← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/07 Developments in Hindu thought – Living in accordance with dharma
Mini-Lesson

Hindu thought: Living in accordance with dharma

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
  2. Mission 2Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
  3. Mission 3Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Hindu thought: Concept of dharma.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?

Make a guess: Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?

Mission 1

Virtue and two kinds of dharma

  • A virtue is a settled quality of character that shows itself in action.
  • Hindu texts set out two levels of duty:
  • Sadharana dharma: duties common to everyone (non-violence, truthfulness, not stealing, purity, self-control). Manusmriti 10.63 gives a list like this for all four varnas (paraphrase).
  • Varnashrama dharma (svadharma): duties of your class and stage of life.
  • The three virtues in this mission belong to the first level: non-violence, detachment, self-restraint.
  • Each is thought to purify the mind and so lead towards moksha (liberation).
Mission 1

Non-violence (ahimsa)

  • Ahimsa: a- (not) + himsa (harm): not harming any living being in thought, word or deed.
  • Basis: the same atman (self) is present in every living being, so harming another is harming life that is one with yours.
  • Karma: Hindus believe harm done returns as suffering in this or a later life.
  • Its positive side: compassion (daya) and kindness to all.
  • Many Hindus apply it to diet: vegetarianism, and avoiding beef in particular.
  • It is weighed against other duties: a warrior may still have to fight (see Mission 3).
Mission 1

Detachment (vairagya)

  • Vairagya: freedom from craving for objects, pleasure and results.
  • Not indifference and not laziness: the Gita's ideal is to act fully while letting go of the fruits (nishkama karma, desireless action).
  • Tyaga: renouncing the fruit of action (Gita 18). Sannyasa: renouncing the world itself, the last ashrama.
  • Why it matters: desire for results binds the self to karma and rebirth.
  • Gita 2:47 (Arnold): "Let right deeds be / Thy motive, not the fruit which comes from them."
Mission 1

Self-restraint (dama)

  • Dama or indriya-nigraha: control of the senses and appetites.
  • Image in Gita 2:58: the wise person draws back the senses from their objects "as the wise tortoise draws its four feet safe / Under its shield" (Arnold).
  • Brihadaranyaka Upanishad V.2: the creator's one syllable "Da" is heard by gods, humans and demons as three lessons: restrain yourselves, give, be compassionate (paraphrase).
  • Practised as fasting, celibacy (brahmacharya) in the student stage, moderation in food and speech.
  • Self-restraint makes the other two virtues possible: anger restrained becomes non-violence; desire restrained becomes detachment.
Mission 1Read the source

Divine qualities

Bhagavad Gita 16:1–3 (Edwin Arnold, 1885), Krishna speaking:

> "… opened hand / And governed appetites; and piety, / And love of lonely study; humbleness, / Uprightness, heed to injure nought which lives, / Truthfulness, slowness unto wrath, a mind / That lightly letteth go what others prize …" (Bhagavad Gita 16:1–3, Arnold)

  • Krishna calls this list the divine endowment (daivi sampad): "The Heavenly Birth brings to deliverance" (16:5, Arnold).

Q1 Which phrases name the three virtues of this mission?

Show answer

"heed to injure nought which lives": non-violence; "governed appetites": self-restraint; "a mind that lightly letteth go what others prize": detachment.

Q2 Which phrase also links to non-violence, through control of anger?

Show answer

"slowness unto wrath".

Quick check
?Which description best fits detachment (vairagya) as the Bhagavad Gita teaches it?
Mission 1

The three gunas

Three strandssattvarajastamaslight, calm,knowledgepassion,energy, desiredarkness,inertia,delusionprakriti (nature, body, mind)atmanbeyond the gunas
  • Prakriti (matter, nature, including mind) is woven from three gunas (strands, qualities). The idea comes from Samkhya philosophy.
  • Sattva: light, purity, calm, goodness, knowledge.
  • Rajas: passion, energy, desire, restlessness.
  • Tamas: darkness, inertia, dullness, delusion.
  • All three are present in everything and everyone; their balance shifts and shapes character.
  • They belong to prakriti, not to the atman, which is beyond them.

> "Sattwan, Rajas, and Tamas, so are named / The qualities of Nature, 'Soothfastness,' / 'Passion,' and 'Ignorance.' These three bind down / The changeless Spirit in the changeful flesh." (Bhagavad Gita 14:5, Arnold)

Mission 1

The virtues of each guna

The gunas sortedSattvaRajasTamasQualitiescalm,knowledge,contentment,truthfulnessgreed,ambition,restlessactivitysloth,confusion,carelessness,crueltyFood (Gita 17:8–10)fresh, mild,nourishingvery spicy,salty, sour,heatingstale, leftovernight,rottenAction (Gita 18:23–25)done as duty,withoutcraving theresultdone for gainor show, withgreat straindone indelusion,careless ofharm to others

The Gita sorts food, worship and action by guna (chapters 14, 17, 18):

SattvaRajasTamas
Qualitiescalm, knowledge, contentment, truthfulnessgreed, ambition, restless activitysloth, confusion, carelessness, cruelty
Food (17:8–10)fresh, mild, nourishingvery spicy, salty, sour, heatingstale, left overnight, rotten
Action (18:23–25)done as duty, without craving the resultdone for gain or show, with great straindone in delusion, careless of harm to others
  • So the three virtues are sattvic: they grow as sattva grows.
  • Many Hindus choose a sattvic diet (often vegetarian, no onion or garlic for some) to support a calm mind.
Quick check
?Which statement about the gunas is accurate in the Bhagavad Gita and Samkhya?
Mission 1Read the source

As you act, so you become

Brihadaranyaka Upanishad IV.4.5–6 (paraphrase):

  • As a person acts and behaves, so they become: good action makes one good; bad action makes one bad.
  • A person is made of desire: as the desire, so the will; as the will, so the deed; as the deed, so the result they reap.
  • One who still desires is bound to return to the world of action.
  • One who is free from desire, whose only desire is the Self, does not return: being Brahman, they go to Brahman.

Q1 Why does this passage make detachment central to liberation?

Show answer

Desire drives will and deed, and so rebirth; only one free of desire is liberated.

Q2 What link does it make between virtue and karma?

Show answer

Character is built by actions: what we repeatedly do, we become.

Mission 1

Virtues, varna, ashrama and the aims of life

  • The Purusha Sukta (Rig Veda 10.90) describes the four varnas coming from the cosmic person's mouth, arms, thighs and feet.
  • The Gita links varna to the gunas: duties are "fixed by reason of the Qualities / Planted in each" (18:41, Arnold). A Brahmin's virtues are "serenity, / Self-mastery, religion, purity" (18:42).
  • Ashramas train the virtues in turn: student (self-restraint, celibacy) → householder (non-violence, generosity, wealth and pleasure within dharma) → forest-dweller (loosening ties) → sannyasi (complete detachment).
  • With the purusharthas: virtues keep artha (wealth) and kama (pleasure) within dharma, and prepare for moksha.
  • Many modern Hindus read guna-based varna as character, not birth; critics note it was used to justify birth-based caste.
Mission 1Evaluate

Is virtue the way to liberation?

Is virtue the way to liberation?Living virtuously is enough to achievemoksha.ForVirtue purifies the mind; the "divineendowment" leads to deliverance (Gita16:5).Brihadaranyaka IV.4.6: the one free ofdesire is not reborn.AgainstEven sattva binds, by attachment tohappiness and knowledge (Gita 14:6). Theliberated person is gunatita, beyond allthree gunas (14:22–25).Advaita Vedanta: only knowledge ofatman as Brahman liberates; virtue onlyprepares. Many bhakti traditions: liberationcomes by God's grace, not merit.Judge it byWhat does each school mean by moksha? · Isvirtue a cause of liberation or a sign of it? ·Can a person be detached while still doingworldly duty?
  • Claim: Living virtuously is enough to achieve moksha.
  • For: Virtue purifies the mind; the "divine endowment" leads to deliverance (Gita 16:5).
  • For: Brihadaranyaka IV.4.6: the one free of desire is not reborn.
  • Against: Even sattva binds, by attachment to happiness and knowledge (Gita 14:6). The liberated person is gunatita, beyond all three gunas (14:22–25).
  • Against: Advaita Vedanta (the non-dualist school of Shankara): only knowledge of atman as Brahman liberates; virtue only prepares. Many bhakti (devotional) traditions: liberation comes by God's grace, not merit.
  • Judgement criteria: What does each school mean by moksha? Is virtue a cause of liberation or a sign of it? Can a person be detached while still doing worldly duty?
Mission check

?Anjali, a Hindu doctor, works long hospital shifts. She does not seek praise or promotion, eats simple vegetarian food, and offers each day's work to God. A colleague says she is "beyond the gunas already". In the Gita's terms, which reply is most accurate?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?

Make a guess: Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?

Mission 2

What ahimsa asks

  • Ahimsa: non-violence, non-harming (a- "not" + himsa "harm").
  • It covers thought, word and deed: hatred and cruel speech are himsa too.
  • It also covers harm you cause or approve through others.
  • Why: the same atman is in every living being.

> "… sees the Life-Soul resident / In all things living, and all living things / In that Life-Soul contained." (Bhagavad Gita 6:29, Arnold)

  • Karma: harm returns as suffering, in this life or the next.
  • Positive side: compassion and respect for all life.
Mission 2

Ahimsa in Hindu tradition

  • Chandogya Upanishad 3.17.4: non-violence is listed with austerity, generosity, uprightness and truthfulness as the "gifts" of a life lived as sacrifice (paraphrase).
  • Mahabharata (Anushasana Parva): ahimsa is called the highest dharma (ahimsa paramo dharmah).
  • Yoga Sutras 2.30–2.35: ahimsa is the first yama (restraint); where it is firmly established, hostility ceases (paraphrase).
  • Manusmrti 10.63: ahimsa is among the duties common to all four varnas (paraphrase).
  • But Hindu ahimsa is usually weighed against other duties: sacrifice in the Vedic period, the warrior's duty, self-defence. It means minimising harm rather than an absolute vow.
  • By contrast, Jains (an Indian tradition with ahimsa at its heart) take it further: monks and nuns vow ahimsa absolutely, some sweeping their path to protect tiny beings; Jains hold that harm binds karma to the soul.
Quick check
?Which statement best shows how Hindu ahimsa differs from Jain ahimsa?
Mission 2

Animals

Circles of carehumanscows and animalsinsectsplantsthoughtworddeedatman in all living beings
  • Animals have atman and are part of samsara: a human may be reborn as an animal, and an animal as a human.
  • The cow is honoured as a mother (gau mata): she gives milk, and Krishna was a cowherd. Most Hindus do not eat beef; many states in India restrict cow slaughter.
  • Vegetarianism is widespread and seen as sattvic, but varies: many Bengali and coastal Hindus eat fish; some communities eat meat; some Shakta temples still offer animal sacrifice.
  • Many Hindus support gaushalas (cow shelters) and avoid leather, silk or products tested on animals; others accept animal testing for human medicine as a lesser harm.
Mission 2Evaluate

Can a person live by ahimsa today?

Can a person live by ahimsa today?Ahimsa, meaning never harming any livingbeing, is a realistic standard in the modernworld.ForMillions of Jains and Hindus live as strictvegetarians; ahimsa shapes diet, work andmedicine.Ahimsa is about intention and minimisingharm, which anyone can practise.AgainstHarm is built into life: farming, transport,medicine. Even the Manusmrti, a Hindulaw text, admits that daily housework killssmall creatures (3.68).Modern supply chains hide harm; theManusmrti says the buyer of meat sharesin the killing (5.51).Judge it byIs ahimsa an absolute rule or an ideal toapproach? · Does intention or outcome mattermore? · Is Jain or Hindu ahimsa the standardbeing tested?
  • Claim: Ahimsa, meaning never harming any living being, is a realistic standard in the modern world.
  • For: Millions of Jains and Hindus live as strict vegetarians; ahimsa shapes diet, work and medicine.
  • For: Ahimsa is about intention and minimising harm, which anyone can practise.
  • Against: Harm is built into life: farming, transport, medicine. Even the Manusmrti, a Hindu law text, admits that daily housework kills small creatures (3.68).
  • Against: Modern supply chains hide harm; the Manusmrti says the buyer of meat shares in the killing (5.51).
  • Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa an absolute rule or an ideal to approach? Does intention or outcome matter more? Is Jain or Hindu ahimsa the standard being tested?
Mission check

?Meera, a Hindu, is choosing a silk sari for a wedding. Ordinary silk is made by boiling silkworms in their cocoons; "ahimsa silk" lets the moths emerge first. She says: "I'm not the one boiling them, so it isn't my concern." Which reply applies Hindu teaching on ahimsa most accurately?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Make a guess: Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Mission 3

Ahimsa meets the warrior's duty

  • In the Bhagavad Gita, Arjuna, a kshatriya (warrior), refuses to fight his relatives at Kurukshetra.
  • Krishna answers: a warrior's svadharma (own duty) is to fight a righteous war (dharma yuddha); refusing would be sin.

> "Nought better can betide a martial soul / Than lawful war" (Bhagavad Gita 2:31, Arnold)

  • The atman cannot be killed (2:19–20), so the soldier destroys only bodies.
  • So in traditional Hindu ethics, ahimsa is the general rule, but force to protect dharma can be a duty for those whose role it is.
Mission 3Read the source

Two ways to read the battle

> "… if thou shunn'st / This honourable field--a Kshattriya-- / If, knowing thy duty and thy task, thou bidd'st / Duty and task go by--that shall be sin!" (Bhagavad Gita 2:33, Arnold)

  • Literal reading (e.g. Sri Aurobindo, 1872–1950, Essays on the Gita): the Gita really does teach that righteous war can be a duty.
  • Allegorical reading (Gandhi, Anasaktiyoga, 1929): Kurukshetra is the human heart; the battle is between good and evil impulses; the Gita teaches selfless action and so, in the end, non-violence.

Q1 What does Krishna say Arjuna's refusal would be?

Show answer

Sin: a failure in his duty as a kshatriya.

Q2 How can Gandhi accept this verse yet reject war?

Show answer

He reads the "field" and the "battle" as the inner struggle of the soul, not a call to physical fighting.

Quick check
?Why can Krishna urge Arjuna to fight without abandoning ahimsa, on the traditional reading of the Gita?
Mission 3

Gandhi's ahimsa

Gandhi's influencesInfluencesGujarati VaishnavahomeJain friends andteachers (e.g.Raychandbhai)the Gita, read asallegoryTolstoythe Sermon on theMountGandhi's ahimsaactive love, notpassivitytruth the end,non-violence themeansthe courage of thestrongdiscipline: simpleliving, vegetarianism,fasting
  • Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi (1869–1948).
  • Influences: his Gujarati Vaishnava home, Jain friends and teachers (e.g. Raychandbhai), the Gita, Tolstoy and the Sermon on the Mount.
  • Ahimsa for Gandhi is active love, not passivity: refusing to hate, while resisting injustice.
  • It is the courage of the strong: he wrote (1920, paraphrase) that if the only choice were cowardice or violence, he would choose violence.
  • Linked with truth: he came to say that "Truth is God". Non-violence is the means; truth is the end.
  • Discipline: brahmacharya, simple living, vegetarianism, fasting.
Mission 3Evaluate

Is ahimsa a workable standard in the modern world?

Is ahimsa a workable standard?Ahimsa is a relevant and viable standard tolive by today.ForGandhi's non-violent resistance(satyagraha, "truth force") helped winIndian independence (1947) and shapedthe US civil rights movement.Modern weapons make war's harmuncontrollable; non-violence may be theonly rational path.AgainstNon-violence relies on the opponent'sconscience. Gandhi's 1938 advice thatJews in Germany resist non-violently wasstrongly criticised (e.g. by Martin Buber,1939).Independence came with the violence ofPartition; India itself keeps an army andnuclear weapons.Judge it byIs ahimsa a personal virtue or a state policy? ·Does it require results to be valid? · Doesdharma yuddha already make ahimsarealistic?
  • Claim: Ahimsa is a relevant and viable standard to live by today.
  • For: Gandhi's non-violent resistance (satyagraha, "truth force") helped win Indian independence (1947) and shaped the US civil rights movement.
  • For: Modern weapons make war's harm uncontrollable; non-violence may be the only rational path.
  • Against: Non-violence relies on the opponent's conscience. Gandhi's 1938 advice that Jews in Germany resist non-violently was strongly criticised (e.g. by Martin Buber, 1939).
  • Against: Independence came with the violence of Partition; India itself keeps an army and nuclear weapons.
  • Judgement criteria: Is ahimsa a personal virtue or a state policy? Does it require results to be valid? Does dharma yuddha already make ahimsa realistic?
Mission check

?A modern Hindu soldier serves in a United Nations peacekeeping force and says: "I keep ahimsa: I use force only to protect civilians, never in anger, and I'd prefer talks to fighting." Which reading of the Gita is he closest to?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • In Hindu teaching, non-violence, detachment and self-restraint are duties for all (sadharana dharma) that purify the mind.
  • In the Gita and Samkhya, the three gunas (sattva, rajas, tamas) make up nature; the virtues are sattvic, but liberation lies beyond all three.
  • Brihadaranyaka IV.4.5–6: as one desires and acts, so one becomes; freedom from desire frees from rebirth.

Mission 2

  • Ahimsa is non-harming in thought, word and deed, based on atman in all beings and on karma.

Mission 3

  • Traditional Hindu ethics weighs ahimsa against a warrior's duty: dharma yuddha allows just war under strict rules.
  • Gandhi read the Gita as an inner battle and made ahimsa a political force through satyagraha.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Hindu thought: Living in accordance with dharma for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why does the Bhagavad Gita say that even goodness can tie you down?
  2. Mission 2Is it possible to live without harming anything at all, even an insect or an embryo?
  3. Mission 3Krishna tells Arjuna to fight; Gandhi called the same book his guide to non-violence. How?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR