← GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A (1RA0) · Paper 3 Area of Study 3A Catholic Christianity – Section 1: Arguments for the Existence of God (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Catholic Christianity: Arguments for the Existence of God (part 1)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If God exists, how could anyone ever know what God is like?
  2. Mission 2If someone sees a vision, how could anyone tell whether it really came from God?
  3. Mission 3A sick person suddenly recovers and doctors can't explain it. Does that show God exists?
  4. Mission 4When someone says they have experienced God, should anyone else believe them?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If God exists, how could anyone ever know what God is like?

Make a guess: If God exists, how could anyone ever know what God is like?

Mission 1

What revelation means

Two kinds of revelationRevelationGod (or ultimate reality) makingknown what humans could not findout on their ownSpecialprophetsreceive God'swordvisions anddreamsmiraclesJesus: God in aperson(Christianbelief)Generalnatureconsciencereasonhistory andinspirationalpeople
  • Revelation: God (or ultimate reality) making known something humans could not find out on their own.
  • Believers say God is transcendent (beyond the world), so humans need God to take the first step.
  • Two kinds:
  • Special revelation: God revealed to particular people at particular times.
  • General revelation: God revealed to everyone, everywhere, through ordinary things.
Mission 1

Special revelation

Two kinds of revelationRevelationGod (or ultimate reality) makingknown what humans could not findout on their ownSpecialprophetsreceive God'swordvisions anddreamsmiraclesJesus: God in aperson(Christianbelief)Generalnatureconsciencereasonhistory andinspirationalpeople
  • Direct, to particular people or groups, often life-changing.
  • Prophets receiving God's word (Moses at Sinai; the Prophet Muhammad in the cave of Hira).
  • Visions and dreams: seeing or hearing something sacred (see Mission 2).
  • Miracles: events showing God acting in the world (see Mission 3).
  • In a person: Christians believe God is revealed most fully in Jesus.
Mission 1

General revelation

Two kinds of revelationRevelationGod (or ultimate reality) makingknown what humans could not findout on their ownSpecialprophetsreceive God'swordvisions anddreamsmiraclesJesus: God in aperson(Christianbelief)Generalnatureconsciencereasonhistory andinspirationalpeople
  • Open to anyone, at any time: no special event is needed.
  • Nature: the beauty, order and size of the universe point to its Creator.
  • Conscience and reason: an inner sense of right and wrong; the ability to think about God.
  • History and inspirational people: seeing God at work in events and in holy lives.
  • Most Christians say nature shows that God exists and is powerful, but God's love and purposes are known through special revelation.
Quick check
?Which of these is an example of special revelation?
Mission 1Read the source

God has spoken by his Son

God has spoken by his SonIn the past: through theprophets, at many timesand in various waysAt the end of thesedays: by his Son"God, having in the past spoken to the fathersthrough the prophets at many times and invarious ways, has at the end of these daysspoken to us by his Son" (Hebrews 1:1–2,WEBBE)

"God, having in the past spoken to the fathers through the prophets at many times and in various ways, has at the end of these days spoken to us by his Son" (Hebrews 1:1–2, WEBBE)

  • The Son is "the radiance of his glory, the very image of his substance" (Hebrews 1:3, WEBBE), greater than the angels (Hebrews 1:4).
  • For Catholics, Jesus is the culmination (high point and completion) of revelation: in him God says everything (CCC 65, paraphrase).

Q1 How did God speak before Jesus, according to Hebrews?

Show answer

Through the prophets, at many times and in various ways.

Q2 What does Hebrews 1:3 say Jesus shows of God?

Show answer

God's glory and very being: "the very image of his substance".

Mission 1

Revelation in the Bible

Revelation in different traditionsHow revealedKey sourceChristiansCovenants with Noah andAbraham; Jesus, the "newcovenant"; the BibleGenesis 9:13;Genesis 12:1–3;Luke 22:20MuslimsThe Qur'an: Allah's ownword, revealed to theProphet Muhammadthrough the angel Jibril,from 610 CESurah 96:1; Surah42:51
  • Covenant: a binding agreement in which God reveals himself and makes promises.
  • Noah: never again a flood; the rainbow is "a sign of a covenant between me and the earth" (Genesis 9:13, WEBBE).
  • Abraham: God calls him to a new land and promises descendants (Genesis 12:1–3; 15).
  • Jesus: the "new covenant" (Luke 22:20).
  • What it shows: God is personal, faithful, keeps promises, acts in history.
  • Divergent views: Catholics receive revelation through Scripture and Tradition, taught by the Magisterium (Dei Verbum, 1965). Many Protestants hold sola scriptura (scripture alone). Some Christians read the Bible as God's exact words; others as inspired writing by humans.
Mission 1

The Qur'an as revelation

Revelation in different traditionsHow revealedKey sourceChristiansCovenants with Noah andAbraham; Jesus, the "newcovenant"; the BibleGenesis 9:13;Genesis 12:1–3;Luke 22:20MuslimsThe Qur'an: Allah's ownword, revealed to theProphet Muhammadthrough the angel Jibril,from 610 CESurah 96:1; Surah42:51
  • Muslims believe the Qur'an is Allah's own word, revealed to the Prophet Muhammad through the angel Jibril over about 23 years, from 610 CE.
  • The first words: "Read: In the name of thy Lord Who createth" (Surah 96:1, Pickthall).
  • Allah speaks to humans only "by revelation or from behind a veil, or (that) He sendeth a messenger" (Surah 42:51, Pickthall).
  • Direct: in Surah 34:46–50 the Prophet tells people to reflect for themselves; his guidance is "because of that which my Lord hath revealed unto me" (Surah 34:50, Pickthall).
  • Divergent views: Sunni Muslims take guidance from the Qur'an and the Prophet's Sunnah; Shi'a Muslims also follow the Imams' teaching as the authoritative interpretation; Sufis seek inner knowledge of Allah through the Qur'an.
Mission 1Diversity

Nature as general revelation: contrasting beliefs

Nature: two viewsMany ChristiansAtheists, Humanistsphysicsevolution"The heavens declarethe glory of God"(Psalm 19:1)Natural processes,explained by science;awe without God
  • Many Christians: "The heavens declare the glory of God" (Psalm 19:1, WEBBE). Nature shows God's power (Romans 1:20). Catholics teach God can be known through creation by reason (CCC 36).
  • Some Protestants: Karl Barth (1886–1968) taught that nature on its own gives no true knowledge of God; only God's revelation in Christ does.
  • Atheists and Humanists: nature shows natural processes, explained by science (evolution, physics).
  • Nature also contains cruelty and disaster; to many non-religious people it does not look like the work of a loving God.
  • Humanists still feel awe at nature, without seeing it as a message from God.
Mission 1

Value and problems

Problems with revelation and responsesProblemsResponsesConflictingrevelationsReligions reportdifferent ideas ofthe divineJohn Hick(1922–2012)Differentrevelations showdifferent sides ofone ultimate realityAlternativeexplanationsIllness, drugs,tiredness, wishfulthinking orupbringingLyingA person mightinvent a revelationMistakenOr honestlymisunderstand anexperienceTestingTest the claimagainst scripture,tradition and theperson's life: "bytheir fruits"
  • Value: revelation can give knowledge of God that reason cannot; it guides life; it can lead people to faith and change their lives.
  • Conflicting revelations: religions report different ideas of the divine (personal or impersonal; one God or many forms). They cannot all be literally true.
  • Alternative explanations: illness, drugs, tiredness, wishful thinking or upbringing.
  • Lying or mistaken: a person might invent a revelation, or honestly misunderstand an experience.
  • Responses: believers test claims against scripture, tradition and the person's life ("by their fruits"). Some, like John Hick (1922–2012), suggest different revelations show different sides of one ultimate reality.
Mission 1Evaluate

"Revelation is a reliable way of knowing about God."

Argument map: revelation"Revelation is a reliable way of knowingabout God."ForIf God exists and is personal, God couldmake himself knownMany lives have been transformedScripture and tradition test claimsGeneral revelation is open to everyoneAgainstRevelations conflictThey cannot be tested by othersNatural explanations are possiblePeople can lie or be mistakenAnother viewRevelation may be reliable for the personwho receives it, but not proof for anyoneelse.Judge it byWho can check a revelation? · Do differencesbetween religions undermine all revelation, oronly some? · Do changed lives count asevidence?
  • Reasons for: if God exists and is personal, God could make himself known; many lives have been transformed; scripture and tradition test claims; general revelation is open to everyone.
  • Reasons against: revelations conflict; they cannot be tested by others; natural explanations are possible; people can lie or be mistaken.
  • Another view: revelation may be reliable for the person who receives it, but not proof for anyone else.
  • Judge it by: Who can check a revelation? Do differences between religions undermine all revelation, or only some? Do changed lives count as evidence?
Quick check
?A man says God spoke to him in a vision telling him to start a new religion. Doctors find he had a very high fever at the time. Which challenge to revelation does this illustrate?
Mission check

?An astronomer becomes convinced, from studying the stars, that the universe has a Creator. She says: "But I still don't know whether this Creator cares about me." Which response would most Christians give?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If someone sees a vision, how could anyone tell whether it really came from God?

Make a guess: If someone sees a vision, how could anyone tell whether it really came from God?

Mission 2

What is a vision?

Kinds of visionseen with the eyesin the mindin a dreammessage
  • A vision: seeing or hearing something sacred that others normally cannot: a holy figure, a light, a voice, a scene.
  • Some are seen with the eyes, some in the mind, some in dreams.
  • Visions are a form of special revelation (see Mission 1): given to particular people, often with a message.
  • Why might they lead to belief in God? They feel real and personal, can carry knowledge the person did not have, and often change lives.
Mission 2Read the source

Abram's vision

"After these things the LORD's word came to Abram in a vision, saying, 'Don't be afraid, Abram. I am your shield, your exceedingly great reward.'" (Genesis 15:1, WEBBE)

  • God takes Abram outside: "Look now towards the sky, and count the stars" (Genesis 15:5, WEBBE). His descendants will be as many.
  • "He believed in the LORD, who credited it to him for righteousness." (Genesis 15:6, WEBBE)
  • God then makes a covenant with Abram, promising the land (Genesis 15:18).

Q1 How does God describe himself to Abram?

Show answer

As his shield and his great reward: a protector.

Q2 How does Abram respond to the vision?

Show answer

He believes God: faith in God's promise.

Mission 2

The Transfiguration

The TransfigurationA voice from a bright cloud"This is my beloved Son, in whom I amwell pleased. Listen to him." (Matthew17:5)JesusMosesElijahPeterJamesJohnMatthew 17:1–13
  • Matthew 17:1–13: Jesus takes Peter, James and John up a high mountain.
  • "His face shone like the sun, and his garments became as white as the light." (Matthew 17:2, WEBBE)
  • Moses and Elijah appear, talking with Jesus.
  • A voice from a bright cloud: "This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased. Listen to him." (Matthew 17:5, WEBBE)
  • The disciples fall down in fear; Jesus tells them not to tell anyone until he is raised from the dead.
  • Significance for Christians: it shows Jesus as the Son of God; Moses (the Law) and Elijah (the Prophets) are seen as pointing to him. Three people saw it together.
Mission 2

Joan of Arc

Joan of ArcFranceOrléansRouenc. 1412Born, a French peasant girlage c. 13Voices and visions of StMichael, St Catherine and StMargaret1429Leads French forces to lift thesiege of Orléans1431Tried by a pro-English Churchcourt; burned in Rouen1456A retrial declares her innocent1920The Catholic Church canonisesher (makes her a saint)
  • Joan of Arc (c. 1412–1431), a French peasant girl.
  • From about age 13 she heard voices and saw visions of St Michael, St Catherine and St Margaret.
  • They told her to help Charles VII drive the English from France. In 1429 she led French forces to lift the siege of Orléans.
  • Captured, she was tried by a pro-English Church court and burned in Rouen in 1431.
  • A retrial declared her innocent (1456); the Catholic Church canonised her (made her a saint) in 1920.
  • For Catholics, her courage and the results of her mission are signs that the visions were genuine.
Quick check
?Why do many Christians see the Transfiguration (Matthew 17:1–13) as an important vision?
Mission 2Read the source

Maryam and the angel

Surah 19:16–22 tells how Maryam (Mary) withdrew to a place apart:

  • "Then We sent unto her Our Spirit and it assumed for her the likeness of a perfect man." (Surah 19:17, Pickthall)
  • The angel says: "I am only a messenger of thy Lord, that I may bestow on thee a faultless son." (Surah 19:19, Pickthall)
  • Maryam asks how, since no man has touched her. The reply: "Thy Lord saith: It is easy for Me." (Surah 19:21, Pickthall)
  • Muslims identify "Our Spirit" as the angel Jibril. The son is the prophet Isa (Jesus).

Q1 Why is Maryam surprised by the message?

Show answer

No man has touched her.

Q2 What does the reply show about Allah?

Show answer

His power: what he wills is easy for him.

Mission 2Diversity

Sunni, Shi'a and Sufi views of visions

Views of visionsVisionspossible?StatusTestSunni MuslimsTrue dreams canstill come fromAllahNo new law:prophecyended withMuhammad(Surah 33:40)Must notcontradict theQur'anShi'a MuslimsSome reportdreams orvisions of theImamsScholars:great cautionMust notcontradict theQur'anSufi MuslimsVisions andkashf("unveiling") onthe pathA shaykhguides how tounderstandthemMust notcontradict theQur'anSalafi MuslimsMost claimedvisions outsidethe Qur'an andSunnah rejected–Qur'an andSunnah
  • All Muslims accept the visions in the Qur'an, such as Jibril appearing to Maryam and to the Prophet Muhammad.
  • Sunni: prophecy ended with Muhammad, the Seal of the Prophets (Surah 33:40). True dreams can still come from Allah: a hadith calls a good dream one of the 46 parts of prophethood (Sahih al-Bukhari, paraphrase). They give no new law.
  • Shi'a: some report dreams or visions of the Imams, including the hidden Twelfth Imam; scholars treat such claims with great caution.
  • Sufi: visions and kashf ("unveiling") can come on the path of closeness to Allah; a Sufi teacher (shaykh) guides how to understand them.
  • Some Muslims, especially Salafi Muslims, reject most claimed visions outside the Qur'an and Sunnah.
  • Test for all: no vision may contradict the Qur'an.
Quick check
?A Muslim says she saw the Prophet Muhammad in a dream, encouraging her to pray more. Which response would most Sunni scholars give?
Mission 2

"Just hallucinations"?

Objections and religious responsesObjectionsHallucinationIllness, fever, drugs, lack of sleep or fastingWish-fulfilmentFreud (1927): people see what they long forExpectationVisions fit the person's own religionLack of evidenceNo one can check; lying or mistaken?Religious responses (not paired one-to-one)Shared visionsThree disciples saw the TransfigurationtogetherFruitsA genuine vision leads to good, lasting changeTested by traditionMust agree with scripture and Church teachingInvestigatedThe Church investigates carefully and approvesfewGod can use natural means: even if the brain isinvolved, God may be at work through it.
  • Atheists and Humanists argue visions give no proof of God.
  • Hallucinations: the brain can produce sights and voices through illness, fever, drugs, lack of sleep or fasting. Some writers suggest Joan of Arc had a neurological illness (a guess; no medical records exist).
  • Wish-fulfilment: people may see what they long for (Sigmund Freud, The Future of an Illusion, 1927).
  • Expectation: visions usually fit the person's own religion (Catholics see Mary; Hindus see Krishna).
  • Lack of evidence: no one else can check a private vision. The person might also be lying or mistaken.
Mission 2

Religious responses

Objections and religious responsesObjectionsHallucinationIllness, fever, drugs, lack of sleep or fastingWish-fulfilmentFreud (1927): people see what they long forExpectationVisions fit the person's own religionLack of evidenceNo one can check; lying or mistaken?Religious responses (not paired one-to-one)Shared visionsThree disciples saw the TransfigurationtogetherFruitsA genuine vision leads to good, lasting changeTested by traditionMust agree with scripture and Church teachingInvestigatedThe Church investigates carefully and approvesfewGod can use natural means: even if the brain isinvolved, God may be at work through it.
  • Shared visions: at the Transfiguration three disciples saw the same thing; hallucinations are usually private.
  • Fruits: a genuine vision leads to good, lasting change (Joan's courage; Abram's faith).
  • Tested by tradition: the Catholic Church investigates claims carefully and approves few. A vision must agree with scripture and Church teaching.
  • God can use natural means: even if the brain is involved, God may be at work through it.
  • Muslims: visions are judged by the Qur'an; the Qur'an itself is the clearest sign.
Quick check
?Which point would a Christian most likely use to argue that the Transfiguration was not a hallucination?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Visions prove that God exists."

Argument map: visions"Visions prove that God exists."ForVisions feel real and personalSome are shared (Matthew 17)They change lives (Joan of Arc)Some bring messages the person couldnot have knownAgainstHallucination, wish-fulfilment andexpectation explain themThey cannot be checkedVisions conflict between religionsPeople can lie or be mistakenAnother viewA vision may be strong evidence for theperson who has it, but weak evidence foranyone else.Judge it byDoes a natural cause rule out God? · Doshared visions matter? · Should the fruits of avision count as evidence?
  • Reasons for: visions feel real and personal; some are shared (Matthew 17); they change lives (Joan of Arc); some bring messages the person could not have known.
  • Reasons against: hallucination, wish-fulfilment and expectation explain them; they cannot be checked; visions conflict between religions; people can lie or be mistaken.
  • Another view: a vision may be strong evidence for the person who has it, but weak evidence for anyone else.
  • Judge it by: Does a natural cause rule out God? Do shared visions matter? Should the fruits of a vision count as evidence?
Mission check

?A woman in a small town says the Virgin Mary has appeared to her with a message. Crowds begin to gather. Which response best matches the Catholic Church's usual approach?
Mission 3

Mission 3: A sick person suddenly recovers and doctors can't explain it. Does that show God exists?

Make a guess: A sick person suddenly recovers and doctors can't explain it. Does that show God exists?

Mission 3

What is a miracle?

What makes a miracleHume"A miracle is a violationof the laws of nature"(1748)beyond thelaws ofnaturecausedby Godhas meaning(a sign)miracleDotted: a striking coincidence, seen by somebelievers as God at work
  • A miracle: an extraordinary event that seems to break the laws of nature, believed to be caused by God.
  • David Hume (1711–1776): "A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature" (An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding, 1748, Section X).
  • Believers add that a miracle has meaning: it shows something about God or answers prayer.
  • Some believers also call a striking, well-timed coincidence a miracle, if they see God at work in it.
  • Miracles are a form of special revelation (see Mission 1): God acting in the world.
Mission 3Read the source

The official's son

John 4:43–54: at Cana, a royal official begs Jesus to come and heal his dying son in Capernaum.

  • "Jesus said to him, 'Go your way. Your son lives.' The man believed the word that Jesus spoke to him, and he went his way." (John 4:50, WEBBE)
  • On the way his servants meet him: the fever left the boy at the very hour Jesus spoke.
  • "He believed, as did his whole house." (John 4:53, WEBBE)
  • John calls this "the second sign" (John 4:54): miracles are signs pointing to who Jesus is.

Q1 How was the boy healed?

Show answer

By Jesus' word, from a distance.

Q2 What was the result of the miracle?

Show answer

The official and his whole household believed.

Mission 3

Lourdes

LourdesLourdesFrancegrotto and spring1858: BernadetteSoubirous (14) reported18 appearances of theVirgin MaryClaimedcureLourdesMedicalBureau(from 1883)examines itLocalbishop candeclare amiracleA cure must be:of a serious illnesssuddencompletelastingwith no medical explanation
  • In 1858, Bernadette Soubirous (1844–1879), aged 14, reported 18 appearances of the Virgin Mary at a grotto in Lourdes, France. A spring appeared there.
  • Millions of pilgrims now visit each year; some report healings.
  • The Lourdes Medical Bureau (from 1883) examines claimed cures. A cure must be of a serious illness, sudden, complete and lasting, with no medical explanation.
  • Only then can the local bishop declare it a miracle. Very few cures pass.
  • One example: Sister Bernadette Moriau, a French nun disabled for decades, recovered suddenly in 2008 after a pilgrimage; her bishop declared it a miracle in 2018.
Mission 3

The Qur'an: the greatest miracle

Miracles in different traditionsMiraclesKey sourceMuslimsThe Qur'an itself, thegreatest miracle: no onecould produce its like. Alsothe Night Journey; thesplitting of the moon; Isahealing the sick by Allah'sleaveSurah 17:88;17:1; 54:1Muslims: divergent viewsMany Sufis accept karamat(wonders granted to saints);Salafi Muslims reject mostsuch claims; some read someaccounts symbolically–
  • Muslims believe the Qur'an itself is the greatest miracle: the Prophet could not read or write, yet brought words no one could match.
  • "Say: Verily, though mankind and the jinn should assemble to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce the like thereof" (Surah 17:88, Pickthall).
  • In Surah 17:89–93 unbelievers demand other signs; the Prophet replies: "Am I aught save a mortal messenger?" (Surah 17:93, Pickthall).
  • Other miracles: the Night Journey (Surah 17:1); the splitting of the moon (Surah 54:1); miracles of earlier prophets, such as Isa healing the sick by Allah's leave.
  • Divergent views: many Sufis accept karamat (wonders granted to saints); Salafi Muslims reject most such claims; some modern Muslims read some miracle accounts symbolically.
Quick check
?In John 4:43–54, what leads the royal official and his household to believe?
Mission 3

The argument from miracles

The argument from miraclesMiracles happen.1Only God could cause them.2So God exists.3Strengthseyewitness accounts across centuries · curesexamined by doctors (Lourdes) · lives changed ·miracles fit a God who cares and actsWeaknessesEvery step can be challenged.
  • 1. Miracles happen. 2. Only God could cause them. 3. So God exists.
  • Strengths: eyewitness accounts across centuries; cures examined by doctors (Lourdes); lives changed; miracles fit a God who cares and acts.
  • Christians also see miracles as signs of who Jesus is (John 4:54) and of God's love.
  • Muslims: anyone can still examine the Qur'an, the miracle that remains.
  • Weaknesses: every step can be challenged.
Mission 3

Scientific and Humanist objections

Objections and religious responsesObjectionsResponsesHume (1748)Experience ofnature's lawsoutweighstestimony; rivalreligions' miraclescancel outLaws describe, GodactsThe God who madethe laws can act innew waysScienceSpontaneousremission, placebo,wrong diagnosis,coincidence;unexplained is notexplained by GodCareful testingLourdes doctors(believers andnon-believers)reject most claimsUnfairnessWhy heal oneperson and notmillions? (Wiles,1986)Signs, not showsRare by purpose,pointing to God
  • Hume (Enquiry, 1748, Section X): our experience that the laws of nature hold is very strong; a report of a miracle is weaker. "A wise man, therefore, proportions his belief to the evidence."
  • Hume adds: few reliable witnesses; people love wonder stories; and miracles from rival religions cancel each other out.
  • Science: cures can come from spontaneous remission, the placebo effect, wrong diagnosis or coincidence.
  • Unexplained is not the same as explained by God: science may explain it later.
  • Unfairness: why would God heal one person and not millions of others? (Maurice Wiles, 1923–2005, God's Action in the World, 1986.)
  • Humanists: wonder at nature, but trust evidence; no miracle has passed a controlled test.
Mission 3

Religious responses

  • Careful testing: Lourdes doctors (believers and non-believers) reject most claims. The Church does not call every recovery a miracle.
  • Laws describe, God acts: laws of nature describe what normally happens; the God who made them can act in new ways.
  • Signs, not shows: miracles are rare by purpose, pointing to God, not solving every problem.
  • Muslims: the Qur'an's challenge (Surah 17:88) still stands for anyone to test.
Quick check
?Which of these is one of David Hume's reasons for not believing reports of miracles?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Miracles prove that God exists."

Argument map: miracles"Miracles prove that God exists."ForExamined cures with no medicalexplanation (Lourdes)Eyewitness accounts (John 4)Changed livesThe Qur'an as a lasting miracle anyone canexamineAgainstHume: testimony is weaker thanexperience of nature's lawsSpontaneous remission and placeboRival miracle claimsWhy heal some and not others?Another viewA miracle may strengthen faith for thosewho already believe, without proving Godto sceptics.Judge it byIs "no explanation yet" good evidence? · Cantestimony ever outweigh experience? · Whyare miracles rare?
  • Reasons for: examined cures with no medical explanation (Lourdes); eyewitness accounts (John 4); changed lives.
  • Also for: the Qur'an as a lasting miracle anyone can examine.
  • Reasons against: Hume: testimony is weaker than experience of nature's laws; spontaneous remission and placebo; rival miracle claims; why heal some and not others?
  • Another view: a miracle may strengthen faith for those who already believe, without proving God to sceptics.
  • Judge it by: Is "no explanation yet" good evidence? Can testimony ever outweigh experience? Why are miracles rare?
Mission check

?A footballer's tumour vanishes before his operation, and doctors cannot explain why. His church calls it a miracle. Which objection would a Humanist most likely make?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When someone says they have experienced God, should anyone else believe them?

Make a guess: When someone says they have experienced God, should anyone else believe them?

Mission 4

What is a religious experience?

Kinds of religious experienceJames (1902): mystical states areineffablenoetictransientpassivemysticalnuminouscharismaticworship andsacramentsvisionsconversionencounterwith God orultimatereality
  • A religious experience: an experience in which a person believes they have encountered God or ultimate reality.
  • It may be sudden or gradual, alone or with others, ordinary or overwhelming.
  • William James (1842–1910), The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902), said mystical states are hard to put into words (ineffable), feel like knowledge (noetic), do not last long (transient), and happen to the person (passive).
  • For many believers it is the most direct evidence of God they have.
Mission 4

Kinds of religious experience

Kinds of religious experienceJames (1902): mystical states areineffablenoetictransientpassivemysticalnuminouscharismaticworship andsacramentsvisionsconversionencounterwith God orultimatereality
  • Conversion: a change of heart, belief or religion.
  • Mystical: a sense of union with God or ultimate reality, beyond words.
  • Numinous: awe and fear before a holy power. Rudolf Otto (1869–1937), The Idea of the Holy (1917): the holy is a mystery that makes us tremble yet draws us in.
  • Charismatic: gifts of the Holy Spirit, such as glossolalia (speaking in tongues: Acts 2:4), prophecy and healing.
  • Worship and sacraments: Catholics believe Christ is truly present in the Mass; many feel God's presence in prayer and liturgy.
Mission 4Read the source

The burning bush

"The LORD's angel appeared to him in a flame of fire out of the middle of a bush. He looked, and behold, the bush burnt with fire, and the bush was not consumed." (Exodus 3:2, WEBBE)

  • God calls: "Take off your sandals, for the place you are standing on is holy ground." (Exodus 3:5, WEBBE)
  • "Moses hid his face because he was afraid to look at God." (Exodus 3:6, WEBBE)
  • God reveals his name, "I AM WHO I AM" (Exodus 3:14), and sends Moses to free Israel.

Q1 Which words show this is a numinous experience?

Show answer

"Holy ground"; Moses hid his face because he was afraid: awe and fear.

Q2 Why can Christians and Jews call it revelation?

Show answer

God makes his name and his purpose known.

Mission 4

Conversion

The Damascus roadMediterraneanSeaJerusalemDamascus"suddenly a light from the sky shone aroundhim" … "Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?"(Acts 9:3–4)Saul → PaulBlinded three days, baptised: the greatmissionary
  • Saul, a persecutor of Christians, travels to Damascus: "suddenly a light from the sky shone around him." (Acts 9:3, WEBBE)
  • He hears: "Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?" … "I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting." (Acts 9:4–5, WEBBE)
  • Blinded for three days, he is baptised and becomes Paul, the great missionary.
  • Some conversions are sudden like this; many are gradual.
Quick check
?Which of these is the clearest example of a numinous experience?
Mission 4

Christian attitudes: welcome and caution

Christian and Muslim attitudes to religious experienceChristiansMuslimsCCC 66–67Public revelation iscomplete in Christ;private revelationsadd nothing to itTestedThe Church does notapprove everyexperience: scripture,teaching, the person,the fruitsMany Protestants"test the spirits,whether they are ofGod" (1 John 4:1)Pentecostal,charismaticExpect experiences ofthe Spirit, such asglossolalia, todayQuakersWait in silence forthe inner lightSigns already clearSurah 2:118: Allah'ssigns are clear in theQur'an and creationCloseness in prayer"in the remembranceof Allah do heartsfind rest!" (Surah13:28)SunniValue prayer,recitation and truedreams; cautiousabout claimedexperiencesShi'aMourning for ImamHusayn (Muharram);visiting shrines of theImamsSufiSeek directexperience throughdhikr (remembrance)and fana (passingaway of the self)
  • CCC 66–67 (paraphrase): God's public revelation is complete in Christ; no new public revelation will come before his return.
  • Private revelations, even those the Church recognises, add nothing to faith; they can help people live it more fully. None can correct or go beyond Christ.
  • So the Church does not approve every experience: it tests whether one agrees with scripture and teaching, and looks at the person and the fruits.
  • Many Protestants test experiences by scripture: "test the spirits, whether they are of God" (1 John 4:1, WEBBE).
  • Pentecostal and charismatic Christians (including Catholic charismatics) expect experiences of the Spirit, such as glossolalia, today.
  • Quakers wait in silence for the inner light. Experience as revelation: God still makes himself known personally (Exodus 3 as the model).
Mission 4

Muslim attitudes

Christian and Muslim attitudes to religious experienceChristiansMuslimsCCC 66–67Public revelation iscomplete in Christ;private revelationsadd nothing to itTestedThe Church does notapprove everyexperience: scripture,teaching, the person,the fruitsMany Protestants"test the spirits,whether they are ofGod" (1 John 4:1)Pentecostal,charismaticExpect experiences ofthe Spirit, such asglossolalia, todayQuakersWait in silence forthe inner lightSigns already clearSurah 2:118: Allah'ssigns are clear in theQur'an and creationCloseness in prayer"in the remembranceof Allah do heartsfind rest!" (Surah13:28)SunniValue prayer,recitation and truedreams; cautiousabout claimedexperiencesShi'aMourning for ImamHusayn (Muharram);visiting shrines of theImamsSufiSeek directexperience throughdhikr (remembrance)and fana (passingaway of the self)
  • "Those who have no knowledge say: Why doth not Allah speak unto us, or some sign come unto us? … We have made clear the revelations for people who are sure." (Surah 2:118, Pickthall)
  • Muslims take from this: Allah's signs are already clear in the Qur'an and creation. Demanding a private experience is not needed for faith.
  • Yet believers find closeness to Allah in prayer: "Verily in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find rest!" (Surah 13:28, Pickthall)
  • Sunni: value prayer, Qur'an recitation and true dreams, but are cautious about claimed experiences.
  • Shi'a: deep experience in mourning for Imam Husayn (Muharram) and visiting shrines of the Imams.
  • Sufi: seek direct experience of Allah through dhikr (remembrance) and fana (passing away of the self); some Sunni scholars warn against claims that go beyond the Qur'an.
Mission 4

The argument from religious experience

The argument from religious experienceMillions, in every age and culture,report experiences of God1The best explanation is that God exists2So God probably exists3Support for step 2: Swinburne (1979)CredulityIf it seems somethingis present, it probablyis, unless there isreason to doubtTestimonyBelieve what othersreport, unless thereis reason to doubtthemChanged lives (Paul) add weight.
  • 1. Millions of people, in every age and culture, report experiences of God. 2. The best explanation is that God exists. 3. So God probably exists.
  • Richard Swinburne (b. 1934), The Existence of God (1979), principle of credulity: if it seems to you that something is present, it probably is, unless there is a special reason to doubt (paraphrase).
  • Principle of testimony: we should believe what others report, unless there is reason to doubt them (paraphrase).
  • Lives changed by experience (Paul) add weight.
  • Divergent: many believers say an experience is strong evidence for the one who has it, but not proof for others.
Mission 4

Challenges from atheists and Humanists

Challenges and responsesChallengesHallucinationIllness, drugs, tiredness or fastingWish-fulfilmentFreud (1927): longing for a protective fatherLack of evidence; lying or mistakenPrivate experiences cannot be checkedCulture shapes experienceChristians meet Jesus, Hindus Krishna,Buddhists no GodReligious responses (not paired one-to-one)Shared experiencesPentecost: a whole group filled with the Spirit(Acts 2)Fruits"By their fruits you will know them" (Matthew7:16)TestingChecked against scripture and teaching; mostare not approvedOne reality?Different responses to one divine reality; or onetradition's account is trueGod may use natural means: brain activity doesnot show God is absent.
  • Hallucination: illness, drugs, tiredness or fasting can produce powerful experiences.
  • Wish-fulfilment: Sigmund Freud (1856–1939), The Future of an Illusion (1927): belief in God answers our longing for a protective father.
  • Lack of evidence: private experiences cannot be checked by others.
  • Culture shapes experience: Christians meet Jesus, Hindus meet Krishna, Buddhists find no God. If the source were one God, why so different?
  • Lying or mistaken: some claims are invented; honest people can misread a feeling.
  • Humanists: the experiences are real, but have natural, psychological causes.
Mission 4

Religious responses

Challenges and responsesChallengesHallucinationIllness, drugs, tiredness or fastingWish-fulfilmentFreud (1927): longing for a protective fatherLack of evidence; lying or mistakenPrivate experiences cannot be checkedCulture shapes experienceChristians meet Jesus, Hindus Krishna,Buddhists no GodReligious responses (not paired one-to-one)Shared experiencesPentecost: a whole group filled with the Spirit(Acts 2)Fruits"By their fruits you will know them" (Matthew7:16)TestingChecked against scripture and teaching; mostare not approvedOne reality?Different responses to one divine reality; or onetradition's account is trueGod may use natural means: brain activity doesnot show God is absent.
  • Fruits: "By their fruits you will know them." (Matthew 7:16, WEBBE) A lasting change for good (Paul) is hard to explain as illusion.
  • Shared experiences: at Pentecost a whole group was filled with the Spirit (Acts 2).
  • Testing: traditions check claims against scripture and teaching; most are not approved.
  • God may use natural means: brain activity during an experience does not show God is absent.
  • Different traditions, one reality? Some believers see differences as different responses to the same divine reality; others think their own tradition's account is the true one.
Quick check
?After her husband dies, a lonely woman feels God's comforting presence every evening. A critic says: "She feels this because she badly longs for comfort." Which challenge is the critic using?
Mission 4Evaluate

"Religious experience proves that God exists."

Argument map: religious experience"Religious experience proves that Godexists."ForExperiences are widespreadChanged livesSome are sharedPrinciples of credulity and testimony(Swinburne)AgainstHallucination; wish-fulfilment (Freud)They cannot be checkedExperiences differ between religionsPeople can lie or be mistakenAnother viewReligious experience may justify belief forthe one who has it, without proving God toanyone else.Church view: experiences must be tested;even approved ones add nothing torevelation in Christ (CCC 67).Judge it byIs a natural cause the whole story? · Shouldwe trust what seems real to us? · Dodifferences between religions weaken everyclaim?
  • Reasons for: experiences are widespread; changed lives; some are shared.
  • Also for: principles of credulity and testimony (Swinburne).
  • Reasons against: hallucination, wish-fulfilment (Freud); cannot be checked; experiences differ between religions; people can lie or be mistaken.
  • Another view: religious experience may justify belief for the one who has it, without proving God to anyone else.
  • Church view: experiences must be tested; even approved ones add nothing to revelation in Christ (CCC 67).
  • Judge it by: Is a natural cause the whole story? Should we trust what seems real to us? Do differences between religions weaken every claim?
Mission check

?Amir, a Muslim, says that during dhikr (chanting in remembrance of Allah) he felt Allah very close. His atheist friend says it was the rhythm and the breathing. His Christian friend asks whether Amir's life has changed for the better since. Which statement is accurate?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Revelation is God making himself known: special (prophets, visions, miracles, Jesus, scripture received) and general (nature, conscience, reason, scripture read by all).
  • Christians see Jesus as the culmination of revelation (Hebrews 1:1–4); Muslims see the Qur'an as Allah's word revealed through Jibril.
  • Problems: conflicting revelations, alternative explanations, lying or mistake; believers reply with tests of scripture, tradition and fruits.

Mission 2

  • A vision is a form of special revelation: seeing or hearing something sacred. Examples: Abram (Genesis 15), the Transfiguration (Matthew 17), Joan of Arc.
  • Maryam and Jibril (Surah 19:16–22); Sunni, Shi'a and Sufi Muslims judge visions by the Qur'an.
  • Atheists and Humanists explain visions as hallucinations, wish-fulfilment or expectation; believers point to shared visions, fruits and testing by tradition.

Mission 3

  • A miracle is an extraordinary event, beyond the laws of nature, believed to be caused by God and to carry meaning: John 4:43–54; Lourdes (Bernadette Moriau).
  • Muslims see the Qur'an as the greatest miracle (Surah 17:88).
  • The argument from miracles faces Hume's challenge, scientific explanations and the "why some?" problem; believers reply with careful testing and the meaning of signs.

Mission 4

  • Religious experience: conversion, mystical, numinous, charismatic, worship and sacraments.
  • Exodus 3 (the burning bush) and Acts 9 (Saul on the Damascus road) are key examples.
  • Catholics welcome but test experiences: private revelations add nothing to Christ (CCC 66–67); Muslims see Allah's signs as already clear (Surah 2:118).
  • Challenges: hallucination, wish-fulfilment, lack of evidence, cultural differences; responses: fruits, shared experiences, testing.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Catholic Christianity: Arguments for the Existence of God (part 1) for Edexcel GCSE Religious Studies A. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If God exists, how could anyone ever know what God is like?
  2. Mission 2If someone sees a vision, how could anyone tell whether it really came from God?
  3. Mission 3A sick person suddenly recovers and doctors can't explain it. Does that show God exists?
  4. Mission 4When someone says they have experienced God, should anyone else believe them?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel