Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A (1RA0) · Area 1 (Paper 1) 1C Islam - Section 2: Practices (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Islam: Practices (part 2)
5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Pilgrims at Makkah run between two hills, retracing one mother's search for water. Who was she?
Mission 2Pilgrims throw stones at three walls near Makkah. What are they rejecting, and why does it matter?
Mission 3Many people think "jihad" means holy war. Why do most Muslims say its main meaning is a struggle inside?
Mission 4Muslims have two great festivals each year. Why is one of them marked by a sacrifice?
Mission 5On the same day, some Muslims fast with thanks and others mourn in the streets. Why?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Pilgrims at Makkah run between two hills, retracing one mother's search for water. Who was she?
Make a guess: Pilgrims at Makkah run between two hills, retracing one mother's search for water. Who was she?
Mission 1
Hajj: the fifth pillar
Hajj is the pilgrimage to Makkah, in the month of Dhul-Hijjah (8th–13th days), one of the Five Pillars.
Who must go: every adult Muslim, once in a lifetime, if able: healthy in body and mind, able to pay after debts and family needs, and able to travel safely.
"Pilgrimage to the House is a duty unto Allah for mankind, for him who can find a way thither." (Qur'an 3:97, Pickthall)
Schools differ on whether a woman must travel with a male relative (mahram); Saudi rules now let women travel in approved groups.
Mission 1
Origins: Ibrahim, Hajar and Isma'il
Step 1 of 4
Muslims believe Allah told Ibrahim (Abraham) to leave his wife Hajar and their baby son Isma'il in the dry valley of Makkah.
Hajar asked whether Allah had commanded this; when Ibrahim said yes, she replied that then Allah would not abandon them (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
When the water ran out, she ran seven times between the hills of Safa and Marwa, searching.
Water burst from the ground near Isma'il: the spring of Zamzam. People came to settle by it.
Later Ibrahim and Isma'il built the Ka'bah as a house for the worship of the One God (2:127), and Ibrahim called people to pilgrimage (22:27).
Over centuries the Ka'bah filled with idols. In 630 CE the Prophet Muhammad cleared them; his Farewell Hajj in 632 set the pattern Muslims follow today.
Mission 1Read the source
The House and its builders
"And when We made the House (at Makka) a resort for mankind and sanctuary, (saying): Take as your place of worship the place where Abraham stood (to pray)." (Qur'an 2:125, Pickthall)
"And when Abraham and Ishmael were raising the foundations of the House, (Abraham prayed): Our Lord! Accept from us (this duty)." (Qur'an 2:127, Pickthall)
2:124–130 also say Allah tested Ibrahim and made him a leader for mankind; Ibrahim prayed for Makkah's safety and for a messenger from his descendants (2:129, which Muslims see fulfilled in Muhammad).
22:25–30: the Sacred Mosque is open equally to residents and visitors; pilgrims come "on foot and on every lean camel" (22:27) and "go around the ancient House" (22:29).
Q1 Who does 2:127 say built the House?
Show answer
Ibrahim and Isma'il.
Q2 What does "sanctuary" in 2:125 suggest about Makkah?
Show answer
It is a place of safety and peace, where fighting and harm are forbidden.
Mission 1
Ihram: purity and equality
Ihram is the sacred state a pilgrim enters before Hajj, at a boundary point (miqat) outside Makkah.
Men: two plain white unstitched cloths. Women: ordinary modest clothes, often white; face and hands uncovered.
Rules: no perfume; no cutting hair or nails; no sexual relations; no hunting; men keep their heads uncovered; no arguing: "no lewdness nor abuse nor angry conversation on the pilgrimage" (Qur'an 2:197, Pickthall).
Significance: rich and poor look the same: equality before Allah. The white cloths are like the burial shroud, a reminder of death and Judgement. The rules focus the mind on Allah.
Quick check
?Why do male pilgrims wear two plain white cloths in ihram?
Mission 1
Tawaf: circling the Ka'bah
The Ka'bah: a cube-shaped building in the centre of the Masjid al-Haram (Sacred Mosque), covered in a black cloth (kiswah) embroidered with Qur'an verses. It is the qiblah for every Muslim's prayer.
Tawaf: walking around the Ka'bah seven times anticlockwise, starting at the corner of the Black Stone, which pilgrims kiss, touch or point to.
After tawaf, two rak'ahs of prayer near the Station of Abraham (2:125).
Significance: Allah at the centre of life; the whole ummah moving as one; following Ibrahim and the Prophet.
Not worship of the building: Muslims worship only Allah. The Ka'bah is a place and a direction, not an object of worship.
Mission 1
Sa'y and Zamzam
Sa'y: walking seven times between the hills of Safa and Marwa, now inside a long covered gallery. Men hurry along one marked stretch, as Hajar ran.
"(the mountains) As-Safa and Al-Marwah are among the indications of Allah." (Qur'an 2:158, Pickthall)
Zamzam: pilgrims drink from the well, and many bring its water home as a gift.
Significance: Hajar's trust in Allah and her effort: Muslims learn to rely on Allah and still act. Allah provides for those who turn to Him.
A woman's search is at the heart of every pilgrim's Hajj.
Quick check
?Which statement about the rituals at Makkah is accurate?
Mission 1Evaluate
"Hajj is the most important of the Five Pillars."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: it unites the whole ummah in one place; a well-known hadith says an accepted Hajj is rewarded with Paradise, and the pilgrim returns free of sin like a newborn; it brings together prayer, giving, sacrifice and self-control.
Reasons against: the Shahadah is the foundation: without it no other pillar counts; salah is five times a day and called the first thing a person is judged on; Hajj is only for those who are able (3:97), so Allah does not make it a test for everyone.
Another view: the pillars hold up one "house": each is necessary and none stands alone.
Judge it by: Is "important" about frequency, reward or effect on life? Can a duty that many Muslims never perform be the most important? What do Muslims themselves say?
Quick check
?Yusuf, 45, has saved for Hajj for years. Just before booking, he learns his business partner has left him with debts he must repay, and his family will struggle if he spends the money. What would most Muslim scholars advise?
Mission check
?On her seventh walk between Safa and Marwa, a tired pilgrim keeps going. A friend asks her why this ritual matters. Which answer fits what most Muslims teach about it?
Hajj retraces the faith of Ibrahim, Hajar and Isma'il, and Allah asks it only of those truly able to make the journey.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Pilgrims throw stones at three walls near Makkah. What are they rejecting, and why does it matter?
Make a guess: Pilgrims throw stones at three walls near Makkah. What are they rejecting, and why does it matter?
Mission 2
The days of Hajj
Step 1 of 5
8 Dhul-Hijjah: in ihram, pilgrims go to Mina, a valley of tents outside Makkah, and pray there.
9th:Arafat: the standing, from midday to sunset. At night, Muzdalifah.
10th: back to Mina: stoning the largest pillar, sacrifice, shaving or cutting the hair. Then to Makkah for tawaf (and sa'y). Muslims worldwide celebrate Id-ul-Adha.
11th–13th: at Mina, stoning all three pillars each day.
Before leaving Makkah: a farewell tawaf around the Ka'bah.
Mission 2
Arafat: the heart of Hajj
On the 9th, pilgrims stand (wuquf) on the plain of Arafat from midday until sunset: praying, reading the Qur'an, and asking Allah for forgiveness.
The Prophet said, "Hajj is Arafat" (hadith, paraphrase): a pilgrim who misses the standing has not completed Hajj.
The Mount of Mercy (Jabal al-Rahmah) rises from the plain. Near it the Prophet gave his Farewell Sermon in 632 CE: all people equal, no Arab better than a non-Arab except by piety; lives and property sacred; women to be treated kindly (paraphrase).
Some traditions say Adam and Hawwa (Eve) were reunited and forgiven here.
Significance: a rehearsal for the Day of Judgement: millions standing before Allah, in plain white, waiting for mercy.
Mission 2
Muzdalifah: a night under the sky
After sunset pilgrims move to Muzdalifah, between Arafat and Mina.
They pray Maghrib and Isha together and sleep on the ground in the open air, rich and poor alike.
"when ye press on in the multitude from 'Arafat, remember Allah by the sacred monument" (Qur'an 2:198, Pickthall)
They collect small pebbles for the stoning at Mina.
Significance: simplicity, equality and trust in Allah after the day of standing.
Mission 2
Mina: stoning, sacrifice, shaving
Stoning (rami): pilgrims throw seven pebbles at the largest pillar (Jamrat al-Aqabah) on the 10th, and at all three on the following days. Today the pillars are tall walls reached by a multi-storey bridge.
Muslim tradition says Shaytan tempted Ibrahim three times here to disobey Allah's command to sacrifice his son, and Ibrahim drove him away with stones.
Significance: pilgrims reject evil and temptation in their own lives.
Sacrifice: a sheep, goat or camel is sacrificed (today usually arranged with a voucher) and the meat goes to the poor. This recalls the ram Allah gave Ibrahim in place of his son (see Mission 4).
Hair: men shave the head or cut it short; women cut a small lock. Most ihram rules now end.
Tawaf al-ifadah: a further tawaf (and sa'y) at the Ka'bah, then back to Mina for the remaining days.
Quick check
?Which action of Hajj is matched with its correct place and meaning?
Mission 2Read the source
Pilgrims and sacrifice
"And proclaim unto mankind the pilgrimage. They will come unto thee on foot and on every lean camel; they will come from every deep ravine" (Qur'an 22:27, Pickthall)
"Their flesh and their food reach not Allah, but the devotion from you reacheth Him." (Qur'an 22:37, Pickthall)
"Then eat thereof and feed therewith the poor unfortunate." (Qur'an 22:28, Pickthall)
22:28–29: pilgrims "witness things that are of benefit to them", mention Allah's name over the animals, and "go around the ancient House" (Pickthall, phrases).
Q1 According to 22:37, what reaches Allah in the sacrifice?
Show answer
Not the animal's flesh, but the pilgrim's devotion.
Q2 Who should receive the meat?
Show answer
The pilgrims may eat some themselves and feed the poor, 22:28.
Mission 2
Benefits: on Hajj and for life
Forgiveness: the Prophet said a pilgrim whose Hajj is accepted returns free of sin, like a newborn (hadith, paraphrase).
Closeness to Allah: days given entirely to prayer and remembrance.
Equality and ummah: people of every nation, colour and class in the same white cloth. Malcolm X (1925–1965) wrote after his Hajj in 1964 that he had eaten and prayed with pilgrims of every colour, and saw true brotherhood (paraphrase).
Patience and self-control: heat, crowds and no arguing (2:197).
Mission 2
Challenges
Cost: travel, accommodation and approved packages are expensive; many save for years.
Physical: summer heat in recent years, long walks, illness, crowds. Deadly crushes have happened (e.g. at Mina in 2015); Saudi authorities have rebuilt the Jamarat bridge and use crowd control.
Quotas: Saudi Arabia limits pilgrims from each country, so many wait years.
Spiritual: keeping patience and focus while tired, crowded and uncomfortable.
Commercialisation: luxury hotels overlooking the Ka'bah; some Muslims fear this undermines equality.
Quick check
?A pilgrim returns from Hajj and says: "The hardest part was the crowds and heat, but it taught me to be patient and to see every Muslim as my equal." Which part of Hajj best supports his second point?
Mission 2Evaluate
"Hajj loses its meaning when it becomes a luxury holiday."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: ihram and Muzdalifah teach equality and simplicity; luxury hotels and VIP tents divide rich from poor; Hajj should involve effort and patience; money could go to the poor.
Reasons against: the rituals stay the same for everyone: all stand at Arafat and throw the same pebbles; comfort helps the old and ill complete Hajj safely; Allah judges the heart and intention, not the hotel.
Another view: comfort is not the problem, but attitude is: a pilgrim can stay in comfort and remain humble, or in a tent and be proud.
Judge it by: What does ihram show about equality? Does safety justify cost? Which matters more: the outward conditions or the intention?
Mission 2Worked answer
Belief, source, development
Question: Explain two reasons why the rituals at Mina are important for Muslims. Refer to a source of wisdom and authority.
Reason 1: stoning the pillars recalls Ibrahim rejecting Shaytan. Development: pilgrims commit to rejecting temptation in their own lives.
Reason 2: the sacrifice shows devotion to Allah and care for the poor. Source: "Their flesh and their food reach not Allah, but the devotion from you reacheth Him" (Qur'an 22:37). Development: what matters is obedience, as Ibrahim obeyed, and the meat is shared with those in need.
5-mark (c) tip: two developed reasons and one source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check
?Months after Hajj, back at work in Leeds, Imran is tempted to cheat a customer. He remembers the pebbles he threw at Mina. Why would most Muslims say that memory should matter to him?
At Mina pilgrims reject Shaytan as Ibrahim did; Hajj is meant to change how they live when they go home.
Mission 3
Mission 3: Many people think "jihad" means holy war. Why do most Muslims say its main meaning is a struggle inside?
Make a guess: Many people think "jihad" means holy war. Why do most Muslims say its main meaning is a struggle inside?
Mission 3
Jihad means "striving"
Jihad comes from the Arabic root j-h-d: to strive, to make an effort, to struggle.
In Islam it means striving in the way of Allah (fi sabil Allah): doing what Allah wants against whatever pulls you away.
It is not the Arabic for "holy war". The words for war and fighting are harb and qital.
"As for those who strive in Us, We surely guide them to Our paths, and lo! Allah is with the good." (Qur'an 29:69, Pickthall)
Two kinds are usually taught: greater jihad (the inner struggle) and lesser jihad (the outward struggle, including defending Islam and, in strict conditions, fighting).
Mission 3
Greater jihad: the daily struggle
The struggle against the nafs (the selfish self): laziness, anger, greed, pride, temptation.
Examples: getting up for Fajr; keeping the fast; paying zakah; being honest when lying is easier; controlling your temper; avoiding gossip; studying the Qur'an.
The Prophet told a man who wanted to join a military campaign to do his jihad by caring for his parents (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
Mission 3
Why most Muslims put greater jihad first
A widely quoted saying has the Prophet return from battle and say, "We have returned from the lesser jihad to the greater jihad" (paraphrase). Many hadith scholars class this report as weak, but its idea is widely accepted.
A reliable hadith teaches that the true striver (mujahid) is the one who strives against his own self for Allah (Jami' at-Tirmidhi, paraphrase).
Reasons Muslims give: greater jihad is for every Muslim, every day; lesser jihad is rare and conditional; anyone who fights without a pure heart has failed the greater jihad first.
Another hadith: the best jihad is a word of truth before an unjust ruler (Sunan Abi Dawud, paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement best describes greater jihad?
Mission 3
Origins of lesser jihad
Step 1 of 4
Makkah (610–622): Muslims were mocked, boycotted, beaten and some killed. For thirteen years they were told to be patient and not to fight back.
622: the Hijrah to Madinah.
Madinah: permission to fight came, for self-defence: 22:39 is traditionally seen as the first verse permitting it.
Battles with the Makkans followed: Badr (624), then the Makkan attacks on Madinah at Uhud (625) and the Trench (627).
628: the Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: a peace treaty the Prophet accepted though its terms seemed unfavourable.
630: the Muslims entered Makkah almost without fighting; the Prophet pardoned its people.
Mission 3Read the source
Permission and limits
"Sanction is given unto those who fight because they have been wronged; and Allah is indeed Able to give them victory" (Qur'an 22:39, Pickthall)
"Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors." (Qur'an 2:190, Pickthall)
2:191–194: fight those who fight you and drove you out, for "persecution is worse than slaughter"; do not fight at the Sacred Mosque unless attacked there; "if they desist, then lo! Allah is Forgiving, Merciful" (2:192); respond only in like manner, and keep your duty to Allah (Pickthall, phrases and summary).
Q1 According to 22:39, why are Muslims given permission to fight?
Show answer
Because they have been wronged: it is a response to injustice.
Q2 Which phrase in 2:190 limits the fighting?
Show answer
"begin not hostilities": Muslims must not be the aggressors.
Mission 3
Conditions for lesser jihad
Just cause: self-defence, defending the oppressed (4:75), or protecting freedom to worship (22:40). Never for land, wealth, revenge or to force conversion (2:256).
Right authority: declared by a legitimate leader, not by an individual or a self-appointed group.
Last resort: after peaceful ways have failed.
Right intention: for Allah and justice, not for glory or hatred.
Conduct: no attacks on non-combatants. The first caliph Abu Bakr told his army not to kill women, children or the elderly, not to harm monks at worship, and not to cut down fruit trees or destroy buildings (paraphrase).
Proportion and an end: fight only as much as needed; stop when the enemy stops (2:192–193); accept peace when offered (8:61).
Quick check
?A small group, with no recognised leader, announces a "jihad" and attacks a crowded market of civilians in a country that has not attacked them. Which answer best identifies the conditions of lesser jihad they have broken?
Mission 3Diversity
Different understandings
Most Muslims: greater jihad is central; lesser jihad is mainly peaceful effort, and armed jihad only defensive, under strict conditions, declared by legitimate authority.
Sunni and Shi'a: many Twelver Shi'a scholars teach that a war started by Muslims (not defence) needs the presence of the Imam; while the Twelfth Imam is hidden, only defensive jihad is allowed.
Classical law: most medieval jurists also allowed a caliph to wage war beyond defence; most scholars today teach that only defence is permitted.
Peace-centred views: some Muslims argue that armed jihad has no place today, as conflicts are handled by states and international law; the struggle now is for justice through peaceful means.
Extremist claims: a small number of groups claim "jihad" for terrorism. In 2014 over 120 Muslim scholars signed an Open Letter to the leader of the group calling itself "Islamic State", setting out from the Qur'an and hadith why its actions were forbidden.
Mission 3Evaluate
"Greater jihad is more important than lesser jihad."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: every Muslim faces it daily; it underlies all other worship; the saying about the "greater jihad" (though weak) and the reliable hadith about striving against the self; lesser jihad without a pure heart is worthless.
Reasons against: lesser jihad can save lives and defend the oppressed (4:75; 22:39–40); the Qur'an praises those who strive with wealth and lives; for a community under attack, defence is urgent; the greater/lesser terms are not in the Qur'an itself.
Another view: they are not rivals: outward struggle for justice is only right when inner jihad has purified the intention.
Judge it by: Which affects more Muslims? Which is more often in the Qur'an and hadith? Does importance depend on the situation? How reliable is the "greater jihad" saying?
Mission 3Worked answer
Belief, source, development
Question: Explain two conditions for declaring lesser jihad. Refer to sacred writings.
Condition 1: it must be in self-defence, not aggression. Source: "Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities" (Qur'an 2:190). Development: Muslims may defend themselves but must never start a war of aggression.
Condition 2: it must be declared by a legitimate authority. Development: this prevents individuals or self-appointed groups from using the word "jihad" for violence; for many Shi'a scholars only defensive jihad is possible while the Imam is hidden.
Mission check
?Yusuf, 15, gives up gaming during Ramadan to read the Qur'an, makes himself pray Fajr on cold mornings, and writes to his MP about unfair treatment of a local family. How would most Muslims describe what he is doing?
For most Muslims, jihad looks like Yusuf's week: the struggle to live as Allah wants, and armed struggle is a rare, strictly limited exception.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Muslims have two great festivals each year. Why is one of them marked by a sacrifice?
Make a guess: Muslims have two great festivals each year. Why is one of them marked by a sacrifice?
Mission 4
Two Ids, one moon
Id (Arabic 'Id) means a festival: literally a day that returns every year.
Islam has two Ids that every Muslim group keeps:
Id-ul-Fitr: the festival of breaking the fast, at the end of Ramadan.
Id-ul-Adha: the festival of sacrifice, during the Hajj.
Both follow the lunar Islamic calendar, so they move about 11 days earlier each year in the solar calendar.
A new month starts when the new crescent moon is seen.
The Prophet set these two festivals in Madinah, in place of older festival days (hadith in Sunan Abu Dawud, paraphrase).
Mission 4
Id-ul-Fitr: why Muslims celebrate
When: 1 Shawwal, the day after Ramadan ends.
Thanks: Muslims thank Allah for the strength to complete the fast.
The Qur'an asks fasting Muslims to "complete the period, and that ye should magnify Allah for having guided you, and that peradventure ye may be thankful" (Qur'an 2:185, Pickthall).
Remembering the Qur'an: Ramadan is the month the Qur'an was first revealed.
Purpose: joy after self-discipline; forgiveness; the whole ummah celebrating together.
Zakat-ul-Fitr (fitrah): a fixed gift of food, or its value, paid for each family member before the Id prayer, so the poor can celebrate too.
Mission 4
Id-ul-Fitr: how Muslims celebrate
Wash (ghusl), wear new or best clothes, eat something sweet such as dates.
Recite the takbir on the way: "Allahu akbar" (God is the Greatest).
Id prayer in congregation: two rak'ahs with extra takbirs, then a sermon. Held in mosques, halls or parks.
Greet: "Id Mubarak" (blessed Id). Embrace and forgive.
Visit family and friends; share a festive meal and sweets.
Children receive gifts or money; cards are sent.
Some families visit the graves of relatives and pray for them.
Quick check
?Why is Zakat-ul-Fitr paid before the Id-ul-Fitr prayer rather than at any time in the year?
Mission 4
Id-ul-Adha: Ibrahim's test
Step 1 of 3
When: 10 Dhu al-Hijjah, the day pilgrims on Hajj sacrifice at Mina. Muslims everywhere join them.
Origin: the Qur'an tells how Ibrahim (Abraham) dreamed that Allah commanded him to sacrifice his son.
The son agreed. Both submitted to Allah. Muslims believe that at the last moment Allah stopped Ibrahim and provided a ram instead.
The Qur'an does not name the son. Most Muslims believe he was Isma'il (Ishmael).
Meaning: total submission to Allah, trust, and Allah's mercy.
Mission 4Read the source
"A clear test"
Step 1 of 3
Surah 37:77–111 first shows Ibrahim rejecting his people's idols (37:83–98), then praying for a righteous son (37:100).
> "O my dear son, I have seen in a dream that I must sacrifice thee. So look, what thinkest thou? He said: O my father! Do that which thou art commanded. Allah willing, thou shalt find me of the steadfast." (Qur'an 37:102, Pickthall)
> "Lo! that verily was a clear test. Then We ransomed him with a tremendous victim." (Qur'an 37:106–107, Pickthall)
Q1 How does the son respond to his father?
Show answer
He accepts Allah's command and promises to be steadfast.
Q2 What does "ransomed" tell Muslims about Allah?
Show answer
Allah did not want the boy's death: He tested obedience, then showed mercy by providing an animal.
Mission 4
Id-ul-Adha: how Muslims celebrate
Id prayer in congregation in the morning, with takbir.
Qurbani (Arabic udhiyah): a sheep, goat, cow or camel is sacrificed after the prayer, in Allah's name. A healthy animal of a set minimum age.
The meat is usually shared in three parts: the family, relatives and friends, and the poor.
Many Muslims pay for qurbani abroad through a charity, so meat reaches people in need.
Family visits, a festive meal, new clothes, gifts.
The Qur'an stresses the inner meaning: "Their flesh and their food reach not Allah, but the devotion from you reacheth Him." (Qur'an 22:37, Pickthall)
Quick check
?A Muslim teacher explains qurbani using Qur'an 22:37. What is the main point she would draw from this verse?
Mission 4Diversity
One festival, different ways
Sunni and Shi'a Muslims both keep Id-ul-Fitr and Id-ul-Adha with Id prayer, charity and family meals.
In Shi'a Islam these two Ids sit beside other key days: Id-ul-Ghadeer and the mourning of Ashura (see Mission 5). Shi'a Muslims also pay Zakat-ul-Fitr, often called fitrah.
Qurbani: the Hanafi school treats it as a duty (wajib) for every adult Muslim who can afford it; the other Sunni schools and Shi'a scholars call it a strongly recommended sunnah.
Moon-sighting: some communities wait to see the moon locally; others follow Saudi Arabia's announcement or astronomical calculation. So Id can fall on different days, even in one city.
Culture: sweet dishes and new clothes for Id-ul-Fitr in many places, such as Turkey and South Asia; long journeys home in Indonesia; animal markets before Id-ul-Adha in Pakistan.
Mission 4Evaluate
"Id-ul-Adha is more important than Id-ul-Fitr."
Step 1 of 4
For: Muslim scholars often call it the greater Id (al-'Id al-Kabir). It is joined to Hajj, a pillar of Islam. It remembers Ibrahim, a model of total submission. It lasts longer: qurbani may continue on the days after Id (to the 12th or, for some schools, the 13th of Dhu al-Hijjah).
For: the sacrifice is an act of worship in itself, and feeds the poor across the world.
Against: Id-ul-Fitr crowns a whole month of fasting, prayer and Qur'an reading. It is often the more widely celebrated festival in families, especially for children.
Against: the Prophet set both Ids together; each teaches a different side of Islam: gratitude after self-discipline, and submission after testing.
Judge it by: link to the Five Pillars? Which shapes daily life more? Which is celebrated more in Britain today? Can festivals with different purposes be ranked?
Mission check
?A Muslim nurse in Bradford is on shift on the morning of Id-ul-Adha. She cannot go to the Id prayer, but she pays a charity to sacrifice a sheep for her family and share it with refugees, and joins her family's meal that evening. Which part of the meaning of Id-ul-Adha does her charity payment show most clearly?
Two festivals, two lessons: thanks after the fast, and submission like Ibrahim's, each shared with the poor.
Mission 5
Mission 5: On the same day, some Muslims fast with thanks and others mourn in the streets. Why?
Make a guess: On the same day, some Muslims fast with thanks and others mourn in the streets. Why?
Mission 5
The tenth of Muharram
Muharram is the first month of the Islamic year: one of the four sacred months.
Ashura comes from the Arabic for "ten": the 10th day of Muharram.
The day carries two memories:
Musa (Moses) and the Israelites saved from Pharaoh: kept by most Sunni Muslims with a voluntary fast.
The martyrdom of Husayn, the Prophet's grandson, at Karbala in 680 CE: mourned by Shi'a Muslims.
Ashura is not an Id: no new clothes or celebration for most Muslims.
Mission 5
Ashura in Sunni Islam: Musa and fasting
In Madinah the Prophet found Jews fasting on this day, to thank God for saving Musa. He said Muslims have a closer claim to Musa, fasted, and told Muslims to fast too (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
When Ramadan became compulsory, the Ashura fast became voluntary (Sahih al-Bukhari, from Aisha, paraphrase).
Many Sunni Muslims fast on the 9th and 10th, following the Prophet's wish to fast the 9th as well (Sahih Muslim, paraphrase).
Meaning: thanks for Allah's rescue of the oppressed; hope of forgiveness for the past year (Sahih Muslim, paraphrase).
Some local customs: in Turkey families cook aşure, a sweet pudding shared with neighbours, linked to Nuh's ark; in Morocco children receive gifts.
Most Sunni Muslims also honour Husayn as a martyr from the Prophet's family.
Mission 5
Karbala, 680 CE
Husayn (Husayn ibn Ali): son of Ali and Fatimah, grandson of the Prophet; for most Shi'a Muslims the third Imam.
In 680 Yazid became caliph. Husayn refused to pledge loyalty to him, seeing his rule as unjust.
Invited by Muslims in Kufa, he set out with family and companions: a small group, women and children among them.
Yazid's army stopped them at Karbala, in present-day Iraq, and cut them off from the river: days without water.
On 10 Muharram 61 AH (680 CE) Husayn and his companions were killed, including his half-brother Abbas and his infant son.
The women, including his sister Zaynab, were taken captive to Damascus. Zaynab spoke out at Yazid's court.
His shrine in Karbala is one of the most visited places of Shi'a pilgrimage.
Mission 5Read the source
Why Husayn stood up
Before leaving Madinah, Husayn wrote to his brother that he did not go out for pride or power, but to seek reform in the community of his grandfather, to command the good and forbid the evil (Husayn's letter to Muhammad ibn al-Hanafiyyah, Shi'a historical sources, paraphrase).
Shi'a Muslims read the Qur'an's words on martyrs as true of Husayn:
> "Think not of those, who are slain in the way of Allah, as dead. Nay, they are living. With their Lord they have provision." (Qur'an 3:169, Pickthall)
At news of loss, Muslims say: "Lo! we are Allah's and lo! unto Him we are returning." (Qur'an 2:156, Pickthall)
Q1 What reason does Husayn give for his journey?
Show answer
Reform: to stand for good and against wrong, not for power.
Q2 Why does 3:169 give mourners hope?
Show answer
Martyrs are alive with Allah; Husayn's death is not the end.
Mission 5
How Shi'a Muslims commemorate Ashura
The first ten days of Muharram are a time of mourning: black clothes, no weddings or parties.
Majlis (gatherings): the story of Karbala is retold, with sermons and mournful poetry.
Matam: rhythmic beating of the chest in grief, often while chanting.
Processions carry standards (alam) and models of Husayn's shrine through the streets.
Water and food are given freely to anyone, recalling Husayn's thirst.
In Iran, ta'ziyeh plays re-enact the events.
A minority cut themselves (tatbir). Many senior Shi'a scholars discourage or forbid this, and many communities hold blood donation drives instead.
Arba'een: 40 days later, huge crowds walk to Karbala on pilgrimage.
Quick check
?Why do Shi'a Muslims set up stalls giving free water and drinks to passers-by during Muharram?
Mission 5
Ashura in Britain and worldwide
Britain: majalis in Shi'a centres (often called Husayniyyas) every evening of early Muharram.
London: a large mourning procession through central London on Ashura, with chanting, banners and water stalls.
Many British Shi'a run blood donation and charity campaigns, presenting Husayn as a model of justice and sacrifice.
Some explain Ashura to neighbours and schools, so the processions are understood.
Worldwide: public holiday and mass mourning in Iran, Iraq, Pakistan and Bahrain; huge crowds in Karbala.
Where Shi'a are a minority, processions can need police protection, and some have been attacked.
Mission 5
Id-ul-Ghadeer
When: 18 Dhu al-Hijjah, eight days after Id-ul-Adha.
What: returning from his Farewell Hajj in 632, the Prophet stopped at the pool of Khumm and spoke to the pilgrims about Ali.
Shi'a Muslims celebrate this as Ali's appointment as the Prophet's successor: an Id, a festival of joy.
Practices: special prayers and du'a, recommended fasting, visiting Ali's shrine in Najaf, gifts, celebratory meals, weddings, and pledges of brotherhood between friends.
Some Shi'a hadith call Ghadir the greatest Id of Allah.
A public holiday in Iran.
Mission 5Read the source
"This day have I perfected your religion"
The Prophet took Ali's hand: "Of whomever I am mawla, Ali is his mawla" (Hadith of Ghadir Khumm, paraphrase). Both Sunni and Shi'a collections record it.
> "This day have I perfected your religion for you and completed My favour unto you, and have chosen for you as religion al-Islam." (Qur'an 5:3, Pickthall)
Shi'a interpretation: revealed at Ghadir, after Ali's appointment. Religion was "perfected" when leadership after the Prophet was settled.
Sunni interpretation: revealed at Arafat during the Farewell Hajj (Sahih al-Bukhari, report of Umar). Religion was perfected as the revelation of law came to completion.
Mawla: Shi'a read "master and guardian"; most Sunni read "friend and helper".
Q1 Why does the place where 5:3 was revealed matter?
Show answer
If at Ghadir, it links the completion of Islam to Ali's appointment.
Q2 Why do most Sunni Muslims not keep Ghadir as a festival?
Show answer
They read the event as honouring Ali, not appointing a successor.
Quick check
?Most Sunni Muslims accept that the Prophet praised Ali at Ghadir Khumm. Why, then, do they not celebrate Id-ul-Ghadeer?
Mission 5Diversity
Same days, different meanings
Ashura, Shi'a: the central day of mourning for Husayn; a lesson in standing against injustice.
Ashura, Sunni: a voluntary fast of thanks for Musa's rescue; Husayn honoured as a martyr, without public mourning in most places.
In South Asia many Sunni Muslims, especially in Sufi traditions, also hold Muharram gatherings and join processions.
Some Sunni scholars criticise mourning rituals as bid'ah (innovation); some Shi'a scholars criticise tatbir.
Some Shi'a fast part of Ashura day until the afternoon in grief, rather than as a fast of thanks.
Ghadir: an Id for Shi'a Muslims; for Sunni Muslims, an honour for Ali, not a festival.
A popular Shi'a saying: "Every day is Ashura, every land is Karbala": Husayn's stand applies everywhere.
Quick check
?Which statement about Ashura is accurate for most Sunni Muslims?
Mission 5Evaluate
"Ashura is the most important day of the year for Shi'a Muslims."
Step 1 of 4
For: Karbala is central to Shi'a identity and to belief in the Imams. Mourning lasts many days and leads to Arba'een. It teaches sacrifice and resisting injustice in every age.
Against: the two Ids were set by the Prophet for all Muslims. Ramadan and Laylat al-Qadr mark the revelation of the Qur'an.
Against: some Shi'a hadith call Ghadir the greatest Id.
Another view: Ashura is a commemoration, not a festival, so it is important in a different way: it is not in competition with the Ids.
Judge it by: what the Prophet commanded; what shapes Shi'a identity most; how much of the year the day affects; whether mourning and celebration can be ranked.
Mission check
?A Shi'a youth group in Birmingham organises a blood donation drive during Muharram under the slogan "Give blood, not tears alone". Which belief about Ashura most explains this choice?
The same tenth of Muharram means thanks for Musa's rescue to most Sunni Muslims and grief for Husayn to Shi'a Muslims.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Hajj (fifth pillar) is required once in a lifetime of every adult Muslim who is able (Qur'an 3:97).
Its origins: Ibrahim, Hajar and Isma'il; Hajar's search between Safa and Marwa; Zamzam; Ibrahim and Isma'il building the Ka'bah (2:125–127).
At Makkah: ihram (equality, purity), tawaf (seven circuits anticlockwise), sa'y (seven walks between Safa and Marwa), Zamzam.
Mission 2
8–13 Dhul-Hijjah: Mina → Arafat (standing until sunset; Mount of Mercy) → Muzdalifah (night, pebbles) → Mina (stoning, sacrifice, hair) → tawaf.
Jihad means "striving" in the way of Allah. Greater jihad is the daily inner struggle against the nafs; most Muslims see it as more important.
Lesser jihad began in Madinah as self-defence (Qur'an 22:39, 2:190): just cause, legitimate authority, last resort, right intention, no harm to non-combatants, and peace when offered.
Mission 4
Id-ul-Fitr ends Ramadan: thanks to Allah, Zakat-ul-Fitr, Id prayer, new clothes, food, gifts and family.
Id-ul-Adha remembers Ibrahim's test (Qur'an 37:102–107) during Hajj: Id prayer, qurbani shared with family, friends and the poor; devotion, not meat, reaches Allah (22:37).
Mission 5
Ashura, 10 Muharram: most Sunni Muslims fast voluntarily, remembering Musa's rescue; Shi'a Muslims mourn Husayn's martyrdom at Karbala (680 CE) with majalis, matam, processions and charity.
In Britain, Shi'a Muslims hold majalis, a mourning procession in London, and blood donation and charity drives.
Id-ul-Ghadeer (18 Dhu al-Hijjah) is a Shi'a Id for Ali's appointment; Shi'a and Sunni Muslims read Surah 5:3 and the Ghadir hadith differently.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Islam: Practices (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A. 🎉
Mission 1Pilgrims at Makkah run between two hills, retracing one mother's search for water. Who was she?
Mission 2Pilgrims throw stones at three walls near Makkah. What are they rejecting, and why does it matter?
Mission 3Many people think "jihad" means holy war. Why do most Muslims say its main meaning is a struggle inside?
Mission 4Muslims have two great festivals each year. Why is one of them marked by a sacrifice?
Mission 5On the same day, some Muslims fast with thanks and others mourn in the streets. Why?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.