← GCSE Religious Studies · Eduqas · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies, Route B (Catholic Christianity) · Component 1 Theme 2: Good and Evil (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Good and Evil (part 2)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Jesus said he came to fulfil the law, then made it harder. What did he expect of his followers?
  2. Mission 2If the Bible says nothing about a choice, how do Christians decide what is right?
  3. Mission 3A marble mother holds her dead son. Why do Catholics find hope, not despair, in that statue?
  4. Mission 4If most sick pilgrims at Lourdes go home uncured, why do so many keep going?
  5. Mission 5Why would Catholics stop at fourteen pictures in turn, or say the same prayer fifty times?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Jesus said he came to fulfil the law, then made it harder. What did he expect of his followers?

Make a guess: Jesus said he came to fulfil the law, then made it harder. What did he expect of his followers?

Mission 1

Why Jesus has moral authority

Words and exampleJesus: moral authorityChristians believe his teaching is God'steachingWordssermonsparablesExamplehealingserviceforgivenessthe cross
  • Christians believe Jesus is the Son of God and the Word of God made flesh (John 1:14): his teaching is God's teaching.
  • The crowds noticed: "he taught them with authority, and not like the scribes" (Matthew 7:29).
  • He teaches by words (sermons, parables) and by example (how he lived and died).
Mission 1Read the source

Fulfilling the law (Matthew 5:17–24)

Law to heartDo notmurderthe lawfulfilno anger, no insult, make peace first(Matthew 5:21–24)"I didn't come to destroy, but to fulfil."(Matthew 5:17)
  • "Don't think that I came to destroy the law or the prophets. I didn't come to destroy, but to fulfil." (Matthew 5:17)
  • Fulfil: to bring the law to its full meaning, and to complete what it pointed towards.
  • Then Jesus goes deeper (5:21–22, paraphrase): the law says "Do not murder"; Jesus says even anger and insults put a person in danger of judgement.
  • Before offering a gift at the altar, first go and make peace with your brother (5:23–24, paraphrase).

Q1 Did Jesus come to abolish the law?

Show answer

No: to fulfil it.

Q2 How does Jesus go beyond "Do not murder"?

Show answer

He forbids the anger that leads to it, and asks for reconciliation first.

Mission 1

The Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7)

Sermon on the MountSermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7)1Beatitudes5:3–122Salt and light5:13–163Deeper than the law5:17–484Real religion, not show6:1–185Trust, not wealth6:19–346Do not judge; the Golden Rule7:1–127Wise and foolish builders7:24–27Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3–12): "Blessedare…"1 the poor in spirit2 those who mourn3 the gentle4 those who hunger and thirst forrighteousness5 the merciful6 the pure in heart7 the peacemakers8 those persecuted for doing right
  • Beatitudes (5:3–12): who is truly blessed.
  • Salt and light (5:13–16): followers should make a difference.
  • Go deeper than the law (5:17–48): anger, adultery, oaths, revenge; "love your enemies" (5:44).
  • Real religion, not show (6:1–18): give, pray (the Lord's Prayer) and fast in secret.
  • Trust, not wealth (6:19–34): "You can't serve both God and Mammon (money)" (6:24).
  • Do not judge; the Golden Rule (7:1–12): treat others as you want to be treated (7:12).
  • Wise and foolish builders (7:24–27): hear these words and do them.
Mission 1Read the source

The Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3–12)

Sermon on the MountSermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7)1Beatitudes5:3–122Salt and light5:13–163Deeper than the law5:17–484Real religion, not show6:1–185Trust, not wealth6:19–346Do not judge; the Golden Rule7:1–127Wise and foolish builders7:24–27Beatitudes (Matthew 5:3–12): "Blessedare…"1 the poor in spirit2 those who mourn3 the gentle4 those who hunger and thirst forrighteousness5 the merciful6 the pure in heart7 the peacemakers8 those persecuted for doing right
  • Beatitude: from Latin beatus, "blessed" or "truly happy".
  • "Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the Kingdom of Heaven." (5:3)
  • Also blessed (5:4–10, paraphrase): those who mourn; the gentle; those who hunger and thirst for righteousness; the merciful; the pure in heart; the peacemakers; those persecuted for doing right.
  • "Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called children of God." (5:9)
  • Q: Which Beatitude would encourage a Christian to help settle a quarrel? (Blessed are the peacemakers.)
Quick check
?What did Jesus mean when he said he came to fulfil the law (Matthew 5:17)?
Mission 1Diversity

How literally should Christians follow it?

Interpretations of the SermonHow the Sermon isreadExampleSome: Quakers, Mennonitesa literal ideal for allrefuse oaths andviolence (Matthew5:34, 5:39)Catholicthe commands bindevery Christiansome (monks, nuns)also follow counsels ofperfection: poverty,chastity, obedienceLutheran traditionshows how fareveryone falls short, soall need God's gracestill a guide for livingLiberal Protestantprinciples of love, notfixed rulesapply agape to eachsituation
  • Literal ideal for all: some (e.g. Quakers, Mennonites) refuse oaths and violence because of Matthew 5:34 and 5:39.
  • Catholic: the commands bind every Christian; some (monks, nuns) also follow "counsels of perfection": poverty, chastity, obedience.
  • Lutheran tradition: the Sermon shows how far everyone falls short, so all need God's grace; it is still a guide for living.
  • Liberal Protestant: principles of love, not fixed rules; apply agape to each situation.
Quick check
?A Quaker refuses to swear an oath in court and instead makes a solemn promise to tell the truth. Which part of Jesus' teaching is she following?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Jesus' moral teaching is too demanding to follow today."

Argument map"Jesus' moral teaching is too demanding tofollow today."For"love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44) and"don't resist him who is evil" (5:39) seemimpossible in a violent worldEven anger is condemned (5:22)Lutheran Christians say no one keeps itperfectlyAgainstMany Christians do live it: e.g. forgiving afamily member's killer, or giving up wealthJesus promises help: the Spirit and graceThe Beatitudes describe God's Kingdom,which Christians grow towardsOrdinary acts of love, such as caring for astranger in need, count tooAnother viewA demanding ideal to aim at, not a set ofrules to tick off; failure is met withforgivenessJudge it byIs it meant as rules or ideals? · Does "toodemanding" mean impossible or just hard? ·Do real examples show it can be lived?
  • Reasons for: Jesus' commands in the Sermon on the Mount, "love your enemies" (Matthew 5:44) and "don't resist him who is evil" (5:39), seem impossible in a violent world. Even anger is condemned (5:22). Lutheran Christians say no one keeps it perfectly.
  • Reasons against: many Christians do live it: e.g. forgiving a family member's killer, or giving up wealth. Jesus promises help: the Spirit and grace (–). The Beatitudes describe God's Kingdom, which Christians grow towards. Ordinary acts of love, such as caring for a stranger in need, count too.
  • Another view: it is a demanding ideal to aim at, not a set of rules to tick off; failure is met with forgiveness.
  • Judge it by: Is it meant as rules or ideals? Does "too demanding" mean impossible or just hard? Do real examples show it can be lived?
Mission check

?A company's code says: "Don't steal from the firm." A new manager tells staff: "Not stealing isn't enough. I want you to want the firm to do well." How does this mirror Jesus' approach to the law?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If the Bible says nothing about a choice, how do Christians decide what is right?

Make a guess: If the Bible says nothing about a choice, how do Christians decide what is right?

Mission 2

Many sources, one decision

Decision compassthe BiblereasonChurch teachingconsciencethedecisionChristians use several sources together.
  • Christians make moral decisions using several sources together:
  • The Bible, especially Jesus' teaching and example (see Mission 1).
  • Church teaching: for Catholics, Tradition and the Magisterium (the Church's teaching office).
  • Reason: thinking carefully about what is good for people.
  • Conscience: the inner sense of right and wrong.
  • Christians differ on which source carries most weight when they seem to clash.
Mission 2

Natural law

Natural lawThomas Aquinaseternal law (God's plan)natural law (known by reason)first principle: "good is to be done andpursued, and evil is to be avoided"primary preceptspreserve lifereproduceeducate the younglive in an ordered societyknow and worship Godsanctity of life:always wrongto directly takeinnocent humanlife
  • Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae (1265–1274): God made the world with a purpose and order.
  • Humans can discover that order by reason: this is natural law.
  • The first principle: "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided" (ST I-II, q. 94, a. 2).
  • Primary precepts (basic goods): preserve life; reproduce; educate the young; live in an ordered society; know and worship God.
  • From the goodness of creation: God made everything "very good" (Genesis 1:31), so human nature itself points towards what is truly good.
  • Paul: people who never heard God's law still "show the work of the law written in their hearts" (Romans 2:15).
Mission 2

Natural law and the sanctity of life

Natural lawThomas Aquinaseternal law (God's plan)natural law (known by reason)first principle: "good is to be done andpursued, and evil is to be avoided"primary preceptspreserve lifereproduceeducate the younglive in an ordered societyknow and worship Godsanctity of life:always wrongto directly takeinnocent humanlife
  • Sanctity of life: human life is holy, because it comes from God and is made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).
  • Preserving life is a primary precept, so natural law reasons that it is always wrong to directly take innocent human life.
Quick check
?According to Aquinas' natural law, how can people know what is morally good?
Mission 2

Conscience

Conscience: the sanctuaryCatholic teaching on conscience"most secret core and sanctuary", where aperson is alone with God (Gaudium et Spes16)CCC 1778conscience is a judgement of reason
  • Conscience: the inner judgement that tells a person what is right or wrong in a particular situation.
  • Catholics call it the voice of God within: a law people did not make for themselves, which calls them to love good and avoid evil (Gaudium et Spes 16).
  • Catholic teaching also calls conscience a judgement of reason (CCC 1778).
  • Catholic teaching adds that conscience must be formed well: by scripture, Church teaching, prayer and advice.
  • John Henry Newman (1801–1890): conscience is "the aboriginal Vicar of Christ" (Letter to the Duke of Norfolk, 1875): Christ's first representative within each person.
Mission 2Read the source

Gaudium et Spes 16 and CCC 1777–1781

  • Gaudium et Spes 16 (Second Vatican Council, 1965, paraphrase): deep within, people find a law they did not make, which they must obey. Conscience is a person's "most secret core and sanctuary", where they are alone with God.

Q1 According to Gaudium et Spes 16, who speaks to a person in conscience?

Show answer

God.

Quick check
?Which statement matches Catholic teaching on conscience?
Mission 2

Virtue, and growing through suffering

VirtueslovefaithhopeprudencejusticefortitudetemperanceTheological virtues (roof): faith, hope, loveCardinal virtues (pillars): prudence (wisdom inchoosing), justice, fortitude (courage),temperance (self-control)"The greatest of these is love." (1 Corinthians13:13)Romans 5:3–4sufferingperseveranceproven characterhope
  • Virtue: a good habit of character, built by practice.
  • Cardinal virtues: prudence (wisdom in choosing), justice, fortitude (courage), temperance (self-control).
  • Theological virtues: faith, hope and love: "The greatest of these is love." (1 Corinthians 13:13)
  • Virtue ethics asks: "What would a good person do?": with Jesus as the model (see Mission 1).
  • Suffering and virtue: Paul writes that "suffering produces perseverance; and perseverance, proven character; and proven character, hope" (Romans 5:3–4). Christians do not seek suffering, but believe God can use it to grow virtue.
  • So natural law, conscience and the chance to grow in virtue are seen as signs of God's goodness.
Mission 2Diversity

When Bible, Church and conscience seem to clash

Authority weightsBibleChurchteachingreasonconscienceCatholicconscience must be followed, but formed byscripture, Tradition and the MagisteriumMany evangelical Protestantsthe Bible is the final authority; conscience"captive to the Word of God" (Luther)Liberal Protestantsreason and conscience may lead them to readsome Bible passages as limited by their timeQuakersthe Inner Light (God's Spirit in each person)guides decisions, tested together in the meeting● stressed ○ used, but less stressed. "Stress",not "only".
  • Catholic: conscience must be followed, but formed by scripture, Tradition and the Magisterium; a conscience that ignores them may be in error.
  • Many evangelical Protestants: the Bible is the final authority; conscience must be "captive to the Word of God" (Luther at Worms, 1521, paraphrase). Some warn that conscience is affected by sin (Jeremiah 17:9).
  • Liberal Protestants: reason and conscience may lead a Christian to read some Bible passages as limited by their time.
  • Quakers: the Inner Light (God's Spirit in each person) guides decisions, tested together in the meeting.
Quick check
?Martin Luther said his conscience was "captive to the Word of God". What does this suggest about how many Protestants see conscience?
Mission 2Evaluate

"A Christian should always follow their conscience."

Argument map"A Christian should always follow theirconscience."ForGaudium et Spes 16: conscience is whereGod's voice is heardCatholic teaching: a certain consciencemust be obeyedNewman would toast conscience first andthe pope afterwardsActing against conscience damages aperson's integrityAgainstConscience can be wrong or badly formed(CCC 1790–1791); people have doneterrible things "in conscience"Many Protestants say the Bible must judgeconscienceChurch teaching and community adviceprotect against self-deceptionAnother viewForm, then follow: follow conscience, butonly after forming it carefullyJudge it byWhat happens when conscience is mistaken?· Who checks a person's conscience? · Is"following conscience" the same as doingwhat one wants?
  • Reasons for: Gaudium et Spes 16: conscience is where God's voice is heard. Catholic teaching: a certain conscience must be obeyed. Newman would toast conscience first and the pope afterwards. Acting against conscience damages a person's integrity.
  • Reasons against: conscience can be wrong or badly formed (CCC 1790–1791); people have done terrible things "in conscience". Many Protestants say the Bible must judge conscience. Church teaching and community advice protect against self-deception.
  • Another view: follow conscience, but only after forming it carefully: the two belong together.
  • Judge it by: What happens when conscience is mistaken? Who checks a person's conscience? Is "following conscience" the same as doing what one wants?
Mission check

?A Catholic doctor is asked to give a treatment that would deliberately end a patient's life. No Bible verse mentions this treatment. She says: "I have prayed and studied what my Church teaches, and I cannot do it." What is she mainly relying on?
Mission 3

Mission 3: A marble mother holds her dead son. Why do Catholics find hope, not despair, in that statue?

Make a guess: A marble mother holds her dead son. Why do Catholics find hope, not despair, in that statue?

Mission 3

Why Catholics make statues

Why Catholics make statuesrememberteachinspireprayGod madevisiblein Christ
  • Catholic churches and homes have statues: of Jesus, Mary, the saints and angels.
  • The Incarnation: God became human in Jesus, so God has been seen, touched and heard. Catholics believe this makes images of Christ possible.
  • A statue is three-dimensional: it stands in the same space as the believer, as if present.
  • Purposes: to remember, to teach, to inspire, and to focus prayer.
Mission 3Read the source

The Word became flesh

"The Word became flesh and lived amongst us. We saw his glory" (John 1:14)

"He is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of all creation." (Colossians 1:15)

Q1 According to John 1:14, what could people now do that they could not do before?

Show answer

See God's glory in a human life.

Q2 How do Catholics use Colossians 1:15 to defend statues of Jesus?

Show answer

If Christ is the visible image of the invisible God, making an image of Christ shows what God has already shown.

Mission 3

Veneration, not worship

Veneration, not worshipWorshipGod alone(adoration)VenerationMary and the saints(honour)a reminder, not a godhonour passes to the person it showsSecond Council of Nicaea (787); CCC 2132
  • Catholics worship God alone (adoration).
  • They venerate (honour) Mary and the saints: a statue is a reminder, not a god.
  • The Second Council of Nicaea (787) and the Catechism (CCC 2132) teach that honour given to an image passes to the person it shows.
  • So lighting a candle before a statue of St Anthony is asking him to pray with you, not praying to stone.
Quick check
?A Catholic kneels and lights a candle in front of a statue of Mary. What does Catholic teaching say she is doing?
Mission 3

Statues in a Catholic church

Statues in a Catholic church: a planaltar and crucifixMMary's sidealtar (M)Christmascribsaints' statuesin niches (orange)e.g. patron saint,Sacred Heart1234567891011121314Stations of the Cross:14 marks around the wallsentrance
  • Crucifix: Christ on the cross, above or near the altar: his sacrifice, renewed in the Mass.
  • Mary: often a side altar or shrine, with candles and flowers.
  • Saints, especially the church's patron; Sacred Heart of Jesus: his love for all people.
  • Stations of the Cross: 14 carved or painted scenes around the walls.
  • Christmas crib: figures of the Nativity scene.
  • How they are used: kneeling, lighting candles, prayer, processions (e.g. crowning a statue of Mary in May), funerals and feasts.
Mission 3

Statues in private prayer

A home shrinerosarycandlestatueflowers(small statue, blank outline: Mary or a saint)quiet prayer: thanks, sorrow, asking for help ·the rosary · children learn the stories
  • Many Catholic homes have a small shrine: a crucifix or statue of Mary or a saint, a candle, perhaps flowers.
  • Families may pray the rosary together in front of a statue of Mary.
  • A statue or holy picture beside a bed, or a small figure carried in a bag, reminds the believer to pray during the day.
  • Statues help children learn the stories of Jesus and the saints.
  • Private prayer before a statue is personal and quiet: thanks, sorrow, asking for help.
Mission 3

Michelangelo's Pietà

The Pietà: compositionMary: calm, eyes loweredsigned sashChrist's body across her lapopen left handpyramid: stable and calmPietà ("pity", "compassion")Michelangelo, 1498–1499 · St Peter's Basilica,RomeLuke 2:35"a sword will pierce through your own soul"
  • Pietà (Italian: "pity", "compassion"); Michelangelo, carved 1498–1499 from one block of Carrara marble, aged about 24.
  • Now in St Peter's Basilica, Rome; the only work he signed (on the sash across Mary's chest).
  • Mary holds the dead body of Jesus across her lap after the crucifixion.
  • Details: a pyramid shape: stable and calm; Mary looks young and serene; her eyes are lowered; her left hand is open, as if offering or accepting; Christ's wounds are small; his body is at peace.
  • The scene is not described in the Gospels: it is a devotional image of Mary's sorrow.
Mission 3

The Pietà: God's goodness and human suffering

The Pietà: compositionMary: calm, eyes loweredsigned sashChrist's body across her lapopen left handpyramid: stable and calmPietà ("pity", "compassion")Michelangelo, 1498–1499 · St Peter's Basilica,RomeLuke 2:35"a sword will pierce through your own soul"
  • Simeon told Mary: "a sword will pierce through your own soul" (Luke 2:35). The Pietà shows that sword.
  • Suffering is real: a mother holds her dead son. Catholics do not pretend suffering is good.
  • Suffering with meaning: Catholics believe Christ's death was a gift of love for the world; Mary's open hand offers him back to God.
  • God's goodness is not cancelled by suffering: the calm faces point to trust and to the resurrection to come.
  • Catholics say Christ shares human suffering, and believers can unite their sufferings with his (Pope John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris, 1984, paraphrase).
  • So the Pietà comforts the grieving: God is present in sorrow, and death is not the end.
Quick check
?In the Pietà, Mary's face is calm and her left hand is open. What do Catholics most often see in this?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Statues of Jesus help faith more than they put it at risk."

Argument map: statues of Jesus"Statues of Jesus help faith more than theyput it at risk."ForThe Incarnation made God visible (John1:14; Colossians 1:15)Statues teach, comfort and focus prayerThe Pietà shows how art can give hope insufferingHonour passes to the person shown(Nicaea II)AgainstThe commandment against images(Exodus 20:4–5)A statue can become an object ofsuperstitionNo one knows what Jesus looked like: astatue may fix a false imageMoney spent on art could serve the poorJudge it byDoes the Incarnation change what thatcommandment forbids? · Is the risk in thestatue or in how people use it? · Do statueshelp everyone, or only those taught how touse them?
  • Reasons for: the Incarnation made God visible (John 1:14; Colossians 1:15); statues teach, comfort and focus prayer; the Pietà shows how art can give hope in suffering; honour passes to the person shown (Nicaea II).
  • Reasons against: the commandment against images (Exodus 20:4–5; part of the first commandment for Catholics, the second for most Protestants); a statue can become an object of superstition; no one knows what Jesus looked like, so a statue may fix a false image; money spent on art could serve the poor.
  • Judge it by: Does the Incarnation change what that commandment forbids? Is the risk in the statue or in how people use it? Do statues help everyone, or only those taught how to use them?
Mission check

?A hospital chapel places a statue of Mary holding the infant Jesus near the entrance, with candles in front of it. A Catholic nurse lights one each morning before her shift. What best explains what she is doing?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If most sick pilgrims at Lourdes go home uncured, why do so many keep going?

Make a guess: If most sick pilgrims at Lourdes go home uncured, why do so many keep going?

Mission 4

Shrines: holy places of prayer

Shrines: places of pilgrimageFRANCEENGLANDLourdesGrotto and spring, 1858
  • A shrine is a holy place linked to a saint, a relic or a reported vision.
  • Many famous shrines are Marian: linked to Mary, the mother of Jesus.
  • Catholics honour (venerate) Mary and ask her to pray for them. They worship God alone.
  • Say: "Catholics honour Mary and ask her prayers" — not: "Catholics worship Mary".
  • Pilgrims go to pray, to ask for help, to give thanks, and to grow closer to God with others.
Mission 4

Lourdes: what happened in 1858

Shrines: places of pilgrimageFRANCEENGLANDLourdesGrotto and spring, 1858
  • Lourdes: a small town in the Pyrenees, south-west France.
  • 11 February 1858: Bernadette Soubirous, a poor 14-year-old, says she sees a young lady in the Grotto (cave) of Massabielle by the river.
  • Over five months she reports 18 visions (apparitions).
  • She says the lady asks for prayer, penance, a chapel and processions.
  • Bernadette digs where she says she was told; a spring appears. It still flows.
  • 1862: the local bishop declares that the apparitions can be believed. Bernadette becomes a nun and is declared a saint (1933).
Mission 4

Lourdes: what pilgrims do

Lourdes: the sanctuary (plan, not to scale)riverGrottostatue nicheSpringCandleswaterBathsPlan, not to scaleProcession route: torchlight processioneach evening; Eucharistic processionThe sick at the front, blessed
  • At the Grotto: pray before the statue of Mary; touch the rock; light a candle as a sign of continuing prayer.
  • The water: drink it, wash in it, or bathe in the baths. A sign of cleansing and new life.
  • Torchlight procession each evening: thousands sing the Ave Maria, candles in hand.
  • Eucharistic procession: the Blessed Sacrament is carried; the sick sit at the front and are blessed.
  • Mass, confession, the Stations of the Cross on the hillside.
  • The sick come first: volunteers push wheelchairs, carry stretchers and serve meals.
Quick check
?Why do many pilgrims at Lourdes drink or bathe in the water from the spring at the Grotto?
Mission 4Read the source

Bernadette's account

Words Bernadette reported the lady saying (1858, translated from the local dialect):

> "I do not promise to make you happy in this world, but in the other." (18 February)

> "I am the Immaculate Conception." (25 March)

  • Immaculate Conception: the Catholic belief that Mary was kept free from original sin from the moment she was conceived (defined in 1854).
  • Say: "the Immaculate Conception is about Mary's own conception" — not: "it is the virgin birth of Jesus".

Q1 What does the first saying suggest pilgrims should expect from Lourdes?

Show answer

Not a promise of earthly happiness or cure; hope of joy with God after this life.

Q2 In the second saying, who does the lady say she is?

Show answer

Mary, named by a Catholic title: the one conceived without original sin. Bernadette, with little schooling, did not know the phrase; this helped convince the parish priest.

Mission 4

Healing and suffering

Lourdes: the sanctuary (plan, not to scale)riverGrottostatue nicheSpringCandleswaterBathsPlan, not to scaleProcession route: torchlight processioneach evening; Eucharistic processionThe sick at the front, blessed
  • Some pilgrims report cures. Doctors at the Lourdes Medical Bureau examine claims.
  • Very few are declared miraculous: 72 by 2025. The Church is cautious.
  • Most pilgrims seek spiritual healing: peace, strength to cope, forgiveness, hope.
  • Catholic belief: suffering can be united with Christ's suffering on the cross, and so it is not wasted (Colossians 1:24, paraphrase).
  • Pope John Paul II taught that suffering can draw a person closer to Christ and awaken love in others (Salvifici Doloris, 1984, paraphrase).
  • He made 11 February, the feast of Our Lady of Lourdes, the World Day of the Sick.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Visiting a shrine brings a Christian closer to God than praying at home."

Argument map: shrine or home?"Visiting a shrine brings a Christian closerto God than praying at home."ForTime set apart from daily lifeA place soaked in centuries of prayerPraying with thousands of others; thesacramentsAgainstGod is present everywhere; Jesus saidpray in a private room (Matthew 6:6)Cost and travel: the money could help thepoor (Matthew 25:31–46)Many Protestants: a place, statue or relicmay distract from ChristJudge it byIs God's presence tied to places? · What thepilgrim does there, and how they liveafterwards? · Is "closer to God" a feeling or achange of life?
  • For: time set apart from daily life; a place soaked in centuries of prayer; praying with thousands of others; the sacraments; many pilgrims report lasting change.
  • Against: God is present everywhere; Jesus told his followers to pray in a private room (Matthew 6:6, paraphrase).
  • Against: cost and travel: the money could help the poor (Matthew 25:31–46); a trip can become tourism.
  • Against: many Protestants: focus on a place, statue or relic may distract from Christ.
  • Judge it by: Is God's presence tied to places? What the pilgrim does there, and how they live afterwards? Is "closer to God" a feeling or a change of life?
Mission check

?Knock, in Ireland, is a Marian shrine where villagers reported a vision in 1879. Siobhan, a Catholic with a long-term illness, prays there and receives the Anointing of the Sick. She comes home not cured, but says she has peace and feels less alone. Which explanation best fits Catholic teaching?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why would Catholics stop at fourteen pictures in turn, or say the same prayer fifty times?

Make a guess: Why would Catholics stop at fourteen pictures in turn, or say the same prayer fifty times?

Mission 5

What popular piety is

Liturgy and popular pietyLiturgyMass andsacramentsRosaryStationsadorationpilgrimageprocessionscandlesflows fromleads back todevotions extend the liturgy; they do notreplace it
  • Popular piety: forms of prayer and devotion that grow from ordinary believers' faith and culture.
  • Examples: the Rosary, the Stations of the Cross, Eucharistic adoration, pilgrimages, processions, candles, medals.
  • Stations of the Cross: fourteen images around a church wall showing Jesus' journey to his death; people walk from one to the next and pray at each.
  • They sit alongside the liturgy (the Mass and sacraments), not instead of it.
  • They engage the whole person: hands (beads), feet (walking), eyes (images), voice (repeated prayer).
  • They can be prayed anywhere: at home, in hospital, on a bus, in a group.
Mission 5

The Rosary

The Rosarycentrepiecegap: Glory Be3 small: Hail Maryslarge: Our Fathercrucifix: Apostles' Creedfive decades, each:one Our Father (large bead), ten Hail Marys,one Glory Be, while thinking about onemysteryFour sets of mysteriesJoyfulLuminousadded by Pope John Paul II in 2002Sorrowfulespecially Tuesdays and Fridays, and in LentGlorious
  • A string of beads with a crucifix, used to count prayers.
  • Start: Apostles' Creed, Our Father, three Hail Marys, Glory Be.
  • Then five decades. Each: one Our Father, ten Hail Marys, one Glory Be.
  • The Hail Mary begins with Gabriel's and Elizabeth's words: "Rejoice, you highly favoured one! The Lord is with you." (Luke 1:28); "Blessed are you amongst women, and blessed is the fruit of your womb!" (Luke 1:42)
  • During each decade the person thinks about one mystery: an event in the life of Jesus and Mary.
  • Four sets: Joyful, Luminous (added by Pope John Paul II in 2002), Sorrowful, Glorious.
  • Christ-centred: Pope John Paul II called it a summary of the whole Gospel, prayed "with Mary". The repetition calms the mind for meditation.
Mission 5

The Sorrowful Mysteries

The Sorrowful Mysteries1. The Agony in the GardenMatthew 26:382. The Scourging at the PillarJohn 19:13. The Crowning with ThornsMatthew 27:294. The Carrying of the CrossJohn 19:175. The Crucifixion and DeathLuke 23:46
  • Prayed especially on Tuesdays and Fridays, and in Lent.
  • 1. The Agony in the Garden: "My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even to death." (Matthew 26:38)
  • 2. The Scourging at the Pillar (John 19:1). 3. The Crowning with Thorns (Matthew 27:29).
  • 4. The Carrying of the Cross (John 19:17). 5. The Crucifixion and Death (Luke 23:46).
  • The Incarnation: God the Son became truly human, so he knew fear, pain, mockery, exhaustion and death from the inside.
  • "We don't have a high priest who can't be touched with the feeling of our infirmities" (Hebrews 4:15). God is not distant from suffering.
  • Mary stood by the cross (John 19:25): a model of faithful presence beside those who suffer. Catholics may unite their own pain with Christ's.
Quick check
?Which describes one decade of the Rosary?
Mission 5Evaluate

"Popular piety is as important for Catholics as the Mass."

Argument map: "Popular piety is as important for Catholics as the Mass.""Popular piety is as important for Catholicsas the Mass."Forcan be prayed daily, anywhere, by anyone,including the sickthe Rosary summarises the Gospelmakes faith personal and part of everydaylifethe Church encourages them (CCC 1674)Againstthey extend the liturgy but do not replaceit (CCC 1675)the Eucharist is the source and summit ofChristian lifedevotions can drift into superstition andneed guiding (CCC 1676)many Protestants see some of them asunbiblicalJudge it byDoes "as important" mean "the same kind ofthing"? · Which leads to which? · What doesthe person praying actually gain?
  • Claim: devotions like the Rosary matter as much as the Mass.
  • For: they can be prayed daily, anywhere, by anyone, including the sick. The Rosary summarises the Gospel. They make faith personal and part of everyday life. The Church encourages them (CCC 1674).
  • Against: they extend the liturgy but do not replace it (CCC 1675). The Eucharist is the source and summit of Christian life. Devotions can drift into superstition and need guiding (CCC 1676). Many Protestants see some of them as unbiblical.
  • Judge it by: Does "as important" mean "the same kind of thing"? Which leads to which? What does the person praying actually gain?
Quick check
?A Catholic says she prays the Rosary "to Mary, instead of Jesus". Which response fits Catholic teaching?
Mission check

?Bernadette, a Catholic, spends several weeks in hospital and cannot get to Mass. Each day she prays the Sorrowful Mysteries. How does Catholic teaching see her devotion?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Christians see Jesus as the Word of God: his teaching and example carry God's authority.
  • In Matthew 5:17–24 Jesus says he came to fulfil the law, and he goes deeper, to attitudes such as anger.
  • The Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5–7) sets out the way of life he expected; Christians differ on how literally to follow it.
  • The Beatitudes describe who is truly blessed.

Mission 2

  • Natural law (Aquinas): reason discovers the purposes God built into a good creation; preserving life is basic, so Catholics uphold the sanctity of life.
  • Conscience is a judgement of reason where Catholics believe God's voice is heard (GS 16; CCC 1777–1781); it must be formed and followed.
  • Christians differ on the weight of Bible, Church, reason and conscience.
  • Virtue grows by practice; many Christians believe God can use even suffering to grow it.

Mission 3

  • Catholics use statues because of the Incarnation (God made visible in Christ): images remind, teach and focus prayer; they are venerated, not worshipped.
  • Sources for the Incarnation argument: John 1:14; Colossians 1:15.
  • Michelangelo's Pietà (1498–99, St Peter's) shows Mary holding the dead Christ: real suffering, trust in God's goodness, hope of resurrection.

Mission 4

  • Lourdes (1858, Bernadette, the Grotto and spring) is a place of prayer and healing where the sick come first; most healing sought is spiritual.

Mission 5

  • Catholic teaching is that popular piety (Rosary, Stations, adoration) extends the liturgy but never replaces it (CCC 1674–1676).
  • The Rosary: five decades, each a meditation on one mystery.
  • Catholics see in the Sorrowful Mysteries God sharing human suffering.
  • The Stations retrace Jesus' way to the cross.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Good and Evil (part 2) for Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies (Route B). 🎉

  1. Mission 1Jesus said he came to fulfil the law, then made it harder. What did he expect of his followers?
  2. Mission 2If the Bible says nothing about a choice, how do Christians decide what is right?
  3. Mission 3A marble mother holds her dead son. Why do Catholics find hope, not despair, in that statue?
  4. Mission 4If most sick pilgrims at Lourdes go home uncured, why do so many keep going?
  5. Mission 5Why would Catholics stop at fourteen pictures in turn, or say the same prayer fifty times?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Eduqas