← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 2 2A Catholic Christianity – Section 4: Peace and Conflict (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Peace and Conflict (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Can a war be holy? What do sacred texts really say about fighting?
  2. Mission 2Can owning a weapon you must never use keep the world safe?
  3. Mission 3Jesus overturned tables in the Temple. Is anger ever right, and can it justify violence?
  4. Mission 4Terrorists sometimes claim to act for God and call bombers martyrs. What do religions really teach?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Can a war be holy? What do sacred texts really say about fighting?

Make a guess: Can a war be holy? What do sacred texts really say about fighting?

Mission 1

What a holy war is

Holy war and just war comparedHoly warJust warReasonreligiousreasonsjustice; religionis not the causeAuthorityclaimed:commanded orapproved byGod or areligious leadera lawfulgovernmentPromise ortesta spiritualreward(forgiveness ofsins, paradise)judged bymoralconditionsTypicalaimsdefend thefaith, win backholy places,spread areligionrestore peaceand justiceMany believers say "holy war" is acontradiction: war cannot be holy, though itmay sometimes be necessary.
  • Holy war: a war fought for religious reasons, believed to be commanded or approved by God or a religious leader.
  • Typical aims: to defend the faith, win back holy places, or spread a religion.
  • Fighters are often promised a spiritual reward (forgiveness of sins, paradise).
  • Compare just war: fought for justice, judged by moral conditions; religion is not the cause.
  • Many believers say "holy war" is a contradiction: war cannot be holy, though it may sometimes be necessary.
Mission 1

War in the Old Testament

War in the Old TestamentExodus 15:3"The LORD is a man of war": Godpictured as a warrior who rescues IsraelDeuteronomy 20rules of war: offer peace first (20:10); donot cut down fruit trees (20:19)Joshua 6; 8:1conquest of Canaan: Jericho, Ai2 Samuel 22:35David praises God, "Who traineth myhands for war"Isaiah 2:4 · Micah 4:3swords into ploughshares: an age withno war
  • God is pictured as a warrior who rescues Israel: "The LORD is a man of war. The LORD is his name." (Exodus 15:3)
  • Conquest of Canaan: God commands Joshua to take the land (e.g. Jericho, Joshua 6; Ai, Joshua 8:1).
  • Some passages command the total destruction of Canaanite cities (Deuteronomy 20:16–17). Jews and Christians have long wrestled with them: many read them as tied to that time and never to be repeated.
  • Rules of war (Deuteronomy 20): offer peace first (20:10); do not cut down fruit trees (20:19).
  • The prophets look ahead to an age with no war (Isaiah 2:4; Micah 4:3).
Mission 1Read the source

Swords and ploughshares

"They will beat their swords into ploughshares, and their spears into pruning hooks. Nation will not lift up sword against nation, neither will they learn war any more." (Micah 4:3; almost the same in Isaiah 2:4)

"Beat your ploughshares into swords, and your pruning hooks into spears." (Joel 3:10)

Q1 What does Micah picture happening to weapons?

Show answer

They are turned into farming tools: war ends.

Q2 Why might someone say the Old Testament speaks with more than one voice on war?

Show answer

Joel calls people to arm for God's judgement; Micah and Isaiah picture war ending for good.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes the Old Testament's teaching on war?
Mission 1

Christianity: the Crusades and today

The Crusades and today1095Pope Urban II calls Christiansto win back Jerusalem;fighters promised remissionof the penance due for sins1099Jerusalem falls, with amassacre of its Muslim andJewish inhabitants12 March2000Day of Pardon: Pope JohnPaul II asks forgiveness forviolence used "in the serviceof the truth"Todaymainstream Churches rejectholy war: Jesus' kingdom isnot spread by force
  • The Crusades (from 1095): Pope Urban II called Christians to win back Jerusalem; fighters were promised remission of the penance due for sins.
  • Jerusalem fell in 1099 with a massacre of its Muslim and Jewish inhabitants.
  • Today mainstream Churches reject holy war: Jesus' kingdom is not spread by force.
  • In 2000 Pope John Paul II publicly asked forgiveness for violence some Christians had used "in the service of the truth" (Day of Pardon, 12 March 2000).
  • "I didn't come to send peace, but a sword." (Matthew 10:34). Most Christians read the "sword" as the division following Jesus can cause, even in families (Matthew 10:35; Luke 12:51 says "division").
  • Matthew 10:34–40 goes on: those who welcome Jesus' followers welcome him.
Quick check
?A student quotes "I didn't come to send peace, but a sword" (Matthew 10:34) as proof that Jesus supported holy war. How do most Christians interpret the verse?
Mission 1Diversity

Islam

Holy war? Five religionsHoly war?IslamNo (most scholars)Harb al-Maqadis ("holy war")only lesser jihad: defensive war with strictconditionsSource: "There is no compulsion in religion"(Qur'an 2:256); "if they incline to peace, inclinethou also to it" (8:61); 9:1–14: tribes that broketreaties and "did attack you first" (9:13)JudaismDefence todaymilchemet mitzvahobligatory war, commanded by God (e.g.Joshua) or in self-defence; most Jews today:only defensive warSource: "Who traineth my hands for war" (2Samuel 22:35)HinduismDuty, not spreading faithKshatriya dharmano war to spread a religion; Arjuna must fightas his duty: shirking it "shall be sin"; many readthe battle as an inner struggleSource: Bhagavad Gita 2.33SikhismDefence of the oppressedsaint-soldier (sant sipahi)devoted to God, ready to defend the oppressedof any faith; Guru Hargobind's two swords: miri(worldly power) and piri (spiritual authority)Source: Bhai Nand Lal's Tankhah Nama: thetrue Khalsa protects the poor, never attacks theinnocentBuddhismNokilling is unskilfulrooted in greed, hatred and delusion(Sammaditthi Sutta); Simile of the Saw(Kakacupama Sutta): anyone who hates evenbandits who cut him limb from limb is notfollowing the teachingDivergence: some Buddhists in historysupported wars; most see this as a betrayal ofthe teaching
  • Harb al-Muqadas ("holy war").
  • Your spec writes Harb al-Maqadis.
  • Most Muslim scholars say Islam has no holy war in the crusade sense: war cannot be fought to spread Islam, because "There is no compulsion in religion" (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall).
  • What exists is lesser jihad: defensive war with strict conditions.
  • "And if they incline to peace, incline thou also to it, and trust in Allah." (Qur'an 8:61, Pickthall)
  • Surah 9:1–14 addresses tribes that broke their treaties and "did attack you first" (9:13); treaty-keepers are exempt (9:4), and any who ask for protection must be given it (9:6). Scholars warn that extremists quote verse 9:5 without this context.
Mission 1Diversity

Judaism, Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism

Holy war? Five religionsHoly war?IslamNo (most scholars)Harb al-Maqadis ("holy war")only lesser jihad: defensive war with strictconditionsSource: "There is no compulsion in religion"(Qur'an 2:256); "if they incline to peace, inclinethou also to it" (8:61); 9:1–14: tribes that broketreaties and "did attack you first" (9:13)JudaismDefence todaymilchemet mitzvahobligatory war, commanded by God (e.g.Joshua) or in self-defence; most Jews today:only defensive warSource: "Who traineth my hands for war" (2Samuel 22:35)HinduismDuty, not spreading faithKshatriya dharmano war to spread a religion; Arjuna must fightas his duty: shirking it "shall be sin"; many readthe battle as an inner struggleSource: Bhagavad Gita 2.33SikhismDefence of the oppressedsaint-soldier (sant sipahi)devoted to God, ready to defend the oppressedof any faith; Guru Hargobind's two swords: miri(worldly power) and piri (spiritual authority)Source: Bhai Nand Lal's Tankhah Nama: thetrue Khalsa protects the poor, never attacks theinnocentBuddhismNokilling is unskilfulrooted in greed, hatred and delusion(Sammaditthi Sutta); Simile of the Saw(Kakacupama Sutta): anyone who hates evenbandits who cut him limb from limb is notfollowing the teachingDivergence: some Buddhists in historysupported wars; most see this as a betrayal ofthe teaching
  • Judaism: milchemet mitzvah, an obligatory war commanded by God (e.g. Joshua's conquest) or fought in self-defence. David praises God, "Who traineth my hands for war" (2 Samuel 22:35, JPS 1917). Most Jews today hold that only defensive war is permitted.
  • Hinduism: no war to spread a religion. Krishna urges Arjuna to fight because it is his duty (dharma) as a Kshatriya: shirking it "shall be sin" (Bhagavad Gita 2.33, Arnold). Many Hindus, like Gandhi, also read the battle as an inner struggle.
  • Sikhism: the saint-soldier (sant sipahi): devoted to God and ready to defend the oppressed of any faith. Guru Hargobind wore two swords, miri (worldly power) and piri (spiritual authority).
  • Bhai Nand Lal's Tankhah Nama describes the true Khalsa as one who protects the poor and fights evil, not one who attacks the innocent (paraphrase).
  • Buddhism: no holy war. The Sammaditthi Sutta counts killing as unskilful action, rooted in greed, hatred and delusion. In the Kakacupama Sutta (Simile of the Saw), the Buddha teaches that even if bandits cut you limb from limb, anyone who hates them is not following his teaching (paraphrase).
  • Divergence: some Buddhists in history (e.g. some Japanese Zen teachers in the Second World War) supported wars; most Buddhists see this as a betrayal of the teaching.
Quick check
?Why does Krishna tell Arjuna in the Bhagavad Gita that he must fight?
Mission 1

Is religion a cause of war?

Is religion a cause of war?PoliticalEconomicNationalNon-religiousideologiesReligion asidentitya label for apeopleReligion asmotivea claimeddivinecommandWarcause or label?
  • Non-religious critics (atheists, Humanists): holy war shows the danger of claiming God's authority; a divine command cannot be questioned by reason or compromise.
  • Examples they give: the Crusades, the European wars of religion (16th–17th centuries), modern jihadist groups.
  • Religious responses: most wars have political, economic or national causes; religion is often a label for a people's identity.
  • Many non-religious ideologies have also caused war.
  • Religious teachings also limit war and inspire peacemakers.
Mission 1Evaluate

"Religion can never justify going to war."

Argument map: can religion ever justify war?Religion can never justify going to war.ForJesus taught love of enemiesHoly wars like the Crusades caused greatsufferingReligion should unite, not divideBuddhist teaching counts killing asunskilful; many Hindus put ahimsa(non-harm) firstAgainstThe Old Testament describes wars Godapproves and sets rules for them(Deuteronomy 20)Defending the right to worship freely maybe a just causeLesser jihad within strict limits (Qur'an8:61)Arjuna's duty as a Kshatriya (Gita 2.33)Sikhs may fight to protect the oppressedof any faithAnother viewReligion may justify defensive war, butnever war to spread a faithJudge it byIs the war about religion or only described inreligious terms? · Does defending a people'sfreedom of religion count? · Who hasauthority to interpret scripture?
  • Reasons for: Jesus taught love of enemies; holy wars like the Crusades caused great suffering; religion should unite, not divide.
  • Buddhist teaching counts killing as unskilful, and many Hindus put ahimsa (non-harm) first.
  • Reasons against: the Old Testament describes wars God approves and sets rules for them (Deuteronomy 20); defending the right to worship freely may be a just cause.
  • Other scriptures and traditions allow fighting in defence: lesser jihad within strict limits (Qur'an 8:61); Arjuna's duty as a Kshatriya (Gita 2.33); Sikhs may fight to protect the oppressed of any faith.
  • Another view: religion may justify defensive war, but never war to spread a faith.
  • Judge it by: Is the war about religion or only described in religious terms? Does defending a people's freedom of religion count? Who has authority to interpret scripture?
Mission check

?A militia leader posts a video: God commands his fighters to seize a holy city from another faith, and anyone killed will go straight to paradise. Which feature makes this a holy war claim rather than a just war argument?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can owning a weapon you must never use keep the world safe?

Make a guess: Can owning a weapon you must never use keep the world safe?

Mission 2

Weapons of mass destruction

Weapons of mass destruction and the treaties against themNuclearblast, heatand radiationChemicalpoison gases(e.g. nerveagents)BiologicaldeadlydiseasesspreaddeliberatelyEffects last for generations.International law1968Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty1972Biological Weapons Convention1993Chemical Weapons Convention2017Treaty on the Prohibition of NuclearWeapons: nuclear-armed states,including the UK, have not joined
  • WMD: weapons that can kill huge numbers of people and cause great damage, without distinguishing soldiers from civilians.
  • Nuclear: blast, heat and radiation. Hiroshima (6 August 1945) and Nagasaki (9 August 1945) are the only wartime uses.
  • Chemical: poison gases (e.g. nerve agents). Biological: deadly diseases spread deliberately.
  • Effects last for generations: radiation sickness, cancers, poisoned land and water.
  • International law: Biological Weapons Convention (1972); Chemical Weapons Convention (1993); Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (1968); Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (2017), which nuclear-armed states, including the UK, have not joined.
Mission 2

Nuclear deterrence

How nuclear deterrence is meant to workACountry ABCountry BIf you strike,we strike backNeither strikes firstmutually assureddestructionForno nuclear warbetween majorpowers since 1945;protects a nationagainst blackmailAgainstaccidents ormisjudgement;enormous cost;others seek weapons;terrorists cannot bedeterred; rests on athreat to kill civilians
  • Deterrence: owning nuclear weapons so that no enemy dares attack, for fear of devastating retaliation.
  • "Mutually assured destruction": if both sides would be destroyed, neither strikes first.
  • The UK keeps a nuclear deterrent (Trident submarines).
  • For: no nuclear war between major powers since 1945; protects a nation against blackmail.
  • Against: accidents or misjudgement could cause catastrophe; enormous cost; encourages other states to seek weapons; terrorists cannot be deterred; it rests on a threat to kill civilians.
  • Unilateral disarmament: giving weapons up alone. Multilateral: all sides disarming together by agreement.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes nuclear deterrence?
Mission 2

Catholic teaching

Catholic teaching on nuclear weapons1965Gaudium et Spes 80: destroyingwhole cities and their people is "acrime against God and man himself"(also CCC 2314); 81: the arms race isnot a safe way to keep peace1982John Paul II: deterrence "may still bejudged morally acceptable", but onlyas a step towards progressivedisarmament2017Francis: the threat to use nuclearweapons, and even possessing them,is to be firmly condemned2017the Holy See is among the first statesto ratify the Treaty on the Prohibitionof Nuclear Weapons2019Francis at Hiroshima: their use andpossession are immoral
  • Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes 80 (1965): any act of war aimed at destroying whole cities and their people is "a crime against God and man himself" (also CCC 2314).
  • The arms race is not a safe way to keep peace (Gaudium et Spes 81).
  • John Paul II (1982): deterrence "may still be judged morally acceptable", but only as a step towards progressive disarmament.
  • Pope Francis (2017): the threat to use nuclear weapons, and even possessing them, is to be firmly condemned. At Hiroshima (2019) he called their use and possession immoral.
  • The Holy See was among the first states to ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (2017).
  • Different Catholic views: some Catholics still accept deterrence for now, until all sides disarm together; others (e.g. Pax Christi) campaign for disarmament now.
Mission 2

Other Christian views

Christian views on nuclear weaponsDeterrence as atemporary necessitymany Anglicans andother Protestants;some Catholics, untilall sides disarmtogetherOppose outright:disarmament nowQuakers, Methodists,Christian CND; otherCatholics, e.g. PaxChristiWhy some oppose them outrightthey cannot meet the just war rule ofdiscrimination
  • Many Anglicans and other Protestants have accepted deterrence as a temporary necessity while working for multilateral disarmament.
  • Quakers, Methodists and Christian CND oppose nuclear weapons outright: they cannot meet the just war rule of discrimination.
  • "all those who take the sword will die by the sword" (Matthew 26:52).
  • Deuteronomy 20:19–20: even in a siege, fruit trees must not be destroyed. If war must spare trees, many argue it cannot justify destroying cities and the land itself.
  • Genesis 1–2: humans are stewards of creation; WMD can poison the earth for generations.
Mission 2

Utilitarian and non-religious arguments

A utilitarian weighing of nuclear weaponsUtilitarianism (Bentham, Mill)actions are right "in proportion as they tend topromote happiness" (Mill, 1863)War preventedif deterrenceprevents a worldwar: the greatestgood for the greatestnumberRisk of catastrophe,costeven a small riskmeans suffering onan unimaginablescale; the moneycould relieve poverty
  • Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham, 1748–1832; John Stuart Mill, 1806–1873): actions are right "in proportion as they tend to promote happiness" (Mill, Utilitarianism, 1863).
  • Argument for acquiring WMD: if deterrence prevents a world war, owning them produces the greatest good for the greatest number.
  • Some argued the Hiroshima bomb saved more lives than it took by ending the war sooner; historians dispute this.
  • Utilitarian argument against: even a small risk of nuclear war risks suffering on an unimaginable scale; the money could relieve poverty.
  • Humanists and atheists judge by consequences and human rights; most support multilateral disarmament; some accept deterrence as the lesser evil for now.
  • Religious responses: some believers accept the deterrence argument; others say deliberately threatening civilians is wrong whatever the outcome.
Quick check
?Which argument would a utilitarian most likely give for a country keeping nuclear weapons?
Mission 2Diversity

Other religions

Five religions on weapons of mass destructionIslamthe rules of lesser jihad forbid killing civiliansand destroying cropsSource: "whosoever killeth a human being … itshall be as if he had killed all mankind" (Qur'an5:32)On deterrence: most scholars reject usingWMD; some accept owning them as adeterrent for defenceJudaismlimits on destruction in warPurity of Arms: weapons used only as needed,never against non-combatantsSource: Deuteronomy 20On deterrence: many accept it to protect life;others say WMD can never be used lawfullyBuddhismWMD break the First Precept on a vast scaleSource: "do not kill, nor cause slaughter"(Dhammapada 130)Hinduismahimsa: harming others harms the one Self inallSource: "He sees indeed who sees in all alike /The living, lordly Soul" (Bhagavad Gita 13.27)On deterrence: India has nuclear weapons;some Hindus defend them as deterrenceSikhismDharam Yudh forbids harming civilians, soWMD fail its conditionsSource: Guru Granth Sahib 146: the importanceof the earth
  • Islam: "whosoever killeth a human being … it shall be as if he had killed all mankind" (Qur'an 5:32, Pickthall). The rules of lesser jihad forbid killing civilians and destroying crops, so most scholars reject using WMD. Some accept owning them as a deterrent for defence.
  • Judaism: Deuteronomy 20 limits destruction in war.
  • The Israeli army's code of Purity of Arms: weapons used only as needed for the mission, never against non-combatants.
  • Many Jews accept deterrence to protect life; others argue WMD can never be used lawfully.
  • Buddhism: "All men tremble at punishment, all men love life; remember that thou art like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter." (Dhammapada 130, Müller). WMD break the First Precept on a vast scale.
  • Hinduism: ahimsa; "He sees indeed who sees in all alike / The living, lordly Soul" (Bhagavad Gita 13.27, Arnold): harming others harms the one Self in all. India has nuclear weapons, and some Hindus defend them as deterrence.
  • Sikhism: Dharam Yudh forbids harming civilians, so WMD fail its conditions.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 146 is your spec's named source on the importance of the earth.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Nuclear deterrence is morally justified."

Argument map: is nuclear deterrence morally justified?Nuclear deterrence is morally justified.ForNo nuclear war between great powerssince 1945A nation has a duty to protect its peopleUtilitarian benefit if war is preventedJohn Paul II (1982) accepted it as atemporary stepAgainstIt rests on a willingness to kill millions ofciviliansOne accident could be catastrophicFrancis (2017) condemned evenpossessionQur'an 5:32 and the First Precept treateach life as preciousVast costAnother viewAcceptable only temporarily, with realsteps towards multilateral disarmamentJudge it byIs threatening an act as wrong as doing it? ·Has deterrence actually kept the peace? ·What happens if one side disarms alone?
  • Reasons for: no nuclear war between great powers since 1945; a nation has a duty to protect its people; utilitarian benefit if war is prevented; John Paul II (1982) accepted it as a temporary step.
  • Reasons against: it rests on a willingness to kill millions of civilians; one accident could be catastrophic; Francis (2017) condemned even possession; Qur'an 5:32 and the First Precept treat each life as precious; vast cost.
  • Another view: acceptable only temporarily, with real steps towards multilateral disarmament.
  • Judge it by: Is threatening an act as wrong as doing it? Has deterrence actually kept the peace? What happens if one side disarms alone?
Mission check

?A country builds a cyber-weapon that could shut down an enemy's hospitals, water and power for months, harming millions. Its leaders say they will never use it: owning it will stop attacks. What would Pope Francis's teaching on nuclear weapons most likely lead him to say?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Jesus overturned tables in the Temple. Is anger ever right, and can it justify violence?

Make a guess: Jesus overturned tables in the Temple. Is anger ever right, and can it justify violence?

Mission 3

Violence and the human condition

Forms of violencephysical!verbalemotionalonlineGenesis 4:8Cain kills hisbrother AbelGenesis 6:11"the earth wasfilled with violence"
  • Violence: using force to hurt, damage or control. It can be physical, verbal, emotional, or online.
  • The Bible shows violence early in the human story: after the Fall, "Cain rose up against Abel, his brother, and killed him" (Genesis 4:8, WEBBE).
  • By Noah's time, "the earth was filled with violence" (Genesis 6:11, WEBBE).
  • Christians see this as a result of sin: human nature is damaged, so violence is part of the human condition.
  • Jesus traces violence to the heart: being angry with a brother "without a cause" puts a person in danger of judgement (Matthew 5:22, WEBBE).
Mission 3

Christian teaching on violence

Christian views on violenceChristian views on violencerefuse all violenceQuakers and someothersforce by the state asa last resortmost ChristiansOff the scaleviolence for personal revengerejected by almost all Christians
  • "Love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you" (Matthew 5:44, WEBBE).
  • "Whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also." (Matthew 5:39, WEBBE)
  • At his arrest: "all those who take the sword will die by the sword" (Matthew 26:52, WEBBE).
  • "Repay no one evil for evil." (Romans 12:17, WEBBE)
  • Almost all Christians reject violence for personal revenge. They differ on force by the state: most accept it as a last resort in self-defence or war; Quakers and some others refuse all violence.
Mission 3Read the source

Two voices

"But I tell you who hear: love your enemies, do good to those who hate you, bless those who curse you, and pray for those who mistreat you." (Luke 6:27–28, WEBBE)

"As you would like people to do to you, do exactly so to them." (Luke 6:31, WEBBE)

Q1 Which line from Luke gives the Golden Rule?

Show answer

Luke 6:31: treat others as you would like to be treated.

Q2 Why do Christians read Luke 6 as a challenge to violence?

Show answer

It asks for good, blessing and prayer in return for hatred and harm.

Quick check
?Which statement about Christian teaching on violence is accurate?
Mission 3

Righteous anger

Anger to actioninjusticerighteous angerrevenge or violenceaims at destroyingthe personcorrect the wrongaims at the wrong,not at destroying thepersonaction for justicenon-violent protest:Martin Luther King,Dorothy Dayviolent protestsuffragettes smashedwindows (1912); theANC turned to armedstruggle (1961)
  • Righteous anger: anger at injustice or wrong done to others, not at personal insult.
  • Jesus "made a whip of cords and drove all out of the temple" and "overthrew their tables" (John 2:15, WEBBE): anger at the Temple being used for trade.
  • "Be angry, and don't sin." (Ephesians 4:26, WEBBE). Christians read this as: anger itself is not sin; what we do with it matters.
  • Righteous anger aims at the wrong, not at destroying the person; many Christians say it should lead to action for justice, not violence.
  • Humanists also see anger at injustice as a healthy motive for change, if channelled peacefully.
Mission 3

Violent protest

Anger to actioninjusticerighteous angerrevenge or violenceaims at destroyingthe personcorrect the wrongaims at the wrong,not at destroying thepersonaction for justicenon-violent protest:Martin Luther King,Dorothy Dayviolent protestsuffragettes smashedwindows (1912); theANC turned to armedstruggle (1961)
  • Protest: a public show of disagreement. In the UK peaceful protest is legal; violent protest (riots, damage, attacks) is not.
  • Examples: some suffragettes smashed windows (1912); the ANC turned to armed struggle against apartheid (1961); Martin Luther King (1929–1968) led non-violent protest for civil rights.
  • Most Christians support non-violent protest, following King and the example of Jesus.
  • Some Christians joined resistance to tyranny: Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906–1945), a Lutheran pastor, was executed for links to the plot against Hitler.
  • Non-religious views vary too: most Humanists favour peaceful change; some argue violence may be justified against tyranny.
Mission 3

Catholics who worked against violence

Two livesDorothy Day1897–1980co-founded theCatholic Worker(1933), New Yorkhouses of hospitalityfor the poorlifelong pacifistOscar Romero1917–1980Archbishop of SanSalvadortold soldiers not tokillshot dead at Mass, 24March 1980declared a saint in2018
  • Dorothy Day (1897–1980): co-founded the Catholic Worker movement (1933) in New York; houses of hospitality for the poor; a lifelong pacifist who opposed every war.
  • Oscar Romero (1917–1980): Archbishop of San Salvador. He spoke out against killings by the army and death squads during El Salvador's civil conflict, and told soldiers not to kill.
  • He was shot dead while celebrating Mass (24 March 1980) and declared a saint in 2018.
  • Both put Luke 6:27–31 into practice: loving enemies while confronting violence and injustice.
Mission 3Diversity

Other traditions on violence

Other traditions on violenceLimits on violenceSourceIslamno killing "save with right";in war, do not kill women,children or the old (AbuBakr)Surah 17:33;Muwatta 21.3.10Judaismlimited by law; self-defencepermitted; God rights theoppressedPsalm 10:18BuddhismFirst Precept: not harmingliving beings; boundless lovefor all beings; EngagedBuddhismKaraniya MettaSutta; Thich NhatHanhHinduismahimsa a high ideal; yetArjuna must fight in arighteous warBhagavad Gita(Gita 11)Sikhismnever for revenge or gain;force only to defend theoppressed, when all elsefails; the five thievesGuru GranthSahib 1330
  • Islam: "slay not the life which Allah hath forbidden save with right" (Surah 17:33, Pickthall).
  • Abu Bakr's instructions in war forbid killing women, children and the old (Malik's Muwatta 21.3.10, paraphrase).
  • Judaism: God will hear the humble, "To right the fatherless and the oppressed, that man who is of the earth may be terrible no more" (Psalm 10:18, JPS 1917). Violence is limited by law; self-defence is permitted.
  • Buddhism: the First Precept: not harming living beings. The Karaniya Metta Sutta (paraphrase): as a mother protects her only child, cultivate boundless love for all beings.
  • Engaged Buddhism (Thich Nhat Hanh, 1926–2022) applies this to war, injustice and violence.
  • Hinduism: ahimsa (non-harm) is a high ideal; yet in the Gita, Arjuna, a warrior, must fight in a righteous war.
  • In Gita 11 he sees Krishna's universal form as all-powerful Time, which destroys the warriors (paraphrase).
  • Sikhism: violence for revenge or gain is wrong; force is allowed only to defend the oppressed, when all else fails.
  • Sikhs trace violence to the five thieves (lust, anger, greed, attachment, pride) in the self-centred mind. Your spec's Sikh source here is Guru Granth Sahib 1330.
Quick check
?A Buddhist group runs workshops for former gang members, teaching meditation on loving-kindness to reduce violence. Which teaching are they applying most directly?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Violence is never justified."

Argument map"Violence is never justified."ForJesus' teaching (Matthew 5:39, 5:44; Luke6:27–31) and exampleviolence breeds more violence (Matthew26:52)non-violent movements (Gandhi, King)achieved changeahimsa and the First PreceptAgainstself-defence and protecting the innocentthe Temple shows anger at injustice canlead to actionSikh and Hindu teaching on defending theoppressedresistance to tyranny (Bonhoeffer)Another viewforce by police or a lawful state differsfrom personal violence; "never" may betoo absoluteNon-religious: Humanists generallyoppose violence, but most acceptself-defence and some just warsJudge it byWho is using force, and why? · Is it the lastresort? · Does it protect others or seekrevenge?
  • Reasons for: Jesus' teaching (Matthew 5:39, 5:44; Luke 6:27–31) and example; violence breeds more violence (Matthew 26:52); non-violent movements (Gandhi, King) achieved change.
  • Also for: ahimsa and the First Precept.
  • Reasons against: self-defence and protecting the innocent; the Temple shows anger at injustice can lead to action.
  • Also against: Sikh and Hindu teaching on defending the oppressed.
  • Also against: resistance to tyranny (Bonhoeffer).
  • Another view: force by police or a lawful state differs from personal violence; "never" may be too absolute.
  • Non-religious: Humanists generally oppose violence, but most accept self-defence and some just wars.
  • Judge it by: Who is using force, and why? Is it the last resort? Does it protect others or seek revenge?
Mission check

?At a peaceful march against a factory polluting a village's water, some protesters start throwing bricks at police. Abi, a Christian, is furious about the pollution but leaves the march and begins a legal campaign instead. Which statement best describes Abi's response?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Terrorists sometimes claim to act for God and call bombers martyrs. What do religions really teach?

Make a guess: Terrorists sometimes claim to act for God and call bombers martyrs. What do religions really teach?

Mission 4

What terrorism is

The three marks of terrorismViolenceor the threatof itFearthe aimCausepolitical,religious orideologicalWar between armiesrules about who maybe targetedTerrorismtargets civilians:people who are notfighting
  • Terrorism: the use or threat of violence, usually against civilians, to spread fear and so force a political, religious or ideological change.
  • Three marks: violence · fear as the aim · a cause beyond the act itself.
  • It targets people who are not fighting: commuters, shoppers, concert-goers.
  • That is what separates it from war between armies, which has rules about who may be targeted.
  • Terrorists are usually small groups, not states, and often call themselves soldiers or martyrs.
Mission 4

Why people turn to terror

Radicalisation: often gradualoften gradualGrievancea sense of being treated unfairly orignoredExtremist messageincreasingly onlineClosed group"us" and "them"Violence presented as a duty
  • Political grievance: a sense that a people is occupied, ruled unfairly or ignored.
  • Ideology: nationalist, far-right, far-left or religious-extremist ideas that divide the world into "us" and "them".
  • Perceived injustice and humiliation: poverty, discrimination, foreign intervention.
  • Belonging and identity: extremist groups offer purpose and a "family" to isolated people.
  • Religion, politics and terrorism: in many 21st-century groups (e.g. al-Qaeda, the so-called Islamic State), political aims are wrapped in religious language. The religion's mainstream scholars reject that use.
  • Not all terrorism is religious or Muslim: e.g. the IRA and ETA (nationalist), the 2011 Norway attacks and the 2019 Christchurch mosque attacks (far-right), and Aum Shinrikyo's 1995 Tokyo attack (a new religious movement).
Mission 4

Radicalisation

Radicalisation: often gradualoften gradualGrievancea sense of being treated unfairly orignoredExtremist messageincreasingly onlineClosed group"us" and "them"Violence presented as a duty
  • Radicalisation: the process by which a person comes to support, and perhaps join, violent extremism.
  • Often gradual: grievance → contact with an extremist message (increasingly online) → a closed group → violence presented as a duty.
  • Recruiters often use a distorted reading of scripture taken out of its context.
Quick check
?A group sets off a bomb in a busy market to force a government to change its policy. What most clearly makes this terrorism rather than an act of war?
Mission 4Diversity

Other religions on terrorism

Religions and Humanists on terrorismChristianity"love your enemies"; mainstream churchescondemn all terrorismSource: Luke 6:27Islamkilling one innocent is "as if he had killed allmankind"; in 2014 more than a hundredscholars rejected the so-called Islamic State'sclaimsSource: Qur'an 5:32Your spec: Malik's Muwatta 21.3.10: Abu Bakrforbade killing women, children or the elderly,or cutting down fruit treesJudaism"Thou shalt not murder"; pikuach nefesh(saving a life) overrides almost every othercommandmentSource: Exodus 20:13Your spec: Psalm 10:12–18: justice is God's, notthe terrorist'sBuddhismthe First Precept: not harming life; hatred feedsmore hatredYour spec: Karaniya Metta Sutta:loving-kindness to all beingsHinduismahimsa (non-harming); the same divine Selflives in every beingYour spec: Bhagavad Gita 11: all beings inGod's handsSikhismprotect the innocent; violence driven by theFive Thieves (lust, anger, greed, attachment,pride) is wrongYour spec: Guru Granth Sahib 1330Humaniststerrorism violates human rights and dignity;disputes should be settled by reason anddemocratic means
  • Islam: "whosoever killeth a human being for other than manslaughter or corruption in the earth, it shall be as if he had killed all mankind" (Qur'an 5:32, Pickthall). In 2014 more than a hundred Muslim scholars signed an open letter rejecting the so-called Islamic State's claims.
  • Malik's Muwatta 21.3.10: Abu Bakr told his army not to kill women, children or the elderly, nor to cut down fruit trees (paraphrase).
  • Judaism: "Thou shalt not murder." (Exodus 20:13, JPS 1917). Life is of supreme value: pikuach nefesh (saving a life) overrides almost every other commandment.
  • Psalm 10:12–18: God hears the oppressed and will bring justice, so justice is God's, not the terrorist's (paraphrase).
  • Buddhism: the First Precept (not harming life); hatred feeds more hatred.
  • The Karaniya Metta Sutta asks for loving-kindness towards all beings without exception (paraphrase).
  • Hinduism: ahimsa (non-harming); the same divine Self lives in every being.
  • Bhagavad Gita 11: Arjuna's vision of the divine form, in which all beings and their fates are in God's hands (paraphrase).
  • Sikhism: protect the innocent; violence driven by the Five Thieves (lust, anger, greed, attachment, pride) is wrong.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 1330 is your spec's named source here.
  • Christianity: "love your enemies" (Luke 6:27); mainstream churches condemn all terrorism.
  • Humanists: terrorism violates human rights and dignity; reason and democratic means should settle disputes.
  • Martyrs: in Christianity a martyr (Greek martys, "witness") and in Islam a shahid ("witness") dies for faith; neither tradition's mainstream teaching counts killing innocents as martyrdom, and Islam forbids suicide.
Quick check
?A recruiter tells a young Muslim that attacking civilians abroad is a religious duty. Which response would most Muslim scholars give?
Mission 4Evaluate

"Religion is the main cause of terrorism."

Argument map: is religion the main cause of terrorism?Religion is the main cause of terrorism.ForSome groups use religious language andpromise heavenly rewardDawkins (The God Delusion, 2006): faiththat cannot be questioned can makeviolence seem holyAgainstMany terrorist groups are nationalist,far-right or politicalPape (Dying to Win, 2005): most suicideattacks linked to resisting occupationMainstream teaching in every religioncondemns terrorismAnother viewReligion is often a label for conflicts aboutland, power or identityJudge it byWhat do the groups themselves want? · Howdo most believers act? · Is a distorted religionstill "religion"?
  • Reasons for: some groups use religious language and promise heavenly reward. Some atheists (e.g. Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion, 2006) argue faith that cannot be questioned can make violence seem holy.
  • Reasons against: many terrorist groups are nationalist, far-right or political. Research on suicide attacks (Robert Pape, Dying to Win, 2005) linked most to resisting occupation. Mainstream teaching in every religion condemns terrorism.
  • Another view: religion is often a label for conflicts about land, power or identity.
  • Judge it by: What do the groups themselves want? How do most believers act? Is a distorted religion still "religion"?
Mission check

?A journalist is held for months by a group fighting a government. She is not harmed. Later she writes that her captors called a recent suicide bombing "martyrdom". How would most Christians and most Muslims describe the bomber?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • A holy war is fought for religious reasons, with claimed divine approval and spiritual reward.
  • The Old Testament contains holy war accounts, rules to limit war (Deuteronomy 20) and visions of peace (Micah 4:3); the Crusades are the Christian example, now rejected by mainstream Churches.
  • Lesser jihad, milchemet mitzvah, Kshatriya dharma and the Sikh saint-soldier are about defence and duty; Buddhism rejects war as unskilful.

Mission 2

  • WMD (nuclear, chemical, biological) kill indiscriminately; deterrence keeps them so they are never used.
  • Catholic teaching condemns indiscriminate destruction (Gaudium et Spes 80); popes have moved from tolerating deterrence (1982) to condemning possession (2017).
  • Utilitarians weigh consequences; most religious traditions reject using WMD, but believers differ about deterrence.

Mission 3

  • Violence is part of the human condition in the Bible (Cain, Genesis 4:8); Jesus teaches love of enemies, turning the other cheek and the Golden Rule (Matthew 5:39, 5:44; Luke 6:27–31).
  • Righteous anger targets injustice, not people (John 2:15; Ephesians 4:26).
  • Most believers support non-violent protest; views differ on resisting tyranny.
  • Other traditions limit violence: Surah 17:33, ahimsa, the First Precept and metta, Sikh defence of the oppressed.

Mission 4

  • Terrorism uses violence against civilians to spread fear for a cause; its causes are political, ideological and personal as well as religious.
  • Mainstream teaching in every major religion, and Humanism, condemns terrorism.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Peace and Conflict (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Can a war be holy? What do sacred texts really say about fighting?
  2. Mission 2Can owning a weapon you must never use keep the world safe?
  3. Mission 3Jesus overturned tables in the Temple. Is anger ever right, and can it justify violence?
  4. Mission 4Terrorists sometimes claim to act for God and call bombers martyrs. What do religions really teach?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel