← A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Religious Studies (A120) · Option B Islam – Theme 1: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Islam: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1A message says "the Prophet said…". How do Muslims decide whether he really said it?
  2. Mission 2The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  3. Mission 3The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?
  4. Mission 4Was the door to new Islamic rulings shut a thousand years ago, and who wants it open?
  5. Mission 5Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?
Mission 1

Mission 1: A message says "the Prophet said…". How do Muslims decide whether he really said it?

Make a guess: A message says "the Prophet said…". How do Muslims decide whether he really said it?

Mission 1

Three words: Sunnah, Hadith, Sira

Three sourcesThe Qur'anMuslims see it as God's wordlived explanationSunnahthe exampleHadithreports of itcarrySirathe life storycontext
  • Sunnah ("trodden path", custom): the Prophet's example: what he said, did, and silently approved.
  • Hadith ("report", plural ahadith): a single report of one saying or action. Hadiths are how the Sunnah is known.
  • Sira ("way of going", biography): the story of the Prophet's life, told in order.
  • Muslims see the Qur'an as God's word; the Sunnah as the Prophet's lived explanation of it.
  • Eduqas wording: sunna (clear trodden path), hadith (report).
Mission 1Read the source

Why follow the Prophet's example?

> "Ye have indeed in the Messenger of Allah a beautiful pattern (of conduct) for any one whose hope is in Allah and the Final Day" (Qur'an 33:21, Yusuf Ali)

> "He who obeys the Messenger, obeys Allah" (Qur'an 4:80, Yusuf Ali)

  • The Qur'an tells the Prophet to "explain clearly to men" what was revealed (16:44, paraphrase): the Sunnah is that explanation.

Q1 Which verse makes the Prophet a model for how to live?

Show answer

33:21: "a beautiful pattern".

Q2 Which verse ties obedience to the Prophet to obedience to God?

Show answer

4:80.

Mission 1

Anatomy of a hadith

Hadith anatomy and gradesisnad (chain)narratornarratornarratorCompanionthe Prophet (pbuh)matn (text)the words or actionreported????each linkknown?trustworthy?could they meet?the textfits the Qur'anand soundSunnah?Gradesstronger ↓ weakersahih (sound)unbroken chain; trustworthy,accurate narratorshasan (good)as sahih, but one memoryless exactda'if (weak)break in the chain orunreliable narratormawdu' (fabricated)invented: rejectednumber ofchainsmutawatirso manythat error isruled outahadone or afew chains
  • Every hadith has two parts.
  • Isnad (chain, "support"): the names of those who passed the report on, back to the Prophet: "A told me that B told him that C heard the Prophet say…".
  • Matn (text): the words or action reported.
  • Scholars test both: is every link in the chain known, trustworthy and able to have met the next? Does the text fit the Qur'an and well-established Sunnah?
  • The study of narrators ('ilm al-rijal, "knowledge of the men") produced huge biographical dictionaries.
  • Hadith qudsi ("sacred report"): God's words in the Prophet's phrasing. It is not Qur'an: it is not recited in salah as Qur'an.
Quick check
?A scholar finds that one narrator in a chain was born after the person he claims to have heard the report from died. What has the scholar found?
Mission 1

Grading a hadith

Hadith anatomy and gradesisnad (chain)narratornarratornarratorCompanionthe Prophet (pbuh)matn (text)the words or actionreported????each linkknown?trustworthy?could they meet?the textfits the Qur'anand soundSunnah?Gradesstronger ↓ weakersahih (sound)unbroken chain; trustworthy,accurate narratorshasan (good)as sahih, but one memoryless exactda'if (weak)break in the chain orunreliable narratormawdu' (fabricated)invented: rejectednumber ofchainsmutawatirso manythat error isruled outahadone or afew chains
  • Sahih (sound): unbroken chain of trustworthy, accurate narrators; no hidden defect; not contradicting stronger reports.
  • Hasan (good): as sahih, but a narrator's memory is slightly less exact. Still used in law.
  • Da'if (weak): a break in the chain or an unreliable narrator. Many allow it only for encouraging good deeds, not for law.
  • Mawdu' (fabricated): invented. Rejected.
  • By number of chains: mutawatir (mass-transmitted, by so many that error is ruled out) and ahad (single or few chains: most hadiths).
  • Your spec: categories "in relation to the overall reliability of text and chain of transmission".
Mission 1

From memory to collections

Compilation timelineSunni track632the Prophet dies767–820al-Shafi'i810–870al-Bukhari: Sahih al-Bukharid. 875Muslim: Sahih MuslimSix Booksal-Bukhari, Muslim + Abu Dawud,al-Tirmidhi, al-Nasa'i, Ibn MajahShi'a trackd. 941al-Kulayni: al-KafiFour Booksreports from the Prophet and the Imamsof his family; al-Kafi is the first
  • 632 CE: the Prophet dies. Companions remember and teach his words; some write notes.
  • 8th century: reports are gathered; fabrication (for politics, sects, piety) makes scholars insist on chains.
  • 9th century: the great Sunni collections. Muhammad al-Bukhari (810–870) chose only reports he judged sound: Sahih al-Bukhari. With Sahih Muslim (Muslim ibn al-Hajjaj, d. 875) it is the most trusted Sunni book after the Qur'an.
  • Sunni Six Books add Abu Dawud, al-Tirmidhi, al-Nasa'i and Ibn Majah.
  • Shi'a Islam accepts reports from the Prophet and from the Imams of his family, mainly through narrators loyal to them. Its Four Books begin with al-Kafi of al-Kulayni (d. 941).
Quick check
?A report has an unbroken chain, but one narrator is known to make small memory slips. No stronger report contradicts it. How would most Sunni hadith scholars grade it?
Mission 1

The Sunnah in daily life and law

  • The Qur'an commands salah; the Sunnah shows how: times, number of units, words, movements. Likewise zakah rates and Hajj rites.
  • So most Muslims treat the Qur'an and Sunnah as one guidance: the Qur'an supreme, the Sunnah explaining and applying it.
  • Everyday Sunnah: eating with the right hand, greeting with "salam", the call to prayer at a baby's birth, kindness to neighbours.
  • Al-Shafi'i (767–820), al-Risala: the "wisdom" taught alongside the Book (2:151) is the Sunnah; a sound hadith binds, even if it has a single chain. This made the Sunnah the second source of law.
Mission check

?A message goes viral: "The Prophet said: whoever shares this message will have every sin forgiven." It gives no source. How would most Sunni hadith scholars respond?
Mission 2

Mission 2: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Make a guess: The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?

Mission 2

Shari'a and fiqh

Shari'a and fiqhshari'aGod's way (ideal)fiqhhumanunderstanding
  • Shari'a: literally "the path to the water": God's way for human life.
  • "Then We put thee on the (right) Way of Religion: so follow thou that (Way), and follow not the desires of those who know not." (Qur'an 45:18, Yusuf Ali) The Arabic word is shari'ah.
  • It covers worship (prayer, fasting) and dealings (family, trade, food, crime): much more than criminal law.
  • Fiqh ("deep understanding"): the human effort to understand and apply the shari'a. Scholars can err; the shari'a, as God's will, cannot.
  • So Muslims distinguish the ideal (God's shari'a) from law in practice (the jurists' fiqh).
Mission 2

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and Sunnah

Scriptural sources: Qur'an and sunna1 Qur'anthe first source: God's worde.g. commands prayer2 sunnathe Prophet's example, known throughhadith: explains and adds detail (shows howto pray)Shi'a: includes the Imams' teachingsHadith graded by chain and textsahihsoundhasangoodda'ifweak
  • Qur'an: the first source, God's word. Some rulings are clear (no pork, 5:3; fasting in Ramadan, 2:185); many verses give principles (justice, 4:58; consultation, 42:38).
  • Sunnah: the Prophet's example, known through hadith. It explains and adds detail: the Qur'an commands prayer; the Sunnah shows how to pray.
  • "So take what the Messenger assigns to you, and deny yourselves that which he withholds from you." (Qur'an 59:7, Yusuf Ali)
  • Hadith are graded by chain and text: sahih (sound), hasan (good), da'if (weak) (see Mission 1).
  • Shi'a Muslims include the teachings of the Imams within the Sunnah.
  • Eduqas spellings: sunna (clear trodden path), hadith (report).
Mission 2

Non-scriptural sources

The sources of lawSunni1 Qur'anGod's word2 sunnaProphet's example3 ijmaconsensus4 qiyasanalogyTwelver Shi'aQur'ansunna, with theImamsijma, if itreflects theImam's view'aql (reason)no qiyasAlso used: 'urf (custom), istihsan (Hanafi),maslahah (Maliki)
  • Ijma (consensus): agreement of the qualified scholars of an age on a ruling. Once reached, Sunnis treat it as binding ("my community will not agree on error", Ibn Majah; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas (analogy): extending a ruling from a case in the texts to a new case that shares its cause ('illah).
  • 'Urf (custom): local practice accepted where it does not contradict the texts (e.g. customary amounts of dowry). Malik also gave weight to the practice ('amal) of Madinah.
  • Other tools: istihsan (juristic preference, Hanafi), maslahah (public interest, Maliki).
  • Twelver Shi'a jurists: Qur'an, Sunnah (with the Imams), ijma (valid if it reflects the Imam's view) and 'aql (reason); they reject qiyas.
Mission 2Read the source

From wine to every intoxicant

Qiyas: from wine to every intoxicant2:219more harmthan benefit4:43don't prayintoxicated5:90avoidcompletelystages many scholars seeoriginal casewine (forbidden in the texts)cause ('illah)intoxication: it clouds the mindnew casecannabis, cocaine, other drugsrulingharam

> "They ask thee concerning wine and gambling. Say: 'In them is great sin, and some profit, for men; but the sin is greater than the profit.'" (Qur'an 2:219, Yusuf Ali)

> "O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper." (Qur'an 5:90, Yusuf Ali)

  • Many scholars see stages: 2:219 (more harm than benefit), 4:43 (do not pray intoxicated), 5:90 (avoid completely).
  • A hadith: "Every intoxicant is khamr, and every khamr is forbidden" (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Qiyas: original case: wine · cause ('illah): intoxication · new case: cannabis, cocaine, other drugs · ruling: haram.

Q1 Which verse gives the final ruling to avoid intoxicants completely?

Show answer

5:90.

Q2 What shared cause allows the ruling on wine to cover drugs?

Show answer

They intoxicate: they cloud the mind.

Quick check
?Which statement best describes how qiyas works?
Mission 2

Al-Shafi'i: a method for law

Al-Shafi'i and the founders of the Sunni schoolsAbu Hanifa699–767Malik ibn Anasc. 711–795al-Shafi'i767–820Ahmad ibn Hanbal780–855700750800850Al-Shafi'i, al-Risala: set out an order ofsources; called the founder of usul al-fiqh.
  • Muhammad ibn Idris al-Shafi'i (767–820), al-Risala ("The Epistle").
  • Before him, regional scholars (Kufa, Madinah) mixed hadith, local practice and personal opinion (ra'y) in different ways.
  • He set out an order of sources: Qur'an → Sunnah → ijma → qiyas.
  • A sound hadith binds, even if reported by a single chain, because the Sunnah explains the Qur'an (2:151: "Scripture and Wisdom", Yusuf Ali).
  • He limited free opinion and istihsan: reasoning must be tied to a text through qiyas.
  • So he is called the founder of usul al-fiqh (the roots, or method, of jurisprudence).
  • Your spec: "the work of Al-Shafi in devising a methodology for fiqh (deep understanding) of shari'a".
Mission 2

The law schools (madhhabs)

The law schools: where each predominatesHanafiTurkey, Central and South AsiaMalikiNorth and West AfricaShafi'iEgypt, East Africa, South-East AsiaHanbaliSaudi Arabia, QatarJa'fariIran, Iraqshading: named countries · dots: named regionsPredominant school only: most areas aremixed, and many Muslims live elsewhere.
  • Hanafi: Abu Hanifa (699–767), Kufa; wide use of reasoning and istihsan; Turkey, Central and South Asia (most British Muslims of South Asian heritage).
  • Maliki: Malik ibn Anas (c. 711–795), Madinah; al-Muwatta; the practice of Madinah; North and West Africa.
  • Shafi'i: al-Shafi'i; Egypt, East Africa, South-East Asia.
  • Hanbali: Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780–855), Baghdad; text first, cautious about reasoning; Saudi Arabia, Qatar.
  • Ja'fari: Ja'far al-Sadiq (d. 765), the sixth Imam; Twelver Shi'a; Iran, Iraq.
  • They agree on essentials; they differ in detail (e.g. hand position in prayer). Each recognises the others as legitimate.
  • Taqlid: ordinary Muslims follow a school or scholar; ijtihad: qualified jurists derive rulings within its framework.
Mission 2

The five rulings (ahkam)

The five rulings (ahkam)fard / wajibobligatorysalah; fasting in Ramadanmustahabb / mandubrecommendedextra prayers; sadaqahmubahpermittedmost foods; ordinary workmakruhdislikedwasting water in wuduharamforbiddenalcohol, gambling (5:90); pork (5:3)halal (lawful)
  • Fard / wajib (obligatory): rewarded if done, sin if left: salah, fasting in Ramadan.
  • Mustahabb / mandub (recommended): rewarded if done, no sin if left: extra prayers, sadaqah.
  • Mubah (permitted): neutral: most foods, ordinary work.
  • Makruh (disliked): better avoided, no sin if done: e.g. wasting water in wudu; coming to the mosque after eating raw garlic.
  • Haram (forbidden): sin if done: alcohol and gambling (5:90), pork (5:3).
  • Halal: lawful, everything not haram. Modesty: lower the gaze and guard modesty (24:30–31); dress rules derive from these verses and the Sunnah.
  • Killing and eating animals: halal meat is slaughtered with God's name (6:121), a swift cut and draining of blood; scholars differ on pre-stunning.
  • Makruh applied: smoking was long called makruh; as its harm became known, many scholars ruled it haram (harm to self is forbidden).
Quick check
?A Muslim decides not to smoke even though his local imam calls it makruh. Which statement about makruh is accurate?
Mission 2

Interpretation and authority beyond the texts

Authority beyond the textsulamascholarsmuftisissue fatwas(non-binding)madhhabslaw schoolsijtihadqualified juristsderive rulingstaqlidordinary Muslimsfollow a school orscholarThe "gate of ijtihad"Closed after about the 10th century? Acommon Sunni view: yes. Wael Hallaq: juristsnever stopped. Twelver Shi'a: always open.
  • Ulama (scholars), muftis issuing fatwas (non-binding legal opinions), and the schools carry authority beyond the texts.
  • Was the "gate of ijtihad" closed after about the 10th century? A common Sunni view said yes; Wael Hallaq (b. 1955) argues jurists never stopped independent reasoning. Twelver Shi'a always kept ijtihad open.
Mission 2Evaluate

Divine law or human interpretation?

Divine law or human interpretation?Shari'a as Muslims practise it is morehuman interpretation than divine law.ForFiqh is human; the schools disagree;rulings change (smoking); applying oldrulings to new cases needs interpretation.Ijma and qiyas are human methods; stateshave codified and reshaped the law.AgainstThe sources and principles are divine;scholars discover rulings, they do notinvent them.The core (prayer, fasting, the mainprohibitions) is agreed across all schools.A further viewThe limits of human understanding canlead to tolerance of diversity withinMuslim practice.Judge it byWhere is the line between Shari'a and fiqh? ·Does diversity weaken authority or show itsdepth?
  • Claim: Shari'a as Muslims practise it is more human interpretation than divine law.
  • For: fiqh is human; the schools disagree; rulings change (smoking); applying old rulings to new cases needs interpretation.
  • For: ijma and qiyas are human methods; states have codified and reshaped the law.
  • Against: the sources and principles are divine; scholars discover rulings, they do not invent them.
  • Against: the core (prayer, fasting, the main prohibitions) is agreed across all schools.
  • A further view: the limits of human understanding can lead to tolerance of diversity within Muslim practice.
  • Criteria: Where is the line between shari'a and fiqh? Does diversity weaken authority or show its depth?
Mission check

?A new synthetic drug is sold as "not mentioned in any holy book, so permitted". A Sunni mufti rules it haram. Which reasoning is he most likely to use?
Mission 3

Mission 3: The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?

Make a guess: The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?

Mission 3

Shari'a and fiqh

Shari'a and fiqh: two layersShari'aGod's will for human lifeperfect, unchangingFiqhhuman understandingwritten by scholars: can be mistakenijtihad(effort)mujtahid
  • Shari'a: literally "the path to the water"; for Muslims, God's will for human life, perfect and unchanging.
  • Fiqh: literally "understanding"; the human effort to know and apply the shari'a. Fiqh is written by scholars and can be mistaken.
  • Many Muslims hold that the shari'a is the ideal; fiqh is the law in practice.
  • So two scholars can disagree on a ruling without either denying the shari'a.
Mission 3

Ijtihad: effort to find the ruling

Shari'a and fiqh: two layersShari'aGod's will for human lifeperfect, unchangingFiqhhuman understandingwritten by scholars: can be mistakenijtihad(effort)mujtahid
  • Ijtihad: from the root j-h-d, "to strive" (the same root as jihad). The jurist's full effort to derive a ruling from the sources.
  • Mujtahid: a scholar qualified to do this: Arabic, Qur'an, Sunna and its chains, earlier consensus, legal method.
  • A widely cited report: the Prophet asked Mu'adh ibn Jabal how he would judge in Yemen. Qur'an, then Sunna, and if neither answered, he would strive to form his own judgement (Abu Dawud; paraphrase; its chain is debated).
  • A judge who strives and is right has two rewards; one who strives and errs has one reward (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase).
  • So honest effort is rewarded; error made in good faith is not sin.
Mission 3

Taqlid and the madhhab

The law schools (madhhabs)SunniHanafiAbu Hanifad. 767MalikiMalikd. 795Shafi'ial-Shafi'id. 820HanbaliAhmad ibn Hanbald. 855Twelver Shi'aJa'fariJa'far al-Sadiqd. 765Main areas today (colours as the cards)Approximate: most areas are mixed.
  • Taqlid: following a qualified scholar's ruling without examining all the evidence yourself (literally "imitation").
  • Most Muslims are not mujtahids, so most practise taqlid, usually of a madhhab (school of law).
  • Sunni schools: Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali. Twelver Shi'a: the Ja'fari school.
  • Defenders: taqlid is like trusting a doctor; it protects ordinary believers from amateur rulings.
  • Critics: rigid taqlid can freeze the law and repeat past mistakes (more in Mission 4).
Quick check
?A Muslim student in Leeds follows the Hanafi school's ruling on shortening prayers when travelling, without studying the hadith herself. What is she practising?
Mission 3

Three roles of shari'a

  • Civil law: in some states, parts of shari'a are law (e.g. family law in many Muslim-majority countries).
  • Religious law: rules of worship (prayer, fasting, zakah) that Muslims keep wherever they live.
  • Moral guide: a way of life and conscience, kept voluntarily, e.g. by Muslims in Britain under British law.
  • The mujtahid gives rulings; most believers follow them by taqlid.
  • Eduqas issue: is "law" a misleading word for shari'a, if it is also worship and ethics?
Mission 3Read the source

Wine and every intoxicant

> "O ye who believe! Intoxicants and gambling, (dedication of) stones, and (divination by) arrows, are an abomination,- of Satan's handwork: eschew such (abomination), that ye may prosper." (Qur'an 5:90, Yusuf Ali)

  • The Prophet is reported to have said: every intoxicant is khamr (wine), and every intoxicant is forbidden (Muslim; paraphrase).
  • Also: what intoxicates in a large amount is forbidden in a small amount (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi; paraphrase).

Q1 Is heroin named in 5:90?

Show answer

No. The verse names wine/intoxicants, gambling and idolatrous practices.

Q2 Which word in the hadith lets jurists reach beyond wine?

Show answer

Every intoxicant: the property of intoxicating, not the drink itself.

Mission 3

Drugs by qiyas

Qiyas: from wine to new drugsOriginal case (asl)wine: forbidden by text (5:90)Effective cause ('illa)intoxication: it clouds the mindNew case (far')heroin, cannabisRuling (hukm)same cause, same ruling: haram
  • Qiyas: analogy. Four parts:
  • Original case (asl): wine, forbidden by text.
  • New case (far'): e.g. cannabis, heroin, cocaine.
  • Effective cause ('illa): intoxication, which clouds the mind and keeps people from remembering God.
  • Ruling (hukm): the new case shares the cause, so it shares the ruling: haram.
  • Medical use differs: many jurists permit anaesthetics and pain relief, as necessity (2:173) and not for intoxication.
Quick check
?In the qiyas that extends the ban on wine to heroin, what is the 'illa (effective cause)?
Mission 3

Usury and banking

  • The Qur'an forbids riba (usury): "Allah hath permitted trade and forbidden usury" (Qur'an 2:275, Yusuf Ali).
  • "Devour not usury, doubled and multiplied" (Qur'an 3:130, Yusuf Ali).
  • Ijtihad question: is all bank interest riba, or only exploitative, multiplying interest?
  • Majority view: any fixed, guaranteed return on a loan is riba (major fiqh councils in the 20th century).
  • Minority view: some scholars allowed fixed returns on modest savings, or defined riba as exploitation of the needy.
  • Response: Islamic banking shares profit and risk instead of charging interest, e.g. murabaha (cost-plus sale), ijara (leasing), mudaraba (profit-sharing).
Mission 3

Tobacco: from dispute to consensus

Tobacco: from dispute to consensusc. 1600Tobacco reaches Muslimlands; no text names itEarly juristsDisagree: haram / makruh /mubah20thcenturyScience: smoking causescancer, heart disease,addictionTodayMany fatwa bodies: haram;others still say makruhThe texts did not change; new knowledgechanged the ijtihad.
  • Tobacco reached Muslim lands around 1600. No text names it.
  • Early jurists disagreed: haram (it harms, wastes money, may intoxicate); makruh (it smells, like raw garlic); mubah (no proof of harm).
  • 20th century: scientific findings showed smoking causes cancer, heart disease and addiction.
  • Principle: there is to be no harm and no returning harm (Ibn Majah; Malik; paraphrase); "make not your own hands contribute to (your) destruction" (Qur'an 2:195, Yusuf Ali).
  • So a growing consensus: many fatwa bodies now call smoking haram; others still say makruh.
  • The texts did not change; new knowledge changed the ijtihad.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does human interpretation get in the way?

Does human interpretation get in the way?Human interpretation impairsunderstanding of the shari'a.ForFiqh is fallible: scholars carry their era'scustoms and blind spots into rulings.Disagreement between schools canconfuse believers about what God wants.AgainstWithout ijtihad, the shari'a could notspeak to heroin, banks or tobacco.Limits of interpretation make room fortolerance of diversity: honest error isrewarded.Judge it byIs fiqh a barrier to shari'a or the only way toit? · Who is qualified to interpret? · Do newsciences make ijtihad more or less reliable?
  • Claim: Human interpretation impairs understanding of the shari'a.
  • For: fiqh is fallible; scholars of one era carry its customs and blind spots into rulings.
  • For: disagreement between schools can confuse believers about what God wants.
  • Against: without ijtihad, the shari'a could not speak to heroin, banks or tobacco at all.
  • Against: the limits of interpretation make room for tolerance of diversity: the reward for honest error (Bukhari, Muslim).
  • Judge it by: Is fiqh a barrier to shari'a or the only way to it? Who is qualified to interpret? Do new sciences make ijtihad more or less reliable?
  • Eduqas issue: the extent to which human interpretation may impair understanding of shari'a.
Mission check

?A Shafi'i Muslim believes that touching his wife breaks his wudu; his Hanafi friend believes it does not. How would most Sunni scholars describe this disagreement?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Was the door to new Islamic rulings shut a thousand years ago, and who wants it open?

Make a guess: Was the door to new Islamic rulings shut a thousand years ago, and who wants it open?

Mission 4

Sunni Islam: the "gate of ijtihad"

The gate of ijtihad: Sunni and Shi'aSunniabsolute ijtihad:"gate closed"absolute mujtahidmujtahid within aschooljurist who rules oncasesmuqallid (follows bytaqlid)ijtihad within theschools went onShi'aijtihad neverclosedliving marja' al-taqlidbelievers (taqlid)
  • By about the 10th century the four Sunni schools were settled.
  • Many later jurists said that absolute ijtihad (founding a new method from the sources) had ended: the "closing of the gate of ijtihad".
  • Scholars after that were ranked: absolute mujtahid · mujtahid within a school · jurist who rules on cases · muqallid (follower by taqlid).
  • But ijtihad within the schools went on: new fatwas on trade, new lands, tobacco.
  • Some scholars always rejected rigid taqlid, e.g. Ibn Taymiyya (1263–1328).
  • Wael Hallaq argued in 1984 that the gate was never closed in theory or practice ("Was the Gate of Ijtihad Closed?").
Mission 4

Shi'a Islam: ijtihad never closed

The gate of ijtihad: Sunni and Shi'aSunniabsolute ijtihad:"gate closed"absolute mujtahidmujtahid within aschooljurist who rules oncasesmuqallid (follows bytaqlid)ijtihad within theschools went onShi'aijtihad neverclosedliving marja' al-taqlidbelievers (taqlid)
  • Twelver Shi'a hold that during the Occultation of the twelfth Imam, qualified jurists act as his general deputies.
  • So ijtihad is a continuing duty. The Usuli school, dominant since the late 18th century, insists on it.
  • Every believer who is not a mujtahid must follow a living mujtahid by taqlid: a marja' al-taqlid ("source of imitation"), a grand ayatollah, e.g. Ali al-Sistani in Najaf.
  • Each marja' publishes a book of rulings; believers may pay khums through his office.
  • The Akhbari minority distrusted ijtihad and relied on the reports (akhbar) of the Imams.
  • Shi'a jurists use reason ('aql) as a source in place of open-ended qiyas.
Quick check
?Which statement describes most Twelver Shi'a teaching on ijtihad and taqlid today?
Mission 4Diversity

Sunni and Shi'a compared

Sunni and Shi'a views on ijtihad comparedSunniTwelver Shi'a (Usuli)Who may do ijtihad?qualified scholars;many classical jurists:only within a schoolqualified mujtahids,alwaysWhom do lay believers follow?a madhhab, oftenthrough a localscholar or muftione living marja'Dead scholars?founders long deadare still followedmost: may not begintaqlid of a deadmujtahidMethodsQur'an, Sunna, ijma,qiyasQur'an, Sunna (incl.the Imams), ijma, 'aqlSharedBoth forbid unqualified people from ruling;both accept honest disagreement.
  • Who may do ijtihad? Sunni: qualified scholars; many classical jurists said only within a school. Shi'a: qualified mujtahids, always.
  • Whom do lay believers follow? Sunni: a madhhab, often through a local scholar or mufti. Shi'a: one living marja'.
  • Dead scholars? Sunni: founders long dead are still followed. Shi'a (Usuli): most say a believer may not begin taqlid of a dead mujtahid.
  • Methods: Sunni: Qur'an, Sunna, ijma, qiyas. Shi'a: Qur'an, Sunna (including the Imams), ijma, 'aql.
  • Shared: both forbid unqualified people from ruling; both accept honest disagreement.
Mission 4

Rashid Rida: back to the sources

Two reformers: Rida and An-Na'imMuhammad Rashid Rida1865Born in Ottoman SyriaCairoWorks in Cairo; student ofMuhammad Abduh1898–1935Edits the journal al-Manar1935Dies; had called for arenewed caliphateAbdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im1946Born in SudanTeacherBuilds on MahmoudMohamed Taha1990Toward an IslamicReformation2008Islam and the Secular State
  • Muhammad Rashid Rida (1865–1935), born in Ottoman Syria, worked in Cairo; student of Muhammad Abduh; editor of the journal al-Manar (1898–1935).
  • A Salafi reformer: return to the Qur'an, the authentic Sunna and the salaf (the first generations).
  • Attacked blind taqlid and loyalty to one madhhab, which he blamed for Muslim decline.
  • Distinguished worship (fixed by text) from social dealings (mu'amalat), where ijtihad based on public interest (maslaha) may make new rules.
  • Such rules should be made by qualified scholars and leaders in consultation (shura).
  • Wanted a renewed caliphate and shari'a as the law of Muslim states.
Mission 4

An-Na'im: reform and a secular state

Two reformers: Rida and An-Na'imMuhammad Rashid Rida1865Born in Ottoman SyriaCairoWorks in Cairo; student ofMuhammad Abduh1898–1935Edits the journal al-Manar1935Dies; had called for arenewed caliphateAbdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im1946Born in SudanTeacherBuilds on MahmoudMohamed Taha1990Toward an IslamicReformation2008Islam and the Secular State
  • Abdullahi Ahmed An-Na'im (b. 1946), Sudanese-born professor of law at Emory University.
  • Toward an Islamic Reformation (1990): building on his teacher Mahmoud Mohamed Taha, he argues the universal message of the Makkan Qur'an should guide law today, rather than Madinan rules suited to the 7th century.
  • So ijtihad must reach even areas with clear texts (classical fiqh said: no ijtihad where a clear text exists).
  • Aim: equality of women and non-Muslims, and human rights, from within Islam.
  • Islam and the Secular State (2008): if the state enforces shari'a, obedience is no longer free and religious; the state should be neutral, and Muslims follow shari'a by conviction.
Mission 4Read the source

Refer it to Allah and His Messenger

> "O ye who believe! Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger, and those charged with authority among you. If ye differ in anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger" (Qur'an 4:59, Yusuf Ali)

  • Rida read "those charged with authority" as the people of standing (scholars and leaders) who decide public matters together.

Q1 According to 4:59, where should disagreements be taken?

Show answer

To Allah and His Messenger: the Qur'an and the Sunna.

Q2 Why might this verse support ijtihad rather than taqlid?

Show answer

It sends believers back to the sources, not to a later school.

Quick check
?Which statement fits Rashid Rida but not An-Na'im?
Mission 4Evaluate

Are the doors of ijtihad closed?

Are the doors of ijtihad closed?The doors of ijtihad are closed.ForThe four schools already cover almostevery question; repeating them protectsunity.Few scholars today master all the sciencesa classical mujtahid needed.AgainstShi'a jurists have practised ijtihad withoutbreak; Sunni fatwas on IVF, banking andtobacco are ijtihad in all but name.Reformers from Ibn Taymiyya to Rida andAn-Na'im argue Islam requires it; Hallaqargues the gate never closed.Judge it byWhat counts as ijtihad: founding a method, orapplying one? · Who is qualified? · Is "closed"a historical claim or a recommendation?
  • Claim: The doors of ijtihad are closed.
  • For: the four schools already cover almost every question; repeating them protects unity.
  • For: few scholars today master all the sciences a classical mujtahid needed.
  • Against: Shi'a jurists have practised ijtihad without break; Sunni fatwas on IVF, banking and tobacco are ijtihad in all but name.
  • Against: reformers from Ibn Taymiyya to Rida and An-Na'im argue Islam requires it; Hallaq argues the gate never closed.
  • Judge it by: What counts as ijtihad: founding a method, or applying one? Who is qualified? Is "closed" a historical claim or a recommendation?
Mission 4Worked answer

Comparing two reformers

Comparing two reformers: answer chainPointBoth reject blind taqlid.DevelopmentEach argues the law of past jurists is humanfiqh, not the shari'a itself.contrastPointThey differ on the goal.DevelopmentRida returns to the salaf and wants shari'a asstate law; An-Na'im reads the Makkanmessage for today and wants a neutral state.Source4:59: refer disputes to Allah and HisMessenger; Rida reads "authority" as scholarsand leaders in consultation.

Task: Examine the approaches of Rashid Rida and An-Na'im to ijtihad.

  • Point: Both reject blind taqlid. Development: each argues the law of past jurists is human fiqh, not the shari'a itself.
  • Point: They differ on the goal. Development: Rida returns to the salaf and wants shari'a as state law; An-Na'im reads the Makkan message for today and wants a neutral state.
  • Source: 4:59: refer disputes to Allah and His Messenger; Rida reads "authority" as scholars and leaders in consultation.
  • AO1 tip: name the scholar, the work and the date, then explain one idea each and the contrast.
Quick check
?Why does An-Na'im argue the state should not enforce shari'a?
Mission check

?A Muslim couple in Birmingham ask whether a new kind of pension fund is lawful. Ahmed, who is Sunni, consults his local mufti, who follows Hanafi rulings. Zainab, who is Twelver Shi'a, checks the rulings of her marja'. What does this show?
Mission 5

Mission 5: Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?

Make a guess: Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?

Mission 5

Jihad means striving

Jihad means strivingjihadstrivingself (nafs)greater jihadtongue and pentruth, teachingwealthgivingarmed strugglelesser jihad
  • Jihad: from j-h-d, "to strive, to make an effort". Not the word for "holy war".
  • "And those who strive in Our (cause),- We will certainly guide them to our Paths" (Qur'an 29:69, Yusuf Ali).
  • Forms of jihad: of the self (nafs); of the tongue and pen (speaking truth, teaching); of wealth (giving); and armed struggle.
  • "Strive in His cause as ye ought to strive" (Qur'an 22:78, Yusuf Ali).
  • Tradition: greater jihad (al-jihad al-akbar): struggle with the self; lesser jihad (al-jihad al-asghar): armed struggle.
Mission 5

Greater jihad: the nafs

Three states of the nafsincitingto evil12:53self-reproaching(conscience)75:2at peace89:27greater jihad:a lifelong climb
  • Nafs: the self, the ego with its desires.
  • Three states named from the Qur'an: the soul inciting to evil (12:53); the self-reproaching soul, conscience (75:2); the soul at peace (89:27).
  • Greater jihad: lifelong effort to move the self towards peace with God: prayer, fasting, honesty, controlling anger and greed.
  • The Prophet is reported to have said that the true striver (mujahid) is the one who strives against his own self for God (Tirmidhi; paraphrase).
  • A popular report calls returning from battle a return "from the lesser jihad to the greater" (al-Bayhaqi; paraphrase; many scholars grade it weak).
Mission 5Read the source

Purifying the self

> "Truly he succeeds that purifies it, And he fails that corrupts it!" (Qur'an 91:9–10, Yusuf Ali)

> "And for such as had entertained the fear of standing before their Lord's (tribunal) and had restrained (their) soul from lower desires" (Qur'an 79:40, Yusuf Ali)

Q1 What decides success in 91:9–10?

Show answer

Whether a person purifies or corrupts the soul.

Q2 What motive for self-control does 79:40 give?

Show answer

Awareness of standing before God at Judgement.

Quick check
?Which of these is the clearest example of greater jihad?
Mission 5

Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time

Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time610–622Makkah: persecution, nofighting; patience andpreaching622Hijrah to Madinah; permissionto fight: "they are wronged"(22:39)624Battle of Badr625Battle of Uhud627Battle of the Trench628Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: peaceon hard terms630Makkah taken almost withoutfighting; general amnesty
  • Makkah (610–622): persecution, but no fighting; patience and preaching.
  • 622: the hijrah to Madinah. Permission to fight comes because the Muslims "are wronged" (22:39).
  • Battles: Badr (624), Uhud (625), the Trench (627).
  • 628: Treaty of Hudaybiyyah: a peace accepted on hard terms.
  • 630: Makkah taken almost without fighting; a general amnesty.
  • Jurists made lesser jihad a communal duty of the ummah (fard kifaya), led by legitimate authority; it becomes an individual duty if the land is invaded.
Mission 5Read the source

Close reading

Reading 9:5 in context9:4treaties kept stand9:5fight the treaty-breakers9:6grant asylum to any who askMost scholars read 9:5 with its context: Arabpolytheists who broke treaties.

> "To those against whom war is made, permission is given (to fight), because they are wronged" (Qur'an 22:39, Yusuf Ali)

> "Fight in the cause of Allah those who fight you, but do not transgress limits; for Allah loveth not transgressors." (Qur'an 2:190, Yusuf Ali)

> "But if the enemy incline towards peace, do thou (also) incline towards peace, and trust in Allah" (Qur'an 8:61, Yusuf Ali)

  • Verses often quoted alone, e.g. 9:5 ("slay the Pagans wherever ye find them"), are read by most scholars in context: Arab polytheists who broke treaties (9:4 exempts those who kept them; 9:13 names those who "took the aggressive"); 9:6 orders asylum for any who ask.

Q1 In 22:39, what is the reason fighting is permitted?

Show answer

The believers have been wronged and attacked.

Q2 Which two limits do 2:190 and 8:61 set?

Show answer

No transgression; accept peace when the enemy offers it.

Mission 5

Conditions of lesser jihad

Conditions of lesser jihadJust causedefence or ending oppression; neverforcing faithLegitimate authoritya recognised leader, not individualsRight intentionfor God and justice, not gain or revengeLast resort and proportion"do not transgress limits" (2:190)Protect non-combatantsno killing women, children or the oldStop when the enemy seeks peace8:61; treat prisoners humanely
  • Just cause: defence, or ending oppression of the weak (4:75), never forcing faith: "no compulsion in religion" (2:256).
  • Legitimate authority: declared by a recognised leader, not by individuals.
  • Right intention: for God and justice, not gain or revenge.
  • Last resort and proportion: "do not transgress limits" (2:190).
  • Protect non-combatants: the Prophet forbade killing women and children (Bukhari, Muslim; paraphrase); Abu Bakr told his commanders not to kill the old or children, cut fruit trees or destroy buildings (Malik, Muwatta; paraphrase).
  • Stop when the enemy seeks peace (8:61); treat prisoners humanely.
Quick check
?A militia leader with no state behind him declares a "jihad" and attacks a market full of civilians. Which two classical conditions does this most clearly break?
Mission 5Diversity

Defensive, expansionist, suspended

  • Classical Sunni jurists (c. 8th–12th centuries) divided the world into dar al-Islam and dar al-harb and allowed wars of expansion led by the caliph, alongside truces.
  • Many modern Sunni scholars read the Qur'an as permitting defensive war only; expansion reflected the empires of its time.
  • Twelver Shi'a: most jurists hold that offensive jihad needs the presence of the infallible Imam, so it is suspended during the Occultation; defensive jihad remains.
  • Sufi teachers stress the inner jihad above all.
  • Ahmadiyya Muslims teach that armed jihad for religion is not permitted today; jihad of the pen is the duty of the age.
  • Eduqas: the historical context of lesser jihad shapes how it is applied now.
Mission 5

Modern warfare and WMD

  • Nuclear, chemical and biological weapons cannot tell soldiers from civilians: they break non-combatant protection.
  • They destroy crops, animals and land for generations: compare the condemnation of one who would "destroy crops and cattle" (2:205).
  • So most scholars hold their use haram; some allow possession only as a deterrent.
  • Iran's Supreme Leader is reported to have issued a fatwa forbidding nuclear weapons; Pakistan holds them for deterrence.
  • Other problems today: who is the "legitimate authority" when Muslims live in many nation-states? Drones and remote war? Wars between Muslim states?
Mission 5

Terrorism is not jihad

  • Terrorism: violence against civilians to spread fear for political goals.
  • Mainstream scholars across Sunni and Shi'a Islam reject calling it jihad: no legitimate authority, civilians targeted, suicide forbidden (4:29).
  • "If any one slew a person - unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the land - it would be as if he slew the whole people" (Qur'an 5:32, Yusuf Ali).
  • Examples: the Amman Message (2004–05); Tahir-ul-Qadri's Fatwa on Terrorism and Suicide Bombings (2010); scholars' open letter to the leader of ISIS (2014).
  • Groups that use the word for terror are a small minority, condemned by most Muslim bodies; many of their victims are Muslims.
Quick check
?Why do most Muslim scholars hold that using a nuclear weapon could not be a lawful lesser jihad?
Mission 5Evaluate

Is lesser jihad still relevant?

Is lesser jihad still relevant?The teachings on lesser jihad have norelevance today.ForModern weapons make the conditionsalmost impossible to meet.Misuse of the word by terrorists harmsMuslims; some argue the inner jihadshould be stressed instead.AgainstThe conditions are a just-war ethic thatcan limit modern war: protect civilians,accept peace, use proportion.Muslims still face invasion and oppression;the right of defence (22:39) still matters.Judge it byAre the principles separable from the7th-century setting? · Who has authoritynow? · Does stressing the greater jihadanswer the misuse?
  • Claim: The teachings on lesser jihad have no relevance today.
  • For: modern weapons make the conditions almost impossible to meet.
  • For: the misuse of the word by terrorists harms Muslims; some argue the inner jihad should be stressed instead.
  • Against: the conditions are a just-war ethic that can limit modern war: protect civilians, accept peace, use proportion.
  • Against: Muslims still face invasion and oppression; the right of defence (22:39) still matters.
  • Judge it by: Are the principles separable from the 7th-century setting? Who has authority now? Does stressing the greater jihad answer the misuse?
  • Eduqas issues: misunderstandings of the term jihad; the relevance today of the teachings about lesser jihad.
Mission check

?Amina, a nurse, starts each long night shift tired and short-tempered. She makes herself pray, stay patient with difficult patients and refuse to cut corners. Most Muslims would describe this as:
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Sunnah is the Prophet's example; Hadith are the reports that carry it, each with an isnad (chain) and matn (text); Sira is his biography.
  • Scholars grade hadiths (sahih, hasan, da'if, mawdu'); al-Bukhari and Muslim compiled the most trusted Sunni collections; Shi'a Muslims have their own Four Books.

Mission 2

  • Shari'a is God's way; fiqh is the human understanding of it. Sources: Qur'an and Sunnah, then ijma, qiyas and custom (Twelvers: reason instead of qiyas).
  • Al-Shafi'i (767–820) set the order of sources; five schools (Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali, Ja'fari) apply them.
  • Every act falls under five rulings: obligatory, recommended, permitted, disliked (makruh), forbidden (haram).

Mission 3

  • For Muslims, shari'a is God's ideal; fiqh is human understanding of it, reached by ijtihad and followed by taqlid within a madhhab.
  • Ijtihad in practice: qiyas extends the wine ban to drugs; scholars debate whether bank interest is riba; science moved the ruling on tobacco.
  • Shari'a works as civil law, religious law and moral guide; the mujtahid interprets, most believers follow by taqlid.

Mission 4

  • Classical Sunni jurists spoke of a closed gate of absolute ijtihad; ijtihad within schools continued, and Hallaq argues the gate never closed.
  • Usuli Shi'a: ijtihad is ongoing; believers follow a living marja' al-taqlid.
  • Rida: ijtihad by returning to the salaf, shari'a as state law; An-Na'im: Makkan principles and a neutral state.

Mission 5

  • Jihad = striving: greater (against the nafs) and lesser (armed, under conditions).
  • Lesser jihad in the Prophet's time was a response to persecution and attack, limited by the Qur'an (22:39, 2:190, 8:61) and the Prophet's rules.
  • Most scholars hold WMD and terrorism break the conditions; whether lesser jihad is relevant today is debated.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Islam: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1A message says "the Prophet said…". How do Muslims decide whether he really said it?
  2. Mission 2The Qur'an never mentions cocaine. How do Muslim scholars know it is forbidden?
  3. Mission 3The Qur'an forbids wine. Who decides whether that covers heroin, bank interest or a cigarette?
  4. Mission 4Was the door to new Islamic rulings shut a thousand years ago, and who wants it open?
  5. Mission 5Why do Muslims call the fight against your own selfishness the "greater" jihad?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas