← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B (1RB0) · Paper 2 2A Catholic Christianity – Section 2: Crime and Punishment (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Crime and Punishment (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
  2. Mission 2When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?
  3. Mission 3If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
  4. Mission 4Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?

Make a guess: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?

Mission 1

Two kinds of evil

Two kinds of evilMoral evilcaused by humanchoicesmurder, cruelty, war,theft, bullyingNatural evilcaused by nature,not by humansearthquakes, floods,disease, famine fromdroughtMixeda quake kills more people wherebuildings were badly made
  • Evil: whatever is bad, harmful or wrong. Suffering: the pain, physical or mental, that it causes.
  • Moral evil: caused by human choices: murder, cruelty, war, theft, bullying.
  • Natural evil (natural suffering): caused by nature, not by humans: earthquakes, floods, disease, famine from drought.
  • Some cases are mixed: a quake kills more people where buildings were badly made.
  • Moral evil raises the question: why did God make people free to do this? Natural evil: why did God make a world that works like this?
Quick check
?A cyclone floods a coastal region. Afterwards, officials steal food aid meant for survivors. Which classification is correct?
Mission 1

The inconsistent triad

The inconsistent triadomnipotentall-powerfulomnibenevolentall-lovingevil existsomniscientall-knowingMany versions: four statements, same name(inconsistent triad)Epicurus' questionsimpotent?"Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? thenis he impotent."malevolent?"Is he able, but not willing? then is hemalevolent."whence evil?"Is he both able and willing? whence then isevil?"Epicurus, as reported by Hume, Dialogues X
  • Theists (Christians, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs and many Hindus) believe God is omnipotent (all-powerful) and omnibenevolent (all-loving).
  • Most also say God is omniscient (all-knowing): God knows about every evil.
  • But evil exists.
  • The problem: these three statements seem not to fit together. If God knew, could stop it and wanted to, why does it happen?
  • This is the inconsistent triad. Many versions add omniscience, giving four statements; the name inconsistent triad is kept. Philosophers call it the logical problem of evil.
  • The evidential problem: even if some evil is needed, why so much, and why such pointless suffering?
Mission 1Read the source

Epicurus' old questions

The inconsistent triadomnipotentall-powerfulomnibenevolentall-lovingevil existsomniscientall-knowingMany versions: four statements, same name(inconsistent triad)Epicurus' questionsimpotent?"Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? thenis he impotent."malevolent?"Is he able, but not willing? then is hemalevolent."whence evil?"Is he both able and willing? whence then isevil?"Epicurus, as reported by Hume, Dialogues X

David Hume (1711–1776), Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779), Part X, has a character repeat questions credited to the Greek philosopher Epicurus (341–270 BCE):

> "Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both able and willing? whence then is evil?"

Q1 Which quality of God does the first question challenge?

Show answer

Omnipotence: "not able" means "impotent", powerless.

Q2 Which does the second challenge?

Show answer

Omnibenevolence: "not willing" means "malevolent", ill-willed.

Mission 1

Innocent suffering and providence

ProvidenceProvidence: God's care and plantowards goodinnocent suffering?babies, children in war, animals in fires"My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?"(Psalm 22:1)
  • Providence: God's loving care for the world, guiding it towards good.
  • Innocent suffering is the hardest case: babies with painful illnesses, children in war, animals in fires. They have done nothing to deserve it.
  • In Fyodor Dostoevsky's novel The Brothers Karamazov (1880), Ivan refuses any future harmony bought with the tears of a tortured child (paraphrase).
  • Even believers cry out: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Psalm 22:1, WEBBE). Christians recall that Jesus prayed these words on the cross (Mark 15:34).
Mission 1Read the source

God of light and darkness, God of mercy

"I form the light and create darkness. I make peace and create calamity. I am the LORD, who does all these things." (Isaiah 45:7, WEBBE)

  • Does God cause suffering? Many Catholics read "calamity" as disasters, not moral evil: God is sovereign over everything and permits suffering for a purpose. Isaiah 45:9 adds that clay cannot question the potter.
  • "In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful. Praise be to Allah, Lord of the Worlds, The Beneficent, the Merciful." (Surah 1:1–3, Pickthall)
  • Muslims say these words in every prayer. If Allah is the Merciful, why do believers suffer?
  • "The LORD is full of compassion and gracious, slow to anger, and plenteous in mercy." (Psalm 103:8, JPS 1917) Jews ask the same: why does the compassionate God allow suffering?

Q1 Why might Isaiah 45:7 make the problem harder for some readers?

Show answer

It seems to say God creates calamity himself.

Q2 Which quality of God does Surah 1 repeat?

Show answer

Mercy: "the Beneficent, the Merciful".

Mission 1

Reject, question or examine

Three reactionsRejectatheists, HumanistsQuestiondoubt and lament: Psalm 22,JobExaminethink harder; find answers(next mission)
  • Some reject belief: atheists argue that the triad shows an all-powerful, all-loving God does not exist.
  • Humanists: suffering has natural causes (evolution, plate movement, disease) and human ones; no God is needed to explain it; people should reduce it themselves.
  • Humanists also point to suffering caused by religion itself: persecution, wars, guilt.
  • Some question: personal tragedy can shake faith; doubt and lament are found in scripture (Psalm 22, Job).
  • Some examine: believers think harder about what God's power and love mean, and find answers.
  • Your spec: the problem may lead some to examine and others to reject their belief.
Quick check
?Leah says: "If God knew the tsunami was coming, could have stopped it and truly loved people, it would not have happened." Which three beliefs about God is Leah putting together?
Mission 1Diversity

Where evil comes from: Abrahamic faiths

Origins of evil and sufferingOriginKey termSourceChristianhumans misusedfree will in theFallOriginal SinGenesis 3;Romans 5:12Jewishfree choicebetween the twoinclinationsyetzerha-tov,yetzer ha-raDeuteronomy30:19MuslimIblis temptshumans;hardship is a testIblis; testSurah 2:34;2:155Hindukarma; ignoranceand illusionkarma,avidya, mayaBhagavataPurana 6.1.45Buddhistcraving and theThree Poisonsdukkha,tanhaDhammapada165Sikhego turnshumans fromGod; the fiveevilshaumai,manmukh–
  • Christian: humans misused free will in the Fall (Genesis 3); "sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin" (Romans 5:12, WEBBE). Original Sin: a damaged nature passed to all.
  • Jewish: humans have a yetzer ha-tov (good inclination) and a yetzer ha-ra (inclination to evil) and free choice: "I have set before thee life and death, the blessing and the curse; therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19, JPS 1917).
  • Muslim: Iblis refused to bow to Adam "through pride" (Surah 2:34, Pickthall) and now tempts humans; hardship is a test: "We shall try you with something of fear and hunger" (Surah 2:155, Pickthall).
Mission 1Diversity

Where suffering comes from: Dharmic faiths

Origins of evil and sufferingOriginKey termSourceChristianhumans misusedfree will in theFallOriginal SinGenesis 3;Romans 5:12Jewishfree choicebetween the twoinclinationsyetzerha-tov,yetzer ha-raDeuteronomy30:19MuslimIblis temptshumans;hardship is a testIblis; testSurah 2:34;2:155Hindukarma; ignoranceand illusionkarma,avidya, mayaBhagavataPurana 6.1.45Buddhistcraving and theThree Poisonsdukkha,tanhaDhammapada165Sikhego turnshumans fromGod; the fiveevilshaumai,manmukh–
  • Hindu: suffering follows karma: as a person acts in this life, so they reap in the next (Bhagavata Purana 6.1.45, paraphrase). Its root is ignorance (avidya) and maya (illusion that hides Brahman).
  • Buddhist: suffering (dukkha) is a mark of all existence; its cause is craving (tanha) and the Three Poisons (greed, hatred, ignorance). Mara stands for temptation and death.
  • "By oneself the evil is done, by oneself one suffers" (Dhammapada 165, Müller).
  • Sikh: life is under God's hukam (will), but humans turn from God through haumai (ego). The manmukh (self-centred person) is ruled by the five evils: lust (kam), anger (krodh), greed (lobh), attachment (moh), pride (ahankar).
Mission 1

Why people suffer: seven traditions

Seven traditionsCatholic / ChristianMatthew 25:40suffering calls peopleto helpMuslimSurah 76:2, 76:8life is a test; feed theneedyJewishExodus 33:19God's goodness isgiven freelyHinduBhagavata Purana 4evil actions bringsufferingBuddhistDalai Lama, Nobelspeech 1989ignorance and selfishdesire; compassionanswersSikhGuru Granth Sahib1062humans responsiblethrough their ownchoicesNon-religioussome say religion causes suffering; believersblame its misuse
  • Catholic / Christian: in the Sheep and the Goats, Christ says "you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me" (Matthew 25:40, WEBBE). Suffering calls people to help; good actions are rewarded with eternal life. Christians differ on how far suffering is punishment.
  • Muslim: "Lo! We create man ... to test him" (Surah 76:2, Pickthall); the righteous "feed with food the needy wretch, the orphan and the prisoner, for love of Him" (Surah 76:8, Pickthall).
  • Jewish: God tells Moses, "I will be gracious to whom I will be gracious" (Exodus 33:19, JPS 1917): God's goodness is given freely, beyond human reckoning.
  • Hindu: good actions bring good births; evil actions bring suffering (Bhagavata Purana 4, paraphrase). Some Hindus stress karma; others God's grace.
  • Buddhist: the XIV Dalai Lama's Nobel speech (10 December 1989, paraphrase): much suffering comes from ignorance and selfish desire; compassion and universal responsibility answer it.
  • Sikh: Guru Granth Sahib 1062 (spec source): humans are responsible for much suffering through their own choices. Guru Granth Sahib 767 is your spec's source for Sikh replies to non-religious views.
  • Non-religious: some say religion itself causes suffering; religious believers reply that misuse of religion, not faith, is to blame.
Quick check
?Which teaching explains suffering by craving within the person, with no creator God in the explanation?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Evil and suffering prove that God does not exist."

Argument map"Evil and suffering prove that God does notexist."Forthe triad seems logically inconsistentthe amount of suffering seems pointless(evidential problem)innocent suffering seems unfairnatural causes explain suffering withoutGodAgainstGod may have good reasons we cannotsee (Isaiah 45:9)free will needs the possibility of evilsuffering may have a purposemany who suffer most keep their faithAnother viewthe problem may show that God's poweror love must be understood differently, notthat God does not existNon-theistic view: for most Buddhiststhere is no creator to blame; the questionbecomes how to end sufferingJudge it byIs "prove" too strong a word? · Does free willexplain natural evil? · Can a finite mind judgeGod's reasons?
  • Reasons for: the triad seems logically inconsistent; the amount of suffering seems pointless (evidential problem); innocent suffering seems unfair; natural causes explain suffering without God.
  • Reasons against: God may have good reasons we cannot see (Isaiah 45:9); free will needs the possibility of evil; suffering may have a purpose; many who suffer most keep their faith.
  • Another view: the problem may show that God's power or love must be understood differently, not that God does not exist.
  • Non-theistic view: for most Buddhists there is no creator to blame; the question becomes how to end suffering.
  • Judge it by: Is "prove" too strong a word? Does free will explain natural evil? Can a finite mind judge God's reasons?
Mission check

?A baby is born with a painful genetic illness. Tom says: "An all-powerful, loving God would not allow this, so there is no such God." The baby's mother, a Christian, prays: "Why, Lord?", but goes on trusting God. Which statement is accurate?
Mission 2

Mission 2: When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?

Make a guess: When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?

Mission 2

What punishment is for

What punishment is forcrime andharmfairpenaltynot revenge: fair rules
  • Punishment: a penalty given by a lawful authority (a court, a judge) to someone who has broken the law.
  • It is not revenge: it follows fair rules, and fits the crime.
  • Why society needs it: to keep order, to protect people, and to show that laws matter.
  • Why it can be justice: the offender is treated fairly, and the victim's harm is recognised.
  • Religions agree that wrongdoing has consequences. They differ on what punishment should mainly aim to do.
  • Luke 12:35–48: servants are judged by how they behave while the master is away; "To whomever much is given, of him will much be required" (Luke 12:48). Punishment is fair when it matches responsibility.
Mission 2

Retribution, deterrence, reformation

Aims of punishment: looking back or forwardthe crime (past)the futureRetributionlooks back: getswhat theydeserveDeterrenceputs people off crimeReformationhelps the offenderchangeProtectionkeeps the public safe
  • Retribution: the offender gets what they deserve; the punishment fits the crime. Looks back at the crime.
  • Deterrence: punishment puts the offender, and others, off committing crimes. Looks forward.
  • Reformation: helping the offender change, so they become a law-abiding member of society (education, courses, counselling). Looks forward.
Mission 2

Protection, reparation, vindication

Aims of punishment: looking back or forwardthe crime (past)the futureRetributionlooks back: getswhat theydeserveDeterrenceputs people off crimeReformationhelps the offenderchangeProtectionkeeps the public safe
  • Protection: keeping the public safe from a dangerous offender (e.g. by prison).
  • Your spec names four aims: protection, retribution, deterrence and reformation.
Quick check
?A judge says: "This sentence must send a clear message to anyone else thinking of carrying a knife." Which aim is the judge stressing?
Mission 2

Strengths and weaknesses

Strengths and weaknesses of the aimsRetributionStrength: fair to victims; the punishment fitsthe crimeWeakness: can look like revenge; does notstop future crimeDeterrenceStrength: may prevent crime before ithappensWeakness: many crimes are done in anger,under the influence, or by people who expectnot to be caughtReformationStrength: the offender may change, so lessreoffending; respects human worthWeakness: not every offender wants tochange; victims may feel it is too softProtectionStrength: keeps the public safeWeakness: only lasts while the offender isheld
  • Retribution: strength: fair to victims; the punishment fits the crime. Weakness: can look like revenge; does not stop future crime.
  • Deterrence: strength: may prevent crime before it happens. Weakness: many crimes are done in anger, under the influence, or by people who expect not to be caught; punishing one person to warn others can seem unfair.
  • Reformation: strength: the offender may change, so less reoffending; respects human worth. Weakness: not every offender wants to change; victims may feel it is too soft.
  • Protection: strength: keeps the public safe. Weakness: only lasts while the offender is held.
Mission 2Read the source

Christian teachings on punishment

Christian teachings on punishmentExodus 21:24"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand forhand, foot for foot"retributionRomans 13:4"he is a servant of God, an avenger forwrath to him who does evil."retributiondeterrenceGalatians 6:1"you who are spiritual must restoresuch a one in a spirit of gentleness"reformation

"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot" (Exodus 21:24)

"he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil." (Romans 13:4)

"Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness" (Galatians 6:1)

  • Exodus 21:24 limits punishment to what fits the crime: retribution in proportion, not unlimited revenge.
  • Romans 13:4: the state has God-given authority to punish (retribution, deterrence).
  • Galatians 6:1–5: "Bear one another's burdens" (6:2): restore the wrongdoer gently (reformation).
  • Your spec's passage runs on to 6:10: "whatever a man sows, that he will also reap" (6:7): actions have consequences.

Q1 Which source supports reformation?

Show answer

Galatians 6:1: restore such a one.

Q2 Which source gives the state the right to punish?

Show answer

Romans 13:4.

Mission 2Diversity

Christian views on the aims

Religious views on the aims of punishmentChristianityKey term: Catechism 2266: redress thedisorder; protect; correctAlso: situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966): do themost loving thingAims: many: reformation; some, often moreconservative: retribution and deterrenceSource: Romans 13:4; Exodus 21:24;Galatians 6:1IslamKey terms: hadd (fixed penalties); qisas(equal retaliation); tawbah (repentance)Aims: retribution; deterrence; the family mayforgive and accept compensationViews: many British Muslims accept UK lawand stress mercy and reformSource: Qur'an 2:178; 2:179; 5:44–46;4:26–28JudaismKey terms: compensation; teshuvah(repentance)Aims: reparation in proportion; everyoffender can changeSource: Leviticus 24:20; Talmud, BavaKamma 83b–84a; Genesis 9:6BuddhismKey term: karuna (compassion)Aims: reform; violence breeds more hatredSource: Dhammapada 197; Bhaddali SuttaHinduismKey terms: danda ("the rod"); prayascitta(atonement)Aims: the ruler punishes justly to protectdharma; atonement reformsSource: Manusmriti 7.13–28; Bhagavad Gita4.35–37SikhismKey term: tankhah (a penance, often sewa)Aims: justice and reform togetherSource: Rahit Maryada; Guru Granth Sahib148
  • All Christians: the state may punish (Romans 13); punishment must be just and respect the offender's dignity.
  • Catholic teaching (Catechism 2266, paraphrase): punishment first redresses the disorder the crime caused (retribution), and should also protect public safety and help correct the offender.
  • Many Christians stress reformation: Jesus came to call sinners to repentance; no one is beyond change.
  • Some, often more conservative, Christians give more weight to retribution and deterrence (Exodus 21:24; Romans 13:4).
  • Quakers and many others: punishment should heal; they support reform and restorative justice (see Mission 3).
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape) in each case; this usually favours reformation, but could support a firm sentence if that protects others.
Quick check
?A prison chaplain leads a course that helps prisoners face what they did and plan a new life. Which Christian teaching supports her aim most directly?
Mission 2Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Religious views on the aims of punishmentChristianityKey term: Catechism 2266: redress thedisorder; protect; correctAlso: situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966): do themost loving thingAims: many: reformation; some, often moreconservative: retribution and deterrenceSource: Romans 13:4; Exodus 21:24;Galatians 6:1IslamKey terms: hadd (fixed penalties); qisas(equal retaliation); tawbah (repentance)Aims: retribution; deterrence; the family mayforgive and accept compensationViews: many British Muslims accept UK lawand stress mercy and reformSource: Qur'an 2:178; 2:179; 5:44–46;4:26–28JudaismKey terms: compensation; teshuvah(repentance)Aims: reparation in proportion; everyoffender can changeSource: Leviticus 24:20; Talmud, BavaKamma 83b–84a; Genesis 9:6BuddhismKey term: karuna (compassion)Aims: reform; violence breeds more hatredSource: Dhammapada 197; Bhaddali SuttaHinduismKey terms: danda ("the rod"); prayascitta(atonement)Aims: the ruler punishes justly to protectdharma; atonement reformsSource: Manusmriti 7.13–28; Bhagavad Gita4.35–37SikhismKey term: tankhah (a penance, often sewa)Aims: justice and reform togetherSource: Rahit Maryada; Guru Granth Sahib148
  • Islam: Shari'ah law sets out punishments. Hadd (fixed) penalties for certain crimes; qisas (equal retaliation) for murder and injury; other penalties left to the judge.
  • "Retaliation is prescribed for you in the matter of the murdered" (Qur'an 2:178, Pickthall); the victim's family may forgive and accept compensation: "an alleviation and a mercy from your Lord".
  • "And there is life for you in retaliation" (Qur'an 2:179, Pickthall): deterrence protects society.
  • Surah 5:44–46: the Torah and Gospel were given to judge by; 5:45 recalls that the Torah prescribed "the life for the life", but "whoso forgoeth it … it shall be expiation for him" (Pickthall).
  • Surah 4:26–28: Allah "would turn to you in mercy" and lighten the burden (Pickthall): repentance (tawbah) and reform matter.
  • Divergent views: many Muslims support Shari'ah penalties in an Islamic state with strict rules of evidence; many British Muslims accept UK law and stress mercy and reform; some scholars call for these penalties to be suspended today.
  • Judaism: "breach for breach, eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (Leviticus 24:20, JPS 1917). The rabbis taught that this means payment of compensation, not injury (Talmud, Bava Kamma 83b–84a): reparation in proportion.
  • Genesis 9:1–6: human life is made in God's image, so taking it must be answered with justice (9:6).
  • Teshuvah (repentance, "returning"): every offender can change.
Mission 2Diversity

Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism

Religious views on the aims of punishmentChristianityKey term: Catechism 2266: redress thedisorder; protect; correctAlso: situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966): do themost loving thingAims: many: reformation; some, often moreconservative: retribution and deterrenceSource: Romans 13:4; Exodus 21:24;Galatians 6:1IslamKey terms: hadd (fixed penalties); qisas(equal retaliation); tawbah (repentance)Aims: retribution; deterrence; the family mayforgive and accept compensationViews: many British Muslims accept UK lawand stress mercy and reformSource: Qur'an 2:178; 2:179; 5:44–46;4:26–28JudaismKey terms: compensation; teshuvah(repentance)Aims: reparation in proportion; everyoffender can changeSource: Leviticus 24:20; Talmud, BavaKamma 83b–84a; Genesis 9:6BuddhismKey term: karuna (compassion)Aims: reform; violence breeds more hatredSource: Dhammapada 197; Bhaddali SuttaHinduismKey terms: danda ("the rod"); prayascitta(atonement)Aims: the ruler punishes justly to protectdharma; atonement reformsSource: Manusmriti 7.13–28; Bhagavad Gita4.35–37SikhismKey term: tankhah (a penance, often sewa)Aims: justice and reform togetherSource: Rahit Maryada; Guru Granth Sahib148
  • Buddhism: punishment should be compassionate (karuna) and aim at reform; violence breeds more hatred.
  • "Let us live happily then, not hating those who hate us!" (Dhammapada 197, Müller). Dhammapada 197–202: hatred and victory breed more suffering.
  • Bhaddali Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 65, paraphrase): the Buddha explains that discipline in the community is meant to train and correct, and works when the offender accepts it.
  • Hinduism: danda ("the rod"): the ruler's duty to punish justly to protect dharma.
  • Manusmriti 7.13–28 (paraphrase): punishment, rightly given, protects all beings; wrongly given, it destroys the ruler.
  • Prayascitta: acts of atonement that purify the offender (reform). Bhagavad Gita 4.35–37 (paraphrase): knowledge burns up karma as fire burns wood; even the worst wrongdoer can cross over.
  • Sikhism: justice and reform together.
  • The Rahit Maryada (Section 6, Chapter 8, Article XXV): a Sikh who breaks the code confesses before the sangat and accepts a tankhah (a penance, often sewa); punishment restores the person to the community. Guru Granth Sahib 148 is your spec's named source.
Mission 2

Non-religious views

Strengths and weaknesses of the aimsRetributionStrength: fair to victims; the punishment fitsthe crimeWeakness: can look like revenge; does notstop future crimeDeterrenceStrength: may prevent crime before ithappensWeakness: many crimes are done in anger,under the influence, or by people who expectnot to be caughtReformationStrength: the offender may change, so lessreoffending; respects human worthWeakness: not every offender wants tochange; victims may feel it is too softProtectionStrength: keeps the public safeWeakness: only lasts while the offender isheld
  • Humanists: no afterlife or divine judgement, so punishment should do good in this life: protect the public, reform offenders, reduce crime.
  • Many stress evidence: what actually lowers reoffending (education, treatment for addiction, restorative justice).
  • Utilitarian thinkers: punishment is justified only by its good results (deterrence, protection, reform).
  • Other non-religious thinkers defend retribution: offenders deserve a penalty that fits the crime, whatever the results.
  • Religious responses: many agree; some add that justice also matters before God.
Quick check
?Many Jews read "eye for eye, tooth for tooth" (Leviticus 24:20). What did the rabbis of the Talmud teach that it means?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Reformation is the most important aim of punishment."

Is reformation the most important aim?"Reformation is the most important aim ofpunishment."ForOffenders can change: "restore" thewrongdoer (Galatians 6:1).It protects society in the long run.It respects human worth.AgainstVictims deserve justice (retribution;Exodus 21:24).Some offenders will not change, so thepublic needs protection.Without deterrence, crime may rise.Romans 13:4 gives the state a duty topunish.Another viewThe aims work together: a just sentencecan punish, protect and reform at once(Catholic teaching).Judge it byWhat does the victim need? · Can theoffender change? · What best reduces futurecrime?
  • Reasons for: offenders can change; Galatians 6:1: restore the wrongdoer. It protects society in the long run. It respects human worth.
  • Jewish teaching on teshuvah (repentance) holds that every offender can change.
  • Muslims point to tawbah (repentance) and Allah's mercy (Surah 4:26–28).
  • Reasons against: victims deserve justice (retribution; Exodus 21:24). Some offenders will not change, so the public needs protection. Without deterrence, crime may rise. Romans 13:4 gives the state a duty to punish.
  • Another view: the aims work together: a just sentence can punish, protect and reform at once (Catholic teaching).
  • Judge it by: What does the victim need? Can the offender change? What best reduces future crime?
Mission check

?A school catches a pupil vandalising the science lab. The head makes him repaint it on Saturdays, meet the technician he upset, and join a mentoring scheme. Which aims of punishment does this mainly show?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?

Make a guess: If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?

Mission 3

Forgiveness, repentance, reconciliation

From wrong to reconciliationa wrong is donerepentancemetanoia · teshuvah ·tawbahforgivenessletting go of anger andrevengereconciliationa broken relationshiprestoredforgiveness isnot forgettingor excusing
  • Forgiveness: choosing to let go of anger and the wish for revenge against someone who has wronged you.
  • It is not pretending the wrong did not happen, and not saying it was acceptable.
  • Repentance: being truly sorry for wrongdoing and turning away from it (metanoia in Christianity; teshuvah in Judaism; tawbah in Islam).
  • Reconciliation: restoring a broken relationship, so both sides can live in peace again.
  • Restorative justice brings offender and victim together to repair harm.
Mission 3Read the source

Jesus on forgiveness

Jesus on forgivenessMatthew 18:21–22"I don't tell you until seven times, but, untilseventy times seven."70 × 7: forgive without limitMatthew 6:14–15"For if you forgive men their trespasses, yourheavenly Father will also forgive you."Luke 23:34"Father, forgive them, for they don't knowwhat they are doing."on the crossMatthew 5:24"First be reconciled to your brother, and thencome and offer your gift."

"Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me, and I forgive him? Until seven times?" Jesus said to him, "I don't tell you until seven times, but, until seventy times seven." (Matthew 18:21–22)

"For if you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you don't forgive men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses." (Matthew 6:14–15)

  • Matthew 5:21–26: anger is like murder in the heart; "First be reconciled to your brother, and then come and offer your gift." (Matthew 5:24)
  • On the cross: "Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing." (Luke 23:34)

Q1 What does "seventy times seven" mean?

Show answer

Forgive without limit; stop counting.

Q2 Why does Matthew 6:14–15 link our forgiving to God's?

Show answer

Christians who refuse to forgive close themselves to God's forgiveness.

Mission 3

Forgiveness and punishment

Forgiveness and justice: two tracks1981Pope John Paul II is shot by Mehmet Ali AğcaVictim:forgiveness (personal)1983: visits Ağca in prison and forgiveshimState:justice (punishment)Ağca stays in prison
  • The tension: if Christians must forgive without limit, should offenders be punished at all?
  • Most Christians answer: forgiveness is personal; justice is the state's duty (Romans 13:4). A victim can forgive and still want a fair sentence.
  • Punishment can itself serve the offender's good: it helps them face the wrong and change.
  • Example: Pope John Paul II was shot in 1981 by Mehmet Ali Ağca. In 1983 he visited Ağca in prison and forgave him, yet Ağca stayed in prison.
  • Catholic teaching: show mercy to criminals, as God shows mercy to all; the Sacrament of Reconciliation shows God's forgiveness for the repentant.
  • Some argue the other way: punishing someone you have forgiven still looks like holding on to the wrong.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes what most Christians mean by forgiveness?
Mission 3Diversity

Different Christian and non-religious views

Unconditional or conditional forgiveness?Unconditionalforgive whether ornot the offenderrepents (Luke 23:34)Conditional"If he repents,forgive him" (Luke17:3)Christian viewsHumanistsa choice, not a duty
  • Unconditional forgiveness: many Christians forgive whether or not the offender repents, following Jesus on the cross (Luke 23:34).
  • Conditional forgiveness: others point to "If he repents, forgive him" (Luke 17:3); full reconciliation needs repentance.
  • Catholic teaching: God's forgiveness is offered to all and received through repentance, especially in the Sacrament of Reconciliation; Catholics are called to forgive as they are forgiven.
  • Humanists: forgiveness can heal both victim and offender and help society; but it is a choice, not a duty, and victims should never be pressured to forgive.
  • Some non-religious people argue some acts should not be forgiven, out of respect for victims.
Mission 3Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Five faiths on forgivenessIslamKey terms: al-Ghafur (the Forgiving); tawbahSource: Qur'an 64:14Teaching: in qisas, the victim's family mayforgive (2:178)JudaismKey term: teshuvah (returning)Source: Micah 7:18; Psalm 130:4; Isaiah 55:7Teaching: wrongs against people must beput right with them first (Mishnah Yoma 8:9)BuddhismKey terms: metta; karunaSource: Dhammapada 5; 3–4Teaching: holding on to anger harms yourselfHinduismKey term: kshama (forgiveness, patience)Source: Mahabharata 3.29Teaching: a virtue of dharmaSikhismKey term: khimaSource: Guru Granth Sahib 1378Teaching: a mark of a gurmukh; anger is oneof the Five Thieves
  • Islam: Allah is al-Ghafur (the Forgiving) and ar-Rahim (the Merciful); forgiveness is offered to all who sincerely repent (tawbah).
  • "And if ye efface and overlook and forgive, then lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful." (Qur'an 64:14, Pickthall)
  • In qisas, the victim's family may forgive the offender (Qur'an 2:178): forgiveness and justice together.
  • Judaism: God is merciful to those who return (teshuvah). "Who is a God like unto Thee, that pardoneth the iniquity … because He delighteth in mercy." (Micah 7:18, JPS 1917)
  • "For with Thee there is forgiveness" (Psalm 130:4, JPS 1917). "Let the wicked forsake his way … and let him return unto the LORD, and He will have compassion upon him" (Isaiah 55:7, JPS 1917).
  • Wrongs against people must be put right with them first: Yom Kippur does not atone for these until the person wronged is reconciled (Mishnah Yoma 8:9, paraphrase).
Mission 3Diversity

Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism

Five faiths on forgivenessIslamKey terms: al-Ghafur (the Forgiving); tawbahSource: Qur'an 64:14Teaching: in qisas, the victim's family mayforgive (2:178)JudaismKey term: teshuvah (returning)Source: Micah 7:18; Psalm 130:4; Isaiah 55:7Teaching: wrongs against people must beput right with them first (Mishnah Yoma 8:9)BuddhismKey terms: metta; karunaSource: Dhammapada 5; 3–4Teaching: holding on to anger harms yourselfHinduismKey term: kshama (forgiveness, patience)Source: Mahabharata 3.29Teaching: a virtue of dharmaSikhismKey term: khimaSource: Guru Granth Sahib 1378Teaching: a mark of a gurmukh; anger is oneof the Five Thieves
  • Buddhism: holding on to anger harms yourself; forgiveness grows from metta (loving-kindness) and karuna (compassion).
  • "For hatred does not cease by hatred at any time: hatred ceases by love, this is an old rule." (Dhammapada 5, Müller)
  • Dhammapada 3–4: in those who keep thinking "He abused me, he beat me, he defeated me, he robbed me", hatred never ceases; in those who let go, it ceases (Müller).
  • Hinduism: kshama (forgiveness, patience) is a virtue of dharma.
  • Mahabharata 3.29 (paraphrase): Yudhishthira tells Draupadi that forgiveness is virtue and sacrifice, and that the world is held together by forgiveness.
  • Sikhism: forgiveness (khima) is a mark of a God-centred (gurmukh) person; anger is one of the Five Thieves.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 1378 (paraphrase): Sheikh Farid teaches not to strike back at those who strike you, but to return home in peace.
Quick check
?A Jewish teenager has spread a cruel rumour about a friend. It is Yom Kippur, and she fasts and prays for forgiveness. According to Jewish teaching, what else must she do?
Mission 3

Restorative justice

Restorative justicevictimoffenderfacilitatorcommunitymeet, ifboth agreeharmexplainedresponsibilityrepair
  • Restorative justice: the offender and the victim (or the community) meet, with a trained facilitator, if both agree.
  • The victim can explain the harm; the offender takes responsibility, apologises and agrees how to repair it.
  • Aims: healing for victims; reformation of offenders; less reoffending; reconciliation.
  • Christian support: reconciliation is at the heart of the Gospel (Matthew 5:24; 2 Corinthians 5:18). Prison Fellowship's Sycamore Tree course teaches it in prisons.
  • Many Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus, Jews and Sikhs also support it: it fits tawbah, compassion, prayascitta, teshuvah and the sangat's role in restoring offenders.
  • Criticisms: not suitable for every crime; some victims find it painful; some say it is too soft without other punishment.
Mission 3

Examples of forgiveness

Examples of forgivenessEnniskillen, 1987Gordon Wilson (Methodist): his daughter Mariewas killed in the bombing. He bore thebombers no ill will and later worked for peace.Liverpool, 2005Gee Walker (Christian): her son Anthony wasmurdered in a racist attack. She forgave hiskillers, because of her faith.1995Azim Khamisa (Muslim): his son Tariq was shotby a 14-year-old. He forgave the boy and setup a foundation with the boy's grandfather tostop youth violence.
  • Gordon Wilson (Methodist): his daughter Marie was killed in the Enniskillen bombing in 1987. He said he bore the bombers no ill will and prayed for them; he later worked for peace.
  • Gee Walker (Christian): her son Anthony was murdered in a racist attack in Liverpool in 2005. She said she forgave his killers, because of her faith.
  • Azim Khamisa (Muslim): his son Tariq was shot by a 14-year-old in 1995. He forgave the boy and set up a foundation with the boy's grandfather to stop youth violence.
  • Each acted from personal belief; none said the crime did not matter.
Quick check
?In a restorative justice meeting, a burglar meets the elderly woman whose house he broke into. What is the meeting mainly for?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Some actions are unforgivable."

Are some actions unforgivable?"Some actions are unforgivable."ForSome crimes (murder, genocide) causeharm that can never be repaired.Forgiving may seem to disrespect victims.Some offenders show no repentance.Humanists: forgiveness is a choice, not aduty.AgainstJesus taught "seventy times seven" andforgave on the cross.Examples like Gordon Wilson and GeeWalker show it is possible.Another viewForgive the person, not the act: the actstays wrong and justice is still done.Judge it byWho has the right to forgive? · Must theoffender repent? · Does forgiveness cancelpunishment?
  • Reasons for: some crimes (murder, genocide) cause harm that can never be repaired. Forgiving may seem to disrespect victims. Some offenders show no repentance. Humanists: forgiveness is a choice, not a duty.
  • Reasons against: Jesus taught "seventy times seven" and forgave on the cross. Examples like Gordon Wilson and Gee Walker show it is possible.
  • Muslims believe Allah is al-Ghafur (the Forgiving); Buddhists teach that "hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada 5), so forgiving frees the victim from hatred.
  • Another view: forgiving the person is possible, while the act stays wrong and justice is still done.
  • Judge it by: Who has the right to forgive? Must the offender repent? Does forgiveness cancel punishment?
Mission check

?A football fan was badly injured when a rival fan attacked him. In court, the injured man says he forgives his attacker, but he also asks the judge to give a fair sentence. Most Christians would say this is:
Mission 4

Mission 4: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Make a guess: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Mission 4

What the death penalty is

The death penalty in the UK1950Timothy Evans hanged1953Derek Bentley hanged1961last execution in Northern Ireland1964last executions in Great Britain1965abolished for murder in GreatBritain1966Timothy Evans pardoned1969abolition for murder madepermanent1973abolished for murder in NorthernIreland1998abolished for all crimes across theUK; Derek Bentley's convictionquashed
  • Capital punishment (the death penalty): the state lawfully executes a person for a crime. A crime that can carry it is a capital offence.
  • Purpose: retribution (a life for a life), deterrence, and protection of society.
  • Great Britain: the last executions were in 1964; it was abolished for murder in 1965 (permanently from 1969). Northern Ireland: last execution 1961, abolished for murder 1973. Abolished across the UK for all crimes by 1998.
  • It is still used in some countries, e.g. China, Iran, Saudi Arabia and some US states.
  • Some people in the UK still call for it to return for the worst murders.
Mission 4

Arguments for

Arguments for and against the death penaltyForAgainstRetributiondeath for themost evil crimesSanctity of lifeonly God mayend lifeDeterrencefear of death maystop killingMistakescannot be undone(Evans, Bentley)Protectioncan never killagainNo cleardeterrencemany murders inanger or panic?Victims' familiesthe crime takenseriouslyNo reformno chance toreform or repentUtilityif it deters, itsaves innocentlivesUtilitymay brutalisesociety
  • Retribution: some crimes are so evil that only death is a just penalty.
  • Deterrence: fear of death may stop people killing.
  • Protection: an executed murderer can never kill again.
  • Justice for victims' families: some feel the crime has been taken seriously.
  • Principle of utility (Jeremy Bentham, 1748–1832): the right act brings the greatest happiness for the greatest number. If executions deter murder and save many innocent lives, a utilitarian could support them.
Mission 4

Arguments against

Arguments for and against the death penaltyForAgainstRetributiondeath for themost evil crimesSanctity of lifeonly God mayend lifeDeterrencefear of death maystop killingMistakescannot be undone(Evans, Bentley)Protectioncan never killagainNo cleardeterrencemany murders inanger or panic?Victims' familiesthe crime takenseriouslyNo reformno chance toreform or repentUtilityif it deters, itsaves innocentlivesUtilitymay brutalisesociety
  • Sanctity of life: many believers hold that all life is sacred and given by God, so only God may end it, a murderer's life included.
  • Mistakes cannot be undone: Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 and pardoned in 1966; Derek Bentley was hanged in 1953 and his conviction quashed in 1998.
  • No clear evidence that it deters better than long prison sentences; many murders happen in anger or panic.
  • No chance to reform or repent.
  • Utility can argue against: executions may brutalise society and wrongful executions cause great harm, so it may not produce the greatest happiness.
Quick check
?Which argument about the death penalty is based on the principle of utility?
Mission 4Read the source

Scripture on both sides

Scripture on both sidesUsed to supportGenesis 9:6Exodus 21:24Romans 13:4Used to opposeMatthew 5:38–39Matthew 5:44Exodus 20:13"his blood will beshed by man"(Genesis 9:6)"don't resist him whois evil" (Matthew5:39)

"Whoever sheds man's blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image." (Genesis 9:6)

"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot" (Exodus 21:24)

"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil" (Matthew 5:38–39)

  • Exodus 21:12: "One who strikes a man so that he dies shall surely be put to death"; 21:13 gives a place of refuge for someone who kills by accident.
  • "love your enemies … pray for those who mistreat you and persecute you" (Matthew 5:44).

Q1 Which passages are used to support the death penalty?

Show answer

Genesis 9:6 and Exodus 21:24.

Q2 How does Matthew 5:38–39 challenge "an eye for an eye"?

Show answer

Jesus calls his followers not to take revenge.

Mission 4

How Catholic teaching developed

How Catholic teaching developedc. 414Augustine: letters beg forthe lives of the condemned,so they have time to repentc. 1225–1274Aquinas: killing adangerous person may"safeguard the commongood"1995John Paul II, EvangeliumVitae 56: such cases are"very rare, if not practicallynon-existent"2018Francis revises Catechism2267: the death penalty is"inadmissible"
  • St Augustine (354–430): the state may use the sword (Romans 13), but in letters to officials (Letter 134 to Apringius; Letter 153 to Macedonius, c. 414) he begs for the lives of the condemned, so they have time to repent (paraphrase).
  • St Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 64, a. 2: if a person is dangerous to the community, "it is praiseworthy and advantageous that he be killed in order to safeguard the common good".
  • Pope John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae 56 (1995): only allowed when there is no other way to defend society; such cases are "very rare, if not practically non-existent".
  • Pope Francis (2018) revised the Catechism (2267): the death penalty is "inadmissible", an attack on the dignity of the person; the Church works for its abolition worldwide.
  • Catholics see this as a development in understanding: modern prisons can protect society without killing.
Mission 4Diversity

Christian views today

Christian views todaysupportopposeSome Christians,often conservativeGenesis 9:6; Romans13:4Most UK churchesMatthew 5:38–48
  • Most UK churches oppose it: Catholic, Church of England, Methodist, Quaker and others. Reasons: sanctity of life; Jesus' teaching on revenge and love of enemies (Matthew 5:38–48); no one is beyond redemption; mistakes.
  • Some Christians support it, often conservative Christians (e.g. many in some US churches): Genesis 9:6 comes before the Law of Moses and applies to all humanity; Romans 13:4 gives the state the sword.
  • Supporters add: justice is not revenge; the state, not the individual, punishes.
  • Each side reads Genesis 9:6, Exodus 21 and Matthew 5:38–48 differently: as a command for all time, or as a limit on revenge that Jesus goes beyond.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how Catholic teaching on the death penalty has developed?
Mission 4Diversity

Islam and Judaism

Five faiths on the death penaltyIslamView: allowed for murder and certain veryserious crimes; the family may forgive;interpretations differ: many support it withstrict proof, some campaign against itSource: Qur'an 6:151; 2:178; Sahih Muslim16:4152JudaismView: the Torah allows it for murder; therabbis were very reluctant to use it; Israelabolished it for murder in 1954Source: Exodus 21:12; Mishnah Makkot 1:10BuddhismView: most opposeKey terms: First Precept; ahimsa; karuna;mettaSource: Brahmajala Sutta (Digha Nikaya 1)HinduismView: ahimsa points against it; some supportit; India keeps it for the "rarest of rare" casesKey terms: ahimsa; karmaSource: Padma Purana 1.31SikhismView: views vary: many oppose (only Godgives and takes life; anyone can reform);others accept it for the worst crimesSource: Guru Granth Sahib 7
  • Islam: the Qur'an allows it for murder and certain very serious crimes: "slay not the life which Allah hath made sacred, save in the course of justice" (Qur'an 6:151, Pickthall).
  • The victim's family may forgive and accept compensation (Qur'an 2:178); forgiveness is praised.
  • Sahih Muslim 16:4152 (paraphrase): a Muslim's life may be taken only in three cases: a life for a life, a married person who commits adultery, and one who abandons the religion and the community. Muslim scholars differ on how these apply today; many read the third case as treason.
  • Interpretations of Shari'ah differ: many Muslims support it for murder with strict proof; many scholars say the conditions make it very rare; some Muslims campaign against it. British Muslims follow UK law.
  • Judaism: the Torah allows it for murder: "He that smiteth a man, so that he dieth, shall surely be put to death." (Exodus 21:12, JPS 1917)
  • Mishnah Makkot 1:10 (paraphrase): a court that executed once in seven years was called destructive; Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah said once in seventy; Rabbis Tarfon and Akiva said that had they sat on the court, no one would ever have been executed. Rabban Simeon ben Gamaliel replied that they would then multiply murderers in Israel: the Mishnah keeps both views.
  • Israel abolished it for murder in 1954; it has been used once since, for the Nazi Adolf Eichmann (1962).
Mission 4Diversity

Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism

Five faiths on the death penaltyIslamView: allowed for murder and certain veryserious crimes; the family may forgive;interpretations differ: many support it withstrict proof, some campaign against itSource: Qur'an 6:151; 2:178; Sahih Muslim16:4152JudaismView: the Torah allows it for murder; therabbis were very reluctant to use it; Israelabolished it for murder in 1954Source: Exodus 21:12; Mishnah Makkot 1:10BuddhismView: most opposeKey terms: First Precept; ahimsa; karuna;mettaSource: Brahmajala Sutta (Digha Nikaya 1)HinduismView: ahimsa points against it; some supportit; India keeps it for the "rarest of rare" casesKey terms: ahimsa; karmaSource: Padma Purana 1.31SikhismView: views vary: many oppose (only Godgives and takes life; anyone can reform);others accept it for the worst crimesSource: Guru Granth Sahib 7
  • Buddhism: most Buddhists oppose it: the First Precept (not to take life), ahimsa, karuna and metta. Killing creates bad karma for those who carry it out.
  • Brahmajala Sutta 1 (Digha Nikaya 1, paraphrase): the Buddha abstains from killing, with rod and weapon laid aside, kind and compassionate to all living beings.
  • Hinduism: ahimsa points against it; karma means the offender will face the results of the act anyway. Gandhi opposed the death penalty.
  • Some Hindus support it; India keeps it for the "rarest of rare" cases.
  • Padma Purana 1.31 is your spec's named source; it is read both ways.
  • Sikhism: views vary. Many Sikhs oppose it: only God gives and takes life, and anyone can reform. Others accept it for the worst crimes, to protect the innocent and uphold justice.
  • Guru Granth Sahib 7 (your spec: God's power of life and death) is used to argue that this power belongs to God.
Quick check
?The Torah allows the death penalty for murder. What does Mishnah Makkot 1:10 show about how the rabbis applied it?
Mission 4

Non-religious views and situation ethics

Humanists on the death penaltyHumanists oppose itone life: this life is the only onemistakes cannot be put right?no clear evidence that it deters
  • Humanists (e.g. Humanists UK) oppose it: this life is the only one; mistakes cannot be put right; no clear evidence it deters; it brutalises society.
  • Utilitarian arguments can go either way: it depends on the evidence about results.
  • Some atheists support it for the worst crimes, on grounds of retribution or protection.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape). Most who use it reject executions as unloving; some argue a rare case might protect many. Religious responses: love includes justice, but also the chance to repent.
Mission 4Evaluate

"The death penalty is never right."

Is the death penalty never right?"The death penalty is never right."ForSanctity of life (Exodus 20:13; Genesis1:27).Jesus rejected revenge (Matthew 5:38–39).Innocent people have been executed.No clear deterrent effect.Catholic teaching calls it inadmissible;Humanists oppose it.AgainstRetribution for the worst crimes (Genesis9:6).Romans 13:4 gives the state the sword.Protection of society.Utility, if it deters.Another viewRight in principle, but almost never inpractice (Evangelium Vitae 56).Judge it byIs life only God's to take? · Can guilt ever becertain? · What do victims and society need? ·What does the evidence show?
  • Reasons for: sanctity of life (Exodus 20:13; Genesis 1:27); Jesus rejected revenge (Matthew 5:38–39); innocent people have been executed; no clear deterrent effect; Catholic teaching calls it inadmissible; Humanists oppose it.
  • Reasons against: retribution for the worst crimes (Genesis 9:6); Romans 13:4; protection of society; utility, if it deters.
  • Muslims point out that the Qur'an allows it for murder (6:151).
  • Another view: right in principle, but almost never in practice (Evangelium Vitae 56).
  • The rabbis of Mishnah Makkot 1:10 took a similar line.
  • Judge it by: Is life only God's to take? Can guilt ever be certain? What do victims and society need? What does the evidence show?
Mission check

?A country with secure prisons votes on bringing back executions for terrorist murders. A Catholic, a Reform Jew and a Humanist all vote against. Which reason could all three share?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Moral evil comes from human choices; natural evil from nature. Suffering raises the inconsistent triad (omnipotent, omnibenevolent God and evil) and the evidential problem; innocent suffering is the hardest case.
  • Isaiah 45:7 and Surah 1 sharpen the question for Catholics and Muslims.
  • Psalm 103 sharpens it for Jews.
  • Traditions locate the origin of evil differently: Fall and Original Sin; yetzer ha-ra and choice; Iblis and testing; karma, ignorance and maya; craving; ego and the five evils.

Mission 2

  • Aims: retribution (deserved), deterrence (put others off), reformation (change the offender).
  • Also protection (keep the public safe).
  • Christian sources: Exodus 21:24 (proportion), Romans 13:4 (authority), Galatians 6:1 (restore).
  • Islam (qisas, mercy), Judaism (compensation, teshuvah), Buddhism (compassion, reform), Hinduism (danda), Sikhism (justice and reform): each tradition balances justice and change.
  • Hindu prayascitta and the Sikh tankhah are penances that restore the offender.

Mission 3

  • Forgiveness: letting go of anger and revenge; repentance: turning from wrong; reconciliation: restoring the relationship.
  • Jesus: forgive "seventy times seven" (Matthew 18:22).
  • Muslims: Allah is al-Ghafur (64:14); Jews: teshuvah (Micah 7:18); Buddhists: "hatred ceases by love" (Dhammapada 5).
  • Forgiving the person can go with justice for the act.
  • Restorative justice tries to do both: repair harm and reform the offender.

Mission 4

  • Death penalty: execution by the state; aims: retribution, deterrence, protection. Abolished in the UK; used in some countries.
  • For: retribution, deterrence, utility (if it saves lives); against: sanctity of life, mistakes, no clear deterrent, no chance to reform.
  • Christians differ (Genesis 9:6 vs Matthew 5:38–39); Catholic teaching has developed to "inadmissible" (2018); other faiths and Humanists also differ.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Crime and Punishment (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
  2. Mission 2When someone breaks the law, what should punishment actually achieve?
  3. Mission 3If you forgive someone who hurt you, should they still be punished?
  4. Mission 4Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel