🚀 Christianity: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2)
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Religious Studies (A120) · Option A Christianity – Theme 4: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson
Christianity: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2)
4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Mission 1Christians belong to thousands of separate churches. Can they be one again, and what would "one" mean?
Mission 2How did a small prayer meeting in Los Angeles become a quarter of world Christianity?
Mission 3In the 1960s, priests in Latin America said God takes the side of the poor. What did they mean?
Mission 4Liberation theologians borrowed ideas from Marx, an atheist. How did the Catholic Church respond?
Mission 1
Mission 1: Christians belong to thousands of separate churches. Can they be one again, and what would "one" mean?
Make a guess: Christians belong to thousands of separate churches. Can they be one again, and what would "one" mean?
Mission 1
What ecumenism is
Ecumenism (Greek oikoumenē, "the whole inhabited world"): the movement to restore unity among Christian churches.
Main families: Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant (Anglican, Lutheran, Reformed, Methodist, Baptist …), Pentecostal, and many independent churches.
Divisions come from history (1054 East–West schism; 16th-century Reformation) and from doctrine: authority, sacraments, ministry.
Ecumenism asks: what unity do Christians already share, and what would visible unity look like?
Unity can mean organic union (churches merging into one) or spiritual ecumenism (praying and working together while staying separate). The World Council of Churches (1948) is a fellowship of churches with no authority over them.
Mission 1Read the source
Jesus' prayer for unity
> "that they may all be one; even as you, Father, are in me, and I in you, that they also may be one in us; that the world may believe that you sent me." (John 17:21, WEBBE)
> "There is one body and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling, one Lord, one faith, one baptism" (Ephesians 4:4–5, WEBBE)
John 17:21 is often called the charter of the ecumenical movement.
Q1 What reason does Jesus give for unity in John 17:21?
Show answer
So that the world may believe: division harms Christian witness.
Q2 Which shared practice does Ephesians 4:5 name, often used today as a basis for mutual recognition?
Show answer
One baptism.
Mission 1
From Edinburgh 1910 to Amsterdam 1948
Step 1 of 3
1910 World Missionary Conference, Edinburgh: rival missions realised that division undermined mission. It set up a Continuation Committee.
Three streams followed:
Mission: International Missionary Council (1921).
Life and Work (Stockholm, 1925; Swedish Lutheran Archbishop Nathan Söderblom): churches acting together on social questions.
Faith and Order (Lausanne, 1927; American Episcopal Bishop Charles Brent, a delegate at Edinburgh): working through doctrinal differences.
1948: Life and Work and Faith and Order merged to form the World Council of Churches (WCC), founded at Amsterdam. The International Missionary Council joined in 1961 (New Delhi).
Mission 1
The World Council of Churches
A fellowship of churches, not a super-church: it has no authority over members. Based in Geneva; over 350 member churches (Protestant, Anglican, Orthodox and others).
Basis (expanded in 1961): churches that confess "the Lord Jesus Christ as God and Saviour according to the scriptures", to the glory of the one God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit (paraphrase with short phrase).
Rationale: Christ's prayer (John 17:21); credible witness; peace after two world wars.
Your spec's three areas of work:
Unity, Mission and Ecumenical Relations: e.g. Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (Lima, 1982), the convergence text of Faith and Order.
Public Witness and Diakonia (service): peace, human rights, refugees, climate justice; the Programme to Combat Racism (1969) against apartheid.
Ecumenical Formation: training leaders, e.g. the Ecumenical Institute at Bossey (1946), near Geneva.
Quick check
?Which statement about the World Council of Churches is accurate?
Mission 1
Why the Catholic Church is not a member
Catholic teaching: the one Church of Christ "subsists in" the Catholic Church (Vatican II, Lumen Gentium 8, 1964). It cannot join as one member church among many.
Practical reasons too: its size, and its worldwide structure under the Pope differ from national member churches.
Yet since Vatican II (Unitatis Redintegratio, 1964) Catholics are committed to ecumenism: a Joint Working Group with the WCC (since 1965); full members of the Faith and Order Commission (since 1968); popes visited Geneva (1969, 1984, 2018).
In Britain, Catholics are full members of Churches Together in England (1990).
Others outside or uneasy: many Pentecostal and evangelical churches are not members; some Orthodox churches (Georgia, Bulgaria) left in the late 1990s, and a special commission changed WCC decision-making to consensus (adopted 2006).
Mission 1Diversity
How denominations view each other
Catholic: other Christians are "separated brethren", in real but imperfect communion with the Catholic Church through baptism (Unitatis Redintegratio 3). Dominus Iesus (2000): Protestant communities are not "Churches in the proper sense".
Orthodox: the Orthodox Church is the one Church; other Christians are valued, but sharing communion requires unity in faith.
Anglican: sees itself as part of the one Church; dialogues with Catholics (ARCIC, since 1970), communion with Nordic and Baltic Lutherans (Porvoo, 1990s), covenant with Methodists (2003).
Evangelical: unity is first spiritual, in the gospel; the Evangelical Alliance (1846) links individuals across denominations. Some evangelicals reject the WCC as doctrinally too broad.
Quick check
?How does Catholic teaching since Vatican II describe Protestant Christians?
Mission 1
Models of unity and what has changed
Organic union: churches merge: Church of South India (1947: Anglicans, Methodists, Reformed); United Reformed Church (1972).
Conciliar fellowship (WCC Nairobi, 1975): churches stay distinct but fully recognise one another.
Reconciled diversity: differences remain, no longer dividing (Lutheran idea).
Agreements: Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (Lutheran–Catholic, 1999), touching the issue at the heart of the Reformation.
Local and spiritual ecumenism: Local Ecumenical Partnerships; Week of Prayer for Christian Unity; Taizé; joint social action.
Receptive ecumenism (Paul Murray, Durham, 2006): each church asks what it can learn from others, not what others must change.
Mission 1Evaluate
Has the ecumenical movement succeeded?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: The ecumenical movement has failed to unite Christianity.
For: Visible unity has not come: Catholics, Orthodox and most Protestants still cannot share Communion together.
For: New divisions (e.g. over women's ordination and sexuality) have opened, even within denominations.
Against: Hostility has largely given way to cooperation: shared prayer, Bible translation, social action, mutual recognition of baptism.
Against: Historic disputes have narrowed (Joint Declaration, 1999; Catholic–Orthodox lifting of the 1054 excommunications, 1965).
Judgement criteria: What is the goal: one structure, or reconciled diversity? Is spiritual unity enough? Do non-members (Catholics, Pentecostals) count as part of the movement?
Issues in your spec: whether the WCC's work is a success or a failure; how far Catholic non-membership affects its aims.
Quick check
?Which is an example of organic union?
Mission check
?In a Northern Irish town, a Catholic parish, a Presbyterian church and a Church of Ireland parish run a joint foodbank, hold a shared service of prayer each January, and study the Bible together. They still celebrate Communion separately. Which description fits best?
Unity can mean merging, recognising or simply working together; Christians still disagree about which one Christ's prayer requires.
Mission 2
Mission 2: How did a small prayer meeting in Los Angeles become a quarter of world Christianity?
Make a guess: How did a small prayer meeting in Los Angeles become a quarter of world Christianity?
Mission 2
Roots: Topeka and Azusa Street
Step 1 of 6
1901, Topeka, Kansas: at Charles Parham's Bible school, Agnes Ozman speaks in tongues. Parham teaches tongues as the "initial evidence" of baptism in the Spirit.
1906–c. 1909, Azusa Street, Los Angeles:William J. Seymour (1870–1922), an African American preacher, leads a revival in a former stable building. Meetings for hours each day, Black and white, rich and poor, women and men together: unusual in segregated America.
Missionaries and a newspaper, The Apostolic Faith, spread it to Europe, Africa, Asia and Latin America within a few years.
Pentecostal denominations form: Church of God in Christ (Pentecostal from 1907), Assemblies of God (USA, 1914), Elim (UK, 1915).
Roots also in the Holiness movement and earlier revivals (e.g. Wales, 1904–05).
Mission 2Read the source
The Spirit at Pentecost
> "Tongues like fire appeared and were distributed to them, and one sat on each of them. They were all filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak." (Acts 2:3–4, WEBBE)
> "But to each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the profit of all." (1 Corinthians 12:7, WEBBE)
Paul then lists gifts: wisdom, knowledge, faith, healings, miracles, prophecy, discerning of spirits, languages (tongues) and their interpretation (1 Corinthians 12:8–10).
Q1 Why do Pentecostals take their name from Acts 2?
Show answer
They expect the same filling with the Spirit, with tongues, today.
Q2 According to 1 Corinthians 12:7, who are the gifts for?
Show answer
For the good of the whole community, not for private status.
Mission 2
Main beliefs
Baptism in the Holy Spirit: a powerful experience of being filled with the Spirit. Classical Pentecostals: a second experience after conversion, usually shown by speaking in tongues (glossolalia).
Gifts of the Spirit (charismata, hence "charismatic") are for today: tongues, prophecy, healing, words of knowledge.
The "Fourfold Gospel": Jesus as Saviour, Baptiser in the Spirit, Healer and Coming King.
The Bible as the authority; personal conversion; evangelism.
Not all Pentecostals agree that tongues are the necessary evidence; many charismatics do not.
Mission 2
The Charismatic Movement after 1960
Step 1 of 6
Charismatic = Pentecostal-style experience inside the historic churches, without leaving them.
1960:Dennis Bennett, an Episcopal priest in Van Nuys, California, tells his congregation he has spoken in tongues; the news spreads nationally.
1964 (UK): Anglican Michael Harper founds the Fountain Trust to support renewal across denominations.
1967: the Duquesne Weekend (Pittsburgh) begins the Catholic Charismatic Renewal.
1980s–90s: John Wimber's Vineyard churches ("signs and wonders"); the "Toronto Blessing" (1994); the Alpha course (Holy Trinity Brompton, London) with its Holy Spirit weekend.
Charismatics in sacramental churches often see Spirit baptism as a release of grace already given in baptism and confirmation, not a second blessing.
Quick check
?What best distinguishes the Charismatic Movement from classical Pentecostalism?
Mission 2
Impact on believers and communities
Believers: a sense of God's closeness, assurance, healing, freedom from addiction; a new moral discipline.
Lay empowerment: anyone can receive gifts and minister; in many churches women preach and lead (e.g. Aimee Semple McPherson, 1920s), though others restrict leadership.
Communities: support for migrants (jobs, housing, language, belonging); growth where other churches decline; renewal in historic churches (e.g. Alpha).
Tensions: congregations split over tongues in the 1960s–70s; authoritarian leaders in some churches.
Prosperity gospel: some teach that faith brings health and wealth; many Pentecostals and other Christians criticise this as unbiblical.
Cessationists (e.g. B. B. Warfield, Counterfeit Miracles, 1918) argue that miraculous gifts ended with the apostles (cf. 1 Corinthians 13:8).
Quick check
?Which factor has most helped Pentecostal churches spread among migrants in European cities?
Mission 2
Challenge 1: can the experience be verified?
Verification: a claim is meaningful or justified only if it can be checked by experience others can test (logical positivism: A. J. Ayer, 1910–1989, Language, Truth and Logic, 1936).
A person who says "the Holy Spirit filled me" reports a private experience. How could anyone else, or even the person, check that the cause is God?
Counterfeits: Paul himself requires "discerning of spirits" (1 Corinthians 12:10) and order in worship (1 Corinthians 14:27, 40).
Response:Richard Swinburne (b. 1934), The Existence of God (1979): the principle of credulity: trust how things seem unless there is a special reason not to; and the principle of testimony: believe others' reports unless there is reason to doubt them.
Reply: experiences of God are unlike sense experience: there are no agreed checks, so credulity may not apply.
Mission 2
Challenge 2: natural explanation
Linguistics: William Samarin, Tongues of Men and Angels (1972): glossolalia sounds like language but lacks consistent grammar and meaning; it can be learned.
Psychology: expectation, group suggestion and music can produce falling, laughter or ecstatic speech (critics' reading of the "Toronto Blessing").
Neuroscience: brain scans during tongues show changed activity (e.g. reduced activity in frontal lobes: Newberg et al., 2006).
Response 1: a natural mechanism does not rule out a divine cause; God may work through brain and body (compare contingency miracles).
Response 2: judge by fruits. William James: "By their fruits ye shall know them, not by their roots" (The Varieties of Religious Experience, 1902, Lecture I).
Response 3: many Pentecostals accept that tongues are often not a known human language; Paul says the speaker "speaks not to men, but to God" (1 Corinthians 14:2, WEBBE).
Mission 2Evaluate
Does a natural explanation take away the religious value?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: If charismatic experiences have a natural explanation, they have no religious value.
For: if the same effects come from suggestion or learning, God is not needed to explain them (Occam's razor).
For: unverifiable claims (ones no one else can check) cannot ground authority, especially when leaders use them to control others.
Against: natural process and divine action need not compete; value may lie in transformed lives (James' fruits).
Against: Richard Swinburne's principle of credulity (trust how things seem unless there is a special reason not to): millions report such experiences; the burden is on the sceptic.
Strengths and weaknesses of the movement: renewal, growth, lay participation, care for migrants vs division, emotionalism, prosperity teaching.
Judgement criteria: Does explaining how answer whether God is involved? What counts as evidence of the Spirit? How should fruits be measured?
AO2 issues: "whether a natural explanation for charismatic experiences conflicts with the religious value of the experience"; "the strengths and weaknesses of the Charismatic Movement".
Quick check
?A researcher shows that people who speak in tongues can learn the skill and that it lacks the grammar of a human language. Which reply would a Pentecostal most likely make?
Mission check
?A Catholic parish in Ireland starts a weekly prayer group where people pray for healing and some speak in tongues. The parish still celebrates Mass, and the members stay Catholic. How is this group best described?
The same experiences of the Spirit can lead people out into new churches (Pentecostal) or renew the churches they already belong to (Charismatic).
Mission 3
Mission 3: In the 1960s, priests in Latin America said God takes the side of the poor. What did they mean?
Make a guess: In the 1960s, priests in Latin America said God takes the side of the poor. What did they mean?
Mission 3
Why Latin America, why the 1960s?
Step 1 of 3
A largely Catholic continent with deep poverty and inequality: land and wealth held by a few.
Many countries under military dictatorships (e.g. Brazil from 1964, Chile from 1973).
The Second Vatican Council (1962–65) asked the Church to read "the signs of the times" and engage with the modern world.
Latin American bishops met at Medellín, Colombia (1968): they spoke of poverty as "institutionalised violence" and called for liberation.
In villages and slums, base ecclesial communities (small lay groups) read the Bible together and asked what it said about their lives.
Mission 3
Gustavo Gutiérrez
Gustavo Gutiérrez (1928–2024), Peruvian priest who worked in a Lima slum; later a Dominican friar.
A Theology of Liberation (Spanish 1971; English 1973).
Theology is the second step. The first step is commitment and action with the poor; theology then reflects critically on that action in the light of God's Word (paraphrase).
Liberation at three levels (one process): (1) political and economic liberation; (2) human liberation, as people become agents of their own history; (3) liberation from sin, into communion with God and others.
Sin is the root of all injustice; but salvation is not only "spiritual": it touches real lives now.
Your spec spells the name "Gutierrez".
Mission 3Read the source
Good news to the poor
> "The Spirit of the Lord is on me, because he has anointed me to preach good news to the poor. He has sent me … to proclaim release to the captives, … to deliver those who are crushed," (Luke 4:18, WEBBE)
> "I have surely seen the affliction of my people who are in Egypt, and have heard their cry because of their taskmasters" (Exodus 3:7, WEBBE)
Jesus begins his ministry in Nazareth with Isaiah's words (Luke 4:16–21).
In the Exodus, God hears the cry of slaves and acts to free them.
Q1 Why is the Exodus central to liberation theology?
Show answer
God sides with the oppressed and frees them in history, not only after death.
Q2 How might a traditional reader interpret "release to the captives" differently?
Show answer
As release from sin, spiritually, rather than from political oppression; Gutiérrez holds both together.
Mission 3
The preferential option for the poor
The Gospel demands that Christians give priority to the poor and act in solidarity with them.
The phrase was adopted by the Latin American bishops at Puebla, Mexico (1979).
Preferential, not exclusive: God loves everyone; but where people are crushed, God's love takes their side first.
Basis: Jesus' own poverty and his ministry; "you did it to one of the least of these my brothers, you did it to me" (Matthew 25:40).
Gutiérrez distinguishes material poverty (an evil, to be fought) from spiritual poverty (openness to God) and voluntary poverty (solidarity with the poor in protest against poverty).
Quick check
?What does the "preferential option for the poor" mean in liberation theology?
Mission 3
Orthopraxis before orthodoxy
Orthodoxy: right belief (official Church teaching). Orthopraxis: right action.
Liberation theology puts right action first: faith is tested by what it does for the poor.
"Faith, if it has no works, is dead in itself." (James 2:17)
It does not reject doctrine: action and reflection feed each other in a hermeneutical circle (act → reflect → act better).
Critics: putting practice first could let politics decide what doctrine means.
Mission 3
The Boffs: see, judge, act
Step 1 of 3
Leonardo Boff (b. 1938), Brazilian theologian, then a Franciscan priest, Jesus Christ Liberator (1972); and his brother Clodovis Boff (b. 1944).
Introducing Liberation Theology (1986; English 1987) sets out three mediations:
Socio-analytical (see): why are people poor? Use the social sciences, including some Marxist tools, to find causes.
Hermeneutical (judge): what does God's Word say about this? Read scripture from the side of the poor.
Practical (act): what must be done? Plan action with the community.
Leonardo Boff: Jesus is the liberator who announces the Kingdom as the transformation of the whole of life.
Quick check
?In the Boffs' method, what happens at the hermeneutical (judging) stage?
Mission 3
Impact on believers and communities
Base ecclesial communities: by the 1980s, many thousands across Brazil and beyond; lay people read the Bible and organised for land, water and rights.
Óscar Romero (1917–1980), Archbishop of San Salvador, spoke for the poor and against violence; shot while saying Mass (24 March 1980); canonised in 2018.
Many priests, nuns and lay catechists were killed in the region's conflicts, among them six Jesuits at the UCA in San Salvador (1989).
Wider influence: Black theology (USA), Dalit theology (India), Minjung theology (Korea), feminist theology; aid agencies such as CAFOD speak of the option for the poor.
Mission 3Evaluate
Is it right to put one group first?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Christians are right to give priority to the poor over other groups.
For: The Bible shows God hearing the cry of the oppressed (Exodus 3:7) and Jesus bringing good news to the poor (Luke 4:18).
For: Neutrality in an unjust society supports the powerful; love must take sides where people are crushed.
Against: God's love is universal; Christians must love rich and poor, oppressor and oppressed (Matthew 5:44).
Against: Taking sides risks dividing the Church along class lines.
Judgement criteria: Is "preferential" the same as "exclusive"? Does the option serve everyone's good? What does Jesus' ministry show?
Mission check
?A church group in a British city runs a food bank. After a year, the members begin to ask why the same families keep coming; they study housing and wages, read the Exodus story together, and then campaign with the families for fair rents. Which liberation-theology idea best describes what they have done?
Liberation theology moves from charity to justice: it asks why people are poor and acts with them. Next: what it borrowed from Marx, and how the Vatican responded.
Mission 4
Mission 4: Liberation theologians borrowed ideas from Marx, an atheist. How did the Catholic Church respond?
Make a guess: Liberation theologians borrowed ideas from Marx, an atheist. How did the Catholic Church respond?
Mission 4
Karl Marx in brief
Karl Marx (1818–1883), German philosopher and economist; The Communist Manifesto (1848, with Friedrich Engels); Capital, vol. 1 (1867).
Economics drives history: who owns the means of production (land, factories) shapes law, politics and ideas.
Class struggle: owners (bourgeoisie) and workers (proletariat) have opposed interests.
On religion: "the opium of the people" (1844): it eases the pain of oppression but keeps people from changing it.
Philosophers have only interpreted the world; "the point is to change it" (Theses on Feuerbach, 1845).
An atheist: he expected religion to disappear once oppression ended.
Mission 4
Alienation
Step 1 of 2
Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts (1844).
Alienation occurs when humans are dehumanised and unable to live fulfilling lives.
In capitalist work the worker is cut off (estranged) from:
(1) the product: it belongs to someone else;
(2) the activity of work: forced, not freely chosen;
(3) their human nature ("species-being"): creative, free labour;
(4) other people: relations become competition and money.
Religion, for Marx, is a symptom: people project their lost humanity onto God.
Mission 4
Exploitation
Step 1 of 2
Exploitation occurs when humans are treated as objects and used as a means to an end.
The worker sells their labour for a wage; the goods they make are worth more than the wage.
The difference, surplus value, goes to the owner as profit.
So inequality is built into the system, not just caused by greedy individuals.
Quick check
?A factory worker spends ten hours a day repeating one movement on a production line. She never sees the finished product, has no say in her work and feels like a machine. Which of Marx's ideas does this describe most directly?
Mission 4
From personal sin to structural sin
Traditional teaching stresses personal sin: wrong acts by individuals.
Liberation theology adds social or structural sin: injustice built into systems, so that ordinary participation harms the poor.
It uses Marxist analysis to find the deeper causes of poverty, violence and injustice:
Capitalism: an economy organised for profit; Latin America kept dependent on rich nations (dependency theory).
Institutions: schools, churches, the state can teach the poor to accept their place. Paulo Freire, Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968): education for conscientisation (critical awareness).
Medellín (1968) called unjust structures "institutionalised violence"; John Paul II later used the phrase "structures of sin" (Sollicitudo Rei Socialis, 1987, §36).
Mission 4Read the source
The prophets and the Magnificat
> "But let justice roll on like rivers, and righteousness like a mighty stream." (Amos 5:24, WEBBE)
> "He has put down princes from their thrones, and has exalted the lowly. He has filled the hungry with good things. He has sent the rich away empty." (Luke 1:52–53, WEBBE)
Amos condemns a society where worship continues while the poor are crushed (Amos 5:11–24).
Mary's song (the Magnificat) praises God for reversing power.
Q1 Why do liberation theologians say they did not need Marx to see injustice?
Show answer
The prophets and Mary already condemn unjust power.
Q2 What, then, did Marx add?
Show answer
Tools to analyse how an economic system produces poverty.
Mission 4
Marx as a tool, not a guide
Liberation theologians used Marx selectively: his analysis of society, not his atheism or materialism.
The Boffs (Introducing Liberation Theology, 1987): Marx can be a companion on the way, but never the guide (paraphrase).
Gutiérrez: class struggle is a fact to be recognised, not a call to hate; Christians must love even their enemies.
The final authority is the Gospel and the poor's experience of God, not Marxist theory.
Critics doubted the tools could be separated from the ideology.
Mission 4
The Vatican's warning (1984)
Step 1 of 3
Instruction on Certain Aspects of the "Theology of Liberation" (Libertatis Nuntius), Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, 6 August 1984; signed by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (later Pope Benedict XVI), approved by John Paul II.
Affirms: the cry of the poor is real; the Church must make a preferential option for the poor; liberation is a Christian theme.
Warns against (paraphrase): borrowing Marxist analysis uncritically, since it cannot be separated from atheist ideology; class struggle as the law of history; reducing salvation to political liberation; a "people's church" set against the bishops.
Leonardo Boff was ordered to a period of silence (1985) over his book Church: Charism and Power (1981).
John Paul II (Puebla, 1979): Jesus as a political revolutionary does not fit the Church's teaching (paraphrase).
Mission 4
Later responses (1986 to today)
Step 1 of 3
Instruction on Christian Freedom and Liberation (Libertatis Conscientia, 1986): a positive account of Christian liberation; "love of preference for the poor".
John Paul II adopted structural sin language (1987) and the option for the poor in his social teaching.
Pope Francis (2013–2025), from Argentina: wanted "a Church which is poor and for the poor" (2013); met Gutiérrez (2013).
Óscar Romero, once viewed with suspicion by some in Rome, was beatified (2015) and canonised (2018).
So the response moved from warning to reception of key themes, while rejecting Marxist ideology throughout.
Quick check
?What did the Vatican's 1984 Instruction on liberation theology criticise?
Quick check
?Which example shows structural sin, as liberation theologians use the term?
Mission 4Evaluate
Did liberation theology engage with Marx too much, or not enough?
Step 1 of 4
Claim: Liberation theology was right to use Marxist analysis.
For: It explains why poverty persists despite charity; the prophets also condemned unjust systems.
For: Truth can be learned from anyone; Aquinas used the pagan Aristotle.
Against (Vatican): The analysis carries atheism and class hatred with it; salvation risks becoming politics.
Against (Marxists): It did not go far enough: it kept religion, which Marx saw as part of the problem.
Against (Clodovis Boff, 2007): Later he argued that some liberation theology had put the poor, not Christ, at the centre.
Judgement criteria: Can a tool be separated from its ideology? Are the religious foundations primary? What has helped the poor most?
Spec issues: political and ethical foundations vs religious foundations; a cultural challenge to the Roman Catholic Church.
Mission check
?A bishop says: "Workers who sew clothes for global brands earn too little to feed their families. No single manager is wicked, yet the system itself is sinful, and the Church must stand with the workers." Which two ideas does the bishop combine?
The Church kept liberation theology's concern for the poor and its idea of structural sin, while rejecting Marx's atheism and class war.
Recap
The big ideas
Mission 1
Ecumenism seeks the unity Jesus prayed for (John 17:21); it grew from Edinburgh 1910 into the World Council of Churches (1948), a fellowship, not a super-church.
The WCC works in three areas: Unity, Mission and Ecumenical Relations; Public Witness and Diakonia; Ecumenical Formation.
The Catholic Church is not a member but cooperates closely; denominations differ on whether others are fully "Church".
Mission 2
Pentecostalism: Topeka (1901) and Azusa Street (1906, Seymour); Spirit baptism, tongues, healing, the gifts of 1 Corinthians 12.
Charismatic Movement (from 1960): renewal within historic churches (Bennett, Fountain Trust, Catholic Renewal 1967).
Challenges: verification and natural explanation; responses: credulity and testimony (Swinburne), mechanism is not cause, fruits (James).
Mission 3
Liberation theology arose in Latin America in the 1960s–70s (Medellín 1968): Gutiérrez (A Theology of Liberation, 1971) and the Boffs (see, judge, act).
The preferential option for the poor: priority and solidarity, not exclusion; orthopraxis: right action comes first, tested against faith.
Mission 4
Marx: exploitation (people used as means to an end), religion as opium.
Marx: alienation (dehumanised, unfulfilled work).
Liberation theology used Marxist tools to analyse structural sin in capitalism and institutions, but not Marx's atheism.
The Vatican warned in 1984 and was more positive in 1986; the option for the poor and "structures of sin" entered Catholic teaching.
🏆
Mini-lesson complete!
⭐⭐⭐
You've worked through Christianity: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Mission 1Christians belong to thousands of separate churches. Can they be one again, and what would "one" mean?
Mission 2How did a small prayer meeting in Los Angeles become a quarter of world Christianity?
Mission 3In the 1960s, priests in Latin America said God takes the side of the poor. What did they mean?
Mission 4Liberation theologians borrowed ideas from Marx, an atheist. How did the Catholic Church respond?
Your stars: 0 / 0
📣 Smashed it? Share your score
Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.