🚀 Good and Evil: Christian perspective; muslim perspective (part 2)
⭐ 0
Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies, Route A (C120QS) · Theme 3: Issues of Good and Evil – Christian perspective; Theme 3: Issues of Good and Evil – Muslim perspective (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Good and Evil: Christian perspective; muslim perspective (part 2)
4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Mission 2If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 3Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 4If God already knows what you will choose, are you still free, and still to blame?
Mission 1
Mission 1: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Make a guess: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Mission 1
Forgiveness, repentance, reconciliation
Forgiveness: choosing to let go of anger and the wish for revenge against someone who has wronged you.
It is not pretending the wrong did not happen, and not saying it was acceptable.
Repentance: being truly sorry for wrongdoing and turning away from it (metanoia in Christianity; teshuvah in Judaism; tawbah in Islam).
Reconciliation: restoring a broken relationship, so both sides can live in peace again.
Mission 1Read the source
Jesus on forgiveness
"Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me, and I forgive him? Until seven times?" Jesus said to him, "I don't tell you until seven times, but, until seventy times seven." (Matthew 18:21–22)
"For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you don't forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses." (Matthew 6:14–15)
On the cross: "Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing." (Luke 23:34)
Q1 What does "seventy times seven" mean?
Show answer
Forgive without limit; stop counting.
Q2 Why does Matthew 6:14–15 link our forgiving to God's?
Show answer
Christians who refuse to forgive close themselves to God's forgiveness.
Mission 1
Forgiveness and punishment
The tension: if Christians must forgive without limit, should offenders be punished at all?
Most Christians answer: forgiveness is personal; justice is the state's duty (Romans 13:4). A victim can forgive and still want a fair sentence.
Punishment can itself serve the offender's good: it helps them face the wrong and change.
Example: Pope John Paul II was shot in 1981 by Mehmet Ali Ağca. In 1983 he visited Ağca in prison and forgave him, yet Ağca stayed in prison.
Some argue the other way: punishing someone you have forgiven still looks like holding on to the wrong.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes what most Christians mean by forgiveness?
Mission 1Diversity
Different Christian and non-religious views
Unconditional forgiveness: many Christians forgive whether or not the offender repents, following Jesus on the cross (Luke 23:34).
Conditional forgiveness: others point to "If he repents, forgive him" (Luke 17:3); full reconciliation needs repentance.
Catholic teaching: God's forgiveness is offered to all and received through repentance, especially in the Sacrament of Reconciliation; Catholics are called to forgive as they are forgiven.
Humanists: forgiveness can heal both victim and offender and help society; but it is a choice, not a duty, and victims should never be pressured to forgive.
Some non-religious people argue some acts should not be forgiven, out of respect for victims.
Mission 1Diversity
Islam and Judaism
Islam: Allah is al-Ghafur (the Forgiving) and ar-Rahim (the Merciful); forgiveness is offered to all who sincerely repent (tawbah).
"And if ye efface and overlook and forgive, then lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful." (Qur'an 64:14, Pickthall)
"Whatever of misfortune striketh you, it is what your right hands have earned. And He forgiveth much." (Qur'an 42:30, Pickthall)
In qisas, the victim's family may forgive the offender (Qur'an 2:178): forgiveness and justice together.
Judaism: God is merciful to those who return (teshuvah). "Who is a God like unto Thee, that pardoneth the iniquity … because He delighteth in mercy." (Micah 7:18, JPS 1917)
Wrongs against people must be put right with them first: Yom Kippur does not atone for these until the person wronged is reconciled (Mishnah Yoma 8:9, paraphrase).
Mission 1Diversity
Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism
Buddhism: holding on to anger harms yourself; forgiveness grows from metta (loving-kindness) and karuna (compassion).
"For hatred does not cease by hatred at any time: hatred ceases by love, this is an old rule." (Dhammapada 5, Müller)
Angulimala: a murderer who wore a garland of his victims' fingers. The Buddha met him with metta; Angulimala became a monk. The karma of his past still brought suffering: forgiveness did not erase consequences.
Hinduism:kshama (forgiveness, patience) is a virtue of dharma.
By the laws of karma, revenge creates more bad karma; forgiving is part of one's dharma, while the offender still faces the karma of the act.
Sikhism: forgiveness (khima) is a mark of a God-centred (gurmukh) person; anger is one of the Five Thieves.
Guru Granth Sahib 866 is your spec's named Sikh source on forgiveness.
Quick check
?A Jewish teenager has spread a cruel rumour about a friend. It is Yom Kippur, and she fasts and prays for forgiveness. According to Jewish teaching, what else must she do?
Mission 1
Examples of forgiveness
Gordon Wilson (Methodist): his daughter Marie was killed in the Enniskillen bombing in 1987. He said he bore the bombers no ill will and prayed for them; he later worked for peace.
Gee Walker (Christian): her son Anthony was murdered in a racist attack in Liverpool in 2005. She said she forgave his killers, because of her faith.
Azim Khamisa (Muslim): his son Tariq was shot by a 14-year-old in 1995. He forgave the boy and set up a foundation with the boy's grandfather to stop youth violence.
Each acted from personal belief; none said the crime did not matter.
Mission 1Evaluate
"Some actions are unforgivable."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: some crimes (murder, genocide) cause harm that can never be repaired. Forgiving may seem to disrespect victims. Some offenders show no repentance. Humanists: forgiveness is a choice, not a duty.
Reasons against: Jesus taught "seventy times seven" and forgave on the cross. Examples like Gordon Wilson and Gee Walker show it is possible.
Muslims believe Allah is al-Ghafur (the Forgiving); Buddhists teach that "hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada 5), so forgiving frees the victim from hatred.
In Buddhist tradition the Buddha accepted even Angulimala.
Another view: forgiving the person is possible, while the act stays wrong and justice is still done.
Judge it by: Who has the right to forgive? Must the offender repent? Does forgiveness cancel punishment?
Mission check
?A football fan was badly injured when a rival fan attacked him. In court, the injured man says he forgives his attacker, but he also asks the judge to give a fair sentence. Most Christians would say this is:
Forgiveness lets go of revenge; justice deals with the wrong. Most believers hold that you can offer one without cancelling the other.
Mission 2
Mission 2: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Make a guess: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 2
Two kinds of evil
Evil: whatever is bad, harmful or wrong. Suffering: the pain, physical or mental, that it causes.
Moral evil: caused by human choices: murder, cruelty, war, theft, bullying.
Natural evil (natural suffering): caused by nature, not by humans: earthquakes, floods, disease, famine from drought.
Some cases are mixed: a quake kills more people where buildings were badly made.
Moral evil raises the question: why did God make people free to do this? Natural evil: why did God make a world that works like this?
Quick check
?A cyclone floods a coastal region. Afterwards, officials steal food aid meant for survivors. Which classification is correct?
Mission 2
The inconsistent triad
Step 1 of 3
Theists (Christians, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs and many Hindus) believe God is omnipotent (all-powerful) and omnibenevolent (all-loving).
Most also say God is omniscient (all-knowing): God knows about every evil.
But evil exists.
The problem: these three statements seem not to fit together. If God knew, could stop it and wanted to, why does it happen?
This is the inconsistent triad. Many versions add omniscience, giving four statements; the name inconsistent triad is kept. Philosophers call it the logical problem of evil.
The evidential problem: even if some evil is needed, why so much, and why such pointless suffering?
Mission 2Read the source
Epicurus' old questions
Step 1 of 3
David Hume (1711–1776), Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779), Part X, has a character repeat questions credited to the Greek philosopher Epicurus (341–270 BCE):
> "Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both able and willing? whence then is evil?"
Q1 Which quality of God does the first question challenge?
Show answer
Omnipotence: "not able" means "impotent", powerless.
Q2 Which does the second challenge?
Show answer
Omnibenevolence: "not willing" means "malevolent", ill-willed.
Mission 2
Innocent suffering and providence
Providence: God's loving care for the world, guiding it towards good.
Innocent suffering is the hardest case: babies with painful illnesses, children in war, animals in fires. They have done nothing to deserve it.
In Fyodor Dostoevsky's novel The Brothers Karamazov (1880), Ivan refuses any future harmony bought with the tears of a tortured child (paraphrase).
Even believers cry out: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Psalm 22:1, WEBBE). Christians recall that Jesus prayed these words on the cross (Mark 15:34).
Mission 2
Reject, question or examine
Some reject belief: atheists argue that the triad shows an all-powerful, all-loving God does not exist.
Humanists: suffering has natural causes (evolution, plate movement, disease) and human ones; no God is needed to explain it; people should reduce it themselves.
Some question: personal tragedy can shake faith; doubt and lament are found in scripture (Psalm 22, Job).
Some examine: believers think harder about what God's power and love mean, and find answers (see Mission 3).
Quick check
?Leah says: "If God knew the tsunami was coming, could have stopped it and truly loved people, it would not have happened." Which three beliefs about God is Leah putting together?
Mission 2Diversity
Where evil comes from: Abrahamic faiths
Christian: humans misused free will in the Fall (Genesis 3); "sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin" (Romans 5:12, WEBBE). Original Sin: a damaged nature passed to all.
Jewish: humans have a yetzer ha-tov (good inclination) and a yetzer ha-ra (inclination to evil) and free choice: "I have set before thee life and death, the blessing and the curse; therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19, JPS 1917).
Berakhot 9:5 (Mishnah, paraphrase): bless God for the bad as for the good; love God with both inclinations. Avodah Zarah 3b (Talmud, paraphrase): when God sees the world deserves judgement, he moves from the throne of judgement to the throne of mercy.
Muslim: Iblis refused to bow to Adam "through pride" (Surah 2:34, Pickthall) and now tempts humans; hardship is a test: "We shall try you with something of fear and hunger" (Surah 2:155, Pickthall).
Mission 2Diversity
Where suffering comes from: Dharmic faiths
Hindu: suffering follows karma: as a person acts in this life, so they reap in the next (Bhagavata Purana 6.1.45, paraphrase). Its root is ignorance (avidya) and maya (illusion that hides Brahman).
The three gunas: goodness brings knowledge; passion brings greed; darkness brings delusion and error (Bhagavad Gita 14.17, paraphrase).
Buddhist: suffering (dukkha) is a mark of all existence; its cause is craving (tanha) and the Three Poisons (greed, hatred, ignorance). Mara stands for temptation and death.
"By oneself the evil is done, by oneself one suffers" (Dhammapada 165, Müller).
Sikh: life is under God's hukam (will), but humans turn from God through haumai (ego). The manmukh (self-centred person) is ruled by the five evils: lust (kam), anger (krodh), greed (lobh), attachment (moh), pride (ahankar).
Your spec's source: Guru Granth Sahib 1342 (barriers to mukti; the five evils).
Quick check
?Which teaching explains suffering by craving within the person, with no creator God in the explanation?
Mission 2Evaluate
"Evil and suffering prove that God does not exist."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: the triad seems logically inconsistent; the amount of suffering seems pointless (evidential problem); innocent suffering seems unfair; natural causes explain suffering without God.
Reasons against: God may have good reasons we cannot see (Isaiah 45:9); free will needs the possibility of evil; suffering may have a purpose (see Mission 3); many who suffer most keep their faith.
Another view: the problem may show that God's power or love must be understood differently, not that God does not exist.
Non-theistic view: for most Buddhists there is no creator to blame; the question becomes how to end suffering.
Judge it by: Is "prove" too strong a word? Does free will explain natural evil? Can a finite mind judge God's reasons?
Mission check
?A baby is born with a painful genetic illness. Tom says: "An all-powerful, loving God would not allow this, so there is no such God." The baby's mother, a Christian, prays: "Why, Lord?", but goes on trusting God. Which statement is accurate?
The same suffering can lead one person to reject God and another to question and examine faith. A later mission: the answers believers give.
Mission 3
Mission 3: Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Make a guess: Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 3
Three kinds of answer
A theodicy ("justifying God") tries to show why a good, all-powerful God allows evil. The word was coined by Gottfried Leibniz (1710).
Philosophical answers: free will, soul-making.
Scriptural answers: Job, the Psalms, life as a test, the suffering of Christ.
Practical answers: prayer, charity, care for those who suffer.
Most believers use all three. Many say: we may not fully explain suffering, but we can trust God and act.
Mission 3
Augustine: free will and privation
Step 1 of 2
St Augustine of Hippo (354–430), Confessions, City of God, Enchiridion.
Augustine teaches that God made a good world. Evil is not a thing God made: "evil has no positive nature; but the loss of good has received the name 'evil.'" (Augustine, City of God XI.9, Dods)
Angels and humans misused free will: the fall of the angels and of Adam and Eve.
Original Sin: all humans inherit a damaged nature; natural evil follows the disorder sin brought into creation.
So evil comes from creatures, not from God. God is just to allow its consequences, and merciful to save through Christ.
Mission 3
Irenaeus and Hick: soul-making
Step 1 of 2
St Irenaeus (c. 130–c. 202), Against Heresies: humans are made in God's image, but must grow into his likeness (Genesis 1:26).
Humans are made immature on purpose, so they can grow freely into goodness.
John Hick (1922–2012), Evil and the God of Love (1966): the world is a "vale of soul-making" (a phrase from the poet Keats).
Courage, compassion and forgiveness can only grow where there is real danger and pain.
Epistemic distance: God keeps a distance, so that people are free to believe or not.
Hick: in the end all people will reach the likeness of God (universal salvation), so all suffering will prove worthwhile.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly contrasts Augustine's and Irenaeus' answers to evil?
Mission 3
Do these answers work?
Against Augustine: science shows death and disease long before humans existed, so natural evil cannot all come from the Fall. How could perfect beings choose evil? Why punish all humans for Adam's sin?
Against soul-making: the amount of suffering is too great: the Holocaust destroyed people, it did not make souls. Babies and animals suffer without growing. Is it loving to use pain as a teacher?
For both: free will is real only if evil is possible; virtues need challenges; God's goodness may reach beyond this life (Romans 8:18).
Atheists and Humanists: the answers explain away real pain; a world with less suffering would still allow free will.
Mission 3Read the source
Job's losses
Job, a good man, loses his children, wealth and health:
"Naked I came out of my mother's womb, and naked will I return there. The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away. Blessed be the LORD's name." (Job 1:21, WEBBE)
His friends insist he must have sinned. God rejects their view. God's answer is a question: "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?" (Job 38:4, WEBBE)
Q1 What does God's question in Job 38:4 suggest about human understanding of suffering?
Show answer
It is limited: humans cannot see the whole of God's plan.
Q2 What does Job 1:21 show about Job's response to his losses?
Show answer
He accepts that all he had came from God, and still praises God.
Mission 3
Islam: life as a test
"Who hath created life and death that He may try you which of you is best in conduct" (Surah 67:2, Pickthall).
Surah 2:151–177: Allah tries believers with "fear and hunger, and loss of wealth and lives" (Surah 2:155, Pickthall). The steadfast say: "Lo! we are Allah's and lo! unto Him we are returning." (Surah 2:156, Pickthall)
Righteousness is faith shown in giving to "orphans and the needy", in prayer, zakah, and patience in hardship (Surah 2:177, paraphrase).
Al-Qadr: Allah knows and decrees all things, yet humans are responsible for their choices (see Mission 4).
Sabr (patient endurance) and du'a (personal prayer) are the believer's response; many Muslims believe hardship patiently borne wipes away sins (hadith).
Divergent: Shi'a Muslims see in Imam Husayn's martyrdom at Karbala (680) the meaning of suffering for justice; some Muslims stress Allah's decree, others human free will.
Mission 3
Judaism: Job, Psalms and the Shoah
Life as a test: "God did prove Abraham" (Genesis 22:1, JPS 1917).
The Shoah (Holocaust, 1933–1945; six million Jews murdered, most between 1941 and 1945) brought very different Jewish responses:
Eliezer Berkovits (1908–1992), Faith after the Holocaust (1973): God hides his face so humans can be free; the evil was human (paraphrase).
Emil Fackenheim (1916–2003): Jews must not give Hitler "posthumous victories" by abandoning Judaism (paraphrase).
Richard Rubenstein (1924–2021), After Auschwitz (1966): belief in a God who controls history is no longer possible (paraphrase).
Elie Wiesel (1928–2016): faith that argues with God, in the tradition of Job and Abraham.
Mission 3
Hindu, Buddhist and Sikh responses
Hindu: suffering follows karma, so it is not unjust. Brahma Sutras 2.1.34–36 (paraphrase): God is not partial or cruel, because what beings receive depends on their own past actions, and the round of rebirth has no first beginning.
Hindus respond with detachment, devotion and seva; liberation (moksha) ends suffering.
Buddhist: there is no creator to justify. The task is to end suffering: the Noble Eightfold Path, and karuna (compassion) for all who suffer.
Sikh: all happens within God's hukam (will). Sikhs accept it with contentment and remember God's name; Guru Nanak taught that suffering can be a medicine and comfort a disease (paraphrase).
Sikhs respond with seva (service), for example the langar, open to all.
Mission 3
Practical responses
Prayer: comfort, strength and solidarity: God "comforts us in all our affliction, that we may be able to comfort those who are in any affliction" (2 Corinthians 1:4, WEBBE).
Charity: Christians through CAFOD or Christian Aid; Muslims through zakah and Islamic Relief; Jews through tzedakah; Sikhs through Khalsa Aid.
Hope: many believe suffering will end: God "will wipe away every tear from their eyes" (Revelation 21:4, WEBBE).
Humanists: use reason, science and compassion to reduce suffering now; this life is the only one, so it matters.
Quick check
?In the Book of Job, what is the main point of God's answer to Job (Job 38–41)?
Mission 3Evaluate
"Religious responses solve the problem of evil."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: free will explains moral evil; soul-making gives suffering a purpose; Job shows humans cannot judge God.
Also for: life as a test gives meaning.
Reasons against: natural evil existed before humans; the amount and pointlessness of suffering; innocent suffering of children and animals.
Also against: the Shoah led some Jewish thinkers (Rubenstein) to reject belief in a God who controls history.
Another view: responses may not solve the problem as a puzzle but help believers live with it; practical responses matter most.
Divergent views of success: many Catholics and Muslims say the answers, taken together, are enough for faith; others stress mystery.
Judge it by: Does it explain natural as well as moral evil? Does it fit the amount of suffering? Does it help people who suffer?
Mission check
?After a flood kills twelve people in her town, Grace, a Christian, says: "God didn't send this. But our town has never been so united, and people have grown braver and kinder." Her friend Sam, a Humanist, replies: "People did that, not God. And why did twelve people have to die for it?" Which statement is accurate?
Believers answer suffering with free will, soul-making, trust (Job), the meaning their faith gives it, and action. Critics ask whether any answer fits the amount of pain.
Mission 4
Mission 4: If God already knows what you will choose, are you still free, and still to blame?
Make a guess: If God already knows what you will choose, are you still free, and still to blame?
Mission 4
Why humans do wrong: Abrahamic faiths
Islam: humans are born good (fitrah), but Shaytan (Iblis) tempts them and the nafs can incline to evil. The gravest sins: shirk (treating anything as equal to God) and kufr (unbelief).
Doing the will of Allah is good; going against it is sin.
Mission 4Read the source
Pride and testing
"And when We said unto the angels: Prostrate yourselves before Adam, they fell prostrate, all save Iblis. He demurred through pride, and so became a disbeliever." (Qur'an 2:34, Pickthall)
"And surely We shall try you with something of fear and hunger, and loss of wealth and lives and crops; but give glad tidings to the steadfast" (Qur'an 2:155, Pickthall)
Q1 What led Iblis to disobey God?
Show answer
Pride.
Q2 According to 2:155, why do hardships come?
Show answer
As a test; the steadfast are given good news.
Quick check
?According to most Muslims, what is the origin of evil choices in human life?
Mission 4
Al-Qadr and free will
Al-Qadr (predestination): God knows, records and wills all that happens. "Lo! We have created every thing by measure." (Qur'an 54:49, Pickthall)
Yet humans are free and responsible: "whosoever will, let him believe, and whosoever will, let him disbelieve" (Qur'an 18:29, Pickthall).
Muslims believe that on the Day of Judgement (Yawm al-Din), each person answers for their own choices.
Sunni Muslims count al-Qadr among the six articles of faith. A common Sunni teaching: God creates all acts; humans acquire responsibility for them by choosing.
Shi'a teaching stresses God's justice ('adl): a just God would not punish what humans could not avoid, so human choice is real.
Many Muslims say: God's knowledge of a choice does not force it.
Quick check
?Which statement best summarises how most Muslims hold al-Qadr and free will together?
Mission check
?A teacher knows her student so well that she correctly predicts he will choose to cheat in a test. He cheats. Many believers use this example to make which point?
Many believers hold that God knows our choices without forcing them, so freedom and responsibility remain.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Forgiveness: letting go of anger and revenge; repentance: turning from wrong; reconciliation: restoring the relationship.
Jesus: forgive "seventy times seven" (Matthew 18:22).
Muslims: Allah is al-Ghafur (64:14); Jews: teshuvah (Micah 7:18); Buddhists: "hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada 5).
Forgiving the person can go with justice for the act.
Mission 2
Moral evil comes from human choices; natural evil from nature. Suffering raises the inconsistent triad (omnipotent, omnibenevolent God and evil) and the evidential problem; innocent suffering is the hardest case.
Traditions locate the origin of evil differently: Fall and Original Sin; yetzer ha-ra and choice; Iblis and testing; karma, ignorance and maya; craving; ego and the five evils.
Mission 3
Augustine: evil is a privation of good, caused by misused free will (the Fall). Irenaeus and Hick: the world is a vale of soul-making. Both face objections (evolution; the amount of suffering).
Job: trust God beyond understanding; practical responses: prayer and charity; Humanists act to reduce suffering.
Muslims see life as a test (Surah 2:155–156, 67:2) met with sabr, prayer and charity.
Jews respond through Job, the Psalms, tzedakah and, after the Shoah, very different theologies.
Mission 4
Wrongdoing is rooted in sin, selfishness, greed or ignorance; every tradition teaches a way to overcome it.
Free will, determinism and predestination; for Muslims, al-Qadr and human freedom are held together.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Good and Evil: Christian perspective; muslim perspective (part 2) for Eduqas GCSE Religious Studies (Route A). 🎉
Mission 1If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
Mission 2If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 3Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 4If God already knows what you will choose, are you still free, and still to blame?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.