← IB World Religions · SL · IB Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
IB Diploma World Religions SL · Part 2: In-depth study – Judaism (part 3 of 3)
Mini-Lesson

Judaism (part 3)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why do Jews pray the same words three times a day, and why is the best gift a job?
  2. Mission 2If the Torah holds 613 commandments, why did only ten go on the stone tablets?
  3. Mission 3Why does a book of Jewish law contain a chapter of advice on how to be a good person?
  4. Mission 4Jewish law says break Shabbat to save a life. Could it ever allow weapons that kill millions?
  5. Mission 5Can a few cells in a dish, which could never grow into a baby there, be used to save lives?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why do Jews pray the same words three times a day, and why is the best gift a job?

Make a guess: Why do Jews pray the same words three times a day, and why is the best gift a job?

Mission 1

Tefillah: judging yourself

Hitpallelhitpallel"to pray"reflexive verb"to judge oneself"prayer as spiritual self-reflection before Goda common explanation of the reflexive form
  • Tefillah = prayer. The verb hitpallel ("to pray") is reflexive: often explained as "to judge oneself".
  • So prayer is spiritual self-reflection before God, not only asking for things.
  • The rabbis call it "service of the heart": Deuteronomy 11:13 commands serving God "with all your heart"; the Talmud asks what that service is and answers: prayer (Ta'anit 2a).
  • Kavanah: inner intention and focus; prayer without it is "a body without a soul" (a later saying, often quoted).
Mission 1

Why pray?

  • Praise, requests and thanks: the three movements of Jewish prayer.
  • Instead of sacrifices: since the Temple fell (70 CE), prayer takes their place: "so will we render for bullocks the offering of our lips" (Hosea 14:2 [Heb. 14:3], JPS 1917).
  • Following the patriarchs: Abraham prayed in the morning, Isaac in the afternoon, Jacob at night (Berakhot 26b).
  • Relationship: prayer speaks to a personal God who listens.
  • Community: Jews mostly pray in the plural ("our God", "heal us"), for the whole people.
  • For many Jews, prayer is the main religious experience of daily life: a regular meeting with God.
Mission 1

The Amidah: three parts

The Amidah3 praise1God of the patriarchs2God's power3God's holiness13 requests4knowledge5repentance6forgiveness7redemption8healing9good harvest10gathering of exiles11justice12against slanderers13for the righteous14rebuilding Jerusalem15the Messiah16hearing prayer3 thanks17for worship18for daily miracles19for peaceweekday: 19 blessingsShabbat and festivalsthe 13 requests are replaced by one blessingfor the day: 3 + 1 + 3 = 7
  • Amidah = "standing" prayer; also Shemoneh Esrei ("eighteen") or simply ha-Tefillah, "the Prayer".
  • Originally 18 blessings; a 19th was added at Yavneh (c. 1st century CE).
  • 3 praise: God of the patriarchs; God's power (giving rain, reviving the dead); God's holiness.
  • 13 requests: knowledge, repentance, forgiveness, redemption, healing, good harvest, gathering of exiles, justice, against slanderers, for the righteous, rebuilding Jerusalem, the Messiah, hearing prayer.
  • 3 thanks: for worship, for daily miracles, for peace.
  • On Shabbat and festivals the 13 requests are replaced by one blessing for the day (7 in all): no weekday requests on a day of rest.
Mission 1Read the source

How the Amidah begins

> "O Lord, open Thou my lips; and my mouth shall declare Thy praise." (Psalm 51:15 [Heb. 51:17], JPS 1917)

> "Now Hannah, she spoke in her heart; only her lips moved, but her voice could not be heard …" (1 Samuel 1:13, JPS 1917)

  • The Amidah opens with Psalm 51's verse; it is said silently, lips moving, as Hannah prayed (Berakhot 31a).
  • Jews stand with feet together, face Jerusalem, take three steps forward at the start and three back at the end, and bow at set points.
  • The Amidah is said three times a day: morning, afternoon and evening.

Q1 What does asking God to "open my lips" suggest about prayer?

Show answer

Even the ability to pray is a gift from God.

Q2 Why might Hannah be a model for silent prayer?

Show answer

She spoke "in her heart": prayer is personal and inward, not a show.

Mission 1Diversity

How Jews pray

How Jews prayOrthodoxLanguageHebrew siddurSeatingapart (mechitzah)Who leadsmenDistinctiveset timesMasortiLanguagetraditional Hebrew liturgySeating, leadingmostly egalitarianReform / LiberalLanguagemore in the vernacularSeatingmixedWho leadswomen rabbis and cantorstooDistinctivemusic, instruments; sometexts changed, e.g. matriarchsaddedHasidicDistinctivejoyful, intense prayer;niggunim (wordlessmelodies); swaying; Breslov:hitbodedut
  • Orthodox: Hebrew siddur; set times; men and women seated apart (mechitzah); men lead.
  • Masorti: traditional Hebrew liturgy; mostly egalitarian.
  • Reform / Liberal: more prayer in the vernacular; music and instruments; mixed seating; some texts changed (e.g. the matriarchs added to the first blessing; "who gives life to all" offered beside "who revives the dead").
  • Hasidic: joyful, intense prayer; wordless melodies (niggunim); swaying; Breslov Hasidim also practise hitbodedut, private spontaneous prayer.
  • Women's prayer: Orthodox women's groups; progressive women rabbis and cantors.
Mission 1

Fixed words, living intention

  • Keva = fixed (set words and times); kavanah = intention.
  • Rabbi Eliezer (Mishnah Berakhot 4:4, paraphrase): if prayer is a fixed routine, it is not true supplication.
  • Fixed words give structure: they teach what to ask for and carry a person when their own words fail.
  • Risk: routine can become empty ritual.
  • Responses: personal additions in the Amidah (e.g. in "hear our prayer"); Hasidic stress on kavanah; Reform creative liturgy.
Mission 1

Tzedakah is justice

Tzedek and tzedakahtzedekjustice,righteousnesstzedakahgiving as a duty10% (a tenth, ma'aser): custom · 20% (a fifth):rabbinic maximum (Ketubot 50a)
  • Tzedakah comes from tzedek, "justice" or "righteousness": giving is a duty, not optional charity.
  • "Thou shalt not harden thy heart, nor shut thy hand from thy needy brother" (Deuteronomy 15:7, JPS 1917).
  • The rich hold wealth in trust from God; the poor have a right to help.
  • Even a person who lives on tzedakah must give some (Gittin 7b).
  • Custom: give a tenth (ma'aser) of income; the rabbis set a maximum of a fifth (Ketubot 50a), so the giver is not made poor.
  • Homes and schools keep a pushke (collection box); many give before Shabbat.
  • "Righteousness delivereth from death" (Proverbs 10:2, JPS 1917): the Hebrew word is tzedakah.
Mission 1

Maimonides' ladder

Maimonides' ladderMishneh Torah 10:7–141helping someone becomeself-sufficient: a gift, loan,partnership or job2giver and receiver do notknow each other3giver knows; receiver does not4receiver knows; giver does not5giving before being asked6giving after being asked7giving less than is fitting, butgladly8giving grudgingly↑ more dignitymore independence ↑
  • Maimonides (1138–1204), Mishneh Torah, Laws of Gifts to the Poor 10:7–14: eight levels, highest first.
  • 1. Helping someone become self-sufficient: a gift, a loan, a partnership or a job.
  • 2. Giver and receiver do not know each other.
  • 3. Giver knows; receiver does not.
  • 4. Receiver knows; giver does not.
  • 5. Giving before being asked.
  • 6. Giving after being asked.
  • 7. Giving less than is fitting, but gladly.
  • 8. Giving grudgingly.
  • Two values rise up the ladder: the receiver's dignity and independence.
Quick check
?On Maimonides' ladder, which ranks higher: giving a fitting amount after being asked, or giving the same amount before being asked?
Mission check

?Four people help a neighbour whose bakery has closed. Which help ranks highest on Maimonides' ladder?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If the Torah holds 613 commandments, why did only ten go on the stone tablets?

Make a guess: If the Torah holds 613 commandments, why did only ten go on the stone tablets?

Mission 2

A mitzvah is a commandment

The 613 mitzvot613 mitzvot248 positive"do"365 negative"do not"Talmud, Makkot 23b
  • Mitzvah (plural mitzvot) means commandment: something God commands, not just a kind act.
  • The Talmud counts 613 mitzvot in the Torah: 248 positive ("do") and 365 negative ("do not") (Makkot 23b).
  • Many apply only in the Land of Israel, in Temple times or to priests; fewer than 300 can be kept by most Jews today.
  • A Jew becomes bar or bat mitzvah, "son" or "daughter of the commandment": now responsible for keeping them.
  • Keeping mitzvot is how Jews live out the covenant made at Sinai.
Mission 2

Towards God, towards people

Towards God, towards peoplebein adam la-Makombetween a person and Gode.g. Shabbat, prayer, kashrutbein adam la-chaverobetween a person andanother persone.g. honesty, charity, not gossipingBoth kinds are commands of God
  • The rabbis sort mitzvot by direction:
  • Bein adam la-Makom: between a person and God (e.g. Shabbat, prayer, kashrut).
  • Bein adam la-chavero: between a person and another person (e.g. honesty, charity, not gossiping).
  • Both kinds are commands of God: wronging a person is also a sin against God.
  • Mishnah Yoma 8:9 (paraphrase): Yom Kippur atones for sins against God; for sins against another person, you must first put things right with that person.
Mission 2Read the source

"Even the ten words"

> "I am the LORD thy God, who brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage." (Exodus 20:2, JPS 1917)

> "And He declared unto you His covenant, which He commanded you to perform, even the ten words; and He wrote them upon two tables of stone." (Deuteronomy 4:13, JPS 1917)

  • The Torah calls them the ten words (Hebrew aseret ha-devarim); the rabbis call them Aseret ha-Dibrot, the Ten Sayings.

Q1 Why is "Ten Sayings" a better name than "Ten Commandments" for Exodus 20:2?

Show answer

It is a statement about God and the Exodus, not an order.

Q2 What does Deuteronomy 4:13 link the ten words to?

Show answer

The covenant God commanded Israel to keep.

Mission 2

Two tablets

Two tabletsTablet 1Tablet 21I am the LORDyour God6do not murder2no other gods, noidols7do not commitadultery3do not take God'sname in vain8do not steal4keep Shabbat9no false witness5honour fatherand mother10do not covetbetween people andGodbetween peoplesaying 5: parents are partners with God inmaking a person (Kiddushin 30b)
  • The usual Jewish count:
  • Tablet 1: (1) I am the LORD your God · (2) no other gods, no idols · (3) do not take God's name in vain · (4) keep Shabbat · (5) honour father and mother.
  • Tablet 2: (6) do not murder · (7) do not commit adultery · (8) do not steal (the Talmud reads this as kidnapping) · (9) no false witness · (10) do not covet.
  • Common reading: tablet 1 is between people and God, tablet 2 between people.
  • Why are parents on tablet 1? The Talmud calls God, father and mother partners in making a person (Kiddushin 30b).
  • Christians number them differently (most start with "no other gods"): do not mix the two systems.
  • Many rabbis read the Ten as headings that hold all 613: e.g. "keep Shabbat" heads the festival laws, "do not steal" heads honest trade (Rashi on Exodus 24:12).
Quick check
?In the usual Jewish count, which of these is the first of the Ten Sayings?
Mission 2Diversity

Orthodox, Reform, Hasidic

Orthodox, Reform, HasidicSourceBinding?EmphasisOrthodoxall 613 fromGod (Torah minha-shamayim)every mitzvahthat can bekept todayOral Torahfixes howReformwritten byinspiredhumansethical mitzvot:"binding onlyits moral laws"(Pittsburgh1885)ritual byinformedchoice; 1999:more ritualencouragedHasidicas Orthodox:from Godfully; oftenstricter (hiddurmitzvah)joy, kavanah,devekutMasorti (Conservative)halakhah binding but developing
  • Orthodox: all 613 come from God (Torah min ha-shamayim, "Torah from heaven"); every mitzvah that can be kept today is binding; the Oral Torah fixes how.
  • Reform: the Torah was written by inspired humans; the ethical mitzvot remain central; ritual mitzvot are chosen by informed choice. Pittsburgh Platform (1885): "we accept as binding only its moral laws". Later Reform statements (Pittsburgh 1999) encourage more ritual practice.
  • Hasidic: fully Orthodox in practice, often stricter (hiddur mitzvah, beautifying the mitzvah); stress joy, kavanah (intention) and devekut (clinging to God) while doing each mitzvah.
  • Masorti (Conservative) Jews hold halakhah binding but developing.
Mission 2

Free to choose, responsible for the choice

Free to chooseRabbis teach two inclinationsyetzer ha-raselfish driveyetzer ha-tovgood driveDeut 30:19"choose life"mitzvot train the first andstrengthen the secondpikuach nephesh (saving life)overrides almost every mitzvah
  • "I have set before thee life and death … therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19, JPS 1917): humans are free to obey or disobey.
  • Rabbis teach two inclinations: yetzer ha-ra (selfish drive) and yetzer ha-tov (good drive); mitzvot train the first and strengthen the second.
  • Rabbi Akiva (Avot 3:15, paraphrase): all is foreseen by God, yet freedom of choice is given.
  • Individual reasoning: halakhah needs judgement: weighing which mitzvah applies, asking a rabbi, and (for Reform Jews) personal autonomy.
  • Top principle: pikuach nephesh, saving life, overrides almost every mitzvah (see Mission 4).
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the Reform approach to the 613 mitzvot set out in the Pittsburgh Platform of 1885?
Mission check

?Maya notices that fair prices and the festival laws are not on the stone tablets. She concludes that they matter less than the ten that are. Which response best reflects the rabbinic teaching in this mission?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why does a book of Jewish law contain a chapter of advice on how to be a good person?

Make a guess: Why does a book of Jewish law contain a chapter of advice on how to be a good person?

Mission 3

A tractate about character

Where Pirkei Avot sitsthe Mishnah (c. 200 CE)Nezikin"damages": civil andcriminal law, courtsand judgesPirkei AvotPirkei Avot: sayings about wisdom, study andcharacter, among the legal tractates
  • Pirkei Avot ("Chapters of the Fathers"; also "Ethics of the Fathers"): a tractate of the Mishnah (c. 200 CE).
  • Unlike the rest of the Mishnah, it has almost no law: it collects sayings of the sages about wisdom, study, character and how to treat others.
  • It sits in the order Nezikin ("damages"): civil and criminal law, courts and judges.
  • Why there? Many explain: judges and those who apply law need good character. The Talmud says whoever wants to be pious should keep the laws of Nezikin; another sage says, "the matters of Avot" (Bava Kamma 30a, paraphrase).
  • Many communities study a chapter of Avot on Shabbat afternoons in the summer.
Mission 3Read the source

Avot 1:1

Avot 1:1: the chain and three sayingsSinaiMosesJoshuathe eldersthe prophetsMen of the Great AssemblyThey said three things:Be careful injudgementRaise upmanystudentsMake a fencearound theTorah

Pirkei Avot 1:1 (paraphrase):

  • Moses received the Torah at Sinai and handed it on to Joshua; Joshua to the elders; the elders to the prophets; the prophets to the Men of the Great Assembly.
  • They said three things: Be careful in judgement. Raise up many students. Make a fence around the Torah.

Q1 What does the opening chain claim about the sages' teaching?

Show answer

It comes in an unbroken line from Sinai, so it carries Moses' authority.

Q2 What might "a fence around the Torah" mean?

Show answer

Extra rules that keep people well away from breaking a commandment.

Mission 3

What the world stands on

What the world stands onSimeon the Righteous (1:2)the world stands onTorahstudyavodahworshipgemilutchasadimloving-kindnessRabban Simeon ben Gamaliel (1:18)the world endures onjusticetruthpeace
  • Simeon the Righteous (1:2): the world stands on three things: Torah (study), avodah (worship; once the Temple service) and gemilut chasadim (acts of loving-kindness).
  • Rabban Simeon ben Gamaliel (1:18): the world endures on three things: justice, truth and peace, citing "execute the judgment of truth and peace in your gates" (Zechariah 8:16, JPS 1917).
  • So the chapter begins with study and worship and ends with justice in society.
  • Ethics is not an extra: it holds the world up.
Quick check
?According to Simeon the Righteous in Avot 1:2, the world stands on three things. Which list is correct?
Mission 3

Sayings of the sages

All paraphrases from Avot 1:

  • Antigonus (1:3): do not serve God like servants working for a reward.
  • Joshua ben Perachiah (1:6): get yourself a teacher, gain a friend, and judge everyone favourably.
  • Hillel (1:12): be a disciple of Aaron: love peace, pursue peace, love people and bring them near to Torah.
  • Hillel (1:14): If I am not for myself, who will be for me? If I am only for myself, what am I? If not now, when?
  • Shammai (1:15): make study a fixed habit; say little and do much; greet everyone cheerfully.
  • Simeon (1:17): not study but action is the main thing.
Mission 3

The Noahide Code

The Noahide Code and the 613 mitzvotall humanity: 7 Noahide lawsset up courts ofjusticedo not blasphemedo not worship idolsno sexual immoralityno murderno theftdo not eat flesh torn from a living animalJews:613 mitzvotSanhedrin 56a. Non-Jews who keep the seven:"righteous among the nations".
  • The rabbis teach that God gave all humanity, through Noah, seven laws (Talmud, Sanhedrin 56a):
  • Set up courts of justice; do not blaspheme; do not worship idols; no sexual immorality; no murder; no theft; do not eat flesh torn from a living animal (cf. Genesis 9:4).
  • Universal values: non-Jews who keep these are "righteous among the nations" and have a share in the world to come (Tosefta Sanhedrin 13:2; Maimonides).
  • Jewish distinctiveness: Jews are bound by 613 mitzvot as the covenant people; others need not convert to be righteous.
  • So most Jewish communities do not actively seek converts.
Mission 3Read the source

Love, justice, holiness

Love, justice, holinessimitate God's qualitiesholiness"Ye shall be holy; for I the LORD your Godam holy." (Leviticus 19:2)love"thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself"(Leviticus 19:18)justice"Justice, justice shalt thou follow"(Deuteronomy 16:20)Shabbat 133b (paraphrase): as God is gracious

> "Ye shall be holy; for I the LORD your God am holy." (Leviticus 19:2, JPS 1917)

> "thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I am the LORD." (Leviticus 19:18, JPS 1917)

> "Justice, justice shalt thou follow" (Deuteronomy 16:20, JPS 1917)

  • God as the source of moral values: Jewish teaching is that humans are to imitate God's qualities. The Talmud (Shabbat 133b, paraphrase): as God is gracious and merciful, so you be gracious and merciful.

Q1 What reason does Leviticus 19:2 give for being holy?

Show answer

Because God is holy.

Q2 Why might "justice" be repeated in Deuteronomy 16:20?

Show answer

The rabbis read it as stress: pursue justice, and by just means.

Mission 3

Gemilut chasadim

Greater than charitytzedakah(charity)gemilutchasadimMeansmoneybody and moneyTo whomthe poorrich and poorWhenthe livingthe living andthe deadSukkah 49b (paraphrase)
  • Gemilut chasadim: acts of loving-kindness, one of the three pillars (Avot 1:2).
  • Greater than charity (Sukkah 49b, paraphrase): charity uses money, kindness uses body and money; charity is for the poor, kindness for rich and poor; charity is for the living, kindness for the living and the dead.
  • Examples: visiting the sick (bikur cholim), hospitality, comforting mourners, burying the dead, free loans.
  • Imitating God: God clothed Adam, visited Abraham, comforted Isaac, buried Moses: Jews are to do the same (Sotah 14a, paraphrase).
Quick check
?Why do the rabbis say gemilut chasadim is greater than tzedakah (charity)?
Mission check

?A Jewish volunteer spends Sunday mornings driving elderly neighbours, Jewish and not, to hospital appointments, refusing any payment. Which teaching from this mission fits best?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Jewish law says break Shabbat to save a life. Could it ever allow weapons that kill millions?

Make a guess: Jewish law says break Shabbat to save a life. Could it ever allow weapons that kill millions?

Mission 4

Every life a world

Every life a worldone lifea whole worldMishnah Sanhedrin 4:5 (paraphrase)destroy one life: as if destroying a whole world;save one life: as if saving a whole world
  • Sanctity of life: Jews believe human life is holy because it comes from God and belongs to God.
  • Humans are made "in the image of God" (Genesis 1:27, JPS 1917), so in Jewish teaching killing a person attacks God's image (Genesis 9:6).
  • Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:5 (paraphrase): whoever destroys one life is as if they destroyed a whole world; whoever saves one life, as if they saved a whole world.
  • In Jewish teaching, every life has infinite value: one life is not worth less than many.
  • "Thou shalt not murder" (Exodus 20:13, JPS 1917).
Mission 4Read the source

"He shall live by them"

> "Ye shall therefore keep My statutes, and Mine ordinances, which if a man do, he shall live by them: I am the LORD." (Leviticus 18:5, JPS 1917)

> "… neither shalt thou stand idly by the blood of thy neighbour: I am the LORD." (Leviticus 19:16, JPS 1917)

  • Talmud (Yoma 85b, paraphrase): "live by them", not die by them. The mitzvot are given for life.

Q1 How does Yoma 85b use Leviticus 18:5 to justify breaking a mitzvah?

Show answer

The mitzvot exist for life, so when keeping one would cost a life, life comes first.

Q2 What extra duty does Leviticus 19:16 add?

Show answer

A duty to act to rescue, not only to avoid killing.

Mission 4

Pikuach nefesh overrides

What pikuach nefesh overridespikuach nefesh"watching overa life"Shabbatdrive tohospitalkashrutnon-kosherfood,medicinefastingbreak a fastoverrides almost every mitzvah
  • Pikuach nefesh = "watching over a life": saving a life overrides almost every mitzvah.
  • Examples: driving to hospital on Shabbat; eating non-kosher food or medicine when needed; breaking a fast.
  • It is a duty, not just a permission: the person who acts fastest is praised (Yoma 84b).
  • It applies in doubt too: if a life might be at risk, act.
  • Many Jews see it as showing the Torah's purpose: "Her ways are ways of pleasantness" (Proverbs 3:17, JPS 1917).
Mission 4

The limits

The three exceptionsthe three exceptionsidolatrymurderforbiddensexualrelationsdie rather than commit (Sanhedrin 74a)
  • Three exceptions (Sanhedrin 74a): a Jew must die rather than commit idolatry, murder or forbidden sexual relations.
  • On murder the Talmud asks: "Who says your blood is redder?" You may not kill an innocent person to save yourself (Sanhedrin 74a; Pesachim 25b).
  • So pikuach nefesh does not allow trading one life for another.
  • It applies to an identifiable person in danger; how far it reaches to future or unknown people is debated (key for embryo research).
  • Applied to war: weapons that kill without telling fighters from civilians trade countless lives, so many Jews see them as breaking these limits; others stress self-defence and deterrence. Jews disagree.
Quick check
?Which situation is NOT permitted by the principle of pikuach nefesh, according to the Talmud?
Mission 4

Who decides?

  • Halakhah gives room for individual judgement in danger.
  • Mishnah Yoma 8:5 and Yoma 83a (paraphrase): on Yom Kippur a sick person is fed if doctors say so; if the patient says they need food, feed them even against the doctors.
  • "The heart knoweth its own bitterness" (Proverbs 14:10, JPS 1917): the person in danger knows.
  • Jerusalem Talmud (Yoma 8:5, paraphrase): the one who stops to ask a rabbi first, when a life is at stake, is like one who sheds blood.
  • Orthodox Jews normally ask a rabbi (posek) on hard questions; Reform Jews stress personal autonomy and conscience.
Mission 4

Seeking peace

Swords into plowsharesswordplough blade"they shall beat their swords into plowshares… neither shall they learn war any more"(Isaiah 2:4)
  • "Seek peace, and pursue it" (Psalm 34:14 [Heb. 34:15], JPS 1917): peace must be actively pursued.
  • Hope for the future: "they shall beat their swords into plowshares … neither shall they learn war any more" (Isaiah 2:4, JPS 1917).
  • Shalom means wholeness, not just no fighting; the Talmud calls Shalom a name of God (Shabbat 10b).
  • The Amidah ends with a prayer for peace (see Mission 1).
Quick check
?On Yom Kippur a doctor says a patient can fast safely, but the patient says she feels she must eat. What does the Talmud teach?
Mission check

?On Shabbat, Eli sees smoke pouring from a neighbour's flat. He is not sure anyone is inside. What does pikuach nefesh require of him?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Can a few cells in a dish, which could never grow into a baby there, be used to save lives?

Make a guess: Can a few cells in a dish, which could never grow into a baby there, be used to save lives?

Mission 5

When does a person begin?

When does a person begin?legal status in halakhah (not biology)up to 40 days"mere water"Yevamot 69b40 days to birth"a limb of itsmother"Chullin 58aat birtha full nefesh(person)Ohalot 7:6;Sanhedrin 72bpotential life: protected throughout
  • In halakhah the unborn child's status grows with time:
  • Up to 40 days after conception: "mere water" (Yevamot 69b), a striking phrase for its low legal status.
  • After 40 days: like "a limb of its mother" (Chullin 58a): part of her body, not yet a separate person.
  • At birth (when the head emerges): a full nefesh (person) (Mishnah Ohalot 7:6; Sanhedrin 72b).
  • Before birth, the mother's life comes first: if a birth endangers her life, the fetus is removed (Mishnah Ohalot 7:6, paraphrase).
  • But the unborn child is still potential life, never valueless: harming it without serious reason is forbidden.
Mission 5Read the source

A fine, not a life

> "And if men strive together, and hurt a woman with child, so that her fruit depart, and yet no harm follow, he shall be surely fined …" (Exodus 21:22, JPS 1917)

> "But if any harm follow, then thou shalt give life for life," (Exodus 21:23, JPS 1917)

  • The rabbis read "harm" as the death of the woman.

Q1 What penalty is given for the loss of the unborn child?

Show answer

A money fine.

Q2 What does this suggest about the fetus's status compared with the mother's?

Show answer

It is valued, but not equal to a born person: only her death brings "life for life".

Mission 5

The unborn child and abortion

Mishnah Ohalot 7:6Mishnah Ohalot 7:6 (paraphrase)before birthif the birth endangers the mother's life, thefetus is removed: her life comes firstonce the greater part has emergedone life may not be set aside for anotherTalmud's version (Sanhedrin 72b) andMaimonides: the head
  • Mishnah Ohalot 7:6 (paraphrase): if a birth endangers the mother's life, the fetus is removed, for her life comes first; once the greater part (in the Talmud's version, Sanhedrin 72b: the head) has emerged, one life may not be set aside for another.
  • Maimonides (Laws of the Murderer 1:9) calls the fetus that threatens the mother a rodef ("pursuer").
  • Orthodox: abortion is allowed (sometimes required) to save the mother's life; some authorities also allow it for grave risk to her health, including mental health; never for convenience.
  • Reform and Liberal: the decision belongs to the woman, guided by Jewish values and conscience; support legal access.
  • No Jewish view treats the fetus as worthless; none treats it as fully equal to the mother before birth.
Quick check
?According to Mishnah Ohalot 7:6, what happens if continuing a birth will kill the mother?
Mission 5

Embryos and stem cells

Embryonic stem cellsearly embryoabout 5 daysstem cellsmany types of celltaking the stem cells destroys the embryo14-day limit (UK)UK: research on embryos only up to 14 days(HFE Act 1990)
  • Stem cells can become many types of cell; embryonic stem cells (from an embryo about 5 days old) can become almost any.
  • Taking them destroys the embryo. Most come from spare IVF embryos, made for fertility treatment and not used.
  • Hope: treatments for diseases such as Parkinson's, diabetes, spinal injury (pikuach nefesh).
  • UK law allows research on embryos only up to 14 days (Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990).
  • Alternatives: adult stem cells; induced pluripotent cells (adult cells reprogrammed, since 2006).
Mission 5

An embryo outside the womb

In the womb or in the dishin the wombcan developin a dishcannot develop alonemany rabbisless status than even a 40-day fetus:destroying it is not murderothers warnstill potential human life; making embryos todestroy them treats life as a tool
  • A pre-implantation embryo in a dish cannot develop into a baby unless placed in a womb.
  • Many rabbis argue it has less status than even a 40-day fetus: it is not "in its mother" at all.
  • So destroying it is not murder, and some say not abortion either.
  • Others warn: it is still potential human life; creating embryos to destroy them treats life as a tool.
  • Israel's law, shaped partly by these rabbinic views, permits embryonic stem-cell research and bans reproductive cloning.
Quick check
?Why do many Orthodox rabbis permit research on spare IVF embryos?
Mission check

?A rabbi is asked about three cases: a 5-day embryo frozen in a fertility clinic; a 10-week fetus in the womb; a baby whose head has emerged during birth. How do most Orthodox authorities rank their status, lowest first?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Tefillah is self-reflection before God, the "service of the heart"; the Amidah (19 blessings: praise, requests, thanks) is said silently, standing, three times a day.
  • Tzedakah is justice, a duty; Maimonides ranks gifts by dignity and independence, with self-sufficiency at the top.

Mission 2

  • A mitzvah is a commandment from God; the Talmud counts 613, between people and God and between people.
  • The Ten Sayings (Aseret ha-Dibrot) begin with God's self-introduction; rabbinic tradition (Saadia, Rashi) reads them as ten categories of the 613.
  • Orthodox Jews hold all 613 binding; Reform Jews treat ethical mitzvot as binding and ritual as informed choice; Hasidic Jews keep Orthodox practice with stress on joy and intention.
  • Humans are free to choose and responsible for their choices; pikuach nephesh overrides almost every mitzvah.

Mission 3

  • Pirkei Avot, a Mishnah tractate in Nezikin, opens with the chain of transmission and collects the sages' ethical sayings.
  • The world stands on Torah, worship and gemilut chasadim (1:2), and endures on justice, truth and peace (1:18).
  • The Noahide Code gives universal values; in Jewish teaching, love, justice and holiness reflect God's own qualities.

Mission 4

  • In Jewish teaching, life is holy because humans are made in God's image; saving one life is like saving a world.
  • Pikuach nefesh overrides almost every mitzvah, even in doubt; it never permits idolatry, murder or forbidden relations.

Mission 5

  • The unborn child's status grows: "mere water" up to 40 days, part of the mother after, a full person at birth; the mother's life comes first.
  • Many Orthodox rabbis permit research on spare embryos outside the womb, as not yet persons, under pikuach nefesh; others urge caution.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Judaism (part 3) for IB World Religions SL. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why do Jews pray the same words three times a day, and why is the best gift a job?
  2. Mission 2If the Torah holds 613 commandments, why did only ten go on the stone tablets?
  3. Mission 3Why does a book of Jewish law contain a chapter of advice on how to be a good person?
  4. Mission 4Jewish law says break Shabbat to save a life. Could it ever allow weapons that kill millions?
  5. Mission 5Can a few cells in a dish, which could never grow into a baby there, be used to save lives?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to IB World Religions · SL