Mission 1: Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?
Make a guess: Two countries earn the same income per person. How can one be far more developed?
Mission 1
Growth is not the same as development
Economic growth: an increase in real GDP (output) over time.
Economic development: an improvement in people's well-being and living standards. It is multidimensional:
higher incomes and less poverty
better health and longer lives
more education and skills
more freedom and choice (Amartya Sen: development as expanding what people are able to do and be)
Features of development: rising real incomes per head, falling poverty, better health and education, a shift from farming to industry and services, and wider political and social freedom.
Growth can happen without much development: the gains may go to a few, or come with pollution.
Development can happen with slow growth: cheap public health and schooling can lengthen and improve lives.
Say: "growth is a rise in real output; development is a rise in well-being" — not: "development means growth".
Mission 1
Monetary indicators
GDP per capita: output per person. GNI per capita adds net income from abroad.
Compare countries at purchasing power parity (PPP): it corrects for differences in price levels (prices tend to be lower in poorer countries).
National income data are useful: produced regularly, under common UN rules, and linked to health and schooling.
But they miss distribution, nonmarket and informal output, and the environment.
Mission 1
Non-monetary indicators
Health: life expectancy at birth, infant mortality rate, maternal mortality.
Education: adult literacy rate, years of schooling.
Inequality: Gini coefficient, income share of the richest 10%.
One indicator alone gives only part of the picture.
Quick check
?A government wants one indicator to track whether its new clinics are reducing deaths among babies. Which is best?
Mission 1
The Human Development Index (HDI)
Published by the UN Development Programme (UNDP) since 1990.
Three dimensions, four indicators:
a long and healthy life: life expectancy at birth
knowledge (education): expected years of schooling for children; mean years of schooling for adults
a decent standard of living: GNI per capita at PPP
Each dimension is scored from 0 to 1, then combined. The HDI runs from 0 to 1.
UNDP groups: very high (0.800 and above), high (0.700–0.799), medium (0.550–0.699), low (below 0.550).
Same income, but P's people live longer and learn more.
Two design features:
Income enters as a logarithm: doubling P's income to 20,000 raises HDI only to 0.756. An extra dollar matters more to the poor.
The three scores are combined by a geometric mean, so a very low score in one dimension pulls the HDI down more than a simple average would.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. Country S has a GNI per capita at PPP far higher than Country T's, but T has the higher HDI. What best explains this?
Mission 1
Why development is hard to measure
Data quality: large informal and subsistence sectors; surveys are costly and infrequent.
Averages hide distribution: a rising mean can leave the poor behind.
Value judgements: which dimensions count, and how to weight them?
Missing dimensions: freedom, security, culture and the environment are hard to put in numbers.
PPP estimates depend on price surveys that may be out of date.
Comparisons are hardest between countries with very different economies, prices and ways of life.
Mission 1
How growth and development are linked
Growth can fund development:
higher incomes for families
more tax revenue for schools, clinics, water and roads
Development can fuel growth: healthier, better-educated workers are more productive.
But growth may not bring development if:
the gains go to a few (rising inequality)
growth comes from exporting a resource that employs few people
it damages health and the environment
So the link is likely but not automatic: it depends on how the gains are shared and spent.
Mission 1Evaluate
Is HDI a better measure of development than GNI per capita?
It depends on:
The purpose: HDI captures health and education; GNI per capita at PPP better shows material living standards.
Distribution: both are averages.
What is left out: HDI has no measure of inequality, freedom, the environment or happiness.
Weights: HDI weights its three dimensions equally. That is a judgement, not a fact.
So: use HDI as a better starting point than income alone, alongside other indicators.
Mission check
?Illustrative data. Over 20 years, Country X's GNI per capita at PPP doubled, mainly from oil exports owned by a small group. Life expectancy and years of schooling barely changed. Which conclusion is best supported?
Income is one part of development, so the same money can buy very different lives.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Can a country get richer today in a way that leaves its future poorer?
Make a guess: Can a country get richer today in a way that leaves its future poorer?
Mission 2
What sustainable development means
Sustainable development: "development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs" (Brundtland Report, 1987).
Three parts that must hold together:
economic: rising incomes and output
social: health, education, fairness, less poverty
environmental: clean air and water, stable climate, renewable stocks of fish, forests and soil
Natural capital: the stock of natural resources that yields output, such as forests, fish stocks, soil and minerals.
Say: "sustainable growth" — growth that does not reduce the ability to produce in the future — not just "fast growth".
Mission 2
Growth in poorer countries: benefits and costs
Benefits:
higher incomes and fewer people in absolute poverty
more tax revenue for health, education and clean water
more jobs; more saving to fund investment
Costs:
pollution, deforestation and loss of soil and fish stocks
rising inequality if gains go mainly to some groups or regions
crowded cities and strained services as people move from the countryside
non-renewable resources (oil, minerals) used up
Whether growth is worth its costs depends on how it happens, not only how fast.
Mission 2Graph lab
Harvest now, less later
Illustrative data. A country's forest regrows by 100 units of timber a decade. Its PPC shows timber vs other goods.
Takeaway: using natural capital faster than it renews raises output now but shrinks capacity later.
Quick check
?Which policy is the clearest example of sustainable development?
Mission 2
The Millennium Development Goals (2000–2015)
In 2000, UN members agreed 8 MDGs for developing countries, with targets for 2015.
1. Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger (target: halve the poverty rate)
2. Universal primary education
3. Gender equality
4. Reduce child mortality
5. Improve maternal health
6. Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases
7. Environmental sustainability
8. A global partnership for development
Results (UN MDG Report, 2015):
extreme poverty in developing regions: 47% of people in 1990 → 14% in 2015
people in extreme poverty: 1.9 billion → 836 million
under-five deaths: 90 → 43 per 1,000 live births
Progress was uneven: China and India played a central role in the fall in poverty.
Mission 2
The Sustainable Development Goals (2015–2030)
Adopted by the UN in 2015: 17 goals, 169 targets, for 2030.
Examples: No poverty (1) · Zero hunger (2) · Quality education (4) · Clean water and sanitation (6) · Affordable and clean energy (7) · Reduced inequalities (10) · Climate action (13).
How they differ from the MDGs:
they apply to all countries, not only developing ones
they give the environment and inequality a bigger place
they aim to end poverty, not halve it
Critics: 169 targets are hard to prioritise and measure; supporters say they cover what development really means.
Mission 2
Progress on one goal in three countries
SDG target 7.1: universal access to affordable, reliable, modern energy by 2030.
Share of the population with electricity (World Bank):
Country
2015
2023
Change
Bangladesh
74%
99.5%
+25.5 percentage points
Kenya
41.6%
76.2%
+34.6 percentage points
Ethiopia
29%
55.4%
+26.4 percentage points
Bangladesh is close to the target.
Ethiopia: about 3.3 points a year. At that pace it reaches about 78.5% by 2030: short of universal access.
Why the gaps differ: grid investment, off-grid solar, income per head, how rural the population is.
Quick check
?Kenya's electricity access rose from 41.6% to 76.2% of the population between 2015 and 2023. Which statement is correct?
Mission 2Evaluate
Can growth be sustainable?
It depends on:
How growth is produced: renewable vs non-renewable resources; clean vs polluting technology.
Who gains: inclusive growth spreads gains; narrow growth can raise inequality.
Policy and institutions: property rights, pollution taxes, catch limits, and whether they are enforced.
Time horizon: costs often fall on future generations, who cannot vote today.
Measurement: GDP does not subtract the loss of natural capital, so growth figures can flatter.
Weigh the benefits of growth for the poor against its costs, and judge which matter more for the country in question.
Mission check
?Illustrative data. A coastal country raises its fish catch so that fish exports grow fast. GDP rises 6% this year. Scientists report that the fish stock is now shrinking each year, because the catch is larger than the number of new fish born. Which conclusion is best supported?
Growth is sustainable only if it does not reduce the ability of future generations to produce and meet their needs.
Mission 3
Mission 3: When rich countries give or lend to poorer ones, when does it actually help them grow?
Make a guess: When rich countries give or lend to poorer ones, when does it actually help them grow?
Mission 3
What counts as aid
Aid: a voluntary transfer of resources to a developing country on better-than-market terms.
Humanitarian aid: short-term relief after a disaster or conflict: food, shelter, medicine.
Development aid: longer-term help to raise living standards: schools, clinics, roads, water.
Bilateral aid: from one government to another. Multilateral aid: through bodies such as the World Bank.
Tied aid: must be spent on goods or services from the donor country.
Mission 3
Official development assistance (ODA)
ODA: aid from governments, given to promote the economic development and welfare of developing countries, as grants or concessional loans.
Measured by the OECD's Development Assistance Committee (DAC).
UN target: donors give 0.7% of their GNI as ODA.
2024 (OECD, preliminary): DAC donors gave 212.1 billion US dollars, 0.33% of their combined GNI. Aid fell 7.1% in real terms on 2023.
Only 4 donors went above 0.7%: Denmark, Luxembourg, Norway and Sweden.
Illustrative data: a donor with GNI of 3,000 bn giving 0.3% gives 9 bn. At 0.7% it would give 21 bn: a gap of 12 bn.
Quick check
?After an earthquake, a donor government flies in tents and medicine. Separately, it lends a poor country money at 1% interest over 40 years to build a power line, on condition that the cables are bought from the donor's own firms. Which description is correct?
Mission 3
How aid could raise growth
Step 1 of 3
Poor countries often face a savings gap: low incomes → low saving → low investment.
They may also face a foreign currency gap: too little export revenue to import machinery and fuel.
Aid can fill both gaps.
Short run: aid spent in the economy raises AD: AD1 → AD2.
Long run: aid spent on infrastructure, health and education raises productive capacity: LRAS shifts right.
Aid spent on consumption, or lost to corruption, may give only the short-run boost.
Mission 3Graph lab
Where the aid goes
Illustrative data. A country receives aid grants worth 5% of its GDP for one year.
Takeaway: aid raises long-run capacity only when it is spent on things that raise future output.
Mission 3
The case for and against aid
For:
fills the savings and foreign currency gaps
saves lives quickly in a disaster
funds merit goods (vaccination, schooling) that markets under-provide
Against:
dependency: governments may rely on aid rather than build a tax system
corruption and fungibility: aid for clinics can free other funds for less useful spending
tied aid can cost more than buying at world prices
food aid can lower prices for local farmers and cut their output
large inflows can push up the exchange rate, making exports less competitive
Economists disagree on aid's overall effect on growth. Evidence varies by country, period and type of aid.
Mission 3
Why external debt can become a trap
External debt: money owed to foreign lenders, often in a foreign currency such as US dollars.
Repayments need foreign currency, earned mainly from exports.
Worked example (illustrative data):
1. Debt: 2 bn US dollars. Exchange rate: 100 local units per dollar → debt = 200 bn local units.
2. The currency depreciates to 150 per dollar → debt = 2 × 150 = 300 bn local units: 50% more, with no new borrowing.
3. Yearly interest at 5% = 0.1 bn dollars: 10 bn local units before, 15 bn after.
Debt service: yearly interest plus repayments. Every dollar spent on it is a dollar not spent on health, education or imports of capital goods.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A country owes 500 million US dollars. Its currency falls from 10 to 12.5 local units per dollar. What happens to the debt measured in local currency?
Mission 3
Debt relief
Debt relief: cancelling, reducing or rescheduling a country's debt.
HIPC Initiative (Heavily Indebted Poor Countries), launched by the IMF and World Bank in 1996.
The Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI), from 2005, added 100% relief on eligible debts to the IMF, World Bank and African Development Fund for countries completing HIPC.
Countries had to meet conditions, including a poverty reduction strategy. By February 2023, 36 countries had completed the process (IMF), most of them in Africa.
For: frees money for health, education and infrastructure; can restore access to credit.
Against: moral hazard (governments may borrow carelessly, expecting future relief); savings may not reach the poor; lenders may lend less in future.
Say: "debt relief cuts debt service payments" — not: "debt relief gives the country new money to spend".
Mission 3
The IMF and the World Bank
Both set up at Bretton Woods in 1944. Member countries own them; votes depend largely on each country's financial contribution (its quota at the IMF, its shares at the World Bank), so richer countries have more say.
IMF (International Monetary Fund):
watches members' economies and global financial stability (surveillance)
lends to countries with balance of payments problems, usually short to medium term
loans come with conditionality: e.g. cut the budget deficit, reform taxes or the exchange rate
World Bank:
finances long-term development projects: roads, power, water, schools
lends to middle-income countries (IBRD) and gives grants and very low-interest loans to the poorest countries (IDA)
Critics: in the 1980s and 1990s, structural adjustment conditions (spending cuts, privatisation, liberalisation) were blamed for hurting the poor. Supporters say they restored stability and growth. Conditions now place more weight on protecting social spending.
Quick check
?A country cannot pay for its imports. Its currency is falling fast and it has run out of foreign currency reserves. Which body is it most likely to turn to, and on what terms?
Mission 3
NGOs and remittances
NGOs (non-governmental organisations): charities and other non-profit groups, independent of governments.
Strengths: local knowledge; work directly with communities; can reach people a weak government cannot.
Limits: small scale; patchy coordination; can depend on donations that change with the news.
Remittances: money sent home by people working abroad.
2023 (World Bank): about 656 billion US dollars went to low- and middle-income countries: more than FDI, and more than ODA, that year.
They go straight to households: they pay for food, school fees and small businesses.
But they can fall in a downturn abroad, and they do not directly build public infrastructure.
Quick check
?A government receives large aid grants for its health service. It then cuts its own health budget by the same amount and spends the money on new military aircraft. What problem does this show?
Mission 3Evaluate
Does aid help growth and development?
It depends on:
What it is spent on: infrastructure, health and education can shift LRAS; consumption gives a short-run boost at most.
Governance: corruption and weak institutions cut the share that reaches its target.
Type and terms: humanitarian vs development; tied vs untied; grants vs loans that add to debt.
Size and timing: large inflows can push up the exchange rate; aid that stops suddenly can stall projects.
Alternatives: trade access, FDI and remittances may matter more for some countries.
Judge the value: the gain in growth and welfare against costs such as dependency, debt and conditions.
Mission check
?Illustrative data. Two countries each receive aid worth 3% of GDP a year for ten years. Country P spends it on rural roads and child vaccination, and audits show little is lost. In country Q, much of it is spent on imported consumer goods and some is lost to corruption. Which outcome is most likely?
Aid can help growth when it builds productive capacity and good institutions make sure it is used well.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Can a government make a poor country richer by stepping in where markets do too little?
Make a guess: Can a government make a poor country richer by stepping in where markets do too little?
Mission 4
Why governments step in
Interventionist strategies: the state actively directs resources to raise growth and development.
The case: in poor countries, markets often fail.
Merit goods (education, health) are underconsumed.
Infrastructure is underprovided by private firms.
Infant industries cannot yet compete with established foreign firms.
Aid and loans from the World Bank and IMF can help pay for these strategies (see Mission 3).
Mission 4
Investing in people
Human capital raises productivity: education, training, health.
Education and health are merit goods: underconsumed in a free market.
Why? Information failure, positive externalities and families unable to borrow against future earnings.
Government role: free or subsidised schooling and health care; vaccination; clean water.
Limits: costly for a small tax base; quality matters as much as places; returns take decades.
Private firms underprovide it: high upfront cost, long payback, and many benefits go to people who cannot be charged.
Benefits: lower costs for firms; access to markets; healthier workers.
Risks: projects chosen for political reasons; corruption; debt if funded by borrowing.
Quick check
?Many families in a low-income country send their children to work rather than to school, even though schooling raises lifetime earnings. Which is the best explanation for this underconsumption?
Mission check
?A low-income country plans new roads linking remote villages to towns. Which is the strongest economic argument for the government, rather than private firms, to fund them?
Where benefits cannot be charged for, the market underprovides, which is the core case for intervention.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Growth is a rise in real output; development is a rise in well-being on many dimensions.
HDI combines health, education and income (GNI per capita at PPP) into one index from 0 to 1.
No single number captures development: use several indicators.
Mission 2
Sustainable development meets present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet theirs: economic, social and environmental.
MDGs (2000–2015, 8 goals) → SDGs (2015–2030, 17 goals, for all countries). Progress is uneven between countries.
Mission 3
Aid: humanitarian or development; bilateral or multilateral; grants, soft loans, tied or untied. ODA target 0.7% of GNI.
Aid raises AD now; it raises LRAS only when spent on productive capacity. Debt in foreign currency gets heavier when the currency falls; debt relief cuts debt service.
IMF: balance of payments lending with conditions. World Bank: long-term development finance. NGOs and remittances also matter.