← IGCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel International GCSE Religious Studies (4RS1) · Paper 1 (Hinduism) Section 1: The universe, creation and the place of human beings; Paper 1 (Hinduism) Section 2: Life and death
Mini-Lesson

Hinduism: The universe, creation and the place of human beings; life and death

7 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If the universe is born, dies and is born again, which part of the cycle are we in now?
  2. Mission 2If you are not your body and not your mind, what are you, and where do you go next?
  3. Mission 3If your life now is shaped by what you did before, are you still free to choose?
  4. Mission 4Can one ultimate reality be beyond all description and also a God you can love?
  5. Mission 5Is there one right way to live, or does the right thing depend on who you are and when?
  6. Mission 6If your past actions shape your life now, are you still free, and how should you treat others who suffer?
  7. Mission 7Can a nurse, a scholar, a meditator and a singer all be on the same spiritual path?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If the universe is born, dies and is born again, which part of the cycle are we in now?

Make a guess: If the universe is born, dies and is born again, which part of the cycle are we in now?

Mission 1

A universe that breathes

A universe that breathescreation(Brahma)preser-vation(Vishnu)dissolution(Shiva)rest1 kalpa (a day of Brahma) = 1,000cycles of the four agesBhagavad Gita 8.17 (Arnold)"If ye know Brahma's Day / Which is athousand Yugas"
  • Most Hindus see time as cyclical: universes come into being, last, and dissolve, again and again, without beginning or end.
  • Each cycle: creation (Brahma) → preservation (Vishnu) → dissolution (Shiva). Then rest, then a new creation.
  • One "day of Brahma" (a kalpa) lasts 1,000 cycles of the four ages:
  • "If ye know Brahma's Day / Which is a thousand Yugas; if ye know / The thousand Yugas making Brahma's Night" (Bhagavad Gita 8.17, Arnold).
  • Each cycle has four ages (yugas); many Hindus believe we now live in the last and darkest, the Kali Yuga.
  • Purpose: the universe gives every atman the chance to act, learn and in the end reach moksha.
Mission 1Read the source

The Hymn of Creation

The Hymn of CreationRig Veda 10.129: Nasadiya Sukta(paraphrase)?v. 1neither existence nor non-existencev. 2That One, breathing without breathvv. 3–4desire, the first seed of mindvv. 6–7Who really knows?

Rig Veda 10.129, the Nasadiya Sukta (paraphrase):

  • In the beginning there was neither existence nor non-existence; no air, no sky beyond (v. 1).
  • There was no death, no immortality, no day or night: only That One, breathing without breath (v. 2).
  • Darkness was hidden in darkness; from heat (tapas) That One was born; then came desire, the first seed of mind (vv. 3–4).
  • Who really knows? Where did creation come from? The gods came after the world was made, so who knows where it came from? (v. 6)
  • Whether it was made or not, the one who watches over it in the highest heaven surely knows, or perhaps he does not know (v. 7).

Q1 Why can't the gods explain creation, according to v. 6?

Show answer

They came after it.

Q2 What attitude does the hymn end with?

Show answer

Humble questioning: even the highest may not know.

Mission 1

Creation stories and Aum

Creation storyAumAum (Om):first soundlotus: Brahmaborn in itserpent Sheshacosmic ocean, between cyclesA widely told story (Puranas)Vishnu rests on the serpent Shesha on thecosmic ocean. A lotus grows from his navel; init Brahma is born and creates the worlds.
  • A widely told story (Puranas): between cycles, Vishnu lies on the serpent Shesha on the cosmic ocean. A lotus grows from his navel; in it Brahma is born and creates the worlds.
  • Aum (Om): many Hindus say the universe begins as sacred sound; Aum is that first vibration and stands for Brahman. It is chanted at the start and end of prayers.
  • Different stories, one message: the universe comes from the divine and depends on it.
Mission 1

Prakriti and purusha

Matter and spiritPurushaspirit, pureconsciousnessPrakriti: matterbody, senses, mindsattvagoodness, light, calmrajaspassion, activity, desiretamasdarkness, laziness,ignoranceBondage = spirit identifying itself with matter
  • Prakriti: matter, nature: everything physical, including the body, the senses and even the mind.
  • Purusha: spirit, pure consciousness, which is not made of matter.
  • Bondage = spirit identifying itself with matter.
Mission 1

The three gunas

Matter and spiritPurushaspirit, pureconsciousnessPrakriti: matterbody, senses, mindsattvagoodness, light, calmrajaspassion, activity, desiretamasdarkness, laziness,ignoranceBondage = spirit identifying itself with matter
  • All of prakriti is made of three gunas (qualities, or "strands"), mixed in different amounts:
  • Sattva: goodness, light, purity, calm, wisdom.
  • Rajas: passion, activity, desire, restlessness.
  • Tamas: darkness, laziness, ignorance, decay.
  • "Sattwan, Rajas, and Tamas, so are named / The qualities of Nature" (Bhagavad Gita 14.5, Arnold).
  • Foods, actions and people show them: fresh fruit (sattva), spicy food (rajas), stale food or alcohol (tamas).
  • Human nature: a person's character is shaped by the gunas. Hindus try to grow sattva, then rise beyond all three.
Quick check
?Arjun stays up all night gaming, skips breakfast, and spends the next day too sluggish to do anything. Which guna do Hindus say is dominating him?
Mission 1Evaluate

"Hindu cosmology fits well with modern science."

Does Hindu cosmology fit well with modern science?"Hindu cosmology fits well with modernscience."ForAn immense, ancient universe (billions ofyears), not a young one; endless cyclesecho some cyclic models in physics.Rig Veda 10.129 asks open questions, likea scientist.Many Hindus see no conflict, readingyugas (ages) and lokas (worlds) spiritually.AgainstMainstream cosmology: one universe,about 13.8 billion years old, with noevidence that it repeats.Texts speak of lokas, devas and asuras,which science cannot test.Some Hindus read the yuga figuresliterally and some do not, so "fit" dependson the reading.Judge it byAre religion and science answering the samequestion (how or why)? · Should ancientnumbers be read literally? · Does a "fit" makea belief more true, or only easier to hold?
  • Reasons for: an immense, ancient universe (billions of years) rather than a young one; endless cycles echo some cyclic models in physics. Rig Veda 10.129 asks open questions, like a scientist. Many Hindus see no conflict, reading yugas (ages) and lokas (worlds) spiritually.
  • Reasons against: current mainstream cosmology describes one universe, about 13.8 billion years old, with no evidence that it repeats. Texts speak of lokas, devas and asuras (heavenly beings and their rivals), which science cannot test. Some Hindus read the yuga figures literally and some do not, so "fit" depends on the reading.
  • Judge it by: Are religion and science answering the same question (how or why)? Should ancient numbers be read literally? Does a "fit" make a belief more true, or only easier to hold?
Mission check

?A Hindu grandfather tells his granddaughter: "This world is not the first, and it won't be the last. Everything in it is made of three strands, and it all comes from the divine." Which summary fits his view?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If you are not your body and not your mind, what are you, and where do you go next?

Make a guess: If you are not your body and not your mind, what are you, and where do you go next?

Mission 2

The atman: the real you

Layers of a personbody(prakriti: matter)mind(prakriti: matter)atmaneternal selfBhagavad Gita 2.20 (Arnold)"Never the spirit was born; the spirit shallcease to be never"
  • Atman = the eternal self, or soul, in every living being: humans, animals, plants.
  • It is not the body and not the mind: both are part of prakriti (matter) and change; the atman does not.
  • "Never the spirit was born; the spirit shall cease to be never" (Bhagavad Gita 2.20, Arnold).
Mission 2Read the source

Changing clothes

Changing clothesworn-out robesnew onesthe spiritBhagavad Gita 2.22 (Arnold)"Nay, but as when one layeth / His worn-outrobes away, / And taking new ones, sayeth, /“These will I wear to-day!” / So putteth by thespirit / Lightly its garb of flesh, / And passethto inherit / A residence afresh."

> "Nay, but as when one layeth / His worn-out robes away, / And taking new ones, sayeth, / "These will I wear to-day!" / So putteth by the spirit / Lightly its garb of flesh, / And passeth to inherit / A residence afresh." (Bhagavad Gita 2.22, Arnold)

Q1 In the image, what are the clothes, and who is the wearer?

Show answer

The clothes are bodies; the wearer is the atman.

Q2 What does this suggest about how a Hindu might face death?

Show answer

Calmly: death is a change of clothes, not the end of the self.

Mission 2

Samsara: the wheel of rebirth

Samsarabirthlifedeathrebirthmoksha: release
  • Samsara: the endless cycle of birth, death and rebirth (reincarnation).
  • At death the atman leaves the body and takes a new one: human, animal or other, in this world or another loka.
  • What decides the next birth? Karma: the results of past actions (see Mission 3).
  • Samsara is seen as full of suffering and impermanence. The goal is to escape it.
Quick check
?Which statement matches the Hindu idea of the atman?
Mission 2

Why we stay stuck: avidya, maya, attachment

What binds the atmanatmanavidya (ignorance)attachmentmayaThe keyknowledge · devotion · detachment (vairagya)
  • Avidya = ignorance: not knowing who we really are; thinking "I am this body".
  • Maya = the power that makes the changing world seem to be all there is (see Mission 1).
  • From ignorance come selfishness, greed and anger: we grab for things that cannot satisfy the atman.
  • In Hindu thought, sin is action against dharma that comes from this ignorance; it creates bad karma and binds the atman.
  • Detachment (vairagya): acting and enjoying life without clinging. "The soul which is not moved ... / Takes sorrow and takes joy indifferently, / Lives in the life undying!" (Bhagavad Gita 2.15, Arnold)
Mission 2

Moksha: liberation

Moksha: liberationsamsaraMoksha: release; theatman is free andnever rebornReached through knowledge, devotion, selflessaction or meditationJivanmukti: free while alive"When all desires dwelling in the heart cease,then the mortal becomes immortal and attainsBrahman here." (Katha Upanishad 6.14,Paramananda)
  • Moksha: release from samsara; the atman is free and is never reborn.
  • Reached through knowledge, devotion, selfless action or meditation.
  • Jivanmukti: being liberated while still alive. "When all desires dwelling in the heart cease, then the mortal becomes immortal and attains Brahman here." (Katha Upanishad 6.14, Paramananda)
Mission 2Diversity

Atman and Brahman: one or two?

Atman and Brahman: one or two?Advaita Vedanta"non-dual"; Shankara, c. 8thcentury CEAtman is Brahman. Moksha =realising this identity. A monistview.Vishishtadvaita"qualified non-dual"; Ramanuja,traditionally 1017–1137Atman is a real part of God, as abody belongs to a soul: one withGod, yet distinct.Dvaita"dual"; Madhva, 1238–1317Atman and God (Vishnu) areeternally distinct. Moksha =eternal, blissful service to God. Amonotheist view.Brahman / Godatmandevotion"tat tvam asi": "you are that" (ChandogyaUpanishad 6.13)Advaitins read it as identity; Ramanuja andMadhva read it differently.
  • Advaita Vedanta ("non-dual"; Shankara, c. 8th century CE): atman is Brahman. The sense of being separate is avidya. Moksha = realising this identity. A monist view.
  • Vishishtadvaita ("qualified non-dual"; Ramanuja, traditionally 1017–1137): atman is a real part of God, as a body belongs to a soul: one with God, yet distinct.
  • Dvaita ("dual"; Madhva, 1238–1317): atman and God (Vishnu) are eternally distinct. Moksha = eternal, blissful service to God. A monotheist view.
  • The sage Uddalaka teaches his son Svetaketu: as salt dissolved in water is everywhere in it though unseen, so is the Self; "tat tvam asi": "you are that" (Chandogya Upanishad 6.13, paraphrase). Advaitins read this as identity; Ramanuja and Madhva read it differently.
Quick check
?A follower of Madhva's Dvaita Vedanta reads "tat tvam asi" ("you are that"). Which interpretation would they most likely give?
Mission 2

Why it matters today

Why it matters todayRespect for lifethe same kind of atman lives in everybeing, so many Hindus are vegetarianand practise ahimsaFacing deathantyesti: cremation, which manyHindus believe helps release theatman; ashes often scattered in theGanges or another riverLiving wellevery action shapes the next life; thelong goal is mokshaEqualitymany Hindus stress that the atmanhas no caste, gender or race
  • Respect for life: the same kind of atman lives in every being, so many Hindus are vegetarian and practise ahimsa.
  • Facing death: funerals (antyesti) include cremation, which many Hindus believe helps release the atman; ashes are often scattered in the Ganges or another river.
  • Living well: every action shapes the next life; the long goal is moksha.
  • Equality: many Hindus stress that the atman has no caste, gender or race.
Mission 2Evaluate

"The atman and Brahman are identical."

Are the atman and Brahman identical?"The atman and Brahman are identical."For"tat tvam asi" (Chandogya 6.8.7 andfollowing) read literally.Brihadaranyaka 4.4.6: one free of desire,being Brahman, goes to Brahman(paraphrase).Advaita explains why the self feelslimited: avidya. Mystics describeexperiences of unity.AgainstIf the atman were already Brahman, howcould it be ignorant? (Ramanuja'sobjection)The Gita speaks of loving devotion toKrishna, which needs two.Dvaita: identity would leave no one toenjoy God's love.Judge it byWhich reading fits the most scriptures? ·What happens to devotion (bhakti) on eachview? · Does the view explain suffering andignorance?
  • Reasons for: "tat tvam asi" (Chandogya 6.8.7 and following) read literally; the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad (4.4.6) says one free of desire, being Brahman, goes to Brahman (paraphrase). Advaita explains why the self feels limited: avidya. Mystics describe experiences of unity.
  • Reasons against: if the atman were already Brahman, how could it be ignorant? (Ramanuja's objection). The Gita speaks of loving devotion to Krishna, which needs two. Dvaita: identity would leave no one to enjoy God's love.
  • Judge it by: Which reading fits the most scriptures? What happens to devotion (bhakti) on each view? Does the view explain suffering and ignorance?
Mission 2Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Samsara and moksha: worked answerTeaching 1the atman is reborn in body after body(samsara).Source"So putteth by the spirit / Lightly its garb offlesh" (Gita 2.22).Developmentso Hindus see death as a change, not an end,and try to live well because their deeds shapetheir next life.Teaching 2the goal is moksha, release from samsara.DevelopmentAdvaitins see it as realising that atman isBrahman; Dvaita Hindus as eternal lovingservice to God; either way, it is the final end ofsuffering.

Question: Explain Hindu teachings about samsara and moksha.

  • Teaching 1: the atman is reborn in body after body (samsara). Source: "So putteth by the spirit / Lightly its garb of flesh" (Gita 2.22). Development: so Hindus see death as a change, not an end, and try to live well because their deeds shape their next life.
  • Teaching 2: the goal is moksha, release from samsara. Development: Advaitins see it as realising that atman is Brahman; Dvaita Hindus as eternal loving service to God; either way, it is the final end of suffering.
Mission check

?Anika's great-grandmother dies peacefully. At the funeral a Hindu priest says: "Her body has been laid aside, but she has not ended. May she be free and not return." Which beliefs lie behind his words?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If your life now is shaped by what you did before, are you still free to choose?

Make a guess: If your life now is shaped by what you did before, are you still free to choose?

Mission 3

Karma means action

Karma means actionActionthought, word, deedintentionResultfor the one who actsagainIntention mattersGood actions bring good results; harmfulactions bring suffering, in this life or a futureone. An accident is not the same as a cruel act.
  • Karma = "action", and the results that follow from it.
  • The law of karma: every intentional action (thought, word, deed) has a consequence for the one who does it.
  • Good actions bring good results; harmful actions bring suffering, in this life or a future one.
  • Karma is about intention: an accident is not the same as a cruel act.
Mission 3

Karma and samsara

Both chains bindsamsaragolden chain:good karmaa better rebirthiron chain:bad karmaa harder rebirthBoth bindAll karma, good or bad, keeps the atman insamsara.freedom from binding karma →moksha
  • Karma decides the next birth: what kind of body, family and circumstances the atman is born into.
  • Good karma → a better rebirth, perhaps in a higher loka. Bad karma → a harder rebirth.
  • But all karma, good or bad, keeps the atman in samsara: some Hindus say good karma is a golden chain, but still a chain.
  • So the goal is not just good karma: it is to be free of binding karma, which leads to moksha.
Mission 3

Three kinds of karma

Three kinds of karmasanchitathe store: all karma from past lives (the arrowsin the quiver)prarabdharipening now: body, family, manycircumstances (the arrow already shot: itcannot be called back)kriyamanabeing made now by today's choices (the arrowon the bow: still your choice)SPK
  • Sanchita karma: the whole store of karma from all past lives.
  • Prarabdha karma: the part that has begun to ripen in this life: your body, family, many circumstances.
  • Kriyamana karma: karma being created now by today's choices; it will ripen later.
  • Classic picture: an archer. Arrows in the quiver = sanchita. An arrow already shot = prarabdha (it cannot be called back). The arrow now on the bow = kriyamana (still your choice).
Quick check
?In the archer picture, which kind of karma is the arrow already flying through the air?
Mission 3

Karma is not fate

Karma is not fateFateeverything is fixed;you can do nothingKarmayour past shapedwhere you start,but you choosewhat you do nowstart: prarabdhaforks: kriyamana(your choice)
  • Fate says: everything is fixed and you can do nothing. Karma says: your past shaped where you start, but you choose what you do now.
  • Prarabdha sets some limits: you cannot choose your birth, your body or some events.
  • Kriyamana is free: how you respond to those limits creates new karma.
  • Freedom and its limits: the gunas (see Mission 1) and old habits pull on us, but humans can choose; that is why humans, more than animals, can work towards moksha.
  • So karma makes people responsible: blaming "fate" is not an excuse.
Mission 3

Sakam and nishkam karma

Sakam and nishkam karma£sakamwith desire forresults: bindsnishkamwithout selfishdesire: does not bindBhagavad Gita 2.47 (Arnold)"Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruitwhich comes from them."
  • Sakam karma: action done with desire for its results (reward, praise, profit). It creates binding karma and keeps the atman in samsara.
  • Nishkam karma: action done without selfish desire, as duty or as an offering to God. It does not bind.
  • "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them." (Bhagavad Gita 2.47, Arnold)
  • This is the heart of karma yoga, the path of action (see Mission 7).
  • Example: helping at a food bank to look good on social media (sakam) or simply because it is right and an offering to God (nishkam).
Mission 3

Karma, suffering and freedom

Karma and sufferingSufferingA chance to use up old karma and growspirituallyRespond with compassion (daya) andservice (seva): these are dutiesGood kriyamana karma: being made nowKarma does not mean "they deserve it, sodon't help".
  • Why do people suffer? Many Hindus answer: partly because of karma from past actions, in this life or earlier ones.
  • But karma does not mean "they deserve it, so don't help": compassion (daya) and service (seva) are duties, and they create good karma.
  • Suffering can be a chance to use up old karma and grow spiritually.
  • Purpose of life: to learn through experience, act rightly and in the end reach moksha.
Mission 3Diversity

Who runs the law of karma?

Who runs the law of karma?Who gives results?Can it be changed?An impersonal law (some Hindus)no one: a natural law,like gravity; no judgeis neededresults follow actionsGod as overseer (many Vaishnava and ShaivaHindus)God gives the fruits ofkarma fairlyyes: God can forgiveand show graceGrace beyond karma (bhakti traditions)Godsurrender to God(Ramanuja's prapatti)can free a devotee fromthe bonds of karma
  • An impersonal law: some Hindus see karma as a natural law, like gravity: no judge is needed.
  • God as overseer: many Vaishnava and Shaiva Hindus believe God gives the fruits of karma fairly, and can also forgive and show grace.
  • Grace beyond karma: in bhakti traditions, surrender to God can free a devotee from the bonds of karma (Ramanuja's prapatti, "surrender").
Mission 3Evaluate

"Karma is a fair explanation of suffering."

Is karma a fair explanation of suffering?"Karma is a fair explanation of suffering."ForIt makes the universe just: nothinghappens without a cause.It makes people responsible for theiractions.It explains why good people may suffer(karma from earlier lives).AgainstNo one remembers past lives, so it is hardto learn from them.It could be misused to blame victims ofillness, poverty or caste.Many Hindus add God's grace orcompassion, suggesting karma alone is notthe whole answer.Judge it byIs it fair to be affected by deeds you cannotremember? · Does belief in karma makepeople kinder or harsher in practice? · Doesadding grace weaken or strengthen the idea?
  • Reasons for: it makes the universe just: nothing happens without a cause. It makes people responsible for their actions. It explains why good people may suffer (karma from earlier lives).
  • Reasons against: no one remembers past lives, so it is hard to learn from them. It could be misused to blame victims of illness, poverty or caste. Many Hindus add God's grace or compassion, suggesting karma alone is not the whole answer.
  • Judge it by: Is it fair to be affected by deeds you cannot remember? Does belief in karma make people kinder or harsher in practice? Does adding grace weaken or strengthen the idea?
Mission 3Worked answer

Influence on Hindus today

Karma today: worked answerWay 1Hindus try to act ethically, e.g. honestly andwithout violence.Developmentevery action creates kriyamana karma, whichshapes the next birth.Way 2many Hindus try to act without selfish desire.Source"Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruitwhich comes from them" (Gita 2.47).Developmentnishkam karma does not bind, so it leadstowards moksha.

Question: Explain two ways in which belief in karma influences Hindus today.

  • Way 1: Hindus try to act ethically, e.g. honestly and without violence. Development: every action creates kriyamana karma, which shapes the next birth.
  • Way 2: many Hindus try to act without selfish desire. Source: "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them" (Gita 2.47). Development: nishkam karma does not bind, so it leads towards moksha.
Mission check

?Ravi was born with a serious illness. He says: "I can't change being ill, but I can choose to study hard and help others with the same condition, as an offering to God." Which Hindu ideas best explain his attitude?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Can one ultimate reality be beyond all description and also a God you can love?

Make a guess: Can one ultimate reality be beyond all description and also a God you can love?

Mission 4

Brahman: ultimate reality

Brahman, Brahma, BrahminBrahmanultimate realityBrahmaone deity: the creator in theTrimurtiBrahminthe priestly class
  • Most Hindus believe in one ultimate reality behind everything: Brahman.
  • Brahman is eternal and unchanging; the source, support and end of all that exists.
  • Many Hindus simply call Brahman God.
  • Do not confuse: Brahman (ultimate reality) · Brahma (one deity, the creator in the Trimurti) · Brahmin (the priestly class).
  • Hindus understand Brahman in two main ways: nirguna (without qualities) and saguna (with qualities).
Mission 4

Nirguna Brahman

Nirguna and saguna Brahmannirgunawithout qualities(without form)"neti, neti"beyond eye, speech,mindsagunawith qualities(with form)conchdiscusVishnuShivaDevipersonal, loving, canbe worshippedKena Upanishad 1.3
  • Nirguna: "without qualities" (attributes).
  • Your spec says "without form".
  • Brahman is beyond every name, shape and description; no human idea can contain it.
  • The Upanishads describe it by negation: neti, neti, "not this, not this".
  • Impersonal: not a "someone" to pray to, but pure being, consciousness and bliss.
  • "There the eye does not go, nor speech, nor mind." (Kena Upanishad 1.3, Paramananda)
Mission 4

Saguna Brahman

Nirguna and saguna Brahmannirgunawithout qualities(without form)"neti, neti"beyond eye, speech,mindsagunawith qualities(with form)conchdiscusVishnuShivaDevipersonal, loving, canbe worshippedKena Upanishad 1.3
  • Saguna: "with qualities".
  • Your spec says "with form".
  • Brahman known as a personal God with qualities such as love, power, beauty and mercy, who can be known, worshipped and loved.
  • Many Hindus know saguna Brahman as Vishnu (and his avatars Rama and Krishna), Shiva, or the Goddess (Devi, Shakti).
Quick check
?Which statement describes saguna Brahman?
Mission 4

One reality, two ways

One Brahman, two waysvapour: formlessnirgunaice: shapedsagunasame waterin lifenirgunameditation, studysagunapuja before a murti,bhajansan analogy, not a scripture
  • Most Hindus see nirguna and saguna as one Brahman, understood in two ways, not two Gods.
  • An image often used: water is one substance, whether as formless vapour or as ice with a shape.
  • Humans need form to relate to the infinite: saguna Brahman lets people love and serve God.
  • In daily life (saguna): worship (puja) before a murti, singing devotional songs (bhajans), festivals, prayer to a chosen deity.
  • In daily life (nirguna): meditation, study of the Upanishads, seeking knowledge (jnana) that sees Brahman in everything.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Brahman is best understood as nirguna."

Argument map: is Brahman best understood as nirguna?"Brahman is best understood as nirguna."ForThe Upanishads say Brahman is beyondeye, speech and mind (Kena 1.3).Any quality would limit the infinite.Advaita teachers hold nirguna as thehighest truth.It avoids picturing God as a human.AgainstIn the Gita, Krishna reveals himself as theSupreme; the path to the unmanifest isharder for embodied beings (Gita 12.5,paraphrase).Love (bhakti) needs a personal God.Most Hindus worship Brahman in sagunaform.Another viewBoth are true: one reality seen from twosides, as the Gita and many teachers hold.Judge it byWhich scriptures carry most weight? · Can theinfinite have qualities? · Which view makessense of Hindu worship?
  • Reasons for: the Upanishads say Brahman is beyond eye, speech and mind (Kena 1.3). Any quality would limit the infinite. Advaita teachers (the school that holds only Brahman is ultimately real) hold nirguna as the highest truth. It avoids picturing God as a human.
  • Reasons against: in the Gita, Krishna reveals himself as the Supreme, and says the path to the unmanifest is harder for embodied beings (Bhagavad Gita 12.5, paraphrase). Love (bhakti) needs a personal God. Most Hindus worship Brahman in saguna form.
  • Another view: both are true: one reality seen from two sides, as the Gita and many teachers hold.
  • Judge it by: Which scriptures carry most weight? Can the infinite have qualities? Which view makes sense of Hindu worship?
Mission 4Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Belief, source, developmentBelief 1BeliefBrahman is nirguna, beyond all qualities.Source"There the eye does not go, nor speech, normind" (Kena Upanishad 1.3)Developmentso some Hindus seek Brahman throughmeditation and knowledge rather thanimagesBelief 2BeliefBrahman is also saguna, with qualities.DevelopmentBrahman can be known as a personal Godsuch as Vishnu or Shiva, so many Hindusworship murtis with love (bhakti)

Question: Explain two Hindu beliefs about the nature of Brahman.

  • Belief 1: Brahman is nirguna, beyond all qualities. Source: "There the eye does not go, nor speech, nor mind" (Kena Upanishad 1.3). Development: so some Hindus seek Brahman through meditation and knowledge rather than images.
  • Belief 2: Brahman is also saguna, with qualities. Development: Brahman can be known as a personal God such as Vishnu or Shiva, so many Hindus worship murtis with love (bhakti).
Mission check

?In a British mandir, Anjali offers flowers to a murti of Krishna and sings bhajans. Her uncle meditates daily on "the One beyond all forms" and rarely uses murtis. Which statement fits Hindu teaching best?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Is there one right way to live, or does the right thing depend on who you are and when?

Make a guess: Is there one right way to live, or does the right thing depend on who you are and when?

Mission 5

Four aims of life

Four aims of lifemokshaliberation: the final aimarthawealth,work,success,gainedhonestlykamapleasure,love, thearts, familylifedharma: the foundationduty, right living, righteousnessArtha and kama are good, not sins, as long asthey are pursued within dharma.
  • Hindus speak of four purusharthas (aims of human life):
  • Dharma: duty, right living, righteousness.
  • Artha: wealth, work, success, security, gained honestly.
  • Kama: pleasure, love, enjoyment of the arts and family life.
  • Moksha: liberation from samsara (see Mission 2).
  • Artha and kama are good, not sins, as long as they are pursued within dharma.
  • Moksha is the final aim; the other three prepare for it.
Mission 5

What is dharma?

Four aims of lifemokshaliberation: the final aimarthawealth,work,success,gainedhonestlykamapleasure,love, thearts, familylifedharma: the foundationduty, right living, righteousnessArtha and kama are good, not sins, as long asthey are pursued within dharma.
  • From a root meaning "to hold" or "support": dharma is what holds the world and society together.
  • It means cosmic order, right conduct and personal duty.
  • Some duties are for everyone (sadharana dharma): truthfulness, non-violence (ahimsa), self-control, generosity.
Mission 5Read the source

Your own duty

Your own dutyContext: Arjuna, a warrior, wantsto give up the fight. Krishna tellsBhagavad Gita 3.35 (Arnold)"Finally, this is better, that one do / His owntask as he may, even though he fail, / Thantake tasks not his own, though they seemgood."

> "Finally, this is better, that one do / His own task as he may, even though he fail, / Than take tasks not his own, though they seem good." (Bhagavad Gita 3.35, Arnold)

  • Context: Arjuna, a warrior, wants to give up the fight. Krishna tells him to do the duty that is his.

Q1 According to 3.35, which is better: your own duty done badly, or someone else's done well?

Show answer

Your own duty, even done imperfectly.

Q2 What does this suggest about comparing yourself with others?

Show answer

Each person has their own dharma; it is not a race to do someone else's.

Quick check
?Meera runs a small shop. She works hard to make a good profit, but always charges fair prices and pays her staff properly. Which aims of life is she balancing?
Mission 5

Four ashramas: stages of life

Four ashramas1 Brahmacharyastudent: learn, self-discipline,respect the teacher2 Grihasthahouseholder: marry, work, raise afamily, support others3 Vanaprastharetirement ("forest-dweller"):hand over; turn to spiritual life4 Sannyasarenunciation: give up possessionsand ties; focus on mokshaDharma changes with each stage of life.
  • Brahmacharya: student. Learn, show self-discipline, respect the teacher.
  • Grihastha: householder. Marry, work, raise a family, support others; artha and kama matter most here.
  • Vanaprastha: retirement ("forest-dweller"). Hand over to the next generation; turn to spiritual life.
  • Sannyasa: renunciation. Give up possessions and ties; focus on moksha. Few Hindus take this stage today.
  • Your spec prints "asharma"; the usual spelling is ashrama.
  • Hindus also speak of varnashrama dharma: duty according to your varna (one of four social groups: priests, rulers, merchants, workers) and your ashrama. Some see varna as set by birth; others, reading Gita 4.13, by qualities and work.
  • Dharma changes with each stage: the same person's duty at 15, 35, 60 and 80 is different.
Quick check
?Mr Patel, 64, has handed his business to his daughter. He now spends more time reading the Gita and helping at the mandir, though he still lives at home. Which ashrama best fits him?
Mission 5Evaluate

"Varnashrama dharma is still relevant today."

Is varnashrama dharma still relevant today?"Varnashrama dharma is still relevanttoday."ForThe ashramas give a wise shape to life:learning, family, handing on, spiritualfocus.Varna, read as qualities and work (Gita4.13), says everyone has a role and a duty.Svadharma (your own duty, Gita 3.35)helps people find their own path ratherthan copy others.AgainstVarna by birth has been used to justifycaste discrimination, which many Hindusand the Indian Constitution reject.Modern careers, mobility and long lives donot fit four neat stages.Sannyasa is rare today.Another viewKeep the ashramas and the idea of duty;reject birth-based varna.Judge it byWhich version of varna is meant? · Can an oldideal guide without being followed exactly? ·What do Hindus in Britain actually do?
  • Reasons for: the ashramas give a wise shape to life: learning, family, handing on, spiritual focus. Varna, read as qualities and work (Gita 4.13), says everyone has a role and a duty. Svadharma (your own duty, Gita 3.35) helps people find their own path rather than copy others.
  • Reasons against: varna by birth has been used to justify caste discrimination, which many Hindus and the Indian Constitution reject. Modern careers, mobility and long lives do not fit four neat stages. Sannyasa is rare today.
  • Another view: keep the ashramas and the idea of duty; reject birth-based varna.
  • Judge it by: Which version of varna is meant? Can an old ideal guide without being followed exactly? What do Hindus in Britain actually do?
Mission 5Worked answer

Belief, source, development

Dharma: worked answerTeaching 1each person has their own dharma.Source"this is better, that one do / His own task ashe may, even though he fail, / Than take tasksnot his own" (Gita 3.35).Developmentso Hindus try to do their own duties (asstudent, parent, worker) faithfully, rather thanenvy others' roles.Teaching 2dharma changes with the stage of life(ashrama).Developmenta student's dharma is to learn with discipline;a householder's is to work and care for family,so the right action depends on who you areand when.

Question: Explain two Hindu teachings about dharma.

  • Teaching 1: each person has their own dharma. Source: "this is better, that one do / His own task as he may, even though he fail, / Than take tasks not his own" (Gita 3.35). Development: so Hindus try to do their own duties (as student, parent, worker) faithfully, rather than envy others' roles.
  • Teaching 2: dharma changes with the stage of life (ashrama). Development: a student's dharma is to learn with discipline; a householder's is to work and care for family, so the right action depends on who you are and when.
Mission check

?Dev, 22, wants to quit his medical degree to become a monk at once. His grandmother says: "Moksha is the goal, but first finish your studies, raise a family and serve others. Your time will come." Which Hindu idea best explains her advice?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If your past actions shape your life now, are you still free, and how should you treat others who suffer?

Make a guess: If your past actions shape your life now, are you still free, and how should you treat others who suffer?

Mission 6

Why is there suffering?

Why is there suffering?samsara: the cycle of birth and deathkarmaactions bringresultsavidyanot knowing thetrue selfmayataking the passingas lastingdesire andattachmentgrasping at whatcannot lastsufferingHindu teachings: linked causes, not onefree choice nownew karma
  • Hindu teachings point to several linked causes, not one.
  • Karma: actions have results. Harmful actions bring suffering later, in this life or a future one (samsara, the cycle of birth and death).
  • Avidya (ignorance): not knowing the true self. People think "I am this body", so loss, illness and death seem to destroy them.
  • Maya (illusion): taking the changing world as if it were the lasting reality.
  • Desire and attachment: grasping at things that cannot last leads to anger, fear and grief.
  • Karma and ignorance keep the atman (eternal self) bound in samsara, and so suffering goes on, until it gains moksha (liberation).
Mission 6

Free, but not unlimited

Why is there suffering?samsara: the cycle of birth and deathkarmaactions bringresultsavidyanot knowing thetrue selfmayataking the passingas lastingdesire andattachmentgrasping at whatcannot lastsufferingHindu teachings: linked causes, not onefree choice nownew karma
  • Most Hindus believe humans have free will: we choose how to act.
  • But some things are already set by past karma: the family, body and situation you are born into.
  • A common picture: you cannot choose the cards you are dealt, but you choose how you play them.
  • Teachers name karmas (kinds of karma): prarabdha karma is already bearing fruit now; kriyamana karma is being made by today's choices (more in Mission 3).
  • A human birth is seen as precious: humans, unlike animals, can choose to act on dharma and seek moksha.
  • So karma is not fate: the past shapes the situation, the present choice is still yours.
Mission 6

Ignorance and knowledge

The rope and the snakein the dark"a snake!"lamp litonly a ropeavidyamistakejnanaseeing trulyKnowledge removes ignorance as light removesdarkness.a traditional Hindu example
  • Avidya is not lack of information. It is not knowing what you really are: the atman, not the body.
  • From that ignorance come selfishness ("I and mine"), greed (lobha) and anger (krodha).
  • The Gita names three "gates" to ruin: lust, anger and greed (Bhagavad Gita 16.21, paraphrase).
  • Sin (papa) here means wrong action that produces bad karma and binds the self; many theistic Hindus also see it as turning away from God.
  • Knowledge (vidya, jnana) means spiritual insight, gained from scripture, a guru and practice.
  • Knowledge removes ignorance as light removes darkness; with it, fear and selfishness lose their grip.
Mission 6Read the source

How desire grows into ruin

Krishna to Arjuna, Bhagavad Gita 2.62–63 (Edwin Arnold's translation, 1885):

> "If one / Ponders on objects of the sense, there springs / Attraction; from attraction grows desire, / Desire flames to fierce passion, passion breeds / Recklessness; then the memory—all betrayed— / Lets noble purpose go, and saps the mind, / Till purpose, mind, and man are all undone."

Q1 What is the first step in the chain?

Show answer

Dwelling on objects of the senses.

Q2 Which virtue would break the chain?

Show answer

Mind and sense control.

Quick check
?Ravi panics whenever his phone is lost or damaged and feels as if part of him has gone. Which Hindu idea best describes the root of his distress?
Mission 6Diversity

Responding to suffering

Responding to sufferingKnowledgeAdvaita Hindus: the atman neverreally suffers; knowledge of the trueself ends suffering.DevotionVaishnava and other devotionalHindus: turn to God; devotion andGod's grace free the soul.ServiceMost Hindus: accept what cannot bechanged, without blaming thesufferer; relieve pain through sevaand compassion.
  • Advaita (non-dual) Hindus: the atman is one with Brahman and never really suffers. Suffering belongs to the world of maya; knowledge of the true self ends it.
  • Vaishnava and other devotional Hindus: suffering comes from forgetting God. Devotion and God's grace free the soul; hardship can turn the heart towards God.
  • Practical response, shared by most: accept what cannot be changed as karma, without blaming the sufferer; act now to relieve pain through seva (selfless service) and compassion.
  • Purpose of life: suffering can be a spur to seek moksha, the release that ends suffering for good.
Mission 6Evaluate

"Suffering is always the result of a person's own karma."

"Suffering is always the result of a person's own karma.""Suffering is always the result of a person'sown karma."ForLaw of karma: actions bring results;nothing happens without a cause. Pastlives explain why the innocent seem tosuffer.It gives meaning and hope: acting wellnow changes the future.AgainstSuffering also comes from avidya andmaya; others' free choices can harm theinnocent.It risks blaming victims; most Hinduteachers say compassion (daya, seva),never judgement.Devotional Hindus: God's grace can liftkarma.Judge it byDoes it fit what scripture says? · Does it leadpeople to act more kindly? · Can it explain thesuffering of a newborn child?
  • For: the law of karma is that actions bring results; nothing happens without a cause (Gita, Upanishads). It explains why the innocent seem to suffer: past lives.
  • For: it gives suffering meaning and hope: acting well now changes the future.
  • Against: many Hindus say suffering also comes from avidya and maya, not only from one's own actions; others' free choices can harm the innocent.
  • Against: it risks blaming victims; most Hindu teachers say the right response is compassion (daya, seva), never judgement.
  • Against: devotional Hindus say God's grace can lift karma, so karma is not the whole story.
  • Judge it by: Does it fit what scripture says? Does it lead people to act more kindly? Can it explain the suffering of a newborn child?
Quick check
?A Hindu teacher says: "Your past has given you this situation; your choices now decide what comes next." Which belief is she expressing?
Mission check

?A Hindu nurse looks after a patient who says, "This illness must be punishment for something I did in a past life." Which response fits most Hindu teaching best?
Mission 7

Mission 7: Can a nurse, a scholar, a meditator and a singer all be on the same spiritual path?

Make a guess: Can a nurse, a scholar, a meditator and a singer all be on the same spiritual path?

Mission 7

Yoga means union

Four paths, one summitmoksha (liberation)karmaaction: duty doneselflesslyjnanaknowledge of thetrue selfastanga / rajameditation:controlling the mindbhaktiloving devotion to apersonal God
  • Yoga comes from a root meaning "to join": union of the self with the divine.
  • It is a whole way of life, not just exercise. (The postures many people do are one small part of one path.)
  • The goal is moksha: liberation from samsara, the cycle of birth and death.
  • Hindus speak of four paths (margas) or yogas, suited to different people:
  • karma (action) · jnana (knowledge) · astanga / raja (meditation) · bhakti (devotion).
Mission 7

Karma yoga: the path of action

Four paths, one summitmoksha (liberation)karmaaction: duty doneselflesslyjnanaknowledge of thetrue selfastanga / rajameditation:controlling the mindbhaktiloving devotion to apersonal God
  • Doing your duty (dharma) selflessly, without craving its rewards.
  • "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them." (Bhagavad Gita 2.47, Arnold)
  • Work is offered to God; so it does not create binding karma.
  • Suits active people. Examples: a nurse who works for patients, not praise; seva (service) at a mandir or food bank.
Mission 7

Jnana yoga: the path of knowledge

Four paths, one summitmoksha (liberation)karmaaction: duty doneselflesslyjnanaknowledge of thetrue selfastanga / rajameditation:controlling the mindbhaktiloving devotion to apersonal God
  • Gaining wisdom about the true self (atman) and ultimate reality (Brahman).
  • Practice: study of scripture with a guru; hearing, reflecting and meditating on the teaching.
  • Viveka (discrimination): telling the lasting from the passing.
  • Linked especially with Advaita Vedanta: knowing that the atman is one with Brahman.
  • Suits thoughtful, reflective people; demanding and often slow.
Quick check
?Meena spends an hour each day studying the Upanishads with her teacher, then reflects on the question "What is my true self?" Which path is she mainly following?
Mission 7

Bhakti yoga: the path of devotion

Four paths, one summitmoksha (liberation)karmaaction: duty doneselflesslyjnanaknowledge of thetrue selfastanga / rajameditation:controlling the mindbhaktiloving devotion to apersonal God
  • Loving devotion to a personal God: e.g. Krishna, Rama, Shiva or the Goddess.
  • Practice: puja, singing (bhajan, kirtan), repeating God's names (japa), pilgrimage, surrender.
  • "A leaf, a flower, a fruit, water poured forth, / That offering I accept, lovingly made" (Bhagavad Gita 9.26, Arnold).
  • Open to everyone, whatever their learning or caste; God's grace helps the devotee.
  • Often described as the most widely followed path in Hinduism today.
Mission 7Diversity

Which path is best?

Which path is stressed?WhoStressesWhyAdvaita(Shankara)jnanaknowledge aloneends ignorance;other paths purifythe mind for itVaishnavas(Ramanuja;ISKCON)bhaktithe highest; God'sgrace savesGandhi andotherskarmaserving others inthe world asservice of GodSwamiVivekananda(1863–1902)all foursame goal; eachsuits a differenttemperamentMany Hindus read the Gita as weaving the
  • Advaita (Shankara): jnana is the direct path; knowledge alone ends ignorance. Other paths purify the mind for it.
  • Vaishnavas (Ramanuja; ISKCON): bhakti is highest; God's grace saves.
  • Gandhi and others: karma yoga in the world, serving others as service of God.
  • Swami Vivekananda (1863–1902): all four lead to the same goal; each suits a different temperament (active, reflective, emotional, meditative).
  • Many Hindus read the Gita as weaving the paths together rather than ranking them.
Mission 7

Paths, karma and moksha

Paths, karma and mokshakarmabinds the selfreleased in three wayskarma yogaselfless action makes no bindingkarmajnanaknowledge burns up karma "As thekindled flame / Feeds on the fuel till itsinks to ash" (Gita 4.37)bhaktiGod's grace releases the devotee fromkarmamoksha: understood in two waysAdvaitarealising onenesswith Brahmandevotional Hinduseternal lovingrelationship with God
  • Karma: selfless action makes no binding karma; selfish action keeps the self in samsara.
  • Jnana: knowledge burns up karma "As the kindled flame / Feeds on the fuel till it sinks to ash" (Bhagavad Gita 4.37, Arnold).
  • Bhakti: God's grace releases the devotee from karma.
  • Moksha means different things: for Advaita, realising oneness with Brahman; for devotional Hindus, eternal loving relationship with God.
  • So the marga a Hindu follows shapes how they hope to reach moksha, and what they think moksha is.
Mission 7

One life, many paths

One life, many pathsone Hindu's week (an example)Morningmeditation and breathing (raja)Workdoing the job well, withoutselfishness (karma)Eveningarti at the home shrine; singingbhajans (bhakti)Weekenda Gita study class (jnana)
  • Most Hindus combine paths rather than choose one.
  • Morning: meditation and breathing (raja).
  • Work: doing the job well, without selfishness (karma).
  • Evening: arti at the home shrine; singing bhajans (bhakti).
  • Weekend: a Gita study class (jnana).
  • Why different types matter: people differ, and so do the stages of life (ashramas): a student, a parent and a retired person have different time and strengths.
Mission 7Evaluate

"Bhakti is the best path to moksha."

"Bhakti is the best path to moksha.""Bhakti is the best path to moksha."ForOpen to everyone, whatever their learning;the Gita calls the devoted yogi "truest andbest" (6.47).Relies on God's grace, not on humanstrength alone; the most widely practisedpath.AgainstAdvaita says only knowledge removesignorance; bhakti prepares for it.Without selfless action (karma yoga),devotion can become private and ignoreothers' needs.Many Hindus say no path is "best": eachsuits a different person.Judge it byWhat is moksha (union or relationship)? ·Does the answer depend on the person? · Dothe paths really separate?
  • For: open to everyone, whatever their learning; the Gita calls the devoted yogi "truest and best" (6.47).
  • For: relies on God's grace, not on human strength alone; the most widely practised path.
  • Against: Advaita says only knowledge removes ignorance; bhakti prepares for it.
  • Against: without selfless action (karma yoga), devotion can become private and ignore others' needs.
  • Against: many Hindus say no path is "best": each suits a different person.
  • Judge it by: What is moksha (union or relationship)? Does the answer depend on the person? Do the paths really separate?
Quick check
?Which statement about the four paths do most Hindus accept?
Mission check

?Dev, a Hindu firefighter, works long shifts, helps at a homeless shelter, and gives his pay rise to a charity without telling anyone. He rarely has time to study or meditate. Which view of his spiritual life would most Hindus take?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Most Hindus see the universe as cyclical: creation, preservation, dissolution, repeated; a day of Brahma is 1,000 cycles of four yugas, and many Hindus believe we live in the Kali Yuga.
  • In Hindu teaching, prakriti (matter) is woven from three gunas: sattva, rajas, tamas; maya is the power that hides the divine behind the world.

Mission 2

  • Hindus believe the atman is the eternal self, distinct from body and mind; it moves from body to body in samsara, shaped by karma.
  • In Hindu teaching, avidya (ignorance), maya and attachment keep the atman bound; moksha is release, possible even while alive (jivanmukti) for some schools.
  • Advaita: atman is Brahman. Vishishtadvaita: atman is part of God, yet distinct. Dvaita: atman is eternally distinct from God.

Mission 3

  • In Hindu teaching, karma is action and its results; it decides rebirth in samsara, and only action without binding desire leads towards moksha.
  • Sanchita (store), prarabdha (ripening now) and kriyamana (being made now): many Hindus say the past sets limits, but present choices are free, so karma is not fate.
  • The Gita teaches that sakam karma (with desire for results) binds; nishkam karma (without selfish desire, offered to God) does not (Gita 2.47).

Mission 4

  • Most Hindus believe Brahman is the one ultimate reality: spirit, absolute truth, the source and support of all.
  • For Hindus, nirguna Brahman is beyond all qualities; saguna Brahman is Brahman with qualities, known as a personal God.

Mission 5

  • The four aims: dharma (duty), artha (wealth), kama (pleasure), moksha (liberation); Hindus see artha and kama as good within dharma.
  • Sanatana dharma ("eternal dharma") is what many Hindus call their religion; varnashrama dharma links duty to varna and ashrama (student, householder, retired, renunciate).

Mission 6

  • Hindus link suffering to karma, avidya (ignorance of the true self), maya (illusion) and attachment; humans have free will within limits set by past karma.
  • Different Hindus stress knowledge, devotion or service as the answer to suffering.

Mission 7

  • Yoga means union with the divine; the four paths are karma (action), jnana (knowledge), astanga/raja (meditation) and bhakti (devotion), all aiming at moksha.
  • Hindus disagree about which path is highest but most combine paths to suit temperament and stage of life.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hinduism: The universe, creation and the place of human beings; life and death for Edexcel International GCSE Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If the universe is born, dies and is born again, which part of the cycle are we in now?
  2. Mission 2If you are not your body and not your mind, what are you, and where do you go next?
  3. Mission 3If your life now is shaped by what you did before, are you still free to choose?
  4. Mission 4Can one ultimate reality be beyond all description and also a God you can love?
  5. Mission 5Is there one right way to live, or does the right thing depend on who you are and when?
  6. Mission 6If your past actions shape your life now, are you still free, and how should you treat others who suffer?
  7. Mission 7Can a nurse, a scholar, a meditator and a singer all be on the same spiritual path?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to IGCSE Religious Studies · Edexcel