilibrium. Quantity demanded contracts, quantity supplied extends: a surplus.
  • Someone pays for the surplus: producers (unsold goods) or taxpayers (guaranteed prices).
  • Consumers pay more; sellers keep the higher price.

Mission 3

  • An indirect tax shifts supply up by the tax; the price rises by less than the tax and quantity falls.
  • The burden falls more on whichever side is less price elastic, whoever hands the money over.
  • In an efficient market the tax also creates a deadweight (welfare) loss.

Mission 4

  • A subsidy shifts supply down by the subsidy; the price falls by less than the subsidy and quantity rises.
  • The government pays s × Q1; the less elastic side of the market gets more of it.
  • In an efficient market a subsidy costs more than the gains it creates: a deadweight (welfare) loss.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Role of government (part 1) for IB Economics HL. 🎉

  1. Mission 1What happens when a government makes something cheaper by law?
  2. Mission 2Why would a government ever make something cost more?
  3. Mission 3When a government taxes sugary drinks, who really pays the tax: the shoppers or the companies?
  4. Mission 4When a government pays firms for every item they make, who ends up with the money?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to IB Economics · HL