Mission 1: Why do people commit crimes, and is breaking the law always the same as doing wrong?
Make a guess: Why do people commit crimes, and is breaking the law always the same as doing wrong?
Mission 1
Crime and sin
A crime breaks the law of the state. The state punishes it (courts, fines, prison).
A sin breaks God's law or a religious teaching. It damages a person's relationship with God.
Many acts are both: murder and theft are crimes and sins ("You shall not murder", "You shall not steal": Exodus 20:13; Exodus 20:15).
Some sins are not crimes in the UK: e.g. lying to a friend, adultery, greed.
Some crimes may not be sins: e.g. breaking an unjust law out of conscience.
An absolutist treats some acts as always sinful whatever the law says; a relativist lets culture and situation decide.
Quick check
?Which act would many Christians call a sin, even though it is not a crime in the UK?
Mission 1Read the source
The woman caught in adultery
John 8:1–11: religious leaders bring a woman caught in adultery to Jesus. The Law of Moses allowed stoning. They ask what he says.
"He who is without sin amongst you, let him throw the first stone at her." (John 8:7)
One by one, they leave.
"Neither do I condemn you. Go your way. From now on, sin no more." (John 8:11)
Q1 What does Jesus suggest about those who judge others?
Show answer
No one is free of sin, so judges must be humble.
Q2 Does Jesus say the sin does not matter?
Show answer
No: "sin no more". He offers mercy and a fresh start, not approval.
Christians draw from it: condemn the wrong, not the person; offer the chance to change.
Mission 1Evaluate
"Someone who steals because they are poor should not be punished."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: poverty limits real choice. Society shares the blame for poverty. Christians: Jesus showed mercy (John 8:11). Help with the cause (food, work) may stop it happening again.
Reasons against: theft still harms a victim, who deserves justice. Most poor people do not steal, so it is still a choice. The commandment "You shall not steal" (Exodus 20:15) makes no exception for need. Excusing it may encourage more crime.
Middle positions: a lighter or different sentence (community service, support) that takes need into account.
Judge it by: Is the person responsible? What does the victim deserve? Which response best prevents future crime?
Mission check
?In one country a new law forbids a religious minority from meeting to pray. A Christian woman holds a peaceful prayer meeting in her home and is arrested. How would most Christians describe what she did?
Crime breaks the law of the state; sin breaks God's law. Why someone did it shapes how believers respond to them.
Mission 2
Mission 2: When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?
Make a guess: When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?
Mission 2
What punishment is for
Punishment: a penalty given by a lawful authority (a court, a judge) to someone who has broken the law.
It is not revenge: it follows fair rules, and fits the crime.
Why society needs it: to keep order, to protect people, and to show that laws matter.
Why it can be justice: the offender is treated fairly, and the victim's harm is recognised.
Religions agree that wrongdoing has consequences. They differ on what punishment should mainly aim to do.
Mission 2
Retribution, deterrence, reformation
Retribution: the offender gets what they deserve; the punishment fits the crime. Looks back at the crime.
Deterrence: punishment puts the offender, and others, off committing crimes. Looks forward.
Reformation: helping the offender change, so they become a law-abiding member of society (education, courses, counselling). Looks forward.
Your spec calls reformation rehabilitation.
Quick check
?A judge says: "This sentence must send a clear message to anyone else thinking of carrying a knife." Which aim is the judge stressing?
Mission 2
Strengths and weaknesses
Retribution: strength: fair to victims; the punishment fits the crime. Weakness: can look like revenge; does not stop future crime.
Deterrence: strength: may prevent crime before it happens. Weakness: many crimes are done in anger, under the influence, or by people who expect not to be caught; punishing one person to warn others can seem unfair.
Reformation: strength: the offender may change, so less reoffending; respects human worth. Weakness: not every offender wants to change; victims may feel it is too soft.
A critical evaluation asks of each aim: is it just to the offender, to the victim and to society?
Mission 2Read the source
Christian teachings on punishment
"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot" (Exodus 21:24)
"he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." (Romans 13:4)
"Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness" (Galatians 6:1)
Exodus 21:24 limits punishment to what fits the crime: retribution in proportion, not unlimited revenge.
Romans 13:4: the state has God-given authority to punish (retribution, deterrence).
Q1 Which source supports reformation?
Show answer
Galatians 6:1: restore such a one.
Q2 Which source gives the state the right to punish?
Show answer
Romans 13:4.
Mission 2Diversity
Christian views on the aims
All Christians: the state may punish (Romans 13); punishment must be just and respect the offender's dignity.
Catholic teaching (Catechism 2266, paraphrase): punishment first redresses the disorder the crime caused (retribution), and should also protect public safety and help correct the offender.
Many Christians stress reformation: Jesus came to call sinners to repentance; no one is beyond change.
Some, often more conservative, Christians give more weight to retribution and deterrence (Exodus 21:24; Romans 13:4).
Quakers and many others: punishment should heal; they support reform and restorative justice (see Mission 3).
Quick check
?A prison chaplain leads a course that helps prisoners face what they did and plan a new life. Which Christian teaching supports her aim most directly?
Mission 2
Non-religious views
Humanists: no afterlife or divine judgement, so punishment should do good in this life: protect the public, reform offenders, reduce crime.
Many stress evidence: what actually lowers reoffending (education, treatment for addiction, restorative justice).
Utilitarian thinkers: punishment is justified only by its good results (deterrence, protection, reform).
Other non-religious thinkers defend retribution: offenders deserve a penalty that fits the crime, whatever the results.
Religious responses: many agree; some add that justice also matters before God.
Mission 2Evaluate
"Reformation is the most important aim of punishment."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: offenders can change; Galatians 6:1: restore the wrongdoer. It protects society in the long run. It respects human worth.
Reasons against: victims deserve justice (retribution; Exodus 21:24). Some offenders will not change, so the public needs protection. Without deterrence, crime may rise. Romans 13:4 gives the state a duty to punish.
Another view: the aims work together: a just sentence can punish, protect and reform at once (Catholic teaching).
Judge it by: What does the victim need? Can the offender change? What best reduces future crime?
Mission check
?A school catches a pupil vandalising the science lab. The head makes him repaint it on Saturdays, meet the technician he upset, and join a mentoring scheme. Which aims of punishment does this mainly show?
The same punishment can serve several aims; what matters is which aim it mainly serves, and why.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Make a guess: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Mission 3
Forgiveness, repentance, reconciliation
Forgiveness: choosing to let go of anger and the wish for revenge against someone who has wronged you.
It is not pretending the wrong did not happen, and not saying it was acceptable.
Repentance: being truly sorry for wrongdoing and turning away from it (metanoia in Christianity; teshuvah in Judaism; tawbah in Islam).
Reconciliation: restoring a broken relationship, so both sides can live in peace again.
Mission 3Read the source
Jesus on forgiveness
"Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me, and I forgive him? Until seven times?" Jesus said to him, "I don't tell you until seven times, but, until seventy times seven." (Matthew 18:21–22)
"For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you don't forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses." (Matthew 6:14–15)
On the cross: "Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing." (Luke 23:34)
Q1 What does "seventy times seven" mean?
Show answer
Forgive without limit; stop counting.
Q2 Why does Matthew 6:14–15 link our forgiving to God's?
Show answer
Christians who refuse to forgive close themselves to God's forgiveness.
Mission 3
Forgiveness and punishment
The tension: if Christians must forgive without limit, should offenders be punished at all?
Most Christians answer: forgiveness is personal; justice is the state's duty (Romans 13:4). A victim can forgive and still want a fair sentence.
Punishment can itself serve the offender's good: it helps them face the wrong and change.
Example: Pope John Paul II was shot in 1981 by Mehmet Ali Ağca. In 1983 he visited Ağca in prison and forgave him, yet Ağca stayed in prison.
Catholic teaching: show mercy to criminals, as God shows mercy to all; the Sacrament of Reconciliation shows God's forgiveness for the repentant.
Some argue the other way: punishing someone you have forgiven still looks like holding on to the wrong.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes what most Christians mean by forgiveness?
Mission 3Diversity
Different Christian and non-religious views
Unconditional forgiveness: many Christians forgive whether or not the offender repents, following Jesus on the cross (Luke 23:34).
Conditional forgiveness: others point to "If he repents, forgive him" (Luke 17:3); full reconciliation needs repentance.
Catholic teaching: God's forgiveness is offered to all and received through repentance, especially in the Sacrament of Reconciliation; Catholics are called to forgive as they are forgiven.
Humanists: forgiveness can heal both victim and offender and help society; but it is a choice, not a duty, and victims should never be pressured to forgive.
Some non-religious people argue some acts should not be forgiven, out of respect for victims.
Mission 3
Restorative justice
Restorative justice: the offender and the victim (or the community) meet, with a trained facilitator, if both agree.
The victim can explain the harm; the offender takes responsibility, apologises and agrees how to repair it.
Aims: healing for victims; reformation of offenders; less reoffending; reconciliation.
Christian support: reconciliation is at the heart of the Gospel (Matthew 5:24; 2 Corinthians 5:18). Prison Fellowship's Sycamore Tree course teaches it in prisons.
Criticisms: not suitable for every crime; some victims find it painful; some say it is too soft without other punishment.
Mission 3
Examples of forgiveness
Gordon Wilson (Methodist): his daughter Marie was killed in the Enniskillen bombing in 1987. He said he bore the bombers no ill will and prayed for them; he later worked for peace.
Gee Walker (Christian): her son Anthony was murdered in a racist attack in Liverpool in 2005. She said she forgave his killers, because of her faith.
Azim Khamisa (Muslim): his son Tariq was shot by a 14-year-old in 1995. He forgave the boy and set up a foundation with the boy's grandfather to stop youth violence.
Each acted from personal belief; none said the crime did not matter.
Quick check
?In a restorative justice meeting, a burglar meets the elderly woman whose house he broke into. What is the meeting mainly for?
Mission 3Evaluate
"Some actions are unforgivable."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: some crimes (murder, genocide) cause harm that can never be repaired. Forgiving may seem to disrespect victims. Some offenders show no repentance. Humanists: forgiveness is a choice, not a duty.
Reasons against: Jesus taught "seventy times seven" and forgave on the cross. Examples like Gordon Wilson and Gee Walker show it is possible.
Another view: forgiving the person is possible, while the act stays wrong and justice is still done.
Judge it by: Who has the right to forgive? Must the offender repent? Does forgiveness cancel punishment?
Mission check
?A football fan was badly injured when a rival fan attacked him. In court, the injured man says he forgives his attacker, but he also asks the judge to give a fair sentence. Most Christians would say this is:
Forgiveness lets go of revenge; justice deals with the wrong. Most believers hold that you can offer one without cancelling the other.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?
Make a guess: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?
Mission 4
What the death penalty is
Capital punishment (the death penalty): the state lawfully executes a person for a crime. A crime that can carry it is a capital offence.
Purpose: retribution (a life for a life), deterrence, and protection of society.
Great Britain: the last executions were in 1964; it was abolished for murder in 1965 (permanently from 1969). Northern Ireland: last execution 1961, abolished for murder 1973. Abolished across the UK for all crimes by 1998.
It is still used in some countries, e.g. China, Iran, Saudi Arabia and some US states.
Some people in the UK still call for it to return for the worst murders.
Mission 4
Arguments for
Retribution: some crimes are so evil that only death is a just penalty.
Deterrence: fear of death may stop people killing.
Protection: an executed murderer can never kill again.
Justice for victims' families: some feel the crime has been taken seriously.
Principle of utility (Jeremy Bentham, 1748–1832): the right act brings the greatest happiness for the greatest number. If executions deter murder and save many innocent lives, a utilitarian could support them.
Mission 4
Arguments against
Sanctity of life: many believers hold that all life is sacred and given by God, so only God may end it, a murderer's life included.
Mistakes cannot be undone: Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 and pardoned in 1966; Derek Bentley was hanged in 1953 and his conviction quashed in 1998.
No clear evidence that it deters better than long prison sentences; many murders happen in anger or panic.
No chance to reform or repent.
Utility can argue against: executions may brutalise society and wrongful executions cause great harm, so it may not produce the greatest happiness.
Quick check
?Which argument about the death penalty is based on the principle of utility?
Mission 4Read the source
Scripture on both sides
"Whoever sheds man's blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image." (Genesis 9:6)
"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot" (Exodus 21:24)
"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil" (Matthew 5:38–39)
Q1 Which passages are used to support the death penalty?
Show answer
Genesis 9:6 and Exodus 21:24.
Q2 How does Matthew 5:38–39 challenge "an eye for an eye"?
Show answer
Jesus calls his followers not to take revenge.
Mission 4
How Catholic teaching developed
St Augustine (354–430): the state may use the sword (Romans 13), but in letters to officials (Letter 134 to Apringius; Letter 153 to Macedonius, c. 414) he begs for the lives of the condemned, so they have time to repent (paraphrase).
St Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 64, a. 2: if a person is dangerous to the community, "it is praiseworthy and advantageous that he be killed in order to safeguard the common good".
Pope John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae 56 (1995): only allowed when there is no other way to defend society; such cases are "very rare, if not practically non-existent".
Pope Francis (2018) revised the Catechism (2267): the death penalty is "inadmissible", an attack on the dignity of the person; the Church works for its abolition worldwide.
Catholics see this as a development in understanding: modern prisons can protect society without killing.
Mission 4Diversity
Christian views today
Most UK churches oppose it: Catholic, Church of England, Methodist, Quaker and others. Reasons: sanctity of life; Jesus' teaching on revenge and love of enemies (Matthew 5:38–48); no one is beyond redemption; mistakes.
Some Christians support it, often conservative Christians (e.g. many in some US churches): Genesis 9:6 comes before the Law of Moses and applies to all humanity; Romans 13:4 gives the state the sword.
Supporters add: justice is not revenge; the state, not the individual, punishes.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how Catholic teaching on the death penalty has developed?
Mission 4
Non-religious views and situation ethics
Humanists (e.g. Humanists UK) oppose it: this life is the only one; mistakes cannot be put right; no clear evidence it deters; it brutalises society.
Utilitarian arguments can go either way: it depends on the evidence about results.
Some atheists support it for the worst crimes, on grounds of retribution or protection.
Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape). Most who use it reject executions as unloving; some argue a rare case might protect many. Religious responses: love includes justice, but also the chance to repent.
Mission 4Evaluate
"The death penalty is never right."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: sanctity of life (Exodus 20:13; Genesis 1:27); Jesus rejected revenge (Matthew 5:38–39); innocent people have been executed; no clear deterrent effect; Catholic teaching calls it inadmissible; Humanists oppose it.
Reasons against: retribution for the worst crimes (Genesis 9:6); Romans 13:4; protection of society; utility, if it deters.
Another view: right in principle, but almost never in practice (Evangelium Vitae 56).
Judge it by: Is life only God's to take? Can guilt ever be certain? What do victims and society need? What does the evidence show?
Mission check
?A country with secure prisons votes on bringing back executions for terrorist murders. A Catholic, a Reform Jew and a Humanist all vote against. Which reason could all three share?
People reach the same conclusion by different routes: sanctity of life, the chance to repent, or the risk of irreversible mistakes.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Fewer than half of people in England and Wales now say they are Christian. Is Britain still Christian?
Make a guess: Fewer than half of people in England and Wales now say they are Christian. Is Britain still Christian?
Mission 5
A Christian heritage
Christianity reached Britain under Roman rule. In 597, Augustine of Canterbury began a mission to the English.
For over 1,400 years Christianity shaped Britain's laws, calendar, language, art and buildings.
Parish churches and cathedrals stand in almost every town; many schools and hospitals were founded by churches.
Your spec: UK laws, festivals and traditions are rooted in the Christian tradition.
Mission 5
Many traditions, one country
Christian traditions: Church of England (Anglican), Catholic, Methodist, Baptist, United Reformed, Pentecostal and black-majority churches, Orthodox, Quakers, Salvation Army.
Other religions: Islam, Hinduism, Sikhism, Judaism, Buddhism, and smaller groups.
Non-religious beliefs:atheism (the belief that there is no God) and Humanism (a non-religious approach to life based on reason and care for people).
Britain is mainly Christian in heritage and diverse in belief today.
Mission 5Read the source
Three censuses
Step 1 of 3
The census asks "What is your religion?" (a voluntary question). England and Wales, % of all people:
2001
2011
2021
Christian
71.7
59.3
46.2
No religion
14.8
25.1
37.2
Muslim
3.0
4.8
6.5
Hindu
–
1.5
1.7
Sikh, Jewish and Buddhist: each under 1% in 2011. About 7% did not answer the question.
Source: Office for National Statistics. Scotland and Northern Ireland hold separate censuses.
Q1 What changed in 2021 that had not happened before?
Show answer
Fewer than half said "Christian"; still the largest group.
Q2 Which two groups grew most from 2011 to 2021?
Show answer
No religion; Muslim.
Quick check
?Which conclusion does the 2021 census of England and Wales support?
Mission 5
The established Church
Established church: a church officially linked to the state by law.
The Church of England is the established church in England.
The Monarch is its Supreme Governor, and promises at the coronation to maintain it.
Parliament must approve some of its laws; the Monarch formally appoints its bishops and archbishops.
Not the whole UK: the Church in Wales was disestablished in 1920. The Church of Scotland is the national church but runs its own affairs. Northern Ireland has no established church.
Mission 5
Religion in public life
Bishops in the House of Lords: 26 Church of England bishops sit there (the "Lords Spiritual").
Christian services mark key events: coronations, royal weddings and funerals, Remembrance Sunday.
Public holidays based on Christian festivals: Christmas, Good Friday, Easter Monday (not in Scotland).
Church schools: many state schools are Church of England or Catholic.
Other traditions are recognised too: Eid, Diwali, Vaisakhi and Hanukkah celebrated in cities and at Downing Street; faith schools of other religions; chaplains of many faiths in hospitals, prisons and the armed forces.
Quick check
?Which of these is an example of the Church of England's established status?
Mission 5
Secularisation
Secularisation: religion losing influence over society, public life and people's lives.
Signs: falling church attendance; the rise of "no religion"; fewer religious weddings; laws changing away from church teaching.
Not the whole story: many people still pray, believe or call themselves Christian without attending. The sociologist Grace Davie called this "believing without belonging" (Religion in Britain since 1945, 1994).
Some churches are growing, especially Pentecostal, black-majority and immigrant congregations; other religions are growing too.
Mission 5Diversity
Responding to a changing Britain
Catholic Church: a call to evangelise: share the Gospel by word and by service ("Go and make disciples of all nations", Matthew 28:19). Falling numbers are seen as a challenge and an opportunity.
Church of England: serves every parish, believers or not; its leaders generally support remaining established so faith keeps a voice in public life.
Evangelical and Pentecostal churches: active mission, church planting, Alpha courses.
Mission 5Evaluate
"Britain is no longer a Christian country."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: fewer than half chose "Christian" in 2021; church attendance is low; many laws now differ from church teaching; Britain is diverse in religion and belief.
Reasons against: Christianity is still the largest group; laws, holidays and the calendar are rooted in Christianity; many people still believe without attending church.
Also against: the Church of England is still the established church, linked to the state by law.
Another view: "Christian" may describe heritage and culture rather than belief; Britain may be best described as diverse or plural (many faiths and beliefs side by side).
Judge it by: Does "Christian country" mean belief, practice, law or history? Which evidence counts most: census, attendance or public institutions?
Quick check
?Grace Davie described many British people as "believing without belonging". What does this mean?
Mission check
?A new town council plans its calendar. The council gives staff the Christmas Day bank holiday, opens with a prayer by the Anglican vicar, and also holds a Diwali lights event and an Eid reception. Which description of Britain does this best illustrate?
Britain's laws and calendar are rooted in Christianity, but its people are increasingly diverse, and many are non-religious.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Crime breaks the law of the state; sin breaks God's law. Many acts are both; some are only one.
Reasons for crime: poverty, upbringing, mental health, addiction, greed, hate, opposition to unjust law. Believers condemn the crime, not the person.