← A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel · A-Level Religious Studies revision
⭐ 0
Edexcel A-level Religious Studies (9RS0) · Paper 4F Sikhism – 2 Sources of wisdom and authority
Mini-Lesson

Sikhism: Sources of wisdom and authority

4 missions. Guess, learn, then check. Your place is saved.

  1. Mission 1Guru Nanak vanished into a river for three days. What did he come back saying, and why does it matter?
  2. Mission 2How did one Guru turn followers into the Khalsa, then end the line of human Gurus?
  3. Mission 3Who wrote the Sikh scripture, and why do scholars argue about how it was put together?
  4. Mission 4Sikhs treat a book as their living Guru. What does that mean, and is it worship?

Also part of this unit: 2 missions in Sikhism: Beliefs (part 2).

Mission 1

Mission 1: Guru Nanak vanished into a river for three days. What did he come back saying, and why does it matter?

Make a guess: Guru Nanak vanished into a river for three days. What did he come back saying, and why does it matter?

Mission 1

How we know about Guru Nanak

How we know about Guru NanakHis hymns in the GGShis own words, but not abiographyBhai Gurdas, Var 1a short early account, about 80years after Nanak's deathJanamsakhis17th century on: Puratan, Bala,Miharban; each episode carriesa teachingcloser to Nanak
  • His hymns in the Guru Granth Sahib (GGS): his own words, but not a biography.
  • Bhai Gurdas (c. 1551–1636), Var 1: a short early account, written about 80 years after Nanak's death.
  • Janamsakhis ("birth stories"): collections of episodes from the 17th century on (Puratan, Bala, Miharban traditions).
  • Janamsakhis teach through story: each episode carries a teaching. Their status as sources.
  • Read them as devotional literature first; historians accept few details as certain.
Mission 1

Birth and the One

  • Born 1469 at Talwandi; father Mehta Kalu, a Khatri village accountant; mother Tripta; sister Nanaki.
  • Janamsakhi: the family astrologer, casting the baby's horoscope, foretold that Hindus and Muslims alike would honour him (paraphrase; versions differ).
  • As a schoolboy, he is said to have written verses on the One God rather than his lessons.
  • Teaching: Ik Oankar: there is one God, Nirankar (formless), creator of all.
Mission 1Read the source

The sacred thread

At about age eleven, Nanak refused the janeu (sacred thread) at his initiation. In Asa di Var he describes the thread he would accept:

  • Make compassion the cotton, contentment the thread, self-control the knot and truth the twist. Such a thread does not break, get dirty, burn or get lost (GGS 471, paraphrase).

Q1 What does Nanak put in place of the outward thread?

Show answer

Inner virtues: compassion, contentment, self-control, truth.

Q2 Why does refusing the thread challenge caste?

Show answer

It was given only to high-caste boys; women and low castes were excluded.

Mission 1

God's court

Guru Nanak's life1469born at Talwandic. 1499Sultanpur Lodhi: the Beinriver and God's courtc. 1500–1520sjourneys (udasis) withMardana1520sfounds Kartarpur on theRavi: farmer andhouseholder1539chooses Angad as Guru;Nanak dies
  • About 1499, at Sultanpur Lodhi, Nanak worked as storekeeper for the governor Daulat Khan Lodi.
  • Bathing in the Bein river, he disappeared for three days.
  • Janamsakhis: he was taken to God's court (dargah), given a cup of nectar (amrit) and sent to praise God's Name and teach others to do the same.
  • He returned saying: "Na koi Hindu, na koi Musalman": "There is no Hindu, there is no Muslim" (janamsakhi tradition).
  • Story: he joined the governor and the qazi at prayer but did not bow: their minds were on a horse purchase and a foal near a well. True prayer is attention to God.
  • Sikhs see this as Nanak's call: his mission to reveal the Name to the world.
Quick check
?Most Sikhs understand "There is no Hindu, there is no Muslim" to mean what?
Mission 1

Journeys with Mardana

Journeys with MardanaPunjabMeccaBaghdadBanarasPuriAssamSri LankaHimalayasMardanaEast: Banaras, Puri, AssamSouth: Sri LankaNorth: the Himalayas, the Nath yogisWest: Mecca, BaghdadRoutes and numbers of journeys vary betweentraditions.
  • About 1500–1520s: long journeys (udasis), usually counted as four, with the Muslim musician Mardana.
  • East (Banaras, Puri, Assam) · South (Sri Lanka) · North (the Himalayas, the Nath yogis) · West (Mecca, Baghdad).
  • At Haridwar he threw water west, "to my fields in Punjab": if water reaches ancestors, it can reach my fields.
  • At Mecca, asked to move his feet from the Kaaba, he asked to be pointed where God is not (janamsakhi).
  • At Eminabad he ate the honest bread of Lalo, a low-caste carpenter, not the feast of the rich official Malik Bhago: honest work over wealth from exploitation.
Mission 1

Sajjan the thug

  • Sajjan kept an inn with a Hindu temple and a mosque for travellers. At night he robbed and killed rich guests.
  • Nanak sang to him (GGS 729, Suhi): bronze is bright and shiny, but rub it and the black shows; washing cannot remove that dirt. Only those who walk with you to the end are friends (paraphrase).
  • Sajjan saw himself in the hymn, confessed, gave his wealth to the poor and became a follower; tradition says his inn became the first dharamsal (place of worship).
  • Teaching: true religion is inner purity and honest deeds, not outward show. Anyone can turn.
Quick check
?Which episode from Guru Nanak's life most directly teaches that outward piety can hide inner impurity?
Mission 1

Kartarpur

A day at Kartarpurdaynightdawndusk12341Before dawn:Japji recitedBhai Gurdas, Var 12Day:farm work: Nanak lived as a farmerand householder3Meals:langar: all castes eat together4Evening:hymns Sodar and Arti sungBhai Gurdas, Var 1rememberGodnam japnaearn honestlykirt karnasharevand chakna
  • In the 1520s Nanak founded Kartarpur ("the Creator's town") on the Ravi, and lived there as a farmer and householder until 1539.
  • Bhai Gurdas (Var 1) describes Japji recited before dawn and the hymns Sodar and Arti sung in the evening.
  • A community of women and men of all castes eating together (langar), working and singing together (sangat).
  • It models three principles: remember God, earn honestly, share.
  • Your spec's terms: nam japna, kirt karna, vand chakna.
  • Liberation is lived in ordinary life, not in retreat.
Mission 1

The Guru line begins

  • Before he died (1539), Nanak chose Bhai Lehna, a devoted disciple, not his own sons. Sri Chand, his elder son, was an ascetic.
  • He renamed him Angad ("my own limb") and bowed to him.
  • Janamsakhis tell of tests of obedience, e.g. carrying a bundle of wet grass that soiled his fine clothes.
  • Sikhs believe the same light (jot) passed from Guru to Guru: only the body changed (Satta and Balwand, GGS 966, paraphrase).
  • So Guru-ship depends on worth, not birth.
  • The line runs to 1708.
Quick check
?Why do Sikhs believe Guru Nanak chose Bhai Lehna (Guru Angad) as his successor?
Mission 1Diversity

Reading the janamsakhis

  • Devotional reading: many Sikhs tell the sakhis as true accounts of the Guru's life and as moral guidance, especially to children.
  • W. H. McLeod (1932–2009), Guru Nanak and the Sikh Religion (1968): tested each episode against other evidence; found only a small core historically secure.
  • N K Singh (Nikky-Guninder Kaur Singh), Sikhism: An Introduction (2011): reads the janamsakhis as literary and devotional art; they show how the community imagined and loved its Guru.
  • W. Owen Cole (1931–2013), The Guru in Sikhism (1982): the true Guru is God; Nanak is the human channel of the divine Word, and that is why his life is an exemplar for Sikhs.
  • Many Sikh scholars warn that purely historical tests miss what the stories are for.
Mission 1Evaluate

Background or key events: which shaped his teaching more?

Background or key events?Background or key events: which shaped histeaching more?BackgroundSant ideas (the Name, nirgun God), Sufidevotion, caste practice and Mughalviolence shaped his themes andvocabularyKey eventsGod's court is, for Sikhs, the source of themessage; Sajjan, Lalo and Mecca showteaching applied to real peopleKartarpur turned teaching into a way oflife and an institution; choosing Angadcreated the Guru lineProblem of evidenceMost "events" come from janamsakhiswritten long after; the hymns are thesurest guideJudge it byWhich source do you trust more? · Doesbackground explain content, or only thewords used? · Can revelation and contextboth be true?
  • Background: sant ideas (the Name, nirgun God), Sufi devotion, caste practice and Mughal violence shaped his themes and vocabulary.
  • Key events: God's court is, for Sikhs, the source of the message; Sajjan, Lalo and Mecca show teaching applied to real people.
  • Key events: Kartarpur turned teaching into a way of life and an institution; choosing Angad created the Guru line.
  • Problem of evidence: most "events" come from janamsakhis written long after; the hymns are the surest guide.
  • Judge it by: Which source do you trust more? Does background explain content, or only the words used? Can revelation and context both be true?
Mission check

?A Sikh business owner pays fair wages, refuses a deal that would cheat suppliers, and gives a tenth of her profit to a free kitchen. Which episode and teaching of Guru Nanak does her conduct best reflect?
Mission 2

Mission 2: How did one Guru turn followers into the Khalsa, then end the line of human Gurus?

Make a guess: How did one Guru turn followers into the Khalsa, then end the line of human Gurus?

Mission 2

The boy Guru

Guru Gobind Singh: timeline1666born at Patna1675Guru at nine, after his father'smartyrdom1688battle of Bhangani1699Vaisakhi at Anandpur: theKhalsa1704–05sieges of Anandpur;Chamkaur; Sirhind1706Damdama Sahib: final text ofthe scripture1708dies at Nanded: Guru Granthand Guru Panth
  • Guru Gobind Singh (1666–1708), born at Patna; Guru from 1675, aged nine, after his father Guru Tegh Bahadur's martyrdom.
  • Grew up at Anandpur in the Punjab hills; learned Persian, Sanskrit and Braj, and the use of arms.
  • Kept poets at his court and wrote poetry himself.
  • Pressed by the hill rajas and by Mughal governors under Emperor Aurangzeb; fought at Bhangani (1688).
  • The question he faced: how could the Panth survive persecution and stay true to Nanak?
Mission 2

Vaisakhi 1699

Amrit at Vaisakhi 1699khandaone bowl:sweetened watersweetsinitiated as the Khalsathe Panj Piare (the Five Beloved Ones)then they initiated himthe GuruGuru and disciple
  • At the spring festival of Vaisakhi, the Guru gathered Sikhs at Anandpur and asked who would give his head.
  • Five men came forward, one by one, from different castes and regions: the Panj Piare (the Five Beloved Ones).
  • He prepared amrit (sweetened water stirred with a double-edged sword, the khanda, while hymns were recited) and initiated them as the Khalsa.
  • Then he asked them to initiate him.
  • New names: Singh ("lion") for men, Kaur ("princess") for women (Sikh tradition; some historians date the general use of Kaur later).
  • A discipline including the 5Ks (kesh, kangha, kara, kachera, kirpan): detail in a later lesson. Accounts of the day differ in detail.
Mission 2

Why the Khalsa?

  • Protector: a community ready to defend faith and the weak against persecution.
  • Restorer: renewing Nanak's equality: all castes drank from one bowl; caste surnames replaced by Singh and Kaur.
  • Direct belonging: "Khalsa" can mean land held directly by the ruler; the corrupt masands (agents) were removed, so Sikhs belonged directly to the Guru.
  • Visible identity: the 5Ks and uncut hair mean a Sikh cannot hide when faith is under threat.
  • Sikh tradition: women were initiated too (Kaur).
  • Zafarnama, his letter to Aurangzeb: when every other means has failed, it is right to take up the sword (paraphrase).
Quick check
?Why did Guru Gobind Singh ask the Panj Piare to initiate him after he had initiated them?
Mission 2

War and loss, 1700–1708

Guru Gobind Singh: timeline1666born at Patna1675Guru at nine, after his father'smartyrdom1688battle of Bhangani1699Vaisakhi at Anandpur: theKhalsa1704–05sieges of Anandpur;Chamkaur; Sirhind1706Damdama Sahib: final text ofthe scripture1708dies at Nanded: Guru Granthand Guru Panth
  • Sieges of Anandpur (1704–05); promises of safe passage were broken when the Sikhs left.
  • At Chamkaur his elder sons, Ajit Singh and Jujhar Singh, died fighting.
  • At Sirhind his younger sons, Zorawar Singh and Fateh Singh (aged about nine and six), were executed for refusing to convert; his mother Mata Gujri died there.
  • At Damdama Sahib (1706) the final text of the scripture was prepared, adding Guru Tegh Bahadur's hymns (see Mission 3).
  • In 1708 at Nanded (in the Deccan) he was stabbed by assassins and died of the wound.
Mission 2

1708: Guru Granth and Guru Panth

Two forms of GuruGuru1708sangatGuru GranthGuru Panththe scripture: theGurus' Word carriesthe Gurus' authoritythe Khalsa community,gathered in thescripture's presenceIn practicePanj Piare lead initiations · a gurmatta(resolution) is passed before the Guru GranthSahib · the Akal Takht issues edicts(hukamnamas)
  • Before his death, he named no human successor.
  • Guru Granth: the scripture is the Guru: the Gurus' Word carries the Gurus' authority.
  • Guru Panth: the Khalsa community, gathered in the scripture's presence, also carries the Guru's authority.
  • A couplet sung after Ardas (later tradition): by the command of the Timeless One the Panth was created; all Sikhs are commanded to accept the Granth as Guru (paraphrase).
  • In practice: the Panj Piare lead initiations; a gurmatta (resolution) is passed before the Guru Granth Sahib; the Akal Takht issues edicts (hukamnamas).
Mission 2Read the source

The Dasam Granth

The Dasam GranthDasam Granth"book of the tenth Guru"Writings attributed to Guru Gobind Singh,gathered after his death (traditionally by BhaiMani Singh)Jaap Sahibdaily prayerrecited at amritAkal Ustatall humans are oneBachittar Natakhis account of his missionZafarnamaPersian letter to Aurangzeb… and other writingswho wrote which parts: debated
  • The Dasam Granth ("book of the tenth Guru"): writings attributed to him, gathered after his death (traditionally by Bhai Mani Singh).
  • Includes Jaap Sahib (daily prayer; recited at amrit), Akal Ustat, Bachittar Natak (his account of his mission), Zafarnama (Persian letter).
  • Akal Ustat (paraphrase): temple and mosque are the same; Hindu worship and Muslim prayer are the same; all humans are one, though they look different. Recognise the whole human race as one.

Q1 Which teaching of Nanak does this passage continue?

Show answer

One God beyond religious labels; equality of all people.

Q2 How does it fit the Khalsa's single bowl?

Show answer

Both deny caste and division: one humanity, one community.

  • Who wrote which parts is debated.
Quick check
?Most Sikhs believe that in 1708 Guru Gobind Singh did what?
Mission 2Diversity

Did he change Nanak's Sikhism?

Did he change Nanak's Sikhism?ContinuityMost Sikhsone light (jot) in all ten Gurus; the Khalsaprotects what Nanak taughtW. O. Colethe Guru is God's Word, spoken througheach Guru; 1708 makes that explicitDevelopmentDevelopment viewHargobind had already taken up arms(miri-piri); Gobind Singh gave the Panth aform fit for survivalChange (in form)W. H. McLeodmuch Khalsa identity took shape in the18th century, recorded in laterrahitnamas; the 1699 accounts are laterN K Singhstresses the Khalsa's equality, including Kaurfor women, alongside its martial side
  • Continuity (most Sikhs): one light (jot) in all ten Gurus; the Khalsa protects what Nanak taught: one God, the Name, equality, honest work, service.
  • Development: Guru Hargobind had already taken up arms (miri-piri); Gobind Singh gave the Panth a form fit for survival.
  • Change (some historians): W. H. McLeod argued that much Khalsa identity took shape in the 18th century, recorded in later conduct codes (rahitnamas); the 1699 accounts are later.
  • W. O. Cole: the Guru is God's Word, spoken through each human Guru; 1708 makes that explicit, so it is continuity.
  • N K Singh: stresses the Khalsa's equality, including Kaur for women, alongside its martial side.
Mission 2Evaluate

"Guru Gobind Singh changed the Sikhism of Guru Nanak."

"Guru Gobind Singh changed the Sikhism of Guru Nanak.""Guru Gobind Singh changed the Sikhism ofGuru Nanak."ForA militarised Khalsa with a visible uniform;the end of human Gurus; new initiation bythe swordA strong, separate identity, where Nanak'scommunity was open and loosely definedAgainstThe beliefs stay the same: one God, theName, grace, equality; Jaap Sahib praisesthe formless OneNanak too opposed tyranny (Babarvani);the Word was already Guru (Bani Guru)Judge it byChange of belief or of practice? · Whichsources: his own writings or later rahitnamas?· Is development a kind of change?
  • For: a militarised Khalsa with a visible uniform; the end of human Gurus; new initiation by the sword.
  • For: a strong, separate identity, where Nanak's community was open and loosely defined.
  • Against: the beliefs stay the same: one God, the Name, grace, equality. Jaap Sahib praises the formless One.
  • Against: Nanak too opposed tyranny (Babarvani); the Word was already Guru (Bani Guru).
  • Judge it by: change of belief or of practice? Which sources: his own writings or later rahitnamas? Is development a kind of change?
Mission 2

His legacy today

  • Vaisakhi marks the Khalsa's birth; amrit ceremonies are often held then.
  • Singh and Kaur are used by most Sikhs, initiated or not.
  • Amritdhari, keshdhari and sahajdhari Sikhs relate differently to the Khalsa discipline.
  • Readiness to defend the oppressed: modern Sikh relief work often cites the saint-soldier ideal (sant-sipahi).
  • Gurdwaras marking his life: Takht Sri Patna Sahib (birth), Anandpur Sahib (Khalsa), Hazur Sahib, Nanded (death).
Quick check
?Which statement about the names Singh and Kaur is accurate?
Mission check

?A gurdwara committee in Leicester disagrees over changing the time of the Sunday langar. After discussion, the sangat gathers before the Guru Granth Sahib, offers Ardas and passes a resolution. Which idea from 1708 does this best reflect?
Mission 3

Mission 3: Who wrote the Sikh scripture, and why do scholars argue about how it was put together?

Make a guess: Who wrote the Sikh scripture, and why do scholars argue about how it was put together?

Mission 3

What the Guru Granth Sahib is

Inside the Guru Granth SahibGuru Granth Sahib1,430 pages (angs)poetry meant to be sung31 raags11,430opens withthe Japji of GuruNanaknear the endsaloks of Farid (pages1377–1384)in each raag: the Gurus in order, then othersaintsAuthors6 Gurus: 1st–5th and 9thbhagats: Hindu and Muslim saintsbhatts: court poetsa few Sikhs of the GurusBar roughly to scale; band edges approximate
  • The Sikh scripture: 1,430 pages (angs) in the standard printing; poetry meant to be sung.
  • Arranged mainly by 31 raags (musical modes). Within each raag: the Gurus in order, then other saints.
  • It opens with the Japji of Guru Nanak, beginning with the Mool Mantar.
  • Authors: six Gurus (the first five and the ninth), bhagats (Hindu and Muslim saints), court poets (bhatts) and a few Sikhs of the Gurus.
  • Each hymn is headed by its Guru's number: "Mahala 1" is Guru Nanak, "Mahala 5" Guru Arjan.
Mission 3

Gurmukhi

  • Gurmukhi: "from the mouth of the Guru". Tradition credits Guru Angad with shaping the alphabet from scripts already used in Punjab.
  • It wrote the spoken language of the people, not Sanskrit (Brahmins' scripture) or Persian (the court).
  • Effect: ordinary Sikhs, of any caste, could read the hymns for themselves.
  • It also gave the Panth its own visible written identity.
  • The Guru Granth Sahib is installed only in Gurmukhi; translations are for study.
Mission 3

From pothis to the Guru

From pothis to the GuruGuru Nanak's pothi (tradition)his hymns kept in a book, passed tohis successors1570s · Goindval PothisGuru Amar Das: the earliestsurviving collection1604 · Adi GranthGuru Arjan, with Bhai Gurdas asscribe; often identified with theKartarpur Pothi1706 · Damdama SahibGuru Gobind Singh, with Bhai ManiSingh as scribe, adds Guru TeghBahadur's hymns1708Nanded: this text is declared the GuruGranth Sahibtraditionmanuscript evidence
  • Guru Nanak kept his hymns in a book (pothi), passed to his successors (tradition).
  • Goindval Pothis (1570s, Guru Amar Das): the earliest surviving collection.
  • 1604, Adi Granth: Guru Arjan, with Bhai Gurdas as scribe; often identified with the Kartarpur Pothi.
  • 1706, Damdama Sahib: Guru Gobind Singh, with Bhai Mani Singh as scribe, adds Guru Tegh Bahadur's hymns.
  • 1708, Nanded: this text is declared the Guru Granth Sahib.
  • Adi Granth ("first book") is the 1604 compilation; Guru Granth Sahib is the final text, as Guru. Many Sikhs use both names for the scripture.
  • Scholars argue over this history. The historian Gurinder Singh Mann studies early manuscripts and sees the text growing in stages; many Sikh scholars, such as the Institute of Sikh Studies, hold that this approach undermines a scripture they regard as revealed.
Quick check
?Which is the most accurate difference between the Adi Granth and the Guru Granth Sahib?
Mission 3

Gurinder Singh Mann: the making of scripture

  • Gurinder Singh Mann, The Making of Sikh Scripture (2001).
  • Method: the study of early manuscripts, as historians study other scriptures.
  • Claims (paraphrase): Guru Nanak himself recorded his hymns; the Goindval Pothis show an earlier stage of the canon under Guru Amar Das.
  • Guru Arjan's Adi Granth built on and reorganised earlier collections.
  • Manuscripts show variations before the text was fixed: the scripture grew in stages, alongside the Gurus' authority.
Mission 3

The Institute of Sikh Studies

  • A body of Sikh scholars in Chandigarh (founded 1989); journal Abstracts of Sikh Studies.
  • It has strongly criticised textual criticism of the scripture by Mann and other academics (e.g. the McLeod school).
  • Its case (paraphrase): the Gurus' hymns are revealed (dhur ki bani, "the Word from the Beyond"); Guru Arjan compiled them with full authority; the Kartarpur text is authentic.
  • It argues that talk of "stages" and "variants" implies human editing and undermines the scripture's status.
  • It questions the dating and handling of the manuscripts, and asks whose assumptions the method brings: methods built for the Bible may not fit the Gurus' Word.
Mission 3Evaluate

Does a history of the text weaken its authority?

Does a history of the text weaken its authority?Does a history of the text weaken itsauthority?YesInstitute of Sikh Studies: if the textchanged, which version is the Guru's?Doubt about the text becomes doubtabout the GuruSome outside scholars treat it as a humanproduct, not revelationNoMann's side: Sikh tradition itself recordsstages (Goindval, Kartarpur, Damdama);history describes how the Gurus did itThe Panth's acceptance in 1708, not amanuscript, makes it GuruJudge it byCan historical and faith claims answerdifferent questions? · Who has access to themanuscripts? · Are the methods neutral?
  • Yes (Institute): if the text changed, which version is the Guru's? Doubt about the text becomes doubt about the Guru.
  • Yes: some outside scholars treat it as a human product, not revelation.
  • No (Mann's side): Sikh tradition itself records stages: Goindval, Kartarpur, Damdama. History describes how the Gurus did it.
  • No: the Panth's acceptance in 1708, not a manuscript, makes it Guru.
  • Judge it by: can historical and faith claims answer different questions? Who has access to the manuscripts? Are the methods neutral?
Quick check
?Which claim would the Institute of Sikh Studies be most likely to make?
Mission 3

The bhagat bani

The bhagats in the Guru Granth SahibKabirweaverRavidasleatherworkerNamdevcloth-printerSainbarberDhannafarmerSheikh FaridMuslim SufiRamanandBrahmin teacherIn the GGSHymns of 15 bhagats, Hindu and Muslim,12th–16th centuries; many of low caste
  • Bhagat bani: hymns of 15 bhagats (saints), Hindu and Muslim, from the 12th to the 16th centuries.
  • Many of low caste: Kabir (weaver), Ravidas (leatherworker), Namdev (cloth-printer), Sain (barber), Dhanna (farmer).
  • A Muslim Sufi: Sheikh Farid. A Brahmin teacher: Ramanand.
  • Included because their teaching agreed with the Gurus': one formless God, the Name, against caste and empty ritual.
  • Placed after the Gurus in each raag, but given the same reverence. The Gurus sometimes add verses responding to them.
  • Your spec: "the collection of testimony from diverse traditions".
Mission 3Read the source

Farid and Ramanand

  • Ramanand (GGS 1195, paraphrase): Where should I go? My home is full of joy. I set out with sandalwood and incense to worship God in a temple, but the Guru showed me God within my own heart.
  • Farid (Saloks of Farid, GGS 1377–1384, paraphrase): do not strike back at someone who strikes you; go home with humility. Elsewhere: answer evil with good, and do not let anger fill your mind.

Q1 What does Ramanand stop doing, and why?

Show answer

Temple worship with offerings: he finds God within.

Q2 Why might Sikhs value a Hindu and a Muslim voice in their scripture?

Show answer

Truth about God is not owned by one community.

Mission 3Diversity

What does the bhagat bani say about other faiths?

  • Openness: many Sikhs read it as proof that God's truth is found beyond one tradition: a basis for respect and interfaith dialogue.
  • N K Singh stresses the scripture's inclusive poetry and many voices.
  • Discernment: others stress that the bhagats were chosen because they matched the Gurus' teaching; their hymns also criticise Hindu and Muslim ritual. Openness, but not "all paths are the same".
  • Both views shape Sikh responses to pluralism today. Nanak's dialogues with Hindus, Muslims and yogis.
Quick check
?Which statement about the bhagat bani is accurate?
Mission check

?A museum shows an early handwritten copy of the Sikh scripture. A historian points out a hymn not found in the standard text. A Sikh visitor replies that the scripture was compiled by Guru Arjan and completed by Guru Gobind Singh, and is the Guru's own Word. Which pairing best matches the scholarly debate?
Mission 4

Mission 4: Sikhs treat a book as their living Guru. What does that mean, and is it worship?

Make a guess: Sikhs treat a book as their living Guru. What does that mean, and is it worship?

Mission 4

The Word is the Guru

  • Guru: often explained as the teacher who leads from darkness to light. Sikhs believe God is the true Guru (Satguru), who speaks through the Word (shabad, bani).
  • The Word is the Guru, and the Guru is the Word; in the Word is all nectar (GGS 982, paraphrase).
  • The ten Gurus carried one light; since 1708 the Word in the scripture is the Guru (see Mission 2).
  • So Sikhs speak of the Guru Granth Sahib, not "the Sikh Bible".
Mission 4

Treated as a living Guru

The prayer hall: treated as a living Gurufrontsangat: on the floor, lower than the Guruno fixed seatsentrance: shoes off, head coveredcanopyrumalastakht / manji sahibchaurgranthi's placedawn: prakashopened; often carriedin on the headnight: sukhasanclosed; carried to itsresting room
  • Placed on a raised throne (takht or manji sahib), under a canopy, wrapped in cloths (rumalas).
  • A chaur (fan) is waved over it, as over a king.
  • Prakash: opened at dawn, often carried in on the head. Sukhasan: closed at night and carried to its resting room.
  • Everyone covers the head, removes shoes, bows and sits lower than the Guru.
  • No image of God or the Gurus is worshipped: the Word is at the centre.
Mission 4

In worship and ceremony

  • All worship happens in its presence: kirtan (singing its hymns), katha (sermon on a hymn), Ardas (prayer).
  • Akhand path: unbroken reading of all 1,430 pages, about 48 hours, by a relay of readers.
  • Naming: a name begins with the first letter of a hymn opened at random.
  • Anand Karaj (marriage): the couple walks four times around it while the Lavan (GGS 773–774) are sung.
  • Amrit initiation and funerals (Kirtan Sohila; a reading completed afterwards) take place in its presence.
Mission 4Read the source

Vak lao: taking the Guru's word

  • Vak lao ("take a saying"): open the Guru Granth Sahib at random; read the hymn at the top of the left-hand page (if it began on the page before, go back to its start).
  • This is the hukamnama: the Guru's command for the day, often written up for the sangat.
  • The daily hukamnama from the Harmandir, Amritsar, is shared worldwide.
  • Sikhs take a vak before decisions and at ceremonies, as advice from the living Guru.

Q1 Why open at random?

Show answer

To receive the Guru's guidance rather than choose a passage to suit oneself.

Q2 How does this show the scripture is "more than a focal point"?

Show answer

It is consulted and obeyed like a living teacher.

Quick check
?A Sikh family takes a vak before buying a house. What are they doing?
Mission 4

Theological and legal status

  • Theological: the final and eternal Guru; the authority for teaching on God, faith and salvation; nothing may be added. Sermons explain it; they do not add to it.
  • Sikh law: the code of conduct (1950) says only the Guru Granth Sahib is installed as Guru in a gurdwara; it lays down how it is treated.
  • Your spec calls the code the Rehat Maryada.
  • Collective decisions (gurmatta) are made in its presence; the Akal Takht issues edicts before it.
  • State law: India's Supreme Court (2000) ruled that the Guru Granth Sahib is a juristic person, able to hold property.
Mission 4

Janamsakhis and the vars of Bhai Gurdas

  • Janamsakhis: life stories of Guru Nanak (Puratan, Bala, Miharban traditions; 17th century on). Not scripture: devotional teaching. Historians use them with care (see Mission 1).
  • Bhai Gurdas (c. 1551–1636): scribe of the Adi Granth; wrote 40 vars (ballads) in Punjabi.
  • Tradition calls his vars the key to the Guru Granth Sahib: they explain its teaching.
  • The code of conduct permits his vars (and Bhai Nand Lal's poems) to be sung in the gurdwara.
  • Status: secondary: respected guides, but they are not the Guru.
Mission 4Diversity

The Dasam Granth

The Dasam Granth: who uses whatGathered after 1708 (traditionally by BhaiMani Singh); attributed to Guru Gobind SinghUsed by allJaap Sahib, Tav-Prasad Savaiye, Benti Chaupai:daily prayer and amrit · the opening of Ardascomes from Chandi di VarAlso installed beside the Guru Granth SahibNihang Sikhs · the takhts at Patna and HazurSahib. Mainstream practice (the code ofconduct): only the Guru Granth Sahib isinstalled as GuruAuthorship debatedmany accept all of it as the Guru's · othersdoubt parts (e.g. mythological and storysections) on grounds of content and style
  • Gathered after 1708 (traditionally by Bhai Mani Singh); writings attributed to Guru Gobind Singh (see Mission 2).
  • Used by all: Jaap Sahib, Tav-Prasad Savaiye and Benti Chaupai in daily prayer and amrit; the opening of Ardas comes from Chandi di Var.
  • Mainstream practice (the code of conduct): only the Guru Granth Sahib is installed as Guru.
  • Nihang Sikhs, and the takhts at Patna and Hazur Sahib, also install the Dasam Granth.
  • Authorship debate: many accept all of it as the Guru's; others doubt parts (e.g. mythological and story sections) on grounds of content and style.
Quick check
?Which statement about the Dasam Granth is accurate?
Mission 4Diversity

Showing respect today

  • Some families keep a Guru Granth Sahib at home in its own room, with daily prakash and sukhasan; many keep only a small prayer book (gutka) and go to the gurdwara.
  • Worn or damaged copies are respectfully cremated, not thrown away.
  • The Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC, Amritsar) controls printing of the full text.
  • Debates: the use of translations and screens in worship, especially among young Sikhs abroad.
  • Practice varies, but all aim at the same respect: treating the Word as the Guru.
Mission 4Evaluate

"Sikhs worship the Guru Granth Sahib."

"Sikhs worship the Guru Granth Sahib.""Sikhs worship the Guru Granth Sahib."It can look like itRoyal treatment, bowing, offerings, thechaur, rest at nightSome Sikh reformers warn againstritualism, e.g. paying for akhand pathswithout listeningAgainstSikhs say they bow to the Guru's Word,through which God is known; worship is ofGod alone (Waheguru, "Wonderful Lord")The scripture itself rejects idol worship; itis consulted and obeyed like a livingteacher, not prayed to as a godJudge it byIs "worship" about the act or the intention? ·Does it function like an idol? · How do Sikhsdescribe their own practice?
  • It can look like it: royal treatment, bowing, offerings, the chaur, rest at night.
  • It can look like it: some Sikh reformers warn against ritualism, e.g. paying for akhand paths without listening.
  • Against: Sikhs say they bow to the Guru's Word, through which God is known; worship is of God alone (Waheguru, "Wonderful Lord", the name Sikhs most use for God).
  • Against: the scripture itself rejects idol worship; it is consulted and obeyed, like a living teacher, not prayed to as a god.
  • Judge it by: is "worship" about the act or the intention? Does it function like an idol? How do Sikhs describe their own practice?
Quick check
?How do most Sikhs explain their bowing before the Guru Granth Sahib?
Mission check

?A hospital in England plans to keep a full Guru Granth Sahib on an open shelf in its multi-faith room, beside other books. A Sikh adviser asks for a change. Which reason best fits Sikh teaching and practice?
Recap

The big ideas

Mission 1

  • Sources: the Guru's hymns, Bhai Gurdas' Var 1, and the later janamsakhis, which teach through story.
  • Key events carry teachings: the One Formless God, the sacred thread refused, God's court and "no Hindu, no Muslim", Sajjan's turning, Lalo's bread, Kartarpur's way of life.
  • Nanak chose Angad for worth, not birth: Sikhs believe one light passed through ten Gurus.

Mission 2

  • 1699: the Khalsa founded through the Panj Piare and amrit; one bowl, Singh and Kaur, the 5Ks, the Guru as disciple too.
  • 1708: no human successor: Guru Granth (the Word) and Guru Panth (the community).
  • Sikhs see continuity of one light from Nanak; historians debate how much the form developed later.

Mission 3

  • The Guru Granth Sahib: 1,430 pages, in Gurmukhi, arranged by raag; hymns of six Gurus, the bhagats and others.
  • Stages: Goindval Pothis → Adi Granth (1604) → Damdama (1706) → declared Guru (1708).
  • Mann reads the history of the manuscripts as a process; the Institute of Sikh Studies defends the authentic, revealed text.

Mission 4

  • The Word is the Guru; since 1708 the scripture is the living Guru, treated with royal respect (takht, chaur, prakash, sukhasan).
  • All worship and rites of passage take place in its presence; vak lao takes its guidance.
  • Secondary texts (janamsakhis, vars of Bhai Gurdas, Dasam Granth) are respected guides; the Dasam Granth's status and authorship are debated.
🏆

Mini-lesson complete!

⭐⭐⭐

You've worked through Sikhism: Sources of wisdom and authority for Edexcel A-level Religious Studies. 🎉

  1. Mission 1Guru Nanak vanished into a river for three days. What did he come back saying, and why does it matter?
  2. Mission 2How did one Guru turn followers into the Khalsa, then end the line of human Gurus?
  3. Mission 3Who wrote the Sikh scripture, and why do scholars argue about how it was put together?
  4. Mission 4Sikhs treat a book as their living Guru. What does that mean, and is it worship?

Your stars: 0 / 0

📣 Smashed it? Share your score

Challenge a friend to beat your stars, or show a parent how you got on.

→ Back to A-Level Religious Studies · Edexcel