← GCSE Religious Studies · AQA · GCSE Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
AQA GCSE Religious Studies B: Catholic Christianity (8063) · Theme A: Religion, relationships and families (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Theme A: Religion, relationships and families (part 2)

6 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?
  2. Mission 2Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?
  3. Mission 3Two mums, a single dad, or grandparents under one roof: what makes a family a family?
  4. Mission 4Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?
  5. Mission 5If a couple cannot have a baby, how far should science help, and who should decide?
  6. Mission 6If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?

Make a guess: Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?

Mission 1

Three ways to decide

Three ways to decideRules anddutiesNatural LawoftenabsolutistConsequencesutilitarianism,situationethicsoften relativistCharactervirtue ethicsgood actsfollow
  • An ethical theory is a method for deciding what is right.
  • Rules and duties: some acts are right or wrong in themselves (e.g. Natural Law: preserve life, never kill the innocent). Often absolutist.
  • Consequences: the right act produces the best results (e.g. utilitarianism, situation ethics). Often relativist.
  • Character: become a good person, and good acts follow (virtue ethics).
  • Religious believers use all three, alongside scripture and religious authority.
Mission 1

Situation ethics

Situation ethics: agape decidesthe most lovingthingrule(a guideline)only one absolute: agape (unselfish love)Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)
  • Joseph Fletcher (1905–1991), American Episcopal priest; Situation Ethics: The New Morality (1966).
  • Only one absolute rule: agape, unselfish love for others.
  • In each situation, do the most loving thing. Other rules are useful guidelines, not absolutes.
  • Fletcher points to Jesus putting people before Sabbath rules: "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath." (Mark 2:27)
  • Criticisms: hard to predict results; people may call selfish choices "loving"; it may allow acts many see as always wrong (e.g. torture "for the greater good").
Mission 1Read the source

Love fulfils the law

Situation ethics: agape decidesthe most lovingthingrule(a guideline)only one absolute: agape (unselfish love)Joseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)

"Love doesn't harm a neighbour. Love therefore is the fulfilment of the law." (Romans 13:10)

  • Jesus: "You shall love your neighbour as yourself." (Matthew 22:39)

Q1 How could a situationist use Romans 13:10?

Show answer

Love is the aim of every rule, so love can decide when rules clash.

Q2 How might a Catholic reply?

Show answer

Love works through God's commands, not against them: "fulfilment", not replacement.

Mission 1

Natural Law

Natural Law treePrimary precepts(as usually taught)secondary preceptspreserve lifedo not murderreproduceeducate the younglive in societyworship GodRoot: the first precept"good is to be done and pursued, and evil is tobe avoided" (Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II,q. 94, a. 2)reason discovers God's moral order in humannature
  • Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225–1274), Summa Theologiae: God built a moral order into human nature that reason can discover.
  • The first precept: "good is to be done and pursued, and evil is to be avoided" (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 94, a. 2).
  • Primary precepts (as usually taught): preserve life; reproduce; educate the young; live in society; worship God.
  • Secondary precepts apply them: e.g. do not murder (from preserving life).
Mission 1Read the source

Aquinas on natural inclinations

Natural Law treePrimary precepts(as usually taught)secondary preceptspreserve lifedo not murderreproduceeducate the younglive in societyworship GodRoot: the first precept"good is to be done and pursued, and evil is tobe avoided" (Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II,q. 94, a. 2)reason discovers God's moral order in humannature

"whatever is a means of preserving human life, and of warding off its obstacles, belongs to the natural law" (Summa Theologiae I-II, q. 94, a. 2)

  • Aquinas adds: humans also share with animals the inclination to "sexual intercourse, education of offspring", and, by reason, "to know the truth about God, and to live in society".

Q1 Which primary precept does the first sentence describe?

Show answer

Preserve life.

Q2 How does Aquinas find these precepts?

Show answer

By reason, from the natural inclinations of human nature.

Mission 1

Virtue ethics

Virtue as the meancowardiceextremecouragethe mean: a virtuerecklessnessextremea virtue is a habit, the mean between twoextremes; the aim: eudaimonia (flourishing)Aristotle (384–322 BCE), Nicomachean Ethics
  • Aristotle (384–322 BCE), Nicomachean Ethics: become a person of good character; aim at eudaimonia (flourishing).
  • A virtue is a habit, the mean between two extremes: courage lies between cowardice and recklessness.
  • Christian virtues: faith, hope and love: "The greatest of these is love." (1 Corinthians 13:13). Also the cardinal virtues: prudence, justice, fortitude and temperance.
  • Criticism: it does not tell you exactly what to do in a hard case.
Quick check
?A Catholic doctor refuses to perform an abortion, saying "Innocent life must always be preserved, whatever the circumstances." Which approach does this most reflect?
Mission 1Diversity

One issue, several theories

One issue, several theoriesRule-basedConsequences / loveDivorcesanctity of vows: apromise before Godmust be keptcompassion: love maymean letting anunhappy couple part(situation ethics)Racial discriminationall people are equal(image of God;Humanist humanrights)positive discriminationmay give a faireroutcome (utilitarian);critics: still treatingpeople by race
  • Divorce: sanctity of vows: a promise before God must be kept (absolutist) · compassion: love may mean letting an unhappy couple part (situation ethics).
  • Racial discrimination: all people are equal (image of God; Humanist human rights) · positive discrimination: favouring under-represented groups may produce a fairer outcome (utilitarian), but critics say it is still treating people by race.
Mission 1Evaluate

"Love is the only rule a Christian needs."

Argument map: love the only rule?"Love is the only rule a Christian needs."ForRomans 13:10 and Matthew 22:39: lovefulfils the lawJesus put people before Sabbath rules(Mark 2:27)Rules cannot cover every situationAgainstCatholic teaching: some acts are alwayswrong, whatever the motiveHumans easily mistake selfish wishes forloveClear rules protect the weakJesus also kept and taught thecommandmentsAnother viewUse both: rules as the normal guide, lovefor the hard casesJudge it byCan humans predict which act is most loving?· Do absolute rules ever cause harm? · Whatdo scripture and tradition say about rules?
  • Reasons for: Romans 13:10 and Matthew 22:39: love fulfils the law; Jesus put people before Sabbath rules (Mark 2:27); rules cannot cover every situation.
  • Reasons against: Catholic teaching holds some acts are always wrong, whatever the motive; humans easily mistake selfish wishes for love; clear rules protect the weak; Jesus also kept and taught the commandments.
  • Another view: use both: rules as the normal guide, love for the hard cases.
  • Judge it by: Can humans predict which act is most loving? Do absolute rules ever cause harm? What do scripture and tradition say about rules?
Mission check

?A hospital has one donor heart. Patient X is a young parent; patient Y is older and has waited longer. Which reasoning best fits virtue ethics?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?

Make a guess: Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?

Mission 2

Methods and reasons

Methods of contraceptionArtificialBarrier: condomHormonal: pill, implant; someemergency pills*IUD: the coil*Natural (NFP): avoid sex on fertiledays, tracked by body signsPermanent: sterilisation: vasectomy(men), tubal ligation (women)* May act after conception: some emergencypills, the IUD in some cases. Many believerswho accept contraception reject these, seeingthem as close to abortion.
  • Contraception: deliberately preventing pregnancy. Family planning: deciding whether, when and how many children to have.
  • Artificial methods: barrier (condom), hormonal (pill, implant), IUD (coil).
  • Natural methods (natural family planning, NFP): avoiding sex on the woman's fertile days, tracked by body signs.
  • Permanent: sterilisation (vasectomy for men, tubal ligation for women).
  • Some methods may work after conception (some emergency pills, the IUD in some cases). Many believers who accept contraception reject these, seeing them as close to abortion.
  • Reasons: spacing children, health, money, the couple's relationship; condoms also protect against STIs.
Mission 2

Catholic teaching: Humanae Vitae

Humanae Vitae: two meanings never separatedHumanae VitaePope Paul VI, 1968 (Catholic teaching)UnitiveProcreativejoins the coupleopen to new lifeneverseparated(HV 12)Natural family planning (NFP): forserious reasons (HV 16)Artificial contraception and sterilisation(HV 14)
  • Humanae Vitae (Pope Paul VI, 1968), paraphrase: sex in marriage has two meanings, unitive (joining the couple) and procreative (open to new life). They must never be separated (HV 12).
  • So each act of intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11): artificial contraception and sterilisation are wrong (HV 14).
  • Responsible parenthood (HV 10): couples may space births for serious reasons using NFP, which works with the body's natural rhythm (HV 16).
Mission 2Read the source

"Be fruitful"

"God blessed them. God said to them, 'Be fruitful, multiply, fill the earth, and subdue it.'" (Genesis 1:28, WEBBE)

  • Catholic reading: children are a gift and a purpose of marriage; the couple cooperates with God the Creator, so sex should stay open to life.
  • Many Protestants: a blessing on humanity as a whole; it does not require every couple to have as many children as possible.

Q1 What does God tell the first humans to do?

Show answer

Be fruitful and multiply: have children.

Q2 Why might a Protestant say this verse still allows contraception?

Show answer

It blesses humanity's growth in general; responsible choices about family size can honour it.

Quick check
?A Catholic married couple have serious health reasons to avoid a pregnancy for two years. What does Catholic teaching allow?
Mission 2Diversity

Other Christians

The range of Christian views on contraceptionNatural methods onlyCouple's conscience123451Catholic: natural methods only2Some conservative evangelicals: leavefamily size to God; avoid contraception3Orthodox: many allow non-abortivemethods within marriage, after pastoralguidance4Church of England: accepted for goodreasons (Lambeth 1930); the couple'sconscience (1958)5Methodists and most Protestants:responsible use is good stewardshipAll these Christians reject methods that actafter conception if they see them as ending alife.
  • Church of England: the Lambeth Conference of 1930 first accepted contraception within marriage for good reasons; by 1958 it called family planning a matter of the couple's conscience.
  • Methodists and most Protestants: responsible use of contraception within marriage is good stewardship; it can strengthen the couple's love.
  • Orthodox: many allow non-abortive methods within marriage after pastoral guidance.
  • Some conservative evangelicals: leave family size to God and avoid contraception.
  • All these Christians reject methods that act after conception if they see them as ending a life.
  • Many Catholics use contraception in practice, though the teaching has not changed.
  • Beyond Christianity: most Sunni Muslim scholars allow reversible methods within marriage, with both spouses' consent, but not methods that act after conception.
Mission 2

Situation ethics and non-religious views

Situation ethics: agape decidesSituation ethicsJoseph Fletcher, Situation Ethics (1966)agapeselfless lovehealththe couple'srelationshipresourcesthe child'swelfareExampleA couple where another pregnancy couldendanger the mother's life: the loving act maybe reliable contraception.
  • Situation ethics (Joseph Fletcher, 1905–1991, Situation Ethics, 1966): the only absolute is agape (selfless love). Do the most loving thing in each situation.
  • E.g. a couple where another pregnancy could endanger the mother's life: the loving act may be reliable contraception.
  • Humanists: decide by reason and consequences: health, the child's welfare, the couple's choice, the planet's resources.
  • Atheists: no divine command against it; most support easy access.
  • Catholic response: love is not measured only by results; Humanae Vitae warned that contraception could lead to less respect for women and more infidelity (HV 17).
  • Other Christians reply: agape and Jesus' command to love fit well with responsible parenthood.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Family planning should be left to the couple, not religious teaching."

Argument map: family planning and the couple"Family planning should be left to thecouple, not religious teaching."ForThe couple knows their health, money andrelationshipSituation ethics: love decides case by caseHumanists: personal freedomMost Protestants and many Jews, Hindus,Buddhists and Sikhs leave it to conscienceAgainstCatholics: the meaning of sex comes fromGod, not from choice (Humanae Vitae)A conscience needs forming by teachingChildren are a gift, not a lifestyle decisionSome methods may end a lifeAnother viewThe couple decides, but within religious limits(e.g. no methods that act after conception).Judge it byWho has authority over moral choices? · Isevery act or the whole marriage what must beopen to life? · How much do consequencesmatter?
  • Reasons for: the couple knows their health, money and relationship; situation ethics: love decides case by case; Humanists: personal freedom; most Protestants and many Jews, Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs leave it to conscience.
  • Reasons against: Catholics: the meaning of sex comes from God, not from choice (Humanae Vitae); a conscience needs forming by teaching; children are a gift, not a lifestyle decision; some methods may end a life.
  • Another view: the couple decides, but within religious limits (e.g. no methods that act after conception).
  • Judge it by: Who has authority over moral choices? Is every act or the whole marriage what must be open to life? How much do consequences matter?
Mission 2Worked answer

Contrasting beliefs with a source

Contrasting beliefs with a sourceBelief 1Catholics believe artificial contraception iswrong.SourceHumanae Vitae (1968) teaches that each actof intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11).DevelopmentA condom or pill closes the act to life, so onlynatural family planning is allowed, and onlyfor serious reasons.contrastBelief 2Many Protestants, e.g. the Church of England,accept contraception within marriage.SourceThey read "Be fruitful, multiply" (Genesis1:28) as a blessing on humanity as a whole,not a rule for every act.DevelopmentSo responsible parenthood can be loving(agape), helping the couple care for thechildren they have.

Question: Explain two contrasting religious beliefs about contraception. Refer to sacred writings or another source of religious belief.

  • Belief 1: Catholics believe artificial contraception is wrong. Source: Humanae Vitae (1968) teaches that each act of intercourse must stay open to life (HV 11). Development: a condom or pill closes the act to life, so only natural family planning is allowed, and only for serious reasons.
  • Belief 2: many Protestants, e.g. the Church of England, accept contraception within marriage. Source: they read "Be fruitful, multiply" (Genesis 1:28) as a blessing on humanity as a whole, not a rule for every act. Development: so responsible parenthood can be loving (agape), helping the couple care for the children they have.
Mission check

?A doctor in a busy clinic is asked by two married patients from different faiths whether their religion allows them to use an implant to space their children. Which reply would be most accurate for both a Church of England patient and a Sunni Muslim patient?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Two mums, a single dad, or grandparents under one roof: what makes a family a family?

Make a guess: Two mums, a single dad, or grandparents under one roof: what makes a family a family?

Mission 3

Types of family

Types of familyNucleartwo parents and theirchildrenExtendedwider relatives livingtogether or closelyinvolvedSingle-parentone parent raisingthe childrenBlended(step-family)parents with childrenfrom earlierrelationshipsSame-sex parentstwo mothers or twofathers
  • Nuclear: two parents and their children.
  • Extended: wider relatives (grandparents, aunts, cousins) living together or closely involved.
  • Single-parent: one parent raising the children.
  • Blended (step-family): parents with children from earlier relationships.
  • Same-sex parents: two mothers or two fathers.
  • Also adoptive and foster families.
Mission 3

What families are for

What families are forFamilyProcreationGenesis 1:28StabilityProtection ofchildrenBuilding blockof societyCare acrossgenerationsExodus 20:12Educatingchildren in afaith
  • Procreation: having children: "Be fruitful, multiply" (Genesis 1:28).
  • Stability: a secure, loving place to grow up.
  • Protection of children: care, safety, food, home.
  • Education: values and, for believers, educating children in a faith.
  • Care across generations: children care for ageing parents: "Honour your father and your mother" (Exodus 20:12).
  • Families are the building block of society: where people first learn love, duty and forgiveness.
Mission 3Read the source

Parents and children

"Children, obey your parents in the Lord, for this is right." (Ephesians 6:1)

"You fathers, don't provoke your children to wrath, but nurture them in the discipline and instruction of the Lord." (Ephesians 6:4)

  • Your spec sets Ephesians 5:21–6:4: mutual submission in marriage (5:21) leads into these duties of children and parents.

Q1 What duty do children have?

Show answer

Obedience to parents, "in the Lord".

Q2 What duty do fathers have?

Show answer

Not to provoke anger, but to nurture and teach their children in the faith.

Mission 3

Catholic teaching: the domestic church

Familiaris Consortio: four tasks of the familyFamiliaris Consortio (1981)John Paul II · FC 17 and 36–851Community ofpersonsin love2Serving lifehaving andeducating children;parents the firsteducators (FC 36)3Serving society4Sharing in theChurch's missionits life and missionThe family as "domestic church" (CCC 1656)
  • The family is the domestic church (CCC 1656, paraphrase): the first place children meet God, learn to pray and live the faith.
  • Familiaris Consortio (John Paul II, 1981), sections 17 and 36–85 (paraphrase): four tasks of the family:
  • (1) forming a community of persons in love; (2) serving life: having and educating children (parents are the first educators, FC 36); (3) serving society; (4) sharing in the life and mission of the Church.
  • The ideal: a married man and woman, open to children, faithful for life.
  • The Church supports every family pastorally, including single-parent and blended families.
Quick check
?A grandmother lives with her daughter, son-in-law and grandchildren, and looks after the children while both parents work. Which type of family is this best described as?
Mission 3Diversity

Christians and new family types

Views on family typesSingle-parent and blended familiesCatholic: welcome and support; the ideal ismarried mother and fatherLiberal Protestant: love, stability and carematter, not the family's shapeHumanist: judge a family by how well it caresfor children, not its structureSame-sex parentsCatholic: welcome in parish life; opposesame-sex couples adoptingLiberal Protestant: love, stability and carematter, not the family's shapeHumanist: an equal right to raise childrenPolygamyChristians teach monogamy: "the two willbecome one flesh" (Mark 10:8).Liberal Protestant: many Anglicans, Methodists,URC
  • Catholic: every child deserves a mother and father; a child is a gift, not a right (CCC 2378, paraphrase). So the Church opposes same-sex couples adopting, and surrogacy; it rejects IVF for every couple, married or not (CCC 2376–2377).
  • Catholics still welcome and support single-parent, blended and same-sex-parent families in parish life.
  • Liberal Protestants (many Anglicans, Methodists, URC): what matters is love, stability and care, not the family's shape.
  • Polygamy: Christians teach monogamy: "the two will become one flesh" (Mark 10:8).
  • Humanists: judge a family by how well it cares for children, not its structure; same-sex couples and single people have an equal right to raise children.
  • Debate: is having children a right (fairness to all adults) or a gift (the child's interest comes first)?
Mission 3Evaluate

"The nuclear family is the best kind of family."

Argument map: is the nuclear family best?"The nuclear family is the best kind offamily."ForCatholic teaching and many Christians:married mother and father is God's plan(Genesis 2:24)StabilityA child's link to both birth parentsAgainstExtended families give more support(many Hindu, Muslim and Sikh families)Single, blended and same-sex-parentfamilies can be equally lovingHumanists judge by care, not shapeAnother viewThe ideal and the reality differ; communitiesshould support every family.Judge it byWhat do children most need? · Is thereevidence that structure, or quality of care,matters most? · Should religious ideals shapelaw?
  • Reasons for: Catholic teaching and many Christians see married mother and father as God's plan (Genesis 2:24); stability; a child's link to both birth parents.
  • Reasons against: extended families give more support (many Hindu, Muslim and Sikh families); single, blended and same-sex-parent families can be equally loving; Humanists judge by care, not shape.
  • Another view: the ideal and the reality differ; communities should support every family.
  • Judge it by: What do children most need? Is there evidence that structure, or quality of care, matters most? Should religious ideals shape law?
Mission 3Worked answer

Purpose with a source

Why the family matters: reasons with a sourceReason 1It is where children are brought up in thefaith.SourceFathers should "nurture them in the disciplineand instruction of the Lord" (Ephesians 6:4).DevelopmentPrayer, worship and values are learned athome first.Reason 2For Catholics, the family is the domesticchurch.DevelopmentFamiliaris Consortio teaches the family formsa community of love and serves society, so astrong family builds a strong Church andsociety.

Question: Explain two reasons why the family is important for Christians. In your answer you must refer to a source of wisdom and authority.

  • Reason 1: it is where children are brought up in the faith. Source: fathers should "nurture them in the discipline and instruction of the Lord" (Ephesians 6:4). Development: prayer, worship and values are learned at home first.
  • Reason 2: for Catholics, the family is the domestic church. Development: Familiaris Consortio teaches the family forms a community of love and serves society, so a strong family builds a strong Church and society.
Mission check

?A council asks local faith leaders: "Should we fund support groups for every kind of family, including single-parent and same-sex-parent families?" Which response fits Catholic teaching most closely?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?

Make a guess: Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?

Mission 4

Roles then and now

Two religious approaches to rolesComplementarianequal in worth;different andcomplementary rolesEgalitarianequal in worth; rolesshared orinterchangeable,decided by gifts andcircumstancesEqual worth
  • Traditional roles: man as breadwinner and head; woman as homemaker and main carer.
  • Today: most couples both work; more fathers share childcare or stay at home; roles are negotiated.
  • Gender equality: men and women have equal worth, rights and opportunities.
  • Two religious approaches:
  • Complementarian: equal in worth, different and complementary roles.
  • Egalitarian: equal in worth, roles shared or interchangeable, decided by gifts and circumstances.
Mission 4

Genesis: equal in God's image

Genesis: equal in God's imageGenesis 1:27male and female:both in God's imageGenesis 2:18=ezer: helper (also used ofGod), so not inferiorGenesis 3:16"he will rule over you"after the Falla common reading: theresult of sin, not God'soriginal plan
  • "God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27)
  • Both share God's image and the same blessing and task (Genesis 1:26–31).
  • Genesis 2:18: the woman is "a helper comparable to him". The Hebrew word (ezer) is also used of God helping Israel, so it does not mean inferior.
  • Genesis 3:16: after the Fall, "he will rule over you". Many Christians and Jews read this as the result of sin, not God's original plan.
  • This is the foundational equality of women and men in the biblical tradition.
Mission 4Read the source

Ephesians 5

"subjecting yourselves to one another in the fear of Christ." (Ephesians 5:21)

"Wives, be subject to your own husbands, as to the Lord." (Ephesians 5:22)

"Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the assembly and gave himself up for her" (Ephesians 5:25)

Q1 What does 5:21 ask of both spouses?

Show answer

To submit to one another.

Q2 What kind of love does 5:25 ask of husbands?

Show answer

Self-giving love like Christ's, who gave his life.

Mission 4Diversity

Christian views on roles

Ephesians 5: to one anotherEphesians 5:21 · to one another"subjecting yourselves to one another in thefear of Christ."5:22"Wives, be subject toyour own husbands,as to the Lord."5:25"Husbands, love yourwives, even as Christalso loved theassembly and gavehimself up for her"
  • Complementarian (many evangelicals, some traditional Christians): the husband is a loving, serving head; the wife supports and respects him (Ephesians 5:22–25).
  • Egalitarian (many Anglicans, Methodists, liberal Christians): 5:21 means mutual submission; "neither male nor female" (Galatians 3:28); roles by gifts.
  • Catholic: man and woman are equal in dignity and complementary. John Paul II (Mulieris Dignitatem, 1988) read Ephesians 5 as mutual submission.
  • CCC 2207 (paraphrase): the family is the original cell of social life, where people first learn respect, care and responsibility.
  • Dignity of work in the home: John Paul II (Laborem Exercens, 1981, 19; Familiaris Consortio, 1981, 23) taught that caring for home and children is real work that society should value; women must not be penalised for it, nor shut out of paid work.
Quick check
?An egalitarian Christian is asked how she reads Ephesians 5:21–25. What would she most likely say?
Mission 4

Non-religious views

Unpaid care: shared or not sharedUnpaid housework and care: an idea, not dataNot sharedone partnerFeminist critique: "different roles" can hideinequality (e.g. women doing most unpaidhousework)Sharedone partnerthe otherRoles decided by the couple, not by sex orscripture (Humanists); many believers alreadyshare rolesReligious responsesComplementarity values women's distinct gifts;Catholic teaching says work in the homedeserves recognition.
  • Humanists: equal rights and opportunities; roles decided by the couple, not by sex or scripture.
  • Feminist critiques: "different roles" can hide inequality (e.g. women doing most unpaid housework).
  • Many atheists and Humanists support shared parental leave and equal pay.
  • Religious responses: complementarity values women's distinct gifts; Catholic teaching says work in the home deserves recognition; many believers already share roles.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Men and women should have different roles in the family."

Argument map: different roles in the family?"Men and women should have differentroles in the family."ForComplementarian reading of Ephesians5:22–25 and Qur'an 4:34Orthodox Jewish and traditional HinduteachingBiological differences (pregnancy,breastfeeding)AgainstGenesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28Ephesians 5:21: mutual submissionGGS 788: "one light in two bodies"Humanist equalityModern families need flexibilityAnother viewEqual worth is essential; whether roles differshould be the couple's free choice.Judge it byDoes "different" mean "unequal"? · Arescripture's roles timeless or cultural? · Whodecides: tradition or the couple?
  • Reasons for: complementarian reading of Ephesians 5:22–25 and Qur'an 4:34; Orthodox Jewish and traditional Hindu teaching; biological differences (pregnancy, breastfeeding).
  • Reasons against: Genesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28; Ephesians 5:21 mutual submission; GGS 788 "one light in two bodies"; Humanist equality; modern families need flexibility.
  • Another view: equal worth is essential; whether roles differ should be the couple's free choice.
  • Judge it by: Does "different" mean "unequal"? Are scripture's roles timeless or cultural? Who decides: tradition or the couple?
Mission check

?In a family, the mother is a surgeon and the father works part-time so he can do the school run and cook. Which statement best describes how the main religious traditions would see this?
Mission 5

Mission 5: If a couple cannot have a baby, how far should science help, and who should decide?

Make a guess: If a couple cannot have a baby, how far should science help, and who should decide?

Mission 5

Infertility and childlessness

Causes of infertilityIn women?eggs notreleased(ovulationproblems)blockedfallopian tubesendometriosisIn menfew spermsperm thatdo notmove wellEither partnerageillnesssmokingweightsometimesno cause isfound
  • Infertility: being unable to conceive after a year or more of regular sex without contraception.
  • Causes in women: eggs not released (ovulation problems), blocked fallopian tubes, endometriosis.
  • Causes in men: few sperm, or sperm that do not move well.
  • Either partner: age, illness, smoking, weight. Sometimes no cause is found.
  • For many couples who long for a child, infertility brings deep grief.
Mission 5

Ways to overcome infertility

Ways to overcome infertilitymore intervention ↓drugs / surgeryhelp ovulation; clear blockedtubesAIHsperm from the husband orpartner placed in the wombAIDsperm from a donor+ third personIVFeggs fertilised in a lab; embryoplaced in the wombegg, sperm or embryodonationa third person's geneticmaterial+ third personsurrogacyanother woman carries thebaby+ third personadoptiona childjoins anewfamily forgoodfosteringcare for achild for atimeor
  • Drugs to help ovulation; surgery to clear blocked tubes.
  • Artificial insemination: sperm placed in the womb; from the husband or partner (AIH) or a donor (AID).
  • IVF (in vitro fertilisation, "in glass"): eggs collected, fertilised with sperm in a lab; an embryo is placed in the womb. First IVF baby: Louise Brown, 1978, Oldham.
  • Egg, sperm or embryo donation: a third person's genetic material is used.
  • Surrogacy: another woman carries the baby.
  • Adoption (a child becomes legally and permanently part of a new family) and fostering (care for a child for a time).
Mission 5

Catholic teaching

Catholic teaching on fertility treatmentAllowedNot alloweddrugs that help acouple conceivenaturallysurgery, e.g. to clearblocked tubesadoption andfosteringIVF, even with thecouple's own eggand spermdonors (e.g. AID,donated eggs)surrogatesCatechism of the Catholic Church 2378"A child is not something owed to one, but is agift"
  • Every human life is sacred from conception; a child should come from the loving sexual union of a married couple.
  • So IVF is rejected, even with the couple's own egg and sperm: it separates conception from the act of love, and usually destroys spare embryos.
  • Donors and surrogates are rejected more strongly: a third person enters the marriage.
  • "A child is not something owed to one, but is a gift" (Catechism of the Catholic Church 2378).
  • Allowed: drugs and surgery that help a couple conceive naturally.
  • The Church urges compassion for childless couples and encourages adoption and fostering.
Mission 5

Is there a right to a child?

Is there a right to a child?adults' wishfor a childchild's rightsand welfareUK lawsingle people and same-sex couples can havefertility treatment and adoptCatholic teachinga child has a right to be born to, and raised by,a married mother and fatherHumanistsequal access; what matters is the child'swellbeing
  • UK law: single people and same-sex couples can have fertility treatment and adopt; female same-sex couples can both be legal parents (HFE Act 2008).
  • Catholic teaching: a child has a right to be born to, and raised by, a married mother and father; so the Church opposes IVF for single people and same-sex couples.
  • Other Christians: views differ: some agree with Catholic teaching; many liberal Protestants and Quakers say loving, stable care matters more than the parents' sex.
  • Humanists: equal access; what matters is the child's wellbeing.
Mission 5Evaluate

"Everyone has the right to have a child."

Argument map: a right to a child?"Everyone has the right to have a child."ForHaving a family is a deep human goodIVF and surrogacy relieve real sufferingHumanists: equal treatment for allGod gave humans skill to healAgainstCatholic: a child is a gift, not a rightThe child's own rights come firstIVF often destroys embryosSurrogacy can exploit womenAnother viewA right to try for a child with support, butnot a right to any child by any methodJudge it byWhose rights come first: adults' or thechild's? · Is a "right" something others mustprovide? · Does the method matter, or onlythe love?
  • Reasons for: having a family is a deep human good; IVF and surrogacy relieve real suffering; Humanists: equal treatment for all; God gave humans skill to heal.
  • Reasons against: Catholic: a child is a gift, not a right; the child's own rights come first; IVF often destroys embryos; surrogacy can exploit women.
  • Another view: a right to try for a child with support, but not a right to any child by any method.
  • Judge it by: Whose rights come first: adults' or the child's? Is a "right" something others must provide? Does the method matter, or only the love?
Mission check

?A married Catholic couple are told that IVF using only their own egg and sperm is their best chance of a baby. What does Catholic teaching say?
Mission 6

Mission 6: If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Make a guess: If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Mission 6

Prejudice, discrimination, equality

Prejudice and discriminationPrejudice(thought)judging unfairlybefore knowing(an attitude)Discrimination(action)treating someoneunfairly becauseof a prejudiceUK law1970Equal Pay Act1975Sex Discrimination Act2010Equality Act (now)
  • Prejudice: judging someone unfairly before knowing them (an attitude). Sexism: prejudice based on sex.
  • Discrimination: treating someone unfairly because of a prejudice (an action).
  • Gender equality: equal rights, status and opportunities for women and men.
  • UK law: Equal Pay Act 1970; Sex Discrimination Act 1975; now the Equality Act 2010.
  • Examples: unequal pay for the same work; women passed over for promotion; girls denied schooling (Malala Yousafzai, shot in 2012 for campaigning for girls' education).
Mission 6

Christian teaching on equality

Christian teaching on equalityGenesis 1:27Both sexes are made in God's image.Galatians 3:28"There is neither Jew nor Greek, there isneither slave nor free man, there is neithermale nor female; for you are all one in ChristJesus."John 20:18Mary Magdalene first told the others thatJesus had risen: women as disciples andwitnesses.CCC 1938 (Catholic, paraphrase)Sinful inequalities between people contradictthe Gospel.
  • Both sexes are made in God's image (Genesis 1:27).
  • "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." (Galatians 3:28)
  • Jesus treated women as disciples and witnesses: Mary Magdalene first told the others he had risen (John 20:18).
  • Catholic: CCC 1938 (paraphrase): sinful inequalities between people contradict the Gospel. Men and women have equal dignity (CCC 369).
  • John Paul II's theology of the body (1979–84): man and woman are equal and complementary; each is a gift to the other.
  • Catholic opposition to discrimination: the Church calls for equal pay, opposes violence against women, and supports girls' education worldwide (e.g. through CAFOD and religious orders' schools).
Mission 6Read the source

Equality and leadership

"But I don't permit a woman to teach, nor to exercise authority over a man, but to be in quietness." (1 Timothy 2:12)

  • Compare Galatians 3:28: "neither male nor female".

Q1 What does 1 Timothy 2:12 forbid?

Show answer

Women teaching or having authority over men.

Q2 How might an Anglican who supports women priests read it?

Show answer

As advice for one church in Paul's time, while Galatians 3:28 states the lasting principle.

Mission 6Diversity

Women's ministry in the churches

Women's ministry in the churches1994Church of England: womenpriests2014Church of England: law allowswomen bishops2015First woman bishop: Libby Lane2025Sarah Mullally chosen as thefirst woman Archbishop ofCanterburyMethodists, Salvation Army, URC, manyBaptists: women ministers; the Salvation Armyfrom its start (Catherine Booth)Catholic and Orthodox: male priesthoodOnly men can be ordained priests. OrdinatioSacerdotalis (John Paul II, 1994): the Churchhas no authority to ordain women. Catholicsstress roles, not worth.
  • Catholic: only men can be ordained priests. John Paul II (Ordinatio Sacerdotalis, 1994): the Church has no authority to ordain women. Reasons: Jesus chose twelve men as apostles; the priest acts in the person of Christ.
  • Catholics stress this is about roles, not worth; women lead as religious sisters, teachers, theologians; since 2021 they can be formally installed as readers and acolytes.
  • Orthodox: male priesthood, for similar reasons of tradition.
  • Church of England: women priests since 1994, bishops since 2014 (first, Libby Lane, 2015); in 2025 Sarah Mullally was chosen as the first woman Archbishop of Canterbury.
  • Methodists, Salvation Army, URC, many Baptists: women ministers; the Salvation Army from its start (Catherine Booth).
  • Some evangelical churches: women lead in many ways but not as senior pastors (1 Timothy 2:12).
Quick check
?A firm refuses to promote a woman because the manager believes "mothers aren't committed to their jobs". Which statement is accurate?
Mission 6

Does equal mean the same?

Does equal mean the same?Equal worthSamenesssame rights, rolesand opportunitieseverywhere,including religiousleadership. ManyHumanists andegalitarian believers.Complementarityequal worth andrights, but some roleslinked to sex.Catholic andOrthodox teaching,Orthodox Judaism,many Muslims.
  • Equality as sameness: the same rights, roles and opportunities everywhere, including religious leadership. Held by many Humanists and egalitarian believers.
  • Equality with difference (complementarity): equal worth and rights, but some roles linked to sex. Held by Catholic and Orthodox teaching, Orthodox Judaism and many Muslims.
  • Humanists: no reason, apart from tradition, to bar women from any role; tradition should change when it causes unfairness.
  • Catholic response: the male priesthood follows Christ's choice and does not judge women's worth; Mary is honoured above all saints.
  • Your spec asks whether treating men and women equally means treating them the same: be ready to argue both ways.
Mission 6Evaluate

"Religions treat women as equals."

Argument map: do religions treat women as equals?"Religions treat women as equals."ForEqual image of God (Genesis 1:27),Galatians 3:28, Qur'an 33:35, GGS 473,Soma SuttaWomen priests, rabbis and leaders inmany traditionsFaiths campaign against sex discriminationAgainstMale-only priesthood (Catholic, Orthodox)and rabbinate (Orthodox Judaism)Separate roles in mosquesSome texts (1 Timothy 2:12; someManusmriti verses)Practice often lags behind teachingAnother viewEqual worth is taught everywhere; the debateis whether different roles are fair.Judge it byEqual worth or equal roles? · Teaching orpractice? · Which tradition or group?
  • Reasons for: equal image of God (Genesis 1:27), Galatians 3:28, Qur'an 33:35, GGS 473, Soma Sutta; women priests, rabbis and leaders in many traditions; faiths campaign against sex discrimination.
  • Reasons against: male-only priesthood (Catholic, Orthodox) and rabbinate (Orthodox Judaism); separate roles in mosques; some texts (1 Timothy 2:12; some Manusmriti verses); practice often lags behind teaching.
  • Another view: equal worth is taught everywhere; the debate is whether different roles are fair.
  • Judge it by: Equal worth or equal roles? Teaching or practice? Which tradition or group?
Mission check

?On one street, the Anglican church's vicar is a woman, while the Catholic parish next door has only ever had male priests. Both churches teach that women and men are made equally in God's image. What best explains the difference?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Situation ethics: do the most loving thing (agape). Utilitarianism: the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
  • Natural Law: reason discovers God's moral order; primary precepts: life, reproduction, education, society, worship.
  • Virtue ethics: build good character; Catholics believe suffering can build virtues.

Mission 2

  • Catholics (Humanae Vitae): only natural family planning, for serious reasons; most other Christians accept contraception within marriage.
  • Situation ethics and Humanists judge by love and consequences.

Mission 3

  • Types: nuclear, extended, single-parent, blended, same-sex parents. Purposes: procreation, stability, protecting and educating children.
  • Christians: Ephesians 6:1–4; Catholics: domestic church (Familiaris Consortio), child as gift, not right.

Mission 4

  • Equal in God's image (Genesis 1:27); Ephesians 5 read as headship (complementarian) or mutual submission (egalitarian).
  • Catholic: equal dignity, complementarity; CCC 2207; work in the home has dignity.

Mission 5

  • Infertility can be treated by drugs, surgery, insemination, IVF, donation and surrogacy; adoption and fostering are alternatives.
  • Catholic teaching rejects IVF and surrogacy; most other Christians and many other faiths accept IVF within marriage; Humanists support regulated access.

Mission 6

  • Prejudice is an attitude; discrimination an action; sex discrimination is illegal under the Equality Act 2010.
  • Christians: Genesis 1:27, Galatians 3:28; Catholic and Orthodox churches ordain only men; Anglicans and most Protestants ordain women.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Theme A: Religion, relationships and families (part 2) for AQA GCSE Religious Studies B. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Should you follow the rules, do the most loving thing, or aim for the happiest result?
  2. Mission 2Why can one married couple use the pill with a clear conscience while another won't?
  3. Mission 3Two mums, a single dad, or grandparents under one roof: what makes a family a family?
  4. Mission 4Equal but different, or equal and the same: who should do what in a family?
  5. Mission 5If a couple cannot have a baby, how far should science help, and who should decide?
  6. Mission 6If a faith teaches that women and men are equal, why can't women lead worship everywhere?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to GCSE Religious Studies · AQA