← GCSE Religious Studies · CCEA · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
CCEA GCSE Religious Studies (4610) · Unit 6: Matters of life and death (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Christian ethics: Matters of life and death (part 1)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?
  2. Mission 2People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?
  3. Mission 3If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
  4. Mission 4Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?

Make a guess: If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?

Mission 1

Sanctity of life

Sanctity of life and quality of lifeSanctity of lifeGod-givenIntrinsic: not fromhealth, ability, ageor usefulnessFrom beginning tonatural endQuality of lifeFreedom from painIndependenceRelationshipsEnjoying life
  • Sanctity of life: the belief that human life is holy (sacred) and has special value, because it is given by God.
  • So life must be protected and respected from its beginning to its natural end.
  • Many believers add: only God may decide when a life begins and ends. "The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away." (Job 1:21)
  • The value is intrinsic: it does not depend on health, ability, age or usefulness.
  • Non-religious people may also say every human life has great value, but not because it is God-given.
Mission 1Read the source

Made by God

Made by God: three sourcesGenesis 1:27"God created man in his own image."Jeremiah 1:5"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you.Before you were born, I sanctified you."1 Corinthians 6:19"Don't you know that your body is atemple of the Holy Spirit who is in you,whom you have from God? You are notyour own"

"God created man in his own image." (Genesis 1:27)

"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you. Before you were born, I sanctified you." (Jeremiah 1:5)

"Don't you know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit who is in you, whom you have from God? You are not your own" (1 Corinthians 6:19)

Q1 Which verse says God knows a person before birth?

Show answer

Jeremiah 1:5.

Q2 Why would "you are not your own" matter for decisions about life and death?

Show answer

Life belongs to God, so it is not simply ours to end.

Mission 1

Quality of life

Quality of life: open questions?pain · independence · relationships · enjoymentWho decides?Can it be measured?Can a life with great suffering still be worthliving?Many believers use both ideasLife is sacred, and suffering should berelieved.
  • Quality of life: how good a person's life is: their health, freedom from pain, independence, relationships, ability to enjoy life.
  • Doctors use it when choosing treatments; patients use it when deciding what they want.
  • Arguments based on quality of life say that a life's value can depend on what it is like for the person living it.
  • Questions: who decides? Can a life with great suffering still be worth living? Can quality of life be measured?
  • Many believers use both ideas: life is sacred, and suffering should be relieved (e.g. by good medical care).
Quick check
?Which statement is an argument from quality of life rather than sanctity of life?
Mission 1Diversity

Christian views

Christian views on sanctity of lifeStrong sanctityWeakersanctity12Catholic teaching; many evangelical andfundamentalist ChristiansInnocent human life must never bedeliberately ended, whatever its quality.1Many liberal Protestants, someAnglicansLife is God's gift, but love (agape) andcompassion can mean quality of lifematters in hard cases.2AllThe sick, disabled and dying are equallyvaluable; relieve suffering (hospices, medicalcare).
  • Strong sanctity of life (Catholic teaching; many evangelical and fundamentalist Christians, who read the Bible as literally true in all it teaches): innocent human life must never be deliberately ended, whatever its quality.
  • Weaker sanctity of life (many liberal Protestants, some Anglicans): life is God's gift, but love (agape) and compassion can mean that quality of life matters in hard cases.
  • All agree that the sick, disabled and dying are equally valuable, and that suffering should be relieved (hospices, medical care).
Mission 1Evaluate

"The sanctity of life matters more than the quality of life."

Evaluate: does sanctity of life matter more than quality of life?"The sanctity of life matters more than thequality of life."ForLife is God's gift (Job 1:21; 1 Corinthians6:19).Judging lives by quality risks treatingdisabled, sick or old people as lessvaluable.Quality is hard to measure and canchange.AgainstCompassion (agape; karuna) meanssuffering matters.Non-religious people stress personalchoice: people should judge their ownlives.Middle positionsMany believers hold both: life is sacred, soit is never ended deliberately, but qualityof life guides care (e.g. refusingburdensome treatment).Judge it byIs value given by God or by experience? · Whodecides? · Can the two ideas be heldtogether?
  • Reasons for: life is God's gift (Job 1:21; 1 Corinthians 6:19). Judging lives by quality risks treating disabled, sick or old people as less valuable. Quality is hard to measure and can change.
  • Reasons against: compassion (agape; karuna, Buddhist compassion) means suffering matters.
  • Non-religious people stress personal choice: people should judge their own lives.
  • Middle positions: many believers hold both: life is sacred, so it is never ended deliberately, but quality of life guides care (e.g. refusing burdensome treatment).
  • Judge it by: Is value given by God or by experience? Who decides? Can the two ideas be held together?
Mission check

?A hospital chaplain visits a young man badly injured in a rugby accident. He says: "My life is worth nothing now." Which reply best reflects a sanctity-of-life view?
Mission 2

Mission 2: People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Make a guess: People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?

Mission 2

Abortion and the law

Abortion and the law in the UK1967Abortion Act (England, Wales,Scotland): legal if two doctorsagree it is needed on setgrounds199024-week limit for mostgrounds; no limit if thewoman's life is at risk, toprevent grave permanentinjury, or for serious fetalabnormality2019–2020Northern Ireland:decriminalised (2019); onrequest up to 12 weeks (since2020)2026England and Wales: a womancannot be prosecuted forending her own pregnancyThe 1967 Act's rules (two doctors, 24 weeks)still govern how abortions are provided.
  • Abortion: the deliberate ending of a pregnancy so that it does not result in the birth of a child. (A miscarriage is the natural loss of a pregnancy.)
  • Abortion Act 1967 (England, Wales, Scotland): legal if two doctors agree it is needed on set grounds, such as risk to the woman's physical or mental health.
  • Since 1990 the limit for most grounds is 24 weeks. No limit if the woman's life is at risk, to prevent grave permanent injury, or for serious fetal abnormality.
  • Since the Crime and Policing Act 2026, a woman in England and Wales cannot be prosecuted for ending her own pregnancy; the 1967 Act's rules (two doctors, 24 weeks) still govern how abortions are provided.
  • Northern Ireland: abortion was decriminalised in 2019. Since 2020 it is available on request up to 12 weeks, and later on health or fetal-abnormality grounds.
  • Laws differ worldwide: from a total ban (e.g. Malta allows it only to save the woman's life) to abortion on request.
Mission 2

When does a life begin?

When does a life begin? Four points in pregnancy010203040weeks1234Conception (0)Egg and sperm join. Many pro-lifebelievers: a human life with full statusstarts here; the Catholic Church: a personfrom conception.1Ensoulment: 120 days (some Muslimteaching)When the soul enters the body.2Viability (around 24 weeks)The fetus could survive outside thewomb, with medical help.3BirthIn Jewish law, the fetus becomes a fullperson once it is born.4
  • Conception (fertilisation): egg and sperm join to form a genetically unique embryo. Many pro-life believers say a human life with full status starts here.
  • Ensoulment: when the soul enters the body. Some Muslim teaching places this at 120 days; the Catholic Church treats the embryo as a person from conception.
  • Viability: when the fetus could survive outside the womb (around 24 weeks with medical help).
  • Birth: in Jewish law, the fetus becomes a full person once it is born.
  • Status of the embryo: an embryo (first weeks) and fetus (from about 8 weeks) may be seen as a person, a potential person, or part of the woman's body.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes viability?
Mission 2

Pro-life and pro-choice

Pro-life and pro-choicePro-lifeThe unborn childhas a right to lifeGroups: SPUC, LIFESanctity of lifeA human beingfrom conceptionDisabled people'slives are equallyvaluablePro-choiceA woman has theright to decide whathappens to herbodyGroups: BPAS,Abortion Rights,Humanists UKAutonomyQuality of life of thewoman and thechildSafe legal abortionprevents dangerousillegal onesAlternatives to abortionadoption · fostering · practical and financialsupport for parents
  • Pro-life: the unborn child has a right to life; abortion is wrong (some allow exceptions, e.g. to save the mother's life). Groups: SPUC (Society for the Protection of Unborn Children), LIFE.
  • Arguments: sanctity of life; the fetus is a human being from conception; disabled people's lives are equally valuable; alternatives exist.
  • Pro-choice: a woman has the right to decide what happens to her body. Groups: BPAS (British Pregnancy Advisory Service), Abortion Rights, Humanists UK.
  • Arguments: autonomy (personal choice); quality of life of the woman and the child; safe legal abortion prevents dangerous illegal ones.
  • Alternatives to abortion: adoption, fostering, practical and financial support for parents.
Mission 2Read the source

Before birth

Before birth: Christian sourcesPsalm 139:13"For you formed my inmost being. You knit metogether in my mother's womb."Jeremiah 1:5"Before I formed you in the womb, I knewyou."Luke 1:41"When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, thebaby leapt in her womb"Side note: Exodus 21:22–23, read two waysHurt to a pregnant woman: if "no harmfollows", a fine; serious harm is "life for life".Older translations read a miscarriage (fetusvalued, not equal to the mother); the WEBBEreads "gives birth prematurely" (both livesprotected equally).

"For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother's womb." (Psalm 139:13)

"Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you." (Jeremiah 1:5)

"When Elizabeth heard Mary's greeting, the baby leapt in her womb" (Luke 1:41)

  • Your spec names Psalm 139:13–16a, Jeremiah 1:5 and Luke 1:39–44.
  • Some Christians point to Exodus 21:22–23: if a pregnant woman is hurt and "no harm follows", there is a fine; serious harm is "life for life". Older translations read the verse as a miscarriage, so some argue the fetus is valued but not equal to the mother; the WEBBE reads "gives birth prematurely", which others take to protect both lives equally.

Q1 What do these three passages suggest about the unborn?

Show answer

God knows and forms them before birth; the unborn child responds to Mary's greeting.

Q2 Do they directly mention abortion?

Show answer

No: they are applied to it by interpretation, which is why Christians disagree.

Mission 2Diversity

Christian views

Christian views on abortionNeverLimited casesConscience123Catholic teachingDirect abortion is always gravely wrong.Mother's life at risk: life-saving treatmentallowed even if the child dies (doubleeffect).1Church of EnglandOpposed in principle; accepts strictlylimited cases as the lesser evil (e.g. risk tothe mother's life, serious abnormality).2Some liberal ProtestantsE.g. many Methodists and Quakers:accept abortion more widely, out ofcompassion and respect for conscience.3Situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966)Do the most loving thing (agape) ineach situation; abortion maysometimes be right, e.g. after rape.Catholic response: love neverrequires killing the innocent.
  • Catholic teaching: life begins at conception; direct abortion is always gravely wrong (CCC 2270–2272).
  • Mother's life at risk: Catholic teaching allows life-saving treatment (e.g. removing a cancerous womb, or the damaged tube in an ectopic pregnancy) even if the unborn child dies as a foreseen but unintended result: the principle of double effect.
  • Church of England: strongly opposed in principle, but accepts strictly limited cases where abortion may be the lesser evil (e.g. risk to the mother's life, serious abnormality).
  • Some liberal Protestants (e.g. many Methodists and Quakers) accept abortion more widely, out of compassion and respect for conscience.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape) in each situation; abortion may sometimes be right, e.g. after rape. Catholic responses: love never requires killing the innocent.
Quick check
?A pregnant woman is found to have an ectopic pregnancy, which will kill her if untreated. Which statement best describes Catholic teaching?
Mission 2

Non-religious arguments

Non-religious arguments on abortionNon-religious viewsHumanists: autonomyMost support the right to choose; thewoman's autonomy and wellbeing mattermost; an early fetus cannot yet feel or haveinterests. Many accept limits later inpregnancy.Utilitarianism: consequencesWeigh the happiness and suffering ofeveryone affected (woman, child, family);abortion may be right if it leads to lesssuffering.Non-religious pro-lifeThe fetus is a human being, and killing it iswrong whatever one's religion.
  • Humanists: most support the right to choose; the woman's autonomy and wellbeing matter most; an early fetus is not yet a person who can feel or have interests.
  • Many Humanists accept limits later in pregnancy, as the fetus develops.
  • Utilitarianism: weigh the happiness and suffering of everyone affected (woman, child, family); abortion may be right if it leads to less suffering.
  • Some non-religious people are pro-life: they argue the fetus is a human being, and killing it is wrong whatever one's religion.
  • Religious replies: the unborn's value does not depend on what it can do (sanctity of life); utilitarian sums can overlook the weakest.
Mission 2Evaluate

"A woman should always have the right to choose abortion."

Evaluate: should a woman always have the right to choose abortion?"A woman should always have the right tochoose abortion."ForAutonomy over one's own body.Quality of life for the woman and child.Safe legal abortion saves women's lives.Utilitarianism may support it in hard cases.Situation ethics (agape) may also supportit in hard cases.AgainstSanctity of life (Psalm 139:13; Jeremiah1:5).The unborn child cannot speak for itself.Alternatives such as adoption.Disability rights concerns.Middle positionsMany accept abortion only in some cases(mother's life at risk, rape, early inpregnancy) or before ensoulment.Judge it byWhen does a person begin? · Whose rightscome first? · Does the reason for the abortionmatter?
  • Reasons for: autonomy over one's own body; quality of life for the woman and child; safe legal abortion saves women's lives; utilitarianism may support it in hard cases.
  • Situation ethics (agape) may also support it in hard cases.
  • Reasons against: sanctity of life (Psalm 139:13; Jeremiah 1:5); the unborn child cannot speak for itself; alternatives such as adoption; disability rights concerns.
  • Middle positions: many accept abortion only in some cases (mother's life at risk, rape, early in pregnancy) or before ensoulment.
  • Judge it by: When does a person begin? Whose rights come first? Does the reason for the abortion matter?
Mission check

?A Catholic and a member of the Church of England are asked about a 30-year-old woman who will die unless her pregnancy is ended. Both say treatment to save her life is acceptable. Which shared belief best explains this?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?

Make a guess: If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?

Mission 3

Kinds of euthanasia

Kinds of euthanasiaActive: something is done to end lifeVoluntarythe person asksNon-voluntarythe person cannot ask (e.g. in along-term coma)Involuntaryagainst, or without asking, thewishes of a person who coulddecidePassive: treatment withdrawn or withheldVoluntarythe person asks for it to stopNon-voluntarythe person cannot ask (e.g. in along-term coma)Involuntaryagainst, or without asking, thewishes of a person who coulddecideAssisted suicide (assisted dying)The person ends their own life with help, e.g.with drugs prescribed by a doctor.Not euthanasiaRefusing treatment that is too burdensome;pain relief that may shorten life when the aimis to ease pain.
  • Euthanasia (Greek: "good death"): ending a life to relieve suffering, sometimes called mercy killing.
  • Voluntary: the person asks for it. Non-voluntary: the person cannot ask (e.g. in a long-term coma). Involuntary: against, or without asking, the wishes of a person who could decide.
  • Active: something is done to end life (e.g. a lethal injection). Passive: treatment that keeps someone alive is withdrawn or withheld, and they die of their illness.
  • Assisted suicide (assisted dying): the person ends their own life with help, e.g. with drugs prescribed by a doctor.
  • Not euthanasia: refusing treatment that is too burdensome, or giving pain relief that may shorten life when the aim is to ease pain.
Mission 3

The law

Euthanasia and assisted dying: the law in some countriesEuropeUKNetherlandsBelgiumSwitzerlandNorth AmericaCanadaOregonUK: illegalBills to allow assisted dying failed in 2026.Euthanasia legalNetherlands, Belgium (2002); Canada (2016)Assisted suicide allowedSwitzerland; some US states, e.g. Oregon(1997)
  • UK: active euthanasia is treated as murder or manslaughter. In England and Wales, assisting suicide is a crime (Suicide Act 1961).
  • Withdrawing treatment that is no longer in a patient's best interests can be lawful (e.g. the Tony Bland case, 1993). Patients may refuse treatment.
  • In 2025 MPs voted for a bill to allow assisted dying for some terminally ill adults in England and Wales, but it ran out of time in the House of Lords in 2026 and did not become law. The Scottish Parliament rejected a similar bill in March 2026.
  • Elsewhere: euthanasia is legal in the Netherlands and Belgium (2002) and Canada (2016); assisted suicide is allowed in Switzerland and some US states (Oregon, 1997).
Quick check
?A man with motor neurone disease, who is fully able to decide, asks his doctor for a lethal injection, and the doctor gives it. What kind of euthanasia is this?
Mission 3

Hospice and palliative care

The hospice movementSt Christopher's HospiceLondon, 1967Dame Cicely SaundersphysicalspiritualemotionalsocialcarePalliative careRelieves pain and other symptoms when acure is no longer possible; neither hastens nordelays death.
  • Palliative care: care that relieves pain and other symptoms when a cure is no longer possible. It neither hastens nor delays death.
  • Hospices care for dying people and their families: physical, emotional, social and spiritual needs.
  • Dame Cicely Saunders (1918–2005), a Christian nurse, social worker and doctor, founded St Christopher's Hospice, London (1967), the start of the modern hospice movement.
  • Many religious believers see hospices as the alternative to euthanasia: dying well, with dignity and without pain.
Mission 3Read the source

Job

Job: sources on sufferingJob 1:21"The LORD gave, and the LORD has takenaway. Blessed be the LORD's name."Job 2:9"Then his wife said to him, 'Do you stillmaintain your integrity? Renounce God,and die.'"Job 2:10"Shall we receive good at the hand ofGod, and shall we not receive evil?"

"The LORD gave, and the LORD has taken away. Blessed be the LORD's name." (Job 1:21)

"Then his wife said to him, 'Do you still maintain your integrity? Renounce God, and die.'" (Job 2:9)

"Shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil?" (Job 2:10)

Q1 How does Job respond to his suffering?

Show answer

He keeps trusting God and does not seek death.

Q2 How might some Christians apply this to euthanasia?

Show answer

Life and death belong to God; suffering can be endured with faith. Others say Job is not about medical choices.

Mission 3Diversity

Christian views

Catholic teaching on euthanasia, and other Christian viewsCatholic teaching (CCC 2276–2279)Never allowedAllowed1234Direct euthanasiaWhatever the motive: gravely wrong.1Stopping burdensome treatmentTreatment that is burdensome,extraordinary or disproportionate.2Pain reliefEven if it may shorten life, if death is notintended.3Palliative careA special form of charity.4Other Christian viewsChurch of England and most other churchesOppose changing the law: life is God's gift;vulnerable people could feel pressure to die.Some Christians in favourSupport assisted dying out of compassion,e.g. Lord Carey (2014), Archbishop DesmondTutu.Situation ethics (Fletcher, 1966)Do the most loving thing (agape); helpingsomeone in great suffering die might beloving. Catholic response: care until naturaldeath, not killing.
  • Catholic teaching (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2276–2279, paraphrase): direct euthanasia, whatever the motive, is murder and gravely wrong. Stopping treatment that is burdensome, extraordinary or disproportionate can be right. Painkillers may be given even if they may shorten life, if death is not intended. Palliative care is a special form of charity.
  • Church of England and most other churches oppose changing the law: life is God's gift; vulnerable people could feel pressure to die.
  • Some Christians support assisted dying out of compassion; e.g. a former Archbishop of Canterbury, Lord Carey (2014), and Archbishop Desmond Tutu.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1966): do the most loving thing (agape); in a case of great suffering, helping someone die might be loving. Catholic response: love means care until natural death, not killing.
Quick check
?A Catholic woman with terminal cancer asks to stop chemotherapy, which no longer helps and makes her very ill, and to receive strong pain relief. What does Catholic teaching say?
Mission 3

Non-religious views

Non-religious views on assisted dyingForDignity in Dying (UKcampaign, 1935;renamed 2006):assisted dying withsafeguardsHumanists:autonomy; qualityof lifeUtilitarianism: mayreduce suffering forperson and familyAgainstDisabled people'sgroups (e.g. NotDead Yet UK):pressure on thevulnerableSlippery slope:safeguards mayweaken over time
  • Dignity in Dying (UK campaign, founded in 1935 as the Voluntary Euthanasia Legalisation Society; renamed in 2006): campaigns for assisted dying for terminally ill, mentally competent adults, with safeguards.
  • Humanists: people should have autonomy over their own lives and deaths; quality of life matters; there is no God whose will must be obeyed.
  • Utilitarianism: assisted dying may reduce suffering for the person and family.
  • Some non-religious people oppose a change: disabled people's groups (e.g. Not Dead Yet UK) fear pressure on the vulnerable; the slippery slope argument says safeguards may weaken over time.
Quick check
?Which argument would most Humanists use to support assisted dying?
Mission 3Evaluate

"Euthanasia should be legal in the UK."

Evaluate: should euthanasia be legal in the UK?"Euthanasia should be legal in the UK."ForAutonomy (Humanists; Dignity in Dying, aUK campaign group).Compassion (Christian agape, Buddhistkaruna).Quality of life.Strict safeguards work in other countries.AgainstSanctity of life (Job 1:21).Vulnerable people may feel a burden.The slippery slope.Good palliative care (hospices) relievesmost suffering.Doctors are meant to heal.Middle positionsAllow refusing treatment and strong painrelief, but not active euthanasia (Catholicand many other teachings).Judge it byWhose life is it? · Can safeguards protect thevulnerable? · Is relieving suffering the same asending life?
  • Reasons for: autonomy (Humanists; Dignity in Dying, a UK campaign group); compassion (Christian agape, Buddhist karuna); quality of life; strict safeguards work in other countries.
  • Reasons against: sanctity of life (Job 1:21); vulnerable people may feel a burden; the slippery slope; good palliative care (hospices) relieves most suffering; doctors are meant to heal.
  • Middle positions: allow refusing treatment and strong pain relief, but not active euthanasia (Catholic and many other teachings).
  • Judge it by: Whose life is it? Can safeguards protect the vulnerable? Is relieving suffering the same as ending life?
Mission check

?A hospice nurse, a practising Catholic, cares for a dying patient who says: "I just want the pain to stop." Which response best fits her faith and her work?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Make a guess: Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Mission 4

What the death penalty is

The death penalty in the UK1950Timothy Evans hanged1953Derek Bentley hanged1961last execution in Northern Ireland1964last executions in Great Britain1965abolished for murder in GreatBritain1966Timothy Evans pardoned1969abolition for murder madepermanent1973abolished for murder in NorthernIreland1998abolished for all crimes across theUK; Derek Bentley's convictionquashed
  • Capital punishment (the death penalty): the state lawfully executes a person for a crime. A crime that can carry it is a capital offence.
  • Purpose: retribution (a life for a life), deterrence, and protection of society.
  • Great Britain: the last executions were in 1964; it was abolished for murder in 1965 (permanently from 1969). Northern Ireland: last execution 1961, abolished for murder 1973. Abolished across the UK for all crimes by 1998.
  • It is still used in some countries, e.g. China, Iran, Saudi Arabia and some US states.
  • Some people in the UK still call for it to return for the worst murders.
Mission 4

Arguments for

Arguments for and against the death penaltyForAgainstRetributiondeath for themost evil crimesSanctity of lifeonly God mayend lifeDeterrencefear of death maystop killingMistakescannot be undone(Evans, Bentley)Protectioncan never killagainNo cleardeterrencemany murders inanger or panic?Victims' familiesthe crime takenseriouslyNo reformno chance toreform or repentUtilityif it deters, itsaves innocentlivesUtilitymay brutalisesociety
  • Retribution: some crimes are so evil that only death is a just penalty.
  • Deterrence: fear of death may stop people killing.
  • Protection: an executed murderer can never kill again.
  • Justice for victims' families: some feel the crime has been taken seriously.
  • Principle of utility (Jeremy Bentham, 1748–1832): the right act brings the greatest happiness for the greatest number. If executions deter murder and save many innocent lives, a utilitarian could support them.
Mission 4

Arguments against

Arguments for and against the death penaltyForAgainstRetributiondeath for themost evil crimesSanctity of lifeonly God mayend lifeDeterrencefear of death maystop killingMistakescannot be undone(Evans, Bentley)Protectioncan never killagainNo cleardeterrencemany murders inanger or panic?Victims' familiesthe crime takenseriouslyNo reformno chance toreform or repentUtilityif it deters, itsaves innocentlivesUtilitymay brutalisesociety
  • Sanctity of life: many believers hold that all life is sacred and given by God, so only God may end it, a murderer's life included.
  • Mistakes cannot be undone: Timothy Evans was hanged in 1950 and pardoned in 1966; Derek Bentley was hanged in 1953 and his conviction quashed in 1998.
  • No clear evidence that it deters better than long prison sentences; many murders happen in anger or panic.
  • No chance to reform or repent.
  • Utility can argue against: executions may brutalise society and wrongful executions cause great harm, so it may not produce the greatest happiness.
Quick check
?Which argument about the death penalty is based on the principle of utility?
Mission 4Read the source

Scripture on both sides

Scripture on both sidesUsed to supportGenesis 9:6Exodus 21:24Romans 13:4Used to opposeMatthew 5:38–39Matthew 5:44Exodus 20:13"his blood will beshed by man"(Genesis 9:6)"don't resist him whois evil" (Matthew5:39)

"Whoever sheds man's blood, his blood will be shed by man, for God made man in his own image." (Genesis 9:6)

"eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot" (Exodus 21:24)

"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil" (Matthew 5:38–39)

  • "You shall not murder." (Exodus 20:13)
  • "Let every soul be in subjection to the higher authorities" (Romans 13:1); the ruler "doesn't bear the sword in vain" (Romans 13:4).

Q1 Which passages are used to support the death penalty?

Show answer

Genesis 9:6 and Exodus 21:24.

Q2 How does Matthew 5:38–39 challenge "an eye for an eye"?

Show answer

Jesus calls his followers not to take revenge.

Mission 4

How Catholic teaching developed

How Catholic teaching developedc. 414Augustine: letters beg forthe lives of the condemned,so they have time to repentc. 1225–1274Aquinas: killing adangerous person may"safeguard the commongood"1995John Paul II, EvangeliumVitae 56: such cases are"very rare, if not practicallynon-existent"2018Francis revises Catechism2267: the death penalty is"inadmissible"
  • St Augustine (354–430): the state may use the sword (Romans 13), but in letters to officials (Letter 134 to Apringius; Letter 153 to Macedonius, c. 414) he begs for the lives of the condemned, so they have time to repent (paraphrase).
  • St Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 64, a. 2: if a person is dangerous to the community, "it is praiseworthy and advantageous that he be killed in order to safeguard the common good".
  • Pope John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae 56 (1995): only allowed when there is no other way to defend society; such cases are "very rare, if not practically non-existent".
  • Pope Francis (2018) revised the Catechism (2267): the death penalty is "inadmissible", an attack on the dignity of the person; the Church works for its abolition worldwide.
  • Catholics see this as a development in understanding: modern prisons can protect society without killing.
Mission 4Diversity

Christian views today

Christian views todaysupportopposeSome Christians,often conservativeGenesis 9:6; Romans13:4Most UK churchesMatthew 5:38–48
  • Most UK churches oppose it: Catholic, Church of England, Methodist, Quaker and others. Reasons: sanctity of life; Jesus' teaching on revenge and love of enemies (Matthew 5:38–48); no one is beyond redemption; mistakes.
  • Some Christians support it, often conservative Christians (e.g. many in some US churches): Genesis 9:6 comes before the Law of Moses and applies to all humanity; Romans 13:4 gives the state the sword.
  • Supporters add: justice is not revenge; the state, not the individual, punishes.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how Catholic teaching on the death penalty has developed?
Mission 4

Non-religious views and situation ethics

Humanists on the death penaltyHumanists oppose itone life: this life is the only onemistakes cannot be put right?no clear evidence that it deters
  • Humanists (e.g. Humanists UK) oppose it: this life is the only one; mistakes cannot be put right; no clear evidence it deters; it brutalises society.
  • Utilitarian arguments can go either way: it depends on the evidence about results.
  • Some atheists support it for the worst crimes, on grounds of retribution or protection.
Mission 4Evaluate

"The death penalty is never right."

Is the death penalty never right?"The death penalty is never right."ForSanctity of life (Exodus 20:13; Genesis1:27).Jesus rejected revenge (Matthew 5:38–39).Innocent people have been executed.No clear deterrent effect.Catholic teaching calls it inadmissible;Humanists oppose it.AgainstRetribution for the worst crimes (Genesis9:6).Romans 13:4 gives the state the sword.Protection of society.Utility, if it deters.Another viewRight in principle, but almost never inpractice (Evangelium Vitae 56).Judge it byIs life only God's to take? · Can guilt ever becertain? · What do victims and society need? ·What does the evidence show?
  • Reasons for: sanctity of life (Exodus 20:13; Genesis 1:27); Jesus rejected revenge (Matthew 5:38–39); innocent people have been executed; no clear deterrent effect; Catholic teaching calls it inadmissible; Humanists oppose it.
  • Reasons against: retribution for the worst crimes (Genesis 9:6); Romans 13:4; protection of society; utility, if it deters.
  • Another view: right in principle, but almost never in practice (Evangelium Vitae 56).
  • Judge it by: Is life only God's to take? Can guilt ever be certain? What do victims and society need? What does the evidence show?
Mission check

?A country with secure prisons votes on bringing back executions for terrorist murders. A Catholic, a Reform Jew and a Humanist all vote against. Which reason could all three share?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Sanctity of life: life is holy and God-given (imago Dei; Job 1:21); quality of life: how good a life is for the person.
  • Christians differ: strong sanctity (Catholic and many fundamentalist Christians) or weaker sanctity, where agape lets quality of life count in hard cases.

Mission 2

  • UK law: Abortion Act 1967, 24 weeks for most grounds, no limit when the woman's life is at risk; since 2026 women in England and Wales cannot be prosecuted for ending their own pregnancy.
  • Northern Ireland: decriminalised 2019; on request to 12 weeks since 2020.
  • Catholic teaching: life from conception; direct abortion always wrong; double effect when the mother's life is at risk. The Church of England accepts strictly limited cases.
  • Pro-life (sanctity) vs pro-choice (autonomy, quality of life); Humanists mostly pro-choice; situation ethics and utilitarianism weigh consequences.

Mission 3

  • Euthanasia: voluntary, non-voluntary, involuntary; active or passive; assisted suicide. In the UK active euthanasia and assisting suicide are crimes; bills to allow assisted dying failed in 2026.
  • Most religions oppose euthanasia (sanctity of life, God decides, karma, First Precept) and support hospices and palliative care (Cicely Saunders, 1967); Catholic teaching allows refusing burdensome treatment and strong pain relief.
  • Humanists and Dignity in Dying support assisted dying for autonomy and quality of life; utilitarianism may support it; some non-religious groups oppose it.

Mission 4

  • Death penalty: execution by the state; aims: retribution, deterrence, protection. Abolished in the UK; used in some countries.
  • For: retribution, deterrence, utility (if it saves lives); against: sanctity of life, mistakes, no clear deterrent, no chance to reform.
  • Christians differ (Genesis 9:6 vs Matthew 5:38–39); Catholic teaching has developed to "inadmissible" (2018); other faiths and Humanists also differ.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Christian ethics: Matters of life and death (part 1) for CCEA GCSE Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If every life is sacred, should anyone ever judge how good a life is?
  2. Mission 2People on both sides of the abortion debate value life. So why do they disagree so deeply?
  3. Mission 3If someone is dying and in pain, is helping them die an act of mercy or of killing?
  4. Mission 4Can a state ever be right to put someone to death for a crime?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · CCEA