← A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Religious Studies (A120) · Option A Christianity – Theme 2: Religious concepts and religious life (part 1 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Christianity: Religious concepts and religious life (part 1)

5 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?
  2. Mission 2Was Jesus fully God, or the first and greatest thing God made? Why did it matter so much?
  3. Mission 3Christians pray to Father, Son and Holy Spirit. How can that still be one God?
  4. Mission 4When Jesus died on the cross, did God suffer too, or can God not suffer at all?
  5. Mission 5How could one death, long ago, put things right between God and everyone else?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?

Make a guess: Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?

Mission 1

Human words for God

God as "Father": is like, is not likeGod as "Father"is like• care• authority• relationshipis not like• male body• human limits• failurestrue in one way, not in another
  • Anthropomorphic language: describing God in human terms (Father, King, Judge, "the hand of God").
  • Christians believe God is spirit (John 4:24) and beyond all creatures, so no human word fits God exactly.
  • Classical theology treats such words as analogy (Thomas Aquinas) or metaphor: true in one way, not in another.
  • Mainstream teaching: God has no sex. Catholic teaching: God "is neither man nor woman: he is God" (Catechism of the Catholic Church 239).
  • Yet Christian worship has used mostly male words: Father, King, Lord, "he".
  • The question: if the words are not literal, do they still shape how people see God, and men and women?
Mission 1

God as personal, God as Father

  • Personal: God can be known, loved and spoken to; God acts with will and love, not as an impersonal force.
  • Jesus taught his followers to pray "Our Father in heaven" (Matthew 6:9).
  • Christians receive "the Spirit of adoption, by whom we cry, 'Abba! Father!'" (Romans 8:15).
  • In the Trinity, "Father" names a relationship: the Father of the Son (see Mission 3). For many Christians it is a revealed name, not just one image among many.
Mission 1

"Father": pastoral benefits and challenges

"Father": benefits and challengesbenefits• intimacy: Jesus'Abba• belonging• carechallenges• painful experience• distance• maleness• male authority
  • Benefits: intimacy and trust (Jesus' Abba); belonging as God's children; care, protection and provision; a model of good fatherhood.
  • Challenges: for people hurt by an absent or abusive father, the image may bring fear, not comfort.
  • It may suggest God is distant or stern, or that God is male.
  • Feminists argue it has been used to justify male authority in the Church and family.
  • Pastoral responses: stress the father of Luke 15 (who runs to forgive), use other biblical images alongside it, or teach clearly that "Father" is not about sex.
Mission 1Read the source

Female images of God in the Bible

Female images in scripturemothercomfortsIsaiah 66:13nursingmotherIsaiah 49:15hen and chicksMatthew 23:37"God created man in his own image… maleand female he created them." (Genesis 1:27)

> "As one whom his mother comforts, so I will comfort you." (Isaiah 66:13, WEBBE)

> "Can a woman forget her nursing child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb? Yes, these may forget, yet I will not forget you!" (Isaiah 49:15, WEBBE)

  • Jesus compares himself to "a hen [who] gathers her chicks" (Matthew 23:37).
  • "God created man in his own image… male and female he created them." (Genesis 1:27)
  • The medieval mystic Julian of Norwich (c. 1343–after 1416) wrote that God is truly our Mother as well as our Father (Revelations of Divine Love, ch. 59, paraphrase).

Q1 What quality of God do the Isaiah verses express through a mother's love?

Show answer

Comfort and faithful, unforgetting compassion.

Q2 How might Genesis 1:27 support using female images for God?

Show answer

Both male and female are in God's image, so both can reflect God.

Quick check
?Which is a pastoral challenge of calling God "Father", rather than a benefit?
Mission 1

McFague: metaphors and models

McFague's models of GodEvery model "is and is not" (McFague)monarchical modelGod as king and lord over the worldtaken literally = an idolMotherLoverFriendnew modelsthe world as God's bodyMother's three roles:creatorgives birthlove"it is goodthat youexist"judgecare for allMcFague (paraphrase)
  • Sallie McFague (1933–2019), American theologian; Metaphorical Theology (1982), Models of God (1987).
  • All talk of God is metaphor: a model of God both "is and is not" what it says (paraphrase).
  • Trouble comes when one metaphor is taken literally and becomes an idol: e.g. God as King.
  • The monarchical model (God as king and lord over the world): distant, controlling, and male. She argues it encourages domination and passivity, and fits badly with an age of nuclear and ecological threat.
  • So she proposes new models: God as Mother, Lover and Friend, and the world as God's body.
Mission 1

McFague: God as Mother

McFague's models of GodEvery model "is and is not" (McFague)monarchical modelGod as king and lord over the worldtaken literally = an idolMotherLoverFriendnew modelsthe world as God's bodyMother's three roles:creatorgives birthlove"it is goodthat youexist"judgecare for allMcFague (paraphrase)
  • Mother as creator: God brings the world to birth, from God's own being, rather than making it as an object from outside (paraphrase).
  • Mother's love (agape in her sense): love that says "it is good that you exist" and wants all its children to live and flourish.
  • Mother as judge: justice as care for all she has borne; judgement falls on what harms the whole family, including the earth.
  • Ethic: care for others and for the planet; a mother does not dominate her children.
  • McFague does not say God is female: Mother is one partial model, used with others.
Mission 1

Daly: "if God is male, then the male is God"

Daly's chain"if God is male, then the male is God" (Daly,Beyond God the Father, ch. 1)God imaged as malethe male seen as god-likemale rule legitimated
  • Mary Daly (1928–2010), American feminist philosopher and theologian; Beyond God the Father (1973).
  • Her claim: "if God is male, then the male is God" (Beyond God the Father, ch. 1).
  • A male image of God, she argues, makes men seem god-like and legitimates patriarchy: male rule in Church, family and society.
  • The symbol of "God the Father" is not harmless picture-language: it shapes power.
  • Daly came to see Christianity as beyond reform and left it ("post-Christian").
Mission 1Diversity

Christian feminist and other responses

Responses to male language for Godtraditional: keep"Father"leave (Daly,Hampson)121inclusive language (alongside "Father")2reform from within (Ruether, Johnson)
  • Reform from within: e.g. Rosemary Radford Ruether (1936–2022) and Elizabeth Johnson (She Who Is, 1992): recover female and wisdom (Sophia) images; keep Christianity.
  • Leave: Daly, and Daphne Hampson (b. 1944): Christianity is irredeemably patriarchal.
  • Inclusive language: some Protestant churches allow inclusive or female language for God in some prayers and hymns, alongside "Father".
  • Traditional: Catholic and Orthodox teaching, and many evangelicals, keep "Father" as the name Jesus revealed, while teaching God has no sex.
  • Some feminists also criticise "Mother": it may fix women's role as nurturing and motherhood.
Quick check
?What is McFague's main reason for proposing the model of God as Mother?
Quick check
?What is the point of Daly's claim about the effects of a male God?
Mission 1Evaluate

Is it valid to refer to God as Mother?

Argument map: God as Mother?It is valid for Christians to refer to God asMother.ForThe Bible uses maternal images (Isaiah49:15, 66:13; Matthew 23:37), and Julianof Norwich did so.If God has no sex, female words are asfitting (and as limited) as male ones.McFague: male-only language has harmfuleffects; Mother expresses care for all.AgainstJesus taught "Father", and the nameexpresses the Father–Son relation in theTrinity.McFague's "world as God's body" may blurGod and creation (a risk of pantheism)."Mother" may itself fix a narrow idea ofwomen.Judge it byIs God-language revealed or chosen? · Doesany image bring a sex into God? · Whichimages help people to know God and treateach other justly?
  • Claim: It is valid for Christians to refer to God as Mother.
  • For: The Bible itself uses maternal images (Isaiah 49:15, 66:13; Matthew 23:37), and Julian of Norwich did so.
  • For: If God has no sex, female words are as fitting (and as limited) as male ones.
  • For: McFague: male-only language has harmful effects; Mother expresses care for all.
  • Against: Jesus taught "Father", and the name expresses the Father–Son relation in the Trinity.
  • Against: McFague's "world as God's body" may blur God and creation (a risk of pantheism).
  • Against: "Mother" may itself fix a narrow idea of women.
  • Judgement criteria: Is God-language revealed or chosen? Does any image bring a sex into God? Which images help people to know God and treat each other justly?
Mission check

?A hymn-writer writes "God our Mother". A critic replies: "That's wrong, because calling God Father shows that God is literally male." On what point do mainstream Christian teaching and feminist theologians agree, against the critic?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Was Jesus fully God, or the first and greatest thing God made? Why did it matter so much?

Make a guess: Was Jesus fully God, or the first and greatest thing God made? Why did it matter so much?

Mission 2

The puzzle

The puzzleOne God"The LORD is our God. The LORD is one."(Deuteronomy 6:4)?Jesus worshippedThomas: "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28)Is Jesus God, or something less than God?
  • Christians inherited strict monotheism: "The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4)
  • Yet the New Testament shows early Christians worshipping Jesus: in John's Gospel, Thomas calls him "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28).
  • So: is Jesus God, or something less than God?
  • In the 4th century this became a crisis that split the Church and reached the emperor.
Mission 2

Arius: the Son is created

Arius and AthanasiusArius (c. 256–336)GodunbegottenSoncreatedbefore timeworldmadethrough himSlogan of his party:"there was when he was not"Athanasius (c. 296–373)Son: fully Godonly Godre-createsGod's image restored"For He was made man that we might bemade God" (On the Incarnation 54)
  • Arius (c. 256–336), a priest in Alexandria, Egypt; dispute from c. 318.
  • God alone is unbegotten, unchanging, without beginning.
  • So the Son (the Word, Logos) must have a beginning: created by God before time, the first and highest creature, through whom God made everything else.
  • Slogan of his party, condemned at Nicaea and attacked by Athanasius: "there was when he was not".
  • Texts he used: "the firstborn of all creation" (Colossians 1:15); "the Father is greater than I" (John 14:28); Proverbs 8:22 (Wisdom "created" in the Greek version).
  • His aim: to protect the oneness and changelessness of God.
Mission 2

Athanasius: only God can save

Arius and AthanasiusArius (c. 256–336)GodunbegottenSoncreatedbefore timeworldmadethrough himSlogan of his party:"there was when he was not"Athanasius (c. 296–373)Son: fully Godonly Godre-createsGod's image restored"For He was made man that we might bemade God" (On the Incarnation 54)
  • Athanasius (c. 296–373), deacon at Nicaea, then bishop of Alexandria from 328; exiled five times.
  • On the Incarnation (c. 318 or c. 335; date debated).
  • Humans, made in God's image, were sliding back into death and corruption through sin.
  • Only the Creator can re-create: a creature cannot restore the image of God.
  • "For He was made man that we might be made God" (On the Incarnation 54): sharing God's life (theosis, deification).
  • So if the Son is a creature, we are not saved. The Son must be fully God.
Mission 2Read the source

The Word before the world

> "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God." (John 1:1, WEBBE)

> "The Word became flesh and lived amongst us." (John 1:14, WEBBE)

> "who, existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a servant" (Philippians 2:6–7, WEBBE)

  • Pre-existence: the Son exists before his human birth: "before Abraham came into existence, I AM" (John 8:58).

Q1 Which phrase in John 1:1 did Athanasius' side stress?

Show answer

"The Word was God."

Q2 What does Philippians 2 say the Son did to become human?

Show answer

He "emptied himself", taking the form of a servant.

Mission 2

Nicaea, 325

Councils of the early Church325Nicaea: homoousios ("of onesubstance with the Father"); Ariuscondemned381Constantinople: Nicaea confirmed
  • Emperor Constantine called the first ecumenical (worldwide) council to end the dispute: roughly 250–300 bishops at Nicaea (ancient counts vary; tradition says 318).
  • The creed of Nicaea: the Son is "begotten, not made", "of one substance with the Father".
  • Key word homoousios: of the same substance (being) as the Father; not homoiousios, "of similar substance".
  • So the Son is co-equal with the Father and has no beginning.
  • Arius was condemned and exiled. Arian views stayed strong for decades; the Council of Constantinople (381) confirmed Nicaea (see Mission 3).
Quick check
?What did the Council of Nicaea (325) mean by calling the Son homoousios with the Father?
Mission check

?A modern group teaches: "Jesus is divine in a lesser sense. He was the first being God created, before the world, and God made everything else through him." Which statement is accurate?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Christians pray to Father, Son and Holy Spirit. How can that still be one God?

Make a guess: Christians pray to Father, Son and Holy Spirit. How can that still be one God?

Mission 3

One God, three persons

The Trinity: Shield and rejected viewsis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpiritViews the Church rejectedTritheismthree separate godsModalismone person in three modesSubordinationismthe Son and Spirit as lesserthan the Father
  • The Trinity: one God in three persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Christians believe each person is fully God, yet there is one God, not three.
  • "Hear, Israel: The LORD is our God. The LORD is one." (Deuteronomy 6:4)
  • Three views the Church rejected:
  • Tritheism: three separate gods.
  • Modalism: one person appearing in three modes (associated with Sabellius, 3rd century).
  • Subordinationism: the Son and Spirit as lesser than the Father.
Mission 3Read the source

Biblical basis

Biblical basis of the TrinityDeuteronomy 6:4"The LORD is our God. The LORD is one."Matthew 28:19"in the name of the Father and of the Son andof the Holy Spirit"2 Corinthians 13:14"The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, God's love,and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit"Matthew 3:16–17at Jesus' baptism the Spirit descends "as adove" and the Father's voice speaks1 Corinthians 8:6"one God, the Father … and one Lord, JesusChrist"John 10:30"I and the Father are one."John 1:1"the Word was God"Acts 5:3–4lying to the Holy Spirit is lying "to God"one Godthree named togetherthe Son as Godthe Spirit as God

The word "Trinity" is not in the Bible. Christians find the pattern in it:

> "baptising them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit" (Matthew 28:19, WEBBE)

> "The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, God's love, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all." (2 Corinthians 13:14, WEBBE)

  • At Jesus' baptism, the Spirit descends "as a dove" and the Father's voice speaks (Matthew 3:16–17).
  • "yet to us there is one God, the Father, of whom are all things … and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things" (1 Corinthians 8:6): Paul places Jesus inside the Jewish confession of one God.
  • "I and the Father are one." (John 10:30)

Q1 In Matthew 28:19, how many "names" are there?

Show answer

One "name", shared by three.

Mission 3

The Son and the Spirit as God

Biblical basis of the TrinityDeuteronomy 6:4"The LORD is our God. The LORD is one."Matthew 28:19"in the name of the Father and of the Son andof the Holy Spirit"2 Corinthians 13:14"The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, God's love,and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit"Matthew 3:16–17at Jesus' baptism the Spirit descends "as adove" and the Father's voice speaks1 Corinthians 8:6"one God, the Father … and one Lord, JesusChrist"John 10:30"I and the Father are one."John 1:1"the Word was God"Acts 5:3–4lying to the Holy Spirit is lying "to God"one Godthree named togetherthe Son as Godthe Spirit as God
  • Son: "the Word was God" (John 1:1); "My Lord and my God!" (John 20:28).
  • Pre-existence: "the glory which I had with you before the world existed" (John 17:5).
  • Spirit: lying to the Holy Spirit is lying "to God" (Acts 5:3–4); "Where could I go from your Spirit?" (Psalm 139:7).
  • Christians read the Spirit as personal: teaches and reminds (John 14:26); not just a force.
  • Early Christians worshipped and baptised in the threefold name before the doctrine was defined.
  • The doctrine explains what Christians already did in prayer.
Quick check
?Which statement about the biblical basis of the Trinity is accurate?
Mission 3

From Nicaea to Constantinople

From Nicaea to Constantinople325Nicaea: the Son is homoousios (ofone substance) with the FatherthenCappadocian Fathers (Basil,Gregory of Nazianzus, Gregory ofNyssa): one ousia, threehypostaseis381Constantinople: the Spirit is "theLord and Giver of life" … "with theFather and the Son together isworshipped and glorified"
  • Nicaea (325): the Son is homoousios (of one substance) with the Father (see Mission 2).
  • Cappadocian Fathers: Basil of Caesarea (c. 330–379), Gregory of Nazianzus (c. 329–390), Gregory of Nyssa (c. 335–c. 395).
  • Their formula: one ousia (being, substance), three hypostaseis (persons).
  • Constantinople (381) completed the creed: the Spirit is "the Lord and Giver of life", who "proceeds from the Father", and "with the Father and the Son together is worshipped and glorified".
  • This Nicene Creed is shared by Catholic, Orthodox and most Protestant churches.
Mission 3

Co-equal and co-eternal

The Trinity: Shield and rejected viewsis notis notis notisisisGodFatherSonHolySpiritViews the Church rejectedTritheismthree separate godsModalismone person in three modesSubordinationismthe Son and Spirit as lesserthan the Father
  • Co-equal: no person is greater or lesser in being; all share the one divine nature.
  • Co-eternal: no person had a beginning; there was never a time when the Father was without the Son and the Spirit.
  • The Athanasian Creed (Latin, 5th–6th century): none of the three is before or after another, none greater or less (paraphrase).
  • But a relation of origin: the Father begets, the Son is begotten, the Spirit proceeds.
  • "The Father is greater than I" (John 14:28): read as Jesus speaking in his humanity, or of the Father as source, not of a greater being.
Mission 3

The filioque

The filioque: East and WestEastFatherSonSpiritmonarchy of theFatherJohn 15:26:"proceeds from theFather"West (filioque)FatherSonSpiritbond of loveGalatians 4:6: "theSpirit of his Son"589Toledo1014Rome1054Schism
  • Latin filioque: "and the Son". The West added it to the creed: the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son.
  • First used in Spain (Council of Toledo, 589); spread in the Frankish church; sung at Mass in Rome from 1014.
  • West (Augustine, On the Trinity): the Spirit is the bond of love between Father and Son; "the Spirit of his Son" (Galatians 4:6).
  • East (Photius, 9th century): the Father is the one source (monarchia) of Son and Spirit; John 15:26 says the Spirit "proceeds from the Father".
  • East also objected that a council's creed was changed without an ecumenical council.
  • A cause of the East–West Schism (1054), with papal authority.
  • Today: the Catholic Church omits the filioque when it uses the Greek creed; Lambeth Conferences (1978, 1988) asked Anglicans to consider omitting it.
Quick check
?Why did Eastern Orthodox theologians object to the filioque?
Mission 3Evaluate

"The doctrine of the Trinity is consistent with monotheism."

Argument map: the Trinity and monotheism"The doctrine of the Trinity is consistentwith monotheism."ForOne divine being (ousia): the persons arenot three beings but three relations withinone GodThe New Testament writers were Jewishmonotheists who placed Jesus inside theone God (1 Corinthians 8:6)AgainstJewish and Muslim critics: worshippingthree persons compromises God's onenessPopular explanations slide into tritheismor modalism; perhaps no coherent middleexists"Person" today means a separate centre ofconsciousness, making three personssound like three godsJudge it byWhat does "one" mean (number, being,unity)? · Does it fit the texts? · Can a mysterybe consistent without being explained?
  • For: there is one divine being (ousia); the persons are not three beings but three relations within one God.
  • For: the New Testament writers were Jewish monotheists who placed Jesus inside the one God (1 Corinthians 8:6).
  • Against: Jewish and Muslim critics: worshipping three persons compromises God's oneness.
  • Against: popular explanations slide into tritheism or modalism; perhaps no coherent middle exists.
  • Against: "person" today means a separate centre of consciousness, making three persons sound like three gods.
  • Also debated: is the Trinity necessary to understand the God of Christianity, or a later philosophical layer?
  • Judge it by: What does "one" mean (number, being, unity)? Does it fit the texts? Can a mystery be consistent without being explained?
Mission check

?A youth leader says: "God is like one actor who plays three parts: first the Father in the Old Testament, then the Son in the Gospels, then the Spirit at Pentecost." Which assessment would most Christian theologians (Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant) give?
Mission 4

Mission 4: When Jesus died on the cross, did God suffer too, or can God not suffer at all?

Make a guess: When Jesus died on the cross, did God suffer too, or can God not suffer at all?

Mission 4

What "impassible" means

Termsimpassiblecannot be acted upon from outside; does notundergo sufferingimmutabledoes not changepassiblecan be affected and can suffer
  • Impassibility: God cannot be acted upon or changed by anything outside God, and so does not undergo suffering or changing emotions (Latin pati, to suffer or undergo).
  • Linked to immutability: God does not change.
  • It does not mean God is cold or indifferent: classical theologians held that God loves perfectly, but without passion in the sense of being moved from outside.
  • Passibility: God can be affected and can suffer.
  • The modern question: can a God who cannot suffer really love a suffering world?
Mission 4Read the source

Texts on both sides

Two sets of textsunchangingMalachi 3:6Numbers 23:19James 1:17feelingGenesis 6:6Hosea 11:8Isaiah 63:9which interprets which?

> "For I, the LORD, don't change" (Malachi 3:6, WEBBE)

> "In all their affliction he was afflicted, and the angel of his presence saved them." (Isaiah 63:9, WEBBE)

  • Other texts for unchanging: "God is not a man… that he should repent" (Numbers 23:19); "the Father of lights, with whom can be no variation" (James 1:17).
  • Other texts for feeling: God "was sorry that he had made man… and it grieved him in his heart" (Genesis 6:6); "My heart is turned within me, my compassion is aroused" (Hosea 11:8).

Q1 What does each quoted verse claim about God?

Show answer

Malachi: God does not change; Isaiah: God shares his people's affliction.

Q2 Why must a reader decide how to relate the two sets of texts?

Show answer

Read literally, they seem to conflict; one set has to interpret the other.

Mission 4

Why classical theology held impassibility

  • From the early Church to the Reformation, most theologians read the feeling texts as anthropomorphic: true of God's acts, not of changes in God.
  • Perfection: a perfect being lacks nothing; change would be gain or loss.
  • Reliability: an unchanging God is faithful (Malachi 3:6).
  • Thomas Aquinas: love and joy in God are acts of will, not passions; God "loves without passion" (Summa Theologica I, q. 20, a. 1).
  • The early Church rejected patripassianism (the view that the Father himself suffered on the cross).
  • Cyril of Alexandria (d. 444): the divine Word "suffered impassibly": he suffered in his own flesh, while remaining unchanged as God (paraphrase).
Mission 4

Moltmann: the context

Moltmann's life1926born1943Hamburg destroyed by bombing1945–48prisoner of war1964Theology of Hope1972The Crucified God (English 1974)2024died
  • Jürgen Moltmann (1926–2024), German Reformed theologian; Theology of Hope (1964), The Crucified God (1972; English 1974).
  • As a teenage soldier he saw Hamburg destroyed by bombing (1943); a prisoner of war 1945–48, he came to faith reading the Bible in the camp, and felt understood by the Christ who cried out on the cross.
  • After Auschwitz, he argued, Christians cannot speak of an untouched God watching from heaven.
  • He recalls Elie Wiesel's account of a boy hanged in Auschwitz: a prisoner asks "Where is God?", and Wiesel hears an inner answer: here, on the gallows (paraphrase of Night, 1958).
  • Moltmann's reply: God is in the suffering, not above it.
Mission 4

Moltmann: the crucified God

The cross in the Trinity (Moltmann, paraphrase)FatherSonthe cross: an event within the Trinitysuffers griefsuffers dying,forsakenSpiritto the godforsakenMoltmann (paraphrase)
  • The cross is an event within the Trinity: between the Father and the Son.
  • The Son suffers dying and abandonment by the Father. The Father suffers the grief of the Son's death. The suffering differs, so this is not patripassianism.
  • From this event the Spirit of love goes out to the godforsaken.
  • A God who cannot suffer, he argues, also cannot love: love means being open to being hurt (paraphrase).
  • So God chooses to suffer, out of love: suffering is not forced on God from outside.
  • Result: God is in solidarity with all victims; no one is outside God's reach.
Mission 4Read the source

The cry from the cross

> "At the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, 'Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani?' which is, being interpreted, 'My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?'" (Mark 15:34, WEBBE)

  • Jesus quotes Psalm 22:1.
  • Moltmann: the heart of the cross; real godforsakenness, endured by God the Son.
  • Classical reading: the Son, in his human nature, takes on human abandonment; Psalm 22 ends in trust and praise.

Q1 Why is this verse central for Moltmann?

Show answer

It shows the Son abandoned by the Father: suffering inside God's own life.

Q2 How might an impassibilist read the same cry?

Show answer

As the Son suffering in his human nature and identifying with sinners, while the divine nature is unchanged; the psalm ends in trust.

Mission 4Evaluate

Does God suffer in or through Jesus?

Argument map: does God suffer?God suffers, not only in Jesus' humanity, butin God's own life.ForMoltmann: it makes sense of texts whereGod grieves (Genesis 6:6; Hosea 11:8;Isaiah 63:9).It answers Auschwitz with God'ssolidarity; love that cannot suffer may notbe love.AgainstClassical: a suffering God changes andlacks some good; the feeling texts areanthropomorphic.Moltmann may come close topatripassianism, or make suffering part ofGod's nature.ImplicationsComfort and solidarity for sufferers; butquestions about God's power, perfection andultimate victory over evil.Judge it byWhich set of biblical texts interprets theother? · Can love be perfect without beingaffected? · Does a suffering God help orhinder hope?
  • Claim: God suffers, not only in Jesus' humanity, but in God's own life.
  • For (Moltmann): It makes sense of texts where God grieves (Genesis 6:6; Hosea 11:8; Isaiah 63:9).
  • For: It answers Auschwitz with God's solidarity; love that cannot suffer may not be love.
  • Against (classical): a suffering God changes and lacks some good; the feeling texts are anthropomorphic.
  • Against: Moltmann may come close to patripassianism, or make suffering part of God's nature.
  • Implications of a suffering God: comfort and solidarity for sufferers; but questions about God's power, perfection and ultimate victory over evil.
  • Judgement criteria: Which set of biblical texts interprets the other? Can love be perfect without being affected? Does a suffering God help or hinder hope?
Quick check
?Why does Moltmann's view not count as patripassianism, in his own account?
Mission check

?After a disaster, a hospital chaplain tells a grieving family: "God is not distant from this. God knows abandonment from the inside, and grieves with you." A theologian replies: "God is unchanging; God's love for you is complete and cannot be shaken, and that is why God can heal you." Which pairing is correct?
Mission 5

Mission 5: How could one death, long ago, put things right between God and everyone else?

Make a guess: How could one death, long ago, put things right between God and everyone else?

Mission 5

Two key terms

Two key termsAtonementat-one-ment: making one againapartmade onepopularised by Tyndale (1526, Romans 5:11)Soteriologythe study of salvationsōtēriasalvationlogosstudy+
  • Atonement: the reconciling of God and humanity. The English word, popularised by William Tyndale's New Testament (1526, Romans 5:11), means "at-one-ment": making one again.
  • Soteriology: the study of salvation (Greek sōtēria, salvation + logos, study). What are we saved from, to, and how?
  • The problem: sin separates humans from God (Isaiah 59:2). Christians believe God offers forgiveness through Jesus' death and resurrection.
  • The creeds say Christ died "for us" but give no single theory of how this works. Several models grew up.
  • Your spec stresses they are "not mutually exclusive": many Christians hold more than one.
Mission 5Read the source

New Testament images

New Testament images: match themImagesVersesransom1 Peter 2:21sacrificeColossians 2:15victoryMark 10:45exampleRomans 3:25Which verse goes with which image?

> "For the Son of Man also came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many." (Mark 10:45, WEBBE)

> "whom God sent to be an atoning sacrifice through faith in his blood" (Romans 3:25, WEBBE)

> "Having stripped the principalities and the powers, he made a show of them openly, triumphing over them in it." (Colossians 2:15, WEBBE)

> "Christ also suffered for us, leaving you an example, that you should follow his steps" (1 Peter 2:21, WEBBE)

Q1 Match each verse to an image: ransom, sacrifice, victory, example.

Show answer

Mark 10:45 ransom; Romans 3:25 sacrifice; Colossians 2:15 victory; 1 Peter 2:21 example.

Q2 What does this suggest about later theories?

Show answer

Each develops an image already in the New Testament.

Mission 5

Sacrifice

Sacrifice: the Day of AtonementDay of Atonement (Leviticus 16)high priest offersblood for cleansingsin confessed over agoat sent into thewildernessHebrews 10:10Jesus as both priest and offering, "oncefor all"
  • Background: the Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16). Sin is confessed over a goat sent into the wilderness; blood is offered for cleansing.
  • "It is the blood that makes atonement by reason of the life." (Leviticus 17:11)
  • Hebrews presents Jesus as both priest and offering, "once for all" (Hebrews 10:10).
  • John the Baptist: "Behold, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!" (John 1:29).
  • Sacrifice language means: a life given to restore the relationship that sin broke.
  • Catholic and Orthodox Christians link this to the Eucharist, which makes present the one sacrifice of Christ.
Mission 5

Christus Victor: victory

Christus Victor: victorysin, death, the devilhumanity held captiveopen tombbroken gate: thecrossresurrection =victoryGod, in Christ, defeats the hostile powers(Aulén)
  • Gustaf Aulén (1879–1977), Swedish Lutheran bishop: Christus Victor (lectures 1930; English 1931).
  • He called this the "classic" view: held by the early Church Fathers and, he argued, by Luther.
  • Humanity is held captive by hostile powers: sin, death and the devil. On the cross God, in Christ, fights and defeats them.
  • "through death he might bring to nothing him who had the power of death, that is, the devil" (Hebrews 2:14).
  • Early ransom forms: Origen said the ransom was paid to the devil; Gregory of Nyssa pictured Christ's humanity as bait hiding the "hook" of his divinity.
  • The resurrection is the victory. The Orthodox Easter hymn: Christ is risen, "trampling down death by death".
  • Aulén: atonement is God's own act from start to finish, not humanity's offering to God.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes Aulén's "classic" view of the atonement?
Mission 5

Anselm: satisfaction

Anselm's logic: satisfactionAnselm, Cur Deus Homo (1098)Sinrobs God of the honour owed by everycreature (I.11)The debttoo great for humans: they already owe GodeverythingGodonly God can payHumanonly a human oughtto payThe God-man"it is necessary for the God-man to make it"(II.6): his free, sinless death gives God morehonour than sin took
  • Anselm of Canterbury (c. 1033–1109), Cur Deus Homo ("Why God Became Man", 1098).
  • He rejected the idea that the devil had any rights over humanity to be bought off.
  • Sin robs God of the honour owed by every creature. "Every wish of a rational creature should be subject to the will of God." (I.11, trans. Deane)
  • Repaying what was taken is "the satisfaction which every sinner owes to God" (I.11).
  • God cannot just overlook this; but humans cannot pay, since they already owe God everything.
  • Only God can pay; only a human ought to. So "it is necessary for the God-man to make it" (II.6).
  • Christ's free, sinless death gives God more honour than sin took away. This is the substitution in which only the divine-human Jesus could act.
Mission 5

Substitution: Christ in our place

Anselm's logic: satisfactionAnselm, Cur Deus Homo (1098)Sinrobs God of the honour owed by everycreature (I.11)The debttoo great for humans: they already owe GodeverythingGodonly God can payHumanonly a human oughtto payThe God-man"it is necessary for the God-man to make it"(II.6): his free, sinless death gives God morehonour than sin tookLater and different:Penal substitutionChrist bears the punishment for sin in ourplace (the Reformers)Anselm: satisfaction instead of punishment(honour restored). Penal substitution:punishment itself, borne by another.
  • Penal substitution: Christ bears the punishment for sin in place of sinners. Developed by the Reformers (Calvin, Institutes II.16) and central to many evangelicals.
  • "He was pierced for our transgressions. He was crushed for our iniquities." (Isaiah 53:5)
  • "For him who knew no sin he made to be sin on our behalf" (2 Corinthians 5:21); Christ became "a curse for us" (Galatians 3:13).
  • Difference from Anselm: Anselm's satisfaction is an alternative to punishment (honour restored); penal substitution is punishment, borne by another.
  • Your spec names both: Jesus as a substitute for humanity, and only the divine-human Jesus as the sacrifice by God for humanity.
Mission 5

Moral example

Moral example: love shown, love awakenedlove shownlove awakenedGod does not need changing; we doAbelard (paraphrase)
  • Peter Abelard (1079–1142), Commentary on Romans (c. 1133–37).
  • The cross does not change God (who already loves); it changes us. Christ's love, shown to the death, kindles love in us and frees us from fear (paraphrase).
  • "Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends." (John 15:13)
  • Jesus is the moral exemplar: how to live, and how to die, faithful and forgiving (Luke 23:34).
  • Aulén called this the "subjective" type: the change happens in the human heart.
  • Developed in liberal theology (e.g. Hastings Rashdall, The Idea of Atonement in Christian Theology, 1919) and by John Hick.
Quick check
?Why did Anselm think the one who makes satisfaction must be both God and human?
Mission 5

Wrath, love and forgiveness

Wrath, love and forgiveness123SinRomans 3:23Justice / wrathRomans 1:18LoveRomans 5:8Substitutionlove provides what justice requires (1John 4:10)1Victorywrath falls on the powers; love frees thecaptives2ExampleGod's love needs no payment, only ourresponse3
  • Assumption 1: humans need divine forgiveness; sin is real and serious (Romans 3:23).
  • Assumption 2: God is just. "The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness" (Romans 1:18).
  • Assumption 3: God is love. "God commends his own love towards us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." (Romans 5:8)
  • How do wrath and love fit? Substitution: love provides what justice requires (1 John 4:10). Victory: wrath falls on the powers, love frees the captives. Example: God's love needs no payment, only our response.
  • Critique: if the Father punishes the Son, is God cruel? Some feminist theologians called this a picture of "divine child abuse"; Steve Chalke and Alan Mann wrote "cosmic child abuse" (The Lost Message of Jesus, 2003).
  • Replies: the Trinity acts together: "God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself" (2 Corinthians 5:19). The Son gives himself freely (John 10:18). "Wrath" is God's settled opposition to evil, not a temper.
Mission 5Diversity

Who stresses which model?

Who stresses which model?TraditionStressesAlsoEasternOrthodoxChristusVictor; theosissin as sicknessand death morethan legal guiltCatholicsatisfactionand sacrifice(Anselm,Aquinas)the Mass: thesacrifice madepresentReformedandevangelicalpenalsubstitutionvictory andexample asresultsLiberalProtestantmoralexampledoubts aboutpunishmentlanguageMany combine them: sacrifice, victory andexample
  • Eastern Orthodox: Christus Victor and theosis (sharing God's life); sin as sickness and death more than legal guilt.
  • Catholic: satisfaction and sacrifice (Anselm, Aquinas); the Mass as the sacrifice made present.
  • Reformed and evangelical: penal substitution as the heart of the gospel (with victory and example as results).
  • Liberal Protestant: moral example; doubts about punishment language.
  • Many theologians today combine them: the cross as sacrifice for sin, victory over evil, and example of love.
Mission 5Evaluate

Are the theories contradictory?

Argument map: are the theories contradictory?The theories of the atonement contradicteach other.ForGod changes (satisfaction, substitution)versus only we change (moral example).Anselm rejected any payment to the devil;the ransom form of Christus Victor needsone.Satisfaction instead of punishment(Anselm) versus punishment itself (penalsubstitution).AgainstEach develops a New Testament image;Paul uses several side by side (Romans3:25; 5:8; Colossians 2:15).They answer different questions: what isremoved (guilt), defeated (evil), awakened(love).Judge it byAre they models (pictures) or literalmechanisms? · Does each fit God as both justand loving? · Does any make God cruel?
  • Claim: The theories of the atonement contradict each other.
  • For: God changes (satisfaction, substitution) versus only we change (moral example).
  • For: Anselm rejected any payment to the devil; the ransom form of Christus Victor needs one.
  • For: Satisfaction instead of punishment (Anselm) versus punishment itself (penal substitution).
  • Against: Each develops a New Testament image; Paul uses several side by side (Romans 3:25; 5:8; Colossians 2:15).
  • Against: They answer different questions: what is removed (guilt), defeated (evil), awakened (love).
  • Judge it by: Are they models (pictures) or literal mechanisms? Does each fit God as both just and loving? Does any make God cruel?
  • Spec issues: "the extent to which the three theories … are contradictory"; "suggest that the Christian God is cruel".
Quick check
?A critic says: "If God demands a death before he will forgive, God is cruel." Which reply comes from inside the Christus Victor tradition?
Mission check

?A hospice chaplain tells a dying man who fears death: "On the cross and in the resurrection, death itself was beaten; it no longer has the last word." Which model is she mainly using?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Words like Father and King are anthropomorphic: analogies or metaphors. Mainstream Christian teaching holds that God has no sex.
  • "Father" brings intimacy, trust and belonging, but can hurt those with painful experiences of fathers and has been used to support male authority.
  • McFague (Models of God, 1987): God as Mother, Lover, Friend; the world as God's body.
  • Daly (Beyond God the Father, 1973): "if God is male, then the male is God".

Mission 2

  • Arius: the Son is the first, highest creature ("there was when he was not"). Athanasius: only God can re-create and save, so the Son is fully God.
  • Nicaea (325): the Son is homoousios, "of one substance with the Father", "begotten, not made".

Mission 3

  • Christians believe in one God in three co-equal, co-eternal persons; not three gods, not three modes, not ranked.
  • Biblical basis: the threefold name (Matthew 28:19; 2 Corinthians 13:14), the divinity of Son and Spirit, and Jewish monotheism (Deuteronomy 6:4).
  • Paul places Jesus inside the one God (1 Corinthians 8:6).
  • Nicaea (325) and Constantinople (381) defined it; the West's filioque helped divide East and West.

Mission 4

  • Impassibility: God is not changed or made to suffer by anything outside God; classical theology read the Bible's "feeling" texts as anthropomorphic.
  • Moltmann (The Crucified God, 1972): after Auschwitz, God suffers in the cross: the Son dies forsaken, the Father grieves; a God who cannot suffer cannot love.

Mission 5

  • Atonement = reconciliation of God and humanity; soteriology = the study of salvation.
  • Models: sacrifice; victory (Aulén, Christus Victor); satisfaction and substitution (Anselm; penal substitution); moral example (Abelard).
  • The theories rest on assumptions about sin, forgiveness, and God's wrath and love; many Christians combine them.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Christianity: Religious concepts and religious life (part 1) for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Christians pray "Our Father". Does that mean they believe God is male?
  2. Mission 2Was Jesus fully God, or the first and greatest thing God made? Why did it matter so much?
  3. Mission 3Christians pray to Father, Son and Holy Spirit. How can that still be one God?
  4. Mission 4When Jesus died on the cross, did God suffer too, or can God not suffer at all?
  5. Mission 5How could one death, long ago, put things right between God and everyone else?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas