← A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Eduqas A-level Religious Studies (A120) · Option D Buddhism – Theme 4: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2 of 2)
Mini-Lesson

Buddhism: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2)

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Why would monks spend weeks making a picture out of sand and then sweep it away?
  2. Mission 2Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?
  3. Mission 3Bombs are falling near your temple. Do you keep meditating or go out to help?
  4. Mission 4Can a Buddhist ordain a tree, march against an army, or ever support a war?
Mission 1

Mission 1: Why would monks spend weeks making a picture out of sand and then sweep it away?

Make a guess: Why would monks spend weeks making a picture out of sand and then sweep it away?

Mission 1

Vajrayana: the diamond vehicle

  • Tibetan Buddhism is Mahayana in its goal: awakening for the sake of all beings, as a bodhisattva.
  • Its distinctive method is Vajrayana, the "diamond (or thunderbolt) vehicle", based on Indian Buddhist tantras.
  • Vajrayana claims a faster path: using body, speech and mind, and powerful symbols, under a qualified teacher (lama).
  • Practice begins with an empowerment (initiation) from the lama.
  • Four main schools: Nyingma, Kagyu, Sakya, Gelug. The Dalai Lamas belong to the Gelug.
Mission 1

Bon and the coming of Buddhism

Bon and the coming of Buddhismbefore 7th c.religion that tradition callsBon: rites for the dead andfor kings; offerings tospirits of mountains, lakes,earth and skyfrom 7th c.Buddhism arrives fromIndia and China8th c.King Trisong Detsen invitesŚāntarakṣita andPadmasambhavac. 779Samye, the first monasterytraditionalPadmasambhava tameslocal spirits, binding themas Dharma protectorsfrom 11th c.Yungdrung Bon organised,in close contact withBuddhismBonBuddhismeach shaped the other(scholars debate how much of laterBon is truly pre-Buddhist)
  • Before Buddhism, Tibet had its own religion, which tradition calls Bon: rituals for the dead and for kings, and offerings to spirits of mountains, lakes, earth and sky.
  • Buddhism arrived from India and China from the 7th century; in the 8th century King Trisong Detsen invited the scholar Śāntarakṣita and the tantric master Padmasambhava. Samye, the first monastery, followed (c. 779).
  • Tradition says Padmasambhava tamed the local spirits and bound them by oath as protectors of the Dharma.
  • Practices such as prayer flags (wind horse), juniper smoke offerings and local protector deities are often linked to this older layer.
  • Bon today (Yungdrung Bon) is a living tradition with its own monasteries and scriptures; it was organised from the 11th century in close contact with Buddhism, so the two shaped each other.
  • Scholars debate how much of later Bon is truly pre-Buddhist.
Mission 1

Body, speech and mind

Body, speech and mindBodygesturemudragestures andposturesSpeechmantrasacredsoundsMindmandalaandvisualisationthe whole person trained to becomea Buddha's body, speech and mind
  • Vajrayana engages the whole person, because awakening is of the whole person.
  • Body → mudra: gestures and postures.
  • Speech → mantra: sacred sounds.
  • Mind → mandala and visualisation.
  • In deity yoga, practitioners visualise themselves as an awakened deity (such as Avalokitesvara), making its gestures, saying its mantra and imagining its mandala around them.
  • The aim: to train ordinary body, speech and mind to become those of a Buddha, while knowing the deity is empty of fixed existence.
Mission 1

Mudra

  • Your spec: mudra, "ritual bodily movements, often hand gestures".
  • In images: earth-touching (the Buddha calls the earth to witness his awakening), teaching (turning the wheel of Dharma), meditation, fearlessness, giving.
  • In ritual, a practitioner holds the vajra (right hand: skilful means and compassion) and the bell (left hand: wisdom); crossed at the heart they show the two united.
  • Mudras accompany mantra and visualisation: e.g. hands form an offering of the whole universe (the mandala offering).
  • Meaning: the body itself is used for practice; the gesture expresses and trains an awakened quality.
Mission 1Read the source

Mantra: Om mani padme hum

Prayer wheel: Om mani padme humoṃmaṇipadmehūṃeach turn countsas a recitationinside: rolled paperprinted with the mantra
  • Your spec: mantra, "sacred sounds".
  • The best-known Tibetan mantra is the six syllables of Avalokitesvara (Tibetan Chenrezig), the bodhisattva of compassion:

> Om maṇi padme hūṃ

  • Maṇi = "jewel" (linked with compassion and method); padme = "lotus" (linked with wisdom). The popular Western gloss "the jewel in the lotus" is disputed by scholars; Tibetans usually leave the mantra untranslated, as the sound matters.
  • It is recited on malas (108 beads), carved on mani stones, printed on prayer flags and rolled inside prayer wheels: each turn counts as a recitation.
  • Its purpose: to purify the mind and cultivate compassion for all beings.

Q1 Why would someone turn a prayer wheel rather than chant?

Show answer

Each turn is believed to send out the mantra; it joins body and mind in practice, for instance while walking.

Q2 Which quality is the mantra meant to grow?

Show answer

Compassion, Avalokitesvara's quality, joined with wisdom.

Quick check
?In Vajrayana practice, how do mudra, mantra and mandala relate to each other?
Mission 1

Mandala

A mandala seen from aboveRings, outside in:fire · vajras · lotus petalspalace with four gatescentre: the deity (shown as a lotus)swept uppouredinto flowing waterimpermanence (anicca)
  • Your spec: mandala, "cosmic diagrams".
  • A mandala shows the palace of an awakened deity seen from above: a square palace with four gates, inside rings of fire, vajras and lotus petals, with the deity at the centre.
  • It maps both the universe and the purified mind: the practitioner "enters" it in visualisation during empowerment.
  • Forms: painted (thangka), three-dimensional, visualised, or made of coloured sand (e.g. the Kalachakra mandala).
  • A sand mandala takes days or weeks; when complete it is dismantled, and the sand is poured into flowing water: a lesson in impermanence (anicca) and a sharing of blessing.
  • The mandala offering imagines the whole universe as a gift to the Buddhas.
Quick check
?Why is a sand mandala swept away after it is completed and blessed?
Mission 1Evaluate

How far is Tibetan Buddhism shaped by Bon?

How far is Tibetan Buddhism shaped by Bon?Claim: The distinctive practices of TibetanBuddhism owe more to Bon than to theBuddha.ForProtectors, prayer flags, smoke offeringsand a crowded world of spirits continue apre-Buddhist outlook.Padmasambhava's taming of spirits showsBuddhism absorbing local religion ratherthan replacing it.AgainstMudra, mantra and mandala have Sanskritnames and come from Indian Buddhisttantras.Their stated aims are Buddhist:compassion, wisdom of emptiness,awakening for all beings.Organised Bon itself borrowed heavilyfrom Buddhism, so influence ran bothways.Judge it byOrigin or purpose? · Is adapting to localculture a skilful means or a dilution?
  • Claim: The distinctive practices of Tibetan Buddhism owe more to Bon than to the Buddha.
  • For: protectors, prayer flags, smoke offerings and a crowded world of spirits continue a pre-Buddhist outlook.
  • For: Padmasambhava's taming of spirits shows Buddhism absorbing local religion rather than replacing it.
  • Against: mudra, mantra and mandala have Sanskrit names and come from Indian Buddhist tantras.
  • Against: their stated aims are Buddhist: compassion, wisdom of emptiness, awakening for all beings.
  • Against: organised Bon itself borrowed heavily from Buddhism, so influence ran both ways.
  • Judgement criteria: origin or purpose? Is adapting to local culture a skilful means or a dilution?
Mission check

?In a British museum, Tibetan monks complete a sand mandala over ten days. At the closing ceremony they chant, ring bells while making hand gestures, then sweep the sand away. Which reading of the ceremony is most accurate?
Mission 2

Mission 2: Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?

Make a guess: Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?

Mission 2

From sati to "mindfulness"

TimelineancientSati (mindfulness): 7th factor ofthe Eightfold Path1975Thich Nhat Hanh, The Miracleof Mindfulness1979Kabat-Zinn founds MBSR1987Mind and Life dialogues begin(Dalai Lama and scientists)2002MBCT (Segal, Williams andTeasdale)2007Google's "Search InsideYourself"2009Mindfulness in Schools Project(UK)2015Mindful Nation UK2022MYRIAD trial reported
  • Sati (Pali): mindfulness, the 7th factor of the Eightfold Path.
  • 1979: Jon Kabat-Zinn (b. 1944), who had trained with Zen and insight teachers, founded MBSR (Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction) at the University of Massachusetts Medical School.
  • He taught it without Buddhist words, so that anyone could use it.
  • His working definition (paraphrase): paying attention on purpose, in the present moment, without judging.
  • 2002: MBCT (Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy), by Segal, Williams and Teasdale, joined mindfulness with cognitive therapy for recurrent depression.
  • The Mindfulness Movement: the spread of these secular forms into health, education and business.
Mission 2

Mindfulness in health care

  • Pain management: MBSR began with patients in chronic pain; the aim is to relate differently to pain, not to remove it.
  • Stress and anxiety: eight-week courses teaching body scan, breathing practice and mindful movement.
  • Depression: NICE (England) recommends MBCT to help prevent relapse in people with recurrent depression.
  • Cancer care: programmes such as Mindfulness-Based Cancer Recovery support patients through treatment.
  • Addiction: Mindfulness-Based Relapse Prevention teaches people to notice cravings without acting on them.
Mission 2

Schools and business

  • Schools: e.g. the UK Mindfulness in Schools Project (founded 2009), with short courses for pupils and teachers.
  • A large UK trial (MYRIAD, reported 2022) found school mindfulness lessons no better than usual teaching for pupils' wellbeing overall.
  • Business: large companies run courses for staff (e.g. Google's "Search Inside Yourself", from 2007) to improve focus, resilience and leadership.
  • Politics: the UK Parliament's Mindfulness All-Party Parliamentary Group published Mindful Nation UK (2015).
  • Supporters: better focus and less stress. Critics: who benefits, the worker or the company?
Quick check
?Which statement best describes how MBSR and MBCT relate to Buddhism?
Mission 2

What is left out?

What is kept, what is leftKept in most secularcoursesUsually left outbreathing practicerefugebody scanthe preceptsmindful movementkarma and rebirthkindness practicesanattathe goal of NirvanaSome teachers keep ethics in through kindnesspractices
  • In Buddhism, mindfulness is right mindfulness: one factor of eight, joined to right view, right intention and ethics.
  • The suttas also speak of wrong mindfulness (MN 117): attention without the rest of the path.
  • Often left out of secular courses: refuge, the precepts, karma and rebirth, anatta, the goal of Nirvana.
  • Critics' example: a sniper or a fraudster can be very attentive. Is that mindfulness?
  • "McMindfulness": a critical term popularised by Ron Purser and David Loy (2013; Purser's book, 2019) for mindfulness sold as a product for self-improvement.
  • Replies: many teachers keep ethics in through kindness practices; and secular courses never claimed to be Buddhism.
Mission 2Read the source

Zizek's critique

Slavoj Zizek (b. 1949), Slovenian philosopher; "From Western Marxism to Western Buddhism" (Cabinet, 2001) and On Belief (2001), paraphrase:

  • "Western Buddhism" presents itself as the cure for the stress of capitalist life.
  • But it lets people keep up with that life's frantic pace while feeling inwardly detached from it.
  • So it works as capitalism's ideal supplement: it helps people cope, so they never challenge the system.
  • Eduqas wording: by encouraging stress-release, mindfulness serves capitalism rather than challenges it.

Q1 What, for Zizek, does mindfulness do for the worker?

Show answer

Helps them cope with stress while carrying on as before.

Q2 Why does he call this a problem?

Show answer

The causes of the stress, in the economic system, are left unchallenged.

Mission 2Diversity

Buddhist responses

Buddhist responsesWelcomeThich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022)any reduction of suffering is good14th Dalai LamaMind and Life dialogues with scientists (from1987)Skilful meansKabat-Zinnthe Dharma in a universal formCautionBhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944)cut off from ethics, it can support consumercapitalismPurser and Loymay reduce stress yet leave greed untouchedZizek (b. 1949)political critic, not a Buddhist responseGroups as the screen gives them, not a ranking
  • Welcome: Thich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022), The Miracle of Mindfulness (1975), taught mindfulness to everyone, including business and political leaders: any reduction of suffering is good.
  • Welcome: the 14th Dalai Lama has worked with scientists (Mind and Life dialogues, from 1987) to study meditation's effects.
  • Skilful means: Kabat-Zinn calls MBSR an expression of the Dharma in a universal form; some Buddhists agree it can be a doorway to deeper practice.
  • Caution: Bhikkhu Bodhi (b. 1944) has warned that, cut off from its ethical setting, mindfulness can end up supporting consumer capitalism.
  • Caution: Purser and Loy: without right intention, it may reduce stress yet leave greed untouched.
Quick check
?Which objection is Zizek's own criticism of the Mindfulness Movement?
Mission 2Evaluate

"The Mindfulness Movement is not really Buddhist."

Argument map"The Mindfulness Movement is not reallyBuddhist."ForIt drops refuge, precepts, rebirth andNirvana: a technique, not a pathIts aims (health, performance) differ fromawakening; MN 117 warns of wrongmindfulnessZizek: it helps people cope with the paceof capitalist life instead of questioning itAgainstThe practice comes from Buddhistteachers; Kabat-Zinn sees it as universalDharmaThich Nhat Hanh and the Dalai Lamawelcome it as a relief of suffering, theBuddha's own concernSecular Buddhists argue the Dharmanever needed metaphysicsJudge it byIs Buddhism defined by belief, practice orgoal? · Who decides what counts? · Can a partcarry the whole?
  • For: it drops refuge, precepts, rebirth and Nirvana; what remains is a technique, not a path.
  • For: its aims (health, performance) differ from awakening; MN 117 warns of wrong mindfulness.
  • For: Zizek: it helps people cope with the pace of capitalist life instead of questioning it.
  • Against: the practice comes from Buddhist teachers; Kabat-Zinn sees it as universal Dharma.
  • Against: Thich Nhat Hanh and the Dalai Lama welcome it as a relief of suffering, the Buddha's own concern.
  • Against: Secular Buddhists argue the Dharma never needed metaphysics.
  • Judgement criteria: Is Buddhism defined by belief, practice or goal? Who decides what counts? Can a part carry the whole?
  • Spec issue: "the extent to which the contemporary Mindfulness movement can be considered to be Buddhist".
Mission 2Evaluate

"Mindfulness offers an antidote to suffering."

  • For: good evidence that MBCT reduces relapse into depression; pain and stress feel more bearable.
  • For: mindful awareness of craving in addiction is close to the Second Noble Truth in practice.
  • Against: Buddhism names three kinds of dukkha: pain itself, the pain of change, and the unsatisfactoriness of all conditioned things. Stress relief touches mainly the first.
  • Against: the root of dukkha is craving and ignorance; only wisdom ends them.
  • Against: Zizek: it soothes symptoms while the causes (overwork, insecurity) remain; the MYRIAD trial is a reminder that benefits are not universal.
  • Judgement criteria: "Antidote" in the medical sense, or in the Buddhist sense? Whose suffering, and at what depth? Can individual practice answer social causes?
Quick check
?A Buddhist teacher says: "Secular mindfulness can ease the suffering of pain, but it leaves untouched the suffering built into all conditioned things." Which teaching lies behind this?
Mission check

?A bank starts lunchtime mindfulness sessions so that staff can cope with longer working hours. Which pairing of person and response is accurate?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Bombs are falling near your temple. Do you keep meditating or go out to help?

Make a guess: Bombs are falling near your temple. Do you keep meditating or go out to help?

Mission 3

What "Engaged Buddhism" means

  • Engaged Buddhism: applying Buddhist teaching and practice to the social, political and environmental causes of suffering, not only to the individual mind.
  • It works on two levels at once: inner change (mindfulness, compassion) and outer change (service, protest, campaigning).
  • Liberationist: aims to free people from suffering caused by structures: war, poverty, caste, oppression, environmental damage.
  • It is a movement across many traditions (Theravada, Mahayana, Vajrayana, Western convert groups), not a separate school.
  • Your spec says Socially Engaged Buddhism and calls it a "liberationist" tradition.
Mission 3

Origins: Vietnam

Engaged Buddhism: many rootsChinaIndia (Nagpur)Sri LankaVietnamFranceThailand1920s–30sChina: Taixu calls for a"Buddhism for human life"1956India: Ambedkar leads the Dalitconversion at Nagpur1958Sri Lanka: Ariyaratne foundsSarvodaya Shramadana1964–65Vietnam: School of Youth forSocial Service1966Order of Interbeing; Thich NhatHanh exiled1967Book: Vietnam: Lotus in aSea of Fire1982Plum Village founded in France1989International Network ofEngaged Buddhists (SulakSivaraksa, Thailand)
  • Thich Nhat Hanh (1926–2022), Vietnamese Zen monk (Lam Te/Linji lineage).
  • 1950s–60s: war in Vietnam. Monks and nuns faced a choice: stay in the monastery, or go out to the bombed villages.
  • His answer: do both. Mindfulness that ignores suffering around you is not real mindfulness (paraphrase).
  • 1964–65: founds the School of Youth for Social Service: young lay people and monastics rebuild villages, run clinics and schools.
  • 1966: founds the Order of Interbeing (Tiep Hien), with fourteen precepts; leaves on a peace tour and is exiled from Vietnam.
  • 1967: his book Vietnam: Lotus in a Sea of Fire spreads the phrase engaged Buddhism in English.
  • 1982: founds Plum Village in France, which spreads engaged practice to the West.
Mission 3

Origins: many roots, not one founder

Engaged Buddhism: many rootsChinaIndia (Nagpur)Sri LankaVietnamFranceThailand1920s–30sChina: Taixu calls for a"Buddhism for human life"1956India: Ambedkar leads the Dalitconversion at Nagpur1958Sri Lanka: Ariyaratne foundsSarvodaya Shramadana1964–65Vietnam: School of Youth forSocial Service1966Order of Interbeing; Thich NhatHanh exiled1967Book: Vietnam: Lotus in aSea of Fire1982Plum Village founded in France1989International Network ofEngaged Buddhists (SulakSivaraksa, Thailand)
  • China, 1920s–30s: the monk Taixu (1890–1947) calls for a "Buddhism for human life" that serves society.
  • India, 1956: B. R. Ambedkar (1891–1956) leads a mass conversion of Dalits (formerly called "untouchables") at Nagpur: Buddhism as escape from caste oppression.
  • Sri Lanka, 1958: A. T. Ariyaratne (1931–2024) founds Sarvodaya Shramadana: village self-help based on generosity and shared labour.
  • Thailand: Sulak Sivaraksa (b. 1933) critiques consumerism; co-founds the International Network of Engaged Buddhists (1989).
  • Aims shared across these: reduce suffering here and now; transform the causes (greed, hatred, delusion) in people and in institutions; act non-violently.
Mission 3

Why a Buddhist might engage

  • Dukkha is the starting point of the Four Noble Truths: the Buddha taught to end suffering, and much suffering has social causes.
  • Karuna (compassion) and metta (loving-kindness): wishing beings free from suffering leads to action.
  • Dependent origination: nothing exists alone; my peace depends on others' peace.
  • The precepts: the first precept (not harming) and right livelihood concern how society treats life.
  • Bodhisattva ideal (Mahayana): vow to work for the awakening of all beings (often described as putting off one's own final nirvana).
  • Your spec's key phrase: the drive to combat suffering, not only to gain a better rebirth or awakening for oneself.
Mission 3Read the source

Two verses

Dhammapada (Müller translation, 1881):

> "All men tremble at punishment, all men fear death; remember that you are like unto them, and do not kill, nor cause slaughter." (Dhammapada 129)

> "For hatred does not cease by hatred at any time: hatred ceases by love, this is an old rule." (Dhammapada 5)

Q1 What reason does verse 129 give for not killing?

Show answer

Others fear death as you do: put yourself in their place.

Q2 How might an engaged Buddhist use verse 5 in a conflict?

Show answer

To argue for non-violent action and reconciliation, not revenge.

  • Note: "nor cause slaughter" goes beyond personal conduct: it also rules out making others kill.
Quick check
?Which statement best describes the "liberationist" side of Engaged Buddhism?
Mission 3

Interbeing

Interbeing: a sheet of paperLook deeply at a sheet of paper…cloudrainsuntreeloggerThe paper "inter-is" with everything.Thich Nhat Hanh's image (paraphrase)
  • Thich Nhat Hanh's key word: interbeing. It restates dependent origination and emptiness in everyday terms.
  • His best-known image (paraphrase): look deeply at a sheet of paper and you see the cloud, the rain, the tree and the logger in it. The paper "inter-is" with everything.
  • So the suffering of others is not outside me: their hunger, fear or anger is part of my world, and my actions feed into theirs.
  • Seeing leads to acting: for Thich Nhat Hanh, real mindfulness is engaged mindfulness (paraphrase of Peace Is Every Step, 1991).
  • Name of his order: Order of Interbeing.
Mission 3

The Fourteen Precepts (1): free minds, open eyes

Fourteen Precepts / Mindfulness TrainingsFourteen Precepts /Mindfulness TrainingsInterbeing (1987; rev. 1993) · paraphrasedViews 1–31Do not worshipany doctrine,even Buddhistones2Knowledge isnever final: stayopen3Never forceviews on anyoneSuffering and simplicity 4–54Do not close youreyes to suffering5Do not pile upwealth: livesimplyMind and speech 6–96Look deeply intoanger; transformit7Return to thepresent moment8No words thatdivide; reconcile9Speak truthfully;speak out oninjusticeCommunity, work, life, body 10–1410Sangha not forgain or a party;stand againstoppression11No job thatharms people ornature12Do not kill;protect life,prevent war13Do not take whatis not yours14Do not mistreatyour body
  • Source: Thich Nhat Hanh, Interbeing: Fourteen Guidelines for Engaged Buddhism (1987; revised 1993). Plum Village now calls them the Fourteen Mindfulness Trainings.
  • Your spec: "Thich Nhat Hanh's Mindfulness Trainings".
  • 1: Do not worship any doctrine or ideology, even Buddhist ones: teachings are guides, not absolute truth.
  • 2: Do not think your present knowledge is final; stay open to others' views.
  • 3: Do not force views on anyone, children included, by authority, threat, money, propaganda or indoctrination.
  • 4: Do not avoid suffering or close your eyes to it; find ways to be with those who suffer.
  • 5: Do not pile up wealth while millions are hungry; live simply.
  • 6: Do not keep anger or hatred; look deeply to understand and transform it.
  • 7: Do not lose yourself in distraction; return to the present moment through mindful breathing.
  • (All paraphrased.)
Mission 3

The Fourteen Precepts (2): speech, community, life

Fourteen Precepts / Mindfulness TrainingsFourteen Precepts /Mindfulness TrainingsInterbeing (1987; rev. 1993) · paraphrasedViews 1–31Do not worshipany doctrine,even Buddhistones2Knowledge isnever final: stayopen3Never forceviews on anyoneSuffering and simplicity 4–54Do not close youreyes to suffering5Do not pile upwealth: livesimplyMind and speech 6–96Look deeply intoanger; transformit7Return to thepresent moment8No words thatdivide; reconcile9Speak truthfully;speak out oninjusticeCommunity, work, life, body 10–1410Sangha not forgain or a party;stand againstoppression11No job thatharms people ornature12Do not kill;protect life,prevent war13Do not take whatis not yours14Do not mistreatyour body
  • 8: Do not speak words that cause division; work to reconcile conflicts.
  • 9: Speak truthfully; have the courage to speak out about injustice, even when it is dangerous.
  • 10: Do not use the Buddhist community for personal gain or turn it into a political party; but it should take a clear stand against oppression and injustice.
  • 11: Do not work in a job that harms people or nature (right livelihood).
  • 12: Do not kill or let others kill; find every means to protect life and prevent war.
  • 13: Do not take what belongs to others; stop others profiting from human suffering or the suffering of other beings.
  • 14: Do not mistreat your body; for lay members, sexual relations only with love and long-term commitment; monastics keep celibacy.
  • Notice the pattern: the first three guard the mind against dogma, the rest turn mindfulness outwards into society.
Quick check
?A Buddhist campaign group says: "Our teaching is the only truth; anyone who rejects it must be made to accept it." Which of Thich Nhat Hanh's precepts does this most directly break?
Mission 3Diversity

New movement or old Buddhism?

New movement or old Buddhism?"It is new"Christopher Queen(with Sallie King,1996)Almost a new"vehicle"Shaped by modernideas: human rights,democracy, socialjustice"It is old"Thich Nhat Hanh,Sulak Sivaraksa,othersThe Buddha advisedkingsSangha open to allcastesLay duties:Sigalovada Sutta(DN 31)Ashoka: medicalcare, wells (RockEdict 2)Traditional caution (some Theravadamonastics)renunciation is the monastic path; the Vinayalimits monks' politics; social work mainly forthe laity
  • "It is new": Christopher Queen (with Sallie King, Engaged Buddhism, 1996) asks whether it is almost a new "vehicle", shaped by modern ideas such as human rights, democracy and social justice.
  • "It is old": Thich Nhat Hanh, Sulak Sivaraksa and others: Buddhism was always engaged. The Buddha advised kings, admitted people of all castes to the Sangha and taught lay duties (Sigalovada Sutta, Digha Nikaya 31); the emperor Ashoka provided medical care for people and animals, and dug wells (Rock Edict 2).
  • Traditional caution (some Theravada monastics): the monastic path is renunciation; the Vinaya limits monks' political involvement; social work is mainly the laity's role.
  • Mahayana emphasis: the bodhisattva who returns to the marketplace makes engagement feel native, not borrowed.
  • Damien Keown's assessment.
Quick check
?Which reason would most support the claim that Engaged Buddhism is a modern development rather than ancient Buddhism?
Mission check

?A Buddhist nun in a city with many homeless people spends her mornings in meditation and her afternoons running a night shelter. A visitor says: "You are wasting your practice: the path is about your own mind." Which reply draws most directly on the teaching behind Engaged Buddhism?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Can a Buddhist ordain a tree, march against an army, or ever support a war?

Make a guess: Can a Buddhist ordain a tree, march against an army, or ever support a war?

Mission 4

From mindfulness to activism

  • Social activism: organised action to change society: campaigns, protest, service, building alternatives.
  • Why a Buddhist may see it as practice, not a distraction:
  • Compassion (karuna): wishing beings free from suffering is incomplete without action.
  • Interdependence: harm to forests, the poor or the enemy is not separate from me.
  • Right action and right livelihood: the path includes how I act and earn in the world.
  • Non-violence (ahimsa): it shapes the method as much as the goal.
Mission 4

Why the movement grew

  • Suffering on a new scale: war in Vietnam and Cambodia, caste in India, poverty, nuclear weapons, climate change.
  • The primary drive: to combat suffering here and now, not only to gain a positive rebirth or one's own awakening.
  • High-profile leaders: the 14th Dalai Lama (b. 1935) leads non-violent resistance over Tibet (Nobel Peace Prize, 1989); Thich Nhat Hanh.
  • Media coverage: images of monks marching or of peace walks reach a global audience.
  • Organisations: the Buddhist Peace Fellowship (founded 1978, Hawaii) and Sakyadhita (founded 1987, Bodh Gaya: an international association of Buddhist women; see an earlier lesson).
  • These are the reasons your spec lists for the development of Socially Engaged Buddhism.
Mission 4

Environmental awareness and action

Three areas of engagementEnvironmentThailand, late 1980s on: treeswrapped in orange robes andordained2009: A Buddhist Declaration onClimate ChangePlum Village: plant-based food,low-carbon living
  • Thai "ecology monks": from the late 1980s, monks wrap trees in orange robes and ordain them, so cutting them would feel like harming a monk.
  • A Buddhist Declaration on Climate Change ("The Time to Act Is Now", 2009): drafted by David Loy and John Stanley with Bhikkhu Bodhi; calls for urgent cuts in emissions, grounded in interdependence and non-harm.
  • Plum Village: plant-based food, low-carbon living, and teaching that we must "fall in love with the Earth" (paraphrase of Thich Nhat Hanh).
  • Teachings used: dependent origination; the first precept extended to all living beings; craving (tanha) as the root of overconsumption.
Mission 4

Joanna Macy: the greening of the self

The greening of the selffuture generationsthe forestmethe ecological selfMacy, World as Lover, World as Self (1991) ·paraphrase
  • Joanna Macy (1929–2025), Buddhist scholar and activist; Mutual Causality in Buddhism and General Systems Theory (1991); World as Lover, World as Self (1991).
  • Dependent co-arising as mutual causality: everything conditions everything else, like a living system.
  • The greening of the self: the self is not a separate thing; widened, it becomes an ecological self that includes the forest and future generations.
  • So protecting the Earth is not self-sacrifice: it is the self acting for its wider self (paraphrase).
  • Despair work / The Work That Reconnects: pain for the world is a sign of interconnection and compassion, not a weakness; facing it frees energy for action.
  • Her view of the movement: engagement flows naturally from core Buddhist insight; it is not a Western add-on.
Mission 4

Opposition to oppression, injustice and poverty

Three areas of engagementEnvironmentThailand, late 1980s on: treeswrapped in orange robes andordained2009: A Buddhist Declaration onClimate ChangePlum Village: plant-based food,low-carbon livingOppression and povertyIndia, from 1956: Ambedkar, Dalitsreject casteSri Lanka: Sarvodaya Shramadana,village self-helpTibet: the Dalai Lama's Middle Way,non-violence and dialogueMyanmar, 2007: monks overturn theiralms bowls
  • Caste: Ambedkar's Navayana movement (from 1956): Dalits embrace Buddhism to reject caste; schools, hostels, legal rights.
  • Poverty: Sarvodaya Shramadana (Sri Lanka): villages build roads, wells and pre-schools together; awakening of the person and the village together.
  • Tibet: the Dalai Lama's Middle Way Approach: genuine autonomy sought only through non-violence and dialogue.
  • Myanmar, 2007 ("Saffron Revolution"): monks march and overturn their alms bowls, refusing alms from the military: a traditional Vinaya sanction used as protest.
  • Women: Sakyadhita campaigns for education and ordination for Buddhist women.
Mission 4

War and peace

Three areas of engagementEnvironmentThailand, late 1980s on: treeswrapped in orange robes andordained2009: A Buddhist Declaration onClimate ChangePlum Village: plant-based food,low-carbon livingOppression and povertyIndia, from 1956: Ambedkar, Dalitsreject casteSri Lanka: Sarvodaya Shramadana,village self-helpTibet: the Dalai Lama's Middle Way,non-violence and dialogueMyanmar, 2007: monks overturn theiralms bowlsWar and peaceVietnam: School of Youth for SocialService; call for a ceasefireCambodia, from 1992: Dhammayietrapeace walksBuddhist Peace Fellowship: againstnuclear weapons and war
  • Vietnam: Thich Nhat Hanh's School of Youth for Social Service helped victims on all sides; he called for a ceasefire and was exiled for it.
  • Cambodia: Maha Ghosananda (d. 2007) leads the Dhammayietra peace walks from 1992, through land once mined, after the Khmer Rouge genocide.
  • Buddhist Peace Fellowship: founded by Robert and Anne Aitken and others; campaigns against nuclear weapons and war, works with prisoners.

> "Victory breeds hatred, for the conquered is unhappy. He who has given up both victory and defeat, he, the contented, is happy." (Dhammapada 201, Müller 1881)

Quick check
?Thai monks wrap a forest's oldest trees in orange robes and ordain them. Which belief most directly lies behind this action?
Mission 4Diversity

Could a Buddhist ever accept war?

Could a Buddhist ever accept war?NeverAs a rare exception1231Never: first precept; Ashoka renouncedconquest after Kalinga (most engagedBuddhists)2Defence of the Dharma: a Mahavamsareading used by some Sri Lankan monks3Compassionate killing as an exception: theship captain (Upayakausalya Sutra)HistoryZen at War (Brian Victoria, 1997): JapaneseZen support for militarism before 1945
  • Never: the first precept; Dhammapada 5 and 201; the emperor Ashoka renounced conquest after the Kalinga war (Rock Edict 13). Most engaged Buddhists hold this view.
  • Defence of the Dharma: the Sri Lankan chronicle Mahavamsa (c. 5th–6th century CE) tells how King Dutthagamani was reassured after a war against a non-Buddhist king; some Sri Lankan monks have used it to back war (studied by Tessa Bartholomeusz, In Defense of Dharma, 2002).
  • Compassionate killing? A Mahayana text, the Upayakausalya Sutra, tells of a ship's captain (the Buddha in a past life) who kills a robber to save 500 merchants and to spare the robber the karma of mass murder; he accepts the bad karma himself.
  • History: Brian Victoria, Zen at War (1997), documents Japanese Zen support for militarism before 1945; many Zen bodies have since apologised.
  • Most Buddhists distinguish intention (cetana) and self-defence from aggression, and hold that killing always carries karmic weight.
Mission 4

Damien Keown: a scholar's assessment

  • Damien Keown (b. 1951), The Nature of Buddhist Ethics (1992); Buddhist Ethics: A Very Short Introduction (2005).
  • New: Engaged Buddhism is largely a modern development: early texts say much about personal ethics but little about political or social structures.
  • Western influence: its language of rights and justice shows contact with Western thought; critics ask whether its values are Buddhist or imported.
  • But grounded: Keown argues such values can be rooted in Buddhist teaching: e.g. human rights are implicit in the precepts ("Are There Human Rights in Buddhism?", 1995).
  • Task ahead: for the movement to last, it needs a clearer doctrinal basis linking action to the goal of nirvana (paraphrase).
  • Compare Macy: she sees engagement as flowing directly from dependent co-arising; Keown sees it as a modern development that must be justified from the sources.
Mission 4Evaluate

Should engagement be central to the Buddhist path?

Should engagement be central?Social engagement is central to theBuddhist path, not a distraction from it.ForThe path aims to end dukkha, and muchdukkha is social; karuna without action isemptyInterbeing: no private awakening apartfrom others; the bodhisattva vows to workfor the awakening of all beingsAgainstThe Buddha left home; nirvana comes byinsight, not by changing societyActivism can bring anger and attachment;monks in politics have backed militarism(Japanese Zen before 1945)Judge it byWhich comes first: awakening or relief ofsuffering? · Can they be separated? · Lay ormonastic? · Does it undo the "inward-looking"stereotype?
  • Claim: Social engagement is central to the Buddhist path, not a distraction from it.
  • For: the path aims to end dukkha, and much dukkha is social; karuna without action is empty.
  • For: interbeing / dependent origination: there is no private awakening apart from others; the bodhisattva ideal (a vow to work for the awakening of all beings).
  • Against: the Buddha left home; nirvana is reached by insight, not by changing society; time in politics is time not spent on practice.
  • Against: activism can bring anger and attachment to results; monks in politics have also backed nationalism and violence (e.g. Japanese Zen support for militarism before 1945).
  • Criteria: Which goal comes first: awakening or relief of suffering? Can the two be separated? Does it matter who acts (lay or monastic)? Does engagement undo the stereotype of Buddhism as inward-looking, or misread the tradition?
  • Issues for evaluation: social justice as a requisite; social engagement as a distraction on the path to Awakening.
Quick check
?Which argument would a Buddhist most likely give for seeing social engagement as a distraction from the path?
Mission check

?A Buddhist group is deciding whether to join a large protest against a new coal mine. Which advice fits the approach of most Engaged Buddhists?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Vajrayana trains body, speech and mind through mudra, mantra and mandala, often together in deity yoga.
  • Tibetan Buddhism grew alongside Bon: it absorbed local spirits and rites, and Bon in turn borrowed from Buddhism.

Mission 2

  • Since 1979, secular mindfulness (MBSR, MBCT) has spread into health care, schools and business, drawing on Buddhist meditation without Buddhist belief.
  • Buddhist responses range from welcome (Thich Nhat Hanh, the Dalai Lama) to caution (Bhikkhu Bodhi; "McMindfulness").
  • Zizek: by relieving stress, mindfulness serves capitalism rather than challenging it.

Mission 3

  • Engaged Buddhism applies Buddhist teaching to the social and structural causes of suffering, alongside inner practice.
  • It grew from many roots (Taixu, Ambedkar, Sarvodaya, Sulak) and above all from Thich Nhat Hanh in wartime Vietnam: interbeing, the Order of Interbeing and its fourteen precepts.

Mission 4

  • Buddhist activism spans the environment (tree ordination, climate declaration), oppression and poverty (Ambedkar, Sarvodaya, Tibet, Myanmar) and peace (Thich Nhat Hanh, Ghosananda, BPF).
  • Macy grounds activism in dependent co-arising and the ecological self; Keown sees a modern development that must be rooted in the sources.
  • Buddhists disagree over whether engagement is central or a distraction, and over whether war could ever be accepted.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Buddhism: Religious practices that shape religious identity (part 2) for Eduqas A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Why would monks spend weeks making a picture out of sand and then sweep it away?
  2. Mission 2Mindfulness apps, office courses, NHS therapy: is any of it still Buddhist?
  3. Mission 3Bombs are falling near your temple. Do you keep meditating or go out to help?
  4. Mission 4Can a Buddhist ordain a tree, march against an army, or ever support a war?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Eduqas