3 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.
Make a guess: Could belief in God grow out of a small child's need for a protective father?
Totem and Taboo (1913), building on Darwin (paraphrase):
Charles Darwin, The Descent of Man (1871), on early humans:
> "lived in small communities, each with as many wives as he could support and obtain"
Q1 Is Darwin's remark an observation of early humans, or an inference?
An inference, from animal behaviour; no one observed early human groups.
Q2 Why does this matter for Freud's theory?
The primal horde rests on speculation, so the theory's historical base is weak: an EDQ-listed challenge.
For Freud, a child's ambivalent bond with a father explains both the comfort and the fear in belief. Whether that settles God's reality is the question critics press.
Make a guess: Could a psychologist think religion is good for you without claiming that God exists?
Q1 Given the earlier screen, what might Jung "know"?
Most likely the reality of the God-image and of experiences of it; he did not claim a proof of God beyond the psyche.
Q2 Does the claim about his patients show that God exists?
No: it is evidence that a religious outlook helps healing, not about what exists beyond the psyche.
Jung can value religion's symbols as vital for growth while saying nothing about God beyond the psyche: positive about religion, and critics say reductive about God.
Make a guess: Is "I don't believe in God" the same claim as "There is no God"?
Richard Dawkins (b. 1941), The God Delusion (2006), paraphrased:
Q1 Does Dawkins claim to know that there is no God?
No: he thinks God very improbable and lives on that assumption, but claims no certainty: a 6, not a 7.
Q2 Why does he think "God designed it" is not a good explanation?
The designer would need explaining even more than the design.
"I don't believe in God" and "there is no God" are different claims: the first reports a lack of belief; the second denies that God exists. Whether either speaker claims to know is a further question. Next: what existentialists and humanists make of a world without God.
Mission 1
Mission 2
Mission 3
You've worked through Challenges to religious belief - religious belief as a product of the human mind for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉
Your stars: 0 / 0