← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/06 Developments in Buddhist thought – Four Noble Truths
Mini-Lesson

Buddhist thought: Four Noble Truths

3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why did the Buddha's first sermon sound like a doctor's diagnosis?
  2. Mission 2If the Buddhist goal is beyond words, how can anyone aim for it?
  3. Mission 3The Eightfold Path has eight parts. Is it a ladder you climb, or something else?

Also part of this unit: 1 mission in Buddhist thought: Samsara; The three marks of existence.

Mission 1

Mission 1: Why did the Buddha's first sermon sound like a doctor's diagnosis?

Make a guess: Why did the Buddha's first sermon sound like a doctor's diagnosis?

Mission 1

The first sermon

  • After his awakening, the Buddha walked to the Deer Park at Isipatana (Sarnath), near Varanasi (Benares), to his five former companions in asceticism.
  • The sermon is the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, "Setting the Wheel of the Dhamma in Motion" (Samyutta Nikaya 56.11).
  • It opens with the Middle Way: avoid both indulgence in sense pleasure and harsh self-torment.
  • Then it sets out the Four Noble Truths.
  • One listener, Kondanna, understood: whatever is subject to arising is subject to ceasing. He became the first disciple to "see the Dhamma".
  • Your spec: "the outline given in the Deer Park Sermon (as recorded in Samyutta Nikaya 56.11)".
Mission 1

Four truths, four tasks

The Four Noble Truthstruthtask1dukkhasufferingunderstand2samudayaorigin: cravingabandon3nirodhacessationrealise4maggapathdevelopwisdomview,intentionethicsspeech,action,livelihoodmeditationeffort,mindfulness,concentration12 aspects: 4 truths × 3 phases (know it ·know its task · know the task done)
  • In the sermon, the Buddha teaches:
  • Dukkha: there is suffering, unsatisfactoriness. Task: fully understand it.
  • Samudaya (origin): dukkha arises from craving (tanha). Task: abandon it.
  • Nirodha (cessation): dukkha ends when craving ends. Task: realise it.
  • Magga (path): the Noble Eightfold Path leads there. Task: develop it.
  • In the sutta the Buddha claims full awakening only after knowing each truth, its task, and that the task is done: twelve aspects in all.
  • They are "noble" (ariya) truths: truths as seen by the noble ones, who have realised them.
Mission 1

The doctor analogy

The doctor analogythe Buddha as a physicianillness=dukkhacause=tanhacure possible=nirodhatreatment=maggaVisuddhimagga XVI
  • A traditional comparison treats the Buddha as a physician:
  • Illness = dukkha · Cause = tanha · Cure is possible = nirodha · Prescription = magga.
  • Buddhaghosa uses it in the Visuddhimagga (XVI): the truths are like a disease, its cause, its cure and the medicine.
  • What it teaches: the Buddha diagnoses in order to heal; the first truth is not the last word.
  • Its limits: the patient must take the medicine personally. No one can be cured by someone else's practice.
Mission 1Read the source

The second and third truths

Samyutta Nikaya 56.11 (paraphrase):

  • Origin: it is craving that leads to renewed existence, bound up with delight and lust, seeking pleasure now here, now there: craving for sense pleasures, craving for existence, craving for non-existence.
  • Cessation: the complete fading away and ending of that same craving: giving it up, letting it go, being free of it.

Q1 Does the sutta say pleasure itself causes dukkha?

Show answer

No: craving, the thirst that chases pleasure "here and there", is the origin.

Q2 How is the third truth defined?

Show answer

As the ending of the very craving named in the second truth: the cure removes the cause.

Quick check
?In the medical metaphor, which noble truth matches the doctor's statement "This illness can be cured"?
Mission 1

Three kinds of craving

Three kinds of cravingkama-tanha"more of this"bhava-tanha"be this / lastfor ever"vibhava-tanha"get rid of this/ not be"pushing awayis craving tooimpermanentdukkha
  • Kama-tanha: craving for sense pleasures: food, comfort, sex, entertainment, possessions.
  • Bhava-tanha: craving for existence or becoming: to be someone, to be admired, to live on for ever.
  • Vibhava-tanha: craving for non-existence: to get rid of what we dislike, even to stop existing.
  • All three grasp at what is impermanent, so all three bring dukkha: the pleasure fades, the identity cracks, the escape never arrives.
  • Vibhava-tanha shows that pushing away is craving too, not freedom from it.
  • Your spec: "craving for material pleasures, craving for existence, craving for non-existence".
Mission 1

Tanha in the chain of causes

  • In dependent origination, tanha is link 8 of the twelve nidanas: conditioned by feeling, it conditions grasping.
  • So the second truth is a short form of the whole chain: craving is the most practical point to work on, while ignorance is its root.
  • Ending craving needs wisdom, not just willpower: craving thrives on not seeing anicca and anatta.
  • Your spec: "tanha as one of the 12 nidanas (causes)".
Quick check
?After a humiliating mistake, Jon says: "I just want to disappear and never face anyone again." Which form of craving would Buddhist teaching see here?
Mission 1

Nirodha and magga

The Four Noble Truthstruthtask1dukkhasufferingunderstand2samudayaorigin: cravingabandon3nirodhacessationrealise4maggapathdevelopwisdomview,intentionethicsspeech,action,livelihoodmeditationeffort,mindfulness,concentration12 aspects: 4 truths × 3 phases (know it ·know its task · know the task done)
  • Nirodha: the "cutting off" of craving through detachment: no longer gripping what changes. This is nibbana (see Mission 2).
  • Magga: the Noble Eightfold Path, in three trainings: wisdom (right view, right intention), ethics (right speech, action, livelihood), meditation (right effort, mindfulness, concentration). Full study.
  • Your spec: "nirodha as the 'cutting off' of craving through detachment".
Mission 1

Disciples and arhats

  • After the Buddha's second sermon (on not-self, Samyutta Nikaya 22.59), all five companions became arhats ("worthy ones"). The Vinaya says there were now six arhats in the world, the Buddha included.
  • Disciples who follow the teaching pass through four stages: stream-entry, once-return, non-return, arhat.
  • Arhat: has ended craving and ignorance, realised nibbana, and will not be reborn.
  • Buddha and arhat both realise nibbana; a Buddha discovers and teaches the path, an arhat follows it.
  • Your spec: "the path of disciples and arhats/arahants who follow the teachings".
Mission 1Evaluate

Is Buddhist detachment positive or negative?

Is Buddhist detachment positive or negative?The ideal of detachment is negative: itmakes people cold and withdrawn.ForMonastics leave family life; the goal is tostop "being attached" even to loved ones.If craving for existence is a fault, it mayseem that caring about life is too.AgainstDetachment means non-clinging, notindifference: one can love without trying toown or freeze what one loves.It is paired with metta (loving-kindness)and karuna (compassion); the Buddha andhis arhats taught for decades out ofcompassion.Judge it byWhat exactly is given up: people, or grasping?· How do detached Buddhists actually treatothers? · Is non-clinging possible for laypeople?
  • Claim: The ideal of detachment is negative: it makes people cold and withdrawn.
  • For: Monastics leave family life; the goal is to stop "being attached" even to loved ones.
  • For: If craving for existence is a fault, it may seem that caring about life is too.
  • Against: Detachment means non-clinging, not indifference: one can love without trying to own or freeze what one loves.
  • Against: It is paired with metta (loving-kindness) and karuna (compassion); the Buddha and his arhats taught for decades out of compassion.
  • Judgement criteria: What exactly is given up: people, or grasping? How do detached Buddhists actually treat others? Is non-clinging possible for lay people?
  • Your spec's issues also ask whether any truth is more important than the others: consider that each truth's task depends on the others.
Quick check
?Which task does the Buddha assign to the second noble truth?
Mission check

?A counsellor helps a client who keeps relapsing into gambling. She (1) names the harm honestly, (2) traces it to the client's urge, (3) shows that freedom is possible, (4) sets a daily plan. A Buddhist says this mirrors the Four Noble Truths. Which statement about step 2 is closest to Buddhist teaching?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If the Buddhist goal is beyond words, how can anyone aim for it?

Make a guess: If the Buddhist goal is beyond words, how can anyone aim for it?

Mission 2

Blowing out

  • Nibbana (Pali; Sanskrit nirvana) means "blowing out" or "extinguishing", as a flame goes out.
  • What goes out are the three fires of greed, hatred and delusion. Samyutta Nikaya 38.1 (paraphrase): the destruction of greed, hatred and delusion: this is called nibbana.
  • It is the third noble truth, nirodha: craving "cut off" through detachment, letting go of what changes (see Mission 1).
  • It is not the destruction of a self: by anatta, there was no lasting self to destroy.
  • Your spec: "nirodha as the 'cutting off' of craving through detachment".
Mission 2

In this life and after death

Two kinds of nibbanaan awakened lifeawakeningdeathBodh Gaya, c. age 35nibbana with remainderfires out, khandhas remainKusinara, c. age 80parinibbanakhandhas end, no rebirth
  • Nibbana with remainder (sa-upadisesa): reached in this life. The fires are out, but the "remainder", the five khandhas, continues: the awakened one still has a body and feelings.
  • Nibbana without remainder (anupadisesa): at the death of an awakened one. The khandhas end and there is no rebirth.
  • Source: Itivuttaka 44 (paraphrase) names these two "elements" of nibbana.
  • The Buddha: awakening at Bodh Gaya (about age 35) = nibbana with remainder; death at Kusinara (about age 80) = parinibbana, final nibbana (Digha Nikaya 16).
  • Your spec pairs parinibbana/parinirvana.
Quick check
?An arhat stubs her toe. What does Theravada teaching say about her experience?
Mission 2

The unconditioned

  • Everything in samsara is conditioned: it arises from causes and so changes.
  • Nibbana is unconditioned (asankhata): not produced by causes, not subject to arising and passing.
  • Udana 8.3 (paraphrase): there is an unborn, unbecome, unmade, unconditioned; if there were not, there would be no escape from the born, become, made and conditioned.
  • So the path does not manufacture nibbana; it removes what obscures it, and nibbana is realised.
  • Your spec: "nibbana/nirvana as un-conditioned existence which cannot be explained".
Mission 2

Where does the fire go?

Where does the fire go?which way did it go?NESWthe question does not applyfire out, fuel goneMajjhima Nikaya 72
  • In Majjhima Nikaya 72 (paraphrase), the wanderer Vacchagotta asks where an awakened one goes after death: is he reborn? not reborn? both? neither? To each, the Buddha says the question does not apply.
  • He asks: when a fire goes out, which direction did it go: east, west, north or south? Vacchagotta: the question does not fit; the fire went out because its fuel ran out.
  • So too the awakened one: no longer reckoned by the khandhas, "deep, immeasurable, hard to fathom, like the ocean" (paraphrase).
  • Scripture speaks of nibbana in three ways:
  • negatively: the end of craving, the unborn, cessation;
  • positively: peace, the highest happiness (Dhammapada 204, Müller), the cool;
  • by images: the further shore, an island, a refuge.
Mission 2Read the source

Milinda's 79th and 80th dilemmas

Milinda's similes for nibbanaform:cannot beshownlotusuntouched bydefilementswatercools, quenchescravingmedicineends sufferingoceancannot bemeasuredspaceunborn, withoutlimitmountain peaklofty,unshakeableand more

The Questions of King Milinda, Book IV (paraphrase):

  • 79th: Is nibbana pure bliss, or mixed with pain? Milinda: those seeking it torment body and mind, restrain the senses and give up pleasures, so it seems painful. Nagasena: the pain belongs to the seeking, not to nibbana. Kings endure hardship to win a kingdom; students struggle to learn a craft. The kingdom itself is not the hardship.
  • 80th: Can the form, shape, age or size of nibbana be shown by simile, reason or cause? Nagasena: no: it has no equal, as the water of the great ocean cannot be measured.
  • But its qualities can be shown by similes: like the lotus, untouched by defilements; like water, cooling the fever of defilement and quenching the thirst of craving; like medicine, ending suffering; like space, unborn and without limit; like a mountain peak, lofty and unshakeable; and more.

Q1 Why does Nagasena move from "form" to "qualities"?

Show answer

Nibbana is unconditioned, so it has no form to describe; but what it is like for the one who realises it can be pointed to.

Q2 One strength and one weakness of the similes?

Show answer

Strength: they show nibbana is positive peace, not nothing. Weakness: each is partial, and they risk making it sound like a place or a feeling.

Quick check
?How does Nagasena answer the king in the 80th dilemma?
Mission 2

Theravada and Mahayana emphases

Theravada and Mahayana emphasesunconditionedarhatparinibbananon-abidinga Buddha keepshelping beingssamsara andnirvana notdifferent(Nagarjuna)TheravadaMahayana
  • Theravada: nibbana is the unconditioned, realised by the arhat; after parinibbana the awakened one is neither "somewhere" nor simply annihilated: the question does not apply.
  • Mahayana: a Buddha does not rest in a nirvana apart from the world but keeps helping beings: non-abiding nirvana (apratisthita-nirvana).
  • Nagarjuna (c. 2nd century CE): there is not the slightest difference between samsara and nirvana when both are seen as empty (Mulamadhyamakakarika 25, paraphrase;).
  • The Lotus Sutra treats the arhat's nirvana as a resting place on the way to Buddhahood (the "magic city").
Mission 2Evaluate

Can the goal of Buddhism be understood?

Can the goal of Buddhism be understood?Nibbana cannot be understood by anyonewho has not realised it.ForLanguage is built for conditioned things;nibbana is unconditioned (Udana 8.3).The Buddha says questions about theawakened one after death "do not apply"(MN 72).AgainstIts qualities can be shown (Milinda'ssimiles), and the third truth defines itclearly: the end of craving.Its effects are visible: arhats and teachersliving without greed or hatred.Partial understanding is enough to begin,as a traveller trusts a destination theyhave not seen.Judge it byWhat counts as "understanding": a definition,a description, or direct experience? · Is a goalthat cannot be described still rational topursue?
  • Claim: Nibbana cannot be understood by anyone who has not realised it.
  • For: Language is built for conditioned things; nibbana is unconditioned (Udana 8.3).
  • For: The Buddha says questions about the awakened one after death "do not apply" (MN 72).
  • Against: Its qualities can be shown (Milinda's similes), and the third truth defines it clearly: the end of craving.
  • Against: Its effects are visible: arhats and teachers living without greed or hatred show what it means in this life.
  • Against: Partial understanding is enough to begin, as a traveller trusts a destination they have not seen.
  • Judgement criteria: What counts as "understanding": a definition, a description, or direct experience? Is a goal that cannot be described still rational to pursue?
Quick check
?Which statement is most typical of Mahayana teaching on nirvana?
Mission check

?A teacher says: "Nibbana is like the moment a long fever breaks. Nothing new is added; the burning stops, and there is coolness and ease." Which comment fits Buddhist teaching about this description?
Mission 3

Mission 3: The Eightfold Path has eight parts. Is it a ladder you climb, or something else?

Make a guess: The Eightfold Path has eight parts. Is it a ladder you climb, or something else?

Mission 3

The Middle Way

The Middle WayIndulgence insense pleasuresextreme: avoidSamyutta Nikaya 56.11Self-mortificationextreme: avoidnirvana /nibbanaMiddle Way = Noble EightfoldPath
  • In his first sermon (Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, Samyutta Nikaya 56.11) the Buddha names two extremes to avoid (paraphrase):
  • Indulgence in sense pleasures: low, worldly, unprofitable.
  • Self-mortification (harsh asceticism): painful, unprofitable.
  • Between them, the Middle Way leads to calm, insight, awakening and nirvana. The Buddha says that Middle Way is the Noble Eightfold Path.
  • It mirrors his life: palace luxury, then six years of harsh ascetic practice, including extreme fasting, then awakening after accepting food.
  • The path is the fourth Noble Truth: magga, the way to the end of dukkha (see Mission 1).
  • Your spec writes magga/marga.
Mission 3

Eight factors, three trainings

Eight factors, three trainings123456781right view2right intention3right speech4right action5right livelihood6right effort7right mindfulness8right concentration1234567812345678wisdomethics /moralitymeditation(panna)(sila)(samadhi)
  • Each factor is samma: "right" in the sense of complete, fitting, skilful; not "right" as opposed to a rule broken.
  • Wisdom (panna): 1 right view (understanding the Four Noble Truths) · 2 right intention (renunciation, goodwill, harmlessness).
  • Ethics / morality (sila): 3 right speech · 4 right action · 5 right livelihood.
  • Meditation (samadhi): 6 right effort · 7 right mindfulness · 8 right concentration.
  • The nun Dhammadinna teaches that the path is included in the three trainings, not the reverse: each factor sorts under one training (Culavedalla Sutta, Majjhima Nikaya 44).
  • Practice usually begins with ethics, which steadies the mind for meditation, which ripens into wisdom; but the list opens with view.
Mission 3Read the source

The way, in the Dhammapada

> "The best of ways is the eightfold; the best of truths the four words; the best of virtues passionlessness; the best of men he who has eyes to see." (Dhammapada 273, Müller 1881)

> "You yourself must make an effort. The Tathagatas (Buddhas) are only preachers." (Dhammapada 276, Müller 1881)

  • "The four words" = the Four Noble Truths.

Q1 What does verse 276 say the Buddha cannot do for a follower?

Show answer

Walk the path for them: Buddhas only point the way; effort is the follower's own.

Q2 Why does verse 273 pair the eightfold way with the four truths?

Show answer

The path is the fourth truth: the cure the diagnosis calls for.

Quick check
?A Buddhist resolves each morning to meet anger with goodwill and to give up thoughts of harming anyone. Which factor of the path is she developing, and in which training?
Mission 3

Inter-reliant, not linear

Inter-reliant, not linear87654321not a ladder:not linearMajjhima Nikaya 117ethicsmeditationwisdomeach turn goes deeper9 right knowledge · 10 rightliberation: the arahant
  • "Path" does not mean eight steps in a row. In the Mahacattarisaka Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 117) the Buddha says (paraphrase):
  • Right view comes first: it lets you tell right intention, speech, action and livelihood from wrong.
  • Right view, right effort and right mindfulness "run around" each of the other factors: you see what is skilful, strive for it, and stay aware of it.
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944), The Noble Eightfold Path (1984): the factors are better called components than steps; with maturity all eight are practised together.
  • A common image: a spiral. Ethics, meditation and wisdom feed each other, and each turn goes deeper.
  • Your spec: the stages as inter-reliant, not linear. Gethin and Harvey (suggested reading) describe the path in the same way.
Mission 3

The ninth and tenth factors

Inter-reliant, not linear87654321not a ladder:not linearMajjhima Nikaya 117ethicsmeditationwisdomeach turn goes deeper9 right knowledge · 10 rightliberation: the arahant
  • The same sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 117) adds two more factors (paraphrase):
  • 9 Right knowledge (samma-ñana): direct insight into the way things are.
  • 10 Right liberation (samma-vimutti): release of the mind from craving and ignorance.
  • The Buddha says the one still in training has eight factors; the arahant has ten.
  • So the ninth and tenth are acquired, not practised: they are the path's fruit, the goal of wisdom reached.
  • They complete the wisdom section: view and intention begin it; knowledge and liberation complete it.
  • Your spec: the ninth and tenth "acquired" stages of wisdom.
Mission 3

Speech, action, livelihood

  • Defined in the Magga-vibhanga Sutta (Samyutta Nikaya 45.8) (paraphrase):
  • Right speech: no lying, no divisive speech, no harsh speech, no idle chatter.
  • Right action: no killing, no taking what is not given, no sexual misconduct.
  • Right livelihood: giving up wrong ways of earning a living. Lay followers should not trade in weapons, living beings, meat, intoxicants or poison (Vanijja Sutta, Anguttara Nikaya 5.177).
  • These overlap with the five precepts. Practice today: a Buddhist may refuse work in an arms factory, avoid gossip at work, or choose a caring profession.
Mission 3

Keown: is ethics left behind?

  • An older view (e.g. Winston King, Melford Spiro) held that ethics is only a raft: useful for the crossing, then left behind by the enlightened.
  • Damien Keown, The Nature of Buddhist Ethics (1992), argues against this: ethics and wisdom are both part of the goal. Nirvana is the full perfection of virtue as well as knowledge.
  • Keown compares Buddhist ethics to virtue ethics (Aristotle): the path forms character, and the arahant is the model of perfect virtue.
  • Bodhi: the path's ethical factors are not preliminary; they are kept, made effortless, in the awakened person.
  • Critics: some verses praise one "who in this world is above good and evil" (Dhammapada 412, Müller 1881), which suggests ethics is transcended. Keown reads such verses as going beyond merit-seeking goodness, not beyond virtue.
  • Keown, Buddhism: A Very Short Introduction (2000), chapter 4, is suggested reading.
Mission 3Evaluate

Is any part of the path more important?

Is any part of the path more important?Claim: Some factors of the Eightfold Pathmatter more than others.ForRight view comes first and guides the rest(Majjhima Nikaya 117).Meditation is where insight happens;without it ethics may stay on the surface.AgainstThe factors are inter-reliant components(Bodhi): remove one and the othersweaken.Ethics is the foundation most layBuddhists practise; for Keown it is part ofthe goal itself.Judge it byWhat does the text say about order? · Whatdo lay and monastic Buddhists practise? · Isthe path a moral guide for every Buddhist,including Pure Land and Zen?
  • Claim: Some factors of the Eightfold Path matter more than others.
  • For: Right view comes first and guides the rest (Majjhima Nikaya 117).
  • For: Meditation (samadhi) is where insight happens; without it ethics may stay on the surface.
  • Against: The factors are inter-reliant components (Bodhi); remove one and the others weaken.
  • Against: Ethics is the foundation most lay Buddhists actually practise; and on Keown's view it is part of the goal itself.
  • Judgement criteria: What does the text say about order? What do lay and monastic Buddhists practise? Is the path a moral guide for every Buddhist, including Pure Land and Zen?
Quick check
?Which statement best captures the teaching of the Mahacattarisaka Sutta (Majjhima Nikaya 117) about how the factors relate?
Mission check

?A meditation teacher tells a student: "Your sitting practice is excellent, so you can stop worrying about how you speak to people." Most Theravada and Mahayana teachers would say this advice is mistaken. Why?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • The Deer Park sermon (SN 56.11): dukkha (understand), samudaya: craving (abandon), nirodha (realise), magga: the Eightfold Path (develop).
  • The doctor analogy: illness, cause, cure, prescription.
  • Three cravings: for sense pleasures, for existence, for non-existence.
  • Tanha is link 8 of the twelve nidanas.
  • The five companions became the first arhats: disciples who realise nibbana by following the path the Buddha discovered.

Mission 2

  • In Buddhist teaching, nibbana ("blowing out") is the end of greed, hatred and delusion: with remainder in this life, without remainder (parinibbana) at death.
  • It is unconditioned; questions about where an awakened one "goes" do not apply. Mahayana stresses non-abiding nirvana.
  • Milinda's 79th dilemma: the pain is in the seeking, not in nibbana; 80th: its form cannot be shown, its qualities can.

Mission 3

  • The Middle Way avoids indulgence and self-mortification; the Buddha identifies it with the Noble Eightfold Path, the fourth Noble Truth.
  • Eight factors in three trainings: wisdom (view, intention), ethics (speech, action, livelihood), meditation (effort, mindfulness, concentration); practised together, not one by one.
  • The arahant has ten factors: right knowledge and right liberation are the "acquired" fruit of the path (Majjhima Nikaya 117).
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Buddhist thought: Four Noble Truths for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why did the Buddha's first sermon sound like a doctor's diagnosis?
  2. Mission 2If the Buddhist goal is beyond words, how can anyone aim for it?
  3. Mission 3The Eightfold Path has eight parts. Is it a ladder you climb, or something else?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR