← GCSE Religious Studies · Eduqas · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies, Route B (Catholic Christianity) · Component 1 Theme 2: Good and Evil (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Good and Evil (part 1)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?
  2. Mission 2If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?
  3. Mission 3How can a baby born in Bethlehem be, as Christians believe, God himself?
  4. Mission 4If God became human, can Christians make pictures of him, and does God know what suffering is?
  5. Mission 5Christians still trust God when disaster strikes. What answers do they give, and do any of them work?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Origins and Meaning (part 1).

Mission 1

Mission 1: How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?

Make a guess: How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?

Mission 1

One God, not three

  • Christians are monotheists, like Jews and Muslims.
  • They hold to the Jewish Shema, which Jesus himself quoted (Mark 12:29): "Hear, Israel: The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4)
  • So the Trinity (Latin trinitas, "threeness": God as three-in-one) never means three gods.
  • The word "Trinity" is not in the Bible. It names a belief Christians find in the Bible.
Mission 1

Three Persons, one God

Shield of the Trinityis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpirit
  • Most Christians believe in one God in three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Each Person is fully God, not a third of God.
  • The three are distinct (not the same as each other) but not separate (not three beings).
  • All three are equal and eternal. None was made.
  • Not three gods. Not one God wearing three masks in turn.
Mission 1

Each Person

Shield of the Trinityis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpiritCreatorsaves humanitypresent and active
  • Trinitarian Christians describe each Person like this:
  • Father: Creator and source of all; loves and cares for people.
  • Son: Jesus Christ, God become human (the Incarnation); saves humanity.
  • Holy Spirit: God present and active in the world now; guides, strengthens and gives life.
Mission 1Read the source

The baptism of Jesus

The baptism of Jesus in symbolsthe heavens were openeda voice out of the heavens"This is my beloved Son, with whom Iam well pleased."the Spirit of God,descending as a doveJesus is baptised: he comes up from the water

"Jesus, when he was baptised, went up directly from the water: and behold, the heavens were opened to him. He saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming on him. Behold, a voice out of the heavens said, 'This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.'" (Matthew 3:16–17)

  • Q1: Find each Person: who is baptised, what descends, who speaks?

Q1 Why do Christians see this passage as evidence for the Trinity?

Show answer

All three are present at once, each doing something different.

Quick check
?In Matthew 3:16–17, how is each Person of the Trinity present at the baptism of Jesus?
Mission 1

The Nicene Creed

From Arius to the Nicene Creedbefore325Arius (c. 250–336) teachesthat the Son was created bythe Father325Council of Nicaea rejects this:the Son is "of one substancewith the Father"381Council of Constantinople addsmore on the Spirit: "the Lordand giver of life"todayThe Nicene Creed, in threeparts: Father, Son, Holy Spirit
  • A priest, Arius (c. 250–336), taught that the Son was created by the Father.
  • The Council of Nicaea (325) rejected this. The Son is "Begotten, not made, Being of one substance with the Father" (Nicene Creed, Book of Common Prayer).
  • Of one substance (Greek homoousios): the same divine being. Catholics say "consubstantial with the Father" at Mass.
  • The Council of Constantinople (381) added more on the Spirit: "the Lord and giver of life", worshipped with the Father and the Son.
  • The Nicene Creed is built in three parts: Father, Son, Holy Spirit.
Quick check
?What was the main point the Council of Nicaea (325) made against the teaching of Arius?
Mission 1

The Trinity in worship and life

  • Baptism is "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit".
  • Sign of the cross (Catholic, Orthodox, many Anglicans and Lutherans) traces the same words.
  • Prayer is often to the Father, through the Son, in the Spirit. Many hymns and blessings end with all three ("Glory be to the Father…").
  • Catholics: the Mass begins with the sign of the cross; the Creed is said on Sundays; the Catechism calls the Trinity the central mystery of Christian faith and life (CCC 234).
  • Trinity Sunday, the Sunday after Pentecost in Western churches, celebrates the belief.
  • Daily life: God is a communion of love, so Christians aim to live in loving community; they rely on the Spirit's help.
Mission 1Evaluate

"The Trinity is a contradiction."

Argument map: is the Trinity a contradiction?The Trinity is a contradiction.ForOne cannot equal threeThe word "Trinity" is not in the BibleDeuteronomy 6:4 stresses that God is oneUnitarians and Christadelphians reject itEvery everyday analogy seems to failAgainstOne in being, three in Persons: "one" and"three" count different thingsScripture treats Father, Son and Spirit asGod (Matthew 28:19; John 10:30;Galatians 4:6)A mystery: beyond full understanding, butnot against reasonExperienceChristians say they meet God as abovethem (Father), with them (Son) and withinthem (Spirit)Judge it byDo "one" and "three" count the same thing? ·Must a belief be fully understood to bereasonable? · Should belief rest on the Biblealone or also on the Church's councils?
  • Reasons for: one cannot equal three. The word "Trinity" is not in the Bible. Deuteronomy 6:4 stresses that God is one. Unitarians and Christadelphians reject it. Every everyday analogy seems to fail.
  • Reasons against: God is one in being and three in Persons: "one" and "three" count different things, so there is no logical contradiction. Scripture treats Father, Son and Spirit as God (Matthew 28:19; John 10:30; Galatians 4:6). Christians call it a mystery: beyond full understanding, but not against reason.
  • Experience: Christians say they meet God as above them (Father), with them (Son) and within them (Spirit).
  • Judge it by: Do "one" and "three" count the same thing? Must a belief be fully understood to be reasonable? Should belief rest on the Bible alone or also on the Church's councils?
Mission check

?A student describes the Trinity as "like one actor playing three roles in a play, one after another". How would most Christians (Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestants) respond?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Make a guess: If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Mission 2

One God, three Persons

One God, three Personsis notis notis notisisisFatherSonHolySpiritGodDistinct by relationships:FatherbegetsSonHoly SpiritproceedsEach Person is fully God: not three gods
  • "Hear, Israel: The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4) Catholics keep this: there is one God.
  • That one God is three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Not three gods; not one Person wearing three masks.
  • Each Person is fully God; none is a part, and none came first.
  • The Persons are distinct by their relationships: the Father begets the Son; the Son is begotten; the Spirit proceeds.
  • The Catechism calls the Trinity the central mystery of Christian faith (CCC 234, paraphrase).
Mission 2Read the source

Father, Son and Spirit in scripture

Jesus' baptismthe heavens openeda dove"This is my beloved Son, with whom Iam well pleased."a voice out of the heavensRiver Jordan · Matthew 3:16–17

"Jesus, when he was baptised, went up directly from the water: and behold, the heavens were opened to him. He saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming on him. Behold, a voice out of the heavens said, 'This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.'" (Matthew 3:16–17)

Q1 Where is each Person at the baptism?

Show answer

The Son in the water; the Spirit as a dove; the Father as the voice.

Quick check
?The word "Trinity" is not in the account of Jesus' baptism. Why do Catholics still see the baptism as evidence for the Trinity?
Mission 2

The Council of Nicaea (325)

The councils and the TrinityArius(c. 250–336) taught the Son wasthe first thing God made: "therewas when he was not"325Council of Nicaea (Constantine):the Son is "of one substance"(homoousios) with the Father381Council of Constantinople(Theodosius I): the Spirit is "TheLord and giver of life",worshipped with Father and Sonlaterthe Latin West adds "and theSon" (Filioque); Catholics say this,the Orthodox do not
  • A priest, Arius (c. 250–336), taught that the Son was the first and greatest thing God made: "there was when he was not".
  • Emperor Constantine called the bishops to Nicaea (in modern Turkey) in 325.
  • The Council taught that the Son is "Begotten, not made, Being of one substance with the Father" (Nicene Creed, Book of Common Prayer).
  • Of one substance (Greek homoousios): the same divine being, not a lesser god. At Mass Catholics say "consubstantial with the Father".
  • Athanasius (c. 296–373), later bishop of Alexandria, defended Nicaea for decades.
  • Nicaea said little about the Spirit: its creed said only "And in the Holy Spirit".
Mission 2

The Council of Constantinople (381)

The councils and the TrinityArius(c. 250–336) taught the Son wasthe first thing God made: "therewas when he was not"325Council of Nicaea (Constantine):the Son is "of one substance"(homoousios) with the Father381Council of Constantinople(Theodosius I): the Spirit is "TheLord and giver of life",worshipped with Father and Sonlaterthe Latin West adds "and theSon" (Filioque); Catholics say this,the Orthodox do not
  • Some still denied that the Holy Spirit is fully God.
  • Emperor Theodosius I called the Council of Constantinople in 381.
  • It expanded the creed: the Spirit is "The Lord and giver of life… Who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified" (Book of Common Prayer).
  • This Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed is the "Nicene Creed" said at Sunday Mass today.
  • Later, the Latin West added that the Spirit proceeds from the Father "and the Son" (Filioque). Catholics say this; the Orthodox Churches do not, and it remains a point of difference.
  • Development: Catholics see the councils as clarifying what scripture already teaches, not inventing new beliefs.
Quick check
?What did the Council of Constantinople (381) add to the faith set out at Nicaea?
Mission 2Read the source

Augustine: lover, beloved, love

Lover, beloved, lovelovesloverFatherbelovedSonloveHoly Spirit"Behold, then, there are three things: he thatloves, and that which is loved, and love."(Augustine, De Trinitate VIII.10, Haddantranslation)Catholic teaching applies this: Father as lover,Son as beloved, Spirit as the love betweenthem.

St Augustine of Hippo (354–430), De Trinitate ("On the Trinity", c. 400–420), Book VIII, chapter 10:

> "Behold, then, there are three things: he that loves, and that which is loved, and love." (Haddan translation, 1873)

  • Love involves three: one who loves (the lover), one who is loved (the beloved), and the love itself. Catholic teaching applies this to the Trinity: the Father as lover, the Son as beloved, the Holy Spirit as the love between them (Augustine calls the Spirit the love of Father and Son in De Trinitate XV.17).
  • So, Catholics believe, God can be love from all eternity, before creating anything.
  • Augustine: "thou dost see the Trinity if thou seest love" (De Trinitate VIII.8.12).
  • He treats this as a starting-point, not a full explanation; he goes on to look for the Trinity's image in the human mind.

Q1 Which Person does Augustine link with love itself?

Show answer

The Holy Spirit, the bond of love.

Q2 Why does the analogy fit the claim that "God is love" (1 John 4:8)?

Show answer

Love needs a lover and a beloved; within God there are both, eternally.

Mission 2

The Trinity in Catholic life

The Trinity in Catholic lifeBaptismin the name of theFather and of theSon and of the HolySpirit (Matthew28:19)Sign of the CrossMass begins with itCreedthe Creed and Gloriapraise all threeLifelove as a community,as the Trinity loves
  • Baptism "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19).
  • Mass: begins with the Sign of the Cross; the Gloria and Creed praise all three; the Eucharistic Prayer ends "Through him, and with him, and in him".
  • Prayer: the Glory Be; most prayers go to the Father, through the Son, in the Spirit.
  • Life: Catholics are called to love as the Trinity loves: as a community, not alone.
  • Before creation: Catholics believe the Father, Son and Spirit have loved one another from all eternity, so God did not need the world in order to love; creation is a free gift.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Human love is a good way to understand the Trinity."

Argument map: human love and the Trinity"Human love is a good way to understandthe Trinity."For"God is love" (1 John 4:8)Love shared by Father, Son and Spiritshows how God could love beforeanything was madeIt makes the mystery personalAugustine's lover–beloved–love showshow God can be love eternallyAgainstHuman lovers are two separate beings,but the Persons are one God (risk of threegods)Love as a "thing" can make the Spiritsound less than a PersonEvery analogy falls short of a mysteryAnother viewStart from what God has done in Jesus andthe Spirit, not from human loveJudge it byDoes the analogy keep both oneness andthree Persons? · Does it fit scripture and theCreed? · Does it help believers pray and live?
  • Reasons for: "God is love" (1 John 4:8); love shared by Father, Son and Spirit shows how God could love before anything was made; it makes the mystery personal.
  • Also for: Augustine's lover–beloved–love shows how God can be love eternally.
  • Reasons against: human lovers are two separate beings, but the Persons are one God (risk of three gods); love as a "thing" can make the Spirit sound less than a Person; every analogy falls short of a mystery.
  • Another view: start from what God has done in Jesus and the Spirit, not from human love.
  • Judge it by: Does the analogy keep both oneness and three Persons? Does it fit scripture and the Creed? Does it help believers pray and live?
Mission check

?A student says: "Before creation God must have been lonely, so God made the world in order to have someone to love." How would Catholic teaching on the Trinity most likely respond?
Mission 3

Mission 3: How can a baby born in Bethlehem be, as Christians believe, God himself?

Make a guess: How can a baby born in Bethlehem be, as Christians believe, God himself?

Mission 3

What "Incarnation" means

One person, two naturesone person: Jesusfully Godfully humanChalcedon, 451not mixed · not dividedthe Word (Logos), with God in thebeginning"the Word became flesh" (John 1:14)
  • Incarnation comes from Latin in carne: "in flesh".
  • Christians believe God the Son, the second Person of the Trinity, became a human being: Jesus of Nazareth.
  • Jesus is fully God and fully human: not half and half, not God in disguise, not a man who became God.
  • One person, two natures (divine and human): agreed at the Council of Chalcedon (451).
  • The Nicene Creed: he "was incarnate by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary, and was made man".
Mission 3Read the source

The Word became flesh

"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." (John 1:1)

"The Word became flesh and lived amongst us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the only born Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." (John 1:14)

  • John 1:1–18 also says: all things were made through the Word (1:3); the Word is life and light (1:4–5); his own people did not receive him, but those who did became children of God (1:11–12); the Son makes the unseen God known (1:18).

Q1 Which verse shows the Word is God?

Show answer

1:1: "the Word was God".

Q2 Which verse shows the Word became human?

Show answer

1:14: "became flesh".

Mission 3

The divine Word

One person, two naturesone person: Jesusfully Godfully humanChalcedon, 451not mixed · not dividedthe Word (Logos), with God in thebeginning"the Word became flesh" (John 1:14)
  • Word translates the Greek Logos: reason, message, God's self-expression.
  • In Genesis 1, God creates by speaking ("God said…"). John says that Word is a Person, present at creation.
  • So Jesus is not a messenger who brings God's word: he is God's Word in human life.
  • Christians believe that to see what God is like, they look at Jesus.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes the Incarnation?
Mission 3Read the source

The mystery and the emptying

  • The kenosis hymn (Philippians 2:5–11). Kenosis = "self-emptying":
  • Christ, "existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant" (Philippians 2:6–7).
  • He humbled himself to death on a cross; so God exalted him, and every tongue will confess "Jesus Christ is Lord" (2:8–11).

Q1 What did Christ do although he existed "in the form of God"?

Show answer

Emptied himself and took the form of a servant.

Quick check
?Philippians 2 says Christ "emptied himself, taking the form of a servant". What do most Christians take this to mean?
Mission 3Diversity

Why it matters, and how Christians differ

Why it matters, and how Christians differStressesSeen inAll mainstream ChristiansGod is not distant;Jesus shows what Godis likeworship at Christmas;serving the poor(Matthew 25:40)CatholicMary as Mother of Godthe Angelus, threetimes a day; ChristmasMidnight MassOrthodoxtheosis: humans shareGod's life"He was made manthat we might be madeGod" (Athanasius)Protestantoften the cross more:the Incarnation makesthe saving deathpossible–
  • For all mainstream Christians: God is not distant; Jesus shows what God is like; God understands human life from the inside.
  • Catholic: Mary as Mother of God; the Angelus prayer recalls the Incarnation three times a day; Christmas Midnight Mass.
  • Orthodox: God became human so humans can share God's life (theosis). Athanasius: "He was made man that we might be made God" (On the Incarnation 54).
  • Protestant: often stress the cross more; the Incarnation makes the saving death possible.
  • Impact: worship at Christmas; respect for human bodies and lives; serving the poor, in whom Jesus is met (Matthew 25:40).
Mission 3Evaluate

"The Incarnation is the most important Christian belief."

Argument map: is the Incarnation the most important Christian belief?"The Incarnation is the most importantChristian belief."ForWithout it, Jesus' death is the death of agood man, not God's saving actIt shows God's love (John 3:16)Only God become human can reveal Godfully (John 1:18)AgainstPaul: faith depends on the resurrection (1Corinthians 15:14)Many Protestants see the cross as thecentreThe Trinity is the foundation all else restsonAnother viewThe beliefs depend on each other:Incarnation, cross and resurrection formone storyJudge it byWhich belief do the others depend on? ·What do Christians celebrate most(Christmas or Easter)? · Which makes mostdifference to daily life?
  • Reasons for: without it, Jesus' death is the death of a good man, not God's saving act. It shows God's love (John 3:16). Only God become human can reveal God fully (John 1:18).
  • Reasons against: Paul says faith depends on the resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:14). Many Protestants see the cross as the centre. The Trinity is the foundation all else rests on.
  • Another view: the beliefs depend on each other: Incarnation, cross and resurrection form one story.
  • Judge it by: Which belief do the others depend on? What do Christians celebrate most (Christmas or Easter)? Which makes most difference to daily life?
Mission check

?A Christmas hymn by Charles Wesley (1739) sings: "Veiled in flesh the Godhead see; hail the incarnate Deity". What belief do mainstream Christian churches take these lines to express?
Mission 4

Mission 4: If God became human, can Christians make pictures of him, and does God know what suffering is?

Make a guess: If God became human, can Christians make pictures of him, and does God know what suffering is?

Mission 4

Incarnate Son, divine Word

One Person, two naturesone Person:Jesus ChristdivinenaturehumannatureFully God and fully human: one Person with twonaturesCouncil of Chalcedon, 451
  • Incarnation (Latin in carne, "in flesh"): Catholics believe God the Son became a human being in Jesus, without ceasing to be God.
  • Fully God and fully human: one Person with two natures, divine and human (Council of Chalcedon, 451).
  • Incarnate Son: Jesus is the eternal Son of the Father, conceived by the Holy Spirit and born of Mary.
  • Divine Word: the Logos, God's self-expression, through whom all things were made, "became flesh" (John 1:14).
  • Significance: God is not distant; God can be seen, heard and touched in Jesus.
  • Because God became visible in Jesus, Catholics make and honour images of him, such as crucifixes and statues (veneration, not worship).
  • Because the Son truly suffered as a human, Catholics believe God knows suffering from the inside.
Mission 4Read the source

The Word became flesh

"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made through him." (John 1:1–3)

"The Word became flesh and lived amongst us. We saw his glory, such glory as of the only born Son of the Father, full of grace and truth." (John 1:14)

  • John 1:18 (paraphrase): no one has ever seen God, but the only Son, who is closest to the Father's heart, has made him known.

Q1 Which words show the Word is divine?

Show answer

"The Word was God"; "all things were made through him".

Q2 Which words show the Word became truly human?

Show answer

"Became flesh and lived amongst us".

Mission 4Read the source

The kenosis hymn

The kenosis hymn: down and updown: self-emptyingin the form of God2:6human2:7the form of aservant2:7death on a cross2:8up: exaltedexalted by God2:9every knee willbow2:10"Jesus Christ isLord"2:11

Paul quotes an early Christian hymn (Philippians 2:5–11). Christ, "existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant" (Philippians 2:6–7). "He humbled himself, becoming obedient to the point of death, yes, the death of the cross." (2:8)

  • Kenosis = "self-emptying". Christ does not stop being God: he lays aside divine glory and takes the lowest place.
  • Then God exalts him: every knee will bow, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord (2:9–11, paraphrase).
  • Shape of the hymn: down (God → human → servant → death) and up (exalted, Lord of all).

Q1 What does Christ "empty" himself into?

Show answer

The form of a servant: human life, and death on a cross.

Q2 What should Christians learn from it?

Show answer

Paul's point (2:5): have the same humble attitude, putting others first.

Quick check
?What do Catholics understand by the kenosis ("self-emptying") of Christ in Philippians 2?
Mission 4

The Incarnation and suffering: Salvifici Doloris

Salvifici Doloris: a response to sufferingThe questionWhy do we suffer? Human reason alonecannot fully answer.Salvifici Doloris (John Paul II, 1984): aresponse, not a proof§13God's love, shown above all in the cross ofChrist§23Christ's power in weakness: suffering canproduce perseverance and hope§19, §22suffering joined to Christ's shares inredemption, and in his gloryresurrectionevil does not have the last word
  • Pope John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris ("On the Christian Meaning of Human Suffering"), 1984.
  • §13 (paraphrase): human reason alone cannot fully answer why we suffer; the answer comes from God's love, shown above all in the cross of Christ.
  • §23 (paraphrase): suffering is always a trial, but Christ's power is shown in weakness; a person who suffers with Christ becomes especially open to God's saving power, and suffering can produce perseverance and hope (Romans 5:3–5).
  • §19 and §22 (paraphrase): suffering united with Christ's can share in his work of redemption, and those who share his sufferings are called to share his glory.
  • Link to the problem of evil: the Incarnation does not explain away evil, but shows God entering it: Emmanuel, God with us, in pain and death.
  • Catholic nuance: the Son suffered truly in his human nature; because he is one Person, Catholics can say "God suffered in the flesh".
Quick check
?According to Salvifici Doloris, how can Christians find meaning in suffering?
Mission 4Evaluate

"The Incarnation answers the problem of evil."

Argument map"The Incarnation answers the problem ofevil."ForGod is not distant but shares humansuffering (Emmanuel)The cross shows love is God's answer (SD13); suffering joined to Christ has meaning(SD 23)The resurrection shows evil does not havethe last wordAgainstIt does not explain why an all-powerful,all-loving God allows suffering at allSharing pain does not remove it; muchsuffering seems to have no purposeFor non-religious thinkers, comfort is notan explanationAnother viewMany Catholics say the Incarnation is aresponse to evil, not a theory of itJudge it byWhat would count as an "answer": anexplanation or a hope? · Does it help thosewho suffer? · Is it consistent with God's powerand love?
  • Reasons for: God is not distant but shares human suffering (Emmanuel); the cross shows love is God's answer (SD 13); suffering joined to Christ has meaning (SD 23); the resurrection shows evil does not have the last word.
  • Reasons against: it does not explain why an all-powerful, all-loving God allows suffering at all; sharing pain does not remove it; much suffering (of children, of animals) seems to have no purpose; for non-religious thinkers, comfort is not an explanation.
  • Another view: many Catholics say the Incarnation is a response to evil, not a theory of it.
  • Judge it by: What would count as an "answer": an explanation or a hope? Does it help those who suffer? Is it consistent with God's power and love?
Mission check

?A Catholic hospital chaplain hangs a crucifix in a ward. A patient asks why. Which answer best fits Catholic belief about the Incarnation?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Christians still trust God when disaster strikes. What answers do they give, and do any of them work?

Make a guess: Christians still trust God when disaster strikes. What answers do they give, and do any of them work?

Mission 5

Three kinds of answer

Three kinds of answerTheoreticalBiblicalPracticalfree willsoul-makingJobthe crossprayercharity
  • Christians do not usually deny the problem. They respond in three ways:
  • Theoretical: reasons why a good God might allow evil (free will, soul-making).
  • Biblical: what scripture says about suffering (Job, a good man who suffers terribly without being told why; the Psalms; the cross).
  • Practical: what to do about suffering (prayer, charity, care for the sufferer).
  • A reasoned defence of God's goodness in the face of evil is a theodicy.
Mission 5

Free will (Augustine)

Two theodiciesAugustine354–430Irenaeusc. 130–c. 202John Hick1922–2012 (book,1966)God madeeverything good(Genesis 1:31)free will for angelsand humansthey turn fromGod: the Fall(Genesis 3)evil = a lack ofgoodgoodGod's imagelikenessa world with realdangers andpain"vale of soul-making"Keats, 1819
  • St Augustine of Hippo (354–430), Confessions (c. 400) and City of God (413–426).
  • God made everything good (Genesis 1:31). Evil is not a thing God made: it is a lack or loss of good (a privation).
  • God gave angels and humans free will. They turned from God: the Fall (Genesis 3).
  • Moral evil comes from misused free will. Augustine links natural evil to a creation disordered by the Fall.
  • Why allow it? Love and goodness must be freely chosen; a world of robots could not love.
Mission 5

The vale of soul-making (Irenaeus, Hick)

Two theodiciesAugustine354–430Irenaeusc. 130–c. 202John Hick1922–2012 (book,1966)God madeeverything good(Genesis 1:31)free will for angelsand humansthey turn fromGod: the Fall(Genesis 3)evil = a lack ofgoodgoodGod's imagelikenessa world with realdangers andpain"vale of soul-making"Keats, 1819
  • St Irenaeus (c. 130–c. 202): humans are made in God's image but must grow into his likeness.
  • John Hick (1922–2012), Evil and the God of Love (1966), develops this idea.
  • Hick borrows the poet John Keats' phrase (1819): the world is a "vale of soul-making".
  • A world with real dangers and pain lets people develop courage, compassion, patience and trust.
  • In a world with no risk, nothing would be at stake: no one could be brave or kind.
  • Hick believed all people will finally reach that goal (heaven), so suffering is not wasted.
Quick check
?After a flood, neighbours who had never spoken risk their lives to rescue strangers. Which response to the problem of evil uses events like this as evidence?
Mission 5

The God who suffers with us

  • Christians believe that in the Incarnation God became human in Jesus, and that Jesus suffered and died on the cross.
  • So God does not watch suffering from far away: God has entered it.
  • Christians also hope that suffering is not the end: the resurrection points to a future without it (Revelation 21:4).
  • Pope St John Paul II, Salvifici Doloris ("On the Christian Meaning of Human Suffering", 1984):
  • §13 (paraphrase): love is the fullest answer to the meaning of suffering, and God gave that answer in the Cross of Christ.
  • §23 (paraphrase): suffering is a trial; in it, human weakness can be filled with God's power, shown in Christ's cross and confirmed by his resurrection (2 Corinthians 12:9).
Quick check
?How does belief in the Incarnation shape many Christians' response to suffering?
Mission check

?A volcano erupts millions of years before the first humans exist. A Christian wants to explain why God would allow natural destruction like this. Which explanation is hardest to use here?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Christians believe in one God in three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit, each fully God, distinct but not separate.
  • At Jesus' baptism (Matthew 3:16–17) all three Persons are present.
  • The Nicene Creed (Nicaea, 325) says the Son is "of one substance" with the Father.

Mission 2

  • One God in three Persons, rooted in Deuteronomy 6:4 and Jesus' baptism (Matthew 3:16–17); Nicaea (325) taught the Son is "of one substance" with the Father.
  • Constantinople (381) taught the Spirit's full divinity; the creed said at Mass comes from both councils.
  • Augustine starts from the three of love (lover, beloved, love); Catholic teaching applies it to the Trinity: God is love from all eternity.

Mission 3

  • Christians believe in the Incarnation: God the Son became human in Jesus, fully God and fully human (John 1:14).
  • Jesus is the divine Word (Logos), through whom all things were made.
  • Philippians 2 celebrates the Son's self-emptying (kenosis).

Mission 4

  • Jesus is the incarnate Son and divine Word: fully God and fully human, one Person (John 1).
  • Kenosis: the Son emptied himself into a servant's life and death; Salvifici Doloris: God's love meets suffering in the cross.

Mission 5

  • Christians respond to evil with theoretical answers (free will, soul-making), biblical answers (Job) and practical action (prayer, charity).
  • Many add that in Jesus God shares human suffering.
  • Salvifici Doloris: love, shown on the Cross, is the fullest answer to suffering.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Good and Evil (part 1) for Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies (Route B). 🎉

  1. Mission 1How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?
  2. Mission 2If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?
  3. Mission 3How can a baby born in Bethlehem be, as Christians believe, God himself?
  4. Mission 4If God became human, can Christians make pictures of him, and does God know what suffering is?
  5. Mission 5Christians still trust God when disaster strikes. What answers do they give, and do any of them work?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Eduqas