Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A (1RA0) · Paper 4 Area of Study 4A Mark's Gospel – Section 1: Who is Jesus? (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Mark's Gospel: Who is Jesus? (part 1)
6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Why would someone Christians call sinless queue up to be baptised for forgiveness?
Mission 2Messiah, Son of Man, Son of God: why did Jesus' followers need so many names for him?
Mission 3If a storm stops or a crowd is fed, does it matter whether it really happened?
Mission 4A frightened woman, a desperate father, a blind beggar: what did their faith have to do with healing?
Mission 5Jesus' own disciples failed to free a suffering boy. What went wrong?
Mission 6Peter gets the answer right, then gets told off. What did he misunderstand?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Why would someone Christians call sinless queue up to be baptised for forgiveness?
Make a guess: Why would someone Christians call sinless queue up to be baptised for forgiveness?
Mission 1
The messenger in the wilderness
Mark opens with prophecy: "Behold, I send my messenger before your face, who will prepare your way before you" (Mark 1:2, echoing Malachi 3:1) and "the voice of one crying in the wilderness" (Mark 1:3, echoing Isaiah 40:3).
John the Baptist is that messenger: he prepares people for someone greater.
He preached "the baptism of repentance for forgiveness of sins" (Mark 1:4). Repentance means turning away from sin and back to God.
Crowds from Judea and Jerusalem came to the River Jordan, confessing their sins (1:5).
Clothing and food: camel's hair, a leather belt, locusts and wild honey (1:6). The belt recalls the prophet Elijah (2 Kings 1:8), whom Jews expected to return before God's day.
Mission 1Read the source
Someone mightier
"After me comes he who is mightier than I, the strap of whose sandals I am not worthy to stoop down and loosen. I baptised you in water, but he will baptise you in the Holy Spirit." (Mark 1:7–8)
Untying sandals was a slave's job: John says he is not fit even for that.
Q1 How does John compare himself with the one who is coming?
Show answer
He is lower than a slave to him.
Q2 What will the coming one do that John cannot?
Show answer
Baptise with the Holy Spirit, not only water.
Quick check
?Why do many Christians think Mark describes John's camel-hair clothing and leather belt?
Mission 1
The baptism of Jesus
Jesus came from Nazareth in Galilee and was baptised by John in the Jordan (1:9).
Coming up from the water, "he saw the heavens parting and the Spirit descending on him like a dove." (Mark 1:10)
A voice: "You are my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased." (Mark 1:11)
In Mark, Jesus himself sees and hears: it is addressed to him.
The words echo Psalm 2:7 (the king as God's son) and Isaiah 42:1 (God's chosen servant, on whom God puts his Spirit).
Mission 1
What the baptism shows
For Christians, the baptism shows:
Identity: Jesus is God's Son, approved by God.
Anointing: the Spirit comes on him; "Messiah" means "anointed one".
The start of the ministry: from here Jesus begins preaching (1:14–15).
The Trinity: Christians see Father (voice), Son (Jesus) and Holy Spirit (dove) together.
Solidarity: Christians believe Jesus was sinless, yet stood in line with sinners: he identifies with the people he came to save.
Example: he shows his followers the way of baptism.
Mission 1Diversity
The baptism for Christians today
Most churches baptise "in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit", using water.
Infant baptism (Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Methodist): grace is God's gift before a person can choose; parents and godparents make promises.
Believer's baptism (Baptists, many Pentecostals and independent churches): only those old enough to repent and believe, often by full immersion, like Jesus in the Jordan.
Orthodox Christians celebrate the baptism at Theophany (6 January) with the blessing of waters.
Quakers and the Salvation Army do not baptise with water; they stress inner baptism by the Spirit (Mark 1:8).
Divergent understandings: some stress the beginning of the ministry; some the revelation of who Jesus is; some the example for believers.
Quick check
?In Mark's account of the baptism, which detail do Christians most often use to support belief in the Trinity?
Mission 1
The temptation
"Immediately the Spirit drove him out into the wilderness." (Mark 1:12)
Forty days, tempted by Satan, with the wild animals; angels served him (1:13).
Forty recalls Israel's forty years in the desert and the forty days of Moses (Exodus 34:28) and Elijah (1 Kings 19:8).
Mark gives no details and no result: Jesus' whole ministry becomes the battle with evil.
Significance: Jesus faces real temptation, so Christians believe he understands theirs: "one who has been in all points tempted like we are, yet without sin" (Hebrews 4:15). Many Christians keep Lent, forty days of prayer and self-denial.
Mission 1Evaluate
"The baptism proves that Jesus is the Son of God."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: a voice from heaven names him as Son; the Spirit descends; John, a prophet, says someone greater is coming; Christians across traditions read this as God's own testimony.
Reasons against (non-religious, e.g. atheist, Humanist): in Mark it is Jesus who sees the Spirit and the voice speaks to him, so it reads as a private experience that others cannot check; the account was written decades later by believers; a dove and a voice could be later symbolic language.
Christian responses: the story is a revelation to be received in faith, not a scientific proof; its meaning is confirmed by Jesus' whole life, death and resurrection; the centurion's words at the cross, "Truly this man was the Son of God!" (15:39), echo it.
Judge it by: What would count as "proof" of a religious claim? Is a private experience evidence for others? Does the story aim to prove or to proclaim?
Mission 1Worked answer
Belief, source, development
Question: Explain two ways the baptism of Jesus is significant for Christians today.
Way 1: it shows who Jesus is. Source: "You are my beloved Son" (Mark 1:11). Development: Christians worship Jesus as the Son of God, the second person of the Trinity.
Way 2: it is an example to follow. Development: Christians are baptised as Jesus was; Baptists do this by full immersion as believers, while Catholics baptise infants into God's family.
(c) 5-mark tip: two developed ways plus a reference to a source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check
?A new head teacher is introduced at assembly. The chair of governors says: "This is the person we have chosen, and we are delighted with her." From then on, she runs the school. Which part of Mark 1:1–13 does this most closely mirror, and why?
For Christians, the baptism marks Jesus out as God's beloved Son and launches his ministry; the temptation shows him facing evil before he begins.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Messiah, Son of Man, Son of God: why did Jesus' followers need so many names for him?
Make a guess: Messiah, Son of Man, Son of God: why did Jesus' followers need so many names for him?
Mission 2
What Jews hoped for
Messiah (Hebrew) and Christ (Greek) both mean "anointed one": someone set apart by God, as kings and priests were anointed with oil.
Under Roman rule, many Jews hoped God would send a Messiah. Hopes varied:
a king from David's family who would drive out the Romans and restore Israel;
a priestly leader (some groups, such as the Dead Sea Scrolls community);
a prophet like Moses (Deuteronomy 18:15).
Most expected a human leader sent by God, not a Messiah who would suffer and die.
Mission 2
Son of David
God promised King David: "I will establish the throne of his kingdom forever." (2 Samuel 7:13)
So "Son of David" meant the royal Messiah: a king of David's line.
Blind Bartimaeus calls out: "Jesus, you son of David, have mercy on me!" (Mark 10:47)
At the entry into Jerusalem the crowd shouts about "the kingdom of our father David" (11:10).
Jesus himself questions the title: David calls the Messiah "Lord", so he must be more than David's son (12:35–37).
Today: Christians see Jesus as fulfilling God's promises to Israel; but his kingdom is not political.
Mission 2
Son of Man
Jesus' favourite name for himself in Mark; others never use it of him.
In Hebrew idiom "son of man" can simply mean "a human being" (God addresses Ezekiel as "Son of man", Ezekiel 2:1).
In Daniel's vision it is a heavenly figure: "there came with the clouds of the sky one like a son of man" (Daniel 7:13), given everlasting dominion (7:14).
In Mark, Jesus uses it in three ways:
Authority now: "the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (Mark 2:10).
Suffering: he "must suffer many things… and be killed, and after three days rise again" (8:31).
Future glory: "coming with the clouds of the sky" (14:62).
Mission 2Read the source
The third passion prediction
"Behold, we are going up to Jerusalem. The Son of Man will be delivered to the chief priests and the scribes. They will condemn him to death, and will deliver him to the Gentiles. They will mock him, spit on him, scourge him, and kill him. On the third day he will rise again." (Mark 10:33–34)
This is the third prediction (after 8:31 and 9:31). The disciples were "amazed" and "afraid" (10:32).
Q1 Which title does Jesus use, and why is it surprising here?
Show answer
Son of Man: in Daniel a glorious figure, here one who suffers.
Q2 Who will hand him over, and to whom?
Show answer
The chief priests and scribes, to the Gentiles, the Romans.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how Jesus uses the title "Son of Man" in Mark?
Mission 2
The suffering servant (Isaiah 53)
Isaiah 52:13–53:12 describes God's servant who suffers for others:
"But he was pierced for our transgressions. He was crushed for our iniquities. The punishment that brought our peace was on him; and by his wounds we are healed." (Isaiah 53:5)
Christians read this as a prophecy of Jesus' death for the sins of others; Mark echoes it: the Son of Man came "to give his life as a ransom for many" (10:45; compare Isaiah 53:12).
Jews usually read the servant as the people of Israel suffering among the nations ("You are my servant, Israel", Isaiah 49:3), and do not see a suffering Messiah there.
Jesus joins the Son of Man and the suffering servant: a Messiah who wins through suffering.
Mission 2
Son of God
1st-century Jewish meaning: God's people (Israel is "my son", Exodus 4:22), the king ("You are my son", Psalm 2:7), or a righteous person close to God. Not usually a divine being.
In Mark the title frames the Gospel: the opening (1:1), the voice at the baptism (1:11) and transfiguration (9:7), the unclean spirits (3:11), the high priest's question (14:61–62) and the centurion: "Truly this man was the Son of God!" (Mark 15:39)
In Mark it is a Gentile soldier who says it at the cross: for Mark, Jesus is shown to be Son of God most clearly in his death.
Christians today: Jesus is the eternal Son, "true God from true God" (Nicene Creed, 325/381), the second person of the Trinity.
Mission 2
The Messianic secret
In Mark, Jesus often tells people not to say who he is: demons (1:34), a healed leper (1:44), the disciples after Peter's confession (8:30) and after the transfiguration (9:9).
William Wrede (1859–1906), The Messianic Secret (1901): the secret is Mark's literary device, explaining why Jesus was not widely recognised as Messiah in his lifetime.
Other explanations: Jesus avoided a political, anti-Roman understanding of "Messiah"; he needed to teach that the Messiah must suffer first; he avoided arrest before his time.
The secret ends at his trial: "Are you the Christ…?" Jesus said, "I am." (Mark 14:61–62)
Quick check
?Many Jews in Jesus' time hoped for a Messiah. Which hope was most widespread?
Mission 2Diversity
What the titles mean today
Many Christians today read the titles like this:
Son of Man: Jesus shared fully in human life and suffering, and will return as judge (the creeds: "he will come again in glory").
Son of God: Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestant Christians: Jesus is fully divine. Some liberal Christians read it as Jesus' unique closeness to God.
Christ / Messiah: Jesus as king; Catholics keep the feast of Christ the King. But his kingship is service (10:45), a model for Christian leaders.
Son of David: God keeps his promises; Christians read the Old Testament as pointing to Jesus.
Jesus' own understanding reshapes each title: power through suffering and service. This calls 21st-century Christians to serve rather than dominate.
Other views: Jews do not accept Jesus as Messiah (no age of peace has come); many non-religious scholars think the higher titles grew in the early Church.
Mission 2Evaluate
"'Son of Man' is the most important title for understanding Jesus."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: it is the title Jesus chose for himself; it holds together his authority, suffering and future glory; it avoids political misunderstanding.
Reasons against: "Son of God" frames the whole Gospel (1:1; 15:39) and is central in the creeds; "Christ" is so important it became part of his name; for many Christians "Saviour" says most about what he does for them.
Another view: no title is enough alone; each corrects the others (e.g. Messiah redefined by Son of Man).
Judge it by: Whose understanding counts most: Jesus', Mark's, or the Church's? Which title best explains the cross?
Mission check
?A charity founder says: "I am not here to be your boss. My job is to look after you, even if it costs me everything." Which title, as Jesus uses it in Mark, does this idea best echo?
In Mark, Jesus reshapes the titles: the Messiah and Son of Man wins through suffering and service.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If a storm stops or a crowd is fed, does it matter whether it really happened?
Make a guess: If a storm stops or a crowd is fed, does it matter whether it really happened?
Mission 3
What is a nature miracle?
A miracle in the Gospels is an act of power. Mark calls them "mighty works" and presents them as showing God at work.
Nature miracles: Jesus shows power over the natural world (wind, sea, food), not only over illness or evil spirits.
In the Jewish scriptures, only God rules the sea and feeds his people in the wilderness.
So the question each story raises is: who is this?
Many Christians see Jesus' miracles as signs that God's Kingdom has come near (1:15); in Mark they call for faith.
Mission 3
Calming the storm
Evening on the Sea of Galilee; Jesus says, "Let's go over to the other side." (Mark 4:35)
A great storm fills the boat with water; Jesus is asleep on a cushion (4:37–38).
The disciples wake him: "Teacher, don't you care that we are dying?" (Mark 4:38)
He rebukes the wind, "Peace! Be still!", and there is a great calm (4:39).
He asks: "Why are you so afraid? How is it that you have no faith?" (Mark 4:40)
Mission 3Read the source
"Who then is this?"
"They were greatly afraid and said to one another, 'Who then is this, that even the wind and the sea obey him?'" (Mark 4:41)
"He makes the storm a calm, so that its waves are still." (Psalm 107:29)
In the Psalm, it is God who stills the storm.
Q1 What are the disciples afraid of at the end of the story?
Show answer
Not the storm now, but the power of the one in the boat.
Q2 What answer does the Psalm suggest to their question?
Show answer
Jesus does what God does.
Quick check
?After the storm is calmed, Jesus asks the disciples, "How is it that you have no faith?" What does this suggest Mark wants readers to learn?
Mission 3
Feeding the five thousand
Step 1 of 4
A crowd follows. Jesus "had compassion on them because they were like sheep without a shepherd" (Mark 6:34) and teaches them.
Disciples: send them away to buy food. Jesus: "You give them something to eat." (Mark 6:37)
Five loaves and two fish. "He took the five loaves and the two fish; and looking up to heaven, he blessed and broke the loaves, and he gave to his disciples to set before them" (Mark 6:41).
"They all ate and were filled." Twelve baskets left over; five thousand men ate (6:42–44).
Took, blessed, broke, gave: Mark uses the same four actions with bread at the Last Supper (14:22).
Echoes: God feeding Israel with manna (Exodus 16); the prophet Elisha feeding a hundred, with some left over (2 Kings 4:42–44); the shepherd of Psalm 23 and Ezekiel 34.
Mission 3
Walking on the water
Jesus sends the disciples across by boat and goes up a mountain to pray (6:45–46).
In the night they are straining at the oars against the wind; he comes to them, walking on the sea (6:48).
They think he is a ghost. He says: "Cheer up! It is I! Don't be afraid." (Mark 6:50)
"It is I" can be read "I am", echoing God's name to Moses (Exodus 3:14). In Job, God alone "treads on the waves of the sea" (Job 9:8).
The wind stops. But "they hadn't understood about the loaves, but their hearts were hardened." (Mark 6:52)
Even the closest disciples are slow to see who Jesus is.
Quick check
?In the feeding of the five thousand, Jesus took the loaves, "blessed and broke" them and gave them. Why do many Christians link this with the Last Supper?
Mission 3Diversity
What do the nature miracles show?
Identity: for Christians, Jesus has God's power over nature, so they see him as the Son of God.
Compassion: he feeds the hungry and cares for the frightened.
The Messiah's banquet: Jews hoped for a great feast in God's Kingdom; the feeding is a foretaste.
Interpretations among Christians:
Literal: real events; God, who made nature, can act in it (Catholic, Orthodox and many evangelical Christians).
Sharing: some liberal Christians suggest the crowd shared food they had hidden; the "miracle" was generosity.
Symbolic: stories that teach trust in Christ in hard times, and point to the Eucharist.
Significance today: trust in God in crisis; the Eucharist; Christian charities such as CAFOD, Christian Aid and Tearfund "give them something to eat".
Mission 3
Non-religious arguments
Science: storms on the Sea of Galilee rise and drop suddenly; calm can follow by chance.
Natural explanations: the crowd may simply have shared food they had brought.
Walking on the water: perhaps on a sandbank, or on the shore in poor light.
David Hume (1711–1776): testimony to miracles is never strong enough to outweigh the uniform experience of nature; and miracle stories "are observed chiefly to abound among ignorant and barbarous nations" (An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding, 1748, Section X).
Late and biased witnesses: the stories were written decades later by believers.
No proof of divinity: in the Bible, prophets such as Elisha also work wonders; Mark warns that false messiahs will show "signs and wonders" (13:22).
Humanists usually see the miracles as legend or symbolic stories.
Quick check
?Which statement is a non-religious argument against the nature miracles, rather than a Christian interpretation of them?
Mission 3Evaluate
"The nature miracles must have really happened for them to matter to Christians."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: Christians claim Jesus is divine; if he did not have God's power, the stories mislead. Mark presents them as events, with places and numbers. Paul says faith is empty if Christ is not raised (1 Corinthians 15:14, paraphrase); many apply the same logic to miracles.
Reasons against: Jesus refuses to give a "sign" to prove himself (8:11–12); the stories' message (trust, compassion, the Eucharist) holds even if read symbolically; many Christians' faith rests on the resurrection and on experience of God, not on these stories.
Christian responses to science: a natural cause and God's action are not rivals (God can act through nature and its timing); laws describe what usually happens, not what God must do.
Judge it by: Can a story be true in meaning without being literal? What does "proof" mean in religion? Is Hume's standard of evidence fair to unique events?
Mission 3Worked answer
Two contrasting beliefs
Question: Explain two contrasting beliefs about the feeding of the five thousand.
Belief 1: It really happened as Mark says. Development: God's Son has power over creation, so Jesus multiplied the bread (Mark 6:41–44); Catholic and many evangelical Christians hold this.
Belief 2: It is a story of sharing, or a symbol. Development: the crowd shared their food, or the story points to the Eucharist; some liberal Christians and many non-religious people take this view.
Mission check
?A firefighter rescues a child moments before a bridge collapses. The child's mother says, "That was God." A scientist says, "That was training and luck." Which response is most like the view of many Christians about Mark's nature miracles?
Christians differ on how literally to read the nature miracles, but agree that they point to who Jesus is.
Mission 4
Mission 4: A frightened woman, a desperate father, a blind beggar: what did their faith have to do with healing?
Make a guess: A frightened woman, a desperate father, a blind beggar: what did their faith have to do with healing?
Mission 4
Healing as a sign
Mark calls them mighty works (6:5). Many Christians see them as signs that God's Kingdom has come near (1:15).
The prophets pictured that time: "Then the eyes of the blind will be opened, and the ears of the deaf will be unstopped." (Isaiah 35:5)
Mark's healings show Jesus' compassion and his authority: he acts by his own word and touch.
They often call for faith: trust in Jesus and in God's power.
They often break a barrier: sickness, uncleanness, death, being pushed aside.
Mission 4
The paralysed man
Capernaum: the house is packed. Four friends dig through the roof and lower their friend on his mat (2:1–4).
"Jesus, seeing their faith, said to the paralytic, 'Son, your sins are forgiven you.'" (Mark 2:5)
Some scribes think: only God can forgive sins; this is blasphemy (2:6–7).
Jesus heals the man so "that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins" (2:10).
The man walks out carrying his mat; everyone glorifies God (2:12).
Faith here is the friends' faith, shown in action.
Mission 4
Jairus' daughter
Step 1 of 3
Jairus, a leader of the synagogue, falls at Jesus' feet: his little daughter is dying (5:22–23).
On the way, a delay (the woman, next screen). Then news: "Your daughter is dead." (5:35)
Jesus: "Don't be afraid, only believe." (Mark 5:36)
He takes only Peter, James and John and the parents. Mourners laugh at "not dead, but … asleep" (5:39–40).
"Talitha cumi!" (Aramaic: "Girl, I tell you, get up!"). She gets up and walks; she is twelve (5:41–42).
He orders silence and tells them to give her something to eat (5:43).
Mission 4
The woman with a haemorrhage
Step 1 of 3
Bleeding for twelve years; she has spent everything on doctors and grown worse (5:25–26).
Under the Law, her bleeding made her ritually unclean (Leviticus 15:25), cut off from worship and touch.
She thinks: "If I just touch his clothes, I will be made well." (Mark 5:28) She is healed at once.
Jesus stops: "Who touched my clothes?" She comes forward, "fearing and trembling", and tells the whole truth (5:30–33).
He calls her "Daughter": healed in body, and welcomed back in public.
Mark sandwiches her story inside Jairus' story: a leader and an outcast, both twelve years, both "daughters".
Mission 4Read the source
"Your faith has made you well"
"He said to her, 'Daughter, your faith has made you well. Go in peace, and be cured of your disease.'" (Mark 5:34)
"But Jesus, when he heard the message spoken, immediately said to the ruler of the synagogue, 'Don't be afraid, only believe.'" (Mark 5:36)
Q1 Whose faith does Jesus praise in 5:34?
Show answer
The woman's: her trust that led her to reach out.
Q2 When is Jairus asked to believe?
Show answer
After hearing his daughter is dead: faith when all seems lost.
Quick check
?Why do many Christians think Mark places the woman's healing in the middle of the story of Jairus' daughter?
Mission 4
Bartimaeus
Leaving Jericho, on the way to Jerusalem. A blind beggar sits by the road (10:46).
He shouts: "Jesus, you son of David, have mercy on me!" (Mark 10:47) Son of David: a title for the Messiah.
The crowd tells him to be quiet; he shouts louder (10:48). Persistent faith.
He throws off his cloak (perhaps all he owns) and comes (10:50).
"Rabboni, that I may see again." Jesus: "Go your way. Your faith has made you well." (10:51–52)
He "followed Jesus on the way" (10:52): he becomes a disciple, on the road to the cross.
He sees clearly, while the disciples, just before, have misunderstood (10:35–45).
Quick check
?Bartimaeus calls Jesus "son of David" and then "followed Jesus on the way". What do many Christians see in this?
Mission 4Diversity
What is faith in Mark?
Trust in Jesus' power: the woman and Jairus believe he can heal (5:28, 5:36).
Faith that acts: the friends break a roof (2:4); Bartimaeus will not be silenced (10:48).
Faith of others: the man is healed through his friends' faith (2:5), the girl through her father's.
Faith that struggles: "I believe. Help my unbelief!" (9:24, a later mission).
Unbelief limits: at Nazareth "he could do no mighty work there", and "marvelled because of their unbelief" (6:5–6).
Mission 4Diversity
Healing miracles today
Literal: real events; Jesus has God's power over sickness and death (Catholic, Orthodox, many Protestants).
Catholic practice: the sacrament of the Anointing of the Sick (James 5:14–15); pilgrimage to Lourdes, where the Church recognises a small number of healings as miracles after medical review.
Pentecostal and charismatic churches hold healing services and pray for healing with laying on of hands.
Liberal readings: healing of mind and body together; the stories mainly teach inclusion and wholeness.
Christian witness: hospitals, hospices and medical missions continue Jesus' care.
Non-religious views: stories grew in retelling; some illnesses may improve through belief (the placebo effect); Humanists value the compassion but not the miraculous claim.
Mission 4Evaluate
"In Mark's healing miracles, faith matters more than the miracle itself."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: Jesus says "your faith has made you well" (5:34; 10:52). Bartimaeus' healing ends in following. Unbelief at Nazareth limits him (6:5–6). The woman gains more than health: a name, "Daughter".
Reasons against: the miracles show who Jesus is: only God forgives sins (2:7–10). Jesus heals where no faith is mentioned (1:34). The girl is dead: she can have no faith. The healings are signs of the Kingdom (Isaiah 35:5–6).
Non-religious view: if the miracles did not happen, the stories still show compassion and courage, but no special power.
Judge it by: Does faith cause the healing or receive it? Is Mark's main point who Jesus is, or how to respond to him? Does it matter whether the events are historical?
Mission check
?A charity offers free eye operations in a remote village. One woman walks two days to reach the clinic, ignoring neighbours who tell her it is a waste of time. How is she most like a person in Mark's healing stories?
In Mark, faith is trust that reaches out, keeps going and then follows; the healings show who Jesus is and invite that response.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Jesus' own disciples failed to free a suffering boy. What went wrong?
Make a guess: Jesus' own disciples failed to free a suffering boy. What went wrong?
Mission 5
Exorcism in Mark
Exorcism: driving out an evil (Mark says "unclean") spirit or demon from a person.
In the first century, many Jews and Gentiles believed spirits could seize people and cause illness, fits, silence or violence.
Mark presents Jesus' exorcisms as a battle: God's Kingdom against Satan.
Jesus: no one can plunder a strong man's house "unless he first binds the strong man" (Mark 3:27).
Jesus commands with a word. Other exorcists of the time used spells, names or objects.
The spirits recognise who Jesus is, even when people do not.
Mission 5
Legion
Across the lake, in Gentile land (pigs are kept there). A man lives among the tombs, breaks chains, cuts himself with stones (5:1–5).
He shouts: "What have I to do with you, Jesus, you Son of the Most High God?" (Mark 5:7)
"My name is Legion, for we are many." (Mark 5:9) A legion was a Roman army unit of thousands.
The spirits enter a herd of about two thousand pigs, which rush into the sea (5:13).
The townspeople find him "sitting, clothed, and in his right mind" and are afraid; they ask Jesus to leave (5:15–17).
He begs to come too; Jesus sends him home to tell what the Lord has done. He preaches in the Decapolis (5:19–20): an early mission to Gentiles.
Quick check
?In Mark's exorcism stories, the spirits call Jesus "the Holy One of God" or "Son of the Most High God". What point do many Christians think Mark is making?
Mission 5
The boy: a scene of failure
Jesus comes down from the Transfiguration with Peter, James and John (9:2–13).
Below, a crowd, arguing scribes, and the other disciples, who have failed.
The father: his son has a spirit that makes him mute, throws him down, makes him foam at the mouth (9:17–18).
"I asked your disciples to cast it out, and they weren't able." (Mark 9:18)
Jesus: "Unbelieving generation, how long shall I be with you?" (Mark 9:19)
Ill "from childhood"; thrown into fire and water. The father: "If you can do anything, have compassion on us and help us." (9:21–22)
Mission 5Read the source
"Help my unbelief!"
"Jesus said to him, 'If you can believe, all things are possible to him who believes.' Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, 'I believe. Help my unbelief!'" (Mark 9:23–24)
Jesus turns the father's "if you can" back on him: the question is not Jesus' power but the father's trust.
Q1 What two things does the father say at once?
Show answer
He believes, and he admits his belief is weak.
Q2 Does Jesus refuse to help because the faith is weak?
Show answer
No: he heals the boy, and takes him by the hand, 9:25–27.
Mission 5
"Why couldn't we?"
Step 1 of 4
The boy seems dead; "Jesus took him by the hand and raised him up" (9:26–27).
Privately the disciples ask: "Why couldn't we cast it out?" (Mark 9:28)
Jesus: "This kind can come out by nothing but by prayer and fasting." (Mark 9:29)
Problems of discipleship shown here:
Weak faith: the "unbelieving generation" includes the disciples (9:19).
Relying on themselves: earlier they had been given authority and had cast out demons (6:7, 13); perhaps they treated it as their own power, not God's.
Lack of prayer: Jesus has just been on the mountain, where God's voice spoke (9:7); below, they have been arguing (9:14).
Pride: straight after, they argue about who is the greatest (9:33–34).
Quick check
?According to Mark 9:28–29, why could the disciples not cast out the spirit?
Mission 5Diversity
Exorcism today
Spiritual evil is real: Catholic, Orthodox and many evangelical Christians believe evil spirits exist.
Catholic teaching: a priest may perform a formal exorcism only with the bishop's permission, and only after checking that the person is not suffering from an illness, which is a matter for medicine (Catechism of the Catholic Church 1673, paraphrase).
Pentecostal and charismatic churches practise deliverance ministry: prayer to free people from evil.
Medical reading: many Christians think Mark describes conditions we now treat as epilepsy or mental illness; Jesus' care still matters.
Symbolic reading: the stories show Jesus freeing people from whatever enslaves them; some read "Legion" as a picture of Roman occupation.
Non-religious view: Humanists see possession as a pre-scientific explanation; they warn that exorcism can harm vulnerable people who need medical help.
Quick check
?Which statement best matches the Catholic Church's approach to exorcism today?
Mission 5Evaluate
"Mark's exorcism stories have little meaning for Christians today."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: modern medicine explains fits and mental illness; belief in possession can lead to harm; many Christians now read these stories as about illness, not demons.
Reasons against: many Christians still believe in spiritual evil and pray for deliverance; the stories show Jesus' authority over all evil; the boy's story teaches prayer and honest faith ("Help my unbelief!", 9:24); they model compassion for people others fear.
Humanist view: the stories have historical interest and show compassion, but no supernatural truth.
Judge it by: Does the meaning depend on believing in demons? Who decides what a story means today? Does a medical explanation remove a spiritual one?
Mission 5Worked answer
Problems of discipleship
Question: Explain two problems of discipleship shown in the healing of the boy (Mark 9:14–29).
Problem 1: weak faith. Source: Jesus calls them an "unbelieving generation" (9:19). Development: Christians today may also doubt, and need to say, like the father, "Help my unbelief!"
Problem 2: relying on their own strength. Source: "This kind can come out by nothing but by prayer" (9:29). Development: Christians believe service depends on God, so prayer comes before action.
5-mark (c) tip: two developed points plus a source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check
?A new youth leader runs a successful first term, then a crisis comes and nothing she tries works. An older Christian says: "You stopped praying because things were going well." Which part of Mark 9:14–29 is this advice most like?
In Mark, even trusted disciples fail when they rely on themselves; Christians take the boy's story as a call to honest faith and prayer.
Mission 6
Mission 6: Peter gets the answer right, then gets told off. What did he misunderstand?
Make a guess: Peter gets the answer right, then gets told off. What did he misunderstand?
Mission 6
A turning point at Caesarea Philippi
Caesarea Philippi: a city in the far north, near the source of the Jordan, with a shrine to the Greek god Pan and a temple honouring the Roman emperor.
A place of other gods and Roman power: a striking setting to ask who Jesus really is.
It falls near the middle of Mark. Before it, Jesus' power is shown; after it, the road leads to the cross in Jerusalem.
Mission 6Read the source
"Who do you say that I am?"
On the way, Jesus asks his disciples who people say he is. They answer: John the Baptiser, Elijah, or one of the prophets (Mark 8:27–28, paraphrase).
"But who do you say that I am?" Peter answered, "You are the Christ." (Mark 8:29)
Q1 What did other people think about Jesus?
Show answer
That he was John the Baptist, Elijah, or another prophet.
Q2 What did Peter see that the crowds did not?
Show answer
That Jesus is the Christ, the Messiah, not just a prophet.
Mission 6
The rebuke
Jesus "commanded them that they should tell no one about him." (Mark 8:30)
Then the first passion prediction: "the Son of Man must suffer many things… and be killed, and after three days rise again." (Mark 8:31)
Peter takes him aside and rebukes him (8:32).
Jesus: "Get behind me, Satan! For you have in mind not the things of God, but the things of men." (Mark 8:33)
Peter's title was right; his idea of the Messiah was wrong. He expected victory; Jesus teaches suffering, death and resurrection.
"Satan" here: Peter is tempting Jesus away from his path, as Satan did in the wilderness.
Quick check
?Why does Jesus call Peter "Satan" at Caesarea Philippi?
Mission 6
The transfiguration
It opens with a promise: some standing here will see "God's Kingdom come with power" (Mark 9:1). Many Christians see that fulfilled on the mountain.
After six days Jesus takes Peter, James and John up a high mountain.
He is "changed into another form"; his clothes become dazzling white (9:2–3).
Elijah and Moses appear, talking with him (9:4).
Your spec spells Elijah as Elias.
Peter, afraid, offers to build three tents (9:5–6).
A cloud overshadows them; a voice: "This is my beloved Son. Listen to him." (Mark 9:7)
Suddenly they see only Jesus (9:8).
Mission 6
Why Moses and Elijah?
Moses = the Law: the lawgiver who received the Torah on Mount Sinai, where the cloud of God's glory covered the mountain (Exodus 24:16).
Elijah = the Prophets: the great prophet, who met God on Mount Horeb; expected to return: "I will send you Elijah the prophet before the great and terrible day of the LORD comes." (Malachi 4:5)
Together they stand for the whole Jewish scriptures. Christians believe Jesus fulfils both.
"Listen to him" recalls Moses' promise of a prophet like himself: "You shall listen to him." (Deuteronomy 18:15)
Coming down (9:9): tell no one until the Son of Man has risen.
(9:10) The disciples wonder what "rising from the dead" means.
Quick check
?Why do Christians think Moses and Elijah appear at the transfiguration?
Mission 6
What the transfiguration shows
For Christians, the transfiguration shows:
Identity: God's own voice calls Jesus "my beloved Son", as at the baptism.
Glory: the three disciples glimpse his divine glory before the suffering ahead.
Authority: "Listen to him": his teaching, including about suffering, carries God's authority.
Link with Caesarea Philippi: Peter has just heard that the Messiah must suffer; now he sees that suffering is not the end.
Resurrection: the glory points ahead to Easter.
Mission 6Diversity
The transfiguration today
Orthodox Christians celebrate it as a major feast (6 August); they see in the light on the mountain God's own uncreated glory, which believers can share (theosis: becoming like God by grace).
Catholics also keep 6 August, and pray it as one of the Luminous Mysteries of the Rosary (added 2002).
Many Protestants stress "Listen to him": the authority of Jesus' words, and encouragement in hard times.
Christians across traditions see it as a "mountain-top" experience that prepares for the "valley" of service.
Mission 6Evaluate
"The transfiguration proves that Jesus is the Messiah."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: God's voice declares him Son; Moses and Elijah, the Law and Prophets, confirm him; three witnesses were present; it fits Jesus' resurrection.
Reasons against (non-religious, e.g. atheist, Humanist): a vision is a private experience; it may have been a dream, a mistake in a frightened state, or a story written later to express faith; three close followers are not neutral witnesses; visions occur in many religions with conflicting messages.
Christian responses: the transfiguration is not offered as proof but as revelation, received by faith; it is consistent with the whole story of Jesus, especially the resurrection; two of the three witnesses, James (Acts 12:2) and, by tradition, Peter, were later killed for their faith.
Judge it by: What counts as evidence for a religious claim? Can an experience be real but not provable? Did Mark intend it as proof or as proclamation?
Quick check
?At Caesarea Philippi Jesus predicts his suffering; at the transfiguration the disciples see his glory. How do many Christians link the two events?
Mission check
?A football coach tells a new player: "You've got the talent everyone talks about. But winning here means early mornings, injuries and sacrifice first." The player says: "No, that won't happen to us!" Which moment in Mark does this most closely mirror?
In Mark, Peter knows Jesus' title but not the path: the Messiah's glory comes through suffering.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
John the Baptist is the messenger foretold by Malachi and Isaiah: he preaches repentance and points to one mightier than himself.
At the baptism the Spirit descends and the voice calls Jesus "my beloved Son": for Christians this reveals who he is, and his ministry begins.
Mission 2
Messiah/Christ means "anointed"; many 1st-century Jews hoped for a royal Son of David to free Israel.
Jesus calls himself the Son of Man (Daniel 7:13): authority, suffering (10:33–34) and future glory; Mark frames him as Son of God (1:1; 15:39).
Isaiah 53's suffering servant and the Messianic secret show a Messiah who must suffer before he is revealed.
Mission 3
In Mark, nature miracles show Jesus doing what, in the Jewish scriptures, only God does: stilling the sea, feeding his people in the wilderness.
Calming the storm asks "Who then is this?" and calls for faith.
Christians read them literally, as acts of sharing, or symbolically; non-religious people (Hume, Humanists) doubt the evidence and say they prove nothing about divinity.
Mission 4
Mark's healings are signs of God's Kingdom and show Jesus' compassion and authority, even over sin and death.
Faith in Mark is trust that acts (the friends, the woman, Jairus, Bartimaeus) and becomes following.
Christians read the healings literally, as wholeness and inclusion, or as continuing in prayer, sacraments and medicine; non-religious people doubt the miraculous.
Mission 5
Mark's exorcisms show Jesus' authority over evil and the coming of God's Kingdom; the spirits know who he is.
The disciples' failure with the boy shows problems of discipleship: weak faith, self-reliance, lack of prayer, pride.
Christians differ on possession today (spiritual, medical, symbolic); Humanists see a pre-scientific explanation.
Mission 6
At Caesarea Philippi Peter confesses "You are the Christ", but rebukes Jesus' prediction of suffering and is called "Satan".
At the transfiguration Jesus is changed in glory; Moses (the Law) and Elijah (the Prophets) appear; God says "This is my beloved Son. Listen to him."
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Mark's Gospel: Who is Jesus? (part 1) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A. 🎉
Mission 1Why would someone Christians call sinless queue up to be baptised for forgiveness?
Mission 2Messiah, Son of Man, Son of God: why did Jesus' followers need so many names for him?
Mission 3If a storm stops or a crowd is fed, does it matter whether it really happened?
Mission 4A frightened woman, a desperate father, a blind beggar: what did their faith have to do with healing?
Mission 5Jesus' own disciples failed to free a suffering boy. What went wrong?
Mission 6Peter gets the answer right, then gets told off. What did he misunderstand?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.