← A-Level Religious Studies · OCR · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
OCR A-level Religious Studies (H573) · H573/06 Developments in Buddhist thought – The development of Mahayana Buddhism (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Buddhist thought: The development of Mahayana Buddhism (part 1)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Centuries after the Buddha died, new sutras appeared in his name. Why did Buddhists accept them?
  2. Mission 2If a father lies to get his children out of a burning house, has he done wrong?
  3. Mission 3Why would anyone vow to stay in a world of suffering until every being is free?
  4. Mission 4Can one person's good deeds help someone else?
  5. Mission 5Was the Buddha a man who lived and died, or something that never dies?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Centuries after the Buddha died, new sutras appeared in his name. Why did Buddhists accept them?

Make a guess: Centuries after the Buddha died, new sutras appeared in his name. Why did Buddhists accept them?

Mission 1

The "Great Vehicle"

  • Mahayana: "Great Vehicle". Its followers aim at full Buddhahood for the sake of all beings, through the bodhisattva path.
  • Some Mahayana texts called other paths Hinayana, "lesser vehicle". This is a polemical term: do not use it for Theravada today.
  • Today Mahayana is the largest Buddhist tradition, across China, Taiwan, Korea, Japan, Vietnam, Tibet and Mongolia (the Tibetan forms are often called Vajrayana).
  • Mahayana was a movement, not at first a separate school: Mahayana monks lived under the same monastic rules (Vinaya) as others, sometimes in the same monasteries.
  • Mahayana Buddhists accepted the new sutras as the Buddha's word (buddhavacana). Traditional accounts say they were taught by the Buddha but kept until people were ready, or revealed in meditation by Buddhas now teaching in other worlds; some also held that whatever agrees with the Dhamma is the Buddha's word.
Mission 1

The context: India, c. 2nd century BCE to 1st century CE

The context of Mahayana: a timelinedatedebatedthe Buddha's death;about a century later,the first split:Sthaviras andMahasanghikasd. c. 232BCEAshoka; Buddhismspreads across Indiaand beyondc. 1stcentury BCEfirst Mahayana sutras(e.g. Perfection ofWisdom in 8,000Lines); Pali Canonwritten down in SriLankac. 1stcentury CEfirst images of theBuddha: Gandharaand Mathurac. 179 CELokaksema translatessutras into Chinese
  • After Ashoka (d. c. 232 BCE): Buddhism spread across India and beyond, with many monastic schools (the first split, between Sthaviras and Mahasanghikas, is traditionally placed about a century after the Buddha's death).
  • North-west India: Indo-Greek, Saka and Kushan rulers; trade along the Silk Road; mixed cultures. The first images of the Buddha appear (Gandhara and Mathura, c. 1st century CE).
  • Writing: scriptures begin to be written down (the Pali Canon in Sri Lanka, 1st century BCE), allowing new texts to spread and be honoured as books.
  • Devotion (bhakti) grows across Indian religion; stupas become great pilgrimage centres.
  • New sutras: the first Mahayana sutras (e.g. the Perfection of Wisdom in 8,000 Lines) date from around the 1st century BCE; some were translated into Chinese by Lokaksema around 179 CE.
Mission 1

Why did it emerge? Competing theories

  • Lay and stupa cult: Hirakawa Akira (1915–2002) linked Mahayana to lay devotees at stupas. Now widely questioned: early texts are mostly by and for monks.
  • Forest ascetics: many early sutras praise strict forest renunciants seeking Buddhahood (e.g. Jan Nattier, A Few Good Men, 2003, on the Ugrapariprccha). A renewal movement, not a lay rebellion.
  • Cult of the book: Gregory Schopen (b. 1947): early Mahayana groups centred on honouring a sutra as the Buddha's presence.
  • Visionary experience: meditation in which practitioners met Buddhas of other worlds and received teaching (e.g. the Pratyutpanna Samadhi Sutra).
  • Doctrinal reasons: the wish to follow the Buddha's own path (bodhisattva, not only arhat); grief at the Buddha's absence; deeper reflection on emptiness.
Quick check
?Which statement about the emergence of Mahayana is best supported by current scholarship?
Mission 1

Key Mahayana ideas

Key Mahayana ideasbodhisattvaideal for allemptiness(shunyata)skilfulmeans(upaya)manyBuddhas,nowBuddhanaturemerittransferMahayana
  • Bodhisattva ideal for all: aim at full Buddhahood out of compassion, not only personal liberation (see Mission 3).
  • Emptiness (shunyata): all things lack fixed own-being; developed in the Perfection of Wisdom sutras and by Nagarjuna (–b).
  • Skilful means (upaya): the Buddha adapts his teaching to his hearers (see Mission 2).
  • Many Buddhas in many worlds, now: e.g. Amitabha, and great bodhisattvas such as Avalokiteshvara who can be called on for help.
  • Buddha nature: every being can become a Buddha.
  • Merit transfer: merit can be shared for the good of all.
Mission 1

A bigger idea of the Buddha

A bigger idea of the BuddhaTheravadaMahayanaWhoGautamaisa human beingwho found thepath and taughtitone BuddhaamongcountlessBuddhasBuddhasnowone Buddha peragecountlessBuddhas incountlessworlds, activenowAfterdeathafter hisparinibbana heis beyond reachhis life farlonger than itappeared (LotusSutra ch. 16)Howhonouredas teacher andexample; hisimages andstupasstill central:images andstupaseverywhere, butone amongmany Buddhastrikaya ("three bodies")Dharma-body · enjoyment-body ·emanation-body
  • Theravada: Gautama was a human being who found the path and taught it. After his parinibbana he is beyond reach; Buddhists honour him as teacher and example. One Buddha per age.
  • Mahayana: there are countless Buddhas in countless worlds, active now; the Buddha's life is far longer than it appeared (Lotus Sutra ch. 16).
  • The trikaya ("three bodies") later explains this: the Dharma-body (ultimate reality), the enjoyment-body (Buddhas in pure lands) and the emanation-body (Gautama's earthly life) (see Mission 5).
  • Gautama is still central in both traditions: his images and stupas are honoured everywhere, but in Mahayana he is one among many Buddhas.
Quick check
?Which belief would a Mahayana Buddhist hold that most Theravada Buddhists would not?
Mission 1

Upaya applied to the original teachings

  • Upaya: "skilful means": the Buddha teaches what each hearer can grasp, as a doctor gives different medicines.
  • Mahayana applies this to Siddhartha's own teaching: the Four Noble Truths, the arhat goal and even his death were true and useful, but provisional: steps towards the one Buddha-vehicle.
  • So the earlier teaching is not rejected but re-placed: the arhat's nirvana is a resting point, not the final goal.
  • Theravada replies: the Buddha taught one path to one nirvana; there is no hidden higher teaching (the Buddha says he had no "closed fist" of secret teachings, Digha Nikaya 16, paraphrase).
  • Your spec: "the idea of upaya (skilful means) and how this is applied to the original teachings of Siddhartha".
Mission 1Read the source

The Lotus Sutra

  • Chapter 2, "Skilful Means" (paraphrase): the Buddhas teach three vehicles (disciples, solitary Buddhas, bodhisattvas) only as skilful means. In truth there is one vehicle, the Buddha-vehicle.
  • Chapter 16, "The Lifespan of the Tathagata" (paraphrase): the Buddha awakened immeasurably long ago. A physician whose children have drunk poison sends word that he has died; grief brings them to their senses and they take his medicine. So the Buddha appears to enter nirvana, so that people will not take him for granted.

Q1 What does the physician parable say about the Buddha's death in 483 BCE (or c. 400 BCE)?

Show answer

It was a skilful means: the Buddha did not truly pass away.

Q2 How does chapter 2 treat the arhat's path?

Show answer

As a provisional vehicle within the one Buddha-vehicle.

  • OCR suggested source: Lotus Sutra, chapter 2. The burning house (ch. 3) and other parables.
Quick check
?A Mahayana teacher says the Buddha's first sermon on the Four Noble Truths was "skilful means". What does she mean?
Mission 1Evaluate

Faithful development or a new religion?

Faithful development or a new religion?Claim: Mahayana is a faithful developmentof the Buddha's teaching.ForIt grew within monastic communitiesunder the same Vinaya; its core (dukkha,anatta, the path) is shared.Upaya is already visible in the Pali Canon:the Buddha adapted teaching to eachhearer.AgainstIts sutras appeared centuries after theBuddha; Theravada does not accept themas his words.Many active Buddhas, Buddha nature anda "lesser vehicle" reshape the goal and thefounder.Judge it byWhat counts as the Buddha's word(buddhavacana): origin or agreement with theDhamma? · Does upaya allow any change? ·How do Mahayana Buddhists themselves seeit?
  • Claim: Mahayana is a faithful development of the Buddha's teaching.
  • For: It grew within monastic communities under the same Vinaya; its core (dukkha, anatta, the path) is shared.
  • For: Upaya is already visible in the Pali Canon: the Buddha adapted teaching to each hearer.
  • Against: Its sutras appeared centuries after the Buddha; Theravada does not accept them as his words.
  • Against: Many active Buddhas, Buddha nature and a "lesser vehicle" reshape the goal and the founder.
  • Judgement criteria: What counts as the Buddha's word (buddhavacana): origin or agreement with the Dhamma? Does upaya allow any change? How do Mahayana Buddhists themselves see it?
  • Your spec issue: what upaya implies for responses to other religious truth claims and diversity within Buddhism (e.g. other paths as skilful means: inclusive, or condescending?).
Mission check

?A Theravada monk tells a Mahayana friend: "The Lotus Sutra cannot be the Buddha's word: it appeared centuries after he died." Which reply would a Mahayana Buddhist most likely give?
Mission 2

Mission 2: If a father lies to get his children out of a burning house, has he done wrong?

Make a guess: If a father lies to get his children out of a burning house, has he done wrong?

Mission 2

The Lotus Sutra

The Lotus Sutra through timeThe Lotus SutraSaddharmapundarika Sutraa Mahayana textc. 1st centuryBCE – 2ndcentury CEComposed in stages, inIndia406 CEKumarajiva's ChinesetranslationLaterLoved across East Asia:Tiantai (China); Tendaiand Nichiren Buddhism(Japan)
  • Full title: Saddharmapundarika Sutra, "the Lotus of the True Dharma". A Mahayana text.
  • Composed in stages, roughly 1st century BCE to 2nd century CE, in India.
  • Kumarajiva's Chinese translation (406 CE) made it one of the most loved texts in East Asia: Tiantai (China), Tendai and Nichiren Buddhism (Japan).
  • Its big claims: there is really one vehicle (ekayana) to Buddhahood; all beings can become Buddhas; the Buddha is far greater than his one human life.
  • It teaches mainly through parables: stories that carry the doctrine.
  • Chapter numbers differ between versions for some chapters; the burning house (3), magic city (7) and hidden gem (8) have the same numbers in the Chinese and Sanskrit versions.
Mission 2

Upaya: skilful means

  • Upaya (full form upaya-kausalya): skilful means, skill in adapting the teaching to the hearer.
  • A good teacher meets people where they are: a child, a scholar and a grieving parent need different words.
  • Lotus Sutra chapter 2 ("Skilful Means"): the Buddha's wisdom is too deep to be grasped at once, so he taught in many ways, to lead beings step by step (paraphrase).
  • So some teachings are provisional: true enough to help, but not the final word.
  • Applied to Siddhartha's original teaching: Mahayana reads the early path to the arhat's nirvana as a stage on the way, not the end.
Mission 2Read the source

The burning house

The burning houseFire!one narrow doorgatechildren at playpromised:goatdeeroxgreat carriagewhite oxen · the same for every childIn the storyStands forhouse on firesamsarachildrenall beingsfatherthe Buddhathree cartsthree vehiclesgreat carriagethe one Buddha vehicle

Lotus Sutra, chapter 3 (paraphrase):

  • A rich old man owns a huge, decaying house with one narrow door. Fire breaks out.
  • His children are inside, absorbed in their games. They do not know what fire is, or fear it.
  • He calls them; they ignore him. So he says: the goat-carts, deer-carts and ox-carts you wanted are waiting outside the gate!
  • They rush out and are safe. Then he gives every child the same great carriage, drawn by white oxen: better than anything promised.
  • The Buddha asks Sariputra: did the father lie? Sariputra: no; he saved their lives, and that was his aim from the start.

Q1 Why did the father not simply tell the truth about the fire?

Show answer

The children did not understand fire, so the warning meant nothing to them; the promise of carts did.

Q2 Why does Sariputra say no falsehood was told?

Show answer

The father's purpose was their rescue, and he gave them more than he promised.

Mission 2

Decoding the parable

The burning houseFire!one narrow doorgatechildren at playpromised:goatdeeroxgreat carriagewhite oxen · the same for every childIn the storyStands forhouse on firesamsarachildrenall beingsfatherthe Buddhathree cartsthree vehiclesgreat carriagethe one Buddha vehicle
  • House on fire = samsara, burning with birth, old age, sickness, death and suffering.
  • Children = all beings, absorbed in pleasures, unaware of danger.
  • Father = the Buddha, who cares for all beings as his children.
  • Three carts = the three vehicles taught earlier: the way of disciples (sravaka), of solitary Buddhas (pratyekabuddha), and of bodhisattvas.
  • Great carriage = the one Buddha vehicle: all are finally led to full Buddhahood.
Quick check
?In the parable of the burning house, what does the great carriage drawn by white oxen stand for?
Mission 2

The magic city and the hidden gem

The magic city and the hidden gemMagic city (chapter 7)conjured citytreasureresting place ≠ goalHidden gem (chapter 8)jewel sewninto the liningalready yours
  • Magic city (chapter 7, paraphrase): a guide leads travellers along a long, dangerous road to a place of treasure. Exhausted, they want to turn back. He conjures a city for them to rest in. Refreshed, they are told: this city is not real; the treasure is near.
    • Meaning: the arhat's nirvana is a resting place on the way, not the final goal.
  • Hidden gem (chapter 8, paraphrase): a poor man falls asleep drunk at a rich friend's house. The friend, called away, sews a priceless jewel into his robe. The man wanders in poverty, content with a little; years later the friend shows him the jewel.
    • Meaning: told by arhats about themselves. They already had what was needed for Buddhahood but settled for less.
    • Later East Asian Buddhism read the gem as Buddha nature within every being (see Mission 5).
Mission 2

The Buddha's life as skilful means

  • Lotus Sutra "Lifespan" chapter (ch. 16 in Kumarajiva's version; ch. 15 in Kern's): the Buddha says he became awakened countless ages ago (paraphrase).
  • So his birth, renunciation, awakening under the tree and death were a display for beings' sake.
  • The physician (paraphrase): a doctor's sons have taken poison; some refuse the cure. He goes away and sends word he has died. Shocked, they take the medicine. He returns.
  • Meaning: if the Buddha always seemed present, people would grow careless. His parinirvana was skilful means.
Quick check
?In the parable of the magic city, the conjured city is shown to be unreal. What does this suggest about the arhat's nirvana, on the Lotus Sutra's reading?
Mission 2Diversity

Theravada and Mahayana readings

Two readings of the Lotus SutraMahayanaTheravadaThe Lotus Sutra isthe Buddha's word(buddhavacana)Mahayana sutras notaccepted as theBuddha's wordEarlier vehicles areprovisionalArahantship is thereal goal, not aresting placeOne vehicle toBuddhahood for allTeaching adapted;doctrine notprovisionalShared groundTeaching adapted to hearers · the raft simile(Majjhima Nikaya 22)
  • Mahayana: the Lotus Sutra is the Buddha's word (buddhavacana), revealing what earlier teaching held back. Nichiren Buddhists chant its title, Namu Myoho Renge Kyo.
  • Theravada: does not accept the Mahayana sutras as the Buddha's word. Arahantship is the real goal, not a resting place.
  • Common ground: Pali texts already show the Buddha adapting his teaching to hearers, and the raft simile (Majjhima Nikaya 22) says the Dhamma is for crossing over, not for clinging to.
  • The difference: adapting how truth is taught (shared) vs treating earlier doctrines as provisional (Mahayana).
  • Scholar: Michael Pye, Skilful Means: A Concept in Mahayana Buddhism (1978), traces how upaya became a key Mahayana idea.
Mission 2Evaluate

Is skilful means the key to Buddhism's diversity?

Is skilful means the key to Buddhism's diversity?Skilful means explains why Buddhism hasso many forms.ForSchools can be seen as teachings fitted todifferent people and cultures, all leadingto one goal.Buddhists can respect other traditionswithout calling them simply false.AgainstIt is a Mahayana idea: Theravadins rejectthe claim that their goal is provisional.If any teaching may be provisional, howdoes anyone tell which is final? "Skilful"could excuse anything.Judge it byDoes it fit what the Pali texts already say? ·Does it respect each school's own view ofitself? · Does it keep a test for what counts ashelpful?
  • Claim: Skilful means explains why Buddhism has so many forms.
  • For: Different schools can be seen as teachings fitted to different people and cultures, all leading to one goal.
  • For: It lets Buddhists respect other traditions without calling them simply false.
  • Against: It is a Mahayana idea: Theravadins reject the claim that their goal is provisional, so it cannot unite all Buddhists on its own terms.
  • Against: If any teaching may be provisional, how does anyone tell which is final? The risk is that "skilful" excuses anything.
  • Judgement criteria: Does the idea fit what the Pali texts already say? Does it respect each school's own view of itself? Does it keep a test for what counts as helpful?
Quick check
?Why does the Lotus Sutra say the father in the burning house is not guilty of lying?
Mission check

?A meditation teacher tells anxious beginners: "Just follow your breath; that is all there is to it." Months later she teaches them that watching the breath is only a doorway to insight into impermanence and no-self. How would the Lotus Sutra's idea of upaya describe her first instruction?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Why would anyone vow to stay in a world of suffering until every being is free?

Make a guess: Why would anyone vow to stay in a world of suffering until every being is free?

Mission 3

Bodhisattva: a being set on awakening

Bodhisattva: the wordbodhi= awakeningsattva= beinga being bound for full BuddhahoodPali textsGautama before hisawakeningMahayanaan ideal for all
  • Bodhisattva: bodhi (awakening) + sattva (being): a being bound for full Buddhahood.
  • In the Pali texts the word names Gautama before his awakening, through many lives (the Jataka stories).
  • Tradition tells how, ages ago, the ascetic Sumedha met the Buddha Dipankara and resolved to become a Buddha himself.
  • In Mahayana Buddhism the bodhisattva becomes the ideal for everyone: not only one future Buddha, but all who make the vow.
Mission 3

The arhat: the worthy one

  • Arhat ("worthy one"): one who has fully ended greed, hatred and delusion, and so ends rebirth at death.
  • Four stages of awakening:
  • Stream-enterer: has seen the Dhamma; at most seven more lives.
  • Once-returner: one more human birth.
  • Non-returner: no return to the human world.
  • Arhat: free.
Mission 3

Bodhicitta and the vow

  • Bodhicitta, "the awakening mind": the wish to become a Buddha for the sake of all beings.
  • It is made formal in the bodhisattva vow, often taken in a ceremony before a teacher.
  • A common East Asian form, the Four Great Vows (paraphrase): beings are countless, I vow to free them; delusions are endless, I vow to end them; teachings are boundless, I vow to learn them; the Buddha way is unsurpassed, I vow to reach it.
  • Not "I postpone nirvana forever". Many Mahayana texts teach that a Buddha reaches a non-abiding nirvana: free, but never withdrawn from beings.
  • This is the bodhisattva way: vow, then perfections, then stages.
Mission 3Read the source

Shantideva's aspiration

Shantideva (8th century, India), Bodhicaryavatara ("Entering the Way of Awakening"), chapter 10, verse 55 (paraphrase):

  • For as long as space remains, and as long as there are living beings, may I too remain, to drive away the suffering of the world.
  • The 14th Dalai Lama often names this verse as a lifelong inspiration.

Q1 What two things set the length of the bodhisattva's commitment?

Show answer

The existence of space and of suffering beings.

Q2 Does the verse say the bodhisattva never reaches awakening?

Show answer

No: it is about staying to help; on the non-abiding view, a Buddha does both.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes the bodhisattva vow in Mahayana Buddhism?
Mission 3

The six perfections

The six perfectionsthe far shore1danagenerosity2silaethics3ksantipatience4viryaenergy5dhyanameditation6prajnawisdomguidesthe rest
  • Paramita, "perfection" or "gone to the far shore": a quality practised to its fullest.
  • Dana: generosity, giving even one's life.
  • Sila: ethical conduct.
  • Ksanti: patience, enduring harm without anger.
  • Virya: energy, joyful effort.
  • Dhyana: meditation, a stable mind.
  • Prajna: wisdom, seeing the emptiness of all things.
  • A list of ten adds skilful means, vow, power and knowledge, one for each of the ten stages.
Mission 3

Wisdom and compassion: two wings

  • Compassion (karuna) without wisdom becomes attachment: "I am the helper; you are the helped."
  • Wisdom (prajna) without compassion becomes cold: seeing emptiness, but doing nothing.
  • So the perfection of wisdom guides the other five, like a sighted person leading others on a road (an image from the Perfection of Wisdom texts, paraphrase).
  • True giving sees no fixed giver, gift or receiver: all are empty. It gives freely, without pride.
  • Significance of the paramitas: they turn ordinary virtues into the path to Buddhahood.
Mission 3

The ten bhumis

The ten bhumis1Joyfulgenerosity2Stainless3Luminous4Radiant5Hard to conquer6Facingwisdom7Far-going8Immovable9Good intelligence10Cloud of DharmaknowledgeFrom stage 8: cannot fall backEach stage perfects one paramita.
  • Bhumi, "ground" or stage. The classic list is in the Dasabhumika Sutra.
  • 1 Joyful · 2 Stainless · 3 Luminous · 4 Radiant · 5 Hard to conquer · 6 Facing (wisdom) · 7 Far-going · 8 Immovable · 9 Good intelligence · 10 Cloud of Dharma.
  • Stage 1 begins with the first direct insight into emptiness; each stage perfects one paramita (1 generosity … 6 wisdom … 10 knowledge).
  • From stage 8 the bodhisattva cannot fall back.
  • Traditionally the whole path takes three countless ages.
Quick check
?Which pairing of bodhisattva stage and perfection follows the classic ten-stage scheme?
Mission 3Diversity

Arhat and bodhisattva compared

Arhat and bodhisattva comparedArhatBodhisattvaGoalNirvana, the endof rebirthFullBuddhahoodMotiveFreedom fromsuffering, thenteaching othersFreedom of allbeings from thestartLengthPossible in thislifeCountless livesWhoTheravada: thegoal for mostMahayana: thepath for all
  • Goal: arhat — nirvana, the end of rebirth; bodhisattva — full Buddhahood.
  • Motive: arhat — freedom from suffering, then teaching others; bodhisattva — freedom of all beings from the start.
  • Length: arhat — possible in this life; bodhisattva — countless lives.
  • Who: Theravada — the arhat is the goal for most; a few aim at Buddhahood. Mahayana — the bodhisattva path is for all.
  • Fairness check: calling arhats "selfish" is a Mahayana polemic. In the Pali texts the Buddha sent his first arhat disciples out to teach "for the welfare of the many" (Vinaya, Mahavagga I.11, paraphrase).
Mission 3Evaluate

Is the bodhisattva ideal higher than the arhat ideal?

Is the bodhisattva ideal higher than the arhat ideal?The bodhisattva ideal is a higher ideal thanthat of the arhat.ForIt joins wisdom to universal compassion;no one is left behind.It follows the Buddha's own example: hechose Buddhahood and taught for 45years.AgainstArhats also teach and serve; the contrastis overdrawn.A goal reachable in this life may motivatemore than one countless lives away.Judge it byWhich ideal fits the Buddha's teaching asrecorded? · Which is reachable? · Does ahigher aim make a better path?
  • Claim: The bodhisattva ideal is a higher ideal than that of the arhat.
  • For: It joins wisdom to universal compassion; no one is left behind.
  • For: It follows the Buddha's own example: he chose Buddhahood and taught for 45 years.
  • Against: Arhats also teach and serve; the contrast is overdrawn.
  • Against: A goal that is reachable in this life may motivate more than one that is countless lives away.
  • Judgement criteria: Which ideal fits the Buddha's teaching as recorded? Which is reachable? Does a higher aim make a better path?
Quick check
?Most Theravada Buddhists would describe the arhat's goal in which way?
Mission check

?A nurse in a hospice gives up her holidays to sit with dying patients. She is proud of how much she gives and resents those who give less. On the Mahayana account of the perfections, what is missing from her generosity?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Can one person's good deeds help someone else?

Make a guess: Can one person's good deeds help someone else?

Mission 4

The great bodhisattvas

  • Mahayana texts describe bodhisattvas at the highest stages of the path (see Mission 3): of vast wisdom and power, active in many worlds.
  • Buddhists turn to them in devotion: they recite their names and mantras, and make offerings before their images.
  • Each embodies a quality of awakening, so devotion also trains that quality in the devotee.
  • They are often called "celestial" or "transcendent" bodhisattvas.
  • Three that your spec names: compassion, wisdom, and the Buddha to come.
Mission 4

Avalokitesvara: compassion

Three bodhisattvas: emblemsAvalokitesvaracompassion · a thousand armsOm mani padme humGuanyin (China) · Kannon(Japan) · Chenrezig (Tibet)Manjusriwisdomflaming sword: cuts throughignorancebook of the Perfection ofWisdom, on a lotusMaitreyaPali: Metteyyathe Buddha to comeseated with feet on theground, ready to rise
  • Your spec spells Avalokiteśvara.
  • The bodhisattva of compassion, "the lord who looks down" on the world's suffering.
  • Lotus Sutra chapter 25 (Kumarajiva): those who call his name in danger are saved; he takes whatever form will help each being (paraphrase).
  • Often shown with a thousand arms (to help everywhere) and eleven heads.
  • Mantra: Om mani padme hum.
  • Names: Guanyin in China (often in female form), Kannon in Japan, Chenrezig in Tibet.
  • Tibetan Buddhists regard the Dalai Lama as an emanation of Avalokitesvara.
Mission 4

Manjusri: wisdom

Three bodhisattvas: emblemsAvalokitesvaracompassion · a thousand armsOm mani padme humGuanyin (China) · Kannon(Japan) · Chenrezig (Tibet)Manjusriwisdomflaming sword: cuts throughignorancebook of the Perfection ofWisdom, on a lotusMaitreyaPali: Metteyyathe Buddha to comeseated with feet on theground, ready to rise
  • The bodhisattva of wisdom (prajna).
  • Holds a flaming sword that cuts through ignorance, and a book of the Perfection of Wisdom on a lotus.
  • Usually shown as a youth: wisdom that is fresh and sharp.
  • In the Vimalakirti Sutra he alone dares to visit the wise layman Vimalakirti and debate with him.
  • Mount Wutai in China is honoured as his special place.
  • What he represents: wisdom that sees emptiness and frees beings.
Mission 4

Maitreya: the Buddha to come

Three bodhisattvas: emblemsAvalokitesvaracompassion · a thousand armsOm mani padme humGuanyin (China) · Kannon(Japan) · Chenrezig (Tibet)Manjusriwisdomflaming sword: cuts throughignorancebook of the Perfection ofWisdom, on a lotusMaitreyaPali: Metteyyathe Buddha to comeseated with feet on theground, ready to rise
  • Maitreya (Pali Metteyya), from maitri, loving-kindness.
  • Now in the Tushita heaven; he will be the next Buddha, when the Dhamma has been forgotten.
  • Accepted in Theravada too: the Pali canon foretells him (Digha Nikaya 26).
  • Often shown seated with feet on the ground, ready to rise and come.
  • In China the jolly "laughing Buddha" (Budai) is popularly linked with him.
  • What he represents: hope; the Dhamma will be renewed.
Quick check
?A Tibetan Buddhist chants Om mani padme hum while turning a prayer wheel, asking for help for a sick friend. Which bodhisattva is she most likely turning to, and why?
Mission 4

Transfer of merit

Transfer of meritTheravadafamilygiftmonksdedication(pattidana)dead relativerejoicing(anumodana)own meritMahayanadedication (parinamana)practitioner (centre) → all beings
  • Merit (Sanskrit punya, Pali puñña): the good karmic result of wholesome actions.
  • Theravada: after a death, families give food and robes to monks and dedicate the merit to the dead relative (pattidana). The dead rejoice (anumodana), and rejoicing is itself a wholesome act that makes merit of their own.
  • Pali source: the Tirokudda Sutta (Khuddakapatha 7) describes gifts given on behalf of departed relatives (paraphrase).
  • Mahayana: bodhisattvas dedicate all merit to the awakening of all beings (parinamana), often at the end of every practice. In Pure Land Buddhism, Amitabha's merit brings devotees to his Pure Land.
Mission 4Read the source

Who purifies whom?

> "By oneself the evil is done, by oneself one suffers; by oneself evil is left undone, by oneself one is purified. Purity and impurity belong to oneself, no one can purify another." (Dhammapada 165, Müller 1881)

Q1 What problem does this verse raise for transfer of merit?

Show answer

If each person alone makes and reaps karma, how can another's merit help them?

Q2 How does the Theravada idea of rejoicing (anumodana) answer it?

Show answer

The receiver's own act of rejoicing is wholesome, so the merit they gain is theirs.

Mission 4Evaluate

Does transfer of merit contradict karma?

Does transfer of merit contradict karma?Transferring merit contradicts the Buddha'steaching that each person reaps their ownkarma.ForDhammapada 165: no one can purifyanother.Historians see transfer of merit as a lateridea, alongside devotion to saviour figures.AgainstIn Theravada, what helps is the receiver'sown rejoicing: karma stays personal.Giving away merit is itself generosity(dana), so it increases merit; and wisdomsees no fixed owner of merit.Judge it byIs karma a strict law of individual payment, orabout intention? · Does practice (funerals,dedications) show what Buddhists reallybelieve?
  • Claim: Transferring merit contradicts the Buddha's teaching that each person reaps their own karma.
  • For: Dhammapada 165: no one can purify another.
  • For: historians see transfer of merit as a later idea that grew up alongside devotion to saviour figures.
  • Against: In Theravada, what helps is the receiver's own rejoicing: karma stays personal.
  • Against: Giving away merit is itself generosity (dana), so it increases merit; and wisdom sees no fixed owner of merit.
  • Judgement criteria: Is karma a strict law of individual payment, or about intention? Does practice (funerals, dedications) show what Buddhists really believe?
Quick check
?In Theravada practice, how is a dead relative thought to benefit when the family gives food to monks in their name?
Mission check

?At the end of a meditation session, a group of Mahayana Buddhists recite: "May any merit from this practice be dedicated to the awakening of all beings." Which idea best explains what they are doing?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Was the Buddha a man who lived and died, or something that never dies?

Make a guess: Was the Buddha a man who lived and died, or something that never dies?

Mission 5

Theravada: the Buddha as teacher

  • Siddhartha Gautama was a human being who, by his own effort, became awakened: a sammasambuddha, who found the path alone and taught it.
  • He is unique in this age: there is one Buddha at a time. Earlier Buddhas came before him; Metteyya will come after.
  • He had extraordinary powers and qualities, but he was not a god and did not create the world.
  • At death he entered parinirvana: no further rebirth. He cannot be reached as a person now.
  • What remains is the Dhamma, his teaching, and the Sangha that keeps it.
Mission 5Read the source

"Only preachers"

> "You yourself must make an effort. The Tathagatas (Buddhas) are only preachers." (Dhammapada 276, Müller 1881)

  • In the Pali canon the Buddha tells the sick monk Vakkali, who longed to see him: whoever sees the Dhamma sees me (Samyutta Nikaya 22.87, paraphrase).

Q1 What does Dhammapada 276 say a Buddha does, and what must the follower do?

Show answer

The Buddha shows the way; the follower must make the effort.

Q2 What does the Vakkali story suggest the Buddha's true "body" is?

Show answer

His teaching, the Dhamma: a seed of the later idea of a Dharma body.

Mission 5

Mahayana: the Buddha extended

How the idea of the Buddha developedearliestGautama's life: a human teacher whoawakenedEarly schools: the Lokottaravada teach asupramundane BuddhaMahayana takes shape: many Buddhas;the Buddha's life as a displayYogacara sets out the trikaya, the threebodies (c. 4th century CE)latest
  • Many Buddhas: countless Buddhas teach now in countless world-systems, such as Amitabha in his Pure Land in the west.
  • The Buddha's life as a display: the Lotus Sutra says Shakyamuni became awakened countless ages ago; his birth and death were skilful means (see Mission 2).
  • Earlier, a school called the Lokottaravada ("transcendentalists") already taught that the Buddha's life was supramundane: he only seemed to eat, sleep and fall ill.
  • So "Buddha" comes to mean more than one man: awakening itself, present everywhere.
Quick check
?Which statement would most Theravada Buddhists accept about Gautama Buddha?
Mission 5

The three bodies

The three bodies: the moon image1231Dharmakayatruth bodythe moon2Sambhogakayaenjoyment body (heavenly body)its light3Nirmanakayaemanation body (earthly body), e.g.Siddharthareflections in many pools
  • Trikaya: "three bodies" of a Buddha. Developed in Mahayana, set out fully by the Yogacara school (c. 4th century CE).
  • Dharmakaya: the truth or Dharma body: awakening itself, formless, the same in all Buddhas.
  • Sambhogakaya: the enjoyment or bliss body: a glorious form in the Pure Lands, seen by advanced bodhisattvas.
  • Nirmanakaya: the emanation or transformation body: a form that appears in the world, such as Siddhartha.
  • A common teaching image: the moon in the sky (truth body), its light (enjoyment body), its reflections in many pools (emanation bodies).
  • Your spec's names: truth body, heavenly body, earthly body.
Mission 5

Dharmakaya: the truth body

  • In Mahayana teaching, it is not a body in the ordinary sense: it is reality as a Buddha knows it: emptiness, "suchness" (tathata).
  • It does not begin or end; it has no shape, colour or place.
  • All Buddhas share the one Dharmakaya: they are awakened to the same truth.
  • Grows from the early idea that the Buddha's real body is the Dhamma (Vakkali, the earlier screen).
  • Significance for Mahayana Buddhists: the Buddha has not "gone": awakening is always present, and can be realised.
Mission 5

Sambhogakaya: the enjoyment body

  • In Mahayana teaching, a radiant, heavenly form, adorned with the marks of a Buddha.
  • Appears in Pure Lands (Buddha-fields) to bodhisattvas on the higher stages, teaching the Mahayana.
  • Example: Amitabha in his western Pure Land, Sukhavati.
  • Called "enjoyment" because it enjoys and shares the fruits of the Buddha's vast merit.
  • Significance for Mahayana Buddhists: a Buddha can be met in visualisation, devotion and the hope of rebirth in a Pure Land.
Mission 5

Nirmanakaya: the emanation body

  • In Mahayana teaching, a body projected into the world out of compassion, suited to the beings there.
  • Example: Shakyamuni, the Buddha of our age, who seemed to be born, awaken and die.
  • So, for Mahayana Buddhists, the historical Buddha is real, but he is one appearance of something greater.
  • In Tibet, the word for this body, tulku, names recognised teachers believed to be reborn by choice, such as the Dalai Lama.
  • Significance: Mahayana Buddhists hold that compassion never stops sending forms to teach.
Quick check
?In the moon image of the trikaya, what do the reflections of the moon in many pools stand for?
Mission 5Diversity

Two concepts of Buddha

Two concepts of BuddhaTheravadaMahayanaWhoGautama, ahuman beingwho awakenedAwakeningitself, appearingas manyBuddhasHowmany nowOne per ageCountless, inmany worldsAfterdeathParinirvana; notreachable as apersonStill presentthrough thethree bodiesRelation-shipFollow histeaching andexampleAlso devotion,visualisation,Pure Land hopeSharedThe Buddha is not a creator god; his awakeningand his Dhamma are the heart of practice.
  • Who: Theravada — Gautama, a human being who awakened · Mahayana — awakening itself, appearing as many Buddhas.
  • How many now: Theravada — one per age · Mahayana — countless, in many worlds.
  • After death: Theravada — parinirvana; not reachable as a person · Mahayana — still present through the three bodies.
  • Relationship: Theravada — follow his teaching and example · Mahayana — also devotion, visualisation, Pure Land hope.
  • Shared: the Buddha is not a creator god; his awakening and his Dhamma are the heart of practice.
Mission 5Evaluate

Development or departure?

Development or departure?The trikaya doctrine departs from theBuddha's own teaching.ForThe Pali texts present a human teacherwho is gone at death; heavenlyBuddha-bodies are new.It can make the Buddha look like a god,against his teaching of self-effort(Dhammapada 276).AgainstIt develops seeds in the Pali texts: theDhamma as the Buddha's body (Vakkali);his marvellous powers.It answers a real question: how can aBuddha's compassion simply end atdeath?Judge it byFaithfulness to early texts · Coherence · Whatthe doctrine does for practice
  • Claim: The trikaya doctrine departs from the Buddha's own teaching.
  • For: The Pali texts present a human teacher who is gone at death; heavenly Buddha-bodies are new.
  • For: The doctrine can make the Buddha look like a god, against his teaching of self-effort (Dhammapada 276).
  • Against: It develops seeds in the Pali texts: the Dhamma as the Buddha's body (Vakkali); the Buddha's marvellous powers.
  • Against: It answers a real question: how can a Buddha's compassion simply end at death?
  • Judgement criteria: Faithfulness to early texts; coherence; what the doctrine does for practice.
  • Your spec's issue: the development in the understanding of "Buddha".
Quick check
?Which body of the Buddha does a Pure Land Buddhist hope to meet in Amitabha's Pure Land?
Mission check

?A Japanese Buddhist says: "Shakyamuni was real, but his life in India was like a wave on the ocean: the ocean was there before and after." Which doctrine does this best express?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Mahayana ("Great Vehicle") emerged gradually in India, c. 2nd century BCE to 1st century CE, through new sutras, devotion and the bodhisattva ideal; scholars debate why.
  • Mahayana widens the concept of Buddha: many Buddhas active now; Gautama one among them (trikaya in Mission 5).
  • Upaya: Siddhartha's original teachings are true but provisional steps to the one Buddha-vehicle (Lotus Sutra, ch. 2, 16).

Mission 2

  • Upaya (skilful means): the Buddha adapts his teaching to his hearers, so some teachings are provisional.
  • The burning house: the father lures his children out with promised carts, then gives all one great carriage; the three vehicles lead to the one Buddha vehicle.
  • The magic city (a resting place) and the hidden gem (what we already have) make the same point; even the Buddha's death was skilful means.

Mission 3

  • A bodhisattva vows to reach Buddhahood for the sake of all beings (bodhicitta); the arhat reaches nirvana through four stages.
  • Six perfections: generosity, ethics, patience, energy, meditation, wisdom; wisdom guides the rest, and compassion moves them.
  • The ten bhumis map the path stage by stage, from Joyful to Cloud of Dharma.

Mission 4

  • Avalokitesvara (compassion), Manjusri (wisdom, sword and book) and Maitreya (loving-kindness, the Buddha to come) embody qualities of awakening and receive devotion.
  • Transfer of merit: Theravada dedication and rejoicing (pattidana, anumodana); Mahayana dedication to all beings (parinamana); debated against strict personal karma.

Mission 5

  • Theravada: Gautama was a human being who found the path, taught it, and entered parinirvana; one Buddha per age.
  • Mahayana: countless Buddhas; the trikaya: Dharmakaya (truth body), Sambhogakaya (enjoyment or heavenly body), Nirmanakaya (emanation or earthly body).
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Buddhist thought: The development of Mahayana Buddhism (part 1) for OCR A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Centuries after the Buddha died, new sutras appeared in his name. Why did Buddhists accept them?
  2. Mission 2If a father lies to get his children out of a burning house, has he done wrong?
  3. Mission 3Why would anyone vow to stay in a world of suffering until every being is free?
  4. Mission 4Can one person's good deeds help someone else?
  5. Mission 5Was the Buddha a man who lived and died, or something that never dies?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · OCR