← A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Religious Studies (A120) · Option A Christianity – Theme 1: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Christianity: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Christians call the Bible God's word, yet human hands wrote and chose every book. How can both be true?
  2. Mission 2A book finished nearly 2,000 years ago: how do Christians get advice from it for life today?
  3. Mission 3Did the first Christians all preach the same message, and are these Peter's own words?
  4. Mission 4Two experts study the same Jesus. Why does one find a peasant rebel and the other the Messiah?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Christians call the Bible God's word, yet human hands wrote and chose every book. How can both be true?

Make a guess: Christians call the Bible God's word, yet human hands wrote and chose every book. How can both be true?

Mission 1

A library, not one book

The Bible: a libraryOld Testamentlawhistorypoetry/wisdomprophetsdeuterocanonical bookse.g. Tobit, Sirach, 1–2 MaccabeesCatholic and Orthodox canonmost Protestants: "Apocrypha"New Testament: 27 booksgospelshistorylettersapocalyptic66 booksProtestant Bibles73 booksCatholic BiblesOrthodox Bibles include a few more
  • Biblia (Greek): "the books". The Bible is a library written over many centuries by many authors.
  • Old Testament: built on the Jewish scriptures. New Testament: 27 books about Jesus and the first Christians.
  • Genres: law, history, poetry, prophecy, wisdom, gospel, letters, apocalyptic.
  • Protestant Bibles: 66 books. Catholic Bibles: 73, adding the deuterocanonical books (e.g. Tobit, Sirach, 1–2 Maccabees). Orthodox Bibles include a few more.
  • Most Protestants call those extra books the Apocrypha: useful reading, but not Scripture.
  • The canon (Greek kanon, "measuring rod"): the agreed list of books that count as Scripture.
Mission 1

How the Old Testament canon formed

How the canon formedOld Testament3rd–1st c. BCESeptuagint: Greektranslation, with extra booksby c. 2nd c. CEHebrew Bible settled: Torah,Prophets, WritingsNew Testament writingsc. 50s–60s CEPaul's lettersc. 65–100 CEGospels (most scholars)Recognising the New Testamentc. 140Marcion: edited Luke + ten ofPaul’s letters; rejectedc. 180Irenaeus: exactly fourGospels367Athanasius: first known listof our 27 books393 · 397Hippo and Carthage confirmit for the WestReformation1534Luther's Bible: extra booksin a separate section1546Council of Trent: fullycanonical
  • The Hebrew Bible has three parts: Torah (Law), Prophets, Writings. Jewish communities accepted them in stages; the Writings were settled by about the 2nd century CE.
  • The older idea of a single "Council of Jamnia" (c. 90 CE) fixing the list is now widely doubted.
  • The Septuagint (Greek translation, 3rd–1st centuries BCE) included extra books. The early Church mostly read the Old Testament in Greek.
  • Jerome (c. 347–420) preferred the Hebrew list, but his Latin Vulgate came to include the extra books.
  • Reformation: Luther's Bible (1534) placed them in a separate section. Catholic Council of Trent (1546) declared them fully canonical.
  • Order matters too: the Hebrew Bible ends with Chronicles; Protestant and most modern Catholic Old Testaments end with the prophets (Malachi), pointing forward to Christ.
Mission 1

How the New Testament canon formed

How the canon formedOld Testament3rd–1st c. BCESeptuagint: Greektranslation, with extra booksby c. 2nd c. CEHebrew Bible settled: Torah,Prophets, WritingsNew Testament writingsc. 50s–60s CEPaul's lettersc. 65–100 CEGospels (most scholars)Recognising the New Testamentc. 140Marcion: edited Luke + ten ofPaul’s letters; rejectedc. 180Irenaeus: exactly fourGospels367Athanasius: first known listof our 27 books393 · 397Hippo and Carthage confirmit for the WestReformation1534Luther's Bible: extra booksin a separate section1546Council of Trent: fullycanonical
  • Earliest texts: Paul's letters (c. 50s–60s CE); the Gospels followed (c. 65–100 CE, in most scholars' dating).
  • Marcion (c. 140) accepted only an edited Luke and ten of Paul's letters; the Church's rejection of him pushed it to define its list.
  • Irenaeus (c. 180) defended exactly four Gospels.
  • Tests Christians used: apostolic origin (by or close to an apostle); orthodoxy (agreeing with the rule of faith); catholicity (widely used); use in worship.
  • Some books were disputed for a long time (e.g. Hebrews, James, 2 Peter, Revelation).
  • Athanasius, Festal Letter 39 (367), is the first known list of exactly our 27 books; North African councils (Hippo 393, Carthage 397) confirmed it for the West.
  • So the canon was recognised over time, not decreed in one moment.
Quick check
?Which statement about the formation of the New Testament canon is accurate?
Mission 1Read the source

Inspired, and written by people

> "Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness," (2 Timothy 3:16, WEBBE)

> "For no prophecy ever came by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke, being moved by the Holy Spirit." (2 Peter 1:21, WEBBE)

> "it seemed good to me also, having traced the course of all things accurately from the first, to write to you in order, most excellent Theophilus;" (Luke 1:3, WEBBE)

  • Inspired (Greek theopneustos, "God-breathed"): God is the source.
  • Yet Luke researched and wrote; Paul's letters show his own style, moods and plans.

Q1 What two sides of the Bible do 2 Peter 1:21 and Luke 1:3 show together?

Show answer

God's Spirit moves the writers; the writers still speak, research and write as people.

Q2 What is Scripture "profitable" for in 2 Timothy 3:16?

Show answer

Teaching, reproof, correction and instruction in righteousness: guidance for belief and life.

Mission 1

Three views of the Bible's nature

Three views of the Bibleliteral wordof God(inerrant)manyfundamentalistand someconservativeevangelicalChristiansinspired byGod, writtenby humansmost Catholic,Orthodox andmainstreamProtestantChristianshumanrecord ofexperiencesof Godmany liberalChristians
  • The literal word of God: God guided every word; the Bible is inerrant (without error) in all it says, including history and science. Used as a direct rulebook. Held by many fundamentalist and some conservative evangelical Christians.
  • Inspired by God, written by humans: God worked through writers' language, culture and limits. Inerrant (or infallible) in matters of faith and salvation; genre and context matter. Held by most Catholic, Orthodox and mainstream Protestant Christians.
  • A human record of experiences of God: written by people of faith, inspired as great writing is inspired; open to reinterpretation. Held by many liberal Christians.
  • Impact on use: the first view reads teachings as timeless commands; the others ask what a passage meant then and how its principle applies now.
Mission 1

Objective inspiration

  • Objective view: inspiration lies in the text itself. God is its true author, so the words carry God's truth whether or not a reader feels it.
  • Strong forms: verbal, plenary inspiration (every word, in every part); at the extreme, a dictation model (rarely held by scholars).
  • Linked to inerrancy, e.g. the Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978).
  • Catholic teaching (Dei Verbum 11, 1965): God is the author, and the human writers are true authors too; Scripture teaches without error the truth God willed for our salvation (paraphrase).
  • Strength: a fixed, public authority. Challenge: tensions between texts, and the obvious human features of the writing.
Mission 1

Subjective inspiration

  • Subjective view: inspiration lies in people: the writers' experience of God, and the Spirit at work in the reader.
  • The writers were inspired as people of faith; the text is their human response, shaped by their culture.
  • The Bible becomes God's word when God speaks through it to the reader. Karl Barth (1886–1968, Church Dogmatics I) called Scripture a witness to the Word of God, Jesus Christ (paraphrase).
  • Friedrich Schleiermacher (1768–1834) located inspiration in the writers' religious consciousness.
  • Strength: fits the human features of the text and believers' experience of being addressed by it. Challenge: who decides which parts "speak"? Authority may become private.
Mission 1

Calvin's accommodation

Calvin's accommodationsunmoonas they appear:"two great lights" (Gen 1:16)moonSaturn (larger)as astronomers knowMoses wrote in a popular stylefor everyone (Calvin)
  • John Calvin (1509–1564), Institutes of the Christian Religion (final Latin edition 1559).
  • God is infinite; humans are limited. So God accommodates (adapts) revelation to our capacity.
  • Calvin's image (Institutes I.13.1, paraphrase): as nurses speak simply to infants, God "lisps" to us.
  • His example (Commentary on Genesis, 1554, on Genesis 1:16): Moses calls the sun and moon "the two great lights" as they appear to ordinary people, though astronomers know Saturn is larger than the moon. Moses wrote in a popular style for everyone.
  • So anthropomorphic language (God's arm, God "repenting") and ancient science are God speaking at our level, not errors.
  • Calvin also held that the Spirit's inner testimony convinces believers that Scripture is God's word (Institutes I.7.4–5).
Quick check
?A Christian says: "When I read Psalm 23 in hospital, God spoke to me through it; that is when it became God's word for me." Which view of inspiration does this best express?
Mission 1Diversity

Bible and tradition in the churches

Bible and tradition in the churchesCatholicOrthodoxProtestantCanon73 books(Trent, 1546)slightly largerOld Testament66 booksAuthorityScripture andTradition, one"deposit" offaithScripturewithin HolyTraditionmost: solascriptura,Scripture thefinal authorityInterpretertheMagisterium(Pope andbishops)the Church,throughcouncils andthe Fathersthe believerandcongregation,guided by theSpiritProtestants still use tradition (creeds,confessions), tested by Scripture.
CatholicOrthodoxProtestant
Canon73 books (Trent, 1546)slightly larger Old Testament66 books
AuthorityScripture and Tradition, one "deposit" of faithScripture within Holy TraditionSola scriptura: Scripture is the final authority
Interpreterthe Magisterium (Pope and bishops)the Church, through councils and the Fathersthe believer and congregation, guided by the Spirit
  • Protestants still use tradition (creeds, confessions); they test it by Scripture.
Quick check
?Which statement correctly describes a difference between Catholic and Protestant views of the Bible?
Mission 1Evaluate

Is the Bible the inspired word of God?

Is the Bible the inspired word of God?The Bible can be regarded as the inspiredword of God.ForIts own witness (2 Timothy 3:16; 2 Peter1:21)Unity across centuries, centred on ChristThe Church's long recognitionBelievers' experience of the Spiritspeaking through itAgainstHuman features: research, style, variedaccountsTensions between textsAncient scienceThe canon was chosen by people overcenturiesReplies"Inspired but human" explains humanfeatures without denying inspirationCalvin's accommodation: God speaks atour levelThe subjective view moves authority to thereader’s encounter with GodJudge it byWhat does "word of God" mean: dictatedwords, or witness to Christ? · Does inspirationrequire inerrancy? · Can a human selectionprocess be guided by God? · Are the canonicalorders inspired, or only the texts?
  • Claim: The Bible can be regarded as the inspired word of God.
  • For: Its own witness (2 Timothy 3:16; 2 Peter 1:21); its unity across centuries centred on Christ; the Church's long recognition; believers' experience of the Spirit speaking through it.
  • Against: Its human features (research, style, varied accounts); tensions between texts; ancient science; the canon was chosen by people over centuries.
  • Replies: The "inspired but human" view explains human features without denying inspiration.
  • Calvin's accommodation does the same: God speaks at our level.
  • The subjective view moves authority to the reader's encounter with God.
  • Judgement criteria: What does "word of God" mean: dictated words, or witness to Christ? Does inspiration require inerrancy? Can a human selection process be guided by God?
  • Spec issue: whether the canonical orders (the order in which the books are arranged, the earlier screen) are inspired, or only the texts they contain.
Mission check

?Maria, a Catholic, quotes Sirach (Ecclesiasticus) as Scripture in a discussion. Josh, a Baptist, says it is worth reading but is not Scripture. What best explains their disagreement?
Mission 2

Mission 2: A book finished nearly 2,000 years ago: how do Christians get advice from it for life today?

Make a guess: A book finished nearly 2,000 years ago: how do Christians get advice from it for life today?

Mission 2

The Bible in Christian life

The Bible in Christian lifeworshipreadings, lectionary;Psalms sung andprayeddevotionlectio divina: read,meditate, pray,contemplateethicsmoral advice andguidancemeaningmeaning andpurpose of lifecomfortin illness, grief or fearBible
  • Worship: readings at most services; many churches follow a lectionary, a set cycle of readings (often over three years). Preaching explains them.
  • Sacraments and prayer: the words of the Eucharist and the Lord's Prayer come from Scripture; the Psalms are sung and prayed daily in many traditions.
  • Personal devotion: daily reading; Bible-study groups; lectio divina ("divine reading": read, meditate, pray, contemplate).
  • Decisions and ethics: Christians look to the Bible for moral advice and guidance.
  • Meaning and comfort: in illness, grief or fear, many turn to passages they know by heart.
Mission 2Read the source

Moral advice

> "This is the end of the matter. All has been heard. Fear God and keep his commandments; for this is the whole duty of man." (Ecclesiastes 12:13, WEBBE)

> "Therefore be merciful, even as your Father is also merciful. Don't judge, and you won't be judged. Don't condemn, and you won't be condemned. Set free, and you will be set free." (Luke 6:36–37, WEBBE)

  • Ecclesiastes 12:14 adds that God will bring every work into judgement.

Q1 What reason does Luke 6:36 give for being merciful?

Show answer

Because God the Father is merciful: Christians imitate God.

Q2 How does Ecclesiastes 12:13–14 give a motive for keeping the commandments?

Show answer

Duty to God, and accountability: every deed, even hidden, will be judged.

Mission 2Read the source

A guide to living

> "How can a young man keep his way pure? By living according to your word." (Psalm 119:9, WEBBE)

> "I have hidden your word in my heart, that I might not sin against you." (Psalm 119:11, WEBBE)

> "Your word is a lamp to my feet, and a light for my path." (Psalm 119:105, WEBBE)

  • Psalm 119 is the longest psalm: a meditation on God's law (torah: teaching, guidance).
  • Guidance is internalised ("hidden in my heart") and lived over time ("to the end", 119:112).

Q1 What does the image of a lamp suggest about how the Bible guides?

Show answer

It shows the next step on the path, not the whole route at once.

Q2 What practice does verse 11 describe?

Show answer

Learning and remembering Scripture so it shapes choices.

Quick check
?A Christian teenager memorises Bible verses so that she can recall them when she is tempted to lie. Which passage most directly supports her practice?
Mission 2Read the source

Meaning and purpose

> "God created man in his own image. In God's image he created him; male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27, WEBBE)

  • Genesis 1:26–28: humans are made in God's image, blessed, told to be fruitful and to have dominion over the earth: dignity and responsibility.

> "Go your way—eat your bread with joy, and drink your wine with a merry heart; for God has already accepted your works." (Ecclesiastes 9:7, WEBBE)

  • Ecclesiastes 9:5–9: death comes to all, so enjoy life, love and work as God's gift "under the sun".

Q1 What purpose do Christians draw from Genesis 1:26–28?

Show answer

To reflect God, to care for creation as stewards, to build families and communities.

Q2 Why might Ecclesiastes 9 be harder to use as teaching on purpose?

Show answer

It stresses death and limited knowledge; its joy is real but modest and earthly.

Mission 2Read the source

Comfort and encouragement

> "God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble. Therefore we won't be afraid, though the earth changes, though the mountains are shaken into the heart of the seas;" (Psalm 46:1–2, WEBBE)

> "Therefore I tell you, don't be anxious for your life: what you will eat, or what you will drink; nor yet for your body, what you will wear." (Matthew 6:25, WEBBE)

  • Psalm 46 is read at funerals, in disasters and in personal crises.
  • Matthew 6:25–34 (Sermon on the Mount): trust the Father who feeds the birds.

Q1 What reason for not being afraid does Psalm 46:1 give?

Show answer

God is present as refuge and strength.

Q2 How might a critic respond to Matthew 6:25 for someone in real poverty?

Show answer

It can sound unrealistic; many Christians read it as trust that frees people to act, not as a promise of no hardship.

Mission 2

Models of interpretation

Models of interpretationLiteral / fundamentalistmeans what it plainly says; every statementtrue as writtenConservative (evangelical)inerrant or infallible, but read by genre andcontextCatholicliteral sense + spiritual senses; read inTradition, guided by the MagisteriumLiberal / historical-criticala human document; apply its principles, notevery ruleExistentialhow the text addresses me now (Bultmann:"demythologising")
  • Literal / fundamentalist: the text means what it plainly says; every statement is true as written.
  • Conservative (evangelical): inerrant or infallible, but read by genre and context (poetry as poetry, history as history).
  • Catholic: the literal sense (what the human author meant) and spiritual senses (allegorical, moral, anagogical), read in Tradition and guided by the Magisterium.
  • Liberal / historical-critical: a human document; study sources, authors, editing and context; apply its principles, not every rule.
  • Existential: what matters is how the text addresses me now (e.g. Bultmann, 1884–1976, "demythologising").
  • Across these models, most Christians look for principles in Scripture (love of God and neighbour, justice, forgiveness) and apply them with tradition, reason, prayer and the Church's guidance.
Quick check
?A church group studies Genesis 1. One member says the days were six 24-hour days; another, that it is poetry teaching that God made all things good; a third, that it is an ancient myth shaped by Babylonian accounts. Which models do they use, in order?
Mission 2Evaluate

How far are the Psalms a guide to living?

How far are the Psalms a guide to living?The Psalms studied (Psalm 119) are still agood guide to living for Christians.ForThey form habits: memorising, meditating,daily prayerCenturies of use in worshipThey cover all of life, including fear andfailureAgainstPsalm 119 praises the law of Moses, muchof which Christians do not keepPoetry gives attitudes, not specificanswers to modern questionsRepliesChristians read "your word" in the light ofChristThe Psalms guide the heart rather thangiving rulesJudge it byWhat counts as a "guide": rules, principles orformation? · Compare the relative value ofGenesis 1 and Ecclesiastes 9 as teaching onmeaning and purpose
  • Claim: The Psalms studied (Psalm 119) are still a good guide to living for Christians.
  • For: They form habits (memorising, meditating, daily prayer); centuries of use in worship; they cover all of life, including fear and failure.
  • Against: Psalm 119 praises the law of Moses, much of which Christians do not keep; poetry gives attitudes, not specific answers to modern questions.
  • Replies: Christians read "your word" in the light of Christ; the Psalms guide the heart rather than giving rules.
  • Judgement criteria: What counts as a "guide": rules, principles or formation? Compare the relative value of Genesis 1 and Ecclesiastes 9 as teaching on meaning and purpose.
Mission 2Worked answer

Linking a verse to its use

Task: explain how the Bible is a source of comfort (AO1).

  • Belief: Christians believe God is present and powerful in times of fear.
  • Source: Psalm 46:1, "God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble."
  • Development: this is why the psalm is read at funerals and after disasters: it does not deny trouble (the mountains shake) but places God within it.
  • Second source: Matthew 6:25: Jesus tells followers not to be anxious, because the Father cares for them; Christians use it to trust God with daily needs.
Mission check

?Two Christians disagree about remarriage after divorce. Both quote Jesus' words in Mark 10:11–12. One says the words are a fixed rule for all times; the other reads them as protecting abandoned wives in Jesus' culture, and asks what love requires now. What does this case best show?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Did the first Christians all preach the same message, and are these Peter's own words?

Make a guess: Did the first Christians all preach the same message, and are these Peter's own words?

Mission 3

Kerygma and didache

Kerygma and didachekerygmakērygmaproclamationto outsiders: calls fora responsedidachedidachēteachingto believers (Acts2:42)
  • Kerygma (Greek kērygma): the proclamation a herald (kēryx) cries aloud: the public announcement of what God has done in Jesus.
  • Didache (didachē): teaching for those already believers: ethics, instruction, worship (Acts 2:42).
  • The kerygma is aimed at outsiders and calls for a response: repent, believe, be baptised.
  • Your spec says kerygmata: the plural, the proclamations.
Mission 3

Dodd's six points

Dodd's six points of the kerygmaC. H. Dodd (1936)1Fulfilmentthe age foretold hasdawnedActs 2:16–212Jesusministry, death,resurrectionActs 2:22–243Exaltationat God's right handActs 2: ?4Spiritsign of Christ'spresent powerActs 2: ?5Returnthe age sooncompletedActs 2: ?6Appealrepent; forgiveness;the SpiritActs 2:38–39? = place these yourself (next check)Acts 3: which point is each?3:13–153:183:193:21
  • C. H. Dodd (1884–1973), The Apostolic Preaching and its Developments (1936), reconstructed the "Jerusalem kerygma" from Peter's speeches in Acts 2–4 and 10 (paraphrase):
  • 1. Fulfilment: the age foretold by the prophets has dawned.
  • 2. Jesus: it has come through the ministry, death and resurrection of Jesus, descended from David.
  • 3. Exaltation: by the resurrection, Jesus is exalted at God's right hand as messianic head of the new Israel.
  • 4. Spirit: the Holy Spirit in the Church is the sign of Christ's present power and glory.
  • 5. Return: the messianic age will soon be completed when Christ returns.
  • 6. Appeal: repent; receive forgiveness and the Holy Spirit; the promise of salvation.
Mission 3Read the source

Finding the points in Acts 2 and 3

Dodd's six points of the kerygmaC. H. Dodd (1936)1Fulfilmentthe age foretold hasdawnedActs 2:16–212Jesusministry, death,resurrectionActs 2:22–243Exaltationat God's right handActs 2: ?4Spiritsign of Christ'spresent powerActs 2: ?5Returnthe age sooncompletedActs 2: ?6Appealrepent; forgiveness;the SpiritActs 2:38–39? = place these yourself (next check)Acts 3: which point is each?3:13–153:183:193:21

> "But the things which God announced by the mouth of all his prophets, that Christ should suffer, he thus fulfilled." (Acts 3:18, WEBBE)

> "Repent therefore, and turn again, that your sins may be blotted out, so that there may come times of refreshing from the presence of the Lord" (Acts 3:19, WEBBE)

  • 3:13–15: God glorified his Servant; you killed the Prince of life; God raised him.
  • 3:21: heaven receives Jesus "until the times of restoration of all things".
  • The Pentecost speech (Acts 2:14–39) follows the same pattern: Joel's prophecy fulfilled (2:16–21: point 1); Jesus' mighty works, death and resurrection (2:22–24: point 2); the appeal to repent and be baptised for forgiveness, with the promise of the Spirit (2:38–39: point 6). Placing 2:32–36 is the next check.

Q1 Which of Dodd's points does 3:18 express?

Show answer

Point 1, fulfilment, joined to point 2, Jesus' suffering.

Q2 Which point is 3:19?

Show answer

Point 6, the appeal: repent, sins blotted out.

Quick check
?Which of Dodd's six points of the kerygma does Peter express in Acts 2:33: "Being therefore exalted by the right hand of God, and having received from the Father the promise of the Holy Spirit, he has poured out this which you now see and hear"?
Mission 3

Dodd's wider claims

One message, many textskerygma(Dodd)Acts speeches"Servant" (3:13, 26); "made him both Lord andChrist" (2:36)Pauldied, buried, raised on the third day (1Corinthians 15:3–4)Mark's outline (Dodd, 1932)John the Baptist, Galilee ministry, journey,Jerusalem, death, resurrection
  • One message: the same pattern underlies Paul's earliest tradition: "Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures… he was buried… he was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures" (1 Corinthians 15:3–4).
  • The Gospels grew from it: Mark's outline (John the Baptist, Galilee ministry, journey, Jerusalem, death, resurrection) follows the kerygma (Dodd, 1932).
  • Early material in Acts: some phrases sound primitive, not like Luke's later theology:
  • Jesus as God's Servant (3:13, 26); "God has made him both Lord and Christ" (2:36), as if at the resurrection; Semitic turns of phrase.
  • So, for Dodd, the speeches preserve the preaching of the Jerusalem church, not just Luke's ideas.
Mission 3

Do the speeches record what was said?

Do the speeches record what was said?word for wordLuke'scompositions1234Word-for-word recordwhat Peter said, verbatim1Faithful summarieskeep early tradition (F. F. Bruce, 1942)2Middle viewLuke's words, carrying early content3Luke's compositionsas a historian of his day would (MartinDibelius, 1949)4Ancient practiceThucydides 1.22: speakers say what theoccasion required, close to the general sense
  • Ancient practice: the Greek historian Thucydides (c. 460–c. 400 BC), History of the Peloponnesian War 1.22, says he could not recall speeches word for word, so he had speakers say what the occasion required, keeping as close as possible to the general sense (paraphrase).
  • Martin Dibelius (1883–1947; essays on Acts, 1949): the speeches are Luke's compositions, written as a historian of his day would; Peter and Paul preach in the same pattern and style.
  • F. F. Bruce (1910–1990), The Speeches in the Acts of the Apostles (1942): Luke gives faithful summaries that keep early tradition, as their primitive features show.
  • Length: Peter's Pentecost speech takes only a few minutes to read aloud: clearly a summary.
  • Accuracy test: in Acts 5:36–37 the Pharisee Gamaliel names a rebel Theudas before Judas the Galilean (AD 6), but the historian Josephus dates a Theudas to c. AD 44–46, after this scene: a possible slip by Luke, or another Theudas.
Mission 3

Bultmann's challenge

Dodd and Bultmann on the kerygmaDoddBultmannWhat it isa summary of whatGod has done in JesusGod's word addressingthe hearer now: adecisionHistorylinked to a historicaloutline (Mark)faith needs only "that"Jesus came and wascrucified (Dass)The frameworksix points, the returnincludedmyth (heaven above, aquick return):demythologise
  • Rudolf Bultmann (1884–1976), Theology of the New Testament (1948–53).
  • The kerygma is not mainly a summary of past facts: it is God's word addressing the hearer now and calling for a decision of faith (paraphrase).
  • Faith needs only that Jesus came and was crucified (German Dass), not a detailed story of what he did: against Dodd's link between the kerygma and a historical outline.
  • The kerygma comes wrapped in myth: exaltation to a heaven above, a quick return on the clouds. It must be demythologised to speak to modern people.
  • Dodd's point 5 (an imminent return) did not happen as expected: for Bultmann, a sign that the framework is mythical, while the call to decision remains.
  • Bultmann also doubted how much the Gospels and Acts tell us about the historical Jesus and the earliest preaching.
Quick check
?Which statement best captures Bultmann's challenge to Dodd's view of the kerygma?
Mission 3

Adapting the message

Adapting the message3Athens2Lystra1JerusalemJerusalem (Acts 2–3)Scripture: David, Moses, Abraham → Jesusraised; repent1Lystra (14:15–17)creation and seasons: "rains… and fruitfulseasons" → ends before Jesus is named(14:18)2Athens (17:22–31)"TO AN UNKNOWN GOD"; Greek poets(17:28) → Jesus raised; repent3Shared coreturn to the living God who acts
  • To Jews in Jerusalem (Acts 2; 3): Scripture fulfilled; David, Moses, Abraham; Jesus as Messiah; "you… we".
  • To country people at Lystra (14:15–17): turn "to the living God, who made the sky, the earth, the sea"; he gave "rains from the sky and fruitful seasons". No Scripture quoted.
  • To philosophers at Athens (17:22–31): an altar "TO AN UNKNOWN GOD"; Greek poets: "For in him we live, move, and have our being" (17:28); then judgement and resurrection.
  • What stays constant: turn to the living God who acts; in the fuller speeches (Jerusalem, Athens) this leads to Jesus raised and a call to repent. At Lystra the speech, as Luke gives it, ends before Jesus is named (the crowd has to be stopped from offering sacrifice, 14:18).
  • Paul: "I have become all things to all men, that I may by all means save some." (1 Corinthians 9:22, WEBBE)
  • Your spec: "the adapting of the Christian message to suit the audience".
Mission 3Evaluate

Do the speeches have historical value?

Do the speeches have historical value?"The speeches in Acts are reliable evidenceof the earliest preaching."ForDodd, Bruce: primitive titles ("Servant";"made him Lord and Christ"); agreementwith 1 Corinthians 15:3–5Luke claims careful research (Luke 1:1–4)AgainstDibelius: ancient historians composedspeeches; Peter and Paul sound alikeWritten perhaps 50 years later; possibleslips (Theudas)Middle viewLuke's words, shaped for his book,carrying early contentJudge it byWhat did "history" mean to an ancient writer?· Can early material survive in a later style? ·How much would summaries change?
  • Claim: The speeches in Acts are reliable evidence of the earliest Christian preaching.
  • For (Dodd, Bruce): primitive titles and Christology (Servant; "made him Lord and Christ"); agreement with Paul's early tradition (1 Corinthians 15:3–5).
  • For: Luke claims careful research (Luke 1:1–4); some first-hand sources likely.
  • Against (Dibelius): ancient convention let historians compose speeches; Peter and Paul sound alike; Luke's own vocabulary and themes run through them.
  • Against: written perhaps 50 years later; possible slips (Theudas).
  • Middle view: Luke's words, shaped for his book, carrying early content.
  • Judgement criteria: What did "history" mean to an ancient writer? Can early material survive in a later style? How much would summaries change?
Mission 3Evaluate

Is the kerygma of value for Christians today?

Is the kerygma of value today?"The kerygmata in Acts are of little valuefor Christians today."ForNo quick return came; exaltation "above"reflects an ancient picture of the universe(Bultmann)Tailored to 1st-century Jews; modernhearers do not share those scriptures orhopesAgainstThe core many churches still preach: Jesusdied, rose, is Lord; repent, be forgivenBultmann himself kept the kerygmacentral, only reinterpreting itActs itself models adapting the messageJudge it byIs the value in the wording, the structure orthe core claims? · Who decides what is myth?
  • Claim: The kerygmata in Acts are of little value for Christians today.
  • For: the expected quick return did not come; the language of exaltation "above" reflects an ancient picture of the universe (Bultmann).
  • For: they were tailored to 1st-century Jews; modern hearers do not share those scriptures or hopes.
  • Against: they give the core message many churches still preach (creeds, evangelism): Jesus died, rose, is Lord; repent and receive forgiveness.
  • Against: Bultmann himself kept the kerygma central, only reinterpreting it; the call to decision still speaks.
  • Against: Acts itself models adapting the message, which churches still follow.
  • Judgement criteria: Is value in the wording, the structure or the core claims? Who decides what is myth?
Quick check
?Which argument supports the view that the speeches preserve early material rather than only Luke's own theology?
Mission check

?A student hears a modern evangelist's talk: "God promised a rescuer; Jesus lived, died and rose; he now reigns; his Spirit is here; he will return; so turn to God and be forgiven." Which judgement is accurate?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Two experts study the same Jesus. Why does one find a peasant rebel and the other the Messiah?

Make a guess: Two experts study the same Jesus. Why does one find a peasant rebel and the other the Messiah?

Mission 4

The question of the historical Jesus

Two lensesGospel traditionsChrist of faithas Christians worshiphimhistorical Jesuswhat a historian canshow
  • The Christ of faith: Jesus as Christians worship him (Son of God, risen Lord).
  • The historical Jesus: what a historian can show about the man from Nazareth, using ordinary historical methods.
  • The Gospels were written by believers, c. 30–60 years after his death. Historians must ask which material goes back to Jesus.
  • Method decides a great deal: which sources count, what is assumed possible, and what question is asked.
  • Eduqas compares two scholars whose methods and conclusions differ sharply.
Mission 4

Crossan: who he is and how he works

Crossan's first triadCrossan's first triadsocialanthropologyGraeco-Romanand Jewishhistoryliterarystudyhistorical Jesus(Crossan)
  • John Dominic Crossan (b. 1934), Irish-American New Testament scholar, co-founder of the Jesus Seminar (1985).
  • Key work: The Historical Jesus: The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant (1991); shorter: Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography (1994).
  • His method works on three levels (his "triple triad"). First he combines social anthropology (how peasant societies under empire work), Graeco-Roman and Jewish history, and literary study of the texts.
  • Then he inventories the sources, sorts the sayings of Jesus into layers by date, and gives most weight to the earliest material and to sayings independently attested more than once.
Mission 4

Crossan: using apocryphal gospels

Sources: how early?Jesus' death2nd centurythe Gospels: written by believersc. 30–60 years after his deathSourceCrossanMost scholarsGospel ofThomasearly,independent(with Markand Q)2nd century, inthe form wehave it"CrossGospel" (fromthe Gospel ofPeter)early,independentfew accept itas earlier thanthe canonicalGospels
  • Apocryphal gospels: early Christian gospels outside the New Testament canon.
  • Crossan treats some as early, independent sources, alongside Mark and the sayings source Q:
  • The Gospel of Thomas: 114 sayings of Jesus with no birth, death or resurrection story (Coptic text found at Nag Hammadi, 1945).
  • A "Cross Gospel", which he reconstructs from the Gospel of Peter (fragment found at Akhmim, Egypt, 1886–87).
  • Result: the earliest layer, for Crossan, is mostly sayings about the Kingdom, not claims about Jesus' divinity.
  • Most scholars date Thomas, in the form we have it, to the 2nd century, and few accept the Cross Gospel as earlier than the canonical Gospels.
Mission 4

Crossan's Jesus: the social revolutionary

  • Jesus as a product of his time: a Jewish peasant in Roman-occupied Galilee, where land and wealth were being drawn to the cities and elites.
  • What his words meant then: to peasants under Caesar, "the Kingdom of God" meant a different way of living now, not the end of the world.
  • Open commensality: eating with anyone, outcasts included (Mark 2:16), against the social map of honour and shame.
  • Free healing: offered outside the Temple and its fees.
  • Together: a "brokerless kingdom" (Crossan's phrase): direct access to God and to one another, with no patrons or priests as go-betweens.
  • His Jesus is like a Jewish Cynic sage: a radical, non-violent social revolutionary. Easter, for Crossan, is the continuing experience of Jesus' presence, not a bodily return from death.
Quick check
?Why does Crossan conclude that the Kingdom of God, for Jesus, was about life now rather than the end of the world?
Mission 4

Wright: who he is and critical realism

Critical realism (Wright, paraphrase)the real pasthistorianevidenceconversationself-correctingRejected:naive realism: "thetext simply tells us"we only seeourselvesWright (1992), paraphrase
  • N. T. (Tom) Wright (b. 1948), Anglican New Testament scholar, Bishop of Durham 2003–2010.
  • Key works: The New Testament and the People of God (1992), Jesus and the Victory of God (1996), The Resurrection of the Son of God (2003).
  • Critical realism (paraphrase of Wright, 1992): there is a real past, other than the historian, that can be known (realism); but we only reach it through a continuing, self-correcting conversation between the historian and the evidence (critical).
  • So: reject naive "the text simply tells us what happened"; reject too the view that we only ever meet our own ideas.
  • Texts are "the articulation of worldviews": the Gospels express the stories, symbols, questions and practices of first-century Jews and Christians.
Mission 4Read the source

One saying, two readings

One verse, two frames"The time is fulfilled, and God's Kingdom isat hand! Repent, and believe in the GoodNews." (Mark 1:15)Crossanpeasants underRome: God's rulenowWrightIsrael's story: exile →return of God to Zion

> "The time is fulfilled, and God's Kingdom is at hand! Repent, and believe in the Good News." (Mark 1:15, WEBBE)

  • Crossan's reading: the Kingdom is God's rule practised now, by peasants sharing meals and healing, in place of Caesar's rule.
  • Wright's reading: "the time is fulfilled" fits a Jewish worldview story: Israel still in a kind of exile, waiting for God to return to Zion and defeat evil. Jesus announces that the story's climax is now.

Q1 Which phrase in the verse does Wright's reading depend on most?

Show answer

"The time is fulfilled": it places Jesus within Israel's long story.

Q2 Why might the two readings differ, though both use the same verse?

Show answer

They frame it differently: Crossan through peasant society under empire; Wright through the Jewish story of exile and return.

Mission 4

Wright's Jesus: the true Messiah

  • Jesus was a prophet announcing the Kingdom, who came to see himself as Israel's Messiah.
  • His actions are symbols: choosing twelve (Israel's twelve tribes), the Temple protest (Mark 11:17), the Last Supper.
  • He saw his death as the way God's Kingdom would come; he acted out the return of Israel's God to Zion.
  • Best explanation: Wright asks what best explains the Gospel traditions and the rise of the Church. The early belief that Jesus was raised (1 Corinthians 15:3–5), with an empty tomb and appearances, is best explained, he argues, by a bodily resurrection (2003).
  • He uses mainly the canonical Gospels, read within their Jewish setting, and dates Thomas later.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes Wright's critical realism?
Mission 4Diversity

Two methods side by side

Crossan and Wright comparedCrossanWrightStartingpointSocialanthropologyof peasant lifeunder empireJewishworldview:story, symbols,hopesSourcesLayers by date;Thomas, Q,Cross GospelweightedCanonicalGospels inJewish context;Thomas laterJesusPeasant JewishCynic; socialrevolutionaryProphet andtrue MessiahKingdomGod's rulepractised now;brokerlessClimax ofIsrael's story;God returningResurrectionContinuingpresence; not abodily eventBodily; bestexplanation ofthe evidenceMethodlabelJesus as aproduct of histimeCritical realism
CrossanWright
Starting pointSocial anthropology of peasant life under empireJewish worldview: story, symbols, hopes
SourcesLayers by date; Thomas, Q, Cross Gospel weightedCanonical Gospels in Jewish context; Thomas later
JesusPeasant Jewish Cynic; social revolutionaryProphet and true Messiah
KingdomGod's rule practised now; brokerlessClimax of Israel's story; God returning
ResurrectionContinuing presence; not a bodily eventBodily; best explanation of the evidence
Method labelJesus as a product of his timeCritical realism
  • Both are historians of the first century; both place Jesus firmly in Judaism and both read Jesus' words in their original setting. They differ over sources, framing and the possibility of the supernatural.
Mission 4Evaluate

Which method brings us closer to Jesus?

Argument map: which method brings us closer to Jesus?Which method brings us closer to Jesus?Apocryphal gospels (Crossan)ForMay preserve early, independent sayings;avoids relying only on the Church's chosentexts.AgainstMost date Thomas to the 2nd century(Gnostic influence); the Cross Gospel is areconstruction few accept.Critical realism (Wright)ForAvoids both naive acceptance and totalscepticism; tests hypotheses against allthe evidence.AgainstCan become apologetics: the "bestexplanation" may follow what thehistorian already believes.BothEach scholar finds a Jesus who fits his ownoutlook (a charge made famous bySchweitzer, 1906).Judge it byAre the sources early and independent? · Areassumptions stated? · Does the pictureexplain Jesus' Jewish setting and the rise ofthe Church?
  • Validity of apocryphal gospels: for — they may preserve early, independent sayings; using them avoids relying only on the Church's chosen texts.
  • Validity of apocryphal gospels: against — most date Thomas to the 2nd century and see Gnostic influence; the Cross Gospel is a reconstruction few accept. Building on them may tilt the result.
  • Validity of critical realism: for — it avoids both naive acceptance and total scepticism; it tests hypotheses against all the evidence.
  • Validity of critical realism: against — critics say it can become apologetics: the "best explanation" may be decided by what a historian already believes (e.g. whether resurrection is possible).
  • Both: critics say each scholar finds a Jesus who fits his own outlook (a charge first made famous by Albert Schweitzer, 1906, about earlier lives of Jesus).
  • Judgement criteria: Are the sources early and independent? Are assumptions stated? Does the picture explain Jesus' Jewish setting and the rise of the Church?
Quick check
?Which criticism applies specifically to Crossan's method rather than to Wright's?
Mission check

?A historian studies the story of Jesus driving traders from the Temple (Mark 11:15–17). She asks what it meant to poor Galileans who paid Temple dues, and concludes it was a protest against an elite system that stood between people and God. Whose approach is she closest to, and why?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • The canon is the agreed list of books: Catholic Bibles have 73, Protestant Bibles 66.
  • It was recognised over centuries: the Old Testament from Jewish and Greek traditions, the New Testament by tests of apostolic origin, orthodoxy and use (Athanasius, 367).
  • Views of the Bible range from the literal, inerrant word of God, through "inspired by God but written by humans", to a human record of experiences of God.
  • Objective inspiration places inspiration in the text; subjective inspiration in the writers' and readers' experience.
  • Calvin's accommodation: God speaks at our level, so human features of the text are not errors.

Mission 2

  • Christians use the Bible in worship, devotion, ethics and times of need.
  • Moral advice (Eccl 12:13–14; Luke 6:36–37), guide (Ps 119), meaning (Gen 1:26–28; Eccl 9:5–9), comfort (Ps 46:1–3; Matt 6:25).
  • Churches turn Scripture into ethical teaching through principles, tradition and reason; models of interpretation (literal, conservative, Catholic, liberal, existential) lead to different guidance.

Mission 3

  • Kerygma is the public proclamation; Dodd's six points: fulfilment, Jesus' death and resurrection, exaltation, Spirit, return, appeal (Acts 2:14–39; 3:12–26).
  • Historical value: Dibelius sees Luke's compositions on ancient models; Dodd and Bruce see summaries with early content.
  • Bultmann: the kerygma is a present call to decision needing only "that" Jesus came, and its mythical framework must be demythologised; Acts shows the message adapted to each audience.

Mission 4

  • Crossan (b. 1934): triple triad, early layers including apocryphal gospels (Thomas, the Cross Gospel), Jesus a product of his time: a peasant social revolutionary with a brokerless kingdom.
  • Wright (b. 1948): critical realism, texts as the articulation of worldviews, the best explanation of the traditions: Jesus the true Messiah, bodily raised.
  • Evaluate the methods: early dating of apocryphal gospels; whether critical realism is neutral or apologetic.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Christianity: Religious figures and sacred texts (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Christians call the Bible God's word, yet human hands wrote and chose every book. How can both be true?
  2. Mission 2A book finished nearly 2,000 years ago: how do Christians get advice from it for life today?
  3. Mission 3Did the first Christians all preach the same message, and are these Peter's own words?
  4. Mission 4Two experts study the same Jesus. Why does one find a peasant rebel and the other the Messiah?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas