← A-Level Economics · CCEA A-Level Economics revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCE Economics (AS and A2) · The circular flow of income; National income
Mini-Lesson

The circular flow of income; National income

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why must a country's total spending, total income and total output always be equal?
  2. Mission 2If a country's output is worth more money this year, has it really produced more?
  3. Mission 3Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why must a country's total spending, total income and total output always be equal?

Make a guess: Why must a country's total spending, total income and total output always be equal?

Mission 1

Households and firms

Two-sector flowconsumer spendingHouseholdsFirmsgoods andservicesfactorservicesfactor incomes (wages, rent, interest, profit)outer loop: money inner loop: real flows
  • The simplest model has two groups:
    • Households: own the factors of production (land, labour, capital, enterprise) and buy goods and services.
    • Firms: hire factors and produce goods and services.
  • Two flows go round in opposite directions:
    • Real flow: factor services → firms; goods and services → households.
    • Money flow: factor incomes (wages, rent, interest, profit) → households; spending → firms.
  • Assumptions of this simple model: no saving, no government, no trade. Households spend all their income.
Mission 1

Income = output = expenditure

Three views of national incomeexpenditure 500 billionHouseholdsFirmsincome 500 billionoutput500 billionwages 320 + rent 40 + interest 30 + profit 110Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data. In one year, firms produce final goods worth 500 billion.
  • Households buy them: expenditure = 500 billion.
  • Firms pay out what they receive:
    • wages 320 + rent 40 + interest 30 = 390 billion
    • the rest is profit: 500 − 390 = 110 billion, income to the firms' owners.
  • Income = 390 + 110 = 500 billion.
  • Because profit is whatever is left, total income must equal the value of output.
  • And every unit spent is someone's income. So:
    • national output = national income = national expenditure
  • Three ways to measure national income: output (value added), income (factor incomes), expenditure (spending on final output).
  • In real data, the three measures differ a little, because of measurement errors (a "statistical discrepancy").
Quick check
?Why must total income in an economy equal the total value of output, in principle?
Mission 1

Withdrawals and injections

Five-sector flowHouseholdsFirmsBanks andfinancialsectorSIGovernmentTGForeignsectorMXmoney flow: consumer spendingmoney flow: factor incomeswithdrawals: S, T, Minjections: I, G, X
  • Withdrawals (also called leakages): income not passed on as spending on domestic output.
  • Injections: spending on domestic output that does not come from households' consumption.
    • Investment (I) by firms, Government spending (G), Exports (X).
  • Withdrawals shrink the flow; injections enlarge it.
  • Say: "investment is spending by firms on capital goods" — not: buying shares, which is saving.
  • Say: "government spending (G) on goods and services" — not: transfer payments, which only move income between households.
Mission 1

The five sectors

Five-sector flowHouseholdsFirmsBanks andfinancialsectorSIGovernmentTGForeignsectorMXmoney flow: consumer spendingmoney flow: factor incomeswithdrawals: S, T, Minjections: I, G, X
  • Households: supply factors; spend, save, pay tax, buy imports.
  • Firms: produce; pay factor incomes; invest.
  • Government: collects taxes (T); buys goods and services (G); pays transfers.
  • Banks and the financial sector: take households' savings; lend to firms for investment.
  • Foreign sector: buys exports (X); sells imports (M).
  • Every sector depends on the others: one group's spending is another's income.
Quick check
?Which of these is an injection into the circular flow of Canada?
Mission 1

Equilibrium

Equilibrium: W = Jinflow: I + G + X = Joutflow: S + T + M = WJ > Wincome risesequilibrium:W = JW > Jincome fallswater level = national income
  • National income is in equilibrium when total withdrawals (W) = total injections (J):
    • S + T + M = I + G + X
  • Injections > withdrawals: more is entering the flow than leaving → national income rises.
  • Withdrawals > injections: more is leaving than entering → national income falls.
  • As income changes, withdrawals change too (more income → more saving, tax, imports), until W = J again.
  • The pairs need not match: S can be above I, as long as the totals are equal.
Mission 1

Worked example: which way will it go?

Which way will national income goJ = I + G + X = 330W = S + T + M= 300income risesnationalincomeIllustrative data, billions
  • Illustrative data, billions:
WithdrawalsInjections
Saving80Investment90
Taxation120Government spending130
Imports100Exports110
Total W300Total J330
  • J − W = 330 − 300 = 30 more entering than leaving.
  • So national income rises, until withdrawals have risen to 330.
Mission 1Graph lab

What if households save more?

Start: the economy from the previous screen, now in equilibrium with W = J = 330.

What if households save more?incomespendingW 330.0J 330HouseholdsFirmsW = S + T + M · J = I + G + X (90 + 130 + 110)startstartNationalincome
  • Takeaway: a rise in a withdrawal, with injections unchanged, shrinks the flow until W = J again.
Mission 1

Case: spring 2020

  • April 2020, United States, during COVID-19 lockdowns (first estimates):
    • Household spending fell 13.6% in one month.
    • Households saved 33% of disposable income (12.7% in March).
  • More saving = a bigger withdrawal. Less spending = less income for firms and their workers.
  • Personal income actually rose 10.5%, mainly from government benefit payments: a reminder that transfers move income but are not G.
  • Many countries saw the same pattern: saving up, spending and output down.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. An economy has saving 150, taxation 200, imports 170, investment 140, government spending 210 and exports 150 (billions). What will happen to national income?
Mission check

?Illustrative data. On a small island, firms produce final goods worth 200 million in a year. They pay 150 million in wages and 20 million in rent and interest. All output is sold. What is the island's total income for the year?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a country's output is worth more money this year, has it really produced more?

Make a guess: If a country's output is worth more money this year, has it really produced more?

Mission 2

What GDP counts

What's in, what's outCounted in GDPNew carfinal goodNew housefinal goodRestaurant mealfinal serviceNot countedSecond-hand bikecounted when it was newUnemployment benefita transfer: nothing producedBuying sharesa change of ownershipFlour sold to a bakerintermediate: in the bread's price
  • Gross domestic product (GDP): the total value of all final goods and services produced within a country in a period (usually a year or a quarter).
  • Final goods: bought by the end user. Intermediate goods (steel for a car, flour for a baker) are not added separately: their value is already in the final price.
  • Within a country: a foreign-owned factory's output counts where the factory is.
  • Not counted:
    • second-hand sales (the car was counted when it was new)
    • transfer payments (pensions, unemployment benefits): money moves, nothing is produced
    • buying shares or bonds: a change of ownership, not production
  • Say: "final goods and services" — not: "everything that is sold".
Quick check
?Which of these is counted in a country's GDP for this year?
Mission 2

Three measures, one total

Three doors to one totalExpenditureHouseholdsFirmsOutput(valueadded)IncomeOutputvalue addedby everyindustryIncomewages, rent,interest, profitExpenditureC + I + G +(X − M)GDP
  • The circular flow: every unit spent on output becomes someone's income.
  • So national output, income and expenditure measure the same flow:
    • Output method: add the value added by every industry.
    • Income method: add factor incomes: wages, rent, interest, profit.
    • Expenditure method: add spending on final output: C + I + G + (X − M).
  • In practice the data come from different surveys, so the totals differ slightly: a statistical discrepancy.
  • Say: "national output = national income = national expenditure" — not: three different sizes of economy.
Mission 2

Worked example: value added

Value-added staircase40sells 40Farmer:wheat4030sells 70Miller:flour7050sells 120Baker:bread403050= 120Value addedstackedvalue added = sales − bought-in inputsbought in from the stage beforeAdding all sales = 40 + 70 + 120 = 230: doublecounting.Illustrative data
  • Illustrative data. One loaf's journey (assume the farmer buys no inputs):
StageSells forBuys inputs forValue added
Farmer: wheat40040
Miller: flour704030
Baker: bread1207050
  • Value added = sales − cost of bought-in inputs.
  • Sum of value added = 40 + 30 + 50 = 120 = the price of the final loaf.
  • Adding every sale = 40 + 70 + 120 = 230: the wheat and flour are counted twice. That is double counting.
Mission 2

GDP, GNI and NNI

GDP to GNIIreland, 2017 (billion euros)GDP: output produced in Ireland294.1+ income residents earn abroad− income paid to foreign ownersGNI (GNP): income of residents−59.9234.2Net income from abroad = −59.9, so GNI isbelow GDP.Source: Central Statistics Office, Ireland, 2017(as published 2018).
  • GDP measures output produced in the country, whoever owns it.
  • Gross national income (GNI) = GDP + net income from abroad.
    • Net income from abroad = income residents earn abroad − income foreign owners earn here.
  • Gross national product (GNP): GDP + net property income from abroad. The same idea as GNI.
  • Ireland, 2017: GDP 294.1 billion euros; GNI 234.2 billion euros. Much of the gap is profit earned by foreign-owned firms in Ireland and paid out to their owners abroad.
  • So GNI can be the better guide to the income of a country's residents.
Quick check
?Illustrative data (billions). A country's GDP is 500. Its residents earn 30 from investments and work abroad. Foreign owners earn 45 from firms in the country. What is the country's GNI?
Mission 2

Nominal and real

Price times quantityBasket of goods(output)Price tag(price level)×tag upmore goodsNominal GDP (current prices)current tag × basketrises with output and with pricesReal GDP (constant prices)old (constant) tag × basketrises with output onlyIllustrative idea, no figures.
  • Nominal GDP: output valued at current prices. It rises if output rises or if prices rise.
  • Real GDP: output valued at constant prices. Only changes in the quantity of goods and services move it.
  • Real GDP strips out inflation, so it is the measure of economic growth.
  • Rough rule: real growth ≈ nominal growth − inflation (exact method next).
  • Say: "real GDP" when you mean output — not: "GDP went up, so output went up".
Mission 2

Worked example: the GDP deflator

DeflatingBillions02505007501000Deflator 100800800Year 1Deflator 105880838.1Year 2Nominal GDPReal GDP (Year 1 prices)higher prices: 41.9Illustrative data
  • The GDP deflator is a price index for everything in GDP. Base year = 100.
  • Real GDP = nominal GDP × 100 ÷ deflator.
  • Illustrative data (billions):
Nominal GDPDeflatorReal GDP (Year 1 prices)
Year 1800100800
Year 2880105838.1
  • Year 2 real GDP = 880 × 100 ÷ 105 = 838.1.
  • Nominal growth = (880 − 800) ÷ 800 × 100 = 10%.
  • Real growth = (838.1 − 800) ÷ 800 × 100 = 4.76%: about half the headline rise was higher prices.
Mission 2Graph lab

Money up, output up?

Illustrative data. The money flow around the economy = price level × volume of output.

Money up, output up?Money flow = price level × volumebase 1,0001,000.0Nominal GDP
  • Takeaway: nominal GDP can rise with no extra output at all; only real GDP tracks the quantity produced.
Price times quantityBasket of goods(output)Price tag(price level)×tag upsame basketNominal GDP (current prices)risesReal GDP (constant prices)unchangedIllustrative idea, no figures.
Mission 2

Per person, per worker, per year

  • Real GDP per capita = real GDP ÷ population. A bigger total can hide a smaller share per person.
  • Illustrative data, from the deflator example: Year 1, 800 billion ÷ 40 million people = 20,000 per person. Year 2, 838.1 billion ÷ 41 million = 20,441: up only 2.2%.
  • Rate of economic growth = (real GDP this year − real GDP last year) ÷ real GDP last year × 100.
  • Always use real figures, and divide by the earlier year.
Quick check
?Illustrative data. A country's real GDP was 500 billion last year and 520 billion this year. What is its rate of economic growth?
Mission check

?Illustrative data. A country's nominal GDP rose from 2,000 billion to 2,120 billion. Over the same year, its GDP deflator rose from 100 to 108. What happened to real GDP?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?

Make a guess: Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?

Mission 3

Income per person

Size vs shareLarge total GDPSmaller total GDPmany peoplefew peoplesmaller slicebigger sliceGDP per capita: one person's sliceTotal GDP = the whole pie, the size of theeconomy.
  • Living standards: how well people live.
    • Material: the goods and services they can consume.
    • Non-material: health, education, safety, free time, a clean environment.
  • Total GDP shows the size of an economy, not how well-off its people are.
  • GDP per capita = GDP ÷ population: average output, and income, per person.
  • GNP per capita adds net income from abroad, so it can be a better guide to residents' income.
Mission 3

Comparing over time

  • Use real GDP per capita: "real" removes inflation; "per capita" removes population growth.
  • Illustrative data:
Real GDPPopulationReal GDP per capita
Year 1600 billion30 million20,000
Year 2612 billion30.3 million20,198
  • Real GDP grew 2%, but output per person grew only about 1%.
  • Over long periods, take care:
    • quality improves: a phone today does far more than one 20 years ago, so GDP may understate gains.
    • new products and changes in working hours are not fully captured.
  • Comparing economies' performance: real GDP per capita growth alongside inflation, unemployment and the current account. Differences reflect investment, productivity, education and institutions.
Mission 3

Comparing countries: PPP

One basket, two pricesSame basket50 US dollarsUnited StatesSame basket1,000 zedsCountry ZPPP rate = 1,000 ÷ 50 = 20 zeds per dollarMarket rate50 zeds per dollarPPP rate20 zeds per dollarAt the market rate150,000 ÷ 50 = 3,000 dollarsAt PPP150,000 ÷ 20 = 7,500 international dollarsCountry Z's GDP per capita: 150,000 zeds.Illustrative data.
  • To compare, convert to one currency (usually US dollars).
  • Market exchange rates move with trade and capital flows, and ignore that prices differ between countries.
  • Purchasing power parity (PPP): an exchange rate at which the same basket of goods and services costs the same in both countries.
  • Illustrative data. A basket costs 50 US dollars in the US and 1,000 zeds in Country Z. PPP rate = 20 zeds per dollar. Market rate = 50 zeds per dollar.
  • Z's GDP per capita is 150,000 zeds:
    • at the market rate: 3,000 dollars
    • at PPP: 7,500 international dollars
  • Services such as haircuts and rent are usually cheaper in lower-income countries, so PPP figures raise their incomes.
  • Say: "GDP per capita at PPP" for living standards — not: at market exchange rates.
Quick check
?Country K's GDP per capita is 2,000 US dollars at market exchange rates and 6,000 international dollars at PPP. What best explains the gap?
Mission 3

What GDP misses

The GDP icebergMarket output: counted in GDPNonmarket outputHome cookingChildcareVolunteeringNot captured by GDPHidden economyLeisurePollutionDistribution
  • Nonmarket output: cooking, cleaning, caring for children or relatives, home repairs, volunteering. It is produced but not sold, so it is not in GDP.
  • Hidden economy: work not reported, to avoid tax or rules.
  • Leisure: GDP can be the same whether people work 35 or 50 hours a week.
  • Environment: pollution and lost resources are not subtracted; spending to clean up adds to GDP.
  • Health, education, safety and freedom are not measured directly.
  • Distribution: per capita is an average; it does not show who gets the income.
  • Say: "GDP measures market output" — not: "GDP measures welfare".
Quick check
?A parent leaves a paid job to look after their own child at home. The family stops paying for childcare. Nothing else changes. What happens to measured GDP?
Mission 3

Average or typical? Mean and median

  • GDP per capita is a mean: total ÷ number of people.
  • The median is the middle income when incomes are ranked: the typical person.
  • Illustrative data. Five incomes (thousands): 10, 15, 20, 25, 80.
    • Mean = 30. Median = 20.
  • Next year only the top income rises, to 130.
    • Mean = 40 (up 33%). Median = 20 (unchanged).
  • So GDP per capita can rise while the typical person is no better off.
Mission 3

HDI and social indicators

HDI: three dimensionsA long and healthy lifelife expectancy at birthKnowledgemean and expected years ofschoolingA decent standard of livingGNI per capita at PPPHDI10Each dimension is scaled from 0 to 1 andcombined into one HDI between 0 and 1.
  • Human Development Index (HDI), published by the UN Development Programme (UNDP) since 1990. Three dimensions:
    • a long and healthy life: life expectancy at birth
    • knowledge: mean years of schooling (adults) and expected years of schooling (children)
    • a decent standard of living: GNI per capita at PPP
  • Each is scaled from 0 to 1 and combined: HDI runs from 0 to 1.
  • Countries with similar GNI per capita can have very different HDI scores, because health and education differ.
  • Other indicators: literacy rate, infant mortality, access to clean water, doctors per 1,000 people, internet access.
  • Limits of HDI: only three dimensions, fixed weights; it ignores inequality and the environment.
Quick check
?Countries X and Y have the same GNI per capita at PPP. X has higher life expectancy and more years of schooling than Y. Which statement is correct?
Mission 3Evaluate

How useful is GDP per capita for comparing living standards?

It depends on:

  • What you compare: between countries, use PPP; over long periods, quality and new products are hard to capture.
  • The nonmarket and hidden economy: larger in some countries, so their output is understated more.
  • Distribution: the same mean can hide very different median incomes.
  • What else differs: working hours, health, environment, freedom.
  • But: GDP data are regular, follow international rules (the UN System of National Accounts), and tend to go with better health and education.
  • So: use GDP per capita alongside other indicators, not alone.
Mission check

?Real GDP per capita in Country P is 20% higher than in Country Q, measured in the same prices. Which finding would most weaken the claim that people in P have a higher material living standard?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Spending by one sector is income to another, so national output = national income = national expenditure.
  • Withdrawals (S, T, M) leave the flow; injections (I, G, X) enter it. Equilibrium: S + T + M = I + G + X.

Mission 2

  • GDP: the value of final goods and services produced within a country in a period.
  • Output, income and expenditure measure the same flow; value added avoids double counting.
  • GNI (GNP) = GDP + net income from abroad.
  • Real GDP = nominal GDP × 100 ÷ deflator. Only real GDP measures growth in output.
  • Growth rate = change in real GDP ÷ earlier year × 100; per capita = ÷ population.

Mission 3

  • Real GDP per capita is the usual starting point for comparing living standards.
  • Between countries, convert at PPP, not market exchange rates.
  • GDP leaves out nonmarket output.
  • It also misses the hidden economy, leisure, the environment and distribution.
  • HDI adds health and education to income.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Circular flow of income; National income for CCEA A-level Economics. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why must a country's total spending, total income and total output always be equal?
  2. Mission 2If a country's output is worth more money this year, has it really produced more?
  3. Mission 3Can a country's income tell you how well its people really live?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Economics · CCEA