Crime and its causes

A crime is an act that breaks the law. People commit crimes for many reasons:

• Causes of crime: poverty, upbringing, addiction, mental illness, greed, peer pressure, or opposition to an unjust law.
• Types of crime: against the person (e.g. assault), against property (e.g. theft), and against the state.
• Religious response: many believers accept that difficult circumstances play a part, while still holding people responsible for their choices; they emphasise justice and compassion.

Non-religious view: Humanists tend to focus on the social causes of crime and on rehabilitation and prevention, based on evidence about what reduces reoffending.

The aims of punishment

Why does society punish people who break the law? There are several aims of punishment:

• Deterrence — to put people off committing crime.
• Retribution — the wrongdoer "pays back" for what they did.
• Reformation (rehabilitation) — to help the offender change and become a better person.
• Protection — to keep society safe from harm.

Religious emphasis: many Christians stress reformation and mercy ("go and sin no more"); Islam and Christianity both value justice, so retribution and protection also matter.

Aims of punishment

The death penalty

The death penalty (capital punishment) is the most debated form of punishment. There is a genuine range of views:

• Arguments for: some argue it delivers justice for the worst crimes, deters others, and protects society.
• Arguments against: many argue it is wrong to take life, that mistakes cannot be undone, and that it does not clearly deter crime.
• Religious views differ: the Roman Catholic Church now teaches the death penalty is inadmissible; many Christians oppose it, valuing sanctity of life and forgiveness. Some believers point to scriptural support for it. Views also vary among Muslims.
• Non-religious view: many Humanists oppose the death penalty, focusing on human rights and the risk of executing the innocent.

Forgiveness

Forgiveness means letting go of blame or the desire for revenge. It is a central value in many faiths.

• Christianity: Jesus taught forgiving "seventy times seven" (Matthew 18:21–22) and prayed for those who crucified him. Forgiveness does not always mean removing all consequences.
• Islam: Allah is "the Most Merciful"; Muslims are encouraged to forgive, and mercy is highly valued.
• Non-religious view: many Humanists value forgiveness and reconciliation for the good it does to people and relationships, without a religious basis.

Key idea: forgiveness and justice can go together — a person can be forgiven and still face fair consequences.

Aim → meaning

Tap an aim of punishment on the left, then its meaning on the right.

The origin of evil

Where does evil come from? Two types are often distinguished:

• Moral evil — suffering caused by human choices (e.g. cruelty, war).
• Natural evil — suffering caused by nature (e.g. earthquakes, disease).

Religious explanations include:

• Free will: God gave humans genuine freedom, and moral evil results from misusing it (linked to the Fall in Genesis 3).
• Test / soul-making: some argue struggle and suffering can help people grow.

Non-religious view: Humanists usually explain evil and suffering through human behaviour and natural processes, without reference to God.

Moral vs natural evil

The problem of suffering

If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why is there suffering? This is the problem of evil (often linked to Epicurus).

• Free will response: genuine love and goodness require freedom, and freedom allows evil.
• Trust in God: the Book of Job suggests humans cannot always understand God's reasons, but can still trust him.
• Responding to suffering: many believers respond with prayer, charity and practical help for those who suffer.
• Non-religious view: some atheists argue suffering is strong evidence against an all-loving, all-powerful God; Humanists focus on reducing suffering through human effort.

Good, evil and conscience

How do people decide what is good? Sources of moral guidance include:

• Sacred texts and teachings — e.g. the Ten Commandments, Jesus' teaching, the Qur'an and Sunnah.
• Conscience — an inner sense of right and wrong; many believers see this as a God-given guide.
• Reason and consequences — Humanists especially stress using reason, evidence and empathy to work out how to reduce harm and increase wellbeing.

Shared ground: religious and non-religious people often agree on many moral basics — such as that murder, cruelty and dishonesty are wrong.

Views on the death penalty

Whose view?

Tap a view, then tap whether it is best described as a religious-based or a non-religious (Humanist) view.

Name it

Read each description, then tap the correct term.

Forgiveness

The problem of evil

What to know

You've covered the Eduqas theme Issues of Good and Evil. Press Finish to see your score.