🚀 Arguments for the Existence of God: 3A Catholic Christianity and 3B Christianity (part 2)
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A (1RA0) · Paper 3 Area of Study 3A Catholic Christianity – Section 1: Arguments for the Existence of God; Paper 3 Area of Study 3B Christianity – Section 1: Arguments for the Existence of God (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Arguments for the Existence of God: 3A Catholic Christianity and 3B Christianity (part 2)
6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 2Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 3If someone prays for a friend to get better and she doesn't, was the prayer answered?
Mission 4Why do some people come to believe in God while others, raised the same way, doubt it?
Mission 5Everything that happens has a cause. Does the universe itself need one?
Mission 6If you found a watch on a heath, you'd know someone made it. Is the universe like that watch?
Mission 1
Mission 1: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Make a guess: If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 1
Two kinds of evil
Evil: whatever is bad, harmful or wrong. Suffering: the pain, physical or mental, that it causes.
Moral evil: caused by human choices: murder, cruelty, war, theft, bullying.
Natural evil (natural suffering): caused by nature, not by humans: earthquakes, floods, disease, famine from drought.
Some cases are mixed: a quake kills more people where buildings were badly made.
Moral evil raises the question: why did God make people free to do this? Natural evil: why did God make a world that works like this?
Quick check
?A cyclone floods a coastal region. Afterwards, officials steal food aid meant for survivors. Which classification is correct?
Mission 1
The inconsistent triad
Step 1 of 3
Theists (Christians, Jews, Muslims, Sikhs and many Hindus) believe God is omnipotent (all-powerful) and omnibenevolent (all-loving).
Most also say God is omniscient (all-knowing): God knows about every evil.
But evil exists.
The problem: these three statements seem not to fit together. If God knew, could stop it and wanted to, why does it happen?
This is the inconsistent triad. Many versions add omniscience, giving four statements; the name inconsistent triad is kept. Philosophers call it the logical problem of evil.
The evidential problem: even if some evil is needed, why so much, and why such pointless suffering?
Mission 1Read the source
Epicurus' old questions
Step 1 of 3
David Hume (1711–1776), Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779), Part X, has a character repeat questions credited to the Greek philosopher Epicurus (341–270 BCE):
> "Is he willing to prevent evil, but not able? then is he impotent. Is he able, but not willing? then is he malevolent. Is he both able and willing? whence then is evil?"
Q1 Which quality of God does the first question challenge?
Show answer
Omnipotence: "not able" means "impotent", powerless.
Q2 Which does the second challenge?
Show answer
Omnibenevolence: "not willing" means "malevolent", ill-willed.
Mission 1
Innocent suffering and providence
Providence: God's loving care for the world, guiding it towards good.
Innocent suffering is the hardest case: babies with painful illnesses, children in war, animals in fires. They have done nothing to deserve it.
In Fyodor Dostoevsky's novel The Brothers Karamazov (1880), Ivan refuses any future harmony bought with the tears of a tortured child (paraphrase).
Even believers cry out: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (Psalm 22:1, WEBBE). Christians recall that Jesus prayed these words on the cross (Mark 15:34).
Mission 1Read the source
God of light and darkness, God of mercy
"I form the light and create darkness. I make peace and create calamity. I am the LORD, who does all these things." (Isaiah 45:7, WEBBE)
Does God cause suffering? Many Catholics read "calamity" as disasters, not moral evil: God is sovereign over everything and permits suffering for a purpose. Isaiah 45:9 adds that clay cannot question the potter.
"In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful. Praise be to Allah, Lord of the Worlds, The Beneficent, the Merciful." (Surah 1:1–3, Pickthall)
Muslims say these words in every prayer. If Allah is the Merciful, why do believers suffer?
Q1 Why might Isaiah 45:7 make the problem harder for some readers?
Show answer
It seems to say God creates calamity himself.
Q2 Which quality of God does Surah 1 repeat?
Show answer
Mercy: "the Beneficent, the Merciful".
Mission 1
Reject, question or examine
Some reject belief: atheists argue that the triad shows an all-powerful, all-loving God does not exist.
Humanists: suffering has natural causes (evolution, plate movement, disease) and human ones; no God is needed to explain it; people should reduce it themselves.
Some question: personal tragedy can shake faith; doubt and lament are found in scripture (Psalm 22, Job).
Some examine: believers think harder about what God's power and love mean, and find answers (see Mission 2).
Your spec: the problem may lead some to examine and others to reject their belief.
Quick check
?Leah says: "If God knew the tsunami was coming, could have stopped it and truly loved people, it would not have happened." Which three beliefs about God is Leah putting together?
Mission 1Diversity
Where evil comes from: Abrahamic faiths
Christian: humans misused free will in the Fall (Genesis 3); "sin entered into the world through one man, and death through sin" (Romans 5:12, WEBBE). Original Sin: a damaged nature passed to all.
Jewish: humans have a yetzer ha-tov (good inclination) and a yetzer ha-ra (inclination to evil) and free choice: "I have set before thee life and death, the blessing and the curse; therefore choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:19, JPS 1917).
Muslim: Iblis refused to bow to Adam "through pride" (Surah 2:34, Pickthall) and now tempts humans; hardship is a test: "We shall try you with something of fear and hunger" (Surah 2:155, Pickthall).
Mission 1Evaluate
"Evil and suffering prove that God does not exist."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: the triad seems logically inconsistent; the amount of suffering seems pointless (evidential problem); innocent suffering seems unfair; natural causes explain suffering without God.
Reasons against: God may have good reasons we cannot see (Isaiah 45:9); free will needs the possibility of evil; suffering may have a purpose (see Mission 2); many who suffer most keep their faith.
Another view: the problem may show that God's power or love must be understood differently, not that God does not exist.
Judge it by: Is "prove" too strong a word? Does free will explain natural evil? Can a finite mind judge God's reasons?
Mission check
?A baby is born with a painful genetic illness. Tom says: "An all-powerful, loving God would not allow this, so there is no such God." The baby's mother, a Christian, prays: "Why, Lord?", but goes on trusting God. Which statement is accurate?
The same suffering can lead one person to reject God and another to question and examine faith. A later mission: the answers believers give.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Make a guess: Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 2
Three kinds of answer
A theodicy ("justifying God") tries to show why a good, all-powerful God allows evil. The word was coined by Gottfried Leibniz (1710).
Philosophical answers: free will, soul-making.
Scriptural answers: Job, the Psalms, life as a test, the suffering of Christ.
Practical answers: prayer, charity, care for those who suffer.
Most believers use all three. Many say: we may not fully explain suffering, but we can trust God and act.
Mission 2
Augustine: free will and privation
Step 1 of 2
St Augustine of Hippo (354–430), Confessions, City of God, Enchiridion.
Augustine teaches that God made a good world. Evil is not a thing God made: "evil has no positive nature; but the loss of good has received the name 'evil.'" (Augustine, City of God XI.9, Dods)
Angels and humans misused free will: the fall of the angels and of Adam and Eve.
Original Sin: all humans inherit a damaged nature; natural evil follows the disorder sin brought into creation.
So evil comes from creatures, not from God. God is just to allow its consequences, and merciful to save through Christ.
Mission 2
Irenaeus and Hick: soul-making
Step 1 of 2
St Irenaeus (c. 130–c. 202), Against Heresies: humans are made in God's image, but must grow into his likeness (Genesis 1:26).
Humans are made immature on purpose, so they can grow freely into goodness.
John Hick (1922–2012), Evil and the God of Love (1966): the world is a "vale of soul-making" (a phrase from the poet Keats).
Courage, compassion and forgiveness can only grow where there is real danger and pain.
Epistemic distance: God keeps a distance, so that people are free to believe or not.
Hick: in the end all people will reach the likeness of God (universal salvation), so all suffering will prove worthwhile.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly contrasts Augustine's and Irenaeus' answers to evil?
Mission 2
Do these answers work?
Against Augustine: science shows death and disease long before humans existed, so natural evil cannot all come from the Fall. How could perfect beings choose evil? Why punish all humans for Adam's sin?
Against soul-making: the amount of suffering is too great: the Holocaust destroyed people, it did not make souls. Babies and animals suffer without growing. Is it loving to use pain as a teacher?
For both: free will is real only if evil is possible; virtues need challenges; God's goodness may reach beyond this life (Romans 8:18).
Atheists and Humanists: the answers explain away real pain; a world with less suffering would still allow free will.
Divergent Christian views: many Catholics hold both together; some Protestants stress mystery and trust over explanation; liberal Christians question an all-controlling God.
Mission 2Read the source
Job's losses
Job, a good man, loses his children, wealth and health:
"Naked I came out of my mother's womb, and naked will I return there. The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away. Blessed be the LORD's name." (Job 1:21, WEBBE)
His friends insist he must have sinned. God rejects their view. God's answer is a question: "Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?" (Job 38:4, WEBBE)
"It is good for me that I have been afflicted, that I may learn your statutes." (Psalm 119:71, WEBBE)
Q1 What does God's question in Job 38:4 suggest about human understanding of suffering?
Show answer
It is limited: humans cannot see the whole of God's plan.
Q2 According to Psalm 119:71, what good can come from suffering?
Show answer
Learning God's laws: growing closer to God.
Mission 2
Islam: life as a test
"Who hath created life and death that He may try you which of you is best in conduct" (Surah 67:2, Pickthall).
Surah 2:151–177: Allah tries believers with "fear and hunger, and loss of wealth and lives" (Surah 2:155, Pickthall). The steadfast say: "Lo! we are Allah's and lo! unto Him we are returning." (Surah 2:156, Pickthall)
Righteousness is faith shown in giving to "orphans and the needy", in prayer, zakah, and patience in hardship (Surah 2:177, paraphrase).
Al-Qadr: Allah knows and decrees all things, yet humans are responsible for their choices.
Sabr (patient endurance) and du'a (personal prayer) are the believer's response; many Muslims believe hardship patiently borne wipes away sins (hadith).
Divergent: Shi'a Muslims see in Imam Husayn's martyrdom at Karbala (680) the meaning of suffering for justice; some Muslims stress Allah's decree, others human free will.
Mission 2
Christians: the suffering of Christ
Christians believe God does not stay distant from suffering: in Jesus, God shares it.
"He was despised and rejected by men, a man of suffering and acquainted with disease." (Isaiah 53:3, WEBBE)
"By his wounds we are healed." (Isaiah 53:5, WEBBE) Christians read this as pointing to Christ's death.
Mission 2
Practical responses
Prayer: comfort, strength and solidarity: God "comforts us in all our affliction, that we may be able to comfort those who are in any affliction" (2 Corinthians 1:4, WEBBE).
Charity: Christians through CAFOD or Christian Aid; Muslims through zakah and Islamic Relief; Jews through tzedakah; Sikhs through Khalsa Aid.
Hope: many believe suffering will end: God "will wipe away every tear from their eyes" (Revelation 21:4, WEBBE).
Humanists: use reason, science and compassion to reduce suffering now; this life is the only one, so it matters.
Quick check
?In the Book of Job, what is the main point of God's answer to Job (Job 38–41)?
Mission 2Evaluate
"Religious responses solve the problem of evil."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: free will explains moral evil; soul-making gives suffering a purpose; Job shows humans cannot judge God.
Also for: Christ's suffering shows God shares pain.
Also for: life as a test gives meaning.
Reasons against: natural evil existed before humans; the amount and pointlessness of suffering; innocent suffering of children and animals.
Another view: responses may not solve the problem as a puzzle but help believers live with it; practical responses matter most.
Divergent views of success: many Catholics and Muslims say the answers, taken together, are enough for faith; others stress mystery.
Judge it by: Does it explain natural as well as moral evil? Does it fit the amount of suffering? Does it help people who suffer?
Mission check
?After a flood kills twelve people in her town, Grace, a Christian, says: "God didn't send this. But our town has never been so united, and people have grown braver and kinder." Her friend Sam, a Humanist, replies: "People did that, not God. And why did twelve people have to die for it?" Which statement is accurate?
Believers answer suffering with free will, soul-making, trust (Job), the meaning their faith gives it, and action. Critics ask whether any answer fits the amount of pain.
Mission 3
Mission 3: If someone prays for a friend to get better and she doesn't, was the prayer answered?
Make a guess: If someone prays for a friend to get better and she doesn't, was the prayer answered?
Mission 3
What is prayer?
Prayer: communicating with God. An old Christian definition calls it "the raising of the mind and heart to God" (St John Damascene, 8th century).
Christians pray in four main ways (ACTS): Adoration (praise), Confession (saying sorry), Thanksgiving, Supplication (asking, for yourself or others).
Set prayers, such as the Lord's Prayer (Matthew 6:9–13), are shared words. Informal (extempore) prayer is in a person's own words.
Prayer can be alone or together, spoken, sung or silent.
For believers it is an experience of God: a relationship, not only a request list.
Mission 3Read the source
Asking according to God's will
"This is the boldness which we have towards him, that if we ask anything according to his will, he listens to us. And if we know that he listens to us, whatever we ask, we know that we have the petitions which we have asked of him." (1 John 5:14–15, WEBBE)
The letter is written so that believers "may know that you have eternal life" (1 John 5:13, WEBBE).
Verses 16–17 (paraphrase): if you see a fellow believer committing a sin "not leading to death", pray for them, and God will give them life.
Q1 What condition does verse 14 attach to prayer being heard?
Show answer
Asking "according to his will".
Q2 Why might a Christian say verse 16 shows prayer is for others, not only for yourself?
Show answer
It asks believers to pray for a brother or sister who is sinning.
Mission 3
When prayer is answered
Step 1 of 3
Jesus: "Ask, and it will be given you. Seek, and you will find." (Matthew 7:7, WEBBE)
Some prayers seem answered in the way the person expects: a recovery, a safe journey, a decision made clear.
To the believer this can feel like God acting personally: it strengthens faith, or begins it.
Others see God's answer in peace or strength to cope, even when events do not change.
Your spec's point: an answer that matches the request can lead someone to believe in God, because it seems too fitting to be chance.
Quick check
?According to 1 John 5:14–15, when can a Christian be confident that God hears a request?
Mission 3
When prayer seems unanswered
Step 1 of 3
Many Christians say God answers every prayer: yes, no or not yet.
Jesus in Gethsemane: "Please remove this cup from me. However, not what I desire, but what you desire." (Mark 14:36, WEBBE) The cup was not removed.
Paul asked three times to be freed from a "thorn in the flesh"; the answer: "My grace is sufficient for you" (2 Corinthians 12:9, WEBBE).
Jesus teaches that God, like a good parent, gives "good things to those who ask him" (Matthew 7:11, WEBBE): not always the thing asked for.
When people do not know how to pray, "the Spirit himself makes intercession for us" (Romans 8:26, WEBBE).
Mission 3Diversity
Christians differ on what prayer does
Step 1 of 3
Catholic and Orthodox: prayer is above all communion with God; saints are asked to pray for us; some healings are investigated and recognised (e.g. Lourdes).
Pentecostal and charismatic: expect God to heal and act today in answer to prayer (James 5:16).
Reformed (Calvinist): prayer does not change God's plan; God uses prayer as one of the ways his plan is carried out.
Liberal Protestant: prayer mainly changes the one who prays: their attitude, courage and love.
All agree prayer is not a slot machine: its heart is the relationship with God.
Mission 3
The atheist and Humanist challenge
Coincidence: with millions of prayers, some will match what happens by chance.
Confirmation bias: people remember the "hits" and forget the "misses".
Natural causes: many illnesses improve anyway; hope and calm can help recovery.
Tests: a large 2006 US study of prayer for heart-surgery patients found no benefit from being prayed for.
Unfairness: why would a loving God answer one person's prayer for a child's recovery and not another's? For some, unanswered prayer leads to loss of belief.
Humanists: quiet reflection and support from others can help, for natural reasons.
Quick check
?Joe prays for sunshine on five Saturdays. He says it worked twice, but has forgotten the three wet Saturdays. Which challenge to answered prayer fits Joe best?
Mission 3
Christian responses to the challenge
Not a test of God: Jesus refuses to put God to the test (Matthew 4:7); many Christians say an experiment cannot measure a relationship.
"No" is an answer: Gethsemane and Paul's thorn show faithful prayer that was not granted.
The answer may be strength: comfort, patience and courage are real changes.
Testimony: many believers report answers too specific to be chance.
Faith comes first: most Christians do not base belief on results; prayer is part of trusting God.
Mission 3Evaluate
"Answered prayer proves that God exists."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: many detailed reports of answers; changed lives; prayer is experienced as a real relationship; 1 John 5:14–15 promises God listens.
Reasons against: coincidence and confirmation bias; natural recovery; tests show no effect; many prayers seem to go unanswered.
Another view: answered prayer may give the believer good reason to trust God, without proving anything to others.
Judge it by: Can a "no" ever count against God? Is personal experience enough? What would count as proof?
Mission check
?Ruth prays for her brother to get a job. He is turned down. A month later he finds a better job. Ruth's atheist friend says: "That was luck." Ruth replies: "God heard me. The first 'no' was part of a better answer." Which statement about this conversation is accurate?
The same event can be read as God's answer or as chance. For believers, prayer is a relationship with God, so a "no" is not the end of it.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Why do some people come to believe in God while others, raised the same way, doubt it?
Make a guess: Why do some people come to believe in God while others, raised the same way, doubt it?
Mission 4
Theist, atheist, agnostic
Theist: believes God exists.
Atheist: believes God does not exist, or has no belief in God.
Agnostic: thinks it is not possible, or not yet possible, to know whether God exists. Term coined by T. H. Huxley (1825–1895) in 1869.
Humanist: a non-religious person who lives by reason, empathy and concern for human flourishing; most Humanists are atheist or agnostic.
Mission 4
A religious upbringing
Christian: infant baptism (or dedication), prayers at home, church and Sunday school, Christmas and Easter, Christian schools, then confirmation: the young person's own commitment.
At baptism Catholic and many other parents promise to bring the child up in the faith.
Why it may lead to belief: faith is learned from people you trust; practice becomes habit; a community supports it.
Mission 4Read the source
Teaching children
"Train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old he will not depart from it." (Proverbs 22:6)
Christians read this as a duty to pass on faith, and a hope that it lasts. Parents are to "nurture them in the discipline and instruction of the Lord" without provoking them (Ephesians 6:4).
Q1 What does Proverbs 22:6 say early training leads to?
Show answer
Lasting faith and values in later life.
Q2 What does Ephesians 6:4 add about how parents should pass on faith?
Show answer
Nurture children in the discipline and instruction of the Lord, without provoking them.
Mission 4
Upbringing: the debate
Non-religious arguments: children cannot yet judge; religion taught as certain fact is indoctrination.
Richard Dawkins (b. 1941), The God Delusion (2006): calling a child "a Christian child" is like calling a child "a Marxist child"; children are too young to have such views (paraphrase).
Strict or unanswered-questions upbringing can lead to rejecting God later.
Religious responses: all parents pass on values, including non-religious ones; faith is offered, not forced; young people make their own commitment (confirmation, bar/bat mitzvah, Amrit).
"There is no compulsion in religion." (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall)
Humanists: bring children up to think for themselves and learn about many beliefs.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how most Christian churches view a religious upbringing?
Mission check
?Sam was brought up going to church. At seventeen she says: "I'm not sure God exists. I can't see clear evidence either way." Which word describes Sam, and why?
Upbringing, reasoning, experience and science all shape whether people believe, doubt or reject God.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Everything that happens has a cause. Does the universe itself need one?
Make a guess: Everything that happens has a cause. Does the universe itself need one?
Mission 5
A chain of causes
Step 1 of 3
Everything we see has a cause: you were caused by your parents, a tree by a seed, rain by clouds.
Each cause was itself caused by something earlier.
The First Cause argument asks: what started the chain?
Its answer: there must be a first cause that was not itself caused. Believers say this is God.
It is also called the cosmological argument (from kosmos, Greek for "ordered world"): it argues from the existence of the universe to God.
Mission 5
Aquinas' First Three Ways
Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Catholic priest and philosopher, Summa Theologiae (1265–1274), Part I, Question 2, Article 3: "five ways" to show God exists.
1. Motion (change): things change, and each change is caused by something else. There must be a first mover, unmoved by anything.
2. Cause: nothing causes itself, and the chain of causes cannot go back forever. There must be a first cause.
3. Contingency: everything in nature could have not existed (it is contingent). If everything were like that, at some time there would have been nothing, and nothing would exist now. So there must be a necessary being: one that cannot not exist.
Aquinas ends each Way: this is what everyone calls God.
Mission 5Read the source
The Second Way
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I, Q. 2, Art. 3 (English Dominican translation, 1920):
> "There is no case known (neither is it, indeed, possible) in which a thing is found to be the efficient cause of itself; for so it would be prior to itself, which is impossible."
> "Therefore it is necessary to admit a first efficient cause, to which everyone gives the name of God."
An efficient cause is whatever makes something happen or exist.
Q1 Why can nothing cause itself, according to Aquinas?
Show answer
It would have to exist before itself, which is impossible.
Q2 What does Aquinas say "everyone" calls the first cause?
Show answer
God.
Mission 5
Kalam: al-Ghazali
Kalam (Arabic: "speech", then "theology by reasoned argument").
Al-Ghazali (1058–1111), Muslim theologian, Kitab al-Iqtisad fi'l-I'tiqad (The Moderation in Belief), c. 1095.
His argument (paraphrase):
1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause.
2. The universe began to exist: it cannot be infinitely old.
3. So the universe has a cause, and that cause is God, who did not begin.
Note the wording: not "everything has a cause", but "everything that begins".
Many Muslims see the argument as reason confirming what the Qur'an teaches: Allah alone is the eternal Creator.
Quick check
?Which of Aquinas' Ways argues that things in nature could have not existed, so there must be a being that cannot not exist?
Mission 5Diversity
What the argument shows about God
Catholic teaching: human reason can know God exists from created things (CCC 36, paraphrase; First Vatican Council, 1870). The Ways show God as Creator, eternal, necessary and omnipotent.
Other Christians: many Protestants value the argument as support for faith, but say it cannot show God is loving or the God of the Bible; for that, revelation is needed.
Muslims: the heaven Allah built shows his power: "Are ye the harder to create, or is the heaven that He built?" (Surah 79:27, Pickthall). Kalam fits tawhid: one Creator, uncaused.
Most believers say the argument supports faith; few say it alone creates it.
Mission 5
Objections from atheists and Humanists
What caused God? If everything needs a cause, so does God. If God needs none, perhaps the universe needs none either.
The universe might just be there. Bertrand Russell (1872–1970), BBC radio debate with Frederick Copleston (1948): the universe is a brute fact that needs no explanation (paraphrase).
Parts and whole. Russell: every human has a mother, but the human race does not have a mother (paraphrase). A cause for each part does not prove a cause for the whole. A character in David Hume's (1711–1776) Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779), Part IX, makes the same point.
The chain might go back forever. Why can't there be an infinite chain of causes?
Science: the Big Bang (about 13.8 billion years ago) may have a natural explanation. Humanists say "we don't yet know" is more honest than "God did it".
Which God? Even a first cause would not show it is loving, personal, or the God of any one religion.
Quick check
?A critic says: "Every person in this room has a mother, but that does not mean the whole room has a mother." Which weakness of the First Cause argument does this illustrate?
Mission 5
Religious replies
God is not caused. The argument never says "everything has a cause". Aquinas: contingent things need a cause, but God is necessary. Kalam: what begins needs a cause, but God is eternal.
An infinite chain explains nothing. A train of carriages stretching back forever still needs an engine to move at all.
The Big Bang fits a beginning. It was first proposed (1927, 1931) by Georges Lemaître (1894–1966), a Catholic priest and physicist. Many believers say science explains how; the argument asks why there is anything at all.
Which God? Believers agree the argument is limited. It shows a Creator; revelation and experience fill in the rest.
Muslims add: the Qur'an invites people to reflect on creation, so reasoning to the Creator is a duty, not a rival to faith.
Mission 5Evaluate
"The First Cause argument proves that God exists."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: everything we observe has a cause; nothing causes itself (Aquinas); the universe had a beginning (Big Bang), as kalam claims; a necessary being explains why anything exists.
Reasons against: "what caused God?"; the universe may be a brute fact (Russell); parts-and-whole (Hume); an infinite chain may be possible; the cause need not be the God of religion.
Another view: many believers say it shows God is reasonable to believe in, not proved; faith completes it.
Judge it by: Is "uncaused God" special pleading? Does "proof" mean certainty or good reason? Does the Big Bang help or hurt?
Mission 5Worked answer
Belief, source, development
Question: Explain two reasons why some religious believers think the cosmological (First Cause) argument shows God exists.
Reason 1: Nothing can cause itself, so the chain of causes needs a first cause. Source: Aquinas' Second Way. Development: an infinite chain would leave nothing to start it, so Catholics see God as the uncaused Creator.
Reason 2: Whatever begins to exist has a cause, and the universe began. Source: al-Ghazali's kalam argument; "Are ye the harder to create, or is the heaven that He built?" (Surah 79:27, Pickthall). Development: the eternal Creator explains the beginning; the Big Bang is taken as support.
(c) 5-mark tip: two reasons, each developed, plus one source of wisdom and authority.
Quick check
?An atheist asks: "If everything has a cause, what caused God?" Which reply would al-Ghazali's kalam argument give?
Mission check
?A student says: "My life depends on my parents, theirs on their parents, and so on. Even if the chain went back forever, every link could have not existed, so why is there a chain at all?" Which argument is the student closest to?
The cosmological argument has more than one form: from change, from cause, from contingency, and from a beginning (kalam). Each needs one cause that is not itself caused.
Mission 6
Mission 6: If you found a watch on a heath, you'd know someone made it. Is the universe like that watch?
Make a guess: If you found a watch on a heath, you'd know someone made it. Is the universe like that watch?
Mission 6
Order that looks planned
The design argument says the world shows signs of being planned, so it must have a designer: God.
It is also called the teleological argument (from Greek telos, "end" or "purpose").
Purpose: parts work together for a goal (the eye for seeing, wings for flying).
Believers say order and purpose like this do not happen by chance.
Mission 6
Paley's watch
Step 1 of 3
William Paley (1743–1805), Church of England priest, Natural Theology (1802).
Crossing a heath, you kick a stone: you might think it had always been there.
You find a watch: its springs and wheels are shaped and fitted together to tell the time. You conclude it had a maker (paraphrase).
You would think this even if you had never seen a watch made, or if it sometimes went wrong.
Living things, such as the eye, are far more complex than any watch, with parts fitted for a purpose.
So nature, Paley argues, needs an even greater designer: God.
Mission 6Read the source
Aquinas' Fifth Way
Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae I, Q. 2, Art. 3 (English Dominican translation, 1920):
> "Whatever lacks intelligence cannot move towards an end, unless it be directed by some being endowed with knowledge and intelligence; as the arrow is shot to its mark by the archer."
Aquinas' design argument is from regularity: things without minds (planets, plants) act in regular ways towards an end.
Q1 What does the archer stand for in Aquinas' picture?
Show answer
God, the intelligent being who directs nature.
Q2 Why can't the arrow reach its mark on its own?
Show answer
It has no intelligence; it must be directed.
Mission 6
A universe tuned for life
Physicists find that some basic numbers of nature (such as the strength of gravity) fall in a narrow range that allows stars, planets and life.
Change them slightly, and no life could exist. This is called fine-tuning.
The anthropic principle (from Greek anthropos, "human"; named by physicist Brandon Carter in 1973): the universe has the features that allow observers like us.
Many believers read this as design: the universe was formed for humanity.
Others read it differently: we could only exist to notice it in a universe that allows life.
Quick check
?"Plants without minds grow towards light, and planets keep regular orbits, so something with a mind must direct them." Which version of the design argument is this closest to?
Mission 6Read the source
Creation shows its maker
"For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made, even his everlasting power and divinity" (Romans 1:20, WEBBE)
Paul says people who ignore this are "without excuse" and turned to idols instead (Romans 1:18–24, paraphrase).
"Lo! In the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the difference of night and day … are signs (of Allah's Sovereignty) for people who have sense." (Surah 2:164, Pickthall)
Q1 What two qualities of God does Romans 1:20 say are seen in creation?
Show answer
His everlasting power and divinity.
Q2 Who does the source say will recognise the signs?
Show answer
People who reflect: "people who have sense".
Mission 6Diversity
What design shows about God
Catholics: God is a wise, powerful and good designer. Evolution can be the way God works: Pope Pius XII (Humani Generis, 1950) and Pope John Paul II (1996) accepted evolution of the body as compatible with faith.
Many Protestants agree. Some evangelical creationists read Genesis 1 literally and reject evolution; some support intelligent design, which says some features are too complex to have evolved.
Muslims: nature is full of ayat (signs) of Allah; the Qur'an repeatedly asks people to reflect on them.
Mission 6
Objections from atheists and Humanists
Weak comparison. David Hume (1711–1776), Dialogues concerning Natural Religion (1779): the universe is not much like a machine, so we cannot be sure it had a maker like a watch's.
Which designer? Hume's character Philo says the world could be "the first rude essay of some infant deity" (Dialogues, Part V): perhaps a team of gods, or a careless one.
Evolution. Charles Darwin (1809–1882), On the Origin of Species (1859): natural selection produces living things fitted for their surroundings, step by small step, without a designer.
Richard Dawkins (b. 1941), The Blind Watchmaker (1986): nature's only "watchmaker" is blind natural selection (paraphrase).
Evil and suffering. Diseases, parasites and earthquakes look like poor design for a loving God.
Fine-tuning by chance. If there are many universes, or we could only exist in one that allows life, fine-tuning needs no designer. Humanists say science explains order better than a designer does.
Quick check
?Which objection to the design argument comes from Charles Darwin's work?
Mission 6
Religious replies
Evolution is how God designs. Many Christians, Jews and Muslims accept evolution and see the laws that make it possible as designed. F. R. Tennant (1866–1957), Philosophical Theology (1930), argued that the whole process, not single organs, shows design.
Fine-tuning comes before evolution. Natural selection cannot explain why the universe allows life at all.
One designer is simpler. One God explains order more simply than many gods (a rule of thumb called Ockham's razor).
Suffering may have purposes: free will, or the growth of souls (see Mission 2).
Muslims: the signs are clear "for people who have sense" (Surah 2:164); the argument invites reflection, not blind belief.
Creationists reply differently: they reject evolution as an account of origins.
Mission 6Evaluate
"The design argument shows that God exists."
Step 1 of 4
Reasons for: order and purpose look planned (Paley, Aquinas); fine-tuning allows life; scripture says creation reveals God (Romans 1:20; for Muslims, Surah 2:164 calls nature signs of Allah).
Reasons against: evolution explains apparent design (Darwin); the analogy is weak (Hume); suffering suggests poor design; chance or many universes could explain fine-tuning.
Another view: the argument supports faith for those who already believe, but does not convince on its own.
Judge it by: Does evolution remove the need for a designer, or push design back to the laws of nature? Is the watch analogy strong? Can a designer's goodness be read from a world with suffering?
Quick check
?Hume's character Philo says the world might be "the first rude essay of some infant deity". What is the point of this objection?
Mission check
?A Catholic biologist says: "The eye developed over millions of years, each small change helping survival. That makes God's design even more impressive." Which statement describes her view?
Believers and critics agree that the world contains order. They disagree about whether that order points to a designer, to natural laws, or to both.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Moral evil comes from human choices; natural evil from nature. Suffering raises the inconsistent triad (omnipotent, omnibenevolent God and evil) and the evidential problem; innocent suffering is the hardest case.
Isaiah 45:7 and Surah 1 sharpen the question for Catholics and Muslims.
Mission 2
Augustine: evil is a privation of good, caused by misused free will (the Fall). Irenaeus and Hick: the world is a vale of soul-making. Both face objections (evolution; the amount of suffering).
Job: trust God beyond understanding; practical responses: prayer and charity; Humanists act to reduce suffering.
Psalm 119:71: affliction can bring a believer closer to God's laws.
Muslims see life as a test (Surah 2:155–156, 67:2) met with sabr, prayer and charity.
Mission 3
Prayer is communication with God (adoration, confession, thanksgiving, supplication); set and informal; for believers an experience of God.
Answered prayer can lead to belief; 1 John 5:14–15 ties it to God's will. Unanswered prayer is met with Gethsemane, Paul's thorn and "yes, no, not yet"; critics point to chance, bias and failed tests.
Religious upbringing may lead to belief (Proverbs 22:6); critics call it indoctrination; believers say faith is offered and later chosen.
Mission 5
The First Cause (cosmological) argument reasons from the existence of the universe to an uncaused cause: God.
Aquinas' First Three Ways argue from motion, cause and contingency; al-Ghazali's kalam argues from the universe's beginning.
Objections: what caused God? the universe as brute fact; parts and whole; infinite chains; science; which God? Believers reply that God is necessary and uncaused.
Mission 6
The design (teleological) argument reasons from order and purpose in nature to a designer: Paley's watch, Aquinas' Fifth Way, fine-tuning and the anthropic principle.
Romans 1:20 teaches that creation shows God's power, and for Muslims Surah 2:164 calls nature signs of Allah; traditions differ on evolution and on how to read Genesis 1.
Objections: Hume (weak analogy, which designer?), Darwin's natural selection, evil and suffering, chance; replies: evolution as God's method, fine-tuning, simplicity.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Arguments for the Existence of God: 3A Catholic Christianity and 3B Christianity (part 2) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A. 🎉
Mission 1If God is all-powerful and all-loving, why do children suffer?
Mission 2Believers have lived through floods, plagues and genocide and kept faith. What answers do they give?
Mission 3If someone prays for a friend to get better and she doesn't, was the prayer answered?
Mission 4Why do some people come to believe in God while others, raised the same way, doubt it?
Mission 5Everything that happens has a cause. Does the universe itself need one?
Mission 6If you found a watch on a heath, you'd know someone made it. Is the universe like that watch?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.