🚀 Catholic Christianity: Matters of Life and Death (part 2)
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 1 1A Catholic Christianity – Section 4: Matters of Life and Death (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Catholic Christianity: Matters of Life and Death (part 2)
4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1When someone dies, what do the world's religions say happens next, and does it change how people live?
Mission 2Can anyone show there is life after death, or is it only a comforting hope?
Mission 3If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
Mission 4Can it ever be right to eat animals, or to test medicines on them?
Mission 1
Mission 1: When someone dies, what do the world's religions say happens next, and does it change how people live?
Make a guess: When someone dies, what do the world's religions say happens next, and does it change how people live?
Mission 1
Two shapes, and the question of the soul
Step 1 of 2
Afterlife: existence of some kind after death.
Linear view (Christianity, Islam, Judaism): one life → death → judgement → eternal destiny.
Cyclical view (Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism): birth → death → rebirth, again and again (samsara), shaped by karma (actions and their results), until liberation.
Soul: the non-physical, spiritual part of a person; for many believers, the real self that survives death.
Mission 1
Christian beliefs: judgement, heaven and hell
Death is not the end: Christians believe the risen Jesus has defeated death.
Judgement: God judges each person, through Christ; faith and how people lived both matter (Matthew 25:31–46).
Heaven: eternal life with God. Many Christians, including Catholic teaching, see it as a state of being with God more than a place in the sky.
Hell: eternal separation from God. Catholic teaching describes it as a person's own final rejection of God.
Purgatory (Catholic): a state of cleansing after death for those who die in God's friendship but are not yet fully pure; the living pray for them. Most Protestants reject it: they find no clear basis for it in the Bible.
Orthodox Christians pray for the dead too, but do not use the Catholic doctrine of purgatory.
At the end of time Christ will return, the dead will be raised, and there will be a Last Judgement.
Mission 1Read the source
The resurrection life
"I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in me will still live, even if he dies." (John 11:25)
"The body is sown perishable; it is raised imperishable. … It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body." (1 Corinthians 15:42, 44)
Ephesians 2:1–10 (paraphrase): people were dead in their sins; God, rich in mercy, made them alive with Christ and raised them up with him. "For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God" (Ephesians 2:8).
The resurrection of Jesus is the key evidence for Christians: because he rose, they believe they will too.
Q1 In 1 Corinthians 15, is the raised body the same as the old one?
Show answer
No: it is transformed: imperishable, glorious, spiritual.
Q2 What does John 11:25 link eternal life to?
Show answer
Believing in Jesus.
Mission 1
Resurrection of the body or survival of the soul?
Survival of the soul (popular belief, and the Greek idea of immortality): the soul floats free of the body for ever; the body was only a shell.
Resurrection of the body (Catholic and mainstream Christian teaching): the whole person is raised, body and soul, by God.
Catholic teaching: at death the soul is separated from the body and meets God; at the end of time it is reunited with a transformed, glorified body.
Not resuscitation: Lazarus (John 11) came back to ordinary life and later died again; resurrection means a new, deathless life.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the Catholic belief in the resurrection of the body?
Mission 1
Islam: akhirah
Akhirah: life after death, one of the key Muslim beliefs (Sunni and Shi'a alike). This life is a test.
At death the soul is taken by the angel of death; it waits in barzakh (a barrier) until the Day of Resurrection (Qur'an 23:100).
Day of Judgement: all are raised; each person's deeds are weighed (Qur'an 101:6–9).
Jannah (paradise) for the faithful who did good; Jahannam (hell) for those who rejected God and did evil. God is merciful and just.
Surah 28:60–80 (paraphrase): the goods of this world are brief, "that which Allah hath is better and more lasting" (28:60); on the Day of Resurrection people will answer for what they worshipped; the rich man Qarun trusted in his wealth, but "the reward of Allah for him who believeth and doeth right is better" (28:80).
Muslims differ on whether descriptions of paradise and hell are literal or point to realities beyond words.
Mission 1
Judaism: this world and the world to come
The Tenakh says little about the afterlife; Judaism focuses on living this life by the mitzvot.
Early books speak of sheol: a shadowy place of the dead.
Later books and the rabbis teach resurrection: "many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to reproaches and everlasting abhorrence." (Daniel 12:2, JPS 1917)
Olam ha-ba: "the world to come": the age after the Messiah, or the life of the soul after death.
Rabbinic tradition speaks of Gan Eden (paradise) and Gehinnom, often seen as a place of cleansing, not endless punishment.
Maimonides's Thirteen Principles (12th century): God rewards and punishes (11th); the Messiah will come (12th); the dead will be raised (13th).
Orthodox Jews affirm bodily resurrection. Many Reform Jews speak instead of the soul's survival, or of living on through deeds and memory.
Mission 1
Hinduism: atman, samsara, moksha
Step 1 of 2
Atman: the eternal self or soul in every living being. It is never born and never dies.
At death the atman passes into a new body: reincarnation (transmigration).
"Nay, but as when one layeth / His worn-out robes away, / And taking new ones … / So putteth by the spirit / Lightly its garb of flesh" (Bhagavad Gita 2:22, Arnold 1885).
Karma decides the next birth. Samsara is the cycle; moksha is release from it.
Advaita Hindus: in moksha the atman realises it is one with Brahman. Many Vaishnava Hindus: the soul lives for ever in loving devotion to God (Vishnu or Krishna).
Bhagavad Gita 4.23–30 (paraphrase): actions done without attachment, as an offering, in which everything is seen as Brahman, free a person from karma; those who live by such sacrifice reach the eternal Brahman.
Mission 1
Sikhism: the soul's journey to mukti
Step 1 of 2
The soul (atma) is a spark of God. It passes through many life forms (transmigration, samsara), shaped by karma.
A human birth is rare and precious: the chance to become close to God.
Mukti: liberation from rebirth; the soul merges with Waheguru. It comes through God's grace (nadar), remembering God's name (naam simran), service (sewa) and living as a gurmukh (God-centred), not manmukh (self-centred).
Many Sikhs see heaven and hell as states of being close to or far from God, more than places.
Death is part of God's will (hukam); Sikhs are taught not to mourn excessively.
Mission 1
Buddhism: rebirth without a fixed soul
Step 1 of 4
Anatta: there is no permanent, unchanging self. A person is five ever-changing skandhas (form, feeling, perception, mental formations, consciousness).
Everything is impermanent (anicca), including "me".
So rebirth, not reincarnation: no soul moves on, but a stream of kamma-energy continues, like a flame lit from another flame.
Rebirth may be in one of six realms: gods, demi-gods, humans, animals, hungry ghosts, hell beings. None is permanent.
Nibbana (Sanskrit nirvana) ends rebirth: the fires of greed, hatred and ignorance go out.
Wheel of Life: in the Sahasodgata Avadana (Divyavadana 21), the Buddha has a five-part wheel painted at a monastery gateway to teach rebirth (paraphrase). It shows the realms, held by Yama (death), with the three poisons at the hub.
Many Pure Land (Mahayana) Buddhists hope for rebirth in Amitabha Buddha's Pure Land.
Quick check
?Why do many Buddhists prefer the word "rebirth" to "reincarnation"?
Mission 1Evaluate
"Belief in life after death makes this life more valuable."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: life is a test or preparation; how we live is judged (Matthew 25; Qur'an 99:7–8: "whoso doeth good an atom's weight will see it then"). Karma means every act counts. Human life is rare and precious (Sikh, Buddhist, Hindu). Hope gives comfort and courage to care for the dying.
Reasons against: focus on the next life may lessen effort in this one. Humanists: because this is our only life, it is all the more precious; people live on through memory and good done.
Judge it by: Does hope of reward make good acts less generous? Which view better motivates care for others? Can value come without an afterlife?
Mission check
?Two hospital volunteers, one Catholic and one Hindu, each say their belief about death is part of why they help. Which pair of explanations fits their traditions?
Linear or cyclical, most religions link what happens after death to how people live now.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Can anyone show there is life after death, or is it only a comforting hope?
Make a guess: Can anyone show there is life after death, or is it only a comforting hope?
Mission 2
What could count as evidence?
Nobody can return from a full death and be tested, so people argue from other kinds of evidence:
Experience: near-death experiences; remembered lives; the paranormal (contact with the dead through mediums, ghosts).
Logic: reasoning that a soul or a just God makes an afterlife likely.
Reward: justice seems to need a life where good and evil are finally put right.
Comfort and meeting loved ones: hope that death is not the end of love.
Revelation: what scripture and religious teachers say.
Each one can be questioned. That is this mission.
Mission 2
Near-death experiences
Step 1 of 3
Near-death experience (NDE): what some people report after coming close to death, e.g. in cardiac arrest.
Common features: leaving the body and seeing it from above; a tunnel; a bright, loving light; meeting dead relatives; a review of one's life; a sense of being sent back.
Made widely known by Raymond Moody, Life After Life (1975).
Real? Reports are similar across cultures; some people describe events in the room they could not have seen.
Illusory? The dying brain short of oxygen, drugs, or dream-like states (REM intrusion) can produce similar effects; the person did not actually die; reports are made afterwards and memory changes.
Believers usually treat NDEs as support for faith, not the basis of it.
Mission 2
Remembered lives and the paranormal
Step 1 of 3
Remembered lives: some young children describe a previous life: names, places, the way they died.
Ian Stevenson (1918–2007), psychiatrist, Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation (1966), collected hundreds of such cases, many in India, Sri Lanka, Lebanon and Turkey.
Critics: cases come mainly where rebirth is already believed; families may shape the child's story; checks were made after families had met.
Paranormal: mediums claim to pass messages from the dead; some people report ghosts.
Critics: many mediums have been exposed as frauds; "cold reading" (clever guessing from clues) explains many messages.
Christians, Muslims and Jews mostly reject contacting the dead: the Torah forbids anyone "who consults with a familiar spirit, or a wizard, or a necromancer" (Deuteronomy 18:11).
Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs often accept remembered lives as fitting rebirth; Christians and Muslims usually explain them another way.
Quick check
?A newspaper reports that a four-year-old in Sri Lanka names a village she has never visited and says she drowned there in a past life. Which response is a critic most likely to make?
Mission 2
Logic, reward, comfort: how believers use them
Logic: Christians and Muslims: God who made life the first time can raise the dead (Qur'an 36:79). Hindus and Sikhs: differences at birth (talent, suffering) make sense if karma carries over from past lives.
Reward: a good and just God will reward goodness and right injustice, which often goes unpunished here.
Comfort / loved ones: belief helps mourners; Christians "don't grieve like the rest, who have no hope" (1 Thessalonians 4:13).
Divergent responses: most Christians, Muslims and Jews rely on revelation and set aside mediums and remembered lives. Many Buddhists point to the Buddha recalling his past lives on the night of his enlightenment. Many Hindus and Sikhs welcome remembered-life cases.
Guru Granth Sahib 19 is your spec's named source for remembered lives: Sikhs read Gurbani as teaching that the soul has passed through many births before this human one (paraphrase).
Many Jews say what matters is living well now, whatever follows.
Mission 2
The case against
Lack of evidence: no claim has been confirmed under controlled tests.
Mind depends on the brain: brain damage changes memory and personality; with no working brain, there is nothing left to experience (physicalism).
Fraud: fake mediums and invented stories damage trust in all such reports.
Comfort: belief may be wishful thinking: people believe because they fear death or loss.
Social control: promises of heaven and threats of hell can keep people obedient. Karl Marx (1818–1883) called religion "the opium of the people" (1844): it soothes the poor instead of changing their situation.
Non-religious views of the soul: Humanists and most atheists see the "self" as the activity of the brain; it ends at death. People live on only in memories, children and the good they did.
Mission 2
Is death the end of the person?
Yes: Epicurus (341–270 BCE): death is nothing to us, because when death is, we are not (paraphrase). So there is nothing to fear.
Humanists: this is our one life; make it good for ourselves and others.
No (Catholic): death ends earthly life, but not the person. The soul lives on and meets God; the whole person will be raised (1 Corinthians 15).
Most religions agree: death ends this body; they differ on what, if anything, continues.
Mission 2Read the source
Answers from scripture
"If Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith also is in vain." (1 Corinthians 15:14)
1 Peter 3:18–22 (Christian): "Christ also suffered for sins once, the righteous for the unrighteous, that he might bring you to God, being put to death in the flesh, but made alive in the Spirit" (1 Peter 3:18); he is now "at the right hand of God" (3:22).
Surah 45:22–37 (Muslim): deniers say, "There is naught but our life of the world; we die and we live, and naught destroyeth us save time … they do but guess" (Qur'an 45:24, Pickthall); the reply: "Allah giveth life to you, then causeth you to die, then gathereth you unto the Day of Resurrection" (45:26).
Isaiah 25 (Jewish): "He will swallow up death for ever; and the Lord GOD will wipe away tears from off all faces" (Isaiah 25:8, JPS 1917).
Bhagavad Gita 15.6–12 (Hindu): "The unenlightened ones / Mark not that Spirit when he goes or comes" (15:10, Arnold 1885); the wise see it. Many Hindus reply that lack of evidence shows a lack of spiritual sight.
Brahmajala Sutta (Buddhist, paraphrase): the Buddha lists views that the self is wholly destroyed at death, and views that it lasts for ever, and rejects both as speculation driven by craving.
Guru Granth Sahib 430 (Sikh) is your spec's named source here: Sikhs answer the objections from the Guru's word (Gurbani), which they treat as revelation, not from experiments (paraphrase).
Q1 How does Surah 45:24 describe those who deny an afterlife?
Show answer
They speak without knowledge; "they do but guess".
Q2 Why does Paul say the resurrection of Christ matters so much?
Show answer
Without it, Christian faith would be empty.
Mission 2Diversity
Replying to the objections
Lack of evidence: religious believers say the afterlife is known by revelation and faith, not lab tests; absence of proof is not proof of absence.
Christians point to the resurrection of Jesus and its witnesses (1 Corinthians 15:6).
Mind and brain: dualists say the brain may be how the soul acts in the body, as a radio receives a signal; damage the radio and the signal seems to change.
Comfort: something can be comforting and true. Many teachings (judgement, hell, karma) are not comforting at all.
Fraud: fake mediums do not show that every claim is false; most religions reject mediums anyway.
Social control: early Christians, the first Muslims in Makkah and early Sikhs were persecuted minorities, not rulers; believers point to prophets and Gurus who challenged the powerful.
Buddhist reply: rebirth is not a soul surviving, so "no soul found" does not defeat it; the Buddha told followers to test teachings in their own experience.
Quick check
?A Humanist says: "People believe in heaven because it comforts them, not because it is true." Which reply would most Christians give?
Mission 2Evaluate
"There is no good evidence for life after death."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: no claim survives controlled testing; NDEs have brain-based explanations; remembered-life cases may be shaped by culture; fraud is common; mind depends on brain.
Reasons against: NDE reports are consistent and some are hard to explain; Stevenson's best cases remain puzzling; billions find revelation and religious experience convincing; Christians point to eyewitnesses of the risen Jesus.
Another view: evidence may not be the right test: belief in an afterlife is a matter of faith or trust, like trusting a person.
Judge it by: What should count as "good" evidence for something beyond death? Is personal testimony enough? Does lack of proof show there is nothing?
Mission 2Worked answer
Evaluate with reasons on both sides
Statement: "Belief in life after death is just a comfort for people who are afraid of dying." Evaluate this statement.
For: a Humanist argues there is no evidence, and fear of death explains why the belief is so widespread.
Against + source: Muslims reply that those who deny the afterlife "do but guess" (Qur'an 45:24), while the Qur'an is revelation from God; belief rests on that, not on fear.
Development: belief in judgement can be frightening, not comforting, so comfort cannot be the whole explanation.
Judgement: weigh which reasons are stronger and say why, rather than repeating one side.
12-mark (d): reasoned arguments on both sides, using sources and non-religious views, ending in a justified conclusion.
Mission check
?A TV show claims a medium has passed on messages from a famous singer who has died. A sceptic watching says this tells us nothing about life after death. Which reason fits the sceptic's case best?
Every argument for life after death meets an objection, and every objection meets a reply; the key question is what counts as evidence.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
Make a guess: If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
Mission 3
Kinds of euthanasia
Euthanasia (Greek: "good death"): ending a life to relieve suffering, sometimes called mercy killing.
Voluntary: the person asks for it. Non-voluntary: the person cannot ask (e.g. in a long-term coma). Involuntary: against, or without asking, the wishes of a person who could decide.
Active: something is done to end life (e.g. a lethal injection). Passive: treatment that keeps someone alive is withdrawn or withheld, and they die of their illness.
Assisted suicide (assisted dying): the person ends their own life with help, e.g. with drugs prescribed by a doctor.
Not euthanasia: refusing treatment that is too burdensome, or giving pain relief that may shorten life when the aim is to ease pain.
Mission 3
The law
UK: active euthanasia is treated as murder or manslaughter. In England and Wales, assisting suicide is a crime (Suicide Act 1961).
Withdrawing treatment that is no longer in a patient's best interests can be lawful (e.g. the Tony Bland case, 1993). Patients may refuse treatment.
In 2025 MPs voted for a bill to allow assisted dying for some terminally ill adults in England and Wales, but it ran out of time in the House of Lords in 2026 and did not become law. The Scottish Parliament rejected a similar bill in March 2026.
Elsewhere: euthanasia is legal in the Netherlands and Belgium (2002) and Canada (2016); assisted suicide is allowed in Switzerland and some US states (Oregon, 1997).
Quick check
?A man with motor neurone disease, who is fully able to decide, asks his doctor for a lethal injection, and the doctor gives it. What kind of euthanasia is this?
Mission 3
Hospice and palliative care
Palliative care: care that relieves pain and other symptoms when a cure is no longer possible. It neither hastens nor delays death.
Hospices care for dying people and their families: physical, emotional, social and spiritual needs.
Dame Cicely Saunders (1918–2005), a Christian nurse, social worker and doctor, founded St Christopher's Hospice, London (1967), the start of the modern hospice movement.
Many religious believers see hospices as the alternative to euthanasia: dying well, with dignity and without pain.
Many hospices have religious roots; the Buddhist Hospice Trust (UK) supports Buddhist care of the dying.
Mission 3Read the source
Job
"The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away. Blessed be the LORD's name." (Job 1:21)
"Then his wife said to him, 'Do you still maintain your integrity? Renounce God, and die.'" (Job 2:9)
"Shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil?" (Job 2:10)
Job 2:1–10: Job, covered in painful sores, refuses to curse God and die.
Q1 How does Job respond to his suffering?
Show answer
He keeps trusting God and does not seek death.
Q2 How might some Christians apply this to euthanasia?
Show answer
Life and death belong to God; suffering can be endured with faith. Others say Job is not about medical choices.
Mission 3Diversity
Christian views
Catholic teaching (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2276–2279, paraphrase): direct euthanasia, whatever the motive, is murder and gravely wrong. Stopping treatment that is burdensome, extraordinary or disproportionate can be right. Painkillers may be given even if they may shorten life, if death is not intended. Palliative care is a special form of charity.
Church of England and most other churches oppose changing the law: life is God's gift; vulnerable people could feel pressure to die.
Some Christians support assisted dying out of compassion; e.g. a former Archbishop of Canterbury, Lord Carey (2014), and Archbishop Desmond Tutu.
Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape); in a case of great suffering, helping someone die might be loving. Catholic response: love means care until natural death, not killing.
Quick check
?A Catholic woman with terminal cancer asks to stop chemotherapy, which no longer helps and makes her very ill, and to receive strong pain relief. What does Catholic teaching say?
Mission 3Diversity
Islam and Judaism
Islam: "No soul can ever die except by Allah's leave and at a term appointed" (Qur'an 3:145, Pickthall). Life is a test; euthanasia and assisted suicide are forbidden.
Surah 2:153–156: "Seek help in steadfastness and prayer"; when misfortune strikes, believers say "we are Allah's and lo! unto Him we are returning" (Pickthall).
Many Muslim scholars allow switching off life support when treatment is futile; hospice care is supported.
Judaism: life belongs to God; even a dying person (goses) must not have death hastened.
But it may be right to remove something that holds back death without benefit (a traditional example: stopping a woodchopper's noise that keeps a dying man from dying).
Judges 9:51–57: his skull broken by a millstone a woman dropped, the dying Abimelech asks his armour-bearer to kill him, "that men not say of me, 'A woman killed him'" (9:54). Many read this as a warning, not a model: the text calls his death God's repayment for murdering his brothers (9:56).
Orthodox Jews oppose euthanasia; some Reform Jews accept assisted dying with safeguards. Most support hospice care.
Mission 3Diversity
Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism
Hinduism:ahimsa; ending life early may disturb the atman's journey and bring bad karma, for patient and doctor.
Bhagavad Gita 7.25–30: those who know Krishna, even at the time of death, come to him (paraphrase); many Hindus stress a natural death with the mind on God.
Some Hindus argue that relieving suffering is a duty (compassion), and traditional texts allow prayopavesa (fasting to death) for some elderly people in rare cases.
Sikhism: life is God's gift; birth and death are by hukam (God's will). Most Sikhs oppose euthanasia and stress sewa: caring for the sick.
Lord Indarjit Singh, House of Lords, 12 December 2014: argued that Sikh teaching calls for care and support of the sick and dying, not helping them to die, and warned that vulnerable people could feel pressure (paraphrase).
Buddhism: the First Precept; the state of mind at death affects rebirth. Most Buddhists do not approve of euthanasia.
Vakkali Sutta: a monk in great pain takes his own life; the Buddha says he reached final nirvana.
Most Buddhists say these accounts concern enlightened beings, not a model for others.
Mission 3
Non-religious views
Dignity in Dying (UK campaign, founded in 1935 as the Voluntary Euthanasia Legalisation Society; renamed in 2006): campaigns for assisted dying for terminally ill, mentally competent adults, with safeguards.
Humanists: people should have autonomy over their own lives and deaths; quality of life matters; there is no God whose will must be obeyed.
Utilitarianism: assisted dying may reduce suffering for the person and family.
Some non-religious people oppose a change: disabled people's groups (e.g. Not Dead Yet UK) fear pressure on the vulnerable; the slippery slope argument says safeguards may weaken over time.
Quick check
?Which argument would most Humanists use to support assisted dying?
Mission 3Evaluate
"Euthanasia should be legal in the UK."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: autonomy (Humanists; Dignity in Dying, a UK campaign group); compassion (Christian agape, Buddhist karuna); quality of life; strict safeguards work in other countries.
Reasons against: sanctity of life (Job 1:21); vulnerable people may feel a burden; the slippery slope; good palliative care (hospices) relieves most suffering; doctors are meant to heal.
Other traditions add Qur'an 3:145, the First Precept and ahimsa.
Middle positions: allow refusing treatment and strong pain relief, but not active euthanasia (Catholic and many other teachings).
Judge it by: Whose life is it? Can safeguards protect the vulnerable? Is relieving suffering the same as ending life?
Mission check
?A hospice nurse, a practising Catholic, cares for a dying patient who says: "I just want the pain to stop." Which response best fits her faith and her work?
Almost everyone agrees that suffering should be relieved; the disagreement is whether this may ever include deliberately ending a life.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Can it ever be right to eat animals, or to test medicines on them?
Make a guess: Can it ever be right to eat animals, or to test medicines on them?
Mission 4
Where animals stand
Animal rights: the view that animals have moral claims of their own, such as not to be made to suffer or killed for human benefit.
Animal welfare: animals may be used, but must be treated well and spared needless suffering.
Sentience: being able to feel pain and pleasure. Most people agree many animals are sentient.
Christianity, Islam and Judaism teach that humans have a special place (image of God; khalifah) but must care for animals as God's creatures.
Hinduism, Sikhism and Buddhism stress that all beings have a soul or can be reborn, so harming animals has spiritual consequences.
Mission 4
Animal experimentation
Using live animals in scientific research: testing new medicines and vaccines, studying diseases, checking chemicals for safety.
Supporters: it has helped develop treatments that save many lives; the law requires new medicines to be tested before human trials.
Opponents: it causes suffering; animals' bodies differ from humans'; alternatives exist (cell cultures, computer models).
UK law: the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 licenses research and requires suffering to be kept as low as possible. Testing cosmetics on animals is banned in the UK.
The 3Rs: Replace animals where possible, Reduce the number used, Refine methods to lessen suffering.
Mission 4
Animals for food
Most people in the UK eat meat. Questions raised: factory farming (intensive farming, large numbers in small spaces), animal welfare, and environmental cost.
Vegetarians eat no meat or fish; vegans eat no animal products at all.
Many religions have food laws: halal (Islam), kosher (Judaism), no beef for most Hindus, no ritually slaughtered meat for Khalsa Sikhs.
Reasons for a meat-free diet: compassion, ahimsa, health, the environment.
Reasons people eat meat: scripture allows it, nutrition, tradition and culture.
Quick check
?Which statement describes animal welfare rather than animal rights?
Mission 4Read the source
Christianity and animals
"Every moving thing that lives will be food for you." (Genesis 9:3)
"A righteous man respects the life of his animal, but the tender mercies of the wicked are cruel." (Proverbs 12:10)
Catechism of the Catholic Church 2415–2418 (paraphrase): animals are God's creatures, entrusted to human stewardship. Humans may use them for food and clothing. Medical and scientific experiments are acceptable within reasonable limits if they help to care for or save human lives. It is against human dignity to make animals suffer or die needlessly.
Q1 What does Genesis 9:3 allow?
Show answer
Eating animals.
Q2 What limit does Proverbs 12:10 set?
Show answer
The righteous care about their animals' lives; cruelty is wicked.
Mission 4Diversity
Christian views
Most Christians (including Catholic teaching): animal experiments are acceptable when necessary for human health, with suffering kept low; testing cosmetics is wrong because it is not necessary.
Some Christians oppose most or all experiments: animals are part of God's good creation, and causing pain for human gain is not stewardship. The Anglican theologian Andrew Linzey (born 1952) argues that animals have God-given rights ("theos-rights").
On food: most Christians eat meat (Genesis 9:3; Peter's vision in Acts 10:9–16). Some, e.g. many Seventh-day Adventists and Christian Vegetarian groups, choose a meat-free diet to care for creation.
Utilitarianism: an action is right if it produces the greatest good (or least suffering) for the greatest number. Some Christians use it to justify experiments that save many lives; others point out that animal suffering must be counted too.
Mission 4Diversity
Islam and Judaism
Islam: animals are Allah's creation: "they (all) shall be gathered to their Lord" (Qur'an 6:38, Yusuf Ali). As khalifah, humans must not be cruel.
Hadith tell of a man forgiven for giving water to a thirsty dog, and a woman punished for starving a cat (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
Sahih al-Bukhari 45:656 is your spec's named hadith on kindness to animals.
Meat is allowed if it is halal: the animal is slaughtered quickly, Allah's name is spoken, and the blood drained. Pork is forbidden.
Many Muslim scholars allow experiments that are necessary for human health, with suffering kept as low as possible; testing for cosmetics is widely opposed.
Judaism:tza'ar ba'alei chayim: the duty not to cause animals unnecessary suffering. "Thou shalt not muzzle the ox when he treadeth out the corn" (Deuteronomy 25:4, JPS 1917).
Kashrut (food laws): only certain animals, killed by shechita (a swift cut by a trained shochet). Many Jews accept medical experiments for saving human life (pikuach nefesh), with minimal pain.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the view held by many Muslim scholars on animal experiments?
Mission 4Diversity
Hinduism, Sikhism, Buddhism
Hinduism: every living being has an atman; humans may be reborn as animals. Ahimsa leads many Hindus to vegetarianism; the cow is especially respected and beef is avoided.
Bhagavad Gita 13.27–34: the Lord is present equally in all beings (paraphrase). Many Hindus oppose experiments that cause suffering; some accept them for life-saving medicine.
Sikhism: God's light is in all creatures. Langar (the gurdwara's free kitchen) is vegetarian, so anyone can eat. The Sikh code (Rehat Maryada) forbids kutha meat (ritually slaughtered).
Sikh views on meat differ: many amritdhari Sikhs are vegetarian; others eat jhatka meat (killed with one blow). Kabir's verse criticises killing animals (Guru Granth Sahib 1375); Guru Nanak calls arguments over eating meat foolish (Guru Granth Sahib 1289) (paraphrases).
Buddhism: the First Precept: do not harm or kill living beings. "All men tremble at punishment, all men love life; remember that thou art like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter." (Dhammapada 130, Müller)
Many Mahayana Buddhists are vegetarian. In Theravada, monks may eat meat offered to them if the animal was not killed for them. Most Buddhists oppose experiments that cause suffering.
Mission 4
Singer and speciesism
Peter Singer (born 1946), Australian philosopher, Animal Liberation (1975): a utilitarian (someone who judges actions by how much suffering and happiness they produce) who argues for equal consideration of interests.
What matters morally is the ability to suffer, not species. (Jeremy Bentham made this point in 1789.)
Speciesism (a term coined by Richard Ryder, 1970): favouring the interests of one's own species just because it is one's own, like racism or sexism.
Singer urges vegetarianism and opposes most experiments. An experiment is only justified if we would accept it on a human with similar capacities (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement best summarises Peter Singer's view?
Mission 4Evaluate
"Animal experiments are never right."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: animals suffer (sentience; Singer). Ahimsa and the First Precept forbid harm. Many results do not transfer to humans; alternatives are growing. Some Christians (Linzey) see it as abuse of God's creatures.
Reasons against: many medicines and vaccines depended on it. Humans have a special status (imago Dei, khalifah), and saving human life comes first (pikuach nefesh; CCC 2417). Utilitarians may judge that the benefit to many outweighs the harm.
Judge it by: Is human life more valuable than animal life? Can suffering be reduced enough? Are alternatives good enough? Does the purpose (medicine or cosmetics) matter?
Mission check
?A company proposes two animal tests: a new eye shadow on rabbits, and a new childhood cancer drug on mice. How would most Christians respond?
For most believers the questions are need and suffering; for Singer, whether species should count at all.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Linear views (Christianity, Islam, Judaism): one life, judgement, heaven or hell; resurrection. Cyclical views (Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism): karma, rebirth, liberation (moksha, nibbana, mukti).
Catholics believe in the resurrection of the body, not just survival of the soul (1 Corinthians 15:42–44).
Objections: lack of evidence, mind depends on brain, fraud, wishful thinking, social control (Marx).
Religious replies: revelation and faith; Jesus' resurrection; comfort can still be true; the Gita: the unenlightened do not see the soul.
Mission 3
Euthanasia: voluntary, non-voluntary, involuntary; active or passive; assisted suicide. In the UK active euthanasia and assisting suicide are crimes; bills to allow assisted dying failed in 2026.
Most religions oppose euthanasia (sanctity of life, God decides, karma, First Precept) and support hospices and palliative care (Cicely Saunders, 1967); Catholic teaching allows refusing burdensome treatment and strong pain relief.
Humanists and Dignity in Dying support assisted dying for autonomy and quality of life; utilitarianism may support it; some non-religious groups oppose it.
Mission 4
Animal welfare allows careful use; animal rights opposes using animals as resources. UK law controls experiments (1986 Act, the 3Rs).
Christians, Muslims and Jews generally allow necessary experiments and eating meat, with duties of kindness; many Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs are vegetarian because of ahimsa, rebirth and compassion.
Peter Singer (utilitarian) argues speciesism is like racism: equal suffering counts equally.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Matters of Life and Death (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉
Mission 1When someone dies, what do the world's religions say happens next, and does it change how people live?
Mission 2Can anyone show there is life after death, or is it only a comforting hope?
Mission 3If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
Mission 4Can it ever be right to eat animals, or to test medicines on them?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.