← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/05 Developments in Jewish thought – Maimonides: Jewish theologian and philosopher; H573/05 Developments in Jewish thought – Suffering and hope
Mini-Lesson

Jewish thought: Maimonides: Jewish theologian and philosopher; suffering and hope

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?
  2. Mission 2Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?
  3. Mission 3How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?
  4. Mission 4Job did nothing wrong and lost everything. When God finally speaks, why doesn't He explain?
Mission 1

Mission 1: If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?

Make a guess: If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?

Mission 1

Maimonides writes a list

  • Moses ben Maimon, called Maimonides or Rambam (1138–1204): rabbi, legal scholar, philosopher, physician.
  • Born in Córdoba, Spain; his family fled persecution; he settled in Fustat (Old Cairo), Egypt.
  • In his Commentary on the Mishnah (Arabic, completed c. 1168) he reached Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1: "All Israel have a share in the world to come" (paraphrase).
  • Who counts as "Israel" here? His answer: anyone who holds thirteen foundations (Hebrew yesodot) of faith.
  • They are known as the Thirteen Principles of Faith.
  • Your spec writes G-d, a form many Jews use out of respect.
Mission 1

Thirteen principles, three groups

Thirteen principles, three groupsAbout God (1–5)1God exists and causes all2is one3has no body4is eternal5alone is to be worshippedAbout revelation (6–9)6prophecy7Moses the greatest prophet8the Torah from heaven9the Torah unchangingAbout God and humanity (10–13)10God knows our deeds11reward and punishment12the Messiah13resurrection of the deadGrouping is a teaching aid, not Maimonides'own. Numbers as in Ani Ma'amin.
  • About God (1–5): God exists and causes all · is one · has no body · is eternal · alone is to be worshipped.
  • About revelation (6–9): prophecy · Moses the greatest prophet · the Torah from heaven · the Torah unchanging.
  • About God and humanity (10–13): God knows our deeds · reward and punishment · the Messiah · resurrection of the dead.
  • Principles 6–13: a later mission (see Mission 2).
Mission 1

Principles 1 and 2: God exists; God is one

  • 1. Existence: God exists, is perfect, and is the cause of everything else that exists. Everything depends on God; God depends on nothing.
  • Root: "I am the LORD thy God" (Exodus 20:2), which Maimonides counts as the first commandment: to know that God exists.
  • 2. Unity: God is one, but not one as a pair has one member, nor one as a species, nor one as a body made of parts (paraphrase).
  • God's unity is unique: nothing else is one in this way.
  • Root: "HEAR, O ISRAEL: THE LORD OUR GOD, THE LORD IS ONE." (Deuteronomy 6:4, JPS 1917)
Mission 1Read the source

Principle 3: no body

> "for ye saw no manner of form on the day that the LORD spoke unto you in Horeb out of the midst of the fire" (Deuteronomy 4:15, JPS 1917)

  • 3. Incorporeality: God has no body, no shape, and nothing that happens to bodies (moving, resting, being in a place).
  • So what about God's "hand" or "eyes"? Maimonides uses the Talmud's rule: "The Torah speaks in the language of human beings" (paraphrase).
  • These words are figurative: "hand" means power; "eyes" means knowledge.

Q1 What did the Israelites not see at Horeb (Sinai)?

Show answer

Any form: they heard a voice but saw no shape.

Q2 Why does the Torah still use body words for God?

Show answer

To speak in a way ordinary people understand.

Quick check
?A student reads Exodus 15:6, "Thy right hand, O LORD, glorious in power". How would Maimonides explain the word "hand"?
Mission 1

Principles 4 and 5: eternal; worship God alone

  • 4. Eternity: God is first: before everything, without beginning. Later versions add "and last".
  • Roots: "The eternal God is a dwelling-place" (Deuteronomy 33:27, JPS 1917); "I am the first, and I am the last" (Isaiah 44:6, JPS 1917).
  • 5. Worship God alone: prayer and praise go to God only.
  • Not to angels, stars or forces of nature, and not through them as go-betweens.
  • Root: "Thou shalt have no other gods before Me." (Exodus 20:3, JPS 1917)
  • Principle 5 is about practice: what a Jew may do in prayer, not only what a Jew thinks.
Mission 1

Speaking about God: negative attributes

The negative wayGuide I.50–60Godnot non-existentnot weakEach "not" removes a wrong idea.Attributes of actionmerciful, gracious (Exodus 34:6): what Goddoes, not what God isthe world
  • In the Guide for the Perplexed (Arabic, c. 1190), Part I, chapters 50–60, Maimonides asks what words can truly say about God.
  • Positive attributes ("God is wise", "God is powerful") would divide God into parts, against principle 2.
  • So we can say only what God is not: "God exists" means God is not non-existent; "God is powerful" means God is not weak (paraphrase).
  • Each negation removes a wrong idea, and brings us a little closer.
  • Attributes of action: "merciful" and "gracious" (Exodus 34:6) describe what God does, not what God is.
  • The highest praise is silence: he reads Psalm 65 as "to Thee silence is praise" (Psalm 65:2 in Hebrew numbering, paraphrase).
Quick check
?What does Maimonides mean when he says that "God is living"?
Mission 1

Roots, development, living Judaism

Principles 1–5: roots, development, living JudaismPrinciples 1–5Tanakh rootsMaimonidesLivingJudaismExodus 20:2–3Deuteronomy4:15, 6:4,33:27Isaiah 44:6defined beliefs:who is insideJudaismunique unityno body at allnegativeattributesYigdal (c.14th century)Ani Ma'aminleast disputedtoday
  • Biblical roots: Exodus 20:2–3; Deuteronomy 4:15, 6:4, 33:27; Isaiah 44:6.
  • Maimonides' development: turns these into defined beliefs that mark who is inside Judaism; adds philosophical precision (unique unity; no body at all; negative attributes).
  • Living Judaism: the hymn Yigdal (c. 14th century) sings all thirteen at the start or end of services in many synagogues.
  • Ani Ma'amin ("I believe with perfect faith…"), printed in many prayer books after the morning service, turns each principle into a sentence of faith.
  • Principles 1–5 are the least disputed today: almost all Jewish movements affirm one God, beyond the world, to be worshipped alone.
Mission 1Diversity

Who disagreed about principles 1–5?

  • Raavad (Abraham ben David of Posquières, c. 1125–1198) glossed Maimonides' code: people "greater and better" than Maimonides had read verses literally and thought God has a body; why call them heretics? (paraphrase). Raavad himself did not hold that God has a body.
  • So the dispute was about the status of the belief: a wrong idea, or heresy?
  • Kabbalah (from the late 12th and 13th centuries) speaks of the sefirot, ten emanations of God; critics said this risks dividing God. Kabbalists answered that God (Ein Sof) stays one.
  • Progressive thinkers: Mordecai Kaplan (1881–1983) re-described God as the power in the world that makes for human fulfilment, not a supernatural person.
Mission 1Evaluate

Can a God known only by negation be worshipped?

Can a God known only by negation be worshipped?Maimonides' negative way leaves Jews witha God they cannot love or pray to.ForPrayer addresses God as "Thou", "ourFather, our King"; denial after denialseems to leave nothing to address.The Torah itself speaks of a God whospeaks, acts and cares.AgainstAttributes of action remain, so Jews canpraise what God does in the world.Removing false pictures protects worshipfrom idolatry; awe before what cannot begrasped is itself worship.Judge it byFits the Tanakh's language? · Fits how Jewsactually pray? · Protects God's unity? · Can abeliever live by it?
  • Claim: Maimonides' negative way leaves Jews with a God they cannot love or pray to.
  • For: Prayer addresses God as "Thou", "our Father, our King"; denial after denial seems to leave nothing to address.
  • For: The Torah itself speaks of a God who speaks, acts and cares (God as personal).
  • Against: Maimonides keeps attributes of action, so Jews can praise what God does in the world.
  • Against: Removing false pictures protects worship from idolatry (worshipping a false picture of God); awe before what cannot be grasped is itself worship.
  • Judgement criteria: Does the view fit the Tanakh's language? Does it fit how Jews actually pray? Does it protect God's unity? Can a believer live by it?
Quick check
?Which principle would most directly rule out asking an angel to carry a prayer to God?
Mission check

?A children's book shows God as an old man on a throne in the sky. A rabbi following Maimonides wants to explain what is wrong with the picture. Which explanation fits his principles best?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?

Make a guess: Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?

Mission 2

Principle 6: prophecy

  • 6. Prophecy: God communicates with chosen human beings, the prophets.
  • Root: "the Lord GOD will do nothing, but He revealeth His counsel unto His servants the prophets" (Amos 3:7, JPS 1917).
  • In the Guide (II.32–48) Maimonides explains prophecy as the highest human perfection: God's influence reaches a person's intellect and then their imagination.
  • A prophet must be wise and morally perfected; even then, God may withhold prophecy.
Mission 2Read the source

Principle 7: Moses

> "if there be a prophet among you, I the LORD do make Myself known unto him in a vision, I do speak with him in a dream. My servant Moses is not so; … with him do I speak mouth to mouth" (Numbers 12:6–8, JPS 1917)

  • 7. Moses is the greatest of all prophets, before or after him.
  • Maimonides lists four differences (paraphrase): Moses received prophecy awake, not in a dream; directly, not through an angel; without terror; and whenever he chose.
  • "And there hath not arisen a prophet since in Israel like unto Moses" (Deuteronomy 34:10, JPS 1917).

Q1 How does God speak to other prophets, according to Numbers 12?

Show answer

In a vision or a dream.

Q2 Why does principle 7 matter for principle 8?

Show answer

If Moses' prophecy is unique, no later prophet can overrule the Torah he received.

Mission 2

Principles 8 and 9: the Torah from heaven, unchanging

  • 8. Torah from heaven (Torah min ha-shamayim): the whole Torah we now have was given by God to Moses.
  • Every verse is equally divine: a list of Esau's descendants (Genesis 36) as much as "Hear, O Israel" (Maimonides' own example, paraphrase).
  • The Oral Torah, the explanation of the commandments, also comes from God.
  • 9. Unchanging: the Torah will not be replaced, and nothing will be added or taken away. Root: Deuteronomy 12:32 (13:1 in Hebrew numbering).
  • Context: many Christian and Muslim teachers of his time held that a later revelation completed or replaced the Torah; principle 9 denies this.
Quick check
?A prophet appears who works wonders and announces that God has cancelled a commandment of the Torah. How would Maimonides' principles judge him?
Mission 2

Principles 10 and 11: God knows; reward and punishment

  • 10. God knows human deeds and thoughts: "He that fashioneth the hearts of them all, that considereth all their doings" (Psalm 33:15, JPS 1917).
  • 11. Reward and punishment: God rewards those who keep the commandments and punishes those who break them.
  • The greatest reward is the world to come (olam ha-ba); the greatest punishment is for the soul to be cut off (karet).
  • But Maimonides adds: serve God out of love, not for reward. He cites Antigonus: be not like servants who serve their master for a reward (Pirkei Avot 1:3, paraphrase).
  • His image: a child is given sweets to learn; an adult learns for the sake of truth (paraphrase).
Mission 2

Principles 12 and 13: the Messiah and resurrection

  • 12. The Messiah will come: "though it tarry, wait for it" (Habakkuk 2:3, JPS 1917). Do not calculate the date. (Full picture in Mission 3.)
  • 13. Resurrection of the dead (techiyat ha-metim): "many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake" (Daniel 12:2, JPS 1917).
  • Maimonides stressed a spiritual world to come for souls, so some accused him of denying bodily resurrection.
  • His reply, the Treatise on Resurrection (1191): resurrection is real, a miracle, a foundation of the Torah; the risen will later die, and the final reward is for the soul (paraphrase).
  • Living Judaism: the song "Ani ma'amin… I believe in the coming of the Messiah" (principle 12) was sung by many Jews in the Nazi camps.
Quick check
?Why did Maimonides write his Treatise on Resurrection in 1191?
Mission 2

How his contemporaries received the principles

  • Raavad (c. 1125–1198) criticised Maimonides' code for calling people heretics over beliefs (e.g. a bodily God) held by sincere, learned Jews (see Mission 1).
  • Critics such as Samuel ben Ali, head of the academy in Baghdad, and Meir Abulafia of Toledo questioned his view of resurrection.
  • After his death, the Maimonidean controversy (1230s): some rabbis in Provence banned the Guide and the first book of his code; copies were burned in Montpellier (c. 1233).
  • Others defended him fiercely; Nachmanides (1194–1270) tried to calm the dispute.
  • So the principles were admired and contested from the start.
Mission 2

Later critics: Crescas, Albo, Abarbanel

The Thirteen Principles: admired and contestedc. 1168Commentary on the Mishnah:the Thirteen Principles1191Treatise on Resurrection:Maimonides replies to criticsc. 1233Copies of Maimonides' booksburned in Montpellier1410Crescas, Or Adonai: belief in Godcannot be commanded1425Albo, Sefer ha-Ikkarim: onlythree roots1494Abarbanel, Rosh Amanah: everyteaching equally binding1885Pittsburgh Platform (Reform)
  • Hasdai Crescas (c. 1340–1411), Or Adonai (1410): you cannot be commanded to believe that God exists; it is the presupposition of every command. He also sorted beliefs into different kinds.
  • Joseph Albo (c. 1380–1444), Sefer ha-Ikkarim (1425): only three roots — God's existence, revelation, reward and punishment. The Messiah is a belief, not a root.
  • Isaac Abarbanel (1437–1508), Rosh Amanah: defended Maimonides, but concluded that every teaching of the Torah is equally binding, so none is a "principle" above the rest (paraphrase).
  • The debate: is Judaism defined by beliefs, or by a Torah to be lived?
Mission 2Diversity

The principles today

The principles todayOrthodox8 · Torah fromheavenmost affirm: theboundary ofOrthodox belief12 · Messiahmost affirm13 · resurrectionmost affirmYigdal / Ani Ma'aminin Orthodox prayerbooksMasorti / Conservative8 · Torah from heavenmany reinterpret it: revelation includes ahuman elementReform8 · Torah fromheavenPittsburgh 1885:Torah inspired butwritten by people12 · MessiahPittsburgh: aMessianic Age, not aperson13 · resurrectionPittsburgh: bodilyresurrection rejectedYigdal / Ani Ma'aminReform Yigdalchanges theresurrection lineReconstructionist8 · Torah from heavenKaplan: rejected a supernatural revelationPrinciples 1–5 unite most Jews; 8, 12 and 13divide them most.
  • Orthodox: the principles mark the boundary of Orthodox belief; Yigdal and Ani Ma'amin are in Orthodox prayer books. Some Orthodox scholars note that respected authorities disputed individual principles in the past.
  • Masorti / Conservative: God, Torah and Israel affirmed; revelation includes a human element, so principle 8 is reinterpreted.
  • Reform: the Pittsburgh Platform (1885) rejected bodily resurrection and a personal Messiah (a Messianic Age instead), and saw the Torah as inspired but written by people. Reform versions of Yigdal change the resurrection line.
  • Reconstructionist: Kaplan rejected a supernatural revelation altogether.
  • Principles 1–5 unite most Jews; 8, 12 and 13 divide them most.
Mission 2Worked answer

Root, development, living Judaism

Principle 13: root, development, living JudaismTanakh root"many of them that sleep in the dust of theearth shall awake" (Daniel 12:2); also Isaiah26:19Rabbinic stepMishnah Sanhedrin 10:1: no share in theworld to come for anyone who saysresurrection is not taught in the TorahMaimonidesmakes it a principle; in 1191 defends it as abodily miracle; the final reward is spiritualLiving JudaismOrthodox: "who revives the dead" in everyAmidah · Reform prayer books: "who gives lifeto all"

Task: explain how principle 13 is rooted in Biblical Judaism and developed by Maimonides and by living Judaism.

  • Root: Daniel 12:2: "many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake" (JPS 1917); also Isaiah 26:19: "Thy dead shall live, my dead bodies shall arise" (JPS 1917).
  • Rabbinic step: Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1 denies a share in the world to come to anyone who says resurrection is not taught in the Torah.
  • Maimonides: makes it a principle; in 1191 defends it as a bodily miracle, while the final reward is spiritual.
  • Living Judaism: Orthodox Jews praise God "who revives the dead" in every Amidah; Reform prayer books offer "who gives life to all" instead.
  • AO1 tip: for each principle, three links (Tanakh → Maimonides → today), each with a named source.
Mission 2Evaluate

Does Judaism need a creed?

Does Judaism need a creed?Maimonides was right to define Judaism bya list of beliefs.ForA clear list protects Jews from error (e.g. abodily God) and gives them unity.Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1 already namesbeliefs; Maimonides only made themexplicit.AgainstBiblical and rabbinic Judaism stressespractice and covenant; emunah meanstrust more than assent (Kellner, 1999).Crescas, Albo and Abarbanel disagreed;Mendelssohn: Judaism reveals laws, notdogmas.Judge it byFits the Tanakh and the rabbis? · Unites ordivides Jews today? · Explains why Jews keepthe mitzvot?
  • Claim: Maimonides was right to define Judaism by a list of beliefs.
  • For: A clear list protects Jews from error (e.g. a bodily God) and gives them unity.
  • For: Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1 already names beliefs (resurrection, Torah from heaven); Maimonides only made them explicit.
  • Against: Biblical and rabbinic Judaism stresses practice and covenant; emunah means trust more than assent (a case argued by Menachem Kellner, Must a Jew Believe Anything?, 1999, paraphrase).
  • Against: Crescas, Albo and Abarbanel disagreed about the list; Moses Mendelssohn (1729–1786) held that Judaism reveals laws, not dogmas.
  • Judgement criteria: Does it fit the Tanakh and the rabbis? Does it unite or divide Jews today? Does it explain why Jews keep the mitzvot?
Quick check
?Which view would most Reform Jews today hold about principle 13?
Mission check

?A synagogue sings Yigdal every Friday night. A member says, "We sing all thirteen, so every Jew has always agreed with all thirteen." Which reply is most accurate?
Mission 3

Mission 3: How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?

Make a guess: How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?

Mission 3

Mashiach: the anointed one

  • Messiah comes from Hebrew mashiach, "anointed": a person marked with oil for a task God gives.
  • In the Tanakh, kings and priests were anointed: "Samuel took the horn of oil, and anointed him" (1 Samuel 16:13, JPS 1917), of David.
  • Even the Persian king Cyrus is called "His anointed" (Isaiah 45:1, JPS 1917) for freeing the exiles.
  • Later hope focused on one future king from David's line: the King Messiah (Melekh ha-Mashiach).
  • He is a human being, not divine; Jews pray for him, they do not pray to him.
  • Your spec writes G-d, a form many Jews use out of respect.
Mission 3Read the source

Swords into plowshares

Swords into plowsharesswordspearplowsharepruning hookMicah 4:3 · almost the same in Isaiah 2:4vinefig treeMicah 4:4 only

> "they shall beat their swords into plowshares, and their spears into pruninghooks; nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more." (Micah 4:3, JPS 1917; almost the same in Isaiah 2:4)

> "But they shall sit every man under his vine and under his fig-tree; and none shall make them afraid" (Micah 4:4, JPS 1917)

  • Isaiah 2:2–4 and Micah 4:1–3 share one vision: "in the end of days" all nations stream to "the mountain of the LORD'S house" in Jerusalem to learn God's ways.
  • "For out of Zion shall go forth the law" (Isaiah 2:3, JPS 1917).

Q1 What do the nations do with their weapons?

Show answer

Turn them into farm tools: war ends.

Q2 What does Micah add to Isaiah's picture?

Show answer

Each person safe under their own vine and fig tree, with no one to make them afraid.

Mission 3

The Messianic Age in the prophets

  • A king of David's line: "a shoot out of the stock of Jesse" (Isaiah 11:1, JPS 1917), filled with God's spirit.
  • Judge: God "shall judge between the nations" (Isaiah 2:4); the king judges the poor "with righteousness" (Isaiah 11:4).
  • Ingathering: God "will assemble the dispersed of Israel" (Isaiah 11:12, JPS 1917).
  • Temple rebuilt; Jerusalem a centre of worship for all nations.
  • Knowledge of God: "the earth shall be full of the knowledge of the LORD, as the waters cover the sea" (Isaiah 11:9, JPS 1917).
  • Herald: Elijah, before "the great and terrible day of the LORD" (Malachi 4:5, JPS 1917; 3:23 in Hebrew).
Quick check
?Which detail appears in Micah 4 but not in Isaiah 2?
Mission 3

Maimonides on the Messiah

Maimonides' test for the MessiahA king of David's line; studies Torah;keeps the mitzvotpresumed MessiahRebuilds the Temple? Gathers theexiles?Yescertainly the MessiahFails or is killednot the MessiahLaws of Kings 11:4Side noteNo miracles needed; nature unchanged: "theworld follows its normal course"Laws of Kings 12:1
  • Mishneh Torah, Laws of Kings, chapters 11–12 (paraphrase):
  • Who: a king from the house of David, who studies Torah, keeps the mitzvot and leads Israel to keep them.
  • Test: if he rebuilds the Temple and gathers the exiles, he is certainly the Messiah. If he fails or is killed, he was not.
  • He need not work miracles.
  • Nature unchanged: "the world follows its normal course"; the wolf lying with the lamb (Isaiah 11:6) is a metaphor for peace among nations.
  • Purpose: not power or pleasure, but freedom to study Torah and know God.
  • Do not calculate the date. (Principle 12: wait for him.)
Quick check
?How does Maimonides read Isaiah 11:6, "the wolf shall dwell with the lamb"?
Mission 3

Bringing the Messiah: a purpose of life

  • AQA's three purposes: obedience to God's commandments; bringing the Messiah; repairing the world (tikkun olam).
  • The Talmud links them: asked when he will come, the Messiah answers "To-day, if ye would but hearken to His voice!" (Psalm 95:7, JPS 1917, cited in Sanhedrin 98a).
  • So keeping mitzvot is active waiting: each good deed brings redemption nearer.
  • Tikkun olam: working for justice and peace prepares the world for the Messianic Age.
  • Relative importance: many Orthodox Jews put obedience first (the Messiah comes through Torah); many Progressive Jews put tikkun olam first (people build the Messianic Age).
Mission 3Diversity

Orthodox and Progressive today

Views of the Messiah todaypersonal MessiahChabad Hasidimcampaign to hasten the Messiah throughmitzvotOrthodoxa personal Messiah of David's lineReligious Zioniststhe return to the Land: "the beginning ofredemption"Masorti / Conservativehope affirmed; person or symbol leftopenReforma Messianic Age, not a personMessianic AgeOff the line: some Haredi groups (e.g.Satmar)a human-made state forces the end; only theMessiah should restore IsraelNot a ranking
  • Orthodox: a personal Messiah of David's line; the Amidah prays daily for "the sprout of David"; principle 12 in Ani Ma'amin.
  • Chabad Hasidim: campaign to hasten the Messiah through mitzvot.
  • Religious Zionists (Rav Kook, 1865–1935): the return to the Land is "the beginning of redemption".
  • Some Haredi groups (e.g. Satmar): a human-made state forces the end; only the Messiah should restore Israel.
  • Reform: the Pittsburgh Platform (1885) spoke of "the establishment of the kingdom of truth, justice, and peace among all men": a Messianic Age, not a person. Reform prayer books replaced "redeemer" with "redemption".
  • Masorti / Conservative: the Messianic hope affirmed; whether a person or a symbol is left open.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does messianic hope answer suffering?

Does messianic hope answer suffering?Messianic hope answers the question ofsuffering.ForSuffering is not the last word: history endsin peace and justice (Micah 4).It sustained Jews through exile andpersecution; Ani Ma'amin was sung in thecamps.AgainstIt does not explain why the innocent suffernow.False messiahs (Bar Kokhba, 132–135 CE;Shabbetai Tzvi, 1665–66) brought moresuffering.For Maimonides the Messianic Age leavesnature unchanged: illness and death goon.Judge it byIs "answer" an explanation or a hope? · Doesit fit Orthodox and Progressive views alike? ·Does it help the person suffering now?
  • Claim: Messianic hope answers the question of suffering.
  • For: Suffering is not the last word: history ends in peace and justice (Micah 4).
  • For: It sustained Jews through exile and persecution; Ani Ma'amin was sung in the camps.
  • Against: It does not explain why the innocent suffer now (Job).
  • Against: False messiahs (Bar Kokhba, 132–135 CE; Shabbetai Tzvi, 1665–66) brought more suffering.
  • Against: For Maimonides the Messianic Age leaves nature unchanged: illness and death go on.
  • Judgement criteria: Is "answer" an explanation or a hope? Does it fit Orthodox and Progressive views alike? Does it help the person suffering now?
Quick check
?Which view would most Reform Jews hold about the Messiah?
Mission check

?A leader of David's line rallies thousands to free Jerusalem from an empire, wins early battles and is then killed. His followers had called him the Messiah. How would a Jew following Maimonides judge the claim?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Job did nothing wrong and lost everything. When God finally speaks, why doesn't He explain?

Make a guess: Job did nothing wrong and lost everything. When God finally speaks, why doesn't He explain?

Mission 4

The book of Job

The shape of the book of Job1–2the heavenly court, thetestset: 1–23Job's lamentset: 34 →the friends' speeches (4:the first friend)set: 438 →God's speeches (38:God speaks)set: 3842:1–6Job's replyset: 4242:7–17the restorationset: 42prose frame: 1–2 and 42:7–17 · poetry: 3:1–42:6
  • Job is in the Ketuvim (Writings), among the wisdom books.
  • Shape: a prose frame (chapters 1–2 and 42:7–17) around long poetry (3:1–42:6).
  • Prose: the heavenly court, the test, the restoration. Poetry: Job's lament, the friends' speeches, God's speeches, Job's reply.
  • The question: why do the righteous suffer? Is suffering always punishment?
  • Your study: chapters 1–4 (test, lament, first friend), 38 (God speaks) and 42 (ending).
  • Your spec writes G-d, a form many Jews use out of respect.
Mission 4Read the source

"Doth Job fear God for nought?"

> "that man was whole-hearted and upright, and one that feared God, and shunned evil." (Job 1:1, JPS 1917)

> "Then Satan answered the LORD, and said: 'Doth Job fear God for nought?'" (Job 1:9, JPS 1917)

  • Satan here is Hebrew ha-satan, "the adversary": a member of God's court who tests, not the devil of later thought.
  • His charge: Job is good only because he is rewarded. Take the reward away, and Job will curse God.
  • So the test is about disinterested faith: serving God for nothing.

Q1 What four qualities does Job 1:1 give him?

Show answer

Whole-hearted, upright, God-fearing, shunning evil.

Q2 What is the adversary really questioning?

Show answer

Whether anyone serves God except for reward.

Mission 4

The test: Job 1–2

  • Job loses his oxen, sheep, camels, servants and all ten children in one day.
  • His response: "the LORD gave, and the LORD hath taken away; blessed be the name of the LORD" (Job 1:21, JPS 1917).
  • God says the adversary moved Him against Job "to destroy him without cause" (Job 2:3, JPS 1917): the suffering is undeserved.
  • Then Job is struck with sores. His wife: "blaspheme God, and die" (Job 2:9, JPS 1917).
  • Job: "shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil?" (Job 2:10, JPS 1917).
  • Three friends come and sit with him seven days, silent, "for they saw that his grief was very great" (Job 2:13, JPS 1917).
Quick check
?What does the phrase "without cause" (Job 2:3) establish for the rest of the book?
Mission 4

Job 3: the lament

  • After seven days, Job "opened … his mouth, and cursed his day" (Job 3:1, JPS 1917).
  • "Let the day perish wherein I was born" (Job 3:3, JPS 1917).
  • "Why died I not from the womb?" (Job 3:11, JPS 1917).
  • He curses his birth, not God: the adversary's prediction does not come true.
  • The lament gives permission to protest: Job speaks honestly to and about God.
  • The prose Job (patient) and the poetic Job (protesting) are both part of Jewish tradition.
Mission 4

Job 4: Eliphaz and suffering as punishment

The retribution equationsinsufferingEliphaz (Job 4:8)"they that plow iniquity, and sow mischief, reapthe same"sufferingsin?so: suffering proves sin?Job 2:3: "without cause" · Job 42:7: the friendshave not spoken rightly
  • Eliphaz the Temanite, the first friend, speaks:
  • "who ever perished, being innocent? Or where were the upright cut off?" (Job 4:7, JPS 1917).
  • "they that plow iniquity, and sow mischief, reap the same" (Job 4:8, JPS 1917).
  • Retribution: suffering is punishment for sin; the innocent do not perish.
  • And: "Shall mortal man be just before God?" (Job 4:17, JPS 1917): no human is wholly pure, so Job must have done something.
  • This view has roots in the Torah's covenant blessings and curses (Deuteronomy 11:13–17).
  • The reader knows Eliphaz is wrong about Job (Job 2:3).
Quick check
?Which statement best summarises Eliphaz's view in Job 4?
Mission 4Read the source

God answers out of the whirlwind

> "Then the LORD answered Job out of the whirlwind, and said: Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge?" (Job 38:1–2, JPS 1917)

> "Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? Declare, if thou hast the understanding." (Job 38:4, JPS 1917)

  • God appears and speaks: Job's demand to meet God is answered.
  • But God asks questions: about the sea, the stars ("Canst thou bind the chains of the Pleiades?", 38:31), the raven's young (38:41).
  • God never mentions the wager with the adversary, or Job's sin.

Q1 What kind of answer does God give?

Show answer

Questions about creation, not reasons for Job's suffering.

Q2 What do the questions show about God and Job?

Show answer

God's wisdom and care cover a world far beyond Job's knowledge.

Mission 4

Job 42: reply, rebuke, restoration

  • Job: "I had heard of Thee by the hearing of the ear; but now mine eye seeth Thee" (Job 42:5, JPS 1917).
  • "Wherefore I abhor my words, and repent, seeing I am dust and ashes" (Job 42:6, JPS 1917). Translators disagree on this verse: "abhor myself", "retract", or "am comforted".
  • God to Eliphaz: "ye have not spoken of Me the thing that is right, as My servant Job hath" (Job 42:7, JPS 1917).
  • So the friends' theory is rejected; Job's honest protest is approved.
  • "the LORD gave Job twice as much as he had before" (Job 42:10, JPS 1917), after Job prays for his friends.
  • Problem: does restoration bring back the reward theory? His first children are not brought back.
Mission 4

The apparent hiddenness of God

  • In the poetry Job seeks God and cannot find Him: "Behold, I go forward, but He is not there" (Job 23:8, JPS 1917).
  • "Wherefore hidest Thou Thy face?" (Job 13:24, JPS 1917).
  • Torah background: hester panim, "hiding of the face": "I will surely hide My face" (Deuteronomy 31:18, JPS 1917), there as a response to sin.
  • Job's case is different: God seems hidden from an innocent man.
  • In chapters 38–42, God is no longer hidden but still unexplained.
  • Trust: faith in Job is not having answers; it is staying in relationship with God through protest.
Mission 4Diversity

Jewish readings of Job

Jewish readings of JobReadingWhat it says (paraphrase)Talmud (BavaBatra 15a)one rabbi: a parable; others:historyMaimonides(Guide III.22–23)Job lacked wisdom; truehappiness is knowledge ofGodRabbinic debate(Bava Batra 16a)some praise Job's piety;others: his protest went toofarAfter the Shoahthe innocent protest to God,yet hold onLiving practiceon hearing of a death: "thetrue Judge" (Dayanha-emet)
  • Talmud (Bava Batra 15a): one rabbi says Job never existed but was a parable; others place him in history (paraphrase).
  • Maimonides (Guide III.22–23): Job was righteous but lacked wisdom; when he came to know God truly, he understood that true happiness is knowledge of God, not wealth or health (paraphrase).
  • Rabbinic debate: some sages praise Job's piety; others say his protest went too far (Bava Batra 16a, paraphrase).
  • After the Shoah: many Jews read Job as the voice of the innocent who protest to God yet hold on; some, like Elie Wiesel, put God "on trial" in the tradition of Job (paraphrase).
  • Living Judaism: "the LORD gave, and the LORD hath taken away" is said in the burial service (Tziduk ha-Din) in many communities; on hearing of a death Jews bless "the true Judge" (Dayan ha-emet), and mourners tear their garment.
Mission 4Evaluate

Does Job answer the problem of undeserved suffering?

Does Job answer the problem of undeserved suffering?The book of Job answers the problem ofundeserved suffering.ForIt rejects the view that suffering is alwayspunishment (42:7).God's wisdom is beyond human grasp (Job38), so trust is reasonable.God appears to Job: presence, notexplanation, answers his deepest need.AgainstGod never tells Job why; the wager inchapters 1–2 makes God seem to allowsuffering for a test.The restoration (42:10) cannot replaceJob's dead children.Judge it by"Answer" as explanation or as response? ·Does it help believers trust God? · How doesit fit Messianic hope?
  • Claim: The book of Job answers the problem of undeserved suffering.
  • For: It rejects the view that suffering is always punishment (42:7).
  • For: It shows that God's wisdom is beyond human grasp (Job 38), so trust is reasonable.
  • For: God appears to Job; presence, not explanation, answers his deepest need.
  • Against: God never tells Job why; the wager in chapters 1–2 makes God seem to allow suffering for a test.
  • Against: The restoration (42:10) cannot replace Job's dead children.
  • Judgement criteria: "Answer" as explanation or as response? Does it help believers trust God (OCR issue)? How does it fit Messianic hope (see Mission 3)?
Quick check
?In Job 42:7 God says the friends "have not spoken of Me the thing that is right". What does this most clearly reject?
Mission check

?A young Jewish volunteer works with children in a cancer ward. A parent says, "We must have done something to deserve this." Which response best reflects the book of Job?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Maimonides (1138–1204) set out Thirteen Principles in his Commentary on the Mishnah; principles 1–5 are about God: exists, one, without body, eternal, alone to be worshipped.
  • Body words for God are figurative: "the Torah speaks in the language of human beings".
  • In the Guide, positive words about God are read as negations or as attributes of action.

Mission 2

  • Principles 6–9 are about revelation (prophecy, Moses, Torah from heaven, Torah unchanging); 10–13 about God and humanity (knowledge, reward and punishment, Messiah, resurrection).
  • Contemporaries and later thinkers (Raavad, Crescas, Albo, Abarbanel) disputed the list; the debate is about belief versus practice.
  • Today Orthodox Jews affirm all thirteen; Progressive Jews reinterpret especially 8, 12 and 13.

Mission 3

  • Messiah (mashiach, "anointed") is a human king of David's line; the prophets picture an age of peace, judgement, ingathering and knowledge of God (Isaiah 2, Micah 4, Isaiah 11).
  • Maimonides: the Messiah is known by rebuilding the Temple and gathering the exiles; nature is unchanged.
  • Orthodox Jews await a personal Messiah; Reform Jews look to a Messianic Age that people help to build.

Mission 4

  • Job's suffering is undeserved (2:3); Eliphaz's view that suffering is punishment (4:7–8) is rejected by God (42:7).
  • God answers from the whirlwind (38) with questions about creation, not reasons; God is present but not explained.
  • Jewish readings range from parable (Bava Batra 15a) and Maimonides' knowledge of God to protest after the Shoah.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Jewish thought: Maimonides: Jewish theologian and philosopher; suffering and hope for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1If God has no body, why does the Torah talk about God's hand, eyes and voice?
  2. Mission 2Maimonides listed beliefs every Jew must hold. Why did other great rabbis argue with his list?
  3. Mission 3How would Jews know the Messiah had come? What would the world look like?
  4. Mission 4Job did nothing wrong and lost everything. When God finally speaks, why doesn't He explain?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR