← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/03 Developments in Christian thought – Gender and theology
Mini-Lesson

Christian thought: Gender and theology

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?
  2. Mission 2Christians believe Jesus came to save all people. But Jesus was a man: can a male saviour save women?
  3. Mission 3Some feminists stayed in the Church to change it. Why did others decide they had to leave?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?

Make a guess: Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?

Mission 1

Human words for God

God as "Father": is like, is not likeGod as "Father"is like• care• authority• relationshipis not like• male body• human limits• failurestrue in one way, not in another
  • Anthropomorphic language: describing God in human terms (Father, King, Judge, "the hand of God").
  • Christians believe God is spirit (John 4:24) and beyond all creatures, so no human word fits God exactly.
  • Classical theology treats such words as analogy (Thomas Aquinas) or metaphor: true in one way, not in another.
  • Mainstream teaching: God has no sex. Catholic teaching: God "is neither man nor woman: he is God" (Catechism of the Catholic Church 239).
  • Yet Christian worship has used mostly male words: Father, King, Lord, "he".
  • The question: if the words are not literal, do they still shape how people see God, and men and women?
Mission 1

Daly: "if God is male, then the male is God"

Daly's chain"if God is male, then the male is God" (Daly,Beyond God the Father, ch. 1)God imaged as malethe male seen as god-likemale rule legitimated
  • Mary Daly (1928–2010), American feminist philosopher and theologian; Beyond God the Father (1973).
  • Her claim: "if God is male, then the male is God" (Beyond God the Father, ch. 1).
  • A male image of God, she argues, makes men seem god-like and legitimates patriarchy: male rule in Church, family and society.
  • The symbol of "God the Father" is not harmless picture-language: it shapes power.
  • The implications Daly draws (the "unholy trinity", spirituality through nature) and the comparison with Ruether.
Quick check
?What is the point of Daly's claim about the effects of a male God?
Mission check

?A hymn-writer writes "God our Mother". A critic replies: "That's wrong, because calling God Father shows that God is literally male." On what point do mainstream Christian teaching and feminist theologians agree, against the critic?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Christians believe Jesus came to save all people. But Jesus was a man: can a male saviour save women?

Make a guess: Christians believe Jesus came to save all people. But Jesus was a man: can a male saviour save women?

Mission 2

What is feminist theology?

Feminist theology: two pathspatriarchy?Reform from withinRuether, McFagueLeave:post-ChristianDaly, Hampsontwo answers to the same question
  • Patriarchy: a social system in which men hold power and male experience is treated as the norm.
  • Feminist theology asks how patriarchy has shaped Christian scripture, doctrine, worship and leadership, and what should follow.
  • Context: first-wave feminism (votes for women; Elizabeth Cady Stanton, The Woman's Bible, 1895–98); second-wave feminism of the 1960s–70s.
  • Key themes: women's experience as a source for theology; a hermeneutic of suspicion (reading texts alert to male bias: Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza, In Memory of Her, 1983); language for God (McFague).
  • Two paths: reform Christianity from within (Ruether, McFague) or leave it as beyond repair.
Mission 2

Rosemary Radford Ruether

Ruether's critical principleDoes it promote the fullhumanity of women?Not redemptivedenies ordiminishes itRedemptivepromotes itRuether, Sexism and God-Talk (1983), ch. 1(paraphrase)
  • Rosemary Radford Ruether (1936–2022), American Catholic theologian; Sexism and God-Talk (1983).
  • Her critical principle: whatever denies or diminishes "the full humanity of women" is not redemptive; whatever promotes it reflects the divine (paraphrase, ch. 1).
  • She is a reformist: she stays within Christianity and recovers its prophetic-liberating tradition, in which God sides with the oppressed.
  • Chapter 5 asks the question of this mission: "Can a Male Saviour Save Women?"
  • Your spec lists chapter 9 ("The New Earth") as its reading; the male-saviour question itself is in chapter 5.
Mission 2

The problem of a male Christ

How Christ's maleness was usedAristotle → Aquinas"woman is defective and misbegotten" (asan individual)but: woman is part of God's plan for humannature (ST I q.92 a.1 ad 1)Christ was maleused to argue: only men can represent Christas priests?What saves: Christ's humanity or hismaleness?
  • Over centuries, Christ's maleness was used to rank men above women.
  • Aquinas, following Aristotle, wrote that as an individual, "woman is defective and misbegotten" (Summa Theologica I q.92 a.1 ad 1), while insisting that woman is part of God's plan for human nature.
  • Christ's maleness has been used to argue that only men can represent Christ as priests.
  • An early Christian principle: what Christ did not take on, he did not heal (Gregory of Nazianzus, 4th century). If Christ's maleness is what saves, women seem left out.
  • Ruether: Christ's maleness has no ultimate significance; it matters only as a social symbol in patriarchal societies.
Mission 2

Jesus against the warrior-messiah

Two models of messiahExpectedwarrior-kingdefeat enemiesrule like DavidJesus as servanta servant (Mark10:43)with the poor,outcasts, womenRuether"kenosis of patriarchy": theself-emptying of male power
  • Many Jews of Jesus' time hoped for a Messiah like King David: a warrior who would defeat Israel's enemies and rule.
  • Ruether: Jesus rejected that model of power. He came as a servant, not a ruler:

> "whoever wants to become great amongst you shall be your servant." (Mark 10:43, WEBBE)

  • He sided with the marginalised: the poor, outcasts, women. Women followed him and were first witnesses of the resurrection (Luke 24:9–10).
  • So Jesus' life announces the "kenosis of patriarchy" (Ruether's phrase): the self-emptying of male power.
  • His maleness, read this way, is a critique of patriarchy, not a support for it.
Mission 2Read the source

Wisdom, a female figure

Wisdom textsProverbs 8Wisdom raises hervoice; with God atcreationWisdom 7"a reflection ofeverlasting light"hokmahHebrew · femininesophiaGreek · feminine1 Corinthians 1:24Christ "the wisdomof God"John's Logosthe Word took overher roleRuether: Wisdom is a female principle in God.

> "Doesn't wisdom cry out? Doesn't understanding raise her voice?" (Proverbs 8:1, WEBBE)

> "For she is a reflection of everlasting light, an unspotted mirror of the working of God, and an image of his goodness." (Wisdom 7:26, WEBBE)

  • In Hebrew, wisdom is hokmah; in Greek, sophia. Both are feminine, and the texts personify Wisdom as a woman who is with God at creation (Proverbs 8:22–31).
  • Ruether: Wisdom is a female principle in God; early Christians called Christ "the wisdom of God" (1 Corinthians 1:24). John's Logos (Word) took over her role.

Q1 What role does Wisdom have in God's work?

Show answer

She reflects God's light and goodness; she is present at creation.

Q2 Why does this matter for the male-saviour question?

Show answer

If Jesus is the incarnation of a female Wisdom, Christ is not simply male.

Quick check
?How does Ruether answer the question "Can a male saviour save women?"
Mission 2

The androgynous Christ and the Christlike female

Christ beyond the historical JesushistoricalJesus (male)Christ continued in thecommunity"in the form of our sister"Ruether's phrase
  • Androgynous Christ: Christ unites "masculine" and "feminine" qualities (e.g. Julian of Norwich, Revelations of Divine Love, c. 1395, calls Jesus "our Mother").
  • Ruether values the aim but warns that many androgynous pictures still treat the male as the norm and the "feminine" as a mere side of him.
  • Her own answer: Christ is not confined to the historical Jesus. The Christian community continues Christ's identity, so Christ can be met "in the form of our sister" (Ruether's phrase).
  • The Christlike female: Jesus came to the last and least. Women, among the most marginalised, can show the liberated humanity Christ brings in a fuller way than men who keep power: the last become first (Matthew 20:16).
Mission 2Diversity

Responses to Ruether

  • Catholic and Orthodox teaching: Christ saves all humans because he took on human nature; maleness is not what saves. But his maleness still matters as a sign, e.g. for priesthood.
  • Many evangelicals: Christ is defined by scripture and the creeds; the historical Jesus cannot be replaced by a community's Christ.
  • Other feminists: Elizabeth Johnson, She Who Is (1992), develops a fuller Sophia (Wisdom) Christology.
  • Daphne Hampson: Ruether picks only the parts she likes; a Christianity tied to a male past cannot be made feminist (see Mission 3).
Quick check
?What is a "hermeneutic of suspicion" in feminist theology?
Mission 2Evaluate

Can a male saviour save women?

Can a male saviour save women?A male saviour can save women.ForThe creeds stress Christ became human,not male; in Christ "neither male norfemale" (Galatians 3:28).Ruether: Jesus' life overturns patriarchalpower.AgainstChrist's maleness has been used forcenturies to exclude women; symbolsshape power (Daly).Hampson: one historical man makes themale normative for ever.Judge it byWhat saves: humanity or maleness? · Cantradition be reinterpreted this far? · Effects ofthe symbols on real women?
  • Claim: A male saviour can save women.
  • For: The creeds stress that Christ became human (incarnation), not male; Galatians 3:28: in Christ "neither male nor female".
  • For: Ruether: Jesus' life overturns patriarchal power.
  • For: Ruether: Christ as Wisdom is not only male.
  • Against: Christ's maleness has been used for centuries to exclude women; symbols shape power (Daly).
  • Against: Hampson: the uniqueness of one historical man makes the male normative for ever.
  • Judgement criteria: What saves: Christ's humanity or his maleness? Can tradition be reinterpreted this far? What effects do the symbols have on real women?
  • Spec issues: "whether or not a male saviour can save women"; "whether or not Christianity is essentially sexist".
Mission check

?A Christian group rewrites some of its prayers to call God "Wisdom" and "she" alongside "Father". Its members say they are reclaiming forgotten parts of the Bible and want to change the Church, not leave it. Which approach is this closest to?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Some feminists stayed in the Church to change it. Why did others decide they had to leave?

Make a guess: Some feminists stayed in the Church to change it. Why did others decide they had to leave?

Mission 3

Reform or leave?

Stain or structure?Patriarchy is…a stain on the wallclean it and stayReformists: Ruether,McFague, Johnsona crack in thefoundationsleavePost-Christians: Daly,Hampson
  • All feminist theologians agree that Christianity has been shaped by patriarchy.
  • Reformists (Ruether, McFague, Johnson): the core of Christianity is liberating; remove the sexism and stay.
  • Post-Christian feminists (Daly, Hampson): the sexism is built in; Christianity cannot be repaired, so they left.
  • Post-Christian does not mean atheist: both kept a spirituality; Hampson still believes in God.
  • The question: is patriarchy a stain on Christianity, or part of its structure?
Mission 3

Mary Daly

Two journeys out of ChristianityMary Daly (1928–2010)1968The Church and the Second Sex:reformist call for change1973Beyond God the Father:post-Christian1978Gyn/EcologyDaphne Hampson (b. 1944)onceactive in the campaign forwomen priests1990Theology and Feminism1996After Christianity: post-Christiantheist
  • Mary Daly (1928–2010), American Catholic philosopher and theologian; taught at Boston College (a Jesuit university).
  • The Church and the Second Sex (1968): a reformist call for change.
  • Beyond God the Father (1973): now post-Christian: "if God is male, then the male is God" (see Mission 1).
  • The male symbol of God sanctions male rule in church, family and society.
  • God is not a noun but a verb: "Be-ing", the power of becoming in which women share.
  • Later: Gyn/Ecology (1978) and Pure Lust (1984).
Mission 3

The "unholy trinity"

Daly: the "unholy trinity"rapegenocidewarphallic moralitycentre:Daly, Beyond God the Father, ch. 4Compare (separate)Daly sets it against the Christian Trinity, oftenimagined as male: in her view, a sacred imageof male power.
  • Beyond God the Father, ch. 4: patriarchy produces a "phallic morality" of domination.
  • Its fruits Daly calls an unholy trinity: rape, genocide and war.
  • She sets it against the Christian Trinity: Father, Son and a Spirit often imagined as male, a sacred image of male power.
  • Her argument (paraphrase): a religion whose highest symbols are male trains societies to accept male violence and to blame women (the scapegoating of Eve).
  • So the problem is not a few sexist verses: it runs through the symbols themselves.
Mission 3

Spirituality through nature

Daly: the "cosmic covenant"cosmiccovenantwomencommunitynatureBe-ingDaly: patriarchy dominates women and naturetogether; liberating both belongs together.Beyond God the Father, ch. 6; Gyn/Ecology(paraphrase)
  • Daly calls women to leave patriarchal religion and find a spirituality of "Be-ing".
  • Beyond God the Father, ch. 6: sisterhood as a "cosmic covenant": harmony with all life and the natural world.
  • Gyn/Ecology: patriarchy's domination of women and its domination of nature are linked; liberation of both belongs together (a root of ecofeminism).
  • Spirituality is found in women's experience, community and nature, not in church, creed or male priesthood.
  • Spec issue: "whether or not only women can develop a genuine spirituality".
Quick check
?In Daly's argument, what does the "unholy trinity" name?
Mission 3

Daphne Hampson

Two journeys out of ChristianityMary Daly (1928–2010)1968The Church and the Second Sex:reformist call for change1973Beyond God the Father:post-Christian1978Gyn/EcologyDaphne Hampson (b. 1944)onceactive in the campaign forwomen priests1990Theology and Feminism1996After Christianity: post-Christiantheist
  • Daphne Hampson (b. 1944), British theologian (St Andrews); Theology and Feminism (1990); After Christianity (1996). Once active in the campaign for women priests.
  • Christianity is "irredeemably sexist" because it is a historical religion: it claims a unique revelation of God in a particular past.
  • That past was patriarchal: a male Jesus, God as Father and Son, male apostles. Christians must always look back to it, so the bias can never be removed.
  • Not moral: feminism needs full equality now. Not true: after the Enlightenment, she argues, a unique divine act in one time and place is not credible.
  • She is a post-Christian theist: she believes in God, known through human experience, but not in Christ's uniqueness.
Mission 3Read the source

"Neither male nor female"

> "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free man, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus." (Galatians 3:28, WEBBE)

  • Reformists (Ruether): this is the liberating core of the Gospel; later sexism betrays it.
  • Hampson: one verse, written by a man in a patriarchal world, cannot outweigh the structure of a religion centred on a male saviour and a Father God.

Q1 How would Ruether use this verse?

Show answer

As evidence that equality is part of Christianity's original message.

Q2 Why does Hampson think it is not enough?

Show answer

Christianity remains tied to a male past; the problem is structural, not a matter of verses.

Quick check
?Why does Hampson describe Christianity as irredeemably sexist?
Mission 3Diversity

Ruether, Daly and Hampson compared

Ruether, Daly and Hampson comparedRuetherDalyHampsonPatriarchal?yes, deeplyyes, deeplyyes, deeplyReformable?yes, from itsprophetic corenonoJesusempties malepowerChrist-worshipsanctifiesmalenesshis uniquenessmakes themalenormativeGodGod/ess, theprimal MatrixGod as Verb:Be-ingknown inexperience,beyond anytraditionWhere they gostays:Catholic;Women-Churchleavesleaves
  • Is Christianity patriarchal? All three: yes, deeply.
  • Can it be reformed? Ruether: yes, from its prophetic core. Daly and Hampson: no.
  • What about Jesus? Ruether: he empties male power. Daly: Christ-worship sanctifies maleness. Hampson: his uniqueness makes the male normative.
  • God? Ruether: God/ess, the primal Matrix (her terms). Daly: God as Verb, Be-ing. Hampson: God known in experience, beyond any tradition.
  • Where do they go? Ruether stays in the Catholic Church and helps shape the Women-Church movement. Daly and Hampson leave.
  • Your spec: compare Ruether's and Daly's feminist theologies.
Mission 3Evaluate

Can Christianity be changed, or should it be abandoned?

Can Christianity be changed, or should it be abandoned?Christianity is essentially sexist and shouldbe abandoned.ForHampson: a historical religion is tied to apatriarchal past; Daly: Christ-worshipsanctifies maleness.Centuries of reform have left manychurches still male-led.AgainstRuether: the prophetic tradition and Jesus'practice critique patriarchy; Galatians 3:28.Real change has happened: women priestsand bishops; inclusive language; femaleimages of God.Traditional Christians: God has no sex;equal dignity with different roles is notsexism.Judge it byStructure or distortion? · Defined by origins orby development? · Does reform answerHampson's point about the past?
  • Claim: Christianity is essentially sexist and should be abandoned.
  • For: Hampson: a historical religion is tied to a patriarchal past; Daly: Christ-worship sanctifies maleness.
  • For: Centuries of reform have left many churches still male-led.
  • Against: Ruether: the prophetic tradition and Jesus' practice contain the critique of patriarchy; Galatians 3:28.
  • Against: Real change has happened: women priests and bishops; inclusive language; female images of God (see Mission 1).
  • Against (traditional Christians): God has no sex; equal dignity with different roles is not sexism.
  • Judgement criteria: Is sexism the structure or a distortion? Is a religion defined by its origins or by how it develops? Does reform answer Hampson's point about the past?
  • Spec issues: "whether Christianity can be changed or should be abandoned"; "whether or not Christianity is essentially sexist".
Mission 3

Impact on believers and communities

  • Language: inclusive-language Bibles, hymns and liturgies (e.g. "humankind" for "mankind").
  • Ministry: feminist theology fed the case for ordaining women.
  • Communities: Women-Church groups and women's liturgies; feminist biblical scholarship taught in many seminaries.
  • Limits: the Catholic and Orthodox Churches keep an all-male priesthood; many Christians reject feminist theology as shaped by secular ideology.
Mission check

?Priya leaves her church after many years. She still prays and believes in God, but says: "No religion that looks back to one man, in one patriarchal age, as God's unique revelation can ever treat women as equals." Whose position is closest to Priya's?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Words like Father and King are anthropomorphic: analogies or metaphors. Mainstream Christian teaching holds that God has no sex.
  • Daly (Beyond God the Father, 1973): "if God is male, then the male is God".

Mission 2

  • Feminist theology examines patriarchy in Christianity; reformists stay to change it, post-Christians leave.
  • Ruether (Sexism and God-Talk, 1983): Jesus rejected the warrior-messiah; his maleness has no ultimate significance; Christ can be met in women.
  • Ruether: Christ is Wisdom (Sophia), a female figure in the Bible.

Mission 3

  • Daly: worshipping Christ sanctifies maleness, so she left Christianity.
  • Daly (Beyond God the Father, 1973): if God is male, the male is God; God as Be-ing.
  • Daly: patriarchy's unholy trinity of rape, genocide and war; spirituality in harmony with nature.
  • Hampson (Theology and Feminism, 1990): Christianity is irredeemably sexist because it is tied to a unique, patriarchal past; she remains a theist.
  • Ruether reforms from within; Daly and Hampson leave.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Christian thought: Gender and theology for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?
  2. Mission 2Christians believe Jesus came to save all people. But Jesus was a man: can a male saviour save women?
  3. Mission 3Some feminists stayed in the Church to change it. Why did others decide they had to leave?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR