OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Sufism; H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Science and philosophy
Mini-Lesson
Islamic thought: Sufism; science and philosophy
5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Is Sufism a separate branch of Islam, or the heart of the same faith?
Mission 2Why would a Muslim who already prays five times a day choose a teacher and a path of training?
Mission 3A Sufi cried out "I am the Real" and was executed. What did he mean, and what do Sufis say of God?
Mission 4Why did people who prayed five times a day build observatories, hospitals and algebra?
Mission 5Can a believer follow reason all the way, or does knowing God need more than reason?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Is Sufism a separate branch of Islam, or the heart of the same faith?
Make a guess: Is Sufism a separate branch of Islam, or the heart of the same faith?
Mission 1
What Sufism is
Sufism (Arabic tasawwuf): the inward, mystical dimension of Islam. Its goal is to know and love God directly, not only to obey.
A Sufi seeks to purify the heart, remember God constantly and draw near to Him.
Most Sufis have been Sunni Muslims who follow a law school (madhhab) and pray the five daily prayers; some are Shi'a.
The name probably comes from suf, the coarse wool early ascetics wore. Other suggested roots: safa' (purity) and the ahl al-suffa, poor Companions who lived at the Prophet's mosque.
"Sufism" is a European coinage of about 1800; Sufis usually speak of the path (tariqa) or of ihsan.
Mission 1
Roots in the Qur'an and the Prophet's life
Sufis see their path as rooted in Islam's own sources, not borrowed.
Qur'an: God is close ("We are nearer to him than his jugular vein", Qur'an 50:16, Pickthall); God is to be remembered much (33:41).
The Prophet's practice: his retreats in the cave of Hira, his long night prayers, and the Night Journey and Ascension (isra' and mi'raj) are read as models of inner devotion.
Hadith: the Gabriel hadith defines ihsan: worshipping God as if you see Him (paraphrase; Sahih Muslim, Book of Faith).
Early Western scholars looked for outside sources: Christian monks, Neoplatonist philosophy, Indian ascetics. Most specialists now see some contact but stress Qur'anic roots (Louis Massignon, 1883–1962, argued this from the vocabulary of early Sufis).
Mission 1Read the source
A people God loves
> "soon will Allah produce a people whom He will love as they will love Him" (Qur'an 5:54, Yusuf Ali)
> "Verily in the remembrance of Allah do hearts find rest!" (Qur'an 13:28, Pickthall)
Sufis read 5:54 as showing that love between God and the believer runs both ways.
13:28 grounds the practice of remembrance (dhikr) as the cure for a restless heart.
Q1 What does 5:54 say about who loves first?
Show answer
The verse names God's love before the people's love; Sufis took God's love as the start of the path.
Q2 Why might a Sufi use 13:28 against a purely outward religion?
Show answer
Rest of heart comes through remembering God, not only through outward acts.
Mission 1
Why a more personal faith developed
Step 1 of 4
Wealth and empire: under the Umayyads (661–750) the Muslim state grew rich. Some pious Muslims felt luxury was choking faith and turned to renunciation (zuhd).
Civil wars (fitna) among Muslims left many wary of power and politics.
Law and theology were becoming technical sciences. Some looked for the inner life that rules and debates could not supply.
Early figures:
Hasan al-Basri (642–728), Basra: fear of God, sorrow for sin, distrust of the world.
Rabi'a al-'Adawiyya (d. 801), Basra: worship from love of God alone, not from fear of Hell or hope of Paradise (her prayers survive only in later sources).
The movement shifted from fear to love and from renunciation to knowledge of God (ma'rifa).
Mission 1
Baghdad, sobriety and synthesis
Step 1 of 4
Al-Junayd of Baghdad (d. 910): taught a sober Sufism, in which the mystic returns from experience of God to ordinary life under the law.
Al-Hallaj (c. 858–922): his ecstatic saying "I am the Real" (Ana al-Haqq) and political suspicion led to his execution in Baghdad in 922 (see Mission 3).
Manuals showed Sufism inside Sunni orthodoxy: al-Sarraj (d. 988), Kitab al-Luma'; al-Qushayri (d. 1072), Risala (1045).
Al-Ghazali (1058–1111), The Revival of the Religious Sciences (Ihya' 'Ulum al-Din): a leading Sunni jurist and theologian who found certainty on the Sufi path and argued that law, theology and Sufism belong together.
After al-Ghazali, sober Sufism was widely accepted as part of Sunni learning.
Mission 1
The orders and the spread
From the 12th century, orders (tariqa, plural turuq) formed around a founder and a chain of teachers (silsila):
Qadiriyya: Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani (1077–1166), Baghdad.
Chishtiyya: Mu'in al-Din Chishti (d. 1236), Ajmer, India.
Mevleviyya: followers of Jalal al-Din Rumi (1207–1273), Konya, Anatolia.
Naqshbandiyya: Baha' al-Din Naqshband (1318–1389), Bukhara, Central Asia.
Shadhiliyya: Abu'l-Hasan al-Shadhili (d. 1258), North Africa and Egypt.
Sufis travelled with traders and armies to South Asia, Central Asia, Anatolia, West Africa and Southeast Asia. Many historians credit them with much conversion there; others stress rulers and trade. Usually all three worked together.
Quick check
?Which development first gave Sufism a lasting social structure across the Muslim world?
Mission 1Diversity
Sunni responses
Integration: most Sunni scholars, after al-Qushayri and al-Ghazali, accepted sober Sufism; many jurists were themselves Sufis.
Ibn Taymiyya (1263–1328): attacked the idea of the "oneness of being" linked with Ibn 'Arabi, and asking saints at shrines for help. He respected early Sufis and the ideal of purifying the heart.
Muhammad ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab (1703–1792) and later Salafi reformers: saw shrine veneration and appeals to saints as shirk (associating others with God) and many practices as bid'a (blameworthy innovation).
South Asia: Deobandis (from 1867) kept Sufi initiation but criticised shrine customs; Barelwis defend saint-veneration and celebrate the Prophet's birthday.
Modernist states: Turkey closed the orders and lodges in 1925 as obstacles to a modern secular nation.
Mission 1Diversity
Shi'a responses
Shared ground: most Sufi chains trace back to the Prophet through 'Ali; Shi'a and Sufis both speak of walaya (closeness to God, spiritual authority) and of an inner meaning of the Qur'an.
Safavid Iran: the dynasty began as the Safaviyya Sufi order; after 1501 it made Twelver Shi'ism the state faith. Later Safavid scholars, notably Muhammad Baqir Majlisi (d. 1699), opposed the orders.
Why the tension: for Twelver Shi'a the Imam is the true spiritual guide. A Sufi shaykh's authority can seem to compete with the Imams and the scholars (mujtahids).
Today: Shi'a orders exist (e.g. the Ni'matullahi); many Shi'a scholars prefer 'irfan (mystical knowledge, studied in seminaries) to the orders.
Mission 1
Scholars on Sufism's place
Carl W. Ernst, The Shambhala Guide to Sufism (1997), ch. 1: European scholars coined "Sufism" and often cut it off from Islam; some modern Muslim critics accept the same split from the other side (paraphrase).
Common ground: Sufis themselves claim to be Muslims living Islam fully, not members of a separate religion.
Mission 1Evaluate
Is Sufism a separate tradition?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Sufism is a separate tradition within Islam, like Sunni and Shi'a.
For: Salafi critics and secular states have treated it as a distinct, even rival, form of religion.
Against: it has no separate creed, law or line of succession; Sufis are Sunni or Shi'a and follow a law school.
Against: "Sufism" is partly an outside label for what Muslims call ihsan or tasawwuf.
Scholar: Ernst shows that European scholars coined "Sufism" and often cut it off from Islam.
Judgement criteria: What makes a "tradition" (creed? law? institutions?)? Whose view counts: Sufis, critics or historians? Does the answer differ by time and place?
Mission check
?A Muslim in Lahore prays the five daily prayers, follows the Hanafi law school, belongs to the Chishti order and visits the shrine of a saint every year. Her cousin, a Salafi, says she has "left true Islam". Which statement describes the situation most accurately?
Most Sufis see themselves as Sunni or Shi'a Muslims living the same faith from the inside. A later mission: what the Sufi path asks of a disciple.
Mission 2
Mission 2: Why would a Muslim who already prays five times a day choose a teacher and a path of training?
Make a guess: Why would a Muslim who already prays five times a day choose a teacher and a path of training?
Mission 2
Ihsan: worship as if you see God
The Gabriel hadith (Sahih Muslim, Book of Faith, from 'Umar; also Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of Faith): a stranger in white questions the Prophet; the Prophet later says it was the angel Gabriel, come to teach the religion.
Three levels (paraphrase):
Islam: the five pillars (outward practice).
Iman: faith in God, angels, books, messengers, the Last Day and God's decree.
Ihsan: "to worship God as though you see Him; and if you do not see Him, He sees you."
Sufis take ihsan (doing what is beautiful; spiritual excellence) as their goal: the same religion, lived with full awareness of God.
Spec: "the concept of ihsan (spiritual perfection) in the Gabriel hadith".
Mission 2
Purifying the self
Tazkiyat al-nafs: purifying (and growing) the self (nafs), the part of us that wants and grasps.
Sufis map three states of the nafs from Qur'anic phrases:
The soul that commands evil (al-nafs al-ammara, 12:53).
The self-reproaching soul (al-nafs al-lawwama, 75:2): conscience awake.
The soul at peace (al-nafs al-mutma'inna, 89:27): "But ah! thou soul at peace!" (Qur'an 89:27, Pickthall)
The struggle against the ego is often called the greater jihad (a saying attributed to the Prophet; many hadith scholars judge its chain weak).
"He is indeed successful who causeth it to grow, And he is indeed a failure who stunteth it." (Qur'an 91:9–10, Pickthall). Yusuf Ali has "purifies it": tazkiya means both.
Mission 2
The role of asceticism
Renunciation (zuhd): letting go of attachment to wealth, status and comfort, not of the world itself.
Practices: extra fasting, night vigils, simple food and clothes, retreat (khalwa; the Chishti forty-day chilla).
Poverty (faqr): Sufis are often called fuqara' (the poor); the aim is to need God alone.
Limits: most Sufis reject lifelong celibacy and withdrawal; the Qur'an says monasticism was "invented", not ordained (57:27). The Prophet married, traded and led a community.
So asceticism is a training stage: it weakens the grasping nafs so the heart can turn to God.
Mission 2Read the source
Remembrance
> "O ye who believe! Remember Allah with much remembrance." (Qur'an 33:41, Pickthall)
> "Therefore remember Me, I will remember you." (Qur'an 2:152, Pickthall)
> "And do thou (O Muhammad) remember thy Lord within thyself humbly and with awe, below thy breath, at morn and evening." (Qur'an 7:205, Pickthall)
Q1 Which verse could support silent remembrance?
Show answer
7:205: "within thyself … below thy breath".
Q2 What does 2:152 promise in return for remembering God?
Show answer
That God will remember the believer.
Mission 2
Dhikr and muraqaba
Dhikr (remembrance): repeating God's names or short formulas, e.g. la ilaha illa'llah (no god but God) or Allah, often counted on prayer beads.
Aloud (jahri), often in a group circle (Qadiriyya); or silent (khafi), in the heart (Naqshbandiyya).
A litany (wird) is a daily set of prayers and formulas given by the shaykh.
Goal: to move remembrance from the tongue to the heart, until the whole person is aware of God.
Quick check
?A Naqshbandi Sufi sits quietly after the dawn prayer, repeating "Allah" in her heart without moving her lips. What is she practising?
Mission 2
Master and disciple
The shaykh (also pir, murshid: guide) trains the disciple (murid: one who wills, seeks).
The disciple gives an oath of allegiance (bay'a), often by clasping hands, and joins the shaykh's chain (silsila) back to the Prophet.
The shaykh knows the soul's illnesses and prescribes: fasting, a litany, service, silence. Teaching comes through companionship (suhba) as much as words.
Qur'anic model: Moses asks a servant of God (named Khidr in tradition) to teach him: "May I follow thee, to the end that thou mayst teach me right conduct of that which thou hast been taught?" (Qur'an 18:66, Pickthall). The lesson is patience with what one does not yet understand.
Mission 2
The tariqa: path and order
Tariqa means path: the inner way to God, beside the shari'a (the broad road of law).
A classic image: the shari'a is the boat, the tariqa the sea, and haqiqa (the Reality) the pearl. Without the boat, no one reaches the pearl.
Tariqa also means an order: a community sharing a founder, a silsila, a litany and meetings (e.g. a weekly dhikr circle).
The path is described as stations to be earned (repentance, renunciation, patience, trust, contentment) and states given by God.
So "tariqa" names both the journey and the school that trains people for it.
Quick check
?Which description of the Sufi master-disciple relationship is most accurate?
Mission 2
Sama': spiritual listening
Step 1 of 3
Sama' ("listening"): hearing poetry, chant or music to stir love and longing for God.
Mevlevi ceremony (the "whirling dervishes", Konya): the reed flute (ney) plays; dervishes turn, right palm up to receive from God, left palm down to pass it to the earth.
Their tall hat stands for a tombstone, the white skirt for a shroud: turning is dying to self.
Chishti gatherings in South Asia use qawwali (sung devotional poetry).
Listening can bring wajd (ecstasy), a state in which the listener is overcome.
Debate: many jurists forbid musical instruments; the Naqshbandiyya avoid music; al-Ghazali allowed sama' with conditions of time, place and company (Ihya', Book of Listening).
Mission 2Read the source
Rumi's Song of the Reed
Step 1 of 3
Jalal al-Din Rumi (1207–1273), Masnavi, Book I, opening lines (paraphrase):
Listen to the reed flute, telling of separation.
Since I was cut from the reed-bed, my cry has made men and women weep.
Whoever is far from their source longs to return to the time of union.
Its sound is fire, not wind: the fire of love.
Meaning (as Sufis read it): the reed is the soul; the reed-bed is its origin with God; the lament is longing; the path is the journey home.
William Chittick, The Sufi Path of Love (1983), Part III, reads Rumi's whole path as love drawing the soul back to God (paraphrase).
Q1 Why is the reed's music sad?
Show answer
It has been cut off from the reed-bed: separation from its source.
Q2 What does the reed say its sound really is?
Show answer
Fire, not wind: the fire of love.
Mission 2Evaluate
Is a master necessary?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: spiritual training under a Sufi master is necessary to reach ihsan.
For: the nafs deceives itself; a guide sees what the seeker cannot (Moses and Khidr, 18:65–82). A classical saying, attributed to Abu Yazid al-Bistami: whoever has no shaykh has Satan for a guide (paraphrase).
For: the chain (silsila) keeps teaching tested and tied to the Prophet.
Against: the Qur'an and Sunna are open to all; Muslims need no mediator between themselves and God.
Against: obedience to a shaykh can be abused; Shi'a may see the Imam, and Salafis the scholars, as the proper guides.
Judgement criteria: Is ihsan a skill learned by apprenticeship, or a gift open to every believer? What safeguards keep a master honest?
Quick check
?In the Song of the Reed, what does the reed's lament stand for?
Mission check
?A young British Muslim, already praying five times a day, joins a Sufi circle. Her shaykh tells her to repeat a daily litany, spend ten minutes in silent awareness that God watches her, and keep a diary of her anger. Which idea best explains the purpose of all three tasks?
The Sufi path adds training to the same faith: the aim is a purified self that worships with full awareness of God. A later mission: what Sufis say happens to the self when it draws near to God.
Mission 3
Mission 3: A Sufi cried out "I am the Real" and was executed. What did he mean, and what do Sufis say of God?
Make a guess: A Sufi cried out "I am the Real" and was executed. What did he mean, and what do Sufis say of God?
Mission 3
God beyond comparison
Sufis begin from Tawhid: God is One, and nothing is like Him.
Incomparable (tanzih): "Naught is as His likeness; and He is the Hearer, the Seer." (Qur'an 42:11, Pickthall)
God's essence (dhat) is unknowable in Himself: no mind can grasp it.
Yet the same verse also names God as Hearer and Seer: God is known through His names and signs in creation and the self (41:53).
Ibn 'Arabi (1165–1240) taught that both are needed: incomparability (tanzih) and likeness (tashbih) together give true knowledge of God.
Mission 3
Creation as overflowing light; God within
Step 1 of 3
A saying Sufis love, "I was a hidden treasure and loved to be known, so I created creation" (paraphrase; a hadith qudsi not found in the main collections).
So creation is God's self-disclosure (tajalli): God's names shown in the world, like light shining from the sun.
Emanation: creation flows from God as light overflows from its source. The idea came through Muslim philosophers (al-Farabi, Ibn Sina) who drew on Neoplatonism. Theologians, al-Ghazali among them, insisted that creation is God's free act, not a necessary overflow.
Things have no being of their own: they borrow it from God, moment by moment.
Immanent: "We are nearer to him than his jugular vein" (Qur'an 50:16, Pickthall); "whithersoever ye turn, there is Allah's Countenance" (Qur'an 2:115, Pickthall).
Debate: Ibn 'Arabi's followers spoke of the "oneness of being" (wahdat al-wujud). Critics such as Ibn Taymiyya called this blurring God and the world; Ahmad Sirhindi (1564–1624) taught instead the "oneness of witnessing" (wahdat al-shuhud): the oneness is in the mystic's vision, not in being.
Mission 3Read the source
The verse of Light
> "Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth. The similitude of His light is as a niche wherein is a lamp. The lamp is in a glass. The glass is as it were a shining star. (This lamp is) kindled from a blessed tree, an olive neither of the East nor of the West, whose oil would almost glow forth (of itself) though no fire touched it. Light upon light." (Qur'an 24:35, Pickthall)
Q1 List the five images in the parable.
Show answer
Niche, lamp, glass, blessed olive tree, oil.
Q2 Which phrase suggests that the light is already present before any fire touches it?
Show answer
"whose oil would almost glow forth (of itself) though no fire touched it".
Mission 3Diversity
Reading the Light
Step 1 of 3
Early commentary (attributed to Ibn 'Abbas and Ubayy ibn Ka'b): God is the guide of all in heaven and earth; the lamp is the light of faith in the believer's heart.
Al-Ghazali, The Niche of Lights (Mishkat al-Anwar, c. 1106): God is the only true Light; every other light is borrowed. He maps the images onto five levels of the human spirit: niche = senses; glass = imagination; lamp = intellect; tree = reflective reason; oil = the holy prophetic spirit, which "almost glows" by itself.
Many Sufi commentators: niche = the breast; glass = the purified heart; lamp = the inmost secret where God's light shines; oil = the natural disposition to know God (fitra).
"Light upon light": for Sufis, the light of revelation meeting the light of a purified heart.
Quick check
?In The Niche of Lights, what does al-Ghazali take the phrase "Allah is the Light of the heavens and the earth" to mean?
Mission 3
Fana: passing away in God
Fana' ("passing away", annihilation): the self's awareness of itself dissolves, until only God is in view.
Qur'anic root: "Everyone that is thereon will pass away; There remaineth but the Countenance of thy Lord" (Qur'an 55:26–27, Pickthall).
A hadith qudsi (Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of Softening of Hearts, no. 6502): God draws near to the servant who draws near through extra worship, until God becomes "the hearing with which he hears, the sight with which he sees" (paraphrase).
What fana is not: the soul does not become God (ittihad), and God does not move into a body (hulul). Mainstream Sufis rejected both.
Sober Sufis such as al-Junayd of Baghdad (d. 910) stress what follows: after fana comes baqa' ("remaining"): the self returns, transformed, to live in God and keep the law.
Mission 3
Drunken Sufism: ecstatic sayings
Drunken (sukr, intoxication) Sufism stresses being overwhelmed by God in fana.
In that state some spoke shatahat (ecstatic utterances) that sound like claims to divinity:
Abu Yazid al-Bistami (d. c. 874): "Glory be to me! How great is my majesty!" (paraphrase of the Arabic subhani).
Al-Hallaj (c. 858–922): "I am the Real" (Ana al-Haqq; al-Haqq is a name of God). Executed in Baghdad in 922: in Sufi tradition, for these words; historians also point to political charges.
Readings: (1) blasphemy, as his accusers and later critics held; (2) the human "I" had passed away, so God was speaking: as glowing iron in a fire might say "I am fire" (a classic Sufi image); (3) words of the drunk: excused, but not to be repeated (al-Junayd, al-Ghazali).
Mission 3
Sober Sufism: baqa, states and stations
Al-Junayd of Baghdad (d. 910): after fana comes baqa' ("persistence", remaining): the self returns, transformed, to live in God and keep the law.
Sobriety (sahw) ranks above intoxication: the perfect Sufi lives in the world as the Prophet did.
Stations (maqamat): stages earned by effort and lasting. Al-Sarraj (d. 988), Kitab al-Luma', lists seven: repentance, scrupulousness, renunciation, poverty, patience, trust in God, contentment.
States (ahwal): gifts of God that come and go, e.g. nearness, love, fear, hope, longing, intimacy, certainty.
Al-Qushayri: stations are earnings; states are gifts.
Quick check
?Which statement best contrasts drunken and sober Sufism?
Mission 3
Friends of God: wilaya
"Lo! verily the friends of Allah are (those) on whom fear (cometh) not, nor do they grieve?" (Qur'an 10:62, Pickthall)
Wali (plural awliya'): friend of God, one brought near; wilaya: that friendship and the authority it brings.
Al-Hakim al-Tirmidhi (d. c. 910) wrote the first full theory: a hierarchy of friends of God, and a "seal of the friends".
Friends of God may receive karamat (marvels, graces); prophets alone work mu'jizat (evidentiary miracles). Mainstream teaching: no friend of God is above a prophet.
Shrines of friends of God are visited for blessing (baraka); reformers object when visitors ask the dead for help (see Mission 1).
Shi'a Muslims speak of the walaya of the Imams; Sufis of the wilaya of the saints: related ideas, different holders.
Mission 3Evaluate
Can the soul be one with God without denying Tawhid?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Sufi teaching that the soul becomes one with God is compatible with Tawhid.
For: oneness in fana is of awareness, not essence; mainstream Sufis reject hulul and ittihad.
For: Qur'anic support: 50:16 (nearness), 55:26–27 (all passes but God's Face), the hadith qudsi of the servant God loves.
Against: sayings such as al-Hallaj's blur Creator and creature; his accusers and later critics (Ibn Taymiyya) judged them unbelief.
Against: "oneness of being" can seem to deny the real difference between God and the world.
Judgement criteria: Are Sufi words to be read literally or as language of experience? Who interprets: jurists, theologians, Sufi masters? Does sober Sufism answer the objection?
Quick check
?A Muslim critic says: "Sufi talk of the soul being one with God denies Tawhid." Which reply would a sober Sufi such as al-Junayd most likely give?
Mission check
?After years of dhikr, a Sufi describes a moment in prayer: "I was not there. There was only God. Then I came back, and I was more myself than ever, and went to work." Which pair of terms fits her two moments?
Sufis describe union with God as the self's vanishing from its own view, followed by a return to life in God, while God remains beyond comparison.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Why did people who prayed five times a day build observatories, hospitals and algebra?
Make a guess: Why did people who prayed five times a day build observatories, hospitals and algebra?
Mission 4Read the source
The Qur'an's call to look
> "Proclaim! (or read!) in the name of thy Lord and Cherisher, Who created-" (Qur'an 96:1, Yusuf Ali)
> "Behold! in the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the alternation of night and day,- there are indeed Signs for men of understanding,-" (Qur'an 3:190, Yusuf Ali)
> "Do they not look at the Camels, how they are made?-" (Qur'an 88:17, Yusuf Ali)
The Qur'an calls natural things ayat (signs): the same word used for its own verses.
Q1 What does 3:190 say creation and the cycle of night and day are?
Show answer
Signs for people of understanding.
Q2 Why might a Muslim see the study of nature as reading a second "book"?
Show answer
Both the Qur'an's verses and creation are called signs pointing to God.
Mission 4
Knowledge as a duty
Hadith: seeking knowledge ('ilm) is an obligation on every Muslim (paraphrase; Sunan Ibn Majah, no. 224).
"O my Lord! advance me in knowledge." (Qur'an 20:114, Yusuf Ali)
Al-Ghazali (1058–1111), Revival of the Religious Sciences, Book of Knowledge: medicine and arithmetic are fard kifaya, a communal duty: someone in every community must master them, or all are at fault.
Khalifa (2:30): humans are trustees of the earth; understanding creation helps them care for it.
Mission 4
Worship needed science
Qibla: facing Makkah from Spain or India needs spherical trigonometry.
Prayer times: shift with the sun and season; mosque timekeepers (muwaqqit) built tables and instruments.
Calendar: a lunar calendar needs prediction of the new crescent (Ramadan, Hajj).
Inheritance: the Qur'an's shares (4:11–12) need careful arithmetic; al-Khwarizmi's algebra book includes inheritance problems.
So religious practice gave scholars real problems to solve.
Quick check
?Which statement best explains why al-Ghazali counted medicine as a fard kifaya?
Mission 4
The translation movement
Step 1 of 2
Under the Abbasid caliphs (from 750), Baghdad became a centre of learning.
Greek, Persian, Syriac and Sanskrit works on medicine, mathematics, astronomy and philosophy were translated into Arabic (8th–10th centuries).
The House of Wisdom (Bayt al-Hikma), associated with caliph al-Ma'mun (r. 813–833), linked libraries and translators.
Translators included Christians such as Hunayn ibn Ishaq (809–873), translator of Galen; Jews and Sabians also took part.
Paper, learned from China, spread from Samarkand to Baghdad in the late 8th century and made books cheaper.
Scholars checked, criticised and extended the texts: Arabic became the international language of science.
Mission 4
Mathematics
Step 1 of 3
Al-Khwarizmi (c. 780–c. 850), The Compendious Book on Calculation by Completion and Balancing (c. 820): systematic solving of equations. "Al-jabr" in the title gave us algebra; his name gave algorithm.
He also explained the Indian decimal numerals with zero; Europe later learned them in Arabic form (hence "Arabic numerals").
Trigonometry: sine and tangent tables developed for astronomy and the qibla (e.g. al-Battani, d. 929).
'Umar al-Khayyam (1048–1131): geometric solutions of cubic equations.
Mission 4
Medicine
Step 1 of 3
Hadith: God has not sent down a disease without sending down its cure (paraphrase; Sahih al-Bukhari, Book of Medicine, no. 5678). Seeking cures is part of trusting God.
Hospitals (bimaristan) in Baghdad, Damascus and Cairo treated patients free, with wards and teaching.
Al-Razi (c. 865–925): clinical case notes; first clear account distinguishing smallpox from measles.
Ibn Sina (980–1037), The Canon of Medicine (c. 1025): a systematic medical encyclopaedia, used in European universities for about five centuries.
Al-Zahrawi (c. 936–1013): surgery, with drawings of instruments.
Ibn al-Nafis (1213–1288): described the passage of blood through the lungs (pulmonary circulation).
Mission 4
Astronomy and optics
Step 1 of 3
Observatories: Maragha (founded 1259) and Samarkand (1420s, under Ulugh Beg).
Nasir al-Din al-Tusi (1201–1274) and Ibn al-Shatir (1304–1375), timekeeper of the Umayyad Mosque in Damascus, built models of planetary motion that appear in mathematically similar form in Copernicus. How they reached him is still debated.
Al-Biruni (973–c. 1050): measured the radius of the Earth.
Ibn al-Haytham (c. 965–c. 1040), Book of Optics: sight happens when light enters the eye; he tested claims with controlled experiments, so he is often called a pioneer of experimental method.
Quick check
?Which pairing of scholar and contribution is correct?
Mission 4
Did Muslim science decline after al-Ghazali?
The old "decline" story (e.g. Ernest Renan, 1883): orthodoxy, led by al-Ghazali, killed science after the 11th century.
Historians now: major work came after al-Ghazali: Maragha (1259), Ibn al-Nafis, Ibn al-Shatir, Samarkand (1420s). George Saliba, Islamic Science and the Making of the European Renaissance (2007).
Ahmad Dallal, Islam, Science and the Challenge of History (2010), ch. 2–3: science in Islam was neither a mere copy of the Greeks nor hostile to religion; religion shaped which questions mattered (paraphrase).
Later slowdowns had many causes: the Mongol sack of Baghdad (1258), shifts in trade and wealth, late adoption of printing.
Quick check
?A student writes: "After al-Ghazali, Muslims stopped doing science." Which evidence most directly challenges this?
Mission 4Evaluate
Was the medieval achievement driven by Islam?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: the medieval Muslim contribution to science shows that Islam itself encourages science.
For: the Qur'an calls nature "signs" and commands reflection; worship needed astronomy and mathematics; hadith on knowledge and cures.
For: many scientists were also religious scholars (Ibn al-Shatir a mosque timekeeper; Ibn al-Nafis wrote on law and hadith).
Against: much built on Greek, Indian and Persian learning; Christians, Jews and Sabians took part; courts, not mosques, paid for much of it.
Against: some scholars distrusted philosophy; science later slowed in the same societies.
Judgement criteria: Is "Islam" its texts, its scholars or its civilisation? Does motivation matter, or only results? What else explains the later slowdown?
Mission check
?In 14th-century Damascus, Ibn al-Shatir worked as the timekeeper of the Umayyad Mosque and wrote new models of the planets. Which explanation of his work fits Muslim teaching about knowledge most closely?
The medieval contribution grew where faith, practical worship and inherited learning met. Next missions: al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd on philosophy (see Mission 5); Muslim responses to modern science.
Mission 5
Mission 5: Can a believer follow reason all the way, or does knowing God need more than reason?
Make a guess: Can a believer follow reason all the way, or does knowing God need more than reason?
Mission 5
Two thinkers, one question
Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (1058–1111), from Tus in Persia: jurist, theologian, later Sufi. Head teacher at the Nizamiyya college in Baghdad from 1091.
Ibn Rushd (Averroes, 1126–1198), from Córdoba in al-Andalus: judge (qadi), doctor and the great commentator on Aristotle.
The question: Greek philosophy (falsafa) had become part of Islamic learning. Should Muslims adopt it, and how far?
Al-Ghazali: use its tools, reject its errors, and look beyond reason to experience of God.
Ibn Rushd: philosophy, rightly done, is commanded by the law, and cannot contradict revelation.
Mission 5
The first crisis: doubt
Step 1 of 2
Source: al-Ghazali's autobiography, al-Munqidh min al-Dalal (Deliverance from Error), written c. 1106–1110.
As a young scholar he asked: where does certain knowledge come from?
Senses deceive: a star looks the size of a coin; a shadow seems still but moves.
Reason might deceive too: in dreams we feel certain, then wake. Could waking life be another dream?
For nearly two months he was a sceptic in fact.
Cure: not an argument, but "a light which God Most High cast into the breast" (paraphrase): trust in basic reason returned as a gift.
Then he examined four groups who claimed truth: theologians, philosophers, the Ta'limis (followers of an infallible Imam) and the Sufis.
Mission 5
The second crisis: Sufism
Step 1 of 2
Al-Ghazali studied Sufi books and saw that the path could not be learned by reading: it needed "taste" (dhawq), direct experience, like the difference between knowing the definition of drunkenness and being drunk.
He saw his own motive for teaching was fame, not God.
1095: for six months he was torn; then God "locked his tongue" (paraphrase): he could not lecture or eat, and doctors could not help.
He left Baghdad, gave away his wealth and lived as a Sufi for about ten years (Damascus, Jerusalem, Hajj).
Conclusion: the Sufis are those who truly travel the path to God; certainty comes through experience and the light of prophecy, beyond reason (see Mission 2).
He returned to teach at Nishapur (1106) to revive religion.
Quick check
?What, according to the Munqidh, ended al-Ghazali's first crisis?
Mission 5Read the source
Munqidh III.2: the sciences of the philosophers
Al-Ghazali, Deliverance from Error, III.2 (paraphrase; tr. W. Montgomery Watt, The Faith and Practice of al-Ghazali, 1953):
Three kinds of philosopher: materialists (deny a Creator), naturalists (deny the afterlife), theists (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle). Al-Farabi and Ibn Sina transmitted the theists' views.
Six sciences, judged one by one:
Mathematics and logic: true and neutral. Danger: people who admire their precision trust the philosophers on everything; people who reject them out of zeal make Islam look foolish.
Natural science: acceptable, if nature is seen as subject to God.
Metaphysics: here are most of their errors.
Politics and ethics: borrowed from prophets and Sufis; true in themselves, but mixed with error.
Rule: know the truth by itself, not by who said it (he cites a saying attributed to 'Ali).
Q1 Which sciences does al-Ghazali accept as sound?
Show answer
Mathematics, logic and, with a condition, natural science.
Q2 Why does he think wholesale rejection of philosophy harms religion?
Show answer
Rejecting proven truths, e.g. in mathematics, makes Islam seem opposed to reason.
Mission 5
Three points of unbelief
In The Incoherence of the Philosophers (1095) al-Ghazali listed twenty errors: three are unbelief (kufr), seventeen are innovation.
1. The world is eternal: it denies that God created it in time.
2. God knows only universals, not particular events: it denies God's knowledge of each person and act.
3. Only souls, not bodies, are resurrected: it denies the Qur'an's bodily resurrection.
He repeats these three in the Munqidh as the points where philosophers must be judged unbelievers.
Quick check
?Which teaching did al-Ghazali not count among the three points of the philosophers' unbelief?
Mission 5
Ibn Rushd: the law commands philosophy
The Decisive Treatise (Fasl al-Maqal, c. 1180): a legal ruling on philosophy.
The Qur'an commands reflection on creation: "So learn a lesson, O ye who have eyes!" (Qur'an 59:2, Pickthall); "Have they not considered the dominion of the heavens and the earth" (Qur'an 7:185, Pickthall).
Reflection at its best is demonstration (burhan), the method of philosophy. So philosophy is obligatory or recommended for those able to do it.
Learning from non-Muslims (the Greeks) is like using a knife for a sacrifice: what matters is whether the tool is sound, not who made it.
Truth does not contradict truth: where scripture seems to clash with demonstration, scripture is to be interpreted (ta'wil).
George F. Hourani's translation, Averroes on the Harmony of Religion and Philosophy (1961), is the edition OCR suggests.
Mission 5
Three ways people reach truth
Ibn Rushd: people differ in nature, so the Qur'an speaks to all three:
Demonstrative (burhani): philosophers, by strict proof.
Dialectical (jadali): theologians, by argument from accepted premises.
Rhetorical (khatabi): most people, by persuasion, images and examples.
Each reaches the same truth in a form suited to them.
So interpretations should not be spread to the public: the theologians did harm by publishing debates that confused ordinary believers.
Mission 5
Ibn Rushd's reply to al-Ghazali
The Incoherence of the Incoherence (Tahafut al-Tahafut, c. 1180) answers al-Ghazali point by point; the Decisive Treatise gives the short replies below.
No consensus: on theoretical questions Muslim scholars never reached consensus (ijma'), so calling philosophers unbelievers is unjustified.
Eternity: the dispute is largely about names: the world is neither eternal in the way God is, nor created in time like things in it.
God's knowledge: philosophers do not deny God knows particulars; God's knowledge causes things and is unlike ours, neither "universal" nor "particular".
Resurrection: philosophers affirm it; they differ only on its manner, which is open to interpretation.
Quick check
?A believer with no training in philosophy reads the Qur'an's vivid images of Paradise and is moved to live well. In Ibn Rushd's scheme, how is he reaching truth?
Mission 5Evaluate
Who better served Islam's relation to reason?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Ibn Rushd's defence of philosophy is more convincing than al-Ghazali's critique.
For Ibn Rushd: the Qur'an commands reflection; truth is one; his reply exposes al-Ghazali's charges as resting on no consensus.
For Ibn Rushd: in Latin Europe his commentaries fed the rise of university philosophy and science.
For al-Ghazali: reason has limits: certainty about God needs experience and prophecy; his own crisis shows this.
For al-Ghazali: he did not reject science: he defended mathematics and logic and brought logic into theology; his influence on Islamic thought far exceeded Ibn Rushd's.
Judgement criteria: Can reason judge revelation, or only serve it? Does three-tier truth treat ordinary believers fairly? Which view best explains the role of science and philosophy in later Islamic thought?
Mission check
?A Muslim physicist says: "Where a verse seems to clash with a well-proven result, I read the verse in a way that fits the proof." Whose position is she closest to?
Both men used reason and loved the Qur'an: they differed on whether demonstration or experience is the summit of knowing God.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Sufism (tasawwuf) is the inward path of Islam; it grew from Qur'anic devotion and early renunciation into the orders that spread across the Muslim world from the 12th century.
Most Sunni scholars integrated sober Sufism after al-Ghazali; Ibn Taymiyya, Wahhabi and Salafi reformers attacked shrine practices and monism; Shi'a scholars share ideas of walaya but often distrust the orders.
Mission 2
Ihsan (worship as if you see God) is the goal; tazkiyat al-nafs (purifying the self) and remembrance (dhikr) are the means.
A shaykh trains a disciple within a tariqa (path and order), through bay'a, companionship, litanies and, for some orders, sama'.
Rumi's reed: the soul cut from its source longs to return; love drives the journey.
Mission 3
God is incomparable and unknowable in essence, yet shows Himself in His names and in creation; God is nearer than the jugular vein.
The verse of Light (24:35): for al-Ghazali, God alone is true Light; the heart, purified, receives it.
Fana' (passing away) and baqa' (remaining) describe the soul's oneness with God in awareness, not essence.
Drunken Sufism (al-Bistami, al-Hallaj, shatahat) vs sober Sufism (al-Junayd, baqa', stations earned and states given); wilaya: friendship of God.
Mission 4
The Qur'an calls creation "signs" and urges reflection (3:190, 88:17); hadith make seeking knowledge a duty; al-Ghazali made medicine and arithmetic communal duties.
Medieval Muslim scholars translated and extended Greek, Persian and Indian learning: algebra (al-Khwarizmi), medicine (al-Razi, Ibn Sina, Ibn al-Nafis), astronomy and optics (al-Tusi, Ibn al-Shatir, Ibn al-Haytham).
Historians now reject the idea that science stopped after al-Ghazali.
Mission 5
Al-Ghazali finds unbelief in three of the philosophers' claims: an eternal world, God knowing only universals, and resurrection of souls only.
Al-Ghazali: doubt cured by God's light; a second crisis led him to Sufism and to certainty through experience. In Munqidh III.2, he accepts mathematics and logic.
Ibn Rushd: the law commands philosophy; truth cannot contradict truth.
Ibn Rushd: the Qur'an speaks to demonstrative, dialectical and rhetorical minds; al-Ghazali's charges rest on no consensus.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Islamic thought: Sufism; science and philosophy for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1Is Sufism a separate branch of Islam, or the heart of the same faith?
Mission 2Why would a Muslim who already prays five times a day choose a teacher and a path of training?
Mission 3A Sufi cried out "I am the Real" and was executed. What did he mean, and what do Sufis say of God?
Mission 4Why did people who prayed five times a day build observatories, hospitals and algebra?
Mission 5Can a believer follow reason all the way, or does knowing God need more than reason?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.