← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A (1RA0) · Area 1 (Paper 1) 1C Islam - Section 4: Forms of Expression and Ways of Life
Mini-Lesson

Islam: Forms of Expression and Ways of Life

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1No verse mentions a fruit you have never seen. Is a Muslim allowed to eat it?
  2. Mission 2Why are the first words a Muslim baby hears the same as the call to prayer?
  3. Mission 3A mosque can be a domed palace or a converted shop. What does every mosque need?
  4. Mission 4Some Muslims spend whole nights repeating one name of Allah. What are they searching for?
  5. Mission 5Some Muslims turn in circles to music to remember Allah; others say music has no place in faith. Why?
  6. Mission 6Can a smile count as charity? What makes Muslim giving more than a donation?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Islam: Practices (part 1).

Mission 1

Mission 1: No verse mentions a fruit you have never seen. Is a Muslim allowed to eat it?

Make a guess: No verse mentions a fruit you have never seen. Is a Muslim allowed to eat it?

Mission 1

Halal and haram

Five categories of actionFard or wajib(obligatory)e.g. the five daily prayersMustahabb(recommended)e.g. extra prayers, giving sadaqahMubah(neutral, simply allowed)e.g. choosing which fruit to eatMakruh(disliked)better avoided, but not sinfulHaram(forbidden)sinful, e.g. drinking alcoholhalal (permitted)Where the rules come fromQur'anSunnah(hadith)scholars: ijmaand qiyas
  • Halal: permitted, lawful.
  • Haram: forbidden, unlawful.
  • These are rulings of shari'ah, the "straight path" of Islamic law.
  • They cover far more than food: drink, clothing, money, speech, relationships, work.
  • Starting point: most scholars hold that everyday things are halal unless forbidden. The list of haram things is short; the halal world is wide.
  • Significance: keeping halal is worship. Muslims believe the rules come from Allah, who knows what is good and harmful for people.
  • It also marks Muslim identity: a halal meal, a hijab or refusing a drink shows faith in public.
Mission 1

Where the rules come from, and five categories

Five categories of actionFard or wajib(obligatory)e.g. the five daily prayersMustahabb(recommended)e.g. extra prayers, giving sadaqahMubah(neutral, simply allowed)e.g. choosing which fruit to eatMakruh(disliked)better avoided, but not sinfulHaram(forbidden)sinful, e.g. drinking alcoholhalal (permitted)Where the rules come fromQur'anSunnah(hadith)scholars: ijmaand qiyas
  • Origins: the Qur'an; the Sunnah of the Prophet (hadith); and scholars, using agreement (ijma) and reasoning by analogy (qiyas).
  • Example of qiyas: the Qur'an forbids wine because it intoxicates, so scholars also forbid drugs that intoxicate.
  • The Prophet taught that the halal is clear and the haram is clear, with doubtful matters between them that the careful person avoids (Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, paraphrase).
  • Scholars sort actions into five categories:
  • Fard or wajib (obligatory): e.g. the five daily prayers.
  • Mustahabb (recommended): e.g. extra prayers, giving sadaqah.
  • Mubah (neutral, simply allowed): e.g. choosing which fruit to eat.
  • Makruh (disliked): better avoided, but not sinful.
  • Haram (forbidden): sinful, e.g. drinking alcohol.
  • The first four all fall within the halal (permitted) in its wide sense.
Quick check
?Many Muslims say that "almost everything is halal". Which statement best explains why?
Mission 1Read the source

Forbidden foods

> "He hath forbidden you only carrion, and blood, and swineflesh, and that which hath been immolated to (the name of) any other than Allah. But he who is driven by necessity, neither craving nor transgressing, it is no sin for him." (Qur'an 2:173, Pickthall)

  • Surah 5:3 repeats this list and adds animals killed by strangling, beating, falling or goring, unless properly slaughtered (Qur'an 5:3, paraphrase).
  • "Immolated" means sacrificed or slaughtered.

Q1 Name the four forbidden foods.

Show answer

Animals that died by themselves, blood, pork, and meat offered to anything other than Allah.

Q2 When may a Muslim eat a forbidden food?

Show answer

Only under real necessity, such as starvation, and no more than needed.

Mission 1

Halal food in practice

Halal food checklistForbidden (2:173)carrionbloodporkoffered toother thanAllahNecessity: "it is no sin for him" who is drivenby necessity (2:173).bismillah,Allahu akbarhalalcertificateFish and seafoodmost Sunni scholarsallow allHanafi schoolonly fishShi'a scholarsonly fish with scales,and prawns
  • Dhabihah (halal slaughter): a sane adult Muslim (many Sunni scholars also accept Jews and Christians) uses a very sharp knife, says Allah's name (bismillah, Allahu akbar), and cuts the throat in one swift stroke. Blood is drained.
  • Reason: respect for the life Allah gave, and as little suffering as possible.
  • Stunning: some Muslims accept meat from animals stunned first if the animal is still alive when cut; others accept only unstunned meat.
  • Fish and seafood: most Sunni scholars allow all; the Hanafi school allows only fish; Shi'a scholars allow only fish with scales, and prawns.
  • Hidden ingredients: gelatine, animal fats, alcohol in flavourings. Many Muslims look for a halal certificate.
  • Some Muslims treat doubtful products as makruh and avoid them; others eat them if no haram ingredient is known.
Mission 1

Alcohol and intoxicants

Stages of the alcohol banStage 1 · 2:219drink has some benefit, but more harmStage 2 · 4:43do not pray while drunkStage 3 · 5:90–91"Leave it aside in order that ye may succeed."qiyas: all intoxicants, including drugs

> "Strong drink and games of chance and idols and divining arrows are only an infamy of Satan's handiwork. Leave it aside in order that ye may succeed." (Qur'an 5:90, Pickthall)

  • The next verse gives the reason: Satan uses drink and gambling to bring enmity and to turn people from remembering Allah and from prayer (Qur'an 5:91, paraphrase).
  • The ban came in stages: drink has some benefit but more harm (2:219); do not pray while drunk (4:43); then leave it entirely (5:90).
  • The Prophet taught that every intoxicant is forbidden (Sahih Muslim, paraphrase). By qiyas this covers drugs.
  • Many Muslims also avoid selling or serving alcohol, following a hadith that blames all who make, carry, serve or sell it.
Quick check
?Why do many Muslims refuse to take drugs that cause a "high", although the Qur'an never names them?
Mission 1Read the source

Modesty for men and women

> "Tell the believing men to lower their gaze and be modest. That is purer for them. Lo! Allah is aware of what they do." (Qur'an 24:30, Pickthall)

> "And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and be modest, and to display of their adornment only that which is apparent, and to draw their veils over their bosoms" (Qur'an 24:31, Pickthall)

  • 24:31 then lists close family before whom women need not cover their adornment.

Q1 Which command is given to both men and women?

Show answer

Lower the gaze and be modest.

Q2 Which words do scholars interpret differently?

Show answer

"that which is apparent": face and hands only, or more?

Mission 1

Modesty and dress

Modesty and dressMen: navel toknee at least;loosehijab:headscarfjilbab, abaya:long outergarmentniqab: faceveilchador: fullcoveringburqa: fullcoveringViews on women's dressMajority viewthe hijab is obligatory (24:31, 33:59)Niqaba minority of scholars: obligatory; many:recommended or a personal choice; some: notrequired at allA minority of modern Muslimsthe Qur'an commands modesty, not onegarment
  • Haya (modesty): a quality of character, shown in behaviour, speech and dress.
  • Men: cover at least from navel to knee; loose clothing. The Prophet forbade gold and silk for men, permitting them to women (Sunan Abu Dawud, paraphrase).
  • Women: most scholars teach covering the whole body except face and hands in front of men outside close family.
  • Hijab means "covering": in everyday use, a headscarf. Niqab: a face veil. Jilbab, abaya: long outer garments. Chador, burqa: full coverings in some countries.
  • Both: clothes should not be tight or see-through, worn for pride, or imitate the other sex.
Mission 1Diversity

Divergent interpretations of dress

Modesty and dressMen: navel toknee at least;loosehijab:headscarfjilbab, abaya:long outergarmentniqab: faceveilchador: fullcoveringburqa: fullcoveringViews on women's dressMajority viewthe hijab is obligatory (24:31, 33:59)Niqaba minority of scholars: obligatory; many:recommended or a personal choice; some: notrequired at allA minority of modern Muslimsthe Qur'an commands modesty, not onegarment
  • Majority view: 24:31 and 33:59 require women to cover their hair; the hijab is obligatory.
  • Niqab: a minority of scholars hold it obligatory; many see it as recommended or a personal choice; some say it is not required at all.
  • A minority of modern Muslims: the Qur'an commands modesty, not one garment; covering the hair reflects culture and history.
  • Reasons women give for wearing hijab: obedience to Allah, Muslim identity, being valued for character not looks, dignity.
  • Reasons some do not: they see modesty as being in the heart and behaviour; local laws or safety; personal conviction.
  • Laws differ: Iran requires women to cover their hair; France bans religious symbols such as the headscarf in state schools. In Britain, schools set uniform rules.
  • Many Muslims stress that modesty must be sincere, coming from the heart, not only from rules or pressure.
Quick check
?Two Muslim women discuss Surah 24:31. Amina wears a hijab because she understands "that which is apparent" as the face and hands. Sara wears long sleeves and loose clothes but no headscarf, saying the verse commands modesty, not one garment. Which statement is accurate?
Mission 1

Money: riba and gambling

Interest and Islamic home financeConventional loanriba: forbiddenbankborrowermoneymoney + interestIslamic home financeone common modelown ittogetherbuyer paysrent on thebank's shareand buys moreof itthe buyer'sshare growsbuyer's sharebank's share
  • Riba (usury, interest): "Allah permitteth trading and forbiddeth usury." (Qur'an 2:275, Pickthall)
  • Why: the lender gains without work or risk; debts can trap the poor; wealth is a trust from Allah.
  • Islamic finance: banks share profit and loss with customers, or buy and resell at an agreed mark-up; Islamic home finance uses leasing or joint ownership instead of an interest mortgage.
  • Some scholars allow a conventional mortgage for Muslims in non-Muslim countries when there is real need; many disagree.
Mission 1Evaluate

"Halal and haram laws are the most important part of Muslim identity."

Argument map"Halal and haram laws are the mostimportant part of Muslim identity."ForThey shape every day: food, drink, dress,money.They are visible signs of faith in anon-Muslim society.They come from the Qur'an and Sunnah.AgainstTawhid and the Shahadah are thefoundation: without belief, rules areempty.Identity is also shown through the ummah,prayer and good character (akhlaq).Muslims differ in how strictly they applysome rules, yet share one faith.Another viewThe laws are part of worship: obeyingthem is expressing Tawhid.Judge it bysource of the teaching · outward signs orinner faith · daily impact · diversity of practice
  • For: they shape every day: food, drink, dress, money. They are visible signs of faith in a non-Muslim society. They come from the Qur'an and Sunnah.
  • Against: Tawhid and the Shahadah are the foundation; without belief, rules are empty. Identity is also shown through the ummah (the worldwide Muslim community), prayer and akhlaq (good character). Muslims differ in how strictly they apply some rules (stunning, hijab, mortgages), yet share one faith.
  • Another view: the laws are part of worship and cannot be separated from belief: obeying them is expressing Tawhid.
  • Judge it by: source of the teaching; outward signs or inner faith; daily impact; diversity of practice.
  • 12-mark tip: develop reasons on both sides with Muslim sources, then a justified conclusion.
Mission check

?At a friend's house, a Muslim student is offered a new brand of sparkling drink. The label lists water, fruit juice, sugar and spices: no alcohol and no animal products. No verse or hadith names it. What would most Muslim scholars say about drinking it?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why are the first words a Muslim baby hears the same as the call to prayer?

Make a guess: Why are the first words a Muslim baby hears the same as the call to prayer?

Mission 2

First words: adhan and iqamah

Welcoming a babyAt birthbirthadhan and iqamahadhan into the right ear; manyalso say the iqamah into the lefteartahnika tiny piece of softened date (orhoney) on the gumsOften on the 7th dayday 7tasmiyaha name with a good meaninghead-shavingthe hair's weight in silver (or itsvalue) to the pooraqiqahSunni: often 2 for a boy, 1 for agirl · Shi'a: 1 for eitherkhitan (boys)in the first week, or later inchildhood
  • Soon after birth, the father or an elder whispers the adhan (call to prayer) into the baby's right ear.
  • Many also say the iqamah (the call that begins prayer) into the left ear.
  • So the first words the child hears are "Allahu akbar" and the Shahadah: there is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is His messenger.
  • Meaning: the child is born into the ummah; life begins with Tawhid and the call to worship.
  • Tahnik: a tiny piece of softened date (or honey) is rubbed on the baby's gums, following the Prophet's practice (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase). It expresses hope for a sweet, good life.
  • Muslims believe every child is born in a natural state of submission to Allah (fitrah).
Mission 2

The seventh day: name, hair and aqiqah

Welcoming a babyAt birthbirthadhan and iqamahadhan into the right ear; manyalso say the iqamah into the lefteartahnika tiny piece of softened date (orhoney) on the gumsOften on the 7th dayday 7tasmiyaha name with a good meaninghead-shavingthe hair's weight in silver (or itsvalue) to the pooraqiqahSunni: often 2 for a boy, 1 for agirl · Shi'a: 1 for eitherkhitan (boys)in the first week, or later inchildhood
  • Tasmiyah (naming): often on the 7th day. A name with a good meaning: a prophet's name, or 'Abd ("servant") with one of Allah's names, e.g. Abdullah, Abdur-Rahman.
  • Head-shaving: the baby's hair is shaved; its weight in silver (or its value) is given to the poor, following the example of Fatimah for her son Hasan.
  • Aqiqah: an animal is sacrificed in thanks for the child. In Sunni practice, often two sheep or goats for a boy and one for a girl; in Shi'a practice one for either. The meat is shared with family, friends and the poor.
  • Khitan (circumcision) of boys: a sunnah from Ibrahim. Some do it in the first week; others later in childhood.
  • Importance: thanks to Allah, a good start in the faith, and the community sharing the family's joy.
Mission 2Diversity

One ummah, different welcomes

One ummah, different welcomesShared by alladhana good namethanks to Allahgifts to the poorthese mark the child as part of the ummahWho whispers the adhanfather, grandfather, or a respected imam orscholarAqiqahtwo for a boy, one for a girl (most Sunnischolars); one for either (Shi'a scholars, Malikischool); some later, or through a charityabroadStatus of aqiqahmost scholars: a strong sunnah; some Shi'ascholars stress it moreCulturesome families: a large party; others keep itsimpleBritaincircumcision by trained practitioners ordoctors; aqiqah meat from licensed butchers
  • Shared by all: adhan, a good name, thanks to Allah, gifts to the poor. These mark the child as part of the ummah.
  • Who whispers the adhan: father, grandfather, or a respected imam or scholar.
  • Aqiqah: two animals for a boy and one for a girl (most Sunni scholars); one for either (Shi'a scholars, and the Maliki school). Some hold it later, or pay a charity to sacrifice abroad and give the meat to the poor.
  • Status: most scholars call aqiqah a strong sunnah; some Shi'a scholars stress it more strongly.
  • Culture: in some families a large party follows; others keep it simple, worried that spending can hide the religious purpose.
  • Britain: circumcision is done by trained practitioners or doctors; aqiqah meat comes from licensed butchers.
Quick check
?At an aqiqah, a family shares meat with neighbours and gives some to the poor. What does this mainly express?
Mission 2

Marriage: the nikah

The nikah contractmehndisome familiesnikahcontractwalimahfeastaqd nikah: the contractBride and groomboth must freely consent; offer andacceptance (ijab and qabul)Waliguardian, usually the bride's father (mostSunni schools; Hanafi: an adult womanmay contract her own marriage)WitnessesSunni law: two adult Muslim witnessesrequired; Shi'a law: recommendedMahrgift from the groom to the bride; itbelongs to her alone (4:4)Signaturesthe contract is signed; khutbah and du'afollow
  • Nikah: marriage, a contract (aqd nikah) and a sacred bond. Marriage is strongly encouraged as the Prophet's sunnah.
  • Consent: both bride and groom must freely agree; a forced marriage is not valid.
  • Offer and acceptance (ijab and qabul) are spoken before witnesses: in Sunni law two adult Muslim witnesses are required; Shi'a law recommends witnesses but does not require them.
  • Wali: a guardian, usually the bride's father, represents her in most Sunni schools; the Hanafi school allows an adult woman to contract her own marriage.
  • Mahr: a gift from the groom to the bride, agreed in the contract. It belongs to her alone.
  • The contract is signed; a short sermon (khutbah) and du'a follow, often in a mosque or at home.
Mission 2Read the source

"Love and mercy"

> "And of His signs is this: He created for you helpmeets from yourselves that ye might find rest in them, and He ordained between you love and mercy." (Qur'an 30:21, Pickthall)

Husbands are told to give the women they marry a "free gift of their marriage portions" (Qur'an 4:4, Pickthall).

Q1 According to 30:21, what has Allah placed between husband and wife?

Show answer

Love and mercy.

Q2 What does "free gift of their marriage portions" refer to, and whose is it?

Show answer

The mahr: it belongs to the bride.

Mission 2

Customs and the walimah

The nikah contractmehndisome familiesnikahcontractwalimahfeastaqd nikah: the contractBride and groomboth must freely consent; offer andacceptance (ijab and qabul)Waliguardian, usually the bride's father (mostSunni schools; Hanafi: an adult womanmay contract her own marriage)WitnessesSunni law: two adult Muslim witnessesrequired; Shi'a law: recommendedMahrgift from the groom to the bride; itbelongs to her alone (4:4)Signaturesthe contract is signed; khutbah and du'afollow
  • Before: families meet; in South Asian families, a mehndi (henna) evening for the bride.
  • During: the nikah itself is short and simple: contract, mahr, witnesses, khutbah, du'a for the couple.
  • After: the walimah, a wedding feast given by the groom's family. The Prophet told a newly married companion to give a walimah "even with one sheep" (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
  • Much of the rest (dress colours, music, gold) is culture, varying between countries.
Quick check
?At a nikah in Leicester, the bride's father asks her in front of witnesses if she accepts the marriage, and she says yes. Why is her answer essential?
Mission 2

Death and the funeral

Death and the funeralShahadahAt deaththe Shahadah heard or said; eyesclosed; "we are Allah's and untoHim we are returning" (2:156)Ghuslthe body washed, by people ofthe same sex, usually familyKafanwrapped in simple white cloths:rich and poor alikeSalat al-janazahfuneral prayer said standing,with no bowing or prostrationBurial, facing Makkahas soon as possible, nevercremation; the body on its rightside, facing MakkahHow long do Muslims mourn?relatives: 3 dayswidows: four months and ten days (2:234)Shi'a majalis for the dead:3rd day7th day40th dayyearlysome Sunni cultures also mark the 40th day;other Sunni scholars reject this as bid'ah
  • Beliefs: life is a test; death comes at the time Allah decrees (sovereignty of Allah); then judgement and akhirah (life after death).

> "Every soul will taste of death. And ye will be paid on the Day of Resurrection only that which ye have fairly earned." (Qur'an 3:185, Pickthall)

  • At death: the dying person hears or says the Shahadah; eyes are closed; mourners say "we are Allah's and unto Him we are returning" (2:156).
  • Ghusl: the body is washed, by people of the same sex, usually family.
  • Kafan: wrapped in simple white cloths: rich and poor alike.
  • Salat al-janazah: funeral prayer said standing, with no bowing or prostration.
  • Burial: as soon as possible, usually within a day; never cremation. The body lies on its right side, facing Makkah.
  • Graves are simple. Mourners pray for the dead.
Mission 2Diversity

How long do Muslims mourn?

Death and the funeralShahadahAt deaththe Shahadah heard or said; eyesclosed; "we are Allah's and untoHim we are returning" (2:156)Ghuslthe body washed, by people ofthe same sex, usually familyKafanwrapped in simple white cloths:rich and poor alikeSalat al-janazahfuneral prayer said standing,with no bowing or prostrationBurial, facing Makkahas soon as possible, nevercremation; the body on its rightside, facing MakkahHow long do Muslims mourn?relatives: 3 dayswidows: four months and ten days (2:234)Shi'a majalis for the dead:3rd day7th day40th dayyearlysome Sunni cultures also mark the 40th day;other Sunni scholars reject this as bid'ah
  • Weeping is allowed: the Prophet wept when his infant son Ibrahim died (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase). Loud wailing and tearing clothes are discouraged.
  • Three days of mourning for relatives (hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari); visitors bring food so the family need not cook.
  • Widows: a waiting period of "four months and ten days" (Qur'an 2:234, Pickthall), with no remarriage and simple dress.
  • Shi'a Muslims often hold majalis for the dead on the 3rd, 7th and 40th days, and yearly.
  • Some Sunni cultures, e.g. in South Asia, also mark the 40th day; other Sunni scholars reject this as bid'ah (an added practice).
  • Why the differences: different hadith collections and schools, and local culture.
Quick check
?Why do Muslims bury the dead quickly, wrapped in simple white cloth, rather than in expensive clothes?
Mission check

?A Muslim family in Cardiff welcomes a baby girl. Her grandfather whispers the adhan, a softened date is rubbed on her gums, and on the 7th day she is named Maryam and her hair is shaved. What links all these actions?
Mission 3

Mission 3: A mosque can be a domed palace or a converted shop. What does every mosque need?

Make a guess: A mosque can be a domed palace or a converted shop. What does every mosque need?

Mission 3

Masjid: a place of prostration

What a mosque hasThe Prophet's Mosque, Madinah, 622 CEroof of palm leaves on palm trunksopen courtyardwalls of mud brickOutside: dome and minaretdomevault of heavenminaretcall to prayerNeither is required. Mosques takethe shape of their culture:Xi'an, Chinapagoda roofDjenné, Malimud brickBritainterraced houseInside: everything faces Makkahto Makkahmusalla: rows face the qiblahqiblah wallmihrabnicheminbar3 stepswomen's balcony (upstairs)entranceshoe racksshoes left herewudu areataps and seats
  • Mosque comes from Arabic masjid: "place of prostration" (sujud, bowing the forehead to the ground in salah).
  • Muslims may pray anywhere clean: the Prophet said the whole earth has been made a place of prayer for him (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase).
  • So a mosque is not needed for every prayer. It is where the community prays together.
  • The first mosques: Quba' near Madinah, built when the Prophet arrived in 622 CE; then the Prophet's Mosque in Madinah: a simple courtyard, walls of mud brick, a roof of palm leaves on palm trunks.
  • A large mosque used for Friday prayer is a jami' masjid ("gathering mosque").
Mission 3

Outside: minaret and dome

What a mosque hasThe Prophet's Mosque, Madinah, 622 CEroof of palm leaves on palm trunksopen courtyardwalls of mud brickOutside: dome and minaretdomevault of heavenminaretcall to prayerNeither is required. Mosques takethe shape of their culture:Xi'an, Chinapagoda roofDjenné, Malimud brickBritainterraced houseInside: everything faces Makkahto Makkahmusalla: rows face the qiblahqiblah wallmihrabnicheminbar3 stepswomen's balcony (upstairs)entranceshoe racksshoes left herewudu areataps and seats
  • Minaret: the tower from which the adhan (call to prayer) was traditionally called.
  • Dome: a symbol of the vault of heaven, of Allah's creation over all; it also carries the voice of the imam round the hall.
  • Neither is required. Mosques take the shape of their culture:
  • e.g. pagoda-style roofs at the Great Mosque of Xi'an (China); mud-brick walls at Djenné (Mali); terraced houses and former churches, chapels and shops in Britain.
  • What every mosque needs: a clean prayer space, a way to show the direction of Makkah, and somewhere for wudu (washing).
Mission 3

Inside: everything faces Makkah

What a mosque hasThe Prophet's Mosque, Madinah, 622 CEroof of palm leaves on palm trunksopen courtyardwalls of mud brickOutside: dome and minaretdomevault of heavenminaretcall to prayerNeither is required. Mosques takethe shape of their culture:Xi'an, Chinapagoda roofDjenné, Malimud brickBritainterraced houseInside: everything faces Makkahto Makkahmusalla: rows face the qiblahqiblah wallmihrabnicheminbar3 stepswomen's balcony (upstairs)entranceshoe racksshoes left herewudu areataps and seats
  • Qiblah: the direction of the Ka'bah in Makkah. The wall facing it is the qiblah wall.
  • Mihrab: a niche in the qiblah wall. It shows the direction and marks where the imam leads prayer.
  • Minbar: stepped platform beside the mihrab, from which the imam gives the khutbah (sermon) at Friday prayer. The Prophet preached from a minbar of three steps.
  • Musalla (prayer hall): an open carpeted space, no seats or images; lines on the carpet keep worshippers in straight rows shoulder to shoulder.
  • Wudu area (ablution area): taps, seats and drains for washing hands, mouth, nose, face, arms, head and feet before salah.
  • Shoes are left at the entrance: the prayer space is kept clean.
Quick check
?Which feature of a mosque is matched with its correct purpose?
Mission 3

Men's and women's spaces

  • Most mosques have separate areas for men and women: a balcony, a side room, or a screen.
  • Reasons given: modesty; concentration during bowing and prostration in close rows; it follows the order of rows in the Prophet's mosque, where men prayed in front and women behind.
  • Men are expected to attend Jumu'ah (Friday prayer); women may attend but are not required to.
  • Different practice: in some mosques women pray behind the men in the same hall; at the Ka'bah men and women pray in the same space.
  • Some British Muslims, women and men, criticise mosques with small or no women's areas and campaign for better facilities.
Mission 3Read the source

Ibrahim and the idols

Ibrahim (Abraham) asks his father and his people: "What are these images unto which ye pay devotion?" (Qur'an 21:52, Pickthall)

"Then he reduced them to fragments, all save the chief of them, that haply they might have recourse to it." (Qur'an 21:58, Pickthall)

  • The people say they found their fathers worshipping the idols (21:53); Ibrahim replies that their Lord is the Creator of the heavens and the earth (21:56).
  • When questioned, he points them to the largest idol, which cannot speak (21:59–63, paraphrase).

Q1 What does Ibrahim reject in this passage?

Show answer

Worshipping images made by humans instead of the Creator.

Q2 How might this story explain the absence of pictures in a mosque?

Show answer

Images could become objects of worship, which is shirk; so the prayer space has none.

Mission 3

Calligraphy, pattern, no images

Calligraphy and patternthe name Allahthe name MuhammadStyles include angular Kufic and flowing Naskhand Thulutheight-point stars repeat without endexpresses Tawhid; no images of living beings
  • Mosques contain no pictures of people or animals: nothing that could be worshipped or distract from Allah. Hadith also warn against making images of living beings (paraphrase).
  • Shirk (associating anything with Allah) is the gravest sin; Ibrahim's breaking of the idols (21:58) is its model rejection.
  • Instead: calligraphy (beautiful writing) of Qur'an verses, the name Allah, the name Muhammad, and in Shi'a mosques often Ali, Hasan and Husayn.
  • Styles include angular Kufic and flowing Naskh and Thuluth.
  • Geometric patterns and arabesques (plant-like scrolls) repeat without end: many Muslims see them as pointing to Allah's infinity and the order of creation.
  • Purpose: to express belief (Tawhid), honour Allah's words, aid remembrance, and beautify worship without images.
Mission 3Diversity

Different views on decoration and calligraphy

  • Calligraphy as worship: for many Muslims, writing Allah's words beautifully is an act of devotion; calligraphers often pray and make wudu first.
  • Plain is better: some Muslims, often Salafi, prefer simple mosques: the Prophet's own mosque was plain, and he warned against competing in grand mosque-building (hadith, paraphrase).
  • Other settings: calligraphy hangs in homes, on Qur'an covers, tiles and modern art. Some scholars warn against using verses where they may be damaged or treated carelessly (floors, clothing, rubbish).
  • Images outside the mosque: Muslims differ on photographs and drawings in daily life; in some Shi'a homes, devotional pictures of Imam Ali or Imam Husayn are kept, though never in the prayer space or as objects of worship. Most Sunni and Shi'a Muslims agree that the Prophet must never be depicted.
Mission 3

Objects used in worship

Objects used in worshipQur'an on a rehalstand: raised upprayer matarch points to MakkahMakkahqiblah compass(or an app)turbah: clay tabletused by most Shi'aMuslimsmisbahah (tasbih)33 beads (or 99)to count dhikrafter salah
  • Copies of the Qur'an: kept on high shelves and read on a stand (rehal or kursi); many make wudu before touching the Arabic text.
  • Prayer mat: a clean space for each person's salah; the arch woven into many mats is pointed towards Makkah.
  • Compass (qiblah compass, now often an app): finds the direction of Makkah when praying away from a mosque.
  • Turbah: a small tablet of clay, often from Karbala, used by most Shi'a Muslims: they hold that the forehead should touch earth or something natural that is not eaten or worn.
  • Misbahah (prayer beads; also tasbih): 33 or 99 beads to count dhikr, e.g. SubhanAllah, Alhamdulillah, Allahu Akbar after salah.
  • Furniture is otherwise minimal: shelves, clocks showing prayer times, a board of the day's prayer times, and chairs for those unable to stand.
Quick check
?In a mosque, a worshipper places a small clay tablet on the carpet in front of her before she starts salah. Which statement best explains this?
Mission 3

What happens in a mosque

A week at a mosque (example)A week at a mosqueexampleMonTueWedThuFriSatSunsalah ×5madrasahJumu'ah +khutbahfood bankafter schoolAlso:Ramadanshared iftarnikahmarriagejanazahfuneral prayer
  • Salah five times a day; Jumu'ah (Friday midday prayer) with the khutbah from the minbar; Eid prayers.
  • Madrasah: classes, often after school, where children learn to read the Qur'an in Arabic and learn about Islam.
  • Life events: marriages (nikah), funeral prayers (janazah).
  • Ramadan: shared iftar (meal to break the fast) and night prayers.
  • Community: food banks, advice, youth groups, libraries, and open days for visitors of other faiths and none.
Mission 3Diversity

How important is the mosque?

  • The Prophet taught that religion is easy, warned against overburdening yourself, and urged steady worship in the morning, the afternoon and the last part of the night (Sahih al-Bukhari 2:39, paraphrase). The mosque supports this daily rhythm of prayer.
  • Very important: a well-known hadith says prayer in congregation is worth twenty-seven times prayer alone (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase). Jumu'ah must be prayed together.
  • Many say home matters as much: salah is valid anywhere clean; for women, many Sunni scholars teach that prayer at home is as rewarded as in the mosque.
  • Different communities, different uses: in Britain many mosques serve one ethnic or language group; others are deliberately mixed. Some Shi'a communities also use an imambargah or husayniyya for gatherings (e.g. Muharram).
  • For many young British Muslims, the mosque's role as community and youth centre matters as much as prayer.
Mission 3Evaluate

"A mosque is essential for a Muslim's worship."

Argument map: is a mosque essential?"A mosque is essential for a Muslim'sworship."ForJumu'ah must be prayed in congregationCongregational prayer brings greaterreward (hadith)The mosque teaches the Qur'an, unites theummah and supports family lifeAgainst"The earth has been made a mosque":salah is valid anywhere cleanMany Muslims pray most prayers at home,work or schoolWomen are not required to attend Jumu'ahAnother viewThe mosque is essential for thecommunity; each person's worshipdepends on intention and remembrancewherever they areJudge it byWhich kinds of worship need a group? · Does"essential" mean required by the Shari'ah orvery important in practice? · Does the answerdiffer for men and women, or for Muslims farfrom any mosque?
  • Reasons for: Jumu'ah must be prayed in congregation; congregational prayer brings greater reward (hadith); the mosque teaches the Qur'an, unites the ummah and supports family life.
  • Reasons against: "the earth has been made a mosque": salah is valid anywhere clean; many Muslims pray most prayers at home, work or school; women are not required to attend Jumu'ah.
  • Another view: the mosque is essential for the community, while each person's worship depends on intention and remembrance wherever they are.
  • Judge it by: Which kinds of worship need a group? Does "essential" mean required by the Shari'ah or very important in practice? Does the answer differ for men and women, or for Muslims far from any mosque?
Mission check

?A small Muslim community in a seaside town buys an old shop to use as a mosque. They have little money. Which change is needed first so that they can pray salah together there?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Some Muslims spend whole nights repeating one name of Allah. What are they searching for?

Make a guess: Some Muslims spend whole nights repeating one name of Allah. What are they searching for?

Mission 4

Sufism: the inner path

Shari'ah, tariqah, haqiqaha common Sufi imageShari'ah(the road)tariqah(the path)haqiqah(the truth:nearness toAllah)goal: ihsan
  • Sufism (Arabic tasawwuf) is the inner, mystical dimension of Islam: seeking to know and love Allah directly, with a purified heart.
  • It is not a separate branch like Sunni or Shi'a: most Sufis are Sunni; some are Shi'a.
  • Sufis keep the Shari'ah (the Five Pillars and Islamic law) and add inner disciplines.
  • Their goal is ihsan, described by the Prophet in the Hadith of Jibril: to worship Allah as if you see Him, and if you do not see Him, to know that He sees you (paraphrase).
  • Sufis often describe it as Shari'ah (the road) and tariqah (the path) leading to haqiqah (the truth: nearness to Allah).
Mission 4

Origins

Origins of SufismThe Prophetnights of prayer, retreats inthe cave of Hira, a simple life8th c.Hasan al-Basri (d. 728)in Iraq, turning from luxury toprayer and self-denial8th–9th c.Rabi'a (d. 801); Junayd ofBaghdad (d. 910)from fear to love of Allah,and inner knowledge11th c.al-Ghazali (1058–1111)Sufism fits withinmainstream Sunni teaching12th c. onorders (tariqahs)Qadiri, Naqshbandi, Chishti,Mevlevi1165–1240Ibn al-'Arabi13th c.RumiMevlevi: his followers
  • Sufis trace their path to the Prophet: his nights of prayer, his retreats in the cave of Hira, his simple life.
  • 8th century: as the Muslim empire grew rich, devout people in Iraq turned away from luxury to prayer and self-denial, e.g. Hasan al-Basri (d. 728).
  • Name: probably from suf (wool): the rough woollen cloaks worn by early ascetics.
  • 8th–9th centuries: the stress moved from fear to love of Allah (Rabi'a) and inner knowledge (Junayd of Baghdad, d. 910).
  • 11th century: al-Ghazali showed that Sufism fits within mainstream Sunni teaching.
Mission 4

Orders and saints

Where the Sufi orders are strongAjmerNNNMCNNaqshbandiTurkey, Central Asia, Britain(silent dhikr)MMevleviTurkey, followers of RumiCChishtiSouth Asia, known for musicQQadiriworldwide
  • From the 12th century Sufis formed orders (tariqahs), each led by a sheikh with a chain of teachers (silsilah) going back to the Prophet.
  • Qadiri (from Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani, d. 1166): worldwide. Naqshbandi: silent dhikr; strong in Turkey, Central Asia and Britain. Chishti: South Asia, known for music (see Mission 5). Mevlevi: Turkey, followers of Rumi.
  • Saints (awliya, "friends of Allah", Qur'an 10:62): people close to Allah; some are believed to receive blessing (barakah) and wonders.
  • Their tombs (shrines, e.g. Ajmer in India) are visited, especially on the death anniversary (urs).
  • Today: orders meet in mosques, homes and lodges, including in Britain; many teach charity and service.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how Sufism relates to Sunni and Shi'a Islam?
Mission 4Read the source

Hearts at rest

"Those who believe, and whose hearts find satisfaction in the remembrance of Allah: for without doubt in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find satisfaction." (Qur'an 13:28, Yusuf Ali)

  • Remembrance = dhikr. Sufis take this verse as a central reason for their practice.

Q1 According to the verse, where do hearts find rest?

Show answer

In the remembrance of Allah.

Q2 Why might a Sufi repeat a name of Allah many times?

Show answer

To keep the heart in constant remembrance, so that it finds the rest the verse promises.

Mission 4

Dhikr: remembrance

The heart as a mirror (Sufi image)Sufi image: the heart as a mirrorheart (qalb)in forgetfulness (ghaflah)La ilaha illa'llah(there is no god but Allah)heart (qalb)polished by remembrance(dhikr)"in the remembrance of Allah do hearts findsatisfaction" (Qur'an 13:28)
  • Dhikr: repeating short phrases or names of Allah: "La ilaha illa'llah" (there is no god but Allah), "Allah", "SubhanAllah".
  • Silent dhikr in the heart (Naqshbandi) or aloud in a circle (hadra), often with rhythmic breathing and movement.
  • Prayer beads (misbaha or tasbih) help to count.
  • Purpose: to polish the heart (qalb) so it reflects Allah; to replace forgetfulness (ghaflah) with constant awareness.
  • History: "O ye who believe! Remember Allah with much remembrance." (Qur'an 33:41, Pickthall); orders developed set forms from the 12th century.
  • Divergent views: all Muslims value dhikr (e.g. after salah). Some, often Salafi, Muslims reject group chanting and swaying as bid'ah (innovation not practised by the Prophet).
Mission 4

Sufi fasting

  • Sufis keep Ramadan like all Muslims, and add voluntary fasts, e.g. Mondays and Thursdays, as the Prophet did.
  • Purpose: to weaken the selfish nafs (lower self) and free the heart for Allah.
  • Al-Ghazali's three grades of fasting (in the Revival):
  • (1) ordinary: no food, drink or sex in daylight;
  • (2) special: also keeping eyes, tongue, ears, hands and feet from sin;
  • (3) most special: keeping the heart from everything except Allah.
  • Some orders hold a retreat (khalwa, or chilla: 40 days) of fasting, prayer and dhikr.
  • Divergent views: many Muslims see long or extreme fasting as going beyond the Sunnah; Sufi teachers also warn against harming the body.
Mission 4

The sheikh and the disciple

Chain of teachers (silsilah)Prophet MuhammadAlimany chainsAbu BakrNaqshbanditeachers down the generationssheikhmurshid (guide); pir in South Asiabay'ah (pledge)muriddisciple, "one who seeks"silsilah
  • A sheikh (also murshid, guide; pir in South Asia) guides a murid (disciple, "one who seeks").
  • The disciple makes a pledge (bay'ah) and joins the chain of teachers back to the Prophet.
  • Purpose: like a doctor of the soul, the sheikh sees faults the disciple cannot see (pride, anger, greed) and sets the right practices.
  • A well-known Sufi saying: whoever has no sheikh has Satan as his guide.
  • Divergent views: for many Sufis a living teacher is essential. Some Muslims, Sufi or not, learn from books and scholars without a pledge. Critics warn that blind obedience to a sheikh can be abused, and that only Allah and His Messenger must be obeyed without question.
Mission 4

Al-Ghazali (1058–1111)

Three Sufi teachersal-Ghazali1058–1111Baghdad: Nizamiyya collegeRevival of the Religious Sciences"Shari'ah + heart"Ibn al-'Arabi1165–1240Murcia (Spain) to DamascusThe Meccan Revelations"all existence reveals Allah"Rabi'ad. 801Basrathe torch and the bucket"love of Allah for His own sake"
  • Leading Sunni scholar, professor at the Nizamiyya college in Baghdad.
  • 1095: a crisis of faith; he could no longer speak or teach. He left his post, lived as a Sufi for about ten years, and later explained why in Deliverance from Error.
  • Revival of the Religious Sciences (Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din): 40 books on worship, daily life, the vices that destroy and the virtues that save.
  • Teaching: the Shari'ah and the inner life belong together; outward acts without a sincere heart are empty; inner experience without the Shari'ah goes astray.
  • Qur'anic basis: he grounds Sufism in the Qur'an and Sunnah, e.g. dhikr (13:28) and purifying the soul: "He is indeed successful who causeth it to grow" (Qur'an 91:9, Pickthall).
  • Relevance today: called Hujjat al-Islam ("Proof of Islam"); still taught in mosques and universities; his balance of law and spirituality guides many Muslims, Sufi and not.
Mission 4

Ibn al-'Arabi and Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya

Three Sufi teachersal-Ghazali1058–1111Baghdad: Nizamiyya collegeRevival of the Religious Sciences"Shari'ah + heart"Ibn al-'Arabi1165–1240Murcia (Spain) to DamascusThe Meccan Revelations"all existence reveals Allah"Rabi'ad. 801Basrathe torch and the bucket"love of Allah for His own sake"
  • Ibn al-'Arabi (1165–1240), born in Murcia (Spain), died in Damascus; called al-Shaykh al-Akbar ("the Greatest Master").
  • Works: The Meccan Revelations and The Bezels of Wisdom. All existence depends on Allah and reveals Him; the perfect human reflects Allah's names.
  • Later followers called his teaching Unity of Being. Controversy: critics such as Ibn Taymiyya (d. 1328) said it blurred Creator and creation; defenders say he kept the distinction.
  • Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya (d. 801), Basra: a woman who, the stories say, was freed from slavery because of her devotion.
  • She taught love of Allah for His own sake, not from fear of Hell or hope of Paradise.
  • In a famous story she carries a torch and a bucket of water: to burn Paradise and put out Hell, so that people love Allah purely (paraphrase of later accounts).
Quick check
?Which statement best sums up al-Ghazali's contribution to Islam?
Mission 4Evaluate

"Every Muslim needs a sheikh to grow close to Allah."

Argument map: does every Muslim need a sheikh?Every Muslim needs a sheikh to grow closeto Allah.ForThe nafs hides its own faults; a guide seesthemThe Prophet taught his Companions inpersonSufi orders pass on teaching through anunbroken chainAgainstThe Qur'an and Sunnah are open to all;Allah is "nearer to him than (his) jugularvein" (Qur'an 50:16)Many devout Muslims grow in faiththrough salah, study and communitywithout a pledgeUnchecked authority can be abusedAnother viewA teacher helps, but need not be a Sufisheikh: a scholar, an imam or a wise parentcan guideJudge it byWhat does "close to Allah" mean? · Isguidance the same as obedience? · What didthe Prophet and the Companions do?
  • For: the nafs hides its own faults; a guide sees them. The Prophet taught his Companions in person. Sufi orders pass on teaching through an unbroken chain.
  • Against: the Qur'an and Sunnah are open to all; Allah is "nearer to him than (his) jugular vein" (Qur'an 50:16, Yusuf Ali). Many devout Muslims grow in faith through salah, study and community without a pledge. Unchecked authority can be abused.
  • Another view: a teacher helps, but need not be a Sufi sheikh: a scholar, an imam or a wise parent can guide.
  • Judge it by: What does "close to Allah" mean? Is guidance the same as obedience? What did the Prophet and the Companions do?
Mission 4Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Reason, source, developmentReason 1he united Shari'ah and Sufism.Developmentin the Revival of the Religious Sciences hetaught that outward worship needs a sincereheart, so Muslims today pray not onlycorrectly but attentively.Reason 2he grounded the inner life in the Qur'an.Source"in the remembrance of Allah do hearts findsatisfaction" (13:28)Developmentso dhikr is shown to be Qur'anic, and manyMuslims practise it daily.

Question: Explain two reasons why al-Ghazali is important for Muslims today.

  • Reason 1: he united Shari'ah and Sufism. Development: in the Revival of the Religious Sciences he taught that outward worship needs a sincere heart, so Muslims today pray not only correctly but attentively.
  • Reason 2: he grounded the inner life in the Qur'an. Source: "in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find satisfaction" (13:28). Development: so dhikr is shown to be Qur'anic, and many Muslims practise it daily.
  • 5-mark tip (c): two reasons, each developed, plus one source of wisdom and authority.
Mission check

?Amina prays salah at her local Sunni mosque. On Thursday evenings she also joins a dhikr circle led by a Naqshbandi sheikh. A classmate says she "has left Sunni Islam for the Sufi sect". Which reply is most accurate?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Some Muslims turn in circles to music to remember Allah; others say music has no place in faith. Why?

Make a guess: Some Muslims turn in circles to music to remember Allah; others say music has no place in faith. Why?

Mission 5

Why music, dance and poetry?

Why sama'?sama' (listening)express lovefor Allah and theProphetdhikrremembrancewajdspiritual ecstasysoften the heartother settingsconcerts, weddings,Eid
  • Many Sufis use beauty to stir the heart towards Allah: what moves the heart can also turn it to Allah.
  • Sama' ("listening"): a gathering where Sufis listen to sung poetry, sometimes with instruments and movement, as a form of dhikr (remembrance).
  • Purpose: to express love for Allah and the Prophet; to reach a state of wajd (spiritual ecstasy, being "found" by Allah); to soften the heart.
  • The Qur'an describes hearts softening "to the celebration of Allah's praises" (Qur'an 39:23, Yusuf Ali, of the Qur'an itself); Sufis apply the idea to sacred song.
  • Note: recitation of the Qur'an (tajwid) is melodic, but Muslims do not call it music.
Mission 5

Sama' and the whirling ceremony

Symbols of the Mevlevi semaMevlevi sematall felt hat= tombstone of the egowhite robe= shroudblack cloak, dropped atthe start= leaving the grave ofworldly liferight palm up:from Allahleft palm down:to the earthseen from above: turning anticlockwisesheikhqawwali (Chishti) and nasheedsharmoniumtabladaff
  • The Mevlevi order (Turkey) grew from followers of the poet Jalal al-Din Rumi (1207–1273); his son Sultan Walad organised the order, and its ceremony, the sema, later took a set form.
  • Music: the ney (reed flute) and drums; sung poetry.
  • Symbols: tall felt hat = tombstone of the ego; white robe = shroud; the black cloak dropped at the start = leaving the grave of worldly life.
  • Arms: right palm up to receive from Allah; left palm down to pass blessing to the earth.
  • Turning round the heart, like the planets and all creation praising Allah; the sheikh at the centre.
  • Other settings: banned with all orders in Turkey in 1925, it continued and is now also performed for audiences; UNESCO lists it as intangible cultural heritage.
Mission 5

Qawwali, chanting and nasheeds

Symbols of the Mevlevi semaMevlevi sematall felt hat= tombstone of the egowhite robe= shroudblack cloak, dropped atthe start= leaving the grave ofworldly liferight palm up:from Allahleft palm down:to the earthseen from above: turning anticlockwisesheikhqawwali (Chishti) and nasheedsharmoniumtabladaff
  • Qawwali (South Asia, Chishti order): devotional songs in Urdu, Punjabi and Persian with harmonium, tabla and clapping; traditionally traced to the poet Amir Khusrau (d. 1325).
  • Sung at Sufi shrines (e.g. on Thursday nights and at an urs) to stir love for Allah and the Prophet.
  • Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan (1948–1997) brought qawwali to audiences worldwide.
  • Hadra (North Africa, Middle East): rhythmic group dhikr with chanting, swaying and sometimes drums.
  • Nasheeds: Islamic songs, often voice-only or with a frame drum (daff); sung by Sufis and non-Sufis, at weddings, Eid and concerts, including in Britain.
Quick check
?In the Mevlevi ceremony, why does the turning dancer hold the right palm up and the left palm down?
Mission 5

Poetry as devotion

  • Poetry has been central to Muslim devotion in Arabic, Persian, Turkish and Urdu.
  • Rumi's Masnavi opens with the reed flute, cut from its reed bed, crying out in longing: the soul longing to return to Allah (paraphrase).
  • Rabi'a (see Mission 4) expressed her love for Allah in short prayer-poems.
  • The Burdah of al-Busiri (13th century) praises the Prophet; it is sung across the Muslim world, especially at the Prophet's birthday (mawlid).
  • Divergent views: the Qur'an says Allah did not teach the Prophet poetry, "nor is it meet for him" (Qur'an 36:69, Pickthall), and warns about poets whom "the erring follow" (26:224), but excepts poets "who believe and do good works, and remember Allah much" (26:227, Pickthall). So most Muslims accept poetry that remembers Allah, and reject poetry that leads people astray.
Mission 5Read the source

Sahih al-Bukhari 15:70

  • On an Eid day, two girls were singing songs about an old battle in the house of 'A'ishah, while the Prophet lay resting.
  • Abu Bakr came in and objected: musical instruments of Satan, near the Prophet?
  • The Prophet told him: leave them (paraphrase). In another report of the same event he adds that every people has its festival, and this is ours.

Q1 How did the Prophet respond to the singing?

Show answer

He allowed it and told Abu Bakr to leave the girls alone.

Q2 How might someone who rejects music read this hadith?

Show answer

As a narrow exception: simple songs by young girls on a festival day, not musical worship.

Mission 5Read the source

Sahih al-Bukhari 69:494

  • The Prophet warned that among his followers there would be people who treat as lawful illegal sex, the wearing of silk (for men), alcoholic drink and musical instruments (Arabic ma'azif) (paraphrase).
  • Rejecting reading: instruments are listed beside clear sins, so they are forbidden.
  • Permitting reading: some scholars questioned its chain (Ibn Hazm, d. 1064, judged it broken); others read it as condemning music bound up with drinking and immorality, not all music.

Q1 Why do many scholars read this hadith as forbidding instruments?

Show answer

They appear in a list with things that are clearly forbidden.

Q2 What is one way of reading it that allows some music?

Show answer

It condemns a sinful lifestyle in which music is used, or its chain is weak.

Mission 5Diversity

Three answers

Music in worship: three answers123reject instruments (69:494)many scholars of the four Sunni schools,most Salafis and many Deobandis1voice and daff onlymost who reject instruments: voice-onlynasheeds; the daff at weddings and Eid(15:70)2conditional sama' (al-Ghazali, 15:70)al-Ghazali and many Sufi orders: if thewords are good, the setting is pure andthe heart turns to Allah3Shi'a viewsmost Twelver scholars forbid music of thekind used for entertainment and sin, butpermit some other music; latmiya are chantedunaccompanied
  • Rejecting instruments: many scholars of the four Sunni schools, most Salafis and many Deobandis: musical instruments are forbidden (69:494); dancing in worship is bid'ah (innovation); the Prophet's worship had none. Some cite 31:6 ("idle tales", Yusuf Ali; read by the Companion Ibn Mas'ud as singing).
  • Voice and daff: most who reject instruments still allow voice-only nasheeds, and the daff at weddings and Eid, since the Prophet allowed festival songs (15:70). No instruments in worship.
  • Conditional permission: al-Ghazali (Revival, book on sama') and many Sufi orders: lawful if the words are good, the setting is pure and the listener's heart turns to Allah; forbidden if it stirs lust or leads to sin (15:70).
  • Shi'a views: most Twelver scholars forbid music and singing of the kind used for entertainment and sin, but permit some other music; mourning poems for Husayn (latmiya) are chanted unaccompanied.
Quick check
?Which group would most likely accept a qawwali performance with harmonium and tabla at a shrine in Pakistan?
Mission 5Evaluate

"Music and dance have no place in Muslim worship."

Argument map: do music and dance have a place in Muslim worship?Music and dance have no place in Muslimworship.ForThe Prophet's salah and dhikr used noinstruments69:494 lists instruments with sinsAdding practices to worship risks bid'ahMusic can distract from Allah or stirdesiresAgainst15:70 shows the Prophet allowed singingSufis say sama' is dhikr: it softens theheart (39:23)Al-Ghazali, a great Sunni scholar,permitted it with conditionsMany Muslims came to Islam through Sufimusic and poetryAnother viewDistinguish worship (salah: no music) fromdevotion (nasheeds, poetry: acceptable tomany) and entertainment (debated)Judge it byWhat did the Prophet do and allow? · Howstrong is each hadith? · Does the effect on theheart decide it?
  • For: the Prophet's salah and dhikr used no instruments. 69:494 lists instruments with sins. Adding practices to worship risks bid'ah. Music can distract from Allah or stir desires.
  • Against: 15:70 shows the Prophet allowed singing. Sufis say sama' is dhikr: it softens the heart (39:23). Al-Ghazali, a great Sunni scholar, permitted it with conditions. Many Muslims came to Islam through Sufi music and poetry.
  • Another view: distinguish worship (salah: no music) from devotion (nasheeds, poetry: acceptable to many) and entertainment (debated).
  • Judge it by: What did the Prophet do and allow? How strong is each hadith? Does the effect on the heart decide it?
  • 12-mark tip (d): argue both sides with Muslim viewpoints and sources (e.g. 15:70, 69:494), weigh them, then reach a justified conclusion.
Mission 5Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Reason, source, developmentReason 1instruments are forbidden.SourceSahih al-Bukhari 69:494 lists musicalinstruments with alcohol and illegal sex.Developmentso these Muslims believe music should not bebrought into acts meant to please Allah.Reason 2worship must follow the Prophet's example.Developmenthis salah and dhikr used no instruments, soadding them is bid'ah (innovation), and theQur'an recited beautifully is enough to movethe heart.

Question: Explain two reasons why some Muslims reject the use of music in worship.

  • Reason 1: instruments are forbidden. Source: Sahih al-Bukhari 69:494 lists musical instruments with alcohol and illegal sex. Development: so these Muslims believe music should not be brought into acts meant to please Allah.
  • Reason 2: worship must follow the Prophet's example. Development: his salah and dhikr used no instruments, so adding them is bid'ah (innovation), and the Qur'an recited beautifully is enough to move the heart.
Mission check

?A mosque youth group plans an Eid evening: voice-only nasheeds and a frame drum (daff), but no other instruments. Whose reasoning does this plan follow most closely?
Mission 6

Mission 6: Can a smile count as charity? What makes Muslim giving more than a donation?

Make a guess: Can a smile count as charity? What makes Muslim giving more than a donation?

Mission 6

Sadaqah: voluntary giving

What counts as sadaqahsadaqahcoinsa smilea meala wella booka treesadaqah jariyah (ongoing charity):well, book, tree
  • Sadaqah is voluntary charity: any amount, at any time, to anyone in need, including non-Muslims.
  • The word is linked to sidq, "truthfulness": giving shows that faith is sincere.
  • It need not be money. The Prophet taught that every good deed is sadaqah, and that smiling at your brother is sadaqah (hadith, paraphrase).
  • Sadaqah jariyah ("ongoing charity"): giving that keeps on helping, e.g. a well, a school, planting a tree, or useful knowledge. The Prophet said its reward continues after death (Sahih Muslim, paraphrase).
  • Zakah is the compulsory 2.5%; sadaqah is everything given beyond it.
Mission 6Read the source

Giving in secret and openly

"If ye publish your almsgiving, it is well, but if ye hide it and give it to the poor, it will be better for you, and will atone for some of your ill-deeds." (Qur'an 2:271, Pickthall)

"Those who spend their wealth by night and day, by stealth and openly, verily their reward is with their Lord" (Qur'an 2:274, Pickthall)

  • 2:272–273 add: give seeking only Allah's "Countenance" (favour); remember the poor who are too proud to beg (paraphrase).

Q1 Which kind of giving does 2:271 call "better"?

Show answer

Giving in secret, directly to the poor.

Q2 Does 2:274 forbid open giving?

Show answer

No: it praises giving "by stealth and openly"; the reward is with Allah either way.

Mission 6

Why Muslims give

Why Muslims giveWhy give?Wealth is Allah's57:7Reward grows2:261, seven earsKindness first2:263One bodyhadith
  • Wealth belongs to Allah: humans are trustees (57:7) and must share with those in need.
  • Reward multiplies: those who spend in Allah's way are like a grain that grows seven ears, each with a hundred grains (2:261, paraphrase).
  • Giving does not reduce wealth, the Prophet taught (Sahih Muslim, paraphrase); it purifies and brings blessing.
  • Kindness matters more than the gift: "A kind word with forgiveness is better than almsgiving followed by injury." (Qur'an 2:263, Pickthall)
  • The ummah is one body: when one part hurts, the whole body feels it (hadith, paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which of these would most Muslims count as sadaqah?
Mission 6

Zakah or sadaqah?

Zakah or sadaqah?ZakahSadaqahstatuscompulsory (apillar)voluntaryamountfixed 2.5% ofsavings abovenisabany amount, anyformwhenonce a yearany timewho canreceiveonly the eightgroups in 9:60,mostly Muslimsanyone in need,Muslim or notwhat it canfundnot mosquebuilding; notyour ownparents orchildrenmosques,schools, wells,hospitals,disaster relief
  • Zakah: compulsory (a pillar) · fixed 2.5% of savings above nisab · once a year · only the eight groups in 9:60, mostly Muslims · cannot fund mosque building or go to your own parents or children.
  • Sadaqah: voluntary · any amount, any form · any time · anyone in need, Muslim or not · can fund mosques, schools, wells, hospitals and disaster relief.
  • Both: given for Allah's sake, ideally discreetly, without boasting or hurting the receiver (2:263–264).
Mission 6

Islamic Relief

Muslim charitiesIslamic ReliefFounded1984, Birmingham, by Dr HanyEl-Banna and fellow studentsIn the UKfood parcels and food banks;help for people who arehomeless or in fuel povertyWorldwideemergency relief; water, health,education; orphan sponsorshipWhy"inspired by faith": zakah,sadaqah and 5:32Muslim AidFounded1985 by 23 UK Muslimorganisations; based in LondonFirst chairYusuf Islam (Cat Stevens)Workemergency relief and long-termdevelopment: water, education,small loans, skillsIn the UKhot meals and food parcels forpeople who are homeless andfamilies in poverty
  • Founded in 1984 in Birmingham by Dr Hany El-Banna and fellow students, to help victims of famine in Sudan. Its first donation was 20p.
  • Now one of the largest Muslim charities in the world, working in many countries.
  • In the UK: food parcels and food banks, support for people who are homeless or in fuel poverty, and Ramadan and winter appeals.
  • Worldwide: emergency relief after disasters and war; Qurbani meat at Eid-ul-Adha; water, health, education; orphan sponsorship; long-term projects so people can earn a living.
  • Why: "inspired by faith": zakah, sadaqah and 5:32: "whoso saveth the life of one, it shall be as if he had saved the life of all mankind" (Qur'an 5:32, Pickthall).
  • Helps people whatever their faith, as sadaqah allows.
Mission 6

Muslim Aid

Muslim charitiesIslamic ReliefFounded1984, Birmingham, by Dr HanyEl-Banna and fellow studentsIn the UKfood parcels and food banks;help for people who arehomeless or in fuel povertyWorldwideemergency relief; water, health,education; orphan sponsorshipWhy"inspired by faith": zakah,sadaqah and 5:32Muslim AidFounded1985 by 23 UK Muslimorganisations; based in LondonFirst chairYusuf Islam (Cat Stevens)Workemergency relief and long-termdevelopment: water, education,small loans, skillsIn the UKhot meals and food parcels forpeople who are homeless andfamilies in poverty
  • Founded in 1985 by 23 UK Muslim organisations, in response to famine in Africa; its first chair was the singer Yusuf Islam (Cat Stevens). Based in London.
  • Work: emergency relief (food, shelter, medical care) and long-term development: clean water, education, small loans and skills training so families can support themselves.
  • In the UK: support for people who are homeless and families in poverty, e.g. hot meals and food parcels.
  • Distributes zakah to eligible Muslims and uses sadaqah for wider projects, keeping the two separate.
  • Why: to serve Allah by serving humanity; the ummah as one body.
Mission 6

Local help: body and soul

  • Physical needs: food, water, shelter, medicine, clothes, money for debts.
  • Spiritual needs: dignity and respect; someone to pray with; a copy of the Qur'an or a prayer space in a refugee camp; help to bury the dead with proper Islamic rites; comfort and hope after disaster.
  • Muslim charities aim to meet both: a person is body and soul.
Quick check
?A Muslim charity in Britain wants to build a well in a village where most people are not Muslims. Which kind of giving should it use, according to most scholars?
Mission 6Evaluate

"It is always better to give in secret."

Argument map: giving in secret"It is always better to give in secret."For2:271 says hidden giving is "better foryou"Secrecy protects the receiver's dignity andthe giver's sincerityThe Prophet praised giving so secretlythat the left hand does not know what theright hand gives (hadith)Against2:271 also says open giving "is well", and2:274 praises giving "openly"Public appeals by charities raise far moreand encourage othersZakah is often paid openly throughinstitutions so it can be checkedAnother viewWhat matters is intention (niyyah): givingfor Allah's sake, not for praise, can beopen or secretJudge it byWhat exactly does 2:271 say? · Whoseinterests matter most: the giver's soul, thereceiver's dignity, or the number helped? · Canlarge charities work in secret?
  • Reasons for: 2:271 says hidden giving is "better for you"; secrecy protects the receiver's dignity and the giver's sincerity; the Prophet praised the one who gives so secretly that the left hand does not know what the right hand gives (hadith, paraphrase).
  • Reasons against: 2:271 also says open giving "is well", and 2:274 praises giving "openly"; public appeals by charities raise far more and encourage others; zakah is often paid openly through institutions so it can be checked.
  • Another view: what matters is intention (niyyah): giving for Allah's sake, not for praise, can be open or secret.
  • Judge it by: What exactly does 2:271 say? Whose interests matter most: the giver's soul, the receiver's dignity, or the number helped? Can large charities work in secret?
Mission check

?Zainab has no spare money. She teaches a younger pupil to read the Qur'an for free, every week, for a year. The pupil later teaches others. How would most Muslims describe what Zainab has done?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Halal (permitted) and haram (forbidden) come from the Qur'an, Sunnah and scholars; most things are halal unless forbidden.
  • Actions fall into five categories, from obligatory to forbidden.
  • Forbidden: carrion, blood, pork, meat dedicated to others than Allah (2:173), and all intoxicants (5:90); Surah 24:30–31 commands modesty for both sexes, and Muslims interpret dress differently.
  • Riba and gambling are forbidden.

Mission 2

  • Birth: adhan and iqamah, tahnik, tasmiyah on the 7th day, head-shaving with charity, aqiqah, khitan for boys.
  • Marriage: nikah with consent, offer and acceptance, witnesses, contract and mahr (4:4), then walimah; love and mercy (30:21).
  • Death: ghusl, white kafan, salat al-janazah, quick burial facing Makkah; mourning periods differ (three days; widows four months and ten days; Shi'a 3rd, 7th, 40th days).

Mission 3

  • A mosque (masjid, "place of prostration") is the centre of communal worship and of the local ummah; its key features face Makkah: qiblah wall, mihrab, minbar, musalla, wudu area.
  • No images of living beings; calligraphy and geometric patterns express Tawhid and reject idolatry (Ibrahim breaking the idols, Qur'an 21:58).
  • Objects: Qur'an on a stand, prayer mat, compass, turbah (Shi'a), misbahah.

Mission 4

  • Sufism (tasawwuf) is the inner dimension of Islam, practised by Sunni and some Shi'a Muslims alongside the Shari'ah; its aim is ihsan.
  • Orders (tariqahs) led by sheikhs practise dhikr (Qur'an 13:28); saints (awliya) are honoured at shrines.
  • Al-Ghazali (1058–1111) united Shari'ah and Sufism in the Revival of the Religious Sciences; Ibn al-'Arabi and Rabi'a are other great teachers.

Mission 5

  • Many Sufis use sama', whirling, qawwali and poetry as dhikr: devotion that softens the heart towards Allah.
  • Sahih al-Bukhari 15:70 (singing on Eid allowed) and 69:494 (instruments listed with sins) are read in different ways.
  • Views range from rejecting instruments (most still allowing voice and the daff on joyful occasions) to conditional permission of sama' (al-Ghazali).

Mission 6

  • Sadaqah is voluntary charity of any kind, to anyone; sadaqah jariyah keeps on benefiting (Qur'an 2:271–274; 2:261).
  • Islamic Relief (1984, Birmingham) works in the UK and worldwide, inspired by zakah, sadaqah and 5:32.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islam: Forms of Expression and Ways of Life for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A. 🎉

  1. Mission 1No verse mentions a fruit you have never seen. Is a Muslim allowed to eat it?
  2. Mission 2Why are the first words a Muslim baby hears the same as the call to prayer?
  3. Mission 3A mosque can be a domed palace or a converted shop. What does every mosque need?
  4. Mission 4Some Muslims spend whole nights repeating one name of Allah. What are they searching for?
  5. Mission 5Some Muslims turn in circles to music to remember Allah; others say music has no place in faith. Why?
  6. Mission 6Can a smile count as charity? What makes Muslim giving more than a donation?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel