← GCSE Religious Studies · AQA · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA GCSE Religious Studies B: Catholic Christianity (8063) · 3.1.3 The Triune God, mission and prayer (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

The Triune God, mission and prayer (part 1)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why do Christians sing their prayers, and why do some still use chants over 1,000 years old?
  2. Mission 2Can a worship song with drums and guitars be as holy as an ancient chant?
  3. Mission 3Jesus died once, yet Catholics call every Mass a sacrifice. What happens, step by step, and why?
  4. Mission 4How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?
  5. Mission 5If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Creation (part 1); 1 mission in Incarnation (part 2).

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why do Christians sing their prayers, and why do some still use chants over 1,000 years old?

Make a guess: Why do Christians sing their prayers, and why do some still use chants over 1,000 years old?

Mission 1

Why sing at all?

Three jobs of musicPraisewords for joyand thanks toGodUnitymany voicesbecome onevoiceMemory andteachingsung wordsstick and carrybelief
  • Christians have sung in worship from the start: "speaking to one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs; singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord" (Ephesians 5:19).
  • Music does three jobs:
  • Praise: it gives words to joy and thanks to God.
  • Unity: many voices become one voice, one community.
  • Memory and teaching: sung words stick, and carry belief.
Mission 1

Psalms: the Bible's songbook

Psalm and chantPsalms1–150The Bible's songbook: 150 songsand prayersAt Mass:First readingResponsorial Psalmcantor sings verses;everyone sings theresponsePlainchantsquare notes (neumes) · four-line staveone melodyunisonno instrumentsfree rhythmGregorian chant: named after Pope Gregory I(pope 590–604)
  • The Book of Psalms: 150 songs and prayers of ancient Israel, sung by Jesus and the first Christians.
  • They cover every mood: praise, thanks, sorrow, anger, trust.
  • "Oh come, let's sing to the LORD. Let's shout aloud to the rock of our salvation!" (Psalm 95:1)
  • At Mass: the Responsorial Psalm follows the first reading; a cantor sings verses, everyone sings the response.
  • Daily prayer: monks, nuns, priests and many lay Catholics pray the psalms in the Liturgy of the Hours.
Mission 1

Plainchant

Psalm and chantPsalms1–150The Bible's songbook: 150 songsand prayersAt Mass:First readingResponsorial Psalmcantor sings verses;everyone sings theresponsePlainchantsquare notes (neumes) · four-line staveone melodyunisonno instrumentsfree rhythmGregorian chant: named after Pope Gregory I(pope 590–604)
  • Plainchant (plainsong): one unaccompanied melody line, sung in unison, with a free rhythm that follows the words.
  • Gregorian chant is the Latin plainchant of the Western Church, named after Pope Gregory I (pope 590–604). Most of it took shape later, in the 8th–9th centuries.
  • Written in neumes: square notes on a four-line stave.
  • Words come first: no harmony, no beat, nothing to distract from the prayer.
  • Significance: calm and prayerful; the same chants are sung across the world and down the centuries.
  • Used today in monasteries, cathedrals, Latin Masses and seasons such as Lent and Holy Week.
Mission 1Read the source

Musicam Sacram (1967)

After the Second Vatican Council, the Church issued Musicam Sacram ("Sacred Music"), an Instruction of the Sacred Congregation of Rites, 5 March 1967. In paraphrase:

  • Worship takes a nobler form when it is sung: prayer is expressed more beautifully, hearts are united by the union of voices, minds are raised to heavenly things, and the singing looks forward to the worship of heaven (§5).
  • The people should take part by singing, especially the acclamations and responses (§16).
  • In sung Latin services, Gregorian chant has "pride of place" (§50).

Q1 Give one reason the document gives for singing worship rather than saying it.

Show answer

It unites hearts; raises minds to heaven; foreshadows heaven's worship.

Q2 Who is meant to sing: the choir alone, or everyone?

Show answer

Everyone: the people's singing comes first, especially acclamations.

Quick check
?A visitor to a monastery hears the monks sing at evening prayer. Which feature would show that this is plainchant?
Mission 1

Traditional hymns

Hymn and plainchant comparedHymnPlainchantWordsverses (stanzas)prose textRhythmregular metrefree rhythmTunerepeated tunea single melodylineSoundusually harmonyand organunaccompaniedWho singswholecongregationoften choir orcantor
  • A hymn is a song of praise in verses (stanzas), sung by the whole congregation to a repeated tune, often with organ.
  • Hymns spread fast at the Reformation: Martin Luther's "A Mighty Fortress" (c. 1529).
  • English hymn writers: Isaac Watts, "When I survey the wondrous cross" (1707); Charles Wesley, "And can it be" (1738).
  • Catholic hymns: Thomas Aquinas's Pange lingua (1264); John Henry Newman's "Praise to the Holiest in the height" (1865).
  • At Mass, hymns are often sung at the entrance, the offertory, Communion and the end.
  • Significance: hymns teach doctrine in memorable words ("sung theology") and let everyone join in.
Mission 1

Mass settings

Mass settings through timeThe Ordinary: same texts each weekKyrieGloriaCredoSanctus–BenedictusAgnus DeiA Mass setting = one composer's music for themchant and polyphonychantMissa de Angelis1567Palestrina, Missa PapaeMarcelli (published)c. 1592–93Byrd, Mass for Four Voicesclassical1779Mozart, Coronation Massmodern2010MacMillan, Mass of BlessedJohn Henry Newmancongregational
  • The Ordinary of the Mass: the sung texts that stay the same each week: Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus (with Benedictus) and Agnus Dei.
  • A Mass setting is one composer's music for these texts.
  • Chant: e.g. Missa de Angelis, still sung by congregations.
  • Polyphony (several independent voice parts): Palestrina, Missa Papae Marcelli (published 1567); William Byrd, Mass for Four Voices (c. 1592–93), written for English Catholics who had to worship in secret.
  • Classical: Mozart, Coronation Mass (1779).
  • Modern congregational: James MacMillan, Mass of Blessed John Henry Newman (2010), written for Pope Benedict XVI's visit to Britain.
Mission 1

Why Mass settings matter

Mass settings through timeThe Ordinary: same texts each weekKyrieGloriaCredoSanctus–BenedictusAgnus DeiA Mass setting = one composer's music for themchant and polyphonychantMissa de Angelis1567Palestrina, Missa PapaeMarcelli (published)c. 1592–93Byrd, Mass for Four Voicesclassical1779Mozart, Coronation Massmodern2010MacMillan, Mass of BlessedJohn Henry Newmancongregational
  • Participation: a simple setting lets the whole congregation sing the Mass, as Vatican II asked.
  • Beauty: Catholics believe beauty can lead people towards God; great settings honour the Eucharist.
  • Unity: one setting can be sung by a whole diocese, or at a papal Mass.
  • Influence beyond church: Mass settings shaped Western music (harmony, choirs, the orchestra); many are now performed in concert halls.
  • A tension: an elaborate choral setting can leave the people listening rather than singing; parishes balance choir and congregation.
Mission 1

Four acclamations

Four acclamations in the MassOrder in the MassGloria"Glory to God in the highest" (Luke 2:14)not in Advent or Lent1Alleluia"praise the LORD"; greets the Gospelnot in Lent2Sanctus"Holy, holy, holy" (Isaiah 6:3) + "Hosannain the highest!" (Matthew 21:9)3Mystery of Faithafter the consecration: Christ's death andresurrection (1 Corinthians 11:26)4
  • Gloria: begins with the angels' song at Jesus' birth, "Glory to God in the highest" (Luke 2:14). Sung on Sundays (not in Advent or Lent) and feasts. Praise of Father, Son and Spirit.
  • Alleluia: Hebrew for "praise the LORD". Greets Christ present in the Gospel reading. Not sung in Lent; another acclamation replaces it.
  • Sanctus ("Holy"): the angels' cry, "Holy, holy, holy" (Isaiah 6:3), with the crowd's welcome, "Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord! Hosanna in the highest!" (Matthew 21:9). Earth joins heaven's worship.
  • Mystery of Faith: sung after the consecration. The people proclaim Christ's death and resurrection until he comes again (1 Corinthians 11:26).
  • Significance: these are the people's parts: short, sung shouts of faith.
Quick check
?Which Eucharistic acclamation joins the angels' words in Isaiah's vision to the crowd's welcome of Jesus into Jerusalem?
Mission 1Diversity

Who sings what, and where?

Who sings whatTraditionTypical musicSung by / howCatholicchant, hymns,Mass settings;ResponsorialPsalm everySundaycantor andorganOrthodoxthe wholeLiturgy is sungusually anunaccompaniedchoir;traditionally noinstrumentsAnglicanChoralEvensong;psalms inAnglicanchantcathedral choirsPresbyterianmetricalpsalms andhymnssomecongregationssing psalmsonlyQuakersusually no setmusicsilence is thesetting forworship
  • Catholic: chant, hymns, Mass settings, cantor and organ; Responsorial Psalm every Sunday.
  • Orthodox: the whole Liturgy is sung, usually by an unaccompanied choir; traditionally no instruments.
  • Anglican: cathedral choirs sing Choral Evensong; psalms in Anglican chant.
  • Presbyterian: metrical psalms and hymns; some congregations sing psalms only.
  • Quakers: usually no set music; silence is the setting for worship.
Mission 1Evaluate

"Traditional music is the best music for worship."

Argument map: traditional music"Traditional music is the best music forworship."ForTested by centuriesDeep, biblical wordsLinks worshippers to the whole Church,past and presentCalm, not about performersChant has "pride of place" in Latin liturgy(Musicam Sacram §50)AgainstLatin chant and old hymn language can behard to understandYoung people may find it remoteThe Bible calls for "a new song" (Psalm96:1)Musicam Sacram also values music thatlets the people take partAnother view"Best" depends on the occasion: chant at arequiem, a lively hymn at a school MassJudge it byDoes it help everyone pray and take part? ·Do the words express the Church's beliefs? ·Does it suit the occasion?
  • Reasons for: tested by centuries; deep, biblical words; links worshippers to the whole Church, past and present; calm, not about performers.
  • Also for: chant has "pride of place" in Latin liturgy (Musicam Sacram §50).
  • Reasons against: Latin chant and old hymn language can be hard to understand; young people may find it remote; the Bible calls for "a new song" (Psalm 96:1).
  • Also against: Musicam Sacram also values music that lets the people take part.
  • Another view: "best" depends on the occasion: chant at a requiem, a lively hymn at a school Mass.
  • Judge it by: Does it help everyone pray and take part? Do the words express the Church's beliefs? Does it suit the occasion?
Mission check

?A Catholic parish has families from Poland, Nigeria, the Philippines and England. For the Easter Vigil, the priest has everyone sing the "Holy, holy" (Sanctus) in a simple Latin chant that all can learn. Which reason best fits Catholic teaching on music?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can a worship song with drums and guitars be as holy as an ancient chant?

Make a guess: Can a worship song with drums and guitars be as holy as an ancient chant?

Mission 2

What counts as "contemporary"?

Contemporary worship music: then and nowguitarswords on a screendrums1960scontemporary worship songsbegin, in current styles1967Catholic Charismatic Renewalbegins1983–87Graham Kendrick: "The ServantKing", "Meekness and Majesty","Shine, Jesus, Shine"1999Casting Crowns formed2001modern hymn "In Christ Alone"(Getty and Townend)alsoTaizé chants: short linesrepeated as a prayer
  • Contemporary worship music: songs written from the 1960s onwards in current musical styles.
  • Typical features: simple, repeated choruses; everyday language; guitars, keyboard, drums; words on a screen; a worship band leading.
  • Worship songs often speak directly to God ("you", "I", "we").
  • Modern hymns keep verses and doctrine but use modern tunes, e.g. Keith Getty and Stuart Townend, "In Christ Alone" (2001).
  • Also contemporary, but quiet: Taizé chants from the ecumenical Taizé community in France: short lines repeated many times as a prayer.
Mission 2

Graham Kendrick

Two songwritersGraham Kendrickborn 1950 · England · Baptist background"The Servant King" (1983)Jesus leaves heaven to serve (echoesPhilippians 2:6–8)"Meekness and Majesty" (1986)Jesus fully God and fully human"Shine, Jesus, Shine" (1987)Christ the light of the worldCo-founded March for Jesus (1987)Casting Crownsformed 1999 · USA · by Mark Hall, a youthpastor"Who Am I"wonder that God knows and loves eachperson"Praise You in This Storm"trusting and praising God in suffering"If We Are the Body"churches must welcome outsiders
  • Graham Kendrick (born 1950): English songwriter, from a Baptist background; one of the pioneers of British worship songs.
  • "The Servant King" (1983), also known as "From heaven you came": Jesus leaves heaven to serve, and suffers in Gethsemane; it echoes Philippians 2:6–8.
  • "Meekness and Majesty" (1986): Jesus fully God and fully human.
  • "Shine, Jesus, Shine" (1987): Christ as light of the world, asked to fill the nation.
  • Co-founded March for Jesus (1987): Christians singing in city streets as public witness.
  • His songs are in Catholic and Protestant hymn books and sung in schools.
Mission 2

Casting Crowns

Two songwritersGraham Kendrickborn 1950 · England · Baptist background"The Servant King" (1983)Jesus leaves heaven to serve (echoesPhilippians 2:6–8)"Meekness and Majesty" (1986)Jesus fully God and fully human"Shine, Jesus, Shine" (1987)Christ the light of the worldCo-founded March for Jesus (1987)Casting Crownsformed 1999 · USA · by Mark Hall, a youthpastor"Who Am I"wonder that God knows and loves eachperson"Praise You in This Storm"trusting and praising God in suffering"If We Are the Body"churches must welcome outsiders
  • Casting Crowns: American Christian rock band formed in 1999 by Mark Hall, a youth pastor, with students from his church.
  • Hall kept working as a youth pastor while the band toured: the songs come from church life.
  • "Who Am I": wonder that the God of the universe knows and loves each person (compare Psalm 8:4).
  • "Praise You in This Storm": trusting and praising God in suffering, even when prayers seem unanswered.
  • "If We Are the Body": challenges churches that ignore outsiders; Christians as the Body of Christ must welcome them.
  • Heard more on Christian radio, at concerts and at youth events than sung at Mass.
Quick check
?A visiting student sits in on a Sunday service. Which feature would most clearly show it uses contemporary worship music?
Mission 2

Charismatic worship and tongues

Charismatic worshipwords ona screenworshipbandopen floortime ofworshipsongs flowone into thenextraisedhandsand clappingprayingaloud
  • Charismatic and Pentecostal worship stresses the gifts (charismata) of the Holy Spirit, as at Pentecost (Acts 2:4).
  • Long "times of worship": singing flows from song to song; people raise hands, clap, pray aloud.
  • Catholics too: the Catholic Charismatic Renewal began in 1967 and has prayer groups in many parishes.
Mission 2Read the source

Catechism 2641

The Catechism (CCC 2641) begins by quoting Paul: "speaking to one another in psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs; singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord" (Ephesians 5:19). Then, in paraphrase:

  • The first Christians read the psalms in a new way, singing in them the mystery of Christ.
  • Filled with the Spirit, they also wrote new hymns about what God had done in Jesus: his Incarnation, death, resurrection and ascension.
  • Praise of God (doxology) springs from wonder at all God has done to save.

Q1 According to CCC 2641, were the first Christians content with old songs only?

Show answer

No: they sang the psalms and also composed new hymns.

Q2 What were the new songs about?

Show answer

Christ: his Incarnation, death, resurrection and ascension.

  • Link: "Sing to the LORD a new song!" (Psalm 96:1).
Mission 2

Where and when it is used

Where contemporary worship music is usedProtestant serviceband-led time ofworshipCatholic youth Massyouth and schoolMasses,ConfirmationPrayer groupin many parishesFestival or concertyouth festivals,Christian radioSchoolschool assembliesStreet marchsinging in citystreets
  • Protestant churches: in many evangelical, charismatic and Pentecostal churches, the band-led time of worship is the heart of the service.
  • Catholic parishes: often at youth and school Masses, Confirmation, prayer groups; worship songs sit alongside hymns and the Responsorial Psalm.
  • Other settings: youth festivals and large Catholic youth events, Christian concerts and radio, school assemblies, street marches, streaming at home.
  • Why: to reach young people, to let people pray in their own musical language, to share faith with outsiders.
Mission 2Diversity

The debates

The debate about contemporary worship musicSupporters sayCritics sayLanguageeverydaylanguagepeopleunderstandsome lyricsfocus on "I"more than "we"Depthemotional andpersonalsome lyrics thinon doctrine;repetition canfeel shallowParticipationdraws youngpeople andnewcomerscan feel like aconcert, withthe bandperformingTradition"a new song"(Psalm 96:1);early Christianswrote newhymnscan push outthe Church'solder treasuryof music
  • For contemporary music: everyday language people understand; emotional and personal; draws young people and newcomers; the Bible calls for "a new song" (Psalm 96:1); early Christians wrote new hymns.
  • The Catechism makes that last point: the first Christians composed new hymns about Christ (CCC 2641).
  • Against (or cautious): some lyrics are thin on doctrine, or focus on "I" more than "we"; repetition can feel shallow; can feel like a concert, with the band performing; can push out the Church's older treasury of music.
  • Some Catholic writers, including Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI) in The Spirit of the Liturgy (2000), argued that some pop and rock styles do not suit the liturgy.
  • Orthodox churches keep unaccompanied singing; Quakers often use no music at all.
  • Most churches mix old and new.
Quick check
?Which is a criticism some Christians make of contemporary worship songs?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Contemporary worship songs are better than traditional hymns for worship today."

Argument map: contemporary songs"Contemporary worship songs are betterthan traditional hymns for worship today."ForUnderstood by everyone; personal andheartfeltAttract young people and newcomersA "new song" (Psalm 96:1): the firstChristians wrote new hymns about Christ(CCC 2641)AgainstHymns carry richer doctrine in manyverses, tested over centuriesHymns are shared by all generationsLess dependent on a band's skill; less riskof performanceAnother viewBoth are needed: which helps thiscongregation pray on this occasion?Judge it byDo the words express Christian beliefaccurately? · Can the whole congregation joinin? · Does it suit the occasion?
  • Reasons for: understood by everyone; personal and heartfelt; attract young people and newcomers; a "new song" (Psalm 96:1); continues what the first Christians did, who wrote new hymns.
  • Also for: CCC 2641 says the first Christians composed new hymns about Christ.
  • Reasons against: traditional hymns carry richer doctrine in many verses; tested over centuries; shared by all generations; less dependent on a band's skill; less risk of performance.
  • Another view: both are needed; the question is which helps this congregation pray on this occasion.
  • Judge it by: Do the words express Christian belief accurately? Can the whole congregation join in? Does it suit the occasion?
Mission check

?A hospital chapel holds a Sunday service. One week a nurse leads a guitar worship song; the next week the chaplain uses an old chant. Most Christians who use both would say music is fit for worship when…
Mission 3

Mission 3: Jesus died once, yet Catholics call every Mass a sacrifice. What happens, step by step, and why?

Make a guess: Jesus died once, yet Catholics call every Mass a sacrifice. What happens, step by step, and why?

Mission 3

The shape of the Mass

The shape of the Mass1Introductory Rites2Liturgy of the Word3Liturgy of the Eucharist4Concluding RitesIntroductory Ritesentrance hymn and processionsign of the crossPenitential Act ("Lord, have mercy")GloriaSundays, not Advent/LentCollect (opening prayer)Liturgy of the WordFirst Reading (usually the Old Testament)Responsorial PsalmSecond ReadingSundaysGospel Acclamation (Alleluia)allstandGospelHomilyCreedSundaysPrayer of the FaithfulLiturgy of the EucharistPreparation of the GiftsEucharistic Prayer: SanctusConsecration: Words ofInstitutionpeoplekneelMystery of Faith; Great AmenCommunion Rite: Lord's Prayer, sign ofpeace, Lamb of God, Holy CommunionConcluding Ritesblessingdismissal: "Go forth, the Mass is ended."
  • Mass: the Catholic celebration of the Eucharist. Every Mass in the world has the same four-part shape.
  • Introductory Rites: gather, confess sin, praise God.
  • Liturgy of the Word: God speaks through the Bible.
  • Liturgy of the Eucharist: bread and wine offered, consecrated and received.
  • Concluding Rites: blessing and sending out.
Mission 3

Gathering and the Word

The shape of the Mass1Introductory Rites2Liturgy of the Word3Liturgy of the Eucharist4Concluding RitesIntroductory Ritesentrance hymn and processionsign of the crossPenitential Act ("Lord, have mercy")GloriaSundays, not Advent/LentCollect (opening prayer)Liturgy of the WordFirst Reading (usually the Old Testament)Responsorial PsalmSecond ReadingSundaysGospel Acclamation (Alleluia)allstandGospelHomilyCreedSundaysPrayer of the FaithfulLiturgy of the EucharistPreparation of the GiftsEucharistic Prayer: SanctusConsecration: Words ofInstitutionpeoplekneelMystery of Faith; Great AmenCommunion Rite: Lord's Prayer, sign ofpeace, Lamb of God, Holy CommunionConcluding Ritesblessingdismissal: "Go forth, the Mass is ended."
  • Introductory Rites: entrance hymn and procession; sign of the cross; Penitential Act ("Lord, have mercy"); Gloria on Sundays (not in Advent or Lent); the Collect (opening prayer).
  • Liturgy of the Word: First Reading (usually the Old Testament); Responsorial Psalm; Second Reading (a New Testament letter, on Sundays).
  • Gospel Acclamation (Alleluia) as all stand; the Gospel, read by a priest or deacon.
  • Homily: the priest explains the readings.
  • Creed (on Sundays) and Prayer of the Faithful (bidding prayers for the Church and the world).
Mission 3

The Liturgy of the Eucharist

The shape of the Mass1Introductory Rites2Liturgy of the Word3Liturgy of the Eucharist4Concluding RitesIntroductory Ritesentrance hymn and processionsign of the crossPenitential Act ("Lord, have mercy")GloriaSundays, not Advent/LentCollect (opening prayer)Liturgy of the WordFirst Reading (usually the Old Testament)Responsorial PsalmSecond ReadingSundaysGospel Acclamation (Alleluia)allstandGospelHomilyCreedSundaysPrayer of the FaithfulLiturgy of the EucharistPreparation of the GiftsEucharistic Prayer: SanctusConsecration: Words ofInstitutionpeoplekneelMystery of Faith; Great AmenCommunion Rite: Lord's Prayer, sign ofpeace, Lamb of God, Holy CommunionConcluding Ritesblessingdismissal: "Go forth, the Mass is ended."
  • Preparation of the Gifts: bread and wine brought to the altar; collection.
  • Eucharistic Prayer: "Lift up your hearts"; the Sanctus ("Holy, holy, holy"); the priest asks the Holy Spirit to make the gifts holy.
  • Consecration: the priest speaks Jesus' Words of Institution over the bread and wine; he raises each; bells may ring; people kneel.
  • Mystery of Faith: all proclaim Christ's death and resurrection; the prayer ends with the Great Amen.
  • Communion Rite: Lord's Prayer; sign of peace; the host is broken while all sing the Lamb of God; Holy Communion.
  • Concluding Rites: blessing; dismissal: "Go forth, the Mass is ended."
Quick check
?A visitor arrives at a Sunday Mass just as everyone stands to sing the Alleluia. What will happen next?
Mission 3

"Source and summit"

Source and summitEucharistsource:grace flowsoutsummit:all leadsherethe "source and summit" of the wholeChristian life (LG 11)
  • The Second Vatican Council calls the Eucharist the source and summit of the whole Christian life (Lumen Gentium 11; CCC 1324).
  • Source: the Church's life and grace flow from it, as a river flows from a spring.
  • Summit: everything the Church does leads to it, as a path leads to a mountain top.
  • So Sunday Mass is an obligation for Catholics: the week flows from it and back to it.
  • Other denominations: A later screen.
Mission 3Read the source

Lumen Gentium 7 and 11

Lumen Gentium (Second Vatican Council, 1964), paraphrase:

  • LG 7: really sharing in the Lord's body in the breaking of the bread, we are lifted into communion with Christ and with one another. As Paul says, because there is one bread, we who are many are one body (1 Corinthians 10:17).
  • LG 11: taking part in the Eucharistic sacrifice, the "source and summit" of the whole Christian life, the faithful offer Christ, and themselves with him, to God.

Q1 According to LG 7, what does the Eucharist make the Church?

Show answer

One body: in communion with Christ and with each other.

Q2 According to LG 11, what do the faithful offer at Mass?

Show answer

Christ, and themselves with him.

Mission 3

The Real Presence

Substance and appearancesappearancestaste, look, chemistry(unchanged)substancebread →Body of Christtabernaclelamp burnsCatholics believe the bread and wine becomethe Body and Blood of Christ: the RealPresence.
  • Catholics believe that at the consecration the bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Christ: the Real Presence.
  • Transubstantiation: the substance (what it really is) changes; the appearances (taste, look, chemistry) of bread and wine remain.
  • Aquinas: "the whole substance of the bread is changed into the whole substance of Christ's body" (Summa Theologiae III, q. 75, a. 4).
  • "I am the living bread which came down out of heaven… the bread which I will give for the life of the world is my flesh." (John 6:51)
  • Catholics believe Christ remains present after Mass: hosts are kept in the tabernacle, a lamp burns beside it, and Catholics genuflect.
  • So Catholics adore Christ in the Blessed Sacrament outside Mass.
Mission 3

Words, Lamb, presence, sacrifice

Words, presence, sacrifice, LambWords of Institution (Luke 22:19)Real Presenceone sacrifice of Calvary made presentnot a new or repeated sacrificeLamb of God (John 1:29) received inCommunion
  • Words of Institution: the priest repeats Jesus' words: "This is my body which is given for you" (Luke 22:19). He acts in the person of Christ.
  • Real Presence: Catholics believe that through these words, by the Spirit's power, Christ becomes present.
  • Sacrifice of the Mass: Catholics believe the body "given" and the blood "poured out" are the one sacrifice of Calvary, made present now in an unbloody way. It is not a new or repeated sacrifice.
  • Agnus Dei: as the host is broken, all sing to the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world: "Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!" (John 1:29). Jesus is the new Passover lamb (1 Corinthians 5:7).
  • The chain: words → presence → sacrifice → Lamb received in Communion.
  • Many Protestants object: Christ was offered "once for all" (Hebrews 10:10). Catholics reply: yes, and the Mass makes that one offering present.
Quick check
?Catholics call the Mass a "sacrifice". What does Catholic teaching mean by this?
Mission 3

The acclamations

Acclamations and Mass settingsIntroductory RitesGloriahymn of praiseLiturgy of the WordAlleluiabefore the GospelLiturgy of the EucharistSanctusstart of Eucharistic PrayerMystery of Faithafter the consecrationConcluding RitesMass settingsplainchantMissa de AngelispolyphonyPalestrina, Missa Papae Marcelli (published1567)classicalMozart, Coronation Mass (1779)modern parishJames MacMillan, St Anne's Mass
  • Gloria: a hymn of praise opening with the angels' song at Jesus' birth: "Glory to God in the highest, on earth peace" (Luke 2:14).
  • Alleluia: Hebrew for "Praise the LORD". It greets Christ before the Gospel; in Lent it is replaced by another acclamation.
  • Sanctus: "Holy, holy, holy" (Isaiah 6:3) joined with the crowd's "Hosanna… Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!" (Matthew 21:9). Earth joins heaven's praise before the consecration.
  • Mystery of Faith: after the consecration, the people proclaim Christ's death and resurrection until he comes, echoing 1 Corinthians 11:26.
  • Each acclamation lets the whole congregation take part, often sung.
Mission 3

Mass settings

Acclamations and Mass settingsIntroductory RitesGloriahymn of praiseLiturgy of the WordAlleluiabefore the GospelLiturgy of the EucharistSanctusstart of Eucharistic PrayerMystery of Faithafter the consecrationConcluding RitesMass settingsplainchantMissa de AngelispolyphonyPalestrina, Missa Papae Marcelli (published1567)classicalMozart, Coronation Mass (1779)modern parishJames MacMillan, St Anne's Mass
  • A Mass setting is music for the fixed parts of the Mass: Kyrie, Gloria, Creed, Sanctus, Agnus Dei (and today the Mystery of Faith).
  • Plainchant (Gregorian chant): single melody in Latin, e.g. the Missa de Angelis.
  • Polyphony: many voices woven together, e.g. Palestrina's Missa Papae Marcelli (published 1567).
  • Classical: orchestra and soloists, e.g. Mozart's Coronation Mass (1779).
  • Modern parish settings in English, simple enough for all to sing, e.g. James MacMillan's St Anne's Mass.
  • Significance: music raises hearts to God and helps "full and active participation" (Vatican II). Influence: many settings are now concert works; some say grand settings make the people listeners instead of singers.
Quick check
?Which acclamation joins the angels' cry of Isaiah 6:3 with the crowd's "Hosanna", just before the consecration?
Mission 3Diversity

The Eucharist and worship in other churches

The Eucharist in different churchesname ofservicehow Christ ispresenthow oftenCatholic: transubstantiationMassReal Presenceevery Sunday(obligation)OrthodoxDivine Liturgytruly Christ'sBody and Blood:a mystery–AnglicanHolyCommunionrange of views:real to spiritualpresenceweekly inmanyparishesLutheran–"in, with andunder" the breadand wine–Methodist / PresbyterianLord's Supperspirituallypresentmonthly or afew times ayearBaptist / Pentecostal–a memorial ("Dothis in memoryof me")–– not stated on this screen
  • Orthodox: the Divine Liturgy; the bread and wine truly become Christ's Body and Blood, a mystery not explained by "transubstantiation".
  • Anglican: Holy Communion, weekly in many parishes; views range from real presence to spiritual presence.
  • Lutheran: Christ truly present "in, with and under" the bread and wine.
  • Methodist, Presbyterian: Christ spiritually present; the Lord's Supper monthly or a few times a year.
  • Baptist, Pentecostal, many evangelicals: a memorial ("Do this in memory of me"); worship centres on Bible preaching.
  • Less structured evangelical worship: a band leads songs; prayer is spontaneous; long sermon; room for the Spirit's gifts. They value freedom and personal response; Catholics value a liturgy shared by the whole Church in every place.
Mission 3Evaluate

"Catholics should go to Mass every Sunday."

Argument map: "Catholics should go to Mass every Sunday.""Catholics should go to Mass everySunday."Forthe Church teaches the Eucharist is thesource and summit of Christian lifeSunday is the day of the resurrectionthe Church is one body: "not forsaking ourown assembling together" (Heb 10:25)the Church's law asks itAgainstlove cannot be forced; duty can makeworship routineGod is also met in prayer, creation andservice of othersillness, work or distance can prevent itmost Protestants have no such rule, andstress a free, personal responseJudge it byIs a duty a help or a burden? · Can faith growwithout a community? · What makes worshipreal?
  • Claim: weekly Mass should be a duty for every Catholic.
  • For: the Church teaches that the Eucharist is the source and summit of Christian life (all its life flows from it and leads to it). Sunday is the day of the resurrection. The Church is one body and cannot be lived alone: "not forsaking our own assembling together" (Hebrews 10:25). The Church's law asks it.
  • Against: love cannot be forced; duty can make worship routine. God is also met in prayer, creation and service of others. Illness, work or distance can prevent it. Most Protestants have no such rule, and stress a free, personal response.
  • Judge it by: Is a duty a help or a burden? Can faith grow without a community? What makes worship real?
Mission check

?Kasia, a Polish Catholic, goes to Mass in a Nigerian parish in London. The language, music and dress all feel new. According to Catholic teaching, what is the same as at home?
Mission 4

Mission 4: How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?

Make a guess: How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?

Mission 4

One God, not three

  • Christians are monotheists, like Jews and Muslims.
  • They hold to the Jewish Shema, which Jesus himself quoted (Mark 12:29): "Hear, Israel: The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4)
  • So the Trinity (Latin trinitas, "threeness": God as three-in-one) never means three gods.
  • The word "Trinity" is not in the Bible. It names a belief Christians find in the Bible.
  • This is the oneness of God: one being, one will, one God.
Mission 4

Three Persons, one God

Shield of the Trinityis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpirit
  • Most Christians believe in one God in three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Each Person is fully God, not a third of God.
  • The three are distinct (not the same as each other) but not separate (not three beings).
  • All three are equal and eternal. None was made.
  • Not three gods. Not one God wearing three masks in turn.
Mission 4

Each Person

Shield of the Trinityis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpiritCreatorsaves humanitypresent and active
  • Trinitarian Christians describe each Person like this:
  • Father: Creator and source of all; loves and cares for people.
  • Son: Jesus Christ, God become human (the Incarnation); saves humanity.
  • Holy Spirit: God present and active in the world now; guides, strengthens and gives life.
Mission 4Read the source

The baptism of Jesus

The baptism of Jesus in symbolsthe heavens were openeda voice out of the heavens"This is my beloved Son, with whom Iam well pleased."the Spirit of God,descending as a doveJesus is baptised: he comes up from the water

"Jesus, when he was baptised, went up directly from the water: and behold, the heavens were opened to him. He saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming on him. Behold, a voice out of the heavens said, 'This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.'" (Matthew 3:16–17)

  • Q1: Find each Person: who is baptised, what descends, who speaks?

Q1 Why do Christians see this passage as evidence for the Trinity?

Show answer

All three are present at once, each doing something different.

Quick check
?In Matthew 3:16–17, how is each Person of the Trinity present at the baptism of Jesus?
Mission 4

More roots in scripture

  • Jesus sends his followers to baptise "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19): one name, three Persons.
  • "God sent out the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, 'Abba, Father!'" (Galatians 4:6): Father, Son and Spirit in one verse.
  • So the doctrine grew from texts like these, then was defined by the Church.
Mission 4

The Nicene Creed

From Arius to the Nicene Creedbefore325Arius (c. 250–336) teachesthat the Son was created bythe Father325Council of Nicaea rejects this:the Son is "of one substancewith the Father"381Council of Constantinople addsmore on the Spirit: "the Lordand giver of life"todayThe Nicene Creed, in threeparts: Father, Son, Holy Spirit
  • A priest, Arius (c. 250–336), taught that the Son was created by the Father.
  • The Council of Nicaea (325) rejected this. The Son is "Begotten, not made, Being of one substance with the Father" (Nicene Creed, Book of Common Prayer).
  • Of one substance (Greek homoousios): the same divine being. Catholics say "consubstantial with the Father" at Mass.
  • The Council of Constantinople (381) added more on the Spirit: "the Lord and giver of life", worshipped with the Father and the Son.
  • The Nicene Creed is built in three parts: Father, Son, Holy Spirit.
Quick check
?What was the main point the Council of Nicaea (325) made against the teaching of Arius?
Mission 4

The Trinity in worship and life

  • Baptism is "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit".
  • Sign of the cross (Catholic, Orthodox, many Anglicans and Lutherans) traces the same words.
  • Prayer is often to the Father, through the Son, in the Spirit. Many hymns and blessings end with all three ("Glory be to the Father…").
  • Catholics: the Mass begins with the sign of the cross; the Creed is said on Sundays; the Catechism calls the Trinity the central mystery of Christian faith and life (CCC 234).
  • Trinity Sunday, the Sunday after Pentecost in Western churches, celebrates the belief.
  • Daily life: God is a communion of love, so Christians aim to live in loving community; they rely on the Spirit's help.
Mission 4Evaluate

"The Trinity is a contradiction."

Argument map: is the Trinity a contradiction?The Trinity is a contradiction.ForOne cannot equal threeThe word "Trinity" is not in the BibleDeuteronomy 6:4 stresses that God is oneUnitarians and Christadelphians reject itEvery everyday analogy seems to failAgainstOne in being, three in Persons: "one" and"three" count different thingsScripture treats Father, Son and Spirit asGod (Matthew 28:19; John 10:30;Galatians 4:6)A mystery: beyond full understanding, butnot against reasonExperienceChristians say they meet God as abovethem (Father), with them (Son) and withinthem (Spirit)Judge it byDo "one" and "three" count the same thing? ·Must a belief be fully understood to bereasonable? · Should belief rest on the Biblealone or also on the Church's councils?
  • Reasons for: one cannot equal three. The word "Trinity" is not in the Bible. Deuteronomy 6:4 stresses that God is one. Unitarians and Christadelphians reject it. Every everyday analogy seems to fail.
  • Reasons against: God is one in being and three in Persons: "one" and "three" count different things, so there is no logical contradiction. Scripture treats Father, Son and Spirit as God (Matthew 28:19; John 10:30; Galatians 4:6). Christians call it a mystery: beyond full understanding, but not against reason.
  • Experience: Christians say they meet God as above them (Father), with them (Son) and within them (Spirit).
  • Judge it by: Do "one" and "three" count the same thing? Must a belief be fully understood to be reasonable? Should belief rest on the Bible alone or also on the Church's councils?
Mission check

?A student describes the Trinity as "like one actor playing three roles in a play, one after another". How would most Christians (Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestants) respond?
Mission 5

Mission 5: If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Make a guess: If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Mission 5

One God, three Persons

One God, three Personsis notis notis notisisisFatherSonHolySpiritGodDistinct by relationships:FatherbegetsSonHoly SpiritproceedsEach Person is fully God: not three gods
  • "Hear, Israel: The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4) Catholics keep this: there is one God.
  • That one God is three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Not three gods; not one Person wearing three masks.
  • Each Person is fully God; none is a part, and none came first.
  • The Persons are distinct by their relationships: the Father begets the Son; the Son is begotten; the Spirit proceeds.
  • The Catechism calls the Trinity the central mystery of Christian faith (CCC 234, paraphrase).
Mission 5Read the source

Father, Son and Spirit in scripture

Jesus' baptismthe heavens openeda dove"This is my beloved Son, with whom Iam well pleased."a voice out of the heavensRiver Jordan · Matthew 3:16–17

"Jesus, when he was baptised, went up directly from the water: and behold, the heavens were opened to him. He saw the Spirit of God descending as a dove, and coming on him. Behold, a voice out of the heavens said, 'This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased.'" (Matthew 3:16–17)

  • Mark's account: "Immediately coming up from the water, he saw the heavens parting and the Spirit descending on him like a dove. A voice came out of the sky, 'You are my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.'" (Mark 1:10–11)
  • Paul: "God sent out the Spirit of his Son into your hearts, crying, 'Abba, Father!' So you are no longer a bondservant, but a son; and if a son, then an heir of God through Christ." (Galatians 4:6–7)

Q1 Where is each Person at the baptism?

Show answer

The Son in the water; the Spirit as a dove; the Father as the voice.

Q2 In Galatians, what does the Spirit do for Christians?

Show answer

Lets them call God "Abba, Father" as the Son does: they become God's children and heirs.

Quick check
?The word "Trinity" is not in the account of Jesus' baptism. Why do Catholics still see the baptism as evidence for the Trinity?
Mission 5

The Council of Nicaea (325)

The councils and the TrinityArius(c. 250–336) taught the Son wasthe first thing God made: "therewas when he was not"325Council of Nicaea (Constantine):the Son is "of one substance"(homoousios) with the Father381Council of Constantinople(Theodosius I): the Spirit is "TheLord and giver of life",worshipped with Father and Sonlaterthe Latin West adds "and theSon" (Filioque); Catholics say this,the Orthodox do not
  • A priest, Arius (c. 250–336), taught that the Son was the first and greatest thing God made: "there was when he was not".
  • Emperor Constantine called the bishops to Nicaea (in modern Turkey) in 325.
  • The Council taught that the Son is "Begotten, not made, Being of one substance with the Father" (Nicene Creed, Book of Common Prayer).
  • Of one substance (Greek homoousios): the same divine being, not a lesser god. At Mass Catholics say "consubstantial with the Father".
  • Athanasius (c. 296–373), later bishop of Alexandria, defended Nicaea for decades.
  • Nicaea said little about the Spirit: its creed said only "And in the Holy Spirit".
Mission 5

The Council of Constantinople (381)

The councils and the TrinityArius(c. 250–336) taught the Son wasthe first thing God made: "therewas when he was not"325Council of Nicaea (Constantine):the Son is "of one substance"(homoousios) with the Father381Council of Constantinople(Theodosius I): the Spirit is "TheLord and giver of life",worshipped with Father and Sonlaterthe Latin West adds "and theSon" (Filioque); Catholics say this,the Orthodox do not
  • Some still denied that the Holy Spirit is fully God.
  • Emperor Theodosius I called the Council of Constantinople in 381.
  • It expanded the creed: the Spirit is "The Lord and giver of life… Who with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified" (Book of Common Prayer).
  • This Niceno-Constantinopolitan Creed is the "Nicene Creed" said at Sunday Mass today.
  • Later, the Latin West added that the Spirit proceeds from the Father "and the Son" (Filioque). Catholics say this; the Orthodox Churches do not, and it remains a point of difference.
  • Development: Catholics see the councils as clarifying what scripture already teaches, not inventing new beliefs.
Mission 5

Why councils carry authority

Why councils carry authorityActs 15apostles and elders meet inJerusalem to settle a disputeEcumenical councilsbishops from the whole Church:Nicaea (325), Constantinople(381)Magisterium todaythe Pope and the bishops incommunion with himguidedby theHolySpirit"he will guide you into all truth" (John 16:13)
  • The Magisterium: the teaching authority of the Pope and the bishops in communion with him.
  • An ecumenical council gathers bishops from the whole Church; its solemn teaching on faith is a high exercise of that authority.
  • Catholics believe the Holy Spirit guides such teaching: "he will guide you into all truth" (John 16:13).
  • Model: the apostles and elders met in Jerusalem to settle a dispute (Acts 15).
  • Significance: Nicaea and Constantinople fixed the shape of belief in the Trinity; their creed unites Catholics, Orthodox and most Protestants.
Quick check
?What did the Council of Constantinople (381) add to the faith set out at Nicaea?
Mission 5

Reading Genesis 1:1–3 with the Trinity

Reading Genesis 1:1-3 with the TrinityGenesis 1:1–3, a Catholic reading"God created" → the FatherIn the beginning, God created the heavensand the earth."Spirit… hovering" → the SpiritThe earth was formless and empty. Darknesswas on the surface of the deep and God'sSpirit was hovering over the surface of thewaters."God said" → the Word (Son)God said, "Let there be light," and there waslight.John 1:1–3all things were made through the WordJewish readers do not read these verses as aTrinity

"In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was formless and empty. Darkness was on the surface of the deep and God's Spirit was hovering over the surface of the waters. God said, 'Let there be light,' and there was light." (Genesis 1:1–3)

  • The Father: the Creator, the source ("God created").
  • The Spirit: "hovering over the waters", bringing life and order.
  • The Word (Son): God speaks. John 1:1–3 says all things were made through the Word.
  • "Let's make man in our image" (Genesis 1:26): many Church Fathers heard all three Persons here.
  • Jewish readers do not read these verses as a Trinity; Catholics read the Old Testament in the light of the New.
  • Significance: creation is the work of the whole Trinity, an overflow of love.
Mission 5Read the source

Augustine: lover, beloved, love

Lover, beloved, lovelovesloverFatherbelovedSonloveHoly Spirit"Behold, then, there are three things: he thatloves, and that which is loved, and love."(Augustine, De Trinitate VIII.10, Haddantranslation)Catholic teaching applies this: Father as lover,Son as beloved, Spirit as the love betweenthem.

St Augustine of Hippo (354–430), De Trinitate ("On the Trinity", c. 400–420), Book VIII, chapter 10:

> "Behold, then, there are three things: he that loves, and that which is loved, and love." (Haddan translation, 1873)

  • Love involves three: one who loves (the lover), one who is loved (the beloved), and the love itself. Catholic teaching applies this to the Trinity: the Father as lover, the Son as beloved, the Holy Spirit as the love between them (Augustine calls the Spirit the love of Father and Son in De Trinitate XV.17).
  • So, Catholics believe, God can be love from all eternity, before creating anything.
  • Augustine: "thou dost see the Trinity if thou seest love" (De Trinitate VIII.8.12).
  • He treats this as a starting-point, not a full explanation; he goes on to look for the Trinity's image in the human mind.

Q1 Which Person does Augustine link with love itself?

Show answer

The Holy Spirit, the bond of love.

Q2 Why does the analogy fit the claim that "God is love" (1 John 4:8)?

Show answer

Love needs a lover and a beloved; within God there are both, eternally.

Mission 5

Catherine LaCugna: God for us

Lover, beloved, lovelovesloverFatherbelovedSonloveHoly Spirit"Behold, then, there are three things: he thatloves, and that which is loved, and love."(Augustine, De Trinitate VIII.10, Haddantranslation)Catholic teaching applies this: Father as lover,Son as beloved, Spirit as the love betweenthem.LaCugna: God for usTrinitycommunionthe worldussends the SonSpirit draws inWe know God as Trinity through what God hasdone for us.
  • Catherine Mowry LaCugna (1952–1997), American Catholic theologian at the University of Notre Dame; God for Us: The Trinity and Christian Life (1991).
  • She called the Trinity "a practical doctrine with radical consequences for Christian life".
  • We know God as Trinity through what God has done for us: the Father sends the Son, the Spirit draws people in. God's inner life and God's life with us are not two separate stories.
  • God's very being is communion: persons in loving relationship.
  • She argued Western theology after Augustine had often looked at God's inner life on its own, which made the Trinity seem remote (paraphrase).
  • Significance: Christians should live in communion: inclusive, just, loving relationships.
Mission 5Diversity

Augustine and LaCugna compared

Augustine and LaCugna comparedSame: both Catholic; both say God is loveAugustineLaCugnaStartingpointinward: love andthe human mindsalvationhistory: whatGod has donefor usFocusGod's eternalinner lifeGod's lifeshared with usin communityImage usedlover, beloved,lovecommunion:persons inlovingrelationshipIntimacy"more inward tome than mymost inwardpart"(ConfessionsIII.6)God's inner lifeand life with us:not twoseparate storiesCritiqueLaCugna: riskedmaking theTrinity seem farfrom everydaylifedefenders ofAugustine: hislove analogy isexactly aboutintimacy
  • Same: both are Catholic; both say God is love; both say God's love is intimate: it reaches into the human heart.
  • Augustine on intimacy: God was "more inward to me than my most inward part" (Confessions III.6, Pusey translation).
  • Different starting-point: Augustine looks inward: love and the human mind as images of the Trinity. LaCugna looks at salvation history: what God has done for us.
  • Different focus: Augustine dwells on God's eternal inner life; LaCugna on God's life shared with us in community.
  • LaCugna's critique: Augustine's inward approach risked making the Trinity seem far from everyday life. Defenders reply that Augustine's love analogy is exactly about intimacy.
Mission 5

The Trinity in Catholic life

The Trinity in Catholic lifeBaptismin the name of theFather and of theSon and of the HolySpirit (Matthew28:19)Sign of the CrossMass begins with itCreedthe Creed and Gloriapraise all threeLifelove as a community,as the Trinity lovesDeus Caritas Est 19 (2005)the Spirit changes hearts to love as Christloved: charity and mission are the Spirit'swork
  • Baptism "in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19).
  • Mass: begins with the Sign of the Cross; the Gloria and Creed praise all three; the Eucharistic Prayer ends "Through him, and with him, and in him".
  • Prayer: the Glory Be; most prayers go to the Father, through the Son, in the Spirit.
  • Life: Catholics are called to love as the Trinity loves: as a community, not alone.
  • Before creation: Catholics believe the Father, Son and Spirit have loved one another from all eternity, so God did not need the world in order to love; creation is a free gift.
  • Deus Caritas Est 19 (Benedict XVI, 2005, paraphrase): quoting Augustine, "if you see charity, you see the Trinity". The Spirit changes believers' hearts so they love as Christ loved. The Church's charity and its mission (spreading the Gospel) are the Spirit's work.
  • Compare Acts 1:8: the Spirit gives power to be Jesus' witnesses.
Mission 5Evaluate

"Human love is a good way to understand the Trinity."

Argument map: human love and the Trinity"Human love is a good way to understandthe Trinity."For"God is love" (1 John 4:8)Love shared by Father, Son and Spiritshows how God could love beforeanything was madeIt makes the mystery personalAugustine's lover–beloved–love showshow God can be love eternallyIt explains why the Trinity matters in dailylife (Deus Caritas Est 19)AgainstHuman lovers are two separate beings,but the Persons are one God (risk of threegods)Love as a "thing" can make the Spiritsound less than a PersonEvery analogy falls short of a mysteryAnother viewStart from what God has done in Jesus andthe Spirit, not from human love (LaCugna'sapproach)Judge it byDoes the analogy keep both oneness andthree Persons? · Does it fit scripture and theCreed? · Does it help believers pray and live?
  • Reasons for: "God is love" (1 John 4:8); love shared by Father, Son and Spirit shows how God could love before anything was made; it makes the mystery personal.
  • Also for: Augustine's lover–beloved–love shows how God can be love eternally.
  • Also for: it explains why the Trinity matters in daily life (Deus Caritas Est 19).
  • Reasons against: human lovers are two separate beings, but the Persons are one God (risk of three gods); love as a "thing" can make the Spirit sound less than a Person; every analogy falls short of a mystery.
  • Another view: start from what God has done in Jesus and the Spirit, not from human love.
  • This is LaCugna's approach.
  • Judge it by: Does the analogy keep both oneness and three Persons? Does it fit scripture and the Creed? Does it help believers pray and live?
Mission check

?A student says: "Before creation God must have been lonely, so God made the world in order to have someone to love." How would Catholic teaching on the Trinity most likely respond?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Christians sing to praise God, unite as one body, and remember what they believe: psalms, plainchant and hymns are the traditional forms.
  • Mass settings set the Ordinary to music; the people's acclamations (Gloria, Alleluia, Sanctus, Mystery of Faith) are short sung professions of faith.

Mission 2

  • Contemporary worship music uses current styles, simple repeated choruses and bands; modern hymns keep doctrine with new tunes.

Mission 3

  • The Mass: Introductory Rites → Liturgy of the Word → Liturgy of the Eucharist → Concluding Rites.
  • At the consecration Catholics believe Christ becomes really present (transubstantiation), and the one sacrifice of Calvary is made present, not repeated.
  • The Eucharist is the "source and summit" of Christian life (LG 11; LG 7: it makes the Church one body).

Mission 4

  • Christians believe in one God in three Persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit, each fully God, distinct but not separate.
  • At Jesus' baptism (Matthew 3:16–17) all three Persons are present.
  • The Nicene Creed (Nicaea, 325) says the Son is "of one substance" with the Father.

Mission 5

  • One God in three Persons, rooted in Deuteronomy 6:4 and Jesus' baptism (Matthew 3:16–17); Nicaea (325) taught the Son is "of one substance" with the Father.
  • Constantinople (381) taught the Spirit's full divinity; the creed said at Mass comes from both councils.
  • Augustine starts from the three of love (lover, beloved, love); Catholic teaching applies it to the Trinity: God is love from all eternity.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through The Triune God, mission and prayer (part 1) for AQA GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why do Christians sing their prayers, and why do some still use chants over 1,000 years old?
  2. Mission 2Can a worship song with drums and guitars be as holy as an ancient chant?
  3. Mission 3Jesus died once, yet Catholics call every Mass a sacrifice. What happens, step by step, and why?
  4. Mission 4How can Christians believe in only one God, yet pray to the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit?
  5. Mission 5If Catholics say God is love, who did God love before anything was made?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · AQA