← ❄️ Winter lessons · Home
⭐ 0
Winter History · KS3 · the Little Ice Age: evidence, interpretation, causation
❄️ Winter HistoryMini-Lesson

The Little Ice Age

3 missions and a finale. Frost fairs, a quiet Sun and two historians who disagree. Guess, learn, then check.

  1. Mission 1Why did the River Thames freeze — and then stop freezing?
  2. Mission 2Did the Sun go quiet?
  3. Mission 3Was the cold a disaster — or did people adapt?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why did the River Thames freeze — and then stop freezing?

Make a guess: Why did the River Thames freeze — and then stop freezing?

Mission 1

A fair on the ice

Pulses, not a blockGreat Famine1315–17Tambora 1815lost summer 1816Maunder Minimum1645–1715130014001500160017001800first frost fair 1607–081684 fairlast fair 1814new London Bridge 1831coldest century in NW Europe:the 1600s'Little Ice Age' glacier growth in the Alpsc. 1300–1950Dated events from the sources;not a temperature graph.
  • Between the early 1600s and the early 1800s the Thames at London froze over about 24 times.
  • When it did, Londoners set up stalls on the ice: a frost fair. The first recorded one was in the winter of 1607–08.
  • The last was in 1814. None since.
  • The cold years come in pulses across 1300–1850, not one solid block.
Mission 1

Evidence: a diary, January 1684

  • John Evelyn kept a diary. On 9 January 1684 he wrote that the ice had "become so thick as to bear not only streets of booths, in which they roasted meat, and had divers shops of wares, quite across as in a town, but coaches, carts, and horses passed over."
  • Written at the time by someone who was there: a primary source.
  • A week earlier, on 1 January, he had noted air so cold "as of many years there had not been the like": unusual even then.
Quick check
?Evelyn says coaches and carts crossed the ice in January 1684. What can we safely conclude from this entry alone?
Mission 1

What makes a river freeze

Why a river freezesWide, shallow, slowNarrow, deep, fastriver bedriver bedfreezes easilyhard to freezeFlow shown by arrow length; no measurements
  • Still, shallow water freezes far more easily than deep, fast water.
  • The Thames at London was then wider and shallower than today, and slow-moving.
  • Cold alone is not the whole story. The shape of the river matters too.
Mission 1

Old London Bridge

Old London BridgeOld London Bridge: 19 narrow archesstarlings: pier basesthat narrow the gapsupstreamdownstreamice and debris jamwater held back and slowedslowed water freezes more easily
  • The medieval stone bridge (1209–1832) stood on 19 closely spaced arches.
  • Ice and debris jammed the arches, damming the river and slowing it further.
  • The slowed water froze more easily.
Quick check
?Which change would make the Thames less likely to freeze over?
Mission 1

The river is rebuilt

Before and afterBefore 183119 arches · wide, shallowslow flowice across the riverAfter: later 1800s5 arches · narrow, deepfastdeepwalldredged · embanked · 5 arches
  • 1831: a new London Bridge opened with only 5 arches. The old bridge came down in 1832.
  • Later in the 1800s the river was dredged and lined with embankments.
  • The Thames became too deep and too fast to freeze over fully again.
  • Fewer very cold winters after the mid-1800s were part of it. The rebuilt river was the other part.
Mission 1

Test the explanation: 1963

  • Winter 1962–63 was one of the coldest on the UK instrumental record.
  • The Thames froze over upstream at Windsor and Reading. In central London, no frost fair.
  • A good explanation survives a test: the cold came back; the slow, shallow river did not.
Mission check

?Why did the River Thames freeze — and then stop freezing?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Did the Sun go quiet?

Make a guess: Did the Sun go quiet?

Mission 2

The missing sunspots

The missing sunspotsMaunder Minimum 1645–1715161016251650167517001715estimated yearly sunspot number16121625–26spots seen, not countedSketch from Eddy (1976), Table 1
  • Astronomers have counted sunspots through telescopes since 1610.
  • Normally they rise and fall in a cycle of about 11 years.
  • From 1645 to 1715 they almost vanished. This gap is called the Maunder Minimum.
  • Named after Edward Maunder, a Greenwich astronomer who, using Gustav Spörer's work, traced the gap in old records in the 1890s.
Mission 2

Two things at once

  • The quiet Sun overlaps the 1600s, most likely north-west Europe's coldest century of the last thousand years.
  • Two things happening together is a correlation.
  • A correlation is a clue. On its own it does not show which caused which, or whether something else caused both.
Quick check
?Sunspots were rare from 1645 to 1715, and north-west Europe's coldest century was the 1600s. On its own, what does this show?
Mission 2

A volcano and a lost summer

Tambora to EuropeEuropeNew EnglandIndonesiaTambora · Apr 1815 · VEI 7sulfur haze spreads worldwide, 1815–16cold, wet summer 1816
  • April 1815: Tambora, on Sumbawa in Indonesia, erupted. Rated VEI 7, the largest eruption in recorded history.
  • Tens of thousands died nearby. Sulfur gases spread high around the globe and dimmed sunlight.
  • 1816 was cold across Europe and North America: frosts all summer in New England, failed harvests, hunger. People called it the year without a summer.
Mission 2

Switzerland, summer 1816

  • Mary Shelley spent that summer in Switzerland, by the lake, as Lord Byron's neighbour. She later wrote: "it proved a wet, ungenial summer, and incessant rain often confined us for days to the house."
  • Indoors, they read ghost stories and agreed each to write one. She began Frankenstein.
  • Her account is evidence of the weather. Linking that weather to Tambora is scientists' interpretation.
Quick check
?Which of these is an interpretation, not a piece of evidence?
Mission 2

Weighing the causes

Weighing the causesEddy, 1976?Sunvolcanoes,oceansMiller et al., 2012?Sunvolcanoes,sea iceSame evidence, different weighting
  • Sun: in 1976 the astronomer John Eddy argued the sunspot gap matched the coldest part of the period.
  • Volcanoes and oceans: in 2012 Gifford Miller's team argued clusters of eruptions started the cold, and sea ice and ocean feedbacks kept it going. They concluded that big changes in the Sun were not needed to explain it.
  • Same evidence, different weighting of causes. The debate continues.
Mission check

?Did the Sun go quiet?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Was the cold a disaster — or did people adapt?

Make a guess: Was the cold a disaster — or did people adapt?

Mission 3

1315: rain and hunger

  • From 1315 northern Europe had years of heavy rain and hard winters. Harvests failed.
  • The Great Famine (1315–17, in places to 1322) killed on a scale remembered for centuries.
  • The historian William Chester Jordan argues the famine came from weather plus animal disease, prices, war and social conflict. Not weather alone.
Quick check
?Jordan argues the Great Famine came from a mix of causes, not bad weather alone. Which statement best fits his view?
Mission 3

One diary entry, two pictures

  • Evelyn, 24 January 1684, on the fair: "a bacchanalian triumph, or carnival on the water".
  • Same entry, same sentence: "while it was a severe judgment on the land", with trees splitting and cattle dying.
  • Fuel was so dear "that there were great contributions to preserve the poor alive".
  • One source can show celebration and hardship at once.
Quick check
?What does Evelyn's entry for 24 January 1684 show?
Mission 3

Painted winters

A crowd on the icemost: skating for funworkinga horse that frozeAfter the kind of scene Avercamp painted, c. 1608
  • Dutch artists painted frozen canals. Hendrick Avercamp's Winter Landscape with Ice Skaters (c. 1608, Rijksmuseum) shows hundreds on the ice.
  • Most are skating for pleasure; a few, the museum notes, are there to work, not play. In one corner lies a horse that froze to death.
  • A painting is evidence of what the painter chose to show.
Mission 3

Two historians, one period

Two interpretationsInterpretationsthe same century's evidenceParker 2013coldfailedharvestshunger+ wars,taxes,weak statesrevolt and warDegroot 2018coldnew routes,skills and tradeDutch RepublicprospersBoth built from evidence;different questions, different places
  • Interpretation 1: Geoffrey Parker (Global Crisis, 2013) argues cold weather ruined harvests, and hunger fed the revolts and wars of the 1600s.
  • Interpretation 2: Dagomar Degroot (The Frigid Golden Age, 2018) argues the Dutch Republic prospered in the same cold, turning it to advantage in trade and war.
  • Both are built from evidence. They ask different questions about different places.
Quick check
?Why can two historians study the same cold period and reach different conclusions?
Mission check

?Was the cold a disaster — or did people adapt?
Finale

Was it even one "Little Ice Age"?

Coldest century, by region1400s1600s1600s1400s · central and eastern Pacific1600s · NW Europe, SE North Americamid-1800s · most other regionsColdest century · after Neukom et al., 2019 (simplified)
  • In 2019 a team led by Raphael Neukom tested the label against records from across the world.
  • The coldest century differed by region: the 1400s in the central and eastern Pacific, the 1600s in north-west Europe and south-east North America, the mid-1800s in most other regions.
  • They found no sign of a globally coherent cold period. The label is a convenient generalisation, not one event.
  • By contrast, the warmest period of the last 2,000 years fell in the 1900s for more than 98% of the globe.
Finale

A snowflake, 1611

  • In the winter of 1610–11 Johannes Kepler, in Prague, asked why snowflakes always have six corners.
  • He wrote it up as a New Year's gift for a friend: Strena seu de Nive Sexangula (1611).
  • He could not answer it. The science lesson on this hub picks up where he left off.
Quick check
?A textbook says "the Little Ice Age caused the frost fairs". What is the problem with this sentence?
Recap

The big ideas

  • Europe's cold years c. 1300–1850 came in pulses, and the coldest century differed from region to region.
  • A diary shows what one person saw. Causes need more evidence than one source.
  • The Thames fairs ended for two reasons: fewer very cold winters, and a river rebuilt to run deep and fast.
  • Correlation is a clue, not a cause. Scientists still weigh Sun, volcanoes and oceans differently.
  • Same evidence, different questions: historians can disagree and both be rigorous.
  • "The Little Ice Age caused…" is a sentence to be suspicious of.
❄️

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've finished The Little Ice Age. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why did the River Thames freeze — and then stop freezing?
  2. Mission 2Did the Sun go quiet?
  3. Mission 3Was the cold a disaster — or did people adapt?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a mate to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

❄️ More winter lessons

📚 Sources for this lesson (24)
  1. Department for Education, National curriculum in England: history programmes of study (statutory guidance, 2013), "Purpose of study" aims and "Key stage 3" subject content. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-curriculum-in-england-history-programmes-of-study/national-curriculum-in-england-history-programmes-of-study — aims wording quoted in Coverage; KS3 content headings.
  2. R. Neukom, N. Steiger, J. J. Gómez-Navarro, J. Wang and J. P. Werner, "No evidence for globally coherent warm and cold periods over the preindustrial Common Era", Nature 571 (2019), 550–554 (PAGES 2k contribution). https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1401-2 — "the coldest epoch of the last millennium—the putative Little Ice Age—" most likely coldest in the 1400s in the central/eastern Pacific, the 1600s in NW Europe and SE North America, the mid-1800s elsewhere; "no evidence for preindustrial globally coherent cold and warm epochs"; 20th century warmest for more than 98% of the globe. Used in 2.2, F.1, D1, D10, F.3.
  3. J. A. Matthews and K. R. Briffa, "The 'Little Ice Age': re-evaluation of an evolving concept", Geografiska Annaler A 87 (2005), 17–36. Abstract via UEA research portal: https://research-portal.uea.ac.uk/en/publications/the-little-ice-age-re-evaluation-of-an-evolving-concept/ — glacier-based definition c. AD 1300–1950 (Alps), climate-based c. 1570–1900, Alpine highstands c. 1650 and 1850, "considerable spatial and temporal variation". Used in D1 and the Points section.
  4. John Evelyn, The Diary of John Evelyn, ed. William Bray, vol. 2 (Washington and London: M. Walter Dunne, 1901), entries for 1 January 1683–84, 6, 9, 16 and 24 January and 5 February 1684. Project Gutenberg eBook #42081, plain-text file. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42081 — all Evelyn quotations in 1.2, 1.3, 3.3, 3.4. Evelyn died 1706; Bray died 1832; text is public domain.
  5. London Museum, "Frost fairs: festivities on a frozen River Thames". https://londonmuseum.org.uk/collections/london-stories/frost-fairs-festivities-frozen-river-thames — Thames froze 24 times early 1600s to early 1800s; first recorded frost fair winter 1607–08; 1683–84 fair; last fair 1814; Old London Bridge 1209–1832 with 19 closely spaced arches that broke up and dammed the flow; river wider and shallower then; "A new, wider London Bridge with only five arches replaced the medieval crossing in 1831"; river later dredged and embanked; "too deep and too fast-flowing to fully freeze over again"; cold winters became less frequent as the climate warmed. Used throughout Mission 1.
  6. History Today, "A Fair on the Frozen Thames" (Months Past column; author and issue not shown on the fetched page). https://www.historytoday.com/node/53724 — corroborates "19 narrow arches and their breakwaters slowed the stream down" and that the 1831 five-arch bridge "helped bring the freezing of the Thames to an end". Secondary corroboration only.
  7. University of Reading, Department of Meteorology, Weather and Climate Discussion blog, "The winter of 1962/63". https://blogs.reading.ac.uk/wcd/?p=1715 — "one of the coldest on the UK instrumental record"; January 1963 fifth-coldest month in the Central England Temperature series; "By 18 January the Thames had frozen over completely at Reading and Windsor." Used in 1.8.
  8. John A. Eddy, "The Maunder Minimum", Science 192, no. 4245 (18 June 1976), 1189–1202, DOI 10.1126/science.192.4245.1189 (citation confirmed via Crossref). Table 1, "Estimated annual mean sunspot number, R, from 1610 to 1715", as hosted by NOAA National Geophysical Data Center: https://ngdc.noaa.gov/stp/space-weather/solar-data/solar-indices/sunspot-numbers/ancient/eddy/eddy(1976)_science.pdf — values for D5; telescope record from 1610; minimum from 1645. The abstract itself could not be opened (paywall), so Eddy's argument is characterised via source 9 and source 23.
  9. I. G. Usoskin and 15 co-authors, "The Maunder minimum (1645–1715) was indeed a Grand minimum: a reassessment of multiple datasets", Astronomy & Astrophysics (2015), arXiv:1507.05191. https://arxiv.org/abs/1507.05191 (abstract and PDF) — Maunder Minimum "occurring during the interval 1645–1715 (Eddy, 1976)"; earlier suggestions that activity was moderate or high; review of telescopic, naked-eye, auroral and cosmogenic-isotope data concluding activity was "exceptionally low"; Dalton minimum c. 1790–1830. Used in 2.1, 2.8 option D.
  10. High Altitude Observatory (NCAR/UCAR), "Edward Walter Maunder (1851–1928)". https://www2.hao.ucar.edu/education/scientists/edward-walter-maunder-1851-1928 — joined Royal Observatory Greenwich 1873; using Spörer's work, identified the 1645–1715 lull in the 1890s (paper 1894). Used in 2.1.
  11. US Geological Survey, Hawaiian Volcano Observatory, "Volcano Watch — Infamous Mount Tambora is rumbling again" (29 September 2011). https://www.usgs.gov/observatories/hvo/news/volcano-watch-infamous-mount-tambora-rumbling-again — April 1815 eruption peaking 10–11 April; VEI 7; over 70,000 deaths in surrounding areas; about 60 megatons of sulfur; "Frosts in New England occurred throughout the summer, resulting in almost total failure of major crops"; crop failures and unrest in Europe; 1816 one of the coldest summers of the past six centuries (tree rings). Used in 2.4.
  12. NOAA NESDIS, "This Day in History: Mount Tambora explosively erupts, 1815" (10 April 2020). https://www.nesdis.noaa.gov/news/day-history-mount-tambora-explosively-erupts-1815 — VEI 7; eruption 5–10 April 1815; "largest volcanic eruption ever recorded"; 1816 "The Year Without A Summer"; crop failures in North America, Western Europe and parts of Asia. Used in 2.4.
  13. C. Oppenheimer, "Climatic, environmental and human consequences of the largest known historic eruption: Tambora volcano (Indonesia) 1815", Progress in Physical Geography 27, no. 2 (2003), 230–259 (citation confirmed via Crossref; abstract not accessible). Named in the brief; the lesson's Tambora figures are taken from sources 11 and 12, not from this paper.
  14. J. Luterbacher and C. Pfister, "The year without a summer", Nature Geoscience 8 (2015), 246–248. https://www.nature.com/articles/ngeo2404 — Tambora "caused an unusually cold summer in much of Europe in 1816", poor harvests and malnutrition. Used in 2.4–2.6 for the Europe link.
  15. Mary W. Shelley, Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus (London: Colburn and Bentley, 1831), author's Introduction: "In the summer of 1816, we visited Switzerland… But it proved a wet, ungenial summer, and incessant rain often confined us for days to the house." Project Gutenberg eBook #42324. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42324 — quotation in 2.5. Shelley died 1851; published 1831; public domain.
  16. Smithsonian Institution, Global Volcanism Program, Tambora. https://volcano.si.edu/volcano.cfm?vn=264040 — 1815 eruption VEI 7. Used to corroborate 2.4 and D6.
  17. G. H. Miller and 12 co-authors, "Abrupt onset of the Little Ice Age triggered by volcanism and sustained by sea-ice/ocean feedbacks", Geophysical Research Letters 39 (2012), L02708, DOI 10.1029/2011GL050168. Abstract via NCAR: https://impacts.ucar.edu/en/publications/abrupt-onset-of-the-little-ice-age-triggered-by-volcanism-and-sus/ — cold summers and ice growth began abruptly 1275–1300 and intensified 1430–1455, coinciding with volcanically disturbed half-centuries; sea-ice/ocean feedbacks sustain the cold; "large changes in solar irradiance are not required". Used in 2.7, 2.8, D7.
  18. Princeton University Press, catalogue page for William Chester Jordan, The Great Famine: Northern Europe in the Early Fourteenth Century (Princeton, 1996; paperback 1998). https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691058917/the-great-famine — dates 1315–1322; "frighteningly high mortality"; "years of inundating rains and brutal winters"; causes include animal disease, harvest failures, price volatility, class conflict and war-related breakdowns in distribution. Used in 3.1, 3.2.
  19. Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, Hendrick Avercamp (1585–1634), Winter Landscape with Ice Skaters, c. 1608, oil on panel, 77.3 × 131.9 cm, object SK-A-1718. https://www.rijksmuseum.nl/collectie/SK-A-1718 (also via Europeana https://www.europeana.eu/en/item/90402/SK_A_1718) — "Hundreds of people are out on the ice, most of them for pleasure, others working out of dire necessity"; crows and a dog on a horse that froze to death. Used in 3.5, D8.
  20. Cambridge University Press, catalogue page for Dagomar Degroot, The Frigid Golden Age: Climate Change, the Little Ice Age, and the Dutch Republic, 1560–1720 (Studies in Environment and History, 2018). https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/FD88D1B4AFA571C02A33D34B65484928 — the Republic "thrived" while neighbours struggled; the cold brought "not only challenges… but also opportunities" exploited in trade, warfare and culture. Used in 3.6, 3.7, D9.
  21. Geoffrey Parker, Global Crisis: War, Climate Change and Catastrophe in the Seventeenth Century (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2013). Publication details confirmed via the review listing in Central European History 48/4 (2015), 565–566 (Anya Zilberstein) https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/D782DD3ACB19E1CA28CC441C615D000C; thesis and criticisms summarised from Andrew Coburn's review for the Cambridge Centre for Risk Studies (27 Dec 2014) https://risk-studies-viewpoint.blog.jbs.cam.ac.uk/?p=158 and the Complete Review's digest of press reviews https://complete-review.com/reviews/ghistory/parkerg.htm — cold → harvest failure → famine → unrest, revolt and war; reviewers' charge of determinism. Used in 3.6, 3.7, D9. The Yale catalogue page could not be opened.
  22. St Edmund Hall, University of Oxford, Library blog, "Johannes Kepler on snowflakes, or what to give someone who has everything". https://www.seh.ox.ac.uk/blog/johannes-kepler-on-snowflakes — Strena seu De niue sexangula, Frankfurt 1611; New Year's gift to his friend and patron Wacker von Wackenfels; the six-corner question; Kepler's inconclusive ending. Corroborated by University of Oklahoma Libraries, Galileo's World exhibit, "Snowflake, or the Six-Angled Crystal" https://galileo.ou.edu/exhibits/snowflake-or-six-angled-crystal (1611, Frankfurt, 24 pages) and the Paul Dry Books edition page https://www.pauldrybooks.com/products/the-six-cornered-snowflake (walk across the Charles Bridge in 1610). Used in F.2.
  23. International Association of Meteorology and Atmospheric Sciences (IAMAS), obituary "Jack Eddy (1931–2009)". https://www.iamas.org/irc/?p=554 — Eddy's 1976 Science paper argued that the Maunder Minimum (1645–1715) and the earlier Spörer Minimum coincided with the coldest parts of the Little Ice Age, raising the possibility that solar irregularities affect Earth's climate; the obituary notes the idea "is still a matter of scientific debate". Added at review to corroborate the characterisation of Eddy in 2.7 and D7.
  24. US Geological Survey, Volcano Hazards Program, "Volcanoes Can Affect Climate". https://www.usgs.gov/programs/VHP/volcanoes-can-affect-climate — sulfur dioxide converts to sulfate aerosols in the stratosphere, which "increase the reflection of radiation from the Sun back into space, cooling the Earth's lower atmosphere"; names Tambora 1815. Added at review to source "dimmed sunlight" in 2.4 and the haze in D6.

→ GCSE History revision