← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Justice and liberation; H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Islam and the state; H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Islam in Europe
Mini-Lesson

Islamic thought: Justice and liberation; islam and the state; islam in Europe

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
  2. Mission 2Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?
  3. Mission 3In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
  4. Mission 4Caliph, scholars or voters: who should govern a state that follows Islam?
  5. Mission 5Can a Muslim live faithfully as a minority, and why do so many Europeans fear Islam?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?

Make a guess: Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?

Mission 1

Justice at the heart of revelation

The Balancethe Balance (57:25)16:90justice, the doing ofgood5:8"Be just: that is nextto piety"4:135"stand out firmly forjustice"4:75act for theoppressed
  • 'Adl and qist: justice, fairness, putting things in their right place.
  • Muslims believe God sent prophets with scripture and "the Balance (of Right and Wrong), that men may stand forth in justice" (Qur'an 57:25, Yusuf Ali).
  • "Allah commands justice, the doing of good, and liberality to kith and kin" (Qur'an 16:90, Yusuf Ali).
  • The poor: zakah is their right, not a favour (9:60;). Surah 107 links denying the Judgement with failing to feed the poor.
  • The oppressed (mustad'afun): the Qur'an asks why believers do not act for "those who, being weak, are ill-treated (and oppressed)" (Qur'an 4:75, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 1Read the source

Justice even against yourself

> "O ye who believe! stand out firmly for justice, as witnesses to Allah, even as against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be (against) rich or poor" (Qur'an 4:135, Yusuf Ali)

> "let not the hatred of others to you make you swerve to wrong and depart from justice. Be just: that is next to piety" (Qur'an 5:8, Yusuf Ali)

Q1 Against whom must a believer be ready to give just witness?

Show answer

Themselves, parents, relatives; rich or poor alike.

Q2 What must not bend a Muslim's justice, according to 5:8?

Show answer

Hatred of others, even enemies.

Mission 1

Enjoining good, forbidding wrong

Hand, tongue, hearthandchange it by actiontongueif you cannot: speakheartif you cannot: the weakest faithLimits (protecting rights)no spying (49:12) · no breaking into homes ·only wrongs that are open and agreed · nevercause a greater harmfard kifayaa communal duty (3:104)
  • Al-amr bil-ma'ruf wal-nahy 'an al-munkar: "enjoining what is right, and forbidding what is wrong" (Qur'an 3:104, Yusuf Ali); also 3:110 and 9:71 (believing men and women).
  • Hadith: whoever sees a wrong should change it with his hand; if he cannot, with his tongue; if he cannot, with his heart, the weakest faith (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Fard kifaya: a communal duty. If enough people do it, the rest are released. ("Let there arise out of you a band of people", 3:104.)
  • Protecting rights (classical limits): no spying ("spy not on each other", 49:12); no breaking into homes; act only on wrongs that are open and agreed; never cause a greater harm.
  • Historic office: the muhtasib (market inspector) checked weights, prices and public conduct.
Quick check
?What does it mean to call "enjoining good and forbidding wrong" a fard kifaya?
Mission 1

Jihad and mercy

Two jihadsJihad: "striving" in God's waygreater jihadagainst one's ownnafs (lower self)lesser jihaddefence andagainstoppression; limits:2:190the report calling it greater has a weak chain(hadith scholars); the idea is widespreadmercy21:107 · Makkah 630: former persecutorspardoned
  • Jihad: "striving" in God's way.
  • Greater jihad: the struggle against one's own nafs (lower self). A well-known report calls it greater than fighting; scholars of hadith judge its chain weak, but the idea is widespread.
  • Lesser jihad: armed struggle, for defence and against oppression, within limits: "Fight … those who fight you, but do not transgress limits" (Qur'an 2:190, Yusuf Ali).
  • Mercy: "We sent thee not, but as a Mercy for all creatures" (Qur'an 21:107, Yusuf Ali).
  • At the conquest of Makkah (630) the Prophet pardoned his former persecutors, echoing Joseph's words to his brothers: "This day let no reproach be (cast) on you" (Qur'an 12:92, Yusuf Ali).
  • Hadith: the merciful are shown mercy by the Most Merciful (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi; paraphrase).
Mission 1

Qisas, diya and maslaha

Qisas, diya and forgivenessvictim's family choosesqisasequalretribution(2:178,2:179)diyacompensationforgivenesspraised(5:45)maslahapublic interest: protects faith · life · intellect ·family line · property (al-Ghazali)balance: the family's choice and public interestweighed together
  • Qisas: equal retribution for murder and injury (2:178, 5:45). "In the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life to you" (Qur'an 2:179, Yusuf Ali): it deters and ends blood feuds.
  • Diya: compensation paid to the victim's family instead.
  • Forgiveness is praised: remitting retaliation "is an act of atonement for himself" (Qur'an 5:45, Yusuf Ali). The victim's family chooses.
  • Maslaha: public interest. Al-Ghazali (al-Mustasfa): a true maslaha protects the five aims of Shari'a: faith, life, intellect, family line, property.
  • Examples: Abu Bakr gathering the Qur'an into one book; Umar suspending the penalty for theft in a year of famine.
  • Balance: individual rights (the family's choice in qisas) and public interest (order, safety) are weighed together.
Quick check
?In a case of murder under classical Islamic law, who chooses between qisas, diya and forgiveness?
Mission 1

Ali Shari'ati: religion as revolution

Ali Shari'ati: religion as revolutionAli Shari'ati (1933–1977)Red Shi'ism of Aliprotest, martyrdom,justiceBlack Shi'ism of theSafavidsstate religion,passive mourning,waitingKarbalaHusayn: active resistance to tyranny1979inspired many young revolutionaries
  • Ali Shari'ati (1933–1977), Iranian sociologist; doctorate in Paris (1964), where he read Frantz Fanon and debated existentialists and Marxists.
  • Marxist influence: history as a struggle between oppressors and oppressed (he read Cain and Abel this way). But he rejected Marxist materialism: faith drives liberation.
  • Red Shi'ism of Ali (protest, martyrdom, justice) vs Black Shi'ism of the Safavids (state religion, passive mourning, waiting).
  • Criticism: of religion serving power, in the caliphs' official Sunnism and in apolitical, clerical Shi'ism.
  • Husayn at Karbala: a model of active resistance to tyranny, not only grief.
  • Lectures at the Husayniyeh Ershad, Tehran (1967–72); imprisoned (1973–75); died in England in 1977. His ideas inspired many young revolutionaries of 1979.
Mission 1

Abdal Hakim Murad: the forgotten revolution

Two revolutionsAli Shari'ati(1933–1977)Abdal Hakim Murad(b. 1960)Red Shi'ism of Aliprotest, martyrdom,justiceBlack Shi'ism of theSafavidsstate religion,passive mourning,waitingKarbalaHusayn: activeresistance to tyranny1979inspired many youngrevolutionariestazkiyahpurification of thesoul first"activism within"the first struggle iswith the self13:11God changes apeople when theychange themselves
  • Abdal Hakim Murad (Timothy Winter, b. 1960), Cambridge scholar; founding Dean of Cambridge Muslim College.
  • Essay "Islamic Spirituality: the Forgotten Revolution" (1990s): modern Islamist revivalism is outward, angry and political; it has forgotten the purification of the soul (tazkiyah) (paraphrase).
  • Anger without inner change produces extremism and fails the oppressed.
  • Traditionalist Sufi approach: renew the heart through the classical spiritual tradition; then just action follows.
  • "Activism within": the first struggle is with the self (the greater jihad).
  • Support often cited: "Verily never will Allah change the condition of a people until they change it themselves (with their own souls)." (Qur'an 13:11, Yusuf Ali).
Mission 1

Liberationist approaches

Liberationist approachesSouth AfricaIndiaFarid Esack, South AfricaQur'an, Liberation and Pluralism (1997): Godsides with the oppressedAsghar Ali Engineer, IndiaIslam and Liberation Theology (1990): Islambegan as a movement for the weakcharitystructural change
  • Liberationist: reading the Qur'an from the side of the poor and oppressed, and acting to change unjust structures, not only to give charity.
  • Farid Esack (b. 1959), South Africa: fought apartheid with the Call of Islam movement, alongside Christians and others; Qur'an, Liberation and Pluralism (1997): God sides with the oppressed (paraphrase).
  • Asghar Ali Engineer (1939–2013), India: Islam and Liberation Theology (1990): Islam began as a movement for the weak against the rich of Makkah (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Which statement best describes a liberationist approach in Islam?
Mission 1Evaluate

"The struggle for justice must begin within the self."

Argument map: justice and the self"The struggle for justice must begin withinthe self."For13:11Murad's "activism within": change beginsby purifying the heart (tazkiyah)Murad: outward activism without tazkiyahturns to angerThe greater jihad; the Prophet's mercy atMakkah came from inner disciplineAgainst4:75 demands action for the oppressednowEsack: waiting for inner perfection servesthe oppressorThe hand comes first in the hadith;Shari'ati called for active resistanceAnother viewInner and outer struggle belong together:justice (4:135) and a purified heart are twosides of one faithMercy (21:107) and justice belongtogether tooJudge it byWhat does the Qur'an put first? · What hasworked in history (e.g. South Africa)? · Whosuffers while Muslims wait? · History toweigh: Iran 1979
  • For: 13:11; Murad's "activism within": change begins by purifying the heart (tazkiyah).
  • For: Murad: outward activism without tazkiyah turns to anger.
  • For: the greater jihad; the Prophet's mercy at Makkah came from inner discipline.
  • Against: 4:75 demands action for the oppressed now; liberationists such as Esack: waiting for inner perfection serves the oppressor.
  • Against: enjoining good with the hand comes first in the hadith; Shari'ati called for active resistance.
  • Another view: inner and outer struggle belong together: justice (4:135) and a purified heart are two sides of one faith.
  • Another view: mercy (21:107) and justice belong together too.
  • Judge it by: What does the Qur'an put first? What has worked in history (e.g. South Africa)? Who suffers while Muslims wait?
  • History to weigh: Iran 1979.
Mission check

?A Muslim food-bank volunteer says: "Food parcels are not enough. The Qur'an sides with the oppressed (4:75), so we must also campaign against the low wages and bad housing that cause poverty, with people of any faith." Which approach is this?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?

Make a guess: Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?

Mission 2

Jihad means striving

Jihad means strivingjihadstrivingself (nafs)greater jihadtongue and pentruth, teachingwealthgivingarmed strugglelesser jihad
  • Jihad: from j-h-d, "to strive, to make an effort". Not the word for "holy war".
  • "And those who strive in Our (cause),- We will certainly guide them to our Paths" (Qur'an 29:69, Yusuf Ali).
  • Forms of jihad: of the self (nafs); of the tongue and pen (speaking truth, teaching); of wealth (giving); and armed struggle.
  • "Strive in His cause as ye ought to strive" (Qur'an 22:78, Yusuf Ali).
  • Tradition: greater jihad (al-jihad al-akbar): struggle with the self; lesser jihad (al-jihad al-asghar): armed struggle.
Mission 2

Greater jihad: the nafs

Three states of the nafsincitingto evil12:53self-reproaching(conscience)75:2at peace89:27greater jihad:a lifelong climb
  • Nafs: the self, the ego with its desires.
  • Three states named from the Qur'an: the soul inciting to evil (12:53); the self-reproaching soul, conscience (75:2); the soul at peace (89:27).
  • Greater jihad: lifelong effort to move the self towards peace with God: prayer, fasting, honesty, controlling anger and greed.
  • The Prophet is reported to have said that the true striver (mujahid) is the one who strives against his own self for God (Tirmidhi; paraphrase).
  • A popular report calls returning from battle a return "from the lesser jihad to the greater" (al-Bayhaqi; paraphrase; many scholars grade it weak).
Mission 2Read the source

Purifying the self

> "Truly he succeeds that purifies it, And he fails that corrupts it!" (Qur'an 91:9–10, Yusuf Ali)

> "And for such as had entertained the fear of standing before their Lord's (tribunal) and had restrained (their) soul from lower desires" (Qur'an 79:40, Yusuf Ali)

Q1 What decides success in 91:9–10?

Show answer

Whether a person purifies or corrupts the soul.

Q2 What motive for self-control does 79:40 give?

Show answer

Awareness of standing before God at Judgement.

Quick check
?Which of these is the clearest example of greater jihad?
Mission 2

Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time

Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time610–622Makkah: persecution, nofighting; patience andpreaching622Hijrah to Madinah; permissionto fight: "they are wronged"(22:39)624Battle of Badr625Battle of Uhud627Battle of the Trench628Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: peaceon hard terms630Makkah taken almost withoutfighting; general amnesty
  • Makkah (610–622): persecution, but no fighting; patience and preaching.
  • 622: the hijrah to Madinah. Permission to fight comes because the Muslims "are wronged" (22:39).
  • Battles: Badr (624), Uhud (625), the Trench (627).
  • 628: Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: a peace accepted on hard terms.
  • 630: Makkah taken almost without fighting; a general amnesty.
  • Jurists made lesser jihad a communal duty of the ummah (fard kifaya), led by legitimate authority; it becomes an individual duty if the land is invaded.
  • OCR: lesser and greater jihad are both commanded, within the call to justice and to enjoin good and forbid wrong (3:104).
Mission 2

Conditions of lesser jihad

Conditions of lesser jihadJust causedefence or ending oppression; neverforcing faithLegitimate authoritya recognised leader, not individualsRight intentionfor God and justice, not gain or revengeLast resort and proportion"do not transgress limits" (2:190)Protect non-combatantsno killing women, children or the oldStop when the enemy seeks peace8:61; treat prisoners humanely
  • Just cause: defence, or ending oppression of the weak (4:75), never forcing faith: "no compulsion in religion" (2:256).
  • Legitimate authority: declared by a recognised leader, not by individuals.
  • Right intention: for God and justice, not gain or revenge.
  • Last resort and proportion: "do not transgress limits" (2:190).
  • Protect non-combatants: the Prophet forbade killing women and children (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase); Abu Bakr told his commanders not to kill the old or children, cut fruit trees or destroy buildings (Malik, Muwatta; paraphrase).
  • Stop when the enemy seeks peace (8:61); treat prisoners humanely.
Quick check
?A militia leader with no state behind him declares a "jihad" and attacks a market full of civilians. Which two classical conditions does this most clearly break?
Mission 2

Terrorism is not jihad

  • Terrorism: violence against civilians to spread fear for political goals.
  • Mainstream scholars across Sunni and Shi'a Islam reject calling it jihad: no legitimate authority, civilians targeted, suicide forbidden (4:29).
  • "If any one slew a person - unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land - it would be as if he slew the whole people" (Qur'an 5:32, Yusuf Ali).
  • Examples: the Amman Message (2004–05); Tahir-ul-Qadri's Fatwa on Terrorism and Suicide Bombings (2010); scholars' open letter to the leader of ISIS (2014).
  • Groups that use the word for terror are a small minority, condemned by most Muslim bodies; many of their victims are Muslims.
Mission check

?Amina, a nurse, starts each long night shift tired and short-tempered. She makes herself pray, stay patient with difficult patients and refuse to cut corners. Most Muslims would describe this as:
Mission 3

Mission 3: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?

Make a guess: In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?

Mission 3

Justice and the aims of punishment

Aims of punishmentretributionfor the wrongeddeterrenceprotectionof societyreform andrepentancejustice16:90, 4:58
  • "Allah commands justice, the doing of good" (Qur'an 16:90, Yusuf Ali); "when ye judge between man and man, that ye judge with justice" (Qur'an 4:58, Yusuf Ali).
  • Muslims believe crimes wrong God, the victim and society.
  • Aims of punishment in fiqh: retribution (justice for the wronged), deterrence, protection of society, reform and repentance.
  • Final judgement belongs to God; earthly punishment is limited and needs strict proof.
Mission 3

Hudud: fixed limits

Three categories of punishment1 hududfixed by Qur'an or Sunna; strict proof. e.g. theft(5:38), unlawful sexual relations (24:2), falseaccusation (24:4), hiraba (5:33), alcohol(Sunna)2 qisasequal retribution for murder or deliberateinjury; the family chooses:retributiondiyaforgiveness3 ta'zirdiscretionary: set by a judge or the state;guided by maslaha (public interest)
  • Hudud (singular hadd, "limit"): penalties fixed by Qur'an or Sunna, seen as God's right; a judge may not change them.
  • Examples: theft (5:38); unlawful sexual relations (24:2); false accusation of unchastity (24:4); armed robbery and spreading terror (hiraba, 5:33); drinking alcohol (from the Sunna).
  • Strict proof: e.g. four eyewitnesses for adultery (24:4); confession can be withdrawn; theft only above a minimum value and not from need.
  • Legal maxim: "avert the hudud by doubts" (Tirmidhi; paraphrase). Caliph Umar is reported to have suspended the theft penalty in a famine.
  • Today: few states apply hudud; many Muslims and scholars question whether they can be applied justly now.
Mission 3

Qisas and diya

Qisas: the family's choicedeliberate killing proved in courtthe family choosesretributionqisasdiyacompensationforgivenesspraised: 42:40a court carries out any sentence:never private revengeaccidental killingdiya + expiation(4:92)
  • Qisas: equal retribution for murder or deliberate injury: "life for life, eye for eye" (5:45). It limits revenge: one life for one life, never more (17:33).
  • The victim's family chooses: qisas; diya (compensation, "blood money"); or forgiveness.
  • Diya is also due for accidental killing (4:92), with an act of expiation.
  • A court must try the case and carry out any sentence: never private revenge.
  • Forgiveness is praised: "if a person forgives and makes reconciliation, his reward is due from Allah" (Qur'an 42:40, Yusuf Ali).
  • OCR: qisas (retribution) and diya (restitution).
Mission 3Read the source

Life in the law of equality

> "But if any remission is made by the brother of the slain, then grant any reasonable demand, and compensate him with handsome gratitude, this is a concession and a Mercy from your Lord." (Qur'an 2:178, Yusuf Ali)

> "In the Law of Equality there is (saving of) Life to you, o ye men of understanding; that ye may restrain yourselves." (Qur'an 2:179, Yusuf Ali)

Q1 What does 2:178 call the choice to accept compensation instead of retribution?

Show answer

A concession and a mercy from God.

Q2 How can retribution "save life" (2:179)?

Show answer

It deters killing and stops endless blood feuds.

Quick check
?A man is convicted of deliberate murder in a court applying qisas. Who decides whether he faces retribution, pays diya or is forgiven?
Mission 3

Ta'zir and maslaha

  • Ta'zir: discretionary punishments set by a judge or the state for offences without a fixed penalty: e.g. fraud, bribery, drug dealing, cases where hadd proof fails.
  • Can be fines, prison, community penalties; aimed at reform and deterrence.
  • Guided by maslaha (public interest): laws should protect the five essentials named by al-Ghazali (1058–1111): religion, life, intellect, lineage, property.
  • So the state can make new laws (traffic, cyber-crime) that serve the shari'a's purposes.
  • OCR: maslaha balances individual rights and public interest.
Mission 3

Enjoining good: a communal duty

  • "Let there arise out of you a band of people inviting to all that is good, enjoining what is right, and forbidding what is wrong" (Qur'an 3:104, Yusuf Ali).
  • Al-amr bil-ma'ruf wal-nahy 'an al-munkar is a fard kifaya: a duty on the community, fulfilled when some carry it out.
  • Hadith: whoever sees a wrong should change it with the hand, if unable then with the tongue, if unable then in the heart (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Individual rights limit it: "spy not on each other" (49:12); al-Ghazali taught that a wrong must be openly visible, not found by searching homes.
  • Enforcement by force belongs to lawful authority, not to individuals or vigilante groups.
Quick check
?Which offence would normally be punished by ta'zir rather than by a hadd penalty or qisas?
Mission check

?A driver, keeping to the speed limit, accidentally hits and kills a pedestrian who steps into the road. What would classical Islamic law require?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Caliph, scholars or voters: who should govern a state that follows Islam?

Make a guess: Caliph, scholars or voters: who should govern a state that follows Islam?

Mission 4

Madinah: the model

Madinah: the modelreligiousmoralpoliticalConstitutionof Madinahreligiousprayer,zakah,fastingmoraljustice, carefor the poorpoliticaltreaties,defence,consultationblueprint or principles?
  • In Madinah (622–632) the Prophet was prophet, judge, law-giver and commander.
  • Constitution of Madinah: one community (ummah) above tribe; Jewish tribes kept their religion; disputes referred to God and His Messenger.
  • Religious: prayer, zakah and fasting set the rhythm of society. Moral: justice, care for the poor. Political: treaties, defence, consultation.
  • So most Muslims hold that Islam began with no split between religion and state. A minority disagree: Ali Abd al-Raziq (Islam and the Foundations of Governance, 1925) argued the Prophet's mission was spiritual, not the founding of a state.
  • The debate: is Madinah a blueprint to copy, or a set of principles (justice, consultation, accountability) to apply in new forms?
Mission 4Read the source

Authority and consultation

> "Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you. If ye differ in anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger" (Qur'an 4:59, Yusuf Ali)

> "who (conduct) their affairs by mutual Consultation" (Qur'an 42:38, Yusuf Ali)

  • The Prophet was told: "consult them in affairs (of moment)" (Qur'an 3:159, Yusuf Ali).
  • Shura: consultation. Ulu al-amr: "those charged with authority": rulers, scholars, or both? Interpreters differ.

Q1 Where does 4:59 send a dispute?

Show answer

Back to God and His Messenger: the Qur'an and Sunnah.

Q2 Which verse do Muslim democrats quote most?

Show answer

42:38, consultation; also 3:159.

Mission 4

Sunni theory: a contract

Two theories of the stateSunniShi'acaliphcontract ('aqd)electors"those who loose andbind"ulamainterpret Shari'a andadviseImamchosen by God;infallibleOccultationfrom 874; Greater,from 941ulamageneral deputiesquietistscholars guide, donot rule (e.g. Sistani)wilayat al-faqiha just jurist governs(Khomeini, 1970; Iran1979)
  • After the Prophet, Abu Bakr was chosen by companions and given the bay'ah (pledge of allegiance).
  • Al-Mawardi (974–1058), al-Ahkam al-Sultaniyya (The Ordinances of Government): the imamate (caliphate) is a contract ('aqd) between the caliph and "those who loose and bind" (qualified electors).
  • Caliph's duties: protect the faith, enforce the law, judge, defend the borders, collect zakah, appoint honest officials.
  • Complementary roles: the ruler holds power and enforces; the ulama interpret Shari'a and advise. Neither replaces the other.
  • Obedience: most Sunni scholars counselled obeying even a flawed ruler who keeps the prayer, to avoid civil strife (fitnah). Ibn Taymiyya (1263–1328): government must serve Shari'a (al-Siyasa al-Shar'iyya).
Mission 4

Shi'a theory: the Imam and the ulama

Two theories of the stateSunniShi'acaliphcontract ('aqd)electors"those who loose andbind"ulamainterpret Shari'a andadviseImamchosen by God;infallibleOccultationfrom 874; Greater,from 941ulamageneral deputiesquietistscholars guide, donot rule (e.g. Sistani)wilayat al-faqiha just jurist governs(Khomeini, 1970; Iran1979)
  • Imam: chosen by God, designated by the previous Imam, infallible (ma'sum). The supreme authority in religion and politics.
  • For Twelvers, the twelfth Imam went into Occultation (from 874; the Greater Occultation from 941).
  • In his absence, the ulama act as his general deputies: they judge, teach, receive khums, guide believers.
  • Quietist view: no state is fully legitimate before the Imam returns; scholars guide but do not rule (e.g. Ayatollah Sistani, b. 1930, Najaf).
  • Wilayat al-faqih (guardianship of the jurist): Ayatollah Khomeini (1902–1989), lectures of 1970: a just senior jurist should govern on the Imam's behalf. Basis of Iran's 1979 constitution.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly contrasts pre-modern Sunni and Shi'a theory of the state?
Mission 4

Western codes and secularism

Codes, secularism and oppositioncodes, secularisingopposition1850sOttoman French-based codes1869–76the Mecelle codifies Hanaficivil law1875, 1883Egypt: European-style courts1922Turkey: sultanate abolished1924caliphate abolished1926Turkey adopts the Swiss civilcode1928Muslim Brotherhood founded(al-Banna)1941Jamaat-e-Islami founded(Mawdudi)1949al-Sanhuri's civil code, Egypt1964Qutb, Milestones1979Iranian Revolution
  • In the 19th–20th centuries many reformers identified secularism with modernisation and progress.
  • Ottoman Empire: French-based commercial and penal codes (1850s); the Mecelle (1869–76) codified Hanafi civil law.
  • Turkey: Atatürk abolished the sultanate (1922) and the caliphate (1924), adopted the Swiss civil code (1926), and made the state secular.
  • Egypt: European-style courts (1875, 1883); the civil code of al-Sanhuri (1949) blended French law with Shari'a principles.
  • Iran: Reza Shah (ruled 1925–41) moved law and education away from the clergy.
  • Family law usually stayed Shari'a-based: marriage, divorce, inheritance.
Mission 4

Opposition: God's law, not the West's

Codes, secularism and oppositioncodes, secularisingopposition1850sOttoman French-based codes1869–76the Mecelle codifies Hanaficivil law1875, 1883Egypt: European-style courts1922Turkey: sultanate abolished1924caliphate abolished1926Turkey adopts the Swiss civilcode1928Muslim Brotherhood founded(al-Banna)1941Jamaat-e-Islami founded(Mawdudi)1949al-Sanhuri's civil code, Egypt1964Qutb, Milestones1979Iranian Revolution
  • Critics linked secularism with Western imperialism and moral decline.
  • Hasan al-Banna (1906–1949) founded the Muslim Brotherhood (Egypt, 1928): Islam as a complete way of life, including the state.
  • Abul A'la Mawdudi (1903–1979), Jamaat-e-Islami (1941): sovereignty (hakimiyyah) belongs to God alone; an Islamic state is a "theo-democracy": elected, but bound by Shari'a.
  • Sayyid Qutb (1906–1966), Milestones (1964): societies that replace God's law with human law live in jahiliyyah (ignorance).
  • The Iranian Revolution (1979) put opposition to the secular Shah into power.
  • Many Muslims oppose secularism without endorsing these movements.
Mission 4

Shari'a in modern Muslim states

Shari'a in modern Muslim-majority statessecularIslamic123451Turkeysecular constitution2IndonesiaPancasila: not an Islamic state3Egypt, PakistanShari'a as a source of law4IranIslamic Republic5Saudi ArabiaQur'an and Sunnah as constitutionwhat each constitution says, not a ranking
  • Saudi Arabia: the Qur'an and Sunnah are the constitution (Basic Law, 1992); Hanbali law applied by judges.
  • Iran: Islamic Republic; elected president and parliament under the Supreme Leader and the Guardian Council.
  • Egypt: "principles of Islamic Shari'a are the principal source of legislation" (constitution, from 1980).
  • Pakistan: Islamic Republic (1956); a Federal Shariat Court reviews laws (1980).
  • Turkey: secular constitution. Indonesia: largest Muslim-majority democracy; not an Islamic state (Pancasila), though Aceh applies Shari'a by-laws.
  • Your spec: "the status of the Shari'a in modern Muslim states".
Quick check
?Which statement about Shari'a in modern Muslim-majority states is accurate?
Mission 4

Law schools and democracy

Shari'a and democracy: three viewsIs Islam compatible with democracy?incompatiblelaw-making belongs to God alone (e.g. Hizbut-Tahrir; Qutb)in betweenMawdudi's theo-democracy; Iran's electedbodies checked by juristscompatibleshura (42:38), bay'ah as consent, accountablerulers (e.g. Abou El Fadl, 2004; Ghannouchi)views held by Muslims, not a ranking
  • Incompatible: law-making belongs to God alone; majority votes cannot permit what God forbids (e.g. Hizb ut-Tahrir, banned in the UK since 2024; Qutb).
  • Compatible: shura (42:38), the bay'ah as consent, and the accountability of rulers make Islam friendly to democracy (e.g. Khaled Abou El Fadl, Islam and the Challenge of Democracy, 2004; Rached Ghannouchi, Tunisia).
  • In between: Mawdudi's theo-democracy; Iran's elected bodies checked by jurists.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Islam is compatible with democracy."

Argument map: Islam and democracy"Islam is compatible with democracy."ForShura (42:38, 3:159)The first caliphs were chosen and pledgedtoElections in Indonesia, Pakistan andTunisia (from 2011); British Muslims voteand stand for officeThe contract theory of al-MawardiAgainstSovereignty belongs to God (Mawdudi,Qutb)A majority could vote against Shari'aThe Prophet's authority came fromrevelation, not votesAnother viewIt depends what "democracy" means:majority rule within fixed moral limits isfound in many democraciesJudge it byWho makes law? · Who interprets Shari'a? ·Can minorities be equal citizens? · Is Madinaha blueprint or a set of principles?
  • For: shura (42:38, 3:159); the first caliphs chosen and pledged to; elections in Indonesia, Pakistan and Tunisia (from 2011); British Muslims vote and stand for office.
  • For: the contract theory of al-Mawardi.
  • Against: sovereignty belongs to God (Mawdudi, Qutb); a majority could vote against Shari'a; the Prophet's authority came from revelation, not votes.
  • Another view: it depends on what "democracy" means: majority rule within fixed moral limits is found in many democracies.
  • Judge it by: Who makes law? Who interprets Shari'a? Can minorities be equal citizens? Is Madinah a blueprint or a set of principles?
Mission check

?Amira argues: "The Prophet was told to consult, and the first caliphs were chosen and given a pledge of allegiance. So Muslims today should elect leaders who govern within Shari'a." Which view of Islam and the state does she hold?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Can a Muslim live faithfully as a minority, and why do so many Europeans fear Islam?

Make a guess: Can a Muslim live faithfully as a minority, and why do so many Europeans fear Islam?

Mission 5Read the source

Hijra: migrating for faith

Two migrations for faithRed SeaArabiaAbyssiniaMakkahMadinahc. 615 CEsome Muslims flee to Abyssinia, protected bya just Christian king622 CEHijra: Makkah → Madinah; the Islamic calendarcounts from it
  • Hijra (migration): in 622 CE the Prophet and his followers moved from Makkah to Madinah to practise Islam freely. The Islamic calendar counts from it.
  • Earlier (c. 615) some Muslims fled to Abyssinia, where a just Christian king protected them: a model for living as a minority under a non-Muslim ruler.

> "Was not Allah's earth spacious that ye could have migrated therein?" (Qur'an 4:97, Pickthall)

> "Whoso migrateth for the cause of Allah will find much refuge and abundance in the earth" (Qur'an 4:100, Pickthall)

  • Classical jurists divided the world into dar al-Islam (abode of Islam) and dar al-harb (abode of war); some added dar al-'ahd (abode of treaty).
  • Many held: if you cannot practise Islam where you live, migrate. If you can practise freely, staying is allowed (some Shafi'i jurists said it may even be better).

Q1 According to 4:97, what is wrong with staying where you are oppressed?

Show answer

You could have migrated somewhere you could live your faith.

Q2 Why is Abyssinia important for European Muslims today?

Show answer

It shows Muslims living faithfully under a just non-Muslim ruler.

Mission 5

Da'wa: inviting to Islam

  • Da'wa (invitation, mission): sharing Islam with others.

> "Call unto the way of thy Lord with wisdom and fair exhortation, and reason with them in the better way." (Qur'an 16:125, Pickthall)

  • Limited by "There is no compulsion in religion" (Qur'an 2:256, Pickthall): conversion must be free.
  • Methods: good example (often seen as the most effective); mosque open days; literature and street stalls; online teaching.
  • Many converts in Europe describe study and friendship, not preaching, as what drew them.
  • Debate: is da'wa in a secular society a duty, or a source of tension when it seems pushy?
  • Tariq Ramadan (b. 1962) calls Europe dar al-shahada (abode of witness): a place to bear witness to Islam by how Muslims live.
Mission 5

Minority jurisprudence

Minority jurisprudence: the toolkitmaslahapublic gooddaruranecessityease"desireth nothardship for you"(2:185)'urflocal customFiqh al-aqalliyyatminority jurisprudenceBase: the law of the landcitizenship is a covenant: "keep the covenant"(17:34); obey local law unless it forces sinDeveloped from the 1990s by Taha Jabiral-Alwani (1935–2016) and Yusuf al-Qaradawi(1926–2022), through the European Councilfor Fatwa and Research (1997).
  • Fiqh al-aqalliyyat (minority jurisprudence): applying Shari'a for Muslims who live as a minority.
  • Developed from the 1990s by Taha Jabir al-Alwani (1935–2016, USA) and Yusuf al-Qaradawi (1926–2022), through the European Council for Fatwa and Research (founded 1997).
  • Principles: public good (maslaha); necessity (darura); ease (God "desireth not hardship for you", Qur'an 2:185, Pickthall); local custom ('urf).
  • Respecting the law of the land: citizenship is a covenant; "keep the covenant" (Qur'an 17:34, Pickthall). Muslims obey local law unless it forces them to sin.
  • Example: the Council allowed a conventional mortgage for a family's first home where no Islamic option exists (necessity).
  • Critics: some traditional scholars: it waters down Shari'a; Ramadan and others: Muslims are citizens, not a "minority" needing special law.
Quick check
?A Muslim family in Germany has no access to an Islamic home loan and is paying high rent. A scholar using minority jurisprudence allows them a conventional mortgage. Which principle is she mainly using?
Mission 5

A European Muslim identity

A European Muslim identityseparate:"ghetto Islam" (Tibi)a EuropeanMuslim identitythree ways of arguing for the European end:Bassam Tibi · "Euro-Islam" (from 1992)an Islam that accepts secular democracy,pluralism and individual rightsTariq Ramadanfully European and fully Muslim: faithful toprinciples, flexible in cultureMustafa Cerić · Declaration (2006)accept the social contract; Islam is not foreignto Europe; Europe should recognise Islam
  • Multiculturalism: policies that recognise and support different cultural and religious groups within one state.
  • "Euro-Islam" (Bassam Tibi, b. 1944, from 1992): an Islam that accepts secular democracy, pluralism and individual rights, against what he calls "ghetto Islam".
  • Ramadan: Muslims can be fully European and fully Muslim: faithful to principles, flexible in culture.
  • Mustafa Cerić (b. 1952), Grand Mufti of Bosnia-Herzegovina 1993–2012, A Declaration of European Muslims (2006), paraphrase:
  • European Muslims accept the social contract: the rule of law, democracy, human rights and tolerance.
  • Islam is not foreign to Europe: Bosnian Muslims are native Europeans.
  • He asks Europe to recognise Islam in its institutions and to protect Muslims from discrimination; Muslims must reject terrorism.
  • OCR spellings: hijra, da'wa, Shari'a.
Mission 5

After 9/11: multiculturalism under fire

After 9/11: multiculturalism under fireeventslawsspeeches200111 September attacks2004Madrid bombings2004France bans conspicuous religioussymbols in state schools2005London bombings (7 July)2005–06Danish cartoons2009Swiss voters ban new minarets2010France bans face coverings in public2010Angela Merkel: statemulticulturalism has failed2011David Cameron (Munich): statemulticulturalism has failed; calls forshared national values2015Charlie Hebdo
  • Events: 11 September 2001; Madrid (2004) and London (7 July 2005) bombings; the Danish cartoons (2005–06); Charlie Hebdo (2015).
  • Laws: France banned conspicuous religious symbols in state schools (2004) and face coverings in public (2010); Swiss voters banned new minarets (2009).
  • Opponents of multiculturalism: Angela Merkel (2010) and David Cameron (Munich, 2011) said state multiculturalism had failed and called for shared national values.
  • Supporters reply: multiculturalism is not the cause of extremism; exclusion and discrimination push young people away.
  • Muslims across Europe condemned the attacks, yet often felt treated as suspects.
Mission 5

What is Islamophobia?

Closed and open views of IslamClosed viewsOpen viewsone unchanging blocdiverseseparate from otherculturesinteractinginferioropen to fair criticisman enemymanipulativeRunnymede Trust, Islamophobia: A Challengefor Us All (1997)
  • Term made widely known by the Runnymede Trust report Islamophobia: A Challenge for Us All (1997).
  • It contrasted closed views of Islam (one unchanging bloc; separate from other cultures; inferior; an enemy; manipulative) with open views (diverse; interacting; open to fair criticism).
  • APPG on British Muslims (2018) definition: Islamophobia is rooted in racism and targets "expressions of Muslimness or perceived Muslimness".
  • Debate: critics say "Islamophobia" may chill legitimate criticism of religion and prefer "anti-Muslim hatred"; supporters say it names a real pattern of prejudice.
  • Todd Green (The Fear of Islam, 2015) traces such fears back through European history, long before 9/11.
Quick check
?A commentator writes: "Muslims everywhere think the same way and can never really accept Western values." In Runnymede's terms, which closed view is this mainly?
Mission 5

Bias, misrepresentation, inaccuracy

Bias, misrepresentation, inaccuracyBiaschoosing which stories to tellMisrepresentationa few presented as typical;one stands for manyInaccuracyfalse claims, sometimes latercorrected (IPSO)correction
  • Bias: choosing which stories to tell. Studies of UK newspapers (e.g. Cardiff University, 2008) found most stories about British Muslims framed them as a threat or a problem.
  • Misrepresentation: the actions of a few presented as typical; "Islamist" and "Muslim" blurred.
  • Inaccuracy: false claims, sometimes later corrected by the press regulator (IPSO).
  • Politics: politicians' language about veils, migration or "no-go areas" can make prejudice seem respectable.
  • Online: algorithms reward outrage; organised hate campaigns; groups such as Tell MAMA record anti-Muslim incidents.
  • Edward Said (1935–2003), Covering Islam (1981): Western media present "Islam" as one threatening thing.
Mission 5Read the source

Verify before you judge

> "O ye who believe! If an evil-liver bring you tidings, verify it, lest ye smite some folk in ignorance and afterward repent of what ye did." (Qur'an 49:6, Pickthall)

> "let not hatred of any people seduce you that ye deal not justly." (Qur'an 5:8, Pickthall)

Q1 What does 49:6 tell Muslims to do with news from an untrustworthy source?

Show answer

Verify it before acting.

Q2 How might a Muslim journalist use 5:8 when reporting on people who are hostile to Islam?

Show answer

Report them fairly: hatred must not lead to injustice.

Quick check
?A newspaper prints a story claiming a council banned Christmas lights "to avoid offending Muslims". It later prints a correction: the lights were cancelled for budget reasons. Which issue does this mainly show?
Mission 5Evaluate

Does Islam permit life as a minority?

Does Islam permit life as a minority?Islam fully allows Muslims to live as aminority in non-Muslim lands.ForThe Abyssinian precedent; jurists allowedresidence where Islam can be practisedfreely17:34 on keeping covenants; minorityjurisprudence; Ramadan's "abode ofwitness"AgainstThe classical ideal is life under Shari'a;4:97 warns those who stay where faith ishard; some see minority fiqh ascompromisePractice is sometimes limited (veil bans,minaret ban)Judge it byCan Islam be practised freely? · Is Shari'amainly state law or personal duty? · Does theold dar al-Islam / dar al-harb map fit a worldof citizens?
  • Claim: Islam fully allows Muslims to live as a minority in non-Muslim lands.
  • For: the Abyssinian precedent; jurists who allowed residence where Islam can be practised freely; 17:34 on keeping covenants; minority jurisprudence; Ramadan's "abode of witness".
  • Against: the classical ideal is life under Shari'a; 4:97 warns those who stay where faith is hard; some scholars see minority fiqh as compromise.
  • Against: practice is sometimes limited (veil bans, minaret ban).
  • Judge it by: Can Islam be practised freely? Is Shari'a mainly state law or personal duty? Does the old dar al-Islam / dar al-harb map fit a world of citizens?
Mission 5Evaluate

How far does the media shape perceptions of Islam?

How far does the media shape perceptions of Islam?The media is the main cause of negativeWestern perceptions of Islam.ForMost people meet Islam mainly throughnews; studies show threat-framingOnline outrage spreads fast; Said'sargument (Covering Islam)AgainstReal events (terror attacks) shape fearwhatever the coverage; older history(crusades, empire) shaped attitudes beforemodern media (Green)Personal contact with Muslim neighboursand colleagues changes views; media alsoproduces positive portrayalsJudge it byWhat evidence links coverage to attitudes? ·Which media: press, TV, online? · Is Islamrepresented accurately today?
  • Claim: The media is the main cause of negative Western perceptions of Islam.
  • For: most people meet Islam mainly through news; studies show threat-framing; online outrage spreads fast; Said's argument.
  • Against: real events (terror attacks) shape fear whatever the coverage; older history (crusades, empire) shaped attitudes before modern media (Green).
  • Against: personal contact with Muslim neighbours and colleagues changes views; media also produces positive portrayals.
  • Judge it by: What evidence links coverage to attitudes? Which media: press, TV, online? Is Islam represented accurately today?
Mission check

?After a terrorist attack abroad, a local mosque in Leeds is sprayed with graffiti. A councillor says: "What do they expect? Muslims are all the same, and they answer for what their people do." The mosque holds an open day with neighbours. Which description is most accurate?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Justice ('adl) is central: 57:25, 4:135, 5:8; the poor have a right to zakah; the Qur'an calls for action for the oppressed (4:75).
  • Enjoining good is a communal duty (fard kifaya) within limits; qisas, diya and maslaha balance rights and public interest; mercy marks the Prophet's conduct.
  • Shari'ati: revolutionary "red Shi'ism"; Murad: the forgotten inner revolution; liberationists (Esack, Engineer) side with the poor.

Mission 2

  • Jihad = striving: greater (against the nafs) and lesser (armed, under conditions).
  • Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time was a response to persecution and attack, limited by the Qur'an (22:39, 2:190, 8:61) and the Prophet's rules.

Mission 3

  • Three categories: hudud (fixed, strict proof), qisas (retribution, with diya or forgiveness by the family), ta'zir (discretion, guided by maslaha).
  • Enjoining good and forbidding wrong is a fard kifaya, limited by individual rights (49:12).

Mission 4

  • Madinah united religion and state; Muslims debate whether it is a blueprint or a set of principles (4:59, 42:38).
  • Sunni theory: a contract (al-Mawardi), ruler and ulama in complementary roles; Shi'a theory: the Imam, then the ulama in his absence (quietism or wilayat al-faqih).
  • Modern states range from secular to Islamic; Muslims disagree whether Islam and democracy fit together.

Mission 5

  • Hijra, the Abyssinian precedent, da'wa and minority jurisprudence give Muslims ways to live faithfully as a minority, within the law of the land.
  • European Islam (Tibi, Ramadan, Cerić's 2006 Declaration) argues Muslims can be fully European; opponents of multiculturalism grew louder after 9/11.
  • Islamophobia (Runnymede, 1997) involves closed views of Islam; bias, misrepresentation and inaccuracy in politics, media and online shape perceptions.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islamic thought: Justice and liberation; islam and the state; islam in Europe for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Should Muslims fight injustice with a revolution in the streets, or a revolution in the heart?
  2. Mission 2Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?
  3. Mission 3In Islamic law a murder victim's family can forgive the killer. Why give them that power?
  4. Mission 4Caliph, scholars or voters: who should govern a state that follows Islam?
  5. Mission 5Can a Muslim live faithfully as a minority, and why do so many Europeans fear Islam?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR