← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – Human destiny; H573/04 Developments in Islamic thought – The Shari'a
Mini-Lesson

Islamic thought: Human destiny; the Shari'a

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why does the Qur'an say God created humans? And is this life only a waiting room?
  2. Mission 2Muslims believe the dead wait, rise and are judged. What happens at each stage, and why does it matter now?
  3. Mission 3If God has already decreed everything, how can God fairly judge what you choose?
  4. Mission 4The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  5. Mission 5The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why does the Qur'an say God created humans? And is this life only a waiting room?

Make a guess: Why does the Qur'an say God created humans? And is this life only a waiting room?

Mission 1

Three reasons in the Qur'an

Three reasons triangleonepurposeKnowAdam,2:30–34Serve /worship51:56Be tested67:2"Did ye then think that We had created you injest" (23:115)
  • "Did ye then think that We had created you in jest" (Qur'an 23:115, Yusuf Ali)? The Qur'an insists human life has a purpose.
  • 1. Adam's creation and the knowledge of God: humans are made able to know God, and entrusted with the earth.
  • 2. Worship: humans are created to serve and worship God.
  • 3. Moral tribulation: life is a test of who does best.
  • The three are one purpose seen from three sides: know God, serve God, prove faithful.
  • Your spec: "the three main reasons for human existence given by the Qur'an".
Mission 1Read the source

Adam: the khalifah who knows

> "Behold, thy Lord said to the angels: 'I will create a vicegerent on earth.'" (Qur'an 2:30, Yusuf Ali)

> "And He taught Adam the names of all things" (Qur'an 2:31, Yusuf Ali)

  • The angels ask why God would place on earth one who will shed blood; God answers, "I know what ye know not" (2:30).
  • Adam names what the angels cannot (2:31–33): human knowledge is his distinction. The angels bow to him (2:34).
  • Khalifah (vicegerent, steward): humans hold the earth on trust.

Q1 What does God give Adam that sets him above the angels in this story?

Show answer

Knowledge: the names of all things.

Q2 What role does 2:30 give humans on earth?

Show answer

Vicegerent: khalifah.

Mission 1

Born knowing God

  • Fitrah: every person is created with a natural inclination to know and worship God (30:30).
  • The primordial covenant (7:172): before birth, the children of Adam are asked, "Am I not your Lord?" and answer "Yea! We do testify!"
  • So knowledge of God is not foreign to humans; revelation reminds (dhikr) rather than introduces.
  • The trust (amanah, 33:72): offered to heavens, earth and mountains, which refused; humans accepted it: free, responsible moral agency.
  • Adam's slip: he and his wife disobey, then Adam receives words from God, repents, and is forgiven (2:37). No inherited "original sin": each soul answers for itself.
  • Adam is honoured as the first prophet: human history begins with guidance.
Quick check
?In the Qur'an's account of Adam (2:30–34), which detail shows most clearly why God created humans as His khalifah?
Mission 1Read the source

Created to worship

> "I have only created Jinns and men, that they may serve Me." (Qur'an 51:56, Yusuf Ali)

  • Pickthall: "I created the jinn and humankind only that they might worship Me." The Arabic li-ya'budun covers both serve and worship.
  • God does not need worship (51:57–58 says God asks no provision from them); worship benefits the worshipper.
  • An early gloss, often attributed to Mujahid, reads "worship Me" as "know Me": tying reasons 1 and 2 together.

Q1 Why do the two translations differ?

Show answer

The Arabic word means both serving and worshipping.

Q2 If God needs nothing, whom does worship benefit?

Show answer

The worshipper.

Mission 1

What counts as worship?

Worship circlesritual worshipFive Pillars(below)everyday worshipworkstudyfamilycarehonestyniyyahniyyah (key)intention turns ordinary action into worshipthe Five Pillarsshahadahdeclaration offaithsalahprayerzakahalmsgivingsawmfastingHajjpilgrimagetestshardshipmet with sabr(patient endurance)blessingmet with shukr(gratitude)
  • 'Ibadah (worship, from 'abd, servant) is wider than prayer.
  • Ritual worship: the Five Pillars: shahadah, salah, zakah, sawm, Hajj.
  • Everyday worship: any lawful act done for God's sake: work, study, family care, honesty, removing a harmful object from the road (Sahih Muslim 35, paraphrase).
  • Intention (niyyah) turns ordinary action into worship: the first hadith in al-Bukhari's collection says actions are judged by intentions (Sahih al-Bukhari 1, paraphrase).
  • Ihsan: worship God as though you see Him (Hadith of Jibril): sincerity, not mere routine.
Mission 1

Life as a test

Worship circlesritual worshipFive Pillars(below)everyday worshipworkstudyfamilycarehonestyniyyahniyyah (key)intention turns ordinary action into worshipthe Five Pillarsshahadahdeclaration offaithsalahprayerzakahalmsgivingsawmfastingHajjpilgrimagetestshardshipmet with sabr(patient endurance)blessingmet with shukr(gratitude)
  • "He Who created Death and Life, that He may try which of you is best in deed" (Qur'an 67:2, Yusuf Ali).
  • Tests by hardship: "fear and hunger, some loss in goods or lives" (2:155); tests by blessing as well: "by evil and by good" (21:35).
  • Humans are free to choose: "We showed him the Way: whether he be grateful or ungrateful" (Qur'an 76:3, Yusuf Ali).
  • Outcomes come at the Last Day (see Mission 2); how God's decree and human choice fit together.
  • Key virtues: sabr (patient endurance) and shukr (gratitude).
  • OCR's term: moral tribulation.
Quick check
?A Muslim wins a large sum of money. Which response best reflects the Qur'an's teaching that life is a test?
Mission 1Diversity

Different emphases

  • Legal and ethical emphasis (most scholars): purpose is fulfilled by obeying the Shari'ah: duties to God and to others.
  • Sufi emphasis: purpose is to know and love God. Sufis often cite a saying, "I was a hidden treasure and loved to be known, so I created creation" (paraphrase); hadith scholars say it has no sound chain, but Sufis value its meaning.
  • Modernist and reformist emphasis: khalifah and justice in this world: building a just society is itself worship.
  • Shi'a emphasis: purpose is fulfilled under the guidance of the Prophet and the Imams; justice ('adl) stressed as the frame of the test.
  • All agree: worship, knowledge of God and moral testing belong together.
Mission 1Evaluate

"For Muslims, this life is only important as a preparation for the life to come."

Argument map"For Muslims, this life is only important as apreparation for the life to come."For"the life of this world is but goods andchattels of deception" (3:185)"the Hereafter is better and moreenduring" (87:17)The Prophet: be in this world like astranger or a traveller (hadith).Against"nor forget thy portion in this world"(28:77)The prayer: "give us good in this worldand good in the Hereafter" (2:201).Khalifah gives this world value in itself.Shari'ah protects life, family, property andintellect here.Middle viewThis life matters because it prepares forthe next: worship, justice and care forcreation are the preparation.Judge it byDoes "only" mean "only as preparation" or "ofno value"? · Can a life be both a test and agift? · Which Muslims (Sufi, modernist, legal)would accept the claim, and with whatmeaning?
  • For: "the life of this world is but goods and chattels of deception" (Qur'an 3:185, Yusuf Ali); "the Hereafter is better and more enduring" (87:17); the Prophet: be in this world like a stranger or a traveller (Sahih al-Bukhari 6416, paraphrase).
  • Against: "nor forget thy portion in this world" (Qur'an 28:77, Yusuf Ali); the prayer "give us good in this world and good in the Hereafter" (2:201); khalifah gives this world value in itself; Shari'ah protects life, family, property and intellect here.
  • Middle view: this life matters because it prepares for the next: worship, justice and care for creation are the preparation.
  • Judge it by: Does "only" mean "only as preparation" or "of no value"? Can a life be both a test and a gift? Which Muslims (Sufi, modernist, legal) would accept the claim, and with what meaning?
Quick check
?Which statement would most Sunni and Shi'a scholars accept about the Qur'an's three reasons for human existence?
Mission check

?A Muslim doctor works night shifts in a hospital emergency department. Which description best fits a mainstream Muslim view of how her work relates to her purpose in life?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Muslims believe the dead wait, rise and are judged. What happens at each stage, and why does it matter now?

Make a guess: Muslims believe the dead wait, rise and are judged. What happens at each stage, and why does it matter now?

Mission 2

Akhirah: one life, then the return

Timeline of the returnThis lifeone life, a testDeaththe Angel of Death takes the soulBarzakhquestioning by Munkar and Nakir;garden or pitTrumpet → resurrection → judgementJannahparadiseJahannamhell
  • Akhirah (the hereafter, "the last"): one of the six articles of faith for Sunnis; for Twelver Shi'a, ma'ad (the return) is a root of faith.
  • Muslims believe each person lives one earthly life; there is no rebirth.
  • "Every soul shall have a taste of death: And only on the Day of Judgment shall you be paid your full recompense." (Qur'an 3:185, Yusuf Ali)
  • The stages: death → Barzakh (waiting) → the trumpet and resurrection → judgement → Jannah (paradise) or Jahannam (hell).
  • OCR's phases: Barzakh, the Day of Resurrection (yawm al-qiyama), heaven and hell as final destinations.
Mission 2

The soul and the self

  • Ruh (spirit): God "breathed into him of My spirit" when Adam was formed (Qur'an 15:29, Yusuf Ali). Its nature is known to God alone (17:85).
  • Nafs (soul, self): the person who chooses, and who will be judged.
  • The Qur'an describes the self in states: prone to evil (12:53), self-reproaching (75:2), at peace (89:27). Sufis later read these as stages of growth.
  • The soul is created: it begins with God, not eternal on its own.
  • At death the Angel of Death takes the soul (32:11).
  • Most Muslims hold that a human is soul and body: so resurrection is bodily.
Mission 2

Death and Barzakh

Timeline of the returnThis lifeone life, a testDeaththe Angel of Death takes the soulBarzakhquestioning by Munkar and Nakir;garden or pitTrumpet → resurrection → judgementJannahparadiseJahannamhell
  • At death the person asks to return, but: "Before them is a Partition till the Day they are raised up." (Qur'an 23:100, Yusuf Ali)
  • Barzakh (barrier) is the state between death and resurrection.
  • Hadith describe two angels, Munkar and Nakir, questioning the dead: Who is your Lord? What is your religion? Who is your prophet? (Tirmidhi; paraphrase)
  • The grave becomes a foretaste: "a garden of paradise or a pit of hell" (Tirmidhi; paraphrase).
  • Martyrs are "living" with their Lord (3:169).
  • Justice and mercy already show in Barzakh: the soul begins to meet the fruit of its life.
  • Views differ on how conscious the dead are; most Sunni and Shi'a scholars hold the dead are aware.
Mission 2Read the source

The trumpet and the resurrection

> "The Trumpet will (just) be sounded, when all that are in the heavens and on earth will swoon … Then will a second one be sounded, when, behold, they will be standing and looking on!" (Qur'an 39:68, Yusuf Ali)

> "He says, 'Who can give life to (dry) bones and decomposed ones (at that)?' Say, 'He will give them life Who created them for the first time!'" (Qur'an 36:78–79, Yusuf Ali)

  • In tradition the angel Israfil blows the trumpet (named in hadith, not in the Qur'an).

Q1 How many trumpet blasts does 39:68 describe, and what follows each?

Show answer

Two: all swoon; then all stand.

Q2 What argument does 36:79 give for resurrection?

Show answer

The God who created once can create again.

Mission 2

The Day of Judgement

The Day of Judgement as symbolsthe balance (mizan)good deedsbad deedsthe record of deedsright hand(saved)left hand(lost)the bridge (sirat)hellgarden"Master of the Day of Judgment" (1:4)
  • God is "Master of the Day of Judgment" (Qur'an 1:4, Yusuf Ali).
  • Each person receives their record of deeds: in the right hand (saved) or the left (lost) (69:19–25).
  • Deeds are weighed on the balance (mizan): "if there be (no more than) the weight of a mustard seed, We will bring it (to account)" (Qur'an 21:47, Yusuf Ali).
  • Intercession (shafa'a), above all by the Prophet, only with God's permission (2:255).
  • Hadith describe a bridge (sirat) over hell to paradise (Bukhari; Muslim).
  • Mercy: "My mercy prevails over My wrath" (hadith qudsi, Bukhari; Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Justice: nothing is missed. Mercy: God forgives and multiplies good deeds.
Quick check
?Which statement about Barzakh fits Muslim teaching?
Mission 2Read the source

Paradise and hell

> "(Here is) a Parable of the Garden which the righteous are promised: in it are rivers of water incorruptible; rivers of milk of which the taste never changes; rivers of wine, a joy to those who drink; and rivers of honey pure and clear." (Qur'an 47:15, Yusuf Ali)

> "Every time a Group is cast therein, its Keepers will ask, 'Did no Warner come to you?' They will say: 'Yes indeed; a Warner did come to us, but we rejected him'" (Qur'an 67:8–9, Yusuf Ali)

  • 47:15 contrasts the Garden with those who drink "boiling water". 67:7–10 describe hell drawing in breath and "bursting with fury"; the damned admit, "Had we but listened or used our intelligence" (67:10).

Q1 What word does 47:15 use to introduce the Garden?

Show answer

A "parable" or "similitude", Arabic * mathal *.

Q2 According to 67:8–10, why are people in hell?

Show answer

They were warned and rejected the warning.

Mission 2

Jannah and Jahannam

Timeline of the returnThis lifeone life, a testDeaththe Angel of Death takes the soulBarzakhquestioning by Munkar and Nakir;garden or pitTrumpet → resurrection → judgementJannahparadiseJahannamhell
  • Jannah (the Garden): gardens, rivers, peace, companionship; ranks of paradise; above all, nearness to God.
  • Sunni theologians (Ash'ari, Maturidi, Hanbali) hold the righteous will see God: faces "Looking towards their Lord" (Qur'an 75:23, Yusuf Ali). Mu'tazila and Twelver Shi'a read this as spiritual vision, not sight.
  • Jahannam (hell): fire, boiling water, regret; also separation from God.
  • Most scholars teach that those who rejected faith remain in hell; believers punished for sins may be brought out by mercy and intercession (Bukhari; Muslim).
  • A minority discussed whether hell's punishment ends (e.g. Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya, 1292–1350).
Mission 2Diversity

Literal or symbolic?

Literal or symbolic? A spectrum of readingsbodily andliteralspiritualonly11 Bodily, literalmost Sunni and Shi'a;bi-la kayf, "withoutasking how" (Ash'ari,Hanbali)22 Spiritual onlyIbn Sina (980–1037):only the soul survivesOther voices (not placed on the line)al-Ghazali (1058–1111)denying bodily resurrection: one of three viewshe judged unbeliefIbn Rushd (1126–1198)scripture may be read on more than one levelMuhammad Asad (1900–1992)modern symbolic reading: the images areallegories; 47:15 says "parable"
  • Bodily and literal: most Sunni and Shi'a scholars. Many Sunnis (Ash'ari, Hanbali) add "without asking how" (bi-la kayf). The rivers are real, but beyond present understanding: "no person knows what delights … are kept hidden" (32:17).
  • Spiritual only: Ibn Sina (980–1037) argued the soul alone survives; the images are for ordinary believers.
  • Al-Ghazali (1058–1111), Tahafut al-Falasifa (The Incoherence of the Philosophers, 1095): denying bodily resurrection was one of three views he judged unbelief.
  • Ibn Rushd (1126–1198), Tahafut al-Tahafut: defended the philosophers; scripture may be read on more than one level.
  • Modern symbolic readings: e.g. Muhammad Asad (1900–1992), The Message of the Qur'an (1980): the images are allegories of states beyond imagining (paraphrase); 47:15 itself says "parable".
Quick check
?A Muslim writer says: "The rivers of 47:15 are real, but how they are real is beyond us." Which approach is this?
Mission 2

Why the Akhirah matters now

  • Purpose: life is a test; every act counts (99:7–8).
  • Accountability: no one escapes justice; wrongs not righted on earth will be righted.
  • Hope and fear together (khawf and raja'): fear keeps a believer from sin; hope stops despair (39:53).
  • Comfort in grief: death is a return to God (2:156).
Mission 2Evaluate

Does the Day of Judgement inspire fear or faith?

Does the Day of Judgement inspire fear or faith?Belief in the Day of Judgement inspires fearmore than faith.FearVivid descriptions of hell (67:7–10; 4:56)are meant to warn.A believer can never be certain of theirown outcome.FaithThe warnings serve mercy: a warning is achance to change (67:8)."Despair not of the Mercy of Allah"(39:53); good deeds are multiplied.Judge it byIs fear itself a form of faith (taqwa)? · Doesthe effect differ between believers? · Doparadise texts outnumber hell texts? · Whatdoes God's mercy mean for judgement?
  • Claim: Belief in the Day of Judgement inspires fear more than faith.
  • Fear: vivid descriptions of hell (67:7–10; 4:56) are meant to warn.
  • Fear: a believer can never be certain of their own outcome.
  • Faith: the warnings serve mercy: a warning given is a chance to change (67:8).
  • Faith: "Despair not of the Mercy of Allah" (Qur'an 39:53, Yusuf Ali); good deeds are multiplied.
  • Criteria: Is fear itself a form of faith (taqwa, God-consciousness)? Does the effect differ between believers? Do paradise texts outnumber hell texts? What does God's mercy mean for judgement?
Mission check

?At a Muslim burial, mourners pray that God will keep the dead man firm "when he is questioned". Which belief does this prayer assume?
Mission 3

Mission 3: If God has already decreed everything, how can God fairly judge what you choose?

Make a guess: If God has already decreed everything, how can God fairly judge what you choose?

Mission 3

Al-Qadr: what Muslims agree on

Al-Qadr: both held togetherGod's control(decree, knowledge,will)Humanresponsibility(choice, judgement)Al-Qadr: both held together
  • Al-Qadr (divine decree, "measuring out"): God knows and has recorded all that happens; for most Sunnis, God also wills and creates it.
  • For Sunnis, one of the six articles of faith. In the Hadith of Jibril, belief in the decree, "its good and its bad", is part of faith (Sahih Muslim, Book of Faith, no. 8; paraphrase).
  • Muslims also believe God is just and will judge each person by their deeds.
  • So two beliefs must be held together: God's control of all things, and human responsibility.
Mission 3Read the source

Two sets of verses

> "Verily, all things have We created in proportion and measure." (Qur'an 54:49, Yusuf Ali)

> "But ye shall not will except as Allah wills,- the Cherisher of the Worlds." (Qur'an 81:29, Yusuf Ali)

> "Let him who will believe, and let him who will, reject (it)" (Qur'an 18:29, Yusuf Ali)

> "Verily never will Allah change the condition of a people until they change it themselves (with their own souls)." (Qur'an 13:11, Yusuf Ali)

Q1 Which verses stress God's control, and which human choice?

Show answer

54:49 and 81:29 control; 18:29 and 13:11 choice.

Q2 Does 81:29 deny that humans will at all?

Show answer

No: it says they will, but only within God's will.

  • Every school below reads all four verses; they differ on which set governs the other.
Quick check
?A student says: "If Allah has already decreed whether I pass, revising is pointless." Which reply best fits mainstream Muslim teaching?
Mission 3

The Mu'tazila: justice first

Spectrum of views on divine decreeGod decideseverythinghumans decidetheir acts121 JabriyyaJahm ibn Safwan, d.746: humanscompelled, like a treein the wind2 early QadariyyaMa'bad al-Juhani, d.c. 703: God does notdecree human actsBoth rejected. The early Qadariyya are not theMu'tazila.343 Ash'arial-Ash'ari,873/4–935/6: Godcreates; humansacquire (kasb)4 Mu'tazilaWasil ibn Ata, d. 748:humans originate;God is just
  • Background: an early dispute. The Jabriyya (e.g. Jahm ibn Safwan, d. 746) said humans are compelled, like a tree moved by wind; some early Qadariyya (e.g. Ma'bad al-Juhani, d. c. 703) said God does not decree human acts at all.
  • The Mu'tazila grew from Basra in the 8th century (Wasil ibn Ata, d. 748; later Qadi Abd al-Jabbar, d. 1025). Second of their five principles: adl (God's justice).
  • A just God cannot punish people for acts He created in them. So humans originate their own acts, using a power God gives them.
  • God wills and commands only good; evil acts are the human's own (41:46: "nor is thy Lord ever unjust (in the least) to His Servants", Yusuf Ali).
  • Reason can know good and evil; God's commands match what reason sees.
  • God knows all acts in advance, but knowing is not causing.
Mission 3

The Ash'aris: God's power first

Spectrum of views on divine decreeGod decideseverythinghumans decidetheir acts121 JabriyyaJahm ibn Safwan, d.746: humanscompelled, like a treein the wind2 early QadariyyaMa'bad al-Juhani, d.c. 703: God does notdecree human actsBoth rejected. The early Qadariyya are not theMu'tazila.343 Ash'arial-Ash'ari,873/4–935/6: Godcreates; humansacquire (kasb)4 Mu'tazilaWasil ibn Ata, d. 748:humans originate;God is just
  • Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari (873/4–935/6) was a Mu'tazili until about 912, then broke with them. His school became the main Sunni theology, beside the Maturidis.
  • God is the only creator: "But Allah has created you and your handwork!" (Qur'an 37:96, Yusuf Ali). To say humans create their acts gives God partners in creating.
  • Kasb (acquisition): God creates the act, and with it a power in the person at the moment of acting; the person acquires the act and so is answerable for it.
  • Good is what God commands; God owes creatures nothing, so whatever God does is just by definition.
  • Critics, Mu'tazili and later, found kasb hard to pin down: a saying calls something obscure "subtler than al-Ash'ari's kasb".
Quick check
?Which statement expresses the Ash'ari position?
Mission 3Read the source

Al-Ghazali, The Jerusalem Epistle

The Jerusalem Epistle: four pillarsThe Jerusalem EpistleIGod'sessenceIIGod'sattributesIIIGod'sactsIVthingsknown byrevelationPillar III:God creates all actshumans acquirenothing against His willnot bound to the bestduties known by revelational-Ghazali; later in Book 2 of the Ihya
  • Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (1058–1111). Al-Risala al-Qudsiyya (The Jerusalem Epistle), written in Jerusalem c. 1096, later placed in Book 2 of Ihya Ulum al-Din. An Ash'ari creed.
  • Four pillars of faith: God's essence, God's attributes, God's acts (III), and things known by revelation.
  • From the Third Pillar (paraphrase of its principles):
  • God creates every event, including human acts; the person acquires them (kasb).
  • Nothing happens in God's kingdom against His will.
  • God may cause pain to a creature that has not sinned without injustice: injustice means dealing with what belongs to another, and all belongs to God.
  • God is not bound to do what is best for creatures (against the Mu'tazila).
  • Duties are known by revelation, not by reason alone.

Q1 How does al-Ghazali redefine "injustice" to protect God's omnipotence?

Show answer

As acting on another's property: God owns all, so cannot be unjust.

Q2 Which Mu'tazili belief does the "not bound to do what is best" principle reject?

Show answer

That justice obliges God to do what is best for humans.

Quick check
?In The Jerusalem Epistle, why does al-Ghazali say God is not unjust if He causes pain to a creature that has not sinned?
Mission 3

Living with the decree

  • Purpose: life is a test within God's decree; humans act, are answerable, and trust God with the outcome.
  • Tawakkul (trust in God): do what you can, then rely on God.
  • Sabr (patience) in loss: "To Allah We belong, and to Him is our return" (Qur'an 2:156, Yusuf Ali).
  • Belief in Qadr is meant to prevent both pride in success and despair in failure.
Mission 3Worked answer

Explaining a school's view

Task: explain the Mu'tazili understanding of divine decree.

  • Belief: humans originate their own acts with a power God gives them.
  • Source: "nor is thy Lord ever unjust (in the least) to His Servants" (Qur'an 41:46, Yusuf Ali); 18:29 on choosing to believe.
  • Develop: because God is just (adl), He cannot punish acts He created; so reward and punishment are deserved.
  • Link: God still knows all acts in advance, so knowledge, not causation, is what the decree means for human acts.
  • Strong answers keep the school's reason (justice) attached to its belief, not just list positions.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does the Ash'ari view sacrifice God's justice?

Does the Ash'ari view sacrifice God's justice?The Ash'ari view protects God's power, butat the cost of God's justice.ForIf God creates every act, punishing theperson seems to punish what God made.Kasb is hard to define: maybe a name forthe problem, not a solution.AgainstJustice is not a standard above God:whatever God does is just (al-Ghazali'sargument from ownership).The Mu'tazili view makes humans creatorsbeside God, threatening tawhid.Judge it byWhich verses must each view reinterpret? · Is"justice" a human standard or God's? · Does itkeep real responsibility? · Does it keep Godthe only creator?
  • Claim: The Ash'ari view protects God's power, but at the cost of God's justice.
  • For: If God creates every act, punishing the person seems to punish what God made.
  • For: Kasb is hard to define; it may be a name for the problem rather than a solution.
  • Against: Justice is not a standard above God: whatever God does is just (al-Ghazali's argument from ownership).
  • Against: The Mu'tazili view makes humans creators beside God, threatening tawhid (God's oneness); a hadith in Abu Dawud calls deniers of the decree "the Magians of this community".
  • Criteria: Which verses does each view have to reinterpret? Is "justice" a human standard or God's? Does the view keep real responsibility? Does it keep God the only creator?
  • Spec issue: strengths and weaknesses of different approaches to free will and omnipotence.
Mission check

?In a short story, a thief tells the judge: "God created my act, so I am not to blame." Which reply would an Ash'ari theologian give?
Mission 4

Mission 4: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Make a guess: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Mission 4

Shari'a and fiqh

Shari'a and fiqhshari'aGod's way (ideal)fiqhhumanunderstanding
  • Shari'a: literally "the path to the water": God's way for human life.
  • "Then We put thee on the (right) Way of Religion: so follow thou that (Way), and follow not the desires of those who know not." (Qur'an 45:18, Yusuf Ali) The Arabic word is shari'ah.
  • It covers worship (prayer, fasting) and dealings (family, trade, food, crime): much more than criminal law.
  • Fiqh ("deep understanding"): the human effort to understand and apply the shari'a. Scholars can err; the shari'a, as God's will, cannot.
  • So Muslims distinguish the ideal (God's shari'a) from law in practice (the jurists' fiqh).
  • Your spec: "the Shari'a as an ideal".
Mission 4

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and Sunnah

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and Sunnah1 Qur'anthe first source: God's worde.g. commands prayer2 Sunnahthe Prophet's example, known throughhadith: explains and adds detail (shows howto pray)Shi'a: includes the Imams' teachingsHadith graded by chain and textsahihsoundhasangoodda'ifweak
  • Qur'an: the first source, God's word. Some rulings are clear (no pork, 5:3; fasting in Ramadan, 2:185); many verses give principles (justice, 4:58; consultation, 42:38).
  • Sunnah: the Prophet's example, known through hadith. It explains and adds detail: the Qur'an commands prayer; the Sunnah shows how to pray.
  • "So take what the Messenger assigns to you, and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you." (Qur'an 59:7, Yusuf Ali)
  • Hadith are graded by chain and text: sahih (sound), hasan (good), da'if (weak).
  • Shi'a Muslims include the teachings of the Imams within the Sunnah.
Mission 4

Non-scriptural sources

The sources of lawSunni1 Qur'anGod's word2 SunnahProphet's example3 ijmaconsensus4 qiyasanalogyTwelver Shi'aQur'anSunnah, withthe Imamsijma, if itreflects theImam's view'aql (reason)no qiyasAlso used: 'urf (custom), istihsan (Hanafi),maslahah (Maliki)
  • Ijma (consensus): agreement of the qualified scholars of an age on a ruling. Once reached, Sunnis treat it as binding ("my community will not agree on error", Ibn Majah; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas (analogy): extending a ruling from a case in the texts to a new case that shares its cause ('illah).
  • 'Urf (custom): local practice accepted where it does not contradict the texts (e.g. customary amounts of dowry). Malik also gave weight to the practice ('amal) of Madinah.
  • Other tools: istihsan (juristic preference, Hanafi), maslahah (public interest, Maliki).
  • Twelver Shi'a jurists: Qur'an, Sunnah (with the Imams), ijma (valid if it reflects the Imam's view) and 'aql (reason); they reject qiyas.
  • Your spec: "non-scriptural (consensus of the community, analogical reasoning, custom)".
Mission 4Read the source

From wine to every intoxicant

Qiyas: from wine to every intoxicant2:219more harmthan benefit4:43don't prayintoxicated5:90avoidcompletelystages many scholars seeoriginal casewine (forbidden in the texts)cause ('illah)intoxication: it clouds the mindnew casecannabis, cocaine, other drugsrulingharam

> "They ask thee concerning wine and gambling. Say: 'In them is great sin, and some profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit.'" (Qur'an 2:219, Yusuf Ali)

> "O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper." (Qur'an 5:90, Yusuf Ali)

  • Many scholars see stages: 2:219 (more harm than benefit), 4:43 (do not pray intoxicated), 5:90 (avoid completely).
  • A hadith: "Every intoxicant is khamr, and every khamr is forbidden" (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas: original case: wine · cause ('illah): intoxication · new case: cannabis, cocaine, other drugs · ruling: haram.

Q1 Which verse gives the final ruling to avoid intoxicants completely?

Show answer

5:90.

Q2 What shared cause allows the ruling on wine to cover drugs?

Show answer

They intoxicate: they cloud the mind.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes how qiyas works?
Mission 4

Al-Shafi'i: a method for law

Al-Shafi'i and the founders of the Sunni schoolsAbu Hanifa699–767Malik ibn Anasc. 711–795al-Shafi'i767–820Ahmad ibn Hanbal780–855700750800850Al-Shafi'i, al-Risala: set out an order ofsources; called the founder of usul al-fiqh.
  • Muhammad ibn Idris al-Shafi'i (767–820), al-Risala ("The Epistle").
  • Before him, regional scholars (Kufa, Madinah) mixed hadith, local practice and personal opinion (ra'y) in different ways.
  • He set out an order of sources: Qur'an → Sunnah → ijma → qiyas.
  • A sound hadith binds, even if reported by a single chain, because the Sunnah explains the Qur'an (2:151: "Scripture and Wisdom", Yusuf Ali).
  • He limited free opinion and istihsan: reasoning must be tied to a text through qiyas.
  • So he is called the founder of usul al-fiqh (the roots, or method, of jurisprudence).
Mission 4

The law schools (madhhabs)

The law schools: where each predominatesHanafiTurkey, Central and South AsiaMalikiNorth and West AfricaShafi'iEgypt, East Africa, South-East AsiaHanbaliSaudi Arabia, QatarJa'fariIran, Iraqshading: named countries · dots: named regionsPredominant school only: most areas aremixed, and many Muslims live elsewhere.
  • Hanafi: Abu Hanifa (699–767), Kufa; wide use of reasoning and istihsan; Turkey, Central and South Asia (most British Muslims of South Asian heritage).
  • Maliki: Malik ibn Anas (c. 711–795), Madinah; al-Muwatta; the practice of Madinah; North and West Africa.
  • Shafi'i: al-Shafi'i; Egypt, East Africa, South-East Asia.
  • Hanbali: Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780–855), Baghdad; text first, cautious about reasoning; Saudi Arabia, Qatar.
  • Ja'fari: Ja'far al-Sadiq (d. 765), the sixth Imam; Twelver Shi'a; Iran, Iraq.
  • They agree on essentials; they differ in detail (e.g. hand position in prayer). Each recognises the others as legitimate.
  • Taqlid: ordinary Muslims follow a school or scholar; ijtihad: qualified jurists derive rulings within its framework.
Mission 4

The five rulings (ahkam)

The five rulings (ahkam)fard / wajibobligatorysalah; fasting in Ramadanmustahabb / mandubrecommendedextra prayers; sadaqahmubahpermittedmost foods; ordinary workmakruhdislikedwasting water in wuduharamforbiddenalcohol, gambling (5:90); pork (5:3)halal (lawful)
  • Fard / wajib (obligatory): rewarded if done, sin if left: salah, fasting in Ramadan.
  • Mustahabb / mandub (recommended): rewarded if done, no sin if left: extra prayers, sadaqah.
  • Mubah (permitted): neutral: most foods, ordinary work.
  • Makruh (disliked): better avoided, no sin if done: e.g. wasting water in wudu; coming to the mosque after eating raw garlic.
  • Haram (forbidden): sin if done: alcohol and gambling (5:90), pork (5:3).
  • Halal: lawful, everything not haram. Modesty: lower the gaze and guard modesty (24:30–31); dress rules derive from these verses and the Sunnah.
  • Killing and eating animals: halal meat is slaughtered with God's name (6:121), a swift cut and draining of blood; scholars differ on pre-stunning.
  • Makruh applied: smoking was long called makruh; as its harm became known, many scholars ruled it haram (harm to self is forbidden).
Quick check
?A Muslim decides not to smoke even though his local imam calls it makruh. Which statement about makruh is accurate?
Mission 4

Interpretation and authority beyond the texts

Authority beyond the textsulamascholarsmuftisissue fatwas(non-binding)madhhabslaw schoolsijtihadqualified juristsderive rulingstaqlidordinary Muslimsfollow a school orscholarThe "gate of ijtihad"Closed after about the 10th century? Acommon Sunni view: yes. Wael Hallaq: juristsnever stopped. Twelver Shi'a: always open.
  • Ulama (scholars), muftis issuing fatwas (non-binding legal opinions), and the schools carry authority beyond the texts.
  • Was the "gate of ijtihad" closed after about the 10th century? A common Sunni view said yes; Wael Hallaq (b. 1955) argues jurists never stopped independent reasoning. Twelver Shi'a always kept ijtihad open.
  • Hallaq, An Introduction to Islamic Law (2009), Part 1: before modern states, law grew through scholars, courts and communities; codification by states changed it (paraphrase).
  • Mohammad Hashim Kamali, Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence: the sources and methods as a living discipline for new problems (paraphrase).
Mission 4Evaluate

Divine law or human interpretation?

Divine law or human interpretation?Shari'a as Muslims practise it is morehuman interpretation than divine law.ForFiqh is human; the schools disagree;rulings change (smoking); applying oldrulings to new cases needs interpretation.Ijma and qiyas are human methods; stateshave codified and reshaped the law.Hallaq's account of state codificationsupports this side.AgainstThe sources and principles are divine;scholars discover rulings, they do notinvent them.The core (prayer, fasting, the mainprohibitions) is agreed across all schools.A further viewThe limits of human understanding canlead to tolerance of diversity withinMuslim practice.Judge it byWhere is the line between Shari'a and fiqh? ·Does diversity weaken authority or show itsdepth?
  • Claim: Shari'a as Muslims practise it is more human interpretation than divine law.
  • For: fiqh is human; the schools disagree; rulings change (smoking); applying old rulings to new cases needs interpretation.
  • For: ijma and qiyas are human methods; states have codified and reshaped the law.
  • Against: the sources and principles are divine; scholars discover rulings, they do not invent them.
  • Hallaq's account of state codification supports "for".
  • Against: the core (prayer, fasting, the main prohibitions) is agreed across all schools.
  • A further view: the limits of human understanding can lead to tolerance of diversity within Muslim practice.
  • Criteria: Where is the line between shari'a and fiqh? Does diversity weaken authority or show its depth?
  • Spec issues: "the difference between the Shari'a as an ideal and Islamic law in practice"; "Islamic law as an ongoing interpretive effort".
Mission check

?A new synthetic drug is sold as "not mentioned in any holy book, so permitted". A Sunni mufti rules it haram. Which reasoning is he most likely to use?
Mission 5

Mission 5: The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?

Make a guess: The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?

Mission 5

Shari'a and fiqh

Shari'a and fiqh: two layersShari'aGod's will for human lifeperfect, unchangingFiqhhuman understandingwritten by scholars: can be mistakenijtihad(effort)mujtahid
  • Shari'a: literally "the path to the water"; for Muslims, God's will for human life, perfect and unchanging.
  • Fiqh: literally "understanding"; the human effort to know and apply the shari'a. Fiqh is written by scholars and can be mistaken.
  • Many Muslims hold that the shari'a is the ideal; fiqh is the law in practice.
  • So two scholars can disagree on a ruling without either denying the shari'a.
  • Your spec: Islamic law (fiqh) as an interpretive effort.
Mission 5

Ijtihad: effort to find the ruling

Shari'a and fiqh: two layersShari'aGod's will for human lifeperfect, unchangingFiqhhuman understandingwritten by scholars: can be mistakenijtihad(effort)mujtahid
  • Ijtihad: from the root j-h-d, "to strive" (the same root as jihad). The jurist's full effort to derive a ruling from the sources.
  • Mujtahid: a scholar qualified to do this: Arabic, Qur'an, Sunna and its chains, earlier consensus, legal method.
  • A widely cited report: the Prophet asked Mu'adh ibn Jabal how he would judge in Yemen. Qur'an, then Sunna, and if neither answered, he would strive to form his own judgement (Abu Dawud; paraphrase; its chain is debated).
  • A judge who strives and is right has two rewards; one who strives and errs has one reward (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
  • So honest effort is rewarded; error made in good faith is not sin.
Mission 5

Taqlid and the madhhab

The law schools (madhhabs)SunniHanafiAbu Hanifad. 767MalikiMalikd. 795Shafi'ial-Shafi'id. 820HanbaliAhmad ibn Hanbald. 855Twelver Shi'aJa'fariJa'far al-Sadiqd. 765Main areas today (colours as the cards)Approximate: most areas are mixed.
  • Taqlid: following a qualified scholar's ruling without examining all the evidence yourself (literally "imitation").
  • Most Muslims are not mujtahids, so most practise taqlid, usually of a madhhab (school of law).
  • Sunni schools: Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali. Twelver Shi'a: the Ja'fari school.
  • Ijtihad within the madhhab: later jurists apply the school's founding principles to new cases, rather than starting from scratch.
  • Defenders: taqlid is like trusting a doctor; it protects ordinary believers from amateur rulings.
  • Critics: rigid taqlid can freeze the law and repeat past mistakes.
Quick check
?A Muslim student in Leeds follows the Hanafi school's ruling on shortening prayers when travelling, without studying the hadith herself. What is she practising?
Mission 5Read the source

Wine and every intoxicant

> "O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper." (Qur'an 5:90, Yusuf Ali)

  • The Prophet is reported to have said: every intoxicant is khamr (wine), and every intoxicant is forbidden (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Also: what intoxicates in a large amount is forbidden in a small amount (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi; paraphrase).

Q1 Is heroin named in 5:90?

Show answer

No. The verse names wine/intoxicants, gambling and idolatrous practices.

Q2 Which word in the hadith lets jurists reach beyond wine?

Show answer

Every intoxicant: the property of intoxicating, not the drink itself.

Mission 5

Drugs by qiyas

Qiyas: from wine to new drugsOriginal case (asl)wine: forbidden by text (5:90)Effective cause ('illa)intoxication: it clouds the mindNew case (far')heroin, cannabisRuling (hukm)same cause, same ruling: haram
  • Qiyas: analogy. Four parts:
  • Original case (asl): wine, forbidden by text.
  • New case (far'): e.g. cannabis, heroin, cocaine.
  • Effective cause ('illa): intoxication, which clouds the mind and keeps people from remembering God.
  • Ruling (hukm): the new case shares the cause, so it shares the ruling: haram.
  • Medical use differs: many jurists permit anaesthetics and pain relief, as necessity (2:173) and not for intoxication.
  • Twelver Shi'a jurists mostly reject open-ended qiyas; they reach the same ruling through the hadith and reason ('aql).
Quick check
?In the qiyas that extends the ban on wine to heroin, what is the 'illa (effective cause)?
Mission 5

Usury and banking

  • The Qur'an forbids riba (usury): "Allah hath permitted trade and forbidden usury" (Qur'an 2:275, Yusuf Ali).
  • "Devour not usury, doubled and multiplied" (Qur'an 3:130, Yusuf Ali).
  • Ijtihad question: is all bank interest riba, or only exploitative, multiplying interest?
  • Majority view: any fixed, guaranteed return on a loan is riba (major fiqh councils in the 20th century).
  • Minority view: some scholars allowed fixed returns on modest savings, or defined riba as exploitation of the needy.
  • Response: Islamic banking shares profit and risk instead of charging interest, e.g. murabaha (cost-plus sale), ijara (leasing), mudaraba (profit-sharing).
Mission 5

Tobacco: from dispute to consensus

Tobacco: from dispute to consensusc. 1600Tobacco reaches Muslimlands; no text names itEarly juristsDisagree: haram / makruh /mubah20thcenturyScience: smoking causescancer, heart disease,addictionTodayMany fatwa bodies: haram;others still say makruhThe texts did not change; new knowledgechanged the ijtihad.
  • Tobacco reached Muslim lands around 1600. No text names it.
  • Early jurists disagreed: haram (it harms, wastes money, may intoxicate); makruh (it smells, like raw garlic); mubah (no proof of harm).
  • 20th century: scientific findings showed smoking causes cancer, heart disease and addiction.
  • Principle: there is to be no harm and no returning harm (Ibn Majah; Malik; paraphrase); "make not your own hands contribute to (your) destruction" (Qur'an 2:195, Yusuf Ali).
  • So a growing consensus: many fatwa bodies now call smoking haram; others still say makruh.
  • The texts did not change; new knowledge changed the ijtihad.
Quick check
?Why have many jurists moved from calling smoking makruh to calling it haram?
Mission 5Evaluate

Does human interpretation get in the way?

Does human interpretation get in the way?Human interpretation impairsunderstanding of the shari'a.ForFiqh is fallible: scholars carry their era'scustoms and blind spots into rulings.Disagreement between schools canconfuse believers about what God wants.AgainstWithout ijtihad, the shari'a could notspeak to heroin, banks or tobacco.Limits of interpretation make room fortolerance of diversity: honest error isrewarded.Judge it byIs fiqh a barrier to shari'a or the only way toit? · Who is qualified to interpret? · Do newsciences make ijtihad more or less reliable?
  • Claim: Human interpretation impairs understanding of the shari'a.
  • For: fiqh is fallible; scholars of one era carry its customs and blind spots into rulings.
  • For: disagreement between schools can confuse believers about what God wants.
  • Against: without ijtihad, the shari'a could not speak to heroin, banks or tobacco at all.
  • Against: the limits of interpretation make room for tolerance of diversity: the reward for honest error (Bukhari, Muslim).
  • Judge it by: Is fiqh a barrier to shari'a or the only way to it? Who is qualified to interpret? Do new sciences make ijtihad more or less reliable?
  • OCR issue: how the limits of human interpretation may lead to tolerance of diversity within Muslim practice.
Mission check

?A Shafi'i Muslim believes that touching his wife breaks his wudu; his Hanafi friend believes it does not. How would most Sunni scholars describe this disagreement?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • The Qur'an gives three reasons for human existence: Adam's creation and the knowledge of God (2:30–34), worship (51:56) and moral testing (67:2).
  • Worship ('ibadah) includes every lawful act done with the right intention.

Mission 2

  • Death → Barzakh → trumpet and resurrection → judgement (record, balance, intercession) → paradise or hell.
  • The Qur'an describes paradise and hell vividly (47:15; 67:7–10); Muslims read the images literally "without asking how", or as signs of realities beyond imagining.
  • Each phase shows divine justice (nothing missed) and mercy (forgiveness, intercession).

Mission 3

  • Al-Qadr: God knows and records all things (and, for most Sunnis, wills and creates them); humans are still responsible and will be judged.
  • Mu'tazila: God's justice first; humans originate their acts. Ash'aris: God's power first; God creates acts, humans acquire them (kasb).
  • Al-Ghazali's Third Pillar: God creates all acts, wills all that happens, owes creatures nothing; injustice is acting on another's property.

Mission 4

  • Shari'a is God's way; fiqh is the human understanding of it. Sources: Qur'an and Sunnah, then ijma, qiyas and custom (Twelvers: reason instead of qiyas).
  • Al-Shafi'i (767–820) set the order of sources; five schools (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali, Ja'fari) apply them.
  • Every act falls under five rulings: obligatory, recommended, permitted, disliked (makruh), forbidden (haram).

Mission 5

  • For Muslims, shari'a is God's ideal; fiqh is human understanding of it, reached by ijtihad and followed by taqlid within a madhhab.
  • Ijtihad in practice: qiyas extends the wine ban to drugs; scholars debate whether bank interest is riba; science moved the ruling on tobacco.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islamic thought: Human destiny; the Shari'a for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why does the Qur'an say God created humans? And is this life only a waiting room?
  2. Mission 2Muslims believe the dead wait, rise and are judged. What happens at each stage, and why does it matter now?
  3. Mission 3If God has already decreed everything, how can God fairly judge what you choose?
  4. Mission 4The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  5. Mission 5The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR