← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/06 Developments in Buddhist thought – Meditation
Mini-Lesson

Buddhist thought: Meditation

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Can sitting still and calming the mind be a step towards awakening, or only a pleasant rest?
  2. Mission 2Can watching your own breath and itches show you the truth about who you are?
  3. Mission 3Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Can sitting still and calming the mind be a step towards awakening, or only a pleasant rest?

Make a guess: Can sitting still and calming the mind be a step towards awakening, or only a pleasant rest?

Mission 1

Meditation on the path

Three trainings12345678123456781right view2right intention3right speech4right action5right livelihood6right effort7right mindfulness8right concentration12345678panna(wisdom)sila(ethics)samadhi(meditation)sila (ethics)samadhi (calm)panna (wisdom)steadies the mindseesclearlydeepensethics
  • Pali bhavana: "cultivation" or "bringing into being". Meditation is mind-training, not just sitting.
  • The Eightfold Path falls into three trainings: sila (ethics), samadhi (meditation, concentration), panna (wisdom).
  • The samadhi group: right effort, right mindfulness, right concentration (the 6th, 7th and 8th factors).
  • The trainings support each other: ethics steadies the mind; a steady mind sees clearly; clear seeing deepens ethics.
Mission 1

Two kinds of meditation

Calm and insightSamatha(calm)mind developedpassion abandonedVipassana(insight)discernmentdevelopedignoranceabandonedreleaseAN 2.30 (paraphrase)
  • Samatha: calm, tranquillity. The mind settles on one object and becomes still.
  • Vipassana: insight, clear seeing. The mind looks into how things really are (see Mission 2).
  • An early text pairs them (AN 2.30, paraphrase): calm develops the mind and lets go of passion; insight develops discernment and lets go of ignorance.
  • So they complement each other: calm gives the stability insight needs; insight gives calm its point.
  • Many Theravada teachers, following Buddhaghosa: calm suppresses the defilements for a while; insight uproots them.
  • Jhana (Sanskrit dhyana): a state of deep absorption reached through samatha.
Mission 1

How samatha is practised

  • Choose one object: the breath (anapanasati, mindfulness of breathing), a coloured disc (kasina), a recollection of the Buddha, or loving kindness.
  • Sit upright and still; return the mind each time it wanders.
  • Counting breaths (e.g. one to ten) is a common start.
  • Five hindrances block calm: sensual desire, ill will, sloth and torpor, restlessness and worry, doubt.
  • As they fade, a steady mental image or sign (nimitta) may arise and absorption becomes possible.
Quick check
?Which three factors of the Eightfold Path make up the meditation (samadhi) training?
Mission 1

The jhanas

Jhana stepsfour formless states1st jhanathought (applied, sustained),rapture (piti), happiness (sukha),one-pointedness2nd jhanathought falls awayrapture, happiness,one-pointedness3rd jhanarapture fadeshappiness, equanimity,one-pointedness4th jhanabeyond pleasure and painequanimity, mindfulness,one-pointednessRight concentration = four jhanas (SN 45.8)
  • Jhana (Sanskrit dhyana): a state of deep absorption reached through samatha.
  • 1st jhana: applied and sustained thought, rapture (piti), happiness (sukha), one-pointedness.
  • 2nd: thought falls away; rapture and happiness remain, with inner confidence.
  • 3rd: rapture fades; happiness and mindful equanimity remain.
  • 4th: beyond pleasure and pain; pure equanimity and mindfulness.
  • Beyond these lie four formless states (e.g. infinite space; nothingness).
  • Right concentration (the 8th factor) is defined in the suttas as the four jhanas (SN 45.8).
Mission 1Read the source

Taming the mind

"As a fletcher makes straight his arrow, a wise man makes straight his trembling and unsteady thought, which is difficult to guard, difficult to hold back." (Dhammapada 33, Müller)

"It is good to tame the mind, which is difficult to hold in and flighty, rushing wherever it listeth; a tamed mind brings happiness." (Dhammapada 35, Müller)

  • ("listeth" = wishes)

Q1 What does the image of the arrow-maker suggest meditation does?

Show answer

It straightens and steadies the mind, as skilled work shapes an arrow.

Q2 What result does verse 35 promise?

Show answer

Happiness: a tamed mind brings happiness.

Mission 1

Metta bhavana: loving kindness

Metta circles1 self2 dear person3 neutral person4 hostile person5 all beingsBuddhaghosa, Visuddhimagga IXstart with self, then dear, neutral, hostile(rings 1–4)Common modern formfive stages, ending with all beings (e.g.Triratna: self, good friend, neutral, difficult, allbeings)
  • Metta: loving kindness, a warm wish for the welfare of beings. Bhavana: cultivation.
  • Metta is one of the four brahmaviharas ("divine abodes"): loving kindness, compassion (karuna), sympathetic joy (mudita), equanimity (upekkha).
  • The Karaniya Metta Sutta (Sutta Nipata 1.8, paraphrase): as a mother protects her only child with her life, cultivate a boundless heart towards all beings.
  • Method (Buddhaghosa, Visuddhimagga IX): begin with oneself, then a dear person, a neutral person, a hostile person, and break down the barriers between them.
  • Many Western groups (e.g. Triratna) teach five stages: self, good friend, neutral, difficult, all beings.
  • Metta is a samatha practice that can lead to jhana; it is also the antidote to ill will.
Quick check
?In Buddhaghosa's method of metta bhavana, why does the meditator begin by wishing themselves well?
Mission 1

Thanissaro Bhikkhu: calm and insight together

  • Thanissaro Bhikkhu (b. 1949), American monk of the Thai Forest Tradition; abbot of Metta Forest Monastery, California.
  • The Path of Concentration & Mindfulness (1997) and "One Tool Among Many" (1997), paraphrased:
  • In the suttas, samatha and vipassana are qualities developed together, not two separate techniques.
  • Right mindfulness leads into right concentration: the jhanas are part of the path, not a detour.
  • He criticises teaching insight methods that skip jhana.
  • Compare Gethin, The Foundations of Buddhism (1998), ch. 7: he also presents calm and insight as working in combination.
Mission 1Diversity

Personalised practice

Temperament tableExamples, not the full fortyVisuddhimagga IIITemperamentSuitable subjectgreedythe body'sunattractivenesshatingthe four brahmaviharas(e.g. metta)deluded orspeculativemindfulness of breathingfaithfulrecollection of the Buddha,Dhamma and Sangha
  • Buddhaghosa lists forty meditation subjects and matches them to temperaments (Visuddhimagga III):
  • Greedy temperament: reflection on the body's unattractiveness.
  • Hating temperament: the four brahmaviharas (e.g. metta).
  • Deluded or speculative temperament: mindfulness of breathing.
  • Faithful temperament: recollection of the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha.
  • Traditionally a teacher (kalyanamitta, "good friend") chooses the subject for the student.
  • So practice is personalised: no single method suits everyone.
  • Traditions differ: Theravada stresses breath and the brahmaviharas; Tibetan schools add visualisation; Zen stresses sitting itself (see Mission 2).
Mission 1Evaluate

"Calm is only a preparation; insight is what frees the mind."

Argument map"Calm is only a preparation; insight is whatfrees the mind."ForMN 26: the Buddha learned formlessstates from Alara Kalama and UddakaRamaputta, then left them: calm alone didnot end sufferingAN 2.30: only insight removes ignorance,the root of samsaraMany Theravada commentators: calm onlysuppresses defilements; insight uprootsthemAgainstMN 36: the Buddha awakened from thefourth jhana and recalled childhood jhanaas "the path"SN 45.8: right concentration is the fourjhanas: an essential factor, not an extraThanissaro Bhikkhu: calm and insightdevelop together; metta also shapes moralcharacterJudge it byWhat do the earliest texts say? · Can insightbe stable without calm? · Is ethics changed bycalm as well as by insight?
  • For: the Buddha learned deep formless states from his teachers Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta, then left them: calm alone did not end suffering (MN 26).
  • For: AN 2.30: only insight removes ignorance, the root of samsara.
  • For: many Theravada commentators say calm only suppresses defilements; insight uproots them.
  • Against: the Buddha awakened from the fourth jhana (the deepest of four absorptions, beyond pleasure and pain) and recalled childhood jhana as "the path" (MN 36).
  • Against: right concentration is the four jhanas: an essential factor, not an extra (SN 45.8).
  • Against: the American monk Thanissaro Bhikkhu argues that calm and insight develop together; metta also shapes moral character.
  • Judgement criteria: What do the earliest texts say? Can insight be stable without calm? Is ethics changed by calm as well as by insight?
Quick check
?Which quality is still present in the fourth jhana?
Mission check

?Priya has practised breath meditation for years. She can reach deep, joyful stillness, but her old irritation with her sister comes back as soon as she gets up. Most Theravada teachers, following Buddhaghosa, would explain this how?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Can watching your own breath and itches show you the truth about who you are?

Make a guess: Can watching your own breath and itches show you the truth about who you are?

Mission 2

Vipassana: clear seeing

Three marks lensexperiencebreathaniccachangingdukkhaunsatisfyinganattanot-selfcraving weakens, ignorance ends:towards Nirvana
  • Vipassana (Pali; Sanskrit vipashyana): insight, "seeing clearly".
  • The meditator watches experience closely: breath, sensations, feelings, thoughts.
  • Aim: to see directly the three marks of existence:
  • Anicca: everything changes; nothing stays.
  • Dukkha: nothing conditioned can fully satisfy.
  • Anatta: no fixed, lasting self is found anywhere.
  • Seeing this weakens craving and ends ignorance: insight leads towards Nirvana (nibbana).
  • Samatha steadies the mind; vipassana uses that steadiness to see (see Mission 1).
Mission 2Read the source

Foundations of mindfulness

Four foundations1 Bodybreathing, posturearising …passing away+−02 Feelingspleasant, unpleasant,neutralarising …passing away3 Minde.g. with or withoutangerarising …passing away4 Dhammashindrances, FourNoble Truthsarising …passing away

The Satipatthana Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 10; also Digha Nikaya 22), paraphrase: a meditator is mindful of four things, seeing each arise and pass away:

  • Body (breathing, posture, parts of the body).
  • Feelings (pleasant, unpleasant, neutral).
  • Mind (e.g. a mind with or without anger).
  • Dhammas (mental qualities and teachings: the hindrances, the Four Noble Truths).

"'All created things perish,' he who knows and sees this becomes passive in pain; this is the way to purity." (Dhammapada 277, Müller)

"Without knowledge there is no meditation, without meditation there is no knowledge: he who has knowledge and meditation is near unto Nirvana." (Dhammapada 372, Müller)

Q1 Which mark of existence does verse 277 ask the meditator to see?

Show answer

Anicca: all created things perish.

Q2 What does verse 372 say about meditation and wisdom?

Show answer

Each needs the other; together they bring one near Nirvana.

Mission 2

Right mindfulness

  • Sati: mindfulness; the word also carries the sense of remembering (keeping the Dhamma in mind).
  • Right mindfulness is the 7th factor of the Eightfold Path.
  • It runs through all practice:
  • In ethics: noticing anger before it becomes harsh speech; remembering the precepts.
  • In samatha: noticing when the mind wanders and bringing it back.
  • In vipassana: watching things arise and pass.
  • In daily life: walking meditation, eating, working with full attention.
  • "Right" matters: mindfulness joined to wisdom and good intention, not attention for any purpose (see Mission 3).
Quick check
?What is the main aim of vipassana meditation in Buddhism?
Mission 2

Ways of practising insight

  • Mahasi Sayadaw (1904–1982), Burma: mentally noting each experience ("rising", "falling" of the abdomen; "hearing", "thinking").
  • S. N. Goenka (1924–2013), in the tradition of Sayagyi U Ba Khin (1899–1971): ten-day silent courses; three days of breath awareness, then scanning bodily sensations with equanimity; metta on the last day.
  • The commentaries describe two routes: the vehicle of calm (jhana first, then insight) and the vehicle of pure insight (insight with only "momentary" concentration, without first reaching jhana). Teachers debate which is closer to the suttas.
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944), "Two Styles of Insight Meditation" (2005), paraphrase: the same technique can be practised in two ways:
  • As a naturalistic discipline: it brings calm, equanimity and some insight, but stays within conditioned existence.
  • Within faith and right view (the Four Noble Truths, kamma and rebirth): only then, he argues, does insight aim at final release, Nibbana.
Mission 2

Zazen: just sitting

Three ways of sittingSamathaVipassanaZazen(shikantaza)one chosenobject (e.g. thebreath)watches andinvestigatesexperienceno object, nogoal-seeking→ absorption(jhana)→ insight intothe threemarksSoto: justsitting; Rinzaiadds a koanDifferent practices, not a ranking
  • Zazen: Japanese, "seated meditation"; central to Zen.
  • Posture: lotus or half-lotus, back upright, eyes half-open, hands in an oval mudra.
  • Soto Zen (Dogen, 1200–1253): shikantaza, "just sitting": no object, no goal-seeking. Sitting itself expresses the Buddha nature already present.
  • Rinzai Zen: zazen often with a koan (a paradoxical question) to break through ordinary thinking towards satori or kensho (awakening, seeing one's nature).
  • Unlike samatha it has no chosen object; unlike vipassana it does not analyse experience into parts.
Quick check
?A practitioner sits facing a wall, upright, with no object to focus on and no state to reach, simply sitting with full awareness. Which practice is this?
Mission 2

Meditation in lived Buddhism

  • Purpose: Enlightenment (awakening); on the way, calm, kindness and wisdom grow.
  • For centuries, mainly monks, especially forest monks, meditated intensively.
  • Many lay Buddhists in Asia practise mainly through chanting (refuges, precepts, protective paritta), giving (dana) and study, and keeping precepts.
  • From c. 1900, Burmese teachers (e.g. Ledi Sayadaw, then Mahasi and U Ba Khin) taught insight meditation to lay people; today it is central for many lay and Western Buddhists.
Mission 2

Meditation as therapy

  • Since 1979, meditation drawn from vipassana and Zen has been taught in clinics without Buddhist belief.
  • Examples: MBSR (Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, Jon Kabat-Zinn); MBCT (Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy, for recurrent depression).
  • Buddhist responses vary:
  • Welcome: it relieves suffering; a skilful means that may lead some people to the Dhamma (e.g. Thich Nhat Hanh, the 14th Dalai Lama).
  • Caution: without ethics and wisdom it is not right mindfulness, and it may serve stress-relief only.
  • Fuller detail.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Meditation is the most important element of Buddhist practice."

Argument map"Meditation is the most important elementof Buddhist practice."ForThe Buddha awakened in meditation; onlyinsight removes ignoranceDhammapada 372: knowledge needsmeditation; together they bring one nearNirvanaMany modern lay and Western Buddhistsput meditation at the centre of practiceAgainstEthics (sila) is the first training; meditationbuilt on bad conduct goes wrongMany lay Buddhists practise mainlythrough giving, chanting and precepts;Pure Land Buddhists rely on Amida's vowThe trainings depend on each other;wisdom is the goal and meditation ameansJudge it byImportant for whom (monastic, lay,Theravada, Pure Land)? · Measured by thegoal or by daily life? · Can one training standwithout the others?
  • For: the Buddha awakened in meditation; only insight removes ignorance.
  • For: Dhammapada 372: knowledge needs meditation; together they bring one near Nirvana.
  • For: many modern lay and Western Buddhists put meditation at the centre of practice.
  • Against: ethics (sila) is the first training; meditation built on bad conduct goes wrong.
  • Against: many lay Buddhists practise mainly through giving, chanting and precepts; Pure Land Buddhists rely on Amida's vow.
  • Against: the trainings depend on each other, so none is "most" important; wisdom is the goal and meditation a means.
  • Judgement criteria: Important for whom (monastic, lay, Theravada, Pure Land)? Measured by the goal or by daily life? Can one training stand without the others?
Mission 2Evaluate

"Meditation makes people unhealthily inward-looking."

  • For: retreats withdraw people from family and society; attention is on one's own mind.
  • For: secular courses often aim at personal wellbeing rather than at others.
  • Against: metta and karuna are meditations that turn the heart outward to all beings.
  • Against: insight into anatta undermines selfishness itself.
  • Against: Engaged Buddhists such as Thich Nhat Hanh join mindfulness to social action; monastic meditators teach lay people.
  • Judgement criteria: Is the inward turn a stage or a destination? What does the meditator do afterwards? Which kind of meditation is meant?
Quick check
?In Bhikkhu Bodhi's "Two Styles of Insight Meditation", what separates the two styles?
Mission check

?On day six of a ten-day silent course, Tom feels an itch. He does not scratch. He watches it grow, change and fade, and notices that it is not "his" in any lasting way. What practice is he doing, and with what Buddhist aim?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?

Make a guess: Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?

Mission 3

From sati to "mindfulness"

TimelineancientSati (mindfulness): 7th factor ofthe Eightfold Path1975Thich Nhat Hanh, The Miracleof Mindfulness1979Kabat-Zinn founds MBSR1987Mind and Life dialogues begin(Dalai Lama and scientists)2002MBCT (Segal, Williams andTeasdale)
  • Sati (Pali): mindfulness, the 7th factor of the Eightfold Path (see Mission 2).
  • 1979: Jon Kabat-Zinn (b. 1944), who had trained with Zen and insight teachers, founded MBSR (Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction) at the University of Massachusetts Medical School.
  • He taught it without Buddhist words, so that anyone could use it.
  • His working definition (paraphrase): paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, without judging.
  • 2002: MBCT (Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy), by Segal, Williams and Teasdale, joined mindfulness with cognitive therapy for recurrent depression.
  • The Mindfulness Movement: the spread of these secular forms into health, education and business.
Mission 3

Mindfulness in health care

  • Pain management: MBSR began with patients in chronic pain; the aim is to relate differently to pain, not to remove it.
  • Stress and anxiety: eight-week courses teaching body scan, breathing practice and mindful movement.
  • Depression: NICE (England) recommends MBCT to help prevent relapse in people with recurrent depression.
  • Cancer care: programmes such as Mindfulness-Based Cancer Recovery support patients through treatment.
  • Addiction: Mindfulness-Based Relapse Prevention teaches people to notice cravings without acting on them.
  • So meditation is used in secular, therapeutic contexts: no belief required.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how MBSR and MBCT relate to Buddhism?
Mission 3

What is left out?

What is kept, what is leftKept in most secularcoursesUsually left outbreathing practicerefugebody scanthe preceptsmindful movementkarma and rebirthkindness practicesanattathe goal of NirvanaSome teachers keep ethics in through kindnesspractices
  • In Buddhism, mindfulness is right mindfulness: one factor of eight, joined to right view, right intention and ethics.
  • The suttas also speak of wrong mindfulness (MN 117): attention without the rest of the path.
  • Often left out of secular courses: refuge, the precepts, karma and rebirth, anatta, the goal of Nirvana.
  • Critics' example: a sniper or a fraudster can be very attentive. Is that mindfulness?
  • "McMindfulness": a critical term popularised by Ron Purser and David Loy (2013; Purser's book, 2019) for mindfulness sold as a product for self-improvement.
  • Replies: many teachers keep ethics in through kindness practices; and secular courses never claimed to be Buddhism.
Mission 3Diversity

Buddhist responses

Buddhist responsesWelcomeThich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022)any reduction of suffering is good14th Dalai LamaMind and Life dialogues with scientists (from1987)Skilful meansKabat-Zinnthe Dharma in a universal formCautionBhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944)cut off from ethics, it can support consumercapitalismPurser and Loymay reduce stress yet leave greed untouchedGroups as the screen gives them, not a ranking
  • Welcome: Thich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022), The Miracle of Mindfulness (1975), taught mindfulness to everyone, including business and political leaders: any reduction of suffering is good.
  • Welcome: the 14th Dalai Lama has worked with scientists (Mind and Life dialogues, from 1987) to study meditation's effects.
  • Skilful means: Kabat-Zinn calls MBSR an expression of the Dharma in a universal form; some Buddhists agree it can be a doorway to deeper practice.
  • Caution: Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944) has warned that, cut off from its ethical setting, mindfulness can end up supporting consumer capitalism.
  • Caution: Purser and Loy: without right intention, it may reduce stress yet leave greed untouched.
Mission 3Evaluate

"The Mindfulness Movement is not really Buddhist."

Argument map"The Mindfulness Movement is not reallyBuddhist."ForIt drops refuge, precepts, rebirth andNirvana: a technique, not a pathIts aims (health, performance) differ fromawakening; MN 117 warns of wrongmindfulnessPurser and Loy: sold as a product forself-improvement, it may reduce stress yetleave greed untouchedAgainstThe practice comes from Buddhistteachers; Kabat-Zinn sees it as universalDharmaThich Nhat Hanh and the Dalai Lamawelcome it as a relief of suffering, theBuddha's own concernSecular Buddhists argue the Dharmanever needed metaphysicsJudge it byIs Buddhism defined by belief, practice orgoal? · Who decides what counts? · Can a partcarry the whole?
  • For: it drops refuge, precepts, rebirth and Nirvana; what remains is a technique, not a path.
  • For: its aims (health, performance) differ from awakening; MN 117 warns of wrong mindfulness.
  • For: Purser and Loy: sold as a product for self-improvement, it may reduce stress yet leave greed untouched.
  • Against: the practice comes from Buddhist teachers; Kabat-Zinn sees it as universal Dharma.
  • Against: Thich Nhat Hanh and the Dalai Lama welcome it as a relief of suffering, the Buddha's own concern.
  • Against: Secular Buddhists argue the Dharma never needed metaphysics.
  • Judgement criteria: Is Buddhism defined by belief, practice or goal? Who decides what counts? Can a part carry the whole?
  • Spec issue: "whether or not meditation has to be a religious practice".
Mission check

?A bank starts lunchtime mindfulness sessions so that staff can cope with longer working hours. Which pairing of person and response is accurate?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Meditation (bhavana) is the samadhi training of the Eightfold Path: right effort, right mindfulness, right concentration.
  • Samatha calms the mind (breath, kasinas, metta) and can lead to the jhanas; vipassana gives insight (see Mission 2).
  • Metta bhavana, personalised subjects and debate about how calm relates to insight show the variety of Buddhist practice.

Mission 2

  • Vipassana is insight into the three marks (anicca, dukkha, anatta); right mindfulness (sati) runs through all practice.
  • Styles differ: Mahasi noting, Goenka body-scanning, and Zen zazen (just sitting, or with koans).
  • Two vehicles (calm first or pure insight); Bodhi: the same technique practised naturalistically or within faith and right view.
  • Meditation is now used as therapy; Buddhists both welcome and question this (see Mission 3).

Mission 3

  • Since 1979, secular mindfulness (MBSR, MBCT) has spread into health care, schools and business, drawing on Buddhist meditation without Buddhist belief.
  • Buddhist responses range from welcome (Thich Nhat Hanh, the Dalai Lama) to caution (Bhikkhu Bodhi; "McMindfulness").
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Buddhist thought: Meditation for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Can sitting still and calming the mind be a step towards awakening, or only a pleasant rest?
  2. Mission 2Can watching your own breath and itches show you the truth about who you are?
  3. Mission 3Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR